5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




5(*25< +203621

	






,&.< (//


	



 !!"#$%&
'%	%

#%&(%)'(%'*%#

-./ "",

 ,+12$3

)*''"10

#1	


7

0+,(






	  )  ( 	:
	;<2'""((	$'%&    
7
 80
	
)
:
	
 !!""   
  ))) 	:
	 ; !!""%0'#8	$'%&4 
 

 8 
7
 8 0
	
 )
:
	
 (&2'""((# !!""

	


0"'2%&!''#%&*+%

70=!>?@"'2(!%!''**+',' %& (+"%  8 9 0 =!! >.?6@ "'2  (!%'((%',!''







 

	


 '*+'% 0+,  A%'%' !!""%

,5 &$!( =B&$!(C@ D( *2'*% # #'(%,$+(%*%%&'%&(((%%*+%(!!"(#$%&#%&'(%'*%*+%5',&'($%'%"%$'%(,%#(+$$5E+,$%%(!%'*F5""=B""C@&$!(G(!!"'*%' #  D'% # &3( *!+( + 4. 
	H44>&'(+%,%*%'#'*%#!!"3'"'%5(%""'((+(!(%

A%'%'G(!'*'!" ,+$% !!"'(%&%&D(

'&'(	'<%& $$%',&%%##*%'2(('(%*#*+("'3%&%&,+'"%!"%5!&((#&'(*!'%"%'"3*+(&'(%'"%%5( #'"%'2(%',%!(%2'*,',&'($%"'""(((*'"&'(%5#'" % !(% 2'* ' (+!!% #  "'# (%**+(D#'%&%&$!(&(!(%2'*%&%&D($%""5'""%%&%'$#%&*'$%%'"D	

 %&E+,$%#%&'(%'*%*+%

 

	
!

& #""D', #*%( '2"2', %& +"5', *'$ 

(+$$'I35%&((	+!$+%1
 

 )*$3 4- -.> 7*$  E+2'" #$"7'%% ,' % 	&"352'((  &5 !(% %&*+!"%%&&$#'""7#7*$G(#$'"5D&""+$ " %& %D D &$!(%"23+%&$')*$36D'%',#"% 3+(%'*F%  & #""D', $+$,''('(%%&%&$!%&+%&'%'(%!%%&%0*""!!%"5!$!%%&'&2', "'%%" $5   %#%%35"7%

8% %&% ($ #% 0

8  "*" ('% $ ("7%  ' % '2 	&%"5#%$'',&%&5""D#'!%$%3+'"'&$!(  7*$ D+%5+%&'%'('**%'%&',&%#0+54 %#E*F% (&D & & 3 *'%'2',7(8G(2&'*"%.%&0(!	+%&A'%%(3+,&%&,'"' "7%'%&2&'*"''*%!+*&!$0+5 3+%%#+&$!(G(*"%&',

 #D&+("%D&'"'*+

(%%$% $'%%',%&%&&F'#!'%#$%&"7%"&#*&%'2&'$*%$%"*%'+%('&&&(%33&'2"#%&7*$%%$!%%3+%&2&'*
> 
 

5ROOLQV GLG QRW SDUWLFLSDWH LQ 7KRPSVRQ¶V UHSUHVHQWDWLRQ GXH WR D

FRQIOLFW RI LQWHUHVW DQG ZDV UHOLHYHG RI KLV DSSRLQWPHQW RQ $SULO  'R\OH 5LFKDUGVRQ ZDV VXEVWLWXWHG DV FRFRXQVHO WKH VDPH GD\ +HUHPDLQHG DV FRXQVHO WKURXJK WKH VWDWH SURFHHGLQJV RQ GLUHFW DSSHDO

'""+(%%', %& +% #$ %& %D % %& ('% # %&(%33',  (*'3', (2" (%+*%+(  %&#%+( ",%& D5   (!F %& !& D'%&+%&'%'('7*&(%%*"'#5&'('*%'(


%& "5 $', &+( # 0+5 6 %$ #

(*&(#""D',&$!(G('*%'(#+8%%&!"*''*%'&'((%%$%	&D(#$$+"%'!"(%3D+(%&3*FD#%&#+D+(&3#%"!%%',&',&%"+,*+(',&%3"%%& #('*!%&",'(%%(%'#'%&%(&D+"%&2''$$'%"53+%D+"&2$'*(*'+(##'2%%$'+%( %%&(*(&"5&3*F&35*&&&"(+,'%%&,+&*"+%*&(2"3"(#,((%&%&&"%'((+&D(2'*%&%(&&'#*%3+2352&'*"&D(2'*#(%+,,"!%#$%&(%3D+(7(8D(%'E+


?.	446-4>6=-.-@

"#"$

0+54--.%&%'"*+%!!'%&$(

A((  0& ""'( % !(% &$!( 3+54--A((#'"%'*#'('%5#("(J+(%$%"!(5*&",'*"2"+%'#&$!(%%$'D&%&&D(*$!%%%(%%'"%#+%&%$'&'($%"*!*'%5%%&%'$# %& *'$   7*& 4 -. %'" *+(" #'" 

(+!!"$%5$%' #!(5*&'%'*<$'%'+",'*" <$'%'%%$'D&%&&$!(D( *$!%% % (% %'"  (('(% *+(" D'%& &'(#( D&%& &$!( D( (+##', #$  $%"

 *((5 % (('(% %& #($'%',%', 2'* ( ,+%(%'%+%'
?4 
 

2('" !*((   %& %& (%*+"'3"C@
#!

,"((#2'*!(%,'(%&$!(%%&

,+'"%!&(%'"*+("G(#'*'%!#$*("&'(#%%%&!"%5!&( 
(%#$F',<%'5##%((!(*'335  (%(46%

4.--%'"*+("G(!#$*&$!(G(3&"#%%&!"%5!&(D(%$"5'##*%+"3+%!('%'2"5%'$%"%&'(*+(&"%&% )A *$!"(+(%+!&"%&!%%"5+(3"*%'#&$!(G(%'"%%5( + '%( !(+$ '%!%%'2 (%'*%+( '( %$'(!(% )A &(+"%' 4-
	 64 =4@ (+!!%( %& 2'D %&% %& (%% *+%G(!!"'*%'#D($%&'**%K'%D('

#*% +(3" %&35 (%'(#5', %& J+'$%( # )A   &'( '( ( 3*+(  *$!%% %%5+J+(%'3"5D+"&23%' (+'%3"<!%'*!'%"##(*((+*&(%&'(&"%&D'((%&(%% *+% ' *(%'%+%(  +(3" !!"'*%' #3*+((*(J+*#%'"*+("G(%&E+5D(%,'2%&!!%+'%5%*('2'*3+%&$!(G(%'%',$%"*'%'#%&D('(*&,#$%&25D&'*&$',&%&2*+(%&E+5%*$$%&!%'#"'#'$!'($%D'%&+%!"'(% # %& %& !"%5  ('', %& &',&"5!E+'*'" *(J+*( # %& +(3" (%%,5 #&$!(G(%'"*+("#"D',#$%&''#'"',%&'%&!!<!%%<$'&$!('%'(*"%&%%&(%%*+%G(!!"'*%'#D(+(3"

%& #,', (( 
D+"%&# 2(%&

'(%'*% *+%G( E+,$% ,%', (+$$5 E+,$% %""$%%&'(%'*%*+%D'%&'(%+*%'(%'((+D'%#&3(*!+(2*%',&$!(G(%&(%* +"(( %& 	%% # (( *+*%(  D!"%5%'"!*',D'%&'.5(# $D&'"!2'',&$!(D'%&%&!!!'%!(5*&'%'*(2'*(

 

6SHFLILFDOO\ WKH VWDII DW 0XOWL&RX

GLUHFWHG E\ WKH FRXUW LQ SDUW DV IROORZV

7KH VWDII VKDOO DVVHVV LI DW WKH WLPH D UHVXOW RI PHQWDO GLVHDVH RU GHIHVXEVWDQWLDO FDSDFLW\ HLWKHU WR DSSUHFLFRQGXFW RU WR FRQIRUP KLV FRQGXFW ODZ 7KH WHUPV 3PHQWDO GLVHDVH RU 

DEQRUPDOLW\ PDQLIHVWHG RQO\ E\ UHSHDQWLVRFLDO FRQGXFW

7ULDO FRXQVHO 5LFKDUGVRQ VWDWHG DW 



, UHDOO\ GRQ¶W EHOLHYH KH JRW DQ LPZRXOG DOPRVW DSSHDU IURP WKH UHSRUWDQ H[WHQVLRQ RI WKH 6WDWH , GRQ¶W ELQGHSHQGHQW UHYLHZ DQG LW LV VRPHWVWDUWLQJ WR FRPSODLQ DERXW ,¶YH JRW 

'""((%&%#%&##(# &(!'%"'I%' # #+%& !2"+%'
(+!!%A((%%&%&$!(&!2'+("5(+##D&&D(('<%5("#(*D&'"'%&25D&&D'%&&$$35%&#""D(

7*&4.-.%&%'"*+

3#%%&7+"%'+%57#('*2"+%'%%$'&'%(('(%'&'(D#(%'$#%&*'$ !'">-

%&  '*%', &$!(2"+%'%(%%#*'"'%57'"
(%'%+%=B77
C@#$<'$# #('* !(5*&'%'(%(  !2"+% &$!(  &5 #*$!%%

'" *+(" J+(%' %& 

!(5*&'%'(%(!(5*&",'(%(#+%&!(5*&'%'*2"+%'(
 
 

LQGHSHQGHQW SV\FKLDWULVWLW LV VRPHWLPHV D WZRHGJHG VZRUG:KDWHYHU LV WROG WR WKHP WKH\ FDQ EH FDOOHG WR WHVWLI\ DERXW LWDQG KDYH WR EXW WKDW¶V QRW WR VD\ WKDW , GRQ¶W QHHG LW2Q -XQH   WULDO FRXQVHO ILOHG D 31RWLFH RI ,QWHQW WR 8VH

,QGXVWULDO 3V\FKRORJLVW ́ 7KH QRWLFH VWDWHG WKDW 7KRPSVRQ LQWHQGHG 3WRXVH WKH WHVWLPRQ\ RI 'U *HRUJH &RSSOH &OLQLFDO 3V\FKRORJLVW LQ WKH WULDORI WKLV FDXVH LQ UHJDUG WR GHIHQGDQW¶V PHQWDO FRQGLWLRQ DQG DELOLWLHV ́

%'"*+%,%%&J+(%&!2'('"2%!%1

&'(*+(*$%3&%&%&5#0+"5

-.+!%&J+(%##%G(%%5(#%& +% % !!2 %& <!(( #  !'2%2"+%'#%&#%35!'2%!(5*&'%'(%#%&!+!(###',*+("%&3#'%#!'2%<!% !(5*&'%'* *(+"%%' ' ,( % %&#%

& +% '( # %& !'' %&% %& 7%' #

(+*('(D""%F%&%<!%*(+"%%''(*((5%(+%&%%&*(%'%+%'"',&%(#%&#%!!"5!%*%

 **',"5'%'(&35))%&%%&*&,(

# ('!(5*&'%'(% (&""3!'35%&<*+%'2(*%5#%&	+!$+%#%&	%%#((# (2'*( !#$ 35 %&$  3&"# # %&#%
 (!'% #  %& *+%  !!2',  !(5*&'%'(% %

<$'&$!(*+("+(%&*+%$%"&"%& #+( % &' ) !!"  *"''*" !(5*&",'(%)5"'*&(#&$!(G(%'"*+("(%%(+3(J+%"5%&%%&##%%&'!(5*&'%'(%('$!"5BD(%(+**((#+"C

 (!%#%&'!%'"!!%'*+(""(%2"

%&$!(G(&$%D7",'&%&5

 +% ' & %(%'$5 % %& !&', %& !(5*&'%'(%( D&&$!(#$-.%--', 3'!" '(   (*&(*&'I!&' **', % )J+(%' ( % D&%& L&$',(%'* *'%' # L(*&'I(*&'I!&'3'!"'('"5+"%&C+%&%&$%"&"%&!#(('"(%%'-.()D**"+%&%($#$#,'*3'$,B(*&'I##*%'2'(3'!%& 2'* 3+% &$!(*'%'#%%&*'$(+,,(%(%%&%'$#%&*'$%&'(3+%#%'"*+("G(#'"+%3%(('(%*((%'2(%',%!,',%&$F*&,'&&'(%'$'%&25&'(!(('3D+" &2 **"+ 35 3"$'%',%', *'*+$(%*( %&% %&D%


%&'(*(%&2'"3'"'%5#!(

%&% % %& %'$ # %& *'$ &$!((+###$($#'*"+', !&!( 2 ,'* '((*&'I##*%'2'(&2 !(% %& E+5 D'%& #',+/D&'*&D+""'F"5&2%& ,,2%', *'*+$(%*( *'*+$(%*( **',"5%&"'3'"'%5#%&%&(%*'$%&'((3"!33'"'%5%#'*'%!#$*%%&!"%D+"%&2*$$%&

4 6 % .>- =&"', %&'2(%',%!(%5$'%',%'
? 
 

&2!2'+("5&**('%<!"%&%+

#%&((%&!"%5!*((1

(( '(  OD',&',O (%%%&% '( %& E+5

%$'(D&%&5,,2%',*'*+$(%*(&23(%3"'(&35(3"+3%35%&	%% %& 3"*( %&'( ,'(% 5 $'%',%',*'*+$(%*(#+35%&''2'+"E+(
#%&E+5+'$+("5 #'( %&% %& ,,2%( +%D',& %&$'%',%(%&$+(%3'$!(

6%664=J+%', !6

6.6.?=%&'--@@

 '% ($( J+'% "'F"5 %&% 3+% # %'" *+("G(

3E*%'2"5+(3"(%%,5%',,35%&'#'"+%&'!!!'%!(5*&'%'*<!%%&(+"%%%&!"%5!&(D("'F"5%&23'##%>
	%?K"##4?6--64=-%&

' 4@ =B
# %& E+5 & *(' %& %(%'$5 #<!%('*'",5%<'*",5# #'(#$'"5$$3("%','%'"&+$'I',(%'(%&'((3"!33'"'%5%&%%&$'%%2'*D+"&2 *&, %& **"+(' %&% %& ,,2%',*'*+$(%*(+%D',&%&$'%',%',*'*+$(%*(&*%&(%*'$!(C@='%"J+%%'$F(*'%%'$'%%@K$$466%4-?=#'',%&%*+("G(#'"+%#''##%!(5*&'%'*<!%#%&!"%5!&(#%&%'"D(!E+'*'"3*+('%(+"%' %& !(%%' #  $'%',%' 2'* % "" 2%&+,&%&#%(+###$$'"$%"%%''$''(&*!*'%5@K%?6%4=&"',%&%*+("G(#'"+%!(%!%'%2'*#$%"&'(%5$%"*!*'%5D(!E+'*'"@

 "%&+,&'%&3(*#*$!%%!(5*&'%'*%(%'$5

%&D('(+##'*'%2'*(&D',%&%&$!(D((+##',#$($!(5*&'%'*!(5*&",'*"'$!'$%% %& %'$ # %& *'$ %& D(  %& %& &(+##'*'% * %(%'$5 ''*%', %&% &'( $%"*'%'&(%'%('*-. ()"'!'%

 '%2'D !"'* ##'*( &,$%&&'((%!,#%&(2"',&3(


#

&$!(!(%!#+

%'" %&E+5 *2'*%&'$8

?.	

%(%'#'%%&!(%*2'*%'&!&(*(*+"%3#

)+',%&(%*',!&(&

D'%((( '*"+', #$ *J+'%*(&'(,!%(% "" (*'3 &$!( ( (!('3"&'%((((*'3#$'"5*'*+$(%*('E'%&25&((	+!''%&%BD&'"L&$!(G("(,"2',C&

 " E+" &$!(G( 

(%%'D'%&%&25'D&$!( #$ )*$3 -.(*'3%&'"%'(&'!(,!+%&2<!'*C(*',(('%'2	&%(%'#'& 'E+5 D& %& # &'( %%*F&'$D'%&*D3+(3"5**3+%%&#% &  *((<$'

'*'%( **', &$!(G25 	& (%%%&% &$!( 25#%3',*+%$%'"#'%&'("*%',%&##'*G*""3E+"*FD",2'"%!'(('%&25&

&$!(G(('(%0

"D%(%'#'3+%&$!(G(*%
. 
 

:KHQ DVNHG RQ FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ ZKHWKHU KH 3EDVLFDOO\ >KHOG@

>KLPVHOI@ RXW DV DQ LQGXVWULDO SV\FKRORJLVW PRUH WKDQ D FOLQLFDOSV\FKRORJLVW ́ &RSSOH VDLG

1R 0\ OLFHQVLQJ LQ WKH 6WDWH RI 7HQQHVVHH LV DV D FOLQLFDOSV\FKRORJLVW 7KH DSSOLFDWLRQ WKDW , PDNH RI LW PRVW IUHTXHQWO\LV FRQFHUQLQJ WKH DELOLWLHV DQG WKH ORVW DELOLWLHV WR VRPH H[WHQWRI LQGLYLGXDOV , GRQ¶W EHOLHYH WKDWWKH PDMRULW\ RI P\ ZRUN LVDFWXDOO\ 6RFLDO 6HFXULW\ $GPLQLVWUDWLRQ HYDOXDWLRQV DQG WKDW LVQRW UHDOO\ LQGXVWULDO SV\FKRORJ\ 7KDW LV FOLQLFDO SV\FKRORJ\ EXWLW LV IURP WKH VWDQGSRLQW RI PDNLQJ D SV\FKRORJLFDO HYDOXDWLRQ DVUHODWLQJ WR ZKHWKHU D SHUVRQ FDQ ZRUN DQ\PRUH RU QRW

%+#$D''#%&'('(*&,#$%&25&&'" ' ,' &$!( 3*$ '2"2 ' "%'(&'!D'%&07*$"%%(%'#'%&%&$!(%"&%&%7*$G($%&D(%5',%#*7*$'%!(%'%+%'&

!!""(%(%'#'% (%*',!!"'(  *"''*"

!(5*&",'(%"'*('%&	%%#((3%'&'( A&) ' *"''*" !(5*&",5 #$ %& 
'2('%5 #A'%%(3+,&'->.%+,&%'%&!(5*&",5!%$%%:3'"%
'2('%5#$->.%--*"''*"!*%'* ( D""  % :3'"% !!" %+,&% $"!(5*&",5 *+((  %& 3$" !(5*&",5 *+(*&'"!(5*&",5*+(('%&,'2',#!(5*&",'*"%(%', &'" % :3'"% & (2 ( %& *(+"%',!(5*&",'(% % (% 	%% (!'%" ' !F'(2'"";%+*F5A%#&'(+%'(%&D(%'%2'D!%'%((%%&' 3'"'%5% (%%'"!!"%(%'#'%&% B%&$'!%#$5DF2%&5(D""""#'%&(3*"''*"!(5*&",5C  %&%%& $!&('(&(

'##%%'$(%'*"+2"+%'( # (*'" (*+'%5!!"'*%(2*%'"2"+%'(!!"<!"'%&%%& #$ %(F '2"2 !(5*&",'*" 2"+%'( #''2'+"("",',%&5&2!3"$(%&%D+"!2%%&$#$DF',%&%2*%'"2"+%'(+(#B&"!',!!"*&%&'2*%'","(*&(',2*%'","(C!!"#+%&(%%%&%%&(*'"(*+'%5 2"+%'(  B% ""5 '+(%'" !(5*&",5

 %& %'$ # %'"  ) D D!''3+%D&%&&$!((%%%'"!'%&%&$!(D#&'(<$'%'0+4--&$!(G(%'%',$%"(+,,(%%&%&D("'F"5(+##%&%'$#%& *'$ D2#$"!'' 3+%&$!(G%'$#%&*'$*"'$',%&%(&3+%&$!(G(3*F,+3!''&+(%&'(%&'''*%%&%&$!(D(%*$+%(&D%&%&D((+,'* 3' $,  $%" $+

*+( %& 2'* ( %

&$!( D( + ($ !(5'$!'$%%%&%'$#%&*'$*'$'"*+"!3'"'%5'%'(+*"D&233"%$+%##*%&,+'"%!&('#&'(%'"*+("&!!!'%!(5*&'%'*<!%(+## ($ & 'E+'( '(%3'"'%5+',%&%'$#&'( %&+,&&'($%"*'%'$5(+3(J+%%%&*'$%&!(% **"+ D&%& %& (('(!(5*&'%'*<!%D+"&2"%!&(#&$!(G(%'"

%&%&&%&*%'"

%&%3+%#%'"*+("G(#'*'%& %'" %& E+5 D+" &2 *(%*D(%D%'%&'(%&%%%&(%*',!&(#*('%& #*%(  *'*+$(%*&*%3*F,+#%&>6.
	.>=-?.@K	+%%'1
. 
 

&"!''G((',%&%&$!(G(%'"*+("

*%3#+%&2*%+(3"53*+(%&D( !# # &$!(G( $%" '""(( % %& %'$ # %&*'$ '( *'*+"  +!(+('2  
 D'%&+% %&!! !(5*&'%'* (('(%* % +* 2'* #&$!(G( $%" *'%'  !# *+" 3 ##&+(*+("G((%%,5('$!"5$+%%(%%,5%""!$%%&(%'!*',(
!'2',

&$!(#%&3'"'%5%$+%5#('%&,+'"%!&(%!(%'$!%%$'%',%',2'*3+%&'($%" *'%' % %& !"%5 !&(  
 ( ', %'"*+(""#%%&' *"'%2'%+""5#("(( (%&+,&&D D'%&+% 5 !(%%' #*',%& *&,(  %&(%*&'(D

 %""&" "	


2', **"+ %&% %'" *+("G( !#$* D(

#'*'%'3%&%&,+'"%!"%5!&((#%&'(*(%&<%J+(%''(D&%&%&D(!E+'*(%3"'(&!E+'*+&$!($+(%(&D%&%B%&

'(  (3" !33'"'%5 3(% %& ( %&% %&#*%#' D+" &2 &  (3" +3% (!*%',,+'"%C%&%B%&'((3"!33'"'%5%&%3(%%&(%&(%*D+"&2**"+%&%%&3"*#,,2%',$'%',%',*'*+$(%*('%D%%&C>
	%-

 %& !(% * %& ( % !! % 3 

(3"!33'"'%5%&%3+%#%'"*+("G(%&+,&"5#'*'%!#$*%&E+5D+"&2&(3"+3%3+%&$!(G(,+'"% (&$!(G(%'"%%5(*,'I %& D( 2D&"$', 2'* %&% &*$$'%%%&$+&'"%&D(!!%#(% &$!(G( #*%+" ,+'"% %&  J+(%' (%'"" $'(D&%&&'(%'" *+(" *+"&2$+%  ##*%'2!(5*&'%'*#('%&,+'"%!&(35(&D',%&%&D(+($!(5*&'%'*!(5*&",'*"'$!'$%%%&%'$#%&$+
%&'(,'%(&+"3%%&%%&*($%(+,,(%%&%&$!(D(*$!%%%

 &%'(*"''*"!(5*&",53+%'%$F',!(5*&",'*"2"+%'!(*DF5$%C

!!" %(%'#' %&% & (!

<$'', &$!( 2 (2((('  75  -. !!"77
#%&&"#&D("F',%%&%!'%%D&%%#',' !'( ('%+%'C3'"'%5 %(%', '*"+',  $%&$%'*"#+*%'',%(!!""(,2&$!(

 %%& (* (((' +,+

3+%%&&"#&+(D'%+%5 0'"  % %&% $%', 7'(%7+"%'!&('*A("'%5&$%'* !!*!%'(%%&"F%&(*&*&
F%D%D%5 $'+% ((('( D'%&3,

!!"(%%%&%&$!(&

(2%&,('<%&,"((%%%&%&$!((*#&',&(*&",+%((%%(%'#' %&% ' &'( !'' &(%,%+%+%&!!"#+%+*C#7*$%&$+#7(8
!!"%+%+BD(25(%,(%($+D'(*%'(C!!""(<&'3'%(%,$(#%&F'"%'(*'"!("'%5*((%&% & ' % %&'F &$!($%"'""((


3+%%"%&	%%!(%%&

) 3% " %( "("'*(35%&	%%#((
 
 

:DWVRQ VWDWHG WKDW KH GLG QRW LQWHUSUHW WKH ((* ZKLFK LV D PHGLFDO

WHVW

(%##2"+%'#&$!(%77
%((%%%&%%&!+!(#%&2"+%'D(%%$'%&$%"*$!%*#&$!(%(%%'"%%$'&'($%" (%%+( % %& %'$ # %& "", $+  %(<!"' %&% &$!( *'2 %& F'( #<$'%'(K  !&5('*" <$'%' D&'*& '*"+ "*%*!&",$  !(5*&",'*" 2"+%'  !(5*&'%'* <$'%'  %( %(%'#' %&% %&"*%*!&",$(&D(',#3'$,'%&D($"

%((*'3%&%(%(&!(""5!#$'(%

& $''(% %& *&(" +"% 
%""',* 	*"2'(D&'*&((((('%""*%+"#+*%'',!%%'"%( #+ %&% &$!( &  23" 
P # -6 !#$* 
P#.-   #+""(*" 
P#- D&'*&!"* &'$ ' %& "D, '%""*%+""5  "(''*%B%&%%&'('%""*%+"'$!'$%%&%D+"!"5!%'%&#('*J+(%'(C<%&$!(D(,'2%&', *&'2$%(%!'$'"5#%&!+!(#((((',&'(',3'"'%5%(<!"'%&%%&'(%(%D(*&(3*+(&$!(&*"'$&*+"%  D'% =&@%( #+%&%& D(

',%"2"3%%%&?!*%#%&%(%!!+"%'&'%(,2%&:'(+"7%(%"%(%%((%%%&%%&'(%(%!2'(,"(((($%#3'$,#+%&<!"'%&%'%'(D',%(%%&%BD"F',#2'*#,'*'%5%&C&(F%<!"'D&%&$%35,'*'%5%(!"'1

A(5*&$%'$!'$%&'('(3'$,&D(&'(%5'&'(3*F,+#**+(('%,D'%& !% &(!'%"'I%'(   'G% &2 %&*(#$%&%"(&&'(%5#3',&'%2

 %%$+% % !(%',  #*+("G((%%,5*%+""5(+"%# 3+%%" # '%'" $&$!(

%5% #(%'" *+(

*('%!(%%&$D'%&"5 2'* # &$!(G( B2'*%""'%&!"%5!&(%&$F*&,'&$!(G%&25<!%!(5*&'%'*%(%'$%&%&$!( (+## #$$$%"*'%'D+"&2!2'#&$!(G(B!('%'2J+"'%'((+3(J+%2'"%3&2'D##%&E+55!"+('3"!(5*&'%& (','#'** # &$!(G(D'%((35E+"%&(&3'*%%&' "(($',#%&'*"'%&'('(3*+(#(D&'*&%3+%%&(%%G(!#(#'((+#D&%&&$!(D(


(+$$5%&!#$*#

'%&'(*!'%"*(D(D""3"D(3"(($35%&%'"*+("+,%5%&)+ A*(( "+( 35 #'"',!(5*&'%'* <!% ( '*% 3!+(+%%	 ((+"%#%&

&'!!!'%!(5*&'%'*<!!(5*&'%'*2'*%(('(%2'"%&$("2(#%&!+!%#( % %& ,+'"% !&(  B!('%'2 J+"'%'(C ( $'%',%',!&(D'%&+%%%$!%',%!2'<!"%' # &$!(G( 3&2'
 
 

E+""(D(#**((<$'%'%%(%'#53+%&$!(G('2"2$%'%&2'"%'*'%(D&'"'%&25D&'*&'*"+%&%(%((+"%25!("D'%&  %J+ D*& <%(' 3   #'2'*& (%FF'#

 ( "5 % #( %'" *+(" D( D #

&$!(G(2'"%3&2''%&$'"'%5&+(#(%'" *+(" D( !(% D'%& %& !3"$ # &D %**+% # &$!(G( 2'"% 3&2' ' "',&% # %&'*&( (%%,5 # !(%', &'( B!('%'2 J+"'%'(C2%&"((&$!(G(%'"*+("A(("'I%&%%&D(!+II"',*&,'&$!(G(3&2'#$%&%'$&"'2','3#E'',%&25D&'&$!( D% #$3', B2'"% *!%'2 (!('3"C  B!"(% (5,', *&#+"C % B!'C ''2'+" !% % ,, ' 2'"% ((+"%'23&2' "%&+,&%'"*+("##<!"%'#&$!(G('*"3&2'"*&,%&D(2'*( ) "' *,'I ''*%', %&% &$!( & &'(%5#&'E+'(%&%('*-.&&(&D%'%',$%"(%%+(3*$',!(5*&%'*D'%&$(D',( ''*%'2 # 3'!" '(  (*&'I ##*%'2'(  (*&'I!&'  
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

 

:DWVRQ WHVWLILHG WKDW DOWKRXJK KH Z

LQMXULHV KH GLG QRW KDYH WKH KRVSLWDO UHFR

%&&D'%&&$$D&'"&'-.D"F',#3

%(*%'+1

&(+"%(#%&(&D"2'*#,'*'%53%(%%&'(%& 
%#*D&%D<!*%'(%&%%&D'""3D(%&%&(+"%(%(%L'M#&'((+##',#$

 #+ "(( (  %&
%#*A*+%&#+%& (%,%& + 3('+(,'*'%5&

%("(!#$%&77

D($''(%#%&!+!(%&$"%(%!!+"%'''*%'""((#*%%(#+%&$"',',  &$!( D( #+	"#*!% 	*" D&'*& $(+**!%3+%"(!2'(*"''*"'%((%%%&%%&%(%(+"%((,("#**!%%(*%'7"E+(%$%	*"D("2%3+%%+%('$""'$'%(2'*#$F$%"'(%+%&%%&!(5*&",'*"%(%(D%&$"*+(%&!(5*&DD'%&'$""'$'%(#+%&

%((%%%&%754>

D( &" ' D&'*& "" %& %!(5*&",'*"  (*'" &'(%(+$$'I&(%##**"+
4 
 

7KH QXPEHU UHIHUV WR WKH FDWDORJ QXPEHU RI WKH GLDJQRVLV LQ WKH

'LDJQRVWLF DQG 6WDWLVWLFDO 0DQXDO UG (G :DWVRQ H[SODLQHG WR WKH MXU\WKDW DGXOW DQWLVRFLDO EHKDYLRU LV QRW D SHU VH PHQWDO LOOQHVV RU GHIHFW RU

PHQWDO GLVRUGHU EXW D UHFRJQL]HG VHW RI EHKDYLRUV

L&$!(M<&'3'%#%&(',(###*%'2'""((  '( E+,$%  '(',&%  %& !A(5*&",'*"%(%',2"&'$%3#+*%'','%&2, ,'%""*%+""5%<&'3'% (',(#,'*'%53'$,%&(%"%(% %&  
%#* A*+  A("'%5!#'"( 2"  2'* #  !(5*&('( 3+%''*% $"',', ' %& $%" '""(( '*%'= <$!"%& (*&'I!&'* (* D( %4D&'" *"''*" 3(2%'( 2"  2'* # %&+,&%'(@

&%$',(&$!(( <'( +"% %'(*'"&2'?&#('*%$%&#**"+

%&%&$!(D($%""5*$!%%%(%%'"D(%(+##',#$$%"'((#*%


 '$!(', %& %& !"%5 % %& **"+(' # %&

!"%5!&(%&E+5#+%&,,2%',*'*+$(%*(!+(+%% H6-446='@=-.4@1=@%&$+D((!*'""5&'+(%*'+(*+"'%&%'%'2"2 %%+  !2'%5 # $' =4@ %& #%*$$'%% %& $+ # %& !+!( # 2'', !2%', &'( "D#+" (%  !(*+%'  =6@ %&$+D(*$$'%%D&'"%&#%D(,,'*$$'%%',335F'!!',&%'"*+%%E+,$% (%*', &$!(% %& 35 "*%*+%''(E+,$%#*2'*%'%&(%*D(##'$35%&((	+!$+%
?.	4%

46&
'%	+!$+%'*%''
>-?
	6=--@

 

J+"'%'((2'#$"+5 B,%'2C 2'* ,*'%'&+(%%&!"%5!)!!"G(%(%'$5%&%&$!( D& &( B <,,%"%%'2"5 B ++(+""5 (%+%+*C
%&*%<%#%&'(&$!(&B++(+""5(%+%+*C'(3##"',%%&!'%'(#(<!"'',&'("",3##',$'%',%',2'*#&7235!(%',%(%'$&$!( &   % B+%+B"2',#$'"5C&,!+(5,',*&#+"C3#E%'"%%5('##*%*$%&E+5%'#%&%&$!(&*$$'%%',(+*&&'+(*'$%&E+5D'%&(5$!%&%'*2'*+*%&,#&$!(G(&'$!!%3$(5$!%&E+(%'" *+("%&+,&%&'%'" (%%,5 *&'2 <*%"5 %!"%5!&(

!!"&$!(,+(%&

!(%', &$!(G( B!('%'2!&("(3*F#'!',%&"'*'%%'#2'*3+%#
%&'(,&$!(*"'$(E+" *+" &2 %(%'#' % 2'+('*'%('D&'*&&B((&D(%!!"5!!%%(%%,5D(%!(%&$!(5*((!'%#(*+("G(%(%'#''*%<$'%'33&2''%&25#%&D(*D33+%&'('(*&,#$ %& '*'% ' D&'*& &$'("*%',%&##'*G((&+"
> 
 

&D$+*&D',&%'#5(&+"3**)!!"G(**+* D'%& ) %(  %& #('* %$ %77
 %&% &$!( ' % (+## #$ 5 $%"'""((


(&%&$!(G(%'"*+("D&$(%+,',&%

#$ %& (%% 35 %&' '3'"'%5 % (! % %& (%%G(!(5*&'%'* <!% ('* D'%&+% <!% !(5*&'%'*(('(%* %&5 *+" % !(% !# # &$!(G($%"!3"$(D&'*&$5&2!2'#(%%&*&,(,'(%&'$%%&,+'"%!&(D&'*&*+"&2*(%'%+%$'%',%', 2'* %%&!"%5!&( 
%'(!*'("5 % %&'( !'% %&%  !!!'% !(5*&'%'* !(5*&",'*" <!% D'%(( $5 &2 !2' % %&$$3(#%&E+5%& J+'('%$'*"%(%'$53+%&$!(G($%"*'%'(+*&%&%%&E+(D+"&2*$$%&%&$!(G("'#3(!	!*'#'*""5'%D(%& 3E*% #'"+#&$!(G( <!%D'%(( ('*%35&'(*+("%!(%##*%'22'*#&'($%"!3"$(%&%!E+'*&'$3*+('%!'2&'$#5*&*#*2'*',%&E+5%*$$!"%5(&%#%&%&(%*&$!(3<$'35  J+"'#' !(5*&",'(%  !(5*&'%'(% D& & %&!!!'% <!%'(% 3  ##*%'2 D'%((%&'( (+3(%%'""'F"'&%&%%&(%*',(+"%'%&'(*(D+"&23'##%
%&*'*+$(%*('%'(#'"532'+(%&%%'"*+("G(*'('%!!"5%&*+% #+( % &' ) !!" D( ('$!"5 % B3E*%'2"5(3"C(%%,53*+()!!"D(%' %& !('%' % !2' %& F' # <!% !(5*&'%'*(('(%*J+'35%&)+A*(("+(

'2 %& 3(* # 2'* ' %& #$ # <!%

%(%'$5(+!!%',&$!(G(*"'$%&%&(+###$2($%"*'%'&'(%'"%%5(%&+(!%('#35#+"%%&(%%,5###',#('%&,+'"%!&(D&'"!(%',&$!(G(B!('%'2J+"'%'(C($'%',%',*'*+$(%*('%&!"%5!&(#%&'(*( (%'"*+("'*&(!+%'%&&'(**+("*""+!)!!"%**%+%#%G(B!('%'2$"

 

'XULQJ WKLV VWDJH RI WKH SURFHHGLQJV 

QHZ FRXQVHO

"!'
(

*%3--&$!(

# !(%*2'*%' "'# ' %& +% *"'$',   '##*+("   &$!( "", '

*+(" #'" %1 =@ J+%"53*F,+  !("  <'(%* # $'%',%', 2'*<!%  '2(%',%'2 (('(%*&'E+'(%3%'J+%&$!(G( *$!%*5 % %&'*'$'%',(%%$%(%%&!"'#( % %'" 3*+( %&5 +$+(D'%(((#'"%'$!"'*%' % %& E+5 +', &$!( D( J+' % !('%'"%'$%!!D'%((+', %& !"%5 !&( # %'2(%',%&$!(G($'"'%5*'(',%&'((+#&'(B,*&#%&!(*+%'%$'%$,

3+5--!(%*2



 (" $%' # #+( #!(5*&",'(%  '2(%',%  J+(% B#+( % &'  "!(5*&'%'(%'2(%',%%&'(*(#!(%*2'*%'"'###'2'%#)'""'"'"'*(%% %&% (& 2'D &$$'*" *(D&'*&''*%2'+("5',((&2',3'!(*&'I##*%'2'((*&D(%F',8'%&'+$""%&% BL'M# 7 &$!( '( #+
> 
 

3DUVRQV VWDWHG WKDW &RSSOH ZDV FKRVHQ EHFDXVH FRFRXQVHO

5LFKDUGVRQ KDG WDNHQ D FRXUVH IURP &RSSOH ZKLOH 5LFKDUGVRQ DWWHQGHG9DQGHUELOW DQG &RSSOH ZDV WKH KHDG RI WKH SV\FKRORJ\ GHSDUWPHQW

+",'*"!(5*&",'*"'$!'$%((*'332'%'("'F"5%&%($,#(+*&'$!'$%D+"&2<'(% % %& %'$ # %& ##(  D+" &2 3 (','#'*% #*% ' %$'', D&%&  % 7&$!( D( 3"% !!*'%%& D,#+"(( # &'(*+*%%*#$&'(*+*%%%&J+'$%(#"DD& & *$$'%% %& &$'*' # D&'*& & (%(*2'*%C"'(%%%&%&$!(D('##+""!(5*&",'*"2"+%'

&(%%%'"*+%*+*%2'%'5&',

7*&4?4---%&#&$!(G(%'"*+("%(%'#' )#( %%5 A(( %(%'#' %&% & FD3+%%&&'E+'(D&'*&'*"+B'*D*FD&&D(5+,%&$%&((+"%#((+"%'%&$'"'%5CA(("(*FD",%&%%'"*+("%%$!%%3+%'%3%'""#&$!(G($'*"*(A((''*%%&%%'"*+("'%!(%2'*%%'"#&$!(G(&'E+'(3*+(BDD+"&%&2($<!%!#D'%5%&2&'$%(%%&+,&%&	%%%&5'($%(%(&'$'%%$!%%2"!%&%CA((#+%&(%%%&%%'"*+(""(&%&'D<!%!!"

 *((<$'%' A(( *FD", %&% %'"

*+("&(+,&%$%"2"+%'%&%'%#'"%(&D$%"'""((#*%A(( #+%&,%&%('* %& D( 2'%+""5  "'F"'& %&% %&!(5*&'%'(% *+" #'$%"'""(( *+(" BD%%2"!#$)!!"&'(%(%'$5%&%L&$!(M&($ !('%'2 *&*%'(%'*( & 3'"'%'( %&% D+" 33#'*'" % (*'%5 D&2 & D(C %&"(( '(!( % %& J+(%' %&% %& D(  2'* #,'*'%5%&%!!"&**"+%&%&$!(D((A(((%%1

 (%*',)!!"'(%& #+#++"%!(5*&",'(%'$$(

%#+*%'(#('*!(5*&",('*)!!"G(%(%'$5#&$!(*+(&$!(!!<!%%&5D%3"%$%" '$!'$% "5', +!%'#!(%',&'(B!('%'2$"+!3',',C($'%',%',*$$%'"*+("((%'""5#$'%',%',2'*%%&(%*

& #'"+%&'!!!'

' *(J+*( # &$!(!+!%%'"(%%,5%&+,&+<,,%'%(5%&%%&*'('%& ('," $(% '$!%% *'('*+(" $ ' %&'( *( %$(%%,5D&'*&5'"%&''B!('%'2J+"'%'((2'%& "", %& # 2'* *'%' ( +*2 35 )!!!'% <!% &$!( D$'%',%',2'*3+%&'($**"+('(#)%(%&%&%&$!(D($"',',**', % %& %(%'$5 # )*2'*%'&',%&!(5*&'%#$-.%-- *& #'&$!(G( $%" *'%' %&!(5*&'%'*%$%77
)&$!((+###$($#$D&'*&D((*5%B(*&'I(+3%5!C)(!'%%&#*%%&%&'E+'(3#%&$+  <!3"$(('*'**%'&'(%%&' #'"+ % 3%' %& (!(5*&'%'* <!% D % ' '#$%'  
 2'D # )3*F,+%&%&(&+"3
4 
 

 "%&+,&)!!"D("'*(%!*%'*!(5*&",5'(( !+(+% %    H 646 &*""5"*F%&FD",(F'""<!'*%'',%#+*%'(#('*!(5*&",'(%'*!'%"$+*(( #' ' 
=@=@=3@ # & 	!*'"'%5 +'"'( #('*A(5*&",'(%()!!"&2%(%'#''*!'%"*(&%%(%'#''*'$'"*('5(72&$!(G(%'"*+("$'%%%&%)!!"D(%<!%'*'$'"3&2'&+(35%&'D$'(('&$!(G(%'"*+("**%&%)!!"D+"%&23 *$!%%% #+*%' (  #('*!(5*&",'(% '# %& 	!*'"'%5 +'"'( # ('*A(5*&",'(%(&3'##*%%%&%'$#%&%'"('*& ' % ,+""5 ,, ' %& !*%'* # #('*!(5*&",5

+%&&+"?4#%&((+"#2'*

D&'*&%*F(%&#"+"3!!"'*3"%%&'(*()!!"D+"%&23J+"'#'(<!%D'%(('#('*!(5*&",5+%&*'%'#! "!* 
 &
 - 
	 ?- =--4@ ('*!%35((	+!$+%'"!+

&--	44?=--?@
D&%&$!(%%&(%*',!&(#%&%'"D( %  '+(%'" !(5*&",'(% !'', 3+% D&%&&$!(D+"B%&'2C'!'(3+%J+"'#'<!%D& D+" &"! &'$ (*! %& %& !"%5 35 ,'2',%(%'$53+%&'($%"*'%'((%*2'*%&E+5 %&% %& $'%',%', *'*+$(%*( +%D',& %&,,2%', #*%(%5%%&"!''G(*"'$,'2)!!"G(3*F,+!*%'*('+(%'"!(5*&",'(%&('$!"5D(%J+"'#'%3<!%'%&'(*(

&!(%*('(J+'%",+(%$$

46 6 4 4? =%& ' 4@  & %&'( +%#+%&% *+(" D('##*%'2 # #'"',% !"* #++"%B!(5*&",'(%CD'%&'##%<!%D'%(((&'( *%"$'%',%'D'%(( %%&!"%5!&(  #((%'""5 !2'',  ",'%'$% $'%',%', 2'* %

 

&%&',%&%(%+*F$((

D&"*(D(""5%D'%'##*'%&$D&&"'+!%&D&%F'#!(($D&*$$'%%"",%&'($+%&%D(%'!&23($F'#3''ED&""%3+%%&%%%&%'$%&%$(%*"(&'E+'(DD($%'*"(#D'(*253+%%&%

A((#+%&#"*%%&%

""
*+"2#',++%D&'%&!!((+$',&F'""&'&'(,'"#''3+%
*+&*+"'%
*+"G%+(3*+( %& D %& "%!+II"$2535"(%&'(*(""%&D5%&+,&'%,',##%(%#'!(5*
D%%(5%&'(%&'('(DJ+'%(&'$#%&%&7'"((7%""'%""5#'%&'5**"+('!"*%&D
'G%&2+%#'%%&
(%'""%&+,&%($3+%D'G%&25%&!"*

%D'%&(%',A(('!+(+%&&'E+5%&5"%&$5&2%!+(+'%+,&C

*+(" '*&( %(%'#'

*+("3+%&'(&'E+'(%&%35&'',B!!"*"''*"
 
 

5LFKDUGVRQ VWDWHG

, EHOLHYH WKH WHVWV WKDW WKH\ JDYHWKDW WKH\ JLYH ZLOO UHIOHFW

ZKHWKHU RU QRW WKHUH LV VRPH EUDLQ GDPDJH RU QRW , EHOLHYH

FOLQLFDO SV\FKRORJLVWV GR WKLV IRU SV\FKLDWULVWV 7KH\ GR WKHWHVWLQJ WKDW ZLOO GHWHFW LI D SHUVRQ¶V EUDLQ LV QRW IXQFWLRQLQJSURSHUO\ IURP LQMXU\

&'$  3%%5 # %(%( ' (!*% % %&%C  '*&(

*FD",%&%%&%$%77
#+2'*#,'*'%53+%%&%BDD%!(5*&'%'(%#+DC'*&((%%1

L M' %5 % &'  !(5*&'%'(% 3+% %&% D( %

(+**((#+" '% D( 5+ FD'% D(%&%5! L#M%&','%D(%&5(%D&%&%,D'%&&'(,*&*%(2'#$"+!3',',$D'%& ,% " # 3'"'%5 %&% *+" 3 +( ' %&!'%%'5"'#(%*',
+3%'#%&D'""23%&$%& D%&%&(,3*F,+(&'
G%FD#5%&%&J+(%' ( % D&%& % $'< '% %&%  %5 %**%+%($3'$,%&%D&G%33"%(!%3+%%%&($%'$!33"5D'%&($$',,',$5L('*M*+"&2%&,'2%&E+5%&'%&%%&'($'#&2,%(+%#!'(D'%&($3'$,&D'""F'""($35"(%&%'(F'#*+%!+*%'2D%D'%&(%%,5!33"5'#D&%'%2,'D+",D'%&%&%&(%%,53*+(%&%'G%DF

D2 D& (F1 BLM# *+( '% '( (!*+"%' 5+*+"&2#+!(5*&'%'(%%(5&&3'$,QC'*&((%%%&%&BL!M33"5*+"&2C

) '""' "' %(%'#' <%  "' '(  *"''*"

!(5*&",'(%D'%&$(%G(,'2"!$%"*"''*" !(5*&",5 #$ :3'"%   A&) '2"!$%"  *"''*" !(5*&",5 #$ :3'"% #%,+%',#$:3'"%'-.."'DF%

 

$%" &"%& #*'"'%'E+'*'" ",'("%'2E+'*%'2*!*'%5

* ,-
$

*$$$
$#

& 	!*'"'%5 +'"'( # &%%!1RRDDD+"+R!"(R"'F(&%$

&2' ? =--@@ =$!&('(+'"'(#('*A(5*&",




7A

  -
$


 # 
$ 
2 *$
 

 ('* !(5*&",'(%( 

!(%%%&*+%,%D&'*&%&5D'""%(%'#5*$!%*%&#*%+"3<!'* %'', J+"'#'*%' (  <!%&( #*%+" 3(( % %&<!%%&(!*'#'*$

&%.=$!&('(@

+',%%&!(%*('%D

&$!(G( %'" *+(" % +((',% # &'',  #('* !!"(%&'<!%D'%(()!(5*&'%'(%  2  ," !#('* !(5*&",'(%  %& '2"2 !(5*&",'*" 2"+%'!!"'*%(D'%&!3"$(%&%!2B2*%'"2"+%'(CD&'*&*&%&'2*%'","(*&
 
 

LQ WKH %DNHU (QF\FORSHGLD RI 3V\FKRORJ\ 	 &RXQVHOLQJ

7KH UROH DQG IXQFWLRQ RI D SV\FKRORJLVW LQ D FRXUW VHWWLQJ

FDQ LQYROYH SUHWULDO WULDO DQG SRVWWULDO WDVNV 7KH SUHWULDOTXHVWLRQ RI FRPSHWHQF\ RI WKH GHIHQGDQW WR FRRSHUDWH ZLWK WKHDWWRUQH\ DQG XQGHUVWDQG WKH FKDUJHV LV XVXDOO\ GHWHUPLQHG E\ DFRPELQDWLRQ RI FOLQLFDO LQWHUYLHZV DQG WHVWV VXFK DV LQWHOOLJHQFHWHVWV SURMHFWLYH WHVWV DQG WHVWV IRU OLWHUDF\

7KH SV\FKRORJLVW PD\ DOVR EH DVNHG WR GHWHUPLQH WKH VWDWH

RI WKH GHIHQGDQW¶V PLQG DW WKH WLPH RI WKH FULPH 7KLV LV D UDWKHUFRQWURYHUVLDO DVSHFW RI WKH FRPSHWHQF\ HYDOXDWLRQ EHFDXVH WKHSV\FKRORJLVW LV DVNHG WR GHWHUPLQH WKH GHIHQGDQW¶V PHQWDO VWDWHQRW DW WKH WLPH RI WKH HYDOXDWLRQ EXW DW VRPH SUHYLRXV WLPH

%$.(5

(1&<&/23(',$ 2)

36<&+2/2*< 	 &2816(/,1* VXSUD DW 

#''%'# #('*!(5*&",5&(3 !%35%& $'* A(5*&",'*"8D 	*'%5 )'2'(' > # %& $'* A(5*&",'*" ((*'%'  	!*'#'*""5	*%'=@=@ # & 	!*'"'%5 +'"'( # ('*A(5*&",'(%(!2'(1

 	*!

 & +'"'( (!*'#5 %& %+ # ('3"

!#(('" !*%'* 35 #('* !(5*&",'(%(D'%&' 5 (+3'(*'!"' # !(5*&",5  =,*"''*" 2"!$%" (*'" <!'$%"@D&,,,+""5(#('*!(5*&",'(%(

 A(5*&",'(%C $( 5 ''2'+" D&(

!#(('" *%'2'%'(  #' 35 %& $'* A(5*&",'*" ((*'%'  35,+"%' # %'%" 35 (%% ,'(%%' "'*(+(%&!*%'*#!(5*&",5

3 ,- 
$.   # #


# 
$  *$
 * # #*$
  
$)
)

$''*%(('(%*%*+%(!%'(%"," !*',( **%'"  #('*

 77
 (  !(5*&",'(% ' )!%$%%%&($%'$$%%&:3'"%A(5*&'%5)!'%!'2%!*%'*

"' %(%'#' %&% (& 3,

'(%'%+%'"*('--'*"+(((($%%77
'-.	(2" %'$( ' 7*&  !'**%%'237<'$+%&%%'$"'$''(%B3(%(%( D'%& ($ '%'"    3*+(#%&&'(%5#&'E+*'2  %&% D D"" *C

"' %(%'#'%&% 3( %&

$'*"*(&#$%&#

&'23$'*"*'7&$!(&(&D%&3*$!(5*&%'*&!(5*&%'*$'*%'%%&%%'$"" ,%'  8'%&'+$%%',!(5*&'%'(%(%%&%%'$)")+$3"&""% -- & ',( &'$ '((*&'I##*%'2'&5(*'3&'(,'%%3&&(%'"'%5  &5 (*'3 &'('<!'*#+'%5&""+*'!'&'(%&+,&%(#!(*+(+'*'*+!"#**('*"" 3+', 3%& &'( &( *%'"5%D#%&(!(5*&'%# %&$ & *(' %& !$"',', %&% & D( #F'%&+,&+% %&' '23 *%&( !(5*&'%'(%( & '(*+
. 
 

$"',',3*+(%&5'G%#"%&%'%**+%#""#%&!(5*&%'*(5$!%$(%&5(D'&'$&(FD&%%&#*%(D+"3*((5#&%

2"!!''(%&$!(G(*'%'%%&%'$#%&##("'(%%%&%B%&$(%'$!%%%&',%&%D+"3*((5D+"3#+""&'(%5#+""$'*"*( # 7 &$!( !' % %& *$$'((' # %&##(C	&1

$%&*(
D(3"%2'D'%D(*"%&%%&(*'"&'(%5D(25(F%*&5'%$(#&'($%&'(%5&'(*&'"&&'(+!3',',"(#$'"5&'(%5 # $%"'""((  & ($% 3  L('*M(%,2'*%(+,,(%%&%%&D($%"'""((' &'( #$'"5 !33"5 ' &'( #%& D& *$$'%%(+'*'  D( FD % 3 <%$"5 2'"% !(('3"5'&'($%&3+%#%&( *(D2'"3"

	&%&#(%%%&%(&'%&2!''3+%&$!(G(',(%'*(%%+('-. *((<$'%'"'%(%'#'%&%(&2'D""#%&*(%&%'%&$'*"*#$77
&'( '*"+ '"5 !,(( %( $'*%' (&%( %&!%#%&!(5*&",'*"%(%',%&'(*&,(+$$5%&$'(('(+$$5%&(%##*#*!%%&(*'"DFG(&'(%5&(F'#(&%&+,&%5#%&%(%!*+(D+"'3"(&(%%%&%(&'%2'D%&D%(%%&(F'#(&%&+,&%%&%%&%(%',!*+%77
'-.D(+"'3""'(!1B
G%%&'F'%D(+"'3"
%&'F%&%'% D( % <%('2 +,&C& (F D&% %(%( (&!#$"'<!"'1

& %(%( %&% 
 $''(% ' --4 %&% '*%"5

(( D&%& %& D( !(5*&('(  % 
$''(%%&A 

$''(%%&77A


D&'*&!"*(%&77A
D&'*&D($''(%'-.
$''(%%&(*&*&D&'*&D(%$''(%

 

WKH KLVWRU\ RI WKH ILHOG LWV SULQFLSOH WKDQG LQWHUYHQWLRQV XVHG LQ WKH ILHOG,Q GHVFULELQJ IRUHQVLF SV\FKLDWU\

3V\FKRORJ\ 	 &RXQVHOLQJ VWDWHV

)RUHQVLF SV\FKLDWU\ LV D EUDQFK RI IRUWKDW GHDOV ZLWK WKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI PHG7KH WHUP PHGLFROHJDO UHIHUV WR D EUDQFK RI ODZ WKDW GHDOV ZLWK WKH DSSWR PHGLFDO DQG SV\FKLDWULF SUREOHPVPHGLFROHJDO SV\FKLDWU\ DUH XVHG L3IRUHQVLF SV\FKLDWU\ ́ KDV D VSHFLILF 

XVHG WR GHQRWH WKH LQWHUIDFH VKDUHG E

%DNHU (QF\FORSHGLD RI 3V\FKRORJ\ 	 6LPLODUO\ 3IRUHQVLF SV\FKRORJ\ ́ LV GHILQHRI 3V\FKRORJ\ WR EH 3>D@ EUDQFK RI DSSOLPDNHV SUDFWLFDO VXJJHVWLRQV DERXW WKH 'LFWLRQDU\ RI 3V\FKRORJ\ DOVR GHILQHV 3IR3>W@KH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI SV\FKRORJLFDO SULQLQFOXGLQJ WKH HYDOXDWLRQ RI WHVWLPRQ\ IX

PHWKRGV RI LQWHUURJDWLRQ JXLOW GHWHFWLRQWKHUDS\ DQG JHQHUDO DVVLVWDQFH LQ D YDULH

& !#(('" ,"(  

!(5*&",'(%( %&+( '## $F!(5*&'%'(%(!(5*&",'(%( ( *$5 # A(5*&'%5  8!(5*&'%5'($'*"(+3(!*'"%5*"''*" !*%'* ' %& $5 !!"'%","'((+(C'*"+',**'$'"*$!%*&%%!1RRDDD	'$'""5  %& $'*  D&'*& '( !% # %& $'*A(5*&",5#'(B#('*!(5*%& (*'* !#(('#!(5'((+("%',%%&"D",#('*!(5*&",5'*"+('!2"+%'    <!%  %(%'$#('* '((+(  (+*&  (  %'"  7'  ',&%( *'$'&%%!1RRDDD3#!*$R3*&+&%$
. 
 

6,23 'LYLVLRQ  RI WKH $PHULFDQ 3V\FKRORJLFDO $VVRFLDWLRQ DQG

DQ RUJDQL]DWLRQDO DIILOLDWH RI WKH $PHULFDQ 3V\FKRORJ\ 6RFLHW\ VWDWHV WKDWLWV SXUSRVH LV WR VWXG\ DQG SURPRWH KXPDQ SHUIRUPDQFH LQ RUJDQL]DWLRQDODQG ZRUN VHWWLQJV DQG LV SHUKDSV WKH PRVW DXWKRULWDWLYH VRXUFH LQ WKLVFRXQWU\ IRU LQIRUPDWLRQ DERXW WKH QDWXUH DQG H[SHUWLVH RI LQGXVWULDO

RUJDQL]DWLRQDO ,2 SV\FKRORJLVWV

7KHVH GHVFULSWLRQV RI ,2 SV\FKRORJLVWV DUH JHQHUDOO\ DFFHSWHG E\

SV\FKRORJLVWV )RU H[DPSOH WKH 0DF0LOODQ 'LFWLRQDU\ RI 3V\FKRORJ\GHILQHV 3LQGXVWULDO SV\FKRORJ\ ́ DV 3>W@KH SV\FKRORJLFDO VWXG\ RI DOODVSHFWV RI ZRUN DQG RI WKH ZRUNLQJ HQYLURQPHQW DQG WKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RISV\FKRORJLFDO ILQGLQJV WR LPSURYLQJ HIILFLHQF\ DQG FRQWHQWPHQW DW ZRUNWKURXJK HJ EHWWHU VHOHFWLRQ PHWKRGV LPSURYHG GHVLJQ RI PDFKLQHU\

LPSURYHG WUDLQLQJ RU LPSURYHG RUJDQL]DWLRQDO DQG PDQDJHPHQWVWUDWHJLHV ́ 0$&

0,//$1

',&7,21$5< 2)

36<&+2/2*< G HG VHH

DOVR

7+(

',&7,21$5< 2)

36<&+2/2*<  'HILQLQJ 3LQGXVWULDO

RUJDQL]DWLRQDO SV\FKRORJ\ ́ DV 3>W@KH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI SV\FKRORJLFDO WKHRU\DQG PHWKRGV WR LQGXVWULDO DQG RUJDQL]DWLRQDO SUREOHPV KDYLQJ WR GR ZLWKD SHUVRQ¶V VHOI RWKHUV MRE PDFKLQHV RSHUDWLRQV HWF DV ZHOO DV WRLPSURYLQJ VHOHFWLRQ RI SHUVRQQHO DQG ZRUN SURFHGXUHV DOO LQ WKH LQWHUHVWRI HVWDEOLVKLQJ D SURGXFWLYH DQG KDSS\ FOLPDWH LQ D YDULHW\ RI VKRSVDJHQFLHV DQG RUJDQL]DWLRQV DV ZHOO DV HQKDQFLQJ SURILW ́ $V H[SODLQHGLQ WKH %DNHU (QF\FORSHGLD RI 3V\FKRORJ\ 	 &RXQVHOLQJ

3>D@UHDV RI VSHFLDOL]DWLRQ ZLWKLQ ,2 SV\FKRORJ\ LQFOXGHSHUVRQQHO LQGXVWULDO SV\FKRORJ\ VHOHFWLRQ DQG KLULQJ WUDLQLQJ

DQG SHUIRUPDQFH DSSUDLVDO %$.(5

(1&<&/23(',$ 2)

36<&+2/2*< 	 &2816(/,1*  G HG  VHH DOVR  (1&<&/23(',$ 2)

36<&+2/2*<   GLVFXVVLQJ

LQGXVWULDO DQG RUJDQL]DWLRQDO SV\FKRORJ\ LQ WKUHH DUWLFOHV DERXW

 (+"%%(  (%## !(5*&",'(%( D& 2"!

(*'%'#'*FD",  !!"5'%%%& ("+%'#!3"$(%DFK

 *&(D&%''%&(*&!!"'*%'#

'+(%'",'I%'"!(5*&",5

&%%!1RRDDDR('!,R
AR	
AR3*&+&%$"& $'*

A(5*&",'*" ((*'%'!2'(('$'"#''%'(%%',%&%B'+(%'"R,'I%'"!(5*&",'(%(!!"5!(5*&",'*"!'*'!"((*&$%&(%%&DF!"*'%&'%(%#'$!2',!+*%'2'%5 %& J+"'%5 # DF "'#C&%%!1RRDDD!,R(%+%(R3*&+R(+3#'"(&%$"

 

' -.  & A 
 D( % $''(% %& 77
 

 (*&*& D&'*& '(  !E*%D&'*&D(%%&%&("%(%('D&'*&''2'+"(D(*&*&'(25'##%

"'(%%%&%#$&3%%5#%&% &$!( D( #F',  '""((

 75  -- %& !(%

&$!(G( *"'$ '*"+', &'(*+("*"'$&'(J+(%#&*+%#+1

 )#(*+("$

%&'*"'%G(3*F,+A(% *+(" !(%!3"$(%&!%#7&2 3  #(%%&*(%'%+%(&'",'(%

4 +(" ' % (F <

(('(%* ,', "",&$!(+',&'(5+%&'*$!%*5%%&%'$#%& #*%(  *'*+$(%**(('%5#(+*&*%'

6 +("'%#'"%!(

%%'"&#*%(('$!"5"##(

&$!(!!"%%&

 !!"("",%&%&'(%'"##'"',%=@'%2'DD'%((&'( #( (!*'""5 +'=4@ J+%"5 '2(%',% &'( =6@J+%"5!!%&#(
4 
 

&(('$'"+%# !!"(##'$


-.	4='$ !!--?@
% **"+ %&% &$!( #'" % $(%% 5!(5*&",'*"'$!'$%%&%$5&2<'(%D&'*&D+"&2 *(%'%+% $'%',%', 2'*  %&% &$!(G("",&'E+'(&5##*%+!&'($%"(%3'"'%5%%&%'$#%&$+&% (#&$!(G(*"'$%&%%'"*+("D'##*%'2# #'"', % '%2'D D'%((( % (&D %&% &'( &'E+'( $',&% &2 *%'3+% % &'( *$$'((' # %&*'$'*"+',$,%&(&'((%!#%&%%5'%&$'"'%5%&$%&#&'(*#%%&*+%#+%&%&$!(D(+3"%(&D!E+'*3*+(#%&D'%(((%(%'#'%%&!(%*2'*%'&',%6> B *% (!*+"% +!%&+(#+"((#%&( D'%((( D'%&+% %& '#$%' %&5 *+" &2!2'C&%>

,',%&#'"+%'2(%',%"",&'E+'(

%&((+%#'$'" !!"(&"1

2', %$' %& '(  +%5 % '2(%',%

D&%&5!(5*&",'*"'$!'$%($',&%J+"'#5($'%',%', 2'*D%&"(( **"+%&%%&!%'%'&(#'"%$(%%5!E+'*#$%&#'"+#%'"*+("%#+%&'2(%',%%&&'E+'(
#3##
  #    -
   # 
#
$
$   ) * *  $$*+()"'*"'%,'2!''%&('$!%%'((+(%&2'*(%!!%,'(%%&%'"*+%G(#'',%&%%&#(%%5(D%'##*%'2

&*'('%%#+%&!+(+%&&'E+'('

%& !"%5 !&( # %& %'" "( J+"'#' ( (3" (%%,5  '" *+("G( *'(' %$!&('I%&!%'%'G(!('%'2J+"'%'(%&%&

 

 (%&%'"**""5(&D

%&J+'('%FD",%'<!% (('(%* *((5 %*(%'%+%'" ',&%(  	'$!"5 !+$'*"<!%'(%3J+"'#'3&"#  % 3+% %& (%%G!#$ 35 %& %$ # #!(5*&",'(%( % 77
  	!*!(5*&",'(%(!*'"'I','	*'2"+%'(!!""*F%&(!<!'*%'',%#+*%'%&'(*!'%"*(D&#('*!D(%!2'!(5*&",3&2''%(&D%&%&D

 ($%%##*%'+(%'"!(

)!!"'!%'*+"%+!(#('*!(5*&",'(%('*!'%"	*'%5#
+(%'",'I

!#' )#!*"%(#"!!$"#)%".#"
+(%'",'I%'" =*""*,'I %& '%!,'I%'((*'%5%&# #*%( (+*& ( '*(', ,D', *(+$ D(( *&,', %+ # %& DF##*'"'%% (!(( % '((+( !!"%DF35(2',(3+('(('+(%5"3!+3"'*&"%&,'I%'(1&51 	*'%'(%(D&'2!'*'!

,'I%'"3&2'%&
 
 

7KH OHDG RSLQLRQ¶V DWWHPSW WR FKDUDFWHUL]H 'U &RSSOH DV D FOLQLFDO

SV\FKRORJLVW DV RSSRVHG WR DQ LQGXVWULDO SV\FKRORJLVW E\ YLUWXH RI 'U&RSSOH¶V VHOIVHUYLQJ GHVFULSWLRQ LV XQSHUVXDVLYH 'HVSLWH WKHSURIHVVLRQDO ODEHO WKDW 'U &RSSOH FKRVH IRU KLPVHOI WKH IDFW UHPDLQV WKDWE\ GHILQLWLRQ 'U &RSSOH LV DQ LQGXVWULDO SV\FKRORJLVW LQDVPXFK DV KHVSHFLDOL]HV LQ WKH HYDOXDWLRQ RI 6RFLDO 6HFXULW\ DSSOLFDQWV ZKR DOOHJHGO\VXIIHU IURP SV\FKRORJLFDO GLVRUGHUV ZKLFK SUHYHQW WKH DSSOLFDQWV IURPSHUIRUPLQJ ZRUN LQ WKH QDWLRQDO HFRQRP\ DQG LQ 3YRFDWLRQDO HYDOXDWLRQV ́ZKLFK DUH XVHG WR DVVLVW LQGLYLGXDOV LQ DFKLHYLQJ WKHLU YRFDWLRQDO JRDO6HH 67('0$1¶6 0(',&$/

',&7,21$5<  WK HG  GHILQLQJ

3LQGXVWULDO SV\FKRORJLVW ́ DV D OLFHQVHG SV\FKRORJLVW ZKR VSHFLDOL]HV LQ

3WKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH SULQFLSOHV RI SV\FKRORJ\ WR SUREOHPV LQ EXVLQHVVDQG LQGXVWU\ ́ 6LJQLILFDQWO\ 'U &RSSOH LQ QR ZD\ FRXOG EHFKDUDFWHUL]HG DV D IRUHQVLF SV\FKRORJLVW 6HH LG GHILQLQJ 3IRUHQVLFSV\FKRORJLVW ́ DV D OLFHQVHG SV\FKRORJLVW ZKR VSHFLDOL]HV LQ 3WKHDSSOLFDWLRQ RI SV\FKRORJ\ WR OHJDO PDWWHUV LQ D FRXUW RI ODZ ́ VHH DOVRLQIUD QRWH 

<!%  '(% &'', ) !!"  '+(%'"!(5*&",'(% &$!(G( %'" *+(" 2'(*%&$!(G( *(%'%+%'" %'%"$% + 	 # 5##*%'2 *%%  &$!(G( %'" *+("G( "",<!"%'#&'',!!"D(%&%%&5*+"%#'!(5*&'%'(%'(&2'""('*%&!(5*&'%'(%%&5''"5+(&$2+%# (%% 
##*%&$!(G(%'"

*+("G(*'('%&')!!"(%'!!%&'*"'%#&'(*(%'%+%'"',&%%**((%!!!'%!(5*&'%'*<!%+""'#5',%&!%*%'(!2'35%&)+A*(("+(    ' 46 6 4. 4.- =.%&

'-->@=%',%&%BLM(	<!"'(+!*((J+'(**((% <!%D&D'""*+*%%E+(%53+%!!!'% <$'%'C  #'',%&%%&!%'%'G(B<$D('!!!'%3*+('%'%"2'%%&$'%',%',J+(%'(((%'"%L%&!%'%'MC@K" -> 4 6 .- =-%& ' --@=BL
M	 L%&#%MD(%'%"%&'(D*$!%% !(5*&'%'* <!%C@  
 (&% &$!(G(*(%'%+%'" %'%"$% + 	 D( 

$',"(( 35 &'( *+("G( #'"+ % &'  <!%J+"'#' % !2' %& !(5*&'%'*  !(5*&",'*"(('(%**((5%&!%'%'((+(#&$!(G(*(

 

%(+,,(%3'$,D&'"++!J+%'2(%',%'L(%%,5%*%'*#'"2&" (+!!%  *"'$ # )#*$+(%3,'2%'*+( %D <!%( ' %*+("*%3#+"%#*+"%3(+!!%35$

&%=$!&('(K'%

&((+%#'$'

&$!(G(*"'$%&%%'"*+(#( D'%((( % %(%'#5 !%%&35 !$'%%', %& (%% % '$'"'%5&'(%5&*+%#+1

 %%&!(%*2'*%'&', D'(&',%&%&&$%'$%%(%'#'%&%&'((%%,5%%!%'%' 35 *""', (5$!%&D # %& (%%G( !!%+'%%(%'$53+%%&!%'%'%&!%'D+"&23%2'*%""

 %%5'*&(%(%'#'%

D'%(((%&%D&%#*!+!%&!3"$(%&%&&'%&%%&*((<$'%'#7(3+%B'G%"'IDD+"&+!D&C


 + 2'D #( *+(

!(('3",('&%'%&%&'*'('%!(%&!(D(*"(('*%*%'*"*'('3( +! J+% !!%'(*,+((
44 
 

72%&'(%&','%&*%(+,,(%%&%

'%'"!!%'%'$D'%&%&D'%((*+"&2!2%%&(%%#$##*%'2"5*((<$'',&
#7(E+"D%%(%'#5%""%%&!%'%'G(!'$'"'%53*F,+%&(%%D+"3%'%"%3+%%&%%(%'$5
(+$$5D*%&"%&%%&2'*!!%,'(%%&#'',#%&%'"*+%%&%%'"*+("&!#$##*%'2"5

&%

8(%"5%&((+%#'$'" !!"(E*%

&$!(G('##*%'2(('(%*#*+("3(%&*"'$%&%%'"*+("!%&%$,',2'*%%&!"%5!&(&$!(&*$!"'%&%%&(%%D(""D%!(%$,',2'*'3+%%"%&+,&) %( 3*+( %'" *+(" (F !!" 3+% &'(,J+"'%'(&((+%# !!"((1

 %%5'*&($'%%B
#F"5'%FD

%&%%&L(M%%*+"+('#$%','235%&#%%!(5*&'%'(%C %%5A((%(%'#'%&%%&'(%%,5D(%$!&('I!('%'2%%'3+%(#%& !%'%'  (&D %& E+5 %&% & *+" " !+*%'2"'#'!'()!!"G(%(%'$5!"5F5"'%&'((%%,5 "%&+,&3%&%'"%%5(!!%"5D(+!'(35%&#*%%&%%&(%%*+"+( %& '#$%' *J+' 35 77
 %%5A(( ' *FD", %&% & FD %&% !('%'2%(%'$535)!!"D+"!%& #%&(%%%!(%,%'2'#$%'

 ,' %& !%'%' &( #'" % (%3"'(& 5

!E+'*35D&%2#'*'*5%&$5&23'%& !#$* # *+("  & 2'* ( %!!%,'(%%&#'',%&%%&(%*D+"&2 3 '##% '# %& %%5( & FD %&'#$%' *""*% 35 77
 D+" &2 3$'(('3"
+2'D%'"*+("&"'%%"*&'*%&%&% *"" )!!"'  ##%% (%3"'(&J+%$'%',%', *'*+$(%*(2'#%&&

 

!3%'2 J+(%'( % (F !(5*&'%'(%(&D%'%!"5D'%(((D&*$"53"'2$',&%3"2%%%&!(5*&'%'(%( * '%'#5 %&*!%'2O(5$!%$(#'('%%&'3(2%'("2%352'%'5+"(!(5*&'%'(%',('('%",+,%&%D'"%&###2'*'# %& %(F % & &'2(%',%''%!%%''""5(('(%"5E+(D&,'!(5*&'%'*$%%(%$F%$'%' 3+% %& $#%%%&%'$#%&##

SS

5,'I',#%N($(+"%(3&2'%&''%'"',&%#%&' <!%'( '2(%',%'2  "5%'* !!(5*&'%'(%(#*&!%5$(% **+% %$'%' #3#%&$

	>?
	%..=*'%%'(


%&'(*(%&%'"*+%,%

#+(%&'B!'2%!(5*&'%##', *+(" %& 3#'% # *(+"%%'',(%%&#*(%'%+%'"',&%(#%&#=0 %4>@ "%&+,&&$!(% !(5*&'%'* (('(%* ( J+"+(+	&'(%'"*+("&''+(%'"!(5*&",'(%D&!#(('"J+"'#'*%'(*(($%"!(5*&",'*"<$'%'%& #(  
 #'"', % &' 
> 
 

3*+( %&5 J+(%' %& "'3'"'%5 # %& !(5*&'%'*2"+%'#%&#('*%$%7'"((7%""%&
(%'%+%=B77
C@'"*+("#'"%&'($%'#*+%#+',3*+(&$!(G($%"(%%+(D(''((+#%&D(*&,'%&'(*(&D(,',%3 %'" # &'("'# %& (%% D( ,',% !(%2'*#&'(#+%+,+(((A(+$3"53*+(&$!( $  %&(&" (&D', # !(5*&'%'*(('(%*+	
%&%'"*+%,%&'($%'#

*+%#+(%&'&'(D!(5*&'%'*<!%%(('(%'&'(#(%(!%%&(%%G(!(5*&'%'*<!%(


	%&	+!$+%&"%&%+%&)+A*((

"+(#%&+%%& $$%'',%#%&( %& ',&% % <!% !(5*&'%'* (('(%* +! !"'$'5(&D',%&%&'(('%5%%&%'$#%&##('("'F"5%3(','#'*%#*%%%'" (%&	+!$+% <!"'  '',% #% %  $''$+$ '(%'%" % B**(( %  *$!%% !(5*&'%'(% D& D'""*+*%!!!'%<$'%'(('(%'2"+%'!!%'!(%%'#%&#(C>?
	 %.6

	 "( &" %&% D& !!!'% %& ',&% % <!%(('(%* !!"'( % %& (%*', !&( # *!'%"!*',(&%.
',(%&+%$!&('I%&!'2%""%&%!(5*&'%'*<!%&(*$%!"5'(+*&!*',(1

LM& %& 	%% &( $ %& #%N( $%"*'%'"2%%&'(*'$'"*+"!3'"'%5%%&!+'(&$% & $',&% (+## %& (('(%* # !(5*&'%'(%$5D""3*+*'"%%&#%N(3'"'%5%$(&"&'(#(
%&'("!(5*&'%'(%(,%&#*%(%&+,&!#(('"<$'%''%2'D("(D&%&%%&5D'"" (&D'%&%&E+,E+5K%&5"5I%&'#$%',%&#$'%D!"+('3" **"+('( 3+% %& #%N( $%"*'%'  3+% %& ##*%( # 5 '( 3&2'K  %&5 ## !''( 3+% &D %&#%N( $%" *'%' $',&% &2 ##*% &'(3&2' % %& %'$ ' J+(%' &5 FD %&

 

7KH DOOHJDWLRQ UHDGV LQ SDUW

&RXQVHO ZDV LQHIIHFWLYH IRU IDLOLQJ SUHVHQW UHOHYDQW HYLGHQFH RI 0U 7KLVWRU\ DQG WR VHFXUH DGHTXDWH H[SH7KRPSVRQ LQFOXGLQJ SV\FKRORJLVWV QQHXURORJLFDO H[SHUWV WR HVWDEOLVK LQFOXGLQJ EXW QRW OLPLWHG WR WKUHH V

3 !# %&% %'" *+(" '##% (%%,5 %& &( 3%& (%%,5 D+" &2 *+( %& E+5 #+ %& **"+%&%%&+%*$D+"'# %&E+5 & % &%& %(%', 35 77
  
# 5 D!%'%'G(,*&*%%&%'%"%3+%%"&"53%!(%!#%"" % %& !%'%' &  3*F,+K%&#'"+%!(!',3&2'$',&%&2(('(%*

&%?

& (( 	+!$ 

!!"'*%'#!$'(('%!!


""#,/"

&$!(%&3+,&%%&'(#

+$+("",%'(&$!(*#+',#$%"&"%&'2(+',(%%!(%*2'*%'!*',&%%+!*(("("", $$% ',&% % ##*%'2 &$!(((%%&%&'(%'"*#'"', %1 =@ !#$  (3*F,+$%"&"%&&'(<!%(('(%*,',&'($
4> 
 

XQGHU 7HQQHVVHH ODZ LH WKDW 0U 7KRPSVRQ VXIIHUHG IURPVXEVWDQWLDO PHQWDO GLVRUGHUV DQG GHPRQVWUDEOH SK\VLFDO EUDLQGDPDJH ZKLFK PDGH KLP XQDEOH WR FRQIRUP KLV EHKDYLRU WR WKHODZ OHIW KLP XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI H[WUHPH PHQWDO RU HPRWLRQDOGLVWXUEDQFH >DQG@ VXEVWDQWLDOO\ LPSDLUHG KLV DELOLW\ WR DSSUHFLDWHWKH ZURQJIXOQHVV RI KLV FRQGXFW DW WKH WLPH RI WKH RIIHQVH

$JDLQ LQ D VHSDUDWH DOOHJDWLRQ 7KRPSVRQ DOOHJHG

&RXQVHO IDLOHG WR REWDLQ DGHTXDWH H[SHUW DVVLVWDQFH LQFOXGLQJFRQILGHQWLDO SV\FKRORJLFDO QHXURSV\FKRORJLFDO DQG QHXURORJLFDO

H[SHUWV

2Q )HEUXDU\   7KRPSVRQ ILOHG DQ H[ SDUWH PRWLRQ IRU

WHPSRUDU\ PDQGDWRU\ UHVWUDLQLQJ RUGHU IRU SUHOLPLQDU\ LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHIIRU SHUPDQHQW PDQGDWRU\ LQMXQFWLRQ IRU DQ RUGHU ILQGLQJ SHWLWLRQHULQFRPSHWHQW WR SURFHHG FRQWLQXDQFH DQG WR WROO $WWDFKHG WR WKDW

2'"3"2'*#$%"'""((*+(35%D ('+(&'E+'(K=>@'2(%',%*&"",&$!(G(*$!%*5% (%%'"(D""(&'(*$!%*5%%&%'$#%&##(


%&'+"4=#@L+"'2A4=#@M!%%%&

*+% &$!( *% %&% '(*25 (&+" 3 &,',%&($%%("",'&'(!%'%'(+*&%&#"*(%'%+%'"(%&%$',&%3'(*2+',&3(!*',(&3E*%%'(*252$3 4 --. %& $,'(%% E+, '((+  ""D', *+(" % %F %& !('%'( # %& $%"&"%& <!%( D& & %% &$!( +', &'('**%'&$,'(%%E+,%'!%'%!%%&%%&!%'%'#D'%#&3('*"+"",%'%&%<*+%',%&!%'%'D+"2'"%%&',&%& $$%3*+(&'('*$!%%%3<*+% %%&($%'$%& $,'(%% E+, +%&'I %&  % %F %&!('%'(#&$!(G(%D<!%(!(5*&",'(%5	+"%+!(5*&",'(%5D  2$3 6 --. %& '(%'*% *+%##'$%&$,'(%%E+,G(&'(%'*%*+%"(<!%&(*!#'(*251

 *"'%#%&##*%'2(('(%* 6 6  -? =*+("G( #'"+%&2 B5D( $, %& (&%*$',($+%',%'##*%'2(('(%*6 % .>.>- =&"', %&% %'2(%',%!(%5$'%',(%*',!&(B3*+(&'5,C*(%'%+%'##*%'2B%&'((',(%#"*%(%3'*%'#2**5C@K%4?=%&'--@=#'',%&##*%'2(('(%*#*+("(  (+"% # *+("G( #'"+$'%',%' 2'* ,', 3*F,+,'*3'$%%&%(+*&'#$%'*+"$  ( *'('% D'%&%*%'*"(%%,'*((C@

&*(3#+(#'%((J+"5

D&'*&*+("G(#'"+%&2*!'%"*(*(%'%+%('##*%	!*'#'*""5 %'" *+("G( *'#+(,%'$%'( >? 
	 . .6 =-!(5*&",'(%"*F',%&J+'('%!%&%(F%&D(('$!"5%(%%,5'%&'(*(&$!(G(&'  !!!'% !(5*&'%'* !+!% %'" (%%,5 %&+,&+(+"% &$!(G( %'" %%",'%'$%$'%',%',2'*%%&&*(J+*#%'"*+("G%'" (%%,5 '( %&% %& * "'3'"'%5#%&(%%*+%G(%&

 ( ''*% &$!(G( 

*$$*$%#%&!*',$2##+(%&'!(5*&'%
4 
 

 	#*!!

	 
!"#0!#" *1!"!/#"&'(+%G(*%%&!"%5E+'(!+*''*%(

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

*+("G(#'"+%J+(%'&'("5<!%D'%((3+%&'(!'',',D&%&%&!%'%'"*F%&J+'('%'%%%*$$'%%&*'$(3#!+%%',&'$%&(%%%&*+"!3'"'%5!&(D(B'<*+(3"CB3E*%'2"5+(3"C$+%',%'##*%'2(('(%*#*+("D&%&<!%G(%(%'$5%&%!%'%''%"*F%&J+'('%'%% B*%'*%%& ("#(%&5C BD( *$!"%"5 2(%%', % %& #(C@K 

66-=%&'--?@=+"',%&%%'"*+("G(!%5"#&'(*"'%(B2'*'+(3$"C"3"',&'$(B+%(CBE+(%+%#($35G('((5"+$C D( %  ",'%'$% %'" (%%,5 !'2', &'(

 DIILGDYLW LV WKH 'HFODUDWLRQ RI 'U )D\H 6XD 3K' LQ FOLQLFDO SV\FKRORJ\ IURP WKH GHFODUDWLRQ 6XOWDQ VWDWHG WKDW VKH KDG H[DEDVLV VLQFH  ,Q 6XOWDQ¶V RSLQLRQ DV RDOO RI WKH GLDJQRVWLF FULWHULD IRU PDMRU (SLVRGLF ZLWK ,QWHUHSLVRGH 5HVLGXDO 6\PQRW GLVFXVV 7KRPSVRQ¶V PHQWDO VWDWH DW WLWV IRFXV ZDV WR DGGUHVV KLV WKHQFXUUHQLQDELOLW\ WR SURFHHG ZLWK WKH DSSHDO SURF

7KRPSVRQ ILOHG D PRWLRQ WR DOWHU RU D

)HG 5 &LY 3 E IRU WKH SXUSRVH RI DUHFRUG ZLWK WKH GHSRVLWLRQ DQG DFFRPS6XOWDQ 3K' 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW GHQLHG L

0DUFK  

 '%'""5 '# %& #*%(  !%'%'G($%"&"%&(&+"$'%',%', 2'* !%'%'"'#     #%  *+(5 2"+$( # (%% *+$%( '!!(%&%&$!(&(""($#&'(*"'$(%&$ <$!" !%'%' *"'$(!!"5'2(%',%&'($%"&$'%',%',2'*%%'"*%( %&% & & %D ('%$'%%%3'I"+('D'%(((%%(%'#5%(+*&(&+"&23'%+* *%(%&%&'('(%'%+%'"#(*&'I!&'D'%&!3"$(&""+*'%'(!''%&(#*%+""",%'(&$5&!()D

'("'*(!(5*&",'(%'%&	%#$"'	%%
'2('%5% %& ( # *"''*"  #+!(5*&",5D$%D'&"#%%&&+(0+4
4 
 

&URZQ WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH WHVWV LQFOXGHG

7KH 6KLSOH\ ,QVWLWXWHV RI /LYLQJ 6FDOH WKH *): $XGLWRU\6HOHFWLYH $WWHQWLRQ 7HVW WKH &DWHJRU\ 7HVW WKH .DXIPDQ1HXURSV\FKRORJLFDO $VVHVVPHQW 3URFHGXUH WKH /XULD 0HPRU\7HVW WKH 5HLWDQ,QGLDQD $SKDVLD 6FUHHQLQJ 7HVW WKH 5H\2VWHUUHLWK &RPSOH[ )LJXUH 7HVW WKH 7UDLOPDNLQJ 7HVW :RUG*HQHUDWLRQ )$6 )LQJHU 2VFLOODWLRQ 7HVW DQG WKH :LVFRQVLQ&DUG 6RUWLQJ 7HVW

'FW 5 YRO  ([K  S

&URZQ GHILQHG 3RUJDQLF EUDLQ GDPDJH ́ DV 3GDPDJH WR WKH EUDLQ

WKDW LV RI D SK\VLFDO QDWXUH DQG WKDW SK\VLFDO QDWXUH PD\ EH DQDWRPLF LWPD\ EH HOHFWULFDO RU LW PD\ EH PHWDEROLFDO ́ 5 S :KHQ DVNHG LIKH NQHZ WKH FDXVDWLRQ IRU 7KRPSVRQ¶V EUDLQ GDPDJH KH UHSOLHG 3, GRQ¶WVSHFLILFDOO\ NQRZ WKH FDXVDWLRQ , EHOLHYH LW PD\ EH VHFRQGDU\ WR KLVWKRXJKW GLVRUGHU VLQFH ZH NQRZ WKDW LQ SHRSOH ZLWK WKRXJKW GLVRUGHUV WKDWWKH WKRXJKW GLVRUGHU LWVHOI PD\ HLWKHU EH FDXVHG E\ RU PD\ UHVXOW LQ VRPHGDPDJH WR WKH EUDLQ ́ 5 S 

3'#&'(%5$''(%%(%((+!%&(%(%

(+"%(  %& !%( # %& $%" &"%& !#(('"(%%',&$!(#%&"(%#+%5(D!'%&% &$!( (+## #$ ($ #$ # ,'* 3'$,D&'*&D((*5%B(*&'I##*%'2'(3'!"(+3%5!CD"(#+%&%&$!(&(','#'*% +'%5 !*((', #'*'% D&'*& $( & '(('"5'(%*%35+'%5(%'$+"'#+%&(%%%&%($#%&%(%(+"%("&'$%**"+%&%%&D(($(%#,'*3'$,=-!4>@D2D(%%%&%&D(%3"%$F(((($%#%&(2'%5#%&$,%&%&'%'%%=-!4.@

D ' &D2 **"+ %&% &$!( D(

*$!%%%%&%'$#%&<$'%'0+4--.=-!>?@

	','#'*%"5D%(%'#'%&% & D("5 (F%

!''(%&$!(G(*$!%*5%%&%'$#%&<$'%'%(F%!''(%&$!(G($%"(%%+(%%&%'$#%&##(%'"

 %&'( !, BL%M& #% $+(3"!33'"'%5%&%3+%#(%&(+"%#%&!*',  (3" !33'"'%5 '(  +$'*#'*'%&+%*%->
%&	+!$

&#%*&"",('(D&%&%&'((3"%&(%& #*%#'D+"+3%(!*%',,+'"%&%&(%*(+*&(%&J+(%''(D&%&%&'(3(%%&(%&(%*T*+% % %& <%% '% '!2'*TTD+"&2**"+,,2%',$'%',%',*'*+$%&

&%-
$$46%&'(+%#+%&%%&%BL%M&%&%!%'%'%!232'*%&%%&(+"%D+"&2%&%%&'(  (3"!33&23'##%C&%4?=*

64@

%&!,(#%&%(

#"D#*%D2'D3%&*+%%$'%'(#"*+%2'D',(%%*'*('  (%% *+% **"+('##*%'2(('(%*%3 #*%3>
	%-.@*+%**%"5 (%%%&3# +( '( D&%& %& (%% +(3"!!"'*%'#%&(%+% # 2"+%', *"'$( # *+("
 
 

FODLP LV LQKHUHQWO\ LPSOLHG E\ 7KRPSVRQ¶V SHWLWLRQV IRU UHOLHI 0RUHLPSRUWDQWO\ KRZHYHU WULDO FRXQVHO¶V IDLOXUH WR KLUH DQ\ FRPSHWHQWSV\FKRORJLFDO DVVLVWDQFH ZKDWVRHYHU SURYLGHV D EDVLV IRU JUDQWLQJ7KRPSVRQ UHOLHI DV ZLOO EH GHPRQVWUDWHG'##*%'2(('(%*#*+(",235%&	+!$+%G(%D!,%(%(%#%&'&#'(%!,#%&%(%'(D&%&*+("G(!#$* #""3"D3E*%'2(%#(3"((D&35B*+("$( ( ('+( %&% *+(" D( % #+*%'', ( %&U*+("G,+%%&#%35%&	'<%& $$%C > 
	 % .?  2'D # %'" *+("G(!#$* '( &',&"5 #%'"  & % .-  B  #'

(((($%#%%5!#$*J+'(%&%25##%3$%"'$'%%&'(%%',##*%(#&'(',&%%*(%+*% %& *'*+$(%*( # *+("G( *&"",*+*%  % 2"+% %& *+*% #$ *+("G(!(!*%'2%%&%'$C&
%&'(,#(*+("$+(%(3"5'2(%',%%&#*%(#%&*((3"5%$'%&%'2(%',%''(%*((5"(%&!#$*'(#'*'%	46.>6.>.=%& ' --?@  
 '%' ( %&'( +% !'% +% '25"464-4.--=%&'--?@

'(%+*%%&%BL!M2'"',$(#!*%'*(#"*%' $'* ((*'%'(%(%&"'F,  	%(#'$'"0+(%'*>%>.6=4-.@ =U&)#(+*%'G@,+'(%%$'',D&%'((3"3+%%&5"5,+'(C>
	%..>	%

44   	% >4=*@ (%%(%&% BL(M'*%&%&!"%5'##(#$%&*'$'"!"%'(''%(#'"'%5#(*+("'*!'%"*((&+"(!% %&'( '##* 35 $F', ) ##%( 3&"# #%& **+(C    	%( #'$'"0+(%'*A(*+%'+*%')#(+*%'4=6--6@=$!&('((+!!"'@& (* !, # %&  %(% '( D&%&

*+("G($%'""5!E+'*%&#%


 

2QO\ OLPLWHG SRUWLRQV RI 'U %ODX¶V 

ZLWK WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW


 3+%%" %&  ##

&"+"+%(%'#'%&

''*%'( # ,'* 3' $''(%D2"+"(B*$ %  !'' %&% L&M D!#(('!''C%&%%&%*""%3(%(*',C%&%&%&D+""5D%%*+*%%(%('#B%&D((C(+*&5 '##'*+"%'( +', %& %(%',(',(#"#%&$'(!&#'*'%

&'(%'*%*+%,%(+$$

&$!(G('##*%'2(('(%

&$!( &( #'" % !

!3%'22'*D&'*&D+"%&'(+%%("2#*%+"'(>??
	6?=-.@!2'%&'(+%D'%&5%&+(+!!%"",%'(%&%&%'$&*$$'%%%&*'$%'"&(&$!(!2'(','#'*% !3%'2 2'*(+##',#$(','#'*%$&23!(%%%&E+5!&(($'%',%'2'*

A%'%'&%D'##%!(

3%&(+"%'#'',(##%&*'$%%&%'$#*(&D(%&%%'"*+("'&$!(G(3*F,+$

&'(%'*%*+%&"%&%&$!2'%'5&',
4. 
 

7KRPSVRQ LQGLFDWHG WKDW KH KDV FRQVROLGDWHG WKH VHYHQ LVVXHV XSRQ

ZKLFK WKH FHUWLILFDWH RI DSSHDODELOLW\ ZDV JUDQWHG LQWR IRXU LVVXHV

&'(%'*%*+%,%(+$$5E+,$%%%&

""#&$!(G(*"'$('($'((&$!(G(!%'%'#D'%#&3( *!+('5!!"'*%'#*%'#'*%#!!"3'"'%5&'(+%,%*%'#'*%#!!"3'"'%5  	!%$3 4 4  + '((+( !(%#2'D

	#*!!

+2'D'(,235%& %'%'($##*%'2

)%&A"%5 *%#--A+38>64	%%4> =--@ =B )A C@'"
4
	64644?=--?@
%& )A #"*+%$5% ,%  D'% # &3( *!+( %  (%% !'( D'%&(!*%%5*"'$E+'*%%&$'%(+"((=@%&(%% *+%G( *'(' D( B*%5 %  '2"2 +(3"!!"'*%'#*""5(%3"'(&""D(%$'35%&	+!$+%C4.
	H44>=@=@=-->V	+!!:

@ =4@%& (%%*+%G(*'('BD(3(+(3"!!"'*%'#%&#*%('"',&%#%&2'*!(%'%&	%%*+%!*',(C&H44>=@=4@=-->V	+!!:

@

  (%% *+%G( "," *'(' '( B*%5 %C *""5

(%3"'(& #" "D + H 44>=@=@ B'# %& *+%'2( %  **"+(' !!('% % %&% *& 35 L%&	+!$M+%   J+(%' #"D '#%& (%% *+%*'(  *( '##%"5 %& L%& 	+!$M +%  $%'""5''(%',+'(&3"(%##*%(C/0 4- 
	 64 >46 =4@   B+(3"!!"'*%'C **+( D& B%& (%% *+% '%'#' %&**%","!'*'!"#$L%&	+!$M+%G(*'('(3+%+(3"5!!"'('%%%&#*%(#%&!'(G(*(C&  
 %&'( (%  (%% *+% *'(' '( %+(3"('$!"53*+(%&#"*+%**"+(%&%%& (%% *'(' '( +(  '**%  & % >%&%&#"*+%$+(%%$'%&%%&(%%*+%

 

7KHOHDG RSLQLRQ¶V FRQWHQWLRQ WKDW 7

KLV FODLP WKDW WULDO FRXQVHO ZHUH LQHIIHFWLSV\FKLDWULVW LQVWHDG RI D SV\FKRORJLVW LV 

J+(%'#"D'#%&(%%*+%%&%&'(+%&((%#$#*%(C&%>6&+%"((%%*+%D'""3$B+*""5(%3"'(&#""DB'#%**%,2',","!'*'!"#3+% +(3"5 !!"'( %&% !'!'(G(*(C&K44	%.>6.=44@


%&+%&"%&%

%#"&3(*!+("'#&&'(*(%'%+%'""5,+%',&#*+("D&&'(%'"%%5!(%(+3(%%'"$'%',%',2'!&( # &'( *!'%" $+ %'!%'*+" %& +% #+ %&% *$!%%+',%&,+'"%!&('##*%'2(('(%*%%&(%% '2(%',% B'""'$(G ',&%$!(% 2'* %&% B'""'$( %G'%2*35**',&'(*$$3"3

6--*+('""'$(B'(%&%%&(+"%#%&(%*',!'##%G'#*$!%%*+("&%&(','#'**#""%&2'"3 **"+ %&% B%& :U*'('%&%D(*"+(3"!!"'*%'#*"DGC%&+(%'%"','""'$(%&


%&$%%%&&$!(

%'%"%&3(*!+("'#!' %& ##*%'2 (('(%* # $$%#%&
'%	%%(
>. 
 







8 9'*+'%0+,'((%',*+(%&(%%*+%G(

**"+(' %&% &$!(G( %'" *+(" D %*(%'%+%'""5'##*%'2D(+(3"!!"'*%'#$>
	.=-.>@
D+"

2( %& '(%'*% *+%G( E+,$% ,%', (+$$5E+,$%%""$%%&'(%'*%*+%D'%&'(%+*%'( % '((+  D'% # &3( *!+( 2*%',&$!(G( %& (%* +"((%& 	%% # ((*+*%(D!"%5%'"!*',D'%&'.5(#$ 2"("1 (" 1


 , D'%& %& " !'' %&% &$!(G( &3(

!%'%''(,235%& %'%'($##*%'2)%&A"%5 *%#--($A+38>64	%%4>=--@=B )A C@4.
	H44>=@ )A !2'(%&%!!"'*%'#D'%#&3(*!+(3&"# #  ''2'+" '**% !+(+% %  (%%*2'*%'*%3,%D'%&(!*%%5*"'$%&%D( E+'*%  %& $'%( ' (%% *+% +"(( %&E+'*%'1B=@(+"%'*'('%&%D(*%5%'2"2+(3"!!"'*%'#*""5(%3"'(&#""D(%$'35%&	+!$+%#%&
'%	%%(K=4@(+"%'*'('%&%D(3(+!+(3" %$'%' # %& #*%( ' "',&% # %&2'*!(%'%&(%%*+%!*',C4.
	H44>=@
4-
	64=4@%&


'% 	%%( 	+!$+%'%!%%&'( !2'(' # )A %J+'#"*+%%#'2'"%'#"DB*""5(%3"'(&C35&"',(#%&	+!$+%(#%&%'$#%&"2%(%%*+%*'('&	+!$+%'&"%&%(%%*+%*'(''(B*%5%C*""5(%3"'(&#""DB'#%&(%%*+%'2(% **"+(' !!('% % %&% *& 35 %&'( +%  

 *'(''(3E*%'2"5+("D  & % >4  *%+" #'!(+$**%4.
	H44

		$$$"

3	&

'(%&$!(,+(%&%%&

2'D &$!(G( *"'$( +E+'(%(C(%%&%D(E*%
4-
	64 (%&(%& (%% *+%G( *'('  &'(*+("*"'$'%*(%'%+%$',#H44>=@3*+(&D(('(%* +', &'( !(%*2'*'B#+""!!%+'%5%"'%',%%&(%%*+%B#'"%# %& '((+(C  (J+%"5 H44>=@D('!!"'*3"%&2'D&'(*"'$(+%&! #2'D

&$!(G(,+$%%+*&(+

,', %& !! '%!%%'$'%(C ( %&% %$ '( +( ' $46='(*+((',2'+(!!*&(35$'44@=;'%&0**+',@D&%&#"*(%'%+%'%& $'%(C  '(  %&# (#%'"(%#2'D'#%!!"'#""D%  4 --?@="F',%D&%&(%%*"'$(+3(%%'2"5!*+

 "%&+,&%&'(+%&(B%'

J+'$%%&%(%%*+%E+$'%(G'%D%+#
6 
 

 )G  WK &LU  FHUW GHQLHG  86 7KH 6HFRQG &LUFXLW REVHUYHV WKDW RXU YLHZ RI  ¶V

XQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQ SURQJ LQ 'RDQ QDPHO\ WKDW DQ 3XQUHDVRQDEOH

DSSOLFDWLRQ ́ DQDO\VLV FDQQRW EH SHUIRUPHG RQ D VWDWH FRXUW GHFLVLRQ WKDWIDLOV WR LGHQWLI\ D VWDWH SULVRQHU¶V IHGHUDO FODLP LV LQ WHQVLRQ ZLWK RXUFRQFOXVLRQ LQ +DUULVWKDW ZKHQ D VWDWH FRXUW GHFLGHV D FRQVWLWXWLRQDO LVVXHE\ IRUP RUGHU RU ZLWKRXW GLVFXVVLRQ D KDEHDV FRXUW VKRXOG IRFXV RQ WKHUHVXOW DQG SHUIRUP DQ 3XQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQ ́ DQDO\VLV 6HH 6HOODQ Y

.XKOPDQ  )G   Q G &LU  +RZHYHU -XGJH 0RRUHWKH DXWKRU RI 'RDQ H[SODLQHG WKH DSSDUHQW FRQWUDGLFWLRQ DV IROORZV

+DUULV GHQLHG KDEHDV UHOLHI EHFDXVH WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KDG QRWFOHDUO\ HVWDEOLVKHG D GHIHQGDQW¶V ULJKW WR D IUHH FRS\ RI D

WUDQVFULSW RI KLV FRGHIHQGDQWV¶ SUHYLRXV WULDO IRU WKHLPSHDFKPHQW RI ZLWQHVVHV LQ WKH GHIHQGDQW¶V WULDO +DUULV 

)G DW  ,Q FRQWUDVW WKH GHIHQGDQW LQ 'RDQ KDG D FOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHG 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW ULJKW WR D IDLU DQG LPSDUWLDO MXU\7KHUHIRUH WKH ODQJXDJH LQ +DUULV DERXW WKH VWDWH FRXUW¶VXQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI IHGHUDO ODZ ZDV GLFWD DQG 'RDQ¶V

3FRQWUDU\ WR ́ DQDO\VLV FRQWUROV

6FKRHQEHUJHU  )G DW  0RRUH - FRQFXUULQJ

6%.> =70**+',@B' 

D(!*'#'*""5&"%&%%&(+"%#(%%*+%G(

*'(' *%"( D& %& (%% *+% #'"( % <!"' '%((',C&&%'(BD(%%%&%D*+"%U,%

"'#+"((%&(%%*+%G((+"%'(%'F!',D'%&%&(%'*%+(#%& )A GC&=J+%', 
446%

->6@&+(' D#*+(%&(+"%#%&(%%*+%*'('"2%%%&!%'%'G(+!*((*"'$('*  (%% *+% & (( '%   ' ! $ 46? 6 ?44 =%& ' 4@ D &" %&% %&B*%5%C%&%&%&B+(3"!!"'*%'C!,#H44>=@=@,2(3*+(%&(%%*+%B'%(%& 	+!$ +% #'  +(3" !!"'*%'**%"5 '%'#5 %& ,2', "," !'*'!" "5 %+(3"5!!"5%&%!'*'!"%%&!%'*+"#*%(#%&*(%&C&%?6
$D2'D%& !%'%'G( *"'$ %&% $'((' # *%' %(%'$52'"%&'(',&%(#+!*((%#'%'"D&'*&%&

 








; 8	7*

**+'%&*+%G(*'('%'"#&$!(G(!%'%'#D2 
 D'% (!%"5 %&$!(G( *"'$ %&% &'( *+'##*%'2 % (%*', 
 *&!%'%'(""5%&3('(#%&#

&$!(*"'$(%&%&'(%'"*

'##*%'2'!(%',$'%',%'3*+(&'(*+("'%!(%2'*#&'($%"*'%''((% *%%&%&&$!($ !!!'% !(5*&",'*" D+" &2 3 3"% !(% $%" '""((  % "(% # *'%'&'"
&2(5$!%&5%&'((%,',%&,"!!(5*&",'(%((<!%D'%(((**"+%&%&$!(G(%'"*'##*%'2 ' &'', ) !!&$!(&(!(%2'(&+"&2FD'%&%&%%&%&'($%"*'%'D(&'(%'"%%&%'$#&'(*'$$!!!'%!(5*&",'*"&2 %(%'#' % &$!(G( %'%', $%" *'%' 
 &'',35&$!(G(%'"*+("#"D &'( %(%'$5 ($( ' *(%'%+%'""5'##*%'2(('(%
> 
 

#'*$!%*%%&%'$#%&##(%%'"&'('( %+ 2 %&+,& %& '(%'*% *+% ,% &'$ #+%&'(*25+3(+" 3(%(+*&(&D',%& * 3  *+(  !E+'* +  

%&##2'%'5&',# T6448-..-%S.=%&' +,4-44@=&"',%&%%&!%'%'#'"%2"!%&#*%+"3('(#&'(*"'$(%&%3(%*#%&2'*%&% & D+" &2 !(% %  (!% %'" '% D('$!(('3" % **"+ %&% %& (%% *+% +(3"5%$' %&% & D( % !E+'*@  +%&$ '#&$!('#'"%2"!&'(#'"+%!'%%*%+"$'%',%',2'*%&%(&+"&23!(%'&'(#'"+%(&D!E+'*(%3"'(&(%&%&&(%$%%&J+'$%#H44>=@=4@=@"4.6%

'""5 **',  "", 5%$ 2'"%'

&$!( #'" % '%'#5 3"D  ' %&'( *+% 52'*%&%D(D'%&&"#$&'$%%'"


 (&% &$!(G( ,+$% '( D'%&+% $'%  

%&###'$%&'(%'*%*+%G(&"',(!*'#'*""5!%%&(',#%&'(%'*%*+%(%%&(*"'$(

+
#!

""#%&#,',((%&E+,$%#%&'(%'*%

*+%5',&$!(G(!%'%'#D'%#&3(*!+('(	



 

7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW UHQGHUHG LWV GHFL

UHOLDQFH RQ WKH 3DOO UHDVRQDEOH MXULVWV ́ VW

&'+%# !!"('%#""D',(%1B
%&3(*D*+*%'!%2'D'#%&(%%*+%'%&*%2*""5(%3"'(&#""DC.6=*'%', 446%->


%&'( *(&$!( ((%

!*',( %&% *+(" D( 'J+%"5'2(%',%!'&+%#'$'" !!"(##'$!(%*2'*%'"'#%D,+%&% &$!( & #'" % $>
	

-.	4%4	**+("G(%*%'*"*'('%$!&J+"'%'(%%'"%&%&%(+,(3"%'"(%%,53(+!& 
%& D(%& (%% *'##*%'2 (('(%* # *+("',  (+3(%%'2 "5('(*'(' '( %  +<!"' #" *"'$  &$!(G( *$'%

4"!/#"5

	* &$!( ,+( %

!!"'*%' ' '%( H 44>=@=@ $,(3"E+'(%(C(%%& 	+!$ +% '  J+'($#*('%'!!!'%(% "%&+,&

%&(%!!"'3"D'(" $ '( +*((2'D',%&$%%2 +%G(*'('' #
64 
 

H44>=@$'(+*((5+"((%&'(%'*%*+%G(*'(' *% 3 +!&" + %&% (%  
 $
 
446%->4=##'$',%&'"#&3("'#2%&+,&%&'(%'*%*+%'**%"5!!"'(%(+%& )A @+%&%&'(*+%*##'$*'('#%&'(%'*%*+%'##%,+( ! '	*
&6>>>>=%&'---@

"22"("	!!!"

&$!(,+(%&%&*'2'##*%'2(('(%*#

*+("'3%&%&,+'"%(%*',!&((#&'(*!'%"%'" 3*+( *+(" #'" % '2(%',%  !(%2'* ,', &$!(G( $%" '""((  (*'"&'(%5  #'" % !(% 2'* ' (+!!% #  "'#(%*  	!*'#'*""5 &$!( *%( %&% %'"*+("G(*'('%$!"5!(5*&",'(%%%'" %&%&  !(5*&'%'(% D( 3E*%'2"5 +(3" +"(*"'$(%&%*+("#'"%'%2'D!(%%(%'$5#D'%(((D&*+"&2%(%'#'3+%B3'I*&,C'&$!(G(3&2'#%&,+%#$&',&(*&"%&%$5&2(',"%&(%#$%"'""((


%&	+!$+%+*%D!%%(%

#2"+%','##*%'2(('(%*#*+("*"'$('(%*+("G(!#$*$+(%&23#'*'%'%&%'%#""3"D3E*%'2(%#(3"((	*%&$+(% 3 B (3" !33'"'%5 %&% 3+% # *+("G(+!#(('"(%&(+"%#%&!*',D+"&23'##%C>
	%.?-> %%&($

%'$%&+%*+%'%&%E+'*'"(*+%'5##(*+("G(!#$*$+(%3B&',&"5#%'"C&%.-BLM+("'((%,"5!(+$%&2J+%(('(%*$""(','#'*%*'('('%&<*'(#(3"!#(('"E+,$%C&%-

*+( %& (( (%% *+% **%"5 (%% %&

(%%&J+(%'D$+(%*''(D&%&

%&(%%*+%+(3"5!!"''%&'(*(


%& )A '%'(%+,&%*2'*%&*+%'

 

= @%&*"'$"'(T

='@D+"#*(%'%+%'"%*((*""%"2'D3%&%D(!2'+("5+2'"3=''@  #*%+" !'*% %&% !2'+("5'(*2%&+,'"',*K

=@%&#*%(+"5',%&*"'$(%3"'(&35*"*2'*'*(%'%+%'"(3"#+%&!!"'*%,+'"%5#%&

4.
	H44>=@=4@

& %(% # B#'" % 2"!C 

'"',*($,%#+"%%%%&!'(G(*+("C'&'(&!(%*"'$'(%%*+%!
	 % >64  )'"',* # !+!( +! BD&%& %& !'(%%$!%'"',&%#%&'#$%''2(%',%!+(+*"'$('(%

&$!(*"'$(%&%%&'(%

&'$2'%'5&',3*+(%& #*%+" 3('( # &'( *"'$( '*"'$(%&%&$'"',%##%*"'$('(%%*+%B35J+(%''2(%',%'(+*(%3%J+(%',2'%'5&',%&% & D( ' #+', # $'2(%',%'2(2'*(%%'"!*',(,+(%&% #+"%(%%*+%*3",(%%&	

2'#D((+$%&%&$!(

%&(*"'$(3"D=D&$!('((%'""%%'%"%H 44>=@ 3*+( & #'" %$(%%',,+''((+#$
>> 
 

" !(*+% #$ ,+', %&% '% *+" 3 $3E*%'3"5+(3"+@

&+( ( ", , *+%' '   *%"5

$!&('I'%%5G(*+*%'(%'%"%(%, !(+$!%' %&% '% #""( D'%&'  D' , #(3"!#(('"(('(%*44	%%.> (' BL,M'2%& *&'*( 2'"3"% LA%'%'G(M*+("    D *% (5 %&% %& *+%G( !!"'*%' #6%%5!#$*(%D(3E*%'2"5+(3"C&


("*," 

&$!(((%(%&%%&'(%'*%*+%'5',&'(

!%'%' D'%&+%  2'%'5 &',  %& (!*'#'**"'$(1=@'##*%'2(('(%*#*+("K=4@*$!%*5%%&%'$#%&##(%(%%'" =6@"",5%$2'"%'&$!(#+%&*%(%&%%&	%%D'%&&"<*+"!%52'*D&'*&*""5(+!!%&'( *"'$ # ('+( $%" '""((  !(% #"(2'* ,',&$!(G($%"&"%&+',%'"!(%*2'*%'!*',(

& )A '$!((<!(("'$'%%'(%&3'"'%5#

!%'%'%3%'2'%'5&','#"*+%
/"04-
	>4=4@%&	+!$+%'(%+*%%&%&3(*+%!(%D'%&J+(%#2'%'5&',$+(%#'(%(*%'D&%&%&B!!"'*%&(#'"%2"!%&#*%+"3('(#  *"'$ ' 	%% *+% !*',(C  4. 
	H44>=@=4@K4-
	%>66='%!%',*"+(

( 2'*', *,(('" '%% % *'#5 (% #'"',* +* ' ! )A  *'(' 7 

>
	=--4@@
#%&!!"'*%'%B#'"%2"!C%&*"'$'(%%*+%%&(%%+%(%3  2'%'5 &',  
#  B!!"'*% &( #'" %2"! %& #*%+" 3('( #  *"'$ ' 	%% *+%!*',(C4.
	H44>=@=4@!&'3'%(#"*+%#$*+*%',2'%'5&',%&%*"'$+"((%&!!"'*%$(%%(%&%

 

7KRPSVRQ¶V DPHQGHG SHWLWLRQ IRU 

LQ SHUWLQHQW SDUW

&RXQVHO IDLOHG WR UHTXHVW DQG RE

LQYHVWLJDWLYH DVVLVWDQFH UHJDUGLQJ *LQMXULHV GXULQJ KLV \RXWK DQG IDLOHG DVVLVWDQFH ́ UHJDUGLQJ *UHJRU\ 7KRPWLPH *UHJRU\ 7KRPSVRQ PDGH LQFULPDXWKRULWLHV,Q KLV IHGHUDO KDEHDV SHWLWLRQ 7KRP

'%( '!% E+,$% %&% '**%"5%&!(%%*+%(!!"''$44	%

 (%%*+%G(**"+('%&%*

(('(%*'(%#'',##*%3*+%   > 
	 % (%'2"2$'<&%'D3%&%&'(%'*%*+%*'('-=%&'4@

3
#","

&$!(*%(%&%&*

# *+(" % &'( *!'%" %'" 3'2(%',%&'($%"&"%& !(5*&'%'(%

3,'%%&<%%%&%&$

*+(" D '##*%'2 3*+(
%&%&!(5*&"!*+""5#+"%##'%%(#',+%'#&$!(G(*"%&'(%'*%*+%%&%*+("#'"(('(%*C,',&'(&'E+&'(*$!%*5%%&%'$#%&*
6> 
 

&RXQVHO ZDV LQHIIHFWLYH IRU IDLOLQJ WR IXOO\ LQYHVWLJDWH DQGSUHVHQW UHOHYDQW HYLGHQFH RI 0U 7KRPSVRQ¶V PHQWDO KHDOWKKLVWRU\ DQG WR VHFXUH DGHTXDWH H[SHUW DVVLVWDQFH WR GHIHQG 0U7KRPSVRQ LQFOXGLQJ SV\FKRORJLVWV QHXURSV\FKRORJLFDO DQGRUQHXURORJLFDO H[SHUWV WR HVWDEOLVK YDOLG PLWLJDWLQJ IDFWRUV



&RXQVHO IDLOHG WR REWDLQ DGHTXDWH H[SHUW DVVLVWDQFH LQFOXGLQJ

FRQILGHQWLDO SV\FKRORJLFDO QHXURSV\FKRORJLFDO DQG

QHXURORJLFDO H[SHUWV

(PSKDVLV DGGHG

:H QRWH WKDW 7KRPSVRQ LV UHSUHVHQWHG E\ WKH VDPH RIILFH LQ WKLV

DSSHDO

%'"*+("&2%&$("2(%*(+"%!(5*&'%'(%('%&' %%$!% % (%3"'(& %&% &$!( (+##( #$,'*'%5$%"'""((	%%!(%*2'*%'*+("*%*% ) '""' "'  *"''*" !(5*&",'(%&$!(G(#"&3(*+("%&"$$+'%5)#	2'*(#(%(( *(+"% 5

	+"%!(5*&",'(%5D+!(5*&",'(%
%'(D'%&($""'5%&%D%%&%'%%$!%',%*"'$ %&% &$!( D( *(%'%+%'""5 %'%" % %&(2'*(#!(5*&'%'(%!(%%'"*+("'%3%&%3%'%&$("2(

7 #+$%""5 2 '# %& '((+ & 3 '(

&$!( ' % (%3"'(& %&% & D( *(%'%+%'""5%'%" % <!% !(5*&'%'* (('(%* + 	 (>?
	.=-.@(+*&%&%*+("G(#'"+%%%'  *(%'%+% '##*%'2 (('(%*  
 	 %&	+!$ +% &" %&% BD&  #% &( $ !"'$'5(&D',%&%&'(('%5%%&%'$#%&##('("'F"5%3(','#'*%#*%%%'"+!*((J+'(%&%	%%!2'**((%!(5*&'%'(%G((('(%*%&'('((+'#%&#%*%%&D'(##C	
>?
	%?>.6&	*+%"((%%%&%('$'"**"+('D(J+''%&*%<%#*!'%"(%*',!*',D&%&(%%!(%(!(5*&'%'*2'*#

 

72%%&<%%%&%&

%!(%',2'*#B3'I% %&% E+" %(%'#' %!'%'*3&2'#%E+5D(%&#,'2($''*$5 &2 ##*% &$!(G( !E+'*

6" 

&$!(*"'$(%&%%'"*+

'#('3" (%%,5 # !(%'*',!(D'%&%B+%+*( %'" *+(" D #* *$$'%%(("((*'$+!3',',&3 #'"5$.>?6 =&"',%&% *+(" $'%',%',2'*%(%*',!(*+% #$ !(%', 5 +   3*+( *+#$'3"%(F##',*"'&'3"53+%"(("((*'$F'""',  D&&  "%'2"5*+"%&5!(%2'*#$%&((+%#'$'" *+" &2 !+(+  (%%,5 %,J+"'%'(!2%%&(%,%'22'*3+%&'$+%%& (%%,5 D+" &2 3#'"+ % !(% 2'* # 3&2'$',&%'%("#J+"'#5('4>66--???%&%*+("G(#'"+%!(%5(F %& E+5 % (! %& #'##*%'2(('(%*2(',%.>6 =44@=&"',%&%*+%&#%G(I	%*<!(('# $(3+%(+*&(+%D',&*+("G(*&'*%D'2
>4 
 


-.	4%6>&$!(#+%&#'"%(+3$'%##'2'%(#$D'%(((D&*+"&2%(%'#'%&'("",B3'I3&2'C'&'(#"&3(*%'&+( B&$!( &( #'" % !2' 5 (','#'*%!3%'22'*D&'*&D+"$F'%*((5#%&'(+%%("2#*%+"'(!+%C&(%%*+%'%' **"+',%&%&$!( #'"% (%% '##*%'2(('(%*#*+("*"'$%&'(3('(%&'(%'*%*+%!!"5,%(+$$5E+,$%#"
4.6->

 "%&+,&E+"%(%'#'&$!(*"'$(%&%(&D(

%'#$3+%%&%+#%&!"%5!&(%(%'$5"5%(%'#'3+%%&',((&#"%D+"&"!&$!(D2(%&*#"*%(%&(('$'"+%# !!"(#+*+("DD#%&!%%'",('&%'""D',E+"%%(%'#53+%$%*%'*"*'('%!(%&!('%'2%(%'$5(!%#%&' (%%,5%B&+$'IC&$!(& (%% *+%G(+"','(%+(3"!!"'*%'#D&'*&$!&('I %&% *+%(  % % (*,+(( (%%,'**'('(35*+("

& * #"*%( %&% *+(" *+*%  J+%

'2(%',%''% &$!(G( 3*F,+  A'% %'"3%& *+(" %2" % &$!(G( &$ %D  &5'%2'D"%'2(%*&(',&3(+("FD#&$!(G(&'E+'(#""D+!35J+(%',3%'',<!%(('(%* "%&+,&%&5'%3%'&'($'*"*(%(!!"D*&D#%&( 'E+'( !' % &'( 2"+%' # &$!(= !!%"5 &3( *+(" 2 3%' %& *('%&@&+,&%&"5 D'%(((%&E+5 D(!2'D'%&'$,#&$!((*',,!(#%  " 4> 6 6 ??. =%& ' 4@=#'','##*%'2(('(%*#!!""%*+("##'"',% '( '##*%'2 (('(%* # %'" *+(" D& %'"*+("#'"%'%2'D#$'"5$$3(#'"%2'D(*&"*(#'"%*""5$%"&"%&<!%(K*((*'%%&'@44	%646=44@

 

7KH VWDWH LQWURGXFHG D UHGDFWHG SR

DW 070+, WKRXJK :DWVRQ D UHEXWWDO ZL

%&#%G(#+%+,+(%'$%&	$E'%5$!&('I% *(( ' D&'*& %& #B('+("5 ' J+(%'C +! %&(&D',C&%.4+%&$%D(3"',$"5%!2'%&%'%*+"*&(%&%!(5*&#%G(',&%(%'*"+%&'(*&'*&%.6=B&%'(%'',% #% &(  *(%'%!(5*&'%'(%#&'(!(""'F',&'(DC@

&'(+%&('%!%	%

%%&',&%%!(5*&'%'(%+',#% '( *(%'%+%'""5 !(5*&",'*"C(('(%*+',%%&#%G(('%5D((','# 4@ #% '(  %'" # &!(%( !(5*&'%'* 2'* $$   46 6 4=J+%%' $'%%@  '%&#%&(!J+'('%(!!!!%&#( #%%D (#+&'$*$!%%&	%%2'*%%'"%'%(*('*

&(&$!(##52'%'$ # ##(  &+( %'" *'##*%'2##'"',%3%'!


52%%'"*+("(+,&

#&$!(%&*+%""&$!(D+"&23%A(((%%%&%&&* 35 77
 A((G 5%&',%&'(%&','%&
6 
 

7KH $PHULFDQ 3V\FKRORJLFDO $VVRFLDWLRQ GHVFULEH LQGXVWULDO

SV\FKRORJLVWV DV IROORZV 3,QGXVWULDORUJDQL]DWLRQDO SV\FKRORJLVWV DSSO\SV\FKRORJLFDO SULQFLSOHV DQG UHVHDUFK PHWKRGV WR WKH ZRUN SODFH LQ WKH

LQWHUHVW RI LPSURYLQJ SURGXFWLYLW\ DQG WKH TXDOLW\ RI ZRUN OLIH ́KWWSZZZDSDRUJVWXGHQWVEURFKXUHVXEILHOGVKWPO

+$'%&2"+%'(3577
(%##(%&$!(G( *$!%*5 %%&%'$#%&$+  %%'" (D(%%'""4.6->>=%&'44@
##0+444=4

.@BLDM&22#+*+("%3'##*%'2(""53*+(%&<!%+(D(%&	%%!5""C

&'("2(%&'((+%&%'(!!"53#+(D&%&%'"

*+(" #'" % &' 8 <!% (('(%*  ('""+(%% 32 %& * #"*%( %&% %'" *+("'2(%',%&$!(G($%"&"%&%&%&*'2<!% (('(%* % %%$!% % (%3"'(& 2"' $'%',%',#*%(&*(&D(%&%%'"*+("DD#$%& +%(% # &$!(G( !' & 'E+'( '!!!'%3&2' %&%%&5'2(%',%!(('3"$%" '""((  #*%  &5 J+(%  *$!%*52"+%'  &$!( D( 2"+% #%&'%5 5( 35 %$#<!%(&77
%$#+$%"'""(($%" #*%  '('%5  +(" "( & !!" *"''*"!(5*&",'(%#$!#((#!(5*&",5%:3'"%2"+%&$!(!!"#+2'*#$%"'""((

 !!" &$!( (F( % +$' !!"G(

%(%'$535*(%',&'$(B'+(%'"!(5*&",'(%C%&# ($&D +J+"'#' % $F !(5*&",'*"2"+%'(!!"G(%'"%(%'$53"'(%&'('$'+%'

#!!"G(3'"'%'(!!"&'$("#%(%'#''*%*((<$'%'%&%&'(*"''*"!(5*&",'(%%&%& ' % &" &'$("# +% (  '+(%'" !(5*&",'(% "%&+,&&!#$(2*%'"2"+%'(2"+%'(#(*'"(*+'%5!!"'*%(&(%%%&%%&"%%%'+(%'" !(5*&",5 3+% *"''*" !(5*&",5 #$ %&(%!'%#$F',!(5*&",'*"2"+%'#D&%&

 

,Q KLV EULHI 7KRPSVRQ UHFLWHV ZK

WHVWLILHG ́ WR KDG FRXQVHO 3FRQGXFWHG D SXUSRUWHG WHVWLPRQ\ LV XQVXSSRUWHG E\ DQ\ 5 $SS 

*+(!,#3*+($!"5  *"''*" !(5*&",'(% %+(3"+%&(%&**"+ B*+(" *% 3 (%%,5%&%*+"%3(+!!%& *%&3!E+'*!'2 # 5  '((#*%%%&%'$#%&*+%G( *'(' &"', %&% *++ %& 	'<%& $$% !!"'*%'#

4."!!"

&$!("(*%(%&%*

!(%%(%'$5#D'%((3+%B3'I*&,C'&$,+%#$&',&(*&"%&%$'#$%"'""((%%&D'((*'" &'(%5  	!*'#'*""5 &*+("#'"%'%2'D*"% 0 7*$ &$!(#'"%!!"5!(!(%*2'*%'!*',(&# !!"(#+1

&%&*"'$#'##*%'2

%&#'"+%!(%!%%'"D(&+"3##%%&!(%* 3*+(  # %& D'&', %& !%'%' D( (!E+'**%(!*+"%%&(D'%(((D'%&+%%&'#!2'
> 
 

*2'*%&E+5%&%%&%&(%*D(%E+(%'#'&%4??4

'( "('(%+*%'2& D #+ *+(+

 3(  %'" *+("G( #'"+ % '2(%',%

'(*2!(%$'%',%',2'* %2'%'5&', ' #" *+% % !(% 2'* #$'%',%', *'*+$(%*( %&% & "", &'( %'" *+("(&+"&2!(%&'('*"+2'*%&%%G(*&'"&&$D(2'"%+(%3"%&%&'($%&('(%D3%&&(!'%"'I'$%"&"%&'(%'%+%'(%&%&'(
PD(?-.-
4.6%-6	','#'*%"5

%"(!(%%&2"+%'#*"''*"!(5*&",'(%D&',&%5(#%%&$+%'((+%$'%&%% & !(5*&%'* (5$!%$(  %&+,&% '((*('(%% D'%& !' (*&'I!&'   ,'*"+('"#+%&(%%%&%B"%&+,&%$5&2%!!"+('"%"5!(%%&%'$#&'(%'"%'!#(('"D+"&233"%*,'I$%"*$!$'(3$"!("'%5%'%('<*((#%'(*'"!("'(C&%-6->

5*%(%&$!(&(%!(%52'*#

'*$!%*%%&%'$#%&*'$%'"''%&%&(%%#"!*',( (!2'+("5%#&$!(G(<!%(&2(%!!+!%%&!"%%&F5'((+#&$!(G(*$!%*%%&%'$#%'" (%&((+%#'$'" !!"(&"%&'(!E+'*3*+(BL%M&!%'%'&(#'"%(%3"'(&%&%%&&'E+'(&5##*%+!&'($%"(%3'"'%5%%&%'$#%&$++%&&&(#'"%(%3"'(&%&% 5%5! # !(5*&",'*"'$!'$%' ," $5&2<'(%D&'*&D+"&23$'%',%',2'*C
-.	4%72(%&#,',

"'%5 # *(( (&D( %&'( +% D'"" % #' '##*%'2(('(%*#*+("+"((%&*(%3"'(&(%&%%&'(*%+"$'%',%',2'*%&%D(%!(%


 "%&+,& %& (%% *+% +"  %& !E+'*

!,#'%(+"','(J+""5(+(%'3"+%&

 ($ * *%'+ DF',&$!(G(<!%(#+"%%&% 72%#&$!(!' %&% &$!( (+## #'""((%%&%'$#%&*'$(%%!(%*2'*%'<!% "(%'(%:3'"%*"'%,'2%&%$'#$%'D(#+"%%&%(%',!*+(+(3$"5(%%%&%%&5D%(&!#$$5#%&($D	+"%2<!((D($%""5'""%%&%'$#%&*%&%&D(%(F%(+*!4?66-->-=%&!%'%'#'"%(%3"'(&%&%&2 3 #23" % &'( '(<!%G( !% #'" % (!F %'('%5 % %& %'$ %& ##(6
	.?=4@#+&$!(*$!%%'0+D'%&!!"G(#'',(%&7

 "((%&'(%'*%*+%#+

5$'*" *(!# (+(%'%&"",&'E+'(!$%$,+%&&&5!#%&%&(+###%&%'$#%&*'$&$!(#'"%'(*2&'(#%&&'""((3+%&$!(&22'%&

+("&(D&+$+

%(%'$5%(%3"'(&%&%&$!3''(($%"'""((%%5%%*&!!%+'%5*+("#%&*'%'*"'((+#D&%&&$!%'$#%&*'$
((**+
6. 
 


#
%D'#*(1@3*+(&$!("","5

(+##&'E+'(&$+(%&2(+##3'$,4@3*+(&'(*+%"5(+##',#$(*&'I##*%'2'(&$+(%&23(+##',#$$%"'""((%%&%'$#%&*'$+%'#*(%!#(2&$!(G(<!%(($%*,'I#*&25#'"(%+%$%'*""5%F%&"!#$%&('#*(%%& **"+('%&%& D($%""5'*$!%% %%&%'$ # %& $+  D2 3(% ($ 2'* #,'* 3' $,  $%" '""(( % %& %'$ # %&*'$%'"*+("*%3$'##*%'2##'"',%'(*2($%&',%&%(%!!%<'(% (D&"''
4-6>>6=%&'44@

BL'M%('$!"5*%3('%&%%'"*+("G(*+*%#""3"D  3E*%'2 (% # (3"(( + ('$!"5 3*+( %& "( L# !(('3" 3'$,M"%D&C

8'F %'" *+(" ' '
 &$!(G( %%5(

*%+""5!+(+"#,'*3'$,$%"#*%8'F*+("''BL%M&5*%3$

'##*%'2('*2%%&'("%%%&'($'*"
##(+*&*'%'L%%&%'$#%&*'$MC&%

>6-    "
 4. 6 % > =E*%', %&!%'%'G('##*%'2(('(%*%$'%',%'3*+(%&!%'%' & % !'% % $'%',%', !(5*&",'*"2'*%&%(&+"&23!(%%&#!E+'*D((&D@K
466=%&

'4@=E*%',%&!%'%'G('##*%'2(('(%*%(%*', *"'$ 3(  *+("G( "", #'"+ %'(*2%&%&&!(%%+$%'*(%(('(3*+(%&!%'%'#'"%!'%%5%&','%&*(&D',%&%&(+###$'%@44	%>>.=44@

#  4- 
	 % 6--. =#'', '##*%'2(('(%* D& %'" *+(" #'" % '2(%',% '%+*2'"3"2'*(&D',%&%%&!%'%'D(3"'$%""5%@K"4.6

>?>>-6=%&'4@=#'','##*%'2(('(%*##'"+ % '2(%',%  !(% 2'"3" !# # %&!%'%'G( 3"' $%""5 % 
P  2'+(

 !(5*&",'*"&(!'%"!%(#%'"%&!%'%'&344	%6-=44>4=%&'--@=#''*+(" D& *+(" #'" %2'*%&%%&!%'%'(+##(+(%'3#&D(3K(%%'%&%%&!%'%'G(3'#+*%'D+"&23'"52'"3"&(+,&%'%C@

$$'!%'*+"$(%

%$(%%*+(
%&%*(D'##*%'2%%&!"%5!&#++"%!(5*&",'(%D&(%(%'$3"',D&#'"%!!%'%'G($%"(%%+(
(2	F,,(##%&2"+%'(#%D<$'%&!%'%''!!!%'%'$$46 6 % 4*%'#'!(5*&",'(%(%%%&%	#+*%'%%&"2"#%D& %& <!%  +!(5*&	F,,( &  
P # > D&'*3"'$%""5%&%#++"%!(5*&",'(%G(%(%'$(%#*(%%%""5$'(E+5GC&&+!(5*&",'(%B(+##LM#$(','#'*%*$!*,'%'2#+*%'%&%%&+!(5*&",'*" (((($% *(+"%(*('(%%D'%&($#$&%4?6&'(+%&"%&%3D((3"%((+$%&%%&(%%+%5$'%',%',*'*+$(%*% !!*'% %& *'$'"'%5 # &$%" '""((  %%'  &**"+%&%*+("G(#'"+%$'" $%" %%'  $!E+'* 3*+( '% D( %&