7KLV GHFLVLRQ ZDV RULJLQDOO\ LVVXHG DV DQ 3XQSXEOLVKHG GHFLVLRQ ́ILOHG RQ $XJXVW   2Q 2FWREHU   WKH FRXUW GHVLJQDWHG WKHRSLQLRQ DV RQH UHFRPPHQGHG IRU IXOOWH[W SXEOLFDWLRQ5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS	

			



1,7('7$7(6 2)0(5,&$	

8$1(<(68$1 &(9('2	

 !
"# $	  %&#% #' ( !% "&#% #' )#'!#*" & # ++,-.,/0 "$&#% #' ($**($1(*(% .22&'#$$"$#$1(*(% 2+222
7KH+RQRUDEOH ) $ /LWWOH -U 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW -XGJH IRU WKH:HVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI /RXLVLDQD VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ31	


"$34&#'(#($*%54
4&#% #' ($*	 6"7"$89"$#$%)#'!#*"" : !")%#		
	

&	 ; & #  )#'!#*"   
   $("$ %  3< # < )#'!#*" "   : !" ) %# 		
	 

&	;& # )#'!#*"

 #'(#  ($*  #" "("'6$%  !#"$# ("$ !$$"<#"*#" =% #" % %#$>($*" ("$(.?0@A!#%'%#%%( '##"# (' #"("$2
	BCD"&'0C++("<%$*(# < '"%##"* %%%%E# !#" "  $#% #0( "$ $#% #0( #>("F(%("  !#%*" <%*$ # !#%#" % #" <(%$ '#  !"% #"'($#"*   < ' $   ,2 "(% "G%"("22+++ !$#% #' '( " $##"<$# (*$#"* ! <!96"" *6" #' !'"  $# ( 8"E" " #<#" % $ #%#"'($#"*<%=%E#
 ! %"' #"% % " $ 06 !#% #% "  "'%%#< "0(%$#%' #"
 ! !*#"*%"% !>($*"  !$#% #' '(#%
' %1H?@E! ! ! <=%#(#%$( E#("%%0$# !( 5?2@E! ! !$6%<E%>($#'$0< !$#%#%%$ <=%'"$(' 5?D@E! ! !$#%#%%$ < E% E"$ !  #(  '  '($ $ $#%#%%5 "$ ?-@ E! ! %% $% #' %"' #"% E#%$'"%#$$0$#%#%%E%$$I	  
,. D$DC+D.D ?. !#+++@ !(*!""' #%$#%%# #6$#%#%%#% # ! '$ $"%  % $<  '" ('#(%'"$('  '6$ !% ! 0($"  %!E#"* !  !#% #( '< E% $(  #"0## < "  E#("%%  0$ # !  !"
 !"-22$ C C- ?. ! # +@  !(% #  #% %($ !$#%#%%#%" "0(%$#%' #"# ! <!% !0## <  '< E# !  $#%'6< $ 0(  $% " #"  !% "  $ "< !#"*  6' !#%%( #" #"  $#$ "  # !#%  # #" (" # #6" !%!#% E#=%$ !"$#$! G#"!E!#% !=%#"%%#$$!#%0## < * ! !"'%%<$'(" %'#%"*(*0#"$ '$8#"*0( !$#$" G#"E!<!$#$" %#*" !0"8( !#J #"%"$%"$ !"#" #<%!#"% !!
"# $	  %'($%8 !$'(" %# %("%=%'"$(' #%% #0( 0 !#%'#" #$
%&D,
	.2..DDD-?+.2@5'D$D.,.+ $ !  ! ' % '!"* ! %(   ! 
"# $ %%($>($#'#" ! # '($" '<E# ! !$#% #'  '( =% 	 0 C 2 $#%'6< $$#"A# !( "%E% $'(" K(% % !96"" '($"  %'!$( $%# #"%   ! $#%'6<   !(*!#" $#$" !6#E"#"* !
"# $	  %=% #" % #86#$$%" #''D$ D.?!$#"* !  !" '($" '#"'8" #'E! !$"$" !$#$ #" $#%#%%@#"< !(*! !$#% #' '( $#$" G%%<'"%#$
D%#"$<%"$ ("'6$ !%#"$<%"(*(% ++++("'6$#$ # #""$'#%E" <$$!$  ! <""(<D2 !
"# $	  % %6$ K(%  $(' #"$'(" %("'6$	'##'< !
"# $	  %%(*! $#%'6< $ '6$=%'# ! !E% !(E" ! <!K(% $$'(" %E0$('$E# !#" !# <$<%0<)'!2")<C2 !
"# $	  %%"   '("%$6#%#"* !# !96"" $#$" '#6 !K(#$%"%0<)<222 !
"# $	  %E($6$#%#%%!#% '#")<2-2#" =% "< G$  *6"" '("%#"$#' #"* ! !E($6#$! $'(" % "  0 )< 2. 2  
" !  #" =% "<%  $ ! !!$H'#6$'8*$'(" %G# <"#"'! !#'8<'#" I"$! !"$$ 6#E ! !#"*E% !'#"*!E6"(".2 !
"# $	  %#$ #" '$#%'6<!
"# $	  %K(% $'#%#" =%$ #"' G  ("% "$ $'(" % %!E#"* <" %$" ! < ,2"!
"# $ % % %(*!   #$#' %  " %   0"8''(" % " #6< %"("+2 !"# $	  %'#6$% !K(% $$'(" %"(" D 2 $(#"*  !"#' %  (% '""'#"  #"$#' $ !  ! !$ " $$# #" $'(" %6"   !$#%'6<K(% "("C2 !$#% #' '( " $%'!$(#"*$(%("  $#6F2.?@!$K(#$! $#%'6<#"'($#"*%"%% $#%'6<K(% %0' $0<	 0C2%"("C2!
"# $	  %$%'"$ K(%  $(' #"$'(" %!96"" %(*! '#%$'(" %%!E#"* !%('6#(%'%!<" %$ ! <"$K(% $ ! #" %#*"0"8( !#J #"-
7KH *RYHUQPHQW GLG QRW SURYLGH DQ\ DXWKRULW\ WR WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWLQ LWV PRWLRQ WR VWULNH FODLP RU IRU RWKHU DSSURSULDWH VDQFWLRQV%% !  !
"# $	  %'($0 #"0"8'$%"# %E" 6#< !%(' !("$%"(<,2E$<%  !%"%E%$(#" K(% $E$<% %"$"(<22*6""'("%'$#" =% "<0( '#6$"%"%"(<2.2 !96"" #$ #" % #8'# !# %"' #"%" (*(% 2 ! $#% #'  '(  %  !#"*  02,2" !96"" =% #" % #8#" #$ #%"%"$"(*(% D2!$#% #' '( =%'%"*'$#" =%'("% " #< !# !  ! !$ #%%$ ! %"% $( $  "$#"% (' $!# ! !'($# #"6 #  %"% ''"#$ 0< ! %"% "   !" 0  2  #"  % # $#$ "  '<  " 0 D 2 ! $#% #'  '(  *" $ ! 
"# $ %=% #" % #8'#"$'"'$ !%'!$($!#"*"	 02C2 !$#% #' '( " $#" $  # (  ! '(  " $ !  $(#"*$#%'6< !
"# $	  %K(% $ ! #" $('$'(" %%!E#"* !%(''%!(%$ ('!% ! < "$   #"  (%$  $(' "< %('!$'(" % !
"# $	  %6$ % #8!#%'#!'(  ( !" $ !  6"   ! '(  '" ' $!#% "< *#6!#$$# #" ##" $#$" !#"*!$#% #' '( $#$" #"$#' E!#'!'$( (#0%$ !$#%#%%""' 0C2#" #$ #" % %#$>($*" !#"*% <G'( #"("$$#6F.?0@?@"$?.@
" !  #"#" *$ !! !$   $  '< HE# ! !  $ "$0($"% K(% %  $#%'6< ("$$ 0< ! "<% !96"" I0( !$$##'( #%$('#"*! $'(" % 0'(%#" #% $< !#% "*#%!#%
+LV RQ LWV IDFH DSSURSULDWH RQO\ DV D GHIHQGDQW¶V UHPHG\ ZKLOH5XOH SURYLGHV PRUH H[SDQVLYH FRYHUDJH E\ FRPSUHKHQGLQJ GLVREHGLHQFH RISURGXFWLRQ RUGHUV E\ DQ\ SDUW\ ́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
"# $ 	  % $ E K(% %  $('$'(" % #" #$ %"$  !%'"$K(%  !*6""  #$ ! #" % #8 
" ! #" ! 
"# $ 	  % %" $ !  #    $ '" ' #" " E''%#"%5" (<,2"$*#" " (< 2 2  !(% ("$ ( D,?$@ "$?0@?2@?@ !$#% #' '( !$( !# < $#%#%% !'% " #6< !
"# $	  %*(% !  !$#% #' '(!$( !# < $#%#%%("$(D,?0@(-?0@"$# %#"!" ( !# <
"6#E#"*$#% #' '( =%$#%#%%("$# !(D,?0@?2@(-?0@E'"%#$(
,Q VXSSRUW RI WKLV DUJXPHQW &ODLPDQW FLWHV6RFLHWH ,QWHUQDWLRQDOH3RXU3DUWLFLSDWLRQV ,QGXVWULHOOHV (W &RPPHUFLDOHV 6$ Y 5RJHUV 86   ,Q5RJHUV WKH GLVWULFWFRXUW KDG EDVHG LWV GLVPLVVDOXSRQ 5XOH ELLL EHFDXVH WKH SDUW\ KDG QRW FRPSOLHG ZLWK DGLVFRYHU\ RUGHU 7KH &RXUW RI $SSHDOV KRZHYHU KDG XSKHOG WKHGLVPLVVDO XQGHU 5XOH E 7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KHOG WKDW 3WKHUH ZDV QRQHHG WR UHVRUW WR 5XOH E ́ EHFDXVH GLVPLVVDO ZDV EDVHG RQ3QRQFRPSOLDQFH ZLWK D GLVFRYHU\ RUGHU ́,GDW  7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUWDGGHG WKDW 5XOH E 3DSSHDUV LQ WKDW SDUW RI WKH 5XOHV FRQFHUQHG ZLWKWULDOV DQG ZKLFK ODFNV VSHFLILF UHIHUHQFHV WR GLVFRYHU\ )XUWKHU WKDW 5XOH( !#" #*"$%6#'0K(% % !
"# $	  %!*6"" =%K(% %E""(%"$'("% "#" #"$#' $ ! !!$"<H"#"'!I$'(" %  6#E)% # " < !$#% #'  '(  8 ! ("(%( %   '#"* #" =%'("% " #<!# ! !!$#%%$##"*$$#"0<%6E8%"$ !"E#"*!# # %"%0<	 02("%% #$#$" %"$	('!$#%*$  ! *'#(%"%%  ! $#% #'  '(  '" 0'"%#$$'" ('#(%'
(
!"D$D.-D.?. !#++,@!  !$#% #' '( $#$"  #'( # %'"%#$ #"%%%"' #"%$%"$#'  $#" %( ?" #"* !  !#%( !%"6!$ !  !$#% #' '( #%E# !( E $#%#%%'#" % !#% "$"<%"' #"%<" !0%#%'("%=%'"$(' @! "#$%#"  '" "$% !  ! $#% #'  '(  0(%$ # %$#%' #"#"$#%#%%#"*!#% %(#   ##"* ' #"$#%'6<0'(%!$#$" 6# "<$'#"*$#%'6<'# %(D,?0@?2@E!#'!!'#%E%$#% #' '(  $#%#%%"' #""<# <6# %"'#"*$#%'6<$#6 FD,?0@?2@?6#$#"*%"' #"%%8#"*#" %$%@A#*! L)#)""" B22+?++-@?HG' E!"E(D,?'@MN$ $#"++D#%(D,?0@(%(<!%"#' #"# !!%" 0"'( $I@
C&ODLPDQW KDV DEDQGRQHG RQ DSSHDO KLVFODLP IRU UHOLHI XQGHU 5XOHE ZKLFK DOORZV UHOLHI 3IRU DQ\ RWKHU UHDVRQV MXVWLI\LQJ UHOLHI IURPWKH RSHUDWLRQ RI WKH MXGJPHQW ́ )HG 5 &LY 3 E"$!#6%* $#% "'!#% "<"$ !'(   #"  $$$ !  ! $#$ "  8 $ #$ "$*"#J$ '$% "$ "$$ !#% '!#$"=% %%#% "'#"' #"* !"$#"<!%  $ ! !E%'#"*!#%#"<# !"' 0.2#" %6$!
"# $	  %E# ! !K(% $0"8( !#J #"%"&'022 !$#% #' '( $"#$ ! #"!$#% #' '(  ($ ! #"  #$  %!EG'(%0"*'   "<  ! %" !  >(% ##$ #  ""(<+2#" #$" #'	& !A6#E !$#% #' '( =%$"#(.?0@ #"0(%$#%' #"*
 +%	&*) 2-+D$C+C2-?. !#@"22	 .-D?2@
" !E$%E(% !6H$#"# "$#'"6#' #" !  ! #'('# $  '   >($*" I !  ?K(  #"# $@"  #"  %8% # ("$ ( .?0@?@E!#'! E%  $#% #'  '(   6'   #" >($*"0'(%  H#% 8 #"$6 "' %(#%  G'(%0"*' I!#%( !%%  $ ! (.?0@?@ #"#%#" "$$ 6#$##""< E%# ( #"%1?@E!" <!%$ " G'(%0#% 8 "  "<!%' $E# !( ( !# < ?2@E!" !>($*!%$%(0% " #6#% 8E' #" !#">($*" $"
"
',$22.D$-D-+?. !#2@#" 8%%6*(" %#" %% % !!#%'"$(' E%$( G'(%0"*' %'" "$%!  ! E '(  $  %(0% " #6 #% 8  E0'(%# '8$ !( !# < $#%#%%!#%%(# ! #%.
#" '" "$% ! 0'(%!$#$" 6# "<$'#"*$#%'6< !$#% #' '( E%" ( !#J$ $#%#%% !' #"'!"*% !("$<#"*$#%#%%"!#%**("$%E#" $#$" *(#% 8E#"!#%(.?0@ #" !(% ##"* %6 !#%%("%*"( !$"#(.?0@ #"$% "  "'%% 6#E  ! ("$<#"* >($*" '
'C+D$--2?. !#++C@?'(#@E60'(%!#%(.?0@ #"E% #$ E" <$<%   " <  ! ("$<#"* # ( E# !#" !#'0#$#%%(%*$#"* !("$<#"*$ % #8#"* '#  < 0 !#% (  *
*
,22$2D2DDDC?. !#+D@'#*#" !("$<#"*>($*" %E# !#"! $#"# #"  #% 8 ("$ ( .?0@?@ " 
+%$	%) -./0-.12,, 2$--+-C ?. !#+C@ ?'# #"**,22$ 2D-@' (###"#" #" #"% ! !#%"*' E%G'(%00'(%!$#$" 6# "<'( $!(%!K( %G'(%0"*'  '"%#$ #" !'(0## <' HE! !!  <=% #(  '  #" $#%'6< #% $( E#("%%0$# !( I'
(
D$D.-D...,?. !#++,@3'(% !K(% #"#%E! ! ! >($*"  %!($ 0 %  %#$ ("$ (.?0@?@"$" <E! ! !$#%#%%E%#! %'  ( #"K(#< #% "E  !  #% ("$ (.?0@?@   <(%  #%  $"%   G'(%0 "*'0  ! ' % %('! % E! !  $"$"  !% # #(% $"% "$ >($#'  ! #" # E# 0'"%#$$%#
"+ "3+,.2$2+2+2?. !#++2@% !#% (  !% !$ H $ #" #"  OG'(%0"*' =$%"  ("%<"E! ! !"!%$" ! !%"0<'($$ "%('#"'E# !
,$$#"5 !"' !'#" =%(% %0 8"#" ''(" I
+ 
+-D$,22,2-?. !#+++@?'# #"*
!


* 4"$"#5C,
	DD+.+,?++D@@A" $! HM N!	(( !%G%%<>' $%(**% #"6#(%<$0< !#%'(  ! O# E($0#"# "#JM !'#" %N !#%%#"% !# "<5=I" ! '" < ! (  !$ '#" % (%  H0 !$''(" 0  ! ' % "$ #%%#"%  !# '!%"'("%I! ?K( #"*C,
	  D+.+,@+" 
	
'6 &!"CD,PD$P22A4,.+D.. Q.?. !#(*222@?!$#"* ! "# !%  *#'#%''( #"0<'("%"#%#"   #" !E'"% # ( H#% 8I("$(.?0@?@@5)'78 ##
+*##	 
D$.,.C?. !#+++@?!$#"* ! " "<=%#% 8E#%" 0%#% (.?0@ #@'("%E%$# <#"6#$#"*#"# #$#%'6< !" !% # E%$(##"* 6#$( !K(% $$#%'6< "$#" ##"*  %"$  !
"# $ 	  %=% #"  % #8 6"   ! $#% #'  '(   
*" $"G "%#" # !(*!'("%*$ !#" =% ## $ "*#%! E% 0 #' !'8"E$*$'6$=%'!#$"%%#% $!##"% '#$ !  '6$ !$ 0" H0($"$ E# ! !#" #"%%  !#%  !I E! E% "%$  "(%#"*!E!!6#%# $!$#<("%#$ G#" !" ($( #" !'!E%K(#$ 6#$!E6* "$

	")'	+.2$.D.?. !#++2@?!$#"* !%($$"#"%%'("%E%" G'(%0"*' E!'("%$#$" 6#$$ #% !#%#"%%@ % !#%#( #%"%  ! #"0< !G "$$$($ '("%'8"E$*$#"!#%#$6#  ! !E%E !$$#"0(  ! !HE%("0   ! $$#"$(  !%% !0(%#"%% "$%"0(%#"%%I9#6" %('! 6*( G" #" !$#% #'  '( $#$"0(%# %$#%' #"E!"# $"#$(.?0@#0%$"#" =%#( $"%  G'(%0"*'