03/15/2013 15:12 8472947498 FAA GLRC 

To: (JOT He~&vihq Doc~e\ 

Company. _:F----.!A-'-.:-f+~~-~--

Phone: ----::--------

Fax{ ~ 6 d) L-{ q 3 -5 J L{-')__ 

From: :\I ba.u 0a rq .:S 

Title: EAA- At-/--oy-0~ --( 

u 

-

PAGE 01/07 

Federal Aviation 

Administration 

Regional Counsel's Oflice,AGL-7 

2300 East Devon Avenue 

Des Pl~ines,lllinois 60018 

T847-294-

F 847-294-7498 

Facsimile 

Date: ~ /1 [; (:l() 13 . . ' 

Pages w/cover: 7 RE: Tra.VJS Nvr+~· Av/R+\'on ~GICl.- GL~ o3-oo ~ 
03/15/2013 15:12 

U.S. Departmsnl 

of Tronsportotlon 

Federal Aviation 

Admlnlslration 

8472S474S8 

March 15,2013 

Hearing Docket 

Federal Aviation Administration 

800 Independence Avenue, S.W. 

Washington, D.C. 20591 

Attention Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 

Wilber Wright Building- Suite 2Wl 000 

RE: Late Filed Request for HeaJ:ing 

FAA GLRC 

2012-Gl..-03-0012 TRANS NORTJl AVIATION, LTD 

Ronald J. Schaberg, President 

ATTN: Hearing Docket Clerk 

Great Lakes R.E:!glon 

2300 E. Devon Avenue 

Des Plaines, ll 6001 B 

PAGE 02/07 

Federal, Aviation Administration, by and through counsel, continues its objections to 

the late filing of the appeal of the Final Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty case number 2012-

GL-03-0012 filed by Mr. Charles R. Barnett, III, Attorney at Law on behalf of Trans North 

Aviation, Ronald J. Schaberg, President. Attached is an answer to Trans North's Reply to 

the FAA's Motion to Deny AppeaL 

All correspondence regarding tb.is matter sho\lld be directed to: 

Jeanette B. Daubaras Esq. 

Federal Aviation Administration 

Offi.ce of the Regional Counsel, Great Lakes Region 

2300 East Devon Ave. 

Des Plaines, Illinois 60018 

Sincerely, 

~~· Attorney 
03/15/2013 15:12 8472947498 FAA GLRC PAGE 03/07 

SERVED MARCH 15, Z013 

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTTION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 

IN THE MATTER OF 

TRANS NORTH AVIATION, LTD 

FAA DOCKET NO. (2012-GL- 03-0012 

Civil Penalty Action 

FEDERALAVIAnON'SANSWER TO TRANS NORTH AVIATION, LTD'S REPLY 

TO THE FAA'S MOTION TO DENY APPEALS 

The Federal Aviation Administration, by and through counsel, hereby files its answer to Trans North 

Aviation's Reply and states in support thereof as follows. 

1. In its Reply Trans North alleges that it did not receive or sign for a Domestic Return Receipt and 

provides an affidavit by Ms. Beyersdorf to that effect (See Exhibit A.) 

2. The Agency respectfully provides a copy of a Return Receipt signed by Ms. Beyersdorf and 

returned to the Agency received on February 4, 2013 (See Exhibit B). 

3. Ms. Beyersdorf's Affidavit is clearly in error. 

4. Trans North states that this is the person that customarily receives mail on behalf of Trans 

North. 

5. In accordance with 14 C.F.R. Section 13.211(h) Presumption of Service, Service shall be 

presumed where a party or a person who customarily rece"1ves mail, or receives it in the ordinary 

· course of business, at either the p<=rson's residence or the person's principal place of business, 

acknowledges receipt of the document. 
03/15/2013 15:12 8472947498 FAA GLRC PAGE 04/07 

WHEREFORE, The Federal Aviation Administration again respectfully requests that the Late 

Filed Trans North Aviation's Request for Hearing be Denied. 

Dated: March 15, 2013 

Respectfully Submitted, 

FAA Attorney, Great Lakes 

Great Lakes Regional Counsel's Office 

2300 E. Devon Ave., Suite 479 

Des Plaines, IL 60018 
03/15/2013 15:12 8472947498 FAA GLRC PAGE 05/07 

2 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that I have, 'this date, served the foregoing Late Filed Request for Hearing by 

maUing the follm0ug copies,~ Facscirnile as follows: 

~"1. ....... ,1>-.. &. 

Regnl~r and facsimile 

Original au.d 1 Copy: 

.l!'acsimi.le and Regular Mail 

One Copy: 

Regular Mail 

One Copy: 

Dated this 15th day ofMarch,2013. 

Hearing Docket 

Federal Aviation Admini.stration 

800 Independence Avenue, S. W. 

Washington, DC 20591 

Attn: Hearing Docket Cle;k 

AGC-430, Wilber Wright Building 

Suite 2Wl000 

Facsimile: (202) 493-5142 

Charles R. Barnett, III 

Attorney at Law 

Lake in the Hills Ai;port (3CK) 

8411 Pyott Road, Suite 110 

Lake in the Hills, IL 60156-9704 

Facsimile: (815) 356-7042 

Mr. Ronald J. Schaberg 

President 

Trans North Aviation LTD 

Eagle River Airport 

POBox 1445 

Eagle River, WI 54521 

~ . Yolanda Quiles 

r:i~ Legal Technician 

~ FAA, Great Lakes Region 
03/15/2013 15:12 8472947498 FAA GLRC 

201S-0S-OS &o4:0o (GMT) 

PAGE 05/07 

18153567042 From: Char1t-gEamett. '~. ,. ' ""-11'- u .... , v 

Associated Baiil<: 

'u.S; »EPAKfMENT OFTRANSt'ORTATION 

FEDERAL AVIA U()N 1\.DMiNTSRATION 

AfFfiW{:!T OF' REC,'§Tl'T 0E F'!NA t NQTTCE .QTl PBJ)P6sED CtYTL PENALTY 

NA VlNG COMJ.l bclb.rc-th:e· ~:~ndersi&lled Noticy dui;y: !!Uth"(lrize(l to-~drnrnlster oatlis, 

KAREN BEYERSDORf, <:Il.l!:$tatc u.n4er oath after being properly sworn. ~ltm.the :fb!lQWi!lS 

statements·. lll'e :true and accurate, · · · 

1. l !""'l'IOI ;m em?!oyee <:ifT~s J\forth-Aviru:ion, 'L "''D;, 

2. The ~d.~ ofTtans Nm:tl1 Aviation, L'ID is'l>.Q ... .Box l445, EaileRl'<er. 

3. Once. a week.l'foi"watd tlie mall from P.O. Sox 1445, Eagl~ River, :Wis~nsin {oMr. 

Sclla.b~ ill an aodress qf 6! 4urens SV~ -Chari"-Stpn,. Sl:, 

4. I.dl.d nQI n:ceJ"e; vor.did) sisn ~ I:lo~~tic B.et~rn ~=ipt.foll'!l, ass~iatCd with any 

us Certin¢d.Mall fi'onuhe.F~enu A\<Wtloh .. AdmibiStralion.during:the mcnth of 

1anuary20B addmsMtl tci }",Q. Box. J44$,.Eagle Rll'(J(, Wisc0.11sin. 

Al'B!\NI:. FQRT,HEB, $AYS1'1-'! 1'/AI'JGl;IT 

Tlll~..4<:ctay of'March, ~0:.13~ 

~y~~k .. Countyof" ~u 

State·ofWiScQnsln 
['-

<Sl 

~ 

,_ 

<Sl 

w 

('} 

<I 

[L 

() 

"' _j 

('} 

<I 

<I 

lL 

OJ 

00 

" ['-

" 00 

" ['-

" OJ 

N 

<-< 

lfl 

<-< 

01 

<-< 

<Sl 

N 

~ 

lfl 

<-< 

~ 

01 

<Sl 

.• 

' i 

/ 

---

f·, . .!iO:HiUii. r ,~uo;..'. 

f P-Of Reg1onaJ C:ru~n'-::o>~~, 1-i.~:-L -7 

/_vJ•' ~ost Devon A·-:clll'q 

• Cnmplete Items i, 2, and 3. Also complete 

Item 41! Restrioted.Dellv!'IY Is desired. • Print your nama !lnd·id~rass oo tha revers<l so that we crun .. ttim tlie card to you: • AttaGh this caro to. ihe ~'ac!< of.\he'n).~llplece, or on too !rontff space pemJtls. • .. · .. ,: c... 

1. Artlcle Addressed to: 

Trans North Aviation, LTD 

Eagle Riv-er, WI 

7J:tjg:l(l5/13:12-GL-03-0012 

FNJ?CP 

-.,-.~·,, HHno1~ . ..-;;- ..... 0 

11 YES. :ertter dafive3y address be!Gw; 

Type 

Go.dlfied Mml D EKpress Mall 

0 Aeglsternd D RetumRaoelpttorMart:hBnd!SfJ 

D losured Mall D G.O.D. 

4 f\ostrloted Dellve"" ~ o ... ---· ·· . ,,,,......,,. ... r-ee) DYes 

' 7007 2b'BD 0002 125'! 7721 

· · PS Form 3811, Februaiy 2004 DomesiJc Ratum Bacolpt 102.511ti~·l6·1!)olj[). 

-J_ 

·'-.. 

--0 

·~ 

-s; 

X 

w