01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDDN Joseph R. Maridon, Jr. Respondent's Counsel 6130 Elton Ave Las Vegas, NV 89107 Tel. 702-514-0102 Fax 702-410-6396 Ju the Matter of: U.S DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION FEDERAL AVIATION ADMJNISTRATION Joseph R. Maridon, St·. FAA DOCKET NO. 2014-0116 Respon<lent Judge Richard C. Goodwin PAGE 01/24

RESPONDENT'S SECOND MOTION TO DISMISS FOR VIOLATION OF RESPONDENTS RJGHTS UNDER THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION 

### (ERRATTA- WITH EXHIBITS) Respondent files this second motion to dismiss for violation ofhis rights under the First Amendmentto the **U~uted** States Constin1tion based onthe FAA's construction and application of CPR §91.11 to the facts ofthe instant case. This motion is made and based on all ofthe pleadings and papers onfile herein, the United States Constitution and the argtUllent ofCotmsel. Respondent further renews, realleges and incorporates herein by reference Respondents previous motion to dismiss. Summary ofArgument The Noen-Pennington doctrine prohibits the use ofthe CFR §91.11 in the instant case as consuued and applied, because 

### it denies the Respondent his First Amendment rights offreedom of speech to protest, and the right to seek a redress ofgrievances.01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 I'IARIDDN PAGE 02/24 Factual Background The complainant summarily alleges thaton September 29, 2012 thatRespondent interfered with a flight crew by parking his vehicle on a taxiway attheNorth Las Vegas, Nevada Airport. It ignores the rest ofthe story. Prior to charging the Respondent, the Complainant investigated and caused others to investigate the allegations. (Exhibit 1) The FAA and its inexperienced inspector knew the full background and mture of the alleged incident. Specifically, they were aware that the actions of the Respondent were a protest against the excessive noise of the Vision 

### Air Dornier DO 228 aircraft near his hangar and that he had previously sought a redress of that grievance from the manager of the North Las Vegas Air]Jort on several occasions, to no avail. The interviews and investigation by the FAA and others before charging clearly show that the inspector and charging official were awm:e ofthese facts. (Exhibit 1, Discovery provided by FAA as highlighted) Argtunent The Noerr-Pennington Doctrine Provides lnununitv to Respondent by Prohibiting the Federal Aviation AdministrationFrom Using CFR §91.11 to Restrict Respondents FirstAmendmentRight to Protest and Right to Seek a Redress ofGrievances. The Noerr-Pennington doctrine originatedinthe context ofanti-trust litigation. "Concerted efforts to influence public officials do not violate the antitrust laws even though intended to eliminate competition." UnitedMine Workers of America v. Pennington, 381 U.S. 657, 658 (1965) (citing Eastern R. Confv. Noerr Motors, 365 U.S. 127, 669-672 (1961)). "Whi.le any carrier has the right ofaccess to administrative agencies and courts to defeat appijcations of competitors for certificates as highway carriers, and its purpose to eliminate an applicant as a competitor may be implicit 

### in such opposition, its First Amendment rights are not immunized from regulation when they are used as an integral part of conduct violative of the antitrust laws." California Motor 201/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDDN PAGE 03/24 Transport Co. v. Trucking Unlimited, 404 U.S. 508, 509-515 (1972). "If the allegations that petitioners combined to harass and deter respondents from having "free and unlimited access" to agencies and cotuts, and to defeat that right by massive, concerted, and purposenu group activities are established as facts, a violations ofthe antitrust laws will have been demonstrated, and it is immaterial that the nteans used in violation may be lawful." Jd. The Noerr-Perrni!Jgton doctrine has <:JXpanded to virtually all areas of First aAmendment speech. 

### "It is important to emphasize that a person's speech or petitioning activity is not removed from the ambit ofFirst Amendment protection simply because it advocates an unlawful act. The FirstAmendment do<:lS not permit government 'to forbid or proscribe advocacy ofthe use offorce or of law violation except where such advocacy is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or prodtlce such action." White v. Lee, 227, F.3d 1214, (9th Ci.J:. 2000) (citing Brandenburg 

### v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 44, 447 (1969)). "The Supreme Courthas **de~cribed** the right to petition as "amongthe most precious ofthe liberties safeguarded by the 'Bill of Rights' and 'intimately connected, both in origin and in purpose, with other Fi.J:st Amendment rights of free speech and free press." Jd. at 1231 (citing UnitedMine Workers, Dist. 

### 12 v. fllinots State Bar Ass 'n, 389 U.S. 217, 222 (1967)). "While the Noerr-Pennington doctrine originally arose in the antitrust context, it is based on and implements the First Amendment right to petition and therefore, with one exception..., applies equally in all contexts." Id. ('The immunity is no longer lim.ited to the antitrust context. ...") (citing Boulware v. Nevada Dep 't of Human Resources, 950 F.2d 793, 800 (9th Cir. 1992). "TheNoen·-Pennington doctrine ensures thatthose who petitionthe government for redress ofgrievances remain in1ntune fi·omliability for statutory violations, notwithstanding the fact that their activity might otherwise be proscribed by the statute involved." Jd.; See Professional Real 301/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDON PAGE 04/24 Estate Investors, Inc v. Columbi{l PicturesIndus., Inc., 508 U.S. 49, 56 (1993). **"Noerr~Pennington** is a label for a form of First Aolendment protection; to say that one does not have NoerrPennington protection is to con.clude that one's petitioning activity 

### is unprotected by the First Amendment.'' Id. "The Supreme Court has heldthat a lawsuit is 1.mprotected only ifitis a "sham" -i.e., "objectively baseless inthe sense that no reasonable litigant couldrealistically expect success on the merits." !d.; See Professional Real Estate Investors, Inc 

### v. Columbia Pictures Indus., Inc., 508 

## u.s. 49, 56 (1993). White v. Lee, 227 FJd 1214, (9th Cix. 2000), clearly makes the Noerr-Penningtohn doctrine applicable to the actions ofFederal Age11cies ''ahousing rights advocacy group filed an adtnillistrative complaint with an office of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (I-IUD) in San Francisco. The complaint alleged that three neighbors in Berkeley opposed the conversion of a motel into a multi-family housing unit because they believed that the project would bring people into the neighborhood who were mentally disabled 

### or disabled through substance abuse. Upou receiving the complaint, the San Francisco HUD office initiated an eight-month investigation into the neighbors' activities and beliefs. During the course ofits investigation, HUD officials questioned the neighbors under threat of subpoena about their views and public statements regarding the challenged project; directed them to produce an array of documents and infonnation, including all involved parties' names, addresses, and telephone numbers and all correspondence or other documents relating to their efforts in opposition to the project; informed them and a major metropolitan newspaper that they had violated the Fair Housing Act; and advised them to accept a "conciliation proposal" that required them to cease all litigation and the distribution of "discriminatory'' newsletters and flyers. The HUD officials in San Francisco recommended finding that the neighbors had violated the Fair Housing Act, but officials in Washington ultimately concluded that no violation had occmJ:ed and that the neighbors had engaged solely in activity protected by the First Amendment." 227 F.3d 1214, 1220 (9th Cir. 2000). The present case has very similar facts to White v. Lee. Respondent had originally sought a redress ofthat grievance from the manager ofthe North Las Vegas Airport on several occasions for the excessive noise, to no avail, thereafter he protested by lawfully, peacefully, and 401/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 PAGE 05/24 temporarily stopping his vehicle 

### in the taxiway, intending to convey the message that he was opposed the excessive noise and lack ofaction by the North Las Vegas Airport. When asked why he did so he stated that 

### it was in protest. The protest 

### was peacefuL 

### See, NAACP 

### v. Claiborne Hardware Co., 458 U.S. 886, 916, 102 S.Ct. 3409, 3427, 73 L.Ed.2d 1215 (1982) ("The First Amendment does not protect violence."); The interviews and investigation by the FAA and others before charging clearly show that the inspector aJJd charging official were aware of these facts. When he received no redress of grievance, in protest, Respondent temporarily parked his vehicle ona taxiway attheNorth Las Vegas, NevadaAirport as a symbolic fonn offree speech. The action was not lawless, because the North Las Vegas Airport regulations do not give aircraft on the ground the right ofway over automobiles 

### in areas not controlled by the Tower. This was clearly a peaceful protest becm1se although the vehicle stopped 

### in broad daylight with lights flashing, Respondent removed the vehicle from the taxiway upon being requested to do so by airport personnel and stated that it was a protest. Respondent was a hangar owner and in a place where he had a right to be. (It should be noted that while Vision Air had a right to taxi their airplane on the North Las Vegas Airport, Respondent had a countervailing right under the First Amendment to protest the taxiing by 

### his hm1gar. 

### See, Shell Ojfthore, Inc. v. Greenpeace, Inc., 709 F.3d 1281 (9th 

### Cir. 2013)) 

### It is critical to both cases that Federal Agencies hindered a private party's freedom to protest and seek redress of grievances. Both cases have different, but protected forms ofprotest under the First Amendment. As with the discriminatory newsletters and flyers sent out in the 

### White v. Lee case, the Respondent in the present case was exercising his First Amendment 1ightto protest even after seeking a peaceful redress of grievance. Respondent violated no airport mles and engaged in peaceful protest therefore, under the 

### Noerr-Pennington Doctrine he is immune 

## s01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDON PAGE 05/24 from liability from statLltory violations. The similarity does not end there however, 

### inboth White and the instant case, the Federal Agencies acted as "stalking horses" for the local entities. 

### ln this case, 

### it is clear from the discovery provided, that the FAA is acting as a stalking horse for both Vision Air and the N01ih Las Vegas Airport in charging a violation ofCFR §91.11, knowing that there were two violations of Respondent's First Amendment rights. The FAA's enforcement actions thus have a "chilling effect" on the exercise of First Amendl:nent rights. The FAA's decision to seek a civil penalty under these circumstances is retaliatory. TI1e FAA's reaction to Respondent's protest is clearly excessive since another Federal Agency, Homeland Security, wisely declined to take any action against either the Respondent or Vision Air. (Exhibit 

### l, Discovery provided by FAA as highlighted). Therefore, the present case against the Respondent should be dismissed with prejudice. 

### Conclusion 1. Respondent's Motion to Dismiss should be granted 2. Attorney fees should be assessed against the FAA Respectfully submitted,



### lsi Joseph R !Mi::lridon. Jr. Joseph R. Maridon, 

### Jr. Attorney at Law Counsel for Respondent 6130 Elton Ave. Las Vegas. NV 89107 DATED: January 6, 2015 6 /s/ 

### Walter L. Ayers Walter 

### 1. Ayers Zachary L. Ayers Attorneys at Law Counsel for Respondent Ayers Law Finn, P.L.L.C. 1312 North Monroe Street #l33 Spokane, WA 9920 1 DATED: January 6, 20150110712015 09:14AM 7024105395 PAGE 07124 

### CERTIFICATE OF SERYICF. I hereby certify that the foregoing RESPONDENT'S SECOND MOTION TO DISMISS FOR VIOLATION OF RESPONDENTS RIGHTS UNDER THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION (ERRATTA - WITH EXHIBITS) has been served via Facsimile and/or electronic mail on January 7, 2015, to the follovring: Federal Aviation Administration 800 Independenc"' Avenu"', S.W. Washington, DC 20591 

### Attention: Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 Wilbur-Wright Building-Suite 2W1000 

### Fax 2-Q2 493 §142 (202) 267-1293 

### FAX The Honorable Richard C. Goodwin, Administrative Law Judg"' O:ffic"' ofHearings; M-20 U.S. Department ofTransportation 1200 New 1ersey Avenue, S.E. (Ell-310) Washington, DC 20590 TEL: 202-366-5121 StaffAssistant FAX: 202-366-7536 David Shayne, Complainant's Counsel Office ofthe Regional Couns"'l Federal Aviation Administration Western-Pacific Region 1601 Lind Ave., SW Renton, WA 98057 TEL: 425-227-2165 FAX: 42.5-227-1007 Is/ Joseph R. Maridon, Jr. 701/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDON PAGE 08/24 ---------------------------------- ------------------------------ -----------

**Fed<t~H ~®il**  **~.lion** 

### J



### til}l'l 

### 19, 2013 Jo!iephR Mm'j.don,. 

### J.r_ 

## TheMarldQu.tawFirm 61:'10 J:1)\01tl\Vi;l 

### ·LaS Vegas, 

## NV .&9107 

## w **o,;tetn4~atlfi'l-** 

### 1'\eilllll Oftfue ¢'tllu R.og,illl1\d C{l>lllSel 

## Re: .Joseph R. 

### )'J!lridon. 

### Sr. Qas¢

### Nt1, 2Q12WP190l42 Deat

### Mt.1v.!lu:idon: l';Q. 

### B<IJ< 92007 

### Wls **Ailg~ltll;** CA: **9000~~()(!7**

**T~lephon!l;** (310} 725,7112

**FaosjniU~:** {HO) 725.;58!6 

### Wi; 

### have yout**~eQ:\lellt**

### fQr iofqrmal •l;{lofeten,CI!; 

### (Uil:c4 June 

### ·1 S, 201:3, CQnbel:Jling !:he 

### :illegatrons coJ:rtained 

### in our]l1otice ofl'ropnsed CiviL

### Penalo/ dilted

### May 

### :29,. 2013.; Pursuantto your.re>j,\l"st, the **EnfCI.I'\:em~;nt** 

### Investigative **~p<lrt** 

### (EJE.)lsc 

## being forwardedto the 

### OJ;lice of

### \he 

### .!t¥gional **Qo~l,** 

### Nartll.We$tM9J.1nl;llipRegion. 

### That (!>f!'iqe Will

**~**

### $e@:lg 

## in

**~uch**

### Wit!)

### .you shortly **n:;~ati!ing;** 

### the date .and time of

### !he oonfen:nce. · We
**iwtv~.**

### enclosed a copy 

### ofSection.C and **theltem~** 

### ofPu,lufoft\le ElR We lwve **t~aot;;d** 

### Ptiv!\cy A.;t **JnfQ;,nla~on.**

### regardU;lg per$orul 

### otb\il: 

### than your client, 

### Sineerety, 

## Naomi Tsuda • **R~!gilltllll Co~~** 

**Enc~oilute** Qr.\1!:· **;Al'l'M~7** ;,., NOTE: Ourcompletefile is fol'Warded With the 

### request thatynubandJe 

### $einfl!rmat **~linferwce** 

### and. Qtile dbpmliti<lll. **Ho~~** 

### •.H:-y!lu illt.md t6 

### rlltum illi! 

### case 

## to ns for 

### trial,.plea$¢ 

### Jillow 11a to i!lsue tl).e Order. A

WP•240; 

## t,AS FSDO01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 I•·IARIDDN 

### SECTION 

### C- Items. **ofF~o~** 

### 1. **S~t; VisionCll.pt<Un,.~l'!'ncer**  

### Gardner,. 2•. **SW.,:t~~:ll.t: Vl~i<l;>**  

### Fin;t

## Officer,. Keith

## Maseda. 3. Statement: Clark CountyDeparnnentofAviation 

### Line Service 

### Representative, Vincent 'Ri,V!!J>, 

### 4. Stmerneo,t: 

### Vision t.unp 

### wsQnnel,AleJandto Zepeda.

**.~t Stnrement:Vi!>iotttamp·~el,Mar~;a.Z¢!1edll...**  

### 6. 

### P!:!otQr'l? identify IP$vph 

## Maridon.,k ttQrt)

### hjs web
**~ite** 

### www.mafiqonlaw.wn:t. 7.'Report
**~ent**

### to TSA :from VisiWil

### Airtr<dl: 

### Opefator **~&** 

### COordil:tator. · 8. 

### Statetnent: Vision ChiefP:ilot,Bob 

### Stlenke. 9, :Pboto).1r,Mil!'idon **Sr.·~.t'o** 

### VincentRiVas, 

### tfl. Copy ofLOitoJosepkt :Ma!idpn St, · 

### ll.**R~pqnse**to 

### LOI fr,nn **Jo~h** 

### Maticion Jr.l\tt9meyfor Joseph Ml!idon 

## Sr. tz, Statement fulm FAAin:spect.or, Anthony 

### Paclolll\. ·· . .. 1.3. Correspondence llilm SosephMwdon 

## Jr, attotney 

### forJoseph **~i;lon**

## Sr, 1 

## flc, HangerLe;we **A~~** 

### l\tt(llltj!l)l tQ **·P~~F** 

### S ProhibitedOperations.



### 4.~. 

### Short vldeo **tal\'~**by 

### Vision 

### fitstOfl:'ieet. ' ·•

J6:lA!ldio tee<)rdmg 

## tTPmNorth Las.Veic\ilsATCT.



## .) .01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDON PAGE 10/24

**OnS;l~u[day;** $EPtllllJber.29'"2012, ;ltartl?rlli<lmate\9 a;;ro **pm·Jo~al** 

### time, will recei\M.!l **O\lr~xlcl~tall~** from 19<lrtl!las**Veg;~s** Ground.and l?ejliln o.l!\' 

### taxi to tt11:1 **a~t!ve**

### runway 1

### aUWGT. As we1lJrne.d 

### oorth from 

### the·Vlslonpl!rklng ilte<l 

### and 

### begun **t~l4111S·the** 

### ·"backway'' **tPWi!td~ ru~y** 

### 7

**w~** nOctlc!;\d an 

### lildMdi!al 

### !Unfrom an ppen,ha!Jg<ir**toalrut~**

### ..wh!l:h 

### was parked **next~IMI!aopr.** 

### Hl!.tbenJUmped

### ln **tlletru~k,blieire<llt** 

### outslightly· **(a~.it**Wa$ posltlllnt'Hl 

### againsttbe open hangar ;lf\d the harigarto

### the North), **thendrove.forw~rd,\i~d** finally tumedtbe trnck, 

### mck1@ **degtel.l~ !:llre¢t~~**  **~~a.wtf~J~i~l..~~~~~~~~.JB'~~~i:i~Z~~2liii.'!M~1;~ir:~~~iiti~~mr•Wi~~~~,l \~l~~e-am**  **SMi~~~~~~ts.~S'-~~~Mk'r~··B~~m!ii:t:W}·E .~HJ!im'!n~j;ffJJR~r.aa~**  

### ~~~-~il\ll~~fmm~ Het\tenl¢!0ut 

### l'lls

**~;ell** phon

### a anti appt\arl!dto be**rnakl~**

## a: pi\<Jne call. At

### this time

**~** 

### 11ottflell.N<Jrth

**l~s \/eg~'Gr<J\11\d**  

### ()f.What'had trai!Splred aod they **dJsp~tclieli** 

### an

### alrp<1rtOflll

**v~n**

### to our locatl®, After **con~ctlng**

### Ground

**w~** !Wtlfted 

### QUroperatiOns centerand

**als ~dvls!)d** 

### them 111'What IIM·happened; **AfWt~t** Wlll\otlcect 

### a **sacci\~ ln~M<Jual**  

### eomJI

**ou~**

### of.th!i hangllr. lie prod\KiM 

### a

# cen **plN~Je**

### and appllared t<!

# oo (!ll:orJ:IIng

**~$** 

### while 

### also 

### wav~ at



### il~with 

### hls:·h~nd. He then. 

### ~roteeded in this

### talihloM·~ro~rn~·;;·

# ;;·l**~of~th~ei·~~m:raft** around 

### the teftS!tle1 

### antltlnall\laft of

### thealretl\ftout ·· ·· · ·· 

### !!'1 

### ' ' ' 

# .Sre;,c

**-.~r** 

# T. 

# bar:tlht?r01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 

### FW:lffi! **'".l'as¢nW~den**

**An,thony•~ol1a** 

### tl/01®1'209:12.1\M·. Shaw DetailS' 1;3 •, 

### 4-;· 

# :t

**'li~·**



# ~\· . . . . 

# .



# ''

**·'*·'·~~** MARIDON

**(llj~t**

### l!l,
**~0.12,** 

### lit 

### 15:00, **~~0:**

### Wl!ldml, 4Walde!l@viitlqll.!\1t!lneti&pm,> 'Wl:'Otil:
**'11JanM:~tlif?fAA 'lt<~~dv** 

### bas

## tfl!lWliAo1'$1Jblt\IS$li1ll•

**·7!)~ ~~**  !9Cililpg

### ton **sta~m~nt** 

### ffQmy.,u **C!~ll··nf W~AT,** 



### Tll~nks, **~**

**~~** ' **t..tm~kh"1Vif~~estluoojh.or.~.~~~aoiidlltair~my.&l'llll1~l\elpJI..**
**<l~l,Wg>** PAGE 11/2401/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDDN PAGE 12/24 

## i\1 Whom It ll1lly r;oocern: Wed, NQ\f, 21"' 201Z01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 

## ,FW; **~eqtte~>t**



### JasonWal4oo tQ: 

### Anthony **Pac~olli:l** 

### 11/01/2G1·2 09;tl AM 

## show De*ails MARIDDN
sony I **mi~se.d** ypur **c~li** yesterday:,.! 

### wasgo!ns back
**an~** f\lrth ttl meson. you 

### will receive;) **~till ofW~**  ernalls **c<;lntalll\ng~,a~~me))ts in~ludl~**  **th:i~** 

## one.. Th;;tnk$, 

### Ja>on PAGE 13/24 

### l!l/2012 9;33:50 Jl,iM

**·--~-----·-~~~-...-~---~~~~· "~·-~·~~-**  **Ftol:fll.~lth M<l$e~**  . . $eob **Friday,·~** 26; 2012 3:30 P'M to.;Ja$11 Wl'1tden
**Sub~~~** RE:: r¢i1uest T<>wh<:;m Itmay **001'1~m:** Fri. 

### Oct, ;;!11th 4'012

Keith 

### J; Maseda 

### 'Micm **.Aii'llhe~**01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024106396 MARIDON

**~p.** 

## 29•;fl,

## A,pprm.14:31) **~tower** 

## M1l over tile **~o** (Qr

### a,. COI;mty . 

### mobile, the tower 

## bd'orrned

## tliat•there WM 

### a vehideblocldng .the.

## way of 

### visioJ1 **~** 

### (40SVA) **belw~ll** 

### the IOOI.gars 

## at **c;om~** 

### road, :1: **the~**

**dr~ve** 

## to **theD~** 

## m!J **J1otice,~t ~**  **~~1C** 

### had 

### parked .biB 

### truck 

## on .the 

## yellow .fi\Xl\faY 

### line in 

### N9)

**~J11liii!!&;filli~ ~~~~e1·**  PAGE 14/2401/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 

## FW: St?tement 1 .. .
**J~Wm** Walden. o Anthony pqclolla tt2. !"rom: Ale.lM<iro Zepeda. . ... 

### ·sent: Monclay, **OCI:libe~** 2!ili 

### 201211;15 AM To1 Ja$0ri 

### WaldeJ! **S!Jhje¢.~nt** MARIDON PAGE 15/24 1110112012 09:12AM: M!l·(Aie,li!l'lt,lro **~~da).!lnq M;!.~O**  Zllp\ldll hadjl,l$t launchedthe oo, **2Z8tha~** Spenw**G~rdanerand:.** 

### Keith **Ma~da** 

### were flying to 

### go piCk IJP passengers lit

### the 

### Canyon, .a$they were 

### heading Mrthl'nthe taxi.wav my co-WQtker al1tjl noticed

**·~.** 

### rell: picli; up.t(l\tk with the hood **~pen and~~**  

### em!!rl!ency **1'1!ish~r** 

### ·Oil 

### patlleti on the 

### mtdlllepftl1e.t:uj way antflt

**w~~** 

### biQcldng the 

### patll 

### of

### thl! ain:tah; **u~thlniiJng**

### thllt 

### It hliD 

### broken down we proceedlld 

### to go Mlpthe 

### cwner push Ito11t.ofthe way, 

### upon atrtvlngthe **alrcr<~Tt** 

### .
**Wtl~-already** stopped ln 

### front ofthe

### t"'t:\1: 

### and Vlfll:ent the **C(lunty'~ linem~n,** **w~sjust** 

### artlliing.on the sCi\ne

**~nd ~\!llli~!l.talking**  tQ.

### tna awner,ofth!)pickup trutk, **Me~owhllaijMfhll!r** rmtt! **waswlil~fng**



### ~round 

### the alrll!<ift recording 

### with a.camera.He Wlllked;. 

### ~la;r.ipiun~d~o~n~c~e~tih~eijn~ca~mieito~~~ijm~· 

### i"'iihi!i

**bu~illf#l** cal:d, Whkh · 

### .P: ··· 'Bl/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 f·.·IARIDDN From:· Soot:

**To~** Subject 

### Marca **teped~** 

### . . . . Friday, **NQvemb~r** 02,.l?!Jt2.1

### t04AM Jt>sonWt>lder · **St~>temilnt** PAGE 15/24



### · Oflthe day 

### ofthe 

### Qr;turreMe we(AiliiJalldm·ZefJeda. 

### anti t}h<li.i.laUnchfld 

### thB tlrW 

### pl<me oftlledaytad(; a **p~x plqk!Jif:Wh~~**  w!!'re Clirillng **!ll~ldewe** llOtlced **~(eWli$** aMd trllck In th¢ Way C!f1:\1!!.plaM. we..**(li\lri't.~nowwh!itwa~** going <ln 

### so we gpt on):he $1fqrto

**~e!l** 

### whattt>e **prol'll~m** was. First thought **wasth;~~**the **~ruci<;.Md** bo:>kEJn 

### lbwn becauSB Ithad ltsh6od qpel'land. emeQ!e{]cy llgl\ts o.n, · up and,was talkingtti 

### the oWiler.ahf1!! rl!d pick 

### up. Meanwhile · 

### then

**l;(}lrn!\!·~·1 ~**  . **aJ.IUSlll~SS** .01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDON PAGE 17/24 )
• 

## .•

· **~-~!#111iS~·l'lisht~sre** 

## bei,egn:()tlfiedtl)atif

### SQD1ethlng·OOil!lP!•~~n4i · :@Cll;'ight;or **~·right and;l;l!IY.M.~** 

### re1ated; 

## thatcleat **¢f,ll1llll~O;!!,tl>.** 

### $QC •·li:nl,1J$t

S<l 

### :tbat

### :notifl.Wtiolito IW 'I"S"'!DC

### ean 

### take

# vht®**whi;n~.** """A-i• **~~y.** 

## r. 0$ . . . .. . .. · **AirCJ:d.~r** 

### Secunty Coordlnatoi01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDDN f(Qm: 

### Sent Ta! Silb!liic;l'; Lauies! ,,,, ,., 

### Cu\JJel$l1n, Baroara J.!BarbaraJ,Culll!!rs<>n@lsa,dh,..gav} Wl!ldnflday, C1ctooor oa, :201212:.41 F'M ·· Jotyn Cain; Ka"'l\ Oan'l<'!l H=a. V\JlUntal)' d!5CIOOI1J:a 

## ,, we. <lo ha\1!! l.l 

### v61Ut1tary disclosure **p.NJg~ ~nd.**  \ilere 

### I what. **nee<~s** to take placl'!, PAGE 18/24 You. (\tis;l:on) need to **&en~** via email what. portion

**o~** the ph:Jgram **th~t** was not 

### .foi:towed
**<~nd** 

### why, 

### alol\g 

## with what sti;!!)S 

### V<lll 

### be t;;Jk!!n to easure c:ompl:l,ance wUl 

### tal:!! t:}late in the 1'uture. Example: Send the 

### :!:nformation regarding 

### the incident via email and
**t;~e** 

### fa<;t that the airport control, was ncrtified, 

### Tll<:lt at 

### the time 

### it W.as taking 

### place 

### ;tt \'!liS 

### not be1ieVlld 

### to II¢ 

### security **relatetl~** 

### Yl'lt aft the fa¢t an(! **ilwestj.g~rt;ion** by **yo~r** ct)ffiparty 

### you felt **difhr~<ntly.**

**th~ ~o**  

### tM i1ui:ure 

### Your' **~lllployees** 

### wtl;l 

### be 

### adviseld 

### :Lf it does 

### not feel right, 

### se£im right · **notifiq~tl,.Ort** 

## to· rsoc: wU',l..

**~-** made $0 

### tha't a 

## :J;ot:al T$I 

### c:an detetndne what H 

### any secul'ity relaterJ **:l.n.dp~.Jnt** it. 

### 1\'lay be. . . . . . . .

**on~e** you 

## have done **1:h;:~t,** 1 will. **forw~rd** it to our Regional 

### SeCI!l'.1tY :!;[!spector ahd the 

### I'SS., If th()se **:l:odiv:l.d~l** halit'! q(les:tions .or l"eCOimllendation!l then yoU **W~ll** he notified. $arbo **Culb~~on** 

### Tram;portation 

### Set\lrtty Inspecto.r (TSI) 702·2S9•S29:L tell. . **702.•511-9.0~** 

### Qff1ce. !l!arhara,cuJl!grson@dhs .gov 

# ·-01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 MARIDON 

### FI'Om: S&llt: T9:

**kllill~!i:** Culber11on, **BarhlimJ.{BartJ$f<l,J•t;vl~r!IDl'l@lsadhs1!avl** Wednesday, 

### .Ocitl:lbl!rOS, 2012 12:45. PM 

### Jalyo 

### Cam: Ka.ro!l OaneenHtoza. PAGE 19/24 Please 

### send me the infi;ih!ation 

### r;,garding. the **ifi~ident., ~a>:l'ect'~ve**  

### !lction within 

### thl! nelrt: 24 

### hou<'s in Writing, 

### this will **ens~Jre** 

### it 1!> 

### covet'ed under **volunt~ry** 

### d:isr:lo!lui'Eprog"am. Bal'bll 

### c:albt:!rsort TNm:Sport<ltioll **Secu~Uy** 

### lMpector **('fSl~** 7G2-23\H12r!l tell. 702•517-91'12.9 

### Off:Lr:e. :!l!ltb§ta.• **cul~rson@dhs.** gov01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 1•1ARIDDN 

## • F'romt Sent; To:

**6ubj~t!** Jo\yncaln. ThuiJlday, O¢lober

## O•t :1,012 3:53 PM . .. . . .. ... . . .. J$pnWaldem; Karan Dlilneen Hroza; Robe!t Stlanke; Jennifer,Alvarado f;W; 

### FYI



# J~?t~affli Oif'l:(:.tQr of **St~ons** Vis!® Alrllll<U
**·~All'!»¢,** Dr 

### Nottb 1m

### V'11ilos

### .NV•8903Z **1o2~~0fika** · **:1(>::.-576-:zazt~** 

### call · 7£1:1;-974-'tSss

**~** 

## F'cix

.l$

....

**/fa~~.** 

### ~-} **702~ZaB•B291 U~lt**  

### 7D2:-577-ED29 fiffi!le.· **·a~ubarli:uulherruml!ldhs~** 

### rmm•lqlyri. ¢!.In 

### (ma!lto;Jcatn®vl!!loMitllnes.romJ.

**~!** 

### Thut!l4ay, **.oct~** 

### 04; 2012l1:2!

### AM · 

### to: cull:lel'$¢n, .Batl!aral cc;)ason:**·wa~®n;** 

### Kal':ell· .oanean Ht'Qta;: Robert **St!ell~;** 

### Allli'i BfBiitloo SUbjl(d1 . PAGE 20/24

**Atfi'!~?f1ed'** 

### ls.the. 

### copy ortl)e **iilcld~llt** 

### from 

### Sept 29.fliat We **dlscuss~d** 

### yesterday.
**~ieas~** 

### let me 

### know if**yqth't~~d** 

## tmvthin$.ful'ther. 101/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 Regar<;ls

## ~dJ; 

# Yfktil/i DirectQ( of Stot!ol'l> Vision AlrlJnll'>**~** 

### Airp<>ri:**0~** 

### Nolth l,<n.

### Vegqs NY 89032.**702-5~-** ()ffica 702-sT&-2011- 

## o.n**7o2.-97~1lli15** - fax**I~ARIDDN** PAGE 21/24

201/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395



### · :Anthlil:l).t

### :Paci6lla



### FAA AvbrtionSaf!:!tylnSpi)cl;or LasVeg$ J'SPO . .. 

### 71:8:t .AQ:llgQ 

### Street.Suite 

# ;reo . **l.asV~** 

### ·NV89119



### . . gas. '

**~~~gl** MARIDON PAGE 22/24



### .This letter !S to describe 111y 

### lnyOlvementln. an 

### Incident' irt 

### St;ptemtl!lr 2012 :that 

### occurred

on the VGT <J.i:rl;lort:ru> 

### one.ofour 

## il&

**~za** 

### !lircraft:was **~Urig** 

### !'rom tbeVlSltin:ramp. 

## wthe

**dep~qute** tu>tWay.



### Ar~. 

### altl;l9i't teft<lill:t, 

### Mr. Joseph 

## Ma.ridcm, 

# Sr. is 

## operating a. maintenance

**bu~in~s** 

### fro.:m .a neaJ:by 

### hangar• M;r: **Jos~pb** 

### Maricl.(lrt, Sf. stoppl,ld ol.lr airprW;t o);l, ·a **:t,Ui.W'<~Y:** by 

### U\llng })is pep;onl!l.ve})kle 

## to blo$ **a~s** 

### to the runv<roY. From tile loll!l,ti\!inwMre the . 

### !1\ti:rattpad **~ed,** 

### there was not. 

### another altern<i.,;ive 

### to t;;txl
**~ue ~a**  

### the !ll:z;,e 

### ofthe **attc~ft** 

### · .imd ather **bidl!~ing.**



### . .· .. **~e** 

### . . .. . . . . .. . .. .. t)ur . .··

**M:~~ttdmt** 

## 1 r· ·**wa'~kei\** 

### arot1n!l pur 

## parked4!rc!-'afu wlj:h its 

### engines **runnil1~** 

### an,dto.ok.a video 1 **~plalned** 

### to Mt. Marl

### don, SF, **~hllt~ti.¢h** 

### lininCident

## was J;erious 

## e11ough aaa ·W<IS 

### .,Ievated 

### to the LAS .J3$DO 

### s,nd they woul4

**~¢** 

### irt ljOn,ta.cJ;with 

## him SQon;.I
**:~su to~~**  

## Mr. Mat'id9n, Sr •. fltlit 6\lr Do 22:1;l **atr~raft: ca:nti!l~** 

### ..**safe~y** 

### taltislrt.Sli'J **e~gltitl** 

### prior to **d¢pact:ui'~·due** 

### to l:heNtls,1 · st:ab!ltzat!i?rt ofthe **engl~WS**

### prierto **~akeot'f,** 

### ·01/07/2015 09:14AM 7024105395 

### Pwd: VGT **''fSAlnri!d~t** 

### Rtibert **$tienk~** 

### to; 

### An:thl111YPaoioi!IJ.

**lii0$!2!)l2.03:1~** 

### PM Cc; MARIDDN 

## Ahm Bl'andon, 

## JasqnWald¢1,
**~n**

### Daneen :Htpza,

### Jim 

## Maguire. Sf,ow

## Details ·· . . .Inspector

### Paeiolla, PAGE 23/24

**11/512012~28** 

## PM

r

## ~~e(!**l:timabo~**wl).y

## ~·wn: left

### the 

## bl,I.Sine;~s~ **for~·**andhe said bis



## S~~n**llild~en**vidl!tls of:llw

## P~!W~ it 

### Was 

### stopj)ed, **l~d·oot** 

### oonta$1:Mrc Martdon,J;.Joi **anJi.I~li~.** · · · · ·· · ···

**.** ; . 

### !'?ent **&<i~.my**

## W!id l3egi:tl tbrwi!i'dl;ld 

### message: 

### .Fl'Orm **Roi)littSti~<l'"SRSti~WwwiSiQ!Wi•·S:Ol;r,l>·**

**~t&:** 

### OctQber4; 

### .Z0l2; 12:41:11 

### PMI'D1 

### T<i! las<>n•W!Iid"ll **<J]hlldeil@v)s!G!'ialtlib!;:t.\lotn>,.·~**

### baueen

## Htl:$l. **<DHroza@VlsioMjrll~;WS;s;Qm,>,** 

### Jolyil 

### Cru\x<1Qnn@Vi!l}gMirttnesccom> · · . ·

**<::c~**

### AlM. **~** 

### <;AaniiiW:m@1<:WfMairltnei£mn> $UbjeetlVGT

### 'tsAlDeidtnt Ah;. 

### . J'Wil"'glv!lo **a•·bosin~s~**

### J::atd fromJoseph.Miltld!i!i\,.lr, by()fuis **hrV~T**

### opllratloo$, 

### i.Wl!llqlld q>t<;!rtl) 

## Ml'; **Mati~o!~** 

### han&!lr

**.~o latro~u~;t~**  **tr~Yself; ~~t**  

### fpund **ti'IIMQs~ph** N!atidon; 5r, Is **ope~tlng** 

### a 

### mi!liitenanPe **j)uslnf!~S**

### outohhe 

### hlinger, **atu~.h.is** 

### soo.dropped off.the tafd..

### HIS: 5on lscl) 

### kit:&

### I**aMrru~y**

### with 1'hl;l **Marid~.h** Law 

### Fltro,ttc., 702-514, l>l02:. A<;omllion nllffll! ;Mt. JOI!!sph **iVtarldca\~** ,lr•.**~$ ~Y**  !!; 

### L\IT!l!fficfid:etti)w;tilm, 

### ttnftlrt!Jed 

### Mr, M 

### ariaoll, sr,thatth.e TSA and FAA

**ll~e.**

## been notffletl andwiluld.be 1n oootact with

### him

## rn

**~he** 

### near **future.~~~~~~-~frifrirmed**

### ..**liilitoft\'le·oper;~tillt1lll·.** 

### · 

### · ·. .· . **c:I~Piirt\lre.tt~B**01/07/2015 0g:14AM 70241053g5

**Octo~** 

### 25, 

### 2012 

### REGULARICERTIFIED.MAIL ·RltTURN 

## BECElP'l' **RE~UESTED** 

### Fli,Ji; NO, iol2WPl9014l . . .. 

## :Mt.**.Jp@Pb.~dQn,** 

### Sr. 

### 6429 

### Quioo Way .Las Vegas, NV 89108 

## De!nTMr, Mari,4om PAGE 24/24



### lt

### bas been broughttothe **attentio~** 

### ofthl: Feder;)} Aviati,on Adn;tipj_stt<Jtioll

### (FAA) 

## that on 

### . **S~t~ber29;:2Ql2, an~iQ,entoccunl.ld**  

### •b¢tWeen Yl'lil ao.4 **"'Vision~~~** 

## !lirotaft. Weare

**colh~cti~g** 

### l\tatem¢nts from all pet$ot\li.

### mv!'Jived. **J>ll!!!\$~** 

### \Ulder$nwd

## that ytrut **~itr!OM~J** 

### is v¢zy bnportant til

### till! 

### FAA and. its decision on the outoome oftbis investigation. 1'bis 

### is 

### 19 infom}c

**yn~** 

### this filij.tter 

### ill **'@~r** mwstiglltiOn

### by **the·F~** 

### A:v:!atimi AdminiJ!trati<Jn, We Wish.to. **o~**

### ydt\

### •anl)pportunity

# w ,submit

**~** 

### written, 

### starement This

**~;htiuld** 

### be **acoompli~bed** 

### withlli.lG 

### calertdat days.afterl'e«lipt @fthm letler. **Y•Ytlr-~WI'!l~t** 

### :$ould 

### cmitaJaa(1 **~ettt.fucts** 

### Slid (\.)).y mitigatingC\l:l;uirtStances 

### Wfiich you baJie\ie 

### may

**~e**

### a 

### het!rlng ont\le inojdent, 

## · ThankYI>U 

## :\Ptyour wQpe¢ion in

# tl!is 'Wattet·

S. l "'

mllerey, .. /)-' 

# ~/~. AnthoilY Pac!i:llla
**A~otthhib$$** 

### Silfet;v

### lnspecto:r