08/11/201 1 1G:3 4 FA X 202493514 2 FA A - QMS

ctvw : 121001/00 7 FflG E 0i/C 7

FACSTMTL

E MESSAG E FEDERA LAVIATIO N AD\n M STRAT I O N OFFIC E O FRECIONA LCOUNSV X 1<S0 1 LIX D AVENU E S.W , RENTON . WASHINGTO N ?805 7 Th e informatio n conlaine dI n thi s facsimil e mc5s?tgc i5 Iftgall y privilege dan dconfidential infrrrmano n ac di s intende donl y fo r th aUE C o f th = individua l n^rnr do n thi s co''.^e r sheet , I f th e reader

o f thi s messig e i s no t

th e irtttade drecipient , yo u are hcrcVi y r.otific dtha i an y use , disaeminatinti , oi^tribntion , o : cop y o f dii s Caccimil

e ie.strictl y proKibitcd . I f yo u tiav e receivedthi s facsimil e i n rrrni , pleas e Immtdiaiel y notif y U B b y telephon e a

t ^25-227-3007 . 

## DATE : TO : FA X NO. : 

## PHONE NO. : RE : Augus t 11 . 20T 1 

## DOT AGC-43 0 202.493.514 2 FA A Cas e No . 2009NM7OO05< S X009NM70OO6 5 CP10NM000 6 & CriONMOOO ? NO . PAGES :



## FROM : FA X NO. : PHON E NO. i EMAIL : 

## 7 includin g cove r

Dan aStephenso n 425-227-100 7 425-227-200 7 d3ap_I.stephenson@faa.go v 

## Supplement

to Motio n in Limine an

dReques t

fo r Expedite d Rujing .08/11/201 1 16.3 4 FA X 202493514 2 FA A • ^ QM S iSM 7 0002/00 7 P<:'G E a: ; .'"0 7

1 . 2 3 5 6 ^ a 3 1 0 a i 1 2 1 3 1 4 If f i : 1 9 1 9 a o 3 1 a a 2i i 2 5 2 « 2 7 2 B 3 9 3 C 3 : 3 3 1 0 3 5 3 6 J- J 3 « 1 9 •9 0 4 1 4 3 4 1 4 4 4 5 4 e -1 7 « a 4 » 5 0 E l 5 1

= 3 T:YL EE . T-OMAiOU, ' FA A OFFTCtr

- O FREQIONA L COUNSE L 160 1 Lj>rt5Avx.,S W RHNTCTV , WASWNCTON9«05 7 TELEPHOKE : A:'i-227- 1 ^4 7 FACSIMILE ; ''-25-227-100 7 

## ::rpARTMEMT O F

' XAh T 0PER.M10N ^ mM}i j ! 2 A q:2 3 UNITE D STATE S O FAMERIC A DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON

, D.C, l ath e Matte r

of : FEDtRA l EXPRES S CORPORATIO N

I T th e MPTTC

T of : EMPIR E AIRLINES , TN^C . FA A Docke t Nn . CP l DNMOOW

? P A ACM C No . 200yNM70005 6 DM S Mo . FAA72OI0-C75 0 FA A Docke t

No . CP l ONNfOOO

? FA A ow e No . 2009NM7tX)O6 5 .DM g No . PAA-20 1 0-079 1 JudjT". : Richar dC . Goodwi n SIJPPLEMEN T T O MOTIO N I N LIMIN E AN D REQUES T FO REXPEDITE D RtTJN G .TUDO RGOODWIN : Plca.'^cfindattache dalette r dat« i Augus t

R , 2011 , fromtheDcputyChic f Counse l o f

th e Fipehn c an dKezajdou s Maf^dal s Safet y Adminietratio n (PHIv'SA) . addres s t o Mr . Bo b Rjchard . Thi s aitachment

cerve s a s aSupplement

t o th e .Agency' s Motio n i n Limin e file

d Augus t 1U,20]]. . DATE D thi s 11*

^ da y o f Augi's i 2011 . Re^spectfuJI

y subrnitted ,

Kyf e E . Lomaio w F.A A ATtome y 

### •yir^^yt ^ 1 . '

DM S No . FAA-2O1O.079 0 A ?AA-I0ln-O7? i /AADocteiN o ^7^o^I^]oo(^6ACPIO^^fooo 7 '^\ S fis c - 2O09>JM7OOO5 ^ tn i 200PSM7000tf. 1 KYV E t - LOHAia-'Jr, f

(\ A A.TTORSE: ? T£V . i7li.-iz7.1W7 ; TAX : -425.227.100 708/11/201 1 163 5 FA X 2024S35U 2 FA A ^ QM S [^003/00 7

..•J , J . Ar^-JJ. ! arj-i : PiC E 33/U 7

1 3 4

C

1 0 1 1 1 3 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 5 i : l e 1 9 2 C 3 1 2 2 3 3 2 4 2 6 3 9 ?. g 31 ? 3 1 3: t i c 3 S :* 6 3 : 3 S

• 1 1

• * 4 * ? 4 6 a 7 Ji J •» ? & 0 5 1 57 . 5. 1 CERTIFICAT E O FSERVIC E I hereb y CGitif

y tha t rh e foregciing AgcfiC}''g Supplcrasntt o Motio n i n Limin e ha s been serve d vi afacsimil e an dovernigh t tliL s date , t o th e foJJownnE . Th e Komrabl e Richar dC . Good\vi n Offic e o l hearings , M-2 0 120 0 Me w JcT-if w Av«nue . S-E . .Fas i Biii]di7.f

i (Jroun ^ Floor . R

mK;?-.12 0 Waahiogton.D.C.^O'^^ O TEL' . 202-366- 2 r^ y FAX : 202^366-753 6 Federa l Aviatio n AdminiatniTinn 80 0 Independenc e Av;n.u e S W Washington , D.C . 2059 1 Attn : HaaiiTig Dacte t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wngh l B\aldin €

- Suit e 2W100 0 F.^ : 202-^93-514 ? Cynthi aChandlcr-Snc H Staf f Attoroey ^ Federa l Exprc:^?i, 362 0 Hack s Cro w Roa d BuiWlng B , y ^ Floo r Memphis , T N 3S \25-580 0 TEL : 901-434-835 ] P.AX : 901^45d.-S28 3 Inc .

Date dthi s 1 1 t

hda y o f August . ^ 0 M .

Dan a.Siqihenso n 

### loL^s l 7 Offic e ol'Kepiona l Counse l (ANM-T ; Federal Aviario u AdmirJstTfltion 1*50 1 Lin dAve , S W Kenton , W A9^05 7 475.227-216 4

AEt'C>' t Supplemwi l laM'oilo n i n Limin e DM S >Jo . FA.VJ0H>-0791 > . t FAA--'01P-079 ; FA A DocKt l No . CPlCl'KVlOOOf i & CP10NM000 7 F A ^ CM C - aOOSVM^OOO.ie m d2DMWM70PCC:? ! KriiE , LOMAZ0\i' . FA A ATTOBKK T •rei ^ 4;;.^17.ia4"3 ; FAX : 41 S 2:7.10t> 708/11/201 1 16:3 5 FA X 202433514 2 FA A - DM S 0004/00 7 i:d/ll.-:;ai l 13:1 6 a75???lCF^ 7 AhJH 7 poQ F :"ld/Fi 7 

# e

PtEwflncaix ) Hazardou s Mjrerlat s SaTETvAdmini^anof t N4r , P^be n Ricbard 7S6 7 Unbridle dCou n Manai3a5,V A 2011 2 pea r Bob ; T o follo w up O

D ou i telephon e canvcraatio n about ajvitcnri,n l subpocna

-

• 49 C.F.R , Par

t 9 sot s fort hth e ptocedure s eovcfflin

g th e tcstimcTn

y nf's . DO T employe e i

n whichth e UniredState s i s aparty . Pa n 9 procadur« s alao appl y t o fomier DO T cmpkiyecs . (Scc49G.F.R , §9J' s definitio n of"ftmployoc' ^ ttaiin g that etnploy w mean s aa> ' current

or fonne r office r or employe e o f

th e Dcpaitiricrit. )

« I f FectE r requests yov

x testiioon y you ma

y not testii y a s o

n expe n o i opinio n wtnsn j wit hregardt n an y mfltre r arisin g m n o f you r ofllcia l dutie s (whil e a

t PHMSA ) or

the ftiaclions o f

tt o Department . Yo

u m.?r y tc^ ^ a s t o f^cxs. ufKji ayoiir laaswledft * provide dtha

t th e tsstiiaon y b e subjec t

t o prio r appmva l b y thi s ofEce ao dt o th e Federa l Rule s o f Cjvl j Pirjcsdi man dany applicabl aclai mo f privilege . 3c c 4 9 C.F.^ . §9.70 ) Plftae e call i f yo u hav e an

y additional qQCStiorw

. Sfaezr l Pappa s Dcpur y Chie f Counsel08/11/201 1 1B:3 5 FA X 202^193514 2 FA A ^ OM S

CHA 7 0005/00 7

1 2

s 7 » 3 I D ; i i z •_: \ 1 4 I S 1 6 1 7 1 0 ] « 3 1 2 : 2 3 3- 4 2 5 3 « 2 9 2 3 J O 3 1 2 2 3 1 l a 3 5 I C 3 f 2 9 -t o 4 1 4 2 4 2 1 4 a s 4 £ 4 1 4 8 • 1 > 5 3 5 1 5 2 & 3 F A A 0?51C E C FRHiitO N M . COUl^3EJ . 160 1 Ll WAVE. . S W RZVTON , W,\£fflN'GTO

N 9805 7 T£LEPHi7>n:.'4??-'!27.]»4 7 P.A.CS!vniE : •425-227-100 7 

### UNITE D STATE S O FAMERIC A

DEFARTMEN l O FTRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC E O FHEARING S W.-^SHINGTON . D.C . In th e Mflticr

o f FEDERA LEXPRES S CORPOPj\TlO N fnThe Matte r

of : CORPORAT E AT R F,\ A Docke t No . CPlONMOO l 1 FAA case No . 200SNM70012 7 DM S No . FAA-2 0 10-097 7 FA A Docke t

No . CPlONMOOlO FA A cas e No . 200SN>/70012 6 DM S No . FAA-2010-097 5 .Tiirigr : Richar dC . Goodwi n SUPPLEMEN T T O MOTIO N I N LIMIN E AN D REQtJtS T FO REXPKnTTE D RULIN G JLTDG B GOODWIH

Pleas e 5n dattache daIctt n daie dAugus t 8 , 2011 , fromthe Depiin. ' Chie f Counse l o f

the Pipelin e an dHazardou s Materiab Safet y A'.-lmmii.iTaiio

n (PHMSA V addres s t o Mr . Bo h Vsichard . Thi s atttchnitt: ^ .wrve s a s aSupplemen t t o th e ,^^cnc^' > Kfotio

n i n Limin e filed Auffjs t 10 , 2C'n . DATE D thi s ll'*^dayofAuga^i20n . RcspccxftUl

y cubaiittftd . 

### J Z Kyl e E . Lcmazo w r A A Anome y

A£cnc y 'sSupplemen t

t o Mctior . i

- Limip c DM S No . FAA-20IC"D97' 7 A FAA-^ m0J397 3 FAADOeicrtN o CPJOKSiOOl l * CPI0N"MOOI O ?AJl , Cit e - 10fi«>JM"Jr,;2 6 ani l ;OOSfNM7015. 7 P« t I o f 2 KYL E ^ W3M\2»w , FA A ArTOW-T V TEL : 47."'-:'?'''l8i7 v FAX : ii;-227-I00 708/11/201 1 16-3 5 FA X 2024935142 ^ A A - DM S

HHt'l ? g)006/00 f

1 3

• J t 5 6 7 I C i: . 1 2 1 3 H 1 5 l e l e 1 3 2 3 2 1 3 2 ^ ? 3 4 2« ! 2 C 2 7 3 3 2 !

3 3 3 < 5 S I f ' j 7 I S 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 ^ S 4 S <• ? 4. B « 9 £ a £ 1 a ; 5 3 CERTIFICAT E O FSERVIC E T hereb y certif

y that th e fareccin c .'iEeacy' s Supplcmcn c : o Motio n i n Limin e ha^ bccj i serve d vi afacvmil e an dovernigh t thi s date , ir

> ih c foUowinp : Th-. e Honorabl e RichardC . Gof^wi n Ottic « o f hearings . M-2 0 120 0 Ne w Tsrsff

v Avenue . S,E . Eas t Birildin g Groun dFloor , ?JJ I £12-32 0 Washington . D.C . 20S9 0 TF,L:202-:J65.2I3 9 FAX : 202-36<5-753 6 Federa l Aviatio n Adminifirratio n 80 0 Irtdfipsrdenc e Avenu e S W Waghineton , D.C . ?.059 1 Attr.- . Hearin g Docke t

Clerk , ACIC-4? 0 Wilbu r Wright Buildin g - Suit e 2"^'100 0 FAX;20^493-514 2 Cynthi aChandJer-Snel l StelT Altomey . Federal Exprces , Inc . 362 0 Hack s Croj ^ Road Buildin g B , 3'-Floo r Memphis , T N 38I25-fi90 0 TEL : 901-434-836 1 FAX : 901-434-S2S 3 Date dthi s llthcayofAUgiJ.'^T . 2011 , 

# It ; 

# 2ZZ^i ^ an aSTcphonson Offic e o f Rcgicma l Cotjise l [AKM-7 ) ?cdcra l Aviatio n AdmicislT^tir m l&U l Lin dAve . 8 W Renton,W A 9805 7 435-227-216 4

Azccicy' i Sffpplapnen

r t o Moiio T lr

> LLTin e DM S Nff . ,^.V\-2CIO-09T 7 f>

. FyU^IDlO-097 5 T A Adocke t

^Ia.C?lC'S'MO 0 I I dCPjON?-lf)pi D ^A > C(i5e-20Ci8>M7rM?fianil2nf«>JM'/C12 T KV-L E e . i.0M/\t01ft" , fA A ATTOtSS y TEL : ^25-237.. ' «*? ; r

AX ; 125-227-100 708/11/201 1 16:3 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A' DM S 0007/00 7 uo . li/^oi i ;j:i y':2S227108 7 -Ny 7 POG E ^7f^ l 

# e j__ ^ , waC T f*o ^ D C 2o€ M ^Tmn^p^r^d^ n AUGOS.201 I Pip-lin e an d hJurtJcMJ

S Marcrtal l

Mr . Rober t Richai d 786 7 Unbridle dCour

t Kiinassis.V A 2011 2 Dea r Bob : T o follo w it

p o n OU T telephon e rpnvnsatio n aboui apoientSa ] subpoena

-

• 4 9 C.F.R . Par

t 9 set s fort hth e proceJurc i go^-eraljie th e teolmon y o f aE>O T employe e i n whic hth e Unite dState s i s apatty . Par t 9 proccdurc aai » apply i o fhrme r DO T employees . (.•? « '1 9 C.F.R . §9.3' c deflnhion o f "•inpIo>'ee " statjn c thi l employe e mean s an y currm t or forme r office r or emplnyec o f

th e Department )

• I f FedEx TcqueB

Wyou r testimon y yi.u

i ma y ro t tcstif r a' * a n op^ n or

opinio n witnes s •wit hregar dtn an y matter arisin g out

o f you r offjcia l dutie s (whil e a

t PHMSA ) o r

the fijDction s o f

the Department . Yo

n ma y tesdi^ ' u t o fact s vvitni

n yoxi r knowledg e provide dthat

Ihetttlimon y b e S'abjoct

. t o prie w epprnvnl b y ihi i offic e findt o th e F«dBra l Rule ^ o f Civi l Procadurc an dany applicabl e clii mo f privilege . Se c i 9 C.F.R . 59.7(1? ) Pleas e call I

f you hav o an

y additional quC3tirm,t Shen l Pappa« ' Deput y Chie f Counsel