Appendix B1. Kraft Condensate Standards Incremental Improvement Costs

Improvement NEI Predominant Treatment Method

Current performance level

(decimal percent)a

Currentsystem

capacity

(gal/day)

Upgraderequired(gal/day) b

Capital cost, $(2010)

Annualizedcost, $/yr

Nationwide HAP

reduction, tpy Cost effectiveness, $/ton

Biological sy

upgrade annenergy O&Mcost, $ 

93% NEI42357 Biotreatment 0.92 12,000,000 130435 1,118,089 $ $ 166,671 $ 9

NEI18335 Biotreatment 0.92 28,100,000 305435 2,251,757 $ $ 323,068 $ 20

NEI11251 Stripping 0.92 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI26309 Stripping 0.92 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

$ 8,705,578 $ 991,299 2,046 485 $ 29

94% NEI42357 Biotreatment 0.92 12,000,000 260870 1,977,716 $ $ 285,713 $ 17

NEI18335 Biotreatment 0.92 28,100,000 610870 3,982,989 $ $ 554,988 $ 41

NEI113340 Biotreatment 0.93 10,900,000 117204 1,023,900 $ $ 153,395 $ 8

NEI11338 Biotreatment 0.93 21,300,000 229032 1,776,862 $ $ 258,178 $ 15

NEI18373 Biotreatment 0.93 48,500,000 521505 3,496,964 $ $ 490,454 $ 35

NEI18652 Biotreatment 0.93 15,000,000 161290 1,331,529 $ $ 196,554 $ 11

NEI34070 Biotreatment 0.93 14,600,000 156989 1,302,244 $ $ 192,469 $ 10

NEI11251 Stripping 0.92 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI26309 Stripping 0.92 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI11172 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46739 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46835 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46931 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI6273 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI8196 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

$ 36,235,131 $ 4,137,987 4,092 1,011 $ 140

95% NEI42357 Biotreatment 0.92 12,000,000 391304 2,760,907 $ $ 391,923 $ 26

NEI18335 Biotreatment 0.92 28,100,000 916304 5,560,284 $ $ 762,221 $ 61

NEI113340 Biotreatment 0.93 10,900,000 234409 1,811,110 $ $ 262,883 $ 16

NEI11338 Biotreatment 0.93 21,300,000 458065 3,142,976 $ $ 443,200 $ 31

NEI18373 Biotreatment 0.93 48,500,000 1043011 6,185,555 $ $ 843,625 $ 70

NEI18652 Biotreatment 0.93 15,000,000 322581 2,355,257 $ $ 337,119 $ 22

NEI34070 Biotreatment 0.93 14,600,000 313978 2,303,456 $ $ 330,091 $ 21

NEI11251 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI26309 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI11172 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46739 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46835 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46931 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI6273 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI8196 Stripping 0.93 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI12492 Biotreatment 0.94 15900000 169149 1,384,684 $ $ 203,957 $ 11

NEI18657 Biotreatment 0.94 4130000 43936 456,714 $ $ 71,774 $ 3

NEI42254 Biotreatment 0.94 18900000 201064 1,596,297 $ $ 233,296 $ 13

NEI42410 Biotreatment 0.94 25360000 269787 2,033,176 $ $ 293,292 $ 18

NEI42689 Biotreatment 0.94 9035000 96117 869,719 $ $ 131,524 $ 6

NEI6450 Biotreatment 0.94 39000000 414894 2,897,137 $ $ 410,242 $ 28

NEI8186 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI26495 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI8619 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI7559 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI33883 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI33023 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI18390 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

$ 78,710,994 $ 8,978,397 6,138 1,463 $ 332

96% NEI42357 Biotreatment 0.92 12,000,000 521739 3,498,254 $ $ 490,626 $ 35

NEI18335 Biotreatment 0.92 28,100,000 1221739 7,045,252 $ $ 954,988 $ 82

NEI113340 Biotreatment 0.93 10,900,000 351613 2,528,324 $ $ 360,551 $ 24

NEI11338 Biotreatment 0.93 21,300,000 687097 4,387,620 $ $ 608,445 $ 46

NEI18373 Biotreatment 0.93 48,500,000 1564516 8,635,084 $ $ 1,159,492 $ 104NEI18652 Biotreatment 0.93 15,000,000 483871 3,287,957 $ $ 462,581 $ 32

NEI34070 Biotreatment 0.93 14,600,000 470968 3,215,643 $ $ 452,919 $ 32

NEI11251 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI26309 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI11172 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46739 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

B1‐1
Improvement NEI Predominant Treatment Method

Current performance level

(decimal percent)a

Currentsystem

capacity

(gal/day)

Upgraderequired(gal/day) b

Capital cost, $(2010)

Annualizedcost, $/yr

Nationwide HAP

reduction, tpy Cost effectiveness, $/ton

Biological sy

upgrade annenergy O&Mcost, $ 

NEI46835 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46931 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI6273 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI8196 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI12492 Biotreatment 0.94 15900000 338298 2,449,278 $ $ 349,859 $ 23

NEI18657 Biotreatment 0.94 4130000 87872 807,853 $ $ 122,693 $ 6

NEI42254 Biotreatment 0.94 18900000 402128 2,823,588 $ $ 400,357 $ 27

NEI42410 Biotreatment 0.94 25360000 539574 3,596,355 $ $ 503,682 $ 36

NEI42689 Biotreatment 0.94 9035000 192234 1,538,389 $ $ 225,287 $ 13

NEI6450 Biotreatment 0.94 39000000 829787 5,124,559 $ $ 705,265 $ 56

NEI8186 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI26495 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI8619 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI7559 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI33883 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI33023 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI18390 Stripping 0.94 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI18338 Biotreatment 0.95 23200000 244211 1,873,196 $ $ 271,402 $ 16

NEI26506 Biotreatment 0.95 9200000 96842 875,113 $ $ 132,292 $ 6NEI26526 Biotreatment 0.95 54900000 577895 3,805,220 $ $ 531,427 $ 39

NEI41628 Biotreatment 0.95 30970000 326000 2,375,779 $ $ 339,902 $ 22

NEI6261 Biotreatment 0.95 39200000 412632 2,884,134 $ $ 408,495 $ 28

NEI7181 Biotreatment 0.95 13900000 146316 1,228,944 $ $ 182,224 $ 10

NEI33025 Stripping 0.95 2,667,865 $ $ 250,779

NEI41252 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI42710 Stripping and biotreatment 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI46760 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI759 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI8265 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI9201 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

$ 142,016,521 $ 16,185,871 8,183 1,978 $ 644

97% NEI42357 Biotreatment 0.92 12,000,000 652174 4,203,285 $ $ 584,120 $ 44

NEI18335 Biotreatment 0.92 28,100,000 1527174 8,465,139 $ $ 1,137,711 $ 102NEI113340 Biotreatment 0.93 10,900,000 468817 3,203,556 $ $ 451,303 $ 31

NEI11338 Biotreatment 0.93 21,300,000 916129 5,559,408 $ $ 762,107 $ 61

NEI18373 Biotreatment 0.93 48,500,000 2086022 10,941,230 $ $ 1,453,478 $ 139NEI18652 Biotreatment 0.93 15,000,000 645161 4,166,062 $ $ 579,203 $ 43

NEI34070 Biotreatment 0.93 14,600,000 627957 4,074,435 $ $ 567,089 $ 42

NEI11251 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI26309 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI11172 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46739 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46835 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46931 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI6273 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI8196 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI12492 Biotreatment 0.94 15900000 507447 3,419,211 $ $ 480,094 $ 34

NEI18657 Biotreatment 0.94 4130000 131809 1,127,769 $ $ 168,032 $ 9

NEI42254 Biotreatment 0.94 18900000 603191 3,941,751 $ $ 549,526 $ 40

NEI42410 Biotreatment 0.94 25360000 809362 5,020,540 $ $ 691,637 $ 54

NEI42689 Biotreatment 0.94 9035000 288351 2,147,603 $ $ 308,898 $ 19

NEI6450 Biotreatment 0.94 39000000 1244681 7,153,925 $ $ 969,023 $ 83

NEI8186 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559NEI26495 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559NEI8619 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559NEI7559 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI33883 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI33023 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI18390 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI18338 Biotreatment 0.95 23200000 488421 3,313,375 $ $ 465,975 $ 33

NEI26506 Biotreatment 0.95 9200000 193684 1,547,932 $ $ 226,608 $ 13

NEI26526 Biotreatment 0.95 54900000 1155789 6,730,809 $ $ 914,326 $ 77

B1‐2
Improvement NEI Predominant Treatment Method

Current performance level

(decimal percent)a

Currentsystem

capacity

(gal/day)

Upgraderequired(gal/day) b

Capital cost, $(2010)

Annualizedcost, $/yr

Nationwide HAP

reduction, tpy Cost effectiveness, $/ton

Biological sy

upgrade annenergy O&Mcost, $ 

NEI41628 Biotreatment 0.95 30970000 652000 4,202,363 $ $ 583,999 $ 44

NEI6261 Biotreatment 0.95 39200000 825263 5,101,559 $ $ 702,252 $ 55

NEI7181 Biotreatment 0.95 13900000 292632 2,173,801 $ $ 312,465 $ 20

NEI33025 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI41252 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI42710 Stripping and biotreatment 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46760 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI759 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI8265 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI9201 Stripping 0.95 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI18334 Biotreatment 0.96 49000000 510417 3,435,668 $ $ 482,288 $ 34

NEI18658 Biotreatment 0.96 26350000 274479 2,062,226 $ $ 297,258 $ 18

NEI26514 Biotreatment 0.96 35000000 364583 2,604,816 $ $ 370,883 $ 24

NEI33103 Biotreatment 0.96 10100000 105208 936,857 $ $ 141,071 $ 7

NEI33118 Stripping and biotreatment 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI41314 Stripping and biotreatment 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779NEI18357 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI26476 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI34064 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI34066 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI40247 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI45182 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46599 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

$ 218,255,158 $ 24,735,200 10,229 2,418 $ 1,038

98% NEI42357 Biotreatment 0.92 12,000,000 782609 4,883,590 $ $ 673,677 $ 52

NEI18335 Biotreatment 0.92 28,100,000 1832609 9,835,228 $ $ 1,312,833 $ 122NEI113340 Biotreatment 0.93 10,900,000 586022 3,849,195 $ $ 537,260 $ 39

NEI11338 Biotreatment 0.93 21,300,000 1145161 6,679,841 $ $ 907,728 $ 77

NEI18373 Biotreatment 0.93 48,500,000 2607527 13,146,305 $ $ 1,732,263 $ 173NEI18652 Biotreatment 0.93 15,000,000 806452 5,005,682 $ $ 689,690 $ 54

NEI34070 Biotreatment 0.93 14,600,000 784946 4,895,589 $ $ 675,252 $ 53

NEI11251 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI26309 Stripping 0.92 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI11172 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46739 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46835 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI46931 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI6273 Stripping/Recycle 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI8196 Stripping 0.93 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI12492 Biotreatment 0.94 15900000 676596 4,332,370 $ $ 601,159 $ 45

NEI18657 Biotreatment 0.94 4130000 175745 1,428,959 $ $ 210,113 $ 12

NEI42254 Biotreatment 0.94 18900000 804255 4,994,463 $ $ 688,219 $ 54

NEI42410 Biotreatment 0.94 25360000 1079149 6,361,360 $ $ 866,448 $ 72

NEI42689 Biotreatment 0.94 9035000 384468 2,721,158 $ $ 386,571 $ 26

NEI6450 Biotreatment 0.94 39000000 1659574 9,064,502 $ $ 1,214,451 $ 111NEI8186 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI26495 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559NEI8619 Stripping and biotreatment 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559NEI7559 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI33883 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI33023 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI18390 Stripping 0.94 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI18338 Biotreatment 0.95 23200000 732632 4,625,498 $ $ 639,770 $ 49

NEI26506 Biotreatment 0.95 9200000 290526 2,160,925 $ $ 310,712 $ 19

NEI26526 Biotreatment 0.95 54900000 1733684 9,396,263 $ $ 1,256,840 $ 115

NEI41628 Biotreatment 0.95 30970000 978000 5,866,532 $ $ 802,137 $ 65

NEI6261 Biotreatment 0.95 39200000 1237895 7,121,817 $ $ 964,877 $ 83

NEI7181 Biotreatment 0.95 13900000 438947 3,034,643 $ $ 428,692 $ 29

NEI33025 Stripping 0.95 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI41252 Stripping 0.95 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI42710 Stripping and biotreatment 0.95 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559NEI46760 Stripping 0.95 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

B1‐3
Improvement NEI Predominant Treatment Method

Current performance level

(decimal percent)a

Currentsystem

capacity

(gal/day)

Upgraderequired(gal/day) b

Capital cost, $(2010)

Annualizedcost, $/yr

Nationwide HAP

reduction, tpy Cost effectiveness, $/ton

Biological sy

upgrade annenergy O&Mcost, $ 

NEI759 Stripping 0.95 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI8265 Stripping 0.95 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI9201 Stripping 0.95 5,335,732 $ $ 501,559

NEI18334 Biotreatment 0.96 49000000 1020833 6,077,132 $ $ 829,535 $ 68

NEI18658 Biotreatment 0.96 26350000 548958 3,647,738 $ $ 510,514 $ 37

NEI26514 Biotreatment 0.96 35000000 729167 4,607,491 $ $ 637,401 $ 49

NEI33103 Biotreatment 0.96 10100000 210417 1,657,147 $ $ 241,695 $ 14

NEI33118 Stripping and biotreatment 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI41314 Stripping and biotreatment 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI18357 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI26476 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI34064 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI34066 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI40247 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI45182 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI46599 Stripping 0.96 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI12411 Biotreatment 0.97 25240000 260206 1,973,577 $ $ 285,147 $ 17

NEI18660 Biotreatment 0.97 51000000 525773 3,520,494 $ $ 493,587 $ 35

NEI45474 Biotreatment 0.97 16700000 172165 1,404,967 $ $ 206,778 $ 11

NEI6057 Biotreatment 0.97 24520000 252784 1,927,136 $ $ 278,792 $ 17

NEI26491 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI40488 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI42695 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI45206 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI47074 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI47077 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI8278 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

NEI8560 Stripping 0.97 2,667,866 $ $ 250,779

$ 296,959,429 $ 33,679,688 12,275 2,744 $ 1,512

a. The methodology used to determine the current performance level based on the Part I resultsissummarized in a separate memo, "Summary of Kraft Condensate Control Technology Review."

b. WWT Upgrade Required: proportional; 92 > 93 = Current Size * 93/92, etc.

B1‐4