p.1 

OAR Box 1828 

Prepped by Ollie Stewart 

Document Number: 

301) I V-A-11 

Docket Number: 

A-83-27 

Printed 11/12/200811:12:59 AM Sheet 301 of 325 
P.2_ 

> -Mm r 

oEPA 

United States 

Environmental Protection 

Agency 

Office of Air Quality , 

Planning and Standard! 

Research Triangle Park A-83-27 

Air 

IV-A-11 

Electric Utility Steam 

Generating Units 

Background Information 

for Promulgated 

Emission Standards 

EIS 

S £ _ 
P.3 

mm 

2.3.3 - Special Issue s 

Anthracite Coal 

1. D-21, D-80, D-259, D-326, D-343, D-402, D-409, D-419, D-420, 

D-422, D-42'*>, D-444, D-465, D-511, D-554, D-573, D-578, D-584, D-587, 

D-602, D-606, D-607, D-653, D-660, D-695, D-735, F-la , F-ll , F-lr, 

F-lcc, F-ldd, F-lee , F-lff, H-10, H-15 

Comment: Anthracite coal should be exempt from SO2 regulations or 

a special standard established because: 

• natural low sulfur content will have little impact on S0£ 

emissions 

• standard would encourage use of high sulfur coal 

e reopening and reclamation of anthracite mines would encourage 

or require strict land reclamation which is beneficial and 

will result in cleaning up of culm piles 

• economic benefit to anthracite region 

• unproven controls on anthracite 

• other fuels (e.g., lignite) have related standards 

• since N0X standard does not mention anthracite, precedent 

for exemption already exists 

• l=ss stringent standard will permit anthracite to compete 

wirh other sources of coal which are cheaper to mine 

• would produce no more SO2 emissions with exemption from 

scrubbing than high sulfur bituminous coal with full 

scrubbing 

• anthracite is at a competitive disadvantage because it is almost entirely obtained from deep mining of previously worked 

areas , 

• improved water quality as a result of alleviating existing 

acid-mine drainage problems 

!*?>H 

2-83 

•,^-,.-.--£.-'4»mt\\J 
'•Kv 

i ' 1 

• improved safety as a result of eliminating subsidence problems 

! f 

i. : ••; i m 

. i -i . *..."'• ! 

' i I': i 

j i * i •' '-••' '.•: 

ji 1 1 !«; ; • | 

Iij V>1 

l ! J -i. i ;-: 

i ..I?*! 

; **• * M i 

111'-' 

HX: 

liM, 

,.,'.' I 

Iiii 

i 11 „? 

i ':.;' 

2. D-343 

Comment: The standard unfairly precludes the use of anthracite 

3. D-134, F-3 

Comment: Full scrubbing is economically disadvantageous to anthracite coal. 

4. D-l22 

Comment: Contrary to' popular belief, the averge sulfur content of 

Pennsylvania anthracite coal is 1.09 percent, which would 

not meet NAAQS. (presents survey data) 

5. D-439, D-551, D-729 

Comment: Anthracite coal should not be exempt because: 

• drilling data (1977) indicates sulfur content at 1.1Z S 

• uncontrolled emissions would exceed 1.2 lb/10^ Btu 

6. D-487, D-610 

Comment: The standard for anthracite coal should be 1.0 lb SO2/ 

IO6 Btu (floor) in order to: 

• improve water quality in region 

• reduce subsidence 

• encourage reclamation and restoration of abandoned mine areas 

• stimulate anthracite industry 

• increase employment 

• increase water supply 

2-84 
: probit e 

•. 0-552 

^ nc; Problems which these proposed regulations present for 

utilities burning both anthracite and western 

sub-bituminous coal, though not identical, are similar. 

Anthracite is in fact a "local" coal. Western 

sub-bituminous will be used in many areas where there is in 

fact no "local" coal. Thus, under the Act, the fuel 

characteristics of both coals might be taken into 

consideration in establishing percentage reduction 

requirements for steam generating units in certain 

geographic market areas. 

8. H-l5 

Comment: Anthracite has more problems with particulates than do 

other types of coal. Therefore anthracite coal must 

continue to meet all particulate standards, even if 

scrubbers for SO2 should not be required under special 

provisions of the standard applicable to anthracite. 

9 F-la 

Comment: The State of Pennsylvania has an ongoing large-scale 

project for massive reclamation and rehabilitation at 

several abandoned anthracite sites proposed for reopening. 

One area involves 12,000 to 19,000 acres of despoiled land. 

Financial resources are already being assembled to cover 

costs at the first site. This effort indicates clearly the 

potential environmental gains which are possible if a 

2-85 
if 

• $ 

y 

7 

P.6 

federal incentive such as exemption of anthracite coal froi 

the SO2 standard is provided. 

2-86 
if 

TABLE 2-1 

LIST OF PERSONS SUBMITTING WRITTEN COMMENTS 

No. 

1 

2 

3 

Docket 

D-l 

D-2 

D-3 

: No. Commenters 

H. S. King 

(U. S. Resident) 

J. W. Kellog 

(U. S. Resident) 

Alvin P. Fenton 

(U. S. Resident) 

5 

6 

7 

8 

D-4 

D-5 

D-6 

D-7 

D-8 

Mrs. Norman Jackson 

(U. S. Resident) 

Paul C. Williams 

(U. S. Resident) 

Alice C. Grant 

(U. S. Resident) 

Mr. and Mrs. Kenneth Bell 

(U. S. Resident) 

Ray A. Arditi 

(U. S. Resident) 

K 

ifi 

9 

10 

11 

D-9 

D-10 

D-14 

Verlyn Marth 

(U. S. Resident) 

Vallerle J. Prime 

(Citizens United for 

Responsible Energy) 

Bernard L. Cpffindaffer 

(Craigsville Distributing 

Co., Inc.) 

12 

13 

D-15 

D-21 

Richard Rao 

(Research-Cottrell, Inc.) 

H. John Heinz III, U.S.S. 

(U. S. Senate) 

2-2 
P.8 

^^H 

N No. 

l i 

: J' | 53 

!i i|!

 : ] 

!' S ; 55 

i. i 

• ;. jij 

1 :' 

* . 1 . 11 ' IjI ! ' 5 7 

! ! 58 

' l! I'l 

ill ; ' 59 

6 0 

- 61 

If

 62 

li 

ii

 63 

1 j '6 4 

i ij ' 

f 

r 

u? 1 

TABLE 

Docket No. 

D-75 

D-76 

D-77 

D-78 

D-79 

D-80 

D-82 

D-83 

D-84 

D-85 

D-86 

D-87 

D-88 

2-1 (Continued) 

Commenters 

Alvln Blyer 

(U.S. Resident 

John L. Jordan 

(U.S. Resident) 

George Popper 

(U.S. Resident) 

C. David Gorton 

(U.S. Resident) 

Jean Hough 

(U. S. Resident) 

Ernest P. Kline 

(Lt. Governor of Pennsylvania) 

Greg H. Thompson 

(U. S. Resident) 

Tom Paul 

(U. S. Resident) 

Maria Dawn Music 

(U. S. Resident) 

Ken Long 

(U. S. Resident) 

Thane Puissegar 

(U. S. Resident) 

John J. LaFalce 

(U. S. House of Representatives) 

John J. LaFalce 

John Buchanan 

Tom Bevill 

Robert E. Bodham 

Guinn McKay 

Walter Flowers 

G. V. (Sonny) Montgomery 

Henry J. Nowak 

Stanley N. Lundine 

(U. S. House of Representatives) 

2-6 
P.9 

! • 

!• if 

n i 

rt 

lil 

! f 

f •' 

No. 

228 

229 

230 

231 

232 

233 

234 

235 

241 

TABLE 2-1 

Docket No. 

D-254 

D-255 

D-256 

D-257 

D-258 

D-259 

D-260 

D-261 

D-267 

(Continued) 

Commenters 

W. T. Slick, Jr. 

(Exxon Company, U.S.A.) 

S. B. Milligan 

(The Rust Engineering Company) 

R. C. Kuether 

(Kansas Power and Light Company) 

Joseph A. Schulz 

(The Pittston Company Coal Group) 

Dennis R. Nelson 

(U. S. Resident) 

Gene H. Gockley 

(Pennsylvania Power & Light Co.) 

Don Gasper 

(W. Va. Dept. of Natural Resources) 

John A. Scarola 

(EBASCO Services Incorporated) 

236 

237 

238 

239 

240 

D-262 

D-263 

D-264 

D-265 

D-266 

H. E. Bond 

(Atlantic Richfield Company) 

J. D. Phillips 

(City of Colorado Springs) 

Ed Malenovsky 

(U. S. Resident) 

Steve Berg-Hansen 

(Rocky Mountain Energy Company) 

Claude M. Soales, III 

(Orange and Rockland Utilities, 

Inc.) 

John J. Dyson 

(Department of Commerce, 

State of New York) 

2-18 
No. 

294 

295 

296 

297 

298 

299 

300 

301 

302 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-322 F. K. Smith 

(Texas Municipal Power Agency) 

D-323 Carolyn Embry 

(U.S. Resident) 

D-324 Jim Jontz 

(House of Representatives 

State of Indiana) 

D-325 Robert H. Short 

(Portland General Electric Co.) 

D-326 Robert J. Reichelderfer 

(First Presbyterian Church) 

D-327 James Conroy 

(U.S. Resident) 

D-328 Keith Guelff 

(U.S. Resident) 

D-329 Jacob T. Lee 

(Dunn County Electric Cooperative) 

D-330 D. L. Renberger 

(Washington Public Power Supply System) 

303 

304 

305 

306 

D-331 

D-332 

D-333 

D-334 

Lois J. Imhoff 

(The League of Women Voters of 

John J. LaFalce 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Herman E. Talmadge 

(U.S. Senate) 

Ray Roberts. 

Sam B. Hall 

Omar Burleson 

Ahrahani Kazen 

William Mattox 

W. R. Poage 

Charles Wilson 

Tale Malford 

J. Hightower 

Ali E. Teague 

Henry B. Gonzales 

J. J. Pickle 

Bob Krueger 

George Mahon 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

2-23 
p.11 

«.*' ! 

Ml 

.ii 

:•[!: 

j m i 

N 

I •'.-! 

•.*l 

! Jj 

lif. 

No. 

307 

308 

309 

310 

311 

312 

313 

314 

315 

316 

317 

318 

319 

TABLE 2-

Docket No. 

D-335 

D-336 

D-337 

D-338 

D-339 

D-340 

D-341 

D-342 

D-343 

D-344 

D-345 

D-346 

D-347 

I (Continued) 

Commenters 

Frank W. Griffith 

(Iowa Public Service Company) 

W. Henson Moore 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Janice L. Whitten, M.C. 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Dan Daniel 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Norman E. D'Amours 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

Russell A. Holden 

(New England Power Company) 

Charles H. Percy 

(U.S. Senate) 

and 

Kenneth L. Andres 

(Central Illinois Public Service Co.) 

Allyn M. Davis 

(U.S. EPA, Air and Hazardous Materials 

Division) 

Mrs. Magdelene S. Atkinson 

(U.S. Resident) 

W. G. Kuhns 

(General Public Utilities Corp.) 

and 

William A. Verrochi 

(Pennsylvania Electric Company) 

Charles E. Grassley 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Francis E. Drake, Jr. 

(Rochester Gas and Electric Corp.) 

Norman A. Johnson, Jr. 

(Mississippi Public Service Commission) 

A. Frank Brayman III, P.E. 

(U.S. Resident) 

2-24 
P.12 

i: ii 

li AL ] 

•I I 

'I 

m 

'i_\. 

rifs 

B 

H i 

|

! 

I|l0i, 

• 

No. 

366 

367 

368 

369 

370 

371 

372 

373 

374 

375 

376 

377 

378 

379 

380 

D-400 

D-401 

D-402 

D-40 3 

D-404 

D-405 

D-406 

D-407 

D-408 

TABLE 2-1 

Docket No. 

D-394 

D-395 

D-396 

D-397 

D-398 

D-399 

D-400 

(Continued) 

Commenters 

Beryl Reichenberg 

(Clean Air Coalition) 

John and Marilyn Layon 

(U.S. Resident) 

John C. Bhend 

(U.S. Resident) 

D. T. Berube 

(The Montana Power Company) 

Donald Samsen 

(St. Croix County Electric 

Cooperative) 

Don E. Gerard 

(Board of Public Utilities, 

McPherson, Kansas) 

Lawrence L. Roeser 

(Arizonans for Jobs and Energy) 

John J. Bergan 

(Colorado-Ute Electric Assn., Inc.) 

William F. Matson 

(Allegheny Electric Cooperative, Inc.) 

Gerald G. Bachman 

(Mid-Continent Area Power Pool) 

D. D. Jordon 

(Houston Lighting and Power Company) 

William W. Llyons 

(Northern Energy Resources Company)• 

James A. Patton 

(Northern Plains Resource Council) 

Eric N. Sloth, Ph.D. 

(Nebraska Public Power District) 

Irvin D. Parker 

(Dept. of Consumer Affairs, State 

of South Carolina) 

2-28 
No. 

381 

382 

383 

384 

385 

386 

387 

388 

389 

390 

391 

392 

393 

394 

395 

396 

TABLE 2-1 

Docket No. 

D-409 

D-410 

D-411 

D-412 

D-413 

D-414 

D-415 

D-416 

D-417 

D-418 

D-419 

D-420 

D-421 

D-422 

D-423 

D-424 

(Continued) 

Commenters 

J. R. Thorpe 

(GPU Service Corporation) 

John W. Ellis 

(Puget Sound Power and Light Co.) 

Priseilia Maclean 

(League of Women Voters of Montana) 

G. P. Reidy 

(The CAM Company) 

S. David Freeman 

(Tennessee Valley Authority) 

Donald C. Lutken 

(Mississippi Power and Light Company) 

W. M. Taylor 

(Texas Electric Service Company) 

Alan Beals 

(National League of Cities) 

D. R. Betterton 

(Houston Lighting and Power) 

Dr. T.A. Vanderslice 

(General Electric Company) 

Economic Development Council 

of Northeastern Pennsylvania 

H. John Heinz III, U.S.S. 

(United States Senate) 

Glenn G.C. Olson 

(Northern States Power Company) 

Clarence R. Feldman 

(Americans for Energy Independence) 

Jay D. Myster 

(Otter Tail Power Company) 

Abe H. Frumkin 

(representing the Anthracite Development and Utilization Association) 

2-29 
No. 

381 

382 

383 

384 

385 

386 

387 

388 

389 

% 

390 

391 

392 

393 

394 

395 

396 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-409 J. R. Thorpe 

(GPU Service Corporation) 

D-410 John W. Ellis 

(Puget Sound Power and Light Co.) 

D-411 Priscilla Maclean 

(League of Women Voters of Montana) 

D-412 G. P. Reidy 

(The CAM Company) 

D-413 S. David Freeman 

(Tennessee Valley Authority) 

D-414 Donald C. Lutken 

(Mississippi Power and Light Company) 

D-415 W. M. Taylor 

(Texas Electric Service Company) 

D-416 Alan Beals 

(National League of Cities) 

D-417 D. R. Betterton 

(Houston Lighting and Power) 

D-418 Dr. T.A. Vanderslice 

(General Electric Company) 

D-419 Economic Development Council 

of Northeastern Pennsylvania 

D-420 H. John Heinz III, U.S.S. 

(United States Senate) 

D-421 Glenn G.C. Olson 

(Northern States Power Company) 

D-422 Clarence R. Feldman 

(Americans for Energy Independence) 

D-423 Jay D. Myster 

(Otter Tail Power Company) 

D-424 Abe H. Frumkin 

(representing the Anthracite Development and Utilization Association) 

:M. 

2-29 

•:•••• ill11 

.V.a.'t.T'***" * . 
I 

PJ5_ 

412 

413 

414 

415 

416 

417 

418 

419 

420 

421 

422 

423 

424 

425 

426 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-440 A. L. Cahn 

(Bechtel Power Corporation) 

D-441 Jerilyn E. Bieher 

(McCone Women Involved in Farm 

Economics) 

D-442 Richard J. Grant 

(Central Illinois Public Service Co.) 

D-443 L. A. McReynolds 

(Phillips Petroleum Company) 

D-444 James K. Hambright 

(Bureau of Air Quality Control, 

Pennsylvania) 

D-445 Keith Molin 

(Dept. of Commerce, Michigan) 

D-446 Curtis L. Ritland 

(Iowa Power) 

D-447 A.O. Courtney 

(Commonwealth Edison) 

D-448 James L. Mulloy 

(Department of Water and 

Power, City of Los Angeles) 

D-449 Joseph E. Fulton 

(City Public Service Board of 

San Antonio, Texas) 

D-450 H.E. Bond 

(Atlantic Richfield Company) 

D-451 James F. Purcell 

(Northern Indiana Public Service Co.) 

D-452 James N. Howell 

(Great Lakes Steel Div. of National 

Steel Corporation) 

D-453 Russell V. Randle 

(Yale Environmental Law School) 

D-454 Matthew Gould 

(National Assn. of Manufacturers) 

; "M l 

i 

!> 

r!-

•I' i 

2-31 
P.16 

11!:! 

1 il\ 

I] 1 42? 

11 i: 

B ' i 

1 i !| 

1 |; i^:. «o 

1 (• 1 I fS':! '^ I 

• j i 

• :!' 433 

1 

• :' J i : J 434 

1 i r f 435 1 >'' '1 

1 [ :',f:, 436 ' 

1 ' 

1 H 437 

I'ljN

 438 

••'•"• fi If 

[;' l: 439 

f l 

i 

• 'i ! 

A . «... 

TABLE 2-1 

Docket No. 

D-455 

D-456 

D-457 

D-458 

D-459 

D-460 

D-461 

D-462 

D-463 

D-464 

D-465 

D-466 

D-467 

2-32 

• - . 

.•*••• .- . *•! 

(Continued) 

Commenters 

Richard D. McRanie 

(Southern Company Services) 

Dean B. Suagee 

(U.S. Resident) 

James Barrett 

(Michigan State Chamber of 

Commerce) 

Peter H. Benziger 

(Potomac Electric Power 

Company) 

Mary Ellen Schraeder 

(Department of Public Property 

Springfield, Illinois) *' 

Walter T. Woelfle 

(Wisconsin Electric Power 

Company) 

Andrew T. Bahn, P.E. 

(Illinois Power Company) 

Paul H. Arbesman 

(Department of Environmental Protection, New Jersey) 

Joe L. Gremban 

(Sierra Pacific Power Company) 

Robert A. McKnlght 

cXdany)P°

1 1S

 *"" "* "*' 

David M. Anderson 

(Bethlehem Steel Corporation) 

S.F. Sherwood 

(El Paso Coal Company) 

Paul C. Hittie 

(Consumers Power Company) 
\x 

i: 

iii 

!•'••!'•'! 

i :;'•; :i 

! i!? 

! X 

m 

m 

No. 

475 

476 

477 

478 

479 

480 

481 

482 

483 

484 

485 

486 

487 

488 

489 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-503 

D-504 

D-505 

D-506 

D-507 

D-508 

D-509 

D-510 

D-511 

D-512 

D-513 

D-514 

D-515 

D-516 

D-517 

2-36 

Billie Dytzel 

(New Mexico Lung Association) 

Lori Franklin 

(U.S. Resident) 

Paul H. Arbesman 

(Dept. of Environmental 

Protection, New Jersey) 

Emma Hartzler 

(U.S. Resident) 

Brad Bortner 

(University of Vermont) 

David B. Tegart 

(Western Environmental Trade 

Association, Inc.) 

Evelyn Volpe 

(U.S. Resident) 

Carl Pope 

(Sierra Club) 

Arnold Miller 

(United Mine Workers of 

America) 

Harold F. Elkin 

(Sun Company) 

Richard C. Dolsemer 

(U.S. Resident) 

James C. Wilson 

(Western Regional Council) 

Donald B. Ricky 

(Mid-Valley Lung Association) 

James L. Bechtold 

(Northern States Power Company) 

Ethel Morten 

(U.S. Resident) 
!T»: 

il1? 

!': 

\^\ 

' : •• rii 

^ I 

i •:,' 

i. 

i i ; 

ii! 

No. 

515 

516 

517 

518 

519 

520 

521 

522 

523 

524 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. 

D-547 

D-548 

D-549 

D-550 

D-551 

D-552 

D-553 

D-554 

D-555 

D-556 

Commenters 

Robert L. Livingston 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Joel Pritchard 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

Don C. Frisbee 

(Pacific Power & Light Co.) 

Jeffrey Nedelman 

(U.S. Senate) 

and 

Cecile Helsel 

(City of Superior, Wisconsin) 

Gus Yatron 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

Walter M. Creitz 

(Metropolitan Edison Co.) 

and 

W.G. Kuhns 

(General Public Utilities Corp.) 

Emery Nemethy 

(Ecology/Alert) 

Malcolm Wallop 

(U.S. Senate) 

John M. Daniel, Jr. 

(Commonwealth of Virginia, 

State Air Pollution Control Board) 

Robert Hibbard 

(Pennsylvania Chamber of Commerce) 

Margaret M. Heckler 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

William J. Cadigan 

(Massachusetts Electric) 

Thad Cochran 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

2-40 

.;. • 
! A 

No. 

534 

535 

536 

537 

538 

539 

540 

541 

542 

543 

544 

545 

546 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-566 

D-567 

D-568 

D-569 

D-570 

D-571 

D-5 72 

D-573 

D-574 

D-575 

D-576 

D-577 

D-578 

Marty Bender 

(U.S. Resident) 

Leilani Zutrau 

(U.S. Resident) 

Wm. J. Basiliere 

(U.S. Resident) 

Meg Titus 

(League of Women Voters of 

Texas) 

Tracy Caldewey 

(U.S. Resident) 

Frank Beal 

(State of Illinois, Institute 

of Natural Resources) 

J. Stewart Frame 

(U.S. Resident) 

Robert B. Ludgate 

(Pennsylvania Society of 

Professional Engineers) 

Julio Hernandez-Fragoso 

(Puerto Rico Water Resources 

Authority) 

A. E. Michon 

(Burlington Northern) 

Helen Jacobs 

(Southeastern Wisconsin Coalition 

for Clean Air, Technical Committee) 

Robert S. Anderson 

(U.S. Resident) 

Peter S. Duncan 

(Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, 

Joint Legislative Air and Water 

Pollution Control and Conservation 

Committee) 

2-42 
P.20 

No. 

547 

548 

549 

550 

551 

552 

553 

554 

555 

556 

557 

558 

559 

560 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-579 Ed Herschler 

(Governor of Wyoming) 

D-580 John J. Bugas 

(Colorado-Ute Electric 

Association, Inc.) 

D-581 Julian M. Carroll 

(Governor of Kentucky) 

D-582 John A. Scarola 

(Ebasco Services) 

D-583 James L. Grahl 

(Basin Electric Power Cooperative) 

D-584 Joseph S. Ives 

(National Rural Electric 

Cooperative Association) 

D-585 W.G. Hegener 

(Sargent & Lundy Engineers) 

D-586 William F. Zunker 

(CNB Tri-Fuel Boiler) 

D-587 Abe H. Frumkin, Esq. 

(representing the Anthracite 

Development and Utilization 

Association) 

D-588 D.F. Barrett 

(E.I. DuPont De Nemours & Company) 

D-589 Leroy Michael, Jr. 

(Salt River Project) 

D-590 Patricia Schroeder 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

D-591 Gary L. Allison 

(Wheelabrator Chemical Corp.) 

D-592 Rafe Pomerance 

(National Clean Air Coalition) 

2-43 
P.21 

iiiii h 

i .1 

:

fji 

No. 

561 

562 

563 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-593 

D-594 

D-595 

564 D-596 

565 

566 

D-597 

D-598 

567 

568 

D-599 

D-600 

569 

570 

D-601 

D-602 

James L. Bechthold 

(Northern States Power Company) 

Kay Troitino 

(U.S. Resident) 

G. William Whitehurst 

Robert W. Daniel, Jr. 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

Durwood S. Curling 

(Southeastern Public Service 

Authority of Virginia) 

Mark 0. Hatfield 

(U.S. Senate) 

and 

Don C. Frisbee 

(Pacific Power & Light Company) 

Tom Quinn 

(California Governor's Office) 

Bill Proxmire 

(U.S. Senate) 

and 

Cecile Helsel 

(City of Superior, Wisconsin) 

David C. Treen 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Mark 0. Hatfield 

(U.S. Senate) 

and 

Kenneth W. Self 

(Freightline r Corporation) 

Lewis C. Green 

(Green, Hennings & Henry representing the Coalition for the Environment) 

William B. Harral 

(Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, 

Governor's Office) 

2-44 
No. 

571 

572 

573 

574 

575 

576 

577 

578 

579 

580 

581 

582 

TABLE 2-1 (Continued) 

Docket No. Commenters 

D-603 Henry V. Nickel 

(Hunton & Williams representin g 

t h e Utilit y Air Regulatory Group) 

D-604 Not a comment lette r 

D-605 Gaylord Nelson 

(U.S. Senate) 

D-606 Dennis G. Seipp 

(Coal Coordinator, Commonwealth 

of Pennsylvania) 

D-607 Vincent B. Makowski 

(Solicitor, Borough of Marion 

Heights, Pennsylvania) 

D-608 • Frank L. Blackhall 

(U.S. Resident) 

D-609 Gary Rubenstein 

(State of California Air 

Resources Board) 

D-610 William E. Albers 

(The Appalachian Regional 

Commission) 

D-611 Henry V. Nickel 

(Hunton & Williams representing 

the Utility Air Regulatory Group) 

D-612 Ray Thornton 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

Arch Pettit 

(Arkansas Power & Light Company) 

D-613 Harold T. Johnson 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

D-614 David R. Bowen 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

2-45 
No^. 

615 

TABLE 2-1 

Docket No. 

D-6 49 

(Continued) 

Commenters 

Ray Thornton 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

Arch P. Pettit 

(Arkansas Power and Light Co.) 

616 

617 

618 

619 

620 

621 

622 

623 

624 

K 

625 

626 

D-650 

D-653 

D-654 

D-655 

D-656 

D-657 

D-658 

D-659 

D-660 

H. T. Johnson 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

D-651 

D-652 

Scott Matheson 

(Governor of Utah) 

Pamela Zinn 

(The White House) 

and 

John R. Hamann 

(Detroit Edison) 

Gus Yatron 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

J. Hernandez-Fragoso 

(Puerto Rico Water Resources Authority) 

Meg Titus 

(League of Women Voters) 

R. L. White 

(Texas Utilities Generating Co.) 

M. P. Lanahan 

(N.Y. Dept. of Environmental 

Conservation) 

Arlan Stangeland 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

James L. Grahl 

(Basin Electric Power Cooperative) 

Liz Stajduhar 

(U.S. Resident) 

William W. Scranton, III 

(Lt. Governor, State of Pennsylvania) 

2-49 
No. 

657 

658 

659 

660 

TABLE 2-1 

Docket No. 

D-691 

D-692 

D-693 

D-694 

[ (Continued) 

Commenters 

M. Child 

(U.S. Resident) 

Not a comment letter 

Not a comment letter 

John J. Rhodes 

661 

662 

663 

664 

665 

666 

667 

668 

669 

670 

D-695 

D-696 

D-697 

D-698 

D-699 

D-7 00 

D-701 

D-7 02 

D-7 03 

D-704 

Bob Stump 

Eldon Rudd 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

Richard S. Schweiker 

(U.S. Senate) 

Not a comment letter 

C. Oliver 

(U.S. Resident) 

G.C. Freeman, Jr. 

(Hutton fie Williams) 

Utility Air Regulatory Group 

(UARG) 

G.C. Freeman, Jr. 

(Hutton & Williams) 

Not a comment letter 

Paul S. Sarbanes 

(U.S. Senate) 

and 

Richard E. Hug 

(Environmental Elements Corp.) 

J.E. Bicker 

(McCone WIFE) 

N.D. Grasmehr 

(League of Women Voters of 

Ventura County) 

2-53 
ii 

l l 51 

•f 

I. Ml 

I! !' 

No. 

699 

700 

701 

TABLE 2-1 

Docket No. 

D-733 

D-7 34 

D-735 

(Continued) 

Commenters 

Thad Cochran 

(U.S. Senate) 

and 

G. Adam 

(U.S. Resident) 

Not a comment 1 

R.L. Emrich 

702 

703 

704 

705 

706 

707 

708 

709 

710 

711 

(First Presbyterian Church of 

Greensburg, PA) 

D-736 

D-737 

D-738 

D-739 

D-740 

D-741 

D-742 

D-743 

D-744 

D-745 

Not a comment letter 

Not a comment letter 

Unsigned 

(U.S. Resident) 

Not a comment letter 

K. Katzenstein 

(U.S. Resident) 

Not a comment letter 

John Melcher 

(U.S. Senate) 

R.J. Rauch 

(Environmental Defense Fund) 

G.C. Freeman, Jr. 

(Hunton & Williams) 

Paul Simon 

712 D-746 

(U.S. House of Representatives) 

and 

H.L. Deakins 

(Illinois Power Company) 

Dale Bumpers 

(U.S. Senate) 

2-56 
TABLE 2-II 

LIST OF PERSONS PRESENTING TESTIMONY AT THE PUBLIC HEARING 

• i 

n ! 

NO. 

1 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

Docket No. 

F-laa 

F-lb 

F-lbb 

F-lc 

F-lcc 

F-ld 

F-ldd 

F-le 

F-lee 

F-lff 

F-lg 

F-li 

F-lj 

F-ll 

Commenters 

Walter Markey 

(Gilbert Commonwealth) 

John W. Ross . . 

(Montana Power Co.) 

Leonard V. Ziolkowski 

(Economic Development Council) 

Joseph F. Brecher 

(representing The Sierra Club) 

William Savinsky 

(United Mine Workers of America) 

James McCarville 

(City of Superior, Wisconsin) 

Robert Lazarchik 

(Joint Authority Committee) 

Al Johnson 

(Johnson Brothers Corporation) 

George Gensemer 

(SEDA - Council of Governments) 

Frank Zukas 

(Greater Pottsville Area Chamber 

of Commerce) 

George Greene. 

(Public Service Company of 

Colorado) 

Carl M. Shy, M.D. 

(American Lung Association) 

Meg Titus 

(League of Women Voters of the U.S.) 

Reverend Bruce Tischler 

(Joint Program Agency of Lehigh 

and Lackawanna Presbyteries of the 

United Presbyterian Church) 

2-58 
P.27 

TABLE 2-II (Concluded) 

No. 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

Docket No. 

F-ln 

F-lo 

F-lq 

F-lr 

F-ls 

F-lt 

F-lu 

F-lw 

F-lx 

F-ly 

F-lz 

F-2 

F-3 

Commenters 

Robert Rauch 

(Environmental Defense Fund) 

Daniel Schwartzman 

(Health Resources Management, 

University of Illinois, 

School of Public Health) 

Thomas G. Healy 

(National Coal Association) 

William Albers 

(Appalachian Regional Commission) 

B. G. Godec 

(Utilities of the City of 

Colorado Springs) 

Richard Ayers 

(NRDC) 

George C. Freeman, Jr. 

(Utility Air Regulatory Group) 

John R. McNamara 

(Power Salt River Project) 

Raymond E. Kary, Ph.D. 

(Arizona Public Service Corp.) 

Dennis Eyre 

(Western Systems Coordinating 

Council) 

Irwin Tucker 

(Professor, Univ. of Louisville) 

George P. Green 

(Public Service Company of 

Colorado) 

Allen E. Ertel 

(U.S. House of Representatives)' 

m 

i M 

:

 ;m 

2-59 
.1 

P.28 

TABLE 2-III 

LIST OF OFFICIAL WRITTEN COMMENTS FROM 

OTHER FEDERAL ORGANIZATIONS 

No. 

1 

Docket No. 

H-5 

Commenters 

William V. Skidmore 

(General Council of Commerce) 

H-6 Deputy Assistant Secretary 

(United States Department of 

the Interior) 

H-8 Acting Director of the National 

Park Service 

lil; 

i'i 

10 

11 

12 

H-9 

H-10 

H-ll 

H-12 

H-13 

H-14 

H-15 

H-17 

H-19 

S. David Freeman 

(Tennessee Valley Authority) 

John F. O'Leary 

(Department of Energy) 

Cecil D. Andrews 

(U.S. Department of the Interior) 

Barry P. Bosworth 

(Council on Wage and Price 

Stability) 

William V. Skidmore 

(General Counsel of the U.S. 

Department of Commerce) 

Daniel Badger 

(Department of Energy) 

Jerry Pell 

(Anthracite Division, Office of 

Coal Supply, Dept. of Energy) 

John F. O'Leary 

(Department of Energy) 

Bob Bergland 

(Department of Agriculture) 

2-60