'*$"(& "& (. ,


I=-IG::I(1	-J>I:



16H=>C<IDC	




)* (- , .-



I=-I(1	-J>I:



16H=>C<IDC	


	

*A6>CI>;;H	

K >K>A8I>DC(D

!  ,& & .$)()''$--$)(



!>GHI-IG::I( 

16H=>C<IDC	
	

:;:C96CI











 *A6>CI>;;H6BE6><C&:<6A:CI:GS&T6C9)E:C-:8G:IH7G>C<I=>H68I>DC;DG

9:8A6G6IDGN6C9>C?JC8I>K:G:A>:;JC9:GI=:9B>C>HIG6I>K:*GD8:9JG:8IS*TID8=6AA:C<:I=:

JCG:6HDC67A: 9:A6N 7N :;:C96CI !:9:G6A A:8I>DC DBB>HH>DC S! T DG SDBB>HH>DCT >C

G:HEDC9>C< ID I=:>G *:I>I>DC ID *GDBJA<6I: ,JA:H ;DG ,:EDGI>C< D; SGDBC>7JHT 88DJCIH

S*:I>I>DCT	96I:9J<JHI	


 (:6GAN,(,$5$ /0 &-	>C:8:B7:G
	DC<G:HH6EEGDK:96B:C9B:CIHIDI=:

!:9:G6A A:8I>DC6BE6><C8I S! T DG S8IT 8G:6I>C< C:L HE:8>6A
EJGEDH: 688DJCIH ;DG

C6I>DC6AEDA>I>86AE6GIN8DBB>II::H.=:A:<>HA6I>DC	6AHD@CDLC6HI=:SGDBC>7JHT7:86JH:>IL6H

 .=::CI:G;DG,:HEDCH>K:*DA>I>8H6C9I=:(6I>DC6A$CHI>IJI:DC'DC:N>C*DA>I>8HB:G<:9>C


ID7:8DB:)E:C-:8G:IH

 $$&6C9:CI:G ;DG,:HEDCH>K:*DA>I>8H	*:I>I>DCID*GDBJA<6I:,JA:H ;DG,:EDGI>C< D;

SGDBC>7JHT88DJCIHG:, "


J<	
	=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB

9D8>9


Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 1 of 24
 

IJ8@:9>CIDI=:IG>AA>DCDCHDA>96I:96C9!JGI=:GDCI>CJ>C<EEGDEG>6I>DCH8ID;
	*J7

& (D 
	  -I6I 
	  
 SEEGDEG>6I>DCH 8IT	 6AADL:9 C6I>DC6A E6GIN

8DBB>II::HID:HI67A>H=I=G::C:L@>C9HD;SH:E6G6I:	H:<G:<6I:9T688DJCIHRDC:;DGEG:H>9:CI>6A

CDB>C6I>C<8DCK:CI>DCH	DC:;DGE6GIN=:69FJ6GI:GH7J>A9>C<H	6C9DC:;DGA:<6AEGD8::9>C<HR6C9

IG>EA:9I=:<:C:G6AAN6EEA>867A:A>B>I;DG8DCIG>7JI>DCHID:68=688DJCI

 H 6 G:HJAI	 :68= E6GIN CDL DE:G6I:H JE ID 0$3$, HE:8>6A
EJGEDH: GDBC>7JH

688DJCIHRI=G::;DGI=:E6GI>:HVC6I>DC6A8DBB>II::H6C9ILD;DGI=:>G8DC<G:HH>DC6A6C9H:C6IDG>6A

8DBB>II::H	7:86JH:DCAN6E6GINVHC6I>DC6A8DBB>II::B6N:HI67A>H=6EG:H>9:CI>6ACDB>C6I>C<

8DCK:CI>DC688DJCIR6C9$ "'D;I=DH:688DJCIH>HHJ7?:8IID6H:E6G6I:8DCIG>7JI>DCA>B>I



<G:6I:GI=6CI=:<:C:G6AA>B>I$$/-P
6		$CI=:

:A:8I>DC

8N8A:	I=:G:;DG:	:68=C6I>DC6AE6GINHE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCI>HHJ7?:8IID6A>B>ID;	

E:G

N:6G I=G::I>B:HI=: E6GINVH 76H:A>B>I D; 	

 E:G N:6GRB:6C>C< 6C>C9>K>9J6A 86C CDL

8DCIG>7JI:JEID	

E:GILD
N:6G:A:8I>DC8N8A:ID:68=D;6E6GINVHH:K:CHE:8>6AEJGEDH:

688DJCIH	DG6IDI6AD;+-/$1' ,+(**(-,.$/$*$"1(-,"5"*$1- 0(,&*$. /15



 .=:EEGDEG>6I>DCH8I6B:C9B:CIHID! 	H:I;DGI=>C?JHII=G::E6G6<G6E=H

C:6G I=: :C9 D; 6 

E6<: 6EEGDEG>6I>DCH E68@6<:	 9>9 CDI 9:A>C:6I: I=: E:GB>HH>7A: JH:H D;

C6I>DC6AE6GINHE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCIHDG:HI67A>H=6CN9>H8ADHJG: G:FJ>G:B:CIHHE:8>;>8IDI=:

;JC9H;ADL>C<>CID6C9DJID;I=:B.=:H:B6?DGHI6IJIDGN8=6C<:HIDI=:E6GIN8DCIG>7JI>DCA>B>IH

I=JH9:B6C9:9>BB:9>6I: GJA:B6@>C<7NI=:! ID:CHJG:EGDE:G>BEA:B:CI6I>DCD;I=:C:L

HE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCIH6C9IDEG:K:CII=:B;GDBJC9:G8JII>C<! VH8DG:6CI>
8DGGJEI>DC6C9

IG6CHE6G:C8N<D6AH

 $$ -,1/(!21(-, (+(10 %-/ 		
	 ! 	 =IIEHLLL;:8<DKG:HDJG8:H8BH
8DCI:CI

9D8JB:CIH8DCIG>7JI>DC5A>B>IH58=6GI5


E9;>HHJ:9!:7


Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 2 of 24
 

 .=:DBB>HH>DC	=DL:K:G	9>9CDI=>C<(:6GAN69:869:A6I:G	I=:! =6HN:IID

EGDBJA<6I:6H>C<A:GJA:ID>BEA:B:CII=:H:6B:C9B:CIHIDI=:8IRDG:K:CID>C>I>6I:HJ8=6

GJA:B6@>C<R9:HE>I:=6K>C<G:8:>K:9ILDE:I>I>DCH6H@>C<I=6I>I9DHD	>C8AJ9>C<I=:
*:I>I>DC

;GDBEA6>CI>;;HI=6I>HI=:HJ7?:8ID;I=>HHJ>I

 *A6>CI>;;HV*:I>I>DC	 ;>A:9DCJ<JHI	
	 ;D8JH:9C6GGDLANDCI=:H><C>;>86CI

9>H8ADHJG: 9:;>8>:C8>:H I=6I =6K: 6G>H:C >C I=: 67H:C8: D; !  GJA:H <DK:GC>C< G:EDGI>C< ;DG

C6I>DC6A E6GINGDBC>7JH 688DJCIHH CDI:9>CI=: *:I>I>DC	L=6I:K:G D7HI68A:HI=:G:L:G:ID

8DBEA:I>C<6;JAAGJA:B6@>C<DCI=:H:688DJCIH	>IH=DJA9=6K:7::C:6HN;DGI=:DBB>HH>DC6I

A:6HIIDEGDBJA<6I:H>BEA:6C9HDG:ANC::9:9G:EDGI>C<G:<JA6I>DCH*:I>I>DC6I

 .=:*:I>I>DC9:I6>A:9=DLE6GI>:H=6K:69DEI:9=6E=6O6G96C9>C69:FJ6I:G:EDGI>C<

8DCK:CI>DCH L>I= G:HE:8I ID I=: ;JC9H ;ADL>C< >CID 6C9 DJI D; I=:>G HE:8>6A
EJGEDH: 688DJCIH	

B6@>C<>IK>GIJ6AAN>BEDHH>7A:;DGI=:EJ7A>8IDBDC>IDGI=:E6GI>:HVJH:D;I=:H:688DJCIHDG9>H8:GC

=DLGDBC>7JH;JC9H6G:7:>C<G6>H:96C9HE:CI*:I>I>DC6I


 .D6B:A>DG6I:I=:H:EGD7A:BH	I=:*:I>I>DCG:FJ:HI:9I=6II=:! EGDBJA<6I:GJA:H

6C9;DGBHG:FJ>G>C<C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::HID9:A>C:6I:L>I=>CI=:>GG:EDGIHI=:>C9>K>9J6A6C9

6<<G:<6I: IG6CH68I>DCH >CKDAK>C< I=:>G GDBC>7JH 688DJCIH	 6C9 EGDEDH:9 H:K:G6A HE:8>;>8

G:<JA6IDGN8=6C<:HI=6ILDJA9=:AE68=>:K:HJ8=IG6CHE6G:C8N*:I>I>DC6I

 *A6>CI>;;H HJ7H:FJ:CIAN HJ7B>II:9 8DBB:CIH L>I=I=: !  DC )8ID7:G 	 


SDBB:CIHT	6C9EA6>CI>;;&9>9HD6<6>CDC%JC:	

	G:>I:G6I>C<I=:>BEDGI6C8:D;I=:

E:C9>C<*:I>I>DC6C9EGDK>9>C<699>I>DC6A>C;DGB6I>DC67DJII=:9>H8ADHJG:>HHJ:H>I9:H8G>7:9

 $$DBB:CIHD;&6C9:CI:G;DG,:HEDCH>K:*DA>I>8HDC, "


)8I	
	

=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9
&:II:G;GDB&IDDBB>HH>DC:GH6I

%JC:	

	=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9S&:II:GT

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 3 of 24
 


 H D; I=: ;>A>C< D; I=>H DBEA6>CI	 I=: DBB>HH>DC =6H CDI G:HEDC9:9 ID ($	

<G6CI:9DG9:C>:9I=:*:I>I>DC

 ':6CL=>A:	:B7DA9:C:97NI=:G:<JA6IDGNK68JJB8G:6I:97NI=:! VH;6>AJG:ID

68I	I=:C6I>DC6AE6GI>:H6G:8DCI>CJ>C<IDB6@:JEI=:>GDLCGJA:HH6G:HJAI	:68=C6I>DC6AE6GIN

8DBB>II:: G:EDGIH >IH G:8:>EIH ID 6C9 9>H7JGH:B:CIH ;GDB I=: 688DJCIH >C >C8DCH>HI:CI 6C9

>CHJ;;>8>:CI L6NH	 B6@>C< >I :;;:8I>K:AN >BEDHH>7A: ;DG EA6>CI>;;H DG I=: EJ7A>8 ID 688JG6I:AN

9:I:GB>C:I=:6BDJCID;BDC:N;ADL>C<>CID6C9DJID;I=:688DJCIH

 .=:

:A:8I>DC8N8A:>H6AG:69NL:AAJC9:GL6N1>I=DJIEGDBEI68I>DC7NI=:

! ID:CHJG:I=6II=:BDC:N>CE6GINHE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCIH>HG:EDGI:9;JAAN6C9JC>;DGBAN	

6HI=:8IG:FJ>G:H	I=:EJ7A>86C9EA6>CI>;;HL>AAG:B6>C>CI=:96G@

 NE:GB>II>C<C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::HID:;;:8I>K:AN8DC8:6AHI6IJIDG>ANG:FJ>G:9

9:I6>AH 67DJII=: ;JC9H 8DCIG>7JI:9ID	 6C9 :ME:C9:9 ;GDB	I=:>G HJE:G8=6G<:9 HE:8>6A
EJGEDH:

688DJCIH	I=:DBB>HH>DCVH>C68I>DC>HLG:6@>C<=6KD8DCI=:8IVH8DG:IG6CHE6G:C8NEGDK>H>DCH

6C99:EG>K>C<EA6>CI>;;HD;I=:8DBEA:I:6C9688JG6I:86BE6><C;>C6C8:>C;DGB6I>DCJEDCL=>8=

7DI=9:E:C9ID86GGNDJII=:>GB>HH>DCH

 .=: ! VH N:6GH
ADC<	 JC:MEA6>C:9 ;6>AJG:ID>C>I>6I: 6 GJA:B6@>C< DG DI=:GL>H:

8DC8AJH>K:AN G:HEDC9 ID I=: *:I>I>DC =6H CD 8DC8:>K67A: ?JHI>;>86I>DC 6C9 8A:6GAN 8DCHI>IJI:H

JCG:6HDC67A:9:A6N>CK>DA6I>DCD;I=:**A6>CI>;;HI=:G:;DG:7G>C<I=>H68I>DCEJGHJ6CIIDI=:

*ID8DBE:AI=:DBB>HH>DCIDG:HEDC9IDI=:>G*:I>I>DC




 .=>HDJGI=6H?JG>H9>8I>DCJC9:G/-P.=:G:FJ:HI:9G:A>:;>HEGDE:G

JC9:G/-PP
6C9
6C9I=:9B>C>HIG6I>K:*GD8:9JG:8I	/-PP
Q


 0:CJ:A>:H>CI=>H9>HIG>8IJC9:G/-P:

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 4 of 24
 



 *A6>CI>;; & >H 6 CDCE6GI>H6C CDCEGD;>I DG<6C>O6I>DC I=6I LDG@H ID HIG:C<I=:C

B:G>86C9:BD8G68NI=GDJ<=	(,1$/ *( 	68I>K>I>:HH::@>C<ID:CHJG:I=6II=:EJ7A>8=6H688:HHID

>C;DGB6I>DCG:<6G9>C<I=:;>C6C8>C<6C9HE:C9>C<D;/-:A:8I>DC86BE6><CH

 H E6GI D; I=>H :;;DGI	 & 8DC9J8IH G:H:6G8=	 6JI=DGH G:EDGIH 6C9 6GI>8A:H	 6C9

G:<JA6GAN EGDK>9:H :ME:GI 6C6ANH>H ID I=: B:9>6 & 6AHD A>I><6I:H I=GDJ<=DJI I=: 8DJCIGN

G:<6G9>C<86BE6><C;>C6C8:B6II:GH;>A:H! 8DBEA6>CIHG:FJ:HI>C<I=6I:C;DG8:B:CI68I>DCH7:

I6@:C 6<6>CHI >C9>K>9J6AH DG DG<6C>O6I>DCH I=6I K>DA6I: I=: A6L E6GI>8>E6I:H >C GJA:B6@>C< 6C9

69K>HDGNDE>C>DCEGD8::9>C<H7:;DG:I=:! ID:CHJG:I=:6<:C8N>HEGDE:GAN>CI:GEG:I>C<6C9

:C;DG8>C<;:9:G6A86BE6><C;>C6C8:A6LH6C9:C<6<:H>CA:<>HA6I>K:69KD868N;DGG:;DGBB:6HJG:H

6II=:;:9:G6A	HI6I:	6C9AD86AA:K:AH

 &:ME:C9H H><C>;>86CI G:HDJG8:H6HH>HI>C< G:EDGI:GH6C9 DI=:GB:B7:GH D;I=:

B:9>6>CI=:>G>CK:HI><6I>K:G:H:6G8=>CID86C9>96I:HV6C9E6GI>:HV;>C6C8>6A68I>K>I>:H	ID:CHJG:I=6I

I=: EJ7A>8 >H :FJ>EE:9 L>I= I=: >C;DGB6I>DC C:8:HH6GN ID :K6AJ6I: 9>;;:G:CI 86C9>96I:H 6C9

B:HH6<:H6C986HI>C;DGB:9KDI:H


 &6AHDJH:H>IH6C6ANH:HD;;:9:G6A86BE6><C;>C6C8:9>H8ADHJG:>C;DGB6I>DCID

HJEEDGI>IH69B>C>HIG6I>K:EG68I>8:6II=:! 6C97:;DG:HI6I:6C9AD86A86BE6><C;>C6C8:6<:C8>:H	

6C9ID9:;:C986BE6><C;>C6C8:A6LH>C>IH68I>K:9D8@:ID;86H:H>C;:9:G6A6C9HI6I:8DJGIH

 1=:C >C69:FJ6I: DG >C8DBEA:I: 9>H8ADHJG: D; ;:9:G6A 86BE6><C ;>C6C8: 68I>K>IN

B6@:H>I9>;;>8JAIIDIG68@6EDA>I>86A8DBB>II::VH;JC9G6>H>C<DGHE:C9>C<	G:EDGI:GHD;I:C8DCI68I

&;DG<J>96C8:6HIDL=:I=:GDGL=:G:I=:N86C;>C9I=:86BE6><C;>C6C8:>C;DGB6I>DCI=6I>H

CDI 7:>C< EGDE:GAN G:EDGI:9.=>HLDG@ G:FJ>G:H&ID 9>K:GI G:HDJG8:H6C9 ;JC9H ;GDB DI=:G

DG<6C>O6I>DC6AC::9H

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 5 of 24
 

 *A6>CI>;; )E:C-:8G:IH >H 6 CDCE6GI>H6C CDCEGD;>I DG<6C>O6I>DC I=6I :9J86I:H I=:

B:G>86CEJ7A>867DJIHI6I:6C9;:9:G6ABDC:NVH>C;AJ:C8:DCEDA>I>8H6C9EDA>8N6C969KD86I:H

;DG6BDG:IG6CHE6G:CI6C9688DJCI67A:<DK:GCB:CI$IHB>HH>DC>HIDIG68@I=:;ADLD;BDC:N>C

B:G>86CEDA>I>8H6C9EGDK>9:I=:96I66C96C6ANH>HIDHIG:C<I=:C9:BD8G68N.=:DG<6C>O6I>DCVH

LDG@>H6>B:96I8G:6I>C<6BDG::9J86I:9KDI:G	6C>CKDAK:98>I>O:CGN	6C96BDG:G:HEDCH>K:6C9

688DJCI67A:<DK:GCB:CI

 HI=:C6I>DCVHEG:B>:GG:H:6G8=<GDJEIG68@>C<BDC:N>C/-EDA>I>8H6C9>IH:;;:8I

DC:A:8I>DCH6C9EJ7A>8EDA>8N	)E:C-:8G:IH9:E:C9HDC>IH67>A>INIDG:8:>K:I>B:AN	688JG6I:	6C9

8DBEA:I:9>H8ADHJG:>C;DGB6I>DCJC9:G! 67DJII=:BDC:NG6>H:96C9HE:CI>C;:9:G6AEDA>I>86A

86BE6><CH

 $C E6GI>8JA6G	 688JG6I: 6C9 8DBEA:I: ! 
G:FJ>G:9 9>H8ADHJG: >C;DGB6I>DC >H

:HH:CI>6A ID )E:C-:8G:IHV EJ7A>8 :9J86I>DC	 G:H:6G8=	 6C9 >CK:HI><6I>K: G:EDGI>C< 68I>K>I>:H

)E:C-:8G:IH EJGHJ:H >IH B>HH>DC A6G<:AN I=GDJ<= >IH 6L6G9
L>CC>C< L:7H>I:	 )E:C-:8G:IHDG<	

L=>8=H::@HIDEGDK>9:6C688JG6I:	8DCH>HI:CI	6C98DBEG:=:CH>K:G:HDJG8:	;G::D;8=6G<:	;DG

I=: EG:HH	 H8=DA6GH	 69KD86I:H	 6C9 I=: EJ7A>8 67DJI BDC:N >C /- EDA>I>8H $IH EGD;:HH>DC6A

G:EDGI>C<HI6;;6C9G:H:6G8=:GHLDG@=6C9
>C
=6C9ID8DB7I=:96I6;DGE6II:GCH6C96CDB6A>:H	

L=>8=6G:H=6G:9L>I=I=:EJ7A>8I=GDJ<=)E:C-:8G:IHV9><>I6A:
C:LHA:II:G	G:EDGIH	6C996I6IDDAH

 )I=:G DG<6C>O6I>DCH 6C9 >CHI>IJI>DCH 6AHD G:AN DC I=: 688JG68N D; )E:C-:8G:IHV

86BE6><C;>C6C8:96I66C96C6ANH:H)E:C-:8G:IHVHI6;;6HH>HIC:LHDG<6C>O6I>DCHA6G<:6C9HB6AA

L>I=I=:>G86BE6><C;>C6C8:>CK:HI><6I>DCH6C9D;I:C8DAA67DG6I:L>I=DI=:GB:9>6DG<6C>O6I>DCH

ID 8G:6I: 96I6
9G>K:C ;:6IJG:H >AAJHIG6I>C< I=: GDA: D; BDC:N >C EDA>I>8H )E:C-:8G:IHV 96I6 >H

GDJI>C:AN8>I:9>CI=:C6I>DCVHBDHIEGDB>C:CIEG>CI	7GD6986HI	6C9DCA>C:C:LHDJIA:IH	6HL:AA6H

7N;:9:G6A6C9HI6I:8DJGIH	EJ7A>8EDA>8NB6@:GH	69KD86I:H	6C9H8=DA6GH

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 6 of 24
 

 DI= EA6>CI>;;H I=JH G:AN DC I=: 688JG6I: 6C9 8DBEA:I: G:EDGI>C< D; 86BE6><C

;>C6C8:>C;DGB6I>DCID86GGNDJI68I>K>I>:H8:CIG6AIDI=:>GB>HH>DCH	>C8AJ9>C<I=:EGD9J8I>DCD;

G:EDGIH6C9DI=:GB6I:G>6AHID:9J86I:I=:EJ7A>867DJI86BE6><CHE:C9>C<.=:H:68I>K>I>:H6G:

D7HIGJ8I:9L=:C>C;DGB6I>DCI=6I>HHJ7?:8IIDB6C96IDGN9>H8ADHJG:JC9:G! >HCDIEJ7A>8AN

6K6>A67A:NJCG:6HDC67AN9:A6N>C<G:HDAJI>DCD;I=:*:I>I>DC	I=:! =6H9:C>:9EA6>CI>;;H688:HH

IDHI6IJIDG>ANG:FJ>G:9>C;DGB6I>DC67DJIC6I>DC6AE6GINSGDBC>7JHT688DJCIH	6C9EA6>CI>;;HHJ;;:G

8DC8G:I:>C;DGB6I>DC6A6C9DG<6C>O6I>DC6A=6GBH6H6G:HJAI

 :;:C96CI! >H6C>C9:E:C9:CI;:9:G6A6<:C8N8=6G<:9L>I=I=:69B>C>HIG6I>DC

6C98>K>A:C;DG8:B:CID;! /-P

7






(0"),02/$ +#$-,/1(+&$.2(/$*$+10

 .G6CHE6G:C8N 67DJI I=: BDC:N G6>H:9 6C9 HE:CI >C ;:9:G6A :A:8I>DCH >H 6 8DG:

EJGEDH:D;! .=:8IVH8DBEG:=:CH>K:9>H8ADHJG:EGDK>H>DCHL:G:8G6;I:9IDS:MEDH3:4A6G<:

8DCIG>7JI>DCH6C9:ME:C9>IJG:HIDI=:A><=ID;EJ7A>8>IN	T2")*$53 *$-	/-	

E:G8JG>6B	6C9ID:C67A:6C>C;DGB:9:A:8IDG6I:7N68=>:K>C<SIDI6A9>H8ADHJG:TD;I=:6BDJCIH

6C9HDJG8:HD;;JC9HJH:9ID>C;AJ:C8:;:9:G6A:A:8I>DCH	(#6I$$ *0--,:E(D
	6I

CDI>C<I=6I! L6HSEG:9>86I:9JEDCI=:EG>C8>EA:D;EJ7A>89>H8ADHJG:T/-

P



 /C9:G! 	I=:G:;DG:	6AA;:9:G6AEDA>I>86A8DBB>II::H	>C8AJ9>C<EDA>I>86AE6GIN

8DBB>II::H	 BJHI ;>A: E:G>D9>8 G:EDGIH 688JG6I:AN 9>H8ADH>C< I=:>G G:8:>EIH	 9>H7JGH:B:CIH	 6C9

9:7IH6C9D7A><6I>DCH$$/-P

6
	7.=:H:G:EDGIHBJHI>I:B>O:	(,1$/ *( 	

:68=E:GHDCIDL=DBI=:8DBB>II::=6HB69:DE:G6I>C<:ME:C9>IJG:HDGDI=:G9>H7JGH:B:CIHD;

DK:G 

	 SID<:I=:G L>I= I=: 96I:3H4	 6BDJCI3H4	 6C9 EJGEDH:3H4T D; I=DH: :ME:C9>IJG:H DG

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 7 of 24
 

9>H7JGH:B:CIH	(#P

7		K	6C9BJHI6AHD>C8AJ9:6<<G:<6I:IDI6AH;DG6AA

G:8:>EIH	9>H7JGH:B:CIH	6C986H=
DC
=6C9;DGI=:G:EDGI>C<E:G>D96C9:A:8I>DC8N8A:ID
96I:	0$$

(#P

7


 .=: -JEG:B: DJGI =6H ADC< G:8D<C>O:9 I=6I ! VH 9:I6>A:9 9>H8ADHJG: 6C9

G:EDGI>C<G:FJ>G:B:CIHSEGDK>9:34I=::A:8IDG6I:L>I=>C;DGB6I>DCU6HIDL=:G:EDA>I>86A86BE6><C

BDC:N8DB:H;GDB6C9=DL>I>HHE:CI	VT2")*$5	/-6IFJDI>C<#,,:E(D
	

6I	6C9I=:G:7NS:C67A:34I=::A:8IDG6I:IDB6@:>C;DGB:99:8>H>DCH	T(1(6$,0,(1$#3

	/-
	



 .=:DBB>HH>DC>H8=6G<:9IDS69B>C>HI:G	H::@IDD7I6>C8DBEA>6C8:L>I=	6C9

;DGBJA6I: EDA>8N L>I= G:HE:8I ID 3I=:4 8IT  /- P

7A $C 688DG96C8: L>I= I=>H

B6C96I:	I=:8I6JI=DG>O:HI=:DBB>HH>DCIDEG:H8G>7:HJ8=G:<JA6I>DCH6H6G:C:8:HH6GNID86GGN

DJII=:HI6IJI:VHEJGEDH:H#P

6

#*(+(01/ 1(3$/,"$#2/$"1

 .=: * H:IH ;DGI= <:C:G6A GJA:H <DK:GC>C< I=: >HHJ6C8: D; EGDEDH:9 6C9 ;>C6A

G:<JA6I>DCH7N;:9:G6A6<:C8>:H/-PPQ

 $C E6GI>8JA6G	 I=: * :HI67A>H=:H I=6I S3:468= 6<:C8N H=6AA <>K: 6C >CI:G:HI:9

E:GHDCI=:G><=IIDE:I>I>DC;DGI=:>HHJ6C8:	6B:C9B:CI	DGG:E:6AD;6GJA:T/-P:$I

6AHD G:FJ>G:H I=6I	 SL>I=>C 6 G:6HDC67A: I>B:	 :68= 6<:C8N H=6AA EGD8::9 ID 8DC8AJ9: 6 B6II:G

EG:H:CI:9ID>IT#P7!>C6AAN	I=:6<:C8NBJHI<>K:S3E4GDBEICDI>8:TD;I=:S9:C>6A>C

L=DA:DG>CE6GITD;6LG>II:CE:I>I>DC	ID<:I=:GL>I=6S7G>:;HI6I:B:CID;I=:<GDJC9H;DG9:C>6AT

#P:

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 8 of 24
 

 $C688DG96C8:L>I=I=:*	I=:! =6H69DEI:9EGD8:9JG6AGJA:H9:A>C:6I>C<I=:

EGD8:HH:H<DK:GC>C<I=:HJ7B>HH>DC	8DCH>9:G6I>DC	6C99>HEDH>I>DCD;GJA:B6@>C<E:I>I>DCH;>A:9

L>I=I=:DBB>HH>DC$$!,PP

Q



 /C9:G I=:H: GJA:H	 I=: DBB>HH>DC	 JEDC G:8:>K>C< 6 K6A>9 GJA:B6@>C< E:I>I>DC

JC9:G!,P

	L>AAEJ7A>H=6(DI>8:D;K6>A67>A>IN>CI=:!:9:G6A,:<>HI:G6C9:HI67A>H=

6 EJ7A>8 8DBB:CI E:G>D9 ;DG HI6I:B:CIH >C HJEEDGI D; DG DEEDH>I>DC ID I=: E:I>I>DC $$ (#

P

6 I I=: 8ADH: D; I=: 8DBB:CI E:G>D9H 6C9 ;DAADL>C< I=: DBB>HH>DCVH

8DCH>9:G6I>DCD;I=:E:I>I>DC6C96K6>A67A:G:8DG9	SI=:DBB>HH>DC4(**#$"(#$L=:I=:GID>C>I>6I:

6 GJA:B6@>C< 76H:9 DC I=: ;>A:9 E:I>I>DCT # P

6 :BE=6H>H 699:9 $C I=: :K:CI I=:

DBB>HH>DC9:8A>C:HID>C>I>6I:6GJA:B6@>C<	S>IL>AA<>K:CDI>8:D;I=>H68I>DC7NEJ7A>H=>C<6

(DI>8:D;>HEDH>I>DC>CI=:!:9:G6A,:<>HI:G6C9H:C9>C<6A:II:GIDI=:E:I>I>DC:G	T6C9HJ8=CDI>8:

SL>AA>C8AJ9:67G>:;HI6I:B:CID;I=:<GDJC9H;DGI=:DBB>HH>DCVH9:8>H>DCT#P

7

 HEG:H8G>7:9>CI=:*6C9JC9:G>IHDLCG:<JA6I>DCH	I=:DBB>HH>DC>HD7A><:9

ID9:8>9:	L>I=>C6G:6HDC67A:I>B:	L=:I=:GID>C>I>6I:6GJA:B6@>C<>CG:HEDCH:ID6E:I>I>DCR

;6>A>C<L=>8=I=:*VH?J9>8>6AG:K>:LEGDK>H>DCH:BEDL:G6G:K>:L>C<8DJGIIDS8DBE:A6<:C8N

68I>DCJCA6L;JAANL>I==:A9DGJCG:6HDC67AN9:A6N:934T/-P


 $C9:I:GB>C>C<L=:I=:G6C6<:C8NVH9:A6N>HJCG:6HDC67A:	8DJGIH>CI=>H>G8J>I

<:C:G6AANADD@IDH:K:G6A;68IDGH	>C8AJ9>C<SI=:A:C<I=D;I>B:I=6I=6H:A6EH:9H>C8:I=:6<:C8N

86B:JC9:G69JINID68I	TSI=:8DCI:MID;I=:HI6IJI:L=>8=6JI=DG>O:HI=:6<:C8NVH68I>DC	T

 SI=: 8DCH:FJ:C8:H D; I=: 6<:C8NVH 9:A6N	T 6C9  S6CN EA:6 D; 69B>C>HIG6I>K: :GGDG	

69B>C>HIG6I>K:8DCK:C>:C8:	EG68I>86A9>;;>8JAIN>C86GGN>C<DJI6A:<>HA6I>K:B6C96I:	DGC::9ID

EG>DG>I>O:>CI=:;68:D;A>B>I:9G:HDJG8:HT-!$**3-/1-,	
!9
	
>G



Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 9 of 24
 


FJDI>C<,/$ ,17*'$+(" *-/)$/0,(-,	!9	 >G0$$ *0-

$*$"-++$0$ /"'"1(-,1/3	
!9
	
>G

 $CI=:8DCI:MID;! 9:A6N	8DJGIH=6K:6AHD8DCH>9:G:9	(,1$/ *( 	L=:I=:GI=:

6<:C8NVH ;6>AJG:ID 68I ;GJHIG6I:H 6 SEG>C8>E6A EJGEDH:34 D; ! 	T0$$ $+-"/ 1(" $, 1-/( *

 +. (&,-++3	(D 
8K


%#"	 1& 

	6I  EG>A 	

	DGJC9:GB>C:HS3E4J7A>88DC;>9:C8:>CDJG9:BD8G6I>8:A:8IDG6AHNHI:B	L=>8=I=:8IH::@H

IDEGDI:8I	T(#6I



	




*$+#*$+1001 !)(0' 1(,+ ) /146
/,*+(!207"",2+10

 $C :8:B7:G 
	 6H E6GI D; 6  IG>AA>DC DBC>7JH 6EEGDEG>6I>DCH E68@6<:	

DC<G:HH6B:C9:9! 7N8G:6I>C<I=G::C:LSH:E6G6I:	H:<G:<6I:9TEDA>I>86AE6GIN688DJCIHR

DC: ;DG EG:H>9:CI>6A CDB>C6I>C<8DCK:CI>DCH	 DC: ;DG E6GIN =:69FJ6GI:GH 7J>A9>C<H	6C9 DC: ;DG

A:<6A EGD8::9>C<H	 /- P
6R6C96AADL>C< C6I>DC6A E6GIN8DBB>II::HID688:EI

8DCIG>7JI>DCH >CID :68= D; I=:H: 688DJCIH >C 6BDJCIH JE ID 

 D; I=: DI=:GL>H: 6EEA>867A:

8DCIG>7JI>DCA>B>I/-P
6	6


 (6I>DC6A EDA>I>86A E6GI>:H L:G: I=JH ;G::9 ID G6>H: B>AA>DCH D; 9DAA6GH >CID I=:H:

688DJCIH67DK:I=:<:C:G6AAN6EEA>867A:8DCIG>7JI>DCA>B>IH'DG:DK:G	7:86JH::68=C6I>DC6AE6GIN

=6HI=G::8DBB>II::HRI=:C6I>DC6A8DBB>II::	I=:8DC<G:HH>DC6A8DBB>II::	6C9I=:H:C6IDG>6A

8DBB>II::	 :68= D; L=>8= DE:G6I:H ILD DG I=G:: HE:8>6A
EJGEDH: 688DJCIHR:68= E6GIN CDL

DE:G6I:H JEID H:K:C HE:8>6A
EJGEDH: 688DJCIH	L>I= $ "'HJ7?:8IID 6 8DCIG>7JI>DCA>B>I 



<G:6I:GI=6CI=:76H:8DCIG>7JI>DCA>B>I/-P
6		

 $CI=: 

 :A:8I>DC 8N8A:	I=:G:;DG:	 :68= C6I>DC6A E6GIN 8DBB>II:: HE:8>6A


EJGEDH:688DJCI>HHJ7?:8IID6A>B>ID;	

E:GN:6GI=G::I>B:HI=:76H:A>B>ID;	



Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 10 of 24
 

E:GN:6G	B:6C>C<6C>C9>K>9J6A86CCDL8DCIG>7JI:JEID	

E:GILD
N:6G:A:8I>DC8N8A:ID

:68=D;6E6GINVHH:K:CHE:8>6AEJGEDH:688DJCIH	DG6IDI6AD;BDG:I=6CB>AA>DCE:G:A:8I>DC

8N8A:ID6H>C<A:E6GIN

 .=:;JC9H>CI=:H:H:<G:<6I:9E6GIN688DJCIHBJHI7:G6>H:96C9HE:CI;DGHE:8>;>:9

EJGEDH:H 6C9 86CCDI 7: JH:9 ;DG 86BE6><C
G:A6I:9 :ME:C9>IJG:H 88DG9>C< ID I=: HI6IJIDGN

A6C<J6<:	 I=: 688DJCIH 6G: ID 7: JH:9 SHDA:AN ID 9:;G6N :ME:CH:H >C8JGG:9 L>I= G:HE:8I ID 6

EG:H>9:CI>6ACDB>C6I>C<8DCK:CI>DC	T/-P
6SID9:;G6N:ME:CH:H>C8JGG:9

L>I=G:HE:8IIDI=:EG:E6G6I>DC;DG6C9I=:8DC9J8ID;:A:8I>DCG:8DJCIH6C98DCI:HIH6C9DI=:GA:<6A

EGD8::9>C<H	T(#P
66C9SHDA:ANID9:;G6N:ME:CH:H>C8JGG:9L>I= G:HE:8IIDI=:

8DCHIGJ8I>DC	 EJG8=6H:	 G:CDK6I>DC	 DE:G6I>DC	 6C9 ;JGC>H=>C< D; DC: DG BDG: =:69FJ6GI:GH

7J>A9>C<H D; I=: E6GIN	T DG ID G:E6N AD6CH DG G:HIDG: ;JC9H ID 9:;G6N HJ8= :ME:CH:H	 (#

P
6

 #DL:K:G	I=:EEGDEG>6I>DCH8I9>9CDI;JGI=:G9:;>C:I=:H:EJGEDH:HDG8DCI6>C

9>H8ADHJG:G:FJ>G:B:CIHHE:8>;>8ID;JC9HHE:CIDJID;I=:C:LG:HIG>8I:9E6GIN688DJCIH

 $I L6H I=:G:;DG: >BE:G6I>K: ;DG I=: !  ID JC9:GI6@: HL>;I G:<JA6IDGN 68I>DC ID

EGDK>9: <J>96C8:IDI=: E6GI>:H	 EG:K:CI67JH:	6C9:CHJG:I=6I ;JC9H ;ADL>C<I=GDJ<=I=: C:L

HJE:G8=6G<:9E6GIN688DJCIHLDJA97:;JAANHJ7?:8IIDI=:8IVH8DG:IG6CHE6G:C8NEGDK>H>DCH

5


 ()01,/,*2)& 1$+42)$0*-)$*$+1(+&1'$*$+#*$+10

 .=:HD
86AA:9SGDBC>7JHT6B:C9B:CIHIDD@:;;:8IDC%6CJ6GN	


 $$ -,1/(!21(-,(+(10%-/		
	! 	02./ CDI:

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 11 of 24
 

 .=: ;DAADL>C< BDCI=	 I=: !  >HHJ:9 6 EG:HH G:A:6H: L>I= S>CI:G>BT G:EDGI>C<

<J>96C8:;DGC6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::HDE:G6I>C<GDBC>7JH688DJCIH	L=>8=>I9>G:8I:9E6GI>:HID

;DAADLS3J4CI>AI=:DBB>HH>DC69DEIHC:LG:<JA6I>DCHT

 .=: ! VH >HHJ6C8: D; S>CI:G>BT <J>96C8: K>6 EG:HH G:A:6H: L6H 6 8A:6G

68@CDLA:9<B:CII=6IC:LG:<JA6I>DCHL:G:C:8:HH6GN	6C96IA:6HI6C>BEA>8>I>C9>86I>DCI=6IC:L

G:<JA6I>DCHLDJA97:;DGI=8DB>C<(:K:GI=:A:HH	I=>HS>CI:G>BT<J>96C8:G:;A:8IH:HH:CI>6AANI=:

HJBIDI6AD;I=:6<:C8NVH>CI:GEG:I>K::;;DGIHID96I:	6C9>I9>9CDI:K:C699G:HHHDB:D;I=:BDHI

8DBBDCANG:EDGI:9IG6CH68I>DCH!DG:M6BEA:	I=:EG:HHG:A:6H:L6HH>A:CIDC=DLIDG:EDGII=:

>CI:GC6AIG6CH;:GD;;JC9H7:IL::C688DJCIH6C9=DLIDG:EDGI?D>CI
;JC9G6>H>C<IG6CH;:GH>CIDI=:

HE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCIH.=:<J>96C8:=6HEGDK:CL=DAAN>C69:FJ6I:6C9>C:;;:8I>K:>C86GGN>C<

DJI! VH9>H8ADHJG:EGDK>H>DCH

 .=:! =6H6AHD;6>A:9IDEGDK>9:HJ;;>8>:CI<J>96C8:ID>IHDLC6C6ANHIHDC=DL

ID G:K>:L I=: C6I>DC6A E6GIN 8DBB>II::HV G:EDGIH ;DG 9>H8ADHJG: ;6>AJG:H >CKDAK>C< I=: HE:8>6A


EJGEDH: 688DJCIH .=: DBB>HH>DCVH ,:EDGIH C6ANH>H >K>H>DC ,:K>:L 6C9 ,:;:GG6A

*GD8:9JG:HRI=: <J>9:A>C:H DBB>HH>DC HI6;; JH: ID >9:CI>;N G:EDGI>C< EGD7A:BH	 G:FJ:HI I=6I

8DBB>II::H8DGG:8IG:EDGI>C<:GGDGH;DGI=:7:C:;>ID;I=:EJ7A>8G:8DG9	6C9G:8DBB:C98DGG:8I>K:

6J9>IHR9DCDI:K:CB:CI>DCI=:HE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCIH

.=:G:;DG:	>I>HCDI8A:6GI=6II=:! 

>H :K:C G:FJ>G>C< I=: E6GIN 8DBB>II::H ID 67>9: 7N I=: H86CI <J>96C8: >I =6H >HHJ:9	 ;JGI=:G

;GJHIG6I>C<! VHIG6CHE6G:C8NEJGEDH:

 *G:HH,:A:6H:	 ! 	 !  $HHJ:H $CI:G>B,:EDGI>C< "J>96C8: ;DG (6I>DC6A *6GINDBB>II::

88DJCIH !:7 	 
	 =IIEHLLL;:8<DKJE96I:H;:8
>HHJ:H
>CI:G>B
G:EDGI>C<
<J>96C8:


;DG
C6I>DC6A
E6GIN
688DJCIH  $$ ! 	 ,:EDGIH C6ANH>H >K>H>DC ,:K>:L 6C9 ,:;:GG6A *GD8:9JG:H ;DG I=: 




 A:8I>DC N8A:	 =IIEHLLL;:8<DKG:HDJG8:H8BH
8DCI:CI9D8JB:CIH!>C6A
,:968I:9






,
,:K>:L
,:;:GG6A
*GD8:9JG:HE9;

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 12 of 24
 

 $CI=:C:6GANC>C:N:6GHH>C8:I=:6B:C9B:CIHL:G::C68I:9	I=:DBB>HH>DC=6H

;6>A:9IDEGDBJA<6I:6CNGJA:H9:A>C:6I>C<I=:A>B>I6I>DCH6C99>H8ADHJG:G:FJ>G:B:CIH6EEA>867A:

ID E6GIN HE:8>6A
EJGEDH: 688DJCIH $C9::9	 I=: 6<:C8N =6H CDI :K:C DE:C:9 6 GJA:B6@>C< ID

>BEA:B:CII=:H:H><C>;>86CI8=6C<:HIDI=:8I	6AI=DJ<=>I=6HG:E:6I:9AN7::C6H@:9ID9DHDR

7N L6I8=9D< DG<6C>O6I>DCH 6C9 B:B7:GH D; I=: G:<JA6I:9 8DBBJC>IN 6A>@:	 6H L:AA 6H 7N I=:

6<:C8NVHDLCA6LN:GH


 !DG>IHE6GI	EA6>CI>;;&;>GHIEG:HH:9;DGG:<JA6IDGN68I>DC>C8DBB:CIHHJ7B>II:9

DC%6CJ6GN	
R?JHIL::@H6;I:GI=:GDBC>7JH6B:C9B:CIHL:G:69DEI:9R>CG:HEDCH:ID

6C9K6C8:(DI>8:D;*GDEDH:9,JA:B6@>C<S(*,'TG:<6G9>C<I=:-JEG:B:DJGIVH9:8>H>DC

>C"21"'$-,3	/-
1=>A:EG>B6G>AN;D8JH:9DC6G6C<:D;DI=:G>HHJ:H

8G:6I:9 >C I=: L6@: D; I=6I GJA>C<	 &VH %6CJ6GN 
 8DBB:CIH	 L=>8= L:G: ?D>C:9 7N

:BD8G68N	6AHDJG<:9S3.4DEG:K:CI67JH:D;I=:H:C:LG:HIG>8I:9
JH:;JC9H	I=:DBB>HH>DC

H=DJA9EGDBJA<6I:G:<JA6I>DCHHE:8>;N>C<6C9A>B>I>C<I=:E:GB>HH>7A:JH:HD;I=:H:C:L;JC9H	

EGD=>7>I>C<IG6CH;:GD;I=:H: ;JC9H7:IL::CE6GIN688DJCIH	6C9 G:FJ>G>C<9:I6>A:99>H8ADHJG:D;

I=:H:;JC9HT	

 .:CBDCI=HA6I:G	>C)8ID7:G
	I=:DBB>HH>DC7:<6CCDB>C6AAN8DCH>9:G>C<

6GJA:B6@>C<	6;I:GI=:! );;>8:D;":C:G6ADJCH:AG:8DBB:C9:9I=6II=:DBB>HH>DCEJ7A>H=

6(DI>8:D;*GDEDH:9,JA:B6@>C<S(*,'TID>BEA:B:CII=:EEGDEG>6I>DCH8I6C9EG:E6G:9

6CS)JIA>C:D;G6;I(*,'TI=6ILDJA97:<>CI=:EGD8:HHIDHI6GI6 GJA:B6@>C<
.LDBDCI=H

	 DBB:CIHD;6BE6><C&:<6A:CI:G6C9:BD8G68NG:, "


 6GB6G@>C<	%D>CI

!JC9G6>H>C<	 >H8ADHJG: 6C9 )I=:G $HHJ:H "21"'$-,	 6I  %6C 	 
	

=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9 
 $$ !  <:C96 D8 

 )8I 	 
	 =IIEHLLL;:8<DKG:HDJG8:HJE96I:H

6<:C96H
BI<9D85

7E9;

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 13 of 24
 

A6I:G	>C:8:B7:G 
	I=:DBB>HH>DC 9>H8JHH:9I=: 9G6;I DJIA>C:6I6B::I>C< 7JIIDD@ CD

68I>DC

 $C'6N
	;DAADL>C<H:K:G6ABDG:BDCI=HD;>C68I>DC	&6C9:BD8G68N

G:C:L:9I=:>G8DC8:GCH67DJII=:C::9;DG6GJA:B6@>C<>C6A:II:GIDI=:DBB>HH>DCHI=:A:II:G

CDI:9	 H:K:CI::C BDCI=H =69 7N I=:C 6AG:69N :A6EH:9 H>C8: I=: :C68IB:CI D; I=: GDBC>7JH

EGDK>H>DCH	7JII=:DBB>HH>DC=69S;6>A:9ID69DEIG:<JA6I>DCHID69B>C>HI:G3I=:B4.=:G:>H

CD:M8JH:;DGI=>H;6>AJG:T

 ':6CL=>A:	:K:CI=:G:<JA6I:98DBBJC>INL6HJG<>C<I=:! ID68I)C%6CJ6GN

	 
	 I=: *:G@>CH D>: &&* *DA>I>86A &6L "GDJE ;>A:9 6 E:I>I>DC G:FJ:HI>C< I=6I I=:

DBB>HH>DCDE:C6GJA:B6@>C<ID699G:HHI=:EEGDEG>6I>DCH8I6B:C9B:CIH	7DI=7N69DEI>C<

C:LGJA:H6C9G:K>H>C<G:A:K6CIEG:
:M>HI>C<GJA:H

 .=:*:G@>CHD>: E:I>I>DC	L=>8= <:C:G6AAN 9:I6>A:9I=: C::9 ;DG8DBEG:=:CH>K:

C:LGJA:H<DK:GC>C<I=:DE:G6I>DCD;E6GINGDBC>7JH688DJCIH	6AHDHE:8>;>86AANJG<:9I=:! 

ID6B:C9>IH9>H8ADHJG:GJA:HSIDG:;A:8II=:EG>C8>EA:I=6II=:C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::BJHIG:EDGI

8DCIG>7JI>DCHID6C9:ME:C9>IJG:H;GDBI=:>GH:E6G6I:688DJCIHDCI=:>GG:<JA6GG:EDGIHT

 AI=DJ<=I=:*:G@>CHD>:E:I>I>DCL6HHJ7B>II:9>C%6CJ6GN
	I=:DBB>HH>DC

L6>I:9 6ABDHI I:C BDCI=H ID I6@: I=: B6C96IDGN B>C>HI:G>6A HI:E D; EJ7A>H=>C< 6 (DI>8: D;

$$ $&	 !  <:C96 D8 


	 6I 
	  :8 	 
	 =IIEHLLL;:8<DK

G:HDJG8:HJE96I:H6<:C96H
BI<9D85


6E9; &:II:G;GDB6BE6><C&:<6A:CI:G6C9:BD8G68NIDDBB>HH>DC:GH	6I
96I:9'6N

	
	=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9
 .=: E:I>I>DC	 I=DJ<= CDI HJ7B>II:9 DC 7:=6A; D; 6CN I=:C
8A>:CI D; *:G@>CH D>:	 L6H

8=6G68I:G>O:96HG:;A:8I>C<I=:E:GHE:8I>K:D;EG68I>I>DC:GHL=DG:EG:H:CIE6GI>:HG:<JA6I:97NI=:

! 

$$'6G8 G>@ A>6H6C9*:G@>CHD>:&&**DA>I>86A&6L"GDJE	*:I>I>DC;DG,JA:B6@>C<G:

, " 


 96I:9 %6C 	 
	 =IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9

8DBB:C8>C<9D8JB:CI6I



#6I

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 14 of 24
 

K6>A67>A>IN>CI=:!:9:G6A,:<>HI:G6C9:HI67A>H=>C<6E:G>D9;DGEJ7A>88DBB:CI	L=>8=>I;>C6AAN

9>9>C)8ID7:G 
$$ !, P

6! 	(DI>8: 


,JA:B6@>C<*:I>I>DC

$BEA:B:CI>C<I=:DCHDA>96I:96C9!JGI=:GDCI>CJ>C<EEGDEG>6I>DCH8I	
	!:9,:<

	
)8I	


 $C%6CJ6GN
	>CG:HEDCH:IDI=:(DI>8:D;K6>A67>A>IN	&6C9:BD8G68N

6<6>C HJ7B>II:9 8DBB:CIH JG<>C< I=: DBB>HH>DC ID 68I &VH %6CJ6GN 
 8DBB:CIH

9:I6>A:9	DC8:6<6>C	L=N6 GJA:B6@>C<L6HHDG:ANC::9:9	6C9 G:FJ:HI:9I=6II=:DBB>HH>DC

SEGDBJA<6I: G:<JA6I>DCH HE:8>;N>C< 6C9 A>B>I>C< I=: E:GB>HH>7A: JH:H D; I=:H: C:L ;JC9H	

EGD=>7>I>C<IG6CH;:GD;I=:H: ;JC9H7:IL::CE6GIN688DJCIH	6C9 G:FJ>G>C<9:I6>A:99>H8ADHJG:D;

I=:H:;JC9HT$CE6GI>8JA6G	I=:8DBB:CIHHIG:HH:9I=6IS>I>HK>I6AID:CHJG:I=:G:>H:;;:8I>K:6C9

HE:8>;>89>H8ADHJG:	7N688DJCI	D;6AABDC:NHE:CI;GDBI=:I=G::G:HIG>8I:9688DJCIH8G:6I:97N

I=:)BC>7JH8IT

 .=:DBB>HH>DC6AHDG:8:>K:9EJ7A>88DBB:CIHDCI=:
GJA:B6@>C<E:I>I>DC

;GDB I=: ,:EJ7A>86C (6I>DC6A DBB>II:: S,(T		 I=: (6I>DC6A ,:EJ7A>86C -:C6IDG>6A

DBB>II:: S(,-T 6C9 (6I>DC6A ,:EJ7A>86C DC<G:HH>DC6A DBB>II:: S(,T	

8DBB:CI>C< ?D>CIAN	 6C9 I=: :CI:G ;DG DBE:I>I>K: *DA>I>8H 1=>A: I=: ,:EJ7A>86C

$$DBB:CIHD;6BE6><C&:<6A:CI:G6C9:BD8G68NDC(DI>8:


	,JA:B6@>C<

*:I>I>DCG:, "


96I:9%6C
	
	=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9

 #6I

#6I

	$$DBB:CIHD;,(DC,JA:B6@>C<*:I>I>DCG:, "


96I:9%6C
	
	=IIEH

H:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9
 $$DBB:CIHD;(,-6C9(,G:(DI>8:


96I:9%6C
	
	=IIEHH:GH;:8

<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9 $$DBB:CIH D;:CI:G ;DGDBE:I>I>K:*DA>I>8H G:(DI>8: 


96I:9 %6C 
	 
	

=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 15 of 24
 

8DC<G:HH>DC6A8DBB>II::HDE>C:9I=6I6GJA:B6@>C<L6HJCC:8:HH6GN	I=:DI=:GEJ7A>88DBB:CI:GH

L:G:7GD69ANHJEEDGI>K:D;I=:E:I>I>DCDGC:JIG6A

 .=:EJ7A>88DBB:CIE:G>D9DCI=:*:G@>CHD>:E:I>I>DC8ADH:9>C%6CJ6GN
	

7JII=:DBB>HH>DC9>9CDIEGDBJA<6I:6CN GJA:H	>C>I>6I:6 GJA:B6@>C<	DGDI=:GL>H:I6@:6CN

68I>DC>CG:HEDCH:IDI=:E:I>I>DCDGHJEEDGI>C<8DBB:CIH

) (+1(%%08$1(1(,+1,/,*2)& 1$2)$0%,/$-,/1(+&,%6
/,*+(!207"",2+10

 N J<JHI 
	 BDG: I=6C ILD N:6GH =69 :A6EH:9 H>C8: I=: 8ADH: D; EJ7A>8

8DBB:CIHDCI=:*:G@>CHD>:E:I>I>DC	6C9HI>AAI=:DBB>HH>DC=69CDI>C>I>6I:96GJA:B6@>C<

G:A6I:9 ID GDBC>7JH 688DJCIH 88DG9>C<AN	 DC J<JHI 	 
	 & 6C9 I=: :CI:G ;DG

,:HEDCH>K:*DA>I>8HCDL)E:C-:8G:IHHJ7B>II:9I=:>G*:I>I>DCID*GDBJA<6I:,JA:H;DG,:EDGI>C<

D;SGDBC>7JHT88DJCIHL>I=I=:! EJGHJ6CIID!,P

6C9/-P:


 1=>A: G:8D<C>O>C<I=:G:L6H 6 8DCI>CJ>C< C::9 ;DG G:<JA6I>DCHID>BEA:B:CI 6AA

6HE:8IHD;I=:GDBC>7JH6B:C9B:CIH	I=:*:I>I>DC;D8JH:9DC?JHIDC:H:G>DJHEGD7A:B8G:6I:9>C

I=: A:<>HA6I>DCVH L6@:RC6B:AN	 I=: 9>H8ADHJG: 6C9 G:EDGI>C< >HHJ:H 6HHD8>6I:9 L>I= HE:8>6A


EJGEDH:688DJCIH

 )C )8ID7:G 	 
	 EA6>CI>;;H HJ7B>II:9 8DBB:CIH L>I= I=: !  >C ;JGI=:G

HJEEDGID;I=:*:I>I>DC	EGDK>9>C<699>I>DC6A:M6BEA:HD;I=:9>H8ADHJG:8DC8:GCH>I9:H8G>7:9&

I=:G:6;I:G;DAADL:9JE6<6>C7NA:II:GIDG:>I:G6I:I=:>BEDGI6C8:D;I=:E:C9>C<*:I>I>DC

 HCDI:9>CI=:*:I>I>DC	I=:! VH8DCI>CJ>C<;6>AJG:IDEGDBJA<6I:9>H8ADHJG:GJA:H

;DGGDBC>7JH688DJCIH=6H;DHI:G:9>GG:<JA6G6C9LD:;JAAN>CHJ;;>8>:CIG:EDGI>C<EG68I>8:HI=6I

K>I>6I:I=:EJ7A>8VHHI6IJIDGN>C;DGB6I>DC6AG><=IID@CDLL=D>H8DCIG>7JI>C<IDI=:H:688DJCIH	6C9

$$DBB:CIH	02./ CDI:&:II:G	02./ CDI:	6I

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 16 of 24
 

>C L=6I 6BDJCIH =DLI=:BDC:N>C :68= 688DJCI>H 7:>C< HE:CI 6C9 =DLBJ8=BDC:N :68=

688DJCI>H86GGN>C<DK:G;GDBDC:G:EDGI>C<E:G>D9IDI=:C:MI

 $CE6GI>8JA6G	! G:FJ>G:H:K:GNEDA>I>86A8DBB>II::ID;>A:E:G>D9>8G:EDGIHI=6I

>C8AJ9:I=: 8DBB>II::VHIDI6A G:8:>EIH	IDI6A 9>H7JGH:B:CIH	 6C9 86H=
DC
=6C9 ;DGI=: G:EDGI>C<

E:G>D9 6C9 :A:8I>DC 8N8A: ID
96I: $$  /- P

7 .=: C6I>DC6A E6GIN 8DBB>II::H	

=DL:K:G	G:EDGICDC:D;I=:H:;><JG:H;DGI=:>GHE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCIH

 .=:G:;DG:	>;6B:B7:GD;I=:EJ7A>8L6CIHID<:I>C;DGB6I>DC67DJIIDI6AG:8:>EIH	

9>H7JGH:B:CIH	6C986H=
DC
=6C9;DG6C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::VHHE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCI	I=:N

C::9IDH:6G8=I=:8DBB>II::VHBDCI=ANG:EDGIHRL=>8=6G:INE>86AANI=DJH6C9HD;E6<:HADC<R

6C98DBE>A::68=IG6CH68I>DCI=6IG:;:GHIDI=:688DJCI

 JI :K:C I=>H 6G9JDJH I6H@ >H B69: :;;:8I>K:AN >BEDHH>7A: 7:86JH: I=:G: >H CD

8DCH>HI:CI AD86I>DC DG I:GB>CDAD<N I=6I 8DBB>II::H JH: ID 9:CDI: IG6CH68I>DCH >CKDAK>C< I=:

HE:8>6A
EJGEDH: 688DJCIH $C I=: 67H:C8: D; 8A:6G GJA:H 9:A>C:6I>C< I=:>G G:EDGI>C< D7A><6I>DCH	

8DBB>II::H>CHI:69JH:6B>MD;I=:B:BD	EJGEDH:	6C9SG:8:>EI;DGTS9>H7JGH:B:CI;DGTH:8I>DCH

D;I=:6EEA>867A:! -8=:9JA:6C98DBB>II::;DGBHID>C9>86I:HJ8=IG6CH68I>DCHC9I=:>G

I:GB>CDAD<N6AHDK6G>:HHDH><C>;>86CIAN6HID9:;:6I:;;DGIHID6JIDB6I:I=:96I6
8DAA:8I>DCEGD8:HH

DBEDJC9>C< I=:H: EGD7A:BH	 HDB: 8DBB>II::H :K:C JH: >CI:GC6AAN >C8DCH>HI:CI I:GB>CDAD<N

L>I=>C6H>C<A:G:EDGI

 !DG:M6BEA:	HDB:8DBB>II::H G:;:GIDI=:E6GIN=:69FJ6GI:GH688DJCIJH>C<I=:

CDI:S=F	TL=>A:DI=:GHJH:S=:69FJ6GI:GHTHDB:6AI:GC6I:7:IL::C9>;;:G:CII:GBH68GDHH6C9DG

$$$&	*:I>I>DC6I8>I>C<,(	
%JC:'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I			;>A:9

%JC: 
	 
	 =IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;











E9; (,-	 >H7JGH:B:CIH ID &:M>H
(:M>H ;GDB S#:69FJ6GI:GH 88IT 

	 ! 	

=IIEHLLL;:8<DK96I69>H7JGH:B:CIH96I65INE:EGD8:HH:98DBB>II::5>9


G:8

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 17 of 24
 

4(1'(, G:EDGIH6C9 HDB::BEADN9>;;:G:CII:GB>CDAD<>:H6C9 ;DGB6IHL=:C G:EDGI>C< G:8:>EIH

K:GHJH9>H7JGH:B:CIHRHJ8=6H7NJH>C<I=:9>H7JGH:B:CIEJGEDH:A>C:ID9:CDI:S=F688DJCIQ

HJ7H8G>EI>DCH	TL>I=CD688DBE6CN>C<B:BDI:MI	7JIJH>C<6B:BDI:MI:CIGNID9:CDI:L=:C

8DCIG>7JI>DCH6G:9:EDH>I:9>CI=:SA:<6AEGD8::9>C<H688DJCITDGS=:69FJ6GI:GH688DJCIT

 *A6>CI>;;HCDI:9CJB:GDJH>AAJHIG6I>K::M6BEA:HD;HJ8=G:EDGI>C<>C8DCH>HI:C8>:H	

7DI=>CI=:*:I>I>DC>IH:A;6C9>CHJEEDGI>C<8DBB:CIHI=6II=:N;>A:9>C)8ID7:G
	>C8AJ9>C<

6 $C >IH '6N 
 BDCI=AN ;>A>C<	 I=: ( JH:9 S=F 688DJCIT 6C9

S=:69FJ6GI:GH688DJC<TDCI=:H6B:E6<:

7 .=:(,-9:H8G>7:99>H7JGH:B:CIH;GDBI=:A:<6AEGD8::9>C<H688DJCI7N

CDI>C< S&:<6A *GD8T >C I=: EJGEDH: A>C: ;DG :M6BEA:	 S&:<6A *GD8 Q

IIDGC:NH!::HT	L=:G:6HI=:(,9:H8G>7:99>H7JGH:B:CIH;GDB7DI=

6 S& "& .	T 6C9 6 S, )/(.T 688DJCI		 9:HE>I: 7DI=

6EE6G:CIAN G:;:G:C8>C< I=: H6B: 688DJCI .=: :BD8G6I>8 -:C6IDG>6A

>E>:CI5C6B:A:M>HC:M>HILD5N:6G5IG6CH68I>DC5E:G>D9
B>C596I:
!
!


B6M596I:!!
A6HIK>H>I:9)8I
	
(,	>H7JGH:B:CIHID&:M>H(:M>H

;GDBS#+88IT

	! 	=IIEHLLL;:8<DK96I69>H7JGH:B:CIH96I65INE:EGD8:HH:9

8DBB>II::5>9



G:8>E>:CI5C6B:A:M>HC:M>HILD5N:6G5IG6CH68I>DC5E:G>D9


9>H7JGH:B:CI59:H8G>EI>DC#+A6HIK>H>I:9)8I
	


$$$&	*:I>I>DC6I
8>I>C<(,-	
%JC:'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I			

;>A:9

%JC: 
	 
	 =IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;











E9;(,	
%JC:'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I	
		;>A:9%JC:
	
	=IIEH9D8

FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;













E9; :BD8G6I>8 (6I>DC6A

DBB>II::S(T	
'6N'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I	;>A:9'6N
	
	=IIEH

9D8FJ:GN;:8<DK8<>
7>C;:8>B<






$$$&	*:I>I>DC6I8>I>C<(,-	>H7JGH:B:CIHID&:M>H
(:M>H;GDBS#:69FJ6GI:GH88IT



	02./ CDI:(,	>H7JGH:B:CIHID&:M>H(:M>H;GDBS#+88I	T

	02./ 

CDI:(,-	
%JC:'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	

(,	
%JC:'DCI=AN	02./ 

CDI:	6I	$$ *0-(,-	
%JC:'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	
(,	


%JC:'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	

*:I>I>DC6I8>I>C<(	
'6N'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	

$$DBB:CIH 6I 8>I>C<(,-	
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I	
 ;>A:9

-:EI
	
	=IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DK8<>
7>C;:8>B<




$$DBB:CIH6I 8>I>C<(,	
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I	 ;>A:9

-:EI 
	 
	 =IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;







E9;

	$$DBB:CIH6I8>I>C<(,	
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 18 of 24
 

6BE6><CDBB>II::S-T6AHDG:EDGI:99>H7JGH:B:CIH;GDB7DI=6

SA:<6AH:GK>8:HT6C96SA:<6AH:GK>8:HG:8DJCIT688DJCI


8 .=:(,-G:EDGI:9"-,1/(!21(-,0IDI=:=:69FJ6GI:GH688DJCIL>I=6B:BD

>I:B I=6I H6>9 S# +/,. ,- )/(.	T 7JI I=:C G:EDGI:9

#(0!2/0$+$,10 ;GDBI=6I H6B:688DJCI>C6C:CI>G:AN 9>;;:G:CI ;DGB6I	 7N

LG>I>C<S#+.T>CI=:S*JGEDH:D;>H7JGH:B:CITA>C:6C9A:6K>C<I=:

B:BD>I:B7A6C@

9 .=: (VH 8DCK:CI>DCH ;DG G:EDGI>C< 9>H7JGH:B:CIH 6EE:6G ID =6K:

8=6C<:9 DK:G I>B: $C >IH BDG: G:8:CI G:EDGIH	 I=: ( G:EDGI:9

9>H7JGH:B:CIH>CI=:;DGB6ID;S=:69FJ6GI:GH688DJCIT>CI=:EJGEDH:A>C:	

L>I=CD688DBE6CN>C<B:BDI:MI	L=:G:>I=69EG:K>DJHANG:EDGI:9HJ8=

9>H7JGH:B:CIH7NLG>I>C<SA:<6A688DJCIT>CI=:B:BDI:MI6C9EGDK>9>C<

9:H8G>EI>DCH$&	S").086CK6HH>C<T>CI=:EJGEDH:A>C:

: $CI=:>G %JC: 
BDCI=AN ;>A>C<H	I=: (,- 6C9 (, JH:9I=:I:GB

S=:69FJ6GI:GH 688DJCIT >C DC: E6GI D; I=: G:EDGI	 7JI S=F 688DJCI Q

B6>CI:C6C8:T6C9S=F688IQ8DBEJI:GHJEEDGI	TG:HE:8I>K:AN	>C6CDI=:G

 .D G:B:9N I=:H: IG6CHE6G:C8N EGD7A:BH	 I=: *:I>I>DC G:FJ:HI:9 I=6I I=: ! 

EGDBJA<6I:GJA:H6C9;DGBHG:FJ>G>C<C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::HID9:A>C:6I:L>I=>CI=:>GG:EDGIH

I=:>C9>K>9J6A 6C9 6<<G:<6I:IG6CH68I>DCH>CKDAK>C<I=:>G GDBC>7JH 688DJCIH *:I>I>DC:GH 6AHD

EGDK>9:9H:K:G6AHE:8>;>8EDHH>7A:HDAJI>DCH	CDI>C<I=6II=:DBB>HH>DC8DJA9EGDBJA<6I:6C:L

H8=:9JA:IDI=:C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::HVBDCI=ANG:EDGIHJC9:G/-P
68G:6I:


$$DBB:CIH6I 8>I>C<-	>H7JGH:B:CIH;DGS&:<6A	T


Q


	! 	

=IIEHLLL;:8<DK96I69>H7JGH:B:CIHILD5N:6G5IG6CH68I>DC5E:G>D9

9>H7JGH:B:CI59

:H8G>EI>DCA:<6A96I65INE:EGD8:HH:98DBB>II::5>9


B>C596I:
!
!


B6M596I:
!
!
9>H7JGH:B:CI59:H8G>EI>DCA:<6A A6HI K>H>I:9 )8I 
	




$$DBB:CIH6I8>I>C<(,-	
)8ID7:G'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I	;>A:9)8I


	
	=IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;





E9;

$$DBB:CIH6I 8>I>C<(,-	
)8ID7:G'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:
	6I	

$$*:I>I>DC6I8>I>C<(	
%JC:'DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I	
;>A:9%JC:	
	

=IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;





E9; (	 


'6G8='DCI=AN	! !DGB2	6I	
;>A:9'6G
	
	=IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;











E9;

$$*:I>I>DC 6I
8>I>C<(,-	
%JC:'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I			

(,	


%JC:'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	
		

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 19 of 24
 


6C :;;:8I>K: S8GDHH
>C9:M>C< HNHI:BT JC9:G  /- P
6 DG >HHJ: <J>9:A>C:H DC

JC>;DGBI:GB>CDAD<N;DG6AA8DBB>II::HIDJH:JC9:G/-P
6$$*:I>I>DC6I

 )CJ<JHI	
	I=:DBB>HH>DCEJ7A>H=:96(DI>8:D;K6>A67>A>ING:FJ:HI>C<

8DBB:CIHDCI=:*:I>I>DC.=:8DBB:CIE:G>D98ADH:9DC)8ID7:G	
R%-2/5$ /0 &-


 JG>C<I=:EJ7A>88DBB:CIE:G>D9	;>K:>C9>K>9J6AH6C9:CI>I>:H7:H>9:H&6C9

I=::CI:G;DG,:HEDCH>K:*DA>I>8HHJ7B>II:98DBB:CIH	>C8AJ9>C<*J7A>8>I>O:C	:BD8G68N

	6C9*:G@>CHD>:&&**DA>I>86A&6L"GDJE)CANDC:8DBB:CI:G	6C>C9>K>9J6A	6EE:6G:9

IDDEEDH:I=:>C>I>6I>DCD;6 GJA:B6@>C<*:G@>CHD>:	=DL:K:G	DE>C:9I=6II=:DBB>HH>DC

H=DJA9:C<6<:>C68DBEG:=:CH>K:GJA:B6@>C<8DCH>HI:CIL>I=>IHDLC
E:I>I>DCG6I=:GI=6C

I=:C6GGDL:G9>H8ADHJG:GJA:B6@>C<JG<:9>CEA6>CI>;;HV*:I>I>DC	HIG:HH>C<I=:C::9S;DGI=:! ID

>HHJ:;JAA<J>96C8:DC6AA6G:6HD;I=:A6LDCI=:C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::HVH:<G:<6I:9688DJCIHT	

 $CI=:C:6GAN;DJGN:6GHH>C8:I=:8ADH:D;I=:8DBB:CIE:G>D9DC)8ID7:G	
	

I=:DBB>HH>DC=6HCDI>C>I>6I:96GJA:B6@>C<	8DC8AJH>K:ANG:HEDC9:9ID	DGDI=:GL>H:I6@:C6CN

68I>DCDCI=:*:I>I>DC

 ':6CL=>A:	 B>AA>DCH D; 9DAA6GH 6G: ;ADL>C< I=GDJ<= I=: E6GI>:HV GDBC>7JH

688DJCIH	6C9I=:EJ7A>8=6H6HI6IJIDGNG><=IIDI=:8DGG:HEDC9>C<;>C6C8>6A>C;DGB6I>DC$$

/-P

#DL:K:G	I=6C@HIDI=:DBB>HH>DCVH;6>AJG:IDEGDBJA<6I:6CN9>H8ADHJG:GJA:H

$$DBB:CIHD;*J7A>8>I>O:CG:, "


)8I	
	=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH

=DLE9;=IB9D8>9
 $$DBB:CIHD;:BD8G68NG:, "


,JA:B6@>C<*:I>I>DCID,:FJ>G:,:EDGI>C<

D; -:<G:<6I:9 *6GIN 88DJCIH )8I 	 
	 =IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9


 $$DBB:CIHD;*:G@>CHD>:&&**DA>I>86A&6L"GDJEG:, "


(DI>8:D;*GDEDH:9

,JA:B6@>C<)8I	
	=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GHH=DLE9;=IB9D8>9
 $$DBB:CIHD;6K>9#>B:HG:, "


J<
	
	=IIEHH:GH;:8<DK;DH:GH

H=DLE9;=IB9D8>9
 	$$*:G@>CHD>:
DBB:CIH	02./ CDI:	 6I

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 20 of 24
 

<DK:GC>C<I=:H:688DJCIH	C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::H6G:8DCI>CJ>C<ID9>H8ADH:I=:>GG:8:>EIH6C9

9>H7JGH:B:CIH>CCDC
JC>;DGB6C9B6C>;:HIAN9:;>8>:CIL6NH	:;;:8I>K:AN8DC8:6A>C<>C;DGB6I>DC

;GDBI=:<:C:G6AEJ7A>8

 .=:H>IJ6I>DC=6HCDI>BEGDK:9H>C8:EA6>CI>;;H;>A:9I=:>G)8ID7:G
HJEEDGI>C<

8DBB:CI.=:C6I>DC6AE6GIN8DBB>II::H=6K:8DCI>CJ:9IDG:EDGII=:>GHE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCI

G:8:>EIH6C99>H7JGH:B:CIH>CK6G>:96C9=6E=6O6G9L6NH

6 ABDHI:K:GNE6GIN8DBB>II::G:EDGIH8DCIG>7JI>DCHIDI=:>GHE:8>6A
EJGEDH:

688DJCIH 9>;;:G:CIAN !DG :M6BEA:	 I=: :BD8G6I>8 DC<G:HH>DC6A

6BE6><C DBB>II:: ST JH:H I=: I:GBH S=:69FJ6GI:GH7J>A9>C<

;JC9 8DCIG>7JI>DCT 6C9 SG:8DJCIA:<6A ;JC9 8DCIG>7JI>DC	T
 L=:G:6H I=:

(, JH:H I=: E=G6H:H S8DCIG>7JI>DC =:69FJ6GI:GH 688DJCIT 6C9

S8DCIG>7JI>DC A:<6A EGD8::9>C<H 688DJCIT )C IDE D; I=:H: I:GB>CDAD<N

9>;;:G:C8:H	 HDB: 8DBB>II::H	 A>@: I=: ,(	 LG>I: I=: HE:8>6A
688DJCI

9:H><C6I>DCH6HB:BD>I:BHHDB:	A>@:I=:-	LG>I:I=:9:H><C6I>DCH

>CI=:HE68:G:H:GK:9;DG>C9>86I>C<I=::A:8I>DCIDL=>8=I=:8DCIG>7JI>DC

L>AA7:6EEA>:96C9I=:JH:H7DI=HE68:H

7 .=: HINA>HI>8 9>;;:G:C8:H 8DCI>CJ: ;DG G:EDGI>C< 9>H7JGH:B:CIH >;;:G:CI

E6GIN8DBB>II::HJH:9>;;:G:CII:GBH!DG:M6BEA:	I=:(,-EG:;68:H>IH

SEJGEDH: D; 9>H7JGH:B:CIT :CIG>:H L>I= SA:<6A EGD8T DG S#+ 688DJCI	T

L=>A:I=: EG:;68:H>IH EJGEDH: 9:H8G>EI>DCHL>I= SG:8DJCI	T SA:<6A

EGD8::9>C<H	T DG S=:69FJ6GI:GHT (DI :K:GN 8DBB>II:: :K:C JH:H I=:

SEJGEDH:D;9>H7JGH:B:CITA>C:;DG>IH688DJCI9:H><C6I>DCHI=:,(LG>I:H

I=:688DJCI9:H><C6I>DCH6HB:BD:CIG>:H


	 
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	!DGB 2	6I 	
 ;>A:9-:EI 
	 
	=IIEH9D8

FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;







E9; (,	 
 -:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	 !DGB 2	 6I 	
 ;>A:9 -:EI 
	 
	 =IIEH9D8

FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;







E9; ,(	
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	!DGB2	6I	
;>A:9-:EI
	
	=IIEH9D8FJ:GN

;:8<DKE9;





E9; -	 
 -:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	 !DGB 2	 6I 	
 ;>A:9 -:EI 
	 
	=IIEH9D8

FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;





E9; 
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	


(,-	
B:C9:9*G:
":C:G6A	!DGB2	6I			
;>A:9EG	
	=IIEH

9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;






E9; 	 
 B:C9:9 '6N 'DCI=AN	 !DGB 2 6I 		 	


 ;>A:9 '6G 	 
	

=IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8<DKE9;



E9; ,(
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	

		

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 21 of 24
 

8 .=: E6GIN 8DBB>II::H 6AHD =6K: 9>;;:G:CI I:GBH ;DG G:EDGI>C< IG6CH;:GH

7:IL::CI=:>G<:C:G6A688DJCIH6C9HE:8>6A
EJGEDH:688DJCIH.=:(,-

86AAHI=:H:S>CI:GC6AIG6CH;:GH	TI=:(86AAHI=:BSIG6CH;:GH	T	6C9I=:

(, 86AAHI=:B S6AAD867A: :ME:CH:HT
 .=: >C8AJ9:H 6A:C<I=N

9:H8G>EI>DC I=6I G:;:G:C8:H I=: GDBC>7JH 7>AA ;DG :M6BEA:	 SG:8DJCI

:ME:CH:G:>B7JGH:B:CIT;DAADL:97NSIG6CH;:GQG:8DJCI:ME:CH:HID&>C:

7E:G
GDBC>7JH7>AAT

9 !>C6AAN	I=:E6GIN8DBB>II::H6AA=6K:HDB:9:<G::D;>CI:GC6A>C8DCH>HI:C8N

>CI=:>GG:EDGI>C<!DG:M6BEA:	L=:C9:H8G>7>C<8DCIG>7JI>DCH	I=:(,-

HE:AAH DJI I=: 688DJCI C6B:H >C ;JAA SA:<6A EGD8::9>C<H 688DJCIT 6C9

S=:69FJ6GI:GH 688DJCIT	 L=>A: >I JH:H 677G:K>6I>DCH L=:C >I 9:H8G>7:H

9>H7JGH:B:CIH SA:<6A EGD8T 6C9 S#+ 688DJCIT ->B>A6GAN	 I=: (,

JH:H SA:<6A EGD8::9>C<H 688DJCIT L=:C 9:H8G>7>C< 8DCIG>7JI>DCH 6C9

SG:8DJCITL=:C9:H8G>7>C<9>H7JGH:B:CIH;GDBI=:H6B:688DJCIC9	6H

CDI:967DK:	I=:JH:H7DI=SG:8DJCIT6C9SA:<6AEGD8::9>C<HTL=:C

9:H8G>7>C<>IH9>H7JGH:B:CIH	L>I=7DI=I:GBH:K:C6EE:6G>C<DCI=:H6B:

E6<:D;>IH6B:C9:9'6N
G:EDGI

 .=>HA68@D;HI6C96G9>O:9G:EDGI>C<EDH:H68DC8G:I:D7HI68A:ID&VHLDG@6H6

CDCEGD;>I L6I8=9D< DG<6C>O6I>DC 6C9 ID )E:C-:8G:IHV 67>A>IN ID EGDK>9: 8DBEG:=:CH>K: 6C9

688JG6I:96I667DJII=:C6I>DC6AE6GI>:HV86BE6><CBDC:NIDB:B7:GHD;I=:EJ7A>8	?DJGC6A>HIH	

6C9DI=:GHI6@:=DA9:GH

 .=6II=:DBB>HH>DC =6H CDI	6;I:G C:6GAN6 9:869:	 7::C67A:IDLG>I:6 H>C<A:

G:<JA6I>DCID>BEA:B:CIDCANI=G::E6G6<G6E=HD;HI6IJIDGNI:MI=6HCD8DC8:>K67A:?JHI>;>86I>DC

)K:G%-2/5$ /0=6K:E6HH:9H>C8:EA6>CI>;;H;>A:9I=:>G*:I>I>DCH::@>C<H>BEA:GJA:HID>BEA:B:CI

(,-
B:C9:9*G:
":C:G6A	02./ CDI:	6I	
9:H8G>7>C<9>H7JGH:B:CIH6H6C

S>CI:GC6A A:<6A EGD8::9>C<H :ME:C9>IJG:H IG6CH;:GT 6C9 6C S>CI:GC6A =F 6AAD867A: :ME:C9>IJG:H

IG6CH;:GT

	(	
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	!DGB2	6I	;>A:9-:EI
	
	=IIEH9D8FJ:GN;:8

<DKE9;







E9; 9:H8G>7>C< 6 9>H7JGH:B:CI 6H

S,:8DJCI88DJCIQ.G6CH;:G;DG,:8DJCI6C9)I=:G&:<6A*GD8::9>C< ME:CH:HT


(, 
 -:EI:B7:G 'DCI=AN	 02./  CDI: 
	 6I 	 9:H8G>7>C< 6 9>H7JGH:B:CI 6H

S6AAD867A::ME:CH:HIDA:<6A688IT


-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	


(,-
B:C9:9*G:
":C:G6A	02./ CDI:	6I	


				


(,
-:EI:B7:G'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:
	6I			


B:C9:9'6N'DCI=AN	02./ CDI:	6I	




Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 22 of 24
 

I=: 8DG: IG6CHE6G:C8N G:FJ>G:B:CIH D; ! R6 HI6IJI: DG<6C>O:9 6GDJC9 ILD
N:6G :A:8I>DC

8N8A:HR7JII=:DBB>HH>DCHI>AA=6HN:IID68IDCDG8DC8AJH>K:ANG:HEDC9IDI=:*:I>I>DC.=:

DBB>HH>DCVH N:6GH
ADC<	 8DCI>CJ>C< 9:A6N >H L=DAAN >C9:;:CH>7A:	 JCG:6HDC67A: L>I=>C I=:

B:6C>C<D;I=:*	6C9L6GG6CIHHL>;I8DGG:8I>DC7NI=>HDJGI








	

 *A6>CI>;;HG:E:6I6C9G:6AA:<:E6G6<G6E=H
6H>;H:I;DGI=;JAAN=:G:>C

 /C9:GI=:*	:68=;:9:G6A6<:C8NSH=6AA<>K:6C>CI:G:HI:9E:GHDCI=:G><=IID

E:I>I>DC;DGI=:>HHJ6C8:	6B:C9B:CI	DGG:E:6AD;6GJA:T/-P:0$$ *0-!,

P



 .=:*;JGI=:G9>G:8IH:68=;:9:G6A6<:C8NSID8DC8AJ9:6B6II:GEG:H:CI:9ID>IT

SL>I=>C6G:6HDC67A:I>B:T/-P7"%!,P



 68=;:9:G6A6<:C8NBJHI6AHD<>K:S3E4GDBEICDI>8:TD;I=:9:C>6A>CL=DA:DG>C

E6GID;6E:I>I>DC	ID<:I=:GL>I=6S7G>:;HI6I:B:CID;I=:<GDJC9H;DG9:C>6AT/-P:

0$$ *0-!,P

7


 'DG:I=6C;DJGN:6GH=6K::A6EH:9H>C8:EA6>CI>;;H;>A:9I=:>G*:I>I>DCL>I=I=:! 	

>CJ<JHI
	6C9I=:! HI>AA=6HN:IID68IDCI=:*:I>I>DCDGG:C9:G6;>C6A9:8>H>DC>CG:HEDCH:

ID>I

 .=:DBB>HH>DCVHJCG:6HDC67A:9:A6N6C9;6>AJG:ID68IDCI=:*:I>I>DCK>DA6I:HI=:

*	 L=>8= EGDK>9:H I=6I 6 G:K>:L>C< 8DJGI SH=6AA 8DBE:A 6<:C8N 68I>DCJCG:6HDC67AN

9:A6N:9T/-P


Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 23 of 24
 




1# , !), 	*A6>CI>;;HG:HE:8I;JAANG:FJ:HII=6II=>HDJGI

 :8A6G: I=6I I=: ! VH DC<D>C< ;6>AJG: ID 68I DC DG 8DC8AJH>K:AN G:HEDC9 ID

EA6>CI>;;HV*:I>I>DC8DCHI>IJI:H6<:C8N68I>DCJCG:6HDC67AN9:A6N:9>CK>DA6I>DCD;I=:*

 CI:G6CDG9:G:C?D>C>C<I=:! ;GDB;JGI=:G9:A6N>CG:HEDC9>C<IDI=:*:I>I>DC

6C98DBE:AA>C<I=:! ID>HHJ:6;>C6A9:8>H>DCL>I=>C
96NH

 ,:I6>C?JG>H9>8I>DCD;I=>HB6II:GIDHJE:GK>H:I=:! VHI>B:AN8DBEA>6C8:L>I=>IH

D7A><6I>DCH6HH:I;DGI=>CI=>HDBEA6>CI

 L6G9EA6>CI>;;HI=:>G8DHIH6C9G:6HDC67A:6IIDGC:NVH;::H>C8JGG:9>CI=>H68I>DC

6C9

 "G6CIHJ8=DI=:GG:A>:;6HI=:DJGIB6N9::B?JHI6C9EGDE:G

6I:9)8ID7:G
	
    ,:HE:8I;JAANHJ7B>II:9	   

0$& ,"**$, 

':<6C*'8AA:C6G(D




-=6CC6,:JA768=6G(D

	&	


 - (1	 -



1
	
		  





 




 B6>ABB86AA:C86BE6><CA:<6A8:CI:GDG<

 B6>AHEDGIH86BE6><CA:<6A8:CI:GDG<

..*(" 1(-,%-/ #+(00(-,.$,#(,&

Case 1:23-cv-03163-APM Document 1 Filed 10/20/23 Page 24 of 24