From: Graves, Linda 

Sent: Thursday, April 29, 2010 7:42 PM 

To: Graves, Linda; Edwards, Brenda 

Cc: Cymbalsky, John 

Subject: Fluorescent lamp ballast test procedure and energy conservation standard preliminary analysis

Dear Stakeholders,

DOE conducted a fluorescent lamp ballast public meeting on Monday, April 26, 2010. At the meeting, we 

indicated that parts of the rulemaking preliminary technical support document (TSD) would be revised and 

re-posted on the web. DOE has posted a revised appendix 5C for the energy conservation standard 

preliminary analysis TSD, which adds catalog data for each of the ballasts DOE tested. Appendix 5C is 

also available in MS-Excel format under the preliminary analytical tools section at:

http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_lamp_ballasts_ecs_pr

elim_analytical_tools.html

In addition, DOE has posted a revised executive summary (ES), chapter 8 (Life-Cycle Cost and Payback 

Period Analyses, LCC-PBP), and chapter 9 (Shipments Analysis) for the preliminary TSD. These revised 

chapters correspond with minor corrections to the LCC-PBP spreadsheet, and resulting corrections to 

table ES.2.8, and tables 8.5.1 through 8.5.15. DOE also reconciled Tables ES.2.9 through ES.2.12 with 

corresponding tables in chapter 10 (tables 10.5.2 through 10.5.5). In chapter 9, DOE clarified the 

language introducing tables 9.5.1 and 9.5.2 to distinguish product candidate standard levels (CSLs in the 

first column of the tables) from shipment impacts under potential CSL standards cases.

The revised preliminary TSD materials can be found at:

http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_lamp_ballasts.html

 

Linda Graves

Lighting Standards Project Manager

Building Technologies Program

Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy

1000 Independence Ave., SW, EE-2J

Washington , DC 20585-0121

202-586-1851

 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
3-30-2010 Additional stakeholders to add to list 

aacevedo@LCDL.com 

aaron@feit.com 

acting@actingelectric.com 

adecker@hfc-law.com 

adelaski@standardsASAP.org 

Adelaski1@aol.com 

adman@sternerlighting.com 

adrian@bekolite.com 

agarcia@fulham.com 

akozachuk@canlyte.com 

alex.boesenberg@nema.org 

alison.lehr@navigantconsulting.com 

Allen.Roo@emerson.com 

allison.ober@zumtobelstaff.com 

alllighting@earthlink.com 

amoore@sms-results.com 

Andre.Gondouin@navigantconsulting.com 

andrew@barbican.ca 

andy.albrecht@ge.com 

angela.maddox@cooperindustries.com 

applications@insightlighting.com 

areade@darbylaw.com 

arron@feit.com 

artilight@coqui.net 

asalomon@specialtylightingindustries.com 

babtain@al-babtain-himb.com 

baker.alex@epa.gov 

banwell.peter@epa.gov 

Barry.Ruderman@genesismfginc.com 

barry@lamarlighting.com 

bart.ideker@cooperindustries.com 

bartolomeila@depsci.com 

bbrown@kurtversen.com 

bbyrne@hunterfan.com 

bc@bulbrite.com 

bcastelli@ase.org 

bcatone@guthlighting.com 

bchaves@brokerpower.com 

Bchrisma@energy.state.ca.us 

benoitbeylier@airstar-light.com 

bgriffin@shakespeare-ce.com 

bhartnett@visionairelighting.com 

bhein@visionairelighting.com 

bierma2@rpi.edu 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
bob.gray@depsci.com 

bobc@tapconet.com 

bobf@eclipselightinginc.com 

bolingn@depsci.com 

bre.marsh@charter.net 

bremar@atlanta.tcdnet.dk 

Brenda.Edwards@ee.doe.gov 

brenda@betacalco.com 

brent.eastwood@sylvania.com 

brian.dundon@philips.com 

brian_lips@ncsu.edu 

bronsj@rpi.edu 

bruce@fclighting.com 

BudDrago@aol.com 

buzz@barbican.ca 

c.hammelef@genlytegroup.com 

c.miller@nist.gov 

canmktg@thomascanada.com 

Carol@topaz-usa.com 

carygarris@bellsouth.net 

cbrauks@jjisa.com 

cc@bulbrite.com 

ccalwell@ecosconsulting.com 

cdavenport@itsqs.com 

cenglish@lithonia.com 

cgfdesign@aol.com 

cgonzalez@minkagroup.net 

chatt@genlytegroup.com

chenxp@cnsis.info 

cheryl.english@acuitybrands.com 

chip.taylor@cooperindustries.com 

cholstein@universalballast.com 

chuckh@vistapro.com 

comments@lithonia.com 

ContactUs@indyltg.com 

contech@con-teclighting.com 

craig@3glighting.com 

Cruzp@vistapro.com 

csteeby@ebw-electronics.com 

curt@brownlee.com 

customer.service@voltarc.com 

customerservice@lightsofaustralia.com 

customerservice@litetronics.com 

customerservice@turolight.com 

czanella@lumec.com 

d.mohen@airstar-light.com 

dan.mendicina@philips.com 

daniel@vertexlighting.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
dannyl@hew.com 

Dave.Brook@state.or.us 

david.greening@sylvania.com 

david.nesting@philips.com 

david_wypasek@adlt.com 

Dbeck@energy.state.ca.us 

Debbie.Jeffers@ee.doe.gov 

del@softlite.com 

denis.lynch@ge.com 

detlin@etlin.com 

dgoldstein@nrdc.org 

dhillman@ace-ballast.com 

director@nalmco.org 

djeffers@cheyennehomefurnishings.com 

donna_bard@adlt.com 

drossin@navigantconsulting.com 

dsimpson@gardcolighting.com 

dswisha@electrix.com 

dupton@americanlightingassoc.com 

earl.jones@appl.ge.com 

edw_gray@nema.org 

edward.yandek@ge.com 

eiko@eiko-ltd.com 

elizabeth.kohl@hq.doe.gov 

elizabeth@tmslighting.com 

elizars@lightology.com 

elp2@aol.com 

emily.edwards@sylvania.com 

eric@tslight.com 

fanara.andrew@epa.gov 

frank.latassa@philips.com 

Freitag@dcolighting.com 

gabe_casillas@ameron.com 

gail@auroralampworks.com 

gallight@emirates.net.ae 

gary@minkadg.com.cn 

gavin.mccormick@pnl.gov 

gbf1@pge.com 

gerald.bertsch@northwestern.com 

gflamm@energy.state.ca.us 

gjw@gsld.net 

gkonieczny@con-techlighting.com 

glen.schauer@sylvania.com 

glenn.gooderham@ardon.com 

gleopold@whatley.com 

gmosby1@comcast.net 

gnmarket@yankon.com 

graham.parker@pnl.gov 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
grant.williams@pnl.gov 

greg.alaura@barronltg.com 

greg@trace-lite.com 

grimm@spilighting.com 

gstanley@diablo-technologies.com 

Hakan.Dahlfors@swedishtrade.se 

hansi.mueller@selux.com 

harry@millslighting.com 

hatch@hatchtransformers.com 

Helen.Hayes@Staples.com 

Hingea@aol.com 

Howard.Wolfman@sylvania.com 

ic@interlectric.com 

iluminaciom@prommsa.com.mx 

inductionlighting@aol.com 

info.us@erco.com 

info@aamsco.com 

INFO@AEROLIGHTS.COM 

info@alslights.com 

info@artemide.us 

info@belfer.com 

info@bklighting.com 

info@bulbrite.com 

info@canlyte.com 

info@capriomegalighting.com 

info@colelighting.com 

info@daybritelighting.com 

info@duro-test.com 

info@energielighting.com 

info@energywisegroup.com 

info@fulham.com 

info@globe-electric.com 

info@halcolighting.com 

info@hessamerica.com 

info@hew.com 

info@icof.com 

info@kania.us 

info@kelsey-kane.com 

info@kirlinlighting.com 

info@lightology.com 

info@liteenergy.com 

info@louispoulsen.com 

info@lumid.com 

info@luraline.com 

info@luxurylighting.com 

info@modularinternational.com 

info@pani.com 

info@promolux.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
info@rambusch.com 

info@rigalite.com 

info@satco.com 

info@schrederinc.com 

info@sheedlight.com 

info@spacecannon.com 

info@sperolighting.com 

info@starfirelighting.com 

info@sternberglighting.com 

info@stll.com 

info@swivelier.com 

info@tprlights.com 

info@vandalshields.com 

info@westinghouselighting.com 

info@winonalighting.com 

inviainc@aol.com 

ira@keystoneballast.com 

Isi@lightingsciences.com 

iwasaki-ibd@eye.co.jp 

jack@starfirelighting.com 

jacki.swiernik@intertek.com 

jaddario@dos.state.ny.us 

james_schoolenberg@adlt.com 

jason.hong@cooperindustries.com 

jberardi@wildfirefx.com 

Jcalvin@SpawGlass.com 

jcolant@tcpi.com 

jdobbie@kimlighting.com 

jdsmith@usa.com 

jean.getsy@crouse-hinds.com 

jennifer@atrlighting.com 

jerry.puracchio@sylvania.com 

jerry@lamparts.com 

jferko@cox.net 

jfowler@jjierie.com 

jguarino@kenall.com 

jhanson@etcconnect.com 

jharris@nwalliance.org 

Jholland@energy.state.ca.us 

jim.cyre@philips.com 

jim.oetken@sylvania.com 

Jim.Raba@ee.doe.gov 

Jim.Rannels@ee.doe.gov 

jim_morgan77@yahoo.com 

jimchao@sunpkco.com 

JimW@AZcommerce.com 

jkharrison@gmail.com 

jkingman@navigantconsulting.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
jkinney@bakerdonelson.com 

jkoeppe@phoenixproducts.com 

JLeppert@AmericanElectricLighting.com 

joe@forumlighting.com 

joelle@fullspectrumsolutions.com 

John.Becker@state.vt.us 

john.selander@acuitybrands.com 

jon.digesu@sylvania.com 

JonesRobbA@JohnDeere.com 

joseph.howley@ge.com 

jrains@rllight.com 

jronk@unvlt.com 

jsiegel@epl.com 

jsteinberg@techlighting.com 

julie.vizard@us.schott.com 

Justin.calvin@spawglass.com 

Jvirskus@fcgov.com 

jwilliams@mastercraft-lamps.com 

jwrockportdesign@aol.com 

jzaro@amerlux.com 

kackerly@aceee.org 

kcallahan@ase.org 

kcarberry@visalighting.com 

kdelves@nrcan.gc.ca 

keith.cook@philips.com 

keith.hall@cooperindustries.com 

kelly.gordon@pnl.gov 

ken@craftmetal.com 

ken@xtralight.com 

Khouser@unl.edu 

killark@hep.hubbell.com 

kimberly.kishpaugh@luxous.com 

klc@lumaxlighting.com 

kohalmia@westinghouselighting.com 

kortega@elplighting.com 

kosowsky@sprynet.com 

krisle@depsci.com 

krissmith@hanoverlantern.com 

kyle_pitsor@nema.org 

Lal.Rajat@bcg.com 

larry.beck@martin.dk 

larry.knab@nist.gov 

larry@tempestlighting.com 

lcordes@ase.org 

LegoZ81@a5.com 

lgb@leonbillings.com 

lightech@earthlink.net 

lighting@ieee.org 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
lighting@musco.com 

lighting@simkar.com 

lighting@solaballast.com 

lightingforensic@aol.com 

lights@coloradolighting.com 

lilia@solaballast.com 

Linda.Graves@ee.doe.gov 

lisamarie@tslight.com 

lloyd.reeder@lsi-industries.com 

LLVanWie@lbl.gov 

loa@lightsofaustralia.com 

lsi@lightingsciences.com 

luxonlighting@vsnl.net 

LYNDERSM@westinghouselighting.com 

Mahima.Gupta@navigantconsulting.com 

mail@wildfirefx.com 

makarand.chipalkatti@sylvania.com 

mando@lamparts.com 

mark.chu@grandrich.com 

mark.duffy@ge.com 

Mark.Friedrichs@hq.doe.gov 

mark.shepard@ge.com 

mark@mgvinc.com 

marketing@elliptipar.com 

marketing@novitas.com 

marketing@prescolite.com 

marvin@sentrylighting.com 

mary.gotti@lighting.ge.com 

mary@egl-neon.com 

matt_mazzola@adlt.com 

matt04@thuls.com 

matthew.walker@navigantconsulting.com 

Maureen Murphy@ee.doe.gov 

mbooth@cheyennehomefurnishings.com 

mcaiazza@emessdessign.com 

melhc@consumerfed.org 

mexluz@prodigy.net.mx 

mhertel@lightolier.com 

Mhoye@icfi.com 

Michael.D.Chenard@Lowes.com 

Michael.Lake@ee.doe.gov

michael.leyva@novalighting.org 

michael.myer@pnl.gov 

mike.simacek@grandrich.com 

mike@starlightingproducts.com 

minda.matthews@lsi-industries.com 

mitch.hand@acuitybrands.com 

mjdufresne@sistemalux.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
mmartin@energy.state.ca.us 

mmoisin@luxep.com 

mriebling@genlytegroup.com 

MSAVINI@ALTMANLTG.COM 

naburke@hubbell-ltg.com 

ncohen@luminis.com 

nhorowitz@nrdc.org 

nora@noralighting.com 

obera@zumtobelstaff.com 

ojones@consumertesting.com 

optilight@mindspring.com 

pad@nyserda.org 

pamela.horner@sylvania.com 

pat.mikucki@philips.com 

paul.salvi@sylvania.com 

paul@strong-lighting.com 

paul@voigtlighting.com 

paulg@americanlightingcompany.com 

pcampbell@hfc-law.com 

PCBelding@spectrusinc.com 

pemco@ix.netcom.com 

peter.leitner@xal.com 

PHagen@bdlaw.com 

pileblan@NRCan.gc.ca 

pjanko@lumenelle.com 

ple2@pge.com 

pmustone@reflexlighting.com 

prasad.sastry@voltarc.com 

prescolitemarketing@prescolite.com 

prof@jjisa.com 

progress@progresslighting.com 

ptreadway@Minka.com 

PublicSolutions@earthlink.net 

qsl@qualite.com 

questions@pqlighting.com 

raffi@duralamp.com 

rchikami@ushio.com 

rdearmond@minkagroup.net 

rfoster@cee1.org 

RGraham@EPRI.com 

rharrold@iesna.org 

richard.barton@lighting.ge.com 

richard.heinisch@lithonia.com 

Richard.Karney@ee.doe.gov 

rlambert@venteselectra.com 

rminchin@sternberglighting.com 

rms@aerolights.com 

rob@lightech.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
robert.carmichael@navigantconsulting.com 

robert.cilic@sylvania.com 

Robert.Lingard@pnl.gov 

roger.belanger@sylvania.com 

ron.harris@sylvania.com 

ron_runkles@nema.org 

ronald.paduchak@ge.com 

roy@minkadg.com.cn 

rstummer@nslights.com 

rutand@mail.welchallyn.com 

salary@lumid.com 

sale@pholighting.com 

sales@arclightingsystems.com 

sales@auroralight.com 

sales@elcolighting.com 

sales@fullspectrumsolutions.com 

sales@glasscoat.com 

sales@inconlighting.com 

sales@kingluminaire.com 

sales@litelab.com 

sales@lumaxlighting.com 

sales@lumenform.com 

sales@mailLSI.com 

Sales@NationalCathode.com 

sales@pathwaylighting.com 

sales@spectralighting.com 

sales@sunriselights.com 

sales@teronlight.com 

sales@whatley.com 

sam.loggia@csa.ca 

sandra.weil@philips.com 

sarahc@rebellelighting.com 

sashiller@gmail.com 

sbellovin@legionlighting.com 

sclarkart@earthlink.net 

Scoakley@neep.org 

sean.tham@waclighting.com 

sedap.usa@sedap.com 

service@eyelighting.com 

sguyatt@stresscrete.com 

shaileviton@paraflex.com 

shannon.vaughn@ge.com 

sharmilakumbhat@yahoo.com 

Shawn.holmes@hessamerica.com 

SHilton@Howard-ind.com 

shirin@dmflighting.com 

sima@soleracorp.com 

sjensen@iotaengineering.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
slsandi@speclight.com 

smicucci@oxygenlighting.com 

smosley@pinnacle-ltg.com 

sschneider@winonalighting.com 

sstern@energy-solution.com 

Steve.Karg@acuitybrands.com 

steve_morelli@beta-lighting.com 

steve_morelli@kramerlighting.com 

steve_morelli@ruudlighting.com 

stevel@lycian.com 

stltg@aol.com 

Stonierm@pennglobe.com 

sunny.ho@smc.com.hk 

superhid@163.net 

surya@sroshni.com 

susan.atc.bloom@philips.com 

Susan.bloom@philips.com 

talithac@globe-electric.com 

talktous@cooperlighting.com 

tcriveau@theocl.com 

teckman@nwcouncil.org 

TheLampDude@aol.com 

TheLampoDude@aol.com 

Thomas.heckmann@us.bureauveritas.com 

thomas.leyh@philips.com 

thomas.stoll@philips.com 

tim@aeilighting.com 

tim@formanandassociates.com 

tleonard@leviton.com 

tlowe@kingoffans.com 

tom.hackett@sylvania.com 

tom.salpietra@antiquestreetlamps.com 

TomG@quoizel.com 

tonja@atlaslightinproducts.com 

trevor.peyton@ruud.ca 

tshaffer@jjisa.com 

tsmcneil@aol.com 

tstone@kurtversen.com 

tusa@tivolind.com 

twoods@fulham.com 

ulsmmrm@adelphia.net 

uninex@uninex.com 

us@e3light.com 

ushio@ushio.com 

vbaldwin@genlyte.com 

venture@adlt.com 

verplank@spilighting.com 

vivian@minkadg.com.cn 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
vkniffin@holophane.com 

voigtlight@aol.com 

vs-us@vsus.vossloh-schwabe.com 

vwittmann@qlty.com 

WEBdomino@prescolite.com 

Wendy.Littman@eesllc.net 

Wes.Anderson@ee.doe.gov 

wfharris@wfharris.com 

william@vaxcel.com.cn 

Williams@mastercraft-lamps.com 

wrightb@westinghouselighting.com 

xiao.wang@intertek.com 

ysung@maxlite.com 

zhouy@rpi.edu 

zoppp@litelab.com 

Brenda’s list as of 3/30/2010:

rlyford@americanlighting.com 

kmackenzie@genlyte.com 

jim.mapp@doa.state.wi.us 

Michael.McCabe@ee.doe.gov 

hmisuriello@ase.org 

Alyssa.Morrissey@ee.doe.gov 

remortaz@NRCan.gc.ca 

gmurphy@maxlite.com 

snadel@aceee.org 

Anelkin@halco.com 

bruce.nelson@state.mn.us 

Hnewsome@FTC.gov 

ohno@nist.gov 

ldoquinn@cox.net 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
orourc@rpi.edu 

Jennifer.Owen@ee.doe.gov 

rpelino@robertsonww.com 

rachele.petrella@us.bureauveritas.com 

Francine.Pinto@hq.doe.gov 

kyl_pitsor@nema.org 

ted@energy-solution.com 

bprindle@aceee.org 

ream@rpi.edu 

pjr@nyserda.org 

eric.richman@pnl.gov 

kur_riesenberg@nema.org 

MRivest@navigantconsulting.com 

srosenstock@eei.org 

bobr@aamsco.com 

harvey_sachs@aceee.org 

robert.saint@nreca.org 

MScholand@navigantconsulting.com 

jschwartz@icfi.com 

dshiller@maxlite.com 

jeanlys@keystore.org 

bill.smelser@lithonia.com 

pet_smeltzer@nema.org 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
elissa.sobolewski@nist.gov 

Eric.Stas@hq.doe.gov 

brooke@necanet.org 

mike.stein@worldnet.att.net 

psullivan@universalballast.com 

Richard_P._Theroux@omb.eop.gov 

brinda.thomas@navigantconsulting.com 

mtimmings@canlyte.com 

gtraphagen@robertsonww.com 

marsha@iald.org 

cra_updyke@nema.org 

paul.walitsky@gmail.com 

paul.waide@iea.org 

daniel_whitten@platts.com 

jwilson@energy.state.ca.us 

Stephen.Witkowski@ee.doe.gov 

fwood@onlocationinc.com 

dale.work@philips.com 

edward.yandek@lighting.ge.com 

jyorgey@lutron.com 

dee_zamora@nema.org 

Susan.Anderson@sylvania.com 

tom.bosworth@philips.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24
bob.erhardt@philips.com 

phakkarainen@lutron.com 

rich.hanlon@sylvania.com 

david.kachmarik@ge.com 

Alison.lehr@navigantconsulting.com 

slydecker@lithonia.com 

joseph.mccormick@sylvania.com 

rnachtrieb@lutron.com 

jeffrey.plaskon@lighting.ge.com 

himamshu.prasad@ge.com 

TRIBARI1@irf.com 

christopher.sequeira@navigantconsulting.com 

brian.sok@philips.com 

edward.thomas@ge.com 

matthew.walker@navigantconsulting.com 

gary.wallpe@acuitybrands.com 

david.zizzi@lithonia.com 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 COMMENT 24