08/11/2011 1G:34 FAX 2024935142 FAA - QMS 

ctvw: 

121001/007 

FflGE 0i/C7 

FACSTMTLE MESSAGE 

FEDERAL AVIATION AD\nM STRATI ON 

OFFICE OF RECIONAL COUNSVX 

1<S01 LIXD AVENUE S.W, 

RENTON. WASHINGTON ?8057 

The information conlained In this facsimile mc5s?tgc i5 Iftgally privileged and confidential 

infrrrmanon acd is intended only for tha UEC of th= individual n^rnrd on this co''.^er sheet, 

If the reader of this messige is not the irtttaded recipient, you are hcrcViy r.otificd thai any 

use, disaeminatinti, oi^tribntion, o: copy of diis Caccimile ie.strictly proKibitcd. If you 

tiave received this facsimile in rrrni, please Immtdiaiely notify UB by telephone at 

^25-227-3007. 

DATE: 

TO: 

FAX NO.: 

PHONE NO.: 

RE: 

August 11. 20T1 

DOT AGC-430 

202.493.5142 

FAA Case No. 

2009NM7OO05<S 

X009NM70OO65 

CP10NM0006 & 

CriONMOOO? 

NO. PAGES: 

FROM: 

FAX NO.: 

PHONE NO.i 

EMAIL: 

7 including cover 

Dana Stephenson 

425-227-1007 

425-227-2007 

d3ap_I.stephenson@faa.gov 

Supplement to Motion in Limine and Request for Expedited 

Rujing. 
08/11/201 1 16.3 4 FAX 2024935142 FAA •^ QM S 

iSM7 

0002/00 7 

P<:'GE a:; .'"07 

1. 

2 

3 

5 

6 

^ 

a 

3 

10 

a i 

12 

13 

14 

Iff 

i : 

19 

19 

ao 

3 1 

aa 

2ii 

25 

2« 

27 

2B 

39 

3C 

3 : 

33 

1 0 

3 5 

3 6 

J-J 

3 « 

1 9 

•90 

4 1 

43 

4 1 

44 

45 

4e 

-17 

«a 

4» 

50 

El 

5 1 

= 3 

T:YLE E. T-OMAiOU,' 

FAA OFFTCtr- OF REQIONAL COUNSEL 

1601 Lj>rt5Avx.,SW 

RHNTCTV, WASWNCTON9«057 

TELEPHOKE: A:'i-227-1 ^47 

FACSIMILE; ''-25-227-1007 

::rpARTMEMT OF 

' XAhT 0PER.M10N^ 

m M}ij !2 A q:23 

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D.C, 

la the Matter of: 

FEDtRAl EXPRESS CORPORATION 

IT the MPTTCT of: 

EMPIRE AIRLINES, TN^C. 

FAA Docket Nn. CPl DNMOOW? 

P A A CMC No. 200yNM700056 

DMS Mo. FAA72OI0-C750 

FAA Docket No. CPl ONNfOOO? 

FAA owe No. 2009NM7tX)O65 

.DMg No. PAA-20 1 0-0791 

JudjT".: Richard C. Goodwin 

SIJPPLEMENT TO MOTION IN LIMINE 

AND REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED RtTJNG 

.TUDOR GOODWIN: 

Plca.'^cfind attached a letter dat«i August R, 2011, fromtheDcputyChicf Counsel of the 

Fipehnc and Kezajdous Maf^dals Safety Adminietration (PHIv'SA). address to Mr. Bob 

Rjchard. This aitachment cerves as a Supplement to the .Agency's Motion in Limine filed 

August 1U,20]].. 

DATED this 11*^ day of Augi'si 2011. 

Re^spectfuJIy subrnitted, 

Kyfe E. Lomaiow 

F.AA ATtomey 

•yir^^yt^ 1 . ' 

DMS No. FAA-2O1O.0790 A ?AA-I0ln-O7?i 

/AADocteiNo ^7^o^I^]oo(^6ACPIO^^fooo7 

'^\ S fis c - 2O09>JM7OOO5^ tn i 200PSM7000tf.1 

KYVE t- LOHAia-'Jr, f (\A A.TTORSE:? 

T£V. i7li.-iz7.1W7; TAX: -425.227.1007 
08/11/2011 163 5 FAX 2024S35U2 FAA ^ QMS [^003/007 

..•J , J. A r ^-JJ. ! arj-i: PiCE 33/U7 

1 

3 

4 

C 

10 

11 

13 

13 

14 

15 

15 

i : 

l e 

19 

2C 

31 

22 

33 

24 

26 

39 

?.g 

31? 

31 

3:t 

i c 

3S 

:*6 

3 : 

3S 

• 1 1 

• * 4 

*? 

46 

a7 

JiJ 

•»? 

&0 

5 1 

57. 

5.1 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby CGitify that rhe foregciing AgcfiC}''g Supplcrasntto Motion in Limine has been served 

via facsimile and overnight tliLs date, to the foJJownnE. 

The Komrable Richard C. Good\vin 

Office ol hearings, M-20 

1200 Mew JcT-ifw Av«nue. S-E. 

.Fasi Biii]di7.fi (Jroun^ Floor. Rm K;?-.120 

Waahiogton.D.C.^O'^^O 

TEL'. 202-366-2 r^y 

FAX: 202^366-7536 

Federal Aviation AdminiatniTinn 

800 Independence Av;n.ue SW 

Washington, D.C. 20591 

Attn: HaaiiTig Dactet Clerk, AGC-430 

Wilbur Wnghl B\aldin€ - Suite 2W1000 

F.^ : 202-^93-514? 

Cynthia Chandlcr-SncH 

Staff Attoroey^ Federal Exprc:^?i, 

3620 Hacks Crow Road 

BuiWlng B, y^ Floor 

Memphis, TN 3S\ 25-5800 

TEL: 901-434-835] 

P.AX: 901^45d.-S283 

Inc. 

Dated this 11 th day of August. ^0 M. 

Dana .Siqihenson 

loL^sl 7 

Office ol'Kepional Counsel (ANM-T; 

Federal Aviariou AdmirJstTfltion 

1*501 Lind Ave, SW 

Kenton, W A 9^057 

475.227-2164 

AEt'C>'t Supplemwil la M'oilon in Limine 

DMS >Jo. FA.VJ0H>-0791> .t FAA--'01P-079; 

FAA DocKtl No. CPlCl'KVlOOOfi & CP10NM0007 

F A ^ CMC - aOOSVM^OOO.ie md 2DMWM70PCC:?! 

KriiE, LOMAZ0\i'. FAA ATTOBKKT 

•rei^ 4;;.^17.ia4"3; FAX: 41S 2:7.10t>7 
08/11/201 1 16:3 5 FAX 2024335142 FAA - DMS 0004/00 7 

i:d/ll.-:;ai l 13:1 6 a75???lCF^7 AhJH7 poQF :"ld/Fi7 

e 

PtEwflncaix) Hazardous Mjrerlats 

SaTETvAdmini^anoft 

N4r, P^ben Ricbard 

7S67 Unbridled Coun 

Manai3a5,VA 20112 

pear Bob; 

To follow up OD oui telephone canvcraation about a jvitcnri,nl subpocna-

• 49 C.F.R, Part 9 sots forth the ptocedures eovcffling the tcstimcTny nf's. DOT employee in 

which the Unired States is a party. Pan 9 procadur«s alao apply to fomier DOT 

cmpkiyecs. (Scc49G.F.R, §9J's definition of"ftmployoc'^ ttaiing that etnployw means 

aa>' current or fonner officer or employee of the Dcpaitiricrit.) 

« If FectEr requests yovx testiioony you may not testiiy as on expen oi opinion wtnsnj 

with regard tn any mfltrer arising mn of your ofllcial duties (while at PHMSA) or the 

ftiaclions of tto Department. You m.?ry tc^ ^ as to f^cxs. ufKjia yoiir laaswledft* 

provided that the tsstiiaony be subject to prior appm val by this ofEce aod to the Federal 

Rules of Cjvlj Pirjcsdim and any applicabla claim of privilege. 3cc 49 C.F.^. §9.70) 

Plftaee call if you have any additional qQCStiorw. 

Sfaezrl Pappas 

Dcpury Chief Counsel 
08/11/201 1 1B:35 FAX 202^1935142 FAA ^ OMS 

CHA7 

0005/00 7 

1 

2 

s 

7 

» 

3 

ID 

; i 

iz 

•_:\ 

14 

IS 

16 

17 

10 

]« 

31 

2 : 

23 

3-4 

25 

3« 

29 

23 

JO 

31 

22 

31 

la 

35 

IC 

3f 

29 

-to 

41 

42 

42 

14 

as 

4£ 

4 1 

48 

• 1> 

53 

51 

52 

&3 

F A A 0?51CE CF RHiitON M. COUl^3EJ. 

1601 LlW AVE.. SW 

RZVTON, W,\£fflN'GTON 98057 

T£LEPHi7>n:.'4??-'!27.]»47 

P.A.CS!vniE: •425-227-1007 

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

DEFARTMENl OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

W.-^SHINGTON. D.C. 

In the Mflticr of 

FEDERAL EXPRESS CORPOPj\TlON 

fnThe Matter of: 

CORPORATE ATR 

F,\A Docket No. CPlONMOOl 1 

FAA case No. 200SNM700127 

DMS No. FAA-2 0 10-0977 

FAA Docket No. CPlONMOOlO 

FAA case No. 200SN>/700126 

DMS No. FAA-2010-0975 

.Tiirigr: Richard C. Goodwin 

SUPPLEMENT TO MOTION IN LIMINE 

AND REQtJtST FOR EXPKnTTED RULING 

JLTDGB GOODWIHPlease 5nd attached a Icttn daied August 8, 2011, from the Depiin.' Chief Counsel of the 

Pipeline and Hazardous Materiab Safety A'.-lmmii.iTaiion (PHMSAV address to Mr. Boh 

Vsichard. This atttchnitt:^ .wrves as a Supplement to the ,^^cnc^'> Kfotion in Limine filed 

Auffjst 10, 2C'n. 

DATE D this ll'*^dayofAuga^i20n. 

RcspccxftUly cubaiittftd. 

JZ 

Kyle E. Lcmazow 

r AA Anomey 

A£cncy 'sSupplement to Mctior. i- Limipc 

DMS No. FAA-20IC"D97'7 A FAA-^m 0J3973 

FAADOeicrtNo CPJOKSiOOll * CPI0N"MOOIO 

?AJl, Cite - 10fi«>JM"Jr,;26 anil ;OOSfNM7015.7 

P«t I of 2 

KYLE ^ W3M\2»w, FAA ArTOW-TV 

TEL: 47."'-:'?'''l8i7v FAX: ii;-227-I007 
08/11/2011 16-35 FAX 2024935142^ AA - DMS 

HHt'l? 

g)006/00f 

1 

3 

•J 

t 

5 

6 

7 

IC 

i:. 

12 

13 

H 

15 

l e 

l e 

13 

23 

2 1 

32 

^ ? 

34 

2«! 

2C 

27 

33 

2 ! 

33 

3< 

5S 

If 

' j 7 

IS 

4 0 

4 1 

42 

43 

44 

^S 

4S 

<•? 

4.B 

«9 

£a 

£1 

a ; 

53 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

T hereby certify that the fareccinc .'iEeacy's Supplcmcnc :o Motion in Limine ha^ bccji served 

via facvmile and overnight this date, ir> ihc foUowinp: 

Th-.e Honorable Richard C. Gof^win 

Ottic« of hearings. M-20 

1200 New Tsrsffv Avenue. S,E. 

East Birilding Ground Floor, ?JJI £12-320 

Washington. D.C. 20S90 

TF,L:202-:J65.2I39 

FAX: 202-36<5-7536 

Federal Aviation Adminifirration 

800 Irtdfipsrdence Avenue SW 

Waghineton, D.C. ?.0591 

Attr.-. Hearing Docket Clerk, ACIC-4?0 

Wilbur Wright Building - Suite 2"^'1000 

FAX;20^493-5142 

Cynthia ChandJer-Snell 

StelT Altomey. Federal Exprces, Inc. 

3620 Hacks Croj^ Road 

Building B, 3'-Floor 

Memphis, TN 38I25-fi900 

TEL: 901-434-8361 

FAX: 901-434-S2S3 

Dated this llthcayofAUgiJ.'^T. 2011, 

It; 2ZZ^i^ 

ana STcphonson 

Office of Rcgicmal Cotjisel [AKM-7) 

?cdcral Aviation AdmicislT^tirm 

l&Ul Lind Ave. 8W 

Renton,WA 98057 

435-227-2164 

Azccicy'i Sffpplapnenr to MoiioT lr> LLTine 

DMS Nff. ,^.V\-2CIO-09T7 f>. FyU^IDlO-0975 

T A A docket ^Ia.C?lC'S'MO0 II d CPjON?-lf)piD 

^A> C(i5e-20Ci8>M7rM?fianil2nf«>JM'/C12T 

KV-LE e. i.0M/\t01ft", fAA ATTOtSSy 

TEL: ^25-237..' «*?; r AX ; 125-227-1007 
08/11/201 1 16:35 FAX 2024935142 FAA ' DMS 0007/00 7 

uo. li/^oi i ;j:i y ':2S2271087 -Ny7 POGE ^7f^ l 

e 

j__ ^ , waCT f*o ^ DC 2o€M 

^Tmn^p^r^d^n AUGOS.201I 

Pip-line and hJurtJcMJS Marcrtall 

Mr. Robert Rich aid 

7867 Unbridled Court 

Kiinassis.VA 20112 

Dear Bob: 

To follow itp on OUT telephone rpnvnsation aboui a poientSa] subpoena-

• 49 C.F.R. Part 9 sets forth the proceJurci go^-eraljie the teolmony of a E>OT employee in 

which the United States is a patty. Part 9 proccdurca ai» apply io fhrmer DOT 

employees. (.•?« '19 C.F.R. §9.3'c deflnhion of "•inpIo>'ee" statjnc thil employee means 

any currmt or former officer or emplnyec of the Department) 

• If FedEx TcqueBW your testimony yi.ui may rot tcstifr a'* an op^n or opinion witness 

•with regard tn any matter arising out of your offjcial duties (while at PHMSA) or the 

fijDctions of the Department. Yon may tesdi^' u to facts vvitnin yoxir knowledge 

provided that Ihetttlimony be S'abjoct. to priew epprnvnl by ihii office find to the F«dBral 

Rule^ of Civil Procadurc and any applicable cliim of privilege. Sec i9 C.F.R. 59.7(1?) 

Please call If you havo any additional quC3tirm,t 

Shenl Pappa« ' 

Deputy Chief Counsel