ResidentialFBNOPRCom To:

ments cc: Mohammed Khan/EE/DOE@DOE, Brenda Edwards-Jones/EE/DOE@DOE

Sent by: Brenda Subject: RE: Question from Stakeholders Regarding FB Notice of Data Availability

Edwards-Jones O Federal Record Not a Federal Record

02/22/2007 01:56 PM

User Filed as: Not Categorized in ERMS

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) on February 9, 2007, published in the Federal Register (FR) a Notice

of Data Availability (NODA) responding to two particular issues that were raised by stakeholders at the DOE

October 30, 2006, public meeting. 72 FR 6184. In the NODA, DOE presented revised analysis results for the

Non-Regulatory Alternatives To Standards (regional performance standards) and explained that the new

estimates reflect a distribution of condensing gas furnaces which is more consistent with Gas Appliance

Manufacturers Association (GAMA) sales data. The revised analysis in the NODA updated the life-cycle cost

(LCC) and national impact analysis (NIA) spreadsheets provided in the technical support document that

accompanied the notice of proposed rulemaking. The original spreadsheets and the GAMA data, which was

provided to DOE April 25, 2005, are part of the rulemaking docket and are available for public review. (

http://www.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/furnaces_boilers.html). In order to

facilitate comment on the NODA, DOE is providing the original spreadsheets, as updated, based on the

previously submitted GAMA data.

The purpose of this email is to inform stakeholders that the spreadsheets are available on the Department's web

page and can be accessed via the web link above. The Department looks forward to receiving any comments

you may wish to submit regarding the February 9, 2007, FR notice. Thank you."

Mohammed Khan

Building Technologies Program

United States Department of Energy

EE-RM/STD-01-350 COMMENT 151

15 

ResidentialFBNOPRCom To: 

ments 

Sent by: Brenda 

Edwards-Jones 

cc: Mohammed Khan/EE/DOE@DOE, Brenda Edwards-Jones/EE/DOE@DOE 

Subject: RE: Question from Stakeholders Regarding FB Notice of Data Availability 

o Federal Record • Not a Federal Record 

02/22/2007 01 :56 PM 

User Filed as: Not Categorized in ERMS 

Ladies and Gentlemen, 

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) on February 9, 2007, published in the Federal Register (FR) a Notice 

of Data Availability (NODA) responding to two particular issues that were raised by stakeholders at the DOE 

October 30, 2006, public meeting. 72 FR 6184. In the NODA, DOE presented revised analysis results for the 

Non-Regulatory Alternatives To Standards (regional performance standards) and explained that the new 

estimates reflect a distribution of condensing gas furnaces which is more consistent with Gas Appliance 

Manufacturers Association (GAMA) sales data. The revised analysis in the NODA updated the life-cycle cost 

(LeC) and national impact analysis (NIA) spreadsheets provided in the technical support document that 

accompanied the notice of proposed rulemaking. The original spreadsheets and the GAMA data, which was 

provided to DOE April 25, 2005, are part of the rulemaking docket and are available for public review. ( 

http://www.eere.energy.govlbuildings/appliance _standards/residential/furnaces _ boilers.html). In order to 

facilitate comment on the NODA, DOE is providing the original spreadsheets, as updated, based on the 

previously submitted GAMA data. 

The purpose of this email is to inform stakeholders that the spreadsheets are available on the Department's web 

page and can be accessed via the web link above. The Department looks forward to receiving any comments 

you may wish to submit regarding the February 9,2007, FR notice. Thank you." 

Mohammed Khan 

Building Technologies Program 

United States Department of Energy 
Here listed are the stakeholders that the e-mail below was sent to in the bcc addressed

category:

cadams@aosmith.com, jim.bienias@rheem.com, dmbrunda@southernco.com,

cagnoli@hpba.org, Adelaskil@aol.com, pgauthier@gamanet.org, rglass@raypak.com,

dgoldstein@nrdc.org, jharris@ase.org, mhunt@veec.org, jjohnson@iwpnews.com,

Gmkusterer@cs.com, jmattingly@gamanet.org, terrym@bockwaterheaters.com,

jranfone@aga.org, srosenstock@eei.org, hsachs@aceee.org, fstanonik@gamanet.org,

troy.trant@rheem.com, twilliams@aga.org, cdigiovanni@theapsp.org,

robertboiko@robertboiko.com, mekrebs@il.net, bbeauregard@apga.org,

Ssiddiqu@jandy.com, Jklimp@gamanet.org, Golembeski@hpba.org,

steven-nadel@aceee.org

EE-RM/STD-01-350 COMMENT 151

Here listed are the stakeholders that the e-mail below was sent to in the bcc addressed 

category: 

cadams@aosmith.com, jim. bienias@rheem.com, dmbrunda@southemco.com, 

cagnoli@hpba.org, Adelaskil@aol.com, pgauthier@gamanet.org, rglass@raypakcom, 

dgoldstein@nrdc.org, jharris@ase.org, mhunt@veec.org, jjohnson@iwpnews.com, 

Gmkusterer@cs.com, jmattingly@gamanet.org, terrym@bockwaterheaters.com, 

jranfone@aga.org, srosenstock@eei.org, hsachs@aceee.org, fstanonik@gamanet.org, 

troy. trant@rheem.com, twilliams@aga.org, cdigiovanni@theapsp.org, 

robertboiko@robertboiko.com, mekrebs@il.net, bbeauregard@apga.org, 

Ssiddiqu@jandy.com, Jklimp@gamanet.org, Golembeski@hpba.org, 

steven _nadel@aceee.org