## Automatic Commercial Ice Maker ECS NODA Engineering Analysis Summary Updates to the Engineering Analysis

DOE has made the following changes to the engineering analysis since the NOPR: - Updated the cost of evaporator size increases - Updated the cost of using higher EER compressors - Updated the efficiency impact of higher EER compressors - Updated the efficiency impact of using PSC and ECM fan motors - Updated the efficiency impact of using PSC and ECM pump motors - Changed the order of application of design options to the baseline unit and adjusted certain design options to improve consistency with the design options observed in commercially available ice makers. Based on comments made during the NOPR comment period, DOE developed the following added cost-efficiency curves: - IMH-A-Small-B 22-inch width - IMH-A-Large-B 22-inch width - IMH-W-Small-B 22-inch width - RCU-NRC-Small-C

Based on the data available at the time of the NODA, the engineering team made the following changes to the max-available levels for the cost-efficiency curves: - IMH-A-Small-B max-available level dropped to 19.3% from 23.6% - IMH-A-Large-B (Med) max-available level dropped to 16.1% from 20.7% - IMH-A-Large-B (Large) max-available level dropped to 6.0% from 16.7% - IMH-W-Small-B max-available level dropped to 19.2% from 22.0% - IMH-W-Med-B max-available dropped to 14.3% from 15.7% - IMH-W-Large-B (Large) max-available level dropped to 2.5% from 8.3% The team adjusted the analysis based on data for new products available on the market and on new ratings of existing equipment. The engineering team also considered more narrow ranges of harvest capacity and equipment characteristics when selecting max-available equipment to compare with analysis conducted for any given representative unit. Additional details and documents on the Automatic Commercial Ice Maker rule making can be found here: http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/rulemaking.aspx/ruleid/29. For the NODA engineering analyses described here and in the accompanying notice, DOE has developed new cost-efficiency curves. These curves are based on a variety of new inputs made between the publication of the NOPR analysis and the publication of this NODA, both through public comments and in discussions under NDA with DOE's contractor.

## DOE has made the following changes to the engineering analysis since the NOPR: - Updated the efficiency impact of using PSC and ECM fan motors - Updated the efficiency impact of using PSC and ECM pump motors - Changed the order of application of design options to the baseline unit and adjusted certain design options to improve consistency with the design options observed in commercially available ice makers. Based on comments made during the NOPR comment period, DOE developed the following added cost-efficiency curves:

Based on the data available at the time of the NODA, the engineering team made the following changes to the max-available levels for the cost-efficiency curves: - IMH-A-Small-B max-available level dropped to 19.3% from 23.6% - IMH-A-Large-B (Med) max-available level dropped to 16.1% from 20.7% - IMH-A-Large-B (Large) max-available level dropped to 6.0% from 16.7% - IMH-W-Small-B max-available level dropped to 19.2% from 22.0% - IMH-W-Large-B (Large) max-available level dropped to 2.5% from 8.3% The team adjusted the analysis based on data for new products available on the market and on new ratings of existing equipment. The engineering team also considered more narrow ranges of harvest capacity and equipment characteristics when selecting max-available equipment to compare with analysis conducted for any given representative unit. Additional details and documents on the Automatic Commercial Ice Maker rule making can be found here: http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/rulemaking.aspx/ruleid/29. For the NODA engineering analyses described here and in the accompanying notice, DOE has developed new cost-efficiency curves. These curves are based on a variety of new inputs made between the publication of the NOPR analysis and the publication of this NODA, both through public comments and in discussions under NDA with DOE's contractor.

## - Changed the order of application of design options to the baseline unit and adjusted certain design options to improve consistency with the design options observed in commercially available ice makers.

Based on the data available at the time of the NODA, the engineering team made the following changes to the max-available levels for the cost-efficiency curves: The team adjusted the analysis based on data for new products available on the market and on new ratings of existing equipment. The engineering team also considered more narrow ranges of harvest capacity and equipment Additional details and documents on the Automatic Commercial Ice Maker rule making can be found here: http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/rulemaking.aspx/ruleid/29. For the NODA engineering analyses described here and in the accompanying notice, DOE has developed new cost-efficiency curves. These curves are based on a variety of new inputs made between the publication of

## Automatic Commercial Ice Maker ECS NODA Engineering Analysis Summary Table of Costs by EL Level

**Cost-Efficiency**

**Curve Results: Incremental MPC Results for Batch Ice Makers**
Small (30-inch) 19% 300 Small (22-inch) 17% 300 Medium 14% 850 5% 1500 3% 2600 Small (30-inch) 19% 300 Small (22-inch) 17% 300 16% 800 6% 1500 Large (22-inch) 5% 800 Small 700 16% 1500 15% 2400 Small 110 Large 28% 300 Small 31% 110 Large 28% 200 **Cost-Efficiency**

**Curve Results: Incremental MPC Results for Continuous Ice Makers**

Small 800 1,000 1,800 Large **IMH-W-***-C SCU-A** **-***-B**

**Equipment Class Max A**  **vailable Representative Harvest** 

**Capacity**

**lb/24 hours Equipment Class**  **Max A vailable**  **Representative Harvest**

**Capacity**

**lb/24 hours IMH-W-** *-B**

Large **IMH-A -** *-B** Large (30-inch and 48-inch)

Large **RCU-***-***-B**

**SCU-W-***-B**Small 25% 310 17% 820 1,800 Small 18.4% 800 Large 1,500 Small NA Large 300 Small 24% 220 300 670 **SCU-W-***-C SCU-A** **-***-C** Large **IMH-A -** *-C**

**RCU-***-***-C** Large**10%**

24.0 153 $898 $1,122 $40 23.9 193 $898 $1,122 $40 19.7 153 $1,545 $1,931 $112 22 162 $1,709 $2,136 19.7 174 $3,748 $4,684 **10%** 25.6 NA $916 $1,144 $51 18.5 NA $916 $1,144 $48 22.7 NA $1,494 $1,867 $45 20.0 NA $1,652 $2,065 $413 18.0 NA $1,494 $1,867 $70 **10%** 20.0 NA $1,970 $2,463 $44 19.7 NA $3,203 $4,003 $102 **10%** 30.0 132 $1,224 $1,530 $43 **10%** 34.0 NA $1,051 $1,314 $22 30.0 NA $1,121 $1,402 $39

**10%** Not Analyzed Not Analyzed Not Analyzed**EL2  ** Potable Water (gal/100**

**lb) Condenser Water** 

**(gal/100 lb) Baseline MPC**  **Baseline MSP Potable Water (gal/100** 

**lb) Condenser Water** 

**(gal/100 lb) Baseline MPC**  **Baseline MSP EL2** **

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed**10%**

12.0 NA $2,706 $3,382 $32 13.6 NA $2,090 $2,613 $30 **10%** 12.0 NA $2,090 $2,613 $30 **10% 10%**  12.0 NA $1,411 $1,764 $12 Not Analyzed Not Analyzed Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed Not Analyzed Not Analyzed**Level Cost**  **Level Cost** 

**15% 20%**  **25% 30%**  $70 $136 24% $364 22% $345 $74 $331 22% $345 $226 19% $471 8% $424 7% $526 **15% 20%**  **25% 30%**  $91 $131 $377 26% $381 18% $116 $292 18% $315 $86 $147 23% $378 16% $88 12% $452 $319 16% $322 **15% 20%**  **25%** $82 $411 22% $452 $217 $754 21% $799 **15% 20%**  **25% 30%**  $68 $94 $121 $370 32% $383 **15% 20%**  **25% 30%**  $36 $50 $95 $130 33% $358 $45 $74 $96 29% $347

**Level Cost**  **15% 20%**  **25% 30%**  **Max Tech EL3**  **EL4 EL5**  **EL6 22-inch Max Tech Pt on 30-**  **inch curve Max Tech**  **EL6 EL3**  **EL4 EL5** 

N/A Not Analyzed N/A
N/A N/A N/A
N/A N/A N/A N/A

N/A N/A N/A Not Analyzed**15% 20%**  **25% 30%** 

$48 $113 $419 $528 29% $528 $45 $474 23% $484 **15% 20%**  **25% 30%**  $53 $79 $497 27% $511 **15% 20%**  **25% 30%**  **15% 20%**  **25%** $24 $36 $365 28% $374

## Automatic Commercial Ice Maker ECS NOPR Engineering Analysis Summary Transcription of Cost Efficiency Curves To EL Levels

**Cost-Efficiency Curve Table**

1 7.68 0.00% 2 7.61 0.97% 3 7.31 4.76% 4 7.18 6.50% 5 7.03 8.45% 6 6.05 21.26% 7 5.95 22.49% 8 5.72 25.51% 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table **Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 450 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes) Des. Option No.**  

## IMH-A-Small-B (30-inch)

**Des. Option No.** 

## IMH-A-Large-B-1 (30-inch)

**Energy Consum ption**  **kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction**

**Energy Consum ption**  **kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction**

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 450 lb/24 hours1 6.01 0.0% 2 5.47 9.0% 3 5.31 11.7% 4 5.13 14.7% 5 5.01 16.7% 6 4.93 17.9% 7 4.85 19.3% 8 4.79 20.3% 9 4.60 23.4% 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 5.24 0.0% 2 5.15 1.6% 3 5.06 3.4% 4 4.99 4.7% 5 4.83 7.8% 6 4.81 8.2% 7 4.62 11.8% 8 9 10 

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 450 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes)
**Des. Option No.** 

## IMH-A-Large-B-2 (48-inch)

**Energy Consum ption**  **kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction**

## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 6.14 0.0% 2 5.72 6.8% 3 5.22 15.0% 4 5.01 18.3% 5 4.96 19.2% 6 4.86 20.8% 7 4.68 23.9% 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 4.65 0.0% 2 4.40 5.3% **Des. Option No.**

**Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction**  

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 500 lb/24 hours **IMH-W-Small-B (30-inch)**

**Energy Consum ption**  **kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction**



## IMH-W-Medium-B3 4.32 6.9% 4 3.91 15.8% 5 3.76 19.1% 6 7 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 4.00 0.0% 2 3.95 1.3% 3 3.82 4.4% 4 3.81 4.7% 5 3.67 8.3% 6 7 8 9 10 **Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1436 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes) 

## IMH-W-Large-B-1

## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 4.00 0.0% 2 3.90 2.5% 3 3.85 3.7% 4 3.70 7.4% 5 6 7 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 5.10 0.0% 2 4.93 3.4%

**Energy Consum ption**  **kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction**

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1436 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes) 

## IMH-W-Large-B-2
**Des. Option No.**

**Des. Option No.** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled RCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1000 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes) 

## RCU-NRC-Large-B-1

**Energy Consum ption**  **kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction**3 4.42 13.3% 4 4.32 15.3% 5 4.24 16.9% 6 4.20 17.7% 7 4.16 18.5% 8 4.00 21.7% 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 5.10 0.00% 2 4.81 5.70% 3 4.44 12.90% 4 4.38 14.13% 5 4.28 16.11% 6 4.18 17.99% 7 4.02 21.19% 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table **Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled RCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1000 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes)** 

## RCU-NRC-Large-B-2
**Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction** 1 12.84 0.00% 2 12.12 5.60% 3 10.02 21.96% 4 9.83 23.44% 5 9.42 26.64% 6 9.13 28.86% 7 8.96 30.19% 8 8.64 32.74% 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 9.80 0.00% 2 9.26 5.50% 3 8.20 16.30% 4 7.62 22.20% 5 7.50 23.52% 6 7.35 24.98% 7 7.23 26.26% 8 6.94 29.13% 9 **Baseline Energy**

**Consum ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Less Than Baseline**  **Baseline Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Less Than Baseline**

**Des. Option No. Des. Option No.**  

## SCU-A-Small-B

**SCU-A-Large-B**10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 7.60 0.0% 2 7.06 7.1% 3 6.77 10.9% 4 5.50 27.6% 5 5.34 29.7% 6 5.14 32.4% 7 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 9.05 0.00% 2 8.24 9.00%

**Energy Consum ption**  **kWh/100 lb Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction Des. Option No.** 

**Des. Option No. Percent Energy Use**  **Reduction Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  

## IMH-A-Small-C **SCU-W-Large-B Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled SCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 200 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)** 3 8.03 11.30% 4 7.73 14.55% 5 7.41 18.18% 6 6.93 23.38% 7 6.45 28.68% 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 6.60 0.00% 2 5.79 12.31% 3 5.57 15.67% 4 5.48 17.02% 5 5.38 18.52% 6 5.06 23.32% 7 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table **Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction (Old)** 



## SCU-A-Small-C **IMH-A-Large-C Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Continuous Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 700 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)** 1 10.12 0.00% 2 9.18 9.26% 3 8.08 20.17% 4 7.91 21.77% 5 7.73 23.55% 6 7.23 28.48% 7 8 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 6.33 0.00% 2 5.82 8.06% 3 5.52 12.72% 4 5.19 17.91% 5 4.87 23.11% 6 4.65 26.58% 7 8 9 10 **Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction**  

## RCU-NRC-Small-C **Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction (Old)** 

## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 7.68 0.00% 2 7.57 1.49% 3 7.27 5.28% 4 7.14 7.03% 5 6.99 8.97% 6 6.64 13.50% 7 6.55 14.74% 8 6.29 18.06% 9 10



## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 6.01 0.0% 2 5.81 3.3% 3 5.65 6.0% 4 5.47 9.0% 5 5.35 11.0% 6 5.28 12.2% 7 5.07 15.6% 8 9 10 **Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction** 

**Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction**  

## IMH-A-Large-B (22-inch) **IMH-A-Small-B (22-inch)**

## Cost-Efficiency Curve Table

1 6.14 0.0% 2 5.72 6.8% 3 5.31 13.5% 4 5.10 16.9% 5 5.01 18.5% 6 4.82 21.5% 7 8 9 10 **Des. Option No. Energy Consum** **ption kWh/100 lb**  **Percent Energy Use Reduction**  

## IMH-W-Small-B (22-inch)Baseline Energy Use from Std = 7.68

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline - $ Baseline Increase Condenser Width by 1.3" 57.38 $ Condenser Increase Compressor EER from 4.86 to 5.20 325.52 $ Compressor Switch to PSC Condenser Fan Motor 18.02 $ Fan Motor Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motor 30.11 $ Fan Motor Increase Evaporator Area by 51% (with chassis growth) 87.77 $ Evaporator Switch to ECM Pump Motor 14.35 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger - $ Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 6.01

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** 

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 450 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes) **Design Options Successively Added**

**Design Options Successively Added** 

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 450 lb/24 hours
**Com ponent Inform** **ation**

**Com ponent Inform** **ation**Baseline - $ Baseline Increase Compressor EER from 5.66 to 6.7 417.45 $ Compressor Switch to PSC Condenser Fan Motor 26.47 $ Fan Motor Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motor 44.62 $ Fan Motor Change to Batch Water Fill - $ Controls Switch to ECM Pump Motor 17.57 $ Pump Motor Increase Condenser Height by 3" (with chassis growth) 128.96 $ Condenser Increase Condenser Width by 3.25" 143.64 $ Condenser Drain Water Heat Exchanger - $ Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 5.24

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Switch to PSC Condenser Fan Motor 31.13 $ Fan Motor Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motor 52.62 $ Fan Motor Increase Compressor EER from 7 to 7.16 522.45 $ Compressor Increase Condenser Width by 6", Add One Additional Condenser Row 130.76 $ Condenser Switch to ECM Pump Motor 15.67 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger 

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 450 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes)
**Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation** Baseline Energy Use from Std = 6.14

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline - $ Baseline Increase compressor EER from 4.59 to 5.2 312.11 $ Compressor Increase Condenser Length by 59% 69.68 $ Condenser Change to Batch Water Fill - $ Controls Increase Evaporator Area by 4.7% (with chassis growth) 89.02 $ Evaporator Switch to ECM Pump Motor 11.76 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger - $ Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 4.65

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline - $ Baseline Increase Compressor EER from 5.63 to 6.2 419.66 $ Compressor 

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 500 lb/24 hours

**Design Options Successively Added Design Options Successively Added** 



### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours **Com ponent Inform** **ation**

**Com ponent Inform** **ation**Switch to ECM Pump Motor 17.58 $ Pump Motor Increase Condenser Length by 125% 140.05 $ Condenser Drain Water Heat Exchanger - $ Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 4.0

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increase Compressor EER from 7 to 7.16 486.91 $ Compressor Increase Condenser Size 187.28 $ Condenser Switch to ECM Pump Motor 15.67 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger **Design Options Successively Added** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1436 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)
**Com ponent Inform** **ation**Baseline Energy Use from Std = 4.0

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent**
Baseline $- Baseline Increase compressor EER from 6.05 to 6.32 781.59 $ Compressor Switch to ECM Pump Motors (2) 41.82 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 5.1

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increase Condenser Height by 3" (with condenser growth) 118.20 $ Condenser **Design Options Successively Added** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1436 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes)

**Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled RCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1000 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)**

**Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation**  **Com ponent Inform** **ation**Increase Compressor EER from 5.94 to 7.16 480.33 $ Compressor Switch to ECM Fan Motor 54.62 $ Fan Motor Increase Condenser Width by 5" (with unit growth) 129.25 $ Condenser Switch to ECM Pump Motor 17.57 $ Pump Motor Increase Condenser Width by 6" (with unit growth) 152.68 $ Condenser Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 5.1

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increase compressor EER from 5.68 to 6.32 771.92 $ Compressor Increase Condenser Width by 19", Add One Additional Condenser Row and One Extra Fan 97.33 $ Condenser Switch to ECM Pump Motors (2) 41.82 $ Pump Motor Increase Condenser Width by 18" (with unit growth) 202.90 $ Condenser Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motors (2) 109.25 $ Fan Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 12.84 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled RCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1000 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes)

**Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation** **MPC of Com ponent Prior to**  **Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increase condenser width by 2.5”, Add One Additional Condenser Row 39.08 $ Condenser Increase compressor EER from 3.3 to 4.6 (includes smaller compressor) 193.70 $ Compressor Switch to PSC Condenser Fan Motor 11.76 $ Fan Motor Change to Batch Water Fill $- Controls Switch to ECM Pump Motor 14.61 $ Pump Motor Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motor 19.33 $ Fan Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 9.8

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increase condenser width by 9" 46.22 $ Condenser Increase compressor EER from 4.23 to 5.2 304.72 $ Compressor Change to Batch Water Fill $- Controls Switch to PSC Condenser Fan Motor 18.02 $ Fan Motor Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motor 30.11 $ Fan Motor Switch to ECM Pump Motor 11.76 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger **Design Options Successively Added Design Options Successively Added**  

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled SCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 175 lb/24 hours

**Com ponent Inform** **ation Com** **ponent Inform ation** 



### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled SCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 175 lb/24 hoursBaseline Energy Use from Std =7.6

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Change to Batch Water Fill $- Controls Increase compressor EER from 4.86 to 5.2 321.38 $ Compressor Increase Condenser Length by 112% 65.51 $ Condenser Switch to ECM Pump Motor 14.35 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger $- Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 9.05

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increased compressor EER from 4.68 to 5.4 325.00 $ Compressor **Design Options Successively Added**

**Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation** 

**Com ponent Inform** **ation** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Continuous Ice Machines with Capacities less than 700 lb/24 hours **Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled SCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 200 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)**Increased condenser width by 3.5" 48.45 $ Condenser Switched to PSC Fan Motor 25.30 $ Fan Motor Switched to ECM Fan Motor 42.62 $ Fan Motor Increase evaporator area by 17% and increase condenser height by 4" (with chassis increase) 1,251.92 $ Evaporator Switched to ECM Auger Motor 313.19 $ Auger Motor

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 6.60

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increase Compressor EER from 5.02 to 6.0 384.35 $ Compressor Increase Condenser Width by 1.5", Increase Tube Rows by 1 61.28 $ Condenser Switched to PSC Fan Motor 29.73 $ Fan Motor Switched to ECM Fan Motor 50.23 $ Fan Motor Switched to ECM Auger Motor 400.96 $ Auger Motor

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 10.12 **Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation** 



### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled SCU Continuous Ice Machines with Capacities less than 700 lb/24 hours **Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Continuous Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 700 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes) MPC of Com** **ponent Prior to Change**  **Com ponent**  Baseline - $ Baseline Increased condenser rows to 4 from 3, larger motor 52.38 $ Condenser Changed compressor EER from 4.7 to 5.5 315.92 $ Compressor Switched to PSC Fan Motor 19.45 $ Fan Motor Switched to ECM Fan Motor 32.56 $ Fan Motor Switched to ECM Auger Motor 315.49 $ Auger Motor

Baseline Energy Use from Std = 6.33

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline $- Baseline Increase Compressor EER from 4.75 to 5.4 344.06 $ Compressor Switched to PSC Fan Motor 17.57 $ Fan Motor Switched to ECM Fan Motor 29.32 $ Fan Motor Increase Condenser Width by 23.25 inches 46.24 $ Condenser Switched to ECM Auger Motor 400.96 $ Auger Motor **Com ponent Inform** **ation**

**Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation**  

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours **Design Options Successively Added**Baseline Energy Use from Std = 7.68

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline - $ Baseline Increase Condenser Width by 2" 57.38 $ Condenser Increase Compressor EER from 4.86 to 5.20 325.52 $ Compressor Switch to PSC Condenser Fan Motor 18.02 $ Fan Motor Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motor 30.11 $ Fan Motor Increase Evaporator Area by 18.0% (no chassis growth) 87.77 $ Evaporator Switch to ECM Pump Motor 14.35 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger - $ Drain Water Heat Exchanger

Baseline Energy Use from Std =6.01

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline - $ Baseline Increase Compressor EER from 5.66 to 6.0 417.45 $ Compressor Switch to PSC Condenser Fan Motor 26.47 $ Fan Motor Switch to ECM Condenser Fan Motor 44.62 $ Fan Motor Change to Batch Water Fill - $ Controls Switch to ECM Pump Motor 17.57 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger - $ Drain Water Heat Exchanger **Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation** 

**Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation**  

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours

**Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours**Baseline Energy Use from Std =6.14

**MPC of Com ponent Prior to** 

**Change Com** **ponent** Baseline - $ Baseline Increase compressor EER from 4.59 to 5.2 312.11 $ Compressor Increase Condenser Length by 48% 69.68 $ Condenser Change to Batch Water Fill - $ Controls Switch to ECM Pump Motor 11.76 $ Pump Motor Drain Water Heat Exchanger - $ Drain Water Heat Exchanger **Design Options Successively Added Com** **ponent Inform ation**  

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours$2012 to $2013 PPI Adjustment: 1.006Link

Standard Equation: **[ 10.26-0.0086*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ 915.53

$ 1,144.41

$ Yes 2.73

$ 2.73

$ 918.26

$ 1,147.82

$ Yes 16.37

$ 19.10

$ 934.63

$ 1,168.29

$ Yes 12.15

$ 31.25

$ 946.78

$ 1,183.48

$ No 7.75

$ 39.00

$ 954.53

$ 1,193.16

$ Yes 102.01

$ 141.01

$ 1,056.54

$ 1,320.68

$ No 21.44

$ 162.45

$ 1,077.98

$ 1,347.48

$ No 218.71

$ 381.16

$ 1,296.69

$ 1,620.87

$

Standard Equation: **[ 6.89-0.0011*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 450 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes) **MPC ($) Impact on Unit MPC** 

**Impact on Unit MPC MSP** 

**MSP** 

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 450 lb/24 hours **MPC ($)**N/A - $
-

$ 1,493.99

$ 1,867.49

$ Yes 37.88

$ 37.88

$ 1,531.87

$ 1,914.83

$ Yes 18.26

$ 56.13

$ 1,550.12

$ 1,937.66

$ No 6.67

$ 62.80

$ 1,556.79

$ 1,945.99

$ No 30.18

$ 92.98

$ 1,586.97

$ 1,983.72

$ No 20.01

$ 112.99

$ 1,606.98

$ 2,008.73

$ Yes 23.65

$ 136.64

$ 1,630.63

$ 2,038.29

$ Yes 14.78

$ 151.42

$ 1,645.41

$ 2,056.77

$ No 226.16

$ 377.59

$ 1,871.58

$ 2,339.47

$

Standard Equation: **[ 6.89-0.0011*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ 1,651.97

$ 2,064.97

$ Yes 21.63

$ 21.63

$ 1,673.60

$ 2,092.00

$ No 18.39

$ 40.02

$ 1,691.99

$ 2,114.99

$ Yes 26.28

$ 66.30

$ 1,718.27

$ 2,147.84

$ Yes 68.77

$ 135.07

$ 1,787.04

$ 2,233.80

$ No 20.74

$ 155.81

$ 1,807.78

$ 2,259.73

$ Yes 296.46

$ 452.27

$ 2,104.24

$ 2,630.31

$ **MPC ($)** 

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 450 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes)

**Impact on Unit MPC MSP ($)** Standard Equation: **[ 7.79-0.0055*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ $ 897.98 1,122.47 $ Yes 20.71

$ 20.71

$ 918.69

$ 1,148.36

$ Yes 49.47

$ 70.18

$ 968.16

$ 1,210.20

$ No 30.18

$ 100.36

$ 998.34

$ 1,247.92

$ 9.75 $ 110.12

$ 1,008.09

$ 1,260.11

$ 34.95 $ 145.06

$ 1,043.04

$ 1,303.80

$ 218.71 $ 363.78

$ 1,261.75

$ 1,577

$

Standard Equation: **[ 5.58-0.0011*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A

-

$
-

$ $1,545 1,931 $ Yes 21.11

$ 21.11

$ 1,566.18

$ 1,958

$ **MSP ($) MPC ($)**  

## Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 500 lb/24 hours

**Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)**  **Impact on Unit MPC**



### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours **MSP ($)**Yes 20.01 $ 41.12

$ 1,586.19

$ 1,983

$ No 203.89

$ 245.01

$ 1,790.08

$ 2,238

$ 226.16 $ 471.17

$ 2,016.25

$ 2,520

$

Standard Equation: **[ 4.0 ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ $ 1,708.83 2,136.04 $ Yes 24.49

$ 24.49

$ 1,733.32

$ 2,166.65

$ Yes 81.95

$ 106.44

$ 1,815.27

$ 2,269.09

$ No 20.74

$ 127.18

$ 1,836.01

$ 2,295.02

$ No 296.46

$ 423.64

$ 2,132.47

$ 2,665.59

$ **Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)**  **MSP ($)** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1436 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)Standard Equation: **[ 4.0 ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A

-

$
-

$ 3,747.52

$ 4,684.40

$ Yes 39.31

$ 39.31

$ 3,786.83

$ 4,733.54

$ Yes 39.60

$ 78.91

$ 3,826.43

$ 4,783.04

$ No 447.36

$ 526.27

$ 4,273.79

$ 5,342.24

$

Standard Equation: **[ 5.1 ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Individual Cost Cum** **ulative Cost**

- $
-

$ $ 1,970.43 2,463.04 $ 11.12 $ 11.12

$ 1,981.55

$ 2,476.94

$ **MPC ($)** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1436 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes)
**Impact on Unit MPC**

**MPC ($)** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled RCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1000 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)

**Impact on Unit MPC MSP ($)** 

**MSP ($)**48.49 $ 59.61

$ 2,030.04

$ 2,537.55

$ 24.02 $ 83.63

$ 2,054.06

$ 2,567.58

$ 23.58 $ 107.21

$ 2,077.64

$ 2,597.05

$ 20.01 $ 127.22

$ 2,097.65

$ 2,622.06

$ 28.29 $ 155.51

$ 2,125.94

$ 2,657.42

$ 296.46 $ 451.97

$ 2,422.40

$ 3,028.00

$

Standard Equation: **[ 5.1 ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ $ 3,202.51 4,003.14 $ Yes 38.83

$ 38.83

$ 3,241.34

$ 4,051.67

$ Yes 106.20

$ 145.03

$ 3,347.54

$ 4,184.43

$ No 39.60

$ 184.63

$ 3,387.14

$ 4,233.92

$ Yes 73.99

$ 258.62

$ 3,461.13

$ 4,326.41

$ No 92.98

$ 351.60

$ 3,554.11

$ 4,442.64

$ No 447.36

$ 798.96

$ 4,001.47

$ 5,001.84

$

Standard Equation: **[ 18.0-0.0469*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled RCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 1000 lb/24 hours (Larger Sizes) **MPC ($) Impact on Unit MPC**  **MSP ($)**

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ $ 1,051.42 1,314.28 $ Yes 9.88

$ 9.88

$ 1,061.30

$ 1,326.62

$ Yes 45.88

$ 55.76

$ 1,107.18

$ 1,383.98

$ Yes 7.63

$ 63.39

$ 1,114.81

$ 1,393.51

$ No 30.18

$ 93.57

$ 1,144.99

$ 1,431.24

$ No 21.30

$ 114.87

$ 1,166.29

$ 1,457.86

$ No 15.50

$ 130.37

$ 1,181.79

$ 1,477.24

$ No 227.23

$ 357.60

$ 1,409.02

$ 1,761.27

$

Standard Equation: **[ 9.8 ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ $ 1,121.48 1,401.85 $ Yes 34.17

$ 34.17

$ 1,155.65

$ 1,444.56

$ Yes 12.12

$ 46.29

$ 1,167.77

$ 1,459.72

$ No 30.18

$ 76.47

$ 1,197.95

$ 1,497.44

$ Yes 12.15

$ 88.63

$ 1,210.11

$ 1,512.63

$ No 7.75

$ 96.37

$ 1,217.85

$ 1,522.31

$ No 23.13

$ 119.50

$ 1,240.98

$ 1,551.22

$ No 227.23

$ 346.73

$ 1,468.21

$ 1,835.26

$ **MSP ($) Impact on Unit MPC**  **Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)** 

**MPC ($)** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled SCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities less than 175 lb/24 hours **MSP ($)**



### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled SCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 175 lb/24 hoursStandard Equation: **[ 7.6 ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ $ 1,224.31 1,530.39 $ No 30.18

$ 30.18

$ 1,254.49

$ 1,568.12

$ Yes 16.17

$ 46.35

$ 1,270.66

$ 1,588.32

$ Yes 87.95

$ 134.29

$ 1,358.60

$ 1,698.26

$ No 21.44

$ 155.73

$ 1,380.04

$ 1,725.05

$ No 227.23

$ 382.96

$ 1,607.27

$ 2,009.09

$

Standard Equation: **[ 11.0-0.00629*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25 **Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ $ 2,705.55 3,381.93 $ Yes 28.17

$ 28.17

$ 2,733.71

$ 3,417.14

$ **Impact on Unit MPC**

**Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)**  **MSP ($)**

**MSP ($) MPC ($)**  

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Continuous Ice Machines with Capacities less than 700 lb/24 hours **Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled SCU Batch Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 200 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes)**Yes 7.86 $ 36.02

$ 2,741.57

$ 3,426.96

$ Yes 17.41

$ 53.44

$ 2,758.99

$ 3,448.73

$ No 5.60

$ 59.04

$ 2,764.59

$ 3,455.74

$ Yes 153.58

$ 212.62

$ 2,918.16

$ 3,647.71

$ No 315.07

$ 527.69

$ 3,233.23

$ 4,041.54

$

Standard Equation: **[ 6.6 ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25

**Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A $-
- $ $ 2,090.41 2,613.01 $ Yes 36.96

$ 36.96

$ 2,127.37

$ 2,659.21

$ Yes 10.18

$ 47.14

$ 2,137.55

$ 2,671.94

$ Yes 20.62

$ 67.77

$ 2,158.17

$ 2,697.72

$ No 13.32

$ 81.08

$ 2,171.49

$ 2,714.37

$ No 403.37

$ 484.45

$ 2,574.86

$ 3,218.57

$

Standard Equation: **[ 11.5-0.00629*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25 **MPC ($) MSP ($)**  **Impact on Unit MPC**



### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled SCU Continuous Ice Machines with Capacities less than 700 lb/24 hours **Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Air-Cooled IMH Continuous Ice Machines with Capacities greater than 700 lb/24 hours (Smaller Sizes) Able to Interpolate?**  **Individual Cost Cum** **ulative Cost**

N/A -

$
-

$ $ 1,411.05 1,763.81 $ Yes 10.24

$ 10.24

$ 1,421.29

$ 1,776.61

$ Yes 26.63

$ 36.87

$ 1,447.92

$ 1,809.90

$ Yes 13.19

$ 50.06

$ 1,461.11

$ 1,826.38

$ No 6.51

$ 56.57

$ 1,467.61

$ 1,834.52

$ No 317.38

$ 373.95

$ 1,784.99

$ 2,231.24

$

Standard Equation: **[ 10-0.00459*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25 **Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A $-
- $ $ 2,090.41 2,613.01 $ Yes 20.73

$ 20.73

$ 2,111.14

$ 2,638.92

$ Yes 21.63

$ 42.36

$ 2,132.77

$ 2,665.96

$ No 18.39

$ 60.75

$ 2,151.16

$ 2,688.94

$ Yes 46.52

$ 107.27

$ 2,197.67

$ 2,747.09

$ No 403.37

$ 510.63

$ 2,601.04

$ 3,251.30

$ **MSP ($)**

**Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)**  **MSP ($)** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours **Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)** Standard Equation: **[ 10.26-0.0086*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25 **Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A - $ 915.53

$ 1,144

$ Yes 4.20

$ 4.20

$ 919.73

$ 1,150

$ Yes 16.37

$ 20.57

$ 936.10

$ 1,170

$ Yes 12.15

$ 32.72

$ 948.25

$ 1,185

$ No 7.75

$ 40.47

$ 956.00

$ 1,195

$ Yes 34.51

$ 74.98

$ 990.51

$ 1,238

$ No 21.44

$ 96.42

$ 1,011.95

$ 1,265

$ No 218.71

$ 315.13

$ 1,230.66

$ 1,538

$

Standard Equation: **[ 6.89-0.0011*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25 **Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A -

$
-

$ 1,493.99

$ 1,867

$ Yes 21.00

$ 21.00

$ 1,514.99

$ 1,894

$ Yes 18.26

$ 39.26

$ 1,533.25

$ 1,917

$ No 6.67

$ 45.93

$ 1,539.92

$ 1,925

$ No 30.18

$ 76.11

$ 1,570.10

$ 1,963

$ No 20.01

$ 96.12

$ 1,590.11

$ 1,988

$ No 226.16

$ 322.28

$ 1,816.27

$ 2,270

$ **Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)**  **MSP ($)**

**Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)**  **MSP ($)** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours

**Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours**Standard Equation: **[ 7.79-0.0055*H ]** MSP Markup: 

### 1.25 **Able to Interpolate? Individual Cost** **Cum ulative Cost**  N/A

-

$
-

$ $898 1,122 $ Yes 20.71

$ 20.71

$ 918.69

$ 1,148

$ Yes 40.56

$ 61.28

$ 959.25

$ 1,199

$ No 30.18

$ 91.46

$ 989.43

$ 1,237

$ No 34.95

$ 126.41

$ 1,024.38

$ 1,280

$ No 218.71

$ 345.12

$ 1,243.09

$ 1,554

$ **Impact on Unit MPC MPC ($)**  **MSP ($)** 

### Manufacturing Cost and Energy Consumption Data for Water-Cooled IMH Batch Ice Machines with Capacities between 500 and 1436 lb/24 hours

## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level

**IMH-A -** *-B** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Small 19.3% 300 25.6 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,144.41 **EL2 10%**  $ 51.35$ 64.19 **EL3 15%**  $ 91.16$ 113.95 **EL4 20%**  $ 130.98$ 163.72 **EL5 25%**  $ 377.07$ 471.33 **EL6 26%**  $ 381.16$ 476.45 **EL7 22-inch Max-Tech**  **18.1%** $ 115.54$ 144.42 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0.00 $51.35 $91.16 $130.98



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-A -** *-B** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Large-1 16.1% 800 22.7 **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,867.49 **EL2 10%**  $ 44.74$ 55.93 **EL3 15%**  $ 85.76$ 107.20 **EL4 20%**  $ 147.11$ 183.89 **EL5 23%**  $ 377.59$ 471.98 **EL6 EL7**  **22-inch Max-Tech 15.6%**  $ 88.19$ 110.24 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0.00 $44.74 $85.76 $147.11



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-A -** *-B** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Large-2 6.0% 1500 20.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 2,064.97 **EL2 10%**  $ 413.22$ 516.52 **EL3 12%**  $ 452.27$ 565.34 **EL4 EL5**  **EL6 EL7**  

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0.00 $413.22 $452.27 $0.00 **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level

**IMH-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Small 19.2% 300 24.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,122.47 **EL2 10%**  $ 40.10$ 50.13 **EL3 15%**  $ 70.18$ 87.73 **EL4 20%**  $ 136.13$ 170.17 **EL5 23.9%**  $ 363.78$ 454.72 **EL6 EL7**  **22-inch Max-Tech 21.5%**  $ 345.11$ 431.39 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $40 $70 $136



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Medium 14.3% 850 19.7 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,931.34 **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** **EL2 10%**  $111.78 $ 139.72

**EL3 15%**  $226.29 $ 282.86 **EL4 19%**  $ 471.17$ 588.97 **EL5 EL6**  **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $112 $226 $471

**IMH-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Large-1 5% 1500 22.3 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 2,136.04 **EL2 8%**  $ 423.64$ 529.55 **EL3 EL4**  **EL5 EL6**  **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $424 $0 $0 **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level

**IMH-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Large-2 2.5% 2600 19.7
**Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 4,684.40 **EL2 7%**  $ 526.27$ 657.84 **EL3 EL4**  **EL5 EL6**  **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $526 $0 $0



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **RCU-NRC-Large-B-1 Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Large-1 15.7% 1500 20.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 2,463.04 **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** **EL2 10%**  $ 43.56$ 54.45

**EL3 15%**  $ 82.07$ 102.58 **EL4 20%**  $ 410.93$ 513.67 **EL5 21.7%**  $ 451.97$ 564.96 **EL6 EL7**  

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $44 $82 $411



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **RCU-NRC-Large-B-2 Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Large-2 14.9% 2400 19.7 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 4,003.14 **EL2 10%**  $ 102.29$ 127.86 **EL3 15%**  $ 217.11$ 271.39 **EL4 20%**  $ 754.38$ 942.97 **EL5 21.2%**  $ 798.96$ 998.70 **EL6 EL7**  

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $102 $217 $754 **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level

**SCU-A -** *-B** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Small 31.2% 110 34.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,314.28 **EL2 10%**  $ 22.22$ 27.77 **EL3 15%**  $ 36.24$ 45.30 **EL4 20%**  $ 50.26$ 62.83 **EL5 25%**  $ 94.99$ 118.74 **EL6 30%**  $ 129.82$ 162.28 **EL7 32.7%**  357.60 $ $ 446.99 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $22 $36 $50



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **SCU-A -** *-B** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Large 27.9% 200 30.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,401.85 **EL2 10%**  $ 39.22$ 49.03 **EL3 15%**  $ 44.84$ 56.04 **EL4 20%**  $ 74.01$ 92.51 **EL5 25%**  $ 96.37$ 120.47 **EL6 29%**  $ 346.73$ 433.41 **EL7 EL1**  **EL2 EL3**  **EL4**

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $39 $45 $74



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **SCU-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Large 27.6% 300 30.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,530.39 **EL2 10%**  $ 42.56$ 53.21 **EL3 15%**  $ 68.03$ 85.04 **EL4 20%**  $ 94.38$ 117.98 **EL5 25%**  $ 120.73$ 150.91 **EL6 30%**  $ 370.17$ 462.71 **EL7 32.4%**  382.96 $ $ 478.70 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $43 $68 $94


## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-A -** *-C** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Small 25.4% 310 12.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1** $ -$ 3,381.93 **EL2 10%**  $ 31.58$ 39.48 **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** **EL3 15%**  $ 48.44$ 60.55

**EL4 20%**  $ 112.87$ 141.09 **EL5 25%**  $ 419.08$ 523.85 **EL6 29%**  $ 527.69$ 659.61 **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $32 $48 $113


## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-A -** *-C** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Large 17.0% 820 13.6 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1** $ - 2,613.01 $ **EL2 10%**  $ 30.01 37.52 $ **EL3 15%**  $ 45.10 56.37 $ **EL4 20%**  $ 474.40 593.00 $ **EL5 23%**  $ 484.45 605.56 $ **EL6 EL7**  

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $30 $45 $474


## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **SCU-A -** *-C** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  **EL2 EL3**  **EL4 EL1**  **EL2 EL3**  **EL4**

**EL1**Small 24.4% 220 12.0

**Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1** $ - 1,763.81 $ **EL2 10%**  $ 12.04 15.04 $ **EL3 15%**  $ 24.24 30.30 $ **EL4 20%**  $ 36.45 45.56 $ **EL5 25%**  $ 365.44 456.80 $ **EL6 28.5%**  $ 373.95 467.43 $ **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

$0 $12 $24 $36



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Medium 18.4% 800 12.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 2,613.01 **EL2 10%**  $ 29.75$ 37.18 **EL3 15%**  $ 53.25$ 66.56 **EL4 20%**  $ 79.42$ 99.28 **EL5 25%**  $ 496.52$ 620.65 **EL6 27%**  $ 510.63$ 638.29 **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

- $ $30 $53 $79

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4**  **EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level

**IMH-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Medium 16.6% 300 18.5 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,144.41 **EL2 10%**  $ 48.30$ 60.37 **EL3 15%**  $ 291.82$ 364.78 **EL4 18%**  $ 315.13$ 393.91 **EL5 EL6**  **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

- $ $48 $292 $315



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-A -** *-B** **Max Available Rep. Harvest Rate** **Potable Water - Cont. (gal/100 lb)**  Medium 5.5% 800 18.0 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,867.49 **EL2 10%**  $69.66 $ 87.07 **EL3 15%**  $318.59 $ 398.24 **EL4 15.6%**  $322.28 $ 402.85 **EL5 EL6**  **EL7** 

## Transcription for Summary Table

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** 

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** -

$ $70 $319 $322



## Table of EL Levels Original Water Level **IMH-W-***-B Max Available**  **Rep. Harvest Rate Potable Water - Cont.**  **(gal/100 lb)** Medium 16.9% 300 23.9 **Eff. Lvl. No. Reduc. From Baseline** **Incremental MPC MSP & Incr. MSP** 

**EL1 0%**  $ -$ 1,122.47 **EL2 10%**  $ 40.10$ 50.13 **EL3 15%**  $ 74.34$ 92.93 **EL4 20%**  $ 331.02$ 413.77 **EL5 21.5%**  $ 345.12$ 431.40 **EL6 EL7**  

## Transcription for Summary Table

- $ $40 $74 $331

**EL1 EL2**  **EL3 EL4** **Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  25.6 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

25.60 N/A 25.60 Direct Interpolation 25.60 Direct Interpolation 25.60 Direct Interpolation 25.60 Indirect Interpolation 25.5% $ 381.16 25.60 Max-Tech 25.60
**Level Cost**  $377.07 $381.16 $0.00 26% $381.16
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

**EL3** New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 NA **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation Potable Water (gal/100lb)**  **Interpolation**

22.70 N/A 22.70 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 16.7% $92.98 20.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Max-Tech 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 16.7% $92.98
**Level Cost**  $377.59 $0.00 $0.00 23% $377.59
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

20.00 N/A 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 12% 452 $ 20.00 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 12% $452.27 **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 

**EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?** 

**EL2** New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 152.55 **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

24.00 N/A 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 18% 100 $ 20.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 20.8% 145 $ 20.00 Max-Tech 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 23.9% 364 $
**Level Cost**  $364 $0 $0 24% $364
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  19.7 153.00 **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

19.70 N/A **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**19.70 Direct Interpolation

19.70 Direct Interpolation 19.70 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $0 $0 $0 19% $471
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A

**Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  22.3 162 **Interpolation** 22.30 N/A 22.30 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $0 $0 $0 8% $424 **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 

**EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?** 

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  19.7 174.00 **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

19.70 N/A 19.70 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $0 $0 $0 7% $526
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

20.00 N/A **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 

**Numbers for alternate interpolation Numbers for alternate interpolation** 20.00 Direct Interpolation

20.00 Indirect Interpolation 15.3% $83.63 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 21.7% $451.97 20.00 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $452 $0 $0 22% $452
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  19.7 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

19.70 N/A 19.70 Direct Interpolation 19.70 Direct Interpolation 19.70 Indirect Interpolation 21.2% $798.96 19.70 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $799 $0 $0 21% $799
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

**EL5 EL6**  **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**EL7 Max Tech**  **EL5**New Water Level

**Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

34.00 N/A 34.00 Direct Interpolation 34.00 Direct Interpolation 34.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 28.9% $114.87 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 30.2% $130.37 20.00 Max-Tech
**Level Cost**  $95 $130 $358 33% $358
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

**EL4** New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

30.00 N/A 30.00 Direct Interpolation 30.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 22.2% $76.47 20.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Max-Tech **Numbers for alternate interpolation Numbers for alternate interpolation** 

**EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** **Level Cost** 

$96 $347 $0 29% $347
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

**EL2** New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 131.9 **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

30.00 N/A 20.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 32.4% 382.96 $ 20.00 Max-Tech
**Level Cost**  $121 $370 $383 32% $383 **Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  12.0 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

12.00 N/A 12.00 Direct Interpolation **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 

**EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**12.00 Indirect Interpolation 18.2% 59.04 $ 12.00 Indirect Interpolation 12.00 Indirect Interpolation 28.7% 527.69 $ 12.00 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $419 $528 $0 29% $528 **Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

**N/A** New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  13.6 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

13.60 N/A 13.60 Direct Interpolation 13.60 Direct Interpolation 13.60 Indirect Interpolation 23.3% $484.45 13.60 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $484 $0 $0 23% $484 **Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 12.0 NA

**Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

12.00 N/A 12.00 Direct Interpolation 12.00 Direct Interpolation 12.00 Direct Interpolation 12.00 Indirect Interpolation 28.5% 373.95 $ 12.00 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $365 $374 $0 28% $374
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  12.0 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

12.00 N/A 12.00 Direct Interpolation 12.00 Indirect Interpolation 17.9% 60.75 $ 12.00 Direct Interpolation 12.00 Indirect Interpolation 26.6% 510.63 $ 12.00 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $497 $511 $0 27% $511 **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation EL5**  **EL6 EL7**  **Max Tech Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?** 

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  18.5 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

18.50 N/A 18.50 Direct Interpolation 18.50 Indirect Interpolation 18.1% 315.13 $ 18.50 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $0 $0 $0 18% $315
**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

N/A New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  18.0 NA **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

18.00 N/A 18.00 Indirect Interpolation 11.0% 76.11 $ 18.00 Indirect Interpolation 15.6% 322.28 $ 18.00 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech** 

**EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**$0 $0 $0 16% $322

**Use Potable Water Design Option at Which EL?**

EL3 New Water Level **Potable Water-batch (gal/100 lb)**  **Condenser Water (gal/100 lb)**  20.0 193.00 **Potable Water (gal/100lb) Interpolation** 

23.90 N/A 23.90 Direct Interpolation 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 16.9% 91.46 $ 20.00 Indirect Interpolation 21.5% 345.12 $ 20.00 Max-Tech

**Level Cost**  $345 $0 $0 22% $345 **EL5 EL6**  **EL7 Max Tech**  **Numbers for alternate interpolation**0.5% 12.8% $102.01 **Numbers for alternate interpolation**1.7% 9.0% $37.88

1.1% 9.0% $37.88

1.8% 3.1% $68.77 **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**8.3% 8.2% $49.47

0.8% 0.8% $9.75

0.8% 9.75

$ 1.5% 8.2% $49.47 **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation Numbers for alternate interpolation** **Numbers for alternate interpolation Numbers for alternate interpolation** 0.3% 9.9% $48.49

0.9% 1.6% $23.58 0.8% $28.29

1.2% 2.0% $73.99 **Numbers for alternate interpolation**3.9% 1.5% $7.63

0.2% 16.4% $45.88

2.2% 10.8% $12.12 **Numbers for alternate interpolation Numbers for alternate interpolation** 2.4% 16.7%$87.95 **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**0.9% 9.0%$28.17

3.2% 2.3% $7.86 3.7% 5.2%$153.58

3.3% 3.4% $10.183.5% 10.9% $26.63

2.9% 8.1% $20.73 1.6% 5.2% $46.52 **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**3.1% 4.5% $34.51

1.0% 3.3% 21.00

$ 0.6% 3.3% 21.00

$ **Numbers for alternate interpolation**

**Numbers for alternate interpolation**1.9% 6.7% 61.28 $ 1.5% 6.7% 61.28

$ **Numbers for alternate interpolation**