Your web browser is not supported You're using Internet Explorer, some features might not work. Please switch to another browser like Chrome, Firefox, or Edge for a better experience.


An official website of the United States government Here's how you know
 **Official websites use .gov**
            
            A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
 **Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
            
            A **lock** ( A locked padlock ) or **https://** means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Federal Election Commission | United States of America Calendar
           Glossary
          Search
              Search


Menu
      Home
      Campaign finance data
        All data
            Raising
            Spending
            Loans and debts
            Filings and reports
            Candidates
            Committees
            Bulk data
            Campaign finance statistics
        Find elections. Search by state or ZIP code
          Look up contributions from specific individuals
      Help for candidates and committees
        All compliance resources
            Guides
            Forms
            Dates and deadlines
            Trainings
        Learn about electronic filing
          Find and contact your committee's analyst
      Legal resources
        All legal resources
            Advisory opinions
            Enforcement
            Statutes
            Legislation
            Regulations
            Court cases
            Policy and other guidance
        Search across all legal resources
          Search guidance documents
      About
        All about the FEC
            News and announcements
            Commission meetings
            Mission and history
            Leadership and structure
            Reports about the FEC
            Careers
            Working with the FEC
            Contact
        Introduction to campaign finance and elections


- Home
- ›
        Legal resources
- ›
        Court cases
- ›
      Branstool v. FEC

Branstool v. FEC 
 Summary
 Summary

  
  
    On April 4, 1995, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia granted defendant's motion for summary judgment. This decision sustains the Commission's dismissal of plaintiffs' administrative complaint.BackgroundThe origins of this case are rooted in the 1988 Presidential contest between Republican candidate George Bush and Democratic candidate Michael Dukakis. In the course of the Presidential race, the National Security Political Action Committee (NSPAC) financed the production and airing of the "Willie Horton" ad. This ad attacked the Democratic candidate by blaming then Massachusetts Governor Michael Dukakis for the violent crimes committed by a convict while on furlough from a state prison.Plaintiffs filed an administrative complaint with the FEC in May 1990, alleging that the NSPAC coordinated the production and airing of the Willie Horton ad with the Bush campaign. Under the Federal Election Campaign Act (the Act), a candidate running in a Presidential general election who accepts public funding may not accept contributions. The Bush campaign accepted public funding. If, as plaintiffs claimed, the Horton ad had been coordinated, then it would have been an in-kind contribution, in violation of 26 U.S.C. §9003(b)(2). The complaint thus hinged on the issue of whether the Horton ad was a coordinated in-kind contribution, and therefore illegal, or a permissible independent expenditure as defined under 2 U.S.C. §431(17).[1]After examining the complaint, the Commission found reason to believe that the Bush campaign and the NSPAC had violated the Act, but after a limited investigation into the matter, the Commission deemed the evidence inconclusive and decided to take no further action on the matter. Plaintiffs' complaint was subsequently dismissed.This led plaintiffs to file this suit in January 1992, claiming that the FEC had abused its discretion in not conducting a comprehensive investigation and had violated the Act by dismissing plaintiffs' complaint. Plaintiffs noted that among the FEC investigation's findings were a record of a June 1988 telephone conversation between the Bush campaign's chief media advisor and a NSPAC media consultant, and documentation showing that a media technician worked for both NSPAC and the Bush campaign. Plaintiffs contended that these findings were proof of coordination.The court's decisionIn addressing plaintiffs' challenge to the Commission's decision to limit the investigation into their complaint, the court saw no reason to depart from the general policy of giving broad deference to agency prosecutorial decisions.The court held that it could set aside FEC statutory interpretations as "impermissible" only if they have no reasonable basis. The court concluded that the factual conclusions underpinning the Commission's decision were "sufficiently reasonable" to warrant the court's deference.For instance, in dismissing the complaint, the Commission concluded that the inference of coordination created by the telephone call was rebutted by other findings. With regard to the media technician's dual employment, the Commission reasonably concluded that he performed technical tasks for the two committees and had no role in substantive or strategic decisions.FOOTNOTE:[1] An independent expenditure is an expenditure made without any coordination with a candidate's campaign for a communication which expressly advocates the election or defeat of a clearly identified candidate for federal office.Source: FEC Record— June 1995. Branstool v. FEC, No. 92-0284 (D.D.C. Apr. 4, 1995).


This information is not intended to replace the law or to change its meaning, nor does this information create or confer any rights for or on any person or bind the Federal Election Commission or the public. The reader is encouraged also to consult the Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971, as amended (52 U.S.C. 30101 et seq.), Commission regulations (Title 11 of the Code of Federal Regulations), Commission advisory opinions and applicable court decisions.


About
          Careers
          Press
          Contact
   Privacy and security policy
          Plain language
          No FEAR Act
          Strategy, budget and performance
 Open government
          Protected Voices
          USA.gov
          Inspector General
          FOIA
 OpenFEC API
          GitHub repository
          Release notes
          FEC.gov status


Federal Election Commission
 The FEC's Twitter page
            The FEC's YouTube page Sign up for FECMail


Hide glossary Glossary Search terms