May 10, 2010 

Renee Wright 

Program Manager 

Docket Branch 

Department of Transportation 

1200 New Jersey Ave., S.E. 

Washington, D.C. 20590 

 Re: U.S.-Japan Alliance Case, DOT-OST-2010-0059

Dear Ms. Wright: 

 American Airlines, Inc. and Japan Airlines International 

Co., Ltd. are separately submitting confidential documents and other 

material in response to Order 2010-4-9, April 16, 2010, seeking 

additional information. We request confidential treatment under the 

Joint Applicant’s Rule 12 motion of February 12, 2010, which we 

incorporate herein by reference. Public indexes are attached. 

 Respectfully submitted, 

______________________ ______________________ 

WILLIAM KARAS CARL B. NELSON, JR. 

CAROL GOSAIN Associate General Counsel 

Steptoe & Johnson LLP R. BRUCE WARK 

1330 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Associate General Counsel 

Washington, D.C. 20036 JEFFREY A. OGAR 

(202) 429-6223 Senior Attorney 

wkaras@steptoe.com American Airlines, Inc. 

cgosain@steptoe.com 1101 17th Street, N.W. 

 Washington, D.C. 20036 

Counsel for Japan Airlines (202) 496-5647 

 (817) 967-3478 

 carl.nelson@aa.com 

 bruce.wark@aa.com 

 jeff.ogar@aa.com 

cc: Service list 
AMERICANAIRLINES

INDEXOFADDITIONALCONFIDENTIALDOCUMENTS

U.S.JAPANALLIANCECASE

DOTOST20100059

BatesRangeDateAuthorDescription

AA_101262

AA_101273

4/9/10VariousTalkingpointsrePJBA

AA_101274

AA_101323

UnknownVariousImplementationplanningdocumentsrePJBA

AA_101324

AA_101327

UnknownUnknownFinanceWorkingGroupMandate

AA_101328

AA_101329

UnknownUnknownRouteforecastingdata

AA_101330

AA_101349

2/26/10VariousPJBAPreKickOffMeeting

AA_101350

AA_101409

4/9/10VariousPJBAKickOffMeeting(privilegedcommunicationfromJ.Ogar

redacted)

AA_101410

AA_101416

3/11/10VariousPJBAOrganizationalDevelopment

AA_101417

AA_101423

4/28/10T.AndoEmailreJLscheduleannouncement

AA_101424

AA_101426

3/16/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101427

AA_101431

3/5/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101432

AA_101452

3/4/10T.WilsonEmailandattachmentsrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101453

AA_101458

2/24/10K.HashimotoEmailrePJBAorganizationandimplementation(privileged

communicationfromAALegalredacted)

AA_101459

AA_101464

2/24/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAorganizationandimplementation(privileged

communicationfromAALegalredacted)

AA_101465

AA_101511

2/21/10E.PerhirinEmailandattachmentsrePJBAorganization(privileged

communicationfromAALegalredacted)

AA_101512

AA_101514

3/2/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101515

AA_101518

3/2/10C.FinkEmailreworkinggroups

AA_101519

AA_101524

3/8/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101525

AA_101529

3/10/10T.MizunoEmailrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101530

AA_101532

3/4/10T.MizunoEmailrePJBAworkinggroups

AA_101533

AA_101541

3/3/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoff

AA_101542

AA_101544

3/3/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoff

AA_101545

AA_101550

3/3/10T.MizunoEmailrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101551

AA_101553

3/3/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoff2

AA_101554

AA_101557

3/12/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoff

AA_101558

AA_101561

3/11/10 C.Fink EmailrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101562

AA_101568

3/5/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101569

AA_101579

3/26/10C.FinkEmailretasksforkickoffmeeting

AA_101580

AA_101600

3/25/10C.FinkEmailrekickoffmeetinglogistics

AA_101601

AA_101606

3/12/10C.FinkEmailrekickoffmeetingagenda

AA_101607

AA_101610

3/19/10E.PerhirinEmailrePJBAworkinggroups

AA_1016112/24/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAorganization

AA_101612

AA_101617

3/29/10E.PerhirinEmailrePJBAkickoffmeeting

AA_101618

AA_101620

3/20/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAorganization

AA_101621

AA_101625

3/29/10K.HashimotoEmailrePJBAupdate

AA_101626

AA_101628

3/29/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffmeeting

AA_101629

AA_101631

3/30/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAdinner

AA_101632

AA_101633

4/1/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101634

AA_101636

3/1/10C.FinkMinutesrePJBAconferencecall(regulatoryadvicefromAALegal

redacted)

AA_101637

AA_101638

4/5/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAconferencecall

AA_101639

AA_101641

4/2/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffagenda

AA_101642

AA_101663

4/1/10T.WilsonEmailrePJBAmaterials

AA_101664

AA_101673

4/1/10A.AgawaEmailrePJBAkickoffmeeting

AA_101674

AA_101679

4/7/10C.FinkEmailrePJBAkickoffmeeting

AA_101680

AA_101714

4/14/10T.WilsonPJBAWorkingGroupdeliverablesU.S.-JAPAN ALLIANCE CASE, DOCKET DOT-OST-2010-0059 

JAL Index of Requested Documents 

Tab # Bates Range Document Date Recipients Author Document Title/Descripti

1 JAL000939- JAL000940 1/16/2010 Unknown Unknown JL-AA Joint Business Agree

Functional Working Group

2 JAL000941- JAL000942 2/25/2010 Tsutumo Ando (JAL), Toru Mizuno (JAL), Kenji Hashimoto (AA), Erwan Perhirin (AA), Tom Wilson (AA), Carla Fink (AA) Unknown Minutes – JL/AA PJBA Confere

25 February 2010 DFW / 26 Fe

2010 TYO 

3 JAL000943- JAL000982 2/26/2010 Unknown Unknown PJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Org

and Implementing the PJBA—F

26, 2006 - Tokyo 

4 JAL000983- JAL000984 3/2/2010 Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Nagai, Sakairi Unknown 2-3 Airline Alliance Strate5 JAL000985- JAL000990 3/3/2010 Unknown Unknown PJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Org

and Implementing the PJBA—

3/4, 2010 Conference Call (D

6 JAL000991- JAL001003 3/3/2010 Unknown Unknown PJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Org

and Implementing the PJBA—

3/4, 2010 Conference Ca

7 JAL001004 3/3/2010 Unknown Unknown JL-AA Joint Business Working 

as of March 3, 2010 

8 JAL001005 3/3/2010 Unknown Unknown JL-AA Joint Business Working 

as of March 3, 2010 v.2 

9 JAL001006- JAL001007 3/8/2010 Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Nagai, Sakairi Unknown 2-3 Airline Alliance Strate

10 JAL001008- JAL001017 3/8/2010 Unknown Unknown Draft Plan for Rebuilding Route

Network—Progress Repo

11 JAL001018- JAL001019 3/11/2010 Tsutumo Ando (JAL), Toru Mizuno (JAL), Kenji Hashimoto (AA), Erwan Perhirin (AA), Tom Wilson (AA), Carla Fink (AA) Unknown Minutes – JL/AA PJBA Confere

11 March 2010 DFW / 12 Marc

TYO 

12 JAL001020- JAL001032 3/11/2010 

Tsutumo Ando (JAL), Toru Mizuno (JAL), 

Akira Mori (JAL), Atsu Agawa (JAL), Kenji 

Hashimoto (AA), Erwan Perhirin (AA), 

Tom Wilson (AA), Carla Fink (AA) 

Unknown 

Minutes – JL/AA PJBA Confere

11 March 2010 DFW / 12 Marc

TYO 

13 JAL001033- JAL001039 3/11/2010 Unknown Unknown PJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Org

and Implementing the PJBA—

10/11, 2010 Conference C

14 JAL001040- JAL001041 3/15/2010 Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno, Nagai, Sakairi Unknown 2-3 Airline Alliance Strate

† “DP” refers to Documents to Be Provided. “CQ” refers to Clarification Questions. 
Page 2 of 4 

Tab # Bates Range Document Date Recipients Author Document Title/Descripti

15 JAL001042 3/15/2010 Unknown Unknown JAL-AA Pacific Joint Busin

Implementation Plan Deliver

16 JAL001043 3/15/2010 Unknown Unknown Joint Business Implementat

Administrative and Financial Pr

17 JAL001044- JAL001082 3/17/2010 Unknown Corporate Planning Division Routes and Flight Frequency 

Under the New Reorganizatio

18 JAL001083- JAL001092 3/24/2010 Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno, Nagai, Sakairi Unknown 2-3 Airline Alliance Strate19 JAL001093 3/24/2010 Unknown Unknown JAL-AA Joint Business Exec

Sponsors Meeting Agend

20 JAL001094- JAL001095 3/31/2010 Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno, Nagai, Sakairi Unknown 2-3 Airline Alliance Strate21 JAL001096 4/1/2010 Unknown Unknown JAL-AA Joint Business Kickoff 

Agenda 

22 JAL001097- JAL001126 4/1/2010 Unknown International Operations Department Joint Business Agreement 

American Airlines—Presenta

Materials for April 7, 2010 GM M

23 JAL001127- JAL001128 4/1/2010 Unknown Unknown JAL-AA PJBA Kickoff Meeting L24 JAL001129- JAL001172 4/1/2010 Unknown Unknown PJBA Pre-Kickoff Meeting: Org

and Implementing the PJBA—

2010- Los Angeles 

25 JAL001173- JAL001174 4/5/2010 Unknown Unknown 

JL-AA Joint Business Working 

as of April 5, 2010; JL-AA J

Business Steering Committe

Management Committee As of 

31, 2010 

26 JAL001175 4/5/2010 Unknown Unknown Onishi Closing Speech—ATI K27 JAL001176- JAL001177 4/6/2010 Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno, Nagai, Sakairi Unknown 2-3 Airline Alliance Strate28 JAL001178- JAL001192 4/7/2010 Unknown International Affairs Department Joint Business Agreement 

American Airlines—Presenta

Materials for April 7, 2007 GM M
Page 3 of 4 

Tab # Bates Range Document Date Recipients Author Document Title/Descripti

29 JAL001193- JAL001240 4/7/2010 Unknown Corporate Planning Division Routes and Flight Frequency 

Under the New Reorganization 

Proposal) 

30 JAL001241 4/8/2010 Unknown Unknown JAL-AA PJBA Kickoff Meeting L

Hotel Confirmation Numbe

31 JAL001242- JAL001244 4/8/2010 Unknown Unknown PJBA Kickoff Meeting—Seatin32 JAL001245- JAL001254 4/9/2010 Vice Presidents of AMRDBZ TYOBTZ Overview: Joint Business Agre

with American Airlines 

33 JAL001255- JAL001256 4/9/2010 Unknown Unknown Ando Closing Speech: ATI K34 JAL001257- JAL001264 4/13/2010 Kurusu, Mizutome, Sugimoto, Mizuno, Nagai, Sakairi Unknown 2-3 Airline Alliance Strate35 JAL001265- JAL001266 Unknown Unknown Unknown Joint Business Agreement L

Guidelines 

36 JAL001267- JAL001270 Unknown Unknown Unknown JAL-AA PJBA Contact Li37 JAL001271- JAL001276 Unknown Unknown Unknown JAL-AA PJBA Contact List 38 JAL001277 Unknown Unknown Unknown JAL-AA PJBA Vision and Gu

Principles 

39 JAL001278- JAL001279 Unknown Unknown Unknown PJBA Kickoff Meeting Logis40 JAL001280- JAL001281 Unknown Unknown Unknown Tasks for Kickoff Meetin41 JAL001282- JAL001292 Unknown Unknown Unknown AA-JAL JBA Functional Workin

Contractual Obligations 

42 JAL001293 Unknown Unknown Unknown Working Group Breakout Se

Instructions 

43 JAL001294- JAL001334 Unknown Unknown Unknown PJB Deliverables Plan 44 JAL001335- JAL001355 2/2010 Unknown oneworld Developing the role of oneworld

groups—Global Report 

45 JAL001356- JAL001363 4/8/2010 U.S. Department of Justice American Airlines and Japan Airlines AA/JAL Application for Antit

Immunity—Presentation to 

46 JAL001364- JAL001365 5/10/2010 JAL Privilege Log 47 JAL001366- JAL001378 3/15/2010 JBA Explanatory Materia48 JAL001379- JAL001389 4/2/2010 Competitive Analysis 
Page 4 of 4 

Previously Produced Documents That Are Responsive to Document Requests and Clarifica

Document Request/ 

Clarification Question Bates Range 

CQ1(a) JAL000471-JAL000472, JAL000473-JAL000491, JAL000637-JAL000648, JAL000686-JAL000717 CQ1(b) JAL000750-JAL000891 CQ1(d) JAL000001-JAL000004, JAL000005-JAL000018, JAL000038-JAL000041, JAL000042-JAL000057, JAL000058-JAL000119

JAL000188-JAL000195, JAL000196- JAL000201, JAL000202-JAL000289, JAL000290-JAL000355, JAL000411-JAL000448 

CQ3 JAL000124-JAL000187, JAL000188-JAL000195, JAL000196-JAL000201, JAL000202-JAL000289, JAL000290-JAL000355CQ4(a) JAL000750-JAL000891 CQ4(d) JAL000124-JAL000187, JAL000188-JAL000195, JAL000196-JAL000201, JAL000202-JAL000289, JAL000290-JAL000355

JAL000380-JAL000403, JAL000404-JAL000410, JAL000637-JAL000648, JAL000670-JAL000681 

CQ17 JAL000637-JAL000648 
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

 

 I hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing 

document by email on the following persons: 

 

sascha.vanderbellen@delta.com jhill@dlalaw.com 

scott.mcclain@delta.com bill@mietuslaw.com 

sametta.c.barnett@delta.com mgoldman@sgbdc.com 

kquinn@pillsburywinthrop.com rsilverberg@sgbdc.com 

bkeiner@crowell.com dhainbach@ggh-airlaw.com 

mrosia@crowell.com mcmillin@woa.com 

bruce.rabinovitz@wilmerhale.com eskraft@jamhoff.com 

jeffrey.manley@united.com dpdean@jamhoff.com 

bob.kneisley@wnco.com dkirstein@yklaw.com 

robert.land@jetblue.com jyoung@yklaw.com 

msinick@ssd.com donna.kooperstein@usdoj.gov 

cdonley@ssd.com dwight.moore@ustranscom.mil 

gbleopard@fedex.com jim.ballough@faa.gov 

dvaughan@kelleydrye.com byerlyjr@state.gov 

kevin.montgomery@polaraircargo.com recohn@hhlaw.com 

jrichardson@johnlrichardson.com cjsimpson@zsrlaw.com 

lhalloway@crowell.com pmurphy@lopmurphy.com 

efaberman@wileyrein.com lachter@starpower.net 

mroller@rollerbauer.com anita.mosner@hklaw.com 

howard.kass@usairways.com rpommer@atlasair.com 

benjamin.slocum@usairways.com gmurphy@crowell.com 

sophy.chen@hklaw.com russell.bailey@alpa.org 

david.heffernan@wilmerhale.com 

 

 

 _______________________________ 

 CARL B. NELSON, JR. 

May 10, 2010