# APPENDIX 

# A**Steven L.**  **Beshear**

**Governor Energy**  **and Environment**  **Cabinet Department**  **for Environmental**  **Protection**

**Division for**  **Air Quality**  **200 Fair**  **Oaks Lane,**  **15 1**  **Floor Frankfort,**  **Kentucky 40601-1403** 

**air.ky.gov February**  **13, 2015**  **Beverly Banister,**  **Director Air,**  **Pesticides and**  **Toxics Management**  **Division U.S.**  **Environmental Protection Agency, Region**  **4 Atlanta**  **Federal Center**  **61 Forsyth**  **Street Atlanta,**  **Georgia 30303**  **Dear Ms.**  **Banister: Leonard**  **K. Peters**  **Secretary**

**The Kentucky**  **Division for**  **Air Quality**  **is respectfully**  **submitting 2014**  **hourly ozone**  **and sulfur dioxide**  **data, as**  **well as**  **five-minute sulfur**  **dioxide data,**  **for certification.**  **The data,**  **for which**  **certification is**  **requested, is**  **listed on**  **the following**  **attached AQS-generated**  **reports:**

**• AMP600:**  **hourly averaged**  **ozone data**  **(parameter code**  **44201) and**  **sulfur dioxide**  **data (parameter**  **code 42401)**  **• AMP450nc:**  **five-minute averaged**  **sulfur dioxide**  **data (parameter**  **code 42406)**  

### I **hereby certify**  **that the**  **ambient concentration**  **data and**  **the quality**  **assurance data**  **are completely**  **submitted to**  **AQS.** 

### I **also certify**  **that, to**  **the best**  **of my**  **knowledge, the**  **ambient air**  **concentration data**  **are accurate,**  **taking into**  **account the**  **quality assurance findings.** 

### If **there are**  **any questions**  **or concerns�**  **please contact**  **Ms. Jennifer Miller, Environmental**  **Scientist with**  **our Technical**  **Services Branch,**  **at (502)**  **564-3999, extension**  **4050.**

**SA/jfm Enclosures**  **KentuckyUnbridledSpirit.com Sincerely,** 



# '.1� /fJ1u/ **Sean Alteri,**  **Director**

# �

# �**\.. /DLED** **SP/RIT 'q**  **An Equal**  **Opportunity Employer**  **M/F/D Ms.**  **Beverly Banister** 

**February 13,**  **2015 Page**  **2 c:**  **Darren Palmer,**  **USEPA Region**  **4 Daniel**  **Garver, USEP** **A Region 4 Keith**  **Goff, USEP** **A Region 4 UNITED**  **STATES ENVIRONMENTAL**  **PROTECTION AGENCY**  **User ID:**  **FNX CERTIFICATION**  **EVALUATION AND**  **CONCURRENCE Report**  **Request ID:**  **1297134 Report**  **Code: AMP600**  **GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS**  **Tribal Code**  **State County**  **Site Parameter**  **POC City**  **AQCR UAR**  **CBSA**

**21 PROTOCOL**  **SELECTIONS Parameter**  **Classification Parameter**  **Method CRITERIA**  **CRITERIA 44201**  **42401 SELECTED**  **OPTIONS Option**  **Type MERGE**  **PDF FILES**  **AGENCY ROLE** 

**DATE CRITERIA**  **Start Date**  **End Date**  **2014 2014**  **Duration AGENCY**  **SELECTIONS Kentucky**  **Division For**  **Air Qual**  **i ty** 

**Option Value** 

**YES CERTIFYING** 

**Selection Criteria Page**  **1 CSA**  **EPA Region**  **Feb. 13,**  **2015 Certification**  **Year: 2014**  

### Data **Evaluation and**  **Concurrence Report**  **Summary**

**Certifying Agency**  **(CA): Kentucky**  **Division For**  **Air Quality**  **(0584) Feb.**  **13, 2015** 
**Pollutants in**  **Report: Monitors**  **Evaluated Monitors**  **Recommended for**  **Monitors NOT**  **Recommended Parameter**  **Name Ozone**  **Code 44201**  **Concurrence by**  **AQS for**  **Concurrence by**  **AQS**

**22 22**  **0 Sulfur**  **dioxide 42401**  **9 9**  **PQAOs in**  **Report:**

**PQAO Name**  **PQAO Code**  **TSA Date**  **Kentucky Division**  **For Air**  **Quality 0584**  **Summary of**  **'N' flags**  **for all**  **pollutants: AQS**  **Cert. Agency**  **06/19/12 Parameter**  **Recommended Recommended 0** 

**PQAO Code**  **AQS Site-ID**  **POC F**  **la g** 

# J

# � **Reason for**  **AQS Recommendation**  **S ig**  **n u**  **��Moni�ring O�an** 

**�d on**  **p� n** 

**�� e** 

**�� ��**  **��� ---**  **- -**  **-- -**  **- ----** 

**- -** 

**� v** 

**Page 1 of 1** 

# Data **Evaluation and**  **Concurrence Report**  **for Gaseous**  **Pollutants**

**Certifying Year**  

## 2014 **Certifying Agency**  **Code** 

## Kentucky Division **For Air**  **Quality (0584)**  **Parameter** 

## Ozone **(44201) (ppm)**  **PQAO Name**  

## Kentucky **Division For**  **Air Quality**  **(0584) QAPP**  **Approval Date**  

## 04/21/2011 **NPAP Audit**  **Summary: Number**  **of Valid**  **Audits NPAP**  **Bias Criteria**  **Met 7**  **-1.2658 y**  **Routine Data**  **One Point**  **Quality Check**  **QS POC**  **Monitor Mean**  **Min Max**  **Exceed. Outlier**  **Perc. Precision**  **Bias Complete**  **ite ID**  **Type Count**  **Count Comp.**  

### �1-013-0002 **1 SPM**  

### 0.045 **0.013 0.071**  **0 0**  **97 2.06**  **+/-1.90 94**  **�1-015-0003 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.046 **0.014 0.072**  **0 0**  **99 2.14**  **+/-1.98 100**  **�1-019-0017 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.049 **0.019 0.083**  **0 0**  **99 1.48**  **+3.94 100**  **121-029-0006 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.047 **0.015 0.088**  **0 0**  **90 1.57**  **+2.44 94**  **�1-037-3002 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.051 **0.022 0.082**  **0 0**  **99 3.77**  **+/-4.29 94**  **21-043-0500 1**  **SPM** 

### 0.045 **0.017 0.068**  **0 0**  **99 1.27**  **+/-1.00 100**  **�1-047-0006 2**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.047 **0.014 0.075**  **0 0**  **99 1.17**  **+/-1.13 100**  **21-059-0005 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.048 **0.017 0.077**  **0 0**  **98 3.32**  **+4.42 100**  **21-067-0012 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.049 **0.014 0.074**  **0 0**  **99 1.60**  **+2.62 100**  **21-089-0007 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.047 **0.010 0.075**  **0 0**  **99 0.99**  **+1.42 100**  **21-091-0012 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.049 **0.018 0.082**  **0 0 96**  **1.76 +/-1.88**  **100 21-093-0006**  **1 SLAMS**  

### 0.047 **0.019 0.072**  **0 0**  **90 4.46**  **+/-4.22 94**  **21-101-0014 1**  **SPM** 

### 0.050 **0.019 0.080**  **0 0**  **98 1.49**  **+3.25 100**  **�1-113-0001 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.049 **0.019 0.074**  **0 0**  **99 1.50**  **+3.95 100**  **�1-139-0003 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.049 **0.019 0.074**  **0 0 100**  **1.17 +2.08**  **100 �1-145-1024**  **1 SLAMS**  

### 0.047 **0.016 0.077**  **0 0**  **99 2.24**  **+/-1.50 100**  **�1-185-0004 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.049 **0.021 0.083**  **0 0**  **99 3.39**  **-3.43 100**  **�1-193-0003 1**  **SPM** 

### 0.043 **0.014 0.067**  **0 0**  **100 1.40**  **+3.33 100**  **�1-195-0002 1**  **SPM** 

### 0.044 **0.014 0.084**  **0 0**  **99 0.79**  **+2.90 100**  **121-199-0003 1**  **SPM** 

### 0.047 **0.016 0.074**  **0 0 99**  **1.30 +1.78**  **100 21-213-0004**  **1 SPM**  

### 0.047 **0.013 0.074**  **0 0**  **99 2.23**  **+/-2.05 88**  **21-227-0009 1**  **SLAMS** 

### 0.048 **0.016 0.075**  **0 0**  **98** 

# I **2.46 +/-2.15**  **94**

**- Annual**  **PE NPAP**  **Concur. Flag** 

**Bias Complete**  **Bias PQAO**  **Level QAPP**  **Aqs Rec**  **CA Rec**  **Epa Criteria**  **Appr. Flag**  **Flag Concur** 



### - **2.48 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **1.12 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **1.62 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **3.56 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **2.38 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **1.67 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **0.84 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s** 

### - 1.07 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s** 



### - **0.90 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **0.27 100**  **y y y**  **y s** 



### - **1.72 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **2.32 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s** 

### 0.37 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s**  

### - 2.23 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s** 



### - **0.86 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **2.08 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **0.61 100**  **y y y**  **y s** 



### - **1.72 100**  **- 4.17**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **1.32 100**  **- 2.86**  **y y**  **y y**  **s** 

### 0.78 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s** 



### - **2.38 100**  **- 3.77**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **1.17 100**  **3.77 y**  **y y**  **y s** 

# Data **Evaluation and**  **Concurrence Report**  **for Gaseous**  **Pollutants**

**Certifying Year**  

## 2014 **Certifying Agency**  **Code** 

## Kentucky **Division For**  **Air Quality**  **(0584) Parameter**  

## Sulfur **dioxide (42401)**  **(ppb) PQAO**  **Name** 

## Kentucky **Division For**  **Air Quality**  **(0584) QAPP Approval**  **Date** 

## 04/21/2011 **NPAP Audit**  **Summary: Number**  **of Valid**  **Audits NPAP**  **Bias Criteria**  **Met 2**  **-5.0725 y**  **Routine Data**  **One Point**  **Quality Check**  **A Q** **S POC**  **Monitor Mean**  **Min Max**  **Exceed. Outlier Perc.**  **Precision Bias**  **Complete Site**  **ID Type**  **Count Count**  **Comp.** 

### �1-019-0017 **1 SLAMS**  

### 0.5 **0.0 51.0**  **0 99**  **1.86 -3.89**  **100 �1-037-3002**  **1 SLAMS**  

### 1.5 **0.0 93.0**  **0 99**  **2.19 -3.43**  **100 �1-047-0006**  **2 SPM**  

### 0.6 **0.0 31.0**  **0 99**  **4.49 +4.48**  **85 �** 

### 1-059-0005 **1 SLAMS**  

### 1.6 **0.0 65.0**  **0 99**  **4.05 +/-3.18**  **100 �1-067-0012**  **1 SLAMS**  

### 0.3 **0.0 28.0**  **0 99**  **2.13 -2.49**  **100 �1-089-0007**  **1 SPM**  

### 0.6 **0.0 23.0**  **0 99**  **2.05 +1.99**  **100 21-101-0014**  **1 SLAMS**  

### 0.9 **0.0 38.0**  **0 99**  **0.87 -1.34**  **100 21-113-0001**  **1 SPM**  

### 0.4 **0.0 19.0**  **0 99**  **2.13 -4.35**  **100 21-145-1024**  **1 SLAMS**  

### 0.4 **0.0 38.0**  **0 98**  

# I **4.54 -4.59**  **96 Annual**  **PE NPAP**  **Concur. Flag**  **Bias Complete**  **Bias PQAO**  **Level QAPP**  **Aqs Rec**  **CA Rec**  **Epa Criteria**  **Appr. Flag**  **Flag Concur** 



### - **0.89 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**



### - **2.36 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s** 

### 6.83 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s**  

### 3.34 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s** 



### - **0.32 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s** 

### 1.10 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s**  

### 2.29 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s**  

### 3.27 **100 y**  **y y**  **y s** 



### - **0.36 100**  **y y**  **y y**  **s**

# Data **Evaluation and**  **Concurrence Report**  **for Particulate**  **Matter**

### Data **Concurrence and**  **Evaluation Report**  **for Lead** **UNITED STATES**  **ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION**  **AGENCY User**  **ID: FNX**  **QUICKLOOK ALL**  **PARAMETERS Report**  **Request ID:**  **1297136 Report**  **Code: AMP450NC**  **GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS**  **Tribal Code**  **State County**  **Site Parameter**  **POC City**  **AQCR UAR**  **CBSA**

**21 PROTOCOL**  **SELECTIONS Parameter**  **Classification**

**ALL Parameter Method**  **42406 SELECTED**  **OPTIONS Duration**  **CSA EPA**  **Regio n**  **Feb. 13,**  **2015**

**SCR GROUP**  **SELECTIONS**

# I **SORT ORDER** 

# I'

**L_ __**  **__ __**  **_**

**p __**  **t i** 

**_ o** 

**_ n**  **T yp** 

**__ e** 

**__ __**  **__ __**  **__ __**  **__ __**  **____**

**__ __**  **__ o** **p t** 

**_ _**  **o n**  **V a** 

**_ l** 

**_ u** 

**_ e** 

**____**

**__ __**  **__ ____** 

**____ L** 

**o**

**__**

**_ _**  **_ r**  **__ __** 

**__ __**  **__**

**_ o** 

**_ _**  **u**

**_ _**  **n**

**____**

**__ ____** 

**__ �**  **L**

**---- --**  **-- K**  **_ e**  **_ n**  **_ t**  **_ u**  **_ c**  **y --**  **� MERGE**  **PDF FILES**  **YES 1**  **STATE CODE**  **EVENTS PROCESSING**  **EXCLUDE REGIONALLY**  **CONCURRED EVENTS**  **2 COUNTY**  **CODE AGENCY**  **ROLE PQAO**  **3 SITE**  **ID 4**  **5 6**  **7 PARAMETEJ:l._CODE**  **POC DATES**  **EDT ID**  **DATE CRITERIA**  **APPLICABLE STANDARDS**  **Start Date**  **End Date**  **Standard Description**  **2014 2014** 

**Select i**  **on Criteria**  **Page 1** 

# I **EDT DE$CRIPTION**  **0 NO**  **EVENTS 1**  **EVENTS EXCLUDED**  **2 EVENTS**  **INCLUDED UNITED**  **STATES ENVIRONMENTAL**  **PROTECTION AGENCY**  **AIR QUALITY**  **SYSTEM QUICKLOOK**  **ALL PARAMETERS** 

**EXCEPTIONAL DATA**  **TYPES**

**5 EVENTS**  **WITH CONCURRENCE**  **EXCLUDED Feb.**  **13, 2015** **UNITED STATES**  **ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION**  **AGENCY AIR**  **QUALITY SYSTEM**  **QUICKLOOK ALL**  **PARAMETERS Feb.**  **13, 2015** 

**Parameter Site**  **ID: 21-019-0017**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-min**  **avg Site**  **ID: 21-037-3002**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-min**  **avg Site**  **ID: 21-047-0006**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-min**  **avg Site**  **ID: 21-059-0005**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-min**  **avg Site**  **ID: 21-067-0012**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-min**  **avg Site**  **ID: 21-089-0007**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-min avg**  **Site ID:**  **21-101-0014 42406**  **S02 max**  **5-min avg Site**  **ID: 21-113-0001**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-min**  **avg Unit**  **p 0**  **c PQAO**  **City: Ashland**  **County: Boyd**  **Parts per**  **billion 1**  **0584 City:**  **Highland Heights**  **County: Campbell**  **Parts per**  **billion 1**  **0584 City:**  **Not in**  **a city**  **County: Christian**  **Parts per**  **billion 2**  **0584 City:**  **Not in**  **a city**  **County: Daviess**  **Parts per**  **billion 1**  **0584 City:**  **Lexington-Fayette**

**(corporate name**  **for County:**  **Fayette Lexingto** **n )**  **Parts per**  **billion 1**  **0584 City:**  **Worthington County:**  **Greenup Parts**  **per billion**  **1 0584**  **City: Not**  **in a**  **city County:**  **Henderson Parts**  **per billion**  **1 0584**  **City: Nicholasville**  **County: Jessamine**  **Parts per**  **billion .**  **1 0584**  **Site ID:**  **21-145-1024 °**  **City: Paducah**  **County: McCracken**  **42406 S02**  **max 5-**  **min avg**  **Parts per**  **billion**

**Note: The**  ***** **indicates that**  **the mean**  **" d** **oe s**  **not satisfy summary**  **criteria. 1**  **0584 Year**  **Meth**
**2014 100** 
**2014 100** 
**2014 100** 
**2014 100** 
**2014 100** 
**2014 100** 
**2014 100** 
**2014 100** 
**2014 100**  **# Obs**  **1st Max** 

**Value 2nd**  **Max**

**Value 3rd**  **Max**

**Value 4th**  **Max**

**Value Arith.** 

**Mean Duration**  **Address: FIVCO**  **HEALTH DEPARTMENT,**  **2924 HOLT**  **STREET 8690**  **76. 0**  **52. 0**  **42. 0**  **Address: 524A**  **JOHN'S HILL**  **ROAD 8673**  **218.0 163.**  **0 140.0**  **40. 0** 
**12 5.0**  **. 79**  **1 HOUR** 

**2. 30**  **1 HOUR**  **Address: WILLIAMSON RESIDENCE,**  **10800 PILOT**  **ROCK ROAD**  **7240 36.**  **0 31.**  **0 29.**  **0 27.**  **0 Address:**  **716 PLEASANT**  **VALLEY ROAD**  **8703 133.**  **0 12**  **4. 0**  **121. 0**  **101. 0**  **.85 1 HOUR** 
**2. 95**  **1 HOUR**  **Address: FAYETTE**  **COUNTY HEALTH**  **DEPT, 650 NEWTOWN PIKE**  **8714 35.0**  **22. 0**  **22.0 21.**  **0 Address:**  **SCOTT STREET**  **& CENTER**  **AVENUE 8694**  **31. 0**  **30. 0**  **22. 0**  **22. 0**  **.52 1**  **HOUR**
**. 8 8 1**  **HOUR Address:**  **BASKETT ·**  **FIRE DEPARTMENT,**  **7492 DR.**  **HODGE ROAD**  **8694 66.0**  **60. 0**  **59. 0**  **57. 0**  **1.71 1**  **HOUR Address:**  **KYTC MAINTENANCE**  **GARAGE, 260**  **WILSON DRIVE**  **8710 32.**  **0 19.**  **0 19.**  **0 17.**  **0 . 5**  **5 1 HOUR**  **Address: JACKSON**  **PURCHASE RECC,**  **2901 POWELL**  **STREET 8588**  **46. 0**  **40. 0**  **38. 0**  **34. 0**  **. 7 0**  **1 HOUR** 

**Page 2**  **of 5**  **Cert& l':l**  **tJ Eval**  **>-3**

**0**
**0**
**0**
**0**
**0**
**0**
**0**
**0**
**0 PARAMETER**  **42406 METHOD**  **CODE 100** 

**Note: '**  **The** ***** **indicates that**  **the mean**  **does not**  **satisfy summary**  **criteria. UNITED**  **STATES ENVIRONMENTAL**  **PROTECTION AGENCY**  **AIR QUALITY**  **SYSTEM QUICKLOOK**  **ALL PARAMETERS**  **METHODS USED**  **IN THIS**  **REPORT COLLECTION**  **METHOD ANALYSIS**  **METHOD INSTRUMENTAL**  **ULTRAVIOLET FLUORESCENCE** 

**Page 3**  **of 5**  **Feb. 13,**  **2015**

# IPQM

**0584**

**Note: The**  ***** **indicates that**  **the mean**  **does not**  **satisfy summary criteria. UNITED**  **STATES ENVIRONMENTAL**  **PROTECTION AGENCY**  **AIR QUALITY**  **SYSTEM QUICKLOOK ALL**  **PARAMETERS PQAOS**  **USED IN**  **THIS REPORT** 

**AGENCY DESCRIPTION**  **Kentucky Division**  **For Air**  **Quality**

**Page 4**  **of 5**  **Feb. 13,**  **201"5 FLAG** 

**M N** 

**s**

**u**

**X y**  **MEANING UNITED**  **STATES ENVIRONMENTAL**  **PROTECTION AGENCY**  **AIR QUALITY**  **SYSTEM QUICKLOOK**  **ALL PARAMETERS**  **CERTIFICATION EVALU** **A TION**  **AND CONCURRENCE FLAG MEANINGS** 

**The monitoring**  **organization has**  **revised data**  **from this**  **monitor since**  **the most**  **recent certification**  **letter received**  **from the**  **state. The**  **certifying agency**  **has submitted**  **the certification**  **letter and**  **required summary**  **reports, but**  **the certifying**  **agency and/or**  **EPA has**  **determined that**  **issues regarding**  **the quality**  **of the**  **ambient concentration**  **data cannot**  **be resolved**  **due to**  **data completeness,**  **the lack**  **of performed**  **quality assurance checks**  **or the**  **results of**  **uncertainty statistics**  **shown in**  **the AMP255 report**  **or the**  **certification and**  **quality assurance**  **report. The**  **certifying agency**  **has submitted**  **the certification**  **letter and**  **required summa,ry**  **reports. A**  **value of**  **"S" conveys**  **no Regional**  **assessment regarding**  **data quality**  **per se.**  **This flag**  **will remain**  **until the**  **Region provides**  **an "N"**  **or u**  **yn concurrence**  **flag. Uncertified.**  **The certifying**  **agency did**  **not submit**  **a required**  **certification letter**  **and summary**  **reports for**  **this monitor**  **even though**  **the due**  **date has**  **passed, or**  **the state's**  **certification letter**  **specifically did**  **not apply**  **the certification**  **to this**  **monitor. Certification**  **is not**  **required by**  **40 CFR**  **58.15 and**  **no conditions**  **apply to**  **be the**  **basis for**  **assigning another flag**  **value The**  **certifying agency**  **has submitted**  **a certification**  **letter, and**  **EPA has no**  **unresolved reservations about**  **data quality**  **(after reviewing**  **the letter,**  **the attached**  **summary reports,**  **the amount**  **of quality**  **assurance data**  **submitted to**  **AQS, the**  **quality statistics,**  **and the**  **highest reported**  **co n** **centrations).**

**Note: The**  ***** **indicates that**  **the mean**  **does not**  **satisfy summary**  **criteria. Page**  **5 of**  **5 Feb.**  **13, 2015** UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY DESIGN VALUE REPORT Mar. 6, 2015 Report Request ID: 1304254 Report Code: AMP480

Selection Criteria Page 1 User ID: GYE

State County City Site Parameter POC AQCR UAR CBSA CSA EPA Region 21 037 3002 GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS

PROTOCOL SELECTIONS Parameter Classification Parameter Method Duration DESIGN VALUE 42401

SELECTED OPTIONS
SINGLE EVENT PROCESSING WORKFILE DELIMITER USER SITE METADATA MERGE PDF FILES QUARTERLY DATA IN WORKFILE

AGENCY ROLE Option Type Option Value EXCLUDE REGIONALLY CONCURRED EVENTS

, COUNTY NAME YES NO PQAO DATE CRITERIA
2014 Start Date End Date 2014 Tribal Code

APPLICABLE STANDARDS Standard Description SO2 1-hour 2010

### UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AIR QUALITY SYSTEM PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT Report Date: Mar. 6, 2015

Notes:1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year). 2. Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report due to additional analysis. 3. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ('*'). Page 1 of 3

### UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AIR QUALITY SYSTEM PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT Report Date: Mar. 6, 2015

Notes:1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year). 2. Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report due to additional analysis. 3. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ('*'). Page 2 of 3 

## Pollutant: Standard Units: NAAQS Standard: Statistic: Sulfur dioxide(42401) Parts per billion(008) SO2 1-hour 2010 Annual 99th Percentile Level: Design Value Year: 2014 REPORT EXCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH REGIONALLY CONCURRED EVENT FLAGS. 75 State Name: Kentucky

Site ID COUNTY NAME | | | Comp. Qrtrs 99th Percentile Cert&

Eval |

| | Comp. Qrtrs 99th Percentile Cert&

Eval | | | Comp. Qrtrs 99th

Percentile Cert&

Eval |

| | Design Value Valid

Ind. |

| | 3-Year 2014 2013 2012
21-037-3002 Campbell 4 61 Y 4 71 Y 4 85 Y 72 Y

### UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AIR QUALITY SYSTEM PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT Report Date: Mar. 6, 2015

Notes:1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year). 2. Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report due to additional analysis. 3. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ('*'). Page 3 of 3 M N

S

U

X Y The monitoring organization has revised data from this monitor since the

most recent certification letter received from the state. The certifying agency has submitted the certification letter and required summary reports, but the certifying agency and/or EPA has determined that issues regarding the quality of the ambient concentration data cannot be resolved due to data completeness, the lack of performed quality assurance checks or the results of uncertainty statistics shown in the AMP255 report or the certification and quality assurance report. The certifying agency has submitted the certification letter and required summary reports. A value of "S" conveys no Regional assessment regarding data quality per se. This flag will remain until the Region provides an "N" or "Y" concurrence flag. Uncertified. The certifying agency did not submit a required certification letter and summary reports for this monitor even though the due date has passed, or the state's certification letter specifically did not apply the certification to this monitor. Certification is not required by 40 CFR 58.15 and no conditions apply to be the basis for assigning another flag value The certifying agency has submitted a certification letter, and EPA has no unresolved reservations about data quality (after reviewing the letter, the attached summary reports, the amount of quality assurance data submitted to AQS, the quality statistics, and the highest reported concentrations). MEANING CERTIFICATION EVALUATION AND CONCURRENCE FLAG MEANINGS
FLAG

# APPENDIX 

# B

# ����GY**.**

**OHIO**
**October 14,**  **2014**
**Mr. Bradley**  **M. Miller**  **Southwest Ohio**  **Air Quality**  **Agency 2SO**  **William Howard Taft**  **Drive Cincinnati,**  **Ohio 45219**  **RE: Duke**  **Energy Ohio, Inc.,**  **W.C. Beckjord Station** 

**Facility ID**  **No.: 1413100008**  **Emissions Units:**  **BOO 1,**  **8002, B003,**  **8004, BOOS,**  **and B006**  **Dear Mr.**  **Miller: Duke**  **Energy Ohio,**  **Inc. t 39 E. 4"**  **Street Cincinnati,**  **OH 45202** 

**This letter**  **is to**  **inform you**  **that, as**  **of October**  **1, 2014,**  **the six**  **coal-fired emissions**  **units at**  **W.C. Beckjord**  **Station (B001,**  **8002, 8003,**  **8004, BOOS,**  **and 8006)**  **are permanently**  **shut down**  **and removed**  **from service.**  **It is**  **the understanding**  **of Duke**  **Energy Ohio,**  **Inc. that**  **authorization to**  **operate the affected units has**  **ceased as**  **of October**  **1, 2014**  **and the**  **permittee shall**  **not be**  **required to**  **meet any**  **Title V**  **permit requirements applicable**  **to these**  **emissions units,**  **except for**  **any residual**  **requirements, such**  **as the**  **quarterly deviation**  **reports and**  **annual compliance certification**  **covering the**  **period during**  **which the**  **emissions units**  **last operated.**  **Please call**  **Andrew Roebel**  **at S l**  **3-287-23S6 if**  **you should**  **have any**  **questions regarding**  **this information.**  **Based on**  **information and**  **belief formed**  **after reasonable**  **inquiry, I**  **certify that**  **all factual**  **statements in**  **this transmittal**  **are true,**  **accurate and**  **complete to**  **the best**  **of my**  **knowledge. Very**  **truly yours,**  **Michael Sharp**  **GM III**  **- NonReg**  **Fossil Station** 

# APPENDIX 

# C

# S02 **Redesignation Request Emissions**  **Summary and**  **Projections Campbell,**  **KY- Clermont,**  **OH Introduction**  **In January**  **2015, the Kentucky Division**  **for Air**  **Quality collaborated**  **with the**  **Ohio Environmental**  **Protection Agency**  **(Ohio EPA)**  **to prepare**  **a redesignation**  **request for**  **the sulfur**  **dioxide (S02)**  **National Ambient**  **Air Quality**  **Standard (NAAQS).**  **This redesignation**  **request relates**  **to the**  **interstate area**  **of portions**  **of Campbell**  **County in**  **Kentucky and**  **Clennont County**  **in Ohio.**  **For Campbell**  **County, the**  **portion incudes**  **five Census**  **Tracts: 519.01,** **519.03, 529.00,**  **531.00, and**  **533.01. And**  **for Clermont**  **County, the**  **portion is Pierce**  **Township. Selection**  **of Years**  **In developing**  **this S02**  **redesignation request, the**  **initial step**  **was to**  **select the**  **years from**  **base year**  **to maintenance**  **year. After**  **discussions between**  **representatives from**  **the Kentucky**  **Division for**  **Air Quality**  **and the**  **Ohio EPA,**  **the appropriate**  **years were**  **selected. For**  **the base**  **year, 2011**  **was selected**  **to develop**  **a comprehensive**  **S02 emissions**  **inventory for**  **which projected**  **emissions could**  **be estimated**  **for several**  **future years.**  **For the**  **attainment year,**  **2014 was**  **selected since**  **it corresponds**  **to one**  **of the**  **years in**  **the design**  **value showing**  **attainment. These**  **design value**  **years are**  **2012, 2013,**  **and 2014.**  **The 2014**  **attainment year also**  **corresponds to**  **the year**  **where the**  **permanent and**  **enforceable improvement**  **in air**  **quality leading**  **to attaimnent**  **occurred due**  **to Clermont**  **County's Walter**  **C. Beckjord**  **facility permanently**  **ceasing operations.**  **Below is**  **a summary**  **of the**  **years chosen**  **for each**  **state.**

**YEARS FOR**  **S02 REDESIGN** **A TION**  **REQUEST- KENTUCKY**  **Al\'D O** **HI O**  **Year Year**  **Type Kentucky**  **Ohio 2011**  **Base Year**  **" "**  **2014 Attainment**  **Year "**  **" 2017**  **Interim Maintenance**  **Year "**  **2020 Interim**  **Maintenance Year**  **" 2022**  **' Interim**  **Maintenance Year**  **" 2027**  **Maintenance Year**  **" "**  **Therefore, the**  **years for**  **both states**  **used in**  **this redesignation**  **request are:**  **2011, 2014,**  **2017, 2020,**  **2022, and**  **2027 The**  **2011 National**  **Emissions Inventory**  **(NEI) was**  **used for**  **area and**  **non-highway mobile**  **source emissions.**  **Along with Census**  **and projected**  **Census data, additional**  **years of**  **2010 Census,**  **2020 Kentucky**  **Division for**  **Air Quality-**  **january 2015**  **Page 1**  **i**

**I** 

# i**Census, and**  **2030 Census**  **years are**  **also used**  **as part**  **of the**  **population and**  **growth rate** 

**calculations. Below**  **are detailed**  **explanations for**  **projections on**  **population growth**  **factors and**  **future year**  **S02 emissions**  **from point,**  **area, highway mobile,**  **and non-highway**  **mobile sources. The**  **Kentucky Division**  **for Air**  **Quality has provided**  **all emission**  **and projection**  **data for**  **both counties**  **in an**  **Excel spreadsheet.**  **Unless otherwise**  **noted, the**  **following narr** **ative applies**  **to both**  **Campbell County**  **in Kentucky**  **and Clermont County**  **in Ohio.**  **Population Growth**  **There are**  **a total**  **of five**  **growth rates**  **used for**  **projecting Future**  **Year S02**  **emissions. These**  **growth rates**  **can be**  **divided into**  **three groups**  **based on**  **the specific**  **calculation type.**  **1) There**  **is only**  **one growth rate**  **in the**  **first group:**  **the 2011-2014**  **growth rate.**  **This growth**  **rate, from**  **the base**  **year to**  **the attainment year,**  **was calculated**  **by simply**  **dividing the**  **2014 population by the**  **2011 population.**  **2) There**  **are two**  **growth rates**  **in the**  **second group:**  **the 2014-2017**  **growth rate**  **and the**  **2014-2020 growth**  **rate. Projected**  **from the**  **2014 attainment**  **year, or**  **Present Year,**  **these growth**  **rates were**  **projected out**  **towards and**  **including the**  **Future Year.**  **For this growth**  **rate group,**  **the Future**  **Year was**  **2020 as**  **it would**  **result in**  **more-accurate growth**  **rates. The**  **following formula**  **was used**  **in Excel**  **to calculate**  **these growth**  **rates. Growth**  **Factor= EXP(RATE(Y,-PY,FY))"n**  **Where Y =** **Total Years**  **between Present**  **and Future**  **Years**

**PY =Present**  **Year, in**  **this case,**  **2014 FY**  **= Future**  **Year, in**  **this case,**  **2020 n**  **=Number of**  **Years Out**  **From Present**  **Year Using**  **an example**  **for a**  **growth rate**  **out to**  **the year 2017,**  **the following**  **formula is**  **used.**

**2014-2017 Growth**  **Factor= EXP(RATE(6,-2014,2020))"3**  **where 6**  **represents the**  **total years**  **between 2014**  **(Present Year)**  **and 2020**  **(Future Year).**  **From 2014,**  **projecting 3**  **years (n)**  **out would represent 2017.**  **A similar formula**  **is also**  **applied to**  **calculate the**  **growth rate**  **for 2020.**  **3) The**  **final two**  **growth rates**  **are in**  **the third**  **group: the**  **2014-2022 growth**  **rate and**  **the 2014-2027**  **growth rate. Again,**  **projected from**  **the 2014 attainment**  **year, or**  **Present Year, these**  **growth rates**  **were projected**  **out towards and**  **including the**  **Future Year.**  **For this**  **growth rate**  **group, the**  **Future Year**  **was 2030**  **as it**  **would result**  **in more-accurate**  **growth rates. The 2030**  **year was**  **also used**  **since 2022**  **and 2027**  **falls outside**  **of the**  **range using**  **the Future**  **Year 2020 indicated**  **in the**  **second growth**  **rate group.**  **The following**  **formula was**  **used in**  **Excel to**  **calculate these growth**  **rates.** 

### Kentucky **Division for**  **Air Quality-**  **january 2015**  

### Page **2 Growth**  **Factor= EXP(RATE(Y,-PY,** **FY))"n Where**  **Y = Total**  **Years between**  **Present and**  **Future Years** 

**PY =**  **Present Year,** **in this**  **case, 2014**  **FY =** **Future Year,**  **in this**  **case, 2030**  **n =Number**  **of Years**  **Out From**  **Present Year**  **Using an**  **example for**  **a growth**  **rate out**  **to the**  **year 2022,** **the following**  **formula is**  **used.**

**2014-2022 Growth**  **Factor= EXP**  **(RATE(16,-2 014,** **2030))"8 where**  **16 represents**  **the total**  **years between**  **2014 (Present**  **Year) and**  **2030 (Future**  **Year). From**  **2014, projecting**  **8 years**  **(n) out**  **would represent**  **2022. A**  **similar formula**  **is also**  **applied to**  **calculate the**  **growth rate**  **for 2027.**  **Point Source**  **Emissions For**  **Campbell County,**  **Kentucky, point**  **source facilities**  **were first**  **identified within the**  **five Census**  **Tracts. There were**  **a total**  **of 11**  **facilities located**  **within these**  **Census Tract**  **boundaries. After**  **the facility**  **locations were**  **found, the**  **2011 base**  **year emissions**  **from those**  **point sources**  **were obtained**  **from the**  **Kentucky Emissions Inventory database.**  **Finally, point**  **source emissions were**  **projected for**  **the years**  **2014 attainment**  **year, 2017,2020,**  **2022, and**  **2027. Growth**  **rates for**  **these projected**  **years were**  **used as**  **described in**  **the section**  **titled, "Population**  **Growth." For**  **Pierce Township**  **in Clermont**  **County, Ohio,**  **the only**  **point source**  **facility is**  **Walter C.**  **Beckjord Station.**  **However, in**  **a letter**  **from Duke**  **Energy Ohio,**  **Inc. to**  **the Southwest**  **Ohio Air**  **Quality Agency that**  **is .dated**  **October 14,**  **2014, the**  **six coal-fired**  **emissions units**  **(BOO!, B002,**  **B003, B004,**  **BOOS, and**  **B006) "are**  **permanently shut down and**  **removed from**  **service." The**  **letter continues**  **to indicate**  **"that authorization**  **to operate**  **the affected**  **units has**  **ceased as**  **of October**  **1, 2014."**  **According to**  **Ms. Jennifer**  **Van Vlerah**  **(Ohio EPA),**  **the facility**  **actually ceased**  **operation on**  **September 1,**  **2014. Therefore,**  **this facility**  **only operated**  **for the first**  **eight months**  **of 2014.**  **Area Source**  **Emissions The**  **2011 NEI,** **the most-recent**  **NEI, was**  **used to**  **obtain 2011**  **base year**  **area source**  **emissions for**  **both Campbell**  **County, Kentucky and**  **Clermont County,**  **Ohio. These**  **emissions represent the entire**  **counties. The appropriate**  **population percentages**  **were applied**  **to each**  **county (29.0%**  **for Campbell**  **County, 7.3%**  **for Clermont**  **County). By applying**  **these percentages**  **to the**  **county emissions**  **for area**  **sources, the**  **five Census**  **Tracts and**  **Pierce Town** **ship are**  **now represented.**  **With the**  **2011 base**  **year area source**  **emissions now**  **established for**  **the county**  **port ions,**  **those emissions**  **were multiplied**  **by the**  **2011-2014 growth**  **rate to**  **obtain the**  **2014 emissions.**  **The 2014**  

### Kentucky **Division for**  

### Air **Quality- january**  **2015** 

### Page **3 attainment**  **year emissions**  **were then**  **projected for 2017,**  **2020, 2022,**  **and 2027**  **by using**  **the**

**growth rates**  **explained in**  **the section**  **titled, "Population**  **Growth." Highway**  **Mobile Source**  **Emissions The**  **Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional**  **Council of**  **Governments, or**  **OKI, provided**  **the highway**  **mobile source**  **emissions for**  **2011 base year, 2014 attainment**  **year, 2017,**  **2020, 2022,**  **and 2027.**  **The emissions**  **for the**  **specific county**  **portions were**  **not calculated**  **based on**  **population percentages.**  **Rather, the**  **emissions were**  **more accurately**  **reflected by**  **dividing the**  **vehicle miles**  **traveled in**  **the portion**  **by the vehicle**  **miles traveled**  **in the**  **entire county.**  **Non-Highway Mobile**  **Source Emissions**  **Just like**  **area source**  **emissions, the**  **2011 NEI**  **was used**  **to obtain**  **2011 base**  **year non-highway**  **mobile source**  **emissions for**  **both Campbell County,**  **Kentucky and**  **Clermont County,**  **Ohio. These**  **emissions represent**  **the entire counties.**  **The appropriate population**  **percentages were**  **applied to**  **each county**  **(29.0% for**  **Campbell County,**  **7.3% for**  **Clem1ont County). By**  **applying these**  **percentages to**  **the county**  **emissions for**  **non-highway mobile source sources,**  **the five Census**  **Tracts and**  **Pierce Township**  **are now**  **represented. With**  **the 2011**  **base year**  **non-highway mobile**  **source emissions**  **now established**  **for the**  **county portions,**  **those emissions**  **were multiplied**  **by the**  **2011-2014 growth rate**  **to obtain**  **the 2014**  **emissions. The 2014**  **attainment year**  **emissions were**  **then projected**  **for 2017, 2020, 2022, and**  **2027 by**  **using the**  **growth rates**  **explained in**  **the section**  **titled, "Population**  **Growth." Summary**  **of Emissions**  **As indicated**  **in the**  **Excel worksheet**  **titled, "Total**  **Emissions Summary,"**  **there is**  **a very**  **significant reduction**  **in S02**  **emissions for the**  **subject portions**  **in Campbell**  **County, Kentucky**  **and Clermont**  **County, Ohio.**



### Kentucky **Division for**  

### Air **Quality- january**  **2015** 

### Page4

# REDESIGNATION **REQUEST: POPULATION**  **AND GROWTH**  **DATA**

**Count y** **: Census**  **Tract** 

## 519.01

**-- --**  **---·** 

## 519.03 **529.00**

**--�- -----**  

## 531.00 **533.01 Tracts"** 

# f **Popui<J_tion Projections**  **2015:205(J,_Census Data**  **for 2Q10,**  **2020 ._<ll1d**  **2Q30�To�opulation"._Kentucky �ate**  **Data Cente_r,__**  **htt/):/lksdclouisvil/e.edu/index.php/kentuc�l':demoqraphic-data/orojections** 

## Population **Estimatl!s for**  **201l_a_nd 2012,**  **"l"_otal Populatiof]_i2_q_13)"._Kentucky�ta�ata**  **C:: E'nter,_**  **ht tp://k**  **sdclouisville.edu/fndex.pho/keiJtUcky-demographic-data/estimates/oopulation-and-housinq-units** 

## ) **2010 Census**  **Tract and**  **Bloc_k Dat** **a...:=_ Campbell**  **County, Kentucky**  **Sta_tl! Data**  **Center, _**  **ht tp://ks** **dc.louisville.edu/index.pho/kentuckv_:demographic-data/decennial-census** 

## _!::mail **frorrr_Jennifer VanVIerah,_ghio**  **EPA, P** **� ulati** **()ll__� ata**  **f(Jr:_Pier�To wnshi** **p_i n**  **Clermo _rrt**  **County, Ohio_**  **December 8,**  **2014.** ***** 

## Indicates **that countv-wide**  **growth factors**  **were a**  **due to**  **limited access**  **to <nPrifir**  **Joe Fargacs**  **- Kentucky**  **Division for**  **Air Quality**  

## data. **redesignation request**  **includes five**  **Census Tracts**  **in Campbell**  **County,KY (519.01,**  **519.03, 529.00,**  **531.00, and**  **533.01) and**  **Pierce Township**  **in Clermont**  **County, OH.**  

### --January **2015**

# POINT **SO URCE**  **EMISSIONS**

# l�>oLWTI\Il!tlsl:.**j, _-**  **· ·-•--** **;**

# �P�**/ .** **...**

## ;D,/,· 

# j **---=--**

**. ..** **.**

## AJ{�I\: **.>-·· ·**  **..•.**

## :**.. c�ml!-b¥!JI"CIIlttill>ot,(;9.!1fif;es,.Kt�oH.!f>9l:l:,w** **.. ,**  **..**



# l**�ischer Special_fV]anufacturi�Co** 

**----- ---** **�--�--- - -**  **------- -** **-- - ---** 

# 1-.- **-··.** 

## Griffin **Industries Inc** 

**-- --**  **.•.**

## .,._.. **KY Partners_II**  **LP�ighland_Heights**

**____ _ _**  

# 1

**. .** 

**_ .** 

**_ ·-·o·**  

## . **. .**  **..** 

## Partners **II LP**  **·Alexandria**

**-------- ---···-�-- -----·�- -- --**  **--- -**  **- IIPdmn**  

## Wireless_:_�old5_ **ring_ l_l**  **__ 0.00**  **0.00 0.65** 



## The **area for**  **this 502**  

## redesignation **request includes five**  **Census Tracts in**  **Campbell County, KY**  **(519.01, 519.03,**  **529.00, 531.00,**  

## and **533.01)** 

## and **Pierce Township**  **in Clermont**  **County, OH. 2011**  

## baseyear point **source emissions**  **were determined**  **based on**  **location within**  **these specific**  **localized areas in**  **each county.**  **For Campbell**  **County, 2011**  

## point **source emissions**  **were obtained**  **through the**  **Kentucky Emissions**  **Inventory database.**  **Growth rates**  **in the**  **"Pop Growth"**  **worksheet, shaded**  **in gray,**  **were then**  **applied to**  **the Future**  **Year emissions**  **for 2014**  

## (attainment **year), 2017,** **2020, 2022,** 

## and **2027.** 

## The **Walter C.**  **Beckjord facility**  **in Clermont**  **County permanently**  **closed during**  **2014. 17,**  **2014** 

### Joe **Forgoes -**  **Kentucky Division** **for Air**  **Quality --**  **January 2015** 

# AREA **SO URCE**  **EMISSIONS I'O�L4T�J\It(S):**  **. S02** **ME.A:** 

## .J:a.m **t:i�eJl,cl�ttnt!�tc(i�.ntl.�s; .** **J<Y',oi-! .** **. (Portionsl** 
**.**

# . **. ·** **· ·** **· ··** 

**-·---- ----**  **--· ---------**  **-··** 

## ENTIRE **! PORTION**  **PORTION**

**----------·** 

## Base **Year Base**  **Year Attainment**  **PORTION Projected**  **2017** 

## PORTION

**�rejected 2020**  

## PORTION

**Projected 2022**  

## t**p y**  **- ·**  

## PORTIC>I'I_ **I**

**Projected COUNTY**  **Cam p**  **bell, KY** 



# � **- - --**  

# -**--- --------**  **- -**  

## Clermont, **OH AREAfOtAl**  

# :::::zou **�**

**t p** **y 20.77**  **103.06** 

# 123Jti **__f'_o p** **ulatior:_**

**% 29.0%**  **7.3% 2011** 



## tp**y 6.03**  

# -�-

**--- ----r- -**  **-**

**2014** 

## t**p y**  **6.04**

**- -**  **---** 

### 7.63 

# 1�.61 **'**



## t**p y**  **6.06** 

# j**- -I**  **tp y**  **6.08 7.88**  

## 13.!:15 

# _j **6.03**

**7.86** 

## 13.89

**.__ -·**  **---� ---**  **2027** 

## t**p y**  **6.02 8.00** 

## '14.02

**--**

**- --�**  

# 1 **+ ---**  **-** 

# t
**- -**

**-·---- --** **---- --�**  **- - -** 



# - -**1**

**-**

**- -=1** **:::: _**  **-·· -**  

# -+

**- +-** **-**

**- -**  **- -** **­** 

# j_
**_**

**-**

# -**--** 

# -j-
**- -** 

# 1' **-----·-- --** 

**- -**

# - **_** 

## _l **_ !_**  

# +

**- ,-**  

## i **- -**  

# -=� **-**

**- -�-** **-**



# =**- -** **J� I**  **·­**



# j---
**- --**  **-- -** **- -i** 

**-- · ·**  **- -,** 



# - **-** 

# ! 

# 1

**- ·--** 



# - **-i**

**···-·**



# - **j**

  ** The** **area for**  **this** 

## 502 **redesignation request**  **includes five**  **Census Tracts**  **in Campbell**  **County, KY**  **(519.01, 519.03,** **529.00, 531.00,**  **and 533.01)**  **and Pierce**  **Township in**  **Clermont County,** **OH. 2011**  **baseyear area**  **source emissions**  **were obtained**  **from the**  **National Emissions**  **Inventory (U.S.**  **EPA). Growth**  **rates in**  **the "Pop**  **Growth" worksheet,**  **shaded in**  **gray, were**  **then applied**  **to project**  **the Future**  **Year** 

## 502 **emissions for**  **2014 (attainment**  **year), 2017,**  **2020, 2022,**  **and 2027.**  **County portions**  **were applied**  **by multiplying**  **the 2011**  **emissions for**  **the entire**  **county by**  **the Population**  **%. Emissions**  **from the**  **portions were**  **then be**  **projected out**  **to Future**  **Years. Data**  **Source :**  **National Emissions**  **Inventory (2011},**  **U.S. EPA**  

# -- **1**

**-**
**Joe Forgoes**  **- Kentucky**  **Division for**  **Air Quality**  **-- January**  **2015**

# HIGHWAY **MOB ilE**  **SO URCE**  **EMISSIONS** 

# PQ����.(\1\1�($); **'**

# --**[�--�/ I**  

# $g� **/**

# J **· ...** 

## AR.E.A: 

# . **·** 

# ·- 7T **�am�l!f#lb!:l�tm!lotea,uJ:ItJf#s,RY,o!:l !�§�:tloiliiL**



# . - _j_. **PORTION**

**�- ·** **- ·�**  

## Base **Year PORTION** 

**- -**  **�- -**  

## Attainment 

# r **PORTION**

# � **PORTION PORTION**  **Projected PORTION** 

**Projected Pr** 

# ��i; **ed__**

# j **___**



## _J>

# r�jJ��e **d**

**- �** 
**- �** **- ---**  **- -**  **··· ----** **- -** **- -�** **- -**  **- -** **- 2011** 

**- - -**  **�----** 

## COUNTY **t p** **y Cam** **p bell,**  **KY 1.547**  **2014** 

## t**p y**  **t p** **y** 

# I **t p** **y 2022**  **2027 ._**  **____ __** **_ -+** 

## -

**·· -**  **· ·**  **- -**  

## t**p y**  **t p** **y 1.260**  

## ___ **,.**

**____ _ ··--**  **�-** 

### 1.506 **0.331** 

# ��i�

**-** 

# 1-- **�:��� 1.368**  **0.300 ···** **-**

## t--
**- -** **- --** **- -** **--- -** **- - -**  **- --** **- -** **- -**  **----�-- -**  **·** 

## Clermont, **OH 0.340**  **0.277**

# t!WV**MO.BILI! 1.881**  

# I **·** 

## 1.8!11 

# 1.7!J7 **I I** **uoz 1.668** 

# 1.§!!7

**1**

**-** 

# i

**· ·** 

# -r=- **.**



# -±- **- - ,**  

# +

**- -**  **- -** 

**- -** **-- �**  **- ----**  **- --**  

## I -

**- '** 

**- -** **- -** 



## --- --**-**



## -- **-�+ i** 



# ---**-- -**  **-+--____: -_** 

**_ -----** 

**- -**  **- -** **- -**  **· ·**  **- -**  **· ·**  **_l_**

**_**

**- --** **- -**  **- �** **- -** **- -** 

**-**

## - **- --** **-**

**--- -** **- -** **-** 

# --1---

**·--- --�**

**'**

# � **---- ··-**  **.**
**� - -**  **· ·** 

# j-

**· --** **- ---- -** 

# - **- - -- -** 

**-**

**----- --** **� ----**  **-- -**  **-- -** **- -** **- -**  **- -** **- ---**  **- -**  **- ·**  **· ,**  **- - -**  **- -** 



# ±
**The area**  **for this**  **502 redesignation**  **request includes**  **five Census**  **Tracts in**  **Campbell County,**  **KY (519.01,**  **519.03, 529.00,**  **531.00, and**  **533.01) and**  **Pierce Township**  **in Clermont**  **County, OH.**  **Andy Reser**  **from the**  **Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional**  **Council of**  **Governments, or**  **OKI, provided**  **the highway**  **mobile source emissions**  **for 2011**  **baseyear, 2014**  **(attainment year),**  **2017, 2020,**  **2022, and**  **2027. The**  **emissions for the**  **specific portions of**  **each county**  **were not**  **calculated based**  **on population**  **percentages. Instead,**  **the emissions**  **were more**  **accurately reflected**  **by dividing**  **the vehicle**  **miles traveled**  **in the**  **portion by**  **the vehicle**  **miles traveled**  **in the**  **entire county.** 

**---· -**  **-**

**- -**  **---- --** **- -** **- -** **-- -**  **-- --**  **__ ,,** 

# _**_ Data**  **Source: Ohio-Kentucky--Indiana {OK/)**  **Regional Council**  **of Governments**  

# l-- **1 Joe**  **Forgoes --**  **Kentucky Division** **for Air**  **Quality -** **-- -** **--**

# --**---**

**-- --** **-- -** **- --** 

**--- January**  **2015**

# NON-HIGHWAY **MO BilE**  **SO URCE**  **EMISSIONS**

**I PQ��IJI�** **III II�lL.** 

# f**.Jtii ...** 

# .**J I**  **.** 

# �ll�At. ...•.

# Jt�nj[ll�lf.:�t�rffiqnf�q.Un�i�#IRXt!:iflli>q"*tqHsl., **-•·**


## I **�** 

## COUNTY 

# --- **'** 

# . **ENTIRE ,**  **Base -** **Year** 

# · **1 ,** **- -**  **2011** 

## Po**p ulation** 



# -**� ·** 
**- -**  

# - 

# ' **•.. " '''�'" __ _**  

## t**p y**  **%** 

## PORTION **Base Year**  **2011** 

## PORTION

**Attainment 2014**  

## t**p y**  

# I **t p** **y -** 

# -**- j**  **·--** 

## PORTION **�rejected _**  **2017** 

## PORTION

**Projected**

**- t**  **2020** 

## 1 **_P ()RTION** 

**Projected 2022**  

## t**p y**  

# I **t p** **y --**  **----t t** **p y**  **PORTION**

**- -** 

# - **- -**  

# -**- -** **- Projecte**  **_!l__ l**  **2027** 

## t**p y**  **Cam p** **bell, KY_** 

**-- �**  

## 0.68 **29.0%**

**------- -�----**  

## 0.20 

# + **___** 

## 0.20

**__** 

# �:�� -� **-Ki� 0;20**  **().20 I**  **Clermont, OH**  

# I **2.40**

# NON•HWVtotAll **3.08** 

# +- 

# r**1 1**  **_**

**--**

# -**- 7.3%**  **0.17 0.18** 

# r·**M1**

# , **•**

# o.31**•**

**_ _**  **!** 

# -1-- 

# -=j **.**

**- j**

**-----**

**-**

# 1 

# --� **-l !**  

## - **---;---**



# -**--** 

# --t

**------ 1-** 

**,_______ ----- ----**  **---**



# -**- -** 

# - **j_**

**_**



## I **(),38**

# /;**>J ---**  

## . 0.38

**- -** **·-** 

# l= **0.18 I**  

## 0.19



# o.�:tr-.-- **-r**

**o.as**



# -**j'**

**-**

**- -**  

# 1

**- -**  **1**



# --

# -

**1-------** 

# ---�··---

**---· The**  **area for**  **this** 

## S02 **redesignation request**  **includes five**  **Census Tracts**  **in Campbell**  **County, KY**  

## (519.01,**519.03, 529.00,** **531.00, and**  

## 533.01) **and Pierce**  **Township in**  **Clermont County, OH.**  

# I

**- ··** **-·-- 2011**  **baseyear non-highway**  **source emissions**  **were obtained**  **from the**  **National Emissions**  **Inventory** 

## (U.S. **EPA**

## ) **. Growth**  **rates in**  **the "Pop**  **Growth"**

**worksheet, shaded**  **in gray,**  **were then**  **applied to**  **project the**  **Future Year**  

## S02 **emissions for**  

## 2014 **(attainment year),**  

## 2017, **2020, 2022,** **and** 

## 2027. **County portions**  **were applied**  **by multiplying**  **the** 

## 2011 **emissions for**  **the entire**  **county by**  **the Population**  

## %. **Emissions from**  **the portions**  **were then**  

## 1-
**-­** 

### be **projected out**  **to Future**  **Years.**



## - **----- ---**  

# -**-····- Data**  **Source: National**  **Emissions Inventory (2011),**  **U.S. EPA**  **Joe Forgoes**  **- Kentucky**  **Division for**  **Air Quality**  **--January 2015** 

# T O **T A L**  **EMISSIONS**

**PORTION PORTION**  **PORTION**

**-··· ··-··**  **,-�----·-·· ··-** **-�** 

## Base **Year Attainment**  **Projected**

**-· --------**  **·-�····--- ·�**  **--��- 2011**  **2014 2017** 

**------ ··----**  **------ -**  **·--- ---** 

# S U **MMA RY**  

# _-'_0•**i o** **0 N**  **.**

# . **�- POR!I()N**  **Projected Projected** 

**----- ----�----**  **___ _, __**  **___ ---**  **- -------**  **- - -**  **2020 2022** 

**---- ------ -·---**  **----·-·· ·-·····**  

## t**p y** 

**The area**  **for this**  

## S02 **redesignation request**  **includes five**  **Census Tracts**  **in Campbell**  **County, KY**  **(519.01, 519.03,** **529.00, 531.00,**  **and 533.01)**  **and Pierce Township**  **in Clermont**  **County, OH.**  **2011 baseyear**  **emissions were**  **obtained from**  **a variety**  **of sources.**  **Point source**  **emissions were**  **obtained from**  **state emissions**  **inventory databases.**  **2011 baseyear area and non-highway**  **mobile source**  **emissions were**  **obtained from**  **the National**  **Emissions Inventory**  

## (U.S. **EPA). All**  **highway mobile**  **source emissions**  **were obtained**  **from the**  **Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional**  **Council of**  **Governments, or**  **OKI, in**  **Cincinnati, Ohio.**  **Growth rates**  **in the**  **"Pop Growth"**  **worksheet, shaded**  **in gray, were then**  **applied to**  **project the**  **Future Year**  

## S02 **emissions for**  **2014 (attainment**  **year), 2017,**  **2020, 2022,** **and 2027.**  **Where applicable**  **(area and**  **non-highway), county**  **portions were**  **applied by**  **multiplying the**  **2011 baseyear**  **emissions for**  **the entire**  **county by**  **the Population**  **%. Emissions**  **from the**  **portions were**  **then be**  **projected out**  **to Future**  **Years. Joe**  **Forgoes -**  **Kentucky Division** **for Air**  **Quality --January**  **2015**