## San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District 

# Compliance Source Test Report Panoche Energy Center Panoche Facility Turbine 1

Prepared by Aeros Environmental, Inc.

Determination of Concentrations and Emissions of Particulate, NOx, CO, VOC, NH 3 , 

## Fuel Sulfur (SOx as 

## 50 2 ) 

## and Relative Accuracy Test Audit (RATA) Project 280-6747A

Tested May 11, 2010

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL , INC .

Pano c he Energy Center Panoch e Facility Tu r bine 1

Po ll u t an t ppm 2 . 63 

### NO . 2 . 57 2 . 60 M e an 2 .60 2.62 

### CO 2.02 3.88 Mean 2. 84 2. 1 0 

### NH , 2. 1 1 2.17 M ea n 2 . 13 0 .0 

### VOC 0.0 0.0 M ea n <0 . 1 5 gr

/ DSCF 0 .00086 

### Particul ate 0 .00065 0 .00052 M ea n 0 .00068 gr

/ 100DSC F

AsSin 

## Summary Of R es ults

ppm@**%~** Ib/ h r I b/MM B t u

1 . 96 6 . 50 0 .0071 1 . 91 6 . 35 0 .0069 1 . 94 6.44 0 .0071 1. 9 4 6 .43 0 . 007 1 1 .95 3.94 0 .0043 1 .50 3 .04 0 .0033 2 .90 5 .85 0 .0064 2 . 1 2 4 .2 8 0 . 0047 1.56 1.92 1 .58 1.93 1 .62 1 .98 1 . 58 1 . 94 0 .0 0.00 0 .0000 0.0 0 .00 0.0000 0 .0 0.00 0.0000 

### <0 .11 <0 .1 3 <0 .0001 gT/SeF I b/ hr I b/MM Btu 0.00076 2 .769 0.00279 0.00058 2.184 0.00213 0.00046 1.767 0 .00169 0.00060 2 .240 0.00220 I b/hr Ib/MM Btu As**SO ~**  in As SOl i n 

### Proje ct 2 8 0·6747A May 11, 2 01 0 Permit N o . C·7220·1·0 Pe r m it Li mi ts 

### 2. 5 p pm@1 5 % 0 2 

### an d 8.03 I b /h r 

### 6. 0 p p m@1 5% 0 2 

### and 11. 8 1 Ib/hr 

### 1 0 ppm @ 

### 15 % 

## Oz and 1 1 . 90 Ib/hr 

### 2 .0 p pm@ 1 5 % 0 2 

### a nd 2 . 671 b/hr

0 . 1 g r/DSCF 

### and 6.00 I b /hr 1 9 r/ 100 DSCF Fue l Su lfu r Fue l Gas Sta ck Exhaust StaCk Exhaust 

### an d <0 .06 

### <0 .149 < 0 .0002 2 . 51 Ib/h r Co m ments 

## vae Reported Results Based on Detection Lim it of P rooane 2009 H isto rical H A P S to 

## vae Ratio - O.777 Calculated H APS=O.10 Ib/h r

### Panoche Energy Center 

### Panache Facility Turbine 1

Instrument Aeros 

### °2% 12.95 NOx@15% 

### 1.95 

### CO 15% 

### 2.85 Instrument Aeros



### ° 2% 12 .95 NOx Ib/MMBtu 

### 0.0071 Client 

### 13.00 1.98 2 .46 Client 

### 13.00 0.0072 

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. 

## Summary Of Results

RATA Results Part 60 

### RM AS Difference Oifference+CC 

### 0 .45 N/A 

### 0.05 N/A 

### 2.43 1.90 0.03 N/A 

### 16 . 17 7.67 0.39 0.46 RATA Results Part 75 

### RM Difference Bias Adjustment 

### 0 .45 0.05 N/A 

### 2.25 0 .00009 1.00 

### Project 280-6747A May II, 2010 Permit No. C-7220-1-0 limits 1% Difference 20% RM or 10% AS 10% RM or 5% AS or Difference+CC<5ppm Annual Limits 7.5% RM or 0.7% D ifference 

### 7.5"1. RM or O

. 015Ib/M MB tu Difference

## San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control Distr i ct 

# Compliance Source Test Report Panoche Energy Center Panoche Facility Turbin e 2

Prepared by Aeros Environmental, Inc.

Determination of Concentrations and Emissions of Particulate, NOx, CO, VOC, NH 3 , 

## Fu e l Sulfur (SOx as 50 2 ) 

## and Relative Accuracy Test Audit (RATA) Project 

## 280-6747B

Tested May 

## 12, 2010

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL , INC.

Panoche Energy Center Panoche Facility Turbine 2

Pollutant ppm 2.82 NOx 2.87 2.89 Mean 2.86 2.12 CO 2.06 1 . 97 Mean 2 .05 1 . 81 NH, 1.89 1 . 84 Mean 1.85 0.0 VOC 0.0 0 .0 Mean <0.15 gr/DSCF 0.00043 

### Particulate 0 .00033 0 .00047 Mean 0 .00041 gr/100DSCF AsSln 

## Summary Of Results

ppm@ 

### 15°/c. O 2 Ib/hr IblMMBtu

2.11 7.01 0 .0077 2.14 7 . 14 0 .0078 2.15 7 . 19 0 .0078 2.13 7.11 0 .0078 1.59 3.21 0.0035 1 . 54 3.12 0 .0034 1 . 47 2.99 0.0033 1.53 3.11 0 .0034 1.35 1 .66 1.41 1.74 1 . 37 1 .69 1.37 1.70 0.0 0.00 0.0000 0 .0 0 .00 0 .0000 0.0 0.00 0.0000 <0.11 <0.13 <0.0001 grlSCF Ib/hr Ib/MMBtu 0 .00039 1.430 0 .00141 0 .00030 1.104 0.00107 0.00042 1.591 0.00155 0.00037 1.375 0 .00134 Ib/hr Ib/MMBtu As 50 2 in As S02 in 

### Project 280·67478 May 12, 2010 Permit No. C· 7220·2·0 Permit Limits 2.5 ppm@15%0 2 

### and 8.031b/hr 6.0 ppm @ 15% O2 

### and 11.811b/hr 10 ppm@15%0 2 

### and 11.901b/hr 2.0 ppm@15%0 2 

### and 2.671b/hr

0.1 gr/DSCF 

### and 6 . 00 Ib/hr 1 gr/100 DSCF Fuel Sulfur Fuel Gas Stack Ex.haust Stack Exhaust 

### and <0.06 <0.150 <0.0002 2.51 lb/hr Comments 

## voe Reported Results Based on D etection limit of Propane 2009 His to rical HAPS to 

# voe Ratio-D . 777 Calculated HAPS - O . 10 Ib/hr

### Panache Energy Center Panache Facility Turbine 2

Instrument Aeros 

### °2 % 12.94 NOx (Ql15% 2.12 CO@1S% 1 . 99 Instrument Ae ros 

### °2% 12.94**~.9x** I b/MMBtu 0 .0077

_ _ 

### Client 12.96 2 . 14 1 .96 Client 

### 12 .96 0 .0078 

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC . Summary Of Results

RATA Results Pa rt 60 

### RM AS Difference Oifference+CC 

### 0 . 21 N/A 0 .02 N/A 3.56 3.02 0.02 N /A 3.73 1.24 

### 0 .03 0 .07 RATA Results Part 75 

### RM Difference Bias Adjustment 

### 0 . 21 0 .02 N/A 3.59 0 .00010 1 .00 

### Project 280-6 7478 May 12, 2010 Permit No. C -7220-2-0 limits 1% Difference 20% R M or 1 0 % AS 10% RM or 5% AS or Difference+CC<5ppm Annual Limits 7.5% RM or 0 .7% Difference 7.5% RM or O.015Ib/MMBtu Difference

- - - ---- --

## San Joaqu i n Valley Air Pollution Contro l District 

# Compliance Source Test Report Panoche Energy Center Panoche Facility Turbine 3

Prepared by Aeros Environmental, Inc .

Determination of Concentrations and Emissions of Particulate, NOx, CO, VOC, NH 3 , 

## Fuel Sulfur (Sox as 

## 50 2 ) 

## and Relative Accuracy Test Audit (RATA) Project 280-6747C

Tested May 18, 2010

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC .

Panoch e Energy Cente r Panoche Facility Turbine 3

Pollutant ppm 2.87 NOx 2.85 2 . 85 Mean 2 . 86 0.73 CO 0 . 92 0 .87 M ean 0.84 1 . 8 1 NH, 1 .99 2 . 04 Mean 1.95 0 . 0 VOC 0 . 0 0.0 Mean <0.15 gr/DSCF 0 . 00051 

### Particulate 0 . 00054 0 . 00046 M ean 0 . 00051 gr/100DSCF AsS In 

## Summary Of Results

ppm@ 

### 15% 0 2 Ib/hr Ib/MMBtu

2.12 7 . 06 0 . 0077 211 7 . 02 0 .0077 2 . 10 6 . 99 0 . 0076 2.11 7 . 02 0 . 0077 0 . 54 1 . 09 0 . 0012 0.68 1 . 37 0 .0015 0.64 1.30 0 . 0014 0 . 62 1.25 0.001 4 1 . 34 1 . 65 1.46 1 . 80 1 . 51 1 . 86 1.44 1.77 0 . 0 0 .00 0 . 0000 0 .0 0 . 00 0 . 0000 0 . 0 0 . 00 0 . 0000 

### <0.11 <0. 13 <0.0001 grlSCF Ib/hr Ib/MMBtu 0 . 00046 1 . 747 0.00168 0 . 00048 1 . 845 0 . 00176 0 . 00041 1 . 580 0 . 00149 0 . 00045 1.724 0 . 00164 Ib/hr Ib/MMBtu As S021n As S0 2 in 

### Proje c t 280-6747C May 18, 2010 Permit No . C-7220-3'() Permit Lim its 

### 2 .5 ppm @ 

### 15% O2 

### and 8.031b1hr 

### 6 .0 ppm@15 % Oa 

### and 11.81 I b/hr 

### 1 0 ppm@15%0 2 

### and 11 .9 01b/hr 2.0 ppm@15 % 0 2 

### and 2.67 I b/hr

0.1 gr/DSCF 

### and 8.00 Ib/hr 1 gr/100 DSCF Fuel Sulfur Fuel Gas Stack Exhaust Stack Exhaust 

### and <0.06 <0 . 150 <0 .0002 2.51 Iblhr Comments voe Reoorted Results Based on Detection Limit of Prooane 2009 H istorical HAPS to vee Ratio 0 . 777 Calculated HAPS=O . 10 Iblhrl 

## , Panache Energy Center Panache Facility Turbine 3

Instrument 

### Aeros 

### 0:% 12.91 NOx@15% 

### 2.09 

### CO 15% 0 . 63 Instrument Aeros 

### °2% 12.91 NOx Ib/MMBtu 

### 0.0076 Client 

### 12.93 2.02 0.41 Client 

### 12 .93 0.0074 

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. Summary Of Results

RATA Resu lts Part 60 

### RM AS Difference Difference+CC 

### 0 . 27 NfA 

### 0.02 NfA 

### 3 .96 3 . 31 0 .07 NfA 

### 37 . 37 3.94 0.22 0 . 24 RATA Results Part 75 

### RM Difference Bias Ad ustment 0.27 0.02 NfA 

### 4 . 09 0.00026 1 .04 

### Project 280-6747C May 18 , 2010 Permit No. C-7220-3'() lim i ts 1% Difference 20% RM or 10% AS 10% RM 

### or 5% AS 

### or Difference+CC<5ppm Annual Limits 7.5% RM 

### or 

### 0. 7'1. Difference 7.5% RM 

### or 0.015 IblMMBlu Difference

-- - -- - - -------

## San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District 

# Compliance Source Test Report Panoche Energy Center Panoche Facility Turbine 4

Prepared by Aeros Environmental, Inc.

Determination of Concentrations and Emissions of Particulate, NOx, CO, VOC, NH 3 , 

## Fuel Sulfur (Sox as 50 2 ) 

## and Relative Accuracy Test Audit (RATA) Project 

## 280·67470

Tested May 

## 19, 2010

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC.

Pan ac h e Energy Cen ter Pan ache Facility T u rbin e 4

Pollutant ppm 

### 2 . 84 NOx 2 . 84 2 . 79 Mean 

### 2. 82 2.25 CO 1 .38 1 .53 Mean 

### 1.72 1.78 NH, 1 . 89 1.80 Mean 

### 1.82 0 . 0 VOC 0 .0 0 .0 Mean <0.15 grJDSCF 

### 0 .00076 Particulate 

### 0 .00061 0 .00095 Mean 

### 0 .00 077 gr/100DSCF AsS i n 

## Summary Of Results

ppm@ 15% O 2 Ib/hr Ib/MM Btu



### 2 . 11 6.95 0 .0 077 2.11 6 .91 0.0077 2.08 6 .77 0 .0 076 2.10 6 . 88 0.0077 1 . 67 3 . 34 0 .0037 1 . 03 2.04 0.0023 1 . 14 

### 2 .26 0.0025 1 . 28 2.55 0 .0028 1.32 1.60 1 .41 1 .70 1 .3 4 

### 1.61 1 .36 1. 63 0.0 0 .00 0.0000 0.0 0 .00 0.0000 0.0 0.00 0.0000 < 0 . 11 <0.13 <0.0001 grlSCF Ib/hr Ib/MMBtu 

### 0.00068 2 .5 29 0.00249 0 .00054 2.021 0 .001 98 0.00085 3.128 0 .00310 0.00069 2.5 59 0.00252 Ib/hr IbfMMBtu AsS02 i n As 50 2 i n 

### Project 280-67470 May 19, 2010 Permit No . C-7220-4-0 Permit Limits 2,5 ppm@15%0 2 

### and 8.031b/hr 6.0 ppm@15%0 2 

### and 11.811bfhr 10 ppm 

### @ 15% O 2 

### and 11 .9 01b/hr 

### 2.0 ppm @ 

### 15% O2 

### and 2.671b/hr



### 0.1 g r lDSCF 

### and 6 .001blhr 1 gr/100 DSCF Fuel Sulfur F uel Gas Stack Exhaust Stack Exhaust 

### and <0.06 <0.148 <0.0002 2.51 Ib/hr Comments 

## vae Reported Results Based on Detection Limit of Propane 2009 Historical HAPS to 

## vae Ratio - C.77? Calculated HAPS-O . 10 Ib/hr

# , Panoche Energy Center Panoche Facility Turbine 4 Instrument Aeros 

### °2% 12.98 

### NOx@15% 2.09 

### CO@15% 1.27 Instrument Aeros 

### °2% 12.98 NOx Ib/MMBtu 

### 0 .0076 

### Client 12.99 2.12 1.24 

### Client 12.99 0.0077 

## AEROS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. 

## Summary Of Results

RATA Results Part 60 

### RM AS Difference Difference+CC 

### 0.11 N/A 0.00 N/A 2.25 1.89 0.03 N/A 6.31 1.33 0.03 0.08 RATA Results Part 7 5 

### RM Difference Bias Ad ' ustment 

### 0.11 0.00 N/A 1.69 0.00008 1.00 

### Project 280-67470 May 19, 2010 Perm i t No. C-7220-4-0 Limits 1% Difference 20% RM 

### or 10% AS 10% RM 

### or 5% AS 

### or Difference+CC<5ppm 

### Annual Limits 7.5% RM 

### or 0.7% Difference 7.5% RM 

### or 0.015 Ib/MMBtu Difference