i.tì., r.,r:'r,

KatlrleenHartnett \Nhite,Clta innatt Larr-y R. Soivard,

Commissirtner GlennShankle,ExecutiueDireclor



## Tpxas CorørurrssroN oN

ENVIRoNMENTAL

QUALITy
?. Protecting Texasbg Reducittg and Preuenting Pollution'

Docket Nos.2006-1874-SIP, 2006-17 96-R[IL,r2006-1804-RUL r June 13,2007

RichardE-Greene,

Regional

Adnrinistrator U.S.Environmental

Protection Agency- Region 6 1445 Ross Avenue Dallas. Texas7 5202-2733 

## 3 Dear MayorGreene: f On May 23,2007, the Texas Commissionon EnvironmentalQuality (Commission) adopted revisionstõne Implementation

Plan(SlP)for the Houston-Galveston-Brazoriã lHGe) eiglrt-hour ozone nonattainlnenl al'ea. Theserevisionsincludethree components- The first component is a revisionto the SIP for the HGB eight-hourozone nonattainment

a¡ea that includesadditionalVoluntary Mobile Emission Reduction Program (VMEP) commitments. In addition,

the Commission

adopted amendments

to S 114.6 and$ 114.319 in 30 Tex. Admin.Code Chapter I14, Controlof Ai¡ Pollution frorn Motor Vehicles. Theserules amend the definition of diesel fuel to include marinedistillate fuels, requiring

thernto be compliantwith low emission diesel(LED) standards i¡ the HGB nonattainment area, andamend the compliance

schedule

for the infoduction of LED-compliantmarinediesel fuels intotheHGB areacounties. Lurtty, rhe commission

adopred new$ 1l5.ll0 and amendmenrs ros$ 115.1l2 - ll5.l17, I l5.l19, 115.541 - 1i5.547,

andl 115.549 of 30 Tex-Admin. CodeChapter ll'5, Conh'ol of Ai¡Pollution fromVolatile OrganicCompounds.Specifically, I the newsectionandamendúrents reduce emissions of volatileorganicconipounds (VOC) û'om VOC storage anddegassing I operationsby estabiishing lrore stringentcontrols for fittings on floating loof storagevessels, establishingcontrol I requiretnents

or operational lirnitationsonlandingfloating roofs,establislring control requirenrents for flashelnissions fi-om I crude oil and condensate

storage tanks, andestablishing nore stringent

control requirentents

for degassing

andcleaning ofJ storage, transpoll,and marinevessels. Enclosed

are tlrese

proposed

revisions

tothe SIP,a cornplete record ofthe public hearings. the accompanying

orders, anda public lrearing certification. I lookforward toyourexpeditious approval ofthese SIPrei,isiots. o L. 

### u 6 Þ _ Ðrn rJ¡-rl Þ-< -rrt EC3 v l l-t ú1 er¡ -13 6Jârë



# a'Å -jf l,¡f^,&
Kath leen Hannefi\À4lite Cha\nnan KHWtlis Enclosures ¡ cc: TheHonorable Rick Perr1,. Govenlor of Texas

Mr. Zal< CovaL- Offìce of Budget, Planning

arrd Policy,Offìceof theCovenlor Mr. Glen¡Shankle, Executive Dù-ector. Texas Con'lllission onEnvir-onrnenta) Quaìit1, Sincerely,

P.(_).p-oi.':-3()87

6 A_ustirr. Te,.l¿rs 7åì7ìl-3û87 + 5l!,,!,?9-itl(tfl € ilrr.cr.na', ¿rcici.rr,s:: i¡'.r.r,rt.ictr¡.sLate.t:,..usTexas Commissionon EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearings January29 and 31, and February 1,6,and 8,2007 Concerning Revisions to 30TAC Chapter 11 5 Control of Air Pollutionfrom Volatile Organic Compounds

Control of VOC Emissions from Storage8, Degassing Operations in HGBfor the Eight-Hour Ozone Standard Rule Project No. 2006-038-1 15-ENThe Texas Commissionon EnvironmentalQuality(commission)heldpublichearingsin Houstonon January 29, 2007; Dallas on January 31, 2007; Arlington and Midlothian on February 1, 2007; Longviewon February 6, 2007; and Austin on February 8, 2007, to receive testimony regarding revisionsto 30TAC Chapter 1 14,ControlofAir Pollution from Motor Vehicles; Chapter 115,Control of Air Pollution from Volatile Organic Compounds; Chapter 117, Control of Air Pollution from Nitrogen Compounds; and corresponding revisionsto the state implementationplan.
The comment period closed on February 12, 2007. All testimony and comments have been reviewedand seriously considered. This hearing record contains a complete recordofthe public hearingsand is divided into the followirrgfour sections:

o Public Notificationand Proposal
o Written and Oral Testimony
0 Evaluation ofTestimony
o Staff Recommendations/Order
Additionalcopies ofthis hearing record are maintainedin theTCEQ centralofficeat 12100Park 35 Circle, Austin, Texas 78753. For further information, please contact Teresa Hurleyat (51 2) 239- 5316.

# ORAL

TESTIMONYOral Testimony for the Texas Eight-Hour Ozone SIP Revisions

Seven public hearings were held by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) between January 29 and February 8, 2007, to consider revisions to the elements of the Texas State Implementation Plan (SIP) for air pollution control listed below. Only the transcript of the first public hearing listed below was included with the revisions to Chapter 115 in this State submittal to EPA. The transcripts for the other public hearings were not included since no oral comments were received on this Chapter 115 rule-making action at the other public hearings. The transcripts for each of the seven public hearings are available in docket EPA-R06-OAR-2007-0523, document EPA-R06-OAR-2007-0523- 0010, in this Regulations.gov web site. Texas SIP revisions considered at the seven public hearings: !TCEQ Rule Project No. 2006-034-117-EN: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapter 117, Control of Air Pollution from Nitrogen Compounds --- Chapter 117 Reformat, NOx Controls for Dallas/Forth Worth (DFW) Area Eight-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration and Revisions to Residential Water Heater Rules. !TCEQ Rule Project No. 2006-036-114-EN: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapter 114, Control of Air Pollution from Motor Vehicles --- Low Emission Diesel for Certain Marine Fuels. !TCEQ Rule Project No. 2007-038-115-EN: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapter 115, Control of Air Pollution from Volatile Organic Compounds --- Control of VOC Emissions from Storage and Degassing Operations in Houston/Galveston/Brazoria (HGB) for the Eight-Hour Ozone Standard. (NOTE: TCEQ Rule Project No. “2006-038-115-EN” is listed on the Public Hearing Registration forms as TCEQ Rule Project No. “2007-038-115-EN”.) !TCEQ Rule Project No. 2006-013-SIP-NR: Revisions to the Dallas/Fort Worth (DFW) Eight-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP. !TCEQ Rule Project No. 2006-027-SIP-NR: Revisions to the Houston/Galveston/ Brazoria (HGB) Eight-Hour Ozone SIP. !TCEQ Rule Project No. 2006-030-SIP-NR: Revisions to the Houston/Galveston/ Brazoria (HGB) Eight-Hour Ozone Reasonable Further Progress (RFP) SIP. !TCEQ Rule Project No. 2006-031-SIP-NR: Revisions to the Dallas/Fort Worth (DFW) Reasonable Further Progress (RFP) SIP. The hearings were held: January 29, 2007, 2:00 p.m. - Houston-Galveston Area Council, Houston, Texas; January 29, 2007, 6:00 p.m. - Houston-Galveston Area Council, Houston, Texas; January 31, 2007, 7:00 p.m. - J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, Dallas, Texas; February 1, 2007, 2:00 p.m. - Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, Arlington, Texas; February 1, 2007, 6:00 p.m. - Midlothian Conference Center, Midlothian, Texas; February 6, 2007, 2:00 p.m. - Longview Public Library, Longview, Texas; February 8, 2007, 2:00 p.m. - Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, Austin, Texas. *************************************end*******************************hyl**INDEXOF ORALTES'l7MONY January29,2007,2:00p.m.-Houston-Galveston Area Council, Houston,Texas ReferenceNumber 0-1 0-2 Submitted by Brandt Mannchen, HoustonSierra Club Sabrina Strawn, Galveston-Houston Associationfor Smog Prevention Jane Laping, Mothersfor Clean Air Tem Thomas, Mothersfor CleanAir Thomas McKittrick, Mothersfor Clean Air Lucy Randel, on behalf of herselfPage 1



### TEXAS COMMISSION ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY - -- . -- -.



### ...................................................... PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED REVISIONS

TO 30 

### TAC CHAPTERS 114, 115 

### AND 117 

### AND TO THE STATE IMPLEMENTATION 'LAN JANULRY 

### 29, 2007



### ...................................................... 

# ORiGlWh

. . 

### Reported 

### by Phyllis Loy, CS3, 

### RMR Job No. 61750Page 2 The public hearing was taken on JANUARY 29, 2007, from 2:00 to 3:06, before Phyllis Loy, CSR in and for the State of Texas, reported by computerized stenotype machine, at the offices of Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timrnons Lane, 2nd Floor, Houston, Texas.Page 3 

### APPEARANCES OF PANEL MEMBERS Ms. Jodena N. Henneke Director, Office of Public Assistance Texas Commission on Environmental Quality 12100 Park 35 Circle, Bldg. F, Austin, Texas 78753 Telephone: 512-239.4085 Facsimile: 512.239.4007 E-mail: jhenneke@tceq.state.tx.us 

### Ms. Kelly Keel Statement Implementaticn Plan Team Leader Chief Engineer's Office Texas Commission on Environmental Quality 12100 Park 35 Circle, Bldg. F, 

### Austin, Texas 78753 Telephone: 512.239.3607 Facsimile: 512.239.5687 E-mail: kkee1etceq.state.tx.u~ Ms. Ashley Forbes SIP Rule Development Team Leader Chief Engineer's Office Texas Commission 

### on Environmental Quality 12100 Park 35 Circle, Bldg. F, Austin, Texas 78753 Telephone: 512.239.0493 Facsimile: 512.239.5687 E-mail: aforbes@tceq.state.tx.us



### Ms. Susana M. Hildebrand, P.E. Director, Air Quality Texas Commission on Environmental Quality 12100 Park 35 Circle, Bldg. F, 

### Austin, Texas 78753 I, 

### Telephone: 512.239.4696 Facsimile: 512.239.2546Page
INDEX PAGE 

### Appearances 

# . . . . . . 

# . . . 

# . . . 

# . . 

# . . 

# . . . 3



### LIST OF SPEAKERS: Mr. Ms. Ms. Ms. Ms. Ms. Mr. Ms. Mr. Ms. Ms. Ms. Brant Mannchen 

## . 

# . Sabrina Strawn 

# . . Jane Laping. 

# . . . Melanie Oldham 

# . . Margaret Mitchell. Terri Thomas 

# . . . Thomas McKittrick. Annie Stewart. 

# . . Frank Salzhandler. Lucy Randel. 

# . . . Skelly Holmbeck. 

# . Rosalia Guerrero 

## .Page 5 MS. 

### HENNEKE: Thank you all very 

### much 

# I 

# I been one of those weeks for me already. I'm not sure 2 3

# I what time of day 

### it is, but I promise I'll adjust. for joining this evening 

## -- joining us this afternoon. It's been one of those weeks 

## -- it's 

### a Monday. 

### It's

My name is Jodena Henneke. I 

### 'm with the

Before I get started with the formal hearing, 7

there are few things that I will like to do. Like 

# I Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, Office of 8. Public Assistance.

11

# I Cathy, can you hear us back there? 

# I

l5

# 1 wave around and we'll try our very best to adjust it. 12 13 14

16

# ( Some of you may have heard me earlier. I 

### am here from We have pretty much 

### a full house in here. For any of you, if for whatever reason the sound begins to varies a bit, please stand 

### up and kind of 

# 1 Austin. Cedar is going nuts in Austin right now. My

2o

# I falters, we will try our very best to fix the sound to 18 19

21

# 1 ensure that everyone can hear what is going on. my ears are popping. I have no idea if I'm yelling or I'm whispering. So if for whatever reason my voice

There are a couple of other housekeeping
23

# I items that I want to go through now that we have .24

# 1 additional people with us. I The first .one 

### is- I would .appreciate 

### it .veryPage 6 

### much if people have cell phones or pagers with them; if they would put them on silence or vibrate. If you need to respond to a page or a cell phone, please step out in the hall and do that. This hearing is being recorded on compact disk and it will be picked up on the recording. And we would very much appreciate not to hear that over and over as we evaluate the comments and listen and listen and listen again. In addition, there are rest room facilities across the hall. We going to try our very best to make this a comfortable process. 

### I have a few thlngs that I 

### need to go through formally. Before I get started with that, I would like to acknowledge some folks that are here with us. I have the Office of Chief Engineer's staff with us.. Those of you that are with the Chief Engineer's office, would you stand and wave. I'm not to do individual introductions. I'm going to acknowledge them. 

### I also have Agency Communications that are with me. Andy is moving chairs. Lisa is up here on the laptop. 

### I also have TCEQ staff from Field Operations. How many of you all are here? If you're here from TCEQ, will you stand up and wave. Thank you very much. There probably are some folks here also asPage 7 well from the City of Houston Bureau of Air Quality 

# I Control. Any other local programs that are here that 

# I I should acknowledge? I always have to ask. Do I 

# 1 have any elected officials here with 

### me toda.y? I usually follow that up with 'okay, good, I get to say whatever I want to, but itr s being recorded so no, I don1 

### t get to do that quite either. Okay. I think I've done all of that that I need to do. Now I'm going go through some formal stuff that I have to start the hearing with. I told

' folks a. little bit earlier as we get- to that part, I 'm

. . 

# I going to be calling people t o t h e microphone to give us their comments. We have a 

### -- and I use the word loosely 

### -- podium here at the'microphone. It 

### is a tray for you to put your papers on if that is helpful for you asyou give your comments. Please, please do not lean on 

### it to the right or 

### it will go with you. If you need to lean, kind of lean to the left. But you're better off if you donrt lean at all. You will be better off if you just put your papers there and use 

### it as kind of a holding place. It's better than nothing. But I don't want to trick anybody into doing a tumble here in front of all of us. Because somebody will go, "Uh-oh, how did that happen?" So please don't lean, especially don't lean to the right.Page 8


### I 

### want to welcome everybody and open this hearing being conducted by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality. We're here today to receive comments, both verbal and written, on proposed revisions to Chapter 114, Control of Air Pollution from Motor Vehicles to include certain Marine Distillate Fuels into the definition of diesel fuels and require them to be Texas Low Emissions Diesel or TexLed, compliant in the 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria nonattainment area. The proposal adds a compliance schedule for the introduction of the newly-defined TexLed compliant marine distillate fuels in the 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria nonattainment area. Also, revisions to Chapter 115, Control of Air Pollution From the Volatile Organic Compound Controls of VOC Emissions from Storage and Degassing Operations. The proposed amendments to Chapter 115 requires owners or operators in the Houston-GalvestonBrazoria eight-hour ozone nonattainment area to reduce emissions of volatile organic compounds from VOC storage and degassing operations by establishing more 

# . stringent controls for fittings on floating roof storage vessels, establishing control requirements or operational limitations on landing floating roofs,Page 9 

# I 

# I establishing control requirements for flash emissions I 

### from crude oil and condensate storage tanks, and 

# I establishing more stringent control requirements for degassing and cleaning of storage, transport and marine vessels. Also, proposed revisions to Chapter 117, 

# I Control of Air Pollution From Nitrogen Compounds to include the repeal of the existing rule and replace it with a new reformatted Chapter 117, which includes new rules for the Dallas/Fort Worth eig-ht-hour, ozone nonattainment area attainment demonstration. The proposed rulemaking subjects owners or operators of stationary sources of nitrogen oxides or NOx in the Dallas-Fort Worth eight-hour ozone nonattainment area, as well as in specified counties in the northeast Texas area, to more stringent emission control, monitoring, testing, recordkeeping, and reporting 

# I requirements. The new proposed rules will require further emissions reductions from cement kilns and 

# I electric generating units, controls on compressor engines in 39 

### East Texas counties, and major and minor sources in the DFW area. The proposed rulemaking also implements the requirements of House Bill 965, 

### from the 79th Texas ~e~islature in 2005 

### regarding residential naturalPage 10 

### gas-fired water heaters. The 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria area nonattainment State Implementation Plan, also known as SIP, describing progress toward attainment of the one-hour and eight-hour ozone standards. The 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria 15 

### percent reasonable further progress SIP revision demonstrates that the required 15 

### percent emissions reduction will be met for the analysis period of 2002 to 2008 and includes a revised motor vehicle emissions budget for the milestone year 2008. 

### And, finally, the Dallas/Fort Worth attainment demonstration SIP includes technical work showing how the area will meet the federal requirements for attainment of the eight-hour ozone standard. The DFW 

### 15 

### percent reasonable further progress SIP demonstrates that the required 15 

### percent emissions reduction will be met for the period of 2002 to 2008. If you plan to present 

### -- give us verbal testimony today and have not yet already registered, please sign in now. Cathy is back at the desk, ready to help you. Copies of the proposed rules and SIPS can be obtained from the Commission's Website. 

### I believe there is a piece of paper back at the backPage. 11 that gives you all of that citing. If you do not have access to the Internet, there are sheets available back at the registration table for you to fill in your name and address and we'll mail a copy of the rules to you once the rules have been adopted by the Commission. We will accept both hard copy, both written copy and e-rrLail written comments on this proposal until 

### 5 p.m. Monday, February the 12th, 2007. And, again, the address and the e-mail address to do that are back at the back table. We are here to receive your comments, verbal and written. Once I open the hearing, we will not be responding verbally. If you have any additional questions regarding the pro.posa1, we will be here for, several 

## -- for a while. We're going to have another hearing this evening so we'll be here. If you have questions that you want to come and visit with us
, one-on-one about, we encourage you to do that. I'm going to ask Cathy or some of the staff 

### -- I've already got it. I'm going to be calling names to come to the microphone. Hopefully in the order in which you signed up. I always tell people this is part of 

### -- I promise really 

### it's not an if. It will be when I will mispronounce, I will manglePage 12 

### somebody's name probably in a fashion that I'll have to kind of help figure out who you are. But we will get there, I promise. It is not purposeful on my part. I put it under the heading of I'm left-handed and it's amazing 

## -- it sometimes took me forever to figure out how to pronounce Brandt's name, but I can do it now. If for whatever reason I do mispronounce your name, I truly apologize. It is not purposeful on my part. I also need to introduce 

## -- I have someone here representing Commissioner Sylvia Garcia. Mr.. Robert Gallegos, are you here? Thank you, sir. Do 

### I have any other folks representing elected officials that have joined us? Yes, sir. You are? MR. MOSS: I'm John Moss with Senator Kyle Janer's office. MS. HENNEKE: Thank you. And? MR. COOK: Nathan Cook with Senator John Cornyn's office. MS. HENNEKE: Thank you. MS. BROWN: Harriet Brown with the General's office. MS. 

### HENNEKE: Thank you. 

### MR. PEPPLE: Karl Pepple with Mayor White's office.Page 13 MS. 

### HENNEKE: Thank you. Anyone else?

said there where no elected officials here. 2 3 Okay, folks. We have quite a few commenters See, it's a good thing I didn't start talking about whatever I wanted to talk about a while ago when I

that want to give us verbal remarks.. I 

### 'm goingto suggest that you be as concise in your comments as you can. I'm going to let you go. If you hit much more than about 5 minutes, I'm going 

### -- that's a long time to talk, and this comment period continues to stay open through and including February the 12th, till 5 p.m. It is 

### my intent to give absolutely everybody ample opportunity to provide us comments. So if you hit much nore than about 5 minutes, I'm going' " encourage you to summarize. I'm not going to interrupt you mid-sentence or mid-thought. But at some point I'm going to kind of go, "Okay, Brandt" 

## -- Brandt and I've known each other for a long time. For 19

# 1 those 'of you who' don't

. know

. me, in a former lifetime

22 

# ( I'm going to say, "Brandt, it's time. lY 20 21

I do want you to be able to give us every ago I was the regional director in Houston. So we go way back. ' If Brandt gets, say, 10, 15, 20 minutes,

comment.that you have.. Please take advantage,of that opportunity'here today verbally and in writing. AndPage 14


### once you leave here, if there is additional information you want the Executive Director and the Commissioners to consider, by all 'means submit it. Now, having said that, Brandt, you're up first. 

### I really didn't do that on purpose. 

### I would have had 

### I known you were up first. Brandt will be followed by 

### -- okay, Rudy, we'll get to you in a minute. State your name, please. MR. 

### MANNCHEN: My name is Brandt Mannchen. That's B-R-A-N-D-T M-A-N-N-C-H-E-N. And 

### I'm representing the Houston Sierra Club this afternoon. One of the first comments 

### I want to make is 

### I really think it's unfortunate that none of the Commissioners are here. 

### I can recall for many, many years 

### I haven't seen a Commissioner at a SIP hearing and I think it's really important. This is the most out-of-attainment area in the entire state of Texas. This is where the most people are endangered for their health from ozone and yet we get no Commissioners to come and sit. And 

### I think they should. So 

### I would like to send that as a first comment. The party is over. For over 30 

### years the Houston Sierra Club has commented on TCEQ and its predecessors' SIPS, progress reports and other publicPage 15 

### documents. Every one has stated the same thing: The 

# I
ozone attainment will be reached and the 

### SI'Pprepared is stringent. 

# .I For instance: Statement by Charles 

### R. Barton, who was 'theExecutive Secretary of Texas Air Control Board, May 28th, 1975, "Our control strategy 

# I for hydrocarbon emissions in the Houston Region, on the other hand, was based on sound technical data. Our strategy proposes stringent control of hydrocarbon emissions from industrial sources and relies on stringent federal controls.onautomobile manufacturers." Flash to today. December 13th, 2006, the eight-hour ozone SIP being proposed today. Page 

### 4-1, Chapter 4, 

### the 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria eight-hour ozone attainment area includes one of the most comprehensively controlled industrial complexes in the 

# I world. The TCEQ has developed stringent and innovative regulations that address NOx, VOC, and the most reactive ozone precursors in the 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria area, highly reactive organic compounds. For each SIP the Houston Sierra Club has stated thac more ozone precursor reductions are needed. TCEQ and'its predecessors have ignored usPage 16 

### each time. The Houston Sierra Club has been right 100 percent of the time. The TCEQ has been wrong 100 percent of the time. It is time to get serious or suffer the consequences. If the political leaders of the Houston-Galveston-Brazoria 

### and the state of Texas will not require the TCEQ to do the right thing, then they must accept responsibility for the penalties required by the Federal Clean Air Act Amendments. On page 2 of the November 21st, 2006, Docket No. 2006-1892-SIP and other places throughout the SIP it states, "The state has determined that its fiscal and manpower resources are adequate and will not be adversely affected through the implementation of this plan. " 

### The Sierra Club believes this is an untrue statement. New types of investigations will be ;-
.. 

### required to document compliance with these regulations and rules. In particular, there are thousands of storage tanks that will have to comply with these rules, which means that there will be an incredib1.e effort required to ensure that owners/operatorsldo indeed comply with these rules. The Houston Sierra Club urges TCEQ to no longer claim that it or l'ocal agencies have the resources, including sufficient investigators, toPage 17



### and those local agencies in 

### a non-adversarial and 1 2 3 4 5 

### protected environment. It is the Houston Sierra implement any SIP 

### that is prepared, approved and implemented. For many years it has been obvious that TCEQ 

### and its regulatory partners are struggling to keep up with the work load. For evidence of this problem, TCEQ should interview its own investigators 

# I Club's view. that TCEQ will be 

### surprised what investigators (the thin green line) say when asked about their viewpoint in a politically safe environment. i 

### The Houston Sierra Club is not surprised when the 

### TCEQ states, "The following preliminary results 

# I indicate that while the magnitude of the ozone 

# I concentrations in the 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria area has been reduced, the princi2le cause of 

### the highest 

# I ozone episodes remains unchanged. 

### We are not,

. 

### surprised because: No. 1. TCEQ underes,timztesindustry 

# 1 emissions. 

# I No. 2. 

### TCEQ 

### believes industry about its emissions when it should verify those estimates in the field. No. 3. 

### TCEQ believes industry when TCEQ has been consistently misled 

### by industry.Page 18


### No. 4. TCEQ 

### does not implement the most stringent controls for all sources as quick as possible. No. 5. 

### TCEQ blinds itself with its fear of overcontrol. No. 6. 

### TCEQ does not believe those who say the model is wrong and overpredicts attainment. No. 7. 

### TCEQ refuses to believe the public that the 

### SIP was inadequate and more emission reductions are needed. The following recommended changes 

### -- and - 

### these are not all of them. 

### We have additional ones there -; 

### should be implemented from the 

### VOC rules for storage tank and degassing. And they should be made more stringent. In Tables 

### I (a) and I1 

### (a), for storage tanks instead of 1.5 psia liquids, should be changed to.,,5 psia. In Tables 

### I (a) 

### and I1 (a), for storage tanks, all references to 25,000 gallons should be changed to 10,000 gallons. Tables 

### I (a) and I1 

### (a), for storage tanks, all references to 40,000 gallons should be changed to 10,000 gallons. Page 32, 5 12 

### a 3 

## , for storage tanks,Page 19 

# I change the minimum control efficiency from 90 to 95 

# I percent. Vapor recovery systems can achieve that.

. Require control of VOCflash emissions from 

# I allstorage tanks with emissions equal. to or greater

. . 

# I than 10 tons per, year.

. 

# I Require control of VOC emissions from 

# 1, degassing storage tanks with a capacity equal or 

# 1. great,er than 16,000 gallons. Require control of VOC emissions from degassing storage vessels, transport vessels, and marine vessels in the 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria area by venting to'a control device until the VOC vapors are reduced to less than 10,000 ppm. 10,000 ppm 

### is the highest definition of a leak that VOC sources in 

# I the 

### Houston-Galveston-Brazoria area must meet via a 

# I state or federal air quality regulations. This

. proposal, which allows 34,000 ppm, allows 240 percent 

# I more VOC emissions than a leak allows. At the very least the emissions from the storage tanks should be defined as less than a leak is defined. 

# I The Houston Sierra Club objects to the delay of the degassing rule to January lst, 2017, eight years beyond the January lst, 2009 deadline for some storage tanks. TCEQ should require that all storage tanks meet the.2009 deadline.Page 20 

### Some of the controls that we think TCEQ should have in this document that are not in it: The NOx reduction for large industrial sources, we believe a 90 to 95 percent NOx reduction control efficiency should be required. We believe loading operations for VOC should be increased from 90 to 95 percent or greater. We believe the HRVOC program-type controls should be implemented on regular VOCs the same for fugitive monitoring. MS. HENNEKE: Have you summarized? 

### MR. MANNCHEN: I'm ready to summarize. The Houston Sierra Club requests that TCEQ do the following: Withdraw the eight-hour and RFP SIPS as inadequate. Not seek bump-up status. Prepare a detailed qualitative and quantitative assessment, analysis and evaluation and rule effectiveness analysis for point, area, on-road, non-road, and other sources listed in our comments. Implement as many of the point, area, on-road, non-road, and other sources listed in our comments as possible to maximally reduce NOx and VOC emissions. Make all SIP regulations and rules applyPage 21 

### statewide. End the policy of incrementalism and. minimalism that TCEQ has implemented in the past. Hire, properly train, and fund additional investigators for TCEQ and local air pollution agencies. Accept the start. the sanctions clock and develop a SIP in 18 

### months that will attain the standard. And 9. 

### If' an .acceptable SIP cannot be prepared in 18 months, then gracefully accept sanctions, take a time out, and develop a SIP that will attain the ozone standard. Thank you. 

### MS. HENNEKE: Thank you, Brandt. Rudy Cuaycong. Rudy, are you here? Rudy with Acadia Vantage, Inc. Sabrina Strawn.

. 

### And Ms. Strawn will be followed by Jane Laping. MS. STRAWN: Good afternoon. I am the Galveston-Houston Association for Smog Prevention. I'm here'to add my voice to the course of dismay. .'We've watched deadline after deadline slip by. This year marks the deadline for the one-hour standard now in limbo. When three years ago TCEQ adopted its last ozone reduction plan for Houston, the changeover to the eight-hour standardPage 22 

### had already began. TCEQ then made numerous promises for improvement in modeling, for example, that have not been honored. Now we're told that the region will not reach the standard for many years. What will you do when EPA lowers the standards still further as recommended. Today I will not enumerate the laundry list of controls TCEQ could have proposed. Rest assured, GHASP and others, as we've heard from Brandt already, and written comments will be more comprehensive. TCEQ and industry are busily touting on how good things are. You show ozone levels decreasing, while population increases. Let's own up. Improvements are supposed to overcome population growth. Here's another comparison to Los Angeles. Its ozone levels have decreased twice as fast as Houston's. You also point out how monitor after, monitor is reaching attainment. Then as an aside, admit attainment occurs when the entire region meets the ozone standard. Let's be clear. Each individual area resident deserves clean air. I've heard Clean Air Act requirements derided as SIP world. But then you turn around and use these requirements to your advantage whenever possible. In your proposal, control measures fail to pass muster because they could not take effect before thePage 23 deadline.Let's quit playing games, accept the responsibility to protect human health, accept that one day a reckoning will come. At some point every effort will have to be made to meet the standards. The sooner a decision is made to make steady progress towards the goal, the sooner the goal will bereached; 

# I Why in one scenario or sensitivity run are mobile sources and area sources newly dabbed ground level sources? Surely it's no accident that this renaming 

# I
uses the same terminology ground level used to 

# I distinguish hamful ozone from protective stratospheric ozone. Why offer up the Ship Channel zero out? It ignores scientific findings. And the reactivity and timing of Ship.Channel emissions 

# I uniquely affect ozone formation. Both scenarios appear designed,to give industry cover. 

# I In anot'her deliberate miscommunication you claim to be unable to affect mobile sources, but your own program, the Texas Admissions Reduction Plan, does. ..Let1 s own up. The state and local 'governments affect driving habits and the other mobile choices 

# I every single day. Stop playing word games. Make a commitment to clean up Houston's air sooner rather 

# I than later. Use all the means, at your disposal. 

## IPage 24 

### Commit to clean air now, not some unspecified date in the twenty-teens. The City of Houston, its mayor and residents are more than ready for a change. And I see representatives here from outlying counties. They too are ready for a change. We charge you to stand with, not against us. MS. HENNEKE: 

### Thank you, Ms. Strawn. Jane Laping will be followed by Melanie Oldham. MS. LAPING: Hello. I'm Jane Laping, L-A-P-I-N-GI with Mothers For Clean Air. And coincidentally, my remarks will be similar to the two you have heard before. But I will be delivering these on behalf of the children of the Houston-Galveston area. Here we are at another public hearing and here I am again representing 1,200 members of Mothers for Clean Air. And once again, we are asking for the state to take action, to clean up the air in Houston so that children can play outside and have healthy air to breathe. I have made this same plea for Mothers for Clean Air about the Houston-Galveston area state implementation plan many times in the past 10 years. And every time our plea has been met with another extension, another delay, another missed deadline, another broken promise. It is now 2007, the previousPage 25 deadline to attain the one-hour ozone standard. 2007, 

## I the'year we were supposed to have clean air in Houston. And although we have a new eight-hour ozone standard to meet, last year we exceeded the one-hour standard on 20 days. Yes, that is a big improvement ,over 2005, when there were33 days. But it.'s a long way from the standard of no more than three days over three years. So 

### we will miss another clean'.air deadline.And althqugh the .EPA says that we don't have to achieve the one-hour standard now that the eight-hour standard 

### is in place, do we not have an obligation to provide clean air for our. children now? 

# I

,. Instead, the TCEQ is offering us 

### a plan that 

# I will not get us to clean air in 2010, not in 2013 and 

# I maybe not even 

### in 2018, 11 years from now. We need to get on with 

### an effective solution to this problem, one that looks at all the options, even the unpopular ones and'the ones that will be fought by special interest

Who is the parent here? Is it TCEQ or industry? Is groups. ~ren't children a special interest group? .


### it the legislature or the lobbyist? .

This plan is not a first step. I't is more ' like the 12th step. TCEQ has had more than 30 yearsPage 26


### to come up with an effective plan. This plan is a . 

### step backward, not a step forward. Waiting for federal regulations to kick in, instead of creating our own rules is a cop-out. And the federal rules on cleaner vehicles and fuels won't get us all the way to clean air anyway. We need strong leadership at the top andqwe need a 

### strong, effective clean air plan, one that controls measures for all the emissions, not just 2 

### percent.

. . 

### If Los Angeles can do it, why can't we2 Where is that Houston Can Do attitude? ,Weneed to solve this ozone problem quickly and quit pussyfooting around. We have more serious problems to face li,ke fine particles in air toxics. Please, I beg the ~ommissioners,don1 t make our children hol'd their

., 

### breaths any longer. They have waited enough 

## -- 1:ong enough for clean air. Don't break yet another promise to our kids. MS. HENNEKE: Thank you, Ms. Laping. Melanie Oldham will be followed by Margaret Mitchell. MS. OLDHAM: Good afternoon. My name is Melanie Oldham and I'm a public citizen from Brazoria County, just south of here. And also, 

### I'rn with a called Citizens for Clean Air, Clean Water. . Page 27 I 

### Brazoria County. We're a group of concerned, interested citizens. In addition, 1'm a physical therapist. I've been a health professional for 

### 23 years, very concerned and interested in public health and environmental health, which go hand in hand. Also, 

### I would like to mention that my state rep is Dennis Bonin, who for the third session is. chairman of environmental regulation. Is anybody from ,hisoffice here to represent him? That kind of surprises me. 

### I '.m. glad that there is representative from my senator, Kyle Janer's office. 

### I appreciate that. Senator Janer's office has been interested in listening and learning. But 

### I wonder why the Commissioners aren't here. 

### I know we have the two right now. Actually, last week 

### I went to the Galveston Bay symposium and 

### I hea.rdCommissioner Soward speak. He .talkedabout' how the reality iswe have global warrning'andwe're.one of worst states in ,the.nationas far as emissions of certain VOCs and we do have something we need to get busy and fix. There is a way to have .abalance between economic development, which we all want, and jobs, and balance between environmental regulation. My rep, Dennis Bonin, keeps saying' that we need to keep thePage 28 

### companies happy at all costs. And I think 

# I environmental regulation has taken a back seat. 

### A lot of the citizens 

## -- as a physical therapist doing.home 

# I health, I work in those areas. We are a nonattainrnent county. Brazoria County has been for a long time. We also have a higher than expected incidence of certain cancers, lung cancer in men and non-Hodgkinlslymphoma in women, leukemia in children and we have an unbelievable amount of asthma cases, severe asthma, and people that are on oxygen 24 

### hour-s a day in their fifties. We know we have an issue. We know that' there's pollution and the health problems are related. This is the whole point. You know', how long 

# I are we going to wait to start cleaning up people's 

# I health? I know so many people have died of cancers, I 

### Lou ,Gehrigls disease, rare diseases, that we all 'know in some way is connected to the pollution in our .area. 

# I I've spent a lot of research since we have been in this group, Citizens for Clean Air, and I know that we have companies in Brazoria County that have been on the dirty dozen list for a while, such as Dow Chemical, Equistar, Gulf Chemical Metallurgical. 

### And this continues. We're on the watch list, but nothing 

### -- we don't see many monitors or regulations. When I call the state Region 

### 12, they usuallyPage 29 I I tell us, "We just don't have enough investigators. " I do know thatls the case 

## -- but I don't know that it happened 

### -- but in 2005, the legislature was trying to let go of 60 pepple with TCEQ. I think we don't have enough people to keep track of all the many different things they need to monitor. I know they are not down our county much. Alsoi I would like to,say'all the things that people have mentioned about controlling the VOCs form the storage tanks, degassing operations, marine vessel's. We already have a large Superfund site from marine vessel cleaning thatIs; in.Brazoria County thati 

### is affecting a Qotof neighborhoods on the coast. 

### We locally have asked for fence line monitoring. I know they have up here in Harris County, too, with hardly response from industry. Basically, know 

## , they say.-- I guess their thing is if we don't know who is responsible, then we don't have to do that much about it. I will say,that some companies have 

## --"a few put in fence line monitors. Mainly they use the money that they get I from 

### TCEQ

# . all.know, there

## 's plenty of grants out there that actually pays for them

. . to put in these new cleaner ways of operating. And 

### I. think we need to again look, 

### it affects screeningPage 30 

### levels. We need a panel that's been asked for over and over again of experts from all fields to look at how is it affecting us and our loved ones. I'm a physical therapist and 

### I also have worked at BACH Rehab Center, which treats babies zero to three with birth defects. In Brazoria County, this number keeps climbing and climbing, the number babies children that have severe birth defects. Also, we need to get serious about investigating. already mentioned seem have enough investigators. that. and

don't call for different groups in our area, they say we don't have anyone to send. TCEQ needs to double check data. A lot of our companies, Dow, Gulf Chemical, they pretty much self-monitor themselves and send in what they want to 

### TCEQ. We have had this Clean Air Act, I understand, since 1975. It's 30-plus years.. It keeps being postponed and postponed. Are you going to clean it up for us and our loved ones? MS. 

### HENNEKE: Summarize, please. MS. OLDHAM: 

### I think we need to develop a step'thatwill meet the ozone standards now. This, you know, on a personal level, 

### I have three children. I have a son with a disability. And we live about 20Page 31

. . 

# 1 miles from the petrochemical industry. I would ask again that this is something that we need to take serious, not postpone it another 5, 10, 15 years, but p1eas.e take a look at this now. 

## hank you. MS. HENNEKE: Thank you, Ms. Oldharn. Margaret Mitchell will be followed by Terri Thomas. MS. MITCHELL: My name 

### is Margaret Mitchell and I don't plan to actually read all the 13 footnoted pages of my remarks. And I would like to mention before I get to my remarks that I too am a mother of a disabled child. ,And I 

### am legally required by 

### law to live here. Because if you get 

### a divorce and your spouse lives here, you have to live here. I do not have the right to take my handicapped child away. I think that is outrageous. 

### And when I agreed to that, which I had no choice but to agree to that, I believed that the one-hour standard 

### was going to help 

# I

. - clean up our law 

### -- our area. But I was wrong. So now I will start my remarks. Last election, the voters' of this country 

# I rejecced the current administration's policies. I am 

# I hopeful that new leadership will be provided to give our regulators the tools they need to provide Houston, the city of the future, with the air we need to breathe. I 

### am hopeful that the disastrous decisionPage 32 

### that the current decision-maker has mandated, the decision not to enforce the plain language of Section 181 

### of the Clean Air Act, will be reversed.
. 

### We would do well to heed the example of Detroit. Once the crowning jewel of American industry, the car maker's insistence on outmoded and inefficient technologies that would not meet the demands of t,he future were fueled by foolish government policies advocated by the industry itself. The auto industry assumed its cozy regulatory protections against fuel standards would be more helpful to them, rather than meeting mileage standards mandated for years across the globe, in obtaining their economic profitability. Well, 

### I think the global economy has shown the auto industry the error of their thinking. 

### And it is the American workers who suffer. Other industries have also falsely assumed that their cozy relations with the powers that be would protect them from consequences. Even though individual smokers have been less successful than the # 

### states in their claims, 10 

### years ago few would have imagined that the tobacco companies would be paying out tens of billions of dollars for liability assumed despite the existence of an elaborate regulatoryPage 33 

### scheme to warn the user and limit that industry's liability. Toxic polluters today should understand that the protections they assume permits give them will not protect them tomorrow as the consequences of their horrible choices lead to new understandings. The recent explosion ac 

### the Texas City British Petroleum petrochemical plant that has led to a billion dollar upgrade is emblematic of this. Years of grandfathering outdated technologies resulted in the failure that led to a tragic loss of life. If 

### BP had pollution control equipment that conformed to environmentally appropriate technologies that were developed decades ago, that tragedy would not have occurred. It is time to stop coddling pollcters. Why does an international corporation get permits thatallow them to negligently pollute and kill Americans without any criminal liability? Even if'we are not dying in explosions, the cumulative effects of permitted pollutants have undeniably lethal effects. Our sensitive populations suffer. But we should not only be concerned with them; because economic justice is a false mantra when applied to the effects of air quality because even the fortunaate are adversely affected. The EPAhas written off the continued failurePage 3 

### of the Cancer Coast to meet the standards mandated by the 1990 

### Amendments to the Clean Air Act. They falsely assume that because of Houston's historic association with the petrochemical industry, that Houston is resigned to be the queen of the Cancer Coast. This subtle bias has prevented the world from appreciating the fabulous place that Houston is. Houston is the home to some of the finest minds in the world. Our internationally renowned universities, hospitals, and modern industries, combined with our generous civic spirit and lively creative cultural mix make us a gem among the world's leading industrial cities. Indeed, most people don't understand Houston and think that the energy industry is the biggest industry. But they don't know the heart of Houston. Houston's largest industry is health care. If Houston deserves royal status for anything, it is for being the site of one of the world's great medical centers, including 

### M. D. Anderson. All that is lacking to solve this problem is sufficient leadership. Houston has put a man on the moon. I ask you, if Houston cannot solve our problems, who in the world can?

. 

### MS. HENNEKE: Summarize, please. MS. MITCHELL: My summary is that thePage 35 

### eight-hour standard is completely different from the one-hour standard. And the eight-hour standard should not be imposed. The one-hour standard and all of the sanctions to industries 

### -- I have 14 highly footnoted pages that discuss this. Thank you. MS. HENNEKE: 

### Thank you, Ms. 

### Mitchell. Our next commenter is Terri Thomas, who will be followed by Annie Stewart. Go ahead. MS. THOmS: 

### My name is Terri 

### Thomas. 

### I would like just to make a comment. 

### his is the first time I've come to a TCEQ public hearing and 

### I am disappointed that the none of the Commissioners are here. 

### I hope :hat they will attempt to attend the other public hearings, at least one. I 

### am a board member of Mothers for Clean Air., I'm very pleased to be 

### such.. I went on the board of 

### Mothers for Clean Air after helpl.ng to get an air particulate study for the 1-10 

### expansion, where the 'studyshowed particulate pollution will,increase by 46 percent, with 13 schools and thousands of homes lined within the danger zone. 

### I also helped to get an ozone monitor placed in the Memorial Villages, where in the first year of operation it registered as many bad ozone days as the monitors in the east .side. of town. These are two 

### of the reasons that 

### I wanted toPage 36



### come and speak to the Commissioners today and say in general I am for the rules that the TCEQ has proposed in its clean air plan, but I am 

### definitely opposed to the plan's delay until 2018 

### for implementing the eight-hour ozone standard. Houston's air pollution is a 

### major threat to the public health. I heard the lady from Brazoria talk about her experiences. Our citizens suffer ill health effects from our increasing air particulate and high ozone levels throughout Houston. And everyone suffers the economic cost to our overburdened health care system. Houston air pollution also threatens our economy. Houston will not attract businesses and new jobs in the future if we do not address this serious problem. I'm sure that the Commissioners are all very successful in their chosen endeavors, in their successful careers. I'm also sure that they had the courage to make decisions that they knew were right in their heart. As members of the Commission, you are representing the health and livelihood of millions of people in this region, including some of your family, friends and neighbors. Nearly 50 

### years have past between thePage 37 original passage of the Clean ~ir~ct 

### in 2018, when TCEQ projects the eight-hour ozone standard can be met. The plans and laws are not in place for each of the 2010 EPA-imposed deadlines. TCEQ needs to step up to the plate and propose 

### a plan that will meet 100 percent of the emission reductions needed, not just 2 percent, as they have proposed in this plan. If you,,the Comissioners, 'will have the courage to do what you know in your heart to be right, all Houstonians and the people in this region will live better, healthier lives. Thank you for your 

### time

# . MS. HENNEKE: Thank you, Ms. Thomas. I skipped out of order and I apologize. Tom McKittrick. And next after Mr. McKittrick will be Annie Stewart. My apology. Go ahead, 

### sir. MR. McKITTRICK: My name is Tom McKittrick, M-C-K-I-T-T-R-I-C-K. 

### I'm a native Houstonian and architect, retired from practice, and professor emeritus at Texas A&M University. 

### I'm a mild asthmatic and I have a brilliant 5-year-old grandson who. has to use an Albuterol inhaler on bad air days

## . What are his chances and those many other 5-year-olds of a cancer-free life when you will not force polluters to do everything they can to stopPage 38 

### polluting our air as soon as humanly possible, not 11 

### years down the road when your experts might say again that attainment isn't possible and you gave in again? I, too, am on the board of Mothers for Clean Air. There is no organization called Grandfathers for Clean Air. So I'm proud to be a member of that organization, to try to help in any way I can to see that our children have clean air to breathe. Are there any new ideas out there? 

### I haven't heard any of these mentioned today. And they might not be at all practical, but I'm going to toss them out anyway. Help get rid of all two-stroke engines in the state, not just worn-out engines of trucks and heavy equipment. You've got programs that do that. That means lawn mowers, leaf blowers and some recreational vehicles and watercraft. Add parents from Houston to your turf advisory board. I've looked through the representatives that serve on that board, and most of them seem to appear to represent industries. Yes, many of those members might also be parents. But how about an advocate on that panel for children? You might try through the legislature to require TxDOT 

### to include air quality monitoring stations at all new highway critical locations. Just this week in the Houston Chronicle therePage 39I 

### was an article about how life near busy roads are a threat to children. Terri Thomas has already mentioned that we had 

### a study done on the Katy Freeway and we found that children at Awty School will be subjected to so much air pollution and fine particulates, they will not be able to play outside on many days. Another suggestion, borrow some FEMA 

### trailers and ask the Commissioners to live in Southeast Houston for a few days and then to see how they feel about their responsibilities as TCEQ dommissioners, or simply ask them visit the children's cancer facilities in the Texas Medical Center. And then pray that their grandchildren don't find themselves there as patients. Some of this may sound outrageous. ~ut 

### the outrageous thing is that those Commissioners are not here. 

### I want to look them in 

### the eye and say, "Do something about the quality of the air in this nonattainment area. 

## hat's what you were appointed to do. " 

### Thank you. 

### MS. 

### HENNEKE: Thank you, sir. Annie Stewart will be followed by Frank Salzhandler 

## -- somethi,ng. Frank, 1'11 get back to you in a minute. MS. STEWART: Good afternoon, everybody. 

# IPage 40 

### And this- is my first time being here and I got this information that this meeting was going to be held this afternoon so I didn't have the opportunity to type up anything. I'm concerned about the reason that.this meeting is held at this location when a lot of our processing is on the east side of town where the most chemicals and toxic waste is. This small problem comes from chemicals of various sources, with any type of race, toxic and otherwise. We live in this area. From the Ship Channel area, we have a huge number of chemical 

### -- tanks holding chemicals, as well as incoming ships, the large trucks, 18-wheelers, and what have you, that is hauling this stuff back and forth throughout our neighborhoods. Our neighborhoods are exposed to all of this. The neighborhoods are Clinton Park, Clinton View, Fidelity, Pleasantville, Galena Park, Jacinto, etcetera, all of these are adjacent areas. In the east, the last 30 years large pipes have been moved in this area with waste. pnd I hope to jbst kind of, as I go, show you some of these pipes that have been placed in this area. And this is right down beside 610, between Clinton Drive and Market Street. And they carry this waste over to a placePage 41 

### that they built on the side of 610 

### to store these wastes. Also, here is a water treatment facility on Clinton Drive between Lockwood and South Wayside. 

# I These chemicals are very dangerous to our health, the breathing process. We have various wheezing- and congestions and cancer in the area. Not just us, but for all of the adjacent areas. They have installed these'chemicals in this 

### -- a large I would say two miles in either direction, these chemicals that they dredge from the Ship Channel is placed in this thing that they built on the side of 610 

### there in the past three years. It's a holder. It has been built there along 610 between Clinton and Market Street, as I

this be dealt with? If the fines are high enough, it 

# I is believed these companies will adjust their ways, not just proposing something, because proposing is not fixing the problem. You're making a proposal. Now I do agree with all of the speakers prior to me because I can't address all of the information and they habe addressed a lot of things that 

### I would have addressed had 

### I had time to do so. But there is no reason-forme to re-address what they have alreadyPage 42 

### addressed. It all concerns us. We live in these neighborhoods. So 

### I would say to the people in charge, please get about your business and help people to live a little bit longer, help our children to be able to I 

### attend schools and get an education without having to be snotty-nosed and sneezing and ~arrying germs and stuff that they have collected from this area. The Ship Channel, it's not only the vehicles. I think the these tanks and things carry more hazardous material than a vehicle. Now combined together they may all put the same amount. Thank you. MS. HENNEKE: ' 

### Thank you, Ms. Stewart. Frank Salzhandlyr, and if 

### I have done this totally wrong, just fix it, Frank. And Frank will be followed by Skelly Holmbeck. Go ahead. ' 

### MR. SALZHANDLER: Yes. My name is Frank Salzhandler. I'm representing the Endangered Species Media Project. I 

### sit on numerous boards with organizations like the Children's Environmental Health Institute and Citizens Environmental Coalition, the Citizens for Environmental Action Now. And all of us have been questioning why our city has fallen behind so far in its ability to attain these standards. And our concern is that it's easy to hide behind agencies,Page 43

- but we feel that our state legislature, our lieutenant governor and our governor need to address these issues as well as our national politicians, including the President of United States, who has watered down the Clean Air Act and, from what environmentalists can discern, has put the enviro'mental effo:rt in this country back 30 years. And when we start talking about these issues,
we need to put a face on the individuals that are continuously watering down theseabilities ,for our children to live and thrive in a healthy environment. I talk to teachers that say their children get violently ill when they go out for recess. The amounts of cases of childhood asthma, childhood leukemia have risen to the point to where these politicians, these names and faces that need to be addressed need to understand they are not just talking about a budget and they are not just talking about how much 

### it's going to cost or the most unfathomable statement that it's impossible for us to clean up. They're talking about children's lives. And they're talking about especially the young people and the elderly that are more susceptible to these hazards. And they need to be addressed as individuals, not just as agencies. These politicians need to be heldPage 44 

### accountable as 'individuals, because otherwise they are going to continuously hide behind their agencies. And we need to make them accountable and we need them held to a higher standard and held to the standard of a higher power. Thank you. MS. 

### HENNEKE: Thank you, sir. Lucy Randel. Lucy, are you here? 

### I think that's Lucy. Who will then be followed by Skelly Holmbeck. MS. RANDEL: My name is Lucy Randel, R-A-N-D-E-L. 

### I have a master's degree in chemical engineering and 

### I have 10 

### years experience in environmental engineering, including five years with an engineering firm, working for the petrochemical industry in Houston. I'm also a mother and a community volunteer. Today 

### I'm representing myself. 

### I notice every August,' just as the children go back to.schoo1, the ozone alerts also start coming. Many times they have had to have physical education or recess indoors because the air quality was not suitable for outdoor play. Three of my daughters1 classmates in kindergarten and first grade were I 

### hospitalized during a two-year period because of complications for asthma and pneumonia, conditions exacerbated by high ozone. Many days these children' need to stay inside or miss a soccer game because thePage 45 

### air is too polluted for asthmatic children to play outside. My own daughter does not have asthma, but has experienced frequent upper respiratory infections. 

### I believe you need the strongest implementation plan possible to improve our air quality. Based on my industry experience, 

### I know the controls being proposed are'no-t onerous. I believe monitoring emissions is very important because so much of the emissions inventory is considered uncertain or unreported. 

### I believe the controls on tanks are

. . 

### overdue and' straightforward,,but could be even

. . 

### stronger than proposed. 

### I 'm di~ap~pointed that the compliance date is so far out. The Clean Air Act was passed over 30 

### years ago, yet we and our children are still,waiting "for clean air Houston. MS. 

### HENNEKE: Thank you, mala'm. Skelly Hol~nbeckfollowed by Jackie Ploch. MS. HOLMBECK: Hi. It's Skelly Holmbeck. 

### I'm an environmental scientist with 

### FPL Energy. 

### I want to thank the TCEQ for the opportunity to comment on the draft rules. There have been a lot of passionate comments-today. 

### I think it's this kind public involvement that really makes our country strong and 

### I cornmend TCEQ and all, the participants. As is the case across FPL groups, companiesPage 46 

### nationwide, FPL Energy is committed to producing clean energy and is currently doing so in Texas. Of the almost 4,500 megawatts that we provide in Texas, 36 

### percent of those megawatts are from emission-free wind turbines. The remaining almost 3,000 megawatts are produced by clean natural gas-fired combined cycle units, including the Forney plant in Kaufman County. I'm here today actually to comment on the Dallas-Forth Worth NOx SIP. The Commission's analysis and methodology provide a solid foundation for emissions reduction and SIP compliance with the federal mandate. One of the most efficient and environmentally responsible approaches to reducing NOx emissions, a precursor of ozone formation, is to use an output-based NOx emissions standard. One clarification or addition necessary for this rule to apply as intended is to ensure that an accurately calculated output base

, 

### option applies to gas-fired combustion turbines. In addition, a change to the rule to include a 30-day rolling average to the CO commission standard will continue to allow gas-fired plants to respond to peak power demand in Texas. 

### A few neutral output-based NOx 

### emissions standards will promote more efficient electricPage 47 1 

### generation. The proposed .5 

### pounds per megawatt hour option for gas-fired combined cycle units should apply for the following reasons. 

### An output-based standard gets the air cleaner faster. 

### An output-based methodology rewards efficient plants, in effect integrating energy efficiency into the emissions control program. Rewarding increased deficiency 

# I reduces emissio~s 

### of all pollutants, including NOx, 

### S02, CO and 

### C02. Using an output-based standard for gas-fired combined cycle plants simplifies reporting, 

# I comparison and may influence dispatch modeling. Simply put, an output-based standard is a clear metric. It measures what is most important. It 

# I measures power being produced and the emissions being produced simultaneously. For combined cycle plants, 

# 1
NOx output per megawatt produced must be calculated based on the total megawatts produced by the unit. For instance, when waste heat
' 

### from combustion 

# I turbine is used to power a heat recovery steam generator, the entire megawatts output should be used in the calculation. The language should be clarified or added to the draft regulation to clearly state that the output-based standard applies to investor-owned 

# I and operated stationary combustion turbines, as well 

# IPage 4 

### FPL thanks TCEQ for their hard work on this very complex plan and we appreciate the chance to comment today. Thank you. MS. 

### HENNEKE: Rosalia Guerrero-Leura. If you would, state your name, please. MS. GUERRERO: My name is Rosalia Guerrero. And 

### I iive at 724 Eastpark in Sugar Land, Texas. I was born and raised in this great state of ~ex'as and I'm proud of that. And 

### I think it's both a privilege and a responsibility. And I think that as

-' 

### Texans we try to strive towards excellence. But as a wise man once said, "It is hard to soar like an'eagle when you're surrounded by turkeys." And for that 

### I will try to do my part from letting TCEQ and other agencies like fall into

I would like to say also that Houston's poor air quality does not only affect Houston, but the surrounding area, such as Fort Bend County, which I'm a resident of. And as a 

### resident of Fort Bend County and a member of the Mayfield Park Homeowners Association, I would like to declare myself and my neighborhood affected the proposed revisions to the state implementation plan. We also ask TCEQ to begin testing and monitoring the air inPage 49 Fort Bend county because there is no such testing going on now. So we know how Houston's poor air 

# I quality is affecting our families, as well as those of Harris and Brazoria County. Thank you very much. MS. 

### HENNEKE: Thank you. Is there anyone else who wishes to give us comment this afternoon? Is there anyone else who wishes to give.us comment this afternoon? Like an auction, you get three shots. Anyone else who wishes to give us comment this afternoon? I do want to thank you all very much for taking your time to be with us here this afternoon. We will be here. There are six additional hearings being held. We will be in this room at 6 p.m. We 

# I actually will be 30 minutes in advance of that. We will also be Dallas on Wednesday, this Wednesday, at 7 p.m.; Arlington on Thursday at 2 p.m.; Midlothian at 6 

# i p.m. ; Longview on February the '6th, which is a ' 

# I Tuesday, at 2 p.m.; and in Austin on February the 8th 

# I at 2 p.m; The schedule is detailed in the news release that is back there. The staff will be here for a while if there is something that you would like to visit with us 

# I
one-on-one about. I would like to remind people that this hearing, as well as all the others, are beingPage 5 recorded on compact disk. That will be part of the backup package that is available for our Commissioners to hear and as well as review all of the summaries, as well as all of the written comments. Thank you very much for taking your time. I know it is an effort for everybody to be here. Thank you. And this hearing is closed. (Proceedings concluded at 3:06 p.m.)COUNTY 

### OF HARRIS') STATE OF TEXAS )
REPORTER

### ' S CERTIFICATION 

## I, Phyllis Loy, Certified Court Reporter in and for the State of Texas, hereby certify that this transcript is a true record of the testimony given. 

### I further certify that Iam neither attorney
11 the parties to the action inwhich thls testimony was 

# I I 10 nor counsel for, re1ated to, nor employed by any of


### 12

Subscribe.d 

### a.nd sworn to on February 2, 

### 2007,.

'

# I taken. Further, 

### I 

### am 

### hot a relative or 

### employee 

### of 

### 13 74

Certified Court Reporter In

### and f,or the State of Texas any attorney of record in this case, nor do 

### I have a financial interest inthe action.

Certification 

### No, 3301 Expiration Date: 12/31108

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 1

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Name

. > (PledsePrint) , I.*.. ;., +..A:'~~.

Yes 

### J 

# fiEstwCIee 

# PI l14k 

# LJ~; 

# L .', .A. ' . i 

## . ' ,,.,.8:'.,..,. 1. 'i jib ..?.. ..t, 1, 

### 'l~~b~~~~~~ 

# .. 1-2 ,, ' fi,ta.,*.-
, , 

# 7h-e 

# F&C+S

~xY,o\\~E\oP, I 

## L

'- 

# SeCC L&+dpc( 

# PG-,J 

# EL.-^\&^^ /:., I,.. PresentingOralTestimony? (Circle One)

, , . : , .,,. Yes No

yes 

# (3

yes ... I



# T-Y' &.+- / I 

# J--4

# bb-- &wq~y Yes 

# @

yes

# d\

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SI P-NR, 2006-03 1 -SIP-NR Location: Houston-GalvestonArea Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

## I Concerning: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 11 7; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) 

# F~ 5&332

,- 

# ,o

.CP~D~ Representing 

# oQ,o ~0,fi3~~m5&&t~5



# cry

?.hnp; 

# 1L2 I ten ~f 

# J 

# PL,,, G\ h-7 

# firi(uic~~~h4ilnc 

# he, 

# - 'Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) Yes

# mj

Yes



## -

# bhv\ \/\~.r\h\% u 

# 0; \ 

# Kie Yes 

# @ 

# k.n n [/(taitvc 

# 0.1 

# f 

# GYS TWG

# \c;~h\ \ 

## p2-a 17, 

# ~ut21 ~ie~vi 

# [db Yes 

# O rf7, Yes
NO

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN,2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

## I

Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes 

### &3

Yes 

# @ Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print)

Yes 

# @ Representing

Yes 

# @ 

# Ed-, b~c!,; 

# \ Yes 

# @,

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

### 1

Concerning: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print)

Ye. 

# e Representing

/.?- 

### -



# 2-1 ./-' Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) 

# tb tL42/ t SC&+ 

# -- 50, Lr"\/~45k O..dA 

# p/~/Iep&k @ No 

# TC~ yes 

# a (rm No 

# 4

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SI P-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-03 1 -SIP-NR 

## I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

## I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Yes No Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-GalvestonArea Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

## @

Yes 

## @

Yes 

# c,

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

## I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

### (@iJ

Yes 

# &J

Yes 

# &

G6-e

## ccxs: e -M 

# s; iYes! No

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

### ( Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555Timmons Lane, Houston I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (PleasePrint) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (CircleOne)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print)

$1 

### Ll -

jtL7.t 

# hicL\ S@ 

# \ -5qbt~Oh

I Represent~ng



# U v\(,,evS \

# +"\ { \+aaj+,r\kleq, \ 

# SL

# r

# O+odMonk Gcb PresentingOralTest~rnony? (Circle One) Yes 

# Q

Yes 

# @

Yes 

# @

yes 

# e

Yes 

# GJ

Yes 

## @

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SI P-NR, 2006-02741P-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-03 1 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane. Houston 

### I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) I Name (Please Print) 

# n - 

# 40,G\G\\ 

# 3 w-

\



# BUD Kb\fiac/+, -4 

### L4 

# Chcishm 

# sd-+-,

r- 

### (,Go~.~-ss\ 

# -Jo Ln,~~~ 

# SJ 

# C Yes 

# @ Representing

A 

# scj4 /

l-j 

### .c~+L-XT 

## (-\ -

# GP 

# PMJ-krd~e L Yes

# a

Yes

# c\

Yes 

# a

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 BOOp.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

## I

Concerning: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

# @ 

# I(-~L 

# Fi'k (?i,q& 

# U/hann P 

# ZJ*~ 

# x 'Zt+ / 

# &

# ss Tcb-4

# -st?~ 

# 64 

# XU&
a. Yes 

## @

Yes 

## @

Yes 

## @

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 BOOp.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 1 17;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

,-- 

# 3 '-.J 

# /loO.

# &a*caL - jUyfkan 

## jI~efi 

# ,. ~hf-k 

### v(4~ 

# (?oq 

# AL&/, Name (Please Print) 

# FU S,ALZ~AIL)~C<~ 

## .p

4 

# us ~p-qc4-o 

### r 

## TO^? Capvlyfi

V- 

# 16 

# LC 42 (‘J Representing 5pyA A &,LCD 

## GP zL 5 \A

# yik.~. /

# /ICIr+

# dC jf~~ku

yes 

# a

Yes 

# a

yes 

# @?

Yes 

# & Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) 

# (+~?GJ No
Yes 

# a

## Texas Commission on ~nvironmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 a00p.m. 

# IRule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Tirnrnons Lane, Houston

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment demonstration SIP. HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

\ 1

## -c

./'

TOi4~ llq-,&,~~ Name (Please Print) 

## r> ---5 

### f% 

# i/75X/LJ

7! :1; 9l.q LL,/ 

## I~L~IY~ kc(<



# - 5.

. 

### KYc2 

# rfi .NEIC Representing 

# /w C

# ' / 

### F~C E 13

### E(F&~/ 4 C

# u

Yes 

## @ 

# k\- &,Ac Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)
,6&3 No 

# pro

I Yes 

# @

4") Yes c-I

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 S:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SI P-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SI P-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-GalvestonArea Council, 3555Timmons Lane, Houston Concerning: ~evisions to 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) 

# 9 &la/" 

# @~qglq?3~ J~d4tL 

# ?I Q&~ 

# /' 

# hu~~ 

# SrDtc

i 

### hc4

# (1 es 

# A

# + ;a LiL,acPcon 

# Av\aJo 

# a. ELCA-\;~

/I 

### o~~-J 

## K/ 

# 5 

# c<\

Y 

### >'A 

# I 

# 5 71 ordsialL vib~E

r-



## \

## x~ GT 

# L-~-GAG 

# -77, /-twvl+~im~ I 

# ~6~5- --lq~s 

# sa& Yes No 

# a@ /-=q Yes 

# W

yes
Yes 

### .KG-
? Yes 

# w'

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration January 29,2007 

### SOO p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-11 5-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031 -SIP-NR 

## ( Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555Timmons Lane, Houston

Concerning: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) 

# Lo VB/ 

# /iDbir/SLih/ 7

la,\ 

# LA,, 

# ENIT SOARHA LC&' 1'&?1~5 Representing

/'- ' 

### lZ,



## - Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) 

# )?$c /jj~.Sj~P 

# SuPJ~~cY~O,~C.\ L 

# F"\ Lt, &T-&Sk; 

# L

y NOELL 

## T".., 

# XG Yes 

# a

Yes 

# 0

Yet 

# @ -7, yes

# E,,

I 3 sd& 

### ~os~.\-Io- 

# GLlwy-e,m 

# -~~~~~x 

# 3-e~~ b~~d~\& 

# <~IC \&F4% 

# c 

# C yes 

# 1 NO

Yes 

# 0

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration I January 29,2007 9:00p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

## I Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP



# I I Yes No 

# I Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print) 

# T~~HSRA~ 

# % CoO/~

F 

# - ,+Q .-( 

# ~7y-C~ 

# /c93'T 

### f--!? 

# I I Yes No 

# I Representing

Yes No 

# M ,b 

# AN

# wt>~sac/ cff-ua~ Ct-hl~x 

# I<h'oG 

# - Ti.?I, Yes 

## @

Yes 

# aINDEX OF ORALTESTIMONY January 29, 2007, 6:00 p.m.-Houston-Galveston Area Council, Houston, Texas Nooral comments receivedregardingthis rulemaking

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-GalvestonArea Council, 3555Timmons Lane, ~oust~n

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) 

## B~PKCC 

# RCn 7nr, Yes P'



# 6-Br.4ts

7 

# F !7 L 5Isd 

# efz&</

Yes 

## @ 

# a No
Yes 

# 0
2 

# rrc Yes 

### @66

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston I Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Yes

# a Name (Please Print)

Yes &o

Yes 

# @ - Representing

Yes 

# & Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

# 6 ,L /+ l'JbYvc 

# 1. 

# S-t/iJ<Ic/ T~EQ /<-Iz Yes 

# @

,

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration January 29, 2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555Timmons Lane, Houston Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (PleasePrint) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony?
Yes 

# I Citiztns 

## C\wn

. 

## Air 

# oldh~., clqn
A

### WL*~ 

### in 

## BrruriL Yes NO
Yes 

# @

Yes

# a
/



# f UdY 

# b'd~~4@

(&*,<A& 

# doq C/@J/

# 6~ 

# Cod JJg )I 

# O$L 

# [w~~-J Yes

# q

Yes 

# @

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. RuleProject No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN,2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-GalvestonArea Council, 3555Timmons Lane. Houston 

# I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP7 HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) Yes

# a

Yes 

# Q


# Chh\LL

# GG(, b...-r- 

# Ca Yes 

# a

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR,2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555Timmons Lane, Houston

Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW&Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes Name (Please Print)

L



# .

Yes

. No Representing wdd~&~) 

# &)z 1- 

### r'~e3&f-- 

# 9-re--r-6 Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) 

# @ No

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.:

. 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Houston-GalvestonArea Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

Yes No

Yes No

Yes No

Yes No t

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-GalvestonArea Council, 3555 Timmons Lane, Houston 

# I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes No

Yes No

Yes No

Yes No I Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-GalvestanArea Council, 3555Timmons Lane, Houston

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes No
1 Yes No 

## I Yes NO
Yes No

Yes No

## Texas 

## Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 29,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR,2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Houston-Galveston Area Council, 3555Tirnrnons Lane, Houston

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes 

# 4 Name (Please Print)

Yes No
Yes

# a - Representing

Yes No
Yes No Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

Yes

. No fINDEX OFORAL TESTIMONY January 31,2007, 7:00 p.m.

## -J. ErikJonssonCentral LibraryAuditorium, Dallas, Texas No oral comments received regarding this rulemaking

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) 

# fish g~od~ Representing

Yes 

# @ 

# 3 LbJ<CE

# ik-k2(/0~/ /-7 &UART 

# k:]~,< 

# O!J

# cp~ 

# OL7[ /7:YcJ 

# LJ@,@ 9 Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)



# &\i

# 6, ?

# r,\TG k3isli 

# GPO\/;-- - 

# sh &Lyb/~ 

# 01'k QW~~/~~~~~.~L &kY9 

# 1

# ~m~ .* Yes 

# Q

Yes

# Q

Yes 

## @

Yes 

# &

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31, 2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 1.515 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, .I 15,and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes No Name (Please Print) 

# +. +de[ail.q.~!YLpi'Sdo

Yes No 

# I

Yes No Representing 

## ,/~,r~elr 

# 6P.4 L?Q

# ,,- 9

# q 

# gfi~ b : ,,-, 

# ,~&+;i--c7'rw 

# - Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

~

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule ProjectNo.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-HourOzone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing PresentingOral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

# @ 

# ,A G/oY~

Yes Yes

Yes

Yes .-

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing PresentingOral ~estimon~? (Circle One) 

## Qea, 

## Larrei~ 

# LEE kmg

w 

# 65~ ~nou & 

# ~sX 6roy4 Yes @

Yes 

### @ 

# ,dJ/+ Gm d-e
Yes 

## @

LLL2A/Yr Yes 

# Q

Yes 

# & ~h;l 

# &dY* Ask gpbve Yes 

# G3

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 1515 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP 

### I Name (Please Print)


# 7 t 

## wJ~ de(/ 

# /U~DW~

[A*i~i. 

# L~~- Representing 

# fi3h Gra~.e 

# A54

# L#?D~~ - Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Yes 

# (s

Yes 

# a
L- 

# &-- 7+5~ 

### &ovt Yes 

# c+

yes 

## -7

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 1515 Young Street, Dallas concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP 

## I Name 

## I



# . ~*W-~II Yes 

# 6 r a c;~ 

## s

# 1, Grwe (Please Print)

I 

### I Representing PresentingOral Testimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

# -9 No

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 1515 Young Street, Dallas

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) 

# 1% 

# 6 v;- J

## d.

# % Yes 

# @ 

# iu~AIIL~ 6k*U 

# LY

i :.
'/ 

# 7 ('a lr

# / \( p L 

### 13 ~~f-&~@+,--& 

# I I I I 

# TX 

# I 5; +%L~.L, 

## -ui~L&5 

## 5 

# 4 -D4//p5 

# ]

# ] 

# hiL; Tci 

# p([ \ LeyYes 

# @ /--'. 

# L.,, NO

r- 

### . yes 

## UI /'NO 

# 62; 'L/ NO

Yes No

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 1515Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW 8-HourOzone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

H Yes 

# affdf pLuLd I

,- 

### CA 

## ,h?_efi Yes 

# GI

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-HourOzone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing 

# ., Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) Yes No 

## ,? Yes 

# w,

LCYes @?>

Yes 

# a

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing ~egistration January31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIPrNR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 1515 Young Street, Dallas 

# I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Yes 

# Q

Yes Name (Please Print)

/ 

# -@ No )US? -+I~lv\e harep 

## ei-t ;

# ze

V Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central ~ibrary Auditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) 

## /.q, Yes /No 

### L/'

Yes 

# @

Yes &) -

# I 

# id, L,' yes ,?%&,

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-415-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR,2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. ErikJonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 1515 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print)

5 

# Gc?./lL A

## flRepresenting Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) 

# flw Yes 

# GI

Ye* 

# @ 

# QkA

-rqbyes% No

Yes.: No 

# 0 w G



# '6) u 

# IJCM/G:I &qlAlli'~ ebi~ 

# BLtLJjLEJ i~//l 

# &&

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR Location: J. ErikJonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes 

### @ Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)
; @;jC2. N f,

. Name (Please Print) 

# <

, . 

# &. - ! 

### ,,,,,;7 

## k Representing

c'? 3

### LeL/=

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR,2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) 

# Self Yes 

### (I@.,? Representing PresentingOral Testimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN,2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFPSIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

# 0 &&A3 

### + / -4 =& AdflL&



## '7 

# ,c f /&7 

## ,s ,*, ,(J ( Yes 

# E,

/--. -. Yes

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR,2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: J. ErikJonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas 

# I Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print) .?---., Yes 

# &')

./I Representing

Yes 

# Q

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007

I 7:00 p.m.

Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN,2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-03 1 -SIP-NR Location: J. ErikJonsson Central Library Auditorium, 1515Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
PresentingOralTestimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print) 

# Qi?-c- Q ~i'~~u 

# JJiny 

# J.A~L,~~~ Representing

d--- 

# &L!~,C- P~A- 

### G~~X,I 

# Gr,,Lr DKIILJ 'Lam yes 

# G>

Yes 

# G

Yes No
Yes No

Yes No -

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR,2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: J. ErikJonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (CircleOne) 

# 8fl&pibf5hpL 

# igr4 Yes



# biJ~fiI

# &a

I 

# 0 !iau 

# /3eeio~\ 

# 0 OC~ 

# 5 I Yes 

# 6

Yes 

# (CJ

Yes

# Q)

yes 

# (3 Q~L



### v \ 

# &/& jfi~ 

# CLJ.\~ 

# GI~~-~- / 

# \ f CI

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration

Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: J. ErikJonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 151 5 Young Street, Dallas Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW &Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

## I7 NO

Yes 

# Q

Yes 

# Q

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31, 2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central Library Auditorium, 1515Young Street, Dallas 

# 1 Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes No
Yes No

Yes No Name 

# - (Please Print) 

### TW

Yes No

Yes No Representing

--

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration January 31,2007 7:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: J. Erik Jonsson Central LibraryAuditorium, 1515Young Street, Dallas 

# I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-HourOzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)INDEX OF ORALTESTIMONY February I, 2007, 2:00 p.m.-Arlington City Hall Council Chambers,Arlington, Texas Nooral comments received regardingthis rulemaking

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W.Abrams Street, Arlington I Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Yes

# e,

Yes 

# y;>

u

Yes 

## @

Yes\, 

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington 

### 1

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Yes 

## @ Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print)



# 1

# ffl A.MKFJc#

Yes No

-. Representing

Yes 

# @

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington 

### I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and I 17;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing PresentingOralTestimony? (Circle One)

// Yes 

# PJ

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington I

Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

L/ Yes 

# 0 SFLF Name (Please Print)

, , Representing

, > .. .. ' r,.., PresentingOral Testimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February I, 2007 2:00 p.m.

. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: ArlingtonCity Hall Council Chambers, 101W.Abrams Street, Arlington 

## I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

#

, 

# C/,~,';IZ? a, e~5- 

# /y

6

. ,,*E$.7>;.!?:c.,: .:3$;;,;:, .,:s.?q, ,b,r :.:.>:, :-:., , ;:. ? ...

### .=-,;.;*.iqx7,:. ..-.: >, ,$: , ,.: *

...e,,., .::*&; +*,.;?a>*-;,; !.,SI<..?+. % .*,.%&,~;,, ;w!.$..C

~

# iq$*Qk&$,:F;7&h&;i.:;q'q

... /.-: , ., <." LZri K ..:J'. 

### :;-:wkj$ ,- .>,."> >.,,.

>': ,> * .. -.

Yes No yes 

## &2

--..- 

### @. No

.. .

/ f 

# 0 /,;~15, 

# r

# hi/^hd 

# ej7 [+ 

## rl3 

## 62

## i lh/0~4~,- ! *

Yes No yes 

# e-

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington I

Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 1 17;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

- - Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) Yes 

# a

Yes 

# i /- d 

## jli~ ADF?

# o3 7-7@/~5 &3 L-4- 1 

### LC 

# /4% 

# A?4mF

<- 

## 2~/1/7 

## o(u 

# ,,

el /

### / 

# /LL~- 

# k) e9 \/ 

## / 

# ->AT Yes 

# (g

Yes 

# E,

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington 

## I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP



# 3%- 

# I/ Yes

'.___ _ Yes 

# 61

/ Name (Please Print)

Yes No 

# 0 4c.t4 

# -_ ,$$J$yy,&'

I 

## - , Yes No,%,, 

## v7 

# +)"$&,.e L Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-1 1 5-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street. Arlington

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) 

# Q :\I& A. ec/~>bcz

Yes 

# @
/ Representing

,\. ' un;ver5ilcz 

### &v;51i&z 

## ChG

# CCF,

CJhzi5 &kLdM, 

# dx plbtGyA&+hT 

### b1\(

# cxs ir Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) yes 

### CZi

Yes 

## @

w 

# vyw k& /-- (?-. Yes 

### W

/-T No

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February I, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN,2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR,2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street,Arlington 

## I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW$-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print)

Yes No 

# &\ Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (CircleOne)

#------

%--,- /A-~L~\-~~,

. ---z ,

# L

---.--- ~~au~i~/A -.-A<- A A d - . -, 

# km

7 -. N~
Yes No

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SI P-NR, 2006-027-SI P-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington 

### I Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

,Y Yes 

# 59

*-F- ,' 

# 1. ,...) (-. 

### 1 (,+, 

# iJ (i;, Yes i' No 

## .'

.- :l' 

## 4gD,7

r ,.' - . ,,.. . . /."\. Yes 

## &,,)

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W.Abrarns Street,Arlington 

### I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Ye. Name (Please Print)
Yes 

# @ Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commissionon EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration

Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington 

# I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP Name (Please Print)

/" 

# 3A /,jq 

# (3 

# .E

''1 yh~~~~~;T 

# \ dc:L.

# c, 

# j

# &k [i 

# I?CL!~ 

# 4W\ 

# ijn,

A 

# &, jrLiyq 

# Lit kTLikl 

# e.. i \ 

# + - 

# 14il\:qL 

# tl ci Representing 

# 1'~ L

# F 

# /nil=

. L Presenting Oral Testimony? (CircleOne) ,.Yes." j1No -<.:-.

# .o-

F%..

I t.7 

# LI 

# [d

.< 

# dry ,-. . yes KO,'
yes 

# :a

= ~, ' 

# '. Yes !" No \.
. --. 

# :.n. yes 

### ( NO j L.,

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Arlington City HallCouncil Chambers, 101W.Abrams Street, A2gton 

# I Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Yes Name (Please Print) Representing



### ~0tz7+/~ 

# /R bNC~<q&~&:,,~@~3

-1 . Yes 

# 602 Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes 

## dwod&%r-t&~e~

Yes 

# COQ ,h"k CI,LA 

## -7y Yes 

# GJ

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SI P-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-03 I -SIP-NR Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington 

# - Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP Name (Please Print)

,- I -, 

# ( //?pr tT/ ; T,fiAa. iI//v,, L.L 

### - ! Representing 

# + L 7 -. , 

## rfi Lh/~~c-',! -- 1. 

### *, P.'

. ,'

L .,I 

## p,

# .\q j- i/v

I Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

/.' ) Yes /' No, L'

-. .-. Yes ,\tW2 

### /il n. /I /- {-<,;I 

# - /;: //,

! r7 

# 5.

, 

### is?- 

## (J~ ~Q~~,~~,,~~~~ 

# - 0' 

# !r-J i rc 

# , U, L*L< 

# (5 LqpL

-.- ..'? -1 Yes u- /.No

,---Ti, Yes .(' No 

### i-- 

## -- ,<-- ye, 

# pJ

7. -.?s Yes 

### ,=:

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W.Abrams Street, Arlington 

# I Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP 

# I (Circle One) Presenting Oral Testimony? Name (Please Print) Representing 

# ~YL? (?&L/&~ f-7 I/,-, L,. 'I .; ( 

# 0

# rf lj

,. 

# #~.//vIcI;@~, _-- , ,

-.A 

# haPJ\\ 

# Oqkk '~i 

### .q 

# cw u /- 

# sofiL.o a/\q 

## 5 

# L\: 

# <b Yes 

# @ 

# 0. s No



# S-en~ib~ 

# Chp;~ 

# H~Pv~~s ---, 

# J-v--- \--- - 

# \-;- Yes 

# G~

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-N R, 2006-031 -SIP-NR Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101

### W. Abrams Street, Arlington 

# I Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour OzoneSIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) 

# $

$ / 

# '7217q &&5~4 -0 

# 4 Roo 

# 1-

go*.b=L2- 

# go- !Va..A 

# P?K, 

# q<

# J[ /h-q

I

# 41;:

. . ,' 

# S;CV~~ 

# [ 

# EPA 

# %k7 ,.. e ..--"- No 

# @

Yes
Yes 

# GJ

Yes 

# 6 

# r Yesf - No

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall Council Chambers, 101W.Abrams Street, Arlington 

# I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

Yes No

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Arlington City Hall CouncilChambers, 101W. Abrams Street, Arlington

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Yes No Name (Please Print)

., '\ :. Y 'i

### ,' Li

Yes No

Yes No Representing @5(-,-cc 

### 9% - ('?J 

# L-dL.
1,'"

. 

# 5Jp&~:q
-

# Q Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One) ,,//.:.y.<:

. 

## 7

... - .:-..::. Yes

. No

Yes NoINDEX OF ORAL TESTIMONY February 1,2007,6:00 p.m.-Midlothian ConferenceCenter, Midlothian,Texas Nooral comments received regardingthis rulemaking

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February I, 2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1 Community Circle, Midlothian 

### I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW &Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-HourOzone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP



# fr,,?,

,,[LO



# - 13 , 

## Q- 

## CI~IR,~ 

# 1 )?I

# c

. .v- L 

# 3- No I/ 

# E\Ju.- Rld,.r$,~e-L

# CUFI S.I?I\W.~B I- 

# c/o

# kn

# COrf~if V, yes 

# @I Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (CircleOne)- - - - --- 

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February I, 2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1 Community Circle. Midlothian

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

.-?<~ Yes 

# fy

/-=. Yes LNO)

Yes 

# pH'

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration February 1,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR,2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: MidlothianConference Center, 1 Community Circle, Midlothian 

## I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

- - Name (PleasePrint) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (CircleOne)

Yes 

# tLl C \ v.



# kbL.(

# ifi. Yes 

# &

Yes Cd

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration February 1,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# ( Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1Community Circle, Midlothian 

# 1

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 11 7; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainmentemo on strati on SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes 

# cl Name (Please Print)

Yes 

# (5

fC== 1-k !I 

## iC! Yes (-2

.>,. /Yes:> No

V 

### Lcr- 4' I u ' I Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Yes 

### @I

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration February 1,2007 6:00 p.m. 

# IRule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1Community Circle, Midlothian Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-HourOzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting OralTestimony? (CircleOne)

Yes (No! -.-/

I #-' /== Yes p No. \

I -. 5 

# u V '

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Pubiic Hearing Registration February 1,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-N R, 2006-03 1 -SIP-N R 

# I Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1 CommunityCircle, Midlothian 

### I

Concerning: Revisionsto30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

Yes LTJj 

# - 

# I

Yes 

## (3) J

-\ 

### ---, \, Yes 

### ( NO ) L., 

### /c===,

,-* ,J ! %- - Yes>No

-

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration February 1,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1 Community Circle, Midlothian

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAG Chapters 114, 115, and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Yes No Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print) Representing

I 

### f7 

# j,k$, 

# bcqlsc

# 6.d & 

## by wT/l 

# / 2015

# v

/ 

### A 

# ?&Aqd

I .. 

# y$fl&+&7

, *- I -.

, 

# DQ,.!;, ; 5 I \, 

# 7~
-7 

## 3 

# li Yes 

# E-jj

::,, 

# &.ij9

...,..<..: a-j No

yes 

## i Q

yes 

## u XiCF\ 1 

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-0'1 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1 Community.Circle, Midlothian 

### I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Yes No Name (Please Print)

,/

Yes No

Yes No Representing
9.L - L'.+. &!' 

### i&.~.c,.p(;,&z I 

# i-\ 

# I , 8 

# 3d\<r&.t,~ -f
/- 

# .--p('/~a. Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) ' 

# ;w No ~..

-.

. - -.

## Texas Commission on Environmental 

## Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1, 2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1Community Circle, Midlothian 

## 1

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP


# I Yes No Name (Please Print)

Yes No / Representing PresentingOralTestimony? (Circle One)

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 1,2007 6:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

# r> Location: Midlothian Conference Center, 1 Community Circle,!Midlothian \ 

# + Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print)



# - (-? 

# (2 -&;w\p-l 2- Representing 

# q&IoM /~n

f

# cpJ(\ 

## - -> 

### - 

# s,,./& yes 

## .@

f-----\ Yes *o0-,
yes 

# ,<' L/

Yes No
Yes No
Yes NoINDEX OF ORAL TESTIMONY February6,2007,2:00 p.m.-Longview Public Library, Longview,Texas No oral comments received regardingthis rulemaking

## Texas Commission on ~nvironmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-03 1 -SIP-NR 

# I Location: Longview Public Library,222 W. Cotton Street, Longview

Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW &Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

-) Yes 

### p?,/ PresentingOralTestimony? (Circle One) Name (Please Print) -- Representing
yes 

### *J i 

# \)e aL<lc[< e I

# ly8,L) (I-, 

## , 

## L p- 

## VU.E&,L' I

yes 

# (Jiy

/--\ /'--' \ Yes <No I -*= I ,

". ' TI ; !'

/ /-- 

# ki 

# b- ( /fjjf/5

# siqlt

- - 

# /'/A- 

# 5TL ,Lx - 1-- -3 -- 

## -

/-%' Yes @I&/!2 

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality

, 

### Public Hearing Registration February 6,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN. 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Longview Public Library,222W. Cotton Street, Longview

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) / 

# q,?v/ 4,,?(ZA)Q,( 

### u;.ct szq kfi.-s 

## -- Representing 

# .-

' F, r-

, , 

### /=){g ],I 

## bfJ -=i? 

### ],,3.~;-j++ 

# - PresentingOralTestimony? (Circle One) yes 

# 60, ---\

,= 

## 2-,-ij /y'P,/&?-j/L, 

# /t ,. f, 

### '3 

# 3-hj PfiL-e<W~Qw 

# D 571d ks

# w;.r &i-77k3Qb-.7 

# ~9 -1

.. 

### f

I I ti 

# Dit pil;~c/-~ec- 

# ' . ..... /------ ---\ 

# r' -..

-YesT vo iu-' 

# m. ,..hiyes)' NO \:J

,- 

### -.. 

# <--~ Yes { No ': -i 

# 3 1 f 

# ~eL&,&kd 

# A r'" -
!:

# c:/< 

# r'~;.~~,~~~~ 

# 4 b6y~-g I 

# -. i 7.7 

# hMSci~~Q,.vI

## rw 

# J

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031 -SIP-NR 

### Location: Longview Public Library,222 W. Cotton Street, Longview Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

-Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Yes 

# @J

Yes 

### (20 

## -

Yes 

# Ey <-7, 

# //L.~/>~ ijij2p,
u - _I I/ 

## ,- (=DI(&M& 

# O/I F-j>&? Yes 

# (3).

' ..,- 2

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SI P-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SI P-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Longview Public Library,222W. Cotton Street, Longview Concerning: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print)

Yes 

### @ & Representing

yes 

## (@


# ,/--; Yes I.NO U' PresentingOral Testimony? (Circle One)



## /#,{/$? 6'

/, L 

### vfll ,5;/ 

# JL?

,"-=s Yes I No: L! .-- 

# y55 L,!g,zzv. 

## --y z 

## ;+ e-.>
, yes &o,,,'

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Longview Public Library, 222W. Cotton Street, Longview Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

- --

r-,

r' 

# /&f& [I \ 

### IU&\

'

# &Aw, IQJ-~ ~~4

# R,.arL.l d~rry (k 

### 0 - - 

# 9. [.+.&,iya*q J",(J 

### 0 

# 1 /' 

### r7 

### L ,!#.I ( ., +-L 1 C,,



### i

I' I I Yes 

# (i?~ /] -/ 

# s , T'itf

I- 

# /, 

# -J 

# -&I JL.9 

## ~,m2,!-~~ 

# L- 

# \ \

- 

# C~<Y 

# t

1 Yes

# ,~i5) u
Yes 

# 0 424

7 

# , "C. Yes No 

# ,.L/

i yes 

### E,

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-N R, 2006-031 -SIP-NR Location: Longview Public Library, 222 W. Cotton Street, Longview 

# I Concerning: Revisions to 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Name (Please Print)

I Representing



### r ' -) Yes 'Nq. I i , . ..,'



# L/

h 

### 0,~ 

## ( Presenting OralTestimony? (Circle One)

/ ', i 2' 

### id ,--; Yes /'NO 1 L-.-/

+-, Yes 

# &,;

4. Yes 

### LN'Nqj

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR,2006-031-SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: Longview Public Library,222 W. Cotton Street, Longview 

# I

Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment DemonstrationSIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (CircleOne)

.- Yes \-... /No ) I+-?--- : /' 

### - 

## !L/ 

# r c 

# lor 3 * 

# i

# ~~6 ,,&C=r~


# FTc5 

# - b yes 

## &:>

Yes No) 

# c

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6, 2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SI P-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: Longview Public Library, 222 W. Cotton Street, Longview Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 115, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP 

## I Name 

## I I I (PleasePrint) 

### ',' \,,


### / Representing I

,"I - 

# /hrh Lko;b~

i Presenting Oral Testimony? (CircleOne) Yes 'ICIi \-+) 

# LJ e;U-LIF Yes C4'

>.&p,(q .j+3,)

# - 5/'AL+T. ,?Y> - 

## i/ a?>j->& ,%I

### gYes 

# 6:)

Yes No 

# b\+fi+ ,-L 

# ubtaii Yes 

# c/ o --'.
Yes ?dl,'

I aJ 3

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 6,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# I Location: Longview Public Library, 222W. Cotton Street, Longview

Concerning: Revisions to 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP
Name (Please Print) Representing

Yes No Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)

r: 

# eelz.kr

# \3~;1.~-1 6nevq~t I UJ

Yes No

Yes No yes 

# @

Yes No

Yes NoINDEXOFORALTESTIMONY February8,2007, 2:00 p.m.-Texas Commissionon EnvironmentalQualitycomplex, Austin, Texas Nooral comments received regardingthis rulemaking

## Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Public 

### Hearing Registration February 8,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-1 17-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR 

# 1 Location: TCEQ Headquarters, 121 00 Park 35 Circle, Building

### E, Room201S,Austin Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 1 17;and DFW8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One)
<--- . i~eq

--.._ NO Name (Please Print)

-.-. Representing



# 73% 

# - /: .\TE,CI~ 

# \Jc,q&-dA$h .-.-- 

### \/;; 

# .' L&~ 

## c

j

.73 

### "1, 

## p 

## i.:. ; r, C .-C3 

### 5 C: ~3 c. . . Yes [NO $. 

### i

'k / 

# CfiL \' JG- Yes

7,,, 

# - P4-c

.. 

# &- ./--.. Yes !NO' L-

## Texas Commissionon Environmental Quality Public Hearing Registration February 8,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN, 2006-036-1 14-EN,2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR,2006-030-SIP-N R, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: TCEQ Headquarters, 121 00 Park 35 Circle, Building E, Room 201S, Austin 

# IConcerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment DemonstrationSIP.

HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

,-, - \ Yes 

## To,,..' Name (Please Print)

Yes

.' (' Yes \No! Representing Presenting Oral Testimony? (CircleOne)



## '. I , i i.j GA~ 

## C*d cc

# (1

TL J-. -.> 

### / 

# ;<<-..7-< L &/'

### /.. 

### 7 ; .J
% t/



# <& C* 

# - / . Yes

, No
Yes 

### -go,!

Yes 'N$

## Texas Commission on EnvironmentalQuality Public Hearing Registration February8,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-1 15-EN 2006-01 3-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SIP-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: TCEQ Headquarters, 12100 Park 35 

### Circle, Building El Room201S, Austin Concerning: Revisionsto 30TAC Chapters 114, 11 5, and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration SIP, HGB RFP SIP Revision, and DFW RFP SIP

-- - Name (Please Print)

. . 3

.77 

# c<[\ i7~4~ 

### !$-G,~\+- 

## 2.,,.i

R -. 6% L 

### ,L-- l/jFL,~xJ-~~-,.T r Representing 

## &-A,,Tc l2 

### K>' 

### ,$T Flur P c L 

# 'LU

<: \

. ' ,-. .--.., 

# 4ij. 1' t i.\, >\& i <(**

.. 

### I - PresentingOral Testimony? (Circle One) yes 

### <*N% 

## L~ ..,../ 

# c\ L~C~~~~Lj~ &q 

## + i,Lj.', 

### c~,v 

### ,,

.70 .

## -...-- J v;,J J .---.''-.>" yes 

# e&

yes (,NO " 

# ,

.. .

I' Yes No

.

## Texas 

## Commission 

## on 

## Environmental 

## Quality Public Hearing Registration February 8,2007 2:00 p.m. Rule Project No.: 2006-034-117-EN,2006-036-114-EN, 2007-038-115-EN 2006-013-SIP-NR, 2006-027-SI P-NR, 2006-030-SIP-NR, 2006-031-SIP-NR Location: TCEQ Headquarters, 121 00 Park 35 Circle, Building E, Room201S, Austin Concerning: Revisionsto 30 TAC Chapters 114, 115,and 117; and DFW 8-Hour Ozone SIP, HGB 8-Hour OzoneAttainment Demonstration SIP! 

### HGB RFP SIP Revision,and DFW RFP SIP

Presenting Oral Testimony? (Circle One) Name (PleasePrint)

.? ic

- - I' .: >,* ;,I L"

~ :-.



### , (,.... *.,,*- ,'\>. t2 ;;i -

.--3 ;! ! 1 i

## .+IL,< b.\ 

### , 

### /~1. J )~-:--:2 : ,/

-,I--.

Yes No Representing

! '-3... /- .. 

### .,?'..- 

### r j,,>) t. ;: 1 

### 3.. j 

# L j 

## ' y - 

### 1M"* ' &

+' 

### v4"&-e 

## ;

, /

, '3,,< L. +. , ,K /,- :- J- ?='"' ;- ? - P *

.... ,,dC 

### ;-3j'3
Yes

. No.

Yes No . . Yes

, . NO ;


## .-.

., Yes ! No,;

.. . yes (NO'.