5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	






 $5/ &$//

 !" 	 !# $%&'() !" # $%&	 ' *  ')'(( *+*+ ,'- "!!)-*./ "0 *'1$/,)251,$ 28%/,&

03/2<((63 (7,5(0(17	<67(01 #(: %25. 	7$7(($&+(563 (7,5(0(17	<67(01 #(: %25. ,7<,5( 4(3$570(17 2(16,2181'1 #(: %25. ,7<22/,&( 4(3$570(172(16,21 81'1 #(: %25.,7< ($&+(563 (7,5(0(17	<67(01 #(: %25. ,7<52$5' 2) '8&$7,21(7,5(0(17 	<67(01 #(:%25. ,7< 03/2<((63

(7,5(0(17 	<67(01 626

/1*(/(6 2817<03/2<((63 (7,5(0(17/662&,$7,211 ($&+(563
9 	


			
 #.8

(7,5(0(17

	<67(0 2)

628,6,$1$1 ,7< 2)2+,/$'(/3+,$0*':"):"

*5(!2 '*''( *  '121&25'


19(670(17

203$1<

03/2<((63 ;<=> 252),7

$1'

	+$5,1*

2/$1 $1'

58671 
55(92&$%/(

5867

)25 7+(

5(1(),7 2)

2%(57

2250$1-,*) 	*(' ,?	*+ 1#250$1+2&. 41 #250$1+2&. 4 
1& 2(16,21

$1'

252),7

	+$5,1*

2/$11

#250$1

+2&. 4 
1&


17(*5$7('

252),7

	+$5,1*

2/$1-,#'"0&" *) .$' 15$5%$5$  	+867(51 +($<

$0,/<

2$571(56+,31

	$08(/

@(,661 2,6(

=$7=1

A5$&(  A,66(/48,67

		

#$7,21$/ 
1'8675<2(16,21

81'

	




,&+$5' 6 	&2771 +20$6

 5,67 ?

5 41 



#.8 

@ 	

" (**!" 

!*) &  )*( '(1!" 0*!*' '*' 0&0 1 '( 	 "  0  0'* '$*""**'*'
 	


			
 #.8

 :*'0'0 '*':" * *+ "(*':" **':!" '! 

6': *  : (  "+  ( 9B "  ! -)

C;*'0 B$"* " $ - !" /)(**  $0': !" 88)'(62$"*0")0" (C;**')-*' *'1" ($'!)-*" 1'(*'0 B(89)-*" !0 (!CBB**'"  - !" /)(**  *0"(/+ "!!'( 0#):"' $   '  : (  "+  ':: ( *'*'*( (*': 
' !0*'*!! + "0#):"'$"$' (+ BB" )0" (B" *'?'),

*',0@" $"- 0 (* 0*'B$" '

)-*0D)* ( ")(+ **'" !)-*0&! "'C8**''(0'*-) (B;" +) (C**'0"*- )*'0 B+ '*!" " :'*)( !" ')- !" ( -, 0@"  0)( '  -  '):"  0    '- ()-"*(**'   (' *$)('- )!!*0* ' E0) " !*) &  )*( '('" 5(

/"):"  ,*':)'"  F ( !:G  : "" 

(* 0&' $ 0& ,(* :( ()-*3* *0* '(0*0 *'*!!!* (0'' 0" **':!',!" 0&'0*'" $'*': + '  ! "  F ( !:G    ' '')-*0  *,(+  *'!*'" ! (  0"$' E 0) (*'0"" 
*0 '(" 	$)*$  '0'!*( '* 
'!0 +*), '*' (" 

$)*$(*0 (-,)-*

*'*=!**':!" ,  '(*':4 0 - @ !*'("*'*!!3 :*' *,*')!!*0* ' $*"*0)*,!0$"*0"0  )-'**& *"(!*-**,'" ! H*,!" 5(!- 0"!" (),!,,-,*'*( (*':

#.8 

/$<721



&

@+257(51 

,&+$(/

621*1 @,//,$0 

%281*1 5$1. 	 2<$/41 421$/' 	

$&

#$8*+7211

$*'$/(1$

/9(5+2))

41 4$9,' I$1'(:$7(51

2/80%,$./

($/7+&$5(

25325$7,21

'*'( !

 !	


8

628,6,$1$

	7$7(

03/2<((6

(7,5(0(17

	<67(0

		




$*'$/(1$

/9(5+2))1 ?$<

/ ?$55(//1 ,&+$(/ 

#((%1 2%(57

@+,7(6,'(1

+20$6  5,671 ,&+$(/

621* ?

51 421$/'

	 $&

#$8*+7211 

/$<721



&

@+257(51

$5/  (,&+$5'71 5$1.

2<$/1 ,&+$5' 6 	&2771

4$9,'

I$1'(:$7(51

@,//,$0  %281*1 ?2+1

42('(*0"(4 - *':
; 	


			
 #.8

!*0**)" * *' '( (- *':" !!*0 (* 0: ''(. , !" '*'( ! '('$"*0* (*'" $':!)0*'++ ("  *'12/80%,$./($/7+&$5(

25325$7,21

*'$" - "!"*0*'*- *':-):"

 !	






/ !" 
'* (	 4**0)

!" *(( 4**0! ''  #"+* 

#88188;J"/*::*'

4**0?)(: 

/:) (K4 0 - 9

4 0*( ('(* (K-),9

5 ! K/
#"* !?)(: 1A
%'(6*0)*

?)(: 






	 4'* 65 : 5#	
#6
@
L5A M A		/## # $ %& # $ %& 
@'5( 5/4M5/4@"* 2*'# $%&!/ '2)4$ 6//M@/=
#	 '2&*!'*!/  
4'* 65 : E@5 : ? !! ,#6 *- 5#	
#6
@
L5AMA		/### $%&# $%&
@'5( 5/4M5/4@"* 2*'

#.8  E 0 (  (  "   0)**  + '"#$	

( ; ;9; <( * >*'*( !*!- 0"!" ("$' " 0"   -, 0" * '  (*''(0  ('" (+   *'')-*0*'!9  NB <0**': 
 BB9

!)() ' *' ' , -  *'!  D)'** !" ( #


'"*0 *'*!! : (*

- $ ' ?'), B '( /0@"  %)': '(  *0",,-, *':**'!()-*0 F *0  *!*0*, *'!!)() '0*0 )"*O (%)': '( 0@"     )-'*!*''0*- ' !**'0)!&*':0"*- 0'*-)*C**''(C**'  0

2*'*!! +  " 	0 $' 

" ; 0 '!)'(*'B 	0 "( ( ', 9E* ,C8**'*" !)-*0&99 0&$"*0"( ! '('0**+" *'*!!0-*' (	*'0 (* (!',98B9" !"+  '!  ( -) 9 **'0'" )-'*"(*':0'*') (*'*'' :  ',(*':' *,(+  ''


* : ("()*':" $

B9" !-)C99B19B" !)-*0&C **'  0"*-  )  
98 	


			
 #.8

,W LV XQGLVSXWHG WKDW GLUHFWRU OLDELOLW\ ZRXOG QRW EH ZDLYHG XQGHU

WKH 5HVWDWHG &HUWLILFDWH RI ,QFRUSRUDWLRQ DV LW H[SUHVVO\ SURYLGHV QRSURWHFWLRQ IURP OLDELOLW\ IRU EUHDFK RI WKH GXW\ RI OR\DOW\

2*'*!!:) "" (**00) ' ),+* $ (

"* 0)** !)(0*'(0' D) ',* , * ()'"

 (
" 9(;

;<"*>
*'0 "" (**00)0* (

!',"*': "'" : ' **'""  !0&-,'*'*( *'*'"  ',!)() '"  E ' " "  (**0 0) * ( "* 0* $ '' "  !*'("*'*!!!* ( : *0)*O (!0)!!*0* '0  ()-" (**'   (' !H*,!" 5(0'*( ( '($*"  0"*0*

" (),!,, D)* "" - *'  !" 

0*' '(* " "( &   0 ( '0  +  ', !*'  !(* 0!!*0 0'*':" "( "*'" (-," 0&"( : ' ,
$
	
) ;8/9(9;<4 8;>1(	
'
	" B/9(BB<4 >
'( 4 $ 0'$FP!*()0*,!0*'$"( !"*$'- ' !*'" -*!0'!*( '**'!*'0D)* ("):""*!*()0*,**'- 0" "*()," 0*''(,- " ( 00)'- " 0*' ! ',:*'$*")  :(  $" "  "  0*' )!!  ((: QR3G


!	


 BB99(8<8"*><0**'* (><(*0)*':#
&
	


 /9(B<4 ";>>

/" (**00)- + ("$ + "   !0"

0&$  ( (-,'!!*0 (* 0( ' -*"- 0"!" (),!,,#
& /9(8/

(* 0* ! ( *'"  0*'3 0& $*")*-**," 0*'






/#;;89@68 <4 ",989><0**':
)&
! B/9(;<4 ">>1#
& /9(8 
' !0$" '(* 0'(!!*0 $'0& 0 *+ 0 '*'*'0&" ,")(- 

#.8 

7KH GHULYDWLYH VKDUHKROGHU FODLPV 

LQGLYLGXDO VKDUHKROGHU FODVV FODLPV LQ 01R  ZKLFK ZDV ILOHG LQ WKH 8QL0LGGOH 'LVWULFW RI 7HQQHVVHH RQ $SULO 

GHULYDWLYH VKDUHKROGHU DFWLRQV ZHUH WKHQ GLVWULFW FRXUW RUGHUHG WKDW WKH GHULYFRQVROLGDWHG DQG D VLQJOH DPHQGHG FRPSO

7KH GHULYDWLYH DFWLRQ ILOHG E\ SODLQWLI5HWLUHPHQW 6\VWHP /6(56 LQ D )ORULIHGHUDO FRXUW WUDQVIHUUHG WR WKH 0LGGDGPLQLVWUDWLYHO\ GLVPLVVHG E\ VWLSXODWLRQ 

# $%&!/ '@**@/=
#	 6 /':   *!5@#
6%@/#=M ''  4+*(4/)!") 50& @
66
/	 M ##?  A " #/6 M  ''  ?"'4=*0"=
 ''   @**  @** ?#"+*  ''  !/  







/62 5 A
% ? *0)*

*'++ 0'*( (0&"( ' - "! ! "  '*' (  "0  *' <)-0) ''(! (* 0'(.) ! *'+ *:*' *'  , *0" "0 !)(-," ": '0* '(" !0*** *'*)*' '( " $*  )-*./'($' ()0"" : ( $':(*':  2*'*!!3 0'*( ( 0*'  : ( - 0"!" !*()0*,(),!0 " !*()0*,(),!,,-,* 
 	


			
 #.8

FRQVROLGDWLQJ VXFK FODLPV LQ WKH 0F&DOO FDVH ,Q WKDW VWLSXODWLRQ /6(56DJUHHG WR EH ERXQG E\ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW¶V GHFLVLRQ RQ WKH PRWLRQV WR

GLVPLVV WKDW ZHUH SHQGLQJ LQ 0F&DOO DQG UHVHUYHG WKH ULJKW WR DSSHDO IURP

WKDW GHFLVLRQ

7KHVH DUJXPHQWV PDGH LQ WKH 0F&DOO DSSHDO DUH DGRSWHG E\

/6(56 RQO\ LI LW LV GRHV QRW SUHYDLO RQ LWV GLVFUHWH FODLP WKDW LWV FRPSODLQWZDV LPSURSHUO\ UHPRYHG IURP VWDWH FRXUW 7KH RQO\ IDLU UHDGLQJ RI WKHVWLSXODWLRQ UHTXLUHV XV WR ILQG WKDW /6(56 ZDLYHG WKLV FODLP E\ VWLSXODWLQJWR EH ERXQG E\ WKH GHFLVLRQ LQ 0F&DOO 0RUHRYHU /6(56¶V FKDOOHQJH WR

WKH UHPRYDO LV ZLWKRXW PHULW :KHUH WKHUH LV FRPSOHWH GLYHUVLW\ RIFLWL]HQVKLS DV /6(56 FRQFHGHV WKHUH ZDV WKH LQFOXVLRQ RI DQ XQVHUYHG

UHVLGHQW GHIHQGDQW LQ WKH DFWLRQ GRHV QRW GHIHDW UHPRYDO XQGHU  86& E :HQVLO Y (, 'X3RQW 'H 1HPRXUV DQG &R  ) 6XSS  ' 6&  5HSXEOLF :HVWHUQ ,QV &R Y ,QW¶O ,QV &R ) 6XSS   1 ' &DO  6HH DOVR ,Q UH 1RUSODQW&RQWUDFHSWLYH 3URGV /LDE /LWLJ  ) 6XSS   (' 7H[

(**00)(*':"  !*'(*':'(0'0)*'!" :*  H)(:  (** ( "  0'*( ( 0*' )'( (*+29<-><>!*'(*':"*'*!!"(!* ()!!*0* ',  :  ( '( !)**, )'(  4 $  $  E0) " !*) &  )*( '('" 5(!4* 0  2*'*!! :)  " "  (**0 0) !* (  ,+* $"  :*'*'" *:"!+- " '((  *'" *'  *''(*0*'!" $

"  (* 0 ( ! '(' "  * ? 41 

,'0@" 14'(	0#):"'1:( '/+ "!!41'&,41*0" 6':?1'(@**%)':1!* (H*'-* !' :)*':" "  (** $   -" ! !*)    : ( '(!)**,'(!!*)  0*:*'" (* 04 ! '('*0"(	0$"$"*'!" 5( '(!)-* '(4+*(I'( $ $"$" "* ! *':!!*0 <-)'(* 0> 0"( ( "  H*' -* ! ! "  "  *'(*+*() ( ! '(')-**& $* ( (" ( ! '('3-* !-)'," *) !( '(!)**,/! 0 !) +* $!"  0('(" *0- $$  +  *''(!*'("

#.8 

3ODLQWLIIV DOVR DOOHJHG WKDW WKHUH Z

LQGHSHQGHQFH RI 5HLFKDUGW DQG 5R\DO E

)ULVW ZKR ZDV UHVSRQVLEOH IRU WKHLU EHFDGGLWLRQ WR WKH EXVLQHVV WLHV WR &ROXPE

5HLFKDUGW DQG 5R\DO DOOHJHGO\ EHQHLQYHVWPHQWV LQ WKH /%2 RI +&$ LQ  :KLOH ZH GR QRW GHFLGH WKLV TXHVWLRQ ZDOOHJH WKDW D GLUHFWRU ZDV QRPLQDWHG RU H$URQVRQ  $G DW 


'0*'-," 5($*' E( '( - 0)  * $)( ( )'*,  -  F(( (G *!)'( ':!" ( '( )
 / # ; 8B@6 8B>1 )!
 
 ( 9<4 "8>

&*': "   :*'   

 '- *'!  '0 *' *'*!!*0)*O (!0 )!!*0* '  "  (**'   ('  !  (* 0*'0)(*':	0*'(/+ "!!-, :*':!0"*& *"( ! (* 0 *-**, !- 0"!" (),!0  

*', *'*!!  : ( "

- 0" (" !*()0*,(),!,(*':$"* *' *'!&'$, *0,+**':! ( '"( ! '('('(0'*-) B '( /*  $*" !)(*0) !"* *,(+  (+   0' D) '0  ! )(**0 0) 0'0)( ( " "  :*'!*'*( (*':$  *'!  '0 !!)('("  ! *&!*-**,!',!" (* 0
9 	


			
 #.8

$OWKRXJK SODLQWLIIV DOOHJH WKDW &ROXPELD SURYLGHG 6FRWW DQG

9DQGHZDWHU ZLWK VXEVWDQWLDO VHYHUDQFH SDFNDJHV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWFRUUHFWO\ REVHUYHG WKDW WKH %RDUG¶V GHFLVLRQ LQ WKDW UHJDUG LV QRW UHOHYDQWWR WKH TXHVWLRQ RI ZKHWKHU D GHPDQG ZRXOG KDYH EHHQ IXWLOH RQ $SULO 

:  ( '  (*0  0* ! '( " )-*3"*0": ( (*0 !"  E '*+ *'  ! ! '"'*' -,0 *" 
 '')'0 ( " * F   "( (*0) ( " *!*'(*':$*")-*!!*0*! + '"*" 0"*(G@*") :*':$"" !!*0**:""+ - '*'*!!30*' ("F" 5($$ *'!" 
**'+ *:*'G

 H 0*': "  0* " "  5( $ $  ! " 

*'+ *:*' "  (**0 0) !)'( * , "+  - ' '-  ! "  5(  &    "' $ $ &  +)  "  
 * *0  $*") &*': ',

0*'2*'*!!&"$ ) ""   $)("+  (*0) ( "  !*'(*': $*" *"  "  (* 0"  +   "*:" +  E 0)*+  $" $)( "+ ,  (" 5(($)(-  0)*''('*'!  '0 /"  * " "*:" "'+ : 
 '( 4A  )-*3 "* $   ' ' $,(*0+  ( )!" *0 + '*!" 5($)'$  ! "  
 * *'+ *:*' - !  " *0 $  )-*" (*'*!!"+  : ("" 5("( (,(* :( (*'!*'):: *':$*(  ('(, *0!)(,"+ - '00)*':*')-*3!0*** '*'$*( 

  !"#!' ?), 9  "  5( ! 4* 0 00  ( " 

 *:'*' ! -" 	0 '( I'( $   "  *:'*'$  !$ (-,"  *:'*'! '*' "  '* E 0)*+ 2*'*!!:) "" !*) !

" 5( + 	0- ! ?),9( ' " )*( '(*'/*$)("+ - '!)* 

#.8 

*LYHQ WKH SRVWXUH RI WKLV DSSHDO RX

IURP WKH SODLQWLIIV¶ DPHQGHG DQG FRQVRDOVR SURYLGHG WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW ZLWK FRSLH6(& IRU WKH \HDU HQGLQJ 'HFHPEHU 

GDWHG $SULO   IRU WKH  $QQXDWKH 6(& DQG VHQW WR VKDUHKROGHUV DQG &R,QFRUSRUDWLRQ 'HVSLWH KDYLQJ JUDQWHG WKRI WKHVH PDWWHUV WKH PDJLVWUDWH MXGJH %HUJVWHLQ Y 7H[DV ,QW¶O &R  $

$OWKRXJK GHIHQGDQWV GR QRW FKDOOHQJH WKDQRWLFH RI WKH 5HVWDWHG &HUWLILFDWH RI ,QFRU6¶KROGHUV /LWLJ  $G  'HO &K

&+$0386 LV D IHGHUDOO\ IXQGHG 

'HSDUWPHQW RI 'HIHQVH IRU GHSHQGHQWV R" *'*!!)!!*0* ', : (( " *0*!*' '*' 00 4 * " ):*':!" *'('(( " *'(**- 0) " ,$  '0'*(  (



)-*./ *  4 $

" (D)  '( *'0* 0   ''  )'( (*'8-,: $:: *+ ,"-,;BS!!!*"**'" * : " ' E':  ' 0', '( $  ,   
  :, ! :$: *O : ' 0) 0 ")-*   ( ; "*0 ' '(+ B" " "  '(  ! *:' 0)'*  *': : +*( '(- $ +  ;S ! *  + ')  ! )-* *0* ( *' "   /2
	:$*"' ,+*( !- ' !*)'( "  
8 	


			
 #.8

2*'*!! : (")-*3 '*':  '$*"

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

 D)*,*'  ! 

 '"  D)** >1'(<;>0D)***'0*0 "!!  (*'()0  ' E 0)*+ !: 0'* '(*' !  ( $*" E**': ",*0*'  *'"*  2*'*!!  (" !" ( ! '(' ':: (*'* :*'*(  (*': *'0  " , ( ( $"*  &'$*': !)-*3!)() '0*+** 4: $   : (*'0)( ':" "*':" 0' D) '0 !! ( '( *'+ *:*'0&"( '($"* -$ $)* ! :( $* '( ( 0*'  *' "  +)  ! )-*0&

# (*':+ 0 " !*) &  )*( '(

*'*!! : ("H*,!" 5(!4* 0"(' *'   *' "  $':(*':  0)( ' E 0* *'(  '( 'H)(: ' $*"   0"    ( 0*2*'*!!0" ': " (**'  '(*'(  '( '0 !-)'  !" 5(3 '  - 1"  '  E0 *' - *':

#.8 

$OWKRXJK SODLQWLIIV DUJXH WKDW 

GLVUHJDUGLQJ WKH MXGLFLDO GHWHUPLQDWLRQV PDGH LQ FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK WKH WKLUW\GHWHUPLQDWLRQV KDG QRW EHHQ PDGH DV RI $

" (**00)!*!)'("

- 0'*(  (- 0) *$ $ + !0*' E* '0 - ! !* ( -) ' (*0+  ( )'*  (  *'*':( '(!)**,

/9(;9;B <4 >1+99999; <4 ">/ '0'0)( (K

- ) ',0**'*'+ ")( *(* 0-):*+ *O " !0"!/*800) (*' '  !!*0  ) ! '*''(" $($)('0 $*( 0**'0'()0

"*0'0)*' ' ),+* $!!*0 *'**'@" '" & ': " "   )!!*0* '!*'! "" 5(&' $!   : (,* *0* '(!$ (*')-*3 !0*** :'*)( '(()*'!"  : *' (  *'*': $" "  "  !*)0'*)  0&!:( !*"" 94<	4

$ 	

!%&'#('0"99'(98 

" 
$"*0" : (0  '( ':'(*': ') *'+ *:*'G/)(,!" -* (*0  * ' *'  E ')-* ,  $   +*
9; 	


			
 #.8

,Q GHIHQGLQJ DJDLQVW WKH 7KRPSVRQ ODZVXLW WKH &ROXPELD

GHIHQGDQWV DUJXHG WKDW HYHQ LI WKHUH ZHUH YLRODWLRQV RI IHGHUDO ODZV WKH\GLG QRW FRQVWLWXWH YLRODWLRQV RI WKH )DOVH &ODLPV $FW 7KH )LIWK &LUFXLWUHYHUVHG LQ SDUW DQG UHPDQGHG IRU IXUWKHU IDFWXDO GHYHORSPHQW RQ WKHTXHVWLRQ RI ZKHWKHU SD\PHQWV IRU VHUYLFHV LGHQWLILHG LQ DQQXDO FRVW

UHSRUWV ZHUH FRQGLWLRQHG XSRQ WKH GHIHQGDQWV¶ FHUWLILFDWLRQV RIFRPSOLDQFH ZLWK WKH ODZV 7KH FRXUW DIILUPHG WKH ILQGLQJ WKDW WKHVWDWLVWLFDO VWXGLHV IDLOHG WR DOOHJH IUDXGXOHQW ELOOLQJ SUDFWLFHV ZLWK

VXIILFLHQW SDUWLFXODULW\ 2Q UHPDQG WKH GHIHQGDQWV¶ QHZ PRWLRQ WR

GLVPLVV ZDV GHQLHG 6HH 7KRPSVRQ  ) 6XSSG  6' 7H[

"  5(3 !*)   &  0*'  *'+ *:  )'(  " 0*0)'0 $'*':(!*"

) 
& &!%&'#(#!'' 0"   ! (  : ' ! !) ! ( 

: '0* " 5

	4  '!	'(4  '!4 ! ' **'
'+ *:*'	 +*0  E 0) ( 0"$'')-*3!!*0 *'2 E2*'*!! : ("" $'$   E 0) (*'0'' 0*'$*"'*'$*( ! ( *'+ *:*'!)-*""(- '':*':*'0  *(B
'?),! ( : '*( ("*,!*+ )-*!0*** *'*E  ! +*( '0  *':-,-**':'(" " "0  *'" ?),$'$  ) (-," !!*(+*!5
/: '? "($"*0""   ('?),

/: ' (  ( " !  *' +* $ $*" $*'  

0" 0)',*'0)(*':0) ''(! )-* , " 5
F")'0+  (, *0Q*0R0 0"      ( -, 0  !!*0  '( ':  !)-*3"*" " ": '0* '(" !0*** *'" 	 ! ''  *(A :* E'(  $"    ( !)(  (*0   (*0*( '(/2
	G  (   ( " )-* $ - *':*'+ *: (-," ?)*0 4  '" 2
' 0'(   + '"  

#.8 

7KH 6(& ILOLQJV LQGLFDWH WKDW .DUDP

 LV D 0DMRU 6XSHULRU RI WKH 6LVWHUV RH[WHQVLYH H[SHULHQFH DV D KRVSLWDO DGPLQ$PHULFDQ &ROOHJH RI +HDOWKFDUH ([HFXWL

7KH PDJLVWUDWH MXGJH DPHQGHG KLV 

LQGLYLGXDOV ZKR ZHUH QDPHG LQ WKH 0RU

UHSRUW ZHUH QRW DFWXDOO\ GLUHFWRUV DW WKPDJLVWUDWH FODULILHG WKDW WKLV FRUUHFWLRQ GLG EHFDXVH RQO\ RQH GLUHFWRU ZDV IRXQG WR KDFRXUW¶V RUGHU PLVWDNHQO\ VWDWHV WKDW WKH ZHUH LQWHUHVWHG

	* ?)(*"/''=*:"

( ! '('*''("  *0"($' (( * ' (*)  " "  0* !  +) (!/*8" (0*$  ( *'" 
0

4 ! '('3 + *'

:*  H)(:  !   '(:*  H)(:  )*' ( "  ( *',O (" :)'()'( '( $)( "+  - ' !)* *'*!!"('"$'"H*'   (  0& ( *'(  '( 
0*'$!* (+ (**00)( (" !*'(*':(** (" 0*'*'-* 

* , $  !* (-,*'



	 	**#"+&!  &%

/(**00)3( 0**'(*

9<-><>* +* $ (!

(*)'( ) 9<-><>")('- - ,'(()-"" *'*!!0) ! "* 0* $"*0" $)
 	


			
 #.8


& 
 (/
 BB 
	 ; ;B; <B>  
' " "( ( *+*+ 0*'(*+29 D)* "" *'*!!F : $*"*0)*,G"   ' !!**':  &    )* ( '(  "     (*': D)*  '( (*'4 $ "'0 ,) 9$)00*'0,( 0*- (!$K

2 (*':*'( *+*+ )* :+ ' (-,"'0 ,

)  9 Q$"*0"R    ) 0, $*" *': ' D)*  ' ! !0) *0)*, " (*!! )-'*, ! "   **+  '*0   (*'::+ ' ( ,-,"'0 ,) 8<>) 9*'*!* ( -, 0'0),   '     '*0  (*':'" " "'("  ( *' D)* ( ( +*( '0 @""  ( ) !" *0)*O (!0)  '"   '*" 0*

#
. ;/9(9;;9B; <4 9> <!' * (>

6		   , :)  " ( '( !)**, * 

0 ()D) *':+ ' (-, ''   $" 0'," 	)  )( 0 *'0
0% " B
	8 <>"$" " " !*) & ( '(* E0) ()- 

(  *' ( )'(  "  )-'*+  $ ! "    !*'0*'" )" ("" $!"  !

*'0*' 0' + ' $" ' ( *+*+  0*  -):" )'(  ! (  $  "!
    "   (*':

 D)*  ' ! (  *+ 2 9 * "  0 () -(* '!" )-'*+ *'0* "0&"( 3*:" 0) ( *+*+ )**** (*)*'*'$"*0"( '(* E0) (- 0)  *" " (* 0$  *'0- !&*':'**( 0**'" (* 0

#.8 

- 
		"#!?  "' 4  (

"** E!* (	0**/0
	T9)-*'( '** 0' ("  !*''0*':  '* (*0  * ' $"*0"  : ("'  0* ( )--**':!)'' 0 , +*0 

" 

0*'$)'

$" '" :+ ' '( 0*' (!0 )-*3 B = !( 0*- (" 0*'"+*': <"  ', '( 0 *' )' "*> ':: ( *'  $*( ",*0*'' ,! ! '(*'()0  ! G*'+**'!!"*(*0) "" 5(


'(*0)'*':" *'0 !

(**0 0)  * ( )' "  !0(** (*'?),'( *$ +  (*'-," *!"*1

-




/8	)<	4 E8<B"*>/ )" "" (** (0*'$)F (!:G!/*8
'* " '( (" *:'*!*0'0 & ((  *' $" "  (!-)$" " '"( " 5('(*'(  '( ',0'*(  (- 0"!" (),!0 + '(** (*0 ,  ' (0*'()0  ''(* :-**':

	0*'" 

$)*!" 0*'(*- ! ( " 

0*$    +'
99 	


			
 #.8

3ODLQWLIIV VWDWH RQ DSSHDO WKDW WKH YHUGLFW ZDV UHQGHUHG RQ

)HEUXDU\  

0*0 - 0) " ,$   ! (* 0!!*0 !0'* 0D)* (-,)-*$ + " 0*'(*(' : $*"*0)*,',* 0*+*,*'" '0*'0'0)( !" **!!***'' "" ,$  $ ! : (,* :0D)***'0*0 $)(-  0)*'!"  !*+ (* 0',*$ : (  "+  - '  ', *'++ ( *' )-*30D)***'0*+** @"* $ : $*"" (**00)""  *'"*':* * :-) *" F E'*' -, 0D)***'G  --,*': ' - "! ! *0) '0*' "  *0**' ! 	0 '( *** &'$ (: !" ':  '" : (,+* (" "0 $'( :)*'

**': " )-* *' !  ( $*" ",*0*'

 *'"* *' ))* ! * 0D)***' : *'*!! 0*!*0,  : ( " 	0 $  ', *'++ ( *'0)*':(0( !)("*' )!"**'  *'" *'0:,' "*/  !	0$"*0"$(* (  * !!  ( *'()0  '  4 /-)( (*0*  "* ! ! 4 	0"*0"  *   "  H),$( (	0"*0"  * C9**'*'0)(*':CB**'*')'**+ (:  :*')-* 2*'*!!3 0*' (',"KF" 5($)'D) *'-,$ !"*0 G

- +*': " "  0*' (*( ' *'(*0  $" ' " 

+ (*0$ '(  (" (**00)!)'(" + '*!*$ '(  (- ! /*8" + (*0' $'):: *+ !0 $*( $':(*':@"* $ : " "  $)* (*( ' ' 0 *, $' " * 0*0 $  - *': , (, *0," $)*$   "  + (*0 ")( -  0'*(  ( $*"  ! " !0

#.8 

:KHQ D GHPDQG LV PDGH DQG UHIXVHG

WKH GHULYDWLYH DFWLRQ LI WKH ERDUG¶V UHIXVDO MXGJPHQW UXOH 6HH 6FDWWHUHG &RUS Y &

  'HO  RYHUUXOHG RQ RWKH

DW  5DOHV  $G DW  Q$':!), !) (( '() /9(99<4 > &.! 
##&'

/-*0 * !0 :

$*"" (* 0" "'" -)*' '(!!*!" 0;/9(8B8 <4 8;>$    0" ':  (* 00*'F" 0"*' ,!0( *+*+  )*   '*(  )'!*"!) ':  ')*0" ': " * ,!( )'( " *)"*,F0&"( "  $ !)  )*' ! " - ! " ,$*-  * ()) ;/9(

" (**00)0'0)( ("

" F- '0 !0'0*)-(")( -  +) ( )'(  "  )

  @  :   "  +*(  " ( '( * E0*0)*O (!0 : ( <> Q H*, !R "  (* 0*'(  '( 'QR<9>" 0" ': (" ()0!+*( E 0* !/9(  8;  
' ) "  0)( *+*+  )* ! )'(  "  

 

@"  "  *'0'0*)( 0 !*'!0*':" -)*' 
9 	


			
 #.8

6LQFH WKH FODLPV EDVHG XSRQ LQVLGHU WUDGLQJ DOVR GLG QRW LQYROYH DQ\

%RDUG GHFLVLRQ ZH DOVR DSSO\ WKH 5DOHVWHVW WR GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU GHPDQG

FDQ EH H[FXVHG IRU WKRVH FODLPV

*0*'  "  - '0  ! -( 0*' "  ! &  * **-    ! "   '* *'D)*,0'  (-,

3$" " " (* 0"+ 

0 (*'0'!*,$*"" -)*' H)(: ') *'+*':" 0" ': ('0*'

) ;/9(<0**'* (>

2*'*!!&)0'0)( "" 5(3!*) & 

0*' $*"   0  "  , *0 !)( 00)*': )-*$')'0'0*)( 0**' !*'!0*':2*'*!!3(),!0 0*"$ + * ) !  :*' ! ''! '0  -, "  5( <



F*' '*'*:''0 !GF$*!)-*'(' G" F (!:G"$  *:'! '*,!)() '0*0 >'(0" ':  "  5(3 !*)   &  0*'  *'+ *: )'(  "  0*0)'0   "  0* ( '  :  0'0*)5(( 0**' !*'!0*':


'( )" '" 0))(  *' F$" " '

" *0)*O (!0) :*'0   '- ()-"!" * " 0*'*!* (QH*,!R" -(!(* 00)("+  , E 0* (**'(  '( ' '( (**'   ( -)*'  H)(: ' *' '(*':   ( '(G  ) ; /9(  ;   -*"   '-  ()- *'*!!   '  D)* ( ( !0 " $)( -  )!!*0* '  )  H)(*0*!*'(*':!( '(!)**,(
/


	 B/9(88 <4  88>  # ) *'*!! ( '   '- --**,!)00 '"  *);/9(;)" $" " *'*!!"+  : (!0)!!*0* '  0     '-  ()- 0'0 '*': " (**'   (' '(*'(  '( '0 !H*,!" 5()- (  *' ( !" 00))*'!"  !0& ': " +
	 B89/9(99999<4 ">

#.8 + : 
*'99 $"  (**0 0) !)'(" *'0  **' ! (*'  *-)  C;B ) C **' )')- D) *'-  E 0 $*( !)(/@") ' '' "  , '$""(* E * '0 ':*' "  0*0)'0  " /30*0 

/!" -+ + :  0 '

" "*:" 4A" (**00))-**" : !**'"  ")-*$' (+  *:", "* *' "  0)',1 '( 0  :,)) 0) 0B * '    '  0))-*34A'(
$)!"**')-*3$)(- H) '- *'! 
 '( 4A $  *:' ! 0*+** 

/ 	"0#'##!"#"&'"  '* 5( : (, 0 

" 0',30D)***':" +*)'0*''(" ': 0'* 	0'(* ! )-*3 /0D)***' 4 + *+," ( *!" '0*--,*':!:+ ' '!!*0* 0) +!0D)***' E 0)*+   (" 5
"- ' !*'( D)** $"* " )0" !" *"*

2*'*!!   " !*+  

0@"  0#):"' %)"+  - ' !** $*" )-
9 	


			
 #.8

*'0  *'" *'!0 E4A- *':-* ('( ) ()-*3!0*** 0"* + B9S:$"2*'*!! : ("" (* 0&' $")0" !:$"$' **0,*'- - '!)(	 +  E 0)*+  : (,(" 5
"" 0" ': (0*0  ) ( ! 0  *0*  " ' ( !)-*3" (D) 


'B* : (,:+ F! $ E 0)*+ G'*0 

!#4"$0**0!'" 0',3 )     :: *+  :$" :  "  ( F*'! (   !*:) G '( FD) *'-  00)'*': "(G*'(*':' :*'"" 5( - $   $ !"  *0 " (**0 0) 0'0)( (":*+*':" *0 " $)'( '(- '((*(':*+  *   ' *'!  '0  ! F*'*  *+ G  
 * '' 0 , " *'*!!  :  !0 "$*':  *'* *+ " " *'0*( ' ):: " *,"+ - ' '**+ " (': ":: *+ :$": 0)( )*'D) *'- -**':0*0 


'*0)*'*!! 0' '("" (* 0 ")(

"+ - '  (-,"  !*'0  *'0 E4A'(
 E * '0 ("*! " ,$  0D)* (-,)-*/' E *'*!! : ("' , !  ( (*0 ' $0D)* (-,)-** 0 ': ! *,0 -* ()'( 4A0( $*"" :  *-)  '$ '!SS
" ' S$"* "*0 (0"  J-)'$' (-,)-*J-* (',98S!* *,0 )'( " "*:" 4A0( 

2*'*!!   , '  :*' " / $"*0" "(

"*:" "'+ : 
$*'+ *: (!'(  ( :*' ! D) *'-  -**': 0  *': '(& *':0*0 *$ *( ''(!/1 *0"( 0#):"' '( , $   (* 01 '(, $   -  ! /3 /)(* *  ")!$"*0"0@" $0"*''('(0#):"'$(* 0"()*' ,"*:" "'

#.8 

3ODLQWLIIV KDYH DEDQGRQHG WKHLU FOD

ILGXFLDU\ GXW\ RI FDUH 7KLV LV XQGHUVWXQGHU 'HODZDUH ODZ LV SUHGLFDWHG XSRQ FR$URQVRQ  $G DW 

@ : $*"*'*!!"" 

" :* H)(: 3 '(+* $*':" !0) :*' ($ '- *'!  '0 *'*!0)*':)'" *'*!!30*

" D) *'!$" " *'*0)*, !0 " 0     (**'   ('  '( *'(  '( '(* 0

/(* 0*0'*(  (*'  

$*  0 *+  ' !*''0*- " * ' D), " ( -, " 0 ( 0**'$*"+ F '  (* 0 -) ' "  0) ;/9(@"* " *-**, * ' )!!*0* '  (**'   ('  !  (* 0*0)*O (  :*' *' " )-'**& *"(G!*-**,) ;/9(<D)8B>1"#-	"	*"*
<4 "B>


'"*0 *'*!!*'*'"

!" *& *"(!*-**,(* 0 !*' '*'  0& (),!0 2*'*!!0' 

(* 0 $   *'   ( -, +*!*''0*- ' !*!*'*( +**'!" *(),!,,
; 	


			
 #.8


 !&!#!&"1&''&"22&
&

" 0')!(* 0*-**,!- 0"!" (),

 E 0* *  '*' '*,* :0 0*+** $  (*0) (*'""		
" 	'	$	
 8/9(B<4 ">"  " 0) E*' (""*$F*-," (*!!*0)" ,*'0*'$)'$"*0"*'*!!*:"" $*'H)(: 'G"!
4* 0*-**,!)0"

- 0",* <>!-(( 0**'" ) (*'- 0) " ( 0**' $*(+* ( <9> ! F')'0'*(  (!*) !" -(0*'0*0)'0 *'$"*0" ()   '*' $)( :)-, "+   + ' ( " G"!
/(*0) ( * " (),!0 0**'"*0  ! *' "   0'( 0 :,  " , *  ! " 5(3!*) 0)'( " 0*0)'0 " 0)*'" ("$" '(* 0*-**,* (*0 ()'*:''0 !*-**,0 *':0*+** F',)*' (, *0!*) !" -( E 0* + *:"J)0"') !*)  )  '- *'!*''( *':,  E*J$* -*"" 0&!:(!*""*' 0 ,0'(**'*-**,G"!



'0'*(  (*'0*'0'- " -*!(* 0*-**,

- 0)  + '"):"0 ( 0**' ')-H 0(* 0 '*'(*',-)*' ( 0**'!!!*0 '( ,  (   *' "  0*' 0' *:'*!*0',*'H)  "  0*' '( &  * )-H 0  0**''0*'"!
"*" ,: $)!' * ( 0**'*'

$"*0"" 4 $ 	)  ) E*' ("K

" D) *'!$" " 0 (* 0"- 0 *-  ! "  0*'"):"' : 0!(), * (  *' ( -, "  0*0)'0   
! "  " 0& ,   ( 0'!*( '0  *' ' -+*),)')$", ,  "  !) (  ' : 0 (0+* ,   ! "* (),   (* 0  "*:' ( *" $*!),"):"*' '*'-+*)(': *:'! , $':(*':" $$*0" -)( '!*-**,)'"*

#.8 

:KLOH WKH DXGLW SURFHGXUHV IDLOHG 

%RDUG DVVXUHG WKDW QDWLRQZLGH DXGLWVXQGHUWDNHQ ZLWK DWWHQWLRQ WR DUHDV WKDW FR&ROXPELD $V D UHVXOW ZH DJUHH ZLWK WKH VXEVWDQWLDO OLNHOLKRRG RI OLDELOLW\ EDVHG UHDVRQDEOH UHSRUWLQJ V\VWHPV H[LVWHG

$W RQH KRVSLWDO  RI D ORQ

DWWULEXWHG WR FDSLWDO DQG WKH DXGLWRUV JRYHUQPHQW $  PLOOLRQ UHVHUYH ZDV GLVFRYHUHG

3 	 #
..#&&" 5(3/)(** $

" :!)-*3*' '" * )(* '( "  ( D)0, *' ' 0' '( 00)'*':*   ("  " )-*3 *' ' )(* '*'$*( !0)*':F**,'',3!*:*'G'(((*!*0*'",*'0)( 

2*'*!!0' '("*'!

-))-*3 *-)  ')'*&-  *:' " *  , ( "):") "  0  : (,*'(*0 ((*0 )-* (  "  :+ ' ' '(* *'0)*'!' , '& *': '( (+ *  ' $* *-)  '1* "*!*':)* '  +*0  :  "*:"   E! *( ! *':",*0*

2*'*!! : ("" 

 +*( '0  ! $*(  ( * : F)0'* ',-+ + :  *-))'( " "*:" 4A0( $"0 *E*'( E<
>	0 
8 	


			
 #.8


' B "  /)(* *  ! )-*3 5(

0'* ( ! /+ "!!  *0"( '( 6':  
' 0#):"'  0 ( 6':  /+ "!!  ",*0*'0*0*':*'***(- 0 )-*(* 0*'9	" "(' D)*,*'  *'' "*"" (*'*,*'+  '*' ( (*0 ' 1)-*0D)***'0 (*'***(0#):"'$!  "*' '(  ! -" / '( 2)( '*
')'0 ', "( * (! ")$"   "  "(  + (  "*' ! "  E 0)*+ * 

 *0"(- 0  )-*(* 0*'; '($

"*'!*/)(**  *0"($"*''(!@ :M','(*)-*(*,@ :5'&!8)'*;4)*':"* @ :+*( ()-'*!*''0*-0&*':/	*'0 " '@ :"+*( (C9**'!C-**'0 (*!0**,)-*

6':- 0 )-*(* 0*''( + ('

" 5(3/)(*'( '*'* 6':*' *'*+ -'&*':!*'(0': !" 88)'(62$"*0")0" (C;**')-*' *'

A*+ '" ** E * '0 *'*!!*'*'"" 

!*) !"  (* 00$"  )!'*' '*'  0& (* :(!"  F ( !:G"$' (!" , *0!)() '0*0  , ('( '0): (-,)-*':  '
'*0)*'*!! : ("*' '*'   0&  (* :( 0' -  *'!  ( ! " !*)   0 *' "  !0  ! )(* *'!*' ':*':0D)***'0*0  :*'-):":*')-**'	0*'"  E '*+ ! ( *'+ *:*'" 


**'+ *:*'*')-*3-**':0*0 '(*'0*'-," 5(*?),9

#.8 (
$

>	*'0 " '" 4 $ 	( ( : ' :*: '0   "  (* 03 *-**, !  - 0" 



;/9(891	8B889<4 8B>

/!  +* $*':" 0 $ 0

0)30'0)*'"		
&0 ("" 0('( '," "*': "   0* )'(   *' '*' 0'()0*  D)* ( *-**,( (-,)-*)  8 /9(  

T9<-><>)-*3  ( +*( !$K

4.'%+6/(* 0!"  ',*- " !' ,(: !- 0(* 01
!!
"

 **' **" *-**,- 0"!" (* 03(),!*0&"( <**>!0!*"  $"*0" *'++  *' '&'$*':+**'!$<***>)A ' *'6$!4 '0*'!$"*0"" (* 0 '- ' !*

@" '" +*(*,!)0"+**!0)-*!" 0***(), ! 0  "  $*+  , * (*'( 0*(*':*'(* )*( '(#-	"	*B;
 	


			
 #.8

6LQFH WKH SURWHFWLRQ RI VXFK D SURYLVLRQ LV LQ WKH QDWXUH RI DQ

DIILUPDWLYH GHIHQVH D GHIHQGDQW VHHNLQJ H[FXOSDWLRQ EHDUV WKH EXUGHQ RIHVWDEOLVKLQJ LWV HOHPHQWV (PHUDOG 3DUWQHUV Y %HUOLQ  $G 

 'HO  $V D UHVXOW LW LV QRW WKH SODLQWLII ZKR PXVW HVWDEOLVKEDG IDLWK DW WULDO EXW WKH GHIHQGDQW ZKR EHDUV WKH EXUGHQ KRZHYHU VOLJKWWR VKRZ JRRG IDLWK ,G ,Q WKH FRQWH[W RI GHWHUPLQLQJ GHPDQG IXWLOLW\ RIFRXUVH QR HYLGHQFH LV UHTXLUHG VLQFH WKH LVVXH LV ZKHWKHU WKHSDUWLFXODUL]HG IDFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQV DUH VXIILFLHQW WR FUHDWH GRXEW DERXW WKHGLVLQWHUHVWHGQHVV DQG LQGHSHQGHQFH RI D PDMRULW\ RI WKH GLUHFWRUV


	%

/;9@69<4 ",89>

2*'*!!*'*'"" *(),! 0  0*  '

- (  "   0'( E0 *' E0)(   0*' !(* 0*-**,!F0**''*':(!*"$"*0"*'++ *' '*'*0'()0&'$*':+**'!$G/"):"*'*!!): )*'  F*' '*'*0'()0G*'0)( F 0& ' G$ ('- * + " 4 $ 	)  )$)(*'  " +**'*'"*$,  	* * * )'0  $" "     0&  0 **',-  E0)( (!"  0*'!+**'( ())'T9<-><>/'  *  E*' (K

@" "  "  )  $)(  0  (* 0 :*' 0& 0*': " 0 "  E '" 0& ' *'++ 0'0*)(* :(!&'$'*&*0)(- :) (")0"'0"*'' & ' *' :( !*" '( ") 0)( ' -  *-**, E  ()'( " ' $) '" " "'("  E ' " "  0'()0  : (  -   0&  * (*0 ( ,' :*'!)*' (*' '*'" (),**:)- $" " )0"0'()0*F:,' :*: 'G-)'0'()0)'*':-(!*"

5$/277,M,1.(/67(,14(/$:$5(

6$: 2)

25325$7,216

$1'

586,1(66

5*$1,=$7,216T;9;;

<( (	)9>")$ !*'(" (**00)  (*'0'0)(*':"',*' '*'0'()0$)( 0 "  0*'!" +**'( (*')-*3  ( *!*0 !
'0*'

#.8  #!#'4#"#5& 	

@ !*'("" *0)*O (!

 )!!*0* '  ')-'*" ! !*+ !)-* '- ()-" (**' " 5(!/*8/" "* 0'0)*' *'++  ' (*': $*"   0  ( '*'*'" )"!"  :0*'"  *

/ *:'*!*0' !0 *' ) 

 :*' $ "  * E * ( ! '('  (* 0  :'*O*'"$  0D)* (-,"*' ! )-*3 5( $" '" $*' ('( *"(- ' 2 *( *' ! / *0 </> 0D)* (-,)-**';

0@"  + ()-*

' '') , ! C  ") 
'0"  * B  *' ("* ,  + (* 00@" $ ") !  B  (* 0!/!8B8

,  ",*0*' 0*0*': 

- 0    -  ! )-*3 + ( ' )-*3  '+ 0 '*'':  0&*''( +* $ , 5 ! H*'*':)-*35(!/'( - !*)(*H*' ( )-*3 5( *' )-*3  '*'  +*), - '  -(  - E 0)*+ * !)'