DM1\700933.1

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA 

TOLEDO MACK SALES & 

SERVICE, INC., 

Plaintiff, 

v. 

MACK TRUCKS, INC., 

Defendant. 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

Civil Action No. 2:02-CV-04373-RLB 

JURY TRIAL DEMANDED 

MACK TRUCKS, INC., 

Counterclaim Plaintiff, 

v. 

TOLEDO MACK SALES & SERVICE, 

INC., 

Counterclaim Defendant. 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

: 

JURY TRIAL DEMANDED 

 VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITIONS PLAYED INTO EVIDENCE AT TRIAL

 Attached as exhibits A-I are transcripts of portions of the videotaped depositions played 

to the jury at trial. Below is a chart cross referencing the portions played to the trial transcript in 

this matter. 

Exhibit 

Tab 

Day & Date of 

Trial 

Cross-Reference to Record Description of Video Played 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 134:5-134:6 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 12/4/2004 

(18:3-18:6) 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 135:12-135:13 Kevin Flaherty Deposition dated 11/8/2003 

(119:15-124:18) 

Case 2:02-cv-04373-RB Document 174 Filed 10/25/2006 Page 1 of 6
 2 

DM1\700933.1

Exhibit 

Tab 

Day & Date of 

Trial 

Cross-Reference to Record Description of Video Played 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 146:20-146:21 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(92:12-92:15) 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 164:13-164:14 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(370:1-370:23) 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 165:22-165:23 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(148:7-148:13) 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 178:10-178:11 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(270:14-270:19) 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 182:16-182:17 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(288:17-288:24) 

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 190:25-191:1 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(309:13-309:21)

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 195:1-195:2 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(88:22-89:02)

Exh. “A” Day 4 – 9/18/2006 202:17-202:18 Jeffrey Yelles Deposition dated 11/13/2003 

(83:12-84:13)

Exh. “A” Day 5 – 9/19/2006 30:01-30:03 Ronald Gerhard Deposition dated 1/5/2005 

(103:16-105:23) 

Exh. “B” Day 5 – 9/19/2006 34:25-35:20 Jack Lusty Deposition dated 11/14/2003 

Exh. “C” Day 5 – 9/19/2006 

Day 6 – 9/20/2006 

114:18-115:09 

2:12-2:15 

Jack Lusty Deposition dated 1/14/2005 

Continuation of Jack Lusty Deposition 

dated 1/14/2005 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 7:16-7:17 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (109:21-109:24) 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 8:01-8:02 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (119:23-120:06) 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 9:08-9:09 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (120:15-120:20) 

Case 2:02-cv-04373-RB Document 174 Filed 10/25/2006 Page 2 of 6
 3 

DM1\700933.1

Exhibit 

Tab 

Day & Date of 

Trial 

Cross-Reference to Record Description of Video Played 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 10:03-10:04 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (124:04-124:07) 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 12:10-12:11 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (110:06-110:10) 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 61:12-61:13 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (99:17-99:21) 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 73:09-73:10 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (204:11-204:20) 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 82:22-82:23 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (165:19-165:24) 

Exh. “D” Day 6 – 9/20/2006 97:03-97:04 Deposition of Kevin Flaherty dated 

11/8/2003 (183:23-184:08) 

Exh. “E” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 90:06-90:07 Deposition of Joseph Favia dated 

12/15/2004 (294:10-294:16) 

Exh. “E” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 90:15-90:16 Deposition of Joseph Favia dated 

12/15/2004 (283:13-283:19) 

Exh. “E” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 107:06-107:07 Deposition of Joseph Favia dated 

12/15/2004 (174:17-174:21) 

Exh. “E” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 108:17-108:18 Deposition of Joseph Favia dated 

12/15/2004 (106:06-106:13) 

Exh. “E” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 112:02-112:03 Deposition of Joseph Favia dated 

11/12/2003 (32:19-38:08) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 142:23-142:24 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (56:07-56:20) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 143:13-143:14 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (56:21-57:10) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 146:16:-146:17 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (43:04-45:09) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 148:09-148:10 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (45:08-45:09) 

Case 2:02-cv-04373-RB Document 174 Filed 10/25/2006 Page 3 of 6
 4 

DM1\700933.1

Exhibit 

Tab 

Day & Date of 

Trial 

Cross-Reference to Record Description of Video Played 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 153:11-153:12 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (68:02-68:07) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 160:03-160:04 Deposition of Jeffrey Yelles dated 

11/13/2003 (118:15:118:20) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 161:25-162:01 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (100:15-100:18) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 167:25:168:01 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (133:04-133:14) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 168:17-168:18 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (132:09-132:11) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 169:06-169:07 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (132:13-132:18) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 174:14-174:15 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (163:13:163:17) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 176:11-176:12 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (164:03-164:04) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 177:12-177:13 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (188:18-189:15) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 182:22-182:23 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (112:08-112:10) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 183:13-183:14 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (112:11-112:17) 

Exh. “F” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 184:25-185:01 Deposition of John McCafferty dated 

11/11/2003 (122:07-122:20) 

Exh. “G” Day 7 – 9/21/2006 

Day 8 – 9/22/2006 

217:14-217:15 

2:09-2:10 

Deposition of Stephen Polzer dated 

11/19/2003 

Continuation of Deposition of Stephen 

Polzer dated 11/19/2003 

Exh. “H” Day 9 – 9/25/2006 35:17-35:18 Deposition of Stephen Polzer dated 

1/18/2005 

Case 2:02-cv-04373-RB Document 174 Filed 10/25/2006 Page 4 of 6
 5 

DM1\700933.1

Exhibit 

Tab 

Day & Date of 

Trial 

Cross-Reference to Record Description of Video Played 

Exh. “I” Day 9 – 9/25/2006 36:16-36:17 Deposition of Hallie Giuliano dated 

3/18/2005 

Respectfully Submitted, 

DUANE MORRIS LLP 

By: s/ J. Manly Parks 

 Wayne A. Mack 

 J. Manly Parks 

 James H. Steigerwald 

 David A. Degnan 

 30 South 17th Street 

 Philadelphia, PA 19103-4196 

 215.979.1000 

Attorneys for Plaintiff/Counterclaim 

Defendant Toledo Mack Sales & Service, 

Inc. 

Dated: October 25, 2006 

Case 2:02-cv-04373-RB Document 174 Filed 10/25/2006 Page 5 of 6
DM1\700933.1

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, J. Manly Parks, hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document 

was served this 25th day of October, 2006, by hand delivery upon counsel of record as follows: 

Jeremy Heep, Esquire 

Pepper Hamilton LLP 

Two Logan Square, Suite 3000 

Eighteenth and Arch Streets 

Philadelphia, PA 19103 

 

 ___s/J. Manly Parks 

 J. Manly Parks 

Case 2:02-cv-04373-RB Document 174 Filed 10/25/2006 Page 6 of 6