F ro m: " Sh a w n B

. K e ndall " < Ken d all

. Sha w n @a z deq

. g o v>

T o: G w en Y o s h i m u r a / R 9 / U S E P A / U S @E PA

, " S t e v e n E

. Pepl a u " < Pe p la u

. S t e v e n @a z deq

. go v>

C c: S c o t t Bohn i ng / R 9 / U S EP A / U S @E PA

, M e red i t h Ku r pi u s/ R 9 / U S EP A / U S@ EP A

, M i c h a el A F lag g / R 9 / U S E P A / U S @EPA

D a t e: 04 / 0 1 / 2 01 0 0 4 : 1 1 PM

Su b j e c t: R e : ASA RC O P B s i t e lan g uage

E xc e l l ent s u m m a r y

. A n d I wou l d c on c u r i f a s e c ond s i te i s c ho s e n i t s ho u l d be we s t o f the f a c i l i t y.

F r om : Y o s h i m u r a

. G we n @ e p ama il. e p a .gov < Y os h i m u r a

. G we n @ e p ama il. e p a .go v>

To : S h aw n B. K e n d a ll ; S te v e n E

. Pe pl a u

Cc : B o hn i n g

. Sc o t t @ e p ama il. e p a .gov < B o hn i n g. S c o tt @ e p ama il. e p a .go v >;

K u rpi u s .M e r e di t h @ e p ama il. e p a .gov < K u rpi u s.M e r e di t h @ e p ama il. e p a .go v >; f l a gg

. m i ch ae l a @ e p a .g ov

<f l a gg. m i ch ae l a @ e p a

. g o v>

S e nt : T hu A p r 0 1 1 6: 0 6 : 4 4 2 0 10

S u b j e ct : Re : A S A R C O P B s i te l a n g u a g e

H i S h a wn,

S ee wha t y o u t h i n k o f

the fo l l o w i ng. Mu c h th a n k s to S c ott f o r the w r i te u p!

T han ks,

G w en

A S A R C O H a y d e n P b mo n i to r : Ra t i on ale f o r si t i ng A S A RC O H a y d e n P b mon i t o r a t G l ob e Hi gh w a y

S t a t i on b a s e d on d isc u s s i on w i th S h a wn Ke nd all, A D E Q

, 2 010

- 03

- 31

S ou rc e

- o r i en t ed l e a d ( P b ) m on i to r i ng i s r eq u i r e d f o r the A SA R C O c op p e r s m e l te r i n H a y d en

, A r i z o na.

A D E Q c h o s e t h e Gl obe H i gh w a y S t at i on s i te a f te r an a na l y s i s t h at c on s i de r e d s o u rc e e m i ss i on

c ha r a c te r i s t i cs

, p a s t m on i t o r i ng, and the to p og r a p h y a n d m eteo r o l o g y o f

the f a c i l i t y l o c a t i o n

.

A 1 9 87 s o u rc e a p po r t i on m ent s t ud y u s i n g t h e C h e m ic a l M a ss B a l an c e m ode l c o n c l ud e d t h at 8 0 % o f th e

P M 1 0 P b c a m e f r o m p r o c e ss f ug i t i v e e m i ss i on s w i t h i n the s m e l te r ( " S ou rc e A p po r t i on m ent o f S u s p en d ed

P a r t i c l e s a n d T o x i c E l e m ent s i n H a y d en

, A r i z o na, F i n a l Repo r t "

, N E A In c

., A p r il 1 5 , 19 8 7 ) . D i r e c t

ob s e r v a t i on b y A D E Q s ta ff c on f i r m ed that pa r t i c u l a t e p l u m e e m anate s p r i n c i p a ll y f r o m the s m e l te r

bu i l d i ng i t s e l f

, r athe r

t h an f r o m othe r s ou rc e s s u c h a s o r e h a n d li n g f a c i l i t i e s o r r e

- ent r a i n e d du s t f r o m

s to r age p i l e s

. B e c au s e o f the h i g h te m pe r atu r e s i n v o l v e d i n th e s m e l t i ng p r o c e ss , th i s p l u m e i s b uo y a nt

and ha s s ub s t a nt i a l v e r t i c a l v e l o c i t y

, r e a c h i ng t o 1 00 fe et o r m o r e ab o v e g r ou n d l e v e l . U n li k e f o rnonbu o y a n t g r o und l e v e l p l u m e s , the h i ghe s t g r ou n d l e v e l c on c ent r a t i o n s f r o m s u c h a b uo y a nt p l u m e w o u l d

not b e e x p e c ted t o o cc u r i mm ed i ate l y ad j a c ent to t he f a c ili t y.B e c au s e the b u l k o f S O 2 e m is s i on s a r e a l s o t h o u ght t o be e m i tted a s b u o y a n t f ug i t i v e s f r o m the s m e l te r

bu i l d i ng

, 1 9 70' s m on i to r i n g o f S O 2 i s r e l e v an t f o r P b. ( Si n c e th e s ta c k i s 1000 f ee t ta l l

, S O 2 i m pa c t s f r o m

s ta c k e m is s i on s o cc u r f a r the r a w a y a nd a r e d i l ute d b y the t i m e s ta c k p l u m e r ea c he s the g r ou n d. ) A t th a t

t i m e S O 2 m on i to r i n g w a s c ondu c t ed a t t w e l v e d i ff e r ent m on i to r l o c a t i on s ; G l o b e H i g h w a y S t at i on wa s

f ound to h a v e t he h i g he s t c on c ent r a t i o n s

. B e c au s e o f the s i m il a r

e m i ss i on c ha r a c t e r i s t i cs o f S O 2 a nd P b

f ug i t i v e s

, t h i s s u g ge s t s G l o be H i g h w a y m a y a l s o h a v e the h i g he s t c on c e nt r a t i on s f o r P b.

T he A S A RC O H a y d en s m e l te r i s l o c a t ed i n v e r y c o m p l e x te rr a i n

, w i th t he Gi l a R iv e r m a k i ng a w i nd i ng

s e m i -c i rc l e ea s t t o s ou t h o f the f a c i l i t y

, a nd i nte rs e c t e d b y t he S a n P ed r o R i v e r v a ll e y f r o m the s outh. T he

f a c ili t y i t s e l f i s e l e v at e d r e l a t i v e t o th e v a l l e y s ; the r e i s a 2 0 0 f oot h i l l j u s t s ou t h o f t he f a c i l i t y

, a n d

m ounta i n s r i s i n g t o wa r d t h e no r th / no r t h ea s t. T he v a r i e d te rr a i n c au s e s c o m p l e x w i nd f l o w. W i th i n a n d

ad j a c ent t o t h e r i v e r v a l l e y s , d r a i na g e w i nd s t end to do m i nate at n i g ht u nde r s t a b l e c on d i t i on s

, to w a r d the

we s t on the s o uth an d w e s t o f the f a c i l i t y

, a n d t o wa r d t he s ou t h o n t h e ea s t o f the f a c ili t y . H o w e v e r

, g i v en

the b u o y an c y

o f th e s m e l te r

bu i l d i ng f u g i t i v e p l u m e, a n d th e f a c ili t y ' s e l e v a t ed l o c a t i o n , e m i ss i on s t y p i c a l l y

r i s e ab o v e t h e s e s u r

f a c e f l o w s a nd wo u l d n ot b e e x p e c ted t o r e s u l t i n h i gh P b c on c ent r at i on s

. D u r i n g th e

d a y u n de r c o n v e c t i v e c on d i t i on s

, go o d v e r t i c a l m i x i ng c au s e s po l l u t ed a i r t o r ea c h the g r ou n d. T he

v e r t i c a l m i x i ng a l s o c a u s e s the f l o w to b e c o u p l e d w i th w i nd s a l o f t, wh i c h ge n e r a ll y f l ow t o wa r d t h e e a s t.

A s w a s t h e c a s e f o r S O 2, t he s e a r e the c on d i t i on s e x p e c ted t o l ead to h i g h P b c o n c ent r a t i on s and tha t

a l s o c a r r y the p l u m e ea s t, to w a r d t he Gl o b e H i g h w a y S ta t i o n.

S h o u l d p l a c e m ent o f

ano th e r P b

- T SP m on i to r be p o ss i b l e, E P A s u p po r t s p l a c e m ent we s t o f the s m e l te r

bu i l d i ng

, to c a ptu r e w i n d s m o vi ng e a s t to we s t o v e r t h e s m e l te r

a r ea.

___ _ __ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ __ _ __ __ ___ _ __ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ __ _ G w e n M

. Y o s h i m u r a

Ai r Q u a l i t y A n a l y s i s O ff i c e

E n vi r o n m enta l P r ote c t i on A gen c y

, R e g i o n 9

P h o ne: 415

. 9 4 7.4 1 3 4

E m a il : y o s h i m u r a. g w e n @ e pa. g ov

m a ili ng add r e ss :

U. S

. E n vi r o n m enta l P r ote c t i on A g en c y

Ai r Q u a l i t y A n a l y s i s O ff i c e ( A IR

- 7 )

75 H a wtho r ne S t r ee t

S an Fr a n c i sc o, C A 9 41 05