.'.:1234567C)91011t213t415I6T71BI9,^2L22¿524atrTSTATEOFNBWYORKDEPARTMENTOFENVIRONMENTALCONSERVAT]ONPublicHearingregarding:PROPOSEDAIRQUALITYREGULAT]ONSLocation:StateofNewYorkDeparLmentofEnvironmental-ConservationRegionalOffice6214EastAvon-LímaRoadAvon,NewYork744L4Date:JanuaryL9,2012Time:2:00p.mReportedBVMolIyPricolaAllianceCourtRePorting,Tnc.183MainStreetEast,Suite1500Rochester,NewYorkI4604ALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,INC.VideoConferencìngøndYideogrøphyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.net585.s46.4920800.724.08361234561B91011I213I415I6L71BT9)(\2I222324ôtrLJ2APPEARANCESAppearingasHearingOfficerThomasL.Marriott,P.E.NewYorkStateDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation6274East.Avon-LímaRoadAvon,NewYork144L4tl-marrioGgw.dec.state.nY.usAppearingonBehal-fofNewYorkStateDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation:DanielE.WaJ-sh,P.E.NewYorkStateDepartmentofEnvironmental6214EastAvon-LimaRoadAvon,NewYorkI4414dewalshGgw.dec.state.nY.usAlsoPresentDavidVanHerreweghePamHelmingJosephFiegI*Conservation*ALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,INC.VideoConfereneìngøndVÍdeogrøphyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.net585.546.4920800.724.08361234567I9101-1L213I4ítr-LJL6711BI9ZU2T2223243NYSDECPUBLICHEARTNGPROPOSEDATRQUALITYREGULATIONSTHURSDAY,JANUARYI9,2O12;.(Proceedingsintheabove-titl-edmattercommencingat2:05P.m.)**MR.MARRIOTT:I'l-fcal-1thehearinqtoordernow.ft'sJanuary79,200'1.ft's2:03p'm.Thisisanadminístrativepublichearingwit.halegislativeformatbeforetheNewYorkStateDepartmentofEnvironmental-Conservationinthematterofpart2Ig-9andPart248ofTitte60ftheofficialcompilationofcodes,RulesandRegulationstothest.ateofNewYorkandtheLeadNationalAmbientAirQual-ityInfrastructureAssessmentthatmustbesubmittedtoUSEPA.Thepurposeofthishearingistoreceivepubliccommentont.heproposedregul-ationsandthel-eadassessment.famThomasMarriottandf'mservingasthehearingofficerforthedepartment.Thereareatotal-oftwohearingsessionsfortheseproposal-s.Thisisthesecondandl-asthearingofthetwoscheduled.Iwil-l-nowcallonDaniel-WalshofDivisionofAirResources,RêgionB,tomakeaALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,INC.VídeoConferencingønilYìdeogrøphyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.netthebrief585.s46.4920800.724.08361234561B91011t213I415I61aII1B7920272324z54NYSDECPUBLICHEAR]NGPROPOSEDATRQUAL]TYREGULAT]ONSdepartmentstatement.MR.VTIALSH:Okay.Goodafternoon'everyone.MR.MARRIOTT:Youdon'thaveto--offtherecord.(Therewasadiscussj-onofftherecord.)MR.MARRIOTT:Backontherecord.MR.WALSH:Goodafternoon,everyone.IamDanietVrlalsh,Envj-ronmentafEngineerIIintheDivisionofAirResources,NewYorkStateDepartmentofEnvironmental-Conservation'sRegionBoffice.Thispublichearingisoneofthreescheduledforthepurposeofreceivingstatementsandcommentsonthethreeseparatedepartment'sproposals.First,itwill-amendPart200,GeneralProvisions,oftheairregulations'amendanexistingairregulationgoverningincineralors,addne\,vapplicabilityrequiremenLsandaddanewSubpart21'g-gforsewagesludgeincinerationunits.Theseamendmentswí11incorporate,byreference'therequirementsofFederalRufe40CFR60,PartMMMMthat'sfourMsandaddspecificschedulerequirementsforfacilitiestocomeintocompliancewiththenewregul-ation.ALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,INC.VideoConferencingnndVídeographyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.net585.546.4920800.724.083612?J4561oU91011L213I415I6711B19202T))23z425585.546.4920800.724.0836ÃNYSDECPUBL]CHEARINGPROPOSEDA]RQUAL]TYREGULATIONSThisregul-ationwouldapptystatewidetoexistingseI¡Iage'sludgeandincinerationunitsconstructedonoraboutoctoberI4,20I0.Itwouldestabl-ishmandatoryl-imitsfornineairpollutantsincl-udingparticul-atematter,suffurdioxide,hydrogenchl-orj-de,nitrogenoxides,carbonmonoxide,lead,cadmium,mercuryanddioxins/furans.Theproposedrulewoul-dafsoestabl-íshanopacitylimitaswelfasspecificrequirementsforinitialandannualperformancetestitg,operatortrainingrïecordkeepingandreportíng,andcompliancemonitoring.Anyonewhowishestoobtaininformationorsubmitcommentsrel-atedtothePart2I9-9proposedactionsmaycontactJohnHenkesatNYSDEC/DivisionofAirResources,625Broadway,Albany,NewYork12233-3254;telephone/areacode518-402-8403;e-mail,2IgincinGgw.dec.state.ny.us.Orvisitthedepartment'swebsiteatI^Iww.dec.ny.9ov/requlations/propregulationsthat'sP-R-O-P-R-E-G-U-L-A-T-T-ON-S.html.Second,thedepartmentisproposingtorevise6NYCRRPart248,UseofUl-traLowSulfurDieselFuel-andBestAvailableRetrofitTechnofogyforALLIANTCECOURTREPORTING,INC.VideoConferencingøndVideogrøphyCenterwww,alliancecourtreporting.net1234561B9101172137415I6I11BI9202722,/<.ALA256NYSDECPUBLICHEARINGPROPOSEDAIRQUAL]TYREGULATIONSHeavyDutyvehicles,byamendingdefinitionsandtheeslabl-íshedcompliancescheduleandbyaddingausefullifewaiverprovision.TheproposedchangesareattributabletorecentcourtdecisionsintheNewYorkStateLegisfatureamendingNewYorkEnvironmentalconservatíonLaw,ECL,paragraph19-0323.NYSDEChasthestatutoryauthorítytoamendtheexistingregulatíonpursuanttoECL.TheseamendmentswiltcontinuetoimplementtheDieselEmissionReductionActof2006andconformPart248totherecentECLSection79-0323changes.Inaddition,Tecentcourtdecisionsrequirethedepartmenttoreviseportionsoflheregulation.It.wil-1alsocontinuetogenerallymitíqateapotentialthreattothehealthandwell-beingofNewYorkersposedbydieselexhauslemissionsandprovideemíssionsreduct.íons,therebymeetingtegislativeobjectives.Specificatly,Part248wouldbeamendedbychangingseveraldefinitions,including"contractoI',""primecontractor,""onbehalfof"and"regul-atedentítywork."AsaresulL,therequirementsoftheDiesel-Emissi-onReductionActof2006andPart248ALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,INC.VìdeoConferencingønilVideogrøphyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.net585.546.4920800.724.08361234567oU91-011I213I41516I]1BI9202I2224251NYSDECPUBLICHEAR]NGwillnotbeaPPlicabl-estateagencYwork.PROPOSEDA]RQUALITYREGULAT]ONStosubcontracLorsservicingPart248wouldchangetheexistingcompliancescheduletoal-Iowallvehj-cl-escoveredbythisregul-ationtohavebestavaítabferetrofíttechnofogyonorafterDecember31st,2012'Itwouldal-sodelete33percentand66percentbestavaílableretrofittechnofogyphase-incompliancedeadfines.Finatly,Part248wouldaddauseful-lifewaiverprovision,whichaIlowsthedepartmenttoissueawaiveroftherequirementsofthisparttoabest.avail-abteretrofittechnofogyregul-atedentityorcontracLoruponreceipt.ofrequestfromsuchentityorcontractor,providedthatsuchvehiclewíIlbepermanentJ-ytakenoutofserviceinNewYorkstateonorbeforeDecember31st,2013-AnyonewhowishestoobtaininformationorsubmitwrittencommentsrelatedtotheseproposedactionsmaycontactJimBolognaatNYSDEC,DivisionofAirResources,625Broadway'Al-bârry,NewYork12233-3255;telephone/areacode518-402-8292;e-mail,24BDERAGgw.dec.state.ny.us.orvisitthedepartment'swebsiteatww\,ü.dec.ny.gov/regulations/propregulationsthatrsP-R-O-P-R-E-G-U-L-A-T-I-O-N-S--'html'ALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,INC,VideoConferencíngønilVideographyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.net585.546.4920800.724.08361234561B91011T213I415L6711BI92021z52425ONYSDECPUBLICHEARTNGPROPOSEDA]RQUAL]TYREGULATIONSThedepartmentwiltprovideawritlenresponsetocommentsreceivedatthesehearings'AnyonewhowishestoobtaininformationorsubmitcommentsrelatedtothePart248[sic]proposedactionsmaycontactJohnHenkesatNYSDEC,DivisionofAirResources,625Broadway,Al-bâûY,NewYorkI2233-3254;telephone,areacode51-B-402-8403;e-mai1,2:.9incínGgw.dec.state.ny.us.Orvisitthedepartment'swebsiteatw\ivw.dec.ny.gov/regulations/propregulationsthat'sP-R-O-P-R-E-G-U=L-A-T-T-ON-S.html.Third,thedepartmentisaccePt.ingcommenLsontheLeadNationalAmbientQualityInfrastructureAssessmentOnOctober15,2008,theUnitedStatesEnvironmental-ProtectionAgencyfinalizedne\^//morestringentNationalAmbientAirQuaJ-ityStandardsforl-ead.TheCleanAirActunderSection110(a)(1)requiresstatestosubmitaplanorinfrastructureassessmentwithinthreeyearsaftertherevisionofaNationalAmbientAirQualityStandarddemonstratingtheyhavethebasicaj-rqualj-tymanaqementprogramcomponentsinpJ-acetoprovideforimplementation,maint.enanceandenforcementofsuchstandardsint.heALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,INC,VideoConferencingøndVìdeogrøphyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.net585.546.4920800.724.08361234561B91011T2137415T6T110t92021222324259NYSDECPUBL]CHEAR]NGPROPOSEDAIRQUALITYREGULAT]ONSstate.cl_eanAirActsection110(a)(2)l-iststhespecificelementstobeaddressedintheinfrastructureassessmenL.OnOctober1.3,20II,thedeParLmentsubmitteditsinfrastructureassessmentforthe2008LeadNationalAmbientAirQualitystandardstoEnvironmentalProtectionAgency.Thisdocument,whichaffirmedthatthestate'sairprogramhasthecapabilityandauthorit.ytoimplement,ffiâintainandenforcetheNational-AmbíentAirQual-itystandards,vvassubmittedasarevisiontotheNewYorkstateImplementationPl-an(SIP)-AcopyoftheinfrastructureassessmentcanbeobtainedbycontactingscottGriffinat518-402-8396.CommentsonthisproposalmaybesubmittedbycontactingMr.GriffinoIbye-mailingthemtoairsipsGgw.dec.state'ny.us.Thedepartmentwill-provideawrittenrespon,setocommentsreceivedatthesehearíngs.Thedepartmentísacceptingcommentsonthesethreeproposal-sthrough5p.m.,January26,20L2'That'stheendofthisstatement.MR.MARRIOTT:ThankYou.Currently,thereisnooneínattendanceALLIANICECOURTREPORTING,INC.VídeoConferencìnganilVìdeogrøphyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting.netsgs.546.4920800.724.0836123456lÕ9101112137415I6I11BL9202Tzz23242510NYSDECPUBLTCHEARINGPROPOSEDA]RQUALITYRBGULAT]ONSat.thístimewhowishestosubmitcomments.Correct?Okay.Vle'11temporarilyclosetherecordandwaittenmj-nutesforanyonetoattendwhowishestospeak.Iftherearenoattendeesatthattime,Iwil-l-cfosethehearingrecord.(Theproceedingrecessedat2zIBp.m.)(Theproceedingreconvenedat2:31-p.m.;appearancesasbeforenoted.)MR.MARRIOTT:Thetimenol/vis2:3Ip.m.andthere'snofurtheratLendeesthatwishtospeakatlhishearing.Assuch,I'mclosingthehearingrecord.(TIME:2:32p.m.)***ALLIANCECOURTREPORTING,iNC.VìdeoConferencingnntlVídeographyCenterwww.alliancecourtreporting,nets85.546.4920800.724.0836al1aL34561B910117213L41576!11B2!a223242511CERT]FICATTONSTATEOFNEVüYORK:COUNTYOFMONROE:I,MOLLYPRICOLA,beingaFreelanceCourtReporterandNotaryPubl-icinandforMonroecounty,NewYork,doherebycertifythatIreportedinmachineshorthandtheforegoingpagesoftheabove-styledcause,andthattheywerepreparedbycomputer-assistedtranscriptJ-onundermypersonalsupervisionandconstituteatrueandaccuraterecordoftheproceedíngs.IfurthercertifYthatIamnotanattorneyorcounselofanyparties,norarefativeoremployeeofanyattorneyorcounselconnectedwiththeaction,norfinanciallyinterestedintheaction.WITNESSmyhandintheCityofRochester,CountyofMonroe,StateofNewYork'MOLLYPRCOLAFreelanceCourtRePorterandNotaryPublicNo.01PR6210086forMonroeCountY,NewYorkALLIANCh,inandCOURTREPORTING,INC.VìdeoConferencíngandVìdeogruph¡tÇsn¡¿¡.www.alliancecourtreporting.net585.546.4920'800.724.0836