Comment 1 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Christopher

Last Name: Pearce

Email Address: cppearce@scj.com

Phone Number: 202.331.1186

Affiliation: S. C. Johnson & Son, Inc.

Subject: Approval of South Coast AQMP

Comment:

I will speak on behalf of SC Johnson mainly in support of the

decision to remove control measure CTS-04, relative to LVP-VOCs,

from the AQMP, to encourage the ARB to proceed with the study of

LVPs requested by South Coast, and to offer any assistance SC

Johnson can give to the ARB to ensure completion of an accurate,

science-based study of LVP reactivity.

Attachment: 

Original File Name: 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-09 08:36:29

No Duplicates.
Comment 2 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Harvey

Last Name: Eder

Email Address: harveyederpspc@yahoo.com

Phone Number: (310)3932589

Affiliation: Self & PSPC ( Publis Solar Power Coaliti

Subject: Incorporate by Reference AQMP 2012 SCD In Total +Soc. Econ Study & DEIR/

FinalEIR etc.

Comment:

I hereby rearin incorporate by reference the complete record of the

2012 AQMP in total with all drafts including but not limited to the

DEIR & FEIR & Socio Economic study and all proceedings in the

matter including links etc.. including meetings informal &formal

etc..


 This is comment No. 1 of several. 1/16-13 for self and PSPC the

Public Solar Power Coalition for the SIP. AQMP 2012 SCAQMP/CARB


I question what was or is in the record in the proceedings for the

2012 AQMP etc cited above in total that carb has used and will use

in this proceeding. Attorney for the carb Daniel Whitney


total me on a telephone call at aprx. 4:30 pm Monday 1/14/13 that

the record for the 2012 aqmd ie all related documents , including

references and meetings etc was not part of the record of the carb

1/25/13. If not what is?


 Also Mr Whitney didn't return my call of later in the evening

of 1/15/13 requesting his answer in writing through an email. That

request is made again here now. In addition what is in the record

if not the full record leading to the Dec, 7,2012


SCAQMD 2012 AQMP? Please respond asap.


Solarly, January 17,2013


Thanks, take care


Harvey Eder


and the 


Public Solar Power Coalition (PSPC)


harveyederpspc@yahoo.com


PS I tried vis ve The Notice in this matter as well as throught the

Agenda for electronic service and could not connect on 1/14/13

Monday night and through what was sent to me and the NOTICE 

"ELECTRONIC SUBMITTAL" LAST NIGHT TUESDAY 1/15/13 TO BE WITHIN THE

10 DAYS !? What is the purpose of the 10 day in advance comments

submittal? How does it differ from the submittal date of noon

1/23/13 ? And again what is in/ on the record ?


Attachment: 
Original File Name: 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-16 09:18:28

No Duplicates.
Comment 3 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: David

Last Name: Kelly

Email Address: dkelly@fmiproducts.com

Phone Number: 951-264-8725

Affiliation: Green Fireplace Builders Coalition

Subject: Technology Intevention for Control of PM2.5

Comment:

A large contributor to the poor air quality within the SCAQMD are

existing wood burning fireplaces. PM non-attainment areas in States

like Oregon and Utah are requiring EPA Phase II Qualified wood

burning fireplaces and retro-fit devices to meet there obligations

under the Clean Air Act. Even though new wood burning fireplaces

have been banned within the SCAQMD PM non-attainment area, EPA

Phase II Qualified wood burning fireplace retro-fit devices should

at least be included as a contingency measure in the SIP. These

technologies are considered by Oregon and Utah to be "Beast

Available Control Measures" BACM for wood smoke from fireplaces. 

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/southcoastsip/3-new_epa_retrofit_letter_to_fmi_w_hangtag.pdf

Original File Name: New EPA Retro-Fit Letter to FMI w HangTag.pdf 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-21 07:06:43

No Duplicates.
Comment 4 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: D. Douglas

Last Name: Fratz

Email Address: dfratz@cspa.org

Phone Number: 202-833-7304

Affiliation: Consumer Specialty Products Association

Subject: Comments on Board Item # 13-2-2

Comment:

Please see attached comments with four attachments.

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/southcoastsip/5-cspa_comments_on_arb_agenda_item___13-

2-2_with_attachments.zip

Original File Name: CSPA Comments on ARB Agenda Item # 13-2-2 with Attachments.zip 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-22 12:49:31

No Duplicates.
Comment 5 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Harvey

Last Name: Eder

Email Address: harveyederpspc@yahoo.com

Phone Number: (310)3932589

Affiliation: self & Public Solar Power Coalition 

Subject: a 5 and 10 year Immediate Solar Conversion Plan & Implementation is For 2012

AQMP

Comment:

The comments for Harvey Eder and for Public Solar Power

Coalitionfor the 2012 AQMP. EIR adn Socio Economic Study all drafts

and the Final documents etc are incorporated into the record

herein by reference and responces as well as the Sierra Club (Oct

23,2012) comments and responces. This includes comments submitted

on July 16,17 &18 of 2012, all comments submitted in August and

September, October 21,22,23,24, as well as Nobember 2012 and oral

comments of December 7 2012 and all attachments and references in

comments and responces this also includes the submission of the

1991 AQMP App. IV Solar Hot Water


to reduce 5 Tons of Nox/Ozone per day citing the 1988 conversation

with Harvey Eder/ Public Solar Power Coalition with staff of SCD as

well as the full record of Harvey Eder and PSPC Public Solar Power

Coalition over the past 27 years as well as the record of the

lawsuit filed by the same in 1990, 1991,1992 and or there abouts

for South Coast District Solar Conversion Plan.


 Solar is BACT, BARCT ( best available retrofit control

technology) required by the California Clean Air Act/ and Federal

CCA as well as RACT and LAERIit pays for itself using life cycle

coast analysis and therefor has no cost ( or very low cost ) per

ton /pound of emissions reduced, for green house gas emissions as

well as criteria and toxic emissions. The cost of solar continues

to go down and interest artes are about the lowest ever. Until the

end of 2016 federal tax credits and deductions make solar even

more cost effective ( proposed extensions of the credits for

another 5 years will further help the cost effectiveness ( ACRS

will continue).


 Several parts of the 2012 AQMP are citer in the CARB 21 page

staff report submitted apx 2weeks ago ( so the plan has been

reference into the record by CARB staff already. Harvey Eder's 

comments of last week incorporating all proceedings in the record

in AQMP/ DEIR all drafts and finals as well as meetings


SE Study all drafts and final. Much of this was not available 

timely in the record. Requests were made for hard copies etc which

were late. etc..


 THIS IS COMMENT NUMBER 2 BEFORE CARB THE LAST WAS SUBMITTED

LAST WEEK WITH ANOTHER TO FOLLOW /PLUS


Solarly Harvye Eder & PSPC 1/22/13

Attachment: 
Original File Name: 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-22 17:58:48

No Duplicates.
Comment 6 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Robert

Last Name: Hamilton

Email Address: bob.hamilton@amway.com

Phone Number: 616-485-1047

Affiliation: Amway

Subject: Review of LVP definition and exemption

Comment:

See attached comments

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/southcoastsip/7-arb_sc_board_lvp_comments.doc

Original File Name: ARB SC Board LVP comments.doc 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-23 06:34:07

No Duplicates.
Comment 7 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Michael

Last Name: Tunnell

Email Address: mtunnell@trucking.org

Phone Number: 

Affiliation: American Trucking Associations

Subject: 2012 AQMP

Comment:

Comments attached.

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/southcoastsip/8-ata_comments_on_2012_aqmp.pdf

Original File Name: ATA Comments on 2012 AQMP.pdf 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-23 09:30:18

No Duplicates.
Comment 8 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Lee

Last Name: Wallace

Email Address: lwallace@semprautilities.com

Phone Number: 2132153787

Affiliation: Southern California Gas Co.

Subject: Approval of 2012 South Coast AQMP

Comment:

Support adoption with attached presentation.

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/southcoastsip/9-

socalgas_presentation_carb_adoption_scaqmp_012513.pptx

Original File Name: SoCalGas Presentation CARB Adoption SCAQMP 012513.pptx 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-23 09:44:23

No Duplicates.
Comment 9 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Harvey

Last Name: Eder

Email Address: harveyederpspc@yahoo.com

Phone Number: (310)3932589

Affiliation: self & Public Solar Power Coalition 

Subject: SIP/2012 AQMP Immediate Total Solar Conversion Plan& Immplementation 5-10 yrs

SCD HE/PSPC 

Comment:

This is Comment #3 For CARB on an immediate total solar conversion

plan and implamentation for SCAQMD? STATE OF CA. by Harvey Eder

self & PSPC Public Solar Power Coalition. Attached or in the body

of this comment in the CARB SIP Ozone and PM 2.5 etc plan on the

2012 AQMP SCAQMD meeting 1/25/13 in Diamond Bar


Ca. CARB BD OF Directors


http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-10-25/solar-energy-is-ready-dot-theu-dot-s-dot-isnt#p1


This is the link to the Opening Remarks , Strangling Solar article

by Ken Wells, Page 12 and 13 of the October 29-November 4,2012

Bloomberg Businessweek article on solar conversion "Photovoltaic

power's low cost shouldbe a boon for consumers. Why isn't the U.S.

taking advantage of it ?


with a byline subtitle on page 13 "Realizing solar's potential

requires a smarter national energy policy that takes on entrenched

interests"


The entire 2 page is entered into the record here by reference etc.

This includes the fact "Over the past five years the price of

photovoltaic panels has plummeted 75 percen...Nationally, the cost

of residentialonstallations-including hardware,permits,labor-has

plummeted from $9 a watt in 2006 to $5.46.Averging in commercial

industrial installations, the national installed price plumments to

$3.45 a watt says the Solar Energy Industries Association, a

Washington-based trade group."


Further "many utilities and their political backers are standing in

the way of changes that could boost U.S. energy independence,reduce

carbon emissions and save cousmers billions... Congress should also

extend beyond the 2016 the 30 percent federal solar tax credit for

rooftop installation,then 


gradually phase it out. Five years from now,solar-without

subsidies-will be competitive with conventional power prices in 17

states,and the credit could greatly increase that number ." 


( The Federal Solar Tax credit should be refundable for low and

middle income like the origional solar tan credit in Ca. est. in

the mid to late 70s ) 


 Most solar systems are installed by 3ed party owneds in Ca. at

rates that are lower than the IOUs ( invester owned utilities )

This is no cost but savings per pound/ton of Nox/Ozone and PM 2.5

reduced etc ( GHGs etc)

The Immediate Total Solar Conversion Plan submitted to South Coast

District must be Planed and implemented now as included in the

record. The stated should ficilatate this wiht CARB working with

other agencies through Solar Cal. etc


Solarly, Harvey Eder & PSPC Public Solar Power Coalition 10 am

1/23/13

Attachment: 

Original File Name: 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-23 09:12:08

No Duplicates.
Comment 10 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: James

Last Name: Enstrom

Email Address: jenstrom@ucla.edu

Phone Number: 

Affiliation: University of California, Los Angeles

Subject: Criticism of SCAQMD 2012 AQMP Health Effects

Comment:

My attached January 18, 2013 comments and weblinks on Fine

Particulate Matter Health Effects in the 2012 SCAQMD Air Quality

Management Plan are highly relevant to the South Coast Air Basin

2012 PM2.5 and Ozone State Implementation Plans. 

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/southcoastsip/11-

enstrom_criticism_of_scaqmd_2012_aqmp_health_effects_011813.pdf

Original File Name: Enstrom Criticism of SCAQMD 2012 AQMP Health Effects 011813.pdf 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-23 10:01:14

No Duplicates.
Comment 11 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: James

Last Name: Enstrom

Email Address: jenstrom@ucla.edu

Phone Number: 

Affiliation: University of California, Los Angeles

Subject: Criticism of SCAQMD 2012 AQMP Economic Impacts

Comment:

My attached November 7, 2012 Research Misconduct Complaint Against

California State University Fullerton Professor Jane V. Hall, who

has provided economic justifications for SCAQMD Air Quality

Management Plans (AQMP) during the past 25 years, is highly

relevant to the 2012 AQMP and the South Coast Air Basin 2012 PM2.5

and Ozone State Implementation Plans. 

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/southcoastsip/12-

enstrom_research_misconduct_complaint_re_csuf_hall___brajer_110712.pdf

Original File Name: Enstrom Research Misconduct Complaint re CSUF Hall & Brajer

110712.pdf 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-23 10:01:14

No Duplicates.
Comment 12 for South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) - Non-Reg.

First Name: Timothy

Last Name: French

Email Address: tfrench@emamail.org

Phone Number: 312-929-1970

Affiliation: 

Subject: EMA Comments 

Comment:

The Truck and Engine Manufacturers Association (“EMA”) hereby

submits its comments regarding the California Air Resources Board’s

consideration of the South Coast Air Quality Management Plan

(“AQMP”), and specifically one of the recommended control measures

contained in the South Coast’s State Implementation Plan (“SIP”)

for attaining the federal ozone standard. 

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/prop1b2013/3-

2013_01_25_ema_written_comments_on_air_resources_board.pdf

Original File Name: 2013 01 25 EMA Written Comments on AIR Resources Board.pdf 

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2013-01-24 12:31:06

No Duplicates.
There are no comments posted to South Coast PM2.5 SIP (southcoastsip) that

were presented during the Board Hearing at this time.