----- Forwarded by Melanie King/RTP/USEPA/US on 03/17/2011 09:49 AM

-----

|------------>

| From: |

|------------>

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

 |Kris Noonan <KNoonan@aidea.org> 

|

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

|------------>

| To: |

|------------>

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

 |Melanie King/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA 

|

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

|------------>

| Cc: |

|------------>

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

 |Michael Horowitz/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Chris Mello <CMello@aidea.org>, Steve 

Stassel <sstassel@ak.net> |

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

|------------>

| Date: |

|------------>

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

 |03/16/2011 07:01 PM 

|

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

|------------>

| Subject: |

|------------>

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

 |Addition Information - NSPS Alaska Alternative Implementation Plan 

|

 >---------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------|

Ms. King,
Attached you will find a letter and additional information for the meeting 

scheduled next week in DC with Chris Mello and Steve Stassel.

If you have any questions please let me know.

Kris Noonan

Project Manager

Alaska Energy Authority

907-771-3061

knoonan@aidea.org(See attached file: NSPS Alaska Implementaion Plan.pdf) (See 

attached file: AK Alt Imp Plant - Ruby Chig Pel Fuel Emissions.pdf) (See 

attached file: Emissions OEM data v Tiers-3-15-11-BP-sjs.pdf)(See attached 

file: AK Alt Imp Plan - Kiana RM Shish PM Emissions.pdf)





Annual Fuel Annual Fuel

Hours of Operation Gallons/Hour Consumed Price/Gallon Annual Fuel 

Consumption

Annual fuel cost Consumption 

Over 20 Years

Consumption 

Over 40 Years

(estimate) In Gallons In Gallons In Gallons

Baseline Engine 8760 14.72 $4.00 128,931 $ 515,724.00 2,578,620 5,157,240

After Applied 

Technology

8760 14.72 $4.00 128,931 $ 515,724.00 2,578,620 5,157,240

Annual kWh generated 1663716 kWh/yrTier 3 average fuel efficy 12.9 kWh/gallon 8760 hrs/yrTier 4 average fuel efficy 12.9 kWh/gallon 60000 hrs useful lifeconversion factor 453.6 g/lb estimated JD Brick Mtc Service Costsconversion factor 0.746 kW/HP Mtc Cost ($/trip) interval (hr) Trips/yr $/year Trips/life generator efficiency 92% $9,410 3000 2.92 $27,477 20 $

CO2 per gal of dsl fuel 22.4 lb/gallon

DD S60 D4 6063MK35 324 

$ ‐ Incre

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 3 Std) 

(Tier 2 MK35)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) 

Based on Average Annual 

kW load

Emissions Factor 

(g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 4)

Emissions (lb/yr) 

Based on Average 

Annual kW load

% reduction of 

emissions 

(Tier 4 vs Tier 3)

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost ($/TPY) 

Based on 

Capital Cost (T4-T3) 

(over eng useful life)

Co

An

PM 0.15 802 0.015 80 90.0% 0.36 $0 

PM 0.099 529 0.015 80 84.8% 0.22 $0 $

NMHC+NOx 3.0 16032 0.44 2351 85.3% 6.8

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (lb/gal)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied 

technology Emissions 

Factors (lb/gal)

After applied 

technology (lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost per Ton

CO2 22.4 2888054 22.4 2888054 0% 0.0 #DIV/0! Base

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Pollutant Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied technology 

(lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Pounds/Year 

Reduced

Tons reduced over 

20 year lifetime

Tons reduced over 

40 years.

PM 802 80 90.0% 721 7.2 14.4

NMHC+NOx 16,032 2351 85.3% 13,681 136.8 273.6

CO2 2888054 2888054 0.0% 0 0 0

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Emmission Calculations for Power Generation ‐ Annual, 20 yr life and 40 year life savings

AVEC Kiana

FUEL DATA AND EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

Annual Emmission Calculations for Power Generation

Power Generation Fuel Consumption
Annual Fuel Annual Fuel

Hours of Operation Gallons/Hour Consumed Price/Gallon Annual Fuel 

Consumption

Annual fuel cost Consumption 

Over 20 Years

Consumption 

Over 40 Years

(estimate) In Gallons In Gallons In Gallons

Baseline Engine 8760 8.82 $4.00 77,297 $ 309,188.00 1,545,940 3,091,880

After Applied 

Technology

8760 8.82 $3.00 77,297 $ 231,891.00 1,545,940 3,091,880

Annual kWh generated 1083914 kWh/yrTier 3 average fuel efficy 14.0 kWh/gallon 8760 hrs/yrTier 4 average fuel efficy 14.0 kWh/gallon 60000 hrs useful lifeconversion factor 453.6 g/lb estimated JD Brick Mtc Service Costsconversion factor 0.746 kW/HP Mtc Cost ($/trip) interval (hr) Trips/yr $/year Trips/engine life $generator efficiency 92% $13,700 5000 1.75 $24,002 12 

CO2 per gal of dsl fuel 22.4 lb/gallon

DD S60 K4c 6063TK35 363 

$ 15,000 Incr

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 3 Std) 

(Tier 1 TK35)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) 

Based on Average Annual 

kW load

Emissions Factor 

(g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 4)

Emissions (lb/yr) 

Based on Average 

Annual kW load

% reduction of 

emissions 

(Tier 4 vs Tier 3)

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost ($/TPY) 

Based on 

Capital Cost (T4-T3) 

(over eng useful life)

C

A

PM 0.15 522 0.015 52 90.0% 0.24 $9,118 

PM 0.031 108 0.015 52 51.6% 0.03 $76,932 

NMHC+NOx 3.0 10445 0.44 1532 85.3% 4.5

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (lb/gal)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied 

technology Emissions 

Factors (lb/gal)

After applied 

technology (lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost per Ton

CO2 22.4 1731453 22.4 1731453 0% 0.0 #DIV/0! Bas

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Pollutant Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied technology 

(lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Pounds/Year 

Reduced

Tons reduced over 

20 year lifetime

Tons reduced over 

40 years.

PM 522 52 90.0% 470 4.7 9.4

NMHC+NOx 10,445 1532 85.3% 8,913 89.1 178.3

CO2 1731453 1731453 0.0% 0 0 0

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Emmission Calculations for Power Generation ‐ Annual, 20 yr life and 40 year life savings

AVEC Russian Mission

FUEL DATA AND EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

Annual Emmission Calculations for Power Generation

Power Generation Fuel Consumption
Annual Fuel Annual Fuel

Hours of Operation Gallons/Hour Consumed Price/Gallon Annual Fuel 

Consumption

Annual fuel cost Consumption 

Over 20 Years

Consumption 

Over 40 Years

(estimate) In Gallons In Gallons In Gallons

Baseline Engine 8760 14.00 $3.50 122,635 $ 429,222.50 2,452,700 4,905,400

After Applied 

Technology

8760 14.00 $3.50 122,635 $ 429,222.50 2,452,700 4,905,400

Annual kWh generated 1676848 kWh/yrTier 3 average fuel efficy 13.7 kWh/gallon 8760 hrs/yrTier 4 average fuel efficy 13.7 kWh/gallon 60000 hrs useful lifeconversion factor 453.6 g/lb estimated JD Brick Mtc Service Costsconversion factor 0.746 kW/HP Mtc Cost ($/trip) interval (hr) Trips/yr $/year Trips/engine life $generator efficiency 92% $15,200 5000 1.75 $26,630 12 

CO2 per gal of dsl fuel 22.4 lb/gallon

DD S60 K4c 6063TK35 363 

$ 15,000 Incr

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 3 Std) 

(Tier 1 TK35)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) 

Based on Average Annual 

kW load

Emissions Factor 

(g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 4)

Emissions (lb/yr) 

Based on Average 

Annual kW load

% reduction of 

emissions 

(Tier 4 vs Tier 3)

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost ($/TPY) 

Based on 

Capital Cost (T4-T3) 

(over eng useful life)

C

A

PM 0.15 808 0.015 81 90.0% 0.36 $5,894 

PM 0.035 189 0.015 81 57.1% 0.05 $39,783 

NMHC+NOx 3.0 16159 0.44 2370 85.3% 6.9

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (lb/gal)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied 

technology Emissions 

Factors (lb/gal)

After applied 

technology (lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost per Ton

CO2 22.4 2747024 22.4 2747024 0% 0.0 #DIV/0! Bas

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Pollutant Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied technology 

(lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Pounds/Year 

Reduced

Tons reduced over 

20 year lifetime

Tons reduced over 

40 years.

PM 808 81 90.0% 727 7.3 14.5

NMHC+NOx 16,159 2370 85.3% 13,789 137.9 275.8

CO2 2747024 2747024 0.0% 0 0 0

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Emmission Calculations for Power Generation ‐ Annual, 20 yr life and 40 year life savings

AVEC Shishmaref

FUEL DATA AND EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

Annual Emmission Calculations for Power Generation

Power Generation Fuel Consumption
Annual Fuel Annual Fuel

Hours of Operation Gallons/Hour Consumed Price/Gallon Annual Fuel 

Consumption

Annual fuel cost Consumption 

Over 20 Years

Consumption 

Over 40 Years

(estimate) In Gallons In Gallons In Gallons

Baseline Engine 8760 5.71 $4.00 50,000 $ 200,000.00 1,000,000 2,000,000

After Applied 

Technology

8760 4.57 $4.00 40,000 $ 160,000.00 800,000 1,600,000

Annual kWh generated 568000 kWh/yrTier 3 average fuel efficy 11.4 kWh/gallon 8760 hrs/yrTier 4 average fuel efficy 14.2 kWh/gallon 60000 hrs useful lifeconversion factor 453.6 g/lb estimated JD Brick Mtc Service Costsconversion factor 0.746 kW/HP Mtc Cost ($/trip) interval (hr) Trips/yr $/year Trips/life generator efficiency 92% $9,410 3000 2.92 $27,477 20 

CO2 per gal of dsl fuel 22.4 lb/gallon

John Deere 4045HF485 123 

$ 10,000 Incr

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 3)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) 

Based on Average Annual 

kW load

Emissions Factor 

(g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 4)

Emissions (lb/yr) 

Based on Average 

Annual kW load

% reduction of 

emissions 

(Tier 4 vs Tier 3)

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost ($/TPY) 

Based on 

Capital Cost (T4-T3) 

(over eng useful life)

C

A

PM 0.15 274 0.015 27 90.0% 0.12 $11,600 

NMHC+NOx 3.0 5474 0.44 803 85.3% 2.3

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (lb/gal)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied 

technology Emissions 

Factors (lb/gal)

After applied 

technology (lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost per Ton

CO2 22.4 1120000 22.4 896000 20% 112.0 $ 89 Bas

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Pollutant Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied technology 

(lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Pounds/Year 

Reduced

Tons reduced over 

20 year lifetime

Tons reduced over 

40 years.

PM 274 27 90.0% 246 2.5 4.9

NMHC+NOx 5,474 803 85.3% 4,671 46.7 93.4

CO2 1120000 896000 20.0% 224000 2,240 4,480

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Emmission Calculations for Power Generation ‐ Annual, 20 yr life and 40 year life savings

RUBY RPSU PROJECT

FUEL DATA AND EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

Annual Emmission Calculations for Power Generation

Power Generation Fuel Consumption
Annual Fuel Annual Fuel

Hours of Operation Gallons/Hour Consumed Price/Gallon Annual Fuel 

Consumption

Annual fuel cost Consumption 

Over 20 Years

Consumption 

Over 40 Years

(estimate) In Gallons In Gallons In Gallons

Baseline Engine 8760 6.70 $3.00 58,694 $ 176,082.00 1,173,880 2,347,760

After Applied 

Technology

8760 6.70 $3.00 58,694 $ 176,082.00 1,173,880 2,347,760

Annual kWh generated 805661 kWh/yrTier 3 average fuel efficy 13.7 kWh/gallon 8760 hrs/yrTier 4 average fuel efficy 13.7 kWh/gallon 60000 hrs useful lifeconversion factor 453.6 g/lb estimated JD Brick Mtc Service Costsconversion factor 0.746 kW/HP Mtc Cost ($/trip) interval (hr) Trips/yr $/year Trips/engine life $generator efficiency 92% $13,700 5000 1.75 $24,002 12 

CO2 per gal of dsl fuel 22.4 lb/gallon

John Deere 6090HF485 229 

$ 15,000 Incr

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 3)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) 

Based on Average Annual 

kW load

Emissions Factor 

(g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 4)

Emissions (lb/yr) 

Based on Average 

Annual kW load

% reduction of 

emissions 

(Tier 4 vs Tier 3)

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost ($/TPY) 

Based on 

Capital Cost (T4-T3) 

(over eng useful life)

C

A

PM 0.15 388 0.015 39 90.0% 0.17 $12,267 

NMHC+NOx 3.0 7764 0.44 1139 85.3% 3.3

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (lb/gal)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied 

technology Emissions 

Factors (lb/gal)

After applied 

technology (lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost per Ton

CO2 22.4 1314746 22.4 1314746 0% 0.0 #DIV/0! Bas

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Pollutant Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied technology 

(lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Pounds/Year 

Reduced

Tons reduced over 

20 year lifetime

Tons reduced over 

40 years.

PM 388 39 90.0% 349 3.5 7.0

NMHC+NOx 7,764 1139 85.3% 6,625 66.3 132.5

CO2 1314746 1314746 0.0% 0 0 0

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Emmission Calculations for Power Generation ‐ Annual, 20 yr life and 40 year life savings

CHIGNIK RPSU PROJECT

FUEL DATA AND EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

Annual Emmission Calculations for Power Generation

Power Generation Fuel Consumption
Annual Fuel Annual Fuel

Hours of Operation Gallons/Hour Consumed Price/Gallon Annual Fuel 

Consumption

Annual fuel cost Consumption 

Over 20 Years

Consumption 

Over 40 Years

(estimate) In Gallons In Gallons In Gallons

Baseline Engine 8760 7.79 $3.50 68,249 $ 238,871.50 1,364,980 2,729,960

After Applied 

Technology

8760 7.79 $3.50 68,249 $ 238,871.50 1,364,980 2,729,960

Annual kWh generated 954351 kWh/yrTier 3 average fuel efficy 14.0 kWh/gallon 8760 hrs/yrTier 4 average fuel efficy 14.0 kWh/gallon 60000 hrs useful lifeconversion factor 453.6 g/lb estimated JD Brick Mtc Service Costsconversion factor 0.746 kW/HP Mtc Cost ($/trip) interval (hr) Trips/yr $/year Trips/engine life $generator efficiency 92% $15,200 5000 1.75 $26,630 12 

CO2 per gal of dsl fuel 22.4 lb/gallon

John Deere 6135HF485 372 

$ 20,000 Incr

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 3)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) 

Based on Average Annual 

kW load

Emissions Factor 

(g/bhp-hr) 

(Tier 4)

Emissions (lb/yr) 

Based on Average 

Annual kW load

% reduction of 

emissions 

(Tier 4 vs Tier 3)

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost ($/TPY) 

Based on 

Capital Cost (T4-T3) 

(over eng useful life)

C

A

PM 0.15 460 0.015 46 90.0% 0.21 $13,808 

NMHC+NOx 3.0 9197 0.44 1349 85.3% 3.9

Pollutant Baseline Emissions 

Factor (lb/gal)

Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied 

technology Emissions 

Factors (lb/gal)

After applied 

technology (lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Tons/Year 

Reduced

Cost per Ton

CO2 22.4 1528778 22.4 1528778 0% 0.0 #DIV/0! Bas

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Pollutant Baseline Use (lb/yr) After applied technology 

(lb/yr)

% reduction of 

emissions

Pounds/Year 

Reduced

Tons reduced over 

20 year lifetime

Tons reduced over 

40 years.

PM 460 46 90.0% 414 4.1 8.3

NMHC+NOx 9,197 1349 85.3% 7,848 78.5 157.0

CO2 1528778 1528778 0.0% 0 0 0

VOC*

* VOC Calculation unknown

Emmission Calculations for Power Generation ‐ Annual, 20 yr life and 40 year life savings

PELICAN RPSU PROJECT

FUEL DATA AND EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

Annual Emmission Calculations for Power Generation

Power Generation Fuel Consumption
fuel (lb/gal) Fuel (Btu/lbm)

7.1 20500

10% 25% 50% 75% 100% (g/bhp-hr)

Output (bhp) 0 154.25 308.5 462.75 617

NR Tier IV PM Std 0.00 2.3 4.6 6.9 9.3 0.015NR Tier 3 PM Std 0.00 23.14 46.28 69.41 92.55 0.15

NR Tier 0 PM Std 0.0 61.7 123.4 185.1 246.8 0.4

AP-42 Std (<600HP) 0.0 153.9 307.9 461.8 615.7 0.998

JD 4045HF485, 4.5L, 197 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 3 Stdby

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

197 0.92 135 6.0 129 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 49.3 98.5 147.8 197.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 33.8 67.6 101.4 135.2Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 0 19.4 35.1 52 69.4Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 2.73 4.94 7.32 9.77Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 12.4 13.7 13.8 13.8

JD 6068HF485, 6.8L, 315 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 3 Stdby

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

315 0.92 216 13.0 203 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 78.8 157.5 236.3 315.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 54.0 108.1 162.1 216.2Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 0 30.3 56.2 80.4 109.7Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 4.27 7.92 11.32 15.45Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 12.7 13.7 14.3 14.0

JD 6090HF485, 9.0L, 385 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 3 Stdby

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

385 0.92 264 15.8 248 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 96.3 192.5 288.8 385.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 66.1 132.1 198.2 264.2Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 0 35.94 65.48 96.56 127.87Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 5.06 9.22 13.60 18.01Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 13.0 14.3 14.6 14.7

JD 6135HF485, 13.5L, 617 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 3 Stdby

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

617 0.92 423 23.3 400 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 154.3 308.5 462.8 617.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 105.9 211.7 317.6 423.5Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 0 59.5 108 156.5 216.9Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 8.38 15.21 22.04 30.55Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 12.6 13.9 14.4 13.9

John Deere NOx Emissions Tier 3

0

0.20.40.60.8

1

0 100 200 300 400 500

bhp

NOx (g/hr)

JD 4045BHP @ JD 6068BHP @ JD 6090BHP @ 

John Deere Fuel Economy Tier 3

12.012.513.013.514.014.515.0

0 200 400 600

bhp

kwh/gal

JD 404BHP @ JD 606BHP @ JD 609BHP @ JD 613BHP @ 

John Deere PM Emissions Tier 3

0

20406080

100

0 200 400 600 800

bhp

PM (g/hr)

NR TieNR TieJD 609BHP @ JD 606BHP @ NR Tie
fuel (lb/gal) Fuel (Btu/lbm)

7.1 20500

10% 25% 50% 75% 100% (g/bhp-hr)

Output (bhp) 0 154.25 308.5 462.75 617

NR Tier IV PM Std 0.00 2.3 4.6 6.9 9.3 0.015NR Tier 3 PM Std 0.00 23.14 46.28 69.41 92.55 0.15

NR Tier 0 PM Std 0.0 61.7 123.4 185.1 246.8 0.4

AP-42 Std (<600HP) 0.0 153.9 307.9 461.8 615.7 0.998

JD 4045TFM75, 4.5L, 98BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2 Prime

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

98 0.92 67 0.0 67 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 24.5 49.0 73.5 98.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 16.8 33.6 50.4 67.3Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 10.65 19.88 28.4 36.92Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 1.50 2.80 4.00 5.20Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 11.2 12.0 12.6 12.9

JD 6068TFM75, 6.8L, 148BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2 Prime

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

148 0.92 102 0.0 102 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 37.0 74.0 111.0 148.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 25.4 50.8 76.2 101.6Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 0 17.04 29.11 42.6 55.38Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 2.40 4.10 6.00 7.80Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 10.6 12.4 12.7 13.0

JD 6090SFM75 9.0L, 373BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2 Prime

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

373 0.92 256 0.0 256 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 93.3 186.5 279.8 373.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 64.0 128.0 192.0 256.0Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 0 37.63 68.16 99.4 130.64Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 5.30 9.60 14.00 18.40Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 12.1 13.3 13.7 13.9

JD 6135SFM75 13.5L, 558BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2 Prime

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/ fan Rated

558 0.92 383 0.0 383 output

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 0.0 139.5 279.0 418.5 558.0Electric Output (kW) 0.0 95.7 191.5 287.2 383.0Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/hr) 0 56.09 102.95 149.1 195.96Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 0.00 7.90 14.50 21.00 27.60Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 0.0 12.1 13.2 13.7 13.9

John Deere Marine NOx Emissions Tier 3

0

0.20.40.60.8

1

0 100 200 300 400

bhp

NOx (g/hr)

JD 4045T98BHP @ JD 6068T148BHP 2JD 6090S373BHP 2

John Deere Marine Fuel Economy Tier 3

10.011.012.013.014.015.0

0 200 400 600

bhp

kwh/gal

JD 4045T@ 1800 RJD 6068T@ 1800 RJD 6090S@ 1800 RJD 6135S558BHP 

John Deere Marine PM Emissions Tier 3

0

20406080

100

0 200 400 600 800

bhp

PM (g/hr)

NR Tier NR Tier JD 6090373BHP JD 6068148BHP NR Tier 
John Deere Fuel Economy Tier 2 Marine & Tier 3 NR

10.010.511.011.512.012.513.013.514.014.515.0

0 100 200 300 400 500 

bhp

kwh/gal

JD 4045TFM75, 4.5L, 98BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2JD 4045HF485, 4.5L, 197 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 3JD 6068TFM75, 6.8L, 148BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2JD 6068HF485, 6.8L, 315 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 3JD 6090SFM75 9.0L, 373BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2JD 6090HF485, 9.0L, 385 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 3JD 6135SFM75 13.5L, 558BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier JD 6135HF485, 13.5L, 617 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 
fuel (lb/gal) Fuel (Btu/lbm)

6.99 20500

10% 25% 50% 75% 100% (g/bhp-hr)

Output (bhp) 55 137.5 275 412.5 550 Tier IV

NR Tier IV PM Std 0.83 2.1 4.1 6.2 8.3 0.015

NR Tier 3 PM Std 8.25 20.63 41.25 61.88 82.50 0.15

NR Tier 0 PM Std 22.0 55.0 110.0 165.0 220.0 0.4

AP-42 Std (<600HP) 54.9 137.2 274.4 411.6 548.9 0.998

DD Series 60, 6063GK05, 12.7L, 475 BHP (Prime) @ 1800 RPM, Tier 0

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): Rated

475 0.925 328 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 47.5 118.8 237.5 356.3 475.0Electric Output (kW) 32.8 81.9 163.9 245.8 327.8Particulates (g/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/hr) 674 760 1245 1725 2200 estimated

NOx (g/bhp-hr) 14.19 6.40 5.24 4.84 4.63Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 6.10 11.00 15.90 21.00Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 13.4 14.9 15.5 15.6

DD Series 60, 6063TK35, 12.7L, 550 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 1 Tier 1

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): Rated

550 0.925 380 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 55.0 137.5 275.0 412.5 550.0Electric Output (kW) 38.0 94.9 189.8 284.6 379.5Particulates (g/hr) 6.6 4.2 9.6 7.8 17Particulates (g/bhp-hr) 0.120 0.031 0.035 0.019 0.031 0.03NOx (g/hr) 674 1270 1685 2530 2710NOx (g/bhp-hr) 12.25 9.24 6.13 6.13 4.93 6.63

Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr) 0.465 0.341 0.315 0.314 0.33Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 3.66 6.71 12.39 18.53 25.97Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 10.4 14.1 15.3 15.4 14.6

DD Series 60, 6063MK35, 12.7L, 490 BHP @ 1800 RPM, Tier 2 Tier 2

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): Rated

490 0.925 338 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 49.0 122.5 245.0 367.5 490.0Electric Output (kW) 33.8 84.5 169.1 253.6 338.1Particulates (g/hr) 18.7 26.4 24.2 17.4 28.7Particulates (g/bhp-hr) 0.382 0.216 0.099 0.047 0.059 0.098NOx (g/hr) 296 483 962 1625 2825

NOx (g/bhp-hr) 6.04 3.94 3.93 4.42 5.77 4.3Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr) 0.539 0.389 0.349 0.344 0.335Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 3.78 6.82 12.23 18.09 23.48Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 8.9 12.4 13.8 14.0 14.4

DD Series 60 NOx Emissi

0

500

10001500200025003000

0 200 400 

bhp

NOx (g/hr)

DD Series 60 Fuel Econ

5.07.09.0

11.013.015.017.0

0 100 200 300 400 500 

bhp

kwh/gal

DD Series 60 PM Emiss

0

20406080

100

0 100 200 300 400 500 

bhp

PM (g/hr)
DD Series 60 PM Emissions Tier 0 to 2

0.0

50.0

100.0150.0200.0250.0300.0

0 100 200 300 400 500 

bhp

PM (g/hr)

AP-42 Std (<600HP)NR Tier 0 PM StdNR Tier 3 PM StdDD Series 60, 6063MK35, 12.7L, 490 BHDD Series 60, 6063TK35, 12.7L, 550 BHP NR Tier IV PM Std
fuel (lb/gal) Fuel (Btu/lbm 1 lb

6.99 20500 453.6

10% 25% 50% 75% 100% (g/bhp-hr)

Output (bhp) 215.0 537.0 1075.0 1612.0 2150.0 Tier IV

NR Tier IV PM Std 3.23 8.1 16.1 24.2 32.3 0.015

NR Tier 0 PM Std 86.0 214.8 430.0 644.8 860.0 0.4

AP-42 Std (>600HP) 68.3 170.5 341.3 511.8 682.7 0.318

CAT 3456, Low BSFC, 691HP @ 1800 rpm, Tier 0 Tier 0

BHP gen effy kW w/fan fan kW w/o fan Rated

691 0.924 455 21 476 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 95.1 193.6 352.4 515.2 690.6Electric Output (kW) 66.5 134.8 248.7 362.5 476.3Particulates (lb/hr) 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.06 0.07Particulates (g/hr) 22.7 22.7 22.7 27.2 31.8Particulates (g/bhp-hr) 0.238 0.117 0.064 0.053 0.046NOx (lb/hr) 2.8 5.1 10.3 10.5 9.3NOx (g/hr) 1261.0 2317.9 4681.2 4780.9 4213.9NOx (g/bhp-hr) 13.3 12.0 13.3 9.3 6.1Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 5.70 9.60 16.00 23.00 32.50Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 11.7 14.0 15.5 15.8 14.7

CAT 3512B, Low BSFC, 1478HP @ 1200 rpm, Tier 0 Tier 0

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/o fan Rated

1478 0.952 1015 35 1050 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 206.8 426.4 774.0 1125.5 1477.7Electric Output (kW) 136.5 288.7 542.3 796.0 1049.7Particulates (lb/hr) 0.09 0.11 0.14 0.19 0.26Particulates (g/hr) 40.8 49.9 63.5 86.2 117.9Particulates (g/bhp-hr) 0.197 0.117 0.082 0.077 0.080NOx (lb/hr) 6.7 11.8 20.2 27.7 33.3NOx (g/hr) 3039.1 5361.6 9180.9 12573.8 15091.3NOx (g/bhp-hr) 14.70 12.57 11.86 11.17 10.21Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 13.50 22.70 37.30 52.70 70.20Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 10.1 12.7 14.5 15.1 15.0

CAT 3512C, 1476HP @ 1200 rpm, Tier II Tier 2

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/o fan Rated

1476 0.954 1015 35 1050 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 155.0 381.0 741.0 1106.0 1476.0Electric Output (kW) 102.3 257.9 519.2 782.2 1048.5Particulates (lb/hr) 0.17 0.17 0.13 0.05 0.09Particulates (g/hr) 77.1 77.1 59.0 22.7 40.8Particulates (g/bhp-hr) 0.497 0.202 0.080 0.021 0.028 0.2NOx (lb/hr) 2.02 3.48 7.27 12.48 20.17NOx (g/hr) 916.3 1578.5 3297.7 5660.9 9149.1NOx (g/bhp-hr) 5.91 4.14 4.45 5.12 6.20Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 10.8 21.2 37.2 53.2 69.5Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 9.5 12.2 14.0 14.7 15.1

CAT NOx Emissions T

0

5000

10000150002000025000

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2

bhp

NOx (g/hr)

CAT PM Emissions 

0

200400600800

1000

0 500 1000 1500 2000 

bhp

PM (g/hr)
CAT 3516B, Low BSFC, 1843HP @ 1200 rpm, Tier 0 Tier 0

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/o fan Rated

1842.8 0.962 1285 37 1322 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 241.2 518.6 955.7 1397.5 1842.8Electric Output (kW) 165.5 358.4 679.7 1001.1 1322.5Particulates (lb/hr) 0.09 0.11 0.15 0.21 0.29Particulates (g/hr) 40.8 49.9 68.0 95.3 131.5Particulates (g/bhp-hr) 0.169 0.096 0.071 0.068 0.071NOx (lb/hr) 10.66 19.12 31.11 41.79 50.12NOx (g/hr) 4835.4 8672.8 14111.5 18955.9 22734.4NOx (g/bhp-hr) 20.05 16.72 14.77 13.56 12.34Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 15.60 26.80 44.70 63.70 84.80Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 10.6 13.4 15.2 15.7 15.6

CAT 3516C, 2150HP @ 1200 rpm, Tier II Tier 2

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/o fan Rated

2150 0.962 1506 37 1543 output

10% 25% 50% 75% 100%

Output (bhp) 215.0 537.0 1075.0 1612.0 2150.0Electric Output (kW) 147.6 371.1 764.6 1154.8 1543.0Particulates (lb/hr) 0.19 0.32 0.30 0.15 0.24Particulates (g/hr) 86.2 145.2 136.1 68.0 108.9Particulates (g/bhp-hr) 0.401 0.270 0.127 0.042 0.051 0.2NOx (lb/hr) 2.75 5.11 10.47 16.82 30.81NOx (g/hr) 1247.4 2317.9 4749.2 7629.6 13975.4NOx (g/bhp-hr) 5.80 4.32 4.42 4.73 6.50Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) 16.75 31.86 56.72 83.08 106.17Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) 8.8 11.6 13.5 13.9 14.5

CAT C27, 725 ekW @ 1800 rpm, Tier IV Interim Teir 4i

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/o fan Rated

1049 0.962 725 28 753 output Fan kW is SWAG

10% 25% 50% 75% 100% HP is calculated from kW w/o fan

Output (bhp) 104.9 262.3 524.6 786.9 1049.3 PM data not givenElectric Output (kW) 72.0 181.3 373.1 563.7 753.0 NOX info not givenParticulates (lb/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Particulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (lb/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) not avail not avail 28.7 40.2 53.5Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) #VALUE! #VALUE! 13.0 14.0 14.1

CAT Fuel Economy Tier 0 to 4i

89

10111213141516

0 500 1000 1500 

bhp

kwh/gal

CAT 3456, Low BSFCAT 3512B, Low BSCAT 3512C, 1476HCAT 3516B, Low BSCAT 3516C, 2150HCAT C27, 725 ekW CAT C27, 700 ekW CAT C15 500 ekW 
CAT C27, 700 ekW @ 1800 rpm, Tier II Teir 2

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/o fan Rated

1014 0.962 700 28 728 output Fan kW is SWAG

10% 25% 50% 75% 100% HP is calculated 

Output (bhp) 101.4 253.6 507.2 760.8 1014.4 PM data not givenElectric Output (kW) 69.6 175.3 360.8 545.0 728.0 NOX info not givenParticulates (lb/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Particulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (lb/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) not avail not avail 28.9 39.3 50.3Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) #VALUE! #VALUE! 12.5 13.9 14.5

CAT C15 500 ekW @ 1800 rpm, Tier IV Interim Teir 4i

BHP gen effy Elec Out (kW): fan kW w/o fan Rated

726 0.962 500 21 521 output Fan kW is SWAG

10% 25% 50% 75% 100% HP is calculated 

Output (bhp) 72.6 181.5 363.0 544.5 726.0 PM data not givenElectric Output (kW) 49.8 125.4 258.2 390.0 521.0 NOX info not givenParticulates (lb/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availParticulates (g/hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Particulates (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (lb/hr) not avail not avail not avail not avail not availNOx (g/hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!NOx (g/bhp-hr) #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!Fuel Cons (lbm/bhp-hr)Fuel Cons (gal/hr) not avail not avail 20.8 28.6 36Fuel Cons (kwh/gal) #VALUE! #VALUE! 12.4 13.6 14.5