./!!/CEAN3ERVICE

.ATIONAL/C

6!$-

5NDER3ECRETARYOF#

-ARGARET$AV

3ILVER3PRING-ARYLAND*ULY
)

%XECUTIVE3UMMARY

!SYSTEMOF.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARIES.-3	PROTECTSOVERSQUAREMILESOF53

SIGNIlCANTNATURALANDCULTURALRESOURCES3CIENCEACTIVITYINTHE.-30ROGRAM0ROGRAM	PTHECHANGINGNATUREOFTHESERESOURCESANDTHETHREATSTHEYFACE)TALSOPROVIDESFORRESPO

MANAGEMENTEFFECTIVENESSSUPPORTSPOLICYDEVELOPMENTANDSTRENGTHENSTHE0ROGRAMSSUPPORTOOBJECTIVESFORCOASTALMANAGEMENT!NUNDERSTANDINGOFENVIRONMENTALPROCESSESANDTHEFUNCTIONOFNATURALSYSTEMSISVITALTOENSUREPROTECTEDANDMANAGEDWHILETRADEANDLEISUREACTIVITIESCONTINUEWITHINTHEM4HETARGETFORTHE0HOWENVIRONMENTALSYSTEMSFUNCTIONSOWECANRECOGNIZEUNDERSTANDFORECASTANDRESPONDTONATENVIRONMENTALCHANGE!DELIBERATEEFFORTISUNDERWAYTOIMPROVETHE0ROGRAMSRESEARCHANDMONITORINGCAPACITIESTOSUPP

RESOURCESINTHESANCTUARIES&IRSTWEAREWORKINGTOASSESSOURCURRENTSCIENTIlCSTRENGTHSANDWEAPRIORITYINFORMATIONNEEDSATALLRELEVANTSPATIALANDTEMPORALSCALES3ECONDWEAREDEVELOPINGCA

ABILITYTOADDRESSTHESENEEDSINCLUDINGSTRATEGICPLANNINGINFRASTRUCTUREFUNDINGMECHANISMSAND4HISREPORTCOMPLETESTHElRSTOBJECTIVE)TUSESINFORMATIONGATHEREDFROMSANCTUARYMANAGEMENTANUMBEROFSCIENTIlClELDSANDOTHERRESOURCEMANAGEMENTPRACTITIONERSTOIDENTIFYTHEMOSTIMP

NEEDSFORNATURALRESOURCEMANAGEMENTINTHEMARINESANCTUARIESANDEVALUATESHOWWELLTHESENE

CURRENTANDPLANNEDACTIVITIES4HERESULTSWILLBEUSEDTODIRECTORMODIFYRESEARCHEFFORTSESTABLISH

BUILDSTRATEGICPARTNERSHIPSPROVIDESCIENCEGUIDANCEFOROTHERAGENCIESANDRESPONDTOQUERIESREFUNDINGNEEDS

7ORKSHOPAND3URVEY$URINGASCIENCEWORKSHOPPARTICIPANTSIDENTIlEDPRIORITYSCIENTIlChENDPOINTSvOBJECTIVNEED	WITHINTHEFOLLOWINGMANAGEMENTISSUES

s(ABITAT$ELINEATION
DETERMININGLOCATIONANDEXTENTOFBIOTICANDABIOTICCOMPONENTSOFSANC

RELATIONSHIPSBETWEENHABITATANDLIVINGMARINERESOURCES

s:ONING
CRITERIAFORDETERMINATIONOFLOCATIONANDSIZEOFZONESASWELLASEVALUATINGEFFECTIVENs !SSESSMENTOF,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES
DETERMININGSTATUSANDTRENDSASWELLASMEASURES

7RITTENAND0RODUCEDBY3TEPHEN2'ITTINGS+IMBERLY%"ENSON0AULA*3OUIK-ITCHELL34ARTT

'RAPHIC$ESIGN3ANDRA.ITCHIE
s 7ATER1UALITY0ROTECTION
PREVENTINGTRACKINGANDCONTROLLINGLANDANDSEA
BASEDTHREATSTOWATERQUALITYANDUNDERSTANDING

IMPACTSONSANCTUARYRESOURCES

s &ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS
IMPACTSOFHARVESTINGmORAANDFAUNAASWELLASUNINTENDEDIMPACTSEGGHOSTGEARIMPACTS	s 7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE
EVALUATINGTHREATSOFVARIOUSTYPESOFHUMANACTIVITYTOSANCTUARYRESOURCESs %VENT2ESPONSE
REACTINGTOSPILLSGROUNDINGSHARMFULALGALBLOOMSETC!CTIONSMAYINCLUDETRAJECTORYFORECASTINGIMPACT

ASSESSMENTANDCOUNTER
MEASURES

s 2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION
TECHNIQUESANDEVALUATIONOFMEASURESTORESTOREORENHANCERECOVERYRATESFORNATURALRESOURCES

IMPACTEDBYHUMANACTIVITIES

s )NDUSTRIAL5SES
POTENTIALIMPACTSFROMANDCAPACITIESNEEDEDFORDEALINGWITHINDUSTRIALACTIVITIESWITHINSANCTUARY

BOUNDARIESEGCABLESPIPELINESPLATFORMSMARINETRANSPORTATIONBIOPROSPECTINGAQUACULTURE	

3TAFFATEACHOFTHESANCTUARIESFOCUSEDONNATURALRESOURCEMANAGEMENTWEREASKEDTOPROVIDEPRE
DElNEDNUMERICALRATINGSOFTHERELEVANCECURRENTSCIENTIlCACTIVITYLEVELANDSTATEOFKNOWLEDGEFOREACHENDPOINTIDENTIlEDINTHEWORKSHOP"ASEDONA

MODELOFRECOMMENDEDLEVELSOFRESEARCHANDMONITORINGACTIVITYDERIVEDFROMANENDPOINTSRELEVANCEANDTHECURRENTSTATEOFKNOWLEDGEAPPROPRIATELEVELSOFACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFOREACHENDPOINTANDCOMPAREDTOCURRENTLEVELS2ECOMMENDEDCHANGESRANGEDFROMnSUBSTANTIALDECREASE	TOSUBSTANTIALINCREASE	:ERO	INDICATESTHATNOCHANGEINACTIVITYISRECOMMENDED4HEDATAWEREANALYZEDFROMPROGRAMMATICSITE
SPECIlCREGIONALANDRESOURCE
SPECIlCPERSPECTIVES.OTE 4HESANCTUARIESFOCUSEDONCULTURALRESOURCES-ONITOR.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARYAND4HUNDER"AY.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARYAND5NDERWATER0RESERVEWERENOTEVALUATEDBYTHISPROCESS2ESEARCHANDMONITORINGACTIVITIESFORCULTURALRESOURCES

AREADDRESSEDSEPARATELYBYTHE0ROGRAM

&INDINGS"ASEDONTHEJUDGMENTOFSANCTUARYSTAFFATEACHSITEOFENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDINTHEWORKSHOPWEREJUDGEDTOBEOFMEDIUMORHIGHRELEVANCEONAVERAGE&URTHERNOSINGLEENDPOINTWASJUDGEDASLESSTHANMEDIUMRELEVANCEBYEVERYSITE4HIS

STRONGLYSUGGESTSTHATTHEISSUEGROUPSINTHEWORKSHOPIDENTIlEDENDPOINTSOFLEGITIMATEIMPORTANCETOMANAGEMENTOFNATURALRESOURCESINTHEMARINESANCTUARIES4HEDATASUGGESTTHATALLSITESSHOULDENHANCESCIENCEACTIVITIESFORALMOSTALLMANAGEMENTISSUES/VERALLTHEINCREASEAVERAGED

WITHINDIVIDUALISSUESRANGINGFROMnTO4HEHIGHESTPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSMERITINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESIN

ACTIVITYWEREINTHEFOLLOWINGMANAGEMENTISSUEGROUPS:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION4WOOTHER

GROUPS7ATER1UALITYAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESAPPEAREDTOBETHEISSUESMOSTAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDONTHEWHOLE
)))

/FTHEENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDDURINGTHEWORKSHOPWERERECOGNIZEDASREQUIRINGSUBSTALEASTONESITE4WELVEENDPOINTSWEREIDENTIlEDBYATLEASTEIGHTOFTHEELEVENPARTICIPATINGSITESAS

OR	SUGGESTINGAPARTICULARNEEDTOADDRESSTHESEENDPOINTS4HEYARE

s"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES#OMPETITIONBEs"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES0REDATOR
PREYs"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES2ECRUITMENTs"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST%COLOGICALINDICATORSs(ARVESTING$ATAONSPATIALANDTEMPORALHABITATCHANGESCAUSEDBYlSHINGs(ARVESTING%FFECTSOFlSHINGHARVESTONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICSs(ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES#OMPETITIONBETWEENSPEs(ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES'ROWTHREPRODUCTIONANDs(ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES2ECRUITMENTs(ARVESTING,EVELOFEFFORTSPATIALANDTEMPORALDISTRIBUTIONANDDENSITYFORCOMMERCIALlSHINGs)NDUSTRIAL5SES)DENTIlCATIONOFSOURCESOFINVASIVESPECIESs-APPING#APABILITIES')3COMPATIBLEDATA3OURCEAREASFORCRITICALSPECIES

#ORAL2EEF)NFORMATION.EEDS!NUMBEROFOTHERENDPOINTSCONSISTENTLYAPPEAREDAMONGSITESWITHSIMILARATTRIBUTESDEMONSTRATITHENATUREOFTHERESOURCESPROTECTED)NADDITIONTOTHENEEDSLISTEDABOVEENDPOINTSWITHSUGG

ACTIVITYWEREIDENTIlEDATFOUROFTHElVESITESCONTAININGCORALREEFSORCORALRESOURCES

s"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES(ABITATUSEATs"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST+EYSTONESPECIESE HERBIVORES	s%VENT2ESPONSE,INKAGESBETWEENCAUSESOFEVENTSs%VENT2ESPONSE2ISKASSESSMENT0ROBABILITYOFFUTUREEVENTSs7ATER1UALITY)NCIDENTALCONTAMINANTSFROMVESSELSMERCHANTlSHINGTOURISMPRIVATE	s7ATER1UALITY,EVELSANDMECHANISMSOFCONTAMINANTSCAUSINGMORTALITYs7ATER1UALITY,EVELSANDMECHANISMSOFSUBLETHALSTRESSORSs7ATER1UALITY4EMPORALCHANGESINLEVELSOFPATHOGENSANDPATHOGENICINDICATORSWITHINBIOLOGIs:ONE0ERFORMANCE%FFECTIVENESSOFZONINGREGIMEs:ONE0ERFORMANCE)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONESAREAS)NTENSITYs:ONE0ERFORMANCE)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONESAREAS3PATIALDISTRIBUs:ONE0ERFORMANCE)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONESAREAS4YPESOFIMPACT
-ARINE-AMMAL)NFORMATION.EEDS&IVEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYAPPEAREDPARTICULARLYRELEVANTAMONGSITESTHATPROTECTMARINE

MAMMALS

s"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST%COLOGICALINDICATORSs2ESTORATION6ALUATIONOFSANCTUARYRESOURCESs7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE3USCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSEOFSPECIESOFCONCERN!CUTEANDCHRONICRESPONSEEGBEHAVIORAL 

REPRODUCTIVEPHYSIOLOGICALPHYSICALINJURY	

s7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE3USCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSEOFSPECIESOFCONCERN6ERIlCATIONOFCAUSE
AND
EFFECTRELATIONSHIPSs7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE4HREATASSESSMENTFORSOURCESOFWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE2ANGEOFINmUENCEFORPOTENTIALLYVULNERABLESPECIES

7EST#OAST)NFORMATION.EEDS&INALLYFORSITESALONGTHEWESTCOASTOFTHE53SIXADDITIONALHIGHPRIORITYENDPOINTSWEREIDENTIlEDATFOUROFTHElVESITES

SUGGESTINGUNIQUEREGIONALNEEDS

s"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES#ONDITIONANDTRENDSOFCRITICALHABITATs(ARVESTING"Y
CATCHDATAs(ARVESTING#OMPARISONSOFIMPACTSOFlSHINGANDHARVESTPRESSUREINAREASOFHIGHLOWANDNOACTIVITYs(ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES&OODREQUIREMENTSs(ARVESTING,EVELOFEFFORTSPATIALANDTEMPORALDISTRIBUTIONANDDENSITYFORRECREATIONALlSHINGHARVESTINGs)NDUSTRIAL5SES#HARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFlC"ALLASTEXCHANGEREQUIREMENTSANDPROTOCOLS

)NDIVIDUAL3ITE)NFORMATION.EEDS&OREACHOFTHENATURALRESOURCESANCTUARIESSCIENCEACTIVITIESWEREEVALUATEDTOANSWERTHEFOLLOWINGQUESTIONS!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIESATTHESANCTUARY4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY

&URTHERMOREFOREACHSANCTUARYASUMMARYTABLEPROVIDESALISTOFHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFOR4HISISINTENDEDTOPROVIDETHESANCTUARIESANDRELEVANTPARTNERSWITHTHEDETAILSNECESSARYTOIDENTIFYMANAGEMENT

ISSUESANDMORESPECIlCALLYENDPOINTSWITHTHEGREATESTNEEDFORADDITIONALATTENTION!MONGTHESEENDPOINTSPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFOR	ENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITY

OFUNITS	ENDPOINTSTHATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	CLUSTERSOFENDPOINTSSIMILARINNATURETHAT

MIGHTBEADDRESSEDCOLLECTIVELYBYFUTUREPROJECTS"ELOWARESUMMARIESOFTHEEVALUATIONSCONDUCTEDFOREACHSANCTUARY
6

#HANNEL)SLANDS#OMPAREDTOOTHERSITESTHE#HANNEL)SLANDS.-3HADAFAIRLYLOWPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSTHATREQINACTIVITY4WOMANAGEMENTISSUES&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESSEEMTOWARRANTTHESCIENTIlCEFFORT)NADDITIONANUMBEROFENDPOINTSINTHEAREASOF:ONINGAND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCEATTENTION3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE

FORTHE#HANNEL)SLANDS.-3INCLUDEDEVELOPINGPREDICTIVEMODELSTOUNDERSTANDTHEDYNAMICSOFHREPRODUCTIONANDMORTALITYOFTARGETEDSPECIESECOLOGICALINDICATORSOFBIOLOGICALRESOURCESINCIDENVESSELSBALLASTWATEREXCHANGEREQUIREMENTSANDPROTOCOLSANDACOUSTICSIGNATURESOFVESSELTRAFl

#ORDELL"ANK,IKETHE#HANNEL)SLANDS#ORDELL"ANK.-3ALSOHADAFAIRLYLOWPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSTHATREQUINACTIVITY:ONINGAND&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSSEEMTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlCEFFENDPOINTSINTHEAREAOF)NDUSTRIAL5SES3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFOR

0RIORITYINFORMATIONNEEDSFOR#ORDELL"ANK.-3INCLUDEEFFECTIVENESSOFZONINGREGIMESECOLOGICALAFFECTINGYEAR
CLASSSTRENGTHNATURALANDANTHROPOGENICFACTORSAFFECTINGSANCTUARYHABITATSANDHA

VESSELTRAFlCPROlLESDREDGEANDlLLACTIVITIESANDINVASIVESPECIES)NADDITIONSTAFFINTERVIEWSINDHABITATCHARACTERIZATIONNON
POINTSOURCEPOLLUTIONANDHARMFULALGALBLOOMSAREPRIORITYINFORMATIO

&AGATELE"AY&AGATELE"AY.-3HADACOMPARATIVELYHIGHPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDSUBSTANTIA:ONING2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONAND%VENT2ESPONSEAPPEARTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASEINHIGHESTRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYAREDISTRIBUTEDAMONGMOSTMANAGEMENTISSUES3UBSTAWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE0RIORITYINFORMATIONNEEDSFOR&AGATELE"AYBIOLOGICALCRITERIATHATAFFECTTHESUCCESSOFBIOLOGICALRESOURCESEGCURRENTSRECRUITMENTGROWTHRINCLUDINGHOWTHEYAFFECTZONINGANDRESTORATIONEFFORTSIMPACTSOFlSHINGACTIVITIESONSPECIESOFINVERIFYINGANDTRACKINGEVENTSORDISTURBANCESOFVARIOUSTYPESWITHINANDADJACENTTOTHESANCTUARY&LORIDA+EYS4HE&LORIDA+EYS.-3SAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEFORALLRELEVANTENDPOINTSCOMBINEDWASCLOSSITE4HEAVERAGEWASWELLBELOWTHE0ROGRAM
WIDEMEANOFANDTHELOWESTOFALLSITES&URACOMPARATIVELYLOWPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSREQUIRINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY:ONING,IVIN

&ISHING(ARVESTING%FFECTSAPPEARTOBETHEMANAGEMENTISSUESWARRANTINGTHEGREATESTINCREASESI

INCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE0RIORITYENDPOINTSTHATGREATERACTIVITYINCLUDEOCEANOGRAPHICDATAONWAVEFORCESINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUPARTICULARINTERESTFOODREQUIREMENTSASTHEYAFFECTTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIESMECHAN

BIOLOGICOCEANOGRAPHICANDATMOSPHERICPROCESSESASTHEYINmUENCEHABITATBALLASTEXCHANGEREQSOCIOECONOMICEFFECTSOFWATERQUALITYONCOMMERCIALANDRECREATIONALUSESANDPROlTSANDBY
CAT
&LOWER'ARDEN"ANKS4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYATTHE&LOWER'ARDEN"ANKS.-3WASORHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4HREEMANAGEMENTISSUES:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONREQUIRETHEGREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlC

SUPPORT4HElRSTTWOAPPEARTOWARRANTTHEMOSTATTENTION3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE0RIORITYINFORMATIONNEEDSFORTHE&LOWER'ARDENSAREUNDERSTANDINGRECRUITMENTEFFECTSOFlSHINGONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICSHARVESTLEVELSANDIMPACTSRECOVERYTRAJECTORIESFOLLOWINGVARIOUSIMPACTSPOPULATIONDYNAMICSOFKEYSPECIESANDCOMMUNITYDYNAMICSINCLUDINGTROPHICSTRUCTUREANDSPECIESINTERACTIONS

'RAYS2EEF4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYATTHE'RAYS2EEF.-3WASORHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE.EARLYTWO
THIRDSOFHIGHPRIORITYENDPOINTSREQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY&IVEISSUESAPPEARTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASE

INSCIENTIlCACTIVITY(ABITAT$ELINEATION:ONING,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES7ATER1UALITYAND&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS3UBSTANTIAL

INCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE0RIORITYINFORMATIONNEEDSFORTHE'RAYS2EEFINCLUDE

VARIOUSTYPESOFOCEANOGRAPHICDATASPECIlCTYPESOF')3COMPATIBLEDATAEFFECTSOFlSHINGHARVESTONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICSANDLEVELSMECHANISMSOFCONTAMINANTSCAUSINGMORTALITYANDPOPULATIONTRENDSFORKEYSPECIESANDCOMMUNITIESINCLUDINGRATES

OFGROWTHMORTALITYANDFECUNDITY

'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONES4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYATTHE'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONES.-3WASORBELOWTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE#OMPAREDTOOTHERSITESTHISSITEHASAFAIRLYLOWPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSTHATREQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY4WOISSUESSEEMTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlCACTIVITY&ISHING(ARVESTING%FFECTSAND:ONING3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE0RIORITYTOPICAREASFORFUTUREINVESTIGATIONFORTHE'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESINCLUDEFACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIESANDFACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFOROTHER

SPECIESOFCONCERN)NADDITIONSTAFFINTERVIEWSINDICATEDTHATCERTAINASPECTSOFNON
POINTSOURCEPOLLUTIONHARMFULALGALBLOOMSANDAGRICULTURALRUNOFFAREPRIORITYINFORMATIONNEEDSFORTHESITE

(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYAT(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE.-3WASTHEHIGHESTLEVELINTHE0ROGRAMANDHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE/VERTWO
THIRDSOFHIGHPRIORITYENDPOINTSREQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY&OUR

ISSUESSEEMTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlCATTENTION2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION:ONING,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES

AND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE0RIORITYTOPICAREASFORFUTUREEFFORTATTHE(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE.-3AREFACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES

INFORMATIONONKEYSPECIESANDCOMMUNITIESPERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTERESTAND')3COMPATIBLEDATA
6))

-ONTEREY"AY4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYAT-ONTEREY"AY.-3WASORHIGHERTHANTHE&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCEAND)NDUSTRIAL)SSUESAPPEARTOBETHEMANAGEMENTIS

NEEDFORADDITIONALSCIENTIlCATTENTION3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFOR0RIORITYAREASOFINVESTIGATIONINCLUDEFACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIESINFOCOMMUNITIESNATUREANDSOURCESOFTHREATSTOWILDLIFEANDCHARACTERIZATIONANDMONITORINGALONGP

/LYMPIC#OAST4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYATTHE/LYMPIC#OAST.-3WASJUSTABOVETHE0RO(ARVEST%FFECTS:ONING,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONAPPEARTOBETHEMTHEGREATESTINCREASEINACTIVITY3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPOINAREASFORINVESTIGATIONATTHE/LYMPIC#OAST.-3INCLUDEFACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSUCCESSINFOCOMMUNITIESOCEANOGRAPHICDATAINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNAND')3DATARELATEDTOHABITAT3TELLWAGEN"ANK4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYAT3TELLWAGEN"ANK.-3WASEQUALTOTHE0ROGRATO:ONINGMAYWARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlCEFFORTFOLLOWEDCLOSELYBY,IVING-ARINE2ES

%FFECTSAND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE3UBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYWERERECOMMENDEDFORENDPO

INFORMATIONNEEDSFOR3TELLWAGEN"ANK.-3INCLUDEFACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESANDTHOSEOFSPECIALCONCERN	OCEANOGRAPHICDATASPECIlCALLYTIDESTOURISMPROlLESINFORMATIONO

SUSCEPTIBILITYOFSPECIESTODISTURBANCEANDIMPACTSOFHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS
"ACKGROUND

3CIENCE0LAN 

!0LANTO3TRENGTHEN3CIENCEFOR-ANAGEMENTINTHE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARIES %VALUATIONOF%XISTING0ROGRAMS 

 $EVELOPMENTAND!DMINISTRATIONOFTHE%VALUATION 

!NALYSIS-ETHODS 

3OURCESOF"IAS

0ROGRAMMATIC!NALYSIS

%NDPOINT2ELEVANCE

#HANGE!NALYSIS 

!NALYSISBY2ELEVANCE#ATEGORY 

%NDPOINTSOF(IGH2ELEVANCE%NDPOINTSOF-ODERATE2ELEVANCE %NDPOINTSOF,OW2ELEVANCE

3ITE!NALYSESAND3UMMARIES 

#HANNEL)SLANDS  #ORDELL"ANK  

 &AGATELE"AY 

&LORIDA+EYS  &LOWER'ARDEN"ANKS 'RAYS2EEF 'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONES  

 (AWAIIAN)SLAND(UMPBACK7HALE 

-ONTEREY"AY  /LYMPIC#OAST 3TELLWAGEN"ANK 

.EEDS$IRECTIONSAND4ARGETS 

0ROGRAM)NFORMATION.EEDS #ORAL2EEF)NFORMATION.EEDS -ARINE-AMMAL)NFORMATION.EEDS 

 7EST#OAST)NFORMATION.EEDS .EXT3TEPS !PPENDIXn3URVEY&ORM!PPENDIXn3URVEY0ARTICIPANTS!PPENDIXn%NDPOINTS2ECOMMENDEDFOR3UBSTANTIAL)NCREASEIN!CTIVITY

4ABLEOF#ONTENTS


"ACKGROUND

4HE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY0ROGRAM0ROGRAM	ISENTRUSTEDWITHTHEPROTECTIONOFMARINESANSQUAREMILESOFOCEANAND'REAT,AKESWATERS4HESEWATERSCONTAINSIGNIlCANTNATURALANFORNATIONALPROTECTIONBYVIRTUEOFTHEIRECOLOGICALHISTORICSCIENTIlCEDUCATIONALORAESTHETICVALUE

ASSESSMENTPROTECTIONMONITORINGMAINTENANCEANDRESTORATIONARECRUCIALTOEFFECTIVECONSERVATI3ANCTUARYMANAGERSANDSTAFFHAVEACONTINUALNEEDFORINFORMATIONTOASSESSTHECONDITIONANDTREFUNCTIONALCOMPONENTSOFTHESEPROTECTEDECOSYSTEMS4HE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARIES.-3S	CURRENTLYFACILITATEANDCONDUCTRESEARCHANDMONITORINGPBASIS4HEDEGREEOFSUCCESSINTHESEENDEAVORSVARIESGREATLY3TAFlNGSITESIZEANDACCESSIBILITYA

ASANCTUARYSACCESSTOTHESCIENTIlCINFORMATIONREQUIREDTOINFORMMANAGEMENTACTIONS)NORDER

BASEDINFORMATIONATLOCALREGIONALANDNATIONALSCALESANDTOLEVERAGEANDBENElTFROMOTHERONINITIATIVESTHEREISANEEDWITHINTHE0ROGRAMTOIMPLEMENTBOTHNATIONALLY
COORDINATEDANDSITE
SP

ANDRESEARCHPROGRAMS&ORTHISREASONWEAREDEVELOPINGPLANSTOCOMPLEMENTANDENHANCEON
GIMPLEMENTECOSYSTEM
BASEDISSUE
DRIVENAND0ROGRAM
WIDEEFFORTS

3CIENCE0LAN4HE3CIENCE0LANFORTHE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY3YSTEMPRESENTSASTRATEGICVISIONFORASPRIORITIESAS

s %STABLISHINGANINFRASTRUCTURETHATENSURESADEQUATESTAFlNGEFFECTIVESHORT
ANDLONG
TERMPLAN

ANDEFlCIENTINFORMATIONMANAGEMENTANDDISSEMINATION

s 5NDERSTANDINGTHESTATUSANDTRENDSOFSANCTUARYRESOURCESONLOCALREGIONALANDNATIONALSCA

TRENDSOFHUMANUSEANDNATIONALLYSIGNIlCANTTHEMESEGESSENTIALHABITATIDENTIlCATIONBIO

s #ONDUCTINGAMANAGEMENT
BASEDSCIENCEPROGRAMTHATEMPHASIZESCAPACITY
BUILDINGEG')3

ONINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTEGZONINGEFFECTIVENESSlSHERIESIMPACTSHUMANUSE

/VERTHELASTYEARTHE0ROGRAMHASTAKENSTEPSTOAPPLYTHE3CIENCE0LANTOITSACTIVITIESANDRESPO

lNDINGSOFANINTERNALASSESSMENTANDADVICEFROMEXPERTSWEAREDEVELOPINGSTRATEGIESTOEXPAND

ANDMONITORINGSUPPORTMANAGEMENTPROTECTIONCONSERVATIONANDPOLICYACTIONSANDDECISIONS



 # !&&"!"$%"#%

*$&$"&!%

*$&!$%#%

*	'!!&$&%

	






!

&$&

!

 # !&&"!"$%"#%

*$&$"&!%

*$&!$%#%

*	'!!&$&%

('&"!

!)%%

 $&"!% &$!&% ($# 
#%

	'$$"%%&"%%%%! # !&%!#$"$ %!&&"!


$!!&'$))%& 

!"$%"#


! !&%%'%

  !&%

 !"$ &"!%

 !#"!&%

%%'

!&&"!

 &%

 !)$"$&%

 "#!

 &$&'$

!(!&"$)

!&

'$$!&!

!!&(&%

$"

$"&

!%

 # !&&"!&$&%

 $&$"&!%

 $&!$%#%

 	'!!&$&%

 # !&&"!

!

	
	


	


0HASETHEASSESSMENTOFEXISTINGSCIENCEPROGRAMSCONSISTSOFASERIESOFACTIVITIESTHATBEGANW

CURRENTANDPLANNEDRESEARCHANDMONITORINGACTIVITIESINTHEMARINESANCTUARIESTHATPROTECTN

WASCOMPILEDINADATABASETHATAMONGOTHERINFORMATIONPRESENTSTHEMANAGEMENTAPPLICATIONSISSUESFOREACHSCIENCEACTIVITY4HEDATABASEANDOTHERSOURCESWEREUSEDTOIDENTIFYTHEHIGHESTPRIORITYMANAGEMENTISSUESOFCOFROMTHEOTHERSOURCESWASPROVIDEDTHROUGHINTERVIEWSWITHSANCTUARYSTAFFTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFAG

RESEARCHPLANNINGDOCUMENTSGENERATEDBYTHESITESANDINPREVIOUSWORKSHOPSCONDUCTEDBY./!!CURRENTCONSERVATIONBIOLOGYLITERATURE4HESEISSUESINNOPARTICULARORDERARE

A(ABITAT$ELINEATIONnDETERMININGLOCATIONANDEXTENTOFBIOTICANDABIOTICCOMPONENTSOFSAN

RELATIONSHIPSBETWEENHABITATANDLIVINGMARINERESOURCES

!0LANTO3TRENGTHEN3CIENCEFORTHE-ANAGEME

.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARIES

)NTHEFALLOFTHE0ROGRAMINITIATEDADELIBERATEPROCESSTOSTRENGTHENTHELINKSBETWEENSCIENRESOURCES4HISPROCESSINVOLVESTWODISTINCTPHASES	ASSESSMENTOFEXISTINGSCIENCEACTIVITIESASTRATEGIES&IGURE	
B :ONINGnCRITERIAFORDETERMINATIONOFLOCATIONANDSIZEOFDIFFERENTCATEGORIESOFZONESASWELLASEVALUATINGEFFECTIVENESS

C !SSESSMENTOF,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESnDETERMININGSTATUSANDTRENDSASWELLASMEASURESOFECOLOGICALlTNESS

D7ATER1UALITY0ROTECTIONnPREVENTINGTRACKINGANDCONTROLLINGLANDANDSEA
BASEDTHREATSTOWATERQUALITYAND

UNDERSTANDINGIMPACTSONSANCTUARYRESOURCES

E&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS
IMPACTSOFHARVESTINGmORAANDFAUNAASWELLASUNINTENDEDIMPACTSEGGHOSTGEARIMPACTS	F 7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCEnEVALUATINGTHREATSOFVARIOUSTYPESOFHUMANACTIVITYONSANCTUARYRESOURCESEGLIGHTANDNOISE

POLLUTIONSHIPSTRIKES	

G %VENT2ESPONSEnREACTINGTOSPILLSGROUNDINGSHARMFULALGALBLOOMSETC!CTIONSMAYINCLUDETRAJECTORYFORECASTINGIMPACT

ASSESSMENTANDCOUNTER
MEASURES

H2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONnTECHNIQUESANDEVALUATIONOFMEASURESTORESTOREORENHANCERECOVERYRATESFORNATURAL

RESOURCESIMPACTEDBYHUMANACTIVITIES

I )NDUSTRIAL5SESnPOTENTIALIMPACTSFROMANDCAPACITIESNEEDEDFORDEALINGWITHINDUSTRIALUSESWITHINSANCTUARYBOUNDARIES

EGCABLESPIPELINESPLATFORMSMARINETRANSPORTATIONBIOPROSPECTINGAQUACULTURE	

!WORKSHOPWASTHENCONDUCTEDWITHSANCTUARYRESEARCHSTAFFANDINVITEDEXPERTSTOIDENTIFYSPECIlCSCIENCEOBJECTIVESTHATADDRESSINFORMATIONNEEDSRELATEDTOTHESEMANAGEMENTISSUES&ORPURPOSESOFTHEWORKSHOPANDTHISREPORTTHEFOLLOWINGDElNITIONSAPPLY

-ANAGEMENT)SSUEAGENERALTOPICORAREAOFCONCERNFORWHICHEFFECTIVEMANAGEMENTOFNATURALORCULTURALRESOURCESREQUIRES

SPECIlCINFORMATIONEGZONING	

)NFORMATION.EEDTHEAREASOFINVESTIGATIONCRITICALTOTHEUNDERSTANDINGREQUIREDFOREFFECTIVEMANAGEMENTEGLARVAL

DISPERSIONANDPOST
SETTLEMENTPROCESSESASTHEYAFFECTSPILLOVER	

%NDPOINT3CIENCEOBJECTIVESTOADDRESSANINFORMATIONNEEDEGTHESPATIALANDTEMPORALPATTERNSOFDISPERSALAND

RECRUITMENTFORSELECTEDSPECIESTHESPATIALABUNDANCEPATTERNSOFVARIOUSSIZECLASSESFORTHESESPECIES	

%NDPOINTSFOREACHMANAGEMENTISSUEWEREIDENTIlEDTHROUGHASERIESOFBREAKOUTSESSIONSHELDDURINGTHEWORKSHOP&ORMOREINFORMATIONONTHISWORKSHOPREFERTO3TRENGTHENING3CIENCEFORTHE-ANAGEMENTOF.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARIES3CIENCE7ORKSHOP2EPORT%NDPOINTSGENERATEDDURINGTHEWORKSHOPFORMEDTHEBASISOFANINTERNALEVALUATIONTOASSESSHOWWELLSCIENCEACTIVITIESINSANCTUARIESCONTRIBUTETOMANAGEMENTINFORMATIONNEEDSSEE%VALUATIONAND!NALYSISON&IGURE	4HERESULTSOFTHISEVALUATION

ARETHESUBJECTOFTHISREPORT

4HESEASONALCATCHO4OMALES"AY#!


4HESECONDPHASEOFTHEPLANTOSTRENGTHENSCIENCEINTHE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY0ROGRAMWILLTARGETEDIMPLEMENTATIONPLANS3TRATEGIESWILLBEDESIGNEDTOCONTINUEADJUSTORINITIATESCIENCEA

ENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDTHROUGHTHEEVALUATIONPROCESS)MPLEMENTATIONMECHANISMSTOBECONSIDEREDSUITABLEPARTNERSHIPSRElNEMENTOFEXISTINGPARTNERSHIPSIDENTIlCATIONOFFUNDINGSOURCESANDMEC

ANDEXTRAMURALPROJECTSANDPROMOTIONOFDIRECTEDRESEARCHAMONGFEDERALAGENCIESANDOTHERASSANDRESPONSIBILITIES

%VALUATIONOF%XISTING3CIENCE0ROGRAMS

4HISDOCUMENTPRESENTSTHERESULTSOFTHELASTSTEPOF0HASE)EVALUATIONANDANALYSIS4HEPURPOSE

ELUCIDATETHEEXTENTTOWHICHCURRENTACTIVITIESADDRESSTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSANDENDPOINTSIDENTIl4HEEVALUATIONANDANALYSISPROCESSINVOLVED	THECREATIONOFASURVEYFORMCONSISTINGOFCLEARLYSSANCTUARYSTAFFASTOTHERELEVANCELEVELOFACTIVITYANDINFORMATIONAVAILABILITYFOREACHENDPOINTADATATODETERMINEPROGRAMMATICANDSITE
SPECIlCSTATUSWITHREGARDTOTHEENDPOINTSTOWHICHTHEY

PROVIDESFEEDBACKTOSANCTUARYSTAFFANDOTHERSON0ROGRAMSTRENGTHSGAPSANDAPPARENTSURPLUSE

FORFUTUREEFFORTS

$EVELOPMENTAND!DMINISTRATIONOFTHE%VALUATION.EARLYENDPOINTSWEREIDENTIlEDDURINGTHEWORKSHOP4HESEWEREREVIEWEDBYTHE0ROGRAMSCICLARITY"ECAUSEENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDBYINDEPENDENTBREAKOUTGROUPSFREQUENTLYPERTAINEDTOMORENUMEROUSOVERLAPSWEREEVIDENT3IMILARENDPOINTSWERECOMBINEDANDDUPLICATIONSWEREREMOVED

COMPREHENSIVEEVALUATIONFORMWITHENDPOINTS!PPENDIX	%NDPOINTSINTHEEVALUATIONFORMWEREORGANIZEDINTOPICALCATEGORIES4HEMANAGEMENTISSUESTOWINDICATEDINTHECOLUMNSONTHERIGHT&IGURE	3ITESTAFFlLLEDINTHElRSTTHREECOLUMNSAFTEREACH

EACHENDPOINTASITPERTAINSTOTHEIRSITEANDPROVIDEDARATINGFORTHEFOLLOWINGTHREECATEGORIES

!	#ONCERN2ELEVANCE,EVELOFCONCERNRELEVANCETHESITEASCRIBESTOTHEENDPOINT

NOTAPPLICABLELOWMEDIUMHIGH

"	#URRENT!CTIVITIES%XTENTTOWHICHRECENTPLANNEDORCURRENTSCIENCEEFFORTSADDRESSTHEEND

NOTADDRESSED
SOMEWHATADDRESSEDMODERATELYADDRESSEDWELLADDRESSED

#	3TATEOF+NOWLEDGE!VAILABILITYFROMALLSOURCESOFQUALITYINFORMATIONDATAPERTAININGTOTHEENDPOINTANDTHEUTILITYOFTHIS

INFORMATIONINDECISIONMAKING

NOTAVAILABLELIMITEDAVAILABILITYUTILITYMODERATEAVAILABILITYUTILITYFULLYAVAILABLEUSEFUL

&IGURE%XAMPLEOFAPORTIONOFACOMPLETEDEVALUATIONFORM




54*,74",2,;(4*,

:77,49*90;090,8

#9(9,5-45<2,+.,

()09(9/(7(*9

	'5404.


0;04.(704,",8

&! 759,*9054

08/04.(7;,89


&02+20-,089:7)(4*,

;,49",86548,

",8957(9054",/()

4+:8970(2%8,8 

	
		


*,(45.7(6/0*+(9(04*2:+04.9,3657(2;(70(905404(4+(75:4+(7,(85-*54*,74576(790*:2(7049,7,89

:77,498  
 
 333333333 2(*1*07*:2(905435+,2$0+,8 	 
 
 3 33333 3 30*7590+(27,.054

%6<,2204.  	 	 3 333 3 049,74(2<(;,8(285

#(20409> 
   3 333 ,=9,480;,354095704.

$,36,7(9:7,    3 3333

$:7)0+09> 
 
 
 3 333 333

0./96,4,97(9054 "  
 
 3 333

/,30897> 	 	 	 3 333 3 +,6,4+04.54</(9083,(49)> */,30897>

:970,492:=  
 
 3 333 ):+.,98(4+85:7*,8=>.,4 	   3 333

&(;,-57*,8  	 	 3 3 33333 89573,;,498

/25756/>22(  
 
 3 333 =>,(7

			

,*/(40890*2041(.,8(354..,525.0*)0525.0*5*,(45.7(6/0*(4+(93586/,70*675*,88,8(89/,>04-2:,4*,/()09(9  	 	 333 333 )05,758054	04*7,(8,*57(2 7,*7:093,49

 7,+0*90;,35+,2895:4+,789(4++>4(30*85-/()09(9+08970):9054(4+-(*95789/(904-2:,4*,09,.8:)897(9,):70(2.,(7036(*98*203(9,*/(4.,036(*98 
 
 	 33 333

+,490-0*(90545-(49/7565.,40*/()09(98,.8/06<7,*18(790-0*0(27,,-850262(9-573860,78+:368)59953-08/04..,(78*(78 
 	 	 333 3 3

,525.0*(2*/(7(*9,70?(905404*2:+04.9,*954083(4++0(607083 
 
 
 3

#,+03,49*/(7(*9,70?(9054<09/04(7,(85-*54*,74 
 
 
 3 3 3


!NALYSIS-ETHODS4OANALYZETHERATINGSPROVIDEDBYTHESITESAGENERALMODEL&IGURE	WASDEVELOPEDTORELATETHE

2ELEVANCEAND3TATEOF+NOWLEDGETOARECOMMENDEDLEVELOFACTIVITYIERESEARCHORMONITORINGEDETERMINEDSUBJECTIVELYWITHRECOMMENDEDACTIVITYLEVELSINCREASINGASRELEVANCEINCREASESORASK&ORAPPROXIMATELYHALFTHEPOSSIBLECOMBINATIONSJUDGMENTSASTORECOMMENDEDACTIVITYLEVELWCOMBINATIONSTHATDIDNOTHAVEACLEARRESOLUTIONEG#ONCERN2ELEVANCE3TATEOF+NOWLEDGE!CTIVITY,EVELCOULDBEOR	THEFACTTHATTHEENDPOINTWASATALLRELEVANTWASDEEMEDTOJUSTIFYTACTIVITYLEVEL#URRENT!CTIVITYLEVELSPROVIDEDBYTHESITESFOREACHENDPOINTCOLUMN"ONTHEEVALUATIONFORM	WANDARECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYLEVELWASCALCULATED&IGUREILLUSTRATESOUTCOMESFORTHEFO

LEVELS&OREXAMPLEIFGEOLOGICALCHARACTERIZATIONOFASITEWASRATEDASHIGHLYRELEVANT	BUTTHESRATEDASLOW	THENAHIGHLEVELOFRECOMMENDEDACTIVITY	WOULDBEAPPROPRIATEACCORDINGTO&!CTIVITYLEVELATTHESANCTUARYWASRATEDASLOWLEVEL	ANINCREASEOFACTIVITYOFTWOUNITSWOULDB

4HUSASRESOURCESBECOMEAVAILABLETHESANCTUARYMIGHTWANTTOCONSIDERINCREASINGSCIENCEACTIV

CHARACTERIZATIONFROMhSOMEWHATADDRESSEDvTOhWELLADDRESSEDv&IGURE-ODELSHOWINGTHERECOMMENDEDLEVELSOFSCIENCEACTIVITYNUMBERSINSHADEDBOXES	FOR

#ONCERN2ELEVANCEAND3TATEOF+NOWLEDGESEETEXTFORDESCRIPTIONOFNUMERICALRATINGS	

$PODFSO3FMFWBODF



            

4UBUFPG,OPXMFEHF

    
&ORPURPOSESOFDISCUSSIONINTHISREPORTTERMSWEREADOPTEDTODESCRIBETHEOUTPUTOFTHEEVALUATION%NDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFnANDnWERECONSIDEREDTOMERIThSUBSTANTIALDECREASESvINACTIVITY4HOSEWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESOFnORWARRANTEDhLITTLEORNOCHANGEvINACTIVITY4HOSEWITHORMAYMERIThSUBSTANTIALINCREASESvINATTENTION&URTHERDISTINCTIONSWEREAVOIDEDFORTHEMOSTPARTDUETOTHESUBJECTIVENATUREOFTHERATINGSYSTEMANDSUBSEQUENTANALYSIS


	










   	 


   	 


    	




	


    

	










 	   

 	   

 	 	  




	


 	 	 	 

	










    	

    	

    




	


    


	










 
 	  

 
 	  

 
 
 	 




	


 
 
 	 	

" !!!$ !#!&$"#!#$##!"!
"!!#!&# !!! $"
! !!

!#!& !%! !"! 

4ERMSUSEDTODERECOMMENDEDCHSCIENCEACTIVITY3UBSTANTIALDECREA,ITTLEORNOCHANGE3UBSTANTIALINCREAS


3OURCESOF"IAS4HEANALYSISWASINHERENTLYSUBJECTIVEWITHSEVERALSOURCESOFPOTENTIALBIAS/NEEVALUATIONSURVEY

MARINESANCTUARIESWITHEACHRATINGREPRESENTINGTHECOLLECTIVEOPINIONSOFUPTOTHREEPEOPLE7ITHPARTICIPATEDINMORETHANONESITEEVALUATIONSEE!PPENDIX	2ATINGSFORRELEVANCEACTIVITYLEVELS

EVALUATORSBREADTHOFRESEARCHANDMANAGEMENTEXPERIENCETHEIRLEVELOFEXPERTISEANDTHEIRSPEC

2ESPONSESTOTHEQUESTIONOFANENDPOINTSRELEVANCEMAYHAVEREQUIREDTHEMOSTSUBJECTIVEJUDGMPOSED!CTIVITYANDKNOWLEDGELEVELSAREMUCHEASIERTOJUDGEQUANTITATIVELYEGNUMBEROFPROJECPUBLICATIONS	#OMPARISONSAMONGSITESACTIVITYANDKNOWLEDGELEVELSMIGHTHOWEVERBEPROBLEMADEPRESSEDVALUESINTHESECATEGORIESMIGHTBEPERCEIVEDASADVANTAGEOUSBYTHEEVALUATORFORAVAR

COULDOCCURIFEVALUATORSINTERPRETEDANENDPOINTORQUESTIONTOONARROWLYORTOOBROADLY&URTHERMOKNOWLEDGELEVELSWEREBASEDONCOMPARISONAMONGENDPOINTSATTHATPARTICULARSITE!NINCREASEO

ONESITEMIGHTREQUIREDIFFERENTCONSIDERATIONTHANASIMILARINCREASEATANOTHERSITE$ESPITEBIASINSURVEYSTHEREAPPEAREDTOBEFAIRLYGOODCONSISTENCYAMONGSITESURVEYS&ORTHEPSELECTEDSCIENCESTAFFREVIEWEDCOMPLETEDEVALUATIONSFORAPPARENTERRORSOVERSIGHTSINCONSISTENCIE

)DENTIlEDIRREGULARITIESWEREREFERREDBACKTOTHEORIGINALEVALUATORTOCONlRMORRECONSIDER7HILETHONREMOVINGBIASPERSETHEYMAYHAVERESULTEDININCREASEDCONSISTENCYAMONGTHESITES%VALUATORBIASWASPOSSIBLYCOMPOUNDEDBYTHESTRUCTUREOFTHESURVEYITSELF%NDPOINTSWEREORGANOCEANOGRAPHICREGIMEHABITAT	)FANEVALUATORCONSIDEREDATOPICAREATOBEOFPARTICULARIMPORTAN

JUDGEALLENDPOINTSWITHINTHATTOPICAREATOBEOFHIGHERRELEVANCEORLOWERSTATEOFKNOWLEDGE

!NADDITIONALEFFECTOFTHESURVEYSTRUCTUREALSOREDUCEDTHESTRENGTHOFTHEDATAANALYSIS"ECAUSE

INSCALEORSCOPEANALYSISBASEDONDIRECTCOMPARISONISNOTASROBUSTASITMIGHTBE9ETWHILETHRIGOROUSITISEXTREMELYVALUABLE)TSPURPOSEWASTODETERMINETHESTATUSOFSCIENTIlCEFFORTSINTHETOPRIORITYMANAGEMENTISSUES)TWASALSOINTENDEDTOASSISTTHE0ROGRAMANDOURPARTNERSTODETE

REDIRECTEDORTARGETED&ORTHESEPURPOSESWEBELIEVETHATTHEDATAANDTHEANALYSESAREAPPROPRIA

3ANCTUARYRESEARCHVESSEL*ANE9ARNHEADSOUTTO'RAYS2EEF.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARYTOSUPPORTSCIENCEOPERATIONS
0ROGRAMMATIC!NALYSIS

!NALYSESWERECONDUCTEDFORTHE0ROGRAMASAWHOLEANDONASITE
BY
SITEBASIS&ORTHE0ROGRAMRELEVANCEDATAWEREANALYZEDTODETERMINEWHETHERTHEENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDINTHEWORKSHOPWEREINFACTINFORMATIONNEEDSCONSIDEREDIMPORTANTBYSANCTUARYSTAFF$ATAONRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYLEVELWEREALSOANALYZEDTODETERMINEWHATTHEGREATESTNEEDSAREWITHINTHE0ROGRAM&INALLYRELEVANCEDATAWEREBROKENDOWNBYLEVELAND	ANDCOMBINEDWITHDATAONRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYLEVELTOMORESPECIlCALLYIDENTIFYTHESTATUSOFCURRENTSCIENCEEFFORTSANDPROVIDESPECIlCDIRECTIONFORFUTUREEFFORT%NDPOINT2ELEVANCE4ABLESHOWSTHENUMBEROFENDPOINTSASSOCIATEDWITHEACHMANAGEMENTISSUE7HILETHISDOESNOTREPRESENTANEXHAUSTIVE

LISTOFENDPOINTSAPPLICABLETOANYISSUETHESEENDPOINTSWERECONSIDEREDPRIORITIESBYTHEWORKSHOPATTENDEES!SMANYOFTHE

ENDPOINTSPROVIDEINFORMATIONESSENTIALTOAVARIETYOFMANAGEMENTISSUESTHESUITEOFENDPOINTSASCRIBEDTOEACHMANAGEMENTISSUEISNOTMUTUALLYEXCLUSIVE&OREXAMPLEKNOWLEDGEOFLARVALDISPERSALMECHANISMSISREQUIREDTOMAKEDECISIONSABOUTBOTH:ONINGAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION!SSESSMENTBYTHISORGANIZATIONALSTRUCTUREHELPSTOCORRECTFORDIFFERENCESINSCALEANDSCOPEOFENDPOINTSBYEMPHASIZINGBASICINFORMATIONTHATSERVICESMULTIPLEISSUES4ABLE .UMBEROFTHEENDPOINTSLISTEDINTHEEVALUATIONFORMAPPLICABLETOEACHPRIORITYSANCTUARYMANAGEMENTISSUE






	


 ((! #( $# 

$# # 
''''"#($ * #& #'$)&' 	(&)! (+&$(( $# 
 ' #&*'(('  !!  '()&# *#('%$#' 	'($&( $# ! (( $# #)'(& !'' 

%NDPOINTSARESOBJECTIVESTHATINFORMATIONNEE!SINGLEENDPOIMAYAPPLYTOSEMANAGEMENTISINSTANCEITISIMTOUNDERSTANDTEMPORALVARIATIUPWELLINGTOACCCHARACTERIZEHAASSESSLIVINGMARESOURCESADDRWATERQUALITYISSUNDERSTANDTHEOFlSHINGANDRTOUNFORESEENE


4HEVALIDITYOFTHEENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDBYWORKSHOPPARTICIPANTSISDEMONSTRATEDBYTHERELEVANCERA

ONTHEJUDGMENTOFSANCTUARYSTAFFATEACHSITEANAVERAGEOFALMOSTOFENDPOINTSWEREJUDGEDRELEVANCEWITHARATINGOFEITHEROR&URTHERNOSINGLEENDPOINTWASJUDGEDASLESSTHANMEDIUM

4HISSUGGESTSSTRONGLYTHATTHEBREAKOUTGROUPSINTHEWORKSHOPIDENTIlEDENDPOINTSOFLEGITIMATEIMMANAGEMENT4ABLE 0ERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSWITHINEACHOFFOURRELEVANCECATEGORIESASJUDGEDBYEACHMARIN


4HEROWhvISTHESUMOFTHOSETWOLEVELS

!BBREVIATIONSFORTHISANDSUBSEQUENCTTABLES#"#ORDELL"ANK#)#HANNEL)SLANDS&"&AGATELE"AY&'&LOWER'ARDEN"AN&ARALLONES'2'RAYS2EEF()(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE-"-ONTEREY"AY/#/LYMPIC#OAST3"3TELLWAGEN"ANK)NTERESTINGLYTHE&LORIDA+EYS/LYMPIC#OASTAND-ONTEREY"AYWEREAMONGTHESITESWITHTHEHIGH

MEDIUMTOHIGHRELEVANCEOR	4HISMAYREmECTINPARTTHEFACTTHATTHESEARETHETHREELARGEST

COASTALSEGMENTSANDAREALSOQUITECOMPLEXWITHREGARDTOMANAGEMENTISSUESOFCONCERN/NAVERAGESITESJUDGEDONLYOFENDPOINTSTOBEIRRELEVANTIERELEVANCEOF	ANDNONEWERECSITES&LORIDA+EYS/LYMPIC#OASTAND-ONTEREY"AYCONSIDEREDONLYOFENDPOINTSTOBEIRRELEV

'RAYS2EEFAND(AWAIICONSIDEREDTOBEIRRELEVANT

!  

  	   
   	  
 

  
 
         

 	 
     
   	 

	  	 	 	 	 	 	  
 	 


   
	 

    
 
  

	
   
	 

  	  

   

4HE./!!3HIP-C!24(52ARRIVESAT3OUTHEAST&ARALLON)SLANDFORAROUNDOFSUBMERSIBLEDIVES
#HANGE!NALYSIS.OTE
&ORTHEREMAINDEROFANALYSESINTHISREPORTENDPOINTSATANYGIVENSITEWITHRELEVANCEOFIEIRRELEVANT	WEREEXCLUDED4ABLESHOWSTHECOMPARATIVELYHIGHPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSPERTAININGTOTHREEMANAGEMENTISSUES:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONTHATMAYMERITANINCREASEINACTIVITYOFEITHERTWOORTHREEUNITS4HETABLEALSOSUGGESTSTHAT7ATER1UALITYAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESMAYBETHEISSUESTHATAREMOSTAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDONTHEWHOLE!TLEASTOFENDPOINTSWITHINTHESEISSUESHADRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYWITHINONEUNITOFZERO
OR	!LSOOFNOTEFORANY

MANAGEMENTISSUEBETWEENANDOFENDPOINTSMAYWARRANTSUBSTANTIALDECREASESINACTIVITY4ABLE !VERAGEPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSWITHINEACHLEVELOFRECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYFORPRIORITYMANAGEMENTISSUESIN

THE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY0ROGRAM

)NDIVIDUALSITEDATAMAYBEMOREILLUSTRATIVEANDUSEFULTHANTHE0ROGRAMMEANS3ITESCANUSETHEIRDATATOIDENTIFYISSUESTHAT

REQUIREINCREASEDATTENTIONTHOSETHATMIGHTWARRANTADECREASEINEFFORTANDTHOSETHATAREBEINGADDRESSEDATAPPROPRIATELEVELS

!LLSITESINDICATEDTHATTHEIRSCIENCEACTIVITIESSHOULDBEENHANCEDFORALMOSTALLMANAGEMENTISSUESSEE&IGURE	4HEMEANSFOR

EACHISSUERANGEDFROMn'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONES%VENT2ESPONSETHEONLYNEGATIVEMEAN	TO(AWAIIAN)SLAND(UMPBACK7HALE2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION	/VERALLJUDGMENTSBYTHESTAFFMEMBERSAT(AWAII	-ONTEREY"AY	AND'RAYS2EEF

	SUGGESTTHATTHEIRSITESNEEDTHEGREATESTINCREASEINACTIVITY4ABLE	$ATAFROMTHE&LORIDA+EYS	AND'ULFOFTHE

&ARALLONES	SUGGESTTHATTHEYMAYREQUIRETHELEASTAVERAGECHANGEINACTIVITYLEVEL






	          

!((
"!#(!$#       	  		 

$#!#          !*!#&!#'$)&'   	    	  	 
(&)"!(+     	    	!' !#&*'(('     
     !""!
!'()&#   
    	  	 
*#('%$#'    
     	 '($&(!$# !"!((!$#       	  
 #)'(&!"''       	   

3URVEYSOFSANSTAFFREVEALEDATHATREQUIRESUBINCREASESINSCATTENTION4HEPERCENTAGEOFEREQUIRINGTHEGRATTENTIONWERETHEFOLLOWINGIS:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION


'JHVSF "WFSBHFSFDPNNFOEFEDIBOHFTJOBDUJWJUZMFWFMGPSFBDITBODUVBSZBOEUIF/.41GPSFBDINBOBHFNFO

4DBMFCFMPXGJHVSFTIPXTUIFOVNFSJDBMSBOHFTGPSFBDIMFWFMPGTIBEJOH

)BCJUBU

%FMJOFBUJPO ;POJOH -JWJOH.BSJOF 3FTPVSDFT 8BUFS2VBMJUZ 1SPUFDUJPO 'JTIJOH )BSWFTUJOH 8JMEMJGF %JTUVSCBODF &WFOU 3FTQPOTF 3FTU

3FIB

$IBOOFM*TMBOET

$PSEFMM#BOL

'BHBUFMF#BZ

'MPSJEB,FZT

'MPXFS(BSEFO#BOLT

(SBZT3FFG

(VMGPGUIF'BSBMMPOFT

)BXBJJBO*TMBOET)VNQCBDL8IBMF

.POUFSFZ#BZ

0MZNQJD$PBTU

4UFMMXBHFO#BOL

/.41"WFSBHF

4DBMF     
4ABLE 4HERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYLEVELSWEREAVERAGEDFORALLRELEVANTENDPOINTSFOREACHMARINESANCTUARYANDA0ROGRAM
WIDEMEANWASCALCULATED!NALYSISBY2ELEVANCE#ATEGORY)NORDERTOEVALUATETHEAPPROPRIATENESSOFSCIENCEACTIVITYATTHESITESFORINFORMATIONNEEDSOFDIFFERINGLEVELSOFRELEVANCEDATAWEREDIVIDEDACCORDINGTORELEVANCELEVELS0ROGRAMAVERAGESWEREALSOCALCULATEDFORCOMPARISONTOSITEDATA4ABLE	/FNOTEALMOSTATHIRDOFENDPOINTSHADARECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYOFNEARLYHALFOFHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSREQUIRED

SUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYANDNEARLYALLENDPOINTSOFLOWRELEVANCEWEREJUDGEDTOREQUIRELITTLEORNOCHANGEINACTIVITY

-) '%%&!& "&+"-"+/

')$$$-&+&('"&+*

!&&$*$&* ')$$
&# 
 +$
/ $')"/* $'.))&
&#* )/* ,$'+!)$$'&* 	.""&*$&*,%(#!$ 	'&+)/
/ $/%("'*+ +$$. &
&# /*+%"& 

	"!  "   !#  

 " $   ! !%

	
	

 




	

 

 	





     
     
   

                   

    	  
             	

      
      	 
  	 	  
 

     
  
        
 	    

3ANCTUARIESWERETORANKTHERELEVSCIENCEENDPOINALLOWINGAMOREEVALUATIONOFTHEGREATESTNEED)MALMOSTHALFTHEEJUDGEDTOBEOFHRELEVANCEALSORESUBSTANTIALINCREATTENTION


%NDPOINTSOF(IGH2ELEVANCE3ITESCONSIDEREDANAVERAGEOFOFENDPOINTSTOBEHIGHLYRELEVANT4ABLE	/VERATHIRDOFTHESUBSTANTIALINCREASEINACTIVITYWITHARECOMMENDEDCHANGEOFONAVERAGE4ABLE	)NFACT

THESANCTUARIESTOBEOFHIGHRELEVANCEWEREJUDGEDTOWARRANTANINCREASEINACTIVITYTO	/BY(AWAIIAND/LYMPIC#OASTSTAFFASHIGHLYRELEVANTWARRANTEDANINCREASEDACTIVITYLEVELOF3ITE

PROPORTIONOFENDPOINTSWITHARECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYOFWERE'RAYS2EEFAND&AGATELE

ORCATEGORIESFORTHE(AWAIIAN)SLANDS&AGATELE"AY/LYMPIC#OASTAND'RAYS2EEFTOTALEDRESPECTIVELY4HISREmECTSTHENEEDFORCONSIDERABLEINCREASESINTARGETEDRESEARCHATTHESESITES!COMPARATIVELYHIGHPROPORTIONOFHIGHLYRELEVANTENDPOINTS	WEREJUDGEDTOREQUIRENOCHANG

+EYSANDWARRANTEDNOORMINIMALCHANGEIECHANGEINACTIVITYOFnOR	4HE#HANNEL

CATEGORY"YCONTRAST&AGATELE"AY'RAYS2EEFANDTHE(AWAIIAN)SLANDSHADNOMORETHANO

ZERO!COMPARATIVELYLOWPERCENTAGE	OFHIGHLYRELEVANTENDPOINTSAPPEARTOMERITAREDUCTIONINACTACONSIDERABLEREDUCTION
UNITS	3ITESWITHENDPOINTSINTHESECATEGORIESMAYWANTTOEVALUATETPARTICULAREFFORTS4ABLE 4HENUMBERANDPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCE	WITHINEACHOFTHEhRECOMM

CATEGORIESFOREACHSANCTUARY

 


 &%'&"%*)-"*!

&$$%!% "%
*","*.&


&%

&$$%!% 

%*+(.       &*#     

 
         
  

   	      	  
 

       	   	  

     
 
 
     

    
      	  

  
 
         

            

       	     

       
   
  

   	   	       
      	     

&*#   	  
       
%NDPOINTSOF-ODERATE2ELEVANCE

%NDPOINTSRATEDTOBEMODERATELYRELEVANTTOTHESANCTUARIESCOMPRISEDOFALLRATEDENDPOINTSONAVERAGE4ABLE	!LMOSTTHREEQUARTERSOFTHESEWEREJUDGEDTOWARRANTSOMEINCREASEINACTIVITYWITHRATINGSOFOR4ABLE	.EARLYHALF	OF

THEMODERATELYRELEVANTENDPOINTSREQUIREDONLYASLIGHTINCREASEINACTIVITY	!TOTALOFWARRANTEDNOCHANGEORSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITYIECHANGEINACTIVITYOFnOR	/LYMPIC#OAST'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESAND#ORDELL"ANKWEREATORNEARINTHISCATEGORY4HREESITES'RAYS2EEF3TELLWAGEN"ANKAND-ONTEREY"AY	HADPARTICULARLYHIGHPERCENTAGESOFMODERATELYRELEVANTENDPOINTS

THATWARRANTEDSOMEINCREASEINACTIVITY&IFTY
EIGHTPERCENTOFTHEMODERATELYRELEVANTENDPOINTSRATEDBY'RAYS2EEFWARRANTEDA

CHANGEOFACTIVITYLEVEL#ORRESPONDINGPERCENTAGESAT3TELLWAGEN"ANKAND-ONTEREY"AYWEREANDRESPECTIVELY.OTE

HOWEVERTHATTHENUMBERSOFENDPOINTSRATEDBYSTAFFAT-ONTEREY"AYAND'RAYS2EEFTOBEOFMODERATERELEVANCEWEREHIGH

COMPAREDTO3TELLWAGEN"ANK/NAVERAGEONLYOFTHEMODERATELYRELEVANTENDPOINTSAPPEAREDTOMERITSOMEDECREASEINACTIVITY&LORIDA+EYSWASTHEONLY

SANCTUARYFORWHICHTHEASSESSMENTINDICATEDASUBSTANTIALSURPLUSOFACTIVITYFORANYENDPOINTIERECOMMENDEDCHANGEOF
	FOR

AMODERATELYRELEVANTENDPOINTSPECIlCALLYSALINITYINFORMATION	4ABLE 4HENUMBERANDPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSOFMODERATERELEVANCEWITHINEACHOFTHEhRECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYvCATEGORIESFOREACHSANCTUARY

!#! 

"&%'&"%*)-"*!

&$$%!% "%
*","*.&

!&%'&"%*)-"*!

&$$%!% "%
*","*.&

%*+(.       &*#       *&

            
  



       
     	 
 

     	       	  
	

       	       	


              

   
         	  


   
        	  	 

              


     
 
 	       


            
         	      	 

&*#    	  
       	 

-OSTENDPOINTSJTOBEOFMODERATRELEVANCEWERECONSIDEREDTOBEWELLADDRESSEDQUARTERHOWEVERSUBSTANTIALINCREATTENTION


%NDPOINTSOF,OW2ELEVANCE/NAVERAGESITESCONSIDEREDONLYOFENDPOINTSTOBEOFLOWRELEVANCE4ABLE	$ESPITETHEIR

HALF	OFTHESEENDPOINTSWEREJUDGEDTOMERITSOMEADDITIONALACTIVITY4ABLE	.EVERTHELESS

RECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYLEVELFORALLLOWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWASMINIMALnOR	/VERALLOFTHELOWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEAREDTOMERITADECREASEINACTIVITY&LORIDA+EYSWA

THEASSESSMENTINDICATEDASUBSTANTIALSURPLUSOFACTIVITYIERECOMMENDEDCHANGEOF
	FORALOOXYGENINFORMATION	4ABLE 4HENUMBERANDPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSOFLOWRELEVANCEWITHINEACHOFTHEhRECOMMEND

CATEGORIESFOREACHSANCTUARY

	



 &%'&"%*)-"*!

&$$%!% "%
*","*.&


&

&$$%!

%*+(.      &*#    

    	      

     
     

          

     
     

          

          

     	 	    

          

          

          

     	     

&*#   	      
 

%NDPOINTSJUDGEDTOBEOFLOWRELEVANCETOSANCTUARIESWEREONTHEWHOLECONSIDEREDTOBEWELLADDRESSEDTHOUGHABOUTHALFMAYWARRANTSOMEADDITIONALSCIENTIlCATTENTION
3ITE!NALYSESAND3UMMARIES

&OREACHSANCTUARYSCIENCEACTIVITIESWEREEVALUATEDWITHRESPECTTORELEVANCEANDTODETERMINEHOWWELLINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTAREBEINGMET$ATAFROMEACHSITEWEREANALYZEDTOANSWERTHEFOLLOWINGQUESTIONS

!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIESATTHESANCTUARY4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY

4OANSWERTHElRSTQUESTIONTHESUBSETSOFENDPOINTSASSOCIATEDWITHEACHMANAGEMENTISSUEWEREEVALUATED-ANAGEMENTISSUES

WITHTHEHIGHESTPERCENTAGEOFAPPLICABLEENDPOINTSREQUIRINGLITTLEORNOCHANGEINACTIVITY
OR	WERECONSIDEREDTHEMOSTAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSED,ESSTHANADEQUATEATTENTIONWASINDICATEDBYSUBSTANTIALRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOR	

WHILESUBSTANTIALDECREASES
OR
	WERECONSIDEREDINDICATIVEOFADEQUATETHOUGHPOTENTIALLYEXCESSIVEATTENTION

&ORTHESECONDQUESTIONSPECIlCENDPOINTSWEREEXAMINED!NYENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALDECREASESINACTIVITYLEVEL

WERENOTEDASAREASWHERETHESANCTUARYSHOULDRECONSIDERITSCOMMITMENTS!LLENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASES

INACTIVITYAREPOTENTIALAREASTODIRECTFUTURESCIENCERESOURCES(OWEVERTHEENDPOINTSTHATWEREALSORATEDASHIGHLYRELEVANTTO

THESANCTUARYWERECONSIDEREDTOREPRESENTPRIORITYTARGETSWITHRESPECTTOFULlLLINGTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSOFTHESANCTUARY

&OREACHSANCTUARYASUMMARYTABLEPROVIDESALISTOFHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFOR

4HISISINTENDEDTOPROVIDETHESANCTUARIESANDRELEVANTPARTNERSWITHTHEDETAILSNECESSARYTOIDENTIFYMANAGEMENTISSUES

ANDMORESPECIlCALLYENDPOINTSWITHTHEGREATESTNEEDFORADDITIONALATTENTION!MONGTHESEENDPOINTSPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFOR

THETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFOR	ENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITS	ENDPOINTSTHATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	CLUSTERSOFENDPOINTSSIMILARINNATURETHATMIGHTBE

ADDRESSEDCOLLECTIVELYBYFUTUREPROJECTS.OTE 4ERMSUSEDTODESCRIBERECOMMENDEDCHANGESINSCIENCEACTIVITYINTHEFOLLOWINGSECTIONSARECONSISTENTWITHTHOSEPREVIOUSLYDElNEDANDUSEDINTHEPROGRAMMATICOVERVIEW!hSUBSTANTIALDECREASEvINACTIVITYISSUGGESTEDIFTHECHANGEINACTIVITY

IS
ORnhLITTLEORNOCHANGEWHENTHERECOMMENDEDCHANGEIS
ORANDAhSUBSTANTIALINCREASEvWHENTHECHANGEIN

ACTIVITYISAND

/NEOFTHEMOSTIMPORINFORMATIONNEEDSINMSANCTUARIESINVOLVESURECRUITMENTANDTHEPINmUENCEIT4HISISAT3MOOTHTRUNKlSH,ACTRIQUETER	SMALLERTHAN


3ITE!NALYSIS

#HANNEL)SLANDS.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUAR

&ORTHE#HANNEL)SLANDS.-3OFTHEENDPOINTSWERECONSIDEREDRELEVANTTOMANAGEMENTRECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYFORTHESEWASEQUALTOTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4ABLE	!LLLOWBEAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHISSITEASNONEHADARECOMMENDEDREDUCTIONINACTIVITY4ABLE#

HOWEVERMAYBEWARRANTEDFOROFTHEENDPOINTSOFLOWRELEVANCE4HOSEOFMODERATEANDHIG

COMPARATIVELYWELLADDRESSED/NLYPERCENTOFTHEHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSMAYMERITSUANINCREASEOFTWOTOTHREEUNITS	WELLBELOWTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEOF4ABLE	!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIV#HANNEL)SLANDSAPPEARSTOBEDOINGWELLADDRESSINGTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSASSOCIATEDWITHMANAPERCENTAGESOFASSOCIATEDENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORLITTLEORNOCHANGEINACTIVITY4ABLE#)
	EAVERAGES4ABLE	SEVERALOFTHESEREPRESENTTHEHIGHESTPERCENTAGESFORANINDIVIDUALSANCTUARY-ARINE2ESOURCESAND(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAPPEARTOBEPARTICULARLYWELLADDRESSEDCOMPAREDTOO)SLANDS.INETY
TWOPERCENTANDRESPECTIVELYOFTHEENDPOINTSINTHESEMANAGEMENTISSUESS

ADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITY4ABLE#)
	4HESESUBSTANTIALLYEXCEEDTHECORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAG2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESAPPEARTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTATTENTIONOFALLMANATHEHIGHESTPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORANINCREASEOFORUNITS4ABLE#)
	)NDMANAGEMENTISSUEFOR#HANNEL)SLANDSTHATISHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEEXCEEDINGITBYTWO!TTHE#HANNEL)SLANDSONLYONEENDPOINTMAYMERITADECREASEINACTIVITY4ABLE#)
	4HISENDPO

TEMPERATUREINTHESANCTUARY

!' $!#$!&"!#"!&%"!%$$(!&&&!!%!%)&!"!!&(&*&"$%&"#$&'$!"&$'!$!! #%+!"



 	

 


		

 

     
     
 

      ! !      
 ! !  

      
 ! 	       ! 	 

	 !  
   
  
 !     
  

 

"&    
 

        	 	   

+EY&INDINGSs #OMPAREDTOOTHERSITESTHE#HANNEL

)SLANDS.-3HASAFAIRLYLOWPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSTHATREQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY

s !MONGMANAGEMENTISSUESTHEBEST

ADDRESSEDATTHE#HANNEL)SLANDSAPPEARSTOBE,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESFOLLOWEDCLOSELYBY(ABITAT$ELINEATION

s .OSIGNIlCANTSURPLUSESINSCIENTIlC

ACTIVITYAREEVIDENT

s 4HREEMANAGEMENTISSUES2ESTORATION

2EHABILITATION&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESSEEMTOWARRANTTHE

 GREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlCEFFORT)N

ADDITIONANUMBEROFENDPOINTSINTHE

 AREASOF:ONINGAND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE MAYWARRANTGREATERATTENTION

0RIORITY%NDPOINTSs $EVELOPINGPREDICTIVEMODELSTO 

UNDERSTANDTHEDYNAMICSOFHABITAT DISTRIBUTION

s 'ROWTHREPRODUCTIONANDMORTALITY 

OFTARGETEDSPECIES

s )NCIDENTALCONTAMINANTSFROMVESSELSs "ALLASTWATEREXCHANGEREQUIREMENTS 

ANDPROTOCOLS

s !COUSTICSIGNATURESOFVESSELTRAFlCs 6ESSELTRAFlCPATTERNS
4WENTY
SIXPERCENTOFENDPOINTS	APPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE#)
	/FTHESEENDPOINTSWERERATEDASHIGHLYRELEVANT4ABLE#)
	&ORTHEMOSTPARTTHESEENDPOINTSWEREFAIRLYSPECIlCEACHRELATINGTOASMALLNUMBEROFMANAGEMENTISSUES(OWEVERTWOMANAGEMENTISSUESWEREASSOCIATEDWITHTHEGREATESTNUMBERSOFTHESEENDPOINTS&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESEACHWITHASSOCIATEDENDPOINTS3EVENENDPOINTSWEREASSOCIATEDWITH:ONINGAND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE#)
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESARETHOSE	WITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	THATAREBOTH

NUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE4HETHREEENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORINCREASEOFWEREALLASSOCIATEDWITHVESSELUSEINTHE

SANCTUARY4HESECONCERNEDBALLASTEXCHANGEACOUSTICSIGNATURESANDINCIDENTALCONTAMINATIONFROMVESSELSOFVARIOUSTYPES)N

THESAMEGENERALAREAOFINVESTIGATIONAFOURTHENDPOINTWASRECOMMENDEDFORANINCREASEOFANDCONCERNEDTHENEEDFORDATAONVESSELTRAFlCPATTERNS4WOENDPOINTSIN4ABLE#)
ADDRESSNEEDSWITHINlVEISSUES4HESEENDPOINTSARE	DEVELOPINGPREDICTIVEMODELSTOUNDERSTANDTHEDYNAMICSOFHABITATDISTRIBUTIONAND	GROWTHREPRODUCTIONANDMORTALITYOFTARGETEDSPECIES

 !)$$."$+0 &$,%$+#-,(+0/3(0'$ "')$2$),%.$",**$+#$#"' +&$(+ "0(2(04%,.$ "'* + &$*$+0(//1$(+0'$' ++$)/) +#/ 0 ,%- .0("1) .+,0$ .$1+#$.)(+$# +#$*-' /(5$#(+!,)#






	       

 !(0 0$)(+$ 0(,+    	      

,+(+&   
  	    
	 

(2(+& .(+$$/,1."$/    
      0$.1 )(04   
 	 	    

 

(/'(+& .2$/0%%$"0/   
 	 	 	   
 ()#)(%$(/01.! +"$    
 	 
   
 


2$+0$/-,+/$     	     

$/0,. 0(,+$' !()(0 0(,+    
 
    	 

+#1/0.( )/$/   
  
  
   

4HEKELPFORESTIN#HA.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCPROVIDESHABITATTOAOFSPECIES4OBETTERSANCTUARYHABITATSANMOREINFORMATIONISNPOTENTIALIMPACTSASSWITHCONTAMINANTSBAANDNOISEFROMVESSESANCTUARYWATERS


4ABLE#)
(IGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFORATTHE#HANNEL)SLANDS.ATIONAL-AR

!

%NDPOINTS

2ECOMMENDED

#HANGEIN!CTIVITY

(ABITAT$ELINEATION

")/,/')#!,

2%3/52#%3
 0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST%COLOGICALINDICATORS  

)DENTIFICATIONOFIMPACTSATAPPROPRIATESCALES  

%6%.42%30/.3% 2ISKASSESSMENT#ONSEQUENCESOFEVENTSINCLUDINGCOLLATERALCONSEQUENCES	  

2ISKASSESSMENT$ATASTATISTICSONTHEOCCURRENCEOFPASTEVENTSFOREACHTYPEOFEVENT	  0ROCESSESTHATCREATEANDCHANGESEABEDFORMSINTHEFOLLOWINGCONTEXTS/CEANOGRAPHICEGTURBIDITYFLOWSEROSION	  30ROCESSESTHATCREATEANDCHANGESEABEDFORMSINTHEFOLLOWINGCONTEXTS!TMOSPHERICEGPRECIPITATIONATMOSPHERICDEPOSITIONAIRSEA

EXCHANGEATMOSPHERICLOADING	  3 (!")4!4

0REDICTIVEMODELSTOUNDERSTANDDYNAMICSOFHABITATDISTRIBUTIONANDFACTORSTHATINFLUENCEITEGSUBSTRATEBURIALGEARIMPACTSCLIMATECHANGEIMPACTS	  3%FFECTSOFFISHINGHARVESTONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICS  %FFECTSOFNATURALEVENTSONHARVESTEDORGANISMSANDYIELDS'LOBALWARMING  %FFECTSOFNATURALEVENTSONHARVESTEDORGANISMSANDYIELDS#URRENTS  &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES#OMPETITIONBETWEENKEYSPECIES  &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES'ROWTHREPRODUCTIONANDMORTALITY  $ATAONSPATIALANDTEMPORALHABITATCHANGESCAUSEDBYFISHING  

(!26%34).'

,EVELOFEFFORTSPATIALANDTEMPORALDISTRIBUTIONANDDENSITYFORCOMMERCIALFISHINGHARVESTING  #HARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFFIC"ALLASTEXCHANGEREQUIREMENTSANDPROTOCOLS  #HARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFFIC!COUSTICSIGNATURESOFVESSELTRAFFIC  4OURISMPROFILE!CTIVITIESOFVENDORS  )DENTIFICATIONOFSOURCESOFINVASIVESPECIES  

).$5342)!,53%3

#HARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFFIC6ESSELTRAFFICPATTERNS  

-!00).'

#!0!"),)4)%3 ')3COMPATIBLEDATA3HORELINE  3 

2%34/2!4)/. 6ALUATIONOFSANCTUARYRESOURCES  

)NCIDENTALCONTAMINANTSFROMVESSELSMERCHANTFISHINGTOURISMPRIVATE	  

7!4%215!,)49 4EMPORALCHANGESINLEVELSOFPATHOGENSANDPATHOGENICINDICATORSWITHIN7ATERCOLUMN  

4EMPORALCHANGESINLEVELSOFRELEVANTORGANICSANDMETALSWITHIN7ATERCOLUMN  3USCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSEOFSPECIESOFCONCERNTOWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE6ERIFICATIONOFCAUSE
AND
EFFECTRELATIONSHIPS  3USCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSEOFSPECIESOFCONCERNTOWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE!CUTEANDCHRONICSPECIESRESPONSEEGBEHAVIORALREPRODUCTIVEPHYSIOLOGICALPHYSICALINJURY	  3USCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSEOFSPECIESOFCONCERNTOWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE3ENSORYCAPABILITIESPHYSIOLOGICALTOLERANCESANDTHRESHOLDS  

7),$,)&%

$)3452"!.#%

3PATIALANDTEMPORALVARIABILITYINLEVELSOFWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE  

%NDPOINTSRELATEDTOMANAGEMENTISSUE 


.OTETHATENDPOINTSARELISTEDBYTOPICCATEGORYANDNOTMANAGEMENTISSUE%NDPOINTSMAYRELATETOMORETHANONEMANAGEMENT ISSUE
3ITE!NALYSIS

#ORDELL"ANK.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

3TAFFAT#ORDELL"ANKCONSIDEREDOFTHEENDPOINTSTOBERELEVANTTOADDRESSINGMANAGEMENTISSUESATTHESANCTUARY&ORTHESEENDPOINTSTHEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYWASORBELOWTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4ABLE	.EARLYALLLOWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOBEAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHISSITEASALLHADLITTLEORNORECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITY4ABLE

#"
	4HOSEOFHIGHERRELEVANCEARERELATIVELYWELLADDRESSEDCOMPAREDTOMOSTSITES/NLYPERCENTOFTHEHIGHRELEVANCE

ENDPOINTSANDNONEOFTHEMODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINATTENTIONANINCREASEOFTWO

TOTHREEUNITS	WELLBELOWTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGESOFANDRESPECTIVELY4ABLE	)NFACTSEVENHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSHAD

RECOMMENDEDDECREASESINACTIVITYOFnTHESECONDHIGHESTNUMBERINTHE0ROGRAM!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIESATTHE#ORDELL"ANK.-3&OREIGHTOFTHENINEMANAGEMENTISSUESAT#ORDELL"ANKTHEPERCENTAGEOFASSOCIATEDENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORLITTLEORNOCHANGEINACTIVITYEXCEEDEDTHECORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGES4HESANCTUARYAPPEARSTOBEDOINGPARTICULARLYWELLADDRESSING

ENDPOINTSRELATEDTO7ATER1UALITYAND%VENT2ESPONSE.INETY
THREEPERCENTOFTHEENDPOINTSASSOCIATEDWITH7ATER1UALITYWARRANTEDNOCHANGEORONLYSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITY4ABLE#"
	4HISVALUEEXCEEDSTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEBYANDEQUALS'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESFORTHEHIGHESTVALUEOFALLTHESANCTUARIES4ABLE	$ESPITETHESEDATAFOLLOW
UPINTERVIEWSWITH

SANCTUARYSTAFFINDICATETHATCERTAINWATERQUALITYPARAMETERSINCLUDINGNON
POINTSOURCEPOLLUTIONANDHARMFULALGALBLOOMSARENOTADEQUATELYADDRESSED&OR%VENT2ESPONSEOFTHEAPPLICABLEENDPOINTSWEREEITHERCONSIDEREDAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDORWARRANTEDDECREASEDACTIVITY4HISSUGGESTSTHATTHISMANAGEMENTISSUEGENERALLYHASBEENWELLADDRESSEDTHOUGHOFITSASSOCIATEDENDPOINTSWERE

RECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY

 "(!%"$%"'#"$#"'&#"&%% )"''#% "*'"#'%#!!""

"')'+'#%&'#$%'( %"#'%("% ""!$&,"# 


	 	

 


	

 

 
	




        
        
   

   	   " "       " " 	   "

       " 
     
  "  	  

	 "  
 
     " 
 	 
 
   
 

 

#'  
  		 	   	      	     

+EY&INDINGSs #OMPAREDTOMO

 .-3HASAFAIRLY

ENDPOINTSTHATREINACTIVITY

s!MONGMANAGEM

APPROPRIATELYADAPPEARTOBE7A2ESPONSETHOUGPOLLUTIONANDHAR

 REQUIREADDITIONAs0OTENTIALSURPLUS

%VENT2ESPONSE

 EVALUATEITSINVES

TOOTHERNEEDS

s4WOMANAGEMEN &ISHING(ARVEST

THEGREATESTINCRADDITIONANUMB

 AREAOF)NDUSTRIA

ATTENTION3TAFFICERTAINASPECTSO

 AREALSOAPRIORITY

0RIORITY%NDPOIs %COLOGICALBIOLOGCRITERIAAFFECTINGs .ATURALANDANTHAFFECTINGSANCTUAHARVESTEDSTOCKSs 4OURISMANDVESSs $REDGEANDlLLACs 3OURCESOFINVASI


4WOISSUES:ONINGAND&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAPPEARTOMERITINCREASEDSCIENCEACTIVITYCOMPARED"ANK.EARLYHALFTHEENDPOINTSWITHINTHESETWOISSUESHADRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFAT

.EVERTHELESS&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSWASTHEONLYONEOFTHENINEISSUESTOEXCEEDTHE0ROGRAMAVEENDPOINTSREQUIRINGADDITIONALSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE	4HOUGHNOTREmECTEDINTHISANALYSISFOLLOW

STAFFINDICTEDTHENEEDFORCONSIDERABLEINCREASESINACTIVITYRELATEDTOHABITATCHARACTERIZATIONAT#O4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFSCIENCEACTIVITY3URPLUSESOFACTIVITYWERENOTEDINEIGHTOFTHERELEVANTENDPOINTSAT#ORDELL"ANK.-33EVENOFTH

RELEVANT&IVEOFTHESEWEREPREDOMINANTLYAPPLICABLETOTHEISSUEOF%VENT2ESPONSE	MITIGATION

OFIMPACTSATAPPROPRIATESCALES	EVENTPATHTRACKINGANDIDENTIlCATIONOFLIKELYCONSEQUENCESTOIDENTIFYANDVERIFYANEVENTINSIDEORADJACENTTOTHESANCTUARYAND	CONTINGENCYPLANFORRELEV

THATTHISANALYSISISNOTMEANTTOSUGGESTTHATINVESTMENTSINTHESEACTIVITIESAREINFACTEXCESSIVETHATGIVENTHEHIGHACTIVITYLEVELSRELATIVETOSTATEDKNOWLEDGEANDRELEVANCELEVELSINTHEEVALUATIONITSINVESTMENTANDJUDGEWHETHERITISAPPROPRIATELYDIRECTED4WENTY
FOURPERCENTOFENDPOINTSAPPEARTOMERITSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERRESEARCHACTIVITY4ABLE#"
	%FFECTSHADTHELARGESTPERCENTAGESOFTHESEENDPOINTSANDRESPECTIVELY4ABLE#"
	4HRECOMMENDEDCHANGEOFWASTHEEFFECTIVENESSOFZONINGREGIMES3IGNIlCANTLYALLENDPOINTSTHACTIVITYOFORWEREJUDGEDTOHAVEARELEVANCEOF4ABLE#"
	

!"+%%0#%-2!'%.&%-$/.)-215)2(%!#(+%4%+.&0%#.,,%-$%$#(!-'%)-!#2)4)26&.0%!#(,!-!'%,)113%)-.0$%++!-*!2!.&/!02)#3+!0-.2%!0%3-$%0+)-%$!-$%,/(!1)7%$)-".+$






	      

!")2!2%+)-%!2).-   
 
 
    
 

 .-)-'      		   
 

)4)-'!0)-%%1.30#%1   
       

!2%03!+)26    	
 
     

)1()-'!04%12&&%#21   
   	
   
	 

)+$+)&%)1230"!-#%   
  
 
    

4%-2%1/.-1%    	 	     

%12.0!2).-%(!")+)2!2).-    
  	   
 

-$3120)!+1%1   
 	
 
    
 

!T#ORDELL"ANK.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARYMANAGEMENTACTIVITIESREQUIREADDITIONALHABITATCHARACTERIZATIONANDLIFEHISTORYINFORMATIONONKEYSPECIESSUCHASTHISMIXEDSCHOOLOFROCKlSH
%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE#"
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESARETHOSE	WITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	THATAREBOTHNUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE4HEONLYENDPOINTRECOMMENDEDFORANINCREASEOFTHREEUNITSPERTAINSTOTHEEFFECTIVENESSOF

ZONINGREGIMES/THERAREASOFNEEDINCLUDEINVESTIGATIONSOFTHEEFFECTSOFNATURALEVENTSONHARVESTEDORGANISMSANDYIELDS

ANDFACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHBETWEENPOPULATIONSANDWITHINTARGETEDSPECIESPOPULATIONS%NDPOINTSRELATINGTO

THESEAREASWEREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESANDWERESIMILARINNATURETOOTHERENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDWITHSUBSTANTIALNEED')3COMPATIBLEDATACRITICALHABITATFORSPECIESOFCONCERNWASALSOFOUNDTOBEAPRIORITYENDPOINTBECAUSEOFITAPPLICABILITYTOEIGHTOFTHENINEMANAGEMENTISSUES


#()3,
0./9,3,=(5*,,5+7605;:>0;/9,*644,5+,+*/(5.,:05(*;0=0;@6-
69(;69+,33(52(;065(3(905,



!




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

 ,9;05,5;05-694(;06565:7,*0,:6-:7,*0(305;,9,:;*636.0*(305+0*(;69:  33(*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:65+0;065(5+;9,5+:6-*90;0*(3/()0;(;  333 (*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:<3;0:7,*0,:9,3(;065:/07:  3 (*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:647,;0;065),;>,,52,@:7,*0,:  333 (*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,: 9,+(;6979,@9,3(;065:/07:  333 (*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:!,*9<0;4,5;  333 



!"$!"

5-694(;065652,@:7,*0,:(5+*644<50;0,:644<50;@+@5(40*:,.;967/0*:;9<*;<9,:7,*0,:05;,9(*;065:  33--,*;:6--0:/05.	/(9=,:;6579,+(;6979,@+@5(40*:  3 --,*;:6-5(;<9(3,=,5;:65/(9=,:;,+69.(50:4:(5+@0,3+:36)(3>(9405.  --,*;:6-5(;<9(3,=,5;:65/(9=,:;,+69.(50:4:(5+@0,3+:30B6:  --,*;:6-5(;<9(3,=,5;:65/(9=,:;,+69.(50:4:(5+@0,3+:<990*(5,:  --,*;:6-5(;<9(3,=,5;:65/(9=,:;,+69.(50:4:(5+@0,3+:<99,5;:  (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:647,;0;065),;>,,52,@:7,*0,:  33 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,: 9,+(;6979,@9,3(;065:/07:  33 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:65+0;0656-*90;0*(3/()0;(;  333 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:66+9,8<09,4,5;:  33 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:!,*9<0;4,5;  333 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:96>;/9,796+<*;065(5+469;(30;@  33 @*(;*/+(;(  .,6-;(9.,;69.(50:4:(;;04,6-/(9=,:;  3 (;(65:7(;0(3(5+;,4769(3/()0;(;*/(5.,:*(<:,+)@-0:/05.  3 ,=,36-,--69;:7(;0(3(5+;,4769(3+0:;90)<;065(5++,5:0;@-699,*9,(;065(3-0:/05.	/(9=,:;05.  3 ,=,36-,--69;:7(;0(3(5+;,4769(3+0:;90)<;065(5++,5:0;@-69*644,9*0(3-0:/05.	/(9=,:;05.  3 %,::,3;@7,:<:,+-69-0:/05.(5+/(9=,:;05.  

!%"#

647(90:65:6-047(*;:6--0:/05.(5+/(9=,:;79,::<9,05(9,(:6-/0./36>(5+56(*;0=0;@  3 

*#2#%4'2+:#4+0/0(&2'&)'#/&(+--#%4+6+4+'3.1#%40/-0%#-+:'&(-07&9/#.+%3 	 052+3.120(+-'%4+6+4+'3-0%#4+0/+/4'/3+490(4052+343 	 052+3.120(+-'208+.+490(3#/%45#292'3052%'3401015-#4''#3 	 &'/4+(+%#4+0/0(3052%'30(+/6#3+6'31'%+'3 	 

  

*#2#%4'2+:#4+0/0(6'33'-42#((+%208+.+490(.#,026'33'-42#((+%403'/3+4+6'2'3052%'3 	 

 %0.1#4+$-'#2+4+%#-*#$+4#4(0231'%+'30(%0/%'2/ 	 333 

 %0.1#4+$-'#'&+.'/4491'3 	 3

!

  *2'#4#33'33.'/4(023052%'30(7+-&-+('&+3452$#/%'#/)'0(+/(-5'/%'(02104'/4+#--965-/'2#$-'31'%+'3 	 

" (('%4+6'/'330(:0/+/)2')+.' 
 3 

! !!! " 
 	  

04'4*#4'/&10+/43#2'-+34'&$9401+%%#4')029#/&/04.#/#)'.'/4+335'/&10+/43.#92'-#4'40.02'4*#/0/'.#/#)'.'/4 +335'
3ITE!NALYSIS

&AGATELE"AY.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

&OR&AGATELE"AY.-3OFTHEENDPOINTSWERECONSIDEREDTOBERELEVANTTOMANAGEMENTINFORMATIONNEEDSATTHESANCTUARY4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYFORTHESEENDPOINTSWASORABOVETHE0ROGRAMAVERAGESEE4ABLE	!LLLOWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOBEAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHISSITEASALLHADRECOMMENDEDCHANGESWITHINONEUNITOFZERO4ABLE&"
	4HOSEOFMODERATERELEVANCEAREFORTHEMOSTPARTADEQUATELYADDRESSEDASONLYHADRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYABOVETHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEWAS4ABLE	-ANYENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCEHOWEVERREQUIRESUBSTANTIALLYGREATERATTENTIONWITHHAVINGRECOMMENDEDINCREASESOFORUNITSCOMPAREDTOA0ROGRAMAVERAGEOF!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIESAT&AGATELE"AY.-3&AGATELE"AY.-3APPEARSTOBEDOINGPARTICULARLYWELLADDRESSINGENDPOINTSRELATEDTO(ABITAT$ELINEATION7ATER1UALITYAND

)NDUSTRIAL5SES/VEROFENDPOINTSWITHINTHESEISSUESWARRANTEDNOCHANGEORONLYSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITYEXCEEDING

0ROGRAMAVERAGESBY
4ABLE	/THERISSUEAREASTHATEXCEEDED0ROGRAMAVERAGESWERE,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAND&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS)TSHOULDBENOTEDHOWEVERTHATACOMPARATIVELYHIGHNUMBEROFENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCEWITHINTHESE

TWOISSUESMAYWARRANTSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY4ABLE&"
	4HREEISSUES:ONING2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONAND%VENT2ESPONSEAPPEARTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASEINSCIENCEATTENTION

AT&AGATELE"AY2OUGHLYHALFTHEENDPOINTSWITHINTHESEISSUESHADRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFATLEASTTWOUNITS4ABLE

&"
	&ORTHESETHREEISSUESTHEPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSREQUIRINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYEXCEEDEDTHECORRESPONDING

0ROGRAMAVERAGES4ABLE	

!' $!#$!&"!#"!&%"!%$$(!&&&*)&!"&$" !!!

&(&*&"$%&"#$&'$!"&$'!$!! #%+!"

	

 

		

 

 
	





        
        
   

   	 	  ! !      
 ! !    !

   
    ! 	
   	   
 !    

	 !       	 !     
 
 	  	 

"&        
     
  
    

+EY&INDINGSs #OMPAREDTOOT PERCENTAGEOFE .-3REQUIRESUB ACTIVITYs !MONGMANAGEM ADDRESSEDAPPE $ELINEATION7AT 5SESs .OSURPLUSESINs :ONING2ESTORA AND%VENT2ESP THEGREATESTINC ENDPOINTSWITHT CHANGESINACTIV MOSTMANAGEM0RIORITY%NDPOs 0HYSICALANDBIO THATAFFECTTHES RESOURCESEG GROWTHREPRODU INCLUDINGHOWTH RESTORATIONEFFORs )MPACTSOFlSHIN SPECIESOFINTEREs 0REDICTINGVERIFYEVENTSORDISTURBWITHINANDADJAC


4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDF

SCIENCEACTIVITY!LLENDPOINTSRELEVANTTOTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSOF&AGATELE"AY.-3AREEITHERBEINGAPPROPRIARECOMMENDEDFORINCREASEDACTIVITY.OSURPLUSESWEREIDENTIlED4ABLE&"
	&IFTY
THREEENDPOINTSWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE&"
	ANDOFTHESEARE

4ABLE&"
	4HESEENDPOINTSAREDISTRIBUTEDBROADLYACROSSALLMANAGEMENTISSUESWITHTHEGREAT&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE!LARGENUMBEROFENDPOINTSAPPLYTOSEVERALOFTPERTAINEDTOIMPACTSOFlSHINGACTIVITIESONSPECIESOFINTERESTANDTHEPHYSICALANDBIOLOGICALCRITE

EGCURRENTSRECRUITMENTGROWTHREPRODUCTIONANDMORTALITY	4HOSERELATEDTO%VENT2ESPONSEDANDTRACKINGEVENTSOFVARIOUSTYPESWITHINANDADJACENTTOTHESANCTUARY%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE&"
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCERECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENNUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE%IGHTEENENDPOINTSLISTEDIN4ABLE&"
WERERECOMMENDEDFORINITHESEENDPOINTSREPRESENTFAIRLYSPECIlCAREASOFINVESTIGATIONAPPLICABLETOAFEWENDPOINTS(OWE

NOTEWORTHYBECAUSEOFBROADAPPLICABILITYORSIMILARITYTOOTHERLISTEDENDPOINTS/NEENDPOINTOCEONCURRENTSINANDAROUNDTHESANCTUARYISRELEVANTTOALLISSUES3EVERALENDPOINTSAPPLICABLETOS

CONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFLIVINGRESOURCESEGINTER
SPECIESRELATIONSHIPSSTRESSESGROWTHAAFlNITIESFORDIFFERENTLIFESTAGES4HESEINCLUDEENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORINCREASESOFBOTHA

 !)$$."$+0 &$,%$+#-,(+0/3(0'(+$ "')$2$),%.$",**$+#$#"' +&$(+ "0(2(04%,.$ "'* + &$(//1$(+ & 0$)$ 4 0 ,%- .0("1) .+,0$ .$1+#$.)(+$# +#$*-' /(5$#(+!,)#






	      

 !(0 0$)(+$ 0(,+      
 
   

,+(+&         	
 

(2(+& .(+$$/,1."$/     
     

 0$.1 )(04   
 
 	 
 
   

(/'(+& .2$/0%%$"0/     
     

()#)(%$(/01.! +"$      
 
  

 

2$+0$/-,+/$    	 
 	   

 

$/0,. 0(,+$' !()(0 0(,+    
   
  
 

+#1/0.( )/$/       	   

-ANAGEMENTAT&AGETELE"AY.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARYHASACRITICALNEEDTOUNDERSTANDTHEIMPACTSOFlSHINGACTIVITIES3ANCTUARYREGULATIONSPROHIBITTHEUSEOFDYNAMITETOSTUNORKILLlSHBUTBLAST
lSHINGVIOLATIONSSTILLPOSEATHREATTOTHESANCTUARYSCORALRESOURCESSUCHASTHIS0ORITESSP
$*+5.201;.5.?*7,..7-9827=<@2=1;.,866.7-.-,1*70.<27*,=2?2=B8/8;*=*0*=.5.*B*=287*5*;27.#*7,



!




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

!"!$

 # !! 

 !"

 .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=,85802,*527-2,*=8;<  333 

*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<>5=2<9.,2.<;.5*=287<129<  3 33 

 .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=.B<=87.<9.,2.<.0*9.A9;.-*=8;<,;2=2,*51.;+2?8;.<  3 

*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<7-2,*=8;<8/91B<285802,*5<=;.<<.0+286*;4.;<+5.*,1270  33 3

*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<869.=2=287+.=@..74.B<9.,2.<  333 33 

*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.< ;.-*=8;9;.B;.5*=287<129<  333 33 

*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<*+2=*=><.*=?*;28><52/.<=*0.<  333 33 



"#%"#

*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<".,;>2=6.7=  333 33 

.?.5898;;.?2<.*7-?*52-*=.*99;89;2*=..,85802,*568-.5<=89;.-2,=.?.7=<  

?.7=9*=1=;*,4270*7-2-.7=2/2,*=2878/524.5B,87<.:>.7,.<  

".5.?*7=*7-*99;89;2*=.-*=*=82-.7=2/B*7-?.;2/B*7.?.7=27<2-.8;*-3*,.7==8=1.<*7,=>*;B  

274*0.<+.=@..7=1.,*><.<8/.?.7=<  

-.7=2/2,*=2878/269*,=<*=*99;89;2*=.<,*5.<  

87=270.7,B95*7/8;;.5.?*7=.?.7=<  

&$"# #

"2<4*<<.<<6.7= ;8+*+252=B8//>=>;..?.7=<  

//.,=<8//2<1270	1*;?.<=879;.-*=8;9;.B-B7*62,<  3 3

*,=8;<,87=;855270B.*;,5*<<<=;.70=18/=*;0.=.-<9.,2.<".,;>2=6.7=  333 3

*,=8;<,87=;855270B.*;,5*<<<=;.70=18/=*;0.=.-<9.,2.<;8@=1;.9;8->,=287*7-68;=*52=B  33 33

0.8/=*;0.=8;0*72<6<*==26.8/1*;?.<=  3 3

2<=;2+>=287*7-*+>7-*7,.8//2<1=*;0.=*7-787=*;0.=*=-2//.;.7=52/.<=*0.<  333 33

*,=8;<,87=;855270B.*;,5*<<<=;.70=18/=*;0.=.-<9.,2.< ;.-*=8;9;.B;.5*=287<129<  33 3

*=*87<9*=2*5*7-=.698;*51*+2=*=,1*70.<,*><.-+B/2<1270  3 3

.?.58/.//8;=<9*=2*5*7-=.698;*5-2<=;2+>=287*7--.7<2=B/8;;.,;.*=287*5/2<1270	1*;?.<=270  3 3

"&#$

.?.58/.//8;=<9*=2*5*7-=.698;*5-2<=;2+>=287*7--.7<2=B/8;,866.;,2*5/2<1270	1*;?.<=270  3 3

%#$"%## -.7=2/2,*=2878/<8>;,.<8/27?*<2?.<9.,2.<  

 

 $# #,869*=2+5.-*=*#18;.527.  3 3

" 

"

,.*780;*912,-*=*27,5>-270=.698;*5?*;2*=28727*7-*;8>7-*;.*<8/,87,.;78;9*;=2,>5*;27=.;.<=>;;.7=<  333333

&*5>*=2878/<*7,=>*;B;.<8>;,.<  3 

"#$"$ <<.<<6.7=8/*99;89;2*=.=.,1785802.</8;;.<=8;*=287	;.1*+252=*=28727=1./8558@270,*=.08;2.< 1B<2,*5

<=;>,=>;.  

$.698;*5*7-<9*=2*5-B7*62,<27/5>.7,270@*=.;:>*52=B79>=</;867879827=<8>;,.<*7-<.5.,=.-1>6*7*,=2?2=2.<  3

7,2-.7=*5,87=*627*7=</;86?.<<.5<6.;,1*7=/2<1270=8>;2<69;2?*=.  3 3

'$"!%$(

$.698;*5*7-<9*=2*5-B7*62,<27/5>.7,270@*=.;:>*52=B79>=</;86;2?.;<*7-8>=/*55<  3

75')36-&-/-6:%1(4)53215)2*53)'-)52*'21')41629-/(/-*)(-5674&%1')'76)%1(',421-'53)'-)54)53215))+&),%8-24%/4)342(7'6-8)3,:5-2/2+-'%/3,:5-'%/-1.74:  3

3%6-%/%1(6)0324%/8%4-%&-/-6:-1/)8)/52*9-/(/-*)(-5674&%1')  3 

75')36-&-/-6:%1(4)53215)2*53)'-)52*'21')41629-/(/-*)(-5674&%1')")4-*-'%6-212*'%75)%1()**)'64)/%6-215,-35 
 3 

75')36-&-/-6:%1(4)53215)2*53)'-)52*'21')41629-/(/-*)(-5674&%1'))1524:'%3%&-/-6-)53,:5-2/2+-'%/62/)4%1')5%1(6,4)5,2/(5 
 3

 ,4)%6%55)550)16*245274')52*9-/(/-*)(-5674&%1')4)(-'6276'20)5*248%4-275(-5674&%1')4)+-0)5 
 3

#

 !

 ,4)%6%55)550)16*245274')52*9-/(/-*)(-5674&%1')()16-*-'%6-212*5274')5 
 3 

03%'652*714)564-'6)(,70%1%'6-8-6-)59-6,-1;21)(%4)%516)15-6:  3

03%'652*714)564-'6)(,70%1%'6-8-6-)59-6,-1;21)(%4)%53%6-%/(-564-&76-21  3

03%'652*714)564-'6)(,70%1%'6-8-6-)59-6,-1;21)(%4)%5 :3)52*-03%'65  3 $

**)'6-8)1)552*;21-1+4)+-0)  3 33 

! !!! "  	 	 
 	 	 

26)6,%6)1(32-165%4)/-56)(&:623-''%6)+24:%1(1260%1%+)0)16-557)1(32-1650%:4)/%6)62024)6,%121)0%1%+)0)16 -557)


3ITE!NALYSIS

&LORIDA+EYS.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

!LLBUTONEOFTHEENDPOINTSWEREDETERMINEDTOBERELEVANTTOINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMETHESETHEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYWASWELLBELOWTHE0ROGRAMMEANOFAND	&ORMODERATEANDHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTS&LORIDA+EYSEXCEEDSTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEINTHEPERCADDRESSED2EMARKABLYLITTLEORNOCHANGEWASRECOMMENDEDFOROFHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTS40ROGRAMAVERAGEOF4ABLE	ANDTHEHIGHESTOFANYSITE,OWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOBELESSAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDINTHE&LORIDA+EYSTHANATOTHERS

RECOMMENDEDFOR4ABLE&+
	COMPAREDTOANAVERAGEOFFORALLSITES4ABLE	4HISREmECCONSIDERABLEDECREASES
TOn	INACTIVITYFORlVEENDPOINTSJUDGEDTOBEOFLOWRELEVANCETOTHE&LO!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIE4HE&LORIDA+EYS.-3APPEARSTOBEDOINGPARTICULARLYWELLADDRESSINGENDPOINTSRELATEDTO7ILDLIFE$2EHABILITATIONAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESWITHANDOFENDPOINTSWARRANTINGNOCHANGEORSLRESPECTIVELY4ABLE&+
	)NTERVIEWSWITHSANCTUARYSTAFFHOWEVERSUGGESTTHATTHEREREMAINSTHENEETHESUCCESSOFSPECIlCRESTORATIONACTIONSASKNOWLEDGETODATEHASBEENGAINEDLARGELYTHOUGHTRIAL4HEPERCENTAGESOFADEQUATELYADDRESSEDENDPOINTSFORALLMANAGEMENTISSUESAREATORABOVETHECO

0ROGRAM4ABLE	(OWEVERTHEPERCENTAGESFOR7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCEAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONBECAUSETHEYARETHEHIGHESTVALUESFORANINDIVIDUALSANCTUARY&ORTHE&LORIDA+EYSTHEHIGHESTPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSPOTENTIALLYMERITINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESIN

:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESANDRESPECTIVELY	(O

THEIRCORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGESWITH:ONINGBEINGPARTICULARLYREMARKABLE4ABLE	:ONINGIST

!' $!#$!&"!#"!&%"!%$$(!&&&"$*%)&!!!&(&*&"$%&"#$&'$!"&$'!$!! #%+!"

	
	

 




	

 

     
     

  	  	  ! !       ! ! 

   
   	 ! 	       ! 

	 !   

     !    
   

"&  
  
    	  
  
  
  

+EY&INDINGSs 4HE&+.-3HADTHELOWESTAVERAGE RECOMMENDEDCHANGEFORRELEVANT

ENDPOINTSAMONGSITES

s 4HE&+.-3HADACOMPARATIVELYLOW

PERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSTHATREQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY

s !MONGMANAGEMENTISSUESTHEMOST

APPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHE&+.-3APPEARTOBE7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE)NDUSTRIAL5SESAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONTHOUGHTHEREREMAINSTHENEEDFORCONTROLLEDRESEARCHONTHESUCCESSOFSPECIlCRESTORATIONACTIONS	

s 0OTENTIALSURPLUSESMAYEXISTFOR SEVERALENDPOINTSRELATEDTO(ABITAT

$ELINEATIONAND7ATER1UALITY

s :ONING,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAND &ISHING(ARVESTING%FFECTSAPPEARTO

BETHEMANAGEMENTISSUESWARRANTINGTHEGREATESTINCREASESINSCIENCEEFFORT
4OEFFECTIVELYMANAGETHE&LORIDA+EYS.ATIO3ANCTUARYSANCTUARYREQUIREADDITIONALINFOTHELIFEHISTORYCHARACSPECIESTARGETEDBYREANDCOMMERCIALlSHIN

THESANCTUARYYETTHEPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSTHATAREAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDFORTHISISSUEISPOINTSHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAM

AVERAGE4HISREmECTSTHETREMENDOUS0ROGRAM
WIDENEEDFORINCREASEDSCIENCEACTIVITYTOSUPPORT:ONING

4HEFACTTHATTHE&LORIDA+EYS.-3RANKSWELLABOVETHERESTOFTHESANCTUARIESINADDRESSINGENDPOINTSRELATEDTO:ONINGREmECTS

CONSIDERABLEEFFORTSOVERTHELASTlVEYEARSTOESTABLISHZONESANDMONITORTHEIREFFECTIVENESS$ESPITETHESEEFFORTSRESEARCHONZONINGREMAINSAPRIORITYASITISREQUIREDTOEVALUATETHISCONTROVERSIALAPPROACHTORESOURCEMANAGEMENT4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY4ENOFTHERELEVANTENDPOINTSAT&LORIDA+EYS.-3WERERECOMMENDEDFORDECREASEDSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE&+
	)NGENERAL

THESURPLUSESOCCURREDINENDPOINTSTHATADDRESSEDBASICRESEARCHNEEDSWITHBROADAPPLICABILITYACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUES3URPLUSESWEREEVIDENTINALLLEVELSOFRELEVANCEBUTTHEYWEREPARTICULARLYPROMINENTFORENDPOINTSCONSIDEREDTOBEOFLOWCONCERN

ATTHESANCTUARY4HESEINCLUDEDTWOENDPOINTSREGARDINGOCEANOGRAPHICDATAOXYGENANDTIDES	ANDTHREERELATEDTOCABLELAYING

SEDIMENTTYPESIMPACTSTOHABITATANDINFAUNAEPIFAUNA	3ANCTUARYSTAFFMAYWANTTORECONSIDERRESOURCECOMMITMENTSTOTHESEPARTICULARAREASOFINVESTIGATION!TTHE&LORIDA+EYSOFENDPOINTSORENDPOINTSAPPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE&+
	4WENTY
TWOSHOULDBECONSIDEREDHIGHPRIORITYASTHEYWERERATEDASHIGHLYRELEVANTBYSITESTAFF4ABLE&+
	4HREEMANAGEMENTISSUESHADCOMPARATIVELYHIGHNUMBERSOFAPPLICABLEENDPOINTSINTHISCATEGORYANDMAYWARRANTTHEGREATESTATTENTION&ISHING

(ARVEST%FFECTS,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAND:ONING%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE&+
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESARETHOSE	WITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	THATARE

 !)$$."$+0 &$,%$+#-,(+0/3(0'(+$ "')$2$),%.$",**$+#$#"' +&$(+ "0(2(04%,.$ "'* + &$*$+0(//1$(+0'$),.(# $4/ 0 ,%- .0("1) .+,0$ .$1+#$.)(+$# +#$*-' /(5$#(+!,)#






	       

 !(0 0$)(+$ 0(,+ 
   	  	   	 	

,+(+&    	  
    

(2(+& .(+$$/,1."$/ 	 	 
 	  
  
   0$.1 )(04 	   	 
     

(/'(+& .2$/0%%$"0/ 	 
  		  
   
 

()#)(%$(/01.! +"$  
 
 
 
   
  

2$+0$/-,+/$    
 	     

$/0,. 0(,+$' !()(0 0(,+    
 	 
   


+#1/0.( )/$/          


BOTHNUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE4HREEHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSEACHPERTAININGTOONLYONEMRECOMMENDEDFORACHANGEINACTIVITY4HEMANAGEMENTISSUESANDSPECIlCENDPOINTSWERE	BY
CATCHDATA	7ATER1UALITYSOCIOECONOMICEFFECTSOFWATERQUALITYONCOMMERCIALANDRECREATIO

	)NDUSTRIAL5SESBALLASTEXCHANGEREQUIREMENTSANDPROTOCOLS;.OTE)NTERVIEWSWITHSANCTUARYS

INDICATETHATCOMPAREDTOOTHERINFORMATIONNEEDSTHELATTERTWOENDPOINTSARENOTAMONGTHEHIGH4WOOTHERENDPOINTSARENOTEWORTHYBECAUSETHEYAREASSOCIATEDWITHATLEASTSIXMANAGEMENTISSUEINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST7AVEFORCESREFE

IMPACTOFSTORMEVENTS	AND	-ECHANISTICLINKAGESAMONGGEOLOGICBIOLOGICOCEANOGRAPHICANDTHEYINmUENCEHABITAT2ESEARCHTOINVESTIGATEVARIOUSFACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHFORLIVIN

CONSIDEREDASANAREATOTARGETRESOURCES3IXENDPOINTSPERTAININGTOTHISAREAWERERECOMMENDEDATTENTION)TSHOULDBENOTEDTHATTHE&LORIDA+EYS.-3RECENTLYCONDUCTEDANIN
HOUSEEVALUATIONOFPRIORITYR4HESANCTUARYRELIEDONOUTSIDERESEARCHANDAGENCYCOLLABORATORSFORINPUT!LISTOFHIGHPRIORITYNSCIENCEPLANHASBEENDRAFTED
#()2,0./8,2,<(4*,,4+6504:9=0:/8,*533,4+,+*/(4.,904(*:0<0:?5-58(::/,2580+(,?9(:054(2(804,"(4*:;(



! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

!"!$

 # !! 

 !"

,8:04,4:04-583(:0545496,*0,95-96,*0(204:,8,9:,?9:54,96,*0,9,.(6,>68,+(:589*80:0*(2/,8)0<58,9  3 ,8:04,4:04-583(:0545496,*0,95-96,*0(204:,8,9:*525.0*(204+0*(:589  333 

 !"$!" (*:589*54:852204.:/,9;**,995-?,(8*2(99,9-5896,*0,955+8,7;08,3,4:9  333 3 3 

%#!"" 041(.,9),:=,,4:/,*(;9,95-,<,4:9  

## ,*/(409:0*2041(.,9(354..,525.0*)0525.0*5*,(45.8(6/0*(4+(:3596/,80*685*,99,9(9:/,?04-2;,4*,/()0:(:  333 3

?*(:*/+(:(  3--,*:95--09/04.	/(8<,9:5468,+(:5868,?+?4(30*9  3 3--,*:95-4(:;8(2,<,4:954/(8<,9:,+58.(40939(4+?0,2+925)(2=(8304.  3(*:589*54:852204.?,(8*2(999:8,4.:/5-:(8.,:,+96,*0,9536,:0:054),:=,,41,?96,*0,9  33 3(*:589*54:852204.?,(8*2(999:8,4.:/5-:(8.,:,+96,*0,98,+(:5868,?8,2(:0549/069  33 3(*:589*54:852204.?,(8*2(999:8,4.:/5-:(8.,:,+96,*0,955+8,7;08,3,4:9  33 3(*:589*54:852204.?,(8*2(999:8,4.:/5-:(8.,:,+96,*0,9!,*8;0:3,4:  333 3(*:589*54:852204.?,(8*2(999:8,4.:/5-:(8.,:,+96,*0,985=:/8,685+;*:054(4+358:(20:?  33 33(:(5496(:0(2(4+:,3658(2/()0:(:*/(4.,9*(;9,+)?-09/04.  3 3

!%"#

,<,25-,--58:96(:0(2(4+:,3658(2+09:80);:054(4++,490:?-588,*8,(:054(2-09/04.	/(8<,9:04.  3 3

$"#!$"" /(8(*:,80@(:0545-<,99,2:8(--0*(22(9:,>*/(4.,8,7;08,3,4:9(4+685:5*529  

#" "*536(:0)2,+(:("5;8*,(8,(9-58*80:0*(296,*0,9  333 3 

! *,(45.8(6/0*+(:(04*2;+04.:,3658(2<(80(:05404(4+(85;4+(8,(95-*54*,84586(8:0*;2(804:,8,9:&(<,-58*,9  3 3 33

! *,(45.8(6/0*+(:(04*2;+04.:,3658(2<(80(:05404(4+(85;4+(8,(95-*54*,84586(8:0*;2(804:,8,9:$6=,2204.  3 333 

"5*05,*54530*,--,*:95-=(:,87;(20:?54*533,8*0(2(4+8,*8,(:054(2;9,9(4+685-0:9  3

&#! $#' ,<,29(4+3,*/(409395-9;)2,:/(29:8,99589  3

#,3658(2*/(4.,9042,<,295-6(:/5.,49(4+6(:/5.,40*04+0*(:589=0:/040525.0*(29(362,9  3

! !!! "  
 
  

 
 

5:,:/(:,4+6504:9(8,209:,+)?:560**(:,.58?(4+45:3(4(.,3,4:099;,4+6504:93(?8,2(:,:5358,:/(454,3(4(.,3,4: 099;,


3ITE!NALYSIS

&LOWER'ARDEN"ANKS.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTU

&ORTHE&LOWER'ARDEN"ANKS.-3OFTHEENDPOINTSWERECONSIDEREDRELEVANTTOMANAGEMAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYATTHE&LOWER'ARDENSWASORHIGHERTHANTHE0ROG

LOWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOBEAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHISSITEASONLYONEHADARECOMACTIVITY4ABLE&'
	3LIGHTINCREASESINACTIVITYHOWEVERMAYBEWARRANTEDFOROFTHEENDPOIOFHIGHERRELEVANCEARELESSADEQUATELYADDRESSED/NETHIRDOFTHEMODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINATTENTION4HESEARESLIGHTLYABOVETH

ANDRESPECTIVELY4ABLE	!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITI.-34HE&LOWER'ARDENSAPPEARSTOBEDOINGPARTICULARLYWELLADDRESSINGENDPOINTSRELATEDTO)NDUSTRIALENDPOINTSIN)NDUSTRIAL5SESWARRANTEDNOCHANGEORSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITY4ABLE&'
	COM

4ABLE	/VERALLOFMANAGEMENTISSUEENDPOINTSREQUIREDANINCREASEINACTIVITYOFOR4ABLE&'
	

OF(OWEVERTHEPERCENTAGESFOR:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIORESPECTIVELY4ABLE&'
	SLIGHTLYABOVECORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGESANDWELLABOVETHEPERCENTISSUESATTHE&LOWER'ARDENS

 &# "# %! "! %$! $##' %%%!(##  $(%   %'%)%!#$%!"#%&# !%#& #  "$* !

		

 



	

 

     
     

 	            

   	 
  
  	    	    

	               
 

!%   
   	  
   	  	
  
 

+EY&INDINGSs (ALFOFHIGHPRIORITYENDPOINTSATTHE &LOWER'ARDENSREQUIRESUBSTANTIAL

INCREASESINACTIVITY

s 4HESANCTUARYISADEQUATELYADDRESSING

)NDUSTRIAL5SES

s .OSIGNIlCANTSURPLUSESINACTIVITYARE EVIDENTs 4HREEMANAGEMENTISSUES:ONING &ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND

2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONREQUIRETHE

 GREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlCATTENTION

4HElRSTTWOAPPEARTOWARRANTTHEMOSTATTENTION

0RIORITY%NDPOINTSs 2ECRUITMENTs %FFECTSOFlSHINGONPREDATOR
PREY 

DYNAMICS

s (ARVESTLEVELSANDIMPACTSs 2ECOVERYTRAJECTORIESFOLLOWING  VARIOUSIMPACTSs 0OPULATIONDYNAMICSOFKEY  

SPECIES

s #OMMUNITYDYNAMICSINCLUDING 

TROPHICSTRUCTUREANDSPECIES INTERACTIONS
4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY.OSIGNIlCANTSURPLUSESINACTIVITYWEREFOUNDFORANYMANAGEMENTISSUESATTHE&LOWER'ARDENSANDNOENDPOINTSWERERECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALDECREASESINACTIVITY4ABLE&'
	&URTHERMOREONLYlVEOFTHEENDPOINTSRATEDASRELEVANTBY

SANCTUARYSTAFFAPPEAREDTOWARRANTSLIGHTDECREASES
	/VERALLOFENDPOINTSAPPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY/FTHEHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFORABOVE4ABLE&'
	APPLYTO:ONINGOR&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAMONGOTHERISSUES

/FTHESEVENENDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCETHATREQUIREDANINCREASEINACTIVITYOFFOURAPPLIEDTOEACHOFTHESEISSUES3PECIlC

ENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDWEREASSESSMENTSOFRECRUITMENTASITRELATESTOYEARCLASSSTRENGTHTHEEFFECTSOFlSHINGONPREDATOR
PREY

DYNAMICSCOMPARISONSOFIMPACTSWITHINAREASOFDIFFERINGEFFORTANDPREDICTINGTRAJECTORIESOFRESOURCERECOVERY

%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE&'
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESARETHOSE	WITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	THATAREBOTH

NUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE3EVENENDPOINTSLISTEDIN4ABLE&'
WERERECOMMENDEDFOR
UNITENHANCEMENTINSCIENCEACTIVITY3EVERALOFTHESEARERATHERSPECIlCAREASOFINVESTIGATIONPERTAININGTOFEWMANAGEMENTISSUES/THERSAREPARTICULARLYNOTEWORTHYBECAUSETHEYAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEORSIMILARTOOTHERENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASES!NUMBEROFENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESOFATLEASTPERTAINTOSEVERALMANAGEMENTISSUES4HEYINCLUDEPOPULATIONDYNAMICSOFKEYSPECIESCOMMUNITYDYNAMICSINCLUDINGTROPHICSTRUCTUREANDSPECIESINTERACTIONSPREDATOR
PREYRELATIONSHIPSRECRUITMENT

MECHANISTICLINKAGESAMONGPROCESSESTHATINmUENCEHABITATANDDISTRIBUTIONANDABUNDANCEOFlSHATDIFFERENTLIFESTAGES4HERE

ALSOAPPEARSTOBEADDITIONALNEEDFORINFORMATIONREGARDINGCHARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFlCANDTHEIMPACTSOFHUMANACTIVITY%ACHOFTHESEAREASHADTHREEHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORACHANGEOFOR

3CIENTISTSHAVERECENTDISCOVEREDTHATAGGREGSPECIESSUCHASTHIS-GROUPERAREASSOCIATECERTAINFEATURESATTHE'ARDEN"ANKS.ATIONA3ANCTUARY4HEFACTTHOFMANYCOMMERCIALLYSPECIESISSTILLUNCERTASIGNIlCANTSOURCEOFCSANCTUARYMANAGEMEN

!"+%%0#%-2!'%.&%-$/.)-215)2()-%!#(+%4%+.&0%#.,,%-$%$#(!-'%)-!#2)4)26&.0%!#(,!-!'%,%-2)113%)-2(%+.5%0!0$%-!-*1!2!.&/!02)#3+!0-.2%!0%3-$%0+)-%$!-$%,/(!1)7%$)-".+$






	       

!")2!2%+)-%!2).-     	    
 

 .-)-'      	   		 

)4)-'!0)-%%1.30#%1     	 	   	 !2%03!+)26   
  	    
 

)1()-'!04%12&&%#21   	 
     
 

)+$+)&%)1230"!-#%     
     


4%-2%1/.-1%    
 
     	

%12.0!2).-%(!")+)2!2).-    
 
 		   
 

-$3120)!+1%1     
     


"()3,
0./9,3,=(5*,,5+7605;:>0;/9,*644,5+,+*/(5.,:05(*;0=0;@6-
69(;;/,36>,9(9+,5(52:(;06



! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 



,9;05,5;05-694(;06565:7,*0,:6-:7,*0(305;,9,:;6;,5;0(305=(:0=,:7,*0,:  3 3(*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:9,+(;6979,@9,3(;065:/07:  333 (*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,: ,*9<0;4,5;  333 5-694(;065652,@:7,*0,:(5+*644<50;0,:644<50;@+@5(40*:,.;967/0*:;9<*;<9,:7,*0,:05;,9(*;065:  3 3



 !# !

5-694(;065652,@:7,*0,:(5+*644<50;0,:67<3(;065+@5(40*:05*3<+05.:7,*0,:(5+767<3(;0653,=,3.,5,;0*:30-,/0:;69@(5++0:;90)<;065  3 3 0:2(::,::4,5;96)()030;@6--<;<9,,=,5;: 
 

$" !! +,5;0-0*(;0656-047(*;:(;(7796790(;,:*(3,:  

"" ,*/(50:;0*3052(.,:(465..,636.0*)0636.0*6*,(56.9(7/0*(5+(;46:7/,90*796*,::,:(:;/,@05-3<,5*, /()0;(;  333 

--,*;:6--0:/05.	/(9=,:;6579,+(;6979,@+@5(40*: 
 3 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,: ,*9<0;4,5; 
 333 647(90:65:6-047(*;:6--0:/05.(5+/(9=,:;79,::<9,05(9,(:6-/0./36>(5+56(*;0=0;@ 
 3 ::,::4,5;:6-/(9=,:;,+:;6*2:,.(**,::;6!(5+;90)(3+(;(  3 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:65+0;0656-*90;0*(3/()0;(;  333 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:96>;/9,796+<*;065(5+469;(30;@  33 ,=,36-,--69;:7(;0(3(5+;,4769(3+0:;90)<;065(5++,5:0;@-69*644,9*0(3-0:/05.	/(9=,:;05.  3 $,::,3;@7,:<:,+-69-0:/05.(5+/(9=,:;05.  

 $!"

0:;90)<;065(5+()<5+(5*,6--0:/;(9.,;(5+565;(9.,;(;+0--,9,5;30-,:;(.,:  333 /(9(*;,90A(;0656-=,::,3;9(--0*(33(:;,?*/(5.,9,8<09,4,5;:(5+796;6*63: 
 

#!" #!! /(9(*;,90A(;0656-=,::,3;9(--0*0:;90)<;065(5+()<5+(5*,6-=,::,3:  

/(9(*;,90A(;0656-=,::,3;9(--0*$,::,3;9(--0*7(;;,95:  

"! !*647(;0)3,+(;(!6<9*,(9,(:-69*90;0*(3:7,*0,:  333 

 

  *,(56.9(7/0*+(;(05*3<+05.;,4769(3=(90(;06505(5+(96<5+(9,(:6-*65*,95697(9;0*<3(905;,9,:;<;90,5;-3<?  3 3

"9(1,*;690,:6-796)()3,767<3(;065(5+*644<50;@9,*6=,9@>0;/05(302,3@9(5.,6-(5;/9676.,50*(5+5(;<9(3+0:;<9)(5*,: $ & 
 3

 !# ! "9(1,*;690,:6-796)()3,/()0;(;9,*6=,9@>0;/05(302,3@9(5.,6-(5;/9676.,50*(5+5(;<9(3+0:;<9)(5*,:  3


 
11&11,&-2.'"//0./0*"2&2&$)-.+.(*&1'.00&12.0"2*.-0&)"#*+*2"2*.-*-2)&'.++.5*-($"2&(.0*&1*.(&.$)&,*$"+

/0.$&11&1

 

&4&+1"-%,&$)"-*1,1.'$.-2",*-"-21$"31*-(,.02"+*26  



 &,/.0"+$)"-(&1*-+&4&+1.'/"2).(&-1"-%/"2).(&-*$*-%*$"2.015*2)*-*.+.(*$"+1",/+&1  

&,/.0"+$)"-(&1*-+&4&+1.'0&+&4"-2.0("-*$1"-%,&2"+15*2)*-"2&0$.+3,-  )0&"2"11&11,&-2'.01.30$&1.'5*+%+*'&%*1230#"-$&0&%*$2.32$.,&1'.04"0*.31%*1230#"-$&0&(*,&1 	 


 31$&/2*#*+*26"-%0&1/.-1&.'1/&$*&1.'$.-$&0-2.5*+%+*'&%*1230#"-$&&0*'*$"2*.-.'$"31&"-%&''&$2

0&+"2*.-1)*/1  ,/"$21.'3-0&120*$2&%)3,"-"$2*4*2*&15*2)*-7.-&%"0&"1-2&-1*26  3,/"$21.'3-0&120*$2&%)3,"-"$2*4*2*&15*2)*-7.-&%"0&"1/"2*"+%*120*#32*.-  3,/"$21.'3-0&120*$2&%)3,"-"$2*4*2*&15*2)*-7.-&%"0&"16/&1.'*,/"$21  3 !
''&$2*4&-&11.'7.-*-(0&(*,&  3 

! !!! "    

.2&2)"2&-%/.*-21"0&+*12&%#62./*$$"2&(.06"-%-.2,"-"(&,&-2*113&-%/.*-21,"60&+"2&2.,.0&2)"-.-&,"-"(&,&-2 *113&
3ITE!NALYSIS

'RAYS2EEF.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

!CCORDINGTOSTAFFAT'RAYS2EEF.-3OFTHEENDPOINTSWERERELEVANTTOTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSOFTHESANCTUARY4ABLE'2
	4HEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYFORTHESEENDPOINTSWASWHICHISHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4ABLE	3LIGHTINCREASESINACTIVITYMAYBEWARRANTEDFORALLENDPOINTSOFLOWRELEVANCE4ABLE'2
	4HEHIGHERRELEVANCEENDPOINTSARELESSADEQUATELYADDRESSED&IFTY
EIGHTPERCENTOFMODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINTSANDOFHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWERERECOMMENDEDFORASUBSTANTIALINCREASEINACTIVITY#ORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGESWEREANDRESPECTIVELY!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIESAT'RAYS2EEF.-3'RAYS2EEFAPPEARSTOREQUIRESUBSTANTIALLYMOREACTIVITYTOADDRESSTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORALLMANAGEMENTISSUES&ORALLISSUESPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSWARRANTINGNOCHANGEORONLYSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITY4ABLE'2
	ARELOWCOMPAREDTOOTHERSITESAVERAGINGNEARLYPERCENTAGEPOINTSBELOWCORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGES4ABLE	#OMPAREDTOOTHERISSUESENDPOINTSASSOCIATEDWITH(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAND:ONINGAPPEARTOREQUIRETHEMOSTADDITIONALATTENTIONAT'RAYS2EEFWITHSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYRECOMMENDEDFORANDOFENDPOINTSRESPECTIVELY4ABLE

'2
	&URTHERMORETHEPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSREQUIRINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESFOR(ABITAT$ELINEATION,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES

AND7ATER1UALITYWEREALMOSTTWICETHECORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGES4ABLE	SUGGESTINGTHESEISSUESAREPARTICULARLY

UNDER
ADDRESSEDCOMPAREDTOTHERESTOFTHE0ROGRAM4HEVALUESFOR(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAND7ATER1UALITYREPRESENTTHEHIGHEST

PERCENTAGESFORTHESEISSUESFORALLTHESANCTUARIES

!' $!#$!&"!#"!&%"!%$$(!&&$*,%)&!"&$" !!!&(&*&"$%&"#$&'$!"&$'!$!! #%+!"

		

 



	

 

 	





     
     
   

      ! !      
 ! ! 
   !

       ! 
   
   	 ! 	  	 

	 !      
  !     
   
  

"&     
 	 
 
   
  	     

 

+EY&INDINGSs .EARLYTWO
THIRDS

ENDPOINTSREQUIREINACTIVITY

s !LLMANAGEMENTI

SUBSTANTIALINCREA

s 3URPLUSESINACTIV

COMPATIBLEDATABATHYMETRY

s &IVEISSUES(ABIT

,IVING-ARINE2ESAND&ISHING(ARV

 WARRANTTHEGREAT

ACTIVITY

0RIORITY%NDPOINs 6ARIOUSTYPESOFOs 3PECIlCTYPESOFs %FFECTSOFlSHING PREDATOR
PREYDYNs -ECHANISMSOFCO

CAUSINGMORTALITY

s )NFORMATIONONKE

ANDCOMMUNITIESINCLUDINGRATESOFANDFECUNDITY


4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDF

SCIENCEACTIVITY/NLYOFTHEENDPOINTSRATEDASRELEVANTBYTHE'RAYS2EEFMERITCONSIDERATIONFORADECREASE

WITHARECOMMENDEDCHANGEOFnCONCERNEDTHEACQUISITIONOF')3
COMPATIBLEDATAFORTOPOGRAPHAPPARENTSURPLUSESMAYBEARESULTOFRECENTMAPPINGACTIVITIESINANDAROUNDTHESANCTUARYREDUCACQUISITION/VERALLENDPOINTSWARRANTEDSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE'2
	4WENTY
lVEOFTH

HIGHLYRELEVANTTOTHENEEDSOF'RAYS2EEF4ABLE'2
	/FTHESEFOURMANAGEMENTISSUESHADTHE

ENDPOINTS&ISHING(ARVESTING%FFECTS(ABITAT$ELINEATION,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAND7ATER1UA/FTHEENDPOINTSLISTEDIN4ABLE'2
SEVERALMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONASAREASFORTARGETIN

4HEREISAPARTICULARNEEDFORADDITIONALINFORMATIONREGARDINGTHEOCEANOGRAPHICREGIMEAT'RAYS2ENDPOINTSRELATEDTOOCEANOGRAPHICDATAWERERECOMMENDEDFORA
UNITINCREASEINACTIVITY4HREE

ADDRESSINGDATAONCURRENTSTIDESANDTURBIDITYHAVEBROADAPPLICABILITYACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUEWASALSORECOMMENDEDFORACTIVITIESTOSECURESEVERALTYPESOF')3
COMPATIBLEDATA3PECIlCATTEN

BEDIRECTEDTOWARDCRITICALHABITATFORSPECIESOFCONCERNANENDPOINTAPPLICABLETOEIGHTMANAGEM

RECOMMENDEDFORACHANGEOFINCLUDEEFFECTSOFlSHINGHARVESTONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICSANDCONTAMINANTSCAUSINGMORTALITY/NEENDPOINTRECOMMENDEDFORA
UNITINCREASEALSOWARRANTSCOAREAOFINVESTIGATIONDUETOITSBROADAPPLICABILITYACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUES4HEENDPOINTIS)NFORCOMMUNITIESPOPULATIONTRENDSINCLUDINGRATESOFGROWTHMORTALITYANDFECUNDITY

 !)$$."$+0 &$,%$+#-,(+0/3(0'(+$ "')$2$),%.$",**$+#$#"' +&$(+ "0(2(04%,.$ "'* + &$(//1$(+. 46/$$% 0 ,%- .0("1) .+,0$ .$1+#$.)(+$# +#$*-' /(5$#(+!,)#






	      

 !(0 0$)(+$ 0(,+          

,+(+&      
    

(2(+& .(+$$/,1."$/      	   
 

 0$.1 )(04       
   

(/'(+& .2$/0%%$"0/  	      	 	 

()#)(%$(/01.! +"$     
 
 
  
	 

2$+0$/-,+/$     	
  	  

 

$/0,. 0(,+$' !()(0 0(,+     
 		   		 

+#1/0.( )/$/         
 

2OCKYPLATFORMSAT'RAYS2EEF.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARYARECARPETEDWITHAVARIETYOFINVERTEBRATESSUCHASHARDANDSOFTCORALSSPONGESANDHYDROIDS4HESANCTUARYHASACRITICALNEEDFORADDITIONALHABITATDELINEATIONTOCHARACTERIZETHESEHARDBOTTOMHABITATSANDTHESURROUNDINGAREASOFSOFTSEDIMENT
4ABLE'2
(IGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDCHANGESINACTIVITYOFORAT'RAYS2EEF.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

!PPLICABLE-ANAG

%NDPOINTS

2ECOMMENDED

#HANGEIN!CTIVITY

(ABITAT$ELINEATION

:ONING

,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES

7ATER1UALITY

&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS

")/,/')#!, 0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST-ARINEMAMMALS  33 

2%3/52#%3
 )NFORMATIONONKEYSPECIESANDCOMMUNITIES0OPULATIONTRENDSINCLUDINGRATESOFGROWTHMORTALITYANDFECUNDITY  3333

%FFECTSOFFISHINGHARVESTONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICS  3 3

(!26%34).' !SSESSMENTSOFHARVESTEDSTOCKSEGACCESSTO.-&3&-#ANDTRIBALDATA	  3 3

#OMPARISONSOFIMPACTSOFFISHINGANDHARVESTPRESSUREINAREASOFHIGHLOWANDNOACTIVITY  3 3')3COMPATIBLEDATA3OURCEAREASFORCRITICALSPECIES  333 3 ')3COMPATIBLEDATA#RITICALHABITATFORSPECIESOFCONCERN  333 3')3COMPATIBLEDATA3EDIMENTTYPES  3')3COMPATIBLEDATA(ABITATTYPES  3

-!00).'

#!0!"),)4)%3

')3COMPATIBLEDATA3AMPLINGLOCATIONS  3/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST#HLOROPHYLL
A  3 333/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST/XYGEN  3 333/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST.UTRIENTFLUX  3 333/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST#HEMISTRY  3 333 /CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST,IGHTPENETRATION0!2  3 333/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST4URBIDITY  3 333 /CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST3ALINITY  3 333/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST4IDES  3 333

/#%!./'2!0()#

2%')-%

/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST#URRENTS  33333,EVELSANDMECHANISMSOFCONTAMINANTSCAUSINGMORTALITY  3 7!4%215!,)49 ,EVELSANDMECHANISMSOFSUBLETHALSTRESSORS  3)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS)NTENSITY  3)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS3PATIALDISTRIBUTION  3)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS4YPESOFIMPACTS  3 :/.%0%2&/2-!.#%%FFECTIVENESSOFZONINGREGIME  3 3

%NDPOINTSRELATEDTOMANAGEMENTISSUE      


.OTETHATENDPOINTSARELISTEDBYTOPICCATEGORYANDNOTMANAGEMENTISSUE%NDPOINTSMAYRELATETOMORETHANONEMANAGEMENT ISSUE


3ITE!NALYSIS

'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONES.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTU

3TAFFAT'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESCONSIDEREDOFTHEENDPOINTSTOBERELEVANTTOINFORMATIONNE

AVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYAT'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESWASORBELOWTHE0ROGRAMTHELOWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOBEAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHISSITEALTHOUGHOFWERREDUCTIONINACTIVITY4ABLE'&
	4HOSEOFMODERATEANDHIGHRELEVANCEAREWELLADDRESSEDCOMPA

.OMODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINTSWEREJUDGEDTOMERITANINCREASEINACTIVITYGREATERTHAN/NLYRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYMOREATTENTIONWELLBELOWTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEOF!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVIT

.-34HE'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESAPPEARSTOBEDOINGPARTICULARLYWELLADDRESSINGENDPOINTSRELATEDTO7AT

OFTHEENDPOINTSINTHISMANAGEMENTISSUEWARRANTEDNOCHANGEORONLYSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVIEXCEEDSTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEBYANDEQUALS#ORDELL"ANKFORTHEHIGHESTVALUEOFALLTHESANCT

DATAFOLLOW
UPINTERVIEWSWITHSANCTUARYSTAFFINDICATETHATCERTAINWATERQUALITYPARAMETERSINCLUDHARMFULALGALBLOOMSANDAGRICULTURALRUNOFFARENOTADEQUATELYADDRESSED4HEPERCENTAGEFOR%VENT2ESPONSE	ONLYSLIGHTLYEXCEEDTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE(OWEVERTOTHISISSUEWERECONSIDEREDAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDORWARRANTEDDECREASEDACTIVITY4HISSUGGEST

NEARLYADEQUATETOINFORMMANAGEMENTNEEDS&URTHERMORETHEPERCENTAGESFOREIGHTOFTHENINEMTHE&ARALLONESEXCEEDTHECORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGES/VERALL'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESAPPEARSTOBEDOINGVERYWELLATADDRESSINGMANAGEMENTINFORMATION

HIGHESTPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSREQUIRINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINSCIENCEACTIVITYATTHESITEWERE

!' $!#$!&"!#"!&%"!%$$(!&&&'"&$"!%$" !!!&(&*&"$%&"#$&'$!"&$'!$!! #%+!"

		

 



	

 

     
     

   
   ! ! 
      ! !

     	  ! 
   
    !

	 !        
 
     

"&    	    	        

+EY&INDINGSs #OMPAREDTOOTHERSITESTHE'ULFOF

THE&ARALLONES.-3HASAFAIRLYLOWPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSTHATREQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY

s !MONGMANAGEMENTISSUESTHEMOST

APPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDAPPEARSTOBE

 7ATER1UALITYTHOUGHNON
POINTSOURCE

POLLUTIONHARMFULALGALBLOOMSANDAGRICULTURALRUNOFFMAYREQUIREADDITIONALATTENTION

s 3IGNIlCANTSURPLUSESINACTIVITYARE

POSSIBLEINTWOISSUES%VENT2ESPONSEAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION

s 4WOISSUES&ISHING(ARVESTING%FFECTS

AND:ONINGAPPEARTOWARRANTTHE

 GREATESTINCREASEINSCIENTIlCACTIVITY0RIORITY%NDPOINTSs &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASS

STRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES

s &ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESS

OFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIESOFCONCERN
:ONING4ABLE'&
	!LTHOUGHTHESEPERCENTAGESWERESUBSTANTIALLYHIGHERTHANTHOSEFOROTHERISSUESATTHESANCTUARYONLY&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSEXCEEDEDTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY4HIRTEENOFTHEENDPOINTSCONSIDEREDAPPLICABLETOTHE'ULFOFTHE&ARALLONESMAYHAVEASURPLUSINACTIVITY4ABLE'&
	4HESE

ENDPOINTSAREMOSTAPPLICABLETOTWOMANAGEMENTISSUES%VENT2ESPONSEAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION4ABLE'&
	!LTHOUGHSURPLUSESWEREEVIDENTALLOFTHESEWEREALSORATEDTOBEHIGHLYORMODERATELYRELEVANTTOTHESANCTUARYANDRECOMMENDEDDECREASESDIDNOTEXCEEDTWOUNITS4HELEVELOFRELEVANCEOFTHESEENDPOINTSSUGGESTSTHATANYREDIRECTIONOFRESOURCESSHOULDBECAREFULLYCONSIDEREDBEFOREITISDEEMEDAPPROPRIATE4WENTY
TWOPERCENTOFENDPOINTSMAYWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE'&
	.OHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTS

REQUIREDANINCREASEOFACTIVITYOFUNITSBUTWERERECOMMENDEDFORANINCREASEOF4ABLE'&
	4WOMANAGEMENTISSUESHADTHEMOSTAPPLICABLEENDPOINTSINTHISCATEGORY&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND:ONING

/FTHEENDPOINTSLISTEDIN4ABLE'&
ONEGENERALAREAMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTARGETINGFUTURESCIENTIlCRESOURCES

THATBEINGTHEFACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSES!SSOCIATEDENDPOINTSINTHETOPICAREASOF"IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES

AND(ARVESTINGINCLUDESPECIESOFCONCERNANDTARGETEDSPECIES.EARLYALLOFTHESEENDPOINTSWARRANTEDSUBSTANTIALINCREASESIN

ACTIVITYANDAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUES

3ANCTUARYMANAGERSATHE&ARALLONES.ATIONA3ANCTUARYWOULDLIKETABOUTTHEFACTORSCONTCLASSSTRENGTHOFCOMMRECREATIONALLYTARGETEDSUCHASTHESEBLUEROC3EBASTESMYSTINUS	

 !)$$."$+0 &$,%$+#-,(+0/3(0'(+$ "')$2$),%.$",**$+#$#"' +&$(+ "0(2(04%,.$ "'* + &$*$+0(//1$(+1)%,%0'$ . )),+$/ 0 ,%- .0("1) .+,0$ .$1+#$.)(+$# +#$*-' /(5$#(+!,)#






	       

 !(0 0$)(+$ 0(,+   	 	 	 	    	

,+(+&  
    		  
 
 

(2(+& .(+$$/,1."$/  	      	  

 0$.1 )(04    
      

(/'(+& .2$/0%%$"0/  
    	
  
 
 

()#)(%$(/01.! +"$         
 

2$+0$/-,+/$    	 	   
  

$/0,. 0(,+$' !()(0 0(,+        
 
 

+#1/0.( )/$/  
  	  
  
 
 



7DEOH*)+LJKUHOHYDQFHHQGSRLQWVZLWKUHFRPPHQGHGFKDQJHVLQDFWLYLW\RIRUDWWKH*XOIRIWKH)DUDOORQHV1DWLRQD

!PPLICAB

%NDPOINTS

2ECOMMENDED

#HANGEIN!CTIVITY

(ABITAT$ELINEATION

:ONING

,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES

0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST%COLOGICALINDICATORS  33&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES#ONDITIONANDTRENDSOFCRITICALHABITAT  3 3 3 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES-ULTI
SPECIESRELATIONSHIPS  3 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES#OMPETITIONBETWEENKEYSPECIES  333 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES0REDATOR
PREYRELATIONSHIPS  333 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES2ECRUITMENT  333 

")/,/')#!,

2%3/52#%3


)NFORMATIONONKEYSPECIESANDCOMMUNITIES#OMMUNITYDYNAMICSEGTROPHICSTRUCTURESPECIESINTERACTIONS	  33!SSESSMENTSOFHARVESTEDSTOCKSEGACCESSTO.-&3&-#ANDTRIBALDATA	  3 %FFECTSOFFISHINGHARVESTONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICS  3 %FFECTSOFNATURALEVENTSONHARVESTEDORGANISMSANDYIELDS'LOBALWARMING  %FFECTSOFNATURALEVENTSONHARVESTEDORGANISMSANDYIELDS%L.I¶OS  %FFECTSOFNATURALEVENTSONHARVESTEDORGANISMSANDYIELDS3TORMEVENTS  %FFECTSOFNATURALEVENTSONHARVESTEDORGANISMSANDYIELDS#URRENTS  &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES#OMPETITIONBETWEENKEYSPECIES  33 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES0REDATOR
PREYRELATIONSHIPS  33 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES#ONDITIONOFCRITICALHABITAT  333 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES&OODREQUIREMENTS  33 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES2ECRUITMENT  333 &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES'ROWTHREPRODUCTIONANDMORTALITY  33 "Y
CATCHDATA  !GEOFTARGETORGANISMSATTIMEOFHARVEST  3 $ATAONSPATIALANDTEMPORALHABITATCHANGESCAUSEDBYFISHING  3 ,EVELOFEFFORTSPATIALANDTEMPORALDISTRIBUTIONANDDENSITYFORRECREATIONALFISHINGHARVESTING  3 ,EVELOFEFFORTSPATIALANDTEMPORALDISTRIBUTIONANDDENSITYFORCOMMERCIALFISHINGHARVESTING  3 6ESSELTYPESUSEDFORFISHINGANDHARVESTING  

(!26%34).'

#OMPARISONSOFIMPACTSOFFISHINGANDHARVESTPRESSUREINAREASOFHIGHLOWANDNOACTIVITY  3 )DENTIFICATIONOFSOURCESOFINVASIVESPECIES  #HARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFFIC"ALLASTEXCHANGEREQUIREMENTSANDPROTOCOLS  #HARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFFIC0ROXIMITYOFMAJORVESSELTRAFFICTOSENSITIVERESOURCES  

).$5342)!,53%3

#HARACTERIZATIONOFDREDGEANDFILLACTIVITIES)MPACTONLOCALIZEDFLOWDYNAMICS  

7),$,)&%

$)3452"!.#% 4HREATASSESSMENTFORSOURCESOFWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE2ANGEOFINFLUENCEFORPOTENTIALLYVULNERABLESPECIES  

%NDPOINTSRELATEDTOMANAGEMENTISSUE    


.OTETHATENDPOINTSARELISTEDBYTOPICCATEGORYANDNOTMANAGEMENTISSUE%NDPOINTSMAYRELATETOMORETHANONEMANAGEMENT ISSUE
3ITE!NALYSIS

(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE

.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

/NEHUNDREDANDTWENTY
EIGHTOFTHEENDPOINTSWERECONSIDEREDTOBERELEVANTTOINFORMATIONNEEDSAT(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE.-3&ORTHESEENDPOINTSTHEAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYWASTHEHIGHESTINTHE0ROGRAMANDABOVETHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4ABLE	.OLOWORMODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINTSHADARECOMMENDEDREDUCTIONINACTIVITY4ABLE()
	3LIGHTINCREASESINACTIVITYHOWEVERWERERECOMMENDEDFOROFTHEENDPOINTSOFLOWRELEVANCE4HIRTYPERCENTOFTHEMODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINTSWERERECOMMENDEDFORASUBSTANTIALINCREASEINACTIVITY3EVENTY
ONEPERCENTOFTHEHIGH

RELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOWARRANTASUBSTANTIALINCREASEINATTENTION4HISPERCENTAGEISTHEHIGHESTFORANINDIVIDUALSITEANDISSUBSTANTIALLYHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEOF4ABLE	!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIESAT(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE.-34HE(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE.-3APPEARSTOREQUIRESUBSTANTIALLYMOREACTIVITYTOADDRESSALLMANAGEMENTISSUES&ORALLISSUESTHEPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSWARRANTINGNOCHANGEORONLYSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITY4ABLE()
	AREBELOWCORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGES4ABLE	WITHMOSTFALLINGSUBSTANTIALLYBELOW4HEISSUESTHATAPPEARTOBEBESTADDRESSEDATTHESITE(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAND)NDUSTRIAL5SESHAVEAVERAGESTHATAREONLYSLIGHTLYBELOW0ROGRAMAVERAGES!TTHISSANCTUARY:ONINGAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONHAVETHEHIGHESTPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSREQUIRINGANINCREASEOFOR

UNITS4ABLE()
	&IVEADDITIONALISSUESIE,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES7ATER1UALITY&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE

AND%VENT2ESPONSE	SUGGESTPARTICULARNEEDFORSCIENCEACTIVITY&ORALLSEVENOFTHESETHEPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSREQUIRING

SUBSTANTIALINCREASESINATTENTIONARENEARLYTWICETHECORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGE)NALLBUTONECASEIE7ATER1UALITY	THEPERCENTAGESARETHEHIGHESTOFALLSANCTUARIES

!#)"&#%&#($#%$#('$#'&&!*#(((+#'!#')"% !+(#$(

&$""###(*(,($&'($%&()!&#$(&)#&!##"%'-#$!



 	

 


		

 

 	




     
     
   

      # #      
 # #    #

       #        #    

	 #     
  
 #    
 	 
    

$(!        
    
 
 	 
   	
 



+EY&INDINGSs /VERTWO
THIRDS

ENDPOINTSINTHE(UMPBACK7HASUBSTANTIALINCR

s !LLMANAGEMEN REQUIRESUBSTAN

ACTIVITY

s .OSURPLUSESINs 3EVENISSUES:

2ESOURCES7AT(ARVEST%FFECTS%VENT2ESPONSE2EHABILITATIONS

 GREATESTINCREAS0RIORITY%NDPOs &ACTORSCONTROLL

YEARCLASSESFO

s )NFORMATIONONK

COMMUNITIES

s 0ERTINENTINFORM

SPECIALINTEREST

s ')3COMPATIBLE


4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDF

SCIENCEACTIVITY!LLENDPOINTSRELEVANTTOTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSOF(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMPBACK7HALE.-3AREADDRESSEDORWERERECOMMENDEDFORINCREASEDACTIVITY.OSURPLUSESWEREIDENTIlEDTABLE()
	3EVENTYENDPOINTSWARRANTEDSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE()
	&ORHIGHRELEVANCEERECOMMENDEDFORANINCREASEOFORUNITS4ABLE()
	THEHIGHESTNUMBEROFALLSITES4HESEAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESHOWEVERTWOMANAGEMENTISSUESHAVETHEMOSTAPPLICABLEAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATION%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE()
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENBOTHNUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE-OSTOFTHETENENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORA
UNITINCREASE

SPECIlCTOPICS!LLENDPOINTSRELATEDTOFACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIESI

COMMUNITIESAND')3
COMPATIBLEDATASHOULDBECONSIDEREDPRIORITIESBECAUSETHEYAREBROADLYAPISSUES&INALLYSIXENDPOINTSRELATINGTOINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTERESTWEREIDENTIlEDASINACTIVITY

 )##.!#+0%#,$#+"-,'+0/3'0&'+#!&)#2#),$.#!,**#+"#"!&+%#'+!0'2'04$,.#!&*+%#'+0''+/)+"/1*- !(&)#0,$-.0'!1).+,0#.#1+"#.)'+#"+"#*-&/'5#"'+






	      

 '00#)'+#0',+     	 
    

,+'+%          

'2'+%.'+##/,1.!#/     	     

0#.1)'04      
   		 

'/&'+%.2#/0$$#!0/    
  
	    

')")'$#'/01. +!#     
 
    

2#+0#/-,+/#     
  	   

#/0,.0',+#& ')'00',+       
   

+"1/0.')/#/          

$URINGTHEIRWINTERMIGRATIONHUMPBACKWHALESFREQUENTTHEWATERSOFTHE(AWAIIAN)SLANDS(UMBACK7HALE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY-OREINFORMATIONISNEEDEDTOUNDERSTANDHOWTHISSPECIESRESPONDSTOANDISIMPACTEDBYVARIOUSTYPESOFDISTURBANCE
$*+5.201;.5.?*7,..7-9827=<@2=1;.,866.7-.-,1*70.<27*,=2?2=B8/8;27=1.*@*22*7<5*7-<>69+*,4'1*5*;27.#*7,=>*;B



! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

!"!$

 # !! 

 !"

 .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<= 8=.7=2*527?*<2?.<9.,2.<  3 3 .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=8727-20.78><<9.,2.<  3 3*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<7-2,*=8;<8/91B<285802,*5<=;.<<.0+286*;4.;<+5.*,1270  3 3 3 .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=.B<=87.<9.,2.<.0*9.A9;.-*=8;<,;2=2,*51.;+2?8;.<  3  .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=,85802,*527-2,*=8;<  333  .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=#9.,2.<8/787,87<>69=2?.27=.;.<=.0=8>;2<6<,2.7=2/2,  3 3 .;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<==1.;<9.,2*55B9;8=.,=.-<9.,2.<27=.;7*=287*57*=287*558,*5  3 3*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<87-2=287*7-=;.7-<8/,;2=2,*51*+2=*=  333 33*,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<>5=2<9.,2.<;.5*=287<129<  3 33 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<869.=2=287+.=@..74.B<9.,2.<  333 33 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.< ;.-*=8;9;.B;.5*=287<129<  333 33 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<*+2=*=><.*=?*;28><52/.<=*0.<  333 33 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<88-;.:>2;.6.7=<  333 33 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<".,;>2=6.7=  333 33 7/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.< 89>5*=287=;.7-<27,5>-270;*=.<8/0;8@=168;=*52=B*7-/.,>7-2=B  333337/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<7,2-.7,.8/-./8;62=2.<  3 3 37/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<#9.,2.<D<.*<87*5*7-<9*=2*58,,>;;.7,.-2<=;2+>=287*7-*+>7-*7,.  333337/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<*+2=*=/2-.52=B<=;.70=18/*<<8,2*=287<+.=@..7<9.,2.<*7-1*+2=*=<  33 3 7/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.< 89>5*=287-B7*62,<27,5>-270<9.,2.<*7-989>5*=2875.?.50.7.=2,<52/.12<=8;B*7--2<=;2+>=287  333337/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<866>72=B-B7*62,<.0=;8912,<=;>,=>;.<9.,2.<27=.;*,=287<  33333 



"#%"#

7/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<7,2-.7,.8/-2<.*<.  3 3 3274*0.<+.=@..7=1.,*><.<8/.?.7=<  .?.5898;;.?2<.*7-?*52-*=.*99;89;2*=..,85802,*568-.5<=89;.-2,=.?.7=<  2=20*=287*5=.;7*=2?.<  -.7=2/2,*=2878/269*,=<*=*99;89;2*=.<,*5.<  ?.7=9*=1=;*,4270*7-2-.7=2/2,*=2878/524.5B,87<.:>.7,.<  ".5.?*7=*7-*99;89;2*=.-*=*=82-.7=2/B*7-?.;2/B*7.?.7=27<2-.8;*-3*,.7==8=1.<*7,=>*;B  87=270.7,B95*7/8;;.5.?*7=.?.7=<  

&$"# #

"2<4*<<.<<6.7= ;8+*+252=B8//>=>;..?.7=<  

%#$"%## -.7=2/2,*=2878/<8>;,.<8/27?*<2?.<9.,2.<  

  #,869*=2+5.-*=*;2=2,*51*+2=*=/8;<9.,2.<8/,87,.;7  333 33

 $# #,869*=2+5.-*=*#8>;,.*;.*</8;,;2=2,*5<9.,2.<  333 3 

#ONTINUEDONNEXTPAGE	




! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

!"!$

"9(1,*;690,:6-796)()3,767<3(;065(5+*644<50;?9,*6=,9?>0;/05(302,3?9(5.,6-(5;/9676.,50*(5+5(;<9(3+0:;<9)(5*,: $ &  3

 !# ! "9(1,*;690,:6-796)()3,/()0;(;9,*6=,9?>0;/05(302,3?9(5.,6-(5;/9676.,50*(5+5(;<9(3+0:;<9)(5*,:  3

$(3<(;0656-:(5*;<(9?9,:6<9*,:  ::,::4,5;6-(7796790(;,;,*/5636.0,:-699,:;69(;0659,/()030;(;06505;/,-6336>05.*(;,.690,:0636.0*(3*644<50;0,: 
 ::,::4,5;6-(7796790(;,;,*/5636.0,:-699,:;69(;0659,/()030;(;06505;/,-6336>05.*(;,.690,:,?:7,*0,: 
 

 !" "

::,::4,5;6-(7796790(;,;,*/5636.0,:-699,:;69(;0659,/()030;(;06505;/,-6336>05.*(;,.690,:06.,6*/,40*(3796*,::,:


 

!6*06,*65640*,--,*;:6->(;,98<(30;?65*644,9*0(3(5+9,*9,(;065(3<:,:(5+796-0;: 
 3<4(5/,(3;/04730*(;065:6-7669>(;,98<(30;?,.047(*;:6-(5(3.(,)3664 
 3,=,3:(5+4,*/(50:4:6-:<)3,;/(3:;9,::69: 
 3,=,3:(5+4,*/(50:4:6-*65;(405(5;:*(<:05.469;(30;? 
 3",4769(3*/(5.,:053,=,3:6-7(;/6.,5:(5+7(;/6.,50*05+0*(;69:>0;/05,(*/*(:;69.(50:4: 
 3",4769(3*/(5.,:053,=,3:6-7(;/6.,5:(5+7(;/6.,50*05+0*(;69:>0;/050636.0*(3:(473,: 
 3",4769(3*/(5.,:053,=,3:6-7(;/6.,5:(5+7(;/6.,50*05+0*(;69:>0;/05%(;,9*63<45 
 35*0+,5;(3*65;(405(5;:-964=,::,3:4,9*/(5;-0:/05.;6<90:4790=(;, 
 3 ",4769(3(5+:7(;0(3+?5(40*:05-3<,5*05.>(;,98<(30;?57<;:-9645657605;:6<9*,:(5+:,3,*;,+/<4(5(*;0=0;0,: 
 3",4769(3(5+:7(;0(3+?5(40*:05-3<,5*05.>(;,98<(30;?;46:7/,90*+,76:0;065 
 3

%" #"&

",4769(3(5+:7(;0(3+?5(40*:05-3<,5*05.>(;,98<(30;?57<;:-96490=,9:(5+6<;-(33: 
 3!7(;0(3(5+;,4769(3=(90()030;?053,=,3:6->03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,  "/9,(;(::,::4,5;-69:6<9*,:6->03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,9,+0*;6<;*64,:-69=(906<:+0:;<9)(5*,9,.04,:  !<:*,7;0)030;?(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,$,90-0*(;0656-*(<:,(5+,--,*;9,3(;065:/07: 
 !<:*,7;0)030;?(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,*<;,(5+*/9650*:7,*0,:9,:765:,,.),/(=069(39,796+<*;0=,7/?:0636.0*(37/?:0*(3051<9? 
 !<:*,7;0)030;?(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,!,5:69?*(7()030;0,:7/?:0636.0*(3;63,9(5*,:(5+;/9,:/63+: 
 !<:*,7;0)030;?(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,,/(=069(3=(90()030;? 
 "/9,(;(::,::4,5;-69:6<9*,:6->03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*, (5.,6-05-3<,5*,-6976;,5;0(33?=<35,9()3,:7,*0,: 
 

%

!"# 

"/9,(;(::,::4,5;-69:6<9*,:6->03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,+,5;0-0*(;0656-:6<9*,: 
 --,*;0=,5,::6-@6505.9,.04,  3 47(*;:6-<59,:;90*;,+/<4(5(*;0=0;0,:>0;/05@65,+(9,(:5;,5:0;? 
 347(*;:6-<59,:;90*;,+/<4(5(*;0=0;0,:>0;/05@65,+(9,(:!7(;0(3+0:;90)<;065 
 3 '  47(*;:6-<59,:;90*;,+/<4(5(*;0=0;0,:>0;/05@65,+(9,(:"?7,:6-047(*;: 
 3

! !!! "  

 
 	 

6;,;/(;,5+7605;:(9,30:;,+)?;670**(;,.69?(5+56;4(5(.,4,5;0::<,5+7605;:4(?9,3(;,;6469,;/(565,4(5(.,4,5; 0::<,

4ABLE()
CONTINUED	
3ITE!NALYSIS

-ONTEREY"AY.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

/FTHEENDPOINTSNEARLYALL	WEREJUDGEDTOBERELEVANTTOTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSOF-ONTEREY"AY.-34HESEENDPOINTS

HADANAVERAGERECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYOFORHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4ABLE	,OWRELEVANCEENDPOINTSAPPEARTOBEAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHISSITEASALLHADLITTLEORNORECOMMENDEDCHANGEOFACTIVITY4ABLE-"
	#OMPAREDTOOTHERSITESENDPOINTSOFMODERATEANDHIGHRELEVANCEMAYNOTBEASADEQUATELYADDRESSEDAT-ONTEREY"AY&IFTY
SEVENPERCENTOFMODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINTSANDOFHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWERERECOMMENDEDFORLITTLEORNOCHANGEINACTIVITY4ABLE-"
	COMPAREDTOTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGESOFANDRESPECTIVELY4ABLE	!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVITIESAT-ONTEREY"AY.-3&ORALLMANAGEMENTISSUESLEVELSOFRECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYAT-ONTEREY"AY4ABLE-"
	APPEARTOBECLOSETOPROGRAMAVERAGES4ABLE	%VENT2ESPONSEAPPEARSTOBETHEMOSTAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDMANAGEMENTISSUEATTHISSANCTUARYWITHOFENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORLITTLEORNOCHANGEINACTIVITY4HISISSLIGHTLYHIGHERTHANTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE	FORTHATISSUE,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAND7ATER1UALITY0ROTECTIONAREALSORELATIVELYWELLADDRESSED(OWEVERTHE

PERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSREQUIRINGLITTLEORNOCHANGEINACTIVITYFOR(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAND7ATER1UALITY0ROTECTIONARESLIGHTLY

BELOWCORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGES%NDPOINTSASSOCIATEDWITH:ONINGAND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCEAPPEARTOREQUIRETHEGREATESTINCREASEINACTIVITYCOMPAREDTOOTHERISSUESAT-ONTEREY"AYWITHSUBSTANTIALINCREASESRECOMMENDEDFORANDOFENDPOINTSRESPECTIVELY4ABLE-"
	4HESEPERCENTAGESALSOEXCEEDCORRESPONDING0ROGRAMAVERAGES7HILENOTPARTICULARLYNOTEWORTHYWITHRESPECTTOTHESITETHE

PERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSASSOCIATEDWITH)NDUSTRIAL5SESRECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASEEXCEEDSTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEBYPERCENT&OR)NDUSTRIAL5SESTHISISCLOSETOTHEHIGHESTPERCENTAGEFORANINDIVIDUALSANCTUARY

 &# "# %! "! %$! $##' %%%! %#))(% !%#!   %'%)%!#$%!"#%&# !%#& #  "$* !



 
	

 


	 
	

 

 	




     
     
   

    	    
           

    
        
 
 
  	   	

	     
       
    	  


!%    	 
 

  	
     
     

 

+EY&INDINGSs /VERHALFOFHIGH

AT-ONTEREY"AYINCREASESINSCIE

s %VENT2ESPONSE MANAGEMENTISS

ADDRESSEDBYTH

s .OMAJORSURPLUS

WEREEVIDENT

s :ONING&ISHING

$ISTURBANCEANDTOBETHEMANAGTHEGREATESTNEEATTENTION

0RIORITY%NDPOIs &ACTORSCONTROLLIN

CLASSESFORSPEC

s )NFORMATIONONK

COMMUNITIES

s .ATUREANDSOUR

WILDLIFE

s #HARACTERIZATION

POTENTIALCABLER


4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDF

SCIENCEACTIVITY/NLYOFTHERELEVANTENDPOINTSMAYMERITDECREASESINACTIVITYAT-ONTEREY"AY4HEENDPOINT/UTFALLSAND')3
COMPATIBLEDATA3HORELINE&ORTY
THREEPERCENTOFENDPOINTSENDPOINTS	APPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERRESEARCHAC

OFTHESEWERERATEDASHIGHLYRELEVANT/FTHESETWOMANAGEMENTISSUES:ONINGAND&ISHING(ARVENUMBEROFAPPLICABLEENDPOINTS%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE-"
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCE

INCREASESINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITSORTHOSETHATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUES

WERERECOMMENDEDFORANINCREASEINACTIVITYOFTHREEUNITS-OSTOFTHESEWEREASSOCIATEDWITHONISSUES4WOENDPOINTSWEREASSOCIATEDWITHEIGHTOFTHENINEMANAGEMENTISSUESFOUROTHERSWERE

4HESEENDPOINTSARERELATEDTO	FACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIESAND	COMMUNITIES3PECIlCINFORMATIONNEEDSARERELATEDTOSPECIESANDPOPULATIONLEVELGENETICSLIFEH

RECRUITMENTANDHABITATUSECONDITIONANDTRENDS%NDPOINTSASSOCIATEDWITH)NDUSTRIAL5SESPOINANDMONITORHABITATSRELEVANTTOCABLELAYING

 !)$$."$+0 &$,%$+#-,(+0/3(0'(+$ "')$2$),%.$",**$+#$#"' +&$(+ "0(2(04%,.$ "'* + &(//1$(+,+0$.$4 4 0 ,%- .0("1) .+,0$ .$1+#$.)(+$# +#$*-' /(5$#(+!,)#






	       

 !(0 0$)(+$ 0(,+  
     
 
 	 

,+(+&    	  	   	 

(2(+& .(+$$/,1."$/     	
  	  
 

 0$.1 )(04  	  	 	   	 	 

(/'(+& .2$/0%%$"0/   	  	    
 

()#)(%$(/01.! +"$     
 
 
  
 

2$+0$/-,+/$    
 
     

$/0,. 0(,+$' !()(0 0(,+    
 		 
   
 

+#1/0.( )/$/     	 	 	  
 

3QUIDSHRIMPSARDINESANDSALMONAREJUSTAFEWOFTHESTOCKSTHATARElSHEDCOMMERCIALLYIN-ONTEREY"AY.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY)NFORMATIONONTHEIMPACTOFCOMMERCIALANDRECREATIONALHARVESTINGISESSENTIALFOREFFECTIVESANCTUARYMANAGEMENT
$*+4.
201:.4.>*6,..6-8726<;?2<1:.,755.6-.-,1*60.;26*,<2>2<A7/
7:*<76<.:.A*A*<276*4*:26.#*6



! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

!"!$

 # !! 

*,<7:;,76<:744260<1.;=,,.;;7/A.*:,4*;;.;/7:;8.,2.;758.<2<276+.<?..63.A;8.,2.; 
 333 3*,<7:;,76<:744260<1.;=,,.;;7/A.*:,4*;;.;/7:;8.,2.;".,:=2<5.6< 
 333 3 .:<26.6<26/7:5*<27676;8.,2.;7/;8.,2*426<.:.;<#8.,2.;7/676,76;=58<2>.26<.:.;<.0<7=:2;5;,2.6<2/2,  3 *,<7:;,76<:744260<1.;=,,.;;7/A.*:,4*;;.;/7:;8.,2.;76-2<276*6-<:.6-;7/,:2<2,*41*+2<*<  333 3*,<7:;,76<:744260<1.;=,,.;;7/A.*:,4*;;.;/7:;8.,2.; :.-*<7:8:.A:.4*<276;128;  333 3*,<7:;,76<:744260<1.;=,,.;;7/A.*:,4*;;.;/7:;8.,2.;*+2<*<=;.*<>*:27=;42/.;<*0.;  333 36/7:5*<276763.A;8.,2.;*6-,755=62<2.; 78=4*<276-A6*52,;26,4=-260;8.,2.;*6-878=4*<2764.>.40.6.<2,;42/.12;<7:A*6--2;<:2+=<276  3333



"#%"#

6/7:5*<276763.A;8.,2.;*6-,755=62<2.;*+2<*</2-.42<A;<:.60<17/*;;7,2*<276;+.<?..6;8.,2.;*6-1*+2<*<;  33 3 "2;3*;;.;;5.6<76;.9=.6,.;7/.>.6<;26,4=-260,744*<.:*4,76;.9=.6,.; 
 

&$"# # -.6<2/2,*<2767/258*,<;*<*88:78:2*<.;,*4.;  

 :7,.;;.;<1*<,:.*<.*6-,1*60.;.*+.-/7:5;26<1./7447?260,76<.@<;,.*670:*812,.0<=:+2-2<A/47?;.:7;276  3 $$ :.-2,<2>.57-.4;<7=6-.:;<*6--A6*52,;7/1*+2<*<-2;<:2+=<276*6-/*,<7:;<1*<26/4=.6,.2<.0;=+;<:*<.+=:2*40.*:258*,<;,425*<.,1*60.258*,<;  33 A,*<,1-*<* 
 3.>.47/.//7:<;8*<2*4*6-<.587:*4-2;<:2+=<276*6--.6;2<A/7::.,:.*<276*4/2;1260	1*:>.;<260 
 3 3//.,<;7//2;1260	1*:>.;<768:.-*<7:8:.A-A6*52,;  3 3*<*76;8*<2*4*6-<.587:*41*+2<*<,1*60.;,*=;.-+A/2;1260  3 3.>.47/.//7:<;8*<2*4*6-<.587:*4-2;<:2+=<276*6--.6;2<A/7:,755.:,2*4/2;1260	1*:>.;<260  3 3

"&#$

758*:2;76;7/258*,<;7//2;1260*6-1*:>.;<8:.;;=:.26*:.*;7/120147?*6-67*,<2>2<A  3 31*:*,<.:2B*<2767/-:.-0.*6-/244*,<2>2<2.;*<.:2*4<.@<=:.,7587;2<276*6-87:.?*<.:,1.52;<:A  3 $7=:2;58:7/24.,<2>2<2.;47,*<27626<.6;2<A7/<7=:2;<;  1*:*,<.:2B*<276*6-5762<7:2607/*:.*;:.4.>*6<<7,*+4.4*A260#<*<=;7/,*+4.+=:2*4  1*:*,<.:2B*<276*6-5762<7:2607/*:.*;:.4.>*6<<7,*+4.4*A26058*,<;7/,*+4.4*A260<71*+2<*<  1*:*,<.:2B*<276*6-5762<7:2607/*:.*;:.4.>*6<<7,*+4.4*A2606/*=6**6-.82/*=6*  

%#$"%##

1*:*,<.:2B*<276*6-5762<7:2607/*:.*;:.4.>*6<<7,*+4.4*A260#.-25.6<<A8.;  

  #,758*<2+4.-*<*#7=:,.*:.*;/7:,:2<2,*4;8.,2.;  333 3 

 $# #,758*<2+4.-*<*#.-25.6<<A8.;  3



 ')%01+4%2,-'(%6%-0'.7(-0+6)/214%.8%4-%6-10-0%0(%4170(%4)%51*'10')40142%46-'7.%4-06)4)56764-)06*.7:  3 333

)8).5%0(/)',%0-5/51*57&.)6,%.564)55145  3)8).5%0(/)',%0-5/51*'106%/-0%065'%75-0+/146%.-6;  3 )/214%.',%0+)5-0.)8).51*2%6,1+)05%0(2%6,1+)0-'-0(-'%61459-6,-0"%6)4'1.7/0  3 )/214%.',%0+)5-0.)8).51*4).)8%0614+%0-'5%0(/)6%.59-6,-0)%','%5614+%0-5/5  3 " ! # )/214%.%0(52%6-%.(;0%/-'5-0*.7)0'-0+9%6)437%.-6;02765*41/01021-065174')5%0(5).)'6)(,7/%0%'6-8-6-)5  32%6-%.%0(6)/214%.8%4-%&-.-6;-0.)8).51*9-.(.-*)(-5674&%0') 	  ,4)%6%55)55/)06*145174')51*9-.(.-*)(-5674&%0')4)(-'6176'1/)5*148%4-175(-5674&%0')4)+-/)5 	  ,4)%6%55)55/)06*145174')51*9-.(.-*)(-5674&%0')%0+)1*-0*.7)0')*14216)06-%..;87.0)4%&.)52)'-)5 	 

"

 !

 ,4)%6%55)55/)06*145174')51*9-.(.-*)(-5674&%0')()06-*-'%6-101*5174')5 	 /2%'651*704)564-'6)(,7/%0%'6-8-6-)59-6,-0<10)(%4)%52%6-%.(-564-&76-10  3 $ /2%'651*704)564-'6)(,7/%0%'6-8-6-)59-6,-0<10)(%4)%506)05-6;  3

! !!! "     
 

16)6,%6)0(21-065%4).-56)(&;612-''%6)+14;%0(016/%0%+)/)06-557)0(21-065/%;4).%6)61/14)6,%010)/%0%+)/)06 -557)


3ITE!NALYSIS

/LYMPIC#OAST.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

!LLBUTONEOFTHEENDPOINTSWEREJUDGEDTOBERELEVANTTOMANAGEMENTINFORMATIONNEEDSATRECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYWASJUSTABOVETHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEOF4ABLE	,OWREAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDWITHRECOMMENDEDFORLITTLEORNOCHANGEANDONLYONE/CEANOGRAVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST4IDES	RECOMMENDEDFORASUBSTAN-ODERATERELEVANCEENDPOINTSALSOAPPEARTOBEWELLADDRESSED !LLWERERECOMMENDEDFORLITTLE%NDPOINTSOFHIGHRELEVANCEAPPEARTOBELESSADEQUATELYADDRESSED3IXTY
FOURPERCENTHADSUGG

TWOTOTHREEUNITS4ABLE/#
	SUBSTANTIALLYABOVETHE0ROGRAMAVERAGEOF4ABLE	!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIV4HE/LYMPIC#OAST.-3APPEARSTOBEDOINGPARTICULARLYWELLADDRESSINGENDPOINTSRELATEDTO7AT)NDUSTRIAL5SE3EVENTY
THREEPERCENTANDRESPECTIVELYOFENDPOINTSRELATEDTOTHESEMANAGECHANGEORONLYSLIGHTADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITY4ABLE/#
	!LTHOUGHTHESEARETHEHIGHESTAVERAGESTHEYARESIMILARTOTHEIRCORRESPONDINGAVERAGESFORTHE0ROGRAMAND4ABLE	&ORALLOTHERISSUESTHEPERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY0ROGRAMAVERAGESBYAMOUNTSRANGINGFROMTO4ABLE	:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECT2EHABILITATIONHADTHEHIGHESTPERCENTAGES4ABLE/#
	OFALLMANAGEMENTISSUESSUGGESTINGTHAGREATESTATTENTION

!' $!#$!&"!#"!&%"!%$$(!&&* #"%&)&!!&(&*&"$%&"#$&'$!"&$'!$!! #%+!"

	
	

 




	

 

     
    

      ! !       ! 

   
  
  ! 	
   
    

	 !    	 	
  
	 !      

"&   
 
 	
 	
  	   
    

+EY&INDINGSs 3LIGHTLYMORETHANATHIRDOF

ENDPOINTS	AT/#.-3REQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY

s !MONGMANAGEMENTISSUESTHEMOST

APPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDAT/LYMPIC#OASTAPPEARTOBE7ATER1UALITY0ROTECTIONAND)NDUSTRIAL5SES

s /NLYONEENDPOINTTIDEDATA	MAY REPRESENTASURPLUSOFEFFORTs &ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS:ONING

,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAND2ESTORATION2EHABILITATIONAPPEARTOBETHEMANAGEMENTISSUES

 WARRANTINGTHEGREATESTINCREASEIN

ACTIVITY

0RIORITY%NDPOINTSs &ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASS

SUCCESS

s )NFORMATIONONKEYSPECIESAND

COMMUNITIES

s /CEANOGRAPHICDATAINAND 

AROUNDAREASOFCONCERN

s ')3DATARELATEDTOHABITATAND

CRITICALSPECIES
4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY.OSIGNIlCANTSURPLUSESINACTIVITYWEREFOUNDFORANYMANAGEMENTISSUES/NLYONEOFTHEINDIVIDUALENDPOINTSRATEDASRELEVANTBYTHE/LYMPIC#OASTWARRANTEDACONSIDERABLEDECREASEINACTIVITY
	4HISENDPOINTWAS/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDING

TEMPORALVARIATIONINANDAROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST4IDES&IFTY
FOURENDPOINTS	APPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYMORESCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE/#
	3IGNIlCANTLYALLWEREALSOJUDGEDTO

BEHIGHLYRELEVANT4HREEMANAGEMENTISSUES&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS:ONINGAND,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAPPEARTOWARRANTTHE

GREATESTATTENTIONWITHBETWEENANDASSOCIATEDENDPOINTS4ABLE/#
	%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE/#
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESARETHOSE	WITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	THATAREBOTHNUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE3IXENDPOINTSWITHINFOURDIFFERENTTOPICAREASHADRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOF4WOOFTHESEWERERELATEDTOOCEANOGRAPHICDATA&OUROTHERENDPOINTSINTHISAREAWERERECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYONEOFWHICHISASSOCIATEDWITHALLNINEMANAGEMENTISSUES/CEANOGRAPHICDATAINCLUDINGTEMPORALVARIATIONINAND

AROUNDAREASOFCONCERNORPARTICULARINTEREST#URRENTS%NDPOINTSWITHTHEBROADESTAPPLICABILITYACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESWERERELATEDTOFACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESANDINFORMATIONONKEYSPECIESANDCOMMUNITIES!NUMBEROFENDPOINTSALSOPOINTEDTOTHENEEDFOR')3DATARELATEDTOHABITATANDCRITICALSPECIES

!"*%%/#%,1!'%-&%,$.-),104)1(),%!#(*%3%*-&/%#-++%,$%$#(!,'%),!#1)3)15&-/%!#(+!,!'%+%,1)002%),1(%*5+.)#-!01!1!-&.!/1)#2*!/,-1%!/%2,$%/*),%$!,$%+.(!0)6%$),"-*$






	       

!")1!1%*),%!1)-,      	
   	 



 -,),'    	   
  
 


)3),'!/),%%0-2/#%0      	   	 

!1%/2!*)15     		  	   	

)0(),'!/3%01&&%#10     
 
	    

)*$*)&%)012/"!,#%      		 
  	 	

3%,1%0.-,0%     	 	
   	
 


%01-/!1)-,%(!")*)1!1)-,      
   		 


,$201/)!*0%0   	 	 
 	    

4HESANDYBEACHESROINTERTIDALKELPFORESTSWATERSOFTHE/LYMPIC.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCPROVIDEAWIDERANGEOFORATREMENDOUSVARIESPECIES,EARNINGMOTHESANCTUARYSLIVINGRESOURCESISACRITICALNEEDFORSANCTUARYMA


%*+5. 
201;.5.?*7,..7-9827=<@2=1;.,866.7-.-,1*70.<27*,=2?2=B8/
8;*= 5B692,8*<=*=287*5*;27.



! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

!.;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=8727-20.78><<9.,2.<  3 3!.;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=$9.,2.<1*;?.<=.->7-.;<9.,2*5.A.69=287<,>5=>;*5*,=2?2=2.<  3 !.;=27.7=27/8;6*=28787<9.,2.<8/<9.,2*527=.;.<=20;*=8;B+2;-<9.,2.<  3 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<87-2=287*7-=;.7-<8/,;2=2,*51*+2=*=  333 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<!;.-*=8;9;.B;.5*=287<129<  333 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<*+2=*=><.*=?*;28><52/.<=*0.<  333 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<88-;.:>2;.6.7=<  333 *,=8;<,87=;855270=1.<>,,.<<8/B.*;,5*<<.</8;<9.,2.<#.,;>2=6.7=  333 7/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<!89>5*=287=;.7-<27,5>-270;*=.<8/0;8@=168;=*52=B*7-/.,>7-2=B  3 337/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<866>72=B-B7*62,<.0=;8912,<=;>,=>;.<9.,2.<27=.;*,=287<  3 337/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<!89>5*=287-B7*62,<27,5>-270<9.,2.<*7-989>5*=2875.?.50.7.=2,<52/.12<=8;B*7--2<=;2+>=287  3 337/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<*+2=*=/2-.52=B<=;.70=18/*<<8,2*=287<+.=@..7<9.,2.<*7-1*+2=*=<  33 

  

#$ &#$

7/8;6*=287874.B<9.,2.<*7-,866>72=2.<$9.,2.<D<.*<87*5*7-<9*=2*58,,>;;.7,.-2<=;2+>=287*7-*+>7-*7,.  3 332=20*=287*5=.;7*=2?.<  -.7=2/2,*=2878/269*,=<*=*99;89;2*=.<,*5.<  ?.7=9*=1=;*,4270*7-2-.7=2/2,*=2878/524.5B,87<.:>.7,.<  

'%#$! $

#2<4*<<.<<6.7=!;8+*+252=B8//>=>;..?.7=<  !;8,.<<.<=1*=,;.*=.*7-,1*70.<.*+.-/8;6<27=1./8558@270,87=.A=< ,.*780;*912,.0=>;+2-2=B/58@<.;8<287  3$.-26.7=,1*;*,=.;2C*=287@2=127*;.*<8/,87,.;7  3!;.-2,=2?.68-.5<=8>7-.;<=*7--B7*62,<8/1*+2=*=-2<=;2+>=287*7-/*,=8;<=1*=27/5>.7,.2=.0<>+<=;*=.+>;2*50.*;269*,=<,526*=.,1*70.269*,=<  33 

%%

.,1*72<=2,5274*0.<*68700.85802,+285802,8,.*780;*912,*7-*=68<91.;2,9;8,.<<.<*<=1.B27/5>.7,.1*+2=*=  333 *,=8;<,87=;855270B.*;,5*<<<=;.70=18/=*;0.=.-<9.,2.<87-2=2878/,;2=2,*51*+2=*= 
 333 869*;2<87<8/269*,=<8//2<1270*7-1*;?.<=9;.<<>;.27*;.*<8/120158@*7-78*,=2?2=B 
 3 //.,=<8//2<1270	1*;?.<=879;.-*=8;9;.B-B7*62,<  3 *,=8;<,87=;855270B.*;,5*<<<=;.70=18/=*;0.=.-<9.,2.<!;.-*=8;9;.B;.5*=287<129<  33 *,=8;<,87=;855270B.*;,5*<<<=;.70=18/=*;0.=.-<9.,2.<88-;.:>2;.6.7=<  33 *,=8;<,87=;855270B.*;,5*<<<=;.70=18/=*;0.=.-<9.,2.<#.,;>2=6.7=  333 B,*=,1-*=*  *=*87<9*=2*5*7-=.698;*51*+2=*=,1*70.<,*><.-+B/2<1270  3 .?.58/.//8;=<9*=2*5*7-=.698;*5-2<=;2+>=287*7--.7<2=B/8;;.,;.*=287*5/2<1270	1*;?.<=270  3 .?.58/.//8;=<9*=2*5*7-=.698;*5-2<=;2+>=287*7--.7<2=B/8;,866.;,2*5/2<1270	1*;?.<=270  3 .*;=B9.<><.-/8;/2<1270*7-1*;?.<=270  

#'$%

2<=;2+>=287*7-*+>7-*7,.8//2<1=*;0.=*7-787=*;0.=*=-2//.;.7=52/.<=*0.<  333 1*;*,=.;2C*=2878/?.<<.5=;*//2,,8><=2,<207*=>;.<8/?.<<.5=;*//2, 
 

&$%#&$$ -.7=2/2,*=2878/<8>;,.<8/27?*<2?.<9.,2.<  

1*;*,=.;2C*=2878/?.<<.5=;*//2,*55*<=.A,1*70.;.:>2;.6.7=<*7-9;8=8,85<  

#ONTINUEDONNEXTPAGE	


! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

!"!$

 # !! 

 !

#+758)<1*4-,)<)#7=:+-):-);.7:+:1<1+)4;8-+1-;  333 3 #+758)<1*4-,)<):1<1+)40)*1<)<.7:;8-+1-;7.+76+-:6  333 33#+758)<1*4-,)<)#-,15-6<<A8-;  3#+758)<1*4-,)<))*1<)<<A8-;  3

 

 $#

#+758)<1*4-,)<)$787/:)80A  3 3+-)67/:)801+,)<)16+4=,16/<-587:)4>):1)<17616)6,):7=6,):-);7.+76+-:67:8):<1+=4):16<-:-;<1/0<8-6-<:)<176 "  3 333+-)67/:)801+,)<)16+4=,16/<-587:)4>):1)<17616)6,):7=6,):-);7.+76+-:67:8):<1+=4):16<-:-;<$=:*1,1<A  3 333 +-)67/:)801+,)<)16+4=,16/<-587:)4>):1)<17616)6,):7=6,):-);7.+76+-:67:8):<1+=4):16<-:-;<047:780A44)  3 333+-)67/:)801+,)<)16+4=,16/<-587:)4>):1)<17616)6,):7=6,):-);7.+76+-:67:8):<1+=4):16<-:-;<=<:1-6<.4=@  3 333+-)67/:)801+,)<)16+4=,16/<-587:)4>):1)<17616)6,):7=6,):-);7.+76+-:67:8):<1+=4):16<-:-;<%8?-4416/  3 333 

" 

"

+-)67/:)801+,)<)16+4=,16/<-587:)4>):1)<17616)6,):7=6,):-);7.+76+-:67:8):<1+=4):16<-:-;<=::-6<;  333333$:)2-+<7:1-;7.8:7*)*4-878=4)<176)6,+755=61<A:-+7>-:A?1<016)413-4A:)6/-7.)6<0:787/-61+)6,6)<=:)4,1;<=:*)6+-; "&"(  33

"#%"# $:)2-+<7:1-;7.8:7*)*4-0)*1<)<:-+7>-:A?1<016)413-4A:)6/-7.)6<0:787/-61+)6,6)<=:)4,1;<=:*)6+-;  33

"#$"$ ;;-;;5-6<7.)88:78:1)<-<-+06747/1-;.7::-;<7:)<176:-0)*141<)<17616<0-.7447?16/+)<-/7:1-;1747/1+)4+755=61<1-;  

'$"!%$( #7+17-+76751+-..-+<;7.?)<-:9=)41<A76+755-:+1)4)6,:-+:-)<176)4=;-;)6,8:7.1<;  3

#=;+-8<1*141<A)6,:-;876;-7.;8-+1-;7.+76+-:6<7?14,41.-,1;<=:*)6+-&-:1.1+)<1767.+)=;-)6,-..-+<:-4)<176;018;  3 #=;+-8<1*141<A)6,:-;876;-7.;8-+1-;7.+76+-:6<7?14,41.-,1;<=:*)6+-+=<-)6,+0:761+;8-+1-;:-;876;--/*-0)>17:)4:-8:7,=+<1>-80A;1747/1+)480A;1+)4162=:A  3 ' #$%"$0:-)<);;-;;5-6<.7:;7=:+-;7.?14,41.-,1;<=:*)6+-,-6<1.1+)<1767.;7=:+-;  3 

! !!! "    

  

7<-<0)<-6,8716<;):-41;<-,*A<781++)<-/7:A)6,67<5)6)/-5-6<1;;=-6,8716<;5)A:-4)<-<757:-<0)676-5)6)/-5-6< 1;;=-

4ABLE/#
CONTINUED	


3ITE!NALYSIS

3TELLWAGEN"ANK.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY

&OR3TELLWAGEN"ANK.-3OFTHEENDPOINTSWERECONSIDEREDRELEVANTTOMANAGEMENTINFORECOMMENDEDCHANGEINACTIVITYFORTHESEWASEQUALTOTHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4ABLE	!LLLOWTOBEAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDATTHISSITEWITHRECOMMENDEDFORLITTLEORNOCHANGE4ABLE3ACTIVITYHOWEVERMAYBEWARRANTEDFOROFTHELOWRELEVANCEENDPOINTS(IGHERRELEVANCEENDADDRESSED(ALFTHOSEOFMODERATERELEVANCEMAYREQUIRESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY4HISISW

OF4ABLE	!MONGTHEHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWERERECOMMENDEDFORCONSIDERABLY0ROGRAMAVERAGE!RETHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTISSUESBEINGAPPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDBYSCIENCEACTIVI.-3!T3TELLWAGEN"ANK.-3)NDUSTRIAL5SESAND7ATER1UALITYAPPEARTOBETHEBESTADDRESSEDMANAGPERCENTAGESOFENDPOINTSREQUIRINGLITTLEORNOADJUSTMENTSINACTIVITY4HESEAREFOLLOWEDCLOSELYBY

#OMPAREDTOTHE0ROGRAM3TELLWAGEN"ANKISDOINGRELATIVELYWELLADDRESSINGTHESEISSUESASWELLACORRESPONDINGPERCENTAGESABOVETHE0ROGRAMAVERAGE4ABLE	:ONINGAND&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSMAYWARRANTGREATERATTENTIONTHANOTHERISSUESAT3TELLWAGEN"

PERCENTAGEOFENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITY4ABLE3"
	(OWEVER

REQUIRINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYFORALLISSUESATTHESANCTUARYARELOWERTHANCORRESPONDIN

!' $!#$!&"!#"!&%"!%$$(!&&&)!!)&!!!&(&*&"$%&"#$&'$!"&$'!$!! #%+!"

	
	

 




	

 

     
     

    
  ! ! 
      ! !

       !      
  !

	 !   
    
 ! 
   	   

"&    
 	     
 
  	   

+EY&INDINGSs !MONGMANAGEMENTISSUESTHEMOST

APPROPRIATELYADDRESSEDAT3TELLWAGEN"ANKAPPEARTOBE)NDUSTRIAL5SES

s 4HEISSUESOF7ATER1UALITYAND

(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAPPEARTOBEWELLADDRESSEDBUTBOTHISSUESMAYHAVESOMESURPLUSACTIVITY

s %NDPOINTSRELATEDTO:ONINGMAY WARRANTTHEGREATESTINCREASEIN

SCIENTIlCEFFORTFOLLOWEDCLOSELYBY,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCES

 &ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSAND7ILDLIFE

$ISTURBANCE

0RIORITY%NDPOINTSs &ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESS

OFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES TARGETSPECIESANDTHOSEOFSPECIALCONCERN	

s /CEANOGRAPHICDATASPECIlCALLY

TIDES

s4OURISMPROlLESs )NFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIAL

INTEREST

s 3USCEPTIBILITYOFSPECIESTO 

DISTURBANCE

s )MPACTSOFHUMANACTIVITIESWITHIN

ZONEDAREAS
4OBESTPROVIDEFORTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSFORMANAGEMENTWHICHENDPOINTSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDFORINCREASEDORDECREASED

SCIENCEACTIVITY3EVENOFTHEENDPOINTSCONSIDEREDAPPLICABLETOTHE3TELLWAGEN"ANKMAYHAVEASURPLUSINACTIVITY4ABLE3"
	4HESEENDPOINTSAPPLIEDPRIMARILYTOTWOISSUES(ABITAT$ELINEATIONAND7ATER1UALITY4ABLE3"
	3URPLUSESWEREIDENTIlEDINTHE

FOLLOWINGAREAS')3
COMPATIBLEDATAINCLUDINGSAMPLINGLOCATIONSSPECIALUSEORMANAGEMENTAREASOUTFALLSTOPOGRAPHYANDBATHYMETRY	SEDIMENTCHARACTERIZATIONWITHINAREASOFCONCERNANDGEOLOGICALCHARACTERIZATION!LLOFTHESEAREASWEREALSO

RATEDTOBEHIGHLYRELEVANTTOTHESANCTUARYANDRECOMMENDEDDECREASESDIDNOTEXCEEDTWOUNITS4HELEVELOFRELEVANCEOFTHESEENDPOINTSSUGGESTSTHATANYREDIRECTIONOFRESOURCESSHOULDBECAREFULLYCONSIDEREDBEFOREITISDEEMEDAPPROPRIATE)TISLIKELY

THATSUCHSURPLUSESRESULTFROMEXTENSIVEEFFORTSOF./!!ANDOTHERAGENCIESCONDUCTINGMAPPINGACTIVITIESANDMONITORINGINANDNEARTHESANCTUARY4HIRTY
THREEPERCENTOFENDPOINTSAPPEARTOWARRANTSUBSTANTIALLYGREATERSCIENCEACTIVITY4ABLE3"
	&ORTHEHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESOFOR4ABLE3"
	FOURMANAGEMENTISSUESAPPEARTOWARRANTTHEGREATESTATTENTION:ONING&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTS,IVING-ARINE2ESOURCESAND7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE%NDPOINTSIN4ABLE3"
THATMAYWARRANTPRIORITYCONSIDERATIONFORTHETARGETINGOFSCIENCERESOURCESARETHOSE	WITHRECOMMENDEDINCREASESINACTIVITYOFUNITS	THATAREBROADLYAPPLICABLEACROSSMANAGEMENTISSUESAND	THATAREBOTHNUMEROUSANDSIMILARINNATURE.INEHIGHRELEVANCEENDPOINTSWERERECOMMENDEDFORACHANGEINACTIVITY4WOWERE

ASSOCIATEDWITHSIXMANAGEMENTISSUES4HESEENDPOINTSWERE	&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES#OMPETITIONBETWEENKEYSPECIESAND	&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES&OODREQUIREMENTS/THER

ENDPOINTSTHATHADBROADAPPLICATIONTOMANAGEMENTISSUESWERERELATEDTOOCEANOGRAPHICDATASPECIlCALLYTIDES	ANDRECRUITMENTSUCCESS&INALLYSEVERALGROUPINGSOFENDPOINTSWERERELATEDTOFACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSUCCESSTOURISMPROlLESINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTERESTSUSCEPTIBILITYOFSPECIESTODISTURBANCEANDIMPACTSOFHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS

4HEPRODUCTIVEWATERS3TELLWAGEN"ANK.ATIO3ANCTUARYPROVIDEHABAVARIETYOFSPECIESINENDANGEREDMARINEMANDSEATURTLESSEABIRCOMMERCIALLYIMPORTASTOCKS-ANAGEMENTRESOURCESREQUIRESADINFORMATIONONFACTORSTHESESPECIESINCLUDINREQUIREMENTSANDHUMDISTURBANCE

 !*$$/"$,1 &$-%$,#.-(,104(1'$ "'*$3$*-%/$"-++$,#$#"' ,&$(, "1(3(15%-/$ "'+ , &$+$,1(002$(,1$**4 &$, ,) 1 -%. /1("2* /,-1$ /$2,#$/*(,$# ,#$+.' 0(6$#(,!-*#






	       

 !(1 1$*(,$ 1(-,  
 
  
  
  
 


-,(,&         
 

(3(,& /(,$$0-2/"$0   
  
 
 
   

 1$/2 *(15     

    	 

(0'(,& /3$01%%$"10  
 
  	   
 
 

(*#*(%$(012/! ,"$    
 
  
  
 

3$,1$0.-,0$     	     

$01-/ 1(-,$' !(*(1 1(-,      
   
 


,#201/( *0$0   	  
 	   	


#()3,"0./9,3,=(5*,,5+7605;:>0;/9,*644,5+,+*/(5.,:05(*;0=0;@6-69(;";,33>(.,5(52(;065(3(90



! 




!#!$

!!!




#
 " 

(*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:647,;0;065),;>,,52,@:7,*0,:  333 (*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:66+9,8<09,4,5;:  333  ,9;05,5;05-694(;06565:7,*0,:6-:7,*0(305;,9,:;,@:;65,:7,*0,:,.(7,?79,+(;69:*90;0*(3/,9)0=69,:  3  ,9;05,5;05-694(;06565:7,*0,:6-:7,*0(305;,9,:;*636.0*(305+0*(;69:  33 ,9;05,5;05-694(;06565:7,*0,:6-:7,*0(305;,9,:;"7,*0,:6-565*65:<47;0=,05;,9,:;,.;6<90:4:*0,5;0-0*  3  ,9;05,5;05-694(;06565:7,*0,:6-:7,*0(305;,9,:;;/,9:7,*0(33@796;,*;,+:7,*0,:05;,95(;065(35(;065(336*(3  3 



!"$!"

(*;69:*65;963305.;/,:<**,::6-@,(9*3(::,:-69:7,*0,:!,*9<0;4,5;  333 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:66+9,8<09,4,5;:  33 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:!,*9<0;4,5;  333 ,=,36-,--69;:7(;0(3(5+;,4769(3+0:;90)<;065(5++,5:0;@-699,*9,(;065(3-0:/05.	/(9=,:;05.  3 ::,::4,5;:6-/(9=,:;,+:;6*2:,.(**,::;6"(5+;90)(3+(;(  3 --,*;:6--0:/05.	/(9=,:;6579,+(;6979,@+@5(40*:  3 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:647,;0;065),;>,,52,@:7,*0,:  33 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,: 9,+(;6979,@9,3(;065:/07:  33 (*;69:*65;963305.@,(9*3(:::;9,5.;/6-;(9.,;,+:7,*0,:96>;/9,796+<*;065(5+469;(30;@  3 3 .,6-;(9.,;69.(50:4:(;;04,6-/(9=,:;  3 

!%"#

,=,36-,--69;:7(;0(3(5+;,4769(3+0:;90)<;065(5++,5:0;@-69*644,9*0(3-0:/05.	/(9=,:;05.  3 #6<90:4796-03,*;0=0;0,:6-=,5+69:  #6<90:4796-03,*;0=0;0,:36*(;06505;,5:0;@6-;6<90:;:  #6<90:4796-03, 96?040;@6-:(5*;<(9@9,:6<9*,:;6767<3(;,+(9,(:  

$"#!$""

/(9(*;,90A(;0656-=,::,3;9(--0**6<:;0*:0.5(;<9,:6-=,::,3;9(--0*  

 

 #" "*647(;0)3,+(;("6<9*,(9,(:-69*90;0*(3:7,*0,:  333 

!  *,(56.9(7/0*+(;(05*3<+05.;,4769(3=(90(;06505(5+(96<5+(9,(:6-*65*,95697(9;0*<3(905;,9,:;$7>,3305.  3 3

! *,(56.9(7/0*+(;(05*3<+05.;,4769(3=(90(;06505(5+(96<5+(9,(:6-*65*,95697(9;0*<3(905;,9,:;#0+,:  3 3

"<:*,7;0)030;@(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,%,90-0*(;0656-*(<:,(5+,--,*;9,3(;065:/07:  "<:*,7;0)030;@(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,*<;,(5+*/9650*:7,*0,:9,:765:,,.),/(=069(39,796+<*;0=,7/@:0636.0*(37/@:0*(3051<9@  "<:*,7;0)030;@(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,",5:69@*(7()030;0,:7/@:0636.0*(3;63,9(5*,:(5+;/9,:/63+:  "<:*,7;0)030;@(5+9,:765:,6-:7,*0,:6-*65*,95;6>03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,,/(=069(3=(90()030;@  

&

"#$!

#/9,(;(::,::4,5;-69:6<9*,:6->03+30-,+0:;<9)(5*,!(5.,6-05-3<,5*,-6976;,5;0(33@=<35,9()3,:7,*0,:  47(*;:6-<59,:;90*;,+/<4(5(*;0=0;0,:>0;/05A65,+(9,(:5;,5:0;@  3

' !! 47(*;:6-<59,:;90*;,+/<4(5(*;0=0;0,:>0;/05A65,+(9,(:"7(;0(3+0:;90)<;065  3

47(*;:6-<59,:;90*;,+/<4(5(*;0=0;0,:>0;/05A65,+(9,(:#@7,:6-047(*;:  3

! !!! "  
 

 

6;,;/(;,5+7605;:(9,30:;,+)@;670**(;,.69@(5+56;4(5(.,4,5;0::<,5+7605;:4(@9,3(;,;6469,;/(565,4(5(.,4,5; 0::<,
.EEDS$IRECTIONAND4ARGETS

0ROGRAM)NFORMATION.EEDS/FTHEENDPOINTSIDENTIlEDDURINGTHEWORKSHOPTHATPRECEDEDTHISEVALUATIONWERERECOGNIZEDASREQUIRINGSUBSTANTIALLY

MOREATTENTIONBYATLEASTONESITE!COMPLETELISTOFTHESEENDPOINTSCANBEFOUNDIN!PPENDIX4WELVEENDPOINTSWEREIDENTIlEDBYATLEASTEIGHTOFTHEELEVENPARTICIPATINGSITESASREQUIRINGSUBSTANTIALINCREASESSUGGESTINGAPARTICULARNEEDTO

ADDRESSTHESEENDPOINTS4HEYARE

s "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES#OMPETITIONBETWEENKEYSPECIESs "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES0REDATOR
PREYRELATIONSHIPSs "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES2ECRUITMENTs "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST%COLOGICALINDICATORSs (ARVESTING$ATAONSPATIALANDTEMPORALHABITATCHANGESCAUSEDBYlSHINGs (ARVESTING%FFECTSOFlSHINGHARVESTONPREDATOR
PREYDYNAMICSs (ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES#OMPETITIONBETWEENSPECIESs (ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES'ROWTHREPRODUCTIONANDMORTALITYs (ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIES2ECRUITMENTs (ARVESTING,EVELOFEFFORTSPATIALANDTEMPORALDISTRIBUTIONANDDENSITYFORCOMMERCIALlSHINGHARVESTINGs )NDUSTRIAL5SES)DENTIlCATIONOFSOURCESOFINVASIVESPECIESs -APPING#APABILITIES')3COMPATIBLEDATA3OURCEAREASFORCRITICALSPECIES

)NDIVIDUALSITEANALYSESDEMONSTRATETHECONSIDERABLEVARIATIONININFORMATIONNEEDSTHROUGHOUTTHE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY0ROGRAM.EVERTHELESS4ABLESUMMARIZESTHESITEANALYSESANDSHOWSTHENEAR
CONSENSUSOPINIONOFTHENEEDFORRESEARCHON:ONINGAND&ISHING(ARVEST%FFECTSINTHEMARINESANCTUARIES$ATAFROMALMOSTALLSITESSUBSTANTIATETHESENEEDS7ATER1UALITY

AND)NDUSTRIAL5SESARETHEMANAGEMENTISSUESTHATREQUIRETHELEASTADDITIONALACTIVITY0OTENTIALSURPLUSESINACTIVITYMAYEXIST

AMONGFOUROFTHEISSUESATCERTAINSITES

4WELVEOFTHEENDPOINTSWEREJATLEASTEIGHTOFMARINESANCTUARTOREQUIRESUBSTAINCREASESINSCIEEFFORT-OSTRELAFACTORSAFFECTINGSURVIVALOFKEYSPORTHEEFFECTSOF)NVASIVESPECIESLIKET5NDARIAPINNATIlDA	R-ONTEREY"AYPOSEATHREATTOTHERESOURCETHENATIONALMARINESA-ANAGEMENTATAMAJSANCTUARIESDEMONSTRFORADDITIONALINFORMASOURCESOFINVASIVES


5BCMF 4VNNBSZPGJOEJWJEVBMTJUFBTTFTTNFOUT
JOEJDBUJOHNBOBHFNFOUJTTVFTUIBUB

BEESFTTFECZUIFTJUFT	

3

UIPTFSFRVJSJOHUIFHSFBUFTUJODSFBTFJOBUUFOUJPO	

TVCTUBOUJBMJODSFBTFTJOBUUFOUJPO
CVUTFDPOEBSZUPPUIFST	

P

BOEUIPTFGPS

CFBTVSQMVTJOBDUJWJUZ	o


.BOBHFNFOU*TTVF

"UUSJCVUFTBOE

4JHOJGJDBOU3FTPVSDFT .BSJOF 4BODUVBSZ

)BCJUBU%FMJOFBUJPO

;POJOH

-JWJOH.BSJOF3FTPVSDFT

8BUFS2VBMJUZ

'JTIJOH)BSWFTU&GGFDUT

8JMEMJGF%JTUVSCBODF

0$ O O

3 O 

$#

O

3

O

('

O

3

O 

8FTU$PBTU .# O OO

$*

3

P

3 OP 

.BSJOF.BNNBMT 4# o O P

3o P P

)* OO O 

'#

3

O

3 

'( OO

', o O O o O 3 

$PSBM3FTPVSDFT (3 O O OOO

*ODSFBTF	

OPS

P
      

#FTU"EESFTTFE	

3
   

4VSQMVT	o
   
#ORAL2EEF)NFORMATION.EEDS!NUMBEROFOTHERENDPOINTSCONSISTENTLYAPPEAREDAMONGSITESWITHSIMILARATTRIBUTESDEMONSTRATINGUNIQUENEEDSDICTATEDBYTHENATUREOFTHERESOURCESPROTECTED)NADDITIONTOTHENEEDSLISTEDABOVEENDPOINTSWITHSUGGESTEDSUBSTANTIALINCREASESIN

ACTIVITYWEREIDENTIlEDATFOUROFTHElVESITESCONTAININGCORALREEFSORCORALHABITATS

s "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES(ABITATUSEATVARIOUSLIFESTAGESs "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST+EYSTONESPECIESEGAPEXPREDATORSCRITICAL

HERBIVORES	

s %VENT2ESPONSE,INKAGESBETWEENCAUSESOFEVENTSs %VENT2ESPONSE2ISKASSESSMENT0ROBABILITYOFFUTUREEVENTSs 7ATER1UALITY)NCIDENTALCONTAMINANTSFROMVESSELSMERCHANTlSHINGTOURISMPRIVATE	s 7ATER1UALITY,EVELSANDMECHANISMSOFCONTAMINANTSCAUSINGMORTALITYs 7ATER1UALITY,EVELSANDMECHANISMSOFSUBLETHALSTRESSORSs 7ATER1UALITY4EMPORALCHANGESINLEVELSOFPATHOGENSANDPATHOGENICINDICATORSWITHIN"IOLOGICALSAMPLESs :ONE0ERFORMANCE%FFECTIVENESSOFZONINGREGIMEs :ONE0ERFORMANCE)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS)NTENSITYs :ONE0ERFORMANCE)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS3PATIALDISTRIBUTIONs :ONE0ERFORMANCE)MPACTSOFUNRESTRICTEDHUMANACTIVITIESWITHINZONEDAREAS4YPESOFIMPACTS

-ARINE-AMMAL)NFORMATION.EEDS&IVEENDPOINTSWITHRECOMMENDEDSUBSTANTIALINCREASESINACTIVITYAPPEAREDPARTICULARLYRELEVANTAMONGSITESTHATPROTECTMARINE

MAMMALS

s "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES0ERTINENTINFORMATIONONSPECIESOFSPECIALINTEREST%COLOGICALINDICATORSs 2ESTORATION6ALUATIONOFSANCTUARYRESOURCESs 7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE3USCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSEOFSPECIESOFCONCERN!CUTEANDCHRONICRESPONSEEGBEHAVIORAL

REPRODUCTIVEPHYSIOLOGICALPHYSICALINJURY	

s 7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE3USCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSEOFSPECIESOFCONCERN6ERIlCATIONOFCAUSE
AND
EFFECTRELATIONSHIPS

s 7ILDLIFE$ISTURBANCE4HREATASSESSMENTFORSOURCESOFWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE2ANGEOFINmUENCEFORPOTENTIALLYVULNERABLESPECIES

!MARINERESERVEINTH+EYS.ATIONAL-ARINEWITHBOUNDARIESCLEARBYVESSELSlSHINGALON3ANCTUARIESSHAREACNEEDFORINFORMATIONOPERFORMANCE#REDIT-C#LELLANAND*AMES.ATIONAL-ARINE&ISHE-IAMI&,	


7EST#OAST)NFORMATION.EEDS&INALLYFORSITESALONGTHEWESTCOASTOFTHE53SIXADDITIONALHIGHPRIORITYENDPOINTSWEREIDENTIlE

SUGGESTINGUNIQUEREGIONALNEEDS

s "IOLOGICAL2ESOURCES&ACTORSCONTROLLINGTHESUCCESSOFYEARCLASSESFORSPECIES#ONDITIONANDs (ARVESTING"Y
CATCHDATAs (ARVESTING#OMPARISONSOFIMPACTSOFlSHINGANDHARVESTPRESSUREINAREASOFHIGHLOWANDNs (ARVESTING&ACTORSCONTROLLINGYEARCLASSSTRENGTHOFTARGETEDSPECIESFOODREQUIREMENTSs (ARVESTING,EVELOFEFFORTSPATIALANDTEMPORALDISTRIBUTIONANDDENSITYFORRECREATIONALlSHINGs )NDUSTRIAL5SES#HARACTERIZATIONOFVESSELTRAFlC"ALLASTEXCHANGEREQUIREMENTSANDPROTOCOLS

2ESULTSFROMTHESANCTUARIESWITHMARINEMAMMALSPECIESNOTEAPARTICULARNEEDFORINFORMATIONONTHESOURCESOFANDSUSCEPTIBILITYANDRESPONSETOWILDLIFEDISTURBANCE4RAWLERSANDOTHERVESSELSHARVESTAVARIETYOFMARINERESOURCESINCLUDINGKELP!TTHEWESTCOASTSANCTUARIESTHEREISAGENERALNEEDTOBETTERUNDERSTANDTHEIMPACTSOFHARVESTINGACTIVITIES
.EXT3TEPS

4HISREPORTUSEDINFORMATIONGATHEREDFROMSCIENCEEXPERTSINANUMBEROFlELDSRELEVANTTOMARINESANCTUARYMANAGEMENTASWELLASINPUTFROMPROFESSIONALSACTIVELYPARTICIPATINGINNATURALRESOURCEPROTECTIONANDMANAGEMENT4HEANALYSISOFDATAFROM

SITE
SPECIlCEVALUATIONSISINTENDEDTOPROVIDEGUIDANCEFORPLANNINGBYSANCTUARYPROGRAMSTAFFANDOTHERINDIVIDUALSANDAGENCIES

CONDUCTINGRESEARCHANDMONITORINGINTHEMARINESANCTUARIES4HECHANGESINACTIVITYRECOMMENDEDINTHISREPORTAREMEANTTOSTIMULATECRITICALREVIEWAMONGPROGRAMSTAFFREGARDINGTHEALLOCATIONOFlNANCIALRESOURCESPERSONNELANDEFFORT2ECOGNITIONOF

THEAREASOFGREATESTNEEDCOMBINEDWITHTHEREDISTRIBUTIONOFASSETSWHEREAPPROPRIATEWILLINCREASEEFlCIENCYANDEFFECTIVENESS

ANDIMPROVEOURABILITYTOPRIORITIZEAMONGTHEMANYANDDIVERSEINFORMATIONNEEDSOFTHE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY0ROGRAM4HENEXTPHASEOFTHEPLANTOSTRENGTHENSCIENCEFORTHEMANAGEMENTOFTHE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARIESWILLINVOLVETHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROGRAMSANDPROJECTSTOADDRESSTHEINFORMATIONNEEDSIDENTIlEDINTHISREPORTSEE&IGURE	4HElNDINGS

PRESENTEDHEREWILLDETERMINEWHATPARTNERSHIPSANDMECHANISMSWILLBEREQUIREDTOACCOMPLISHTHIS)MPLEMENTATIONPLANSWILLBEDEVELOPEDTOPROPOSETHEFOCUSAREASPRIORITYPARTNERSHIPSANDSUGGESTEDMECHANISMSWHICHARELIKELYTOINCLUDEPLANNING

WORKSHOPSANDTARGETEDAGREEMENTS4HISREPORTASWELLASFUTUREPLANSRESULTINGFROMITWILLBEPROVIDEDASSCIENCEGUIDANCEFORVARIOUSOTHERPROGRAMSANDAGENCIES4HE.ATIONAL-ARINE3ANCTUARY0ROGRAMISFREQUENTLYASKEDTOPROVIDESUCHINFORMATIONTOASSISTTHEPLANNINGEFFORTSOFTHESEORGANIZATIONS3OMEUSEITTOIMPROVE2EQUESTSFOR0ROPOSALSISSUEDTOTHESCIENTIlCCOMMUNITY/THERSUSEITTOASSISTAGENCY

SCIENTISTSINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFANNUALWORKPLANS%XAMPLESINCLUDESEVERAL./!!0ROGRAMSSUCHASTHE.ATIONAL#ENTERSFOR#OASTAL/CEAN3CIENCETHE.ATIONAL5NDERSEA2ESEARCH0ROGRAMANDITSASSOCIATED#ENTERSACROSSTHECOUNTRYANDTHE/FlCEOF/CEAN%XPLORATION!NOTHER&EDERALAGENCYLIKELYTOUSETHISINFORMATIONFORINTERNALPLANNINGANDPARTNERSHIPBUILDINGISTHE53

'EOLOGICAL3URVEY4HEREPORTWILLALSOBEUSEDTORESPONDTOADMINISTRATIONAND#ONGRESSIONALQUERIESABOUTPROGRAMINFORMATIONANDFUNDINGNEEDS)DENTIFYINGTHEFUNDINGREQUIREMENTSFORTHEPROJECTSANDPROGRAMSDEVELOPEDDURINGTHE)MPLEMENTATION0HASEWILLBENECESSARYTOGENERATEBOTHINTERNALANDEXTERNALSUPPORTFORTHEWORK











				
			
	

*).2 -/#$.,0 ./$*)/# /$*)'-$) )/0-44./ (#.$)$/$/ (0'/$./ ++-* ..# !$-././ +2./*$)1 )/*-4.$ ) 

/$1$/$ ./. 2. 1 '*+ )+*+0'/ 2$/#" ) -'$)!*-(/$*)*0/-  )/0-- )/)+')) /$1$/ .+-*% /./# 

()" ( )/++'$/$*).*! #+-*% /)*./$)!*-(/$*)(*)"*/# -/# . *)./ +2./*#*'2*-&.#*+/#/$)'0 

.)/0-4- . -#./!!)$)1$/ "0 ./.- +- . )/$)" ($"*1 -)( )/))*)"*1 -)( )/'*-")$5/$*).*-&.#*++-/$$+)/

+-*1$  3+ -/$)+0/*)/# .$ )/$!$$)!*-(/$*))+*$)/.)  ..-4/*- ..+-$*-$/4()" ( )/$..0 .2$/#$)/# /$*)'-$) 

)/0-$ .# ) 3/./ +$./*0. /# $)!*-(/$*)"/# - $)/# !$-.//2*./ +./**)0//# !*''*2$)".. ..( )/*!/# .//0.*!.$ ) $)/# 

/$*)'-$) )/0-$ .#$... ..( )/2$'' 1'0/ 
/#  3/ )//*2#$#0-- )//$1$/$ .- ../#  )+*$)/.$ )/$!$ $)/# 2*-&.#*+)/# 1$'$'$/4*!,0'$/4$)!*-(/$*)/+ -/$)$)"/*/#  )+*$)/.)$/.0/$'$/4$) $.$*)(&$)"/#. ) .$") 

/* '0$/ 


/# *1 -''.//0.*!.$ )/$!$ !!*-/.)&)*2' " /#  3/ )//*2#$#.$ )  !!*-/.- /-" /$)"()" ( )/$..0 .0+'$/$*).$)- . -#)(*)$/*-$)" !!*-/.)"+.$)/# /)$)!*-(/$*))  ..-4/*- ..+-$*-$/4()" ( )/$..0 .

*''*2$)"/# $ ) *-&.#*+/#  )+*$)/.2 - - 1$ 2 4/# $ )  (!*-*).$./ )4)'-$/40( -*0.*1 -'+.2 - 

$ )/$!$ (*)"/#  )+*$)/. / -($) 4- &*0/"-*0+.*-+0-+*. .*!/#$... ..( )/.$($'- )+*$)/.2 - "-*0+ $)/*+$'

/ "*-$ .)0+'$/$*).2 - - (*1 *+$'/ "*-$ ..#*0')*/ *)!0. 2$/#/# ()" ( )/$..0 .0. /*./-0/0- - &*

"-*0+.




	


				
	

)/# !*''*2$)". /$*). )+*$)/.- '$./ $)/*+$'/ "*-$ .# ()" ( )/$..0 .- ' 1)//* # )+*$)/- $)$/ *)/# 

-$"#/4# &(-&# !$-.//#- *'0().!*''*2$)"/#  )+*$)/.- !*-/# .. ..( )/' . *).$ - # )+*$)/.$/+ -/$)./

4*0-.)/0-4)+-*1$ -/$)"!*-/# !*''*2$)"/#- / "*-$ .


/ /# ' 1 '*!*) -)- ' 1) 4*0-.$/ .-$ ./*/#  )+*$)/.	
'*2( $0(#$"#/ /#  3/ )//*2#$#-  )/+')) *-0-- )/.$ )  !!*-/.$ /#*. +-*% /./'*" $)/# .$ ) /. 

- ../#  )+*$)/.$ )/$!$ $)/# 2*-&.#*+	)*/- .. 
.*( 2#/- .. (* -/ '4- .. 2 ''- .. / /# 1$'$'$/4!-*(''.*0- .*!,0'$/4$)!*-(/$*)/+ -/$)$)"/*/#  )+*$)/.)/# 0/$'$/4*!/#$.$)!*-(/$*)$ $.$*)(&$)"	)*/1$'' 
'$($/ 1$'$'$/40/$'$/4(* -/ 1$'$'$/40/$'$/4!0''41$'' 0. !0'

*(( )/.*'0()$.'.*+-*1$ !*-+0-+*. .*!'-$!$/$*)

!PPENDIX
3URVEY&ORM

3URVEYINSTRUMENTUSEDTOOBTAININFORMATIONFROMMARINESANCTUARIESONTHEEXTENTTOWHICHINFORMATIONNEEDSHAVEBEEN

ORAREBEINGMETBYTHESCIENTIlCCOMMUNITY



54*,74",2,;(4*,

:77,49*90;090,8

#9(9,5-45<2,+.,

()09(9/(7(*9

	'5404.


0;04.(704,",8

&! 759,*9054

08/04.(7;,89


&02+20-,089:7)(4*,

;,49",86548,

",8957(9054",/()

4+:8970(2%8,8 

	
		
*,(45.7(6/0*+(9(04*2:+04.9,3657(2;(70(905404(4+(75:4+(7,(85-*54*,74576(790*:2(7049,7,89

:77,498 333333333$0+,8 3 33 333 3%6<,2204. 3 333 3#(20409> 3 333$,36,7(9:7, 3 3333$:7)0+09> 3 333 3330./96,4,97(9054 " 3 333/,30897> 3 333 3:970,492:= 3 333=>.,4 3 333&(;,-57*,8 3 3 33333/25756/>22( 3 333

			,*/(40890*2041(.,8(354..,525.0*)0525.0*5*,(45.7(6/0*(4+(93586/,70*675*,88,8(89/,>04-2:,4*,/()09(9 333 333 7,+0*90;,35+,2895:4+,789(4++>4(30*85-/()09(9+08970):9054(4+-(*95789/(904-2:,4*,09,.8:)897(9,):70(2.,(7036(*98*203(9,*/(4.,036(*98 3 3 333+,490-0*(90545-(49/7565.,40*/()09(98,.8/06<7,*18(790-0*0(27,,-850262(9-573860,78+:368)59953-08/04..,(78*(78 333 3 3,525.0*(2*/(7(*9,70?(905404*2:+04.9,*954083(4++0(607083 3#,+03,49*/(7(*9,70?(9054<09/04(7,(85-*54*,74 333 75*,88,89/(9*7,(9,(4+*/(4.,8,(),+-5738049/,-5225<04.*549,=98

93586/,70*,.67,*0609(9054(93586/,70*+,65809054(078,(,=*/(4.,(93586/,70*25(+04. 3*,(45.7(6/0*,.9:7)0+09>-25<8,758054 3


!!!!""""#!"
" "# !

32(*52 *0*9&2(*

855*27(7.9.7.*6

!7&7*3+23:0*),*

&'.7&7-&5&(7

%32.2,

	.9.2,&5.2* *6


$537*(7.32

.6-.2,&59*67

$.0)0.+*.6785'&2(*


9*27 *64326*

 *6735&7.32 *-&'

2)8675.&0#6*6 






	


!(314&7.'0*)&7&

&7-<1*75< 3 33"343,5&4-< 3 3!-35*0.2* 3 3 .9*56 3 387+&006 3 3!4*(.&086*351&2&,*1*27&5*&6 33 3!&140.2,03(&7.326 3$&7*56-*)6 3 3&2)86*6 3 3&'.7&77<4*6 3!*).1*277<4*6 3






	


"#

;75&(7&'0*1.2*5&06    3 35.7.(&0-&'.7&7+3564*(.*63+(32(*52    333 33333!385(*&5*&6+35(5.7.(&064*(.*6    333 3 3



	
2+351&7.3232/*<64*(.*6&2)(31182.7.*6

!4*(.*6=6*&632&0&2)64&7.&03((855*2(*).675.'87.32&2)&'82)&2(* 33333333&'.7&7+.)*0.7<675*2,7-3+&663(.&7.326'*7:**264*(.*6&2)-&'.7&76 33 3 33480&7.32)<2&1.(6.2(08).2,64*(.*6&2)43480&7.320*9*0,*2*7.(60.+*-.6735<&2)).675.'87.32 3333333331182.7<)<2&1.(6*,7534-.(6758(785*64*(.*6.27*5&(7.326 33333 332(.)*2(*3+).6*&6* 33 33332(.)*2(*3+)*+351.7.*6 33 3333
    ! 
  !

21')51 )/)9%1')

855)17'7-9-7-)6

!7%7)2*12:/)(+)

%&-7%7,%5%'7

	$21-1+


-9-1+%5-1) )6

#527)'7-21

-6,-1+%59)67


#-/(/-*)-6785&%1')

9)17 )63216)

 )6725%7-21 ),%&

1(8675-%/"6)6 



	
 !1*250%7-2121.)<63)'-)6%1('20081-7-)6'217-18)(

238/%7-2175)1(6-1'/8(-1+5%7)62*+52:7,0257%/-7<%1(*)'81(-7< 33333333

%'7256'21752//-1+7,)68'')662*<)%5'/%66)6*2563)'-)6

 )'58-70)17 333 33 322(5)48-5)0)176 333 33 3%&-7%786)%79%5-286/-*)67%+)6 333 33 35)(%72535)<5)/%7-216,-36 333 33 3203)7-7-21&)7:))1.)<63)'-)6 333 33 38/7-63)'-)65)/%7-216,-36 3 33 3321(-7-21%1(75)1(62*'5-7-'%/,%&-7%7 333 333331(-'%72562*3,<6-2/2+-'%/675)66)+&-20%5.)56&/)%',-1+ 33 3333

)57-1)17-1*250%7-212163)'-)62*63)'-%/-17)5)67

)()5%/2567%7))1(%1+)5)(257,5)%7)1)(63)'-)6 3 3%5-1)0%00%/6 33 3-+5%725<&-5(63)'-)6 3 37,)563)'-%//<3527)'7)(63)'-)6-17)51%7-21%/1%7-21%//2'%/ 3 3!3)'-)6,%59)67)(81()563)'-%/);)037-216'8/785%/%'7-9-7-)6 3 33!3)'-)62*121'2168037-9)-17)5)67)+7285-606'-)17-*-' 3 3'2/2+-'%/-1(-'%7256 333 3)<6721)63)'-)6)+%3);35)(%7256'5-7-'%/,)5&-925)6 3 3%&-7%73529-()56)+6)%+5%66)60%1+529)6.)/3'25%/ 333 321-1(-+)128663)'-)6 3 327)17-%/-19%6-9)63)'-)6 3 3



	

43)+73!+1+;'3)+

:77+39)9/;/9/+8

"9'9+4,34<1+*-+

'(/9'9.'7')9

	&43/3-


/;/3-'7/3+!+8

% 749+)9/43

/8./3-'7;+89


%/1*1/,+/89:7('3)+

;+39!+85438+

!+8947'9/43!+.'(

3*:897/'1#8+8 



/897/(:9/43'3*'(:3*'3)+4,,/8.9'7-+9'3*3439'7-+9'9*/,,+7+391/,+89'-+8 333 333425'7/84384,/25')984,,/8./3-'3*.'7;+8957+88:7+/3'7+'84,./-.14<'3*34')9/;/9= 3 3$+88+19=5+8:8+*,47,/8./3-'3*.'7;+89/3- 3+'79=5+8:8+*,47,/8./3-'3*.'7;+89/3- 3+;+14,+,,47985'9/'1'3*9+2547'1*/897/(:9/43'3**+38/9=,47)422+7)/'1,/8./3-.'7;+89/3- 3 3+;+14,+,,47985'9/'1'3*9+2547'1*/897/(:9/43'3**+38/9=,477+)7+'9/43'1,/8./3-.'7;+89/3- 3 3'9'4385'9/'1'3*9+2547'1.'(/9'9).'3-+8)':8+*(=,/8./3- 3 3-+4,9'7-+947-'3/828'99/2+4,.'7;+89 3 3=)'9).*'9' 3')9478)4397411/3-=+'7)1'88897+3-9.4,9'7-+9+*85+)/+8

74<9.7+574*:)9/43'3*2479'1/9= 33 333!+)7:/92+39 333 344*7+6:/7+2+398 33 343*/9/434,)7/9/)'1.'(/9'9 333 37+*'94757+=7+1'9/438./58 33 3425+9/9/43(+9<++30+=85+)/+8 33 3

,,+)984,3'9:7'1+;+39843.'7;+89+*47-'3/828'3*=/+1*8

:77+398 3"9472+;+398 3:77/)'3+8 31/>48 314('1<'72/3- 3

,,+)984,,/8./3-.'7;+894357+*'94757+=*=3'2/)8 3 388+882+3984,.'7;+89+*894)08+-'))+8894"'3*97/('1*'9' 3 3
  !!!!" !!!" 

32(*62*0*:&2(*

966*28(8.:.8.*7

 8&8*3+23;0*),*

&'.8&8-&6&(8

	%32.2,


.:.2,&6.2**7

$638*(8.32

.7-.2,&6:*78


$.0)0.+*.7896'&2(*

:*28*74327*

*7836&8.32*-&'

2)9786.&0"7*7 

		

		!-6*&8&77*771*28+367396(*73+;.0)0.+*).7896'&2(*

)*28.+.(&8.323+7396(*7 3 3&2,*3+.2+09*2(*+36438*28.&00<:902*6&'0*74*(.*7 36*).(8398(31*7+36:&6.397).7896'&2(*6*,.1*7 3

 4&8.&0&2)8*1436&0:&6.&'.0.8<.20*:*073+;.0)0.+*).7896'&2(* 3 3 97(*48.'.0.8<&2)6*74327*3+74*(.*73+(32(*6283;.0)0.+*).7896'&2(*

*-&:.36&0:&6.&'.0.8< 3 *2736<(&4&'.0.8.*74-<7.303,.(&0830*6&2(*7&2)8-6*7-30)7 3(98*&2)(-632.(74*(.*76*74327**,'*-&:.36&06*463)9(8.:*4-<7.303,.(&04-<7.(&0.2/96< 3#*6.+.(&8.323+(&97*&2)*++*(86*0&8.327-.47 3 3

		

	!*1436&0&2)74&8.&0)<2&1.(7.2+09*2(.2,;&8*659&0.8<

24987+6316.:*67&2)398+&007 381374-*6.()*437.8.32 324987+63123243.287396(*7&2)7*0*(8*)-91&2&(8.:.8.*7 3

2(.)*28&0(328&1.2&287+631:*77*071*6(-&28+.7-.2,8396.7146.:&8* 33 3 3!*1436&0(-&2,*7.20*:*073+6*0*:&2836,&2.(7&2)1*8&07;.8-.2

 *28.2&036,&2.717 3$&8*6(30912 3 *).1*287 3*&(-(&7836,&2.717 3

!*1436&0(-&2,*7.20*:*073+4&8-3,*27&2)4&8-3,*2.(.2).(&8367;.8-.2

$&8*6(30912 3.303,.(&07&140*7 3*&(-(&7836,&2.717 3

*:*07&2)1*(-&2.7173+(328&1.2&287(&97.2,1368&0.8< 3*:*07&2)1*(-&2.7173+79'0*8-&0786*77367 3


!!!!""""#!"" "# !

32(*62*0*:&2(*

966*28(8.:.8.*7

 8&8*3+23;0*),*

&'.8&8-&6&(8

%32.2,

	.:.2,&6.2**7


$638*(8.32

.7-.2,&6:*78

$.0)0.+*.7896'&2(*


:*28*74327*

*7836&8.32*-&'

2)9786.&0"7*7 

		

	"#91&2-*&08-.140.(&8.3273+4336;&8*659&0.8=*,.14&(873+&2&0,&*'0331 3 3(.3*(3231.(*++*(873+;&8*659&0.8=32(311*6(.&0&2)6*(6*&8.32&097*7&2)463+.87 3					
-&6&(8*6.>&8.32&2)132.836.2,3+&6*&76*0*:&2883(&'0*0&=.2,

 *).1*288=4*7 3 *).1*28(-*1.786= 32+&92&&2)*4.+&92& 314&(873+(&'0*0&=.2,83-&'.8&8 3 8&8973+(&'0*'96.&0 3

-&6&(8*6.>&8.323+:*77*086&++.(

#*77*086&++.(4&88*627 363<.1.8=3+1&/36:*77*086&++.(837*27.8.:*6*7396(*7 3 3(3978.(7.,2&896*73+:*77*086&++.( 3 3.786.'98.32&2)&'92)&2(*3+:*77*07 3#*77*0(0&77.2+361&8.328=4*59&28.8=74**)0*2,8-8322&,*&,*)6&+82&8.32&0.8= 3&6,38=4*59&28.8=:&09*(0&77.+.(&8.32 3(3231.(73+&08*62&8*7-.46398*7 3&00&78*<(-&2,*6*59.6*1*287&2)46383(307 3

)*28.+.(&8.323+7396(*73+.2:&7.:*74*(.*7 3!396.71463+.0*

6.,.2&2)291'*63+:.7.8367 363<.1.8=3+7&2(89&6=6*7396(*78343490&8*)&6*&7 3(8.:.8.*703(&8.32.28*27.8=3+8396.787 3<4*2).896*7'=8396.787 3(8.:.8.*73+:*2)367 3
#### $!$$$%#!  $
$! "  $%"#

21&(51(/(9$1&(

855(17&7,9,7,(6

7$7(2)12:/('*(

$%,7$7+$5$&7

#21,1*

	,9,1*$5,1((6


"527(&7,21

,6+,1*$59(67

",/'/,)(,6785%$1&(


9(17(63216(

(6725$7,21(+$%

1'8675,$/!6(6 







! $ %+$5$&7(5,=$7,212)'5('*($1'),//$&7,9,7,(6

$7(5,$/7(;785(&20326,7,21$1'325(:$7(5&+(0,675< 3 303$&721/2&$/,=(')/2:'<1$0,&6 3 3(6863(16,212)6(',0(17&217$0,1$176 3 3




,6.$66(660(17

$7$67$7,67,&6217+(2&&855(1&(2)3$67(9(176)25($&+7<3(2)(9(17 3216(48(1&(62)(9(176,1&/8',1*&2//$7(5$/&216(48(1&(6 3855(1767$78675(1'62)&$86$/)$&7256(*9(66(/75$)),&3$77(51667$7862)'5,//,1*$1'352'8&7,213/$7)25065(*,21$/2&&855(1&(2)',6($6(287%5($.6

3

52%$%,/,7<2))8785((9(176 3

217,1*(1&<3/$1)255(/(9$17(9(176 3(/(9$17$1'$335235,$7('$7$72,'(17,)<$1'9(5,)<$1(9(17,16,'(25$'-$&(17727+(6$1&78$5< 39(173$7+75$&.,1*$1','(17,),&$7,212)/,.(/<&216(48(1&(6 3'(17,),&$7,212),03$&76$7$335235,$7(6&$/(6 3,7,*$7,21$/7(51$7,9(6 3(9(/23255(9,6($1'9$/,'$7($335235,$7((&2/2*,&$/02'(/67235(',&7(9(176 3,1.$*(6%(7:((17+(&$86(62)(9(176 3
	
))(&7,9(1(662)=21,1*5(*,0( 3 33 303$&762)815(675,&7('+80$1$&7,9,7,(6:,7+,1=21('$5($6

 <3(62),03$&76 33$7,$/',675,%87,21 317(16,7< 3


	

32')52)0)9%2')

855)27'7-9-7-)6

7%7)3*23:0)(+)

%&-7%7,%5%'7

$32-2+

	-9-2+%5-2))6


#537)'7-32

-6,-2+%59)67

#-0(0-*)-6785&%2')


9)27)64326)

)6735%7-32),%&

2(8675-%0!6)6 





	66)661)273*%445345-%7)7)',2303+-)6*355)6735%7-325),%&-0-7%7-32-27,)*3003:-2+'%7)+35-)6

,;6-'%06758'785) 3-3+)3',)1-'%0453')66)6 3);64)'-)6 3-303+-'%0'31182-7-)6 3

367&)2)*-7%2%0;6-6-2'08(-2+7)1435%07,5)6,30(*35-140)1)27-2+45-1%5;5)6735%7-32%'7-9-7-)6 35-7)5-%73)9%08%7))**)'7-9)2)663*5)6735%7-32%'7-326)+4,;6-'%067%&-0-7;&-3-2(-'%7356 3"%08%7-323*6%2'78%5;5)6385')6 3 33


 5%.)'735-)63*453&%&0)

5)'39)5;:-7,-2%0-/)0;5%2+)3*%27,5343+)2-'

%2(2%785%0(-6785&%2')6 333

 5%.)'735-)63*453&%&0)

		

5)'39)5;:-7,-2%0-/)0;5%2+)

3*%27,5343+)2-'%2(2%785%0(-6785&%2')6 333
!PPENDIX
3URVEY0ARTICIPANTS

,ISTOFEVALUATORSFOREACHNATIONALMARINESANCTUARY

4HEKEYSCIENCECONTACTFOREACHSANCTUARYISEMPHASIZEDBYBOLDANDITALICS

	 
		##   $"" " 
""  '"$( $! "(#   
 ( '""# 	 ! $&$$#"(#  
  % $" # 
""  '"'	#%!

 
 	$ #
$"#

 $"((

 # " %"" %" #

(! #$ #$$' 
!


!1)-%!,,!+

 %23.!23 .1!+

-$/.)-32













 



!#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%2.,/%3)3).-"%36%%-*%82/%#)%2   	 	   !#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%2.-$)3).-!-$31%-$2.)3)#!+(!")3!3      !#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%2..$1%04)1%,%-32  	  !#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%2!")3!342%!35!1).42+)&%23!'%2     !#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%2-$)#!3.12.&/(82).+.')#!+231%22%'").,!1*%12"+%!#()-' 	 !#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%24+3)2/%#)%21%+!3).-2()/2    	 !#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%21%$!3.1/1%81%+!3).-2()/2       !#3.12#.-31.++)-'3(%24##%22.&8%!1#+!22%2&.12/%#)%2%#14)3,%-3    	    -&.1,!3).-.-*%82/%#)%2!-$#.,,4-)3)%2.,,4-)38$8-!,)#2%'31./()#2314#341%2/%#)%2)-3%1!#3).-2   -&.1,!3).-.-*%82/%#)%2!-$#.,,4-)3)%2!")3!3&)$%+)38231%-'3(.&!22.#)!3).-2"%36%%-2/%#)%2!-$(!")3!32    -&.1,!3).-.-*%82/%#)%2!-$#.,,4-)3)%2-#)$%-#%.&$%&.1,)3)%2   -&.1,!3).-.-*%82/%#)%2!-$#.,,4-)3)%2-#)$%-#%.&$)2%!2% -&.1,!3).-.-*%82/%#)%2!-$#.,,4-)3)%2./4+!3).-$8-!,)#2)-#+4$)-'2/%#)%2!-$/./4+!3).-+%5%+'%-%3)#2+)&%()23.18!-$$)231)"43).-    -&.1,!3).-.-*%82/%#)%2!-$#.,,4-)3)%2./4+!3).-31%-$2)-#+4$)-'1!3%2.&'1.63(,.13!+)38!-$&%#4-$)38  -&.1,!3).-.-*%82/%#)%2!-$#.,,4-)3)%2/%#)%292%!2.-!+!-$2/!3)!+.##411%-#%$)231)"43).-!-$!"4-$!-#%  %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23#.+.')#!+)-$)#!3.12      	 %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23%823.-%2/%#)%2%'!/%7/1%$!3.12#1)3)#!+(%1")5.1%2 %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23!1)-%,!,,!+2 %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23)'1!3.18")1$2/%#)%2   %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23.-)-$)'%-.422/%#)%2  	 %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%233(%12/%#)!++8/1.3%#3%$2/%#)%2)-3%1-!3).-!+-!3).-!++.#!+  %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23.3%-3)!+)-5!2)5%2/%#)%2  	 %13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23/%#)%2(!15%23%$4-$%12/%#)!+%7%,/3).-2#4+341!+!#3)5)3)%2  





%13)-%-3)-&.1,!3).-.-2/%#)%2.&2/%#)!+)-3%1%23/%#)%2.&-.-#.-24,/3)5%)-3%1%23%'3.41)2,2#)%-3)&)#   

!PPENDIX
%NDPOINTS2ECOMMENDEDFOR3UBSTANTIAL)NCREASEIN!CTIVITY

,ISTOFALLENDPOINTSRECOMMENDEDFORSUBSTANTIALINCREASEINACTIVITYOR	INATLEASTONENATIONALMARINESANCTUA

3ANCTUARIESAREORGANIZEDINTOCATEGORIESTOALLOWCOMPARISONAMONGSANCTUARIESWITHCOMMONRESOURCESORINGEOGRAPHICP
"3*/&".."-

!&450"45 03"-&4063$

/%10*/54













!







0/5*/(&/$:1-"/'033&-&7"/5&7&/54  &7&-01033&7*4&"/%7"-*%"5&"113013*"5&&$0-0(*$"-.0%&-45013&%*$5&7&/54   	 7&/51"5)53"$,*/("/%*%&/5*'*$"5*0/0'-*,&-:$0/4&26&/$&4   	 %&/5*'*$"5*0/0'*.1"$54"5"113013*"5&4$"-&4       */,"(&4#&58&&/5)&$"64&40'&7&/54    *5*("5*0/"-5&3/"5*7&4   &-&7"/5"/%"113013*"5&%"5"50*%&/5*':"/%7&3*':"/&7&/5*/4*%&03"%+"$&/5505)&4"/$56"3:  	  *4,"44&44.&/5
0/4&26&/$&40'&7&/54*/$-6%*/($0--"5&3"-$0/4&26&/$&4 	   *4,"44&44.&/5
"5"45"5*45*$40/5)&0$$633&/$&0'1"45&7&/54'03&"$)5:1&0'&7&/5   

 

*4,"44&44.&/5
30#"#*-*5:0''6563&&7&/54      	 &0-0(*$"-$)"3"$5&3*;"5*0/*/$-6%*/(5&$50/*4."/%%*"1*3*4.  %&/5*'*$"5*0/0'"/5)3010(&/*$)"#*5"54&(4)*183&$,4"35*'*$*"-3&&'40*-1-"5'03.41*&34%6.14#0550.'*4)*/((&"34$"34  &$)"/*45*$-*/,"(&4".0/((&0-0(*$#*0-0(*$0$&"/0(3"1)*$"/%"5.041)&3*$130$&44&4"45)&:*/'-6&/$&)"#*5"5  3&%*$5*7&.0%&-4506/%&345"/%%:/".*$40')"#*5"5%*453*#65*0/"/%'"$50345)"5*/'-6&/$&*5&(46#453"5?*"-(&"3*.1"$54$-*."5&$)"/(&*.1"$54     30$&44&45)"5$3&"5&"/%$)"/(&4&"#&%'03.4*/5)&'0--08*/($0/5&954
5.041)&3*$&(13&$*1*5"5*0/"5.041)&3*$%&104*5*0/"*34&"&9$)"/(&"5.041)&3*$-0"%*/(  30$&44&45)"5$3&"5&"/%$)"/(&4&"#&%'03.4*/5)&'0--08*/($0/5&954
$&"/0(3"1)*$&(563#*%*5:'-084&304*0/    



&%*.&/5$)"3"$5&3*;"5*0/8*5)*/"3&"40'$0/$&3/  ,*3+8&6,*836,&2.717&88.1*3+-&6:*78 
 
 
 
  
 
 77*771*2873+-&6:*78*)783(/7*,&((*7783"&2)86.'&0)&8& 
 
 
 
 <(&8(-)&8& 
 

 
314&6.73273+.14&(873++.7-.2,&2)-&6:*7846*7796*.2&6*&73+-.,-03;&2)23&(8.:.8<  
 
 
 
  &8&3274&8.&0&2)8*1436&0-&'.8&8(-&2,*7(&97*)'<+.7-.2, 
 



 

 .786.'98.32&2)&'92)&2(*3++.7-8&6,*8&2)2328&6,*8&8).++*6*280.+*78&,*7 
  
 ++*(873++.7-.2,-&6:*783246*)&83646*<)<2&1.(7 
 
 
 
 
 
    ++*(873+2&896&0*:*28732-&6:*78*)36,&2.717&2)<.*0)7966*287 
 
 
 
 ++*(873+2&896&0*:*28732-&6:*78*)36,&2.717&2)<.*0)70.>37 
 
 ++*(873+2&896&0*:*28732-&6:*78*)36,&2.717&2)<.*0)703'&0;&61.2, 
 
 
 ++*(873+2&896&0*:*28732-&6:*78*)36,&2.717&2)<.*0)7966.(&2*7 
 
 ++*(873+2&896&0*:*28732-&6:*78*)36,&2.717&2)<.*0)7"8361*:*287 
 
 &(8367(3286300.2,<*&6(0&77786*2,8-3+8&6,*8*)74*(.*7314*8.8.32'*8;**2/*<74*(.*7 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 &(8367(3286300.2,<*&6(0&77786*2,8-3+8&6,*8*)74*(.*732).8.323+(6.8.(&0-&'.8&8  
 
 
 
 &(8367(3286300.2,<*&6(0&77786*2,8-3+8&6,*8*)74*(.*733)6*59.6*1*287 
 
 
 
  
 &(8367(3286300.2,<*&6(0&77786*2,8-3+8&6,*8*)74*(.*763;8-6*463)9(8.32&2)1368&0.8< 
 
 
 
 
  
 &(8367(3286300.2,<*&6(0&77786*2,8-3+8&6,*8*)74*(.*7 6*)&83646*<6*0&8.327-.47 
 
 
 
 
 
 &(8367(3286300.2,<*&6(0&77786*2,8-3+8&6,*8*)74*(.*7!*(69.81*28 
 
 
 
    *&68<4*797*)+36+.7-.2,&2)-&6:*78.2, 
 *:*03+*++36874&8.&0&2)8*1436&0).786.'98.32&2))*27.8<+36(311*6(.&0+.7-.2,-&6:*78.2, 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 *:*03+*++36874&8.&0&2)8*1436&0).786.'98.32&2))*27.8<+366*(6*&8.32&0+.7-.2,-&6:*78.2, 
 
 
   
 

!$"#

$*77*08<4*797*)+36+.7-.2,&2)-&6:*78.2, 
 
 
 


"2*.&"--",

!&34/"34 /2",

.%0/*.43













!



)"2"$4&2*:"4*/.".%-/.*4/2*.(/'"2&"32&,&6".44/$"#,&,"9*.(-0"$43/'$"#,&,"9*.(4/)"#*4"4  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/.".%-/.*4/2*.(/'"2&"32&,&6".44/$"#,&,"9*.(.'"5."".%&0*'"5."  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/.".%-/.*4/2*.(/'"2&"32&,&6".44/$"#,&,"9*.(&%*-&.4490&3  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/.".%-/.*4/2*.(/'"2&"32&,&6".44/$"#,&,"9*.(4"453/'$"#,4*",  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'%2&%(&".%'*,,"$4*6*4*&3-0"$4/.,/$",*:&%',/7%9."-*$3   )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'%2&%(&".%'*,,"$4*6*4*&3"4&2*",4&8452&$/-0/3*4*/.".%0/2&7"4&2$)&-*3429  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'%2&%(&".%'*,,"$4*6*4*&3&3530&.3*/./'3&%*-&.4$/.4"-*.".43  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'6&33&,42"''*$
$/534*$3*(."452&3/'6&33&,42"''*$    )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'6&33&,42"''*$",,"34&8$)".(&2&15*2&-&.43".%02/4/$/,3     )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'6&33&,42"''*$"2(/490&15".4*496",5&$,"33*'*$"4*/.  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'6&33&,42"''*$*342*#54*/.".%"#5.%".$&/'6&33&,3 )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'6&33&,42"''*$$/./-*$3/'",4&2."4&3)*02/54&3  )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'6&33&,42"''*$2/8*-*49/'-"+/26&33&,42"''*$4/3&.3*4*6&2&3/52$&3    )"2"$4&2*:"4*/./'6&33&,42"''*$ &33&,42"''*$0"44&2.3  %&.4*'*$"4*/./'3/52$&3/'*.6"3*6&30&$*&3        /52*3-02/'*,&
$4*6*4*&3,/$"4*/.*.4&.3*49/'4/52*343    /52*3-02/'*,&
$4*6*4*&3/'6&.%/23  




/52*3-02/'*,&2/8*-*49/'3".$45"292&3/52$&34/0/05,"4&%"2&"3   $/-0"4*#,&%"4"2*4*$",)"#*4"4'/230&$*&3/'$/.$&2.    $/-0"4*#,&%"4""#*4"4490&3  $/-0"4*#,&%"4""-0,*.(,/$"4*/.3 $/-0"4*#,&%"4"&%*-&.4490&3    $/-0"4*#,&%"4")/2&,*.&  $/-0"4*#,&%"4"/52$&"2&"3'/2$2*4*$",30&$*&3      $/-0"4*#,&%"4"/0/(2"0)9  








$/-0"4*#,&%"4"!"4&23)&%3 

$&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34)&.*3429 $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34)-0201)9--"  $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34522&/43  	$&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34*()41&/&42"4*0/
 	 $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34542*&/4-58    $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&3489(&/ $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34"-*/*49 $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34*%&3 $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&3452#*%*49 	 $&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&3417&--*/(   







$&"/0(2"1)*$%"4"*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-6"2*"4*0/*/"/%"205/%"2&"30'$0/$&2/021"24*$5-"2*/4&2&34 "6&'02$&3  
"2*/&".."-

 &340"34 02"-&30

/%10*/43













 





2"+&$402*&30'120#"#-&)"#*4"42&$06&297*4)*/"-*,&-92"/(&0'"/4)2010(&/*$"/%/"452"-%*3452#"/$&3  	 

!

 2"+&$402*&30'120#"#-&1015-"4*0/"/%$0..5/*492&$06&297*4)*/"-*,&-92"/(&0'"/4)2010(&/*$

"/%/"452"-%*3452#"/$&3   	 
33&33.&/40'"112012*"4&4&$)/0-0(*&3'022&3402"4*0/2&)"#*-*4"4*0/*/4)&'0--07*/($"4&(02*&3*0(&0$)&.*$"-120$&33&3   
33&33.&/40'"112012*"4&4&$)/0-0(*&3'022&3402"4*0/2&)"#*-*4"4*0/*/4)&'0--07*/($"4&(02*&3*0-0(*$"-$0..5/*4*&3    
33&33.&/40'"112012*"4&4&$)/0-0(*&3'022&3402"4*0/2&)"#*-*4"4*0/*/4)&'0--07*/($"4&(02*&3&931&$*&3   
33&33.&/40'"112012*"4&4&$)/0-0(*&3'022&3402"4*0/2&)"#*-*4"4*0/*/4)&'0--07*/($"4&(02*&3)93*$"-3425$452& 	 034#&/&'*4"/"-93*3*/$-5%*/(4&.102"-4)2&3)0-%'02*.1-&.&/4*/(12*."292&3402"4*0/"$4*6*4*&3   2*4&2*"40&6"-5"4&&''&$4*6&/&330'2&3402"4*0/"$4*0/3&(1)93*$"-34"#*-*49#*0*/%*$"4023    




"-5"4*0/0'3"/$45"292&3052$&3 		 

:2'3.+'19./251/)'9/4384,5447<'9+76:'1/9=+-/25')984,'3'1-'+(1442  3)/*+39'1)439'2/3'398,742;+88+182+7).'39,/8./3-94:7/8257/;'9+  	    +;+18'3*2+).'3/8284,)439'2/3'398)':8/3-2479'1/9=   	 +;+18'3*2+).'3/8284,8:(1+9.'1897+88478    4)/4+)4342/)+,,+)984,<'9+76:'1/9=43)422+7)/'1'3*7+)7+'9/43'1:8+8'3*574,/98     !+2547'1'3*85'9/'1*=3'2/)8/3,1:+3)/3-<'9+76:'1/9=92485.+7/)*+548/9/43  !+2547'1'3*85'9/'1*=3'2/)8/3,1:+3)/3-<'9+76:'1/9=35:98,74234354/3984:7)+8'3*8+1+)9+*.:2'3')9/;/9/+8  	 !+2547'1'3*85'9/'1*=3'2/)8/3,1:+3)/3-<'9+76:'1/9=35:98,7427/;+78'3*4:9,'118   !+2547'1).'3-+8/31+;+184,5'9.4-+38'3*5'9.4-+3/)/3*/)'9478</9./3+').)'8947-'3/828   !+2547'1).'3-+8/31+;+184,5'9.4-+38'3*5'9.4-+3/)/3*/)'9478</9./3/414-/)'18'251+8   !+2547'1).'3-+8/31+;+184,5'9.4-+38'3*5'9.4-+3/)/3*/)'9478</9./3$'9+7)41:23     !+2547'1).'3-+8/31+;+184,7+1+;'3947-'3/)8'3*2+9'18</9./3+').)'8947-'3/828  !+2547'1).'3-+8/31+;+184,7+1+;'3947-'3/)8'3*2+9'18</9./3 +*/2+398   !+2547'1).'3-+8/31+;+184,7+1+;'3947-'3/)8'3*2+9'18</9./3 +39/3'147-'3/828  

$!"!%

!+2547'1).'3-+8/31+;+184,7+1+;'3947-'3/)8'3*2+9'18</9./3$'9+7)41:23     5'9/'1'3*9+2547'1;'7/'(/1/9=/31+;+184,</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)+ 	  		  :8)+59/(/1/9='3*7+85438+4,85+)/+84,)43)+7394</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)+):9+'3*).743/)85+)/+87+85438++-(+.';/47'17+574*:)9/;+5.=8/414-/)'15.=8/)'1/30:7=   	  :8)+59/(/1/9='3*7+85438+4,85+)/+84,)43)+7394</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)++.';/47'1;'7/'(/1/9=      :8)+59/(/1/9='3*7+85438+4,85+)/+84,)43)+7394</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)+ +3847=)'5'(/1/9/+85.=8/414-/)'1941+7'3)+8'3*9.7+8.41*8   :8)+59/(/1/9='3*7+85438+4,85+)/+84,)43)+7394</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)+#+7/,/)'9/434,)':8+'3*+,,+)97+1'9/438./58 	   !.7+'9'88+882+39,4784:7)+84,</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)+*+39/,/)'9/434,84:7)+8  	   !.7+'9'88+882+39,4784:7)+84,</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)+7+*/)94:9)42+8,47;'7/4:8*/89:7('3)+7+-/2+8 	 	 

$

 !"

!.7+'9'88+882+39,4784:7)+84,</1*1/,+*/89:7('3)+'3-+4,/3,1:+3)+,47549+39/'11=;:13+7'(1+85+)/+8 	  ,,+)9/;+3+884,>43/3-7+-/2+ 	 	 	25')984,:37+897/)9+*.:2'3')9/;/9/+8</9./3>43+*'7+'839+38/9=  	  	  25')984,:37+897/)9+*.:2'3')9/;/9/+8</9./3>43+*'7+'8 5'9/'1*/897/(:9/43  	  	  

&

25')984,:37+897/)9+*.:2'3')9/;/9/+8</9./3>43+*'7+'8!=5+84,/25')98