5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




//$1  ,//6



	


,9(5 (50,1$/ $,/:$<

203$1<









$)$5*( 25325$7,21






//(*$ 	/$* (&29(5<


1&





!!"#$%&'()"
*+(",	(

%&()"&()"&*+(&+-(%

 012#(&+-+#"'

&3.",5-(6"&

"-+,",#*,+$",54#
 	
	




 




7KH +RQRUDEOH0\URQ + %ULJKW 6HQLRU &LUFXLW -XGJH IRU WKH 8QLWHG

6WDWHV &RXUW RI $SSHDOV IRU WKH (LJKWK &LUFXLW VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ

9"%&"59::	:
#*,9
:




+&-.+(4.,3"






	  +-)"$$" 4 	)"")#* 
: ;
:2$"/"$#*,)+ %&!!"$$#*(+-)#&,:.&6(	<

		;2	=2$"/"$#*, )+ %& !!"$$""
+-)"$$" 4	)"")#* #/+,  
: ; 
: 2 $"/"$#*, )+ %& !!"$$#*(  +-)#&, :.&6(+'(*8 4 4#"> 	<

 		 ; 2	=2$"/"$#*,)+%&!!"$$""







=  9
: +&-.+( 4.,3"  ? &#+$&#,

?&>"&"'!$8",68+/"&"&'+*#$#+$?#8&!&#(+*@+/"&"&'+*#$A.(#+*",+*B.&+"?)"*#$#3!+("C!$,",)" "'!$8"" 6&.3)( #* #-(+* #3#+*( +/"& "&'+*#$.*,"& ()" ","&#$ '!$8"&D +#6+$+(8 -( @A %&,#'#3"%&'()"+&+*B.&+"+/"&"&'+*#$+*(.&*.3)(+*,"'*+%+-#(+* & +* ()" #$("&*#(+/" -*(&+6.(+* %&'#%#&3"&!&#(+*@#%#&3"A#*,$$"3#	$#3"-/"&8
*-@$$"3#A+/"&"&'+*#$#$$"3",()#(()""()+&,!#&(+"?"&"*"3$+3"*(#*,&"!*+6$"%&()""C!$+*
 	
	




 

()"!#&(8&"E.+&",(!#8()"'*"8%#+$",('#>"#3,%#+() "%%&( ( "(($" ()" -#"FGH  )+ "/ ,"I0@A

!#&(8)#'#,"#3,%#+()"%%&(("(($"?)"*+()#

%.$$8 -!"&#(", +* ,+-/"&8 !&-"",+*3 &#(+*#$$8"/#$.#(",+( &+> #*, !("*(+#$$+#6+$+(8 *( #(("'!(",(.**"-"#&+$8,"$#8()"!&-"",+*3#*,'#,"#3,%#+()'*"(#&8"(($"'"*(%%"&&&"!*,",(*"+*3,%#+()	
0 7,770@)+ JA


*#.''#&8-*+,"&#(+*%()"'#(("&?+().(#)"#&+*3

()" ,+(&+-( -.&( ,"*+", !&"B.,3'"*( +*("&"(  )" -.&(&"$+",* 	
!"KJ#(L@)+

!!4#*A%&()"!&!+(+*()#(#)"#&+*3+*(&"E.+&", ?)"&" #* #?#&, #!!"#& .*$+>"$8  )" -.&(,"("&'+*",()#(#%#&3")#,,+!$#8",.%%+-+"*(3,%#+()+*+(/"&#$$6")#/+&,.&+*3()"$+(+3#(+*.-)()#(+(%#+$.&"( '#>" #* %%"& ( "(($" ,+, *( ,+-(#(" #* #?#&, %!&"B.,3'"*(+*("&"( 0 7,#(70@(#(+*3

()#(#!#&(8?+()#3,%#+()6B"-(+/"$8&"#*#6$"6"$+"%()#(+(+*($+#6$"*"",*( "C("*, #'*"(#&8 "(($"'"*(%%"&A

)","-++**((#?#&,!&"B.,3'"*(+*("&"($+"?+()+*

()".*,,+-&"(+*%()"-.&(#

K"-*-$.,"()#(()"

,+(&+-( -.&( ,+, *( #6." +( ,+-&"(+* +* ,"*8+*3!&"B.,3'"*(+*("&"(




--&,+*3$8?"	

()"B.,3'"*(+*#$$&"!"-(

  

7KH +RQRUDEOH 3DWULFLD $ +HPDQQ 

IRU WKH 1RUWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 2KLR WR ZKRP GLVSRVLWLRQ E\ FRQVHQW RI WKH SDUWLHV SXUV

$OOHJD KDG KLUHG /DIDUJH¶V HPSOR\

$OOHJD HPSOR\HHV DIWHU WKH PLGQLJKW FKD

%("&"(($"'"*(%()""'!$8""

.6'+((",+/"&"&'+*#$D()+&,!#*,$$"3#((&+#$68B.&8)"B."&'+*#$M +*,"'*+(8 -$#+' #3#+-.&("*("&",B.,3'"*(%&+/"&#'.*(!$.#((&*"8D%""+*-.&&"'!$8""D $#?.+(  )" -.&( .6"E."*('(+*%&!&"B.,3'"*

#%#&3" #!!"#$ ()" B.,3'

+*,"'*+%+-#(+*,"*($+"##'+/"&"&'+*#$-&#!!"#$%&'+*("&"(K"	



 !

)""/"*(.*,"&$8+*3()+-#"

	"!("'6"&-(6"& *"	(""$@NA)"6$#(%.&*#-"!68!&,.-($#3K)"*()"'$("*% ()" %.&*#-" ()" +&* %$? +&#+$&#,-#&+/"&"&'+*#$?*#*,()"&#+$&#,8("'()#((&#*!$#3&.*+*(#*#,B+*+*3!+(#%#(N*()"*+3)(%	"!("'6"&-*(&#-(?+()N"C!+&",#*,$$"$#3!+(

%("&#"&+"%-#()#%+$$",

-$()")($#3?+()?#("&%&')"&"#&",&#+*+*()"!+((&"'$#3)#-$",()"!+(!"&#(&,
0 	
	




 

/DIDUJH DQG $OOHJD DOVR PRYHG IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW RQ WKH

FRQWULEXWLRQ FODLPV DQG RQ EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLPV UDLVHG E\ 5LYHU7HUPLQDO LQ LWV DPHQGHG WKLUG SDUW\ FRPSODLQW 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW GHQLHGVXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW DV WR FRQWULEXWLRQ EXW JUDQWHG VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW WRERWK /DIDUJH DQG $OOHJD RQ WKH EUHDFK RI FRQWUDFW FODLPV 7KHVH UXOLQJVZHUH QRW UDLVHG DV HUURU

&"#,8+(%&()"*"C("&+"%-#(+*3)"!+('.(6",&86"-#."+(-#*"&.!(+%?#("&+(&#!!",6"*"#())($#3)"'&"?#("&(&#!!",.*,"&()"$#3()"3&"#("&()"$+>"$+),#*,()"'#3*+(.,"%()""&.!(+*

(#!!&C+'#("$8507*-(6"& ()"$#3

!+("&.!(",2+"-"%$#3%$"?()&.3)()"#+&#*,$#*,",*& #&.*, ()" +/"& "&'+*#$ $-'(+/" +* ?)+-) $$#*+$$#*,+-)#&,K&+3)(?"&"?&>+*39()'"*.%%"&",+*B.&+"?)"*()"8,/"(()"%$&%()"$-'(+/"+$$#*, K&+3)( %+$", !"&*#$ +*B.&8 $#?.+( #3#+*( +/"&"&'+*#$.*,"&+$$%+$",)+-$#+'+*%","&#$-.&(OK&+3)(%+$",)+-$#+'+*)+(#("-.&(

+/"&"&'+*#$%+$",()+&,!#&(8-'!$#+*(#3#+*(#%#&3"

#*,$$"3#+*6()$#?.+("">+*3+*,"'*+%+-#(+*%&&-*(&+6.(+*(?#&,#*8$+#6+$+(8+/"&"&'+*#$+*-.&&",%&+$$M &K&+3)(M+*B.&+" 9"%&"(&+#$+/"& "&'+*#$"(($", ?+() +$$ #*, K&+3)(  	)&($8 ()"&"#%("& +/"&"&'+*#$%+$",#*#'"*,",()+&,!#&(8-'!$#+*(+*%","&#$-.&(+*?)+-)+(#,,",()"K&+3)("(($"'"*((()"!"*,+*3%","&#$-.&($+(+3#(+*

+/"& "&'+*#$ #%#&3" #*, $$"3# #$$ '/", %&

.''#&8 B.,3'"*( * ()" +." % +*,"'*+%+-#(+*  )",+(&+-( -.&( ,"*+", #$$ '(+* * ()+ +."  +/"&

"&'+*#$M-$#+'%&+*,"'*+%+-#(+*#*,-*(&+6.(+*?"*(((&+#$6"%&"#B.&8)"B.&8&"(.&*",#/"&,+-(+*%#/&%$$"3# # ( 6() +*,"'*+%+-#(+* #*, -*(&+6.(+* 6.(&"(.&*",#/"&,+-(%&+/"&"&'+*#$*+(+*,"'*+%+-#(+*-$#+'#3#+*(#%#&3")"B.&8%.*,()#(+/"&"&'+*#$)#,*(6""**"3$+3"*(?+()&"!"-((+$$M#*,K&+3)(M

  !&C+'#("$8-#.",+*B.&+"(+("?"&"%&()"-*+,"&#(+*%()"&"B"-(",()"-*("*(+*

#%#&3"#$#&3."()#(()""/+,

*(.!!&(%+*,+*3()#(#%#&3"66&"#-)68#%#&3"-#.",()"+*B.#%#&3" #&3." ()#( ()"&" + * ").$,)#/">*?*#6.(#*8?##$!+*((("(+'*8()#(+("'+*!"-(+*3()"$#3!+(*()"*+3)(()+-#&"-*(+*.",&+3)(.!(()"-?)+-)!+*(#%#&3"M,.(8"C!+&"

$$()""-*("*(+*?"&"&"$/

()"/"&,+-(%()"B.&8)""/+,"*-?#-#.",68()"!&""*-"%+3*()"$#3!+(#%#&3"?#&"!*+6#*,,&#+*+*3%()"!+(.*(+$#!!&C6"%&"+("&.!(",)"B.&8-.$,#%#&3" )#, 6&"#-)", +( ,.(8 ((&#!!",.*,"&)($#3#*,()#(()"K&+3)(M+*B.&+"

)"&"%&"?"&"B"-(#%#&3"M-

,"*(.!!&(()"B.&8/"&,+-(


!#	

+/"& "&'+*#$ #!!"#$ ()" ,+

'(+*%&#*#?#&,%!&"B.,3'"

K)"&" (#(" $#? -$#+' -'" 

.!!$"'"*(#$B.&+,+-(+*()"#?#&"(*(#("$#?
$


J  ,JJ07 @() +& (#(.("!&/+,"()#(!&"B.,3'"*(B.,3'"*(&"*,"&",+*#-+/+$#-(+*P+% .!* '(+* % #*8 !#&(8 ,"("&'+*"#(#)"#&+*3)"$,.6"E
J 	
	




 

*"3$+3"*-" & ()&.3) #-(.#$ >*?$",3" % #,#*3"&. +(.#(+* #*, #-E.+"-"*-" +* ()"-*(+*.#*-"()"&"%

 0,#(77

)+ &.$" #!!$+" )"&" *(?+()(#*,+*3 ()" #6"*-" % #

+,"(&#-> #3&""'"*(  +/"& "&'+*#$ 6"-#'" $+#6$" ( +("'!$8"".*,"&M (#*,#&,% -#&"?)+-) &"E.+&"()#( ()" "'!$8"& !&/+," # #%" !$#-" ( ?&>  
*-*+,"&+*3#%#&3"M.''#&8B.,3'"*('(+*?"'.(/+"?#$$%#-(+*()"$+3)('(%#/$"(+/"&"&'+*#$#>+*3 ()+ /+"? +/"& "&'+*#$ ?#   !#+/"$8

*"3$+3"*( # -'!#&", ( #%#&3"M #-(+/" *"3$+3"*-")"&"%&" ?" -*-$.," ()#( )+ $#? !"&'+( +/"&"&'+*#$M+*,"'*+%+-#(+* #-(+* K" #%%+&'()" ,+(&+-(-.&(M,"*+#$%#%#&3"M'(+*%&.''#&8B.,3'"*(%,+'+#$%()"+*,"'*+(8-$#+'&"/"&()"B.&8/"&,+-(#3#+*(#%#&3"%+*,+*3+(?)$$8$+#6$"%&()"+*B.&+"(()""'!$8""%+/"&"&'+*#$-*%+&'+/"&"&'+*#$D&+3)((+*,"'*+(8	



#%#&3"#$"">(/"&(.&*()"B.&8M%+*,+*3()#(+/"&

"&'+*#$?#*(*"3$+3"*(#*,()#(#%#&3"?#*"3$+3"*(B.&8M,"("&'+*#(+*#(6&"#-)%,.(8#*,!&C+'#("-#."#&"&"/"&+6$"*$8+%()"8#&"P'#*+%"($8-*(&#&8(()"*#(.&#$#*,&"#*#6$"+*%"&"*-"(6",&#?*%&'()""/+,"*-" # ( !&,.-" # &".$( +* -'!$"(" /+$#(+* %.6(#*(+#$B.(+-"H%
	
&$

0, 0 0 @)+ !!  J0A @+*("&*#$ E.(#(+* '#&>'+((",A

#%#&3"$+("/"&#$#%"(8!&"-#.(+*()#(+/"&"&'+*#$

-.$,)#/"(#>"*(!&("-(+("'!$8""#%#&3"#$$"3"()#(+/"&"&'+*#$68!$#-+*3+( &#+$&#,(&#->*"#&()"$#3!+(%#+$+*3(6.+$,)+3)"&?#$$6"(?""*()"$#3!+(#*,()" (&#-> #*, %#+$+*3 ( (&#+* +( "'!$8"" ( &"!*,-&&"-($8+*()" "/"*(% #* "&.!(+*6&"#-)", #,.(8 #*,

  +*B.&+"()#(#%#&3")#,6""**"3+*B.&+" #*, ()#( #%#&3" ?# +*B.&+"

)",+(&+-(-.&("*("&",B.,3'

&"!&""*(", ()" "(($"'"*( #'.#((&*"8 %"" +* ,"%"*,+*3 #3#+$#?.+(+/"&"&'+*#$'/",+*-$.,"!&"B.,3'"*(+*("&"()")""#!!"#$%$$?",




	


)",+(&+-(-.&(,"*+",()".'

#$$()&""!#&(+"#(()"+*,"'*+%,"("&'+*#(+*()#(()"&"?"&"3"*.&"3#&,+*3?)"()"&()"*"3$+3"*-"+$$M #*,K&+3)(M+*B.&+"'
	
0
		 ()" -.&(M ,"*+#$ % #%#&3B.,3'"*((	
)
*!
+& A

#%#&3"#&3."()#(()"6#+%&

(()"B.&8,"*("C+(.*,"&)+)+$#?&"-3*+S"#*+'!$+",-?)"&" ()" (&(%"#& )#&" # -'!#&(+"#*,#&"&"$#(",#('$+#6$" %& ()" ?&*3 -''+((","'!)#+S"+*+(6&+"%()#(()"*)+ -.&( ( '""( ()+ (#*?)$"#$"& #*, &"(#+$"& #6.((+*'.*+-+!#$+(8 +*,"!"*,"*( -*(&#
 	
	




 

7KLV OLVW LV IRXQG LQ VHYHUDO 2KLR VWDWH FRXUW RSLQLRQV EXW QR FDVH

VWDWHV WKDW WKLV OLVW LV H[KDXVWLYH 6HH HJ 0RWRULVWV 0XWXDO ,QV &R Y+XURQ 5RDG +RVS  1(G   2KLR  TXRWLQJ 5H\QROGVY 3K\VLFLDQV ,QV &R RI 2KLR  1(G   2KLR  /RVLWR Y.UXVH  1(G   2KLR  &RFKUDQ Y % 	 2 55 1(G   2KLR $SS  QRWLQJ WKDW WKH UHODWLRQVKLSV LQ WKH OLVWDUH 3H[DPSOHV ́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

7KH 2KLR 6XSUHPH &RXUW ODWHU RYHUUXOHG WKH 7UDYHOHUV GHFLVLRQ LQ

SDUW 6HH 0RWRULVWV 0XWXDO  1(G DW  +RZHYHU WKH SULQFLSOHWKDW DQ LPSOLHG LQGHPQLW\ H[LVWV EHWZHHQ SDUWLHV ZKR DUH SULPDULO\ DQGVHFRQGDULO\ OLDEOH ZDV QRW D EDVLV IRU WKDW GLVDSSURYDO

'#("& #*, "&/#*(  ). #%#&3" -*("*, +* ()"

-+&-.'(#*-")"&"?)"&"*-*(&#-(.#$&"$#(+*)+!"C+(6"(?""*+/"&"&'+*#$#*,#%#&3"+*,"'*+%+-#(+*-#**($+"##'#(("&%$#?K"&"B"-(()+-*("*(+*

)" )+ 	.!&"'" .&( )# &"-3*+S", ()" &+3)( %

+*,"'*+(8#3#+*(()"!&+'#&8(&(%"#&*()"!#&(%*""-*,#&+$8 $+#6$"  PFKG)"&" # !"&* + -)#&3"#6$" ?+()#*()"&D?&*3%.$#-(#*,!#8,#'#3"(()"+*B.&",!#&(8##&".$(()"&"%)")##&+3)(%+*,"'*+(8%&'()"!"&*-''+((+*3()"?&*3%.$#-(()"!#&(8!#8+*3()",#'#3"6"+*3*$8"-*,#&+$8$+#6$"O?)"&"#()"!"&*-''+((+*3()"?&*3%.$#-(+!&+'#&+$8$+#6$"H	#


	
"
$,JJ @)+ 7A


*,"&)+-''*$#?+*,"'*+(8'#8$+"+*%#/&%#

!#&(8?)?#*(#-(+/"$8*"3$+3"*(6.(+**"()"$"'#,"$+#6$".*,"&()"$#?"	
)




, @)+ 07A@(#(+*3()#(#-#"%!&+'#&8#*,"-*,#&8$+#6+$+(8#&+"?)"&"#!"&*P68&"#*%)+

  

0RWRULVWV 0XWXDO FLWHG E\ /DIDU

SDVVLYH QHJOLJHQFH DV LQ WKDW FDVH WKH XQGHU VXEURJDWLRQ ULJKWV DGPLWWHG WKDQHJOLJHQW ́  1(G DW &"$#(+*)+!(()"?&*3,"&&6'#,"$+#6$"AO )"#
  @)+ 00A@(#(+*3()#(!#&(8+)"$,$+#6$"68+*%"&"*-"%%P#-(+/"!#&(+-+!#(+*HAO#!
00, 0@()#($+#6+$+(8+'!",68(#(.("'#+*,"'*+(8?)"&"()"!#&(8$+#6$".!#+/"$8*"3$+3"*(A


*	
$
 0

+& A()+-.&(+*("&!&"(",&"$#("(!#+/"*"3$+3"*-"#+*(#(&(%"#&?)"#-(+/"*""'!$8""#%#&3"#(("'!((,+

()#(()"&#+$&#,6#",+(+*,"'*++,"(&#->#3&""'"*(
*("&!&"(+*3&"E.+&",()+-.&((&.$"?)"()"&.*,"&8"(*$8!#+/"$8*'#8 '#+*(#+* #* +*,"'*+%+-#(+*(&(%"#&)"$,()#(+(--#")#-)#*3",()"!&+*-+!$"#!!

%&',	
(07J!! JA(#(",5

&"!"-+%+-#$$8+*,"'*+(8+

?)+*$8"-*,#&+$8$+#6$!"&*!&+'#&+$8$+#6$"%&!&(#()+&,!#&(8+*B.&",()&.3)-''*,.(+"!"&*+()+&,!#&(8?)"&")+*"3$+3"*B+*?+()#-(+/"*"3$+3"*-"+*B.&8!"&*+!&+'#&+$8