O 7 1 P

• S ? o 

## ^ 9

. cu S e w u j

. s >

^ 

### K -S " 2

o - * "-"li b

u c 

## ORIGINA L

( O t n t o CM C N

o (A c a > Q

. 0 } </ 3

3 1 

# Q\J S

1/

1 tf} 

### U.S . DEPARTMENT O F TRANSPORTATION OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

I NTH E MATTE ROF : ELIT E AIR , INC . RESPONDENT

LITIGATIONCONFERENC E BEFOR E TH E HONORABL E JUDG E J . E . SULLIVA N

DOCKE T NO . PMSSA^^aO-ll-llg! ? T O

, L ; ro=5:?z: ^



### (F-SDERA L MOTO RCARRIER

SAFETYADMINISTRATION )

MARC H1 , 201 2 1:0 0P.M

. 

# M^ ' J",2«^ w



## • 8 201 2 

# HiARIN O DOCKE T

800.262.877 7 www.CountyCourtReporters.co m 877.837.831 3[ NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/203 2 CCR«16773- 1

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 APPEARANCES :

ONBEHAL F O F ELIT E AIR , INC . B . GRAYGIBBS , PRESIDEN T ELIT E AI RINC. , RESPONDEN T 10 0 SECON D AVENU E SOUT H SUIT E 101- S ST . PETERSBURG , F L 3370 1

ONBEHAL F O F FEDERA L AVIATIO NADMINISTRATIO N RYA NM . LANDERS , COMPLAINANT' S COUNSE L OFFIC E O F TH E REGIONA L COUNSEL , AEA- 7 SOUTHER NREGIO N FEDERA L AVIATIO NADMINISTRATIO N P.O . BO X2063 6 ATLANTA , GA3032 0

TH E HONORABL E J . E . SULLIVAN ADMINISTRATIV E LAWJUDG E OFFIC E O F HEARINGS , 2 0 U.S . DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N 120 0 NE WJERSE YAVENUE , S.E . WASHINGTON , D C 2059 0



# COURT/pePORTIN G VIdcograph y^^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' "I NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#I6773- 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 LITIGATIO NCONFERENC E MARC H 1 , 201 2 JUDG E SULLIVAN : W e ar e o nth e recor di n th e matte r o f Elit e Air , Inc . Thi s i s Docke t No . FAA

2011-1125 . Toda yi s Thursday , Marc h1 , 201 2 an dth e partie s hav e convene d b ytelephon e fo r a litigatio n schedulin g conference . Th e Federa l Aviatio n Administration' s attorney , Rya nM . Lander s i s presen t bytelephone . Th e Respondent , Elit e Air , Inc. , President , B . Gra yGibb s i s als o presen t bytelephone . Mr . Gibb s i s a nattorne ya s wel l a s th e Presiden t o f th e Respondin g party , an d w e ar e goin g t o tal k abou t tha t dua l rol e i njus t a moment . Goo dafternoon , everybody . MR . LANDERS : Goo dafternoon . You r Hono r

• • > .. _ „. . . M R.GIBBS : Goo d afternoon . .^ . .. . . _„

_JUDG E ..SULLIVAN : I wil l not e tha t o n .Januar y4 , 2Q12 , this..Administrativ e Cour t file dan Orde r settin g Rul e 1 6 Litigatio nSchedulin g conferenc e an d directin g Rul e 26{f ) plannin g an dsubmission . Subsequently , o nFebruar y22 , 2012 , th e partie s submitte d a draf t join t Sectio n13.217/Rul e 26(f ) Repor t submitte d b yClaimant' s FA

AandRespondent , Elit e Air , Inc . An di ntha t particula r documen t o n Pag e 1 , Paragraph l , Mr . Lander s wa s identifie da s



# COURT/pePORTIN G Vidtograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' " iv0,ttj.*77 7 C HiMar n>oitfAaS3tlno

- (

. I Jt O J^riJ nS[;*i»vj ; RM O {

. SUpScn:*!

. V * J?05 0^>IO«7.ti6 5I NTH EMATTE

RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCRn6773- l4

• 1 Counse l fo r th e FAA , an dMr . Gibb s wa s identifie da s 2 Counse l fo r th e Respondent . Mr . Gibbs , let' s tur nt o 3 yo u firs t then , befor e w e wen t o nth e recor dthi s 4 afternoon , yo u mentione dtha t eve nthoug hyo u ar e a n 5 attorney , yo u ar e als o th e Presiden t o f th e Responden t 6 i nthi s matter . So , I ama littl e unclea r a s t o ho w 7 yo u wan t t o identif yyoursel f today . Ar e yo u th e 8 attorne yrepresentativ e fo r th e Respondent , ar e yo u t o 9 Pr o S e Presiden t respondin g o nbehal f o f th e Company ? 1 0 Yo u know , tel l m e ho wyo u wan t t o b e identified . 1 1 MR . GIBBS : Well , 1 mean , a s a practica l 1 2 matter . You r Honor , i t doesn' t mak e anydifference , bu t 1 3 I , yo u know...a s yo u pointe d ou t o nth e earlie r thing s 1 4 w e filed , I identifie dmysel f a s Counse l fo r 1 5 Respondent , s o tha t i s absolutel yfine . I mean... 1 a m 1 6 anattorney , an d I d o a Federa l Practice , s o I mea nI 1 7 thin k tha t i s probabl yth e wa yt o d o i t is , "Counse l 1 8 fo r Respondent. " I d o wan t Your.Hono r t o b e awar e tha t 1 9 I am

also , yo u know . Presiden t o f Elit e Air , so...bu t I 2 0 thin k Counse l fo r Responden t i s th e wayt o go . 2 1 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , I jus t wan t t o 2 2 mak e sur e I knew , becaus e peopl e wh o ar e representin g 2 3 themselve s prefe r t o hav e outsid e counse l com e in , and 2 4 I didn' t kno wwhethe r tha t wa s you r ultimat e goa l o r 2 5 not . ' 

# COURTf^GPORTIN G Vldcograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' " «5,:.t2.*77 7 C Ml-^3'l < JOitfi iS3il.-»Q-

. C I:t & JftrJU nSe*ii«-

. RM C (

. 5Up.^CI>:CLn

. V * jrtS O C >I 0«t7.Ut ]I NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 5 1 MR . GIBBS : You r Honor , candidly , I mea n 2 I thin k tha t I amactuall you t o f m yoffic e today , bu t 3 I thin k th e tota l tim e involve d i s $5,00 0 o r less , an d 4 s o yo u know , i t i s jus t no t cos t effectiv e t o ge t 5 outsid e counse l fo r suc ha smal l matter . 6 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , jus t s o tha t w e 7 ar e clear , th e Civi l Penalt ytha t ha s bee nallege di s 8 $5,775.00 , jus t a littl e bi t ove r a $5,00 0 figure . 9 MR . GIBBS : Okay . 1 0 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Than k you . Let' s cha t 1 1 the nbriefl yabou t th e Draf t Join t Sectio n13.217/Rul e 1 2 26{f ) Report . Than k yo u ver ymuc hfo r submittin g it . 1 3 I hav e a coupl e o f question s t o as k bot ho f yo u abou t 1 4 it , an d I wil l star t wit hCounse l fo r th e FAA , Mr . 1 5 Landers . Mr . Landers , typicall yI pu t .int o thes e order s 1 6 a.littl e not e tha t th e partie s shoul dcompl ywit hth e 1 7 Interrogator ylimitatio ntha t i s i n14CF RSectio n 1 8 13.220K1 , an d I amwonderin g i f tha t i s acceptabl e t o 1 9 you r clien t t o includ e tha t i nth e Litigatio nOrder . 2 0 MR . LANDERS : I t is . You r Honor . 2 1 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Mr . Gibbs , i s tha t als o 2 2 acceptabl e t o you ? 2 3 MR . GIBBS : I t is . 2 4 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay . Le t m e as k yo u 2 5 the nabou t th e deadlin e fo r response s to * follow-u p



# COURT/pePORTIN G VJdtograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y" 543,I6J.*77 7 C Hi-J0'K>*iiAiS3n.-»a-

. (

. lltOJfrfSinSc»ifMvHw o (

. 5i«p^lcf*:c.i

. V AarOSO /

. >lO«7.tit lI NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 6 1 discover yrequests , yo u ha didentified...yo u jointl y 2 ha d identifie d tha t a s Ma y8 , 2012 . A s I rea dyou r 3 materials , tha t mean s tha t yo u ar e goin g t o b e finishe d 4 wit hal l depositions , al l interrogatories , al l request s 5 fo r documents , o no r befor e Ma y8 , 2012 . I s tha t a 6 correc t interpretation , Mr . Landers ? 7 MR . LANDERS : Yes , You r Honor , fro mou r 8 perspective , i t is . 9 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , an dMr . Gibbs ? 1 0 MR . GIBBS : I thin k tha t i s wha t w e . . . I 1 1 thin k tha t i s a correc t interpretatio no f wha t w e put , 1 2 an d no wa s I si t here , tha t doe s occu r t o m e tha t i s a 1 3 fairl yshor t fuse , sinc e obviousl yinterrogatories , and 1 4 reques t fo r admissions , al l requir e thirt yday s from 1 5 th e tim e the yar e submitted , tha t put s u s o na 1 6 relativel yshor t leash . I mea nth e cas ei s no t rea l 1 7 complicated , Judge...bu t I mean , yes , .tha t i s wha t w e 1 8 presented . 1 9 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , mayb e w e ca nge t 2 0 bac k t o tha t a t a late r moment . Ther e wa s a notatio n 2 1 i nyou r material s abou t Jun e 8 , 201 2 a s th e deadlin e 2 2 fo r filin g anyan d al l Pre-hearin g motions , whic hcoul d 2 3 includ e dispositiv e motion s and/o r summar yjudgemen t 2 4 motions . An d I typicall ylik e t o outlin e ver y 2 5 specificall ywhe nanswer s ar e du e t o suc hmotions , whe n



# e c u RT/p e PORTIN G VIdEograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' «I NTH EMATTE

RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCRn6773- l7 1 replie s ar e du e t o suc hmotions , an dthe nse t a nora l 2 telephon e conferenc e fo r argument s o nsuc hmotions . 3 Particularly , whe nthe yar e dispositiv e i nnature . 4 And , s o wha t I woul dlik e t o d o i s tal k t o yo u al l 5 abou t that . I als o wan t t o tal k t o yo u abou t 6 identifyin g a fina l dat e fo r exchangin g a lis t o f 7 witnesse s an d exhibit s prio r t o th e hearing , an dthe n 8 tal k briefl yabou t th e hearin g dat e itself . So , let' s 9 star t wit hJun e 8 , 2012 , Mr . Landers , startin g wit h 1 0 you , thi s present s tha t Ma y8 , 201 2 i s th e fina l 1 1 deadlin e fo r exchangin g ai l o f th e material s an dfo r 1 2 gettin g al l o f th e deposition s taken , an dfo r havin g 1 3 anysupplementa l disclosur e o f document s afte r suc h 1 4 deposition s ar e taken . I nterm s o f th e Jun e 8t h 1 5 deadline , wha t ~type o f answer , reply , tim e ar e yo u 1 6 lookin g a t afte r Jun e 8 , 2012 , o r hav e yo u talke dabou t 1 7 that , at , all? . „ 1 8 MR . LANDERS : W e ha dno t talke dabou t 1 9 this . You r Honor , tha t di d no t cros s ou r minds . 2 0 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , wel l let' s tal k 2 1 abou t i t now , becaus e I thin k tha t woul db e helpful . 2 2 MR . LANDERS : Lookin g a t m yschedule , I 2 3 coul d hav e anyanswe r t o anymotio ntha t Elit e Ai r 2 4 migh t fil e withi na wee k an d a half , fiftee ndays . 2 5 JUDG E SULLIVAN : I amlookin g a t ideall y



# COURT/pePORTIN G VJdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' " 5^3.Zfc2.S77 7 C WivJaii^JoiioiSsrtriQ t (

. Ilt o Jfrrw nSc*"*!-

. Rw<3 I

. SUp.lcniC'i

. V * JJOS O i5-l0W7.fc;6 3I NTH EMATTE

RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCRItl6773- l8 1 a t perhap s Jun e 22nd , whic hwoul d be.. . 2 MR . LANDERS : Okay , tha t woul db e fin e a s 3 well . 4 JUDG E SULLIVAN : ...fo r a nanswer , an d 5 tha t woul d b e tru e i f th e revers e happened , s o tha t i f 6 yo u file d a Motio nfo r Summar yJudgemen t o nal l o r par t 7 o f th e Elite' s answe r woul dthe nb e du e o no r befor e 8 Jun e 22nd , 2012 . O r i nth e fairl yrar e occasio nwher e 9 peopl e cros s plead , yo u know , yo u bot hwoul dhav e 1 0 answer s due . I nterm s o f th e repl ydate , i f th e answe r 1 1 i s du e Jun e 22nd , let' s pu t th e repl ydat e a s Jul y3rd . 1 2 Doe s tha t wor k fo r you , Mr . Landers ? 1 3 MR . LANDERS : Yes , You r Honor . 1 4 JUDG E SULLIVAN : An dwoul dthat.. . 1 5 MR . GIBBS : Judge , I amactuall ygoin g t o 1 6 b e ou t o f th e countr yfro mJun e th e 23r dt o Jul yth e 1 7 4th , i s ther e anywa yw e ca nbuil di nthat...som e 1 8 relie f o ntha t point ? 1 9 JUDG E SULLIVAN : O f course . So , let' s 2 0 tal k abou t tha t a littl e bit . I f yo u ar e leavin g from 2 1 Jun e 23r d throug hJul y3rd , w e ma ywan t t o juggl e thes e 2 2 tim e line s a bit . I s thi s th e onl ytim e yo u ar e goin g 2 3 t o b egon e fo r a significan t perio do f tim e durin g say , 2 4 tha t 9 0 da ystretch ? 2 5 MR . GIBBS : I t is , s o I thin k th e Jun e



# CGURT/pePORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' « «3,;.tJ.577 7 t

wi«a" « >oii* iS3'i-iO

- ^

. II Mio'ii nSc*tfO-

- Rw d£

. 5*itif>cn:c. \V * jroS O £>t O M7,fcJ HI N TH E MATTE R O F ELIT E AIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2 CCRII16773- 1 9 1 22n d dat e fo r filin g motions...o r fo r filin g any 2 replie s woul d be...o r filin g anyanswer s t o a motio ni s 3 fine , i f yo u coul d mayb e ad dte nday s beyon dJul yth e 4 4t hto...or , tha t woul db e grea t fo r a reply . 5 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Well , assumin g tha t th e 6 othe r part yi s no t travelin g an d ha s th e answer , w e ma y 7 want.. . 8 MR . GIBBS : Right . 9 JUDG E SULLIVAN : ...t o stretc htha t ou t a 1 0 littl e bi t s o that , fo r example , i f yo u wer e th e 1 1 answerin g party , yo u ca nge t you r materia l i nbefor e 1 2 yo u leav e o nJun e 22n d 2012.-. . 1 3 MR . GIBBS : Okay.. . 1 4 JUDG E SULLIVAN : ..bu t i f th e othe r part y 1 5 i s th e answerin g party , ther e i s n o reaso nno t t o giv e 1 6 th e FA

Aanothe r wee k i f yo u ar e no t ther e anyway . 1 7 MR . GIBBS : Right . 1 8 MR . LANDERS : You r Honor , tha t woul dwor k 1 9 fo r me . You r Honor , becaus e I amactuall yi ntria l wit h 2 0 yo u th e 20t han d th e 21st . 2 1 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay . O hyes , yes , 2 2 okay...wel l let' s pus htha t answe r dat e ou t t o Jun e 29 , 2 3 2012 , an d the na repl ycoul db e file dby...woul dJul y 2 4 13t hwork , Mr . Landers ? 2 5 MR . LANDERS : Tha t woul db e fine .



# CGURT/pePORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' « Sv3.;.t3.«77 7 C Hi-;3i K}0i<4^S3r1na TC 1 IC O Jpr^^nSC firv]--RH O i

. SlCCs'-.cn:c.i

. V &srOS O I >1 0 M7.Ub 3I N TH E MATTE R O F ELIT E AIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2 CCRIfl6773- l 1 0

1 JUDG E SULLIVAN : And , I though t tha t wa s 2 Mr . Gibbs . 3 MR . GIBBS : I t woul dwor k fo r me , yes , 4 You r Honor . 5 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , so , I wil l alway s 6 star t wit hth e Petitionin g Part yan dthe nI wil l mov e 7 t o th e Re^sponden t reply , jus t s o tha t yo u al l kno wwh o 8 I amgoin g t o b e talkin g to . Jul y13 , 201 2 fo r th e 9 Reply . Le t u s tal k the nafte r Jul y13th , w e ar e goin g 1 0 t o b e talkin g abou t a one-hou r telephon e conferenc e 1 1 wher e anyora l arguments . Lookin g a t you r calendars , 1 2 woul d eithe r th e wee k o f Jul y16t ho r th e wee k 1 3 following , whic hstart s wit hMonday , Jul y23rd . Mr . 1 4 Landers , startin g wit hyou , d o yo u hav e anyblackou t 1 5 tim e durin g those.. . 1 6 MR . LANDERS : I' msorry , yes . You r Honor , 1 7 I am

ou t o f townth e wee k o f th e 16th . 1 8 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , s o let' s loo k a t 1 9 th e wee k o f th e 23rd , d o yo u hav e anyblackou t day s 2 0 durin g tha t week ? 2 1 MR . LANDERS : No , You r Honor . 2 2 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , Mr . Gibbs , turnin g 2 3 t o you , fo r th e wee k o f Jul y23rd , d o yo u hav e any 2 4 blackou t date s fo r tha t week ? 2 5 MR . GIBBS : No .



# e c u RT/p G PORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y'" •I NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 i l 1 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , d o yo u have , sir , 2 ..stayin g wit hyou , Mr . Gibbs , a preferenc e a s t o th e 3 da yfo r ora l arguments , o r a tim e durin g th e day ? 4 MR . GIBBS : N o preference . 5 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Mr . Landers , d o yo u hav e 6 anypreference ? 7 MR . LANDERS : No , You r Honor . 8 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , the nlet' s tryfo r 9 Wednesday , Jul y25th , an dar e yo u bot ho nth e Eas t 1 0 Coast , Mr . Landers , startin g wit hyou ? 1 1 MR . LANDERS : Yes , You r Honor . 1 2 JUDG E SULLIVAN : And , Mr . Gibbs ? 1 3 MR . GIBBS : Yes , You r Honor . 1 4 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Then , let' s tryfo r 1 5 Wednesday , Jul y25 , 201 2 a t 1 0 a.m. , 1 1 a. mfo r Ora l 1 6 Arguments . 1 7 .. . MR . GIBBS : Okay . 1 8 MR . LANDERS : Okay . 1 9 JUDG E SULLIVAN : I usuall ylik e t o giv e 2 0 anOra l Rulin g a t th e en do f Ora l Arguments , the nI 2 1 wan t t o follo wi t up wit ha writte ndecision . An dso , 2 2 I amgoin g t o giv e mysel f unti l Augus t 1 t o issu e a 2 3 writte ndecision . An dsometimes , an dI a msur e yo u 2 4 hav e see nthis , th e issue s ar e fairl ycomplex , an dth e 2 5 Cour t canno t reac t o nora l argument s immediately , an d



# COURT/pePORTIN G Videograph y^^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' « £v3.:fc2.«77 7 iHi-vSai k J*id*;S3Maa ! C i:tOJfrrwnSc*tfnsB,3g c (

. Slcclcntw

. V A3t?05 0iyi0«7.tjt jI NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 1 2 1 thi s give s m e a littl e tim e t o loo k a t al l o f th e 2 material s i nth e even t tha t tha t occurs . 3 No wlet' s tal k abou t th e fina l exchang e o f 4 th e witnes s lists , an d Exhibits . I amno t quit e sur e 5 wha t you r obligation s migh t b e fo r August . I kno wsom e 6 peopl e ma yhav e childre ntha t ar e stil l ou t o f school , 7 and the yar e goin g t o g o o nvacations . So , startin g 8 wit hyou , Mr . Landers , d o yo u hav e anyblackou t date s 9 i nAugus t tha t I shoul db e considering ? 1 0 MR . LANDERS : No...excus e me . No , ma'am . 1 1 JUDG E SULLIVAN : And , Mr . Gibbs , ho w 1 2 abou t you ? 1 3 MR . GIBBS : No , none . 1 4 JUDG E SULLIVAN : I f yo u receiv e a writte n 1 5 decisio no nSummar yJudgement , o no r befor e Augus t 1 , 1 6 2012 , Mr . Lander s , woul d yo u fee l comfortabl e gettin g 1 7 Mr . Gibb s a lis t o f witnesse s an dexchangin g you r 1 8 Exhibit s b

yAugus t 22nd , 2012 ? 1 9 MR . LANDERS : Yes , You r Honor , tha t 2 0 shoul d b e plent yo f time . 2 1 JXTOG E SULLIVAN : Okay , Mr . Gibbs , woul d 2 2 tha t b e acceptabl e t o yo u too ? 2 3 MR . GIBBS : Yes , You r Honor . 2 4 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , the nlet' s tal k 2 5 the nabou t th e actua l tria l date . Mr . Landers , ho wmuc h



# COURT/pePORTIN G VIdEcgraph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y" Si^.<ii.ft77 7 C U>^a< K >9<<->^S3nna^(

. I1G & Jor^nSHini-

. RN O (

. 5Ulh'^cn-c^i

. V A2roS 0/ >lO&fr7,Ub 3I NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 1 3 1 tim e d o yo u thin k yo u ar e goin g t o nee dt o pu t o nyou r 2 owncas e ai ntrial...assuming , tha t n o summar y 3 judgemen t rulin g i s offere d i nyou r behalf . 4 MR . LANDERS : Right , a ma xo f a day , 5 includin g openin g statements , an dshoul dw e ge t there , 6 closin g statements . You r Honor . 7 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , an dMr . Gibb s ho w 8 abou t you ? 9 MR . GIBBS : I gues s I woul db e surprise d 1 0 i f th e whol e thin g too k mor e tha nfou r hours . You r 1 1 Honor , s o a da ycertainl yi s plenty . 1 2 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Well , I amhearin g fro m 1 3 Mr . Lander s tha t h e think s hi s whol e cas e i s goin g t o 1 4 tak e a day , an d I amaskin g yo u ho wlon g yo u thin k you r 1 5 portio no f you r respons e wil l be . 1 6 MR . GIBBS : I don' t thin k min e wil l tak e 1 7 mor e tha ntw o hours . 1 8 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , al l right , s o I am 1 9 goin g t o er r o nth e sid e o f cautio nrigh t now , an dI 2 0 wil l jus t simpl ysa ythi s i s a two-da ytria l jus t t o b e 2 1 o nth e saf e side . An ds o let' s loo k a t som e time s fo r 2 2 that . Ho wabou t th e wee k o f Augus t 27th , Mr . Landers , 2 3 d o yo u hav e tim e ope no ntha t week ? 2 4 MR . LANDERS : Yes , You r Honor , I amopen . 2 5 JUDG E SULLIVAN : An dMr . Gibbs , ho wabou t



# e c u RT/p e PORTIN G VidEograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' ^ 5v3.;.tl.877 7 i «l-.;3it tf»P«AiS3rt.io : ( , 116 9 JffrijnSe«ii>l-

. RM C i

. Sl«(W!CO:*.i

. V4 J?0S 6 C 5-IOM7.t5t 3I NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 1- 1 1 you ? 2MR . GIBBS : I a mopen . 3 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay . Let' s d o thi s o n 4 Augus t 28th , whic hi s a Tuesda yandAugus t 29th , whic h

- S i s a Wednesday . Tha t leave s Monday , Augus t 27th , an d 6 Thursday , Augus t 30t hfo r trave l day s fo r thos e o f \^ s 1 wh o ma ynee d t o b e goin g ou t o f town . And , becaus e w e 8 hav e a Jun e 8t hdeadlin e fo r Pre-hearin g motio nanda 9 Ma y8t hdeadlin e fo r fina l discovery , I wan t t o jus t 1 0 chec k i nwit hyo u t o se e i f eithe r o f yo u thin k tha t 1 1 yo u wan t t o pus hth e Ma y8t hdat e a littl e close r t o 1 2 Jun e 8th , o r i f yo u ar e comfortabl e wit htha t on e mont h 1 3 windo wi nbetween . Mr . Landers ? I' } MR . LANDERS : I amope nt o pushin g i t 1 5 bac k i f tha t i s wha t Mr . Gibb s woul dlike . H e ha d 1 6 indicate d tha t h e though t i t migh t b e a littl e cramme d 1 7 a t th e beginnin g o f thi s conversation , s o I amwillin g 1 8 t o mov e tha t bac k a s well . 1 9 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , Mr . Gibbs , wha t 2 0 woul d yo u lik e t o se e differen t fromth e Ma y8t hdat e 2 1 i nbetween.. . 2 2 MR . GIBBS : Wel l maybe.. . 2 3 JUDG E SULLIVAN : ...g o ahead , sir . 2 4 MR . GIBBS : ...Well , You r Honor , I 2 5 mean...i t jus t seem s tha t Ma y8t hi s a littl e bi t



# e c u RT/p G PORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' « ivO.?.«,577 7 IUiz^yii i;o(tfj. = Siiinq : C 11 Wi^isr , Sctiiyj iRw c ^5>(Ci^cn--C'^

. V A3707 & i>I 0M7.Ut 3I NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCRS16773- 1 1 5 1 short , I mea neve nMa yth e 18t hwoul dgiv e u s a n 2 additiona l te ndays , an d I don' t thin k i t would...an d 3 the nwoul d stil l giv e u s plent yo f tim e t o mak e th e 4 Jun e 8t hdate , o r jus t fo r seve ndays , eve nI thin k 5 unti l th e 15th , whatever.. . whateve r th e Cour t desires , 6 w e wil l certainl ymak e i t work . But , Ma y8t hdoe s 7 occu r t o m e tha t i t i s kin do f a short , shor t period . 8 . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Whydon' t w e se t i t fo r 9 Ma y31 , 2012 . Tha t i s o na Thursday , an dtha t i s 1 0 essentiall yon e week , plu s on e da yawa yfro mJun e 8th . 1 1 MR . GIBBS : Okay . 1 2 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Woul dyo u thin k tha t 1 3 woul d giv e yo u enoug htime , startin g wit hyou , Mr . 1 4 Landers , t o loo k a t al l o f you r materials , exhibi t 1 5 summary s o r a motio nfo r a dispositiv e revie wavailabl e 1 6 an d readyt o fil e b yJun e 8t h 1 7 MR . LANDERS : Yes , You r Honor , I ca nmak e 1 8 tha t work . 1 9 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Ho wabou t you , Mr . 2 0 Gibbs ? 2 1 MR . GIBBS : Yes , tha t i s fine . Judge , 2 2 than k you . 2 3 JUDG E SULLIVAN : An dvenue , a s I 2 4 understan d it , i s Tampa , Florid a i s ou r agreement . I 2 5 d o hav e a questio nfo r you , give nth e tim e fram e tha t



# COURT/pePORTIN G VIdEograph y^i; ^

Litigatio n Technolog y'* ' «3,*tl.677 7 C Wi«3'"t3o'M-53i1ftO : (

. Jlb PJ&riar * StWtM-RMf li

. Slcirficr*-&i

. V

AxrOS O ij-IO.«7.t.;t 5INTH EMATTE

ROFELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCR(tl6773- l1 6 1 yo u hav e offered , yo u hav e indicate dtha t Motion s t o 2 Compe l o r t o Disput e Discover yshoul db e withi n1 4 3 days , I a mgoin g t o recommen dt o yo u tha t i t shoul db e 4 1 0 days , an d th e reaso nI sa ytha t i s becaus e i t i s 5 sometime s a littl e difficul t t o ge t everybod yo nth e 6 phone , eve no na nexpedite dmotion . And , i f yo u hav e a 7 1 0 da yturnaroun dtime , i t jus t keep s peopl e o ntrac ka 8 littl e bi t better . So , woul deithe r o f yo u hav e an y 9 objectio nt o cuttin g th e tim e fram e fro m1 4 day s t o 10 . 1 0 Mr . Landers ? 1 1 MR . LANDERS : No , You r Honor , tha t wil l 1 2b e fine . 1 3 JUDG E SULLIVAN : An dMr . Gibbs ? 1 4 MR . GIBBS : Tha t i s fine . You r Honor . 1 5 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , I wil l s o not e 1 6 tha t i nth e Orde r tha t 1 sen dou t t o you . An dthe nI 1 7 a mjus t goin g t o le t yo u kno wtha t if , i nfac t yo u hav e 1 8 an ytroubl e wit hdiscovery , you r informa l discussion s 1 9 don' t work , th e bes t wa yt o addres s tha t i s t o consul t 2 0 wit heac hothe r a s yo u woul dhav e t o Unde r CR37 , t o 2 1 consul t wit heac hother , an dwhil e yo u ar e consultin g 2 2 wit heac hother , loo ka t you r calendar s an dfin da t 2 3 leas t thre e date s wher e yo u ar e bot havailabl e fo r a 2 4 telephon e conference . S o the nth e Movin g Party , th e 2 5 perso nwh o i s unhapp ywit hth e discover yissue , ca n



# ec u RT/p G PORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' «I NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 1 7 1 cal l m

yoffice , giv e thos e date s t o m ylega l secretary , 2 an d sh e ca ncalenda r somethin g o nm ycalenda r a s soo n 3 a s possible , an d the nyo u ca nfil e you r motio nwithi n 4 2 4 hour s o f tha t an dstar t th e bal l rollin g t o ge t th e 5 Cour t involved . I f yo u d o that , tha t wil l pu t th e 6 matte r up o nm

ycalenda r an d a t m yattentio na s fas t a s 7 possibl e s o tha t yo u ca nge t relie f a s fas t a s 8 possible . I ntha t way , yo u woul dno t suffer , wha t I 9 hav e see nhappe nbefor e wher e peopl e jus t wait , and 1 0 the nal l o f th e tria l calenda r ha s t o b e completel y 1 1 reschedule d a t everybody' s dismay . S o I wil l pu t tha t 1 2 i nm

yorde r fo r yo u tha t yo u hav e i t i nwriting . 1 3 Startin g wit hyou , Mr . Landers , i s ther e anythin g els e 1 4 tha t w e nee d t o addres s o nbehal f o f you r clien t today ? 1 5 MR . LANDERS : No t tha t I ca nthin k of , 1 6 You r Honor . 1 7 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , an dMr . Gibbs , o n 1 8 behal f o f you r client , anythin g els e w e nee dt o 1 9 address ? 2 0 MR . GIBBS : No , You r Honor . 2 1 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Then , 1 wil l loo k 2 2 forwar d t o talkin g wit hyo u o nJul y25 , 201 2 durin g th e 2 3 Ora l Arguments , an d jus t s o tha t yo u know , ofte ntime s 2 4 wha t I wil l d o i f ther e i s n o motio nfile dbyany 2 5 party , jus t conver t tha t ora l telephon e conferenc e int o



# CGURT/pGPORTIN G Vldtogpaph y^i; ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' " «-3,:M.677 7 C WIWari« ;o<i*=.S3rtna-

. (

. I1H> Jfrr#jnScrifM-.Rw O I

. St^clcnicn

. V AJ?05 0L>iO«'.Ht 3I NTH EMATTE RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCRn6773- l

1 a Pretria l Statu s conference , jus t s o tha t I hav e 2 everybod yo nth e lin e an d fin dou t tha t thing s ar e 3 movin g swiftl yan d i f ther e i s anythin g tha t need s t o 4 addres s befor e th e cas e goe s t o trial . So , kin do f 5 kee p tha t i nth e bac k o f you r mind . 6 Wit hthat , i t appear s ou r busines s i s 7 complete . I wil l b e sendin g ou t a writte norde r ver y shortl ycodifyin g everythin g w e talke dabou t today , an d 9 als o givin g yo u som e informatio nabou t ho wt o labe l 1 0 Exhibit s fo r th e tria l itsel f i f you r settlemen t 1 1 discussion s don' t resul t i na resolutio no f thi s 1 2 dispute . Wit hthat , w e ca ng o of f th e record . I wis h 1 3 yo u al l a goo d day . 1 4 MR . LANDERS : Than k you , You r Honor . 1 5 MR . GIBBS : Than k you . You r Honor . 1 6 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Than k you , too . Good

1 7 bye . 1 8 (WHEREUPON , th e proceeding s conclude da t 1:2 4 p.m . ) 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 

# COURM^GPORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y"I NTH EMATTE RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2 CCR(|16773- 1 1 9 1 CAPTIO N 2 3 Th e Hearin g i n th e matter , o n th e date , an d a t th e tim e 4 an d plac e se t ou t o n th e titl e pag e hereof . 5 6 I t wa s requeste d tha t th e Hearin g b e take nb yth e 7 reporte r an d tha t sam e b e reduce d t o typewritte nform . 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 

# COURT/pePORTIN G VIdEogpaph y^ ^ Litigatio n Technolog yrv. 5i3.m.6" 7 tMi«3iK>»i«*sS3r1na-

. C 1 lt &J«»'*3f*5e*ifM-

. RM< S i

. SUpftcn-.c^n

. V AJ?t5 0 I >IO«7.t;t lI NTH EMATTE

ROFELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCR)fl6773- l2 0



### 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 1 2 CERTIFICAT E O F REPORTE R 3 COMMONWEALT H O F VIRGINI AA T LARGE : 4 I d o herebycertif ytha t th e witnes s i nthe 5 foregoin g transcrip t wa s take no nth e date , and a t th e tim e an d plac e se t ou t o nth e Titl e pag e hereo f afte r firs t bein g dul yswor nand tha t th e sai d matte r wa s recorde d stenographicall yand mechanicall ybym e and reduce d t o typewritte nfor m unde r m

ydirection , an d constitute s a tru e recor d o f th e depositio na s taken , t o th e bes t o f m yskil l and 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2

- , ^ability . 2 4 I certif ytha t I amno t relate d t o o r a n 1 5 employe e o f counsel , an d tha t I hav e n o financia l 1 6 interes t i nth e outcom e o f thi s matter . 

### IMI^Q

- ^AMA

y
PAUL AJ . GREE R COUR T REPORTE R/ NOTAR Y 2 2 NOTAR YREGISTRATIO NNUMBER : 751238 7 2 3 MyCommissio nExpires : 2 4 2 5 

# COURT/REPORTIN G VIdeograph y^^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y" * K-3.;.W.«77 7 £mtsan t >9H.3 ^Ssrina : ^H WJc'^nSW">3-

. Sw O (

. 5»cRlcn:ci

. V A;^?t5 0l>iPfr»7,t>j; 2I NTH EMATTE

RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCR#16773- 1 2 1 $ $5,00 05: 3 5: 8 $5,775.0 05: 8

1 1 3: 23: 5 3:2 5 11:2 212:1 5 1:2 4 18:1 8 1 011:1 5 16: 4 16: 7 16: 9 1 1 11-1 5 J » ^

_

LJ

. • J

. *_

^ 1 3 10: 8 13.217/Rul e 3:2 25:1 1 13.220K 1 5:1 8 13t h9:2 4 10: 9 1 4 16: 216: 9 14CF R5:1 7 15t h15: 5 1 6 3:1 9 16t h10:1 210:1 7 18t h15: 1

2 2011-112 5 3: 5 201 23: 23: 5 3:1 8 3:2 1 6: 26: 5 6:2 1 7: 9 7:1 0 7:1 6 8: 8 9:1 2 9:2 3 10: 8 11:1 5 12:1 6 12:1 8 15: 9 17:2 2 20t h9:2 0 2Xs t 9:2 0 2 23:2 1 22n d8: 1 8: 8 8:1 1 9 : 1 9:1 212:1 8 23r d8:1 6 8:2 1 10:1 3 10:1 9 10:2 3 2 4 17: 4 2 5 11:1 5 17:2 2 25t h11: 9 26( f 3:2 03:2 2 5:1 2 27t h13:2 214: 5 28t h14: 4 2 9 9:2 2 29t h14: 4

3 30t h14: 6 3 1 15: 9 3 r d8:1 1 8:2 1

4 4 3:1 8 4 t h8:1 7 9: 4

8 8 6: 26: 5 6:2 1 7 : 9 7:1 07:1 6 8 t h7:1 4 14: 8 14: 9 1 4 : 1 1 14:1 2 1 4 :2 01 4 :2 5 15: 4 15: 6 15:1 015:1 6 9 9 08:2 4 A a . m11:1 5 11:1 5 absolutel y4:1 5 acceptabl e5:1 8 5:2 212:2 2 actua l12:2 5 actuall y5: 28:1 5 9:1 9 a d d9: 3 additiona l15: 2 addres s 16:1 9 17:1 4 17:1 9 18: 4 Administration' s 3 : 8 Administrativ e 3:1 8 admission s 6:1 4 afternoo n3:1 3 3:1 5 3:1 6 4: 4 agreemen t

15:2 4 ahea d14:2 3 a i n13: 2 A i r 3: 4 3: 9 3:2 4 4:1 9 7:2 3 allege d5: 7 a m4: 6 4:1 5 4:1 9 5: 25:1 8 7:2 5 8:1 5 9:1 9 10: 8 10:1 7 11:2 2 1 1 :2 3 12: 4 13:1 2 13:1 4 13:1 8 13:2 4 14: 214:1 4 1 4 :1 7 ]6: 3 16:1 7 and/o r 6:2 3 answe r 7:1 5 7:2 3 8: 4 8: 7 

# e c u RT/p e PORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y' ^ K-S.JH.*?! ? /

m-.Jar K

j5itf*i53r;no : i

< J3t PJ(-ri)nSc#ino ; Rw O /"

. SlCR^TCrt-.d

. V A2105 0/

>iOW7.(-it JI NTH EMATTE RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCR#16773- 1 2 2

8:1 09: 6 9:2 2 answerin g 9:1 1 9:1 5 answer s 6:2 5 8:1 0 9 : 2 anythin g 17:1 3 17:1 8 18: 3 appear s 18: 6 argument s 7 : 2 10:1 1 11: 3 11:1 6

1 1 -^j ^1 1 -^J " 11:2 011:2 5 17:2 3 assumin g 9: 5 attentio n17: 6 attorne y3: 8 3:1 1 4 : 5 4: 8 4:1 6 Augus t 11:2 212: 5 12: 9 12:1 5 12:1 8 13:2 21 4 : 4 14: 4 14: 5 14: 6 availabl e15:1 5 16:2 3 Aviatio n3 : 7 awar e4:1 8 awa y15:1 0

B bal l17: 4 be..

. o r

9: 2 beginnin g 14:1 7 behal f 4: 9 13: 3 17:1 4 1 7 :1 8 bes t 16:1 9 bette r 16: 8 beyon d9: 3 b i t 5: 8 8:2 08:2 2 9:1 014:2 5 16: 8 blackou t

10:1 4 10:1 9 10:2 4 12: 8 briefl y5:1 1 7: 8 buil d8:1 7 busines s 18: 6 by...woul d9:2 3 by e13:1 7

C calenda r

17: 2 17: 217: 6 17:1 0 calendar s 10:1 1 16:2 2 candidl y5: 1 cas e6:1 6 13: 2 13:1 3 18: 4 cautio n13:1 9 certainl y13:1 1 1 5 • 6

- L-w ' • W cha t 5:1 0 chec k 14:1 0 childre n12: 6 Civi l5: 7 Claimant' s 3:2 3 clea r 5: 7 clien t 5:1 9 17:1 4 17:1 8 close r 14:1 1 closin g 13: 6

^ Coas t 11:1 0 codifyin g 18: 8 comfortabl e12:1 6 1 4 :1 2 Compan y4: 9 Compe l16: 2 complet e18: 7 completel y17:1 0 comple x11:2 4 complicate d6:1 7 compl y5:1 6 conclude d18:1 8 conferenc e3: 1 3: 7 3:1 9 7: 2 10:1 016:2 4 17:2 5 18: 1 considerin g 12: 9 consul t 16:1 9 16:2 1 consultin g 16:2 1 convene d3: 6 conversatio n 14:1 7 conver t

17:2 5 correc t 6: 6 6:1 1 cos t 5: 4 counse l4: 1 4: 2 4:1 4 4:1 7 4:2 0 4:2 3 5: 5 5:1 4 countr y8:1 6 coupl e5:1 3 cours e8:1 9 Cour t 3:1 8 11:2 5 15: 5 17: 5 CR3 7 16:2 0 

# COURT/RGPORTIN G VidEograph y Litigatio n Technolog y'vSv3,;.M.t7J 7

. tHi-.!aii « j!>i«j.iS3rl.iQ- : ^ , 1 It O 3(.rSa n SMino"-RM d £ ; St<{>,1CI>:cn

. VAJJOS O I >JO«7.t.;ti 3I NTH EMATTE RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201- 2 CCR#16773- 1 2 3

cramme d14:1 6 cros s 7:1 9 8: 9 cuttin g 16: 9

D dat e7: 6 7: 8 8:1 0 8:1 1 9: 1 9:2 2 12:2 5 14:1 1 1 4 :2 0 15: 4 date s 10:2 4 12: 8 16:2 3 17: 1 da y8:2 4 11: 3 11: 3 13: 4 13:1 1 13:1 4 15:1 016: 7 18:1 3 day s 6:1 4 7:2 4 9: 3 10:1 9 14: 6 15: 215: 4 16: 3 16: 4 16: 9 deadlin e5:2 5 6:2 1 7:1 1 7:1 5 14: 8 14: 9 decisio n11:2 1 11:2 3 12:1 5 deposition s 6: 4 7:1 27:1 4 desire s 15: 5 differenc e4:1 2 differen t

14:2 0 difficul t

16: 5 directin g 3:2 0 disclosur e7:1 3 discover y6: 1 14: 9 ]

. 6 : 2 16:1 8 16:2 5 discussion s 16:1 8 18:1 1 disma y17:1 1 dispositiv e 6:2 3 7: 3 15:1 5 disput e16: 2 18:1 2 Docke t 3: 4 document ' 3:2 4 document s 6: 5 7:1 3 draf t 3:2 2 5:1 1 dua l3:1 3 du e6:2 5 7: 1 8: 7 8:1 0 8:1 1 durin g 8:2 3 10:1 5 10:2 011: 3 17:2 2 E earlie r 4:1 3 Eas t 11: 9 effectiv e5: 4 eithe r 10:1 2 1 4 :1 0 16: 8 Elit e3: 4 3: 9 3:2 4 4:1 9 7:2 3 Elite' s 8: 7 els e17 : 1 3 17:1 8 e r r 13:1 9 essentiall y15:1 0 even t 12: 2 everybod y3:1 4 16: 5 18: 2 everybody' s 17:1 1 everythin g 18: 8 exampl e9:1 0 exchang e12: 3 exchangin g 7: 6 7:1 1 12:1 7 exhibi t 15:1 4 exhibit s 7: 7 12: 4 12:1 8 18:1 0 expedite d16: 6

F FA A3: 4 3:2 3 4 : 1 5:1 4 9:1 6 fac t 16:1 7 fairl y6:1 3 8: 3 1 1 :2 4 fas t 17: 6 17: 7 Februar y3:2 1 Federa l3: 7 4:1 6 fee l12:1 6 fiftee n7:2 4 figur e5: 8 fil e7:2 4 15:1 6 17: 3 file d3:1 8 4 : 1 4 8: 6 9:2 3 17:2 4 filin g 6:2 2 9: 1 9: 1 9: 2 fina l7: 6 7:1 0 1 2: 3 14: 9 fin e4:1 5 8: 2 9: 3 9:2 5 15:2 1 16:1 2 16:1 4 finishe d6: 3 firs t 4: 3



# e c u RT/p e PORTIN G VIdeograph y^^ ^ Litigatio n Technolog y'* f «3,;.M.*7J 7 tWi-!oiK3oiiaiS3rlna : (

. JTRp JortfanSHifrt"

. RM( J '{

. stijclcn'o^i

. ^ * *?05 0 i iJOtt'.tjt JI NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCRn.6773- 1 2 4 Florid a 15:2 4 follow-u p 5:2 5 forwar d 17:2 2 fram e 15:2 5 16: 9 fus e 6:1 3

G gettin g 7:1 2 12:1 6 Gibb s 3:1 0 3:1 1 3:1 6 4: 1 4: 2 4:1 1 5: 1 5: 9 5:2 1 5:2 3 6: 9 6:1 0 8:1 5 8:2 5 9: 8 9:1 3 9:1 7 10: 2 10: 3 10:2 2 10:2 5 11: 2 11: 4 11:1 2 11:1 3 11:1 7 12:1 1 12:1 3 12:1 7 12:2 1 1 2 :2 3 13: 7 13: 9 13:1 6 13:2 b 14: 2 14:1 5 14:1 9 14:2 2 14:2 4 15:1 1 15:2 0 15:2 1 16:1 3 16:1 4 17:1 7 17:2 0 18:1 5 give n15:2 5 give s 12: 1 givin g 18: 9 goa l 4:2 4 gon e 8:2 3 Gra y3:1 0 grea t 9: 4 gues s 13: 9 r 1 H hal f 7:2 4 happe n17: 9 happene d 8: 5 havin g 7:1 2 hearin g 7: 7 7: 8 13:1 2 helpfu l 7:2 1 Hono r 3:1 5 4 : 1 2 4 :1 8 5: 1 5:2 0 6: 7 7:1 9 8:1 3 9:1 8 9:1 9 10: 4 10:1 6 10:2 1 11: 7 11:1 1 1 1 :1 3 12:1 9 1 2 :2 3 13: 6 13:1 1 13:2 4 14:2 4 15:1 7 16-1 1 16-1 4 17 : 1 6 17:2 0 18 : 1 4 18:1 5 hour s 13:1 0 13:1 7 1 7 : 4 1 ideall y7:2 5 identifie d 3:2 5 4: 1 4:1 0 4:1 4 6: 2 identified.. . yo u 6: 1 identif y4: 7 identifyin g 7: 6 I' m10:1 6 immediatel y11:2 5 In c 3: 4 3: 9 3:2 4 includ e 5:1 9 6:2 3 includin g 13: 5 indicate d 14:1 6

- \/ ^1 16: 1 informa l 16:1 8 informatio n18: 9 interpretatio n 6: 6 6:1 1 interrogatorie s 6: 4 6 : 1 3 Interrogator y 5:1 7 involve d 5: 3 17: 5 issu e 11:2 2 16:2 5 issue s 11:2 4

J Januar y3:1 8 join t 3:2 2 5:1 1 jointl y6: 1 Judg e 3: 3 3:1 7 4 :2 1 5: 6 5:1 0 5:2 1 5:2 4 6: 9 6:1 9 7:2 0 7:2 5 8: 4 8 : 1 4 8:1 5 8:1 9 9: 5 9: 9 9:1 4 9:2 1 10: 1 10: 5 10:1 8 10:2 2 11: 1 11: 5 11: 8 1 1 :1 2 1 1 :1 4 11:1 9 12:1 1 12:1 4 12:2 1 12:2 4 13: 7 13:1 2 13:1 8 13:2 5 14: 3 14 : 1 9 14:2 3 15: 8 15:1 2 15:1 9 15:2 1 15:2 3 

# COURT/pePORTIN G VIdeograph y^; ^

Litigatio n Technolog y'»' • 5i3,;.tJ,e7T 7 tM"'!0» < toi'S-JiSjilnO t(

. 1 1 t O J&rS4nSH'rn-

. HM O {

. SkcOcnicn

. V As;05 0 I >JO«tT.«t lI N TH E MATTE R O F ELIT E AIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2 CCR(I16773- 1 2 5 16:1 3 16:1 5 17 : 1 7 17:2 1 18:1 6 Judge...bu t 6:1 7 judgemen t 6:2 3 8: 6 12:1 5 13: 3 juggl e 8:2 1 Jul y8:1 1 8:1 6 8:2 1 9: 3 9:2 3 10: 8 10: 9 10:1 2 10:1 3 10:2 3 11: 9 11:1 5 1 7 :2 2 Jun e 6:2 1 7: 9 7 8 8 9 1 ^ 1. ^ 1 4 7:1 6 8: 1 8 8:1 1 8:1 6 2 1 8:2 5 9:1 2 2 2 1 4 : 8 1:1 2 15: 4 15:1 0 :):1 6 K kne w4:2 2 know.. . a s 4:1 3

L labe l 18: 9 Lander s 3: 8 3:1 5 3:2 5 5:1 5 5:1 5 5:2 0 6: 6 6: 7 7: 9 7:1 8 7:2 2 8: 2 8 : 1 2 8:1 3 9:1 8 9:2 4 9:2 5 10 : 1 4 10:1 6 10:2 1 1 1 : 5 11: 7 11:1 0 11:1 1 11:1 8 12: 8 12:1 0 12:1 6 12:1 9 12:2 5 13: 4 13:1 3 13:2 2 13:2 4 14:1 3 14:1 4 15 : 1 4 15:1 7 16:1 0 16:1 1 17:1 3 17:1 5 18:1 4 late r 6:2 0 leas h6:1 6 leas t 16:2 3 leav e 9:1 2 leave s 14: 5 leavin g 8:2 0 lega l 17: 1 les s 5: 3 let' s 4: 2 5:1 0 7: 8 7:2 0 8:1 1 8:1 9 9:2 2 10:1 8 11: 8 11:1 4 12: 3 12:2 4 13:2 1 14: 3 limitatio n5:1 7 lin e 18: 2 line s 8:2 2 lis t 7: 6 12:1 7 list s 12: 4 litigatio n3: 1 3: 6 3:1 9 5:1 9 littl e 4: 6 5: 8 5:1 6 8:2 0 9:1 0 12: 1 14:1 1 14:1 6 1 4 :2 5 16: 5 16: 8 lon g 13:1 4

M ma'a m12:1 0 Marc h3: 2 3: 5 materia l 9:1 1 material s 6: 3 6:2 1 7:1 1 12: 2 15:1 4 matte r 3: 4 4: 6 4 :1 2 5: 5 17: 6 ma x13: 4 ma y6: 2 6: 5 7:1 0 8:2 1 9: 6 12: 6 14: 7 1 4 : 9 14:1 1 1 4 :2 0 1 4 :2 5 15: 1 15: 6 15: 9 mayb e 6:1 9 9: 3 14:2 2 mea n4:1 1 4:1 6 5: 1 6:1 6 6:1 7 15: 1 mean.. . I 4:1 5 mean...i t 14:2 5 mean s 6: 3 mentione d 4: 4 min d 18: 5 mind s 7:1 9 min e 13:1 6 momen t 3:1 3 6:2 0 Monda y10:1 3 14: 5 mont h14:1 2 motio n7:2 3 8: 6 9: 2 14: 8 15:1 5 16: 6 17: 3 17:2 4 motion s 6:2 2 6:2 3 6:2 4 6:2 5 7: 1 7: 2 16: 1 

# COURT/RePORTIN G VIdeograph y Litigatio n Technolog y' " 5;j,;.6J,*7J 7 C Ml-.?3ii«j5i«*iSJrtaQ- ; ^ < Iltpjt-rijnScfirvi-RH O (

. Stcps'icrv'&n

. V i S^OStl ;•J0«7.^5t' ;I NTH EMATTE RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2CCRn6773- l2 6

motions...o r

9: 1 mov e10: 6 14:1 8 movin g 16:2 4 18: 3 • mysel f 4:1 4 11:2 2
N natur e7: 3 No...excus e12:1 0 non e12:1 3 notatio n6:2 0 not e3:1 7 5:1 6 16:1 5 0 objectio n16: 9 obligation s 12: 5 obviousl y6:1 3 occasio n8: 8 occu r 6:1 215: 7 occur s 12: 2 offere d13: 3 16: 1 offic e5: 217: 1 Oh9:2 1 Oka y4:2 1 5: 6 5: 9 5:2 4 6: 9 6:1 9 7:2 08: 29:1 3 9:2 1 10: 5 10:1 8 10:2 211: 1 11: 8 11:1 7 11:1 8 12:2 1 12:2 4 13: 7 13:1 8 14: 3 14:1 9 15:1 1 16:1 5 17:1 7 okay...wel l9:2 2 one-hou r

10:1 0 ope n13:2 3

13:2 4 14: 214:1 4 openin g 13: 5 ora l7: 1 10:1 1 11: 3 11:1 5 11:2 0 11:2 011:2 5 17:2 3 17:2 5 orde r 3:1 9 5:1 9 16:1 6 1 7 :1 218: 7 order s 5:1 5 outlin e6:2 4 outsid e4:2 3 5: 5

P p. m18:1 8 Pag e3:2 5 Paragraph l3:2 5 particula r

3:2 4 Particularl y7: 3 partie s 3: 6 3:2 1 5:1 6 part y3:1 29: 6 9:1 1 9:1 4 9:1 5 10: 6 16:2 4 17:2 5 Penalt y5: 7 peopl e4:2 28: 9 12: 6 16: 7 17: 9 perhap s 8: 1 ^^ perio d8:2 3 15: 7 perso n16:2 5 perspectiv e6: 8

* • X Petitionin g 10: 6 phon e16: 6 plannin g 3:2 0 plea d8: 9 plent y12:2 0 13:1 1 15: 3 plu s 15:1 0 poin t 8:1 8 pointe d4:1 3 portio n13:1 5 possibl e17: 3 17: 7 17 : 8 practica l4:1 1 Practic e4:1 6 prefe r 4:2 3 preferenc e11: 2 11: 4 11: 6 Pre-hearin g 6:2 21 4 : 8 presen t

3: 8 3:1 0 presente d6:1 8 present s 7:1 0 Presiden t

3:1 0 3:1 1 4: 5 4: 9 4 :1 9 Pretria l18: 1 prio r 7: 7 Pr o 4 : 9 probabl y4:1 7 proceeding s 18:1 8 pus h9:2 214:1 1 pushin g 14:1 4 put s 6:1 5

Q questio n15:2 5 

# COURT/fi e PORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^

Litigatio n Technolog y'" • ii3.:LtX,577 7 i

. Hl-.:3iic3oi4*iS3'-l--H) - C 116 5 J&rSar vSCf"V3-

. B.M O /

. Srcc^'cn-.C-n.'/AX?05 0 i JiCttT.tJt lI NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCRn6773- l 2 7 question s 5:1 3 quit e 12: 4

T i K rar e 8: 8 reac t 11:2 5 read y15:1 6 rea l 6:1 6 reaso n9:1 5 16: 4 receiv e 12:1 4 recommen d 16: 3 recor d 3: 3 4: 3 18:1 2 relativel y6:1 6 relie f 8:1 8 17: 7 replie s 7: 1 9: 2 repl y7:1 5 8:1 0 8:1 1 9: 4 9:2 3 10: 7 10: 9 Repor t 3:2 3 5:1 2 A . representativ e 4: 8 representin g 4:2 2 reques t 6:1 4 ^ request s 6: 1 6: 4 requir e 6:1 4 ^ reschedule d 17:1 1 resolutio n18:1 1 Responden t 3: 9 3:2 3 4: 2 4: 5 4: 8 4 : 1 5 4:1 8 4:2 0 1 0 : 7 respondin g 3:1 2 4: 9 respons e 13:1 5 response s 5:2 5 resul t 18:1 1 revers e 8: 5 revie w15:1 5 rol e 3:1 3 rollin g 17: 4 Rul e 3:1 9 3:2 0 rulin g 11:2 0 13: 3 Rya n3: 8 ^ S saf e 13:2 1 schedul e 7:2 2 schedulin g 3: 7 3:1 9 schoo l 12: 6 S e 4: 9 secretar y17: 1 Sectio n3:2 2 5:1 1 5:1 7 seem s 14:2 5 see n11:2 4 17: 9 sen d 16:1 6 sendin g 18: 7 settin g 3:1 9 settlemen t 18:1 0 seve n15: 4 shor t 6:1 3 6:1 6 15: 1 15: 7 15: 7 shortl y18: 8 significan t 8:2 3 simpl y13:2 0 si r 11: 1 14:2 3 si t 6:1 2 smal l 5: 5 so...bu t 4:1 9 sorr y10:1 6 specificall y6:2 5 star t 5:1 4 7: 9 10: 6 17: 4 startin g 7: 9 10:1 4 11:1 0 12: 7 15:1 3 17:1 3 start s 10:1 3 statement s 13: 5 13: 6 Statu s 18: 1 stayin g 11: 2 stretc h8:2 4 9: 9 submissio n3:2 0 submitte d 3:2 2 3:2 3 6:1 5 submittin g 5:1 2 Subsequentl y3:2 1 suffe r 17: 8 SULLIVAN3: 3 3:1 7 4:2 1 5: 6 5:1 0 5:2 1 5:2 4 6: 9 6:1 9 7:2 0 7:2 5 8: 4 8:1 4 8:1 9 9: 5 9: 9 9:1 4 9:2 1 10: 1 10: 5 10:1 8 10:2 2 11: 1 11: 5 11: 8 11 : 1 2 11:1 4 

# COURT/p e PORTIN G VIdeograph y^; ^

Litigatio n Technolog yrv. 5v3.;.*1.577 7 t ' WlMOii t>*i«*:;Sj'lna - C llt O JfrrSinSwmo-

. RM d C S'«(#cn:o.V

. V i S?05 ti

. >lQ^T,tiC iT NTH EMATTE RO FELIT EAIR , INC

. 03/01/201 2 CCR)I16773- 1 2 8 1 1 : ]

. 9 12:1 1 12:1 4 12:2 1 12:2 4 13: 7 13:1 2 13:1 8 13:2 5 1 4 : 3 14:] 9 1 4 :2 3 15: 8 15:1 215:1 9 15:2 3 16 : 1 3 16:1 5 17:1 7 17:2 1 18:1 6 summar y6:2 3 8: 6 12:1 5 13: 2 summary s 15:1 5 supplementa l7:1 3 sur e4:2 2 11:2 3 12: 4 surprise d13: 9 swiftl y18: 3

T tal k 3:1 2 7: 4 7: 5 7: 8 7:2 0 8:2 0 10: 9 12: 3 12:2 4 talke d7:1 6 7:1 8 18: 8 talkin g 10: 8 10:1 017:2 2 Tamp a15:2 4 telephon e3: 6 3: 9 3:1 07: 2 10:1 0 16:2 4 17:2 5 t e n9: 3 15: 2 term s 7:1 4 8:1 0 than k 5:1 0 5:1 2 15:2 218:1 4 18:1 5 18:1 6 that...som e8:1 7 themselve s 4:2 3 thirt y6:1 4 Thursda y3: 5 14: 6 15: 9 to.. . o r

9: 4 toda y3: 5 4: 7 5: 2 17:1 4 18: 8 tota l5: 3 tow n10:1 7 14: 7 trac k 16: 7 trave l14: 6 travelin g 9: 6 tria l9:1 9 12:2 5 13:2 0 17:1 018: 4 18:1 0 trial..

. assumin g 13: 2 troubl e16:1 8 tru e8: 5 t r y11: 8 11:1 4 Tuesda y14: 4 tur n4: 2 turnaroun d16: 7 turnin g 10:2 2 two-da y13:2 0 typ e7:1 5 typicall y5:1 5 6 : 2 4 U ultimat e4:2 4 unclea r

4: 6 understan d15:2 4 unhapp y16:2 5 usuall y11:1 9

V vacation s 12: 7 venu e15:2 3

W wai t 17: 9 we.. . I6:1 0 Wednesda y11: 9 11:1 5 14: 5 wee k 7:2 4 9:1 6 10:1 210:1 2 10:1 7 10:1 9 10:2 010:2 3 10:2 4 13:2 2 13:2 3 15:1 0 whatever..

. whateve r

15: 5 WHEREUPO

N18:1 8 whethe r

4:2 4 whol e13:1 0 13:1 3 willin g 14:1 7 windo w 14:1 3 wis h18:1 2 witnes s 12: 4 witnesse s 7: 7 12:1 7 wonderin g 5:1 8

1 » f

\n' ^ i~ \- It~ t wor k 8:1 2 9:1 8 9:2 4 10: 3 15 : 6 15:1 8 16 : 1 9 would...an d15: 2 writin g 17:1 2 

# COURT/p G PORTIN G VIdeograph y^ ^ LitigationTechnotog y»< i •5i5,:.tl,*7J 7 tMi-.Jai n JoPiiiSsrina - ^

. no o Jfrrw:^Se*»r>i-

. RM< 3'{

. Sl5p,l<n-.c..i

. V AjlOS ti ' i'0«r.«& iI NTH E MATTE RO F ELIT E AIR , INC . 03/01/201 2 CCR#16773- 1 2 9

writte n11:2 1 11:2 3 12:1 4 18: 7 yoursel f

4: 7



# COURT^ e PORTIN G

VIdeograph y^p ^

Litigatio n Technolog y'" • ii3.?.13,677 7 tni-a' H JoiiacS3ilna - C "t O J&ria n spfim tRM O £

. Srcirficn-fri

. V AjrOSf t/

i-lCi«7.Mt ;