## ZUCKERT SCOUTT 6-

## RASENBERGER, L.L.P.

888 Seventeenth Street, NW;Washington, DC 20006-3309 Telephone [202] 298-8660 Fax [202] 342-0683 www.zsrlawcom

CHARLESJ. SIMPSON,JR. DIRECT DIAL (202) 973-7926 cjsimpson@zsrlaw.com August 2, 2010



### BY HAND

Ms. Renee Wright Program Manager, Docket Operations U.S. Department ofTransportation West Building Ground Floor, Room W12-140 1200NewJersey Avenue, SE Washington, DC 20590



### Re: JointResponse ofAll Nippon Airways Co., Ltd., ContinentalAirlines, Inc. and United AirLines,Inc. to Order2010-4-9 (Docket OST-2010-0059)

DearMs. Wright:

In further response to item 17 ofAttachment 2 ofOrder2010-4-9 inthe above-captioned docket, All NipponAirways Co., Ltd. ("ANA") encloses (i) an Englishtranslation ofthe June 18,2010, application filed by ANA with the Ministry ofLand, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism ("MLIT"), as revised and resubmitted onJuly 22, 2010, together with English translations ofdata submitted by ANA to MLIT in connection with the application on July 22, 2010; and (ii) an updated index ofconfidential documents submittedto the Department.

The enclosed documents consist ofconfidential business information and are being providedunder seal in envelopes marked "Confidential TreatmentRequested Under 

### § 302.12." ANA hereby incorporates by reference the December23,2010Motion ofJoint Applicants for Confidential Treatment, and requests confidential treatment ofthe documents produced herewith, for all ofthe reasons set forth in the Motion and in accordance with Order 2009-12-22.

Sincerely,

# ~~;1{~ Charles J. Simpson, Jr. David M. Endersbee Counsel for All Nippon Airways Co., Ltd. --;ZUCKERT SCOUTT b-RASENBERGER, L.L.P.

Ms. Renee Wright August 2, 2010 Page 2

Enclosures

cc: Susan McDermott Todd Homan Peter Irvine Paul Gretch All Parties onthe Attached Service ListCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certifythat I have this date served a copy ofthe foregoing on all persons listed belowby electronic mail:

carl.nelson@aa.com jeffrey.ogar@aa.com recohn@hhlaw.com prrizzi@hhlaw.com sascha.vanderbellen@delta.com sametta.c.bamett@delta.com scott.mcclain@delta.com kquinn@pillsburywinthrop.com bob.kneisley@wnco.com robert.land@jetblue.com howard.kass@usairways.com jhill@dowlohnes.com mcmillin@woa.com matwood@sherblackwell.com rpommer@atlasair.com kevin.montgomery@polaraircargo.com cdonley@ssd.com msinick@ssd.com slachter@lachter-clements.com dvaughan@kelleydrye.com dwight.moore@ustranscom.mil anita.mosner@hklaw.com horanaviation@gmail.com rclayman@geclaw.com ejames@jarnhoff.com cgosain@steptoe.com

DATED: August 2,2010 jrichardson@johnlrichardson.com tom.fosko@airtransport.cc agoerlich@ggh-airlaw.com charters@evergreenairlines.com rsilverberg@sgbdc.com mgoldman@sgbdc.com nssparks@fedex.com anbird@fedex.com efaberman@wileyrein.com mroller@rollerbauer.com benjamin.slocum@usairways.com sophy.chen@hklaw.com dhainbach@ggh-airlaw.com mchopra@jamhoff.com russell.bailey@alpa.org dkirstein@yklaw.com jyoung@yklaw.com pmurphy@lopmurphy.com ldwasko@erols.com bill@mietuslaw.com absteinberg@jonesday.com byerlyjr@state.gov donna.kooperstein@usdoj.gov john.allen@faa.gov wkaras@steptoe.comDOCUMENTSSUBJECTTO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDER RULE12

Index ofAll Nippon Airways Co., Ltd. Confidential Documents Provided with InitialApplication

Document to
Bates Number be Provided Date Custodian Title (DP) or Range Clarification Question (CQ) NHOOOI-0007 September4,2008 CorporatePlanning Impact ofLiberalization in the CQl;CQ15 Aviation Industry: Promoting Open Sky Policy: Structure of International Passenger Business Including Anti Trust Immunity [Japanese Original] NHOO08-0020 September 4, 2008 Corporate Planning Impact ofLiberalization in the CQl; CQ15 Aviation Industry: Promoting Open Sky Policy: Structure of International Passenger Business Including Anti Trust Immunity [English Translation] NH0050-0060 May 28,2009 Corporate Planning; Enhanced Strategic Alliance with CQl Alliance and International Affairs; LH(Eurasia+)**~Based** on the result Marketing and Sales Planning ofJapan-Germany air**talks~** [Japanese Original] NH0061-0072 May 28,2009 Corporate Planning; Enhanced Strategic Alliance with CQl Alliance and International Affairs; LH(Eurasia+)**~Based** on the result Marketing and Sales Planning ofJapan-Germany air**talks~** [English Translation] NH0129-0163 April 25, 2008 Alliance and International Affairs Alliance Committee [Japanese CQ4, CQ9 Original] NH0164-0198 April 25, 2008 Alliance and International Affairs Alliance Committee [English CQ4, CQ9 Translation]

1DOCUMENTSSUBJECTTO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDER RULE12

Document to
Bates Number be Provided Range Date Custodian Title (DP) or Clarification Question (CQ) NH0225-0231 June 17,2009 Corporate Planning Enhanced Alliance among Airlines CQ1 I [Japanese Original] NH0232-0244 June 17,2009 Corporate Planning Enhanced Alliance among Airlines CQ1 [English Translation] NH0250-0266 November 13,2008 Corporate Planning Alliances, Open Skies And CQ1 Antitrust Immunity NH0267-0268 August 31, 2009 Corporate Planning Transpacific Joint Venture and CQ17 Japanese ATI NH0271-0286 August 31, 2009 Alliance and International Affairs Transpacific Joint Venture CQL

- - -- - -

2DOCUMENTSSUBJECT TO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDER RULE12

Index ofAll Nippon Airways Co., Ltd. Confidential Documents Submitted in Response to Order2010-4-9

Bates Number Document Range Date Custodian Title Production Number(s) NH1001-1016 December 11, 2009 Marketing and Sales Planning Enhanced Alliance Partnership CQ16 with UA&CO (Pacific Joint Venture) [Japanese Original] NH1017-1032 December 11, 2009 Marketing and Sales Planning Enhanced Alliance Partnership CQ16 with UA&CO (Pacific Joint Venture) [EnglishTranslation] NH1033-1038 December25, 2009 CorporatePlanning Group Origin: ATI Application CQl, CQ4 and Joint Venture: ANA, CO, and

I UAThree-company JointVenture Efforts [Japanese Original] NH1039-1044 December 25,2009 Corporate Planning Group Origin: ATI Application CQ1, CQ4 and Joint Venture: ANA, CO, and UAThree-company Joint Venture Efforts [English Translation] NH1045-1050 January 14,2010 Corporate Planning; Alliance and Eurasia+ Update [Japanese DP2 International Affairs; Internal Original] Regulatory Affairs; Marketing and Sales Planning NH1051-1056 January 14,2010 Corporate Planning; Alliance and Eurasia+ Update [English DP2 International Affairs; Internal Translation] Regulatory Affairs; Marketing and Sales Planning NH1057 January 28,20010 Marketing and Sales Planning Going Forward Plan: Overall DP2, CQ16 'rimeline for both JV NH1058-1059 January 28, 20010 Marketing and Sales Planning Names & Titles ofPacific JV DP2 (Draft)

- - ---- - - - --



### 3DOCUMENTSSUBJECTTO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDER RULE12



### Bates Number Document Date Custodian Title Production Range Number(s) NH1060-1061 February 26,2010 Corporate Planning Re: Information request by JFTC CQ17 [Japanese Original] NH1 062-1063 February 26, 2010 Corporate Planning Re: Information request by JFTC CQ17 [English Translation] NH1064-1141 February 26, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 1-2, 2-1, CQ17 and 4-1 ofabove letter [Japanese Original] NHl142-1219 February 26,2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 1-2,2-1, CQ17 and 4-1 ofabove letter [English Translation] NH1220 February 26,2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 1-4 of CQ17 above letter [Japanese Original] NH1221 February 26, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 1-4 of CQ17 above letter [EnglishTranslation] NH1222-1223 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Re: Information request byJFTC CQ17 [Japanese Original] NH1224-1225 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Re: Informationrequest by JFTC CQ17 [English Translation] NH1226-1239 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 1-3, 1-5, CQ17 1-6,1-7,2-2,2-3,2-5, and 3-1 of above letter [Japanese Original]l NH1240-1253 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 1-3, 1-5, CQ17 1-6,1-7,2-2,2-3,2-5, and 3-1 of above letter [English Translation] NH1254 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 1-8 of CQ17 above letter [Japanese Original]

1 Version as corrected and re-submitted on May 13,2010.



### 4DOCUMENTSSUBJECTTO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDER RULE12



### Bates Number Document Date Custodian Title Production Range Number(s) NH1255 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 1-8 of CQ17 above letter [English Translation] NH1256-1262 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NH1263-1268 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NHl269-1274 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NH1275-l281 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NH1282-1287 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NH1288-l294 March 5,2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NH1295-l299 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NHl300-1306 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 2-4 of CQl7 above letter NH1307-1312 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NHI313-1320 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 2-4 of CQ17 above letter NH1321-1322 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachmentinregard to 3-2 and 3- March 5, 2010 3 ofabove letter [Japanese Original] NH1323-1324 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 3-2 and 3- March 5,2010 3 ofabove letter [English Translation]

-**-~~~**

5DOCUMENTSSUBJECTTO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDER RULE12

Bates Number Document Date Custodian Title Production Range Number(s) NH1325 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment in regard to 4-2 of March 5, 2010 above letter [Japanese Original] NH1326 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 4-2 of March 5, 2010 above letter [English Translation] NH1327-l450 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 6 ofabove March 5, 2010 letter [Japanese Original] NH145l-1572 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 6 ofabove March 5,2010 letter [English Translation] NH1573-2232 March 5, 2010 Corporate Planning Attachment inregard to 7 ofabove CQ17 letter NH2233-2237 March 19,2010 Corporate Planning ANA Group FY2010-2011 CQ4 Corporate Strategy [Japanese Original] NH2238-2244 March 19,2010 Corporate Planning ANA Group FY2010-20l1 CQ4 Corporate Strategy [English Translation] NH2245 April 1, 2010 Corporate Planning Materials inregard to 4-1 ofprior CQ17 letter [Japanese Original] NH2246 April 1, 2010 Corporate Planning Materials inregard to 4-1 ofprior CQ17 letter [English Translation] NH2247-2248 April 1, 2010 Corporate Planning Materials inregard to 1-3 and 3-4 CQ17 ofprior letter [Japanese Original] NH2249-2250 April 1,2010 Corporate Planning Materials inregard to 1-3 and 3-4 CQ17 ofprior letter [English Translation] NH225 1-2253 April 2, 2010 Corporate Planning Timeline for Eurasia+ and Pacific CQ17 JV [Japanese/English Original] NH2254 April 2, 2010 Corporate Planning Timeline for Eurasia+ and Pacific CQ17

------ ----- JV [EnglishTranslation]

6DOCUMENTSSUBJECTTO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDERRULE12

Bates Number Document Range Date Custodian Title Production Number(s) NH2255 May 2010 

### N/A ANA Confidential Response to CQ8 Clarification Question 8 NH2256-2258L 

### N/A N/A ANA Confidential Response to 

### N/A Evidence Request in Attachment 3

2 Bates range NH2256-2258 is a document describing the methodology used for ANA's data submission. The data submission consists ofa separate file.

7DOCUMENTSSUBJECTTO CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT UNDER RULE12

Index ofAllNippon Airways Co., Ltd. Confidential Documents Submitted on August 2, 2010

Bates Number Document Date Custodian Title Production Range Number(s) NH3001-3059 June 22, 2010 N/A Application to MLIT Pursuantto CQ17 Paragraph 1ofArticle 111 ofthe Civil Aeronautics Act and exhibits [English Translation]

8