# May 10, 2010

Renee Wright

Program Manager

Docket Branch

Department of Transportation

1200 New Jersey Ave., S.E.

Washington, D.C. 20590

Re: U.S.-Japan Alliance Case, DOT-OST-2010-0059

Dear Ms. Wright:

American Airlines, Inc. and Japan Airlines International

Co., Ltd. are separately submitting confidential documents and other

material in response to Order 2010-4-9, April 16, 2010, seeking

additional information. We request confidential treatment under the

Joint Applicant’s Rule 12 motion of February 12, 2010, which we

incorporate herein by reference. Public indexes are attached.

Respectfully submitted,

______________________ ______________________ WILLIAM KARAS CARL B. NELSON, JR.

CAROL GOSAIN Associate General Counsel

Steptoe & Johnson LLP R. BRUCE WARK

1330 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Associate General Counsel

Washington, D.C. 20036 JEFFREY A. OGAR

(202) 429-6223 Senior Attorney

wkaras@steptoe.com American Airlines, Inc.

cgosain@steptoe.com 1101 17th Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036

Counsel for Japan Airlines (202) 496-5647

(817) 967-3478

carl.nelson@aa.com

bruce.wark@aa.com

jeff.ogar@aa.com

cc: Service list

# AMERICANAIRLINESINDEXOFADDITIONALCONFIDENTIALDOCUMENTSU.S.JAPANALLIANCECASEDOTOST20100059

BatesRangeDateAuthorDescriptionAA_101262AA_1012734/9/10VariousTalkingpointsrePJBAAA_101274AA_101323UnknownVariousImplementation planningdocumentsrePJBAAA_101324AA_101327UnknownUnknownFinanceWorkingGroupMandateAA_101328AA_101329UnknownUnknownRouteforecastingdataAA_101330AA_1013492/26/10VariousPJBAPreKickOffMeetingAA_101350AA_1014094/9/10VariousPJBAKickOffMeeting(pri vilegedcommunicationf romJ.Ogarredacted)AA_101410AA_1014163/11/10VariousPJBAOrganizationalDevelopmentAA_101417AA_1014234/28/10T.AndoEmailreJLscheduleannouncementAA_101424AA_1014263/16/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecallAA_101427AA_1014313/5/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecallAA_101432AA_1014523/4/10T.WilsonEmailandattachmentsrePJBAconferencecallAA_101453

AA_1014582/24/10K.HashimotoEmailrePJBAorganizationandimplementation(privilegedcommunicationfromAALegalredacted)AA_101459AA_1014642/24/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAorganizationandimplementation(privilegedcommunicationfromAALegalredacted)AA_101465AA_1015112/21/10E.PerhirinEmailandattac hmentsrePJBAorganization(privilegedcommunicationfromAALegalredacted)AA_101512AA_1015143/2/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecallAA_101515AA_1015183/2/10C.FinkEmailreworkinggroupsAA_101519AA_1015243/8/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecallAA_101525AA_1015293/10/10T.MizunoEmailrePJBAconferencecallAA_101530AA_101532 3/4/10T.MizunoEmailrePJBAworkinggroupsAA_101533AA_1015413/3/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffAA_101542AA_1015443/3/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffAA_101545AA_1015503/3/10T.MizunoEmailrePJBAconferencecallAA_101551AA_1015533/3/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoff# 2AA_101554AA_1015573/12/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffAA_101558AA_1015613/11/10 C.Fink EmailrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101562AA_1015683/5/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAconferencecallAA_101569AA_1015793/26/10C.FinkEmailretasksforkickoffmeetingAA_101580AA_1016003/25/10C.FinkEmailreki ckoffmeetinglogisticsAA_101601AA_1016063/12/10C.FinkEmailrekickoffmeetingagendaAA_101607AA_1016103/19/10E.PerhirinEmailrePJBAworkinggroupsAA_1016112/24/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAorganizationAA_101612AA_1016173/29/10E.PerhirinEmailrePJBAkickoffmeetingAA_101618AA_1016203/20/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAorganizationAA_101621AA_1016253/29/10K.HashimotoEmailrePJBAupdateAA_101626AA_1016283/29/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffmeetingAA_101629AA_1016313/30/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAdinnerAA_101632AA_1016334/1/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAconferencecallAA_101634AA_1016363/1/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconference call(regulatoryadvicefromAALegalredacted)AA_101637AA_1016384/5/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAconferencecallAA_101639AA_1016414/2/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffagendaAA_101642AA_1016634/1/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAmaterialsAA_101664AA_1016734/1/10A.AgawaEmailrePJBAkickoffmeetingAA_101674AA_1016794/7/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffmeetingAA_101680AA_1017144/14/10T.WilsonPJBAWorkingGroupdeliverablesU.S.-JAPAN ALLIANCE CASE,DOCKET DOT-OST-2010-0059JAL Index of Requested DocumentsTab # Bates RangeDocumentDateRecipients Author Document Title/DescriptionDocumentRequest/Clarification†1JAL000939-JAL0009401/16/2010 Unknown UnknownJL-AA Joint Business AgreementFunctional Working GroupsCQ5, CQ72JAL000941-JAL0009422/25/2010Tsutumo Ando (JAL), Toru Mizuno (JAL),Kenji Hashimoto (AA), Erwan Perhirin(AA), Tom Wilson (AA), Carla Fink (AA)UnknownMinutes – JL/AA PJBA Conference Call25 February 2010 DFW / 26 February2010 TYODP23JAL000943-JAL0009822/26/2010 Unknown UnknownPJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Organizingand Implementing the PJBA—February26, 2006 - TokyoDP2,CQ7, CQ174JAL000983-JAL0009843/2/2010Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Nagai,SakairiUnknown 2-3 Airline Alliance StrategyDP 2,CQ 175JAL000985-JAL0009903/3/2010 Unknown UnknownPJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Organizingand Implementing the PJBA—March3/4, 2010 Conference Call (Draft)DP26JAL000991-JAL0010033/3/2010 Unknown UnknownPJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Organizingand Implementing the PJBA—March3/4, 2010 Conference CallDP27 JAL001004 3/3/2010 Unknown UnknownJL-AA Joint Business Working Groupsas of March 3, 2010DP28 JAL001005 3/3/2010 Unknown UnknownJL-AA Joint Business Working Groupsas of March 3, 2010 v.2DP29JAL001006-JAL0010073/8/2010Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Nagai,SakairiUnknown 2-3 Airline Alliance StrategyDP2,CQ1710JAL001008-JAL0010173/8/2010 Unknown UnknownDraft Plan for Rebuilding Route, FlightNetwork—Progress ReportDP2,CQ1411JAL001018-JAL0010193/11/2010Tsutumo Ando (JAL), Toru Mizuno (JAL),Kenji Hashimoto (AA), Erwan Perhirin(AA), Tom Wilson (AA), Carla Fink (AA)UnknownMinutes – JL/AA PJBA Conference Call11 March 2010 DFW / 12 March 2010TYODP212JAL001020-JAL0010323/11/2010Tsutumo Ando (JAL), Toru Mizuno (JAL),Akira Mori (JAL), Atsu Agawa (JAL), KenjiHashimoto (AA), Erwan Perhirin (AA),Tom Wilson (AA), Carla Fink (AA)UnknownMinutes – JL/AA PJBA Conference Call11 March 2010 DFW / 12 March 2010TYODP213JAL001033-JAL0010393/11/2010 Unknown UnknownPJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Organizingand Implementing the PJBA—March10/11, 2010 Conference CallDP214JAL001040-JAL0010413/15/2010Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno,Nagai, SakairiUnknown 2-3 Airline Alliance StrategyDP2,CQ17†“DP” refers to Documents to Be Provided.“CQ” refers to Clarification Questions.Page 2 of 4Tab # Bates RangeDocumentDateRecipients Author Document Title/DescriptionDocumentRequest/Clarification15 JAL001042 3/15/2010 Unknown UnknownJAL-AA Pacific Joint BusinessImplementation Plan DeliverablesDP216 JAL001043 3/15/2010 Unknown UnknownJoint Business Implementation:Administrative and Financial ProtocolsDP217JAL001044-JAL0010823/17/2010 UnknownCorporate PlanningDivisionRoutes and Flight Frequency PlanUnder the New Reorganization PlanDP2,CQ1418JAL001083-JAL0010923/24/2010Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno,Nagai, SakairiUnknown 2-3 Airline Alliance StrategyDP2,CQ1719 JAL001093 3/24/2010 Unknown UnknownJAL-AA Joint Business ExecutiveSponsors Meeting AgendaDP220JAL001094-JAL0010953/31/2010Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno,Nagai, SakairiUnknown 2-3 Airline Alliance StrategyDP2,CQ1721 JAL001096 4/1/2010 Unknown UnknownJAL-AA Joint Business Kickoff MeetingAgendaDP222JAL001097-JAL0011264/1/2010 UnknownInternational OperationsDepartmentJoint Business Agreement withAmerican Airlines—PresentationMaterials for April 7, 2010 GM MeetingDP2,CQ223JAL001127-JAL0011284/1/2010 Unknown Unknown JAL-AA PJBA Kickoff Meeting Logistics DP224JAL001129-JAL0011724/1/2010 Unknown UnknownPJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Organizingand Implementing the PJBA—April 9,2010- Los AngelesDP2,CQ1(a)25JAL001173-JAL0011744/5/2010 Unknown UnknownJL-AA Joint Business Working Groupsas of April 5, 2010; JL-AA JointBusiness Steering Committee andManagement Committee As of March31, 2010DP226 JAL001175 4/5/2010 Unknown Unknown Onishi Closing Speech—ATI Kickoff DP227JAL001176-JAL0011774/6/2010Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno,Nagai, SakairiUnknown 2-3 Airline Alliance StrategyDP2,CQ1728JAL001178-JAL0011924/7/2010 UnknownInternational AffairsDepartmentJoint Business Agreement withAmerican Airlines—PresentationMaterials for April 7, 2007 GM MeetingDP2,CQ2Page 3 of 4Tab # Bates RangeDocumentDateRecipients Author Document Title/DescriptionDocumentRequest/Clarification29JAL001193-JAL0012404/7/2010 UnknownCorporate PlanningDivisionRoutes and Flight Frequency PlanUnder the New Reorganization (FinalProposal)DP2,CQ1430 JAL001241 4/8/2010 Unknown UnknownJAL-AA PJBA Kickoff Meeting Logistics:Hotel Confirmation NumbersDP231JAL001242-JAL0012444/8/2010 Unknown Unknown PJBA Kickoff Meeting—Seating Chart DP232JAL001245-JAL0012544/9/2010 Vice Presidents of AMRDBZ TYOBTZOverview: Joint Business Agreementwith American AirlinesDP2,CQ233JAL001255-JAL0012564/9/2010 Unknown Unknown Ando Closing Speech: ATI Kickoff DP234JAL001257-JAL0012644/13/2010Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno,Nagai, SakairiUnknown 2-3 Airline Alliance StrategyDP2,CQ1735JAL001265-JAL001266Unknown Unknown UnknownJoint Business Agreement LegalGuidelinesDP236JAL001267-JAL001270Unknown UnknownUnknownJAL-AA PJBA Contact List DP237JAL001271-JAL001276Unknown UnknownUnknownJAL-AA PJBA Contact List v.2 DP238 JAL001277 Unknown UnknownUnknownJAL-AA PJBA Vision and GuidingPrinciplesDP239JAL001278-JAL001279Unknown UnknownUnknownPJBA Kickoff Meeting Logistics DP240JAL001280-JAL001281Unknown UnknownUnknownTasks for Kickoff Meeting DP241JAL001282-JAL001292Unknown UnknownUnknownAA-JAL JBA Functional Working GroupContractual ObligationsDP2,CQ5, CQ742 JAL001293 Unknown UnknownUnknownWorking Group Breakout SessionInstructionsDP243JAL001294-JAL001334Unknown UnknownUnknownPJB Deliverables Plan DP244JAL001335-JAL0013552/2010 UnknownoneworldDeveloping the role of oneworld: Focusgroups—Global ReportCQ1(d)45JAL001356-JAL0013634/8/2010 U.S. Department of JusticeAmerican Airlines andJapan AirlinesAA/JAL Application for AntitrustImmunity—Presentation to DOJCQ1(a)46JAL001364-JAL0013655/10/2010 JAL Privilege Log DP147JAL001366-JAL0013783/15/2010JBA Explanatory Materials CQ1848JAL001379-JAL0013894/2/2010 Competitive Analysis CQ18Page 4 of 4Previously Produced Documents That Are Responsive toDocument Requests and Clarification QuestionsDocument Request/Clarification QuestionBates RangeCQ1(a) JAL000471-JAL000472, JAL000473-JAL000491, JAL000637-JAL000648, JAL000686-JAL000717CQ1(b) JAL000750-JAL000891CQ1(d)JAL000001-JAL000004, JAL000005-JAL000018, JAL000038-JAL000041, JAL000042-JAL000057, JAL000058-JAL000119, JAL000124-JAL000187,JAL000188-JAL000195, JAL000196- JAL000201, JAL000202-JAL000289, JAL000290-JAL000355, JAL000411-JAL000448CQ3 JAL000124-JAL000187, JAL000188-JAL000195, JAL000196-JAL000201,JAL000202-JAL000289, JAL000290-JAL000355, JAL000637- JAL000648CQ4(a) JAL000750-JAL000891CQ4(d)JAL000124-JAL000187, JAL000188-JAL000195, JAL000196-JAL000201, JAL000202-JAL000289, JAL000290-JAL000355, JAL000377-JAL000379,JAL000380-JAL000403, JAL000404-JAL000410, JAL000637-JAL000648, JAL000670-JAL000681CQ17 JAL000637-JAL000648

# CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing

document by email on the following persons:

sascha.vanderbellen@delta.com jhill@dlalaw.com

scott.mcclain@delta.com bill@mietuslaw.com

sametta.c.barnett@delta.com mgoldman@sgbdc.com

kquinn@pillsburywinthrop.com rsilverberg@sgbdc.com

bkeiner@crowell.com dhainbach@ggh-airlaw.com

mrosia@crowell.com mcmillin@woa.com

bruce.rabinovitz@wilmerhale.com eskraft@jamhoff.com

jeffrey.manley@united.com dpdean@jamhoff.com

bob.kneisley@wnco.com dkirstein@yklaw.com

robert.land@jetblue.com jyoung@yklaw.com

msinick@ssd.com donna.kooperstein@usdoj.gov

cdonley@ssd.com dwight.moore@ustranscom.mil

gbleopard@fedex.com jim.ballough@faa.gov

dvaughan@kelleydrye.com byerlyjr@state.gov

kevin.montgomery@polaraircargo.com recohn@hhlaw.com

jrichardson@johnlrichardson.com cjsimpson@zsrlaw.com

lhalloway@crowell.com pmurphy@lopmurphy.com

efaberman@wileyrein.com lachter@starpower.net

mroller@rollerbauer.com anita.mosner@hklaw.com

howard.kass@usairways.com rpommer@atlasair.com

benjamin.slocum@usairways.com gmurphy@crowell.com

sophy.chen@hklaw.com russell.bailey@alpa.org

david.heffernan@wilmerhale.com

_______________________________ CARL B. NELSON, JR.

May 10, 2010