08/25/201 1 14:3 2 FA X 202493514 2 08/25/201 1 5:d2A

M FA X FA A • rQM S 1^001/00 9

gioooi/ooo a

Michae l Selig , MD , FACC , CFl- H 281 6 Orefiel dRoa d Allentown , PA . 1810 4 Augus t 25 , 201 1 

### :';:i^ARTMEN TO F : ;^ANSPORWIO N

. OCKF i .OPERATION S i mrtUG2 5 P3

- 3 5 U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC EO FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Complainan t M & RHelicopters , LLC . Responden t V , Honorabl e Richar dGoodvl n Docket : 2010-121 1

RESPONDENT' S REPL Y T O TH EORDE RT O SHO WCAUS E AN D NOW , come s respondent , MICHAE LB . SELIG . MD . FACC , principl e fo r

M RHelicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operational , n o pilo t an dwit hn o incom e sinc e befor e violatio n issued ) who maver s an dfile s th e followin g Repl y t o th e Orde r

t o Sho w Cause . Wh y shoul dth e relie f requeste dI nComplainant s Motio nno t b e granted ? 1 . Th e Complain t

speak s t o For move r Substanc e wit hth e remot e theor y o f a violatio n tha t

i s broke n i n an y resemblanc e o f practica l applicatio nan d therei n frivilous . 2 . Th e Complain t

wa s originall y site dunde r adifferen t

arra y o f

- 1 -08/25/201 1 14.3 2 FA? ( 202493514 2 FA A- DMS 0002/00 9 08/25/201 1 5 C2A M FAX 0)0002/000 9

circumstances , withou t prope r fac t finding, assumin g tha t Mr . Bake r

wa s no t o nan y monitorin g program . Irrespectiv e o f tha t th e particular s wer e speculative , th e compan y ha dn o incom e an dwa s no t operational . Th e Complaint , neve r

th e les s ha dt o chang e an devolv e t o approac hsom e vague , undefine dminima l threshol di norde r t o b e pursued . 3 . Th e Complain t

ha dt o evolv e an dchang e fro mit s origina l form , whe ni t exceede dth e statu e o f limitation s b y 6 months . Eve ni nit s curren t form , i t fall s i n withi n l da y o f th e 2 yea r

Statu e o f

Limitations . 4 . Th e Complain t

targete da n individua l a t alim e o f

persona l crisi s (perverte d divorce) , tha t

indefinitel y suspende doperations , laudably , i norde r t o no t pu t th e publi c a t

ris k unde r 119.6 9 an di ngoo dconsciou s an di ngoo d faith . 5 . MR H wa s no t

operationa l durin g th e propose dperio ddu e t o th e abov e an d therefor e n o person , a t an y tim e wa s a t

risk . 6 . Ther e wa s n o pilo t an dn o operation s performe ddurin g th e site dperiod . 7 . Th e operationa l specification s wer e unde r revisio nan dno t

vali do r current , wit hn o pilo t

sinc e befor e th e violatio nwa s initiate ddu e t o th e nam e chang e an dstructure , eve n thoug hth e operatio nsomewher e wa s liste da s active . S . Th e LL C Compan y supportin g th e abov e ha dn o income , a s i t ha dno t performe dan y flights, sinc e i t wa s no t operational . 9 . Th e violatio n wa s cite dagains t regulation s tha t

ha dfirst

change dit s wordin g an dmeanin g bac k i nFebruar y o f

2004 .

~ 2 -08/25/201 1 14:3 2 FAX 202493514 2 FA A- OM S @|003/00 9 08/25/201 1 5:d2A M FAX 2)0003/000 9

10 . Th e violatio n wa s cite dagains t regulation s tha t

wer e change dagain , no t liste dregulation s (sinc e Jul y 2009) , bu t confusin g i ntha t

the y wer e Remove dan dReserved . 11 . Th e regulation s cite dcoul donl y b e foun db y wa y o f avariabl y an d inconsistentl y workin g softwar e hypertex t lin k o nth e FA

A websit e showin g th e actua l regulations , therei nhidden . 12 . Th e tw o regulation s cite dwer e s o inconsistent , confusing , contradictor y an dproblematic , th e Rulemakcr s change dan dmodifie dthe m2 times . 13 . Th e violatio n wa s cite dagains t regulation s tha t

ha dchange dan dno t eve n th e FA A official s wer e awar e of th e change s o r

thei r interpretatio n includin g thei r

ow n Drug/Alcoho l audito r Vincen t

Root s durin g hi s audi t o f MRH . 14 . Th e maintenanc e an doperation s inspector s o f MRH , th e FSD O tha t wa s acros s th e stree t

fro mwher e th e MR H Helicopte r wa s hangared , als o wer e no t awar e o f

th e changes , therei nHoldin g th e Responden t t o aHighe r Standar dtha n it s ow n Officials , therefor e asetu p fo r entrapment . 15 . Th e violatio n wa s cite dagains t regulation s tha t

ha dchange dan dno t revise dwithi n ih c signe dof f o p spec s contrar y t o th e Rule s o f Ful l Disclosure . 16 . Ther e wa s n o notificatio n syste mi nplac e t o mak e th e agencie s official s o r th e operator s awar e o f th e regulatio nchang e an dwithou t followin g sui t wit hth e operationa l specification s format .

- 3 -08/25/201 1 14:3 2 FAX 202493514 2 FA A- OM S (2)004/00 9 08/25/201 1 5-42A M FA X • 130004/000 9

Document s Requeste dt o b e Entere dInt o Evidenc e 14 . Respondent s Repl y t o Jul y 29 , 201 1 Pleading s b y Complainants , Jul y 21 , 2011 . 15 . Respondent s Repl y t o Complainant s Brief, Jun e 3 , 2011 . 16 . Lette r

t o M s Pont o concernin g MR H Ta x information , Apri l 1 , 2011 . 17 . Cod e o f

Regulation s 135.25 1 an d135.255 . 18 . Motio nfo r

Mor e Definit e Statement , Inadequat e Disclosur e (neve r addresse db y Complainants) , Februar y 17 , 2011 . 19 . Motio nfo r

Mor e Definit e Statement , Inadequat e Method s of Compliance , Februar y 14 , 2011 , (neve r addresse db y Complainants) . 20 . Motio n t o Defin e an dente r 4 Truth s o f

Admissions , Februar y 13 , 2011 . 2 1 . Motio n fo r

Protectiv e Order , Februar y 6 , 2 0 H , (neve r responde dtO) . 22 . Motio n fo r

Mor e Definit e Statement , 199,6 9 Shutdow nan dHuma n Factors , Januar y 24 , 2011 , als o contain s ta x information . 23 . Motio n fo r

Mor e Definit e Statement , Changin g th e Caus e o f Action , Januar y 24 , 2011 . 24 . Motio nfo r

Mor e Definit e Statement , Holdin g Responden t t o aHighe r Standard , tha n th e FA A Officials , Januar y 24 , 20U , 25 . Respondent s Repl y t o th e Amende dComplaint , Decembe r 14 , 2010 . 26 . Respondent s Motio n an dBrie f Supportin g th e Motio nt o Quash , Strik e o r Dismis s Complaint . Novembe r 29 , 2010 , a s i t

contain s pertinen t

evidence , critica l t o th e case . 27 . Preliminar y Objections , Novembe r 27 , 2010 , a s i t

contain s pertinen t

- 4 -08/25/20nU:33M X 202.935M 2 F. A-O. S ^3005/00 3 08/26/201 1 5:42A M FA X

evidence , critica l t o th e case . 28 . Th e undedacte dET Rfile. Wherefore , th e Responden t pray s t o thi s Honorabl e Court , tha t th e followin g evidenc e b e entere dint o th e hearin g recor do r i nth e alternativ e tha t thi s cas e wil l b e immediatel y dismisse di nit s entirety . Michae l B . Sclig , MD , FACC , CFl- H Electronicall y signed—mb s Protecte d

- 5 -08/25/201 1 1 4 3 3 f^A X 202493514 2 08/25/201 1 5-42A

M FA X FA A - DM S aOOG/00 9

(210008/000 9

Michae l Selig , MD , FACC , CFl- H 281 6 Orefiel dRoa d Allentown , PA , 1810 4 Augustus , 201 1

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC EO PHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Complainan t V . M & RHelicopterft > LLC . Responden t Honorabl e Richar dGoodwi n Docket : 20lO-121 1

RESPONDENT' S MOTIO N T O COMPE LDISCOVER Y 4 AND NOW . come s respondent , MICHAE LB . SELIG , MD , FACC , principl e fo r

MRHelicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operational , n o pilo t an dwit hn o incom e sinc e befor e violatio n issued ) who mfiles th e followin g MOTIO Nt o COMPE LDISCOVER Y 4 . 1 . Fo r Complainan t

t o provid e th e requeste dspecifi c regulations , language , details , an dreference s wit hregar dt o th e specifi c regtUatio nchange s tha t ha doccurred . 2 . Fo r Complainan t

t o produc e regulation s reference di nth e complaint , inclusiv e o f

adoptio n dates , change s an drevisio ndates . 3 . Fo r Complainan t

t o produc e prio r

requeste dfull , unaltere dcopie s o f

- 1 -08/25/201 1 14:3 3 FAX 202493514 2 FA A^ DMS g|007/00 3 06/25/201 1 5 42A M FA X @0007/000 S

document s tha t

wer e produce di nth e incomplet e Enforcemen t Investigativ e Repor t

(EIR) , tha t

wer e eithe r

stricken , blocke dout , redacte d an dspoliated . 4 . Fo r Complainant s t o provid e th e prio r requeste dreference s o f Jordo nv . Departmen t

o f Justic e tha t

complainan t

cite di nhe r

correspondenc e an d ho w eac hspecifi c referenc e directl y applie dt o eac hspecifi c redacte dpar t o f th e EI Ran dt o provid e th e referenc e fo r policie s o ndisclosur e restrictions . 5 . Th e responden t

hereb y request s i nadditio nth e followin g of complainant , a ) Provid e copie s o f

al l document s intende dt o b e introduce da s evidenc e i n thi s case . b ) A complet e lis t

o f eac han dev^r y perso nt o b e presen t wh o i s associate d wit hth e FAA an dthei r position . c ) A complet e lis t

o f eac han dever y perso nintende dt o b e calle da s a witnes s o r

exper t witness , t o giv e testimon y o r wil l b e presen t

o nbehal f o f th e agency . d ) Title , occupation , employer , busines s address , curriculu mvita , licens e an dcertificatio n numbers , educationa l backgroun dan dcomplet e credentials , o f

al l person s wh o wil l b e presen t a t th e hearing , 0) Th e natur e o f

th e state dtestimon y t o b e provide d(factual , witnes s o r exper t witness) , b y eac hindividual , th e subjec t matte r upo nwhic heac h witnes s i s expecte dt o testify , th e natur e o f knowledg e possesse db y eac h witnes s an dth e fact s t o whic heac hwitnes s i s expecte dt o testify .

- 2 -08/25/201 1 14.3 3 FA X 202493514 2 FA A^ OM S 13008/00 9 08/25/201 1 5'43At 4 FA X [2)0009/000 9

f ) Provid e copie s o f

an y an dal l statement s mad e b y th e witnesse s identifie di n respons e t o th e interrogatorie s concerning , referring , o r involvin g th e circumstance s se t fort hi nth e complaint . g) Approximat e tim e o f testimon y o f

eac hindividual . Respectfull y Submitted , Michae l B . Selig , MD , FACC , CFI- H Electronicall y signed--mb s Protecte d

- 3 -08/25/201 1 143 3 FA X 202493514 2 08/25/201 1 5-43A

M FA X FA A - DM S a009/00 9

120009/000 9

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

Federa l Avlatio D Administratio n

Complainan t V . M & RH«Itoopterfi , LLC . Responden t Honorabl e Judg e Richar d Ooadwl n Docke t : 2010-121 1

CERTIFICAT EO FSERVIC E 1 HEREB Y CERTIP Y tha t I hav e thi s da y serve dth e foregoin g entrie(s) : RESPONDENT' S REPL Y T O TH EORDE RT O SHO WCAUS E RESPONDENT' S MOTIO NT O COMPE LDISCOVER Y 4 upo nal l partie ao f

recor di nthi s proceeding , i narx:ordanc « wit hih c requirement s o f Rul e 2 9 pursuan t

t o 2 8 U . S . C . § 174 6 . Servic e b v firnt

jolog o mri\l . ijujUiki . pn^^.HJd . HIUJIL-ULL Iu n^olio^^Q : Federa l Aviatio nAdminiaLratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W WUbu r Wrigh t Avenue-Suit e 2W100 0 Washington , DC . 205 9 L Att : Hearin g DtKike t

ClftrW, AGC-43 0 i^FA X 20 2 49 3 514 2 Charle GRale y Enforcemen t

I)ivigion/AOC-30 0 Offic e of th e Chie f

Counse l FA A 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 t^AX20 2 26 7 510 6 Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n U S Departmen t

o f TrEuisponatio n Offic e o f HeaHngs , M-20 , koo mE12-32 0 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue . S.K . Washington , D C 2059 0 FA X 20 2 36 6 7536—no t

workin c p^,^1vmai l patricia.Tnatthewa@dot.go v By;_Electronicall y aigne dMB S Michae l B . Sclig , MD , FACC . 281 6 Orefiel dRoa d Allentown . Pa . 1810 4 61 0 36 0 395 3 Date : 8-25- 1 1