~:.1; ··~ ..... , o'," 1 ·, ' ·,-":'·• <·o'JI"•' .-·~,, 0 •., •i';i ;. •l~··-··, .. · ., ._ -·,..· ,' '• ''I • •'·41.~~~ 

:~ .. ':: ·~.' '· ·.I • ; . ,._·:\· .... ···, .,·~,i· ... ::f~: .... ~ .. ·"'·; t ·.~·~·- ••• ;·:, ~l:·r.:·· :}· .. :: __ ... '-.. -: .' ~~-:.:.> •., -,~,~~:-~ 

' .·'·. • . . ! , : •.. •. ." · .. '. . •.• ;• ':. ' ; ; • <_ , • ·' ... ~ ·,' i "[ • ,• • (: . ~ .. ! 'I . . . ·. ! ·. •:· . •;] 

., . ·;: .' 8~ /• ·· ed~~:, li~~.,:;. 1 ~ot .. ~s. N~. ;o w'edn~;· ~'Y: Pebni~J : ~~·:·;~Rul~~ ~;;~ lie~~. j:~~ : ._-; '::~·~1 

.To be atctpt~bl.: 1/M ontho,."ly 'misst . molarists;..,;;, thelr~ l!Jcl-;;b;,ro..;-l/l.l • o~lell hupettion" aod mlllliiCJUmct ol .. :; .<~ be adequate to lmplemenllnld'. · : tests. the actual propor11on of vehldd ; ltshl-duty vehiclos.ln a eentraUzed • . · .. 1 

efiectl\•c:Jy enlo'l'CC tht program and ·. • falling is usually • amalltrr numbettban··· •progrt.m lnllieted with volunfory ropalr ... ~ 

muil not b1 ClOnditioned opon furth11t • . tho 11ringoncy of tho proarom.)!t::r;. •. '-' _In Dcoomoor 1900 and lull numdotory . · , .: 

lcgi.J!Ilotlyoepprovat or nny o.th~ . ·- · Dop.on . ~typo (p~vate ~·.• ~ ·.·• operolion in December 1981. As • ~ault .·' · ·.'; .subslnndol crintlngenoy. However, tho sornge or tm1 liitd lnop®U~n) n if ';:' ·;. of 118 Rouonoblo Further Proarcu (RFP) · 

.leafslntion tml dolcgoto cerlnin d~clslon "mnndntory" 1/M P"'lv.llm moy 1•o •.:>." . ," , 'cnleulntion. the State hnu cnmmlllod too ~ · .. ; .• j_' 

making t~ ~n oppropriate regulatory· . • lmp1e~nt~ us late~· December 31 • . ~ . CO eml11l0n reductiOn of ot loout 2S ... .._ · _ body. For oxompl\llo 1lolc depllrtmcot . t98:4and the ollalnment dolo mny be •• from light-duty wblcleo by 11187, Thuo. · of en\'ironmenlal Pt'Oiectfon or • :: ~ late Ul Oeceinber 31~ 1087. Bnted on an the Qty or Mempbls has adequale lesal 

dcpnrtm!:nl oltnDJpartoUon moy be lmplem"entattoa dole of DWcomber 31; . outhority, oommitmenllaod ochodule1 

ch&tlled with lmplom""llng the prilgron~ 1i82 and a :OS olringency l1c!.,.., EPA . . to implomtnl thei/M p""'"'DL • oelecl!ng tho type of tnt pnl<"dure..,. predicts lbe reduc:tiono of both CO arid ' . EPAI1todoy coaditionall7 opprovina 

well 01 tho type of prcJinlm to be uoed. · HC wousfemlulono ol25~ cnn be. ; · the Momphl1 CO pion bued on tho . . and ndopllns oU nece1ury.rnl ... and . achieved by D"""mbor 31, 18!7. Earlier ·• · proper offidolt' correc:tinathe · regula~onf!o 1/IA lcgol outhorily must bo · , lmplolf.!cni&Uon oii/Mproduco gn>oter: • dcll~londosnoted below by Morel• 15, 

included 'l'lth uny pion rovlalon which • cmlon!OII reductions. Thun, becauao of 10110. Thla dole hao boon chonaed by · estobl!Bhel OJJollalnmont dolo beyond 1tho Acl'i requirement for'tho .• · • . .- EPA on roquo11£rom tho Stoto.from the 

December:31, 10112, unleU'an upproved , lmplemeotatlon of aU r1010nably • -, orJalnol propooed date ofDecombor 30. 

extension to cerUfy lllga] authority is 4

, evallob1c control measureS and_ because 1~ lo allow the State tufficle-nt time to · granted by EPA, The ifii'Ung of such on Now Jersey aod.Ari&ana hovo. , · adoplthonoceswy provltlono; tho 

eztensiDD. bowf!'ref, lo ao exceptionaf ellcctlvt!y dr:niaootrated pnc:tical Stoll ho1lndlooled they would not be 

remedy to.be"Wlud only whco 1 olllle opoiadoo ofi/M w11b 20'!0· • • oblolo m.,.l the originolly poopoo<d 

leyislahm! hu bod no opportvnily to • otrinaency !actDrw.lllo EPA lJOllcy to dolo of Oo<IO.mb• 31.11179. 

consider enobllnalestllol!bo. usc o zss emission reduction aatho lnndoquacieoln lhlo SIP oubmlulon 

Written'ovldence II llloo ~qulred to crilorion Ia dolermlno oompllnnco o£ the concemlna oecUon 172(b)(t1) oro; : . establish rot 010 oppropriole 1/M portion with 1ec:tion 172(1>)(2). ' 1-Tho Stale hoi noloubmllled apoclllc . govomme to I bod!os oro "committed to EPI\ has recolved on opiniOn from the lron•portolion mtBa)ll"tl11 and · • lmplemen ond enforce tho opprop:dolc Tennessee Attomey Control concluding implcmontation commitments. Howover, 

cllltDenlll o£ tho plo.n." (1ectlon . thot theie;, oufficlartlalalutory . _ the Mempbla aod Slwlby County Office 

172(b)(IO).) Under IOCI!on 112(b)(7). authority for on Inspection ond . or Plannlr\K ond Developmi!Dt hu .• 

iupportlna c:ommltmenll £or the mulnle!IJ!J\Cil program to be . Identified ihe followms m .. 1uru otl 

n•CHYl'J' finoru:iol ond manpower Implemented by certain dllu In the boina cont1ined ia the Ttanoportsllc!lo 

...,.oun:es" oro ot.o roqul.rod. , Stole. EPA hl5 abo rocotvod 0 IePJ lmpronmeol ~/Annual Elemon.t 

A spet\fic lchedulolo establish on, opinion from the Memphl.a City ' o~d hlvin8 olr quolit)' booell11 Thue 

lnspection/mrdntonance program ts Atlomoy'a office concuning with the mco1ures have bcru~tubmJU~ lo tho 

rcqulred.·_(oocllon 172(b)(11)(8).) Thejul~ logul o,plnlon of tho TeMOI .. o AIIDmey Stale for fonnalodopUoo. 

17, 1018. sulduncc memomndom Conemland lndlcallnsthot Mamphls is 

estnblishod os EPA poUcy the key vno of the cides with th!t nuthorlty. Tho ' ......,. """::"""" 

mn .. tones for thelmplemeniBUoo of the City hno submitted ololtorlndlcotfug --....!.-----------

.\ 

. ' 

-. 

. l '. ;,~ ' r . 

. 

' 

. . : 

---'" p~m•~ ThHe milestone. that a cnta (which ..... .,....;o.."':;y,oo!i<";ip;;;; _ _.. tt7t. 

meetthesenerolS!Prcqulremc1i!for----··EPAullhprotiosmclwll --=-.----·='"'-"'------ complluce achedules u goveuuid by 40 roqultcment to m.eet •pedfiMI cminioa ___, ... .,.. .... _._ __ Maod'l ,,._ 

CFR SU~c). Thnt aection requires that l~elal must be met before 11.n Inspection ......_.. '!.:.... $A..a:J ~ = ,':J: 

lll<tei!Wlll of be contained In doc:al will be iuued.ln oddlllon. the - - .....,. • · compli.atlcoa cdulfl'lofoveroneyear Moyoror. MamphJshaaaubmHicda ._....,.,...,~_,.._ .. c ,.,., • 

In . I ens -~ J • Iotter cominl!U!J8 to support an I M """ . , I ~~Yttdll:t~bo*' 

To be cceptnblo on 1/M program · pruiJmm in Memphll und committing to WI hrdl. ll.S ~!!lite! llari', 1- '•' 1m 

must. ocijleve tho rcqul.site 25'3\i tho 1/M s.cJ.!edule suhmiUcd in •lhe SIP. II ~ •-=....-~~ so~ ~ v .. ttu. 

rodu~j>t In both hydrocarbon (HC) should be noted thollho Muyor'p .,.....,..""* 

and C::arl;on monolddo (CO) usl conunitmeut.a to J/M oro mode .... 

em!ssiorl. from passenger cars by the "conllnaent upon tho 1upport of the • end ofchlendarycar1Dil7. The AC! Memphis City Council" for futuro mandates "implom~mtaHon of ali reooun:es and opp10val of !he final · 

rensona!>Jy anJt.blo control &4 1 1peclfic reguloliolliL WhUo EPf. 

expeditiously as p·racUmble:· $ection · that the Mayor cannOt 

t72(b)(2/· At the limo ofpa .. .go,-of tho commit the City Council to nny future 

Clean P~ir Act 1\mondmenls ol l~. ncllun, llohould oo undorolood thnt a sevezal IJupoollon/mnlntenon~e . !allure by the City to IMtllulo o 

progrmria ware otrc11dy opera~n , mondatory 1/M progrum. nccordlng to 

lncludir.g mondolory program• I New tho uchedule submitted In the SIP, will 

Jersey and Arlmn11. opcnatlng oth bbul u mnkc the nreo IJab!e to tho lmpo! ition of 

2010 slringtrncy. (Tho 1triogo"cy bra tbOIJl'O"'th Md ecooomlc re1trle!lon.s 

program b defined u the irUtWL ond/or Fedcnll enforcemcnt•ctlons 

EPA comidertfl the inclD.Jion or these mensum in the TfP/AB to be a porllol 

commitment to thm impJemt"ntallon. 

Foll lmplcmentatfo.n commllmm\1 must 

be 1ubmllled by March 15. 1goo. 2. Tho submittal does not conlnin n schedule for tho analysis of the 

ahcrnoUvo trons:portatlon control 

mc01surcs under section 108. Al11o. there 

Is no commitment from the propt1r .I 

ogency(o) to Implementing no expeditiously 11 practicable the 

I 

• 

' 

. i 

p10porllon ol vohlclvo wbich 'M\ d'bovo p10vlded lor in the Ciun Air Act. failed the propm'• atandardi if the Another commitment neccti nry in the 

mea tuft'S found" feasible for ado·piJon or - to lutHfy tho decbi-on not to impl• menl . 

nny or lhose measurca. . ~ 

u!fected lleol '\•d not undergon' 1/M SIP 11 em)ss;oil reductlono. The progroln 

... ~ ... ·:r~--r .... _ ........... ~ .. 

3. n1Q 5Ubmlft41 does 00f coqloin 0

1J,. , ... • I 

commllmcn1 of the pmper ogr.ncy(i) to . • . · >~ ~-"· 

!

. ,· ' .. •:•; 

' 'L • 

.: ·}-~ 

.. ~··