**OFFICE OF**  **THE ATTORNEY**  **GENERAL OF**  **TEXAS AUSTIN** 

iioaorablo ?. t. OraM8 COunCJ Llttornu7 ca8sroo Goant Bwvnaville, T8388

in your letter Corpomtlon A, Christ1 l

d car a t met* rot f o o t h

ala d w PuhO u888

The quurtloa p;eoatd’ia rhuthu? raoha tmpuetlon, if aoasummt~d &or ruoh faotr 8ad uI?uumUrw8s, I8 da- - **nouncud** bJ **thU %tslpI**  **anti-tPUat 8titUte8.** 

The **rt8tutr** 1Jardietely l~rolvrd ir Artialo 7427, pzovidlrg :

### Honorable P. T, QfQMa, pge 2

‘A noaopoly is .a ooabtrvtiou or oonsoll~- ticu OS tvo **or** 

### DAOP~ corporcrtloms vhisa effected iB **9ithOP Of**  

### thr **fOllOViBg EdhOdSJ**  

### Nl. **YhOB** 

### the dlraatlon **of** 

### the 8ffr3.1’8 of tt?o **or** 801~0**~OP~O~~fOtU** 18 in any **mMeP** brought 

### under **the** 

### samm **nWasgeEent** 

### o control **for the**  

### pur**pa54** 

### of **podwing,** war 

### rhea’* suah own m&gomm 

### or coatrol tends t o oriMktel **trust 45**  

### detlMd IB th# **lf?St** Wlvlv **Of bhf8**  **Chibpt@P.** I 

### l 2. mar* bfty aorporutioa 

### l lq ulrrr

the **S-Per oP**  **eoPtiii55tr8 Ot**  **8took or**  **bODd#, IPWahiu**  **OP** other rlghtr, o* the ph?slU1 pqwrtles oP 

### l o;l ~&art thwoor, or **any** 

### other oorpQlutlon or berporrtioar, **ror** thr purporo of preventing **or 1055oBlng,**  O? **vhero** tha 8ireot 02 ruuh baquirltloa t*ndr to 8tfeCt **OP 1.850!&**  tl~t:tiOXL, 

### Vh& iO P l **U5b 56**  qulsltlon 

### Is rocomplisheddlr#,otl7 or **through** the **i~5tPfJ8ORt6lft~ Of**  **trBlt558 0**  **OtkW ’** **Vi55:** 

### A **mretul** 

### basl7~ls ot this rtatuta **llakea** 

### ltr aosntng and **purpors** rirple 

### aad unhrsUndablu. Fha speoiflc act prohibited $9 8 roablaatloa or oonsollbtion of **tvo or**  **wro corpomtloM.**  **” Bat**  **1, is**  fmjmrtant **50** 

### obrervo that suoh l
“ ooablMt:on or COn80ildntieBm **is BOt**  draoaneud unlmr it **15 ;;f;ottd**  **iB** ona ol the sethods prohibited by the **swtutr** lt-

. 

### Th. flrrt method tiflaed &nd aade illoel 1s vhen it 

### ia rought to brlq 

### *the dlreotlon of th l if8lrs of **tvo** OP **8OPO** OOP~~tiOBS **Mdsr t&**  **8&W B5lrr~vlseBt**  **OP** OOn$POl **an&** vhero such **COR~OIL 55bpc)gMOBt**  

### tends to **Orebte 5**  **tx ’** **ust.** 

### Obvlourly **this** 

### prohibition vould **not oover**  l 

### trUs@otlon betvecn an uctive corpotitlon and OM vhlch 18 dlrsolred and in **process** 

### of llquidbtlon.

Too, NP. **sust:oe** 

### Pewnn of the **T*rrrs** 

### Suplww Court, has pointed **out** 

### t&t **on5 OS**  

### the **5855nttil** rleaents **10 -king**  l 

### crse under 

### this subdlvlalon vould bo tJm proved existence o f l 

### dealgned bnd united **ooopemtioa of**  **the** offeadlly( agen

### ales to moonpUsh the 

### u0Uvfu.l **puppora.** 

### 80 s8ld in **part I**  **-**.\ 

## 773

xonoPab& ?. t. Qmhm, paa* J

**I**



### ... Xn **order** 

### to ooartltuto 8 truot,

vlth**fD tb**  **UDfM Of**  **kh. 8WtUt8**  tbs?l **atrt- •**  

### 'ocaablmlloa

of $4&~iUl,



# l klli OS **aata br**  two OP aore.n Wcmbilytlo8,~ aa hart, uaad, waaua w&ion **or** aaaoa*tiatt. x r t he r e be DO p a i w l a M- o UtW **by 0~**  **w ran**  **at sklr**  **‘ arpital,**  

### ekill or l a t a ,í tw r e m a be a@ o a bl m tio &í

m a 4 he Do * m a ‘ traat. ’ **VheD ua**  **amtdar tha**  **p-98 forr**  **uh%ak%ha ‘** **aa8biutADD ’**  **aas8 be**  **for80& to**  

### em r itki s

t he l **tStUte, t&e**  **oaeSat%Sl m5Sning**  **Of tb**  **UWd ‘** **OdlDio*tiOD,** **’ unb**  

### tb **fD8t -t**  l **paDiObOD% t8**  **~#BW:kd ior**  

### ueh **dry th6l**  **k&** $?a09 aoatlnaea in exiateaea, va bra led to the ooaolDalm t&St the aDieD or Damaution of '84pl. uq, a&ill 01 out0 draarmwd i8 l?hmM the pnst100 I.DI& gutieular baa 

### deal&Dad the aaited 

### a*r wti# Of bWh bgOWfS8, ~rtriCh R@ht &VO k.8 o ch wv* t8 d a 

### doat a d 

### eapetiDg, f or

### tb* lu**oaa w**  **8oPe of**  **SDOh paPpoaeo** * **x00*?,** 

### 39 **8. v.**  **IOn.** 

### Theaaeoa4

wthod of ‘oo8blmtlaa 

### 6P muO1ibrtiOee that 

### 1 0 de a o u n ed

l a vhwr OD a o o Pp w~tiq n

l oqu%Ma 

### t3n

*- $1641 gropartiea af *aother 00?pomt10n to? #&a 

### parpoee of **prov.Et~ Qo**  **1WbS&il?& S3**  **ShWS the**  **OffSOt Ot**  **OUSh SSqUi8:-**  tion 

### toDda

to l rroot 8 **b55ea** or8EqietltleP. ’

**h V#u**  **8Sttd irr**  **-XaO.**

**The** us+tfoo **you** mire **UDbr 8obhtViOiDD**  **2** 

### awae **to**



### I D ar l8il a P

l ba8tleE hem or&e & Pp a POt:~

MQU iMd t b l**588tO WXt**  **ph aadmr**  **vhieh wu**  **about to**  dlreolve **u ar**  **180~ f~PCf~?ti?H**  **Oi** 80 out of bue&aee 

### and 1av01vlag

#&Lovoa7l

Utate, theFartUwth 

### CeuPt or Clvll Appwla mid:

w

**. .**  **. (the**  **oqmatloa)**

**. .**  **.** Md 

### detar8fn.d **to bl8801Va,**  **it oe?tbiDly**  

### h8d **thr rl&t**  **to** 

### da **80 aDdeP**  **Ibn lav,**  **red tha**  **al*** **(te a**  **0Q8pet:tw) UD** 

ue tolbu, se va mast, the deal*Jatlma of tha **Co-85** 

### OD this 

### l

**ubjort. A~glied**  **I*** **yWP rUtO888t**  **hSP8, B**  **0-P-Y aa**  **a s-t**  **89 p**  **wit of**  bwlneee **@ad to**  **die art**  LOO. **CampMyA MS**  l 

### right to piualrrea_ ~.i..

.,.: 

## 774

bemwlr to do **so** 

### vi11**orlther** peveat aor lersso cempetltion.
**lo** reaashlq **thfa QOMlSS19a~**  uoa ac ep t a0 l6aurete 

### sad tzuathermulta et 79~ 

## rbbdim to the rfiaet tbt t&a 

### 10 00 doal&a'aa @#~80, ne UaitOd

eOOp?Otl~ to ofrea8veat

lm lau. Skew, 

### lo rushelrmmmmaea, n &me coeolm%edthr **OLVll 8ktuW8**  Ue net VlOlbted 

### 1% fO~3~8 **t&t the**  **SStr** tiaa?lbe& 

### Us no0 dancuiiea& b7 is. ehil4r proviaioslr~,oS the ,PWl Cede.



### Xiiadb ..-,d.