From: Graves, Linda

Sent: Thursday, April 29, 2010 7:42 PM To: Graves, Linda; Edwards, Brenda Cc: Cymbalsky, John Subject: Fluorescent lamp ballast test procedure and energy conservation standard preliminary analysis

Dear Stakeholders,

DOE conducted a fluorescent lamp ballast public meeting on Monday, April 26, 2010. At the meeting, we indicated that parts of the rulemaking preliminary technical support document (TSD) would be revised and

re -posted on the web. DOE has posted a revised appendix 5C for the energy conservation standard preliminary analysis TSD, which adds catalog data for each of the ballasts DOE tested. Appendix 5C is also available in MS-Excel format under the preliminary analytical tools section at:

http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_lamp_ballasts_ecs_pr elim_analytical_tools.html

In a ddition, DOE has posted a revised executive summary (ES), chapter 8 (Life-Cycle Cost and Payback Period Analyses, LCC-PBP), and chapter 9 (Shipments Analysis) for the preliminary TSD. These revised chapters correspond with minor corrections to the LCC-PBP spreadsheet, and resulting corrections to table ES.2.8, and tables 8.5.1 through 8.5.15. DOE also reconciled Tables ES.2.9 through ES.2.12 with corresponding tables in chapter 10 (tables 10.5.2 through 10.5.5). In chapter 9, DOE clarified the language introducing tables 9.5.1 and 9.5.2 to distinguish product candidate standard levels (CSLs in the first column of the tables) from shipment impacts under potential CSL standards cases.

The revised preliminary TSD materials can be found at:

http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_lamp_ballasts.html

Linda Graves Lighting Standards Project Manager Building Technologies Program Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy 1000 Independence Ave., SW, EE- 2J Washington , DC 20585-0121 202 -586-18513- 30 -2010 Additional stakeholders to add to list

aacevedo@LCDL.com aaron@feit.com acting@actingelectric.com adecker@hfc-law.com adelaski@standardsASAP.org Adelaski1@aol.com adman@sternerlighting.com adrian@bekolite.com agarcia@fulham.com akozachuk@canlyte.com alex.boesenberg@nema.org alison.lehr@navigantconsulting.com Allen.Roo@emerson.com allison.ober@zumtobelstaff.com alllighting@earthlink.com amoore@sms-results.com Andre.Gondouin@navigantconsulting.com andrew@barbican.ca andy.albrecht@ge.com angela.maddox@cooperindustries.com applications@insightlighting.com areade@darbylaw.com arron@feit.com artilight@coqui.net asalomon@specialtylightingindustries.com babtain@al-babtain-himb.com baker.alex@epa.gov banwell.peter@epa.gov Barry.Ruderman@genesismfginc.com barry@lamarlighting.com bart.ideker@cooperindustries.com bartolomeila@depsci.com bbrown@kurtversen.com bbyrne@hunterfan.com bc@bulbrite.com bcastelli@ase.org bcatone@guthlighting.com bchaves@brokerpower.com Bchrisma@energy.state.ca.us benoitbeylier@airstar-light.com bgriffin@shakespeare-ce.com bhartnett@visionairelighting.com bhein@visionairelighting.com bierma2@rpi.edubob.gray@depsci.com

bobc@tapconet.com bobf@eclipselightinginc.com bolingn@depsci.com bre.marsh@charter.net bremar@atlanta.tcdnet.dk Brenda.Edwards@ee.doe.gov brenda@betacalco.com brent.eastwood@sylvania.com brian.dundon@philips.com brian_lips@ncsu.edu bronsj@rpi.edu bruce@fclighting.com BudDrago@aol.com buzz@barbican.ca c.hammelef@genlytegroup.com c.miller@nist.gov canmktg@thomascanada.com Carol@topaz-usa.com carygarris@bellsouth.net cbrauks@jjisa.com cc@bulbrite.com ccalwell@ecosconsulting.com cdavenport@itsqs.com cenglish@lithonia.com cgfdesign@aol.com cgonzalez@minkagroup.net chatt@genlytegroup.c om chenxp@cnsis.info cheryl.english@acuitybrands.com chip.taylor@cooperindustries.com cholstein@universalballast.com chuckh@vistapro.com comments@lithonia.com ContactUs@indyltg.com contech@con-teclighting.com craig@3glighting.com Cruzp@vistapro.com csteeby@ebw-electronics.com curt@brownlee.com customer.service@voltarc.com customerservice@lightsofaustralia.com customerservice@litetronics.com customerservice@turolight.com czanella@lumec.com d.mohen@airstar-light.com dan.mendicina@philips.com daniel@vertexlighting.comdannyl@hew.com

Dave.Brook@state.or.us david.greening@sylvania.com david.nesting@philips.com david_wypasek@adlt.com Dbeck@energy.state.ca.us Debbie.Jeffers@ee.doe.gov del@softlite.com denis.lynch@ge.com detlin@etlin.com dgoldstein@nrdc.org dhillman@ace-ballast.com director@nalmco.org djeffers@cheyennehomefurnishings.com donna_bard@adlt.com drossin@navigantconsulting.com dsimpson@gardcolighting.com dswisha@electrix.com dupton@americanlightingassoc.com earl.jones@appl.ge.com edw_gray@nema.org edward.yandek@ge.com eiko@eiko-ltd.com elizabeth.kohl@hq.doe.gov elizabeth@tmslighting.com elizars@lightology.com elp2@aol.com emily.edwards@sylvania.com eric@tslight.com fanara.andrew@epa.gov frank.latassa@philips.com Freitag@dcolighting.com gabe_casillas@ameron.com gail@auroralampworks.com gallight@emirates.net.ae gary@minkadg.com.cn gavin.mccormick@pnl.gov gbf1@pge.com gerald.bertsch@northwestern.com gflamm@energy.state.ca.us gjw@gsld.net gkonieczny@con-techlighting.com glen.schauer@sylvania.com glenn.gooderham@ardon.com gleopold@whatley.com gmosby1@comcast.net gnmarket@yankon.com graham.parker@pnl.govgrant.williams@pnl.gov

greg.alaura@barronltg.com greg@trace-lite.com grimm@spilighting.com gstanley@diablo-technologies.com Hakan.Dahlfors@swedishtrade.se hansi.mueller@selux.com harry@millslighting.com hatch@hatchtransformers.com Helen.Hayes@Staples.com Hingea@aol.com Howard.Wolfman@sylvania.com ic@interlectric.com iluminaciom@prommsa.com.mx inductionlighting@aol.com info.us@erco.com info@aamsco.com INFO@AEROLIGHTS.COM info@alslights.com info@artemide.us info@belfer.com info@bklighting.com info@bulbrite.com info@canlyte.com info@capriomegalighting.com info@colelighting.com info@daybritelighting.com info@duro-test.com info@energielighting.com info@energywisegroup.com info@fulham.com info@globe-electric.com info@halcolighting.com info@hessamerica.com info@hew.com info@icof.com info@kania.us info@kelsey-kane.com info@kirlinlighting.com info@lightology.com info@liteenergy.com info@louispoulsen.com info@lumid.com info@luraline.com info@luxurylighting.com info@modularinternational.com info@pani.com info@promolux.cominfo@rambusch.com

info@rigalite.com info@satco.com info@schrederinc.com info@sheedlight.com info@spacecannon.com info@sperolighting.com info@starfirelighting.com info@sternberglighting.com info@stll.com info@swivelier.com info@tprlights.com info@vandalshields.com info@westinghouselighting.com info@winonalighting.com inviainc@aol.com ira@keystoneballast.com Isi@lightingsciences.com iwasaki-ibd@eye.co.jp jack@starfirelighting.com jacki.swiernik@intertek.com jaddario@dos.state.ny.us james_schoolenberg@adlt.com jason.hong@cooperindustries.com jberardi@wildfirefx.com Jcalvin@SpawGlass.com jcolant@tcpi.com jdobbie@kimlighting.com jdsmith@usa.com jean.getsy@crouse-hinds.com jennifer@atrlighting.com jerry.puracchio@sylvania.com jerry@lamparts.com jferko@cox.net jfowler@jjierie.com jguarino@kenall.com jhanson@etcconnect.com jharris@nwalliance.org Jholland@energy.state.ca.us jim.cyre@philips.com jim.oetken@sylvania.com Jim.Raba@ee.doe.gov Jim.Rannels@ee.doe.gov jim_morgan77@yahoo.com jimchao@sunpkco.com JimW@AZcommerce.com jkharrison@gmail.com jkingman@navigantconsulting.comjkinney@bakerdonelson.com

jkoeppe@phoenixproducts.com JLeppert@AmericanElectricLighting.com joe@forumlighting.com joelle@fullspectrumsolutions.com John.Becker@state.vt.us john.selander@acuitybrands.com jon.digesu@sylvania.com JonesRobbA@JohnDeere.com joseph.howley@ge.com jrains@rllight.com jronk@unvlt.com jsiegel@epl.com jsteinberg@techlighting.com julie.vizard@us.schott.com Justin.calvin@spawglass.com Jvirskus@fcgov.com jwilliams@mastercraft-lamps.com jwrockportdesign@aol.com jzaro@amerlux.com kackerly@aceee.org kcallahan@ase.org kcarberry@visalighting.com kdelves@nrcan.gc.ca keith.cook@philips.com keith.hall@cooperindustries.com kelly.gordon@pnl.gov ken@craftmetal.com ken@xtralight.com Khouser@unl.edu killark@hep.hubbell.com kimberly.kishpaugh@luxous.com klc@lumaxlighting.com kohalmia@westinghouselighting.com kortega@elplighting.com kosowsky@sprynet.com krisle@depsci.com krissmith@hanoverlantern.com kyle_pitsor@nema.org Lal.Rajat@bcg.com larry.beck@martin.dk larry.knab@nist.gov larry@tempestlighting.com lcordes@ase.org LegoZ81@a5.com lgb@leonbillings.com lightech@earthlink.net lighting@ieee.orglighting@musco.com

lighting@simkar.com lighting@solaballast.com lightingforensic@aol.com lights@coloradolighting.com lilia@solaballast.com Linda.Graves@ee.doe.gov lisamarie@tslight.com lloyd.reeder@lsi-industries.com LLVanWie@lbl.gov loa@lightsofaustralia.com lsi@lightingsciences.com luxonlighting@vsnl.net LYNDERSM@westinghouselighting.com Mahima.Gupta@navigantconsulting.com mail@wildfirefx.com makarand.chipalkatti@sylvania.com mando@lamparts.com mark.chu@grandrich.com mark.duffy@ge.com Mark.Friedrichs@hq.doe.gov mark.shepard@ge.com mark@mgvinc.com marketing@elliptipar.com marketing@novitas.com marketing@prescolite.com marvin@sentrylighting.com mary.gotti@lighting.ge.com mary@egl-neon.com matt_mazzola@adlt.com matt04@thuls.com matthew.walker@navigantconsulting.com Maureen Murphy@ee.doe.gov mbooth@cheyennehomefurnishings.com mcaiazza@emessdessign.com melhc@consumerfed.org mexluz@prodigy.net.mx mhertel@lightolier.com Mhoye@icfi.com Michael.D.Chenard@Lowes.com Michael.Lake@ee.doe.g ov michael.leyva@novalighting.org michael.myer@pnl.gov mike.simacek@grandrich.com mike@starlightingproducts.com minda.matthews@lsi-industries.com mitch.hand@acuitybrands.com mjdufresne@sistemalux.commmartin@energy.state.ca.us

mmoisin@luxep.com mriebling@genlytegroup.com MSAVINI@ALTMANLTG.COM naburke@hubbell-ltg.com ncohen@luminis.com nhorowitz@nrdc.org nora@noralighting.com obera@zumtobelstaff.com ojones@consumertesting.com optilight@mindspring.com pad@nyserda.org pamela.horner@sylvania.com pat.mikucki@philips.com paul.salvi@sylvania.com paul@strong-lighting.com paul@voigtlighting.com paulg@americanlightingcompany.com pcampbell@hfc-law.com PCBelding@spectrusinc.com pemco@ix.netcom.com peter.leitner@xal.com PHagen@bdlaw.com pileblan@NRCan.gc.ca pjanko@lumenelle.com ple2@pge.com pmustone@reflexlighting.com prasad.sastry@voltarc.com prescolitemarketing@prescolite.com prof@jjisa.com progress@progresslighting.com ptreadway@Minka.com PublicSolutions@earthlink.net qsl@qualite.com questions@pqlighting.com raffi@duralamp.com rchikami@ushio.com rdearmond@minkagroup.net rfoster@cee1.org RGraham@EPRI.com rharrold@iesna.org richard.barton@lighting.ge.com richard.heinisch@lithonia.com Richard.Karney@ee.doe.gov rlambert@venteselectra.com rminchin@sternberglighting.com rms@aerolights.com rob@lightech.comrobert.carmichael@navigantconsulting.com

robert.cilic@sylvania.com Robert.Lingard@pnl.gov roger.belanger@sylvania.com ron.harris@sylvania.com ron_runkles@nema.org ronald.paduchak@ge.com roy@minkadg.com.cn rstummer@nslights.com rutand@mail.welchallyn.com salary@lumid.com sale@pholighting.com sales@arclightingsystems.com sales@auroralight.com sales@elcolighting.com sales@fullspectrumsolutions.com sales@glasscoat.com sales@inconlighting.com sales@kingluminaire.com sales@litelab.com sales@lumaxlighting.com sales@lumenform.com sales@mailLSI.com Sales@NationalCathode.com sales@pathwaylighting.com sales@spectralighting.com sales@sunriselights.com sales@teronlight.com sales@whatley.com sam.loggia@csa.ca sandra.weil@philips.com sarahc@rebellelighting.com sashiller@gmail.com sbellovin@legionlighting.com sclarkart@earthlink.net Scoakley@neep.org sean.tham@waclighting.com sedap.usa@sedap.com service@eyelighting.com sguyatt@stresscrete.com shaileviton@paraflex.com shannon.vaughn@ge.com sharmilakumbhat@yahoo.com Shawn.holmes@hessamerica.com SHilton@Howard-ind.com shirin@dmflighting.com sima@soleracorp.com sjensen@iotaengineering.comslsandi@speclight.com

smicucci@oxygenlighting.com smosley@pinnacle-ltg.com sschneider@winonalighting.com sstern@energy-solution.com Steve.Karg@acuitybrands.com steve_morelli@beta-lighting.com steve_morelli@kramerlighting.com steve_morelli@ruudlighting.com stevel@lycian.com stltg@aol.com Stonierm@pennglobe.com sunny.ho@smc.com.hk superhid@163.net surya@sroshni.com susan.atc.bloom@philips.com Susan.bloom@philips.com talithac@globe-electric.com talktous@cooperlighting.com tcriveau@theocl.com teckman@nwcouncil.org TheLampDude@aol.com TheLampoDude@aol.com Thomas.heckmann@us.bureauveritas.com thomas.leyh@philips.com thomas.stoll@philips.com tim@aeilighting.com tim@formanandassociates.com tleonard@leviton.com tlowe@kingoffans.com tom.hackett@sylvania.com tom.salpietra@antiquestreetlamps.com TomG@quoizel.com tonja@atlaslightinproducts.com trevor.peyton@ruud.ca tshaffer@jjisa.com tsmcneil@aol.com tstone@kurtversen.com tusa@tivolind.com twoods@fulham.com ulsmmrm@adelphia.net uninex@uninex.com us@e3light.com ushio@ushio.com vbaldwin@genlyte.com venture@adlt.com verplank@spilighting.com vivian@minkadg.com.cnvkniffin@holophane.com

voigtlight@aol.com

vs -us@vsus.vossloh-schwabe.com vwittmann@qlty.com WEBdomino@prescolite.com Wendy.Littman@eesllc.net Wes.Anderson@ee.doe.gov wfharris@wfharris.com william@vaxcel.com.cn Williams@mastercraft-lamps.com wrightb@westinghouselighting.com xiao.wang@intertek.com ysung@maxlite.com zhouy@rpi.edu zoppp@litelab.com

Brenda’s list as of 3/30/2010:



### rlyford@americanlighting.com

kmackenzie@genlyte.com

jim.mapp@doa.state.wi.us

Michael.McCabe@ee.doe.gov

hmisuriello@ase.org

Alyssa.Morrissey@ee.doe.gov

remortaz@NRCan.gc.ca

gmurphy@maxlite.com

snadel@aceee.org

Anelkin@halco.com

bruce.nelson@state.mn.us

Hnewsome@FTC.gov

ohno@nist.gov

ldoquinn@cox.net

### orourc@rpi.edu

Jennifer.Owen@ee.doe.gov

rpelino@robertsonww.com

rachele.petrella@us.bureauveritas.com

Francine.Pinto@hq.doe.gov

kyl_pitsor@nema.org

ted@energy-solution.com

bprindle@aceee.org

ream@rpi.edu

pjr@nyserda.org

eric.richman@pnl.gov

kur_riesenberg@nema.org

MRivest@navigantconsulting.com

srosenstock@eei.org

bobr@aamsco.com

harvey_sachs@aceee.org

robert.saint@nreca.org

MScholand@navigantconsulting.com

jschwartz@icfi.com

dshiller@maxlite.com

jeanlys@keystore.org

bill.smelser@lithonia.com

pet_smeltzer@nema.org

### elissa.sobolewski@nist.gov

Eric.Stas@hq.doe.gov

brooke@necanet.org

mike.stein@worldnet.att.net

psullivan@universalballast.com

Richard_P._Theroux@omb.eop.gov

brinda.thomas@navigantconsulting.com

mtimmings@canlyte.com

gtraphagen@robertsonww.com

marsha@iald.org

cra_updyke@nema.org

paul.walitsky@gmail.com

paul.waide@iea.org

daniel_whitten@platts.com

jwilson@energy.state.ca.us

Stephen.Witkowski@ee.doe.gov

fwood@onlocationinc.com

dale.work@philips.com

edward.yandek@lighting.ge.com

jyorgey@lutron.com

dee_zamora@nema.org

Susan.Anderson@sylvania.com

tom.bosworth@philips.com

### bob.erhardt@philips.com

phakkarainen@lutron.com

rich.hanlon@sylvania.com

david.kachmarik@ge.com

Alison.lehr@navigantconsulting.com

slydecker@lithonia.com

joseph.mccormick@sylvania.com

rnachtrieb@lutron.com

jeffrey.plaskon@lighting.ge.com

himamshu.prasad@ge.com

TRIBARI1@irf.com

christopher.sequeira@navigantconsulting.com

brian.sok@philips.com

edward.thomas@ge.com

matthew.walker@navigantconsulting.com

gary.wallpe@acuitybrands.com

david.zizzi@lithonia.com