INDEX TO DOCKET EPA-R09-OAR-2013-0588

Promulgation of Air Quality Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze and Interstate 

Visibility Transport Federal Implementation Plan, Final Rule

INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

A. EPA Guidance Documents, Policies and Rulemakings

A.1. Review of NSPS Subpart P - Chap 1-9 1984-03 -0003

A.2. Final Rule - Visibility Protection for Federal Class I Areas, 

45 FR 80084

1980-12-02 -0003

A.3. AP-42, Chapter 11, Section 6 - Portland Cement 

Manufacturing

1995-01 -0003

A.4. Proposed Rule - Regional Haze Regulations, 62 FR 41138 1997-07-31 -0003

A.5. AP-42, Chapter 1, Section 4 - Natural Gas Combustion 1998-07 -0003

A.6. IWAQM Phase 2 Summary Report And Recommendations 

For Modeling Long Range Transport Impacts

1998-12 -0003

A.7. Visibility Monitoring Guidance, EPA-454/R-99-003 1999-06 -0003

A.8. Final Rule - Regional Haze Regulations, 64 FR 35714 1999-07-01 -0003

A.9. Proposed Guidelines for BART Determinations Under the 

Regional Haze Regulations, 66 FR 38108

2001-06-20 -0003

A.10. EPA Control Cost Manual 2002 -0003

A.11. 2002 Base Year Emission Inventory SIP Planning 2002-11-18 -0003

A.12. Guidance for Estimating Natural Visibility Conditions under 

the Regional Haze Rule

2003-09 -0003

A.13. Guidance for Tracking Progress under the Regional Haze 

Rule

2003-09 -0003

A.14. Proposed Rule, Regional Haze Regulations and Guidelines 

for BART Determinations, 69 FR 25184

2004-05-04 -0003

A.15. BART Guidelines Error Correction Memo 2005-06-24 -0003

A.16. Final Rule - Regional Haze Regulations and Guidelines for 

BART Determinations, 70 FR 39104

2005-07-06 -0003

A.17. Emissions Inventory Guidance for Implementation of Ozone 

and Particulate Matter NAAQS and Regional Haze 

Regulations

2005-11 -0003

A.18. Memorandum from Joseph W. Paisie regarding Regional 

Haze Regulations and Guidelines for BART

2006-07-19 -0003

A.19. Guidance for SIP Submissions to Meet Current Outstanding 

Obligations Under Section 110(a)(2)(D)(i) for the 8-hour 

Ozone and PM2.5 NAAQS (Memorandum from William T. 

Harnett)

2006-08-15 -0003

A.20. Additional Regional Haze Questions (Guidance) 2006-09-27 -0003

A.21. Final Rule - Revision to Regional Haze Regulations, 71 FR 

60612

2006-10-13 -0003

A.22. Guidance for Setting Reasonable Progress Goals Under the 2007-06-01 -0003
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

Regional Haze Program

A.23. Alternative Control Techniques Document Update - NOx 

Emissions from New Cement Kilns

2007-11 -0003

A.24. Finding of Failure To Submit SIPs Required by the 1999 

Regional Haze Rule, 74 FR 2392

2009-01-15 -0003

A.25. Guidance on SIP Elements Required Under Sections 

110(a)(1) and (2) for the 2006 24-Hour PM2.5 NAAQS 

(Memorandum from William T. Harnett)

2009-09-25 -0003

A.26. Final Rule - Portland Cement NESHAP and NSPS, 75 FR 

54970

2010-09-09 -0003

A.27. Proposed Rule - Approval of Colorado Regional Haze SIP, 

77 FR 18051

2012-03-26 -0003

A.28. Proposed Rule - Approval, Disapproval and Promulgation of 

Air Quality Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze 

State and Federal Implementation Plans [“Phase 1”], 77 FR 

42834 

2012-07-20 -0003

A.29. Final Rule - Montana Regional Haze FIP, 77 FR 57864 2012-09-18 -0003

A.30. Final Rule - Approval, Disapproval and Promulgation of Air 

Quality Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze State 

and Federal Implementation Plans [“Phase 1”], 77 FR 72512

2012-12-05 -0003

A.31. Proposed Rule - Partial Approval and Disapproval of Air 

Quality Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze and 

Visibility Impacts of Transport, Ozone and Fine Particulates, 

77 FR 75703

2012-12-21 -0003

A.32. Proposed Rule - Partial Approval and Partial Disapproval of 

Air Quality State Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional 

Haze Requirements, 78 FR 29292

2013-05-20 -0003

A.33. Final Rule - Approval and Disapproval of Air Quality State 

Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze and Interstate 

Transport Requirements, 78 FR 46141

2013-07-30 -0003

B. State Plans, Rules, Support Documents, and 

Correspondence 

B.1. Regional Haze SIP for the State of Arizona [submitted by

Arizona Department of Environmental Quality under section 

309 of the Regional Haze Rule]

2003-12-23 -0004

B.2. Revision SIP for Regional Haze [submitted by Arizona 

Department of Environmental Quality under section 309 of 

the Regional Haze Rule] 

2004-12-31 -0004

B.3. Revision to the Arizona SIP Under CAA Section 

110(a)(2)(D)(i) – Regional Transport

2007-05-24 -0004

B.4. Letter from Stephen A. Owens, ADEQ, to Wayne Nastri, 

EPA 

2008-12-14 -0004

B.5. Arizona SIP Revision under CAA Section 110(a)(1) and (2); 2009-10-14 -0004
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

2006 PM2.5 NAAQS, 1997 PM2.5 NAAQS, and 1997 8-hour 

Ozone NAAQS

B.6. Arizona Regional Haze SIP Under Section 308 of the Federal 

Regional Haze Rule (with appendices, 6 total files)

2011-01 -0004

B.6.a. Arizona Regional Haze SIP 2011-01 -0004

B.6.b. Arizona Regional Haze SIP Appendix A 2011-01 -0004

B.6.c. Arizona Regional Haze SIP Appendix B 2011-01 -0004

B.6.d. Arizona Regional Haze SIP Appendix C 2011-01 -0004

B.6.e. Arizona Regional Haze SIP Appendix D 2011-01 -0004

B.6.f. Arizona Regional Haze SIP Appendix E 2011-01 -0004

B.7. Revision to the Regional Haze SIP for the State of Arizona 

with Technical Support Document

2013-05-03 -0004

B.8. Attachments to the 2013 Arizona Regional Haze SIP revision 2013-05-03 -0004

C. EPA Communications with Outside Parties

C.1. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Martz 2012-11-06 -0005

C.2. Email from Martz, PCC, to McKaughan, EPA 2012-11-28 -0005

C.3. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Martz, PCC 2012-12-14 -0005

C.4. Letter from Enos, SRPMIC to Blumenfeld, EPA 2012-12-20 -0005

C.5. Email from Withey, EPA, to Tsiolis, PCC, et al. 2014-01-09 -0005

C.6. Email from Tsiolis, PCC, to Withey, EPA, et al. 2014-01-10 -0005

C.7. Letter from Garrity, ASARCO, to Webb, EPA, and 

attachments

2013-01-25 -0005

C.7.a. Letter from Garrity, ASARCO, to Webb, EPA 2013-01-25 -0005

C.7.b. Response to Item 8 2013-01-25 -0005

C.7.c. Response to Item 9 2013-01-25 -0005

C.8. Letter from Cooke-FMMI to Webb, EPA, and Appendices A, 

C, and J (4 files)

2013-01-25 -0005

C.8.a. Letter from Cooke-FMMI to Webb 2013-01-25 -0005

C.8.b. Letter from Cooke-FMMI to Webb Appendix A 2013-01-25 -0005

C.8.c. Letter from Cooke-FMMI to Webb Appendix C 2013-01-25 -0005

C.8.d. Letter from Cooke-FMMI to Webb Appendix J 2013-01-25 -0005

C.9. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Bohnee et al. 2013-01-29 -0005

C.10. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Bohnee et al. 2013-02-04 -0005

C.11. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Bohnee 2013-02-11 -0005

C.12. Email from Bohnee, SRPMIC, to McKaughan, EPA 2013-02-12 -0005

C.13. [reserved] -0005

C.14. Emails (2) from McKaughan, EPA, to Grady, CalPortland 2013-02-26 -0005

C.15. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Barry, Lhoist 2013-02-26 -0005

C.16. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Martz, PCC, and Bohnee, 

SRPMIC

2013-02-26 -0005
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

C.17. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Bakken and Yockey, TEP 2013-02-27 -0005

C.18. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Bark, FMMI 2013-02-27 -0005

C.19. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Garrity-ASARCO 2013-02-27 -0005

C.20. Letter from Blumenfeld, EPA to Enos, SRPMIC 2013-02-28 -0005

C.21. Email from Bark, FMMI, to McKaughan, EPA 2013-02-28 -0005

C.22. Email from Garrity, ASARCO, to McKaughan, EPA 2013-02-28 -0005

C.23. Letter from Parameswaran, ASARCO, to Nudd, EPA 2013-03-06 -0005

C.24. Letter from Garrity, ASARCO, to Webb, EPA 2013-07-11 -0005

C.25. Letter from Cooke, FMMI, to Webb, EPA 2013-07-12 -0005

C.26. Letter from Blumenfeld, EPA, to Enos, SRPMIC 2013-09-25 -0005

C.27. Letter from Enos, SRPMIC, to Blumenfeld, EPA 2013-10-18 -0005

C.28. Email from Withey, EPA, to Giff, SRPMIC, et al. 2013-11-25 -0005

C.29. Email from Withey, EPA, to Giff, SRPMIC et al. 2013-12-10 -0005

C.30. Email from Tsiolis, PCC, to Withey, EPA et al. 2013-12-11 -0005

C.31. Email from Withey, EPA, to Tsiolis, PCC, et al. 2013-12-11 -0005

C.32. Email from Tsiolis, PCC, to Withey, EPA, et al. 2013-12-20 -0005

C.33. Email from Withey, EPA, to Tsiolis, PCC, et al. 2013-12-21 -0005

C.34. Letter from McKaughan, EPA, to Cooke, FMMI 2013-01-10 -0005

C.35. Email from McKaughan, EPA, to Garrity and Tsiolis, 

ASARCO

2013-01-13 -0005

C.36. Letter from Erik Bakken, TEP, to Greg Nudd, EPA, re 

Comments from Tucson Electric Power (TEP)

2013-03-06 -0005

C.37. Letter from Erik Bakken, TEP, to Greg Nudd, EPA, 

regarding TEP Sundt Modeling & Cost Information

2013-05-10 -0005

C.38. Letter from Jay Grady to Gregory Nudd re CalPortland 

Company AZ RH SIP Comments

2013-06-18 -0005

C.39. Email from Bryan Paris, ADEQ, to Greg Nudd, EPA 2013-08-01 -0005

C.40. Email exchange between Greg Nudd, EPA, and Bob 

Downing, Maricopa County

-0005

C.40.a. Emails between Greg Nudd, EPA, and Bob Downing, 

Maricopa County

2013-08-21 -0005

C.40.b. Spreadsheet attachment to email from Greg Nudd, EPA, and 

Bob Downing, Maricopa County

2013-08-06 -0005

C.41. Letter from Erik Bakken, TEP, to Greg Nudd, EPA, 

regarding TEP Sundt Unit 4 BART Alternative

2013-11-01 -0005

C.42. Letter from Verle Martz to Greg Nudd re: Phoenix Cement 

Company AZ RH SIP Comments (includes Trinity 

Consultants’ report and SNCR cost estimate)

2013-03-06 -0005

D. EPA Contractor Documents

D.1. University of North Carolina (UNC) Task 5 Report (AZBART-Modeling-Protocol)2012-07-16 -0006

D.2. UNC Task 7 Deliverable (CLC Nelson-Sundt4-Catalyst 2012-10-03 -0006
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

Paper BART Analysis Report)_final

D.3. UNC Task 9 Deliverable (Springerville-Cholla-IrvingtonCalPortland-Phoenix-RPAnalysis Report)_final and 

attachments (9 files)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.3.a. TOXECON Cost Estimates for Coal-Fired Boilers 2006-12 -0006

D.3.b. Memo Regarding Costs and Performance of Controls 2009-03-10 -0006

D.3.c. Memo Regarding Wet Scrubber Cost Algorithms 2010-02-26 -0006

D.3.d. Sundt Unit 4 Cost Calculations (EGU Costs_Ch3) 2012 -0006

D.3.e. RP EGU Cost Calculation (EGU Costs_Ch5) 2012 -0006

D.3.f. Non-EGU BART Cost Calculations (Non EGU_BART_Ch3) 2012 -0006

D.3.g. Non-EGU RP Cost Calculations (Non EGU_RP_Ch5) 2012 -0006

D.3.h. Memo Regarding NOx, SO2 and CO2 emissions from 

Cement Kilns (Emissions Memo) 

2009-03-10 -0006

D.4. UNC Task 6 Deliverable (AZ-sources-subject-to-BART_v4) 2012-07-19 -0006

D.5. Particulate Matter Speciation Files -0006

D.5.a. Sundt unit 4 non-FGD PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FFpmSpeciationProfile_IrviUnit4_

base_ctrl1-4-5-8-9.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.b. Cholla unit 1 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Cho

lla-Unit1-filtPM.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.c. Cholla unit 2 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Cho

lla-Unit2-filtPM.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.d. Cholla unit 3 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Cho

lla-Unit3-filtPM.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.e. Cholla unit 4 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Cho

lla-Unit4-filtPM.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.f. Sundt unit 4 FGD PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Irvi

Unit4_ctrl2-3-6-7-10-11.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.g. Springerville unit 1 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Spri

ngerville-Unit1-filtPM.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.h. Springerville unit 2 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Spri

ngerville-Unit2-filtPM.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.i. Springerville unit 3 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Spri

ngerville-Unit3-filtPM.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.5.j. Springerville unit 4 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Spri

2012-10-03 -0006
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

ngerville-Unit4-filtPM.xls)

D.5.k. CalPortland kiln 1,2,3 PM speciation 

(2006FinalDryCementKilnFFSpeciation_CalPortland_k123.x

ls)

2013-01-10 -0006

D.5.l. CalPortland kiln 4 & Phoenix Cement PM speciation 

(2006FinalPreheaterPrecalcinerKilnFFSpeciation_CalPortlan

d_k4.xls)

2013-01-10 -0006

D.5.m. Nelson kiln 1 (unit 2) PM speciation 

(Nelson_ChemLime_kiln1_unit2_PMspeciation_CoalfiredRo

taryLimeKilnFF.xls)

2013-02-04 -0006

D.5.n. Nelson kiln 2 (unit 3) PM speciation 

(Nelson_ChemLime_kiln2_unit3_PMspeciation_CoalfiredRo

taryLimeKilnFF.xls)

2013-02-04 -0006

D.5.o. Nelson RICE (unit 1) PM speciation 

(Nelson_ChemLime_RICE_unit1_PMspeciation_Uncontrolle

dIndustrialResOilBlr.xls)

2013-02-04 -0006

D.5.p. UNC Task 6 Sundt PM speciation (WA5-12 Task6 AZsources-subject-to-BART_supporting-data.xls)2012-03-26 -0006

D.6. UNC Emission Inputs for Modeling -0006

D.6.a. AZ EGUs - NOx Emission Data 2012-06-08 -0006

D.6.b. UNC master emissions spreadsheet for Tasks 7 & 8 

(AZ_BART_sources_all-Task7-8_2012-08-29.xls)

2012-08-29 -0006

D.6.c. UNC master emissions spreadsheet for Task 9 

(AZ_RP_sources_all-Task9_2012-09-30.xls)

2012-09-30 -0006

D.6.d. UNC Task 6 Sundt model input (WA5-12 Task6 AZ-sourcessubject-to-BART_data.xlsx)2012-03-26 -0006

D.7. UNC Modeling Outputs and Tables for Reports -0006

D.7.a. UNC Task 6 Sundt model output (WA5-12 Task6 AZsources-subject-to-BART-Table4-5data-v4.xlsx)2012-07-19 -0006

D.7.b. Nelson Lime tables of emissions, dollars, deciviews 

(che_az_unit1-3_dollarperdv_analysis_final.xls)

2012-10-08 -0006

D.7.c. Cholla unit 1 tables of emissions, dollars, deciviews

(cho_az_unit1_dollarperdv_analysis_final.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.7.d. Phoenix Cement tables of emissions, dollars, deciviews 

(phc_az_task9_dollarperdv_analysis_final.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.7.e. Springerville units 1,2 tables of emissions, dollars, deciviews

(spg_az_unit1-2_dollarperdv_analysis_final.xls)

2012-10-03 -0006

D.7.f. CalPortland Cement tables of emissions, dollars, deciviews 

(cpc_az_unit1-4_dollarperdv_analysis_final_fixed.xls)

2014-01-15 -0006

D.7.g. Sundt unit 4 tables of emissions, dollars, deciviews

(irv_az_unit4_dollarperdv_analysis_final_fixed.xls)

2014-01-15 -0006

D.7.h. Sundt units 1,2,3 tables of emissions, dollars, deciviews 

(irv_az_units1-3_dollarperdv_analysis_final_fixed.xls)

2014-01-15 -0006
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

D.8. AirControlNet Development Report, Version 4.1 

(AirControlNet-DevelopmentReport.pdf)

2006-05 -0006

D.9. Introduction to Area Source Emission Inventory

Development (IntroAreaSourceEI.pdf)

2001-01 -0006

D.10. NOx Control Technologies for the Cement Industry 2000-09-19 -0006

D.11. IPM Model Revisions to Cost and Performance of DSI 2010-08-01 -0006

D.12. Impact of Ammonia in Fly Ash on its Beneficial Use, 

Memorandum from EC/R to EPA

2010-08-31 -0006

D.13. Memo Regarding MACT Floor Analysis for Coal- and Oilfired EGUs2011-12-16 -0006

E. EPA Work Products

E.1. Reasonable Progress Q/d Screening Calculations, updated 

with 2008-10 CAMD data (10D Screening Update - 2008-10 

Emission Data.xlsx)

2013 -0007

E.2. Reasonable Progress Q/d Screening Calculations (UNC 

Task4 Deliverable (10D Screening) (EPA edits).xlsx)

2013-09-30 -0007

E.3. Summary of best performing wall-fired coal boilers (CAMD 

Wall-fired Coal EGUs.xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.4. Nelson Lime Plant Control Costs (LNA Nelson Control Costs 

(final for NPRM docket).xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.5. Sundt Unit 4 Control Costs (TEP Sundt4 Control Costs (final 

for NPRM docket).xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.6. Summary of Total Annual Cost Estimates for Arizona 

Regional Haze Phase 3 FIP

2014-01-27 -0007

E.7. Regulatory Flexibility Act Screening Analysis 2014-01-27 -0007

E.8. Summary of Communications and Consultation between 

EPA, PCC and SRPMIC

2014-01-27 -0007

E.9. St Mary's Cement cost effectiveness 2012-11-19 -0007

E.10. Ash Grove BART Analysis 2007-06 -0007

E.11. CalPortland Rillito Kilns 1-3 Cost Estimates (CalPortland

Cement K1-3 Cost Estimates (final for NPRM docket).xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.12. CalPortland Rillito Kiln 4 Cost Estimates (CalPortland 

Cement K4 Cost Estimates (final for NPRM docket).xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.13. CalPortland Rillito Plant and Phoenix Cement Clarkdale 

Plant Emission Calculations (Cement Plant Emission 

Calculations (final for NPRM docket).xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.14. Phoenix Cement Clarkdale Plant Cost Estimates (Phoenix 

Cement Cost Estimates (final for NPRM docket).xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.15. TEP Springerville CAMD Emissions Data & Maxima 

(Springerville_CAMD_max)

2012-08-10 -0007

E.16. ASARCO Hayden – Anode furnace cost calculations 

(ASARCO Control Cost - anode plant.xlsx)

2014-01 -0007
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

E.17. ASARCO Hayden – Converter cost calculations (ASARCO 

Control Cost Converters.xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.18. FMMI Miami – Converter and Electric Furnace cost 

calculations (FMMI Control Cost Converter and ELF.xls)

2014-01 -0007

E.19. FMMI Miami – Modeling emission rate calculations, max 

24-hr (FMMI SO2 Emissions Model.xlsx)

2014-01 -0007

E.20. Holcim BART Analysis (EPA) 2012-03-20 -0007

E.21. Andover Technology Partners cement kiln responses 2012-08-02 -0007

E.22. EPA corrections to UNC model output spreadsheets 2014-01-15 -0007

E.23. Look-up tables for UNC and EPA modeling Class I areas 

(lookups.xlsx) 2014-01-27

-0007

E.24. FMMI CALPUFF inputs, old emissions 

(FMMI_cpf_inputs_experiment.xlsx) 2013-08-23

-0007

E.25. FMMI modeled as buoyant line source, old emissions 

(FMMI_vis_buoyant_line_experiment.xlsx) 2013-08-29

-0007

E.26. FMMI modeled as point source, old emissions 

(FMMI_vis_point_experiment.xlsx) 2013-09-03

-0007

E.27. Sundt DFGD disbenefit at Saguaro NP 

(Sundt4_DFGD_disbenefit_check.xlsx) 2013-07-26

-0007

E.28. Sundt NO conversion effect (Sundt4_vis_NO2conv.xlsx) 2014-01-06 -0007

E.29. Phoenix Cement NO conversion effect 

(PhoenixCement_vis_NO2conv.xlsx) 2014-01-27

-0007

E.30. CalPortland Cement Rillito Plant NO conversion effect 

(CalPortlandCement_vis_NO2conv.xlsx) 2014-01-27

-0007

E.31. Sundt4 modeling results (Sundt4_visibility_results.xlsx) 2014-01-15 -0007

E.32. CalPortland Rillito Plant modeling results 

(CalPortland_visibility_results.xlsx) 2014-01-24

-0007

E.33. Phoenix Cement modeling results 

(PhoenixCement_visibility_results.xlsx) 2014-01-24

-0007

E.34. ASARCO Hayden modeling results 

(Hayden_visibility_results.xlsx) 2014-01-18

-0007

E.35. FMMI Miami modeling results 

(FMMI_visibility_results.xlsx) 2014-01-11

-0007

E.36. Nelson Lime modeling results 

(Nelson_Trinity_visibility_results.xlsx) 2014-01-12

-0007

E.37. Modeling results for Cholla1, Springerville12, Sundt123 

(Other_RP_visibility_results.xlsx) 2014-01-23

-0007

E.38. ASARCO Hayden stack parameters 

(Hayden_stack_parameters.xlsx) 2013-08-01

-0007

E.39. FMMI Miami stack parameters 

(FMMI_stack_parameters.xlsx) 2013-12-10

-0007

E.40. Arizona Area Source NOx emissions data from the 2008 

National Emissions Inventory (2008-NEI-Az-NOx-v3) 2013-08-22

-0007
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

E.41. Arizona Area Source SO2 emissions data from the 2008 

National Emissions Inventory (2008-NEI-Az-SO2) 2013-08-06

-0007

E.42. AZ FIP Cost Analysis (AZ FIP CoST Analysis_for Greg 

Nudd Rg 9_2013-08-13) 2013-08-13

-0007

E.43. Memo to Docket Regarding TEP Sundt Unit I4 BART 

Eligibility 2012-11-21

-0007

E.44. Technical Support Document for Technical Products 

Prepared by the Western Regional Air Partnership (WRAP) 

in Support of Western Regional Haze Plans (EPA WRAP 

TSD) 2011-02-28

-0007

E.45. TEP Sundt 4 2001-12 Emission Calculations (TEP Sundt4 

2001-12 Emission Calcs 2014-01-24.xlsx) 2014-01-24

-0007

E.46. CALPUFF inputs table 2014-01 -0007

E.47. ASARCO model emission rates, max 24-hr (public non-CBI) 2013-08-09 -0007

E.48. RP EGU Cost Calculation, with EPA edits (EGU Costs_Ch5

(EPA revisions)(final for NPRM docket)) 2014-01-25

-0007

F. Additional Documents Considered for Proposed 

Rulemaking

F.1. ASARCO Title V Permit 2001-10-09 -0008

F.2. ASARCO Title V Permit TSD 2001-10-09 -0008

F.3. FMMI Title V Permit 2006-07-05 -0008

F.4. FMMI Title V TSD 2006 -0008

F.5. Typical Installation Timelines for NOx Emission Control 

Technologies

2006-12-04 -0008

F.6. Summary of WRAP RMC BART Modeling for Arizona, 

Draft Number 5

2007-05-25 -0008

F.7. ASARCO Hayden CEMS Test Report, Energy and 

Environmental Measurement Corporation

2012-09 -0008

F.8. Memorandum from Ralph Morris and Lynsey Parker, 

ENVIRON, to Eric Hiser, Jorden, Bischoff and Hiser

2013-03-04 -0008

F.9. FMMI Expansion - ADEQ Sig Revision App - Final 2013-07-31 -0008

F.10. BART Five Factor Analysis, Lhoist North America Nelson 

Lime Plant and attachments (6 files)

2013-08-13 -0008

F.10.a. LNA Nelson-1998 Hydrogeologic Water Supply Study 1998 -0008

F.10.b. Nelson BART Control Costs 08.26.13_Public 2013 -0008

F.10.c. Nelson BART Five Factor Analysis 09.27.13 - Public 2013 -0008

F.10.d. Noltech DSI quote - Public 2013 -0008

F.10.e. Southern Environmental Quote - semi-dry scrubbing-Public 2013 -0008

F.11. [reserved]

F.12. Chemical Lime Nelson Title V Permit 2011-08-08 -0008

F.13. Chemical Lime Nelson Title V TSD 2011 -0008

F.14. Lime MACT Economic Impact Analysis 2003-08-25 -0008
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

F.15. Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory -0008

F.15.a. 2005 Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory 2005 -0008

F.15.b. 2006 Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory 2006 -0008

F.15.c. 2007 Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory 2007 -0008

F.15.d. 2008 Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory 2008 -0008

F.15.e. 2008 Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory Revision 2008 -0008

F.15.f. 2009 Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory 2009 -0008

F.15.g. 2010 Phoenix Cement Emission Inventory 2010 -0008

F.16. Supplementary Information for Four Factor Analyses by

WRAP States (corrected) (4FactorAnalysis_WRAP)

2010-04-20 -0008

F.17. Colorado Air Quality Control Commission, Regulation 

Number 7, 5 CCR 1001-9, Section XVII

2011 -0008

F.18. Tucson Electric Power Form 10-K (2011 Annual Report) 2012-02-28 -0008

F.19. Grupo Mexico 2011 Annual Report 2011 -0008

F.20. NPCA v. EPA – Docket 2011-2013 -0008

F.21. NPCA v. EPA - D.D.C. Memorandum Opinion and Order 2012-05-25 -0008

F.22. 2012 FMMI Title V Permit 2012-11-26 -0008

F.23. 2012 FMMI Title V TSD 2012-11-26 -0008

F.24. NPCA v. EPA - Order Revising CD Deadlines 2013-09-06 -0008

F.25. NPCA v. EPA - Stipulation Extending Phase 3 FIP Deadlines 2013-11-15 -0008

F.26. Colorado Regional Haze SIP 2011-01-07 -0008

F.27. TEP Sundt4 Compliance CEMS Test Report 2011-06-08 -0008

F.28. TEP Sundt4 Test Results 2011-06-08 -0008

F.29. Advanced Combustion Technology Ultra-Low NOx Control 2007-01-01 -0008

F.30. CalPortland Rillito 5 Factor RP Analysis 2013-05-09 -0008

F.31. What’s New in SCRs 2006-05-16 -0008

F.32. Federal Land Managers’ Air Quality Related Values Work 

Group (FLAG)- Phase I Report Revised (2010)

2010-10 -0008

F.33. Haldor-Topsoe SCR Experience List 10-09 2010 -0008

F.34. Hitachi SCR experience list 2010-02 -0008

F.35. Nitrogen Oxides Emission Control Options for Coal-Fired 

EGUs AWMA 

2009-05 -0008

F.36. Assessment of Control Technology Options for BARTEligible Sources, NESCAUM 2005-03 -0008

F.37. Lessons Learned from SCR Reactor Retrofit 2003-08 -0008

F.38. TEP Sundt Title V Permit No. 1052 TSD 2007-05-18 -0008

F.39. TEP Sundt Title V Permit No. 1052 2010-07-13 -0008

F.40. CalPortland Rillito TV Permit 47259 2010-06-01 -0008

F.41. CalPortland Rillito TV Permit 47259 TSD 2010-06-01 -0008

F.42. ASARCO cesium-promoted catalyst MSDS and sales 

proposals

2013-01-25 -0008
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

F.43. FMMI Annual SO2 Emissions calculations 2005-2012 2013-01-25 -0008

G. Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and Technical Support 

Document

G.1. Technical Support Document (TSD) for the Proposed Phase 3 

Action on the Federal Implementation Plan for the Regional 

Haze Program in the State of Arizona

2014-01 -0009

G.2. TSD Appendix A, Areas and facilities modeled including 

map 2014-01

-0009

G.3. TSD Appendix B, Visibility impact bar charts and tables 2014-01 -0009

G.4. Proposed Rule: Air Quality State Implementation Plans; 

Approvals and Promulgations: Arizona; Regional Haze and 

Interstate Visibility Transport Federal Implementation Plan 2014-02-18

-0001

H. Additional Documents for Notice of Final Rulemaking

H.1. CalPortland Cement K4 Cost Estimates (Revised for Final 

Rule)

2014-04-25

H.2. LNA Nelson Control Costs (Revised for Final Rule) 2014-04-25

H.3. Memorandum from J. Nikkari, Hatch to C. West, FMMI 

(Hatch Memo)

2013-11-14

H.4. EPA Arizona Regional Haze Phase 1 Brief 2013-12-12

H.5. FMMI Presentation to EPA (non-CBI version) 2014-04-29

H.6. Memo to Docket re FMMI Meeting 2014-04-29

H.7. Memo to Docket re FMMI Call 2014-05-13

H.8. EPA Arizona Regional Haze Phase 2 Brief 2014-04-18

H.9. Memo to File re Communications with TEP 2014-04-18

H.10. BART EGU FIP Summary 2014-06

H.11. Memo to File re ASARCO Meeting and attachments 2014-05-15

H.12. Comments from NPS on Phase 2 Proposal 2013-03-06

H.13. Asarco Hayden BART submittal 2013-03-20

H.14. Letter from Colleen McKaughan, EPA, to Jack Garrity, 

ASARCO

2013-06-27

H.15. Letter from Colleen McKaughan, EPA, to Derek Cooke, 

FMMI 

2013-06-27

H.16. Memo to Docket re Communications with Cal Portland 2014-03-26

H.17. Memorandum from Stephen Page to Regional Air Division 

Directors, Guidance for 1-Hour SO2 Nonattainment Area SIP 

Submissions (April 23, 2014)

2014-04-23

H.18. Memo to Docket re FMMI Call 2014-05-21

H.19. Memo to Docket re FMMI Call 2014-05-28

H.20. Memo to File - Communications with LNA and attachments

H.20.a. Memo to File - Communications with LNA 2014-06-13
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

H.20.b. Email from Ed Barry, LNA, to Colleen McKaughan, EPA12014-04-28

H.20.c. Response to EPA’s Request for Information Consolidating 

Startup Emissions into 30-kiln operating day limit

2014-04-15 

H.20.d. Letter from Ed Barry, LNA, to Colleen McKaughan, EPA 2014-04-29

H.20.e. Letter from Ed Barry, LNA, to Colleen McKaughan, EPA 2014-05-09

H.20.f. Email from Ed Barry, LNA, to Colleen McKaughan, EPA –

attachment is item H.20.g.

2014-06-03

H.20.g. Public-Summary of LNA Nelson March, May and June 2013 

CEMS Testing

2014-06

H.21. Memo to File re Communications with PCC and SRPMIC

and attachments

H.21.a. Memo to File re Communications with PCC and SRPMIC 2014-06-13

H.21.b. Letter from Enos, SRPMIC, to Blumenfeld, EPA (with 

5/14/14, 5/12/14, 5/6/14, and 5/1/14 emails between 

McKaughan, EPA, and Martz, PCC, attached)

2014-05-22

H.21.c. Email from Colleen McKaughan, EPA, to Verle Martz, PCC 2014-05-30

H.22. Memo to File re Communications with FMMI on RH FIP 2014-06-17

H.23. Memo to File - Full Technical Response to Modeling 

Comments for June 2014 Final Arizona Regional Haze FIP 

2014-06-16

H.24. CALMET/CALPUFF Protocol for BART Exemption 

Screening Analysis for Class I Areas in the Western United 

States 

2006-08-15

H.25. Simulation Specification for 2018 Preliminary Reasonable 

Progress Simulation version B

2009-08-11

H.26. Arizona Class I Areas FIP Reasonable Progress Goal (RPG) 

Estimates and linked spreadsheets

H.26.a. WRAP Arizona Point Source Emissions, August 2013 2013-08

H.26.b. WRAP modeling inventory totals, August 2013 2013-08

H.26.c. FIP RPG Estimates 2014-06

H.27. Summary of NOx emissions for Phoenix Cement, Kiln, 2005-

10 (public)

2014-06-17

H.28. Alternative Control Techniques Document – NOX Emissions 

from Process Heaters (Revised), OAQPS (September 1993)

1993-09

H.29. Comments on Draft NOx Control Measure Summary for 

Lime Kilns, National Lime Association

2006-03-30

H.30. AP-42, Chapter 11.17 Lime Manufacturing 1998-02

H.31. DSI Cost Calculations for Anode Furnace at ASARCO 

Hayden Smelter (“Anode Furnace - DSI Cost 

Calculation.xls”)

2014-06-05

H.32. Arizona Electric Cooperative (AEPCO) Comments on EPA 

Regional Haze FIP (with CBI Release)

2012-10-15

H.33. TEP Sundt4 2001-12 Emission Calcs.xls (Revised BART 2014-05-31

 

1 Two attachments with confidential business information (CBI) removed.
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

Alternative Emission Calculations)

H.34. DRAFT ADEQ Air Quality Class I Permit # 53592 (As 

Amended by Significant Revision No. 58409

2014-04-22

H.35. DRAFT Technical Support Document for ADEQ Air Quality

Class I Permit # 53592 (As Amended by Significant Revision 

No. 58409)

2014-04-22

H.36. Roofline Study, prepared by Trinity Consultants for Freeport 

McMoRan, Inc.

2013-11-14

H.37. Report: Extended Roofline SO2 Emissions Summary 2014-03-19

H.38. Letter from FMMI to EPA and enclosures

H.38.a. Letter from Jay Spehar, FMMI, to Geoffrey Glass, EPA 2014-05-07

H.38.b. Enclosure 1 – FMMI BART Report 2014-03

H.38.c. Enclosure 2 – Financial Information 2013-07-12

H.38.d. Enclosure 3, Appendix A - Annual SO2 Emissions 

calculations 2005-2012

2013-01-25

H.38.e. Enclosure 3, Appendix G – Daily TS CEM SO2 Averages 

2005-2012

2013-01-25

H.39. Miami Project Execution Schedule 2014-05-13

H.40. Memo re cost effectiveness of SO2 BART controls for 

converters at Miami Smelter using cost data from FMMI

2014-06-24

H.40.a. Miami Smelter Converters SO2 BART Supplemental Cost 

Calculations 

2014-06

H.41. Revised BART Analysis for SO2 at ASARCO Hayden –

Converters 1, 3, 4, and 5 

2014-06

H.41.a. ASARCO_scaled_benefit.xlsx 2014-06

H.41.b. Cost Calculations for Revised BART Analysis for SO2 at 

ASARCO Hayden

2014-06

H.42. Summary of Costs for Final Rule 2014-06

I. Comments Received

I.1. Lhoist North America (LNA) Comments 2014-03-26 -0010

I.2. El Paso Natural Gas (EPNG) Company Comments 2014-03-27 -0011

I.3. Freeport McMoRan Miami, Inc. (FMMI) Comments22014-03-28 -0012

I.4. Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) 

Comments

2014-03-31 -0013

I.5. America's Natural Gas Alliance (ANGA) Comments 2014-03-31 -0014

 

2 Appendix A is FMMI's BART analysis, which includes three sub-Appendices: A, B, and C. FMMI initially claimed 

Appendix A, Sub-Appendix B ("Emission Reduction and Cost Effectiveness Calculations") as CBI, but subsequently 

withdrew its claim. Accordingly, EPA has added FMMI’s BART Analysis with all sub-appendices as a separate docket entry, 

H.38.b. 
INDEX NO. CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

EPA-R09-OAR2013-0588-

XXXX

I.6. EarthJustice/National Parks Conservation Association 

(NPCA) et al Comments3

2014-03-31 -0015

I.7. Tucson Electric Power (TEP) Company Comments 2014-03-31 -0016

I.8. Arizona Mining Association (AMA) Comments 2014-03-31 -0017

I.9. American Coalition for Clean Coal Electricity (ACCCE) 

Comments

2014-03-31 -0018

I.10. National Mining Association (NMA) Comments 2014-03-31 -0019

I.11. National Park Service (NPS) Comments 2014-03-31 -0020

I.12. Phoenix Cement Company (PCC) Comments 2014-03-31 -0021

I.13. Asarco Comments 2014-03-31 -0022

I.14. CalPortland Comments 2014-03-31 -0023

I.15. Marsha Honn Comment Letter 2014-02-20 -0024

I.16. Transcripts and written comments from public hearings in 

Phoenix, AZ (2/25/2014) and Tucson, AZ (2/26/2014)

2014-02-25 

and 

2014-02-26

-0025

I.17. Friends of Saguaro National Park Comments 2014-03-13

I.18. Arizona Rock Products Association Comments 2014-03-31

J. Notice of Final Rulemaking 

J.1. Index to Docket EPA-R09-OAR-2013-0588 (this document) 2014-06-27

J.2. Final Rule: Air Quality State Implementation Plans; 

Approvals and Promulgations: Arizona; Regional Haze and 

Interstate Visibility Transport Federal Implementation Plan

2014-06-27

 

3 Exhibit 12 contains copyrighted material and is retained in the administrative record, but will not be posted to 

regulations.gov.