Appendix E

Central Class I Areas Consultation Plan
1

UNITED STATES

Central Class I Areas Consultation Plan

Scope

This consultation plan establishes the objectives, activities, and timelines to facilitate stakeholder

input for meeting visibility requirements in the federal Regional Haze Rule for the following

federal Class I areas:

• Hercules Glades Wilderness Area (Missouri)

• Mingo Wilderness Area (Missouri)

• Caney Creek Wilderness Area (Arkansas)

• Upper Buffalo Wilderness Area (Arkansas)

Background

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) promulgated the federal Regional Haze Rule

on July 1, 1999. The federal Regional Haze Rule and the Clean Air Act require consultation

between the states, tribes, and the Federal Land Managers (FLM) for managing Class I areas.

Since regional haze often results from pollution emitted across broad regions, this multi-state

planning effort will help in developing the most cost-effective controls for regional haze. This

consultation process will provide a coordinated effort to achieve the federal visibility

requirements and aid in developing regional strategies for meeting progress goals.

Plan Objectives

This consultation plan provides state air quality agencies with technical information including

emission sources, modeling analysis, and source apportionment for Missouri and Arkansas’

Class I areas. These state agencies are being given the opportunity to review this analysis and to

participate in consultation to develop plans for meeting regional haze reduction requirements for

these Class I areas. Regional Planning Organizations (RPOs), FLMs, and the EPA will also be

contacted with the opportunity to participate in the development of actions and control strategies

for meeting the federal Regional Haze Rule requirements. This plan includes:

1. Consultation Process

2. Technical Analyses

3. Agency Roles/Responsibilities

1. Consultation Process

Consultation discussion will focus on the primary reasonable progress issues including:
2

• Source area identifications

• State contribution apportionment

• Emission management strategies

The consultation process will be initiated in early 2007. Draft and final documents will be

circulated via email to participating consulting agencies. After the initial kick-off, most

consultation discussions will occur through conference calls. However, there will be some

instances where a meeting may be desirable (e.g. unresolved issues, complex technical

discussions, etc.).

The Missouri Department of Natural Resources’ Air Pollution Control Program will work with

the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality and the Central States Regional Air

Partnership (CENRAP) to set up conference calls/meetings for the consultation process.

Technical documents will be provided for discussion before conference calls or meetings.

Draft and final documents will include supporting materials that describe analytical methods,

assumptions, and conclusions that were relied upon in developing the documents. Comments on

any draft documents will be requested from the consultation group members.

All consultation activities will be documented, including who participated in consultation

discussions and on what dates, outcomes of consultation discussions (issues agreed, disagreed,

resolutions) and justification for long term strategy. Each contributing state will be requested to

share documentation confirming implementation of emission controls being relied on to meet

regional haze Uniform Reasonable Progress (URP) goals.

Documents and consultation logs will be posted on the Missouri Department of Natural

Resources’ Air Pollution Control Program website for public viewing. All conference

call/meeting minutes will also be posted on the agency website. When new documents are

posted on the website, the Missouri Department of Natural Resources’ Air Pollution Control

Program will email all consultation participants to inform them that new information has been

posted.

MDNR/ADEQ will work with the FLMs and EPA for consultation through conference

calls/meeting. This will include an opportunity for consultation with FLMs in person and at least

60 days prior to holding any public hearing on a state implementation plan as required by federal

rule.

Action Items

Participate in kick-off

Comment on the draft consultation plan
3

Confirm emissions inventory and planned control activities

Develop/share individual state timelines for control implementation

Develop/share control progress

Other actions as needed

Reconciliation of Unresolved Issues

If a contributing state/tribe cannot agree with the lead agency establishing the reasonable

progress goal, then certain actions will be taken to resolve the disagreement. These actions are

as follows:

• Discuss position and supporting documentation

• If still unresolved, elevate to necessary decision makers

• If still unresolved, document disagreement by describing issue(s) in a letter to the

EPA, including regional offices and the Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards

All issues must be addressed and incorporated into the long-term strategy. These outreach efforts

will also be documented in the state implementation plan.

Contact Information

Contact information is provided in Attachment A.

Continued Consultation

Consultation between the States and the FLMs will continue as the federal Regional Haze

program progresses. The consultation will continue in a similar manner via participation in an

RPO. This effort will include development and review of SIP revisions and 5-year progress

reports. It will also provide for consideration of any other programs that are implemented and

have the potential to contribute to impairment of visibility in Class I areas.

Consultation Timeline

Below, in Table 1, is the consultation process timeline that will be used to achieve milestones for

consultation on the federal Regional Haze program.

2. Technical Analyses

In assisting the states/tribes in developing regional haze control strategies for Class I areas within

CENRAP states and tribes, CENRAP has contracted Environ/Alpine to conduct the modeling

and other technical analyses. Alpine assembled available information that was useful in

quantifying the reduction in individual fine particulate aerosol species concentrations needed to
4

satisfy the URP goals. Pertinent “attribution of haze” documents were evaluated. These

documents include CENRAP Comprehensive Air Quality Model with extensions

(CAMx)/Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) modeling system visibility modeling

results, fine particulate modeling results for the central US, and other technical reports, papers,

and analyses bearing directly on the quantification of emissions-source/visibility-receptor

impacts at the ten CENRAP Class I and twelve adjoining areas.

Current Regional Haze modeling continues to indicate visibility shortfalls to reaching the

necessary URP goals for deciview increments for some of the Central Class I areas in CENRAP.

A deciview is a haze index used to quantify incremental changes in visibility perception, where

higher deciview values indicate greater levels of visibility impairment. In some of the areas,
5

Table 1: Consultation Process Timeline

2006 2006 2007 2007 2007 2007

Fall Winter Early Spring Spring Late Spring Summer

Develop Baseline Develop a Initiate Develop Negotiate Document

and URP Goals Consultation Plan Collaboration Long Term Changes to Consultation

with States Strategy (LTS) LTS

Back trajectory & Identify issues Consultation log Follow Emission Who met and

Factor analysis for discussion consultation plan reduction when (FLM,

requirements/ RPO, EPA)

strategies and discussion

Identify probable Review baseline, Discuss URP Discuss emissions Emission budget Consultation

area of influence URP goals, and Goals & reduction strategies discrepancies outcome

emissions contributions Issues agreed,

reduction assessment disagreed,

targets resolutions

Apportion state Develop Follow consultation Consult with FLM Tribal Impacts Justification

contributions Action items plan & EPA of LTS

Develop initial Issues for FLM Consult with FLM Note areas of Additional control

emission cuts & EPA input & EPA (thru RPO?) irreconcilable strategies

to meet 2018 disagreement

URP Goals

Timetable for Evaluate and

resolution identify sources

upwind (BART,

non-BART,

CAMR, other)

URP goals are expected to be met based on modeling results, but consultation may be necessary

to ensure that the emission reductions used in the modeling are actually planned to occur.

Individual Class I Area Characteristics

The Central Class I areas each have individual characteristics. Individual examination of each

area elicits a greater understanding of how the Regional Haze problem affects each, and what

aspects are of greatest significance.
6

Hercules Glades

Situated in extreme southwest Missouri, Taney County, Hercules Glades is managed by

the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Forest Service. The area is 12,315

acres and in some of the most rugged hills of the Missouri Ozarks. The closest urban area

is the Springfield/Branson metropolitan statistical area, 40 miles to the west/northwest.

Mingo National Wildlife Refuge

The Mingo National Wildlife Refuge is managed by the federal Fish and Wildlife

Service. The Refuge is situated in the Mississippi Flyway. Only part of it is a Class I

area (7,730 acres). Memphis to the south and St. Louis to the north are some of the

largest urban areas nearby, although there are a few smaller population centers mostly to

the east. Proximity to sources in the Ohio River Valley is a consideration.

Upper Buffalo National Area

The Upper Buffalo Class I area (2,200 acres) is managed by the National Park Service in

conjunction with overseeing the Buffalo National River. This area in north central

Arkansas is south of Springfield, Missouri and east of Fayetteville and Fort Smith. It is

an area of low mountains and largely forested, with bisecting streams.

Caney Creek Class I Area

Caney Creek is a 14,460 acre area in the Oachita Mountains of west-southwest Arkansas,

the tallest mountain range between the Appalachians and the Rockies. It is south of Fort

Smith and west of Little Rock. The area is managed by the USDA Forest Service.

Identification of Source Areas (Areas of Influence)

Source areas must be determined in order to focus the consultation process. That is, locations of

significant sources that are likely to affect each Class I area must be identified, and sources

within those areas considered for control. Alpine, under its contract to CENRAP, identified

Areas of Influence (AOIs), using a variety of data and analyses. In combining the AOI

information with emission inventories for the areas, we are able to identify a number of large

sources which are of interest.

Figure 1 indicates two Level I AOI’s for the Central Class I Areas, one for nitrate (NO3), and a

second grouped collectively for sulfate (SO4), elemental carbon (EC), organic carbon (OC),

coarse mass, and fine soil, along with indicators for sources contained in those areas.
7

Figure 1 – Alpine AOI’s for Central Class I Areas
8

Attachment B identifies total emissions reductions necessary for level 1 AOI’s based on control

of sulfate and nitrate species across all four Class I areas. Attachment B also includes inventory

tables developed listing possible sources where emissions can be reduced in each state to meet

the goals. These emissions provide an overall frame of reference for any reductions in those

species.

Contributing States

Source apportionments have recently been conducted on modeling (using Particulate Matter

Source Apportionment Technology; PSAT, a source apportionment tool implemented in CAMx)

and monitoring data (using positive matrix factorization; PMF/Trajectories) for all four Class I

Areas. Attachment C provides both model and monitoring data source apportionment results.

Attachment D provides a list of results for Q/D (emissions/distance) used as a third analysis

measure. All these, along with Alpine sulfate AOI’s described above have been analyzed in

tables in attachment E to determine a list of contributing states for each Class I area.

Methodology

Table 2 and 3 (for illustration) below indicate the overall (average) significant contributing states

to decreased visibility due to sulfate and nitrate precursor emissions at the Mingo Site. A

decision on whether a given state was a contributor was based on the combined analysis results

of the four approaches, i.e., PMF/Trajectories, AOI, PSAT, and Q/D. If a state is found to be a

major contributor in at least 3 of the 4 approaches, it is believed that inclusion of this state is

appropriate. All states in red/bold in the Average row are determined to have sources that are

significant contributors to decreased visibility.

Specific to each analysis type, inclusion of a state under the PMF/Trajectories approach

depended on the level of probability that an air mass originated from the state during the days of

high contribution by sulfate or nitrate sources where the emission impact potential was

significant. A state with a high potential of emission impact would be considered a significant

contributor.

States were included in the AOI listing if they were part of the level 1 group as determined by

Alpine Geophysics. This AOI was based primarily on residence time of air masses, along with

evaluation of source emissions of, in this case, nitrate and sulfate.

PSAT analysis was determined based on the 2018 Modeled sulfate and nitrate contribution to

average extinction for the 20% worst days. Any state with the contribution of 2.0 deciview or

higher was identified as a candidate.
9

Lastly, Q/D was determined by dividing total SO2 and NO2 precursor emissions for the state by

distance from a state geographic centroid. If totals were less than 200, the state was not indicated

as a significant contributor under Q/D.
10

Table 2 – Contributing States for the Mingo Wildlife Refuge Area

Sulfate

Table 3 – Contributing States for the M

Nitrate

PMF/ PMF/

Q/D* Trajectories AOI PSAT Average Q/D* Trajectories AOI 

MN MN MN MN MN MN MN MN 

SD SD SD SD SD SD SD SD WI WI WI WI WI WI WI WI 

IA IA IA IA IA IA IA IA 

NE NE NE NE NE NE NE NE 

KS KS KS KS KS KS KS KS 

MO MO MO MO MO MO MO MO 

IL IL IL IL IL IL IL IL 

IN IN IN IN IN IN IN IN 

OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH 

MI MI MI MI MI MI MI MI 

KY KY KY KY KY KY KY KY 

TN TN TN TN TN TN TN TN 

AR AR AR AR AR AR AR AR OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK 

TX TX TX TX TX TX TX TX LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA 

MS MS MS MS MS MS MS MS 

AL AL AL AL AL AL AL AL 

*Informational *Informational State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States
11

State list

Following are lists of the contributing states for Central Class 1 Areas in Missouri and Arkansas

based on the analysis described above;

Hercules Glades

Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, and Texas

Mingo National Wildlife Refuge

Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, and Texas

Upper Buffalo National Area

Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Texas

Caney Creek Class I Area

Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Texas

3. Agency Roles/Responsibilities

The agencies listed in this section are being requested to participate in the consultation process

for the federal Regional Haze Rule. Part of this process is the opportunity for States to review

the foregoing analysis and the attachments to this plan and provide feedback, and to consider

necessary controls available that will assist in meeting the goals prescribed by the regional haze

requirements. Federally enforceable measures to control emissions and thereby achieve the URP

will be our ultimate measure of success.

Proposed Roles and/or responsibilities are as follows:

 Missouri Department of Natural Resources’ Air Pollution Control Program

– Co-lead consultation effort for Central Class I areas (Missouri and Arkansas) (i.e.

schedule conference calls/meetings, etc. and lead discussions)

– Evaluate regional haze modeling for reasonable progress

– Evaluate emissions data

– Identify air pollutants for Missouri Class I areas

– Evaluate back trajectory analysis

– Evaluate probable source area identifications

– Evaluate state contribution apportionment

– Share upwind source information (including Best Achievable Retrofit Technology

(BART), non-BART, Clean Air Mercury Rule (CAMR), etc.)
12

– Determine emission management strategies necessary to meet federal Regional

Haze Rule requirements

– Provide detailed description of methods used in the SIP to calculate baseline,

natural condition, and uniform rate (including supporting documentation for any

methods that are not previously established, documented, or supported)

– Document consultation process

 Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality

– Co-lead consultation effort for Central Class I areas (Missouri and Arkansas) (i.e.

schedule conference calls/meetings, etc. and lead discussions)

– Evaluate regional haze modeling for reasonable progress

– Evaluate emissions data

– Identify air pollutants for Arkansas Class I areas

– Evaluate back trajectory analysis

– Evaluate probable source area identifications

– Evaluate state contribution apportionment

– Share upwind source information (including BART, non-BART, CAMR, etc.)

– Determine emission management strategies necessary to meet federal Regional

Haze Rule requirements

– Document consultation process

 Illinois Environmental Protection Agency, Ohio Environmental Protection Agency,

Indiana Department of Environmental Management, Kentucky Department of

Environmental Protection, Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation,

Oklahoma Division of Environmental Quality, Iowa Department of Natural

Resources, Kansas Department of Health and Environment, Texas Commission on

Environmental Quality, and Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality

 United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma, Eastern Shawnee Tribe

of Oklahoma, Alabama Coushatta Tribe of Texas, Sac and Fox Nation of Missouri,

Kickapoo Tribe in Kansas, Potawatomi Nation

– Participate in consultation effort for Central Class I areas (Missouri and Arkansas)

(i.e. conference calls/meetings, discussions, etc.)

– Provide feedback on reasonable progress analysis (modeling, emissions data, back

trajectory, source area identifications, state contribution apportionment)

– Share upwind source information (including BART, non-BART, CAMR, etc.)

– Determine emission management strategies necessary to meet federal Regional

Haze Rule requirements

 EPA

– Participate in consultation effort for Central Class I areas (Missouri and Arkansas)

(i.e. conference calls/meetings, discussions, etc.)

– Provide comments on approvability of consultation plan

– Provide reconciliation on unresolved issues
13

 FLMs (US Fish and Wildlife Service, National Park Service and the US DA Forest

Service)

– Participate in consultation effort for Central Class I areas (Missouri and Arkansas)

(i.e. conference calls/meetings, discussions, etc.)

– Provide feedback on reasonable progress analysis (modeling, emissions data, back

trajectory, source area identifications, state contribution apportionment)

– Provide feedback on controls necessary to meet federal Regional Haze Rule

requirements

 Regional Planning Organization

– Participate in consultation effort for Central Class I areas (Missouri and Arkansas)

(i.e. conference calls/meetings, discussions, etc.)

– Provide updates and summaries of any work in process (e.g. development of

baselines and natural conditions, inventories, modeling efforts and contribution

assessments)
14

Attachment A

Contact Information

States

Mr. Mike Bates, Chief

Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality

Air Division

8001 National Drive

P.O. Box 8913

Little Rock, AR 72219-8913

Phone: (501) 682-0750) Fax: (501) 682-0753

Email: bates@adeq.state.ar.us

Ms. Catharine Fitzsimmons, Director

Iowa Department of Natural Resources

Air Quality Bureau

7900 Hickman, Suite 1

Urbandale, IA 50322

Phone: (515) 281-8034 Fax: (515) 242-5094

Email: catharine.fitzsimmons@dnr.state.ia.us

Ms. Laurel Kroack, Bureau Chief

Illinois Environmental Protection Agency

Bureau of Air

1021 North Grand Avenue East

Springfield, IL 62794

Phone: (217) 785-4140 Fax: (217) 782-2465

Email: laurel.kroack@epa.state.il.us

Ms. Kathryn Watson, Branch Chief

Indiana Department of Environmental Management

Office of Air Quality

100 North Senate Avenue

Indianapolis, IN 46206

Phone: (317) 233-5694 Fax: (317) 233-5967

Email: XXXXXXXXXX
15

Mr. Clark Duffy, Director

Kansas Department of Health and Environment

Bureau of Air and Radiation

1000 South West Jackson, Suite 310

Topeka, KS 66612

Phone: (785) 296-1593 Fax: (785) 296-1545

Email: cduffy@kdhe.state.ks.us

Mr. John Lyons, Director

Kentucky Department for Environmental Protection

Division for Air Quality

803 Schenkel Lane

Frankfort, KY 40601

Phone: (502) 573-3382 Fax: (502) 573-3787

Email: john.lyons@ky.gov

Mr. Michael Vince, Director

Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality

Air Quality Assessment Division

P.O. Box 4314

Baton Rouge, La. 70821-4314

Phone: (225) 219-3485 Fax: (225) 219-3240

Email: michael.vince@la.gov

Mr. James Kavanaugh, Director

Missouri Department of Natural Resources

Air Pollution Control Program

P.O. Box 176

Jefferson City, MO 65102-0176

Phone: (573) 751-4817 Fax: (573) 751-2706

Email: james.kavanaugh@dnr.mo.gov

Mr. Bob Hodanbosi, Chief

Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

Division of Air Pollution Control

122 S, Front Street

Columbus, OH 43215

Phone: (614) 644-2310 Fax: (614) 644-3681

Email: bob.hodanbosi@epa.state.oh.us
16

Mr. Eddie Terrill, Director

Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality

Air Quality Division

707 North Robinson

Oklahoma City, OK 73101

Phone: (405) 702-4154 Fax: (405) 702-4101

Email: eddie.terrill@deq.state.ok.us

Mr. Barry Stephens, Director

Tennessee Department of Environmental and Conservation

Division of Air Pollution Control

401 Church Street, 9th Floor

L & C Annex

Nashville, TN 37243

Phone: (615) 532-0554 Fax: (615) 532-0614

Email: barry.stephensl@state.tn.us

Mr. Greg Nudd, Director

Texas Commission on Environmental Quality

Air Quality Division

12100 Park 35 Circle, (MC 206)

Austin, TX 78753

Phone: (512) 239-1247 Fax: (512) 296-6188

Email: gnudd@tceq.state.tx.us

Tribal

Mr. Summer King

United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma

P.O. Box 746

Tahlequah, OK 74465

Phone: (918) 453-2823 Fax: (918) 453-2838

Email: XXXXXXXXXXX

Ms. Lisa Brenneman

Eastern Shawnee Tribe of OK

P.O. Box 350

Seneca, MO 64865

Phone: (918) 666-5151, Ext. 210 Fax: (918) 666-1590

Email: XXXXXXXXXXX
17

Mr. Perry Williams

Alabama Coushatta Tribe of Texas

571 State Park Road 56

Livingston, TX 77351

Phone: (936) 563-1100 Fax: (936) 563-1341

Email: XXXXXXXXXXX

Mr. Henry Harjo

Kialegee Tribal Town

P.O. Box 332/106 N Main

Wetumka, Oklahoma, 74883

Phone: (405) 452-5501 Fax: (405) 452-3037/3413

Email: XXXXXXXXXXX

Mr. Roger Anderson

Absentee Shawnee Tribe

2025 S. Gordon Cooper

Shawnee, Oklahoma, 74801

Phone: (405) 273-9966 Fax: (405) 273-9865

Email: XXXXXXXXXXX

Mr. Rick Campbell

Sac and Fox Nation of Missouri

RR 1 Box 60

Reserve, KS 66434

Phone: (785) 742-4705 Fax: (785) 742-2180

Email: XXXXXXXXXXX

Ms. Annie Freitag

Kickapoo Tribe in Kansas

1107 Goldfinch Road

Horton, KS 66439

Phone: (785) 486-2601 Fax: (785) 486-2445

Email: XXXXXXXXXXX

Mr. Arthur Muller

Citizen Potawatomi Nation

1601 S. Gordon Cooper

Shawnee, OK 74801

Phone: (405) 878-4672 Fax: XXXXXXXX

Email: amuller@Potawatomi.org
18

Federal Lands

Mr. Tim Allen

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

7333 W. Jefferson, Suite 375

Lakewood, CO 80235

Phone: (303) 914-3802 Fax: (303) 969-5444

Email: Tim_Allen@fws.gov

Mr. Bruce Polkowsky

National Park Service

NPS-ARD

P.O. Box 25287

Denver, CO 80225

Phone: (303) 987-6944 Fax: (303) 969-2822

Email: Bruce Polkowsky@nps.gov

Mr. Charles Sams

U.S. Department of Agriculture Forest Service

Eastern Region (R-9)

310 West Wisconsin Avenue, Suite 580

Milwaukee, WI 53203

Phone: (414) 297-3529 Fax: (414) 944-3964

Email: csams@fs.fed.us

Regional Planning Organizations:

Ms. Annette Sharp

Central States Regional Air Partnership (CENRAP)

10005 South Pennsylvania, Street C

Oklahoma City, OK 73159

Phone: (405) 378-7377 Fax: (405) 378-7379

Email: asharp@cenrap.org

Mr. Michael Koerber

Midwest Regional Planning Organization

2250 East Devon Avenue, Suite 250

Des Plaines, Illinois, 60018

Phone: (847) 720-7880 Fax: XXXXXXXX

Email: koerber.ladco.org
19

Mr. John E Hornback

Visibility Improvement State and Tribal Association of the Southeast (VISTAS)

526 Forest Parkway Ste F

Forest Park, GA 30297-6140

Phone: (404) 361-4000 Fax: XXXXXXXXX

Email: XXXXXXXXX

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Regions:

Ms. Kay Prince

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency – Region 4

Air Planning Branch

Sam Nunn Atlanta Federal Center

61 Forsyth Street, South West

Atlanta, GA 30303

Phone: 404-562-9900 Fax: (404) XXXXXXXXX

Email: Prince.Kay@epa.gov

Mr. Steve Rothblatt

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency - Region 5

Air and Radiation Division

77 West Jackson Boulevard (A-18J)

Chicago, IL 60604

Phone: 312-886-6555 Fax: (312) XXXXXXXXX

Email: Rothblatt.Steven@epa.gov

Ms. Becky Weber

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency - Region 6

Air Programs Division

1445 Ross Avenue, Suite 1200

Dallas, Texas, 75202

Phone: (214) 665-6656 Fax: (214) XXXXXXXXXX

Email: Weber.Becky@epa.gov
20

Mr. Joshua Tapp

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency - Region 7

Air Planning Branch

901 N. 5th St.

Kansas City, KS 66101

Phone: (913) 551-7942 Fax: (913) 551-7844

Email: Tapp.Joshua@epa.gov
21

sulfate/SO2 nitrate/NOx

Class I Area ST Name DV DV Sulfate Nitrate Sulfate Nitrate

Big Bend Nat'l TX BIBE -0.004 -0.002 133,000 265,000 82,000 10,000

Boundary Wate MN BWCA -0.006 -0.004 91,000 136,000 39,000 51,000

Breton Island LA BRET -0.002 -0.002 96,000 96,000 70,000 9,000

Caney Creek AR CACR -0.002 -0.002 18,000 12,000 11,000 2,000

Guadalupe Mou TX GUMO -0.004 -0.01 147,000 59,000 58,000 7,000

Hercules-Glade MO HEGL -0.002 -0.002 200,000 127,000 113,000 23,000

Mingo MO MING -0.002 -0.002 235,000 149,000 118,000 33,000

Upper Buffalo AR UPBU -0.002 -0.002 112,000 71,000 65,000 11,000

Voyageurs MN VOYA2 -0.006 -0.004 43,000 65,000 11,000 24,000

Wichita Mounta OK WIMO -0.001 -0.005 368,000 74,000 158,000 22,000

Level 1 AOI Emissions Reductions Needed (Tons)

One pollutant control Proportionate Controls

Attachment B

 Table 1. EMISSION REDUCTIONS NEEDED TO MEET THE 2018 RPG

IN CENTRAL CLASS I AREAS
22

Table 2. SO4 Inventory Tables For Level I AOI Contributing States

(tons/summer day)

PLANT ID STATE PLANT NAME SIC SIC DESCRIPTION SO2_TPD NOX_TPD

4800310 Texas FULLERTON GAS PLANT 1321 NATURAL GAS LIQUIDS 6.50599 0.00000

484691 Texas EI DU PONT DE NEMOURS 2869 INDUSTRIAL ORGANIC CHEMICALS,NEC 0.00000 10.33888

470850011 Tennessee TVA JOHNSONVILLE FOSSIL PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 300.62585 68.40613

470730007 Tennessee TVA JOHN SEVIER FOSSIL PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 98.99900 28.54810

471650025 Tennessee TVA GALLATIN FOSSIL PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 94.72930 33.50815

471630003 Tennessee EASTMAN CHEMICAL COMPANY 2869 INDUSTRIAL ORGANIC CHEMICALS,NEC 66.36360 35.39940

4715700528 Tennessee ALLEN FOSSIL PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 52.32034 40.03523

471610011 Tennessee TVA CUMBERLAND FOSSIL PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 45.79200 137.25500

471070012 Tennessee BOWATER NEWSPRINT & DIRECTORY - CALHOUN 2611 PULP MILLS 25.40730 17.57016

470374703700002 Tennessee E I DUPONT DE NEMOURS & CO INC 2869 INDUSTRIAL ORGANIC CHEMICALS,NEC 18.74385 0.00000

470630197 Tennessee LIBERTY FIBERS CORPORATION 2823 CELLULOSIC MAN-MADE FIBERS 14.73094 5.63459

470090008 Tennessee ALUMINUM COMPANY OF AMERICA - SOUTH PLAN 3334 PRIMARY ALUMINUM 11.24313 0.00000

471050081 Tennessee A.E. STALEY MANUFACTURING COMPANY 2046 WET CORN MILLING 9.40970 5.27573

4715700475 Tennessee LUCITE INTERNATIONAL INC. 2819 INDUSTRIAL INORGANIC CHEMICALS 9.39796 0.00000

470710002 Tennessee PACKAGING CORPORATION OF AMERICA 2631 PAPERBOARD MILLS 8.02611 7.42406

4715700045 Tennessee CARGILL CORN MILLING 2046 WET CORN MILLING 7.53864 0.00000

470653070 Tennessee SIGNAL MOUNTAIN CEMENT CO. 3241 CEMENT, HYDRAULIC 7.45430 14.19100

470010020 Tennessee U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY Y-12 PLANT 3499 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS, NEC 6.45058 0.00000

470850010 Tennessee INLAND PAPERBOARD & PACKAGING INC. 2679 CONVERTED PAPER PRODUCTS, NEC 6.05144 0.00000

471390004 Tennessee INTERTRADE HOLDINGS INC. 2819 INDUSTRIAL INORGANIC CHEMICALS 5.12497 0.00000

470730026 Tennessee AFG INDUSTRIES - GREENLAND PLANT 3211 FLAT GLASS 0.00000 5.53680

471630007 Tennessee SEAMAN CORPORATION 2295 COATED FABRICS, NOT RUBBERIZED 0.00000 13.59050

40097799 Oklahoma GRAND RIVER DAM AUTH 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 43.79260 38.29550

400891733 Oklahoma WEYERHAEUSER - VALLIANT 2631 PAPERBOARD MILLS 6.85920 8.73920

40031211 Oklahoma PUBLIC SVC CO OF OK 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 8.07136

390310616000000 Ohio CONESVILLE POWER PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 415.59965 80.90937

390251413100008 Ohio CINERGY CG&E WC BECKJORD STATION 4931 ELEC & OTHER SERVICES COMBINED 189.03354 48.73621

390010701000060 Ohio DP&L KILLEN GENERATING STATION 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 62.09508 24.70857

391390370020002 Ohio SHELBY MUNICIPAL LIGHT PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 10.97583 0.00000

390690335010105 Ohio CAMPBELL SOUP COMPANY 2032 CANNED SPECIALTIES 9.19665 0.00000

390030302020012 Ohio PREMCOR REFINING GROUP 2911 PETROLEUM REFINING 8.63332 5.82966

390611431390903 Ohio THE PROCTER AND GAMBLE CO. 2841 SOAP AND OTHER DETERGENTS 5.06495 0.00000

3100100042 Nebraska Whelan Energy Center 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 6.04710 0.00000

290990016 Missouri AMERENUE-RUSH ISLAND PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 61.58000 10.63480

291890010 Missouri AMERENUE-MERAMEC PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 42.16141 22.98658

291430004 Missouri ASSOCIATED ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE INC-NEW 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 38.72200 98.94600

290990003 Missouri DOE RUN COMPANY-HERCULANEUM SMELTER 3339 PRIMARY NONFERROUS METALS, NEC 38.52199 0.00000

290830001 Missouri KANSAS CITY POWER & LIGHT CO-MONTROSE GE 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 24.74788 8.80744

290950021 Missouri TRIGEN ENERGY CORPORATION-GRAND AVENUE S 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 23.22464 0.00000

290770005 Missouri CITY UTILITIES OF SPRINGFIELD MISSOURI-J 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 18.58675 19.25697

295100003 Missouri ANHEUSER-BUSCH INC-ST. LOUIS 2082 MALT BEVERAGES 17.82469 0.00000

291860001 Missouri MISSISSIPPI LIME COMPANY-MISSISSIPPI LIM 3274 LIME 16.44205 7.57345

290770039 Missouri CITY UTILITIES OF SPRINGFIELD MISSOURI-S 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 11.91107 7.09601

290930009 Missouri DOE RUN COMPANY-BUICK SMELTER 3339 PRIMARY NONFERROUS METALS, NEC 11.47904 0.00000

291430008 Missouri NORANDA ALUMINUM INC-NORANDA ALUMINUM IN 3334 PRIMARY ALUMINUM 11.21103 0.00000

291510002 Missouri CENTRAL ELECTRIC POWER COOPERATIVE-CHAMO 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 10.40103 7.95615

291950010 Missouri MARSHALL MUNICIPAL UTILITIES-MARSHALL MU 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 8.36287 0.00000

290190002 Missouri COLUMBIA MUNICIPAL POWER PLANT-COLUMBIA 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 5.23420 0.00000

281212812100036 Mississippi PURSUE ENERGY CORPORATION THOMASVILLE G 2819 INDUSTRIAL INORGANIC CHEMICALS 33.21600 0.00000

280592805900058 Mississippi CHEVRON PRODUCTS COMPANY PASCAGOULA REF 2911 PETROLEUM REFINING 15.54386 11.21247

280192801900011 Mississippi CHOCTAW GENERATION LLP RED HILLS GENERA 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 12.12464 0.00000

280232802300031 Mississippi MAGNOLIA RESOURCES INC PACHUTA HARMONY 1321 NATURAL GAS LIQUIDS 6.16490 0.00000

281372813700025 Mississippi TRUNKLINE GAS COMPANY INDEPENDENCE COMP 4922 NATURAL GAS TRANSMISSION 0.00000 5.90938

281492814900027 Mississippi ENTERGY MISSISSIPPI INCBAXTER WILSON PL 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 21.38220

281512815100048 Mississippi ENTERGY MISSISSIPPI INC GERALD ANDRUS P 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 16.13000

220750015 Louisiana CONOCOPHILLIPS COALLIANCE REFINERY 2911 PETROLEUM REFINING 9.05244 6.99716

220050004 Louisiana CF INDUSTRIES INC.DONALDSONVILLE NITRO 2873 NITROGENOUS FERTILIZERS 0.00000 9.40132

220710014 Louisiana ENTERGY NOMICHOUD 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 12.34510

211772117700006 Kentucky TVA PARADISE STEAM PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 231.14800 129.45000

210912109100003 Kentucky WESTERN KY ENERGY CORP COLEMAN STATION 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 136.73500 18.52110

210412104100010 Kentucky KENTUCKY UTILITIES CO GHENT GENERATING S 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 128.63700 53.32750

211672116700001 Kentucky KENTUCKY UTILITIES CO BROWN FACILITY 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 126.12264 22.49524

211272112700003 Kentucky KENTUCKY POWER CO BIG SANDY PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 116.35500 40.56600

211612116100009 Kentucky EAST KY POWER COOP SPURLOCK ST. MAYSVILL 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 114.74800 22.85900

211452114500006 Kentucky TVA-ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS SHAWNEE PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 93.72150 52.22210

211110127 Kentucky LOU GAS & ELEC MILL CREEK 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 62.90400 40.62600

211992119900005 Kentucky EAST KY POWER COOP JOHN SHERMAN COOPER P 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 60.98100 12.39360

211110126 Kentucky LOU GAS & ELEC CANE RUN 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 41.51100 17.38838

211772117700001 Kentucky KENTUCKY UTILITIES CO GREEN RIVER STATIO 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 36.53400 0.00000

212332123300001-B Kentucky WESTERN KY ENERGY CORP REID 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 26.99800 0.00000

210492104900003 Kentucky EAST KY POWER COOP WILLIAM C DALE PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 25.84360 6.17140

211832118300069 Kentucky WESTERN KY ENERGY CORP WILSON STATION 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 24.39500 22.78500

212232122300002 Kentucky LOUISVILLE GAS & ELECTRIC TRIMBLE CO GEN 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 23.13700 14.14800

210592105900027 Kentucky OWENSBORO MUNICIPAL UTIL ELMER SMITH STA 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 19.66360 25.20099
22

Table 3. NO3 Inventory Tables For Level I AOI Contributing States

(tons/summer day)

Plant ID STATE PLANT NAME SIC SIC DESCRIPTION NOX_TPD SO2_TPD

40131212 Oklahoma PUBLIC SVC CO OF OK 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 50.98726 100.50654

401011209 Oklahoma OG&E 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 50.35082 78.30093

40097799 Oklahoma GRAND RIVER DAM AUTH 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 38.29550 43.79260

40143639 Oklahoma VISTEON TULSA FIELD PLT 3211 FLAT GLASS 6.83041 0.00000

40101643 Oklahoma FORT JAMES OPERATING CO 2621 PAPER MILLS EXC BUILDING PAPER 5.45118 6.43248

40131166 Oklahoma LAFARGE BDLG MATERIALS 3241 CEMENT, HYDRAULIC 5.36456 6.48181

4007911 Oklahoma AES SHADY POINT LLC 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 16.77580

311090005 Nebraska NPPD Sheldon Station 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 22.06600 16.02900

3113100036 Nebraska OPPD Nebraska City Station 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 19.00005 30.02221

310550002 Nebraska Omaha Public Power District - North Omah 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 16.69760 32.90430

3102500002 Nebraska Ash Grove Cement Co 3241 CEMENT, HYDRAULIC 10.15431 13.17575

3100100042 Nebraska Whelan Energy Center 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 6.04710

3107900606 Nebraska Platte Generating Station 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 6.27660

291750001 Missouri ASSOCIATED ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE INC-THOM 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 38.53500 35.04050

290950031 Missouri AQUILA INC-SIBLEY GENERATING STATION 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 32.55300 31.17500

290970001 Missouri EMPIRE DISTRICT ELECTRIC CO-ASBURY PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 21.33100 15.26500

290770005 Missouri CITY UTILITIES OF SPRINGFIELD MISSOURI-J 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 19.25697 18.58675

291650007 Missouri KANSAS CITY POWER & LIGHT CO-IATAN GENER 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 18.34496 37.06906

290210004 Missouri AQUILA INC-LAKE ROAD PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 12.39498 10.36408

290830001 Missouri KANSAS CITY POWER & LIGHT CO-MONTROSE GE 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 8.80744 24.74788

291510002 Missouri CENTRAL ELECTRIC POWER COOPERATIVE-CHAMO 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 7.95615 10.40103

290770039 Missouri CITY UTILITIES OF SPRINGFIELD MISSOURI-S 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 7.09601 11.91107

290950022 Missouri KANSAS CITY POWER & LIGHT CO-HAWTHORN ST 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 5.53993 8.89822

290190002 Missouri COLUMBIA MUNICIPAL POWER PLANT-COLUMBIA 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 5.23420

290190004 Missouri UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI - COLUMBIA-POWER 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 34.08629

290470096 Missouri INDEPENDENCE POWER AND LIGHT-MISSOURI CI 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 16.42886

290930008 Missouri DOE RUN COMPANY-GLOVER SMELTER 3339 PRIMARY NONFERROUS METALS, NEC 0.00000 128.82087

290930009 Missouri DOE RUN COMPANY-BUICK SMELTER 3339 PRIMARY NONFERROUS METALS, NEC 0.00000 11.47904

290950021 Missouri TRIGEN ENERGY CORPORATION-GRAND AVENUE S 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 23.22464

290950050 Missouri INDEPENDENCE POWER AND LIGHT-BLUE VALLEY 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 16.31967

291950010 Missouri MARSHALL MUNICIPAL UTILITIES-MARSHALL MU 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 8.36287

201070005 Kansas KANSAS CITY POWER & LIGHT CO. 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 107.52207 71.32573

201490001 Kansas WESTAR ENERGY INC. 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 75.33946 167.18284

200450014 Kansas WESTAR ENERGY INC. 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 16.77377 25.03380

202090008 Kansas BOARD OF PUBLIC UTILITIES - NEARMAN 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 9.45550 20.95800

202090048 Kansas BOARD OF PUBLIC UTILITIES - QUINDARO 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 9.00230 10.32060

201770030 Kansas WESTAR ENERGY INC. 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 8.97410 19.17812

200150004 Kansas FRONTIER EL DORADO REFINING COMPANY 2911 PETROLEUM REFINING 6.48527 0.00000

201110007 Kansas PANHANDLE EASTERN PIPE LINE COMPANY 4922 NATURAL GAS TRANSMISSION 5.99508 0.00000

201330001 Kansas ASH GROVE CEMENT COMPANY 3241 CEMENT, HYDRAULIC 5.81100 0.00000

202057022 Kansas LAFARGE MIDWEST INC. 3241 CEMENT, HYDRAULIC 5.73203 6.35085

201210015 Kansas PANHANDLE EASTERN PIPE LINE COMPANY 4922 NATURAL GAS TRANSMISSION 5.12310 0.00000

200210002 Kansas EMPIRE DISTRICT ELECTRIC COMPANY (THE) 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 0.00000 9.32330

1915578-01-026 Iowa MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO. - COUNCIL BLUFFS 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 32.06380 49.21420

1919397-04-010 Iowa MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO. - GEORGE NEAL NOR 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 30.01136 59.63300

1919397-04-011 Iowa MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO. - GEORGE NEAL SOU 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 21.21000 40.52000

1917990-07-001 Iowa IPL - OTTUMWA GENERATING STATION 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 19.83300 37.82200

1901508-03-004 Iowa NORTHERN NATURAL GAS CO. - OGDEN COMPRES 4922 NATURAL GAS TRANSMISSION 5.17890 0.00000

1916985-01-007 Iowa IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY ISU HEATING PLANT 8221 COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, NEC 0.00000 5.64581

1917968-09-001 Iowa CARGILL INC. - EDDYVILLE 2046 WET CORN MILLING 0.00000 6.08014

050630506300042 Arkansas ENTERGY ARK-INDEPENDENCE 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 46.64000 72.93600

050070500700107 Arkansas SWEPCO-FLINT CREEK POWER PLANT 4911 ELECTRIC SERVICES 15.50800 33.27100

050830508300088 Arkansas CENTERPOINT ENERGY-DUNN COMPRESSOR 4922 NATURAL GAS TRANSMISSION 5.46066 0.00000

050630506300036 Arkansas EASTMAN CHEMICAL COMPANY-ARK EASTMAN DIV 2869 INDUSTRIAL ORGANIC CHEMICALS,NEC 0.00000 17.27739
23

Attachment C – Source Apportionment Analysis

Source Apportionment for the Hercules Glades Class I Area

PSAT Model Source Apportionment
24

Hercules Glades Projected 2018 – Worst 20%
25

Monitoring Data Source Apportionment

The Coal Combustion Factor at the Hercules Glades Class I Area
26

The Secondary Nitrate plus Oil Combustion Factor at the Hercules Glades Class I Area
27
28

Source Apportionment for the Mingo Class I Area

PSAT Model Source Apportionment
29

Mingo Projected 2018 – Worst 20%
30

Monitoring Data Source Apportionment

The Coal Combustion Factor at the Mingo Class I Area
31

The Nitrate plus Spring Burning Factor at the Mingo Class I Area
32
33

Source Apportionment for the Upper Buffalo Class I Area

PSAT Model Source Apportionment
34

Upper Buffalo Projected 2018 – Worst 20%
35

Monitoring Data Source Apportionment

The Coal Combustion Factor at the Upper Buffalo Class I Area
36

The Secondary Nitrate Factor at the Upper Buffalo Class I Area
37
38

Source Apportionment for the Caney Creek Class I Area

PSAT Model Source Apportionment
39

Caney Creek Projected 2018 – Worst 20%
40

Monitoring Data Source Apportionment

The Coal Combustion Factor at the Caney Creek Class I Area
41

The Secondary Nitrate plus Oil Combustion Factor at the Caney Creek Class I Area
42
43

Attachment D

StateCo UPBU/so2Total UPBU/no2Total UPBU/so2Max UPBU/no2Max StateCo UPBUso2/no2Total StateCo UPBUso2/no2Max

AR 606.3 307.9 247.1 106.8 MO 1,264.1 AR 353.9

IL 518.6 150.6 50.6 14.4 TX 1,254.7 MO 211.9

IN 601.5 172.8 109.2 33.3 AR 914.2 TX 191.5

IA 234.1 72.4 31.7 19.5 OK 777.8 OK 182.7

KS 182.4 200.7 33.9 36.3 IN 774.3 IN 142.5

KY 409.5 96.1 81.8 46.3 LA 746.1 KY 128.1

LA 540.2 205.9 87.9 23.4 IL 669.2 TN 126.0

MS 78.4 48.2 31.4 15.1 KY 505.6 LA 111.3

MO 945.9 318.2 177.3 34.6 TN 435.0 KS 70.2

OH 225.0 56.5 21.7 10.0 KS 383.1 IL 65.0

OK 453.8 324.0 106.0 76.7 IA 306.5 IA 51.2

TN 341.9 93.1 107.2 18.8 OH 281.5 MS 46.5

TX 902.9 351.8 146.1 45.4 MS 126.6 OH 31.7

StateCo

de

Ming/so2Total MING/no2Total MING/so2Max MING/no2Max StateCo MINGso2/no2Total StateCo MINGso2/no2Max

AR 365.7 213.0 141.8 87.5 MO 2,450.5 KY 439.9

IL 1,020.0 326.5 198.0 50.8 IN 1,368.2 MO 425.0

IN 1,063.8 304.4 221.2 67.5 IL 1,346.5 IN 288.7

IA 268.5 77.3 35.1 18.4 KY 1,158.6 TN 263.4

KS 136.3 143.7 26.9 28.8 TX 837.9 IL 248.8

KY 906.8 251.8 280.9 159.0 TN 776.4 AR 229.3

LA 442.6 164.1 74.0 19.7 LA 606.7 TX 110.4

MS 77.8 51.3 29.7 15.3 AR 578.7 LA 93.7

MO 1,820.1 630.4 349.8 75.2 OH 401.6 OK 75.0

OH 320.3 81.3 32.9 13.3 OK 347.3 KS 55.7

OK 205.4 141.9 43.5 31.5 IA 345.8 IA 53.5

TN 613.8 162.6 229.7 33.7 KS 280.0 OH 46.2

TX 604.4 233.5 81.9 28.5 MS 129.1 MS 45.0

StateCo Carc/so2Total CACR/Total CACR/so2Max CACR/Max StateCo CACRso2/no2Total StateCo CACRso2/no2Max

AR 499.6 269.4 244.8 58.4 TX 1,921.0 TX 371.8

IL 399.4 115.0 37.6 11.1 LA 940.8 AR 303.2

IN 488.6 140.3 87.4 26.7 OK 928.4 OK 181.7

IA 191.3 59.9 26.8 16.3 MO 853.1 MO 139.7

KS 139.8 157.5 27.7 29.7 AR 769.0 LA 134.7

KY 328.9 75.6 60.7 34.4 IN 628.9 IN 114.1

LA 676.3 264.5 106.4 28.3 IL 514.4 TN 101.9

MS 83.5 48.7 34.2 15.9 KY 404.5 KY 95.1

MO 640.9 212.2 120.5 19.2 TN 354.2 KS 57.4

OH 195.8 49.0 18.6 8.9 KS 297.3 MS 50.1

OK 553.5 374.9 114.5 67.2 IA 251.2 IL 48.7

TN 277.3 76.9 86.1 15.8 OH 244.8 IA 43.1

TX 1,381.8 539.2 294.0 77.8 MS 132.2 OH 27.5
44

Attachment D (cont’)

StateCo Hegl/so2Total HEGL1/Total Hegl/so2Max HEGL1/Max StateCo HEGL1so2/no2Total StateCo HEGL1so2/no2Max

AR 498.5 254.6 178.5 101.9 MO 1,706.0 MO 309.5

IL 603.4 175.5 57.2 17.8 TX 1,080.6 AR 280.4

IN 666.2 191.5 120.3 36.7 IN 857.7 OK 161.7

IA 267.4 82.0 35.7 22.0 IL 778.9 IN 157.0

KS 214.2 231.3 38.4 41.1 AR 753.1 TX 153.6

KY 448.3 106.2 92.5 52.3 OK 664.6 KY 144.8

LA 475.4 179.2 77.7 20.7 LA 654.6 TN 132.5

MS 71.4 44.2 28.1 13.8 KY 554.5 LA 98.4

MO 1,261.9 444.1 230.6 78.9 KS 445.5 KS 79.5

OH 239.6 60.2 23.2 10.6 TN 445.2 IL 75.0

OK 388.0 276.6 93.8 67.9 IA 349.4 IA 57.7

TN 349.5 95.7 112.8 19.7 OH 299.8 MS 41.9

TX 778.4 302.2 116.3 37.3 MS 115.6 OH 33.8
45

Table 1 – Contributing States for Hercules Glades Sulfate Table 2 – Contributing States for H

PMF/ PMF/

Q/D* Trajectories AOI PSAT Average Q/D* Trajectories AOI 

MN MN MN MN MN MN MN MN 

SD SD SD SD SD SD SD SD WI WI WI WI WI WI WI WI 

IA IA IA IA IA IA IA IA 

NE NE NE NE NE NE NE NE 

KS KS KS KS KS KS KS KS 

MO MO MO MO MO MO MO MO 

IL IL IL IL IL IL IL IL 

IN IN IN IN IN IN IN IN 

OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH 

MI MI MI MI MI MI MI MI 

KY KY KY KY KY KY KY KY 

TN TN TN TN TN TN TN TN 

AR AR AR AR AR AR AR AR 

OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK 

TX TX TX TX TX TX TX TX LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA 

MS MS MS MS MS MS MS MS 

AL AL AL AL AL AL AL AL 

*state total > 200 tons/km * state total > 200 tons/km State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States

Attachment E
46

Table 3 – Contributing States for the Mingo Wildlife Refuge Area

Sulfate

Table 4 – Contributing States for the 

Nitrate

PMF/ PMF/

Q/D* Trajectories AOI PSAT Average Q/D* Trajectories AOI 

MN MN MN MN MN MN MN MN 

SD SD SD SD SD SD SD SD WI WI WI WI WI WI WI WI 

IA IA IA IA IA IA IA IA 

NE NE NE NE NE NE NE NE 

KS KS KS KS KS KS KS KS 

MO MO MO MO MO MO MO MO 

IL IL IL IL IL IL IL IL 

IN IN IN IN IN IN IN IN 

OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH 

MI MI MI MI MI MI MI MI 

KY KY KY KY KY KY KY KY 

TN TN TN TN TN TN TN TN 

AR AR AR AR AR AR AR AR OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK 

TX TX TX TX TX TX TX TX LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA 

MS MS MS MS MS MS MS MS 

AL AL AL AL AL AL AL AL 

*state total > 200 tons/km * state total > 200 tons/km l State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States
47

Table 5 – Contributing States for the Upper Buffalo National Area

Sulfate

Table 6 – Contributing States for the U

Nitrate

PMF/ PMF/

Q/D* Trajectories AOI PSAT Average Q/D* Trajectories AOI 

MN MN MN MN MN MN MN MN 

SD SD SD SD SD SD SD SD WI WI WI WI WI WI WI WI 

IA IA IA IA IA IA IA IA 

NE NE NE NE NE NE NE NE 

KS KS KS KS KS KS KS KS 

MO MO MO MO MO MO MO MO 

IL IL IL IL IL IL IL IL 

IN IN IN IN IN IN IN IN 

OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH 

MI MI MI MI MI MI MI MI 

KY KY KY KY KY KY KY KY 

TN TN TN TN TN TN TN TN 

AR AR AR AR AR AR AR AR 

OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK 

TX TX TX TX TX TX TX TX LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA 

MS MS MS MS MS MS MS MS 

AL AL AL AL AL AL AL AL 

* state total > 200 tons/km l * state total > 200 tons/km State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States
48

Table 7 – Contributing States for the Caney Creek Area Sulfate Table 8 – Contributing States for the 

PMF/ PMF/

Q/D* Trajectories AOI PSAT Average Q/D* Trajectories AOI 

MN MN MN MN MN MN MN MN 

SD SD SD SD SD SD SD SD WI WI WI WI WI WI WI WI 

IA IA IA IA IA IA IA IA 

NE NE NE NE NE NE NE NE 

KS KS KS KS KS KS KS KS 

MO MO MO MO MO MO MO MO 

IL IL IL IL IL IL IL IL 

IN IN IN IN IN IN IN IN 

OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH 

MI MI MI MI MI MI MI MI 

KY KY KY KY KY KY KY KY 

TN TN TN TN TN TN TN TN 

AR AR AR AR AR AR AR AR 

OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK 

TX TX TX TX TX TX TX TX LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA 

MS MS MS MS MS MS MS MS 

AL AL AL AL AL AL AL AL 

* state total > 200 tons/km * state total > 200 tons/km State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States State in Red/Bold = Major Contributing States