u

c

u

H i n 

# ORIGINA L

t o 

### U.S . DEPARTMENT O F TRANSPORTATION OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

I NTH E MATTE ROF : IV YENTERPRISES , INC . RESPONDENT

LITIGATIONCONFERENC E BEFOR E TH E HONORABL E JUDG E J . E . SULLIVA N

M A'Z-Ot l-W/ 6 DOCKETNO

. H<CaA"201 1 -IJrl i (KEBERMrrMOTORreftRfilfiB u SAFET YADMlWiyTKATlON )



### FEBRUARY29 , 201 2 1:0 0 P.M . • s - rc ' r-, >


### ' 0

, •-J'^Pn^

. i—=^r o '-^co ^ 

### '"' o (vi=^ m 

## ?E;^ ; 

# Ssv ;

MAR-8201 2 

# '^^EAR/N G DOCKE T

800.262.877 7 WWW.CountyCourtReporters.CO m 877.837.831 316772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , I NTHE MATTE RO F 02/29/201 2 PAGE 2 APPEARANCE S

O NBEHAL F O F TH E RESPONDENT: JOHNCOONE Y RUSKI NMOSCO UFALTISCHE K P. C 142 5 RXRPLAZ A EAS T TOWER , 15T H FLOO R UNIONDALE , N

Y11556-142 5

1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 O NBEHAL F O F TH E COMPLAINAN T JEANIN E C . GOTIME R OFFIC E O F TH E REGIONA L COUNSE L EASTERNREGION FEDERA L AVIATIO NADMINISTRATIO N 1 AVIATIO NPLAZ A JAMAICA , N

Y1143 4

ALS O PRESENT : LOUI S MISIANO , FEDERA L AVIATIO NADMINISTRATIO N PRIY AKRISHA , ATTORNE YINTERN ,16772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , INTH E HATTE RO F 02/29/201 2 PAG E 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 LITIGATIO NCONFERENC E FEBRUAR Y29 , 201 2 JUDG E SULLIVAN : W e ar e o n th e recor di n th e matte r o f Iv

yEnterprises , Inc. . Thi s i s docke t numbe r FMSCA-2011-1116 . Toda yi s Wednesday , Februar y 29 , 2012 , and th e partie s hav e convene db ytelephon e fo r a firs t litigatio nschedulin g conference . Th e Fh A i s represente d b

yJeanin e Gotimer , th e Attorne yo f Record . Als o presen t i n he r offic e an d sittin g a s a n observer , i s Aviatio nSafet yInspector , Loui s Misiano . Presen t o n behal f o f th e Respondent , Iv yEnterprise s i s JohnCooney , a n Associat e wit hth e lawfirmtha t i s o f recor d representin g th e Respondent , Alexande r G . Bateman , Jr. , th e Attorne yo f Record , i s no t presen t toda yand Mr . Coone yi s sittin g i n fo r him . I n additio npresen t a t th e Offic e o f Hearing s i s Priya Krishna , an Attorne yInter nwh o i s sittin g i n a s a n observe r onl ytoday . Goo d afternoon . Counsel .

MR . COONEY : Goo d afternoon , You r Honor . JXTOG E SULLIVAN : I wil l simpl ynot e tha t ther e ha s bee na variet yo f activitie s o n thi s file , and i n essence , ther e wa s a n orde r issue db ythi s Cour t o nFebruar y21 , 201 2 identifie d a s "Orde r Denyin g Respondent' s Motion s fo r a Mor e Definitiv e Statemen t and a Sta yo f Discovery , and Granting/Denyin g Othe r

ThG ReportEP S Grou p ^O l IDT ^ D^Dr^DTCDC T CourtReporting

. Vide o StephEnson

. V

AUVJUP I IM^^f^^ n I CnO.in c&Litigatio n TEchnoiog y www.rcportGrsgroup.co m Vidcograph y^ ^ Litigatio n Technolog ywww.advlEgaltech.co m Corporate : Histori cJorda n Spring s < 116 0 Jorda n Spring s Roa d i Stephenson , V A2265 6 800.262.877 7 www.CountyCourtReporters.co m 877.837.831 316772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , INTH E MATTE RO F 02/29/201 2 PAG E A 1 2 3 A 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 Relief. " And i nth e introductor yparagrap ho f tha t two-pag e order , o nPag e 1 i s a mor e specifi c statemen t o f th e genera l histor yo f th e cas e leadin g u p t o today' s proceeding . Accordin g t o thi s particula r order , th e Cour t essentiall yi s directin g th e Responden t t o follo wwritte nanswe r o no r befor e Marc h 2 , 201 2 accordin g t o th e Regulatio nwit ha deferra l o f th e partie s jointl ywritte npropose dRul e 26(f ) Scheduling/Discover yPla nunti l afte r Marc h2 , 2012 . Thi s particula r telephon e conferenc e wa s retaine ds o tha t w e hav e th e easiest , fastest , mos t efficien t wa y o f resettin g th e deadline s fo r bot hth e Rul e 26(f ) Discover yPla nand fo r a second litigatio nschedulin g conferenc e pursuan t t o th e prio r orde r tha t wa s entere d b yth e Court . S o le t m e tal k wit hth e FA ACounse l first . Lookin g a t you r calendar , afte r Marc h2 , 2012 , abou t ho wmuc htim e d o yo u think yo u ar e goin g t o nee d t o consul t wit hMr . Batema no r Mr. . Coone yfo r Rul e 26(f ) conference ? Typically , I grant... I se t thes e u p s o tha t th e partie s hav e betwee n3 0 and6 0 day s t o tal k t o eac hother . Thi s cas e obviousl yha s bee nlingerin g a littl e bi t longe r tha nthat . Howmuc htim e woul dyo u lik e t o have ? MS . GOTIMER : You r Honor , I thin k anythin g te nday s afte r th e answe r o r beyon di s fin e County The Reporter

s Grou p ^O l I PT> fPCPOPT^P ^ Cour

tReporting

. Video Stephenson

. V

A\-*JUr 4 l£^^^~y^r \ I CPI^

. Inc

. &Litigatio n Technology www.reportcrsgroup.co m Vidcograph y^ ^ Litigatio n Technolog ywww.advlcgaltech.co m Corporate : Histori cJorda n Spring s ( 116 0 Jorda n Spring s Roa d i Stephenson , V

A2265 6 800.262.877 7 www.CountvCourtReporters.co m 877.837.831 316772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , I NTH E MATTE R O F 02/29/201 2 PAG E 5 1 2 3 A 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 wit hth e Agency . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay . Mr . Cooney , o n behal f o f th e Respondent , ho wmuc htim e woul dyo u lik e t o have ? MR . COONEY : Tha t i s abou t th e appropriat e amoun t o f time . Ms . Gotime r and I hav e discusse d anythin g fromMarc h1 4 forwar dwoul db e fin e wit hus , You r Honor .

JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay . Whydon' t I tak e a loo k a t m

ycalenda r too . Okay , I hav e t o ge t ou t o f 2013 , m

yconferenc e jus t befor e thi s one , w e wer e talkin g abou t som e date s nex t year...fo r reason s I don' t nee d t o g o into . M yMarc hcalenda r righ t no wi s booke d ever ywee k wit hou t o f stat e trials'. ' So , th e earlies t tha t I coul d hol da Rul e 1 6 Litigatio n Schedulin g Conferenc e woul d b e th e wee k o f Apri l 2 , 2012 . Wh

ydon' t w e d o this , whydon' t w e se t th e conferenc e first , and the nw e ca n bac k trac k a wee k fo r filin g o f th e Rul e 26(f ) discover yplans , and tha t may end up givin g yo u bot ha littl e bi t mor e wiggl e room , i f yo u wil l fo r furthe r negotiation .

MR . COONEY : Yes , tha t wil l help . You r Honor , than k you .

JXTOG E SULLIVAN : Ms . Gotimer , startin g wit hyou , d o yo u hav e anydate s tha t ar e blackou t date s

Th e Reporter s Grou p ^C WIDT X DCDODT^D ^ CourtReporting

. Vide o Stephenson

. V

AUUUr i Ig^J^XZfXJr KI C P I 3

. Inc

. &Litigatio n Technolog y www.rcportersgroup.co m Videograph y^ ^ Litigatio n Technolog ywww.advlGgaltcch.co m Corporate : Histori cJorda n Spring s L 116 0 Jorda n Spring s Roa d : Stephenson , V A2265 6 800.262.877 7 www.CountyCourtReporter5.co m 877.837.831 316'772- 1 TV YENTERPRISES , INC , I NTH E MATTE R O F 02/29/201 2 PAG E 6 1 2 3 A 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5

- durin g th e wee k o f Apri l 2 , 201 2 fo r a secon d litigatio nconference ?

MS . GOTIMER : Yes , You r Honor , jus t Apri l 3 and 4th . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , whe nyo u say , "jus t Apri l 3 and 4th, " ar e thos e th e date s tha t yo u ar e no t available ?

MS . GOTIMER : Yes . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , and turnin g t o you , Mr . Cooney , anyblackou t date s durin g th e firs t wee k o f Apri l 2012 ?

MR . COONEY : No , You r Honor , eithe r I o r Mr . Batema nwil l b e availabl e anyda yth e Cour t chooses . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , let' s tal k abou t Apri l 5 , 2012 , whic hi s Thursday . Ms . Gotimer , d o yo u hav e a preferre d tim e durin g tha t dayfo r a on e hou r schedule d conference ?

MS . GOTIMER : Anythin g i n th e morning , o r th e earl yafternoo nwoul db e th e Agency' s preference . On e o'cloc k o r before .

JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , Mr . Cooney , any preferenc e o n Thursday , Apri l 5 , 2012 ?

MR . COONEY : Tha t i s fin e wit hus . You r Honor , on e p.m. , o r befor e i s fine . Countyy ^ Th e Reporter

s Grou p fO I IDT.i 7 DCDODTCD C Cour tReporting

. Video Stephenson

. V A\-V-IU n l/j^Cr^^J n I CPl^.lnc

. £ , Litigatio n Technolog y www.rcpoptcrsgroup.co m Videograph y^ ^ Litigatio n Technolog ywww.advlegaltGch.co m Corporate : Histori cJorda n Spring s c116 0 Jorda n Spring s Roa d cStephenson , V A2265 6 800.262.877 7 www.CountyCourtReporters.co m 877.837.831 316772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , INTH E HATTE R O F 02/29/201 2 PAG E 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 l A 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , whydon' t w e se t thi s fo r Thursday , Apri l 5 , 201 2 a t te n a.m . i n th e morning . And I wil l er r o n th e sid e o f caution , and
as k partie s t o reserv e on e hour . M yconference s wil l generall yrun anyv;her e fromeigh t minute s t o a n hou r dependin g o n ho wprepare d th e partie s are .

Let' s tal k the nnex t abou t th e du e dat e fo r filin g th e Rul e 26(f ) Discover yPlan . I usuall y lik e t o hav e th e partie s fil e i t on e wee k i n advanc e o f th e actua l conference , tha t woul d b e Marc h29 , 2012 , give nou r Apri l 5 , 201 2 date . Ms . Gotimer , startin g wit hyou , i s tha t a nacceptabl e time ?

MS . GOTIMER : Yes , You r Honor . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , and Mr . Cooney , fo r you r client , i s tha t als o acceptable ?

MR . COONEY : Yes , i t is . You r Honor . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , and tha t i s th e dat e tha t w e wil l se t fo r th e filin g o f th e partie s jointl ywritte nand submitte d discover yplan . I wil l
as k yo u specificall yt o mak e sur e yo u addres s th e issu e o f venu e i n tha t plan , a s wel l a s anyand al l date s fo r dispositiv e motion , discover ycutoff...thos e kind s o f thing s tha t ar e alreadyreference dgenerall yi n th e origina l orde r directin g yo u conduc t a 26(f ) Discover y conferenc e betwee nth e tw o o f you . Wit hthat , I wil l O Count yy Th e Reporter s Grou p f"O I IDT^DCDODTdD ^ CourtReporting

. Vide o Stephenson

. V

AUWUP i IZ^Cr^^-lP i I Cn^.lnc

. &Litigatio n Technolog y www.rcportcrsgroup.co m Videograph yg- ^ Litigatio n Technolog ywwwadvlegaltech.co m Corporate : Histori cJorda n Spring s i 116 0 Jorda n Spring s Roa d cStephenson , V A2265 6 800.262.877 7 www.CountYCourtReporters.co m 877.837.831 3L6772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , I NTHE MATTE RO F 02/29/201 2 PAG E 3 1 2 3 A 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 anticipate , Mr . Cooney , tha t you r clien t wil l b e filin g a writte nanswe r o no r befor e Marc h2 , 2012 , whic hi s thi s Friday . MR . COONEY : Yes , You r Honor .

JUDG E SULLIVAN : I s ther e anythin g els e tha t yo u woul d lik e t o addres s o nbehal f o f you r clien t today , then ? MR . COONEY : No , no t a t thi s time . You r Honor , than k you .

JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , andMs . Gotimer , o nbehal f o f you r client , anythin g els e Cha t yo u woul d lik e t o addres s o nbehal f o f you r client ?

MS . GOTIMER : No , than k you . You r Honor . JUDG E SULLIVAN : Okay , the nwha t I wil l do . Counsel , i s I wil l b e sendin g ou t a writte norde r codifyin g i nwritin g th e date s o f Marc h29 , 2012 , and th e conferenc e dat e o f Apri l 5 , 201 2 a t 1 0 a.m . Yo u shoul d b e gettin g tha t b ytomorro wb

yfax , ando f
cours e w e wil l als o mai l i t b yUnite dState s mail. ' Wit hthat , i t appear s ou r busines s i s complete . W e ca n g o of f th e record , andI wis hyo u al l a goo dday . (WHEREUPON , th e proceeding s wer e conclude da t 1:0 9 p.m . )

Count yy ^ Th e Reporter

s Grou p fO I IDTi yDCDODT^R^ ^ Cour tReporting

. Video Stephenson

. VA^V-FU n l£^^^r'\Jr \ I CPI^J

. Inc

. E > Litigatio n Technolog y www.reportcrsgroup.co m Videograph y^ ^ Litigatio n Technolog ywww.advlcgaltech.co m Corporate ; Histori cJorda n Spring s i 116 0 Jorda n Spring s Roa d ^ ' Stephenson , V

A2265 6 800.262.877 7 www.CountyCourtReporters.co m 877.837.831 316772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , I NTHEHATTE RO F02/29/201 2PAGE9 CAPTIO N

Th e Hearin g i nth e matter , o nth e date , anda t th e tim e
and plac e se t ou t o nth e titl e pag e hereof .

I t wa s requeste d tha t th e Hearin g b e take nbyth e reporte r and tha t sam e b e reduce dt o typewritte nform .

9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 516772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , INTH E MATTE RO F 02/29/201 2 PAG E 1 0 

### 1 2 3 A 

### 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 \ A 

### 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 CERTIFICAT E O F REPORTE R COMMONWEALT H O F VIRGINI AA T LARGE :

I d o herebycertif ytha t th e witnes s i nth ^ foregoin g transcrip t wa s take no nth e date , an d a t th e tim e an d plac e se t ou t o nth e Titl e pag e hereo f afte r firs t bein g dul yswor nan d tha t th e sai d matte r wa s recorde d stenographicall yan d mechanicall ybym e an d reduce d t o typewritte nform unde r m

ydirection , an d constitute s a tru e recor d o i th e depositio na s taken , t o th e bes t o f myskil l an c ability . I certif ytha t I amno t relate d t o o r a n employe e o f counsel , an d tha t I hav e n o financia l interes t i nth e outcom e o f thi s matter . 

### UUtUuQ^-J^AUK

y

PAUL AJ . GREE R COUR T REPORTE R/ NOTAR Y NOTAR YREGISTRATIO NNUMBER : 751238 7 MyCommissio nExpires :16772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , INTH E HATTE ROF 1 1 4: 2 1:0 9 8:2 2 1 0 8:1 7 1 4 5: 7 1 6 5:1 5 2 2 4: 7 4: 9 4:1 6 5:1 6 6: 1 8: 2 201 2 3: 2 3: 6 3:2 3 4: 7 4: 9 4:1 6 5:1 7 6: 1 6:1 1 6:1 6 6:2 3 7: 2 7:1 0 7:1 1 8: 2 8:1 6 8:1 7 201 3 5:1 1 2 1 3:2 3 26( f 4: 8 4:1 2 4:1 9 5:1 9 7: 8 7:2 4 2 9 3: 2 3: 6 7:1 0 8:1 6 3 3 6: 4 6: 6 3 0 4:2 0 4 4t h6: 4 6: 6

5 5 6:1 6 6:2 3 7: 2 7:1 1 8:1 7 6 6 0 4:2 0
A a. m7: 2 8:1 7 acceptabl e 7:1 2 7:1 5 accordin g 4: 4 4: 7 activitie s 3:2 1 actua l 7:1 0 additio n3:1 6 addres s 7:2 0 8: 6 3:1 2 advanc e 7 : 9 afternoo n3:1 8 3:1 9 6:2 0 Agenc y5: 1 Agency' s 6:2 0 Alexande r 3:1 3 alread y7:2 3 amoun t 5: 6 answe r 4: 6 4:2 5 8: 2 anticipat e 8: 1 anythin g 4:2 5 5: 7 6:1 9 8: 5 8:1 1 anywher e 7: 5 appear s 8:2 0 appropriat e 5: 6 Apri l 5:1 6 6: 1 6: 3 6: 6 6:1 1 6:1 6 6:2 3 7: 2 7:1 1 8:1 7 Associat e 3:1 2 Attorne y3: 8 3:1 4 3:1 7 availabl e 6: 7 6:1 3 Aviatio n3:1 0

B Batema n3:1 4 4:1 8 6:1 3 02/29/201 2 PAG E . U behal f 3:1 1 5: 3 8: 6 8:1 1 8:1 2 beyon d 4:2 5 bi t 4:2 2 5:2 0 blackou t 5:2 5 6:1 0 booke d 5:1 4 busines s 8:2 0

C calenda r 4:1 6 5:1 0 5:1 3 cas e 4: 3 4:2 1 cautio n7: 3 choose s 6:1 4 clien t 7:1 5 8: 1 8: 6 8:1 1 8:1 2 codifyin g 8:1 6 complet e 8:2 0 conclude d 8:2 2 conduc t 7:2 4 conferenc e 3: 1 3: 7 4 :.1 0 4 : 1 4 4:1 9 5:1 1 5:1 6 5:1 8 6: 2 6:I B 7 : 1 0 7:2 5 8:1 7 conference s 7 : 4 consul t 4:1 8 convene d 3: 5 Coone y3:1 2 3:1 5 3-:1 9 4 : 1 8 5: 2 5: 5 5:2 2 6:1 0 6:1 2 6:2 2 6:2 4 7:1 4 7:1 6 8: 1 8: 4 8: 8 Counse l 3:1 8 4:1 5 8 : 1 5 cours e 8:1 916772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , I NTHE MATTE RO

F Cour t 3:2 2 4: 5 4:1 5 6:1 3 cutoff...thos e 7:2 2
D dat e 7: 7 7:1 1 7 : 1 8 8:1 7 date s 5:1 2 5:2 5 5:2 5 6: 6 6:1 0 7:2 1 8:1 6 da y6:1 3 6:1 7 8:2 1 day s 4:2 0 4:2 5 deadline s 4:1 2 deferra l 4: 7 Definitiv e 3:2 4 Denyin g 3:2 3 dependin g 7: 6 directin g 4: 5 7:2 4 discover y3:2 5 4:1 3 5:1 9 7: 8 7:1 9 7:2 2 7:2 4 discusse d 5: 7 dispositiv e 7:2 2 docke t 3: 4 du e 7: 7 durin g 6: 1 6:1 0 6 : 1 7
E earlies t 5:1 5 earl y6:2 0 easies t 4:1 1 efficien t 4:1 1 eigh t 7: 5 eithe r 6:1 2 els e 8: 5 8:1 1 entere d 4:1 4 Enterprise s 3 : 4 3:1 1 er r 7: 3 essenc e 3:2 2 essentiall y4: 5

F FA A3: 7 4:1 5 fastes t 4:1 1 fa x8:1 8 Ff'bruar y3 : 2 3: 5 3:2 3 fil e 3:2 1 7: 9 filin g 5:1 9 7: 8 7:1 8 8: 1 fin e 4:2 5 5: 7 6:2 4 6:2 5 fir m3:1 2 firs t 3: 7 4:1 6 5:1 8 6:1 0 FMSCA-2011-111 6 3: 5 forwar d 5: 7 Frida y8: 3

G genera l 4: 3 generall y7: 5 7:2 3 gettin g 8:1 8 give n7:1 1 givin g 5:2 0 Gotime r 3: 8 4:2 4 5: 6 5:2 4 6: 3 6: 8 6:1 6 6:1 9 7:1 1 7:1 3 02/29/201 2 PAG E 1 2 8 : 1 0 8:1 3 grant... I 4:1 9 Granting / Denyin g 3:2 5

H Hearing s 3:1 6 hel p 5:2 2 histor y4: 3 hol d 5:1 5 Hono r 3:1 9 4:2 4 5: 8 5:2 3 6: 3 6:1 2 6:2 5 7:1 3 7:1 6 8: 4 8: 9 8:1 3 hou r 6:1 7 7: 4 7: 5

I identifie d 3:2 3 In c 3: 4 Inspecto r 3:1 0 Inter n3:1 7 introductor y4: 1 issu e 7:2 0 issue d 3:2 2 Iv y3: 4 3:1 1

J Jeanin e 3: 8 Joh n3:1 2 jointl y4: 8 7:1 9 J r 3:1 4 JUDG E 3: 3 3:2 0 5: 2 5: 9 5:2 4 6: 5 6: 9 6:1 5 6:2 2 7: 1 7:1 4 7:1 7 8: 5 8:1 0 8:1 4
K16772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , INTH E MATTE RO F 02/29/201 2 PAG E 1 3 kind s 7:2 2 Krishn a 3:1 7

L la w3:1 2 leadin g 4: 3 let' s 6:1 5 7: 7 lingerin g 4:2 1 litigatio n3: 1 3: 7 4:1 3 5:1 5 6: 2 littl e 4:2 2 5:2 0 longe r 4:2 2 Loui s 3:1 0

M mai l 8:1 9 8:1 9 Marc h4: 6 4: 9 4:1 6 5: 7 5:1 3 7:1 0 8: 2 8:1 6 matte r 3; 4 ma y5:1 9 minute s 7: 5 Misian o 3:1 0 mornin g 6:1 9 7: 3 motio n7:2 2 Motion s 3:2 4

N negotiatio n5:2 1 not e 3:2 0

0 observe r 3:1 0 3:1 8 obviousl y4:2 1 o'cloc k 6:2 1 offic e 3: 9 3:1 6 Oka y5: 2 5: 9 5:1 0 6: 5 6: 9 6:1 5 6:2 2 7: 1 7:1 4 7:1 7 8:1 0 8:1 4 orde r 3:2 2 3:2 3 4: 2 4: 5 4:1 4 7:2 4 8:1 5 origina l 7:2 4

P p. m6:2 5 8:2 3 Pag e 4: 2 paragrap h4: 1 particula r 4 : 4 4 :1 0 partie s 3: 6 4: 8 4 :2 0 7: 4 7: 6 7: 9 7:1 8 pla n4: 9 4:1 3 7: 8 7:1 9 7:2 1 plan s 5:1 9 preferenc e 6 : 2 0 6:2 3 preferre d 6:1 7 prepare d 7: 6 presen t 3: 9 3:1 1 3:1 4 3:1 6 prio r 4:1 4 Priy a 3:1 6 proceedin g 4: 4 proceeding s 8:2 2 propose d 4: 8 pursuan t 4:1 4

R reason s 5:1 2 recor d 3: 3 3: 9 3:1 3 3 : 1 4 8:2 1 reference d 7:2 3 Regulatio n4: 7 Relie f 4: 1 represente d 3: 8 representin g 3:1 3 reserv e 7: 4 resettin g 4:1 2 Responden t 3:1 1 3:1 3 4: 6 5: 3 Respondent' s 3:2 4 retaine d 4:1 0 roo m 5:2 0 Rul e 4: 8 4:1 2 4:1 8 5:1 5 5:1 9 7: 3 ru n7: 5
S Safet y3:1 0 schedule d 6:1 8 schedulin g 3 : 7 4 : 1 3 5:1 6 Scheduling / Discover y4 : 9 secon d 4:1 3 6: 1 sendin g 8:1 5 simpl y3:2 0 sittin g 3: 9 3:1 5 3:1 7 specifi c 4: 2 specificall y7:2 0 startin g 5:2 4 7:1 1 stat e 5:1 4 statemen t 3:2 4 4: 2 State s 8:1 916772- 1 IV YENTERPRISES , INC , I NTH EMATTERO F

Sta y3:2 5 submitte d7:1 9 SULLIVA N3: 3 3:2 0 5 : 25: 9 5:2 4 6: 5 6 : 9 6:1 5 6:2 2 7 : 1 7:1 4 7:1 7 8 : 5 8:1 08:1 4 sur e7:2 0

T tal k 4:1 5 4:2 0 6:1 5 7: 7 talkin g 5:1 2 telephon e3: 6 4:1 0 t e n4:2 5 7: 2 than k 5:2 3 8: 9 8:1 3 Thursda y6:1 6 6:2 3 7: 2 toda y3: 5 3:1 5 3:1 8 8: 7 today' s 4: 4 tomorro w 8:1 8 trac k 5:1 8 trial s 5:1 4 turnin g 6: 9 two-pag e4: 2 Typicall y4:1 9

U Unite d8:1 9 usuall y7: 8

V variet y3:2 1 venu e7:2 1

W Wednesda y3: 5

wee k 5:1 4 5:1 6 5:1 8 6: 1 6:1 1 7 : 9 WHEREUPON8:2 2 wiggl e5:2 0 wis h8:2 1 writin g 8:1 6 writte n4: 6 4: 8 7:1 9 8: 28:1 5 Y year...fo r

5:1 2 02/29/201 2PAGE1 4