p. 1 

# OAR Box 1828 Prepped byOllie Stewart



## Document

Number: 

# 301 ) IV-A-1 1 Docket Number: 

# A-83-2 7

Printed 11/12/200811:12:59AM Sheet 301 of 325P.2 _

> -Mm r 

# oEPA Unite d State s Environmenta l Protectio n Agency Offic e ofAi rQualit y, Plannin g an d Standard ! Researc h Triangl e Par k 

# A-83-27 Ai r IV-A-1 1 

# Electri c Utilit yStea m Generatin g Unit s Backgroun d Informatio n fo rPromulgate d Emissio n Standard s EI S

S £ _P. 3 

## mm

2.3. 3 - Specia lIssue s Anthracit eCoa l 1 . D-21 , D-80 , D-259 , D-326 , D-343 , D-402 , D-409 , D-419 , D-420 , D-422 , D-42'*> , D-444 , D-465 , D-511 , D-554 , D-573 , D-578 , D-584 , D-587 , D-602 , D-606 , D-607 , D-653 , D-660 , D-695 , D-735 , F-la , F-ll , F-lr , F-lcc , F-ldd , F-lee , F-lff , H-10 , H-1 5 Comment : Anthracit e coa l shoul d be exemp t fro mSO 2 regulation s o r a specia l standard establishe d because :

• natura l lo

wsulfur conten t wil l have littl e impac t o n S0 £ emission s

• standard woul d encourag e us e o f highsulfur coa l e reopening an

d reclamatio n o f anthracit e mine s woul d encourag e or requir e stric t lan d reclamatio n whic hi s beneficia l an d wil l resul t i n cleaning u p o f cul mpile s

• economi c benefi t t o anthracit e regio n

• unprove n control s o n anthracit e

• othe r fuel s (e.g. , lignite ) hav e relate d standard s

• sinc e N0 Xstandard doe s no t mentio n anthracite , preceden t fo r exemptio n alread yexist s

• l=s s stringen t standard wil l permi t anthracit e t o compet e wirhothe r source s o f coa l whic har e cheape r t o min e

• woul d produc e n o mor e SO 2 emission s wit hexemptio n fro m scrubbing than hig

hsulfur bituminou s coa l wit hful l scrubbing

• anthracit e i s a t a competitiv e disadvantag e becaus e i t i s al mos t entirel yobtaine d fro mdeep mining o f previousl yworke d area s ,

• improve d wate r qualit ya s a resul t o f alleviating existing acid-min e drainag e problem s !*?> H

2-8 3

•,^-,.-.--£.-'4»mt\\J'•Kv

i ' 1

• improve dsafet y a s a resul t of eliminatin g subsidenc e prob lem s

! f

i . : ••

; im

. i -i . *..."'• ! ' iI' : i j i* i•

' '-••' '.• : j i1 1 !«; ; • | Ii j V>1 l ! J -i. i ;- : i ..I?* !

; ** •* M i 

## 111'- ' HX: 

### liM ,

,.,'. ' I 

### Iii i i 1 1 „ ? i ' : .; ' 2 . D-34 3 Comment : The standar dunfairly

preclude s th

e us e o f anthracit e 3 . D-134 , F- 3 Comment : Ful l scrubbin g i s economicall y

disadvantageou s to anthra cit e coal . 4 . D-l2 2 Comment : Contrar

y to ' popular belief , th e averge sulfu

r content of Pennsylvani a anthracit e coa l i s 1.0 9 percent , whichwoul d no t mee t NAAQS . (present s surve y data ) 5 . D-439 , D-551 , D-72 9 Comment : Anthracit e coa l shouldnot b e exempt because : • drillin

g dat a (1977 ) indicate s sulfu r content a

t 1.1 Z S • uncontrolle

demissions woul dexcee d1. 2 lb/10 ^ Bt u 6 . D-487 , D-61 0 Comment : Th

e standar

dfo r anthracit e coa l shoul db e 1. 0 l bSO2 / IO 6 Bt u(floor ) inorder to : • improv

e wate r quality

inregio

n • reduc e subsidenc e • encourage reclamatio nan drestoratio

no f abandone

dmin e area s • stimulat e anthracit e industr y • increas e employment • increas e water supply

2-8 4: prob it e • . 0-55 2

^ nc ; Problems whic hthes e propose d regulation s presen t fo r

utilitie s burning bot hanthracit e an d wester n sub-bituminou s coal , thoughno t identical , ar e similar . Anthracit e i s i n fac t a "local " coal . Wester n sub-bituminou s wil l b e use d i n man yarea s wher e ther e i s i n fac t n o "local " coal . Thus , unde r the Act , th e fue l characteristic s o f bot hcoal s migh t b e take n int o consideratio n i n establishing percentag e reductio n requirement s fo r steamgenerating unit s i n certai n geographi c marke t areas . 8 . H-l 5 Comment : Anthracit e ha s mor e problem s wit hparticulate s than d o

othe r type s o f coal . Therefor e anthracit e coa l mus t continu e t o mee t al l particulat e standards , eve n i f scrubber s fo r SO 2 shoul d no t b e require d unde r specia l provision s o f the standard applicabl e t o anthracite . 9 F-l a Comment : Th e Stat e o f Pennsylvani a ha s a n ongoing large-scal e

projec t fo r massiv e reclamatio n an d rehabilitatio n a t severa l abandone d anthracit e site s propose d fo r reopening . On e are a involve s 12,00 0 t o 19,00 0 acre s o f despoile d land . Financia l resource s ar e alread ybeing assemble d t o cove r cost s a t the firs t site . Thi s effor t indicate s clearl ythe potentia l environmenta l gain s whic har e possibl e i f a 2-8 5i f

• $ y 7 P. 6

federa l incentiv

e suc ha s exemptio

nof anthracit e coa l fro i th e SO 2 standar

di s provided .

2-8 6

# if TABL E 2- 1 LIS T OF PERSON S SUBMITTIN GWRITTE

N COMMENT S



### No . 1 2 3 Docket



### D- l D- 2 D- 3 : No . Commenter s

H . S . Kin

g (U . S . Resident ) J . W . Kellog (U . S . Resident ) Alvi nP . Fenton (U . S . Resident )

5 6 7 8 

### D- 4

D- 5 D- 6 D- 7 D- 8 Mrs . NormanJackson

(U . S . Resident ) Pau l C . Williams (U . S . Resident ) Alic e C . Grant (U . S . Resident ) Mr . an dMrs . KennethBel l (U . S . Resident ) Ra y A . Ardit i (U . S . Resident )



### K 

# if i 9 1 0 1 1 D- 9

D-1 0
D-1 4 Verly nMart h (U . S . Resident ) Vallerl e J . Prim

e (Citizens Unitedfor Responsibl e Energy ) Bernar dL . Cpffindaffe r (Craigsvill e Distributin g Co. , Inc. ) 

### 1 2 1 3 D-1 5

D-2 1 Richar dRao (Research-Cottrell , Inc. ) H . Joh nHein z III , U.S.S . (U . S . Senate ) 

### 2- 2P. 8



## ^^ H N No . 

# l i 

# : J ' 

# | 5

3 

# | ] ! i i ! : !' S ; 5 5 i. i

• ; . ji j 1 : ' * . 1 . 

# 1 1

' Ij I ! ' 5 7 ! ! 5 8

' l ! I'l 

# ill ;' 5

9

6 0



### - 6 1 

# If 6

2 l i 

# ii6

3 1 j '6 4 

# i i j 

# '

f r 

## u ? 1 TABLE Docke t No . D-7 5 D-7 6 D-7 7 D-7 8 D-7 9 D-8 0 D-8 2 D-8 3 D-8 4 D-8 5 D-8 6 D-8 7 D-8 8 2- 1 (Continued ) Commenter s Alvl nBlye r (U.S . Resident Joh nL . Jorda

n (U.S . Resident ) George Poppe r (U.S . Resident ) C . Davi dGorto

n (U.S . Resident ) JeanHoug

h (U . S . Resident ) Ernes t P . Kline (Lt . Governor o f Pennsylvania ) Greg H . Thompso

n (U . S . Resident ) To m Pau l (U . S . Resident ) Mari a Daw

nMusi c (U . S . Resident ) KenLon g (U . S . Resident ) Thane Puissegar (U . S . Resident ) Joh nJ . LaFalc e (U . S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Joh nJ . LaFalc e Joh nBuchanan To m Bevil l Rober t E . Bodha

m Guin nMcKa y Walte r Flower s G . V . (Sonny ) Montgomer y Henr y J . Nowak Stanle y N . Lundine (U . S . Hous e o f Representatives ) 2- 6P. 9

! • ! •i f



## n 

## i



## rt 

# li l ! f f• ' No . 22 8 22 9 23 0 23 1 23 2 23 3 23 4 23 5

24 1 TABL E 2- 1 Docke tNo . D-25 4 D-25 5 D-25 6 D-25 7 D-25 8 D-25 9 D-26 0 D-26 1

D-26 7 (Continued ) Commenter s W . T . Slick , Jr . (Exxon Company , U.S.A. ) S . B . Milliga n (Th e Rus t Engineering Company ) R . C . Kuethe r (Kansa s Powe r an

d Ligh t Company ) JosephA . Schul z (Th e Pittsto n Compan

yCoa l Group ) Denni s R . Nelso n (U . S . Resident ) Gen e H . Gockle y (Pennsylvani a Powe r & Ligh t Co. ) Do n Gaspe r (W . Va . Dept . o f Natura l Resources ) John A . Scarol a (EBASCO Service s Incorporated ) 

### 23 6 23 7 23 8 23 9 24 0 D-26 2

D-26 3 D-26 4 D-26 5 D-26 6 H . E . Bond

(Atlanti c Richfiel d Company ) J . D . Phillip s (Cityo f Colorad o Springs ) E d Malenovsky (U . S . Resident ) Stev e Berg-Hanse n (Rock yMountai n EnergyCompany ) Claud e M . Soales , II I (Orang e and Rockland Utilities , Inc. ) John J . Dyso n (Departmen t o f Commerce , Stat e o f Ne wYork )

2-1 8No . 29 4 29 5 29 6
29 7 29 8 29 9 30 0 30 1 30 2 TABL E 2- 1 (Continued )

Docke t No . Commenter s D-32 2 F . K . Smit h

(Texa s Municipa lPowe r Agency ) D-32 3 Caroly nEmbry

(U.S . Resident ) D-32 4 Ji mJont z

(Hous e o f Representative s Stat e o f Indiana ) D-32 5 Rober t H . Shor t

(Portlan

d Genera l Electri c Co. ) D-32 6 Rober t J . Reichelderfe r

(Firs t Presbyteria n Church ) D-32 7 Jame s Conroy

(U.S . Resident ) D-32 8 Keit hGuelf f

(U.S . Resident ) D-32 9 Jaco bT . Le e

(Dun n Count yElectri c Cooperative ) D-33 0 D . L . Renberge r

(Washingto n Publi c Powe r Suppl ySystem ) 

### 30 3 30 4 30 5 30 6 D-33 1

D-33 2 D-33 3 D-33 4 Loi s J . Imhof f

(The Leagu e o f Wome n Voter s o f John J . LaFalc e (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Herma n E . Talmadg e (U.S . Senate ) RayRoberts . SamB . Hal l Oma r Burleso n Ahrahan i Kaze n WilliamMatto x W . R . Poag e Charle s Wilso n Tal e Malfor d J . Hightowe r Al i E . Teagu e HenryB . Gonzale s J . J . Pickl e BobKruege r Georg e Maho n (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) 2-2 3p.1 1

«.* ' ! 

## M l

.i i :•[! :

j m i



## N

I•'.- ! •.* l ! J j lif . No . 30 7 30 8 30 9 31 0 31 1

31 2

31 3 31 4 31 5

31 6 31 7 31 8 31 9 TABL E 2 - Docke tNo . D-33 5 D-33 6 D-33 7 D-33 8 D-33 9

D-34 0

D-34 1 D-34 2 D-34 3

D-34 4 D-34 5 D-34 6 D-34 7 I (Continued ) Commenter s Frank W . Griffit h (Iow a Publi c Servic e Company ) W . Henso n Moor e (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Janic e L . Whitten , M.C . (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Da n Danie l (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Norma n E . D'Amour s (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d Russel l A . Holde n (NewEngland Powe r Company ) Charle s H . Perc y (U.S . Senate ) an d Kennet hL . Andre s (Centra l Illinoi s Publi c Servic e Co. ) Ally n M . Davi s (U.S . EPA , Ai r an

d Hazardou s Material s Division ) Mrs . Magdelen e S . Atkinso n (U.S . Resident ) W . G . Kuhn s (Genera l Publi c Utilitie s Corp. ) and WilliamA . Verroch i (Pennsylvani a Electri c Company ) Charle s E . Grassle y (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Franci s E . Drake , Jr . (Rocheste r Ga s an

d Electri c Corp. ) Norma n A . Johnson , Jr . (Mississipp i Publi c Servic e Commission ) A . Frank Brayma n III , P.E . (U.S . Resident ) 2-2 4P.1 2

i : i i

l iAL ]

• I I 

# ' I

m 'i_\. 

### rifs B

H i | ! 

### I|l0i ,

• No . 36 6 36 7 36 8 36 9 37 0 37 1 

### 37 2 37 3 37 4 37 5 37 6 37 7 37 8 37 9 38 0 D-40 0

D-40 1 D-40 2 D-4 0 3 D-40 4 D-40 5 D-40 6 D-40 7 D-40 8 TABL E 2- 1 Docke t No . D-39 4 D-39 5 D-39 6 D-39 7 D-39 8
D-39 9
D-40 0 (Continued )

Commenter s Bery l Reichenber g (Clean Ai r Coalition ) John an d Marily

n Layo n (U.S . Resident ) Joh n C . Bhen

d (U.S . Resident ) D . T . Berub e (Th e Montan a Powe r Company ) Donal d Samse n (St . Croi xCount yElectri c Cooperative ) Do n E . Gerard (Boar d o f Publi c Utilities , McPherson , Kansas ) Lawrenc e L . Roese r (Arizonan s fo rJob s an dEnergy ) Joh n J . Bergan (Colorado-Ut e Electri c Assn. , Inc. ) WilliamF . Matso n (Alleghen

yElectri c Cooperative , Inc. ) Geral d G . Bachma n (Mid-Continen t Are a Powe r Pool ) D . D . Jordo n (Houston Lighting an d Powe r Company ) Willia mW . Llyon s (Northern Energ

yResource s Company) • Jame s A . Patto n (Northern Plain s Resourc e Council ) Eri c N . Sloth , Ph.D . (Nebraska Publi c Powe r District ) Irvi n D . Parke r (Dept . o f Consume r Affairs , Stat e o f Sout hCarolina ) 2-2 8No . 38 1 38 2 38 3 38 4 38 5 38 6 38 7 38 8 38 9 39 0 39 1 39 2 39 3 39 4 39 5 39 6 TABLE 2- 1

Docke t No . D-40 9 D-41 0 D-41 1 D-41 2 D-41 3 D-41 4 D-41 5 D-41 6 D-41 7 D-41 8 D-41 9 D-42 0 D-42 1 D-42 2 D-42 3 D-42 4 (Continued )

Commenter s J . R . Thorpe (GP UServic e Corporation ) Joh nW . Elli s (Puget Soun

dPowe r an

dLight Co. ) Priseili a Maclean (Leagu e o f WomenVoter s o f Montana ) G . P . Reid

y (Th e CA M Company ) S . Davi dFreeman (Tennessee Valle

y Authority ) Donal dC . Lutken (Mississipp i Powe r an dLight Company ) W . M . Taylor (Texas Electri c Servic e Company ) AlanBeal s (Nationa l League o f Cities ) D . R . Betterto

n (Housto nLightin

g an dPower ) Dr . T.A . Vanderslic e (Genera l Electri c Company ) Economi c Development Counci l o f Northeaster

nPennsylvani a H . Joh nHein z III , U.S.S . (Unite dState s Senate ) Glen nG.C . Olso

n (Norther

nState s Power Company ) Clarenc e R . Feldma

n (Americans fo

r Energ y Independence ) Ja y D . Myste r (Otte r Tai l Power Company ) Abe H . Frumki n (representin

g th e Anthracit e Develop ment an dUtilizatio

nAssociation ) 2-2 9No .

38 1 38 2 38 3 38 4 38 5 38 6 38 7 38 8 38 9 % 39 0 39 1 39 2 39 3 39 4 39 5 39 6 TABL E 2- 1 (Continued )

Docke t No . Commenter s D-40 9 J . R . Thorpe

(GP UServic e Corporation ) D-41 0 Joh

nW . Elli s (Puget Soun

dPowe r an

dLight Co. ) D-41 1 Priscill a Maclean

(Leagu e o f WomenVoter s o f Montana ) D-41 2 G . P . Reid y (Th e CA M Company ) D-41 3 S . Davi dFreeman

(Tennessee Valle

y Authority ) D-41 4 Donal dC . Lutken

(Mississipp i Powe r an dLight Company ) D-41 5 W . M . Taylor

(Texas Electri c Servic e Company ) D-41 6 AlanBeal s

(Nationa l League o f Cities ) D-41 7 D . R . Betterto n (Housto nLightin

g an dPower ) D-41 8 Dr . T.A . Vanderslic e

(Genera l Electri c Company ) D-41 9 Economi c Developmen t Counci l

o f Northeaster

nPennsylvani a D-42 0 H . Joh

nHein z III , U.S.S . (Unite dState s Senate ) D-42 1 Glen

nG.C . Olso

n (Norther

nState s Powe r Company ) D-42 2 Clarenc e R . Feldma n (Americans fo

r Energ y Independence ) D-42 3 Ja

y D . Myste r (Otte r Tai l Powe r Company ) D-42 4 Abe H . Frumki n

(representin

g th e Anthracit e Develop ment an dUtilizationAssociation ) :M . 2-2 9 •:••• • ill 1 1

.V.a.'t.T'*** " *

.

# I PJ5 _

41 2 41 3
41 4 41 5 41 6
41 7 41 8 41 9 42 0
42 1
42 2 42 3 42 4
42 5 42 6 TABL E 2- 1 (Continued )

Docke t No . Commenter s D-44 0 A . L . Cah n (Bechte l Powe r Corporation ) D-44 1 Jerily

n E . Biehe r (McCon e Wome n Involve d i n Farm Economics ) D-44 2 Richar d J . Gran t

(Centra l Illinoi s Publi c Servic e Co. ) D-44 3 L . A . McReynold s

(Phillip s Petroleu

mCompany ) D-44 4 Jame s K . Hambrigh t

(Bureau o f Ai r Qualit yControl , Pennsylvania ) D-44 5 Keit hMoli n

(Dept . o f Commerce , Michigan ) D-44 6 Curti s L . Ritland

(Iow a Power ) D-44 7 A.O . Courtne y

(Commonwealt hEdison ) D-44 8 Jame s L . Mullo y

(Departmen t o f Wate r an d Power , Cit yo f Lo s Angeles ) D-44 9 JosephE . Fulto n

(CityPubli c Servic e Board o f San Antonio , Texas ) D-45 0 H.E . Bon d (Atlanti c Richfiel d Company ) D-45 1 Jame s F . Purcel l



### (Norther nIndian aPubli c Servic eCo. ) D-45 2 Jame s N . Howel l

(Grea t Lake s Stee l Div . o f Nationa l Stee l Corporation ) D-45 3 Russel l V . Randl e

(Yal e Environmenta l La wSchool ) D-45 4 Matthe wGoul d

(Nationa l Assn . o f Manufacturers ) ; " Ml 

### i
!>



### r! -

•I' i 2-3 1P.1 6 

# 11!: ! 1 

# il\ I ] 1 42

? 

# 1 1 i : B ' i 

# 1

# i ! 

# | 1 | ; i^ :

# . « o 

# 1( •1 I fS': ! 

# ' ^ I • j i • :! ' 43 3 

# 1 • : 

## ' Ji : J43 4 

# 1 ir f 

# 43 5 

# 1 >' ' ' 1 1 [ : 

## ',

f 

## : , 43 6 ' 1 ' 

# 1 H43

7 I'lj N 4 

# 3 8

••'•" • fi I f 

### [; ' l : 

### 43 9 

# f l i

• 'i ! A . «.. . TABL E 2- 1 Docke t No . D-45 5 D-45 6 D-45 7
D-45 8
D-45 9
D-46 0
D-46 1 D-46 2
D-46 3 D-46 4
D-46 5 D-46 6 D-46 7

2-3 2

• - . .•*•• • . - . *• !

(Continued ) Commenter s

Richar d D . McRani e (Southern Compan

yServices ) Dea n B . Suage e (U.S . Resident ) Jame s Barret t (Michigan Stat e Chambe r o f Commerce ) Pete r H . Benzige r (Potoma c Electri c Powe r Company ) MaryElle n Schraede r (Departmen t o f Publi c Propert y Springfield , Illinois ) * ' Walte r T . Woelfl e (Wisconsi n Electri c Powe r Company ) Andre wT . Bahn , P.E . (Illinoi s Powe r Company ) Pau l H . Arbesma n (Departmen t o f Environ
menta l Protection , Ne wJersey ) Jo e L . Gremba n (Sierr a Pacifi c Powe r Company ) Rober t A . McKnlgh t 

# cX d 

# any) P 

# ° 1 1 S 

# *""" * "* ' Davi d M . Anderso n (BethlehemStee l Corporation ) S.F . Sherwoo d (E l Pas o Coa l Company ) Pau l C . Hitti e (Consumer s Powe r Company )

# \x i: 

# ii i

!•'••!'•' !

i :;'• ; : i 

# ! i! ?

! 

### X



## m m No . 47 5 47 6 47 7
47 8 47 9 48 0
48 1 48 2 48 3
48 4 48 5 48 6 48 7 48 8 48 9 TABLE 2- 1 (Continued )

Docke t No . Commenter s D-50 3 D-50 4 D-50 5 D-50 6 D-50 7 D-50 8 D-50 9 D-51 0 D-51 1 D-51 2 D-51 3 D-51 4 D-51 5 D-51 6 D-51 7 2-3 6 Billi e Dytze l (Ne w Mexic o Lun

g Association ) Lor i Frankli n (U.S . Resident ) Pau l H . Arbesma

n (Dept . o f Environmenta l Protection , Ne

w Jersey ) Emm a Hartzler (U.S . Resident ) Bra dBortner (Universit

y o f Vermont ) Davi dB . Tegar t (Wester nEnvironmenta l Trade Association , Inc. ) Evely nVolpe (U.S . Resident ) Car l Pope (Sierr a Club ) Arnol dMille r (Unite dMine Worker s o f America ) Harol dF . Elki n (Su nCompany ) Richar dC . Dolseme r (U.S . Resident ) Jame s C . Wilson (Wester nRegiona l Council ) Donal dB . Rick

y (Mid-Valle

y Lun g Association ) Jame s L . Bechtol d (Norther

nState s Power Company ) Ethe l Morten (U.S . Resident )

### !T» :

il 1 ? !' :

\^\

' : •• rii 

# ^ I
i •:, '

i . ii ; 

## ii ! No . 51 5 51 6

51 7

51 8

51 9 52 0 52 1 52 2 52 3

52 4 TABL E2- 1 (Continued ) Docke t No . D-54 7 D-54 8

D-54 9

D-55 0

D-55 1 D-55 2 D-55 3 D-55 4 D-55 5

D-55 6 Commenter s Rober t L . Livingsto n (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Joe l Pritchar d (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d Do n C . Frisbe e (Pacifi c Powe r & Ligh t Co. ) Jeffre yNedelma n (U.S . Senate ) an d Cecil e Helse l (Cityo f Superior , Wisconsin ) Gu s Yatro n (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d Walte r M . Creit z (Metropolitan Ediso n Co. ) an d W.G . Kuhn s (Genera l Publi c Utilitie s Corp. ) EmeryNemeth

y (Ecology/Alert ) Malcol mWallo p (U.S . Senate ) John M . Daniel , Jr . (Commonwealt ho f Virginia , Stat e Ai r Pollutio n Contro l Board ) Rober t Hibbar d (Pennsylvani a Chambe r o f Commerce ) Margare t M . Heckle r (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d WilliamJ . Cadigan (Massachusett s Electric ) Thad Cochra n (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) 2-4 0

.;. •! A No . 53 4 53 5 53 6 53 7
53 8 53 9
54 0 54 1
54 2
54 3 54 4
54 5 54 6 TABL E 2- 1 (Continued )

Docke t No . Commenter s D-56 6 D-56 7 D-56 8 D-56 9 D-57 0 D-57 1 D- 5 7 2 D-57 3 D-57 4 D-57 5 D-57 6 D-57 7 D-57 8 Mart yBende r (U.S . Resident ) Leilan i Zutra u (U.S . Resident ) Wm . J . Basilier e (U.S . Resident ) Me g Titu s (Leagu e o f Wome n Voter s o f Texas ) Trac yCaldewe y (U.S . Resident ) Frank Bea l (Stat e o f Illinois , Institut e o f Natura l Resources ) J . Stewar t Frame (U.S . Resident ) Rober t B . Ludgat e (Pennsylvani a Societ yo f Professiona l Engineers ) Juli o Hernandez-Fragos o (Puert o Ric o Wate r Resource s Authority ) A . E . Micho n (Burlingto n Northern ) Hele n Jacob s (Southeastern Wisconsi n Coalitio n fo r Clea n Air , Technica l Committee ) Rober t S . Anderso n (U.S . Resident ) Pete r S . Dunca n (Commonwealt ho f Pennsylvania , Join t Legislativ e Ai r an d Wate r Pollutio n Contro l an d Conservatio n Committee ) 2-4 2P.2 0

No . 54 7 54 8
54 9 55 0 55 1 55 2
55 3 55 4 55 5

55 6 55 7 55 8 55 9 56 0 TABL E 2- 1 (Continued )

Docke t No . Commenter s D-57 9 E d Herschle r

(Governo r o f Wyoming ) D-58 0 John J . Buga s

(Colorado-Ut e Electri c Association , Inc. ) D-58 1 Julia n M . Carrol l

(Governo r o f Kentucky ) D-58 2 John A . Scarol a

(Ebasc o Services ) D-58 3 Jame s L . Grah l

(Basi n Electri c Powe r Cooperative ) D-58 4 Josep hS . Ive s

(Nationa l Rura l Electri c Cooperativ e Association ) D-58 5 W.G . Hegene r

(Sargen t & Lund

yEngineers ) D-58 6 WilliamF . Zunke r

(CN B Tri-Fue l Boiler ) D-58 7 Ab e H . Frumkin , Esq .

(representing the Anthracit e Developmen t an

d Utilizatio n Association ) D-58 8 D.F . Barret t

(E.I . DuPon t D e Nemour s & Company ) D-58 9 Lero yMichael , Jr .

(Sal t Rive r Project ) D-59 0 Patrici a Schroede r

(U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) D-59 1 Gar yL . Alliso n (Wheelabrato r Chemica l Corp. ) D-59 2 Raf e Pomeranc e

(Nationa l Clea n Ai r Coalition ) 2-4 3P.2 1

iiii i h i . 1

: fj i No . 56 1 56 2 56 3 TABL E 2- 1 (Continued ) Docke tNo . Commenter s D-59 3 D-59 4 D-59 5

56 4 D-59 6

56 5 56 6 D-59 7

D-59 8

56 7 56 8 D-59 9

D-60 0

56 9 57 0 D-60 1

D-60 2 Jame s L . Bechthol d

(Northern State s Powe r Company ) KayTroitin o (U.S . Resident ) G . WilliamWhitehurs t Rober t W . Daniel , Jr . (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d Durwoo d S . Curling (Southeastern Publi c Servic e Authorit yo f Virginia ) Mar k 0 . Hatfiel d (U.S . Senate ) and Do n C . Frisbe e (Pacifi c Powe r & Ligh t Company ) To mQuinn (Californi a Governor' s Office ) Bil l Proxmir e (U.S . Senate ) an d Cecil e Helse l (Cityo f Superior , Wisconsin ) Davi dC . Tree n (U.S . Hous eo f

Representatives ) Mar k0 . Hatfiel d (U.S . Senate ) an d Kennet hW

. Sel f (Freightline rCorporation ) Lewi s C . Gree n (Green , Henning s & Henr yrepresent in gth eCoalitio nfo rth eEnvironment ) Willia mB . Harra l (Commonwealtho f

Pennsylvania , Governor' s Office ) 2-4 4No . 57 1 57 2 57 3 57 4 57 5 57 6 57 7 57 8 57 9 58 0

58 1 58 2 TABL E2- 1 (Continued ) Docke t No . Commenter s D-60 3 Henr y V . Nicke l

(Hunto n& William s representin g t h eUtilit y Ai r

Regulator y Group ) D-60 4 No t acommen t

lette r D-60 5 Gaylor d Nelso n

(U.S . Senate ) D-60 6 Denni s G . Seipp

(Coa l Coordinator , Commonwealt h o f Pennsylvania ) D-60 7 Vincen t B . Makowsk i

(Solicitor , Borougho f Mario n Heights , Pennsylvania ) D-60 8 • Frank L . Blackhal l

(U.S . Resident ) D-60 9 GaryRubenstei n

(Stat e o f Californi a Ai r Resource s Board ) D-61 0 WilliamE . Alber s

(The Appalachia n Regiona l Commission ) D-61 1 HenryV . Nicke l

(Hunto n & William s representing th e Utilit yAi r RegulatoryGroup ) D-61 2 RayThornto n

(U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) and Arc hPetti t (Arkansa s Powe r & Ligh t Company ) D-61 3 Harol d T . Johnso n

(U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) D-61 4 Davi d R . Bowe n

(U.S . Hous e o f Representatives )

2-4 5No^ .



### 61 5 TABL E 2- 1

Docke t No . D- 6 4 9 (Continued ) Commenter s Ra yThornto n (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d Arc hP . Petti t (Arkansa s Powe r an d Ligh t Co. ) 

### 61 6 61 7 61 8

61 9 62 0 62 1 62 2 62 3

62 4 

# K

62 5 62 6 D-65 0

D-65 3 D-65 4 D-65 5 D-65 6 D-65 7

D-65 8

D-65 9 D-66 0 H . T . Johnso n (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) D-65 1 D-65 2 Scot t Matheso n (Governo r o f Utah ) Pamel a Zin n (Th e Whit e House ) 

### an d Joh n R . Haman n (Detroi t Edison ) Gu s Yatro n (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) J . Hernandez-Fragos o (Puert o Ric o Wate r Resource s Authority ) Me g Titu s (Leagu e o f Wome n Voters ) R . L . Whit e (Texa s Utilitie s Generatin g Co. ) M . P . Lanaha n (N.Y . Dept . o f Environmenta l Conservation ) Arla n Stangelan d (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d Jame s L . Grah l (Basi n Electri c Powe r Cooperative ) Li z Stajduha r (U.S . Resident ) Willia mW . Scranton , II I (Lt . Governor , Stat e o f Pennsylvania )
2-4 9

### No .

65 7 65 8 65 9 66 0 TABL E 2- 1

Docke t No . D-69 1 D-69 2 D-69 3 D-69 4 [ (Continued ) Commenter s M . Chil d (U.S . Resident ) No t a commen t lette r No t a commen t lette r Joh n J . Rhode s

66 1 66 2 66 3 66 4 66 5 66 6 66 7 66 8



### 66 9 67 0 D-69 5

D-69 6 D-69 7 D-69 8 D-69 9 D- 7 0 0 D-70 1 D- 7 0 2

D- 7 0 3 D-70 4 BobStum p Eldo n Rud

d (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) Richard S . Schweike r (U.S . Senate ) No t a commen t lette r C . Olive r (U.S . Resident ) G.C . Freeman , Jr . (Hutton fie Williams ) Utilit yAi r RegulatoryGrou p (UARG ) G.C . Freeman , Jr . (Hutton & Williams ) No t a commen t lette r Pau l S . Sarbane s (U.S . Senate ) an d Richard E . Hug (Environmenta l Element s Corp. ) J.E . Bicke r (McCon e WIFE ) N.D . Grasmehr (Leagu e o f Wome n Voter s o f Ventur a County ) 2-5 3i

i

l l 5 1

• f I . M l I ! ! ' 

### No . 69 9

70 0 70 1 TABL E 2- 1

Docke t No . D-73 3

D- 7 3 4 D-73 5 (Continued ) Commenter s Tha d Cochra n (U.S . Senate ) an d G . Adam (U.S . Resident ) No t a commen t 1 R.L . Emric h

70 2 70 3 70 4 70 5 70 6 70 7 70 8 70 9 71 0 71 1 (Firs t Presbyteria n Churc ho f Greensburg , PA ) D-73 6 D-73 7 D-73 8 D-73 9 D-74 0 D-74 1 D-74 2 D-74 3 D-74 4 D-74 5 No t a commen t lette r

No t a commen t lette r Unsigne d (U.S . Resident ) No t a commen t lette r K . Katzenstei n (U.S . Resident ) No t a commen t lette r John Melche r (U.S . Senate ) R.J . Rauc h (Environmenta l Defens e Fund ) G.C . Freeman , Jr . (Hunton & Williams ) Pau l Simo n



### 71 2 D-74 6 (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives ) an d H.L . Deakin s (Illinoi s Powe r Company ) Dal e Bumper s (U.S . Senate ) 2-5 6TABL E 2-I I LIS T O F PERSON S PRESENTIN GTESTIMON

Y A T TH E PUBLI C HEARIN G

• i

n! NO . 1



### 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 Docke t No .

F-la a F-l b F-lb b F-l c F-lc c F-l d F-ld d F-l e F-le e F-lf f
F-l g
F-l i F-l j F-l l Commenter s

Walte r Markey (Gilber t Commonwealth ) Joh n W . Ros s . . (Montana Powe r Co. ) Leonar d V . Ziolkowsk i (Economi c Developmen t Council ) JosephF . Breche r (representing Th e Sierr a Club ) WilliamSavinsk

y (United Min e Worker s o f America ) Jame s McCarvill e (Cit yo f Superior , Wisconsin ) Rober tLazarchi k (Join t Authorit yCommittee ) A l Johnso n (Johnson Brother s Corporation ) Georg e Genseme r (SED A- Counci l o f Governments ) Frank Zuka s (Greate r Pottsvill e Are a Chambe r o f Commerce ) Georg e Greene . (Publi c Servic e Compan yo f Colorado ) Car l M . Shy , M.D . (American Lun g Association ) Me g Titu s (Leagu e o f Wome n Voter s o f th e U.S. ) Reverend Bruc e Tischle r (Join t ProgramAgenc yo f Lehigh an d Lackawann a Presbyterie s o f the Unite d Presbyteria n Church ) 2-5 8P.2 7

TABLE 2-I I (Concluded ) 

### No . 1 5 1 6

1 7 1 8 1 9
2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4

2 5 2 6
2 7 Docke t No .

F-ln F-l o

F-lq F-l r F-l s
F-l t F-l u F-l w F-l x F-ly F-l z 

### F- 2

F- 3 Commenter s

Rober t Rauch (Environmenta l Defens e Fund ) Danie l Schwartzma

n (HealthResource s Management , University

o f Illinois , Schoo l o f Publi c Health ) Thoma s G . Heal y (Nationa l Coa l Association ) Willia m Alber s (Appalachia

nRegiona l Commission ) B . G . Gode c (Utilitie s o f th

e City o f Colorad o Springs ) Richar dAyer s (NRDC ) George C . Freeman , Jr . (Utilit y Ai r Regulator

y Group ) Joh nR . McNamara (Power Sal t Rive r Project ) Raymon dE . Kary , Ph.D . (Arizon a Publi c Servic e Corp. ) Denni s Eyr e (Wester nSystem

s Coordinatin

g Council ) Irwi nTucke r (Professor , Univ . o f Louisville ) George P . Gree

n (Publi c Servic e Compan y o f Colorado ) AllenE . Erte l (U.S . Hous e o f Representatives) ' 

# m

i M 

## : ; 

## m

2-5 9.

1 P.2 8

TABLE 2-II I LIS T O F OFFICIA

L WRITTE

N COMMENT S FRO

M OTHE RFEDERA

L ORGANIZATIONS No . 1 Docke t No .



### H- 5 Commenter s

Willia m V . Skidmore (Genera l Counci l o f Commerce ) 

### H- 6 Deput y Assistant Secretar y (Unite dState s Department o f th e Interior ) 

### H- 8 Actin g Director o f th

e Nationa l ParkServic e

lil ; 

### i' i 

### 1 0

1 1 1 2 H- 9

H-1 0 H-l l H-1 2

H-1 3
H-1 4 H-1 5

H-1 7 H-1 9 S . Davi dFreema n (Tennessee Valle

y Authority ) Joh nF . O'Lear

y (Department o f Energy ) Ceci l D . Andrews (U.S . Department o

f th e Interior ) Barr y P . Bosworth (Counci l o

nWag e an

dPric e Stability ) Willia m V . Skidmore (Genera l Counse l o f the U.S . Department o f Commerce ) Danie l Badger (Department o f Energy ) Jerr y Pel l (Anthracit e Division , Offic e o f Coa l Supply , Dept . o f Energy ) Joh nF . O'Lear

y (Department o f Energy ) Bo bBerglan

d (Department o f Agriculture ) 2-6 0