1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 BAIRD , WILLIAM S & GREER , L.L.P
. 6225 NORT H 24

TM STREET , SUITE12

5 PHOENIX , ARIZONA 8501 6 TELEPHON

E(602 ) 256-940 0 

### Daryl M
. William s (004631 ) Attorney s fo

r complainan

t UNITE D STATES DEPARTMEN T OFTRANSPORTATION FEDERA L AVIATION ADMINISTRATION Valle y Aviatio n Services , LLP , a n Arizon a limitedliabilit

y partnership
. Complainant , vs . Th e Cit y of Glendale , a

n Arizon a municipality , Respondent
. No
. 16-09-0 6 Notic e of Errat a t o Respons e t o Motio n t o Dismis s

Come s no w Valley Aviatio n Services , L.L.P. , a n Arizon alimite dliabilit

y partnership , an

d give s notic e tha

t it i s filing herewit

h declaratio n of

Georg e Va

n Houten by wa

y of a n errat ato th e respons e to motio n t o dismis s filedFriday , Octobe r 30 , 2009
. O n pag e 13 , line s tw o throug h fou r of th e respons e t o motio n t o dismis s referenc e i s mad e t o on-the-spot

inspection s made b

y th e cit y a s atteste dby a

n affidavi t o f Georg e Va

n Houten
. Th

e affidavi t dealin g wit

h submitte dfailedto dea

l wit h th e subject

o f on-the-spo t

inspection s wa s inadvertently omitted
. Attache dhereto i s th e declaratio n o f Georg e Va

n Houten dealing wit

h th e subject of on-the-spo t

or unannounce dinspection s a s reference do n pag e thirteen
. Datedthi s 2n

dda y of Novembe r 2009
. yl M

LWilliam s lird , Williams & Greer , LL P 622CNOIS I 

### 24 * Street , Suit e 12 5 Phoenb^Arizon a8501 6 Attorney s fo

r complainan

t

### 1 MAILIN G CERTIFICATIO N

2 Origina l an dthre e copie s delivere dthi s 2n dda y o f Novembe r

200 9 vi acertifie dU.S
. 3 Mail , postag e prepai dto : 4 Offic e o f Chie f Counse l Attn : FA A Par t

1 6 Airport

Proceeding s Docke t 5 AGC-610 , Roo m92 5 Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 6 80 0 Independenc e Ave. , S.W
. Washington , D.C
. 2059 1 7 

### 8 9 I hereb y certif

y tha t I hav e thi s da

y serve dth e foregoin g Notic e o f Errat ao n th e followin g perso n at

th e followin g addres s vi aemai l an dcertifie dU.S
. Mail , postag e prepaid : 1 0 E
. Tazewel l Ellett Willia mL
. Elde r 1 1 Hoga n & Hartson , L.L.P
. Columbi aSquar e 1 2 55 5 13t h St. , N W Washington , D C 2000 4 1 3 wlelder(a),hhlaw.co m Counse l t o th e City o f

Glendale , Arizon a 1 4 1 5 A cop y o f

thi s Notic e o f

Errat aha s been delivere dvi aemai l thi s sam e da y to : 1 6 Mr
. Ton y Garci a Western-Pacifi c Regio n 1 7 Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 1500 0 Aviatio n Blv d 1 8 Hawthorne , C A 9025 0 Anthony.GarciafSl F 1 9 20 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5DECLARATIO N O FGEORG E VA N HOUTE N I , Georg e Van Houten , unde r penalt y o f

perjury , declare : 1
. I hav e bee n involve da s an equity owne r i n th e managemen t

an dth e operatio n o f

th e hangar s presentl y owned'b y Valle y Aviatio n Services , LLP , sinc e th e earl y 1990s
. Durin g that

perio do f time I hav e ha

dmteraction s wit

h the variou s airpor

t managers . Rut

h Fishe r wa s tlie airpor

t manage r up unti l early 1994
. She wa s followe db y a n actin g airpor

t manager , Bruc e Burrows , wh o wa s replace din Decembe r 199 4 b y Jame s McCue
. Mr
. McCue continueda s th e airpor

t manage r unti l 2001 , when Michael Munro e wa s th e actin g aupor t manage r unti l Mar k Ripley becam

e th e manager . Mar

k Ripley serve dunti l 2006 , when Mr
. Munro e becam

e th e actin g manage

r agai n unti l h e was , I a

minformed , fired, andreplace db y Jud y Skeen , th e present

airpor t manager . I hav e ha

dver y Umite dinteractio n wit

h Jud y Skeen
. 2
. Wifl

i the exceptio n o f

Ms
. Skeen , each o f

th e prio r airpor t manager s an

dactin g airpor t managers hav e tol dme tiiey ha dtiie righ t to uispec t ttie hangar s ownedb y Valley Aviatio n a t an y time they chose
. They hav e done so . 3
. The letter

attache da s exhibi t

A was written by Ju n McCue to m y co-owner , Richar dJ
. Smith
. I personally talke dt o McCue about thi s letter , an dh e informedm e tha t he wa s awar e o f non-aviatio n use s i n hangar s becaus e h e hadinspecte dthe mwithout notic e and , as a result , sen t thi s notic e o f

defaul t seekin g to terminat

e ou r lease
. 4
. I t wa s acoupl e o f

week s late

r tha t Mr
. McCue seij t

u s anine-da

y notic e o f

mten t t o inspect all the hangara
. Thi s nine-da y notic e i s attache da s exliibit B
. 5
. Abou t

amont h later , Mr
. McCue wrote th e letter attache da s exhibit

C requirin g tenant s to ope

n their hangar s or

tiie cit y woul dcu

t th e lock s of

f s o th e cit y coul denter

th e hangar s t o do a n inspection
.6
. Unnannounce dinspection s becam e routine
. Indeed , i n 199 9 th e airpor t manage r sen t the lette r attache da s exhibi t

D informing u s th e cit

y ha dth e right t o do on-the-spot inspections
. 7
. The city' s routine , unannounce dinspection s o f ou r hangar s ha s been ongoing sinc e a t leas t 1999
. Tli e variou s airpor

t manager s o

r othe r airpor t employee s hav e com

e t o ou r ofQc e an dannounce dtha

t the y wante dto see particula r hangar s an drequire du s to open tiiemup o n th e spot . W

e hav e alway s complied
. Thi s ha s mean t tha t w e hav e ofte

n cu t tenants ' locks of

f without notic e t o th e tenant

s o th e cit y couldd o a n inspectio n a s demanded
. 8
. Evenhially , it

wa s necessar

y fo r u s t o infor mall o f ou r tenant s tha

t they couldno t put their own . lock s o n th e hangar s becaus e th e cit y demandedon-the-spo t

acces s fo r inspection withou t notice
. The inspection s o f

our hangar s an

dT-shade s occurre dregularly
. Airpor t vehicle s woulddriv e u p anddow n th e hanga r an dT-shade row s lookm

g fo r violations
. They wouldpeer through cracks an

dpartiall y opene ddoor s an dthe n demandtha t w e immediately open th e hangars i f they wer e suspicious
. Thi s wa s aweekly , sometime s daily , occurrence . Date dthi s J£a^da y o f

October , 2009 , Oeorgt J Va n Hpute nI 'l l



# Exhibi t AMr . Richar d J . Smit h

db a Smit h Enterprise s 184 0 Eas t Thux-sto

n Spokane , Washingto n 9920 3 Jun e 15 / 199 5 Dea r Mr . Smith : I t ha s com e t o ou r attentio n tha t certai n hanga r tenant s o f Smit h Enterprise s ar e using .th e lease d premise s fo r purpose s othe r tha t th e storag e an d parkin g o f aircraft . I brin g t o you r attentio n Articl e I I B 3 , o f you r Leas e Agreement , whic h read s i n par t a s follows:"I t i s specificall y. understoo d an d agree d upo n betwee n th e Lesse e ari d Lesso r tha t th e demise d premise s shal l b e use d onl yfo r th e storag e an d parkin g o f aircraf t an d tha t th e genera l publi c shal l hav e th e righ t o f reasonabl e acces s fo r aircraf t transi t throug h th e premesis . Aircraf t maintenance , repair , washing , commercia l operation , o r an

yothe r activit yno t specificall ydescribe d b y thi s agreemen t i s prohibite d unles s prio r writte n approva l ha s bee n grante d byth e Aviatio n Director" . I n particular , tenant s whic h t o ou r knowledg e ar e no t usin g th e lease d premise s fo r purpose s o f storin g o r parkin g aircraf t ar e locate d i n D-11 , D-27 , 1-20 . Th e tenant s i n D-1 1 ar e storin g boxes ; th e tenant s i n B-2 7 hav e sol d thei r aircraft ; th e tenant s i n 1-2 0 ar e storin g A/ C parts . Thi s imprope r us e o f th e lease d premise s mus t cease . I n th e even t anyothe r tenant s ar e usin g th e lease d premise s fo r an ypurposes.othe r tha n the storin g an d parkin g o f aircraft , suc h us e o f th e premise s als o mus t cease . S o tha t ther e i s n o misunderstandin g between , us , th e Cit yha s no t approve d an d doe s no t approv e th e us e o f the lease d premise s excep t a s provide d i fo r i n Articl e I I B 3 . Mr . Smith , sinc e leasing hanga r spac e fo r othe r tha n th e storag e an d parkin g o f aircraf t i s i n direc t violatio n o f you r existin g lease , yo u ar e hereb ynotifie d tha t th e Cit ydeem s yo u t o b e i n defaul t o f you r obligation s unde r th e lease , I.E. : th e obligatio n t o us e the lease d premise s onl yfo r th e storag e an d parking o f aircraft . I f th e defaul t i s no t cure d withi n 3 0 day s o f receip t o f thi s 

### CD0O42O ' " ~ Oil yo l Glerulal o . . , . _ Glendal e Munidpa l Airpor t • 680 1 Nort h Glo n Haito rBlvd
. Suit e 20 1 • Glendale , Arizon a 8530 7 • (602 ) 931-555 5 • FA X D72-127 8notice , Th e Cit yshal l terminat e th e leas e pursuan t t o Articl e

I X A3 . Aa msendin g yo u a copyo f thi s lette r by1s t Clas s mai l i n the even t tha t yo u d o no t accep t you r certifie d mail . Shoul d yo u hav e an yquestions , fee l fre e t o cal l a t an ytime . .Regards , , ^ ' ^

cc : Ke n Martin , Deput yCit yManage r Chri s Ware , Asst . Cit yAttorne y Airpor t Advisor yCommissio n Dea n Stryke r A..A . E . Airpor t Manage r



### CLD042 1

### REC8VE D J'JL 0 5 83 5 GLENQ|t £

Mr . Dea n Stryke r Manage r Glendal e Airpor t Hangar s 663 5 N . Gle n Harbo r Blvd . Glendale , AZ . 8530 7 Jul y3 , 1995 . Dea r Mr . Stryker : A t a recen t meeting o f the Aviatio n Advisor yCommission , the Commissio n directe d tha t Airpor t Managemen t shoul d conduc t an inspectio n o f th e Airpor t Hangars . Unde r Articl e X V o f yo u curren t agreement , an inspectio n i s authorized . Airpor t Managemen t an

d Cit yCod e Enforcemen t personne l wil l conduc t the inspection . I t i s fel t thi s notificatio n wil l allow fo r prope r advanc e plannin g o n you r par t a s w e woul d lik e t o conduc t thi s inspectio n o n Jul y12t h a t 9:0 0 A.M . W e wil l mee t wit h yo u i n you r offic e a t tha t time . Shoul d you . hav e an

yquestions , pleas e fee l fre e t o cal l a t an y time .



## '-^a ^ < 'Jame s J . ftcCue, A.A.E . Ai«por t Manage r cc : Ke n Martin , Dep . Cit yManage r y - Chri s Ware , Asst . Cit yAttorneyv / Stev e Speer , Airpor t Specialis t Richar d Smit h

GLEN027 2 ~ Cll yo f Glendale Glendal e Municipa l Airpor t • 680 1 Nort h Gle n Haito rBlvd
. Suit e 20 1 • Glendale , Arizon a 8S30 7 • <60d ) 93 1 -556 5 • FA X 872-127 8

# Exhibi t

B

## GLENQt e REcavE o j'J i 0 5 m

Mr . Dea n Stryke r Manage r Glendal e Airpor t Hangar s 663 5 N . Gle n Harbo r Blvd . Glendale , AZ . 8530 7 Jul y3 , 1995 . Dea r Mr . Stryker : A t a recen t meeting o f the Aviatio n Advisor yCommission , th

e Commissio n directe d tha t Airpor t Managemen t shoul d conduc t a n inspectio n o f th e Airpor t Hangars . Unde r Articl e X V o f yo u curren t agreement , an inspectio n i s authorized . Airpor t Managemen t an

d Cit yCode Enforcemen t personne l wil l conduc t th e inspection . I t i s fel t thi s notificatio n wil l allow fo r prope r advanc e plannin g o n you r par t a s w e woul d lik e t o conduc t thi s inspection , o n Jul y12t h a t 9:0 0 A.M . W e wil l mee t wit h yo u i n you r offic e a t tha t time . Shoul d yo u hav e an

yquestions , pleas e fee l fre e t o cal l a t an y time . Sincerely , /jame s J . McCue , A.A.E . Airpor t Manage r cc : Ke n Martin , Dep . Cit yManage r ^ Chri s Ware , Asst . Cit yAttorneyv/ ^ Stev e Speer , Airpor t Specialis t Richar d Smith .

GLEN027 2 T Cll y o f Glendal e Glendal e Municipa

l Airport * 680 1 Nort

h Gien Harbor

Blvd
. Suit e 20 1 • Glendale , Arizona8530 7 • {BOi. ) 931-555 5 • FA

X 872-127 8

# Exhibi t

CST E 197 0 PRDF . OFFICE S ID:509-624-500 1 flU6 08'9 5 9:4 8 No.00 2 P.0 4

Augus t 3 , 199 5 ajSS| E

Glendal e Airpor t Hangar a 663 5 N . Gle n Harbo r Blvd . Qlendal e Municipa l Airpor t Glendale , AZ . 8530 7 Attn t Dea n Stryke r Dea r Mr . Stryker i Severa l week a ago , yo u wer e notifie d tha t a n inspectio n o f th e Glendal e Hangar s woul d b e takin g plac e o n a give n da yan d time . However , i £ a hanga r tenan t requeste d a differen t tim e fo r Inspection , w e mad e ever yeffor t t o accommodat e tha t request . T o date , th e respons e ha s bee n favorable , . bu t ther e ar e tenant s tha t hav e no t complie d wit h th e reques t t o ope n hangar s o r hav e disregarde d th e request . A s i t i s necessar yt o infor mth e Aviatio n Advisor yCommissio n of

- th e results , w e mus t cornplet' e th e remainde r o f th e inspection s b yAugus t 16th . Th e hangar s whic h nee d inspectio n are : A-1 , A-7 , A-15 , B-19 , B-22 , D-Xl , D-14 , D-33 , D-24 , 0-86 , I-2WS , 1-4 , 1-7 , 1-8 , 1-21 . Shoul d th e abov e hmigar s no t b e inspecte d b yAugus t 1 6 th , i t wil l b e necessar yt o remov e th e look s t o facilitat e sai d inspection . Also , wit h regar d t o th e inspections , n o on e ha s bee n evicted . Ther e ha s bee n som e misunderstandin g eithe r b yyou r offic e o r som e othe r quarter . However , al l informatio n wil l b e presente d t o th e Aviatio n Advisor yCommissio n an d a reques t fo r approva l wil l b e mad e t o tak e 4 r action s tha t wil l insur e ful l complianc e wit h al l leas e provisions . shoul d yo u hav e an yquestions , pleas e - fee l ..fre e t o cal l a t an y time ,

Jame s J . McCue , A.A.B . Airpor t Manage r cc i Blain e Scruggs , Mayo r .Dr . Marti n Vanacour , Cit yManage r E d Beasley , Asst . Cit yManage r Ke n Martin , Dep . Cit yManage r Chri s Hare ; Asst . Cit yAttorne y Richar d Smit h \/ ^

CIlyofGUendiU e Qtondal * Muntdpa l Airport • 680 1 Nort h Ole n Harbo rBlvd
. Bult o 20 1 • Qlmdalo , Arizon a 8530 7 • (802 ) 931-5S6 5 • FAX 872*127 8

CL0034 6

# Exhibi t

D'©eittMrrSlryke e Soptetttber l i i m

$»'%s§f i ar e #* ^ teriaat s e f

(|l0n^i$!i!yjp0rfHwgWS , yo u ma y \ M t0:eh4ck

mttw i
tjttss|hoi?#;^^adoa:iM ^ A ? yDUf:i^J5fS?sf t $*a^S ? Pennit : biitlitie s

P 0 \s#;;0r e 9Q<JM

> I n addfdoii , d0(fe.^Ctimptoee'tof>fe^tpr5 Wlllsfep b e ^jiakiiig ( ^ to assur e eotai^IiWidB
. StQidda^n-lmyft*j y 4p¥$tiQJ» i fi?^^^ Ifeeei't p < ^ a t aa y time ,

'^Janie aL , N<&rC.t«i

, A
. AJE , AiribortMaftag w esjl<?tt.Ji%&(,D<^ ]

GLg.h|Q3$ § 9tOteratal«»

- SlendrieWunf«iiM*lrj»rit..«.ffW. J NWU l C3l.^.i i HptiC!rllV!d.iute:^O t

.•^endi1(&vAzesjasr»'t^3)-«3P-^Sf l *-Pax(^):^'?^^ ^