**OUTCOMES:  ARTICLE ID:_________ YEAR:________REVIEWER A:_________ B:________**

CONTINUOUS OUTCOME NAME:

*ONE PAGE FOR EACH OUTCOME. For a single outcome with multiple times, use SEPARATE PAGES for each time.*

**1**. Outcome **Type**

 Acne(

         Economic(

Psychological(

    Compliance(

Adverse effect(

**2**. Outcome **Definition***Operational definition as defined in the study, e.g., how was lesion severity assessed; what instrument was used?*

**

**3. Outcome Definition Citation**

****

**4. Objectivity**of assessment *In your judgment, was the method of assessment objective or not (subjective)*

**

    Yes(

         Somewhat(

*“Somewhat” = Although subjective, assessment was systematic*

      No(

          Can’t say(

**5. Consistency**of assessment *Was the assessment made the same way in all patients in this arm?*

    Yes(

         Somewhat(**

      No(

          Can’t say(

**6. Denominator** USED BY AUTHOR FOR WHOLE STUDY where denominator for each arm not available

             Can’t say     (

**ARM (Treatment Name)**

****

****

****

****

****

**1. Denominator**by ITT *Intention to treat*

Can’t say   (

Can’t say   (

Can’t say   (

**2. Denominator***used by*

*author*

Can’t say   (

Can’t say   (

Can’t say   (

**2a.Number lost to**

**follow-up**

Can’t say   (

Can’t say   (

Can’t say   (

**3. Outcome Mean**

**4. Outcome SD**

**5. Follow up duration, mean**

**6. Follow up duration, standard deviation**

Can’t say  ( 

Can’t say  ( 

Can’t say  ( 

**7. Follow up duration,**

**units**

**8. Raw data cannot be reconstructed**

(

(

(

(std dev = std error *sqrt(arm size)

**9**. **Data source** (Page #/Table #)

**10. Comments** (over if necessary)

DISCRETE OUTCOME NAME:

**1**. Outcome **Type**

 Acne(

         Economic(

Psychological(

    Compliance(

Adverse effect(

**2**. Outcome **Definition***Operational definition as defined in the study, e.g., how was lesion severity assessed; what instrument was used?*

**

**3. Outcome Definition Citation**

****

**4. Objectivity**of assessment *In your judgment, was the method of assessment objective or not (subjective)*

**

    Yes(

         Somewhat(

*“Somewhat” = Although subjective, assessment was systematic*

      No(

          Can’t say(

**5. Consistency**of assessment *Was the assessment made the same way in all patients in this arm?*

    Yes(

         Somewhat(**

      No(

          Can’t say(

**6. Denominator** USED BY AUTHOR FOR STUDY where denominator for each arm not available

Can’t say       (

**ARM (Treatment Name)**

****

****

****

****

****

****

**1. Denominator**by ITT *Intention to treat*

Can’t say   (

Can’t say     (

Can’t say     (

**2. Denominator***used by author/*

Can’t say   (

Can’t say     (

Can’t say    (

**2a.Number lost to follow-up**

****

Can’t say   (

Can’t say     (

Can’t say    (

**3. Numerators**

***Labels***

***Category 1***

***Category 2***

***Category 3***

***Category 4***

***Category 5***

***Category 6***

***Category 7***

***Category 8***

**4. Follow up duration, mean**

**5. Follow up duration, standard deviation**

Can’t say (

Can’t say (

Can’t say (

**6. Follow up duration, units *Preference 6 & 12 weeks***

**7. Raw data cannot be reconstructed**

(

(

(

std dev = std error * sqrt(arm size)

**9**. **Data source** (Page #/Table #)

**10. Comments** (over if necessary)

PAGE  

183