APPENDIX 6A. ENERGY USE CHARACTERIZATION RESULTS USED IN THE

NATIONAL IMPACTS ANALYSIS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

6A.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 6A­1

6A.2 GENERAL SERVICE FLUORESCENT LAMPS................................................. 6A­1

6A.3 INCANDESCENT REFLECTOR LAMPS............................................................ 6A­4

LIST OF TABLES

Table 6A.2.1 4­Foot Medium Bi­Pin T8 GSFL 3­Lamp System Power Rating and

Annual Energy Consumption...................................................................... 6A­1

Table 6A.2.2 4­Foot Medium Bi­Pin T8 GSFL 2­Lamp System Power Rating and

Annual Energy Consumption...................................................................... 6A­2

Table 6A.2.3 4­Foot Medium Bi­Pin T12 GSFL 3­Lamp System Power Rating and

Annual Energy Consumption...................................................................... 6A­2

Table 6A.2.4 8­Foot T8 Single­Pin Slimline GSFL 2­Lamp System Power Rating and

Annual Energy Consumption...................................................................... 6A­3

Table 6A.2.5 8­Foot T12 Single­Pin Slimline GSFL 2­Lamp System Power Rating and

Annual Energy Consumption...................................................................... 6A­3

Table 6A.3.1 IRL Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption, 90PAR38...................... 6A­4

Table 6A.3.2 IRL Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption, 75PAR38...................... 6A­5

Table 6A.3.3 IRL Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption, 50PAR30...................... 6A­6

Table 6A.3.4 IRL Product Substitution Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption...... 6A­6

6A­i

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1
APPENDIX 6A. ENERGY USE CHARACTERIZATION RESULTS USED IN THE

NATIONAL IMPACTS ANALYSIS

6A.1 INTRODUCTION

This appendix presents the energy end use characterization results used in the shipments

and national impacts analysis (NIA). In addition to many of the lamp and lamp­and­ballast

designs considered in the LCC and PBP, the NIA includes designs that do not save energy or do

not emit lumens within 10 percent of the baseline lamp­and­ballast system. Product substitutions

such as reflector CFLs which are not included in the LCC and PBP analyses are also considered

in the NIA.

6A.2 GENERAL SERVICE FLUORESCENT LAMPS

Table 6A.2.1 4­Foot Medium Bi­Pin T8 GSFL 3­Lamp System Power Rating and Annual

Energy Consumption

Technology

Option

System Power Rating Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial†

W kWh kWh

0.88BF32 Eleca 87.5 300.6 419.6

0.88BF30 Elec 80.5 276.5 386.0

0.88BF28 Elec 71.1 244.2 340.9

0.88BF25 Elec 66.8 229.5 320.3

0.78BF32 Elec 78.5 269.6 376.4

0.78BF30 Elec 72.4 248.7 347.2

0.78BF28 Elec 63.3 217.4 303.5

0.78BF25 Elec 58.1 199.6 278.6

0.75BF32 Elec 75.9 260.7 363.9

0.75BF30 Elec 70 240.5 335.7

0.75BF28 Elec 60.9 209.2 292.0

0.75BF25 Elec 55.5 190.6 266.1

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the

commercial sector of 3,435.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial

sector of 4,795.1 hours

a A notation of the form “1.18BF32Elec” indicates a lamp­ballast system consisting of a 32W lamp paired with an

electronic ballast of a 1.18 ballast factor. “0.95BF40 Mag” refers to lamp­ballast system of a 40W lamp paired with

a magnetic ballast of a 0.95 ballast factor.

6A­1

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1
Table 6A.2.2 4­Foot Medium Bi­Pin T8 GSFL 2­Lamp System Power Rating and Annual

Energy Consumption

Technology

Option

System Power Rating Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial†

W kWh kWh

0.88BF32 Elec 58.5 200.9 280.5

0.88BF30 Elec 54.7 187.9 262.3

0.88BF28 Elec 47.8 164.2 229.2

0.88BF25 Elec 44.0 151.1 211.0

0.78BF32 Elec 51.9 178.3 248.9

0.78BF30 Elec 49.1 168.7 235.4

0.78BF28 Elec 42.5 146.0 203.8

0.78BF25 Elec 38.9 133.6 186.5

0.75BF32 Elec 49.9 171.4 239.3

0.75BF30 Elec 47.4 162.8 227.3

0.75BF28 Elec 41.0 140.8 196.6

0.75BF25 Elec 37.4 128.5 179.3

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the

commercial sector of 3,435.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial

sector of 4,795.1 hours

Table 6A.2.3 4­Foot Medium Bi­Pin T12 GSFL 3­Lamp System Power Rating and Annual

Energy Consumption

Technology

Option

System Power Rating Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial†

W kWh kWh

0.95BF40 Mag 129.0 443.1 618.6

0.88BF34 Mag 108.0 371.0 517.9

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the

commercial sector of 3,435.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial

sector of 4,795.1 hours

6A­2

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1
Table 6A.2.4 8­Foot T8 Single­Pin Slimline GSFL 2­Lamp System Power Rating and

Annual Energy Consumption

Technology

Option

System Power Rating Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial†

W kWh kWh

0.88BF55 Elec 102.0 350.4 489.1

0.88BF57 Elec 107.5 369.3 515.5

0.88BF59 Elec 112.8 387.5 540.9

0.85BF55 Elec 98.5 338.3 472.3

0.85BF57 Elec 106.0 364.1 508.3

0.85BF59 Elec 109.1 374.8 523.1

0.78BF55 Elec 90.2 309.8 432.5

0.78BF57 Elec 102.5 352.1 491.5

0.78BF59 Elec 100.4 344.9 481.4

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the

commercial sector of 3,435.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial

sector of 4,795.1 hours

Table 6A.2.5 8­Foot T12 Single­Pin Slimline GSFL 2­Lamp System Power Rating and

Annual Energy Consumption

Technology

Option

System Power Rating Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial†

W kWh kWh

0.94BF75 Mag 158.0 542.7 757.6

0.88BF60 Mag 126.0 432.8 604.2

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the

commercial sector of 3,435.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the GSFL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial

sector of 4,795.1 hours

6A­3

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1
6A.3 INCANDESCENT REFLECTOR LAMPS

Table 6A.3.1 IRL Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption, 90PAR38

Technology

Option

Lamp

Efficacy

Lamp

Power

Rating

Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial† Residential**

lm/W W kWh kWh kWh

CSL0, Halogen 14.6 90.0 310.5 419.8 79.6

CSL0, Halogen 15.0 120.0 414.0 559.7 106.1

CSL1, Improved

Halogen 16.6 79.0 272.6 368.5 69.9

CSL2, HIR 18.0 70.0 241.5 326.5 61.9

CSL2, HIR 20.3 100.0 345.0 466.4 88.4

CSL3, Improved HIR 19.8 66.0 227.7 307.8 58.4

CSL3, Improved HIR 22.6 90.0 310.5 419.8 79.6

CSL3, Improved HIR 22.0 100.0 345.0 466.4 88.4

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the commercial sector

of 3,450.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial sector of

4,664.0 hours

** Residential annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the residential sector of

884.2 hours

6A­4

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1
Table 6A.3.2 IRL Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption, 75PAR38

Technology

Option

Lamp

Efficacy

Lamp

Power

Rating

Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial† Residential**

lm/W W kWh kWh kWh

CSL0, Halogen 14.0 75.0 258.8 349.8 66.3

CSL0, Halogen 14.6 90.0 310.5 419.8 79.6

CSL1, Improved

Halogen 15.9 66.0 227.7 307.8 58.4

CSL1, Improved

Halogen 16.6 79.0 272.6 368.5 69.9

CSL2, HIR 17.5 60.0 207.0 279.8 53.1

CSL2, HIR 18.8 80.0 276.0 373.1 70.7

CSL2, HIR 20.3 100.0 345.0 466.4 88.4

CSL3, Improved HIR 19.1 55.0 189.8 256.5 48.6

CSL3, Improved HIR 22.6 90.0 310.5 419.8 79.6

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the commercial sector

of 3,450.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial sector of

4,664.0 hours

** Residential annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the residential sector of

884.2 hours

6A­5

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1
Table 6A.3.3 IRL Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption, 50PAR30

Technology

Option

Lamp

Efficacy

Lamp

Power

Rating

Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial† Residential**

lm/W W kWh kWh kWh

CSL0, Halogen 11.6 50.0 172.5 233.2 44.2

CSL0, Halogen 11.0 65.0 224.3 303.2 57.5

CSL1, Improved

Halogen 14.0 44.3 152.8 206.6 39.2

CSL1, Improved

Halogen 14.4 50.0 172.5 233.2 44.2

CSL1, Improved

Halogen 15.4 65.0 224.3 303.2 57.5

CSL2, HIR 15.0 41.3 142.5 192.6 36.5

CSL2, HIR 16.5 50.0 172.5 233.2 44.2

CSL2, HIR 17.0 65.0 224.3 303.2 57.5

CSL3, Improved HIR 17.0 40.0 138.0 186.6 35.4

CSL3, Improved HIR 18.0 50.0 172.5 233.2 44.2

CSL3, Improved HIR 19.1 65.0 224.3 303.2 57.5

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the commercial sector

of 3,450.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial sector of

4,664.0 hours

** Residential annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the residential sector of

884.2 hours

Table 6A.3.4 IRL Product Substitution Power Rating and Annual Energy Consumption

Technology

Option

Lamp

Efficacy

Lamp

Power

Rating

Annual Energy Consumption

Commercial* Industrial† Residential**

lm/W W kWh kWh kWh

CSL3, Reflector CFL 46.9 16.0 55.2 74.6 14.1

* Commercial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the commercial sector

of 3,450.0 hours

† Industrial annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the industrial sector of

4,664.0 hours

** Residential annual energy usage is based on the IRL U.S. average operating hours for the residential sector of

884.2 hours

6A­6

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1
6A­7

 EE-2006-STD-0131 COMMENT 16.1