2/24/2010 Cost Data Verification of the MCBAT Tool

Item

Control 

Measure

Type of 

Monitoring Type of Cost

Capital/

Annual

Original 

Cost in Tool

Able to 

Reconfigure 

Cost?

Modified Cost 

($2008) References Notes

CO CO CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual $ 9,331.48 Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

HCl HCl CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual $ 9,331.48 Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

VOC CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

Organic HAP CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

PM(fine) 

condensable Yes $ 5,712.27 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

PM/PM(fine) 

filterable Yes $ 5,712.27 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

PM(fine) 

condensable Yes $ 5,712.27 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

PM/PM(fine) 

filterable Yes $ 5,712.27 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

PM(fine) 

condensable Yes $ 5,712.27 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

PM/PM(fine) 

filterable Yes $ 5,712.27 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

SO2 SO2 CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual $ 9,331.48 Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

Hg Hg CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual $ 16,507.86 Yes $ 11,772.18 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

Hg Hg CEMS Annual RATA Annual $ 34,837.68 Yes $ 35,774.52 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

Hg Hg CEMS Cylinder Gas Audits Annual $ 17,730.86 Yes $ 17,741.54 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

VOC CEMS Annual Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

Organic HAP CEMS Annual Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

VOC CEMS Annual Yes $ 8,535.09 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

Organic HAP CEMS Annual Yes $ 8,535.09 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

VOC CEMS Annual Yes $ 1,470.74 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

Organic HAP CEMS Annual Yes $ 1,470.74 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

VOC (outlet only) $ 9,132.75

$ 8,097.92

$ 8,097.92

PM (beta 

gauge)

PM 

(extractive)

CEMS

CEMS

Recordkeeping and 

Reporting Annual

$ 12,554.10 VOC (inlet 

and outlet)

Day-to-Day Activities

Annual RATA

Recordkeeping and 

Reporting Annual

$ 8,698.01 VOC (inlet 

and outlet) Recordkeeping and 

Reporting

CEMS

Annual

Recordkeeping and 

Reporting

PM (in situ) $ 8,097.92

VOC (inlet 

and outlet) $ 11,465.89

Page 1 of 5
2/24/2010 Cost Data Verification of the MCBAT Tool

Item

Control 

Measure

Type of 

Monitoring Type of Cost

Capital/

Annual

Original 

Cost in Tool

Able to 

Reconfigure 

Cost?

Modified Cost 

($2008) References Notes

NOX NOX CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual $ 9,331.48 Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

CO2 CO2 CEMS Day-to-Day Activities Annual $ 9,331.48 Yes $ 6,798.93 

RTI CEMS 2007 

Spreadsheet

$3,742.43 Control Cost Manual

$946.28 

Labor sheet handed 

down from Kathy

$3,742.43 Control Cost Manual

$946.28 

Labor sheet handed 

down from Kathy

$3,742.43 Control Cost Manual

$946.28 

Labor sheet handed 

down from Kathy

$3,742.43 Control Cost Manual

$946.28 

Labor sheet handed 

down from Kathy

Carbon Injection 

Rate

Carbon 

Injection CPMS Support Facilities Annual $5,200.00 No

Face 

Velocity/Flow 

Rate

Capture 

Devices CPMS Support Facilities Annual

$5,200.00

No

Flame Detector 

w/Equip. Inspect. Flare

CPMS Support Facilities Annual

$5,200.00

No

Gas Flow Rate Capture 

Devices CPMS QAQC Plan Annual $10,358.94 No

Gas Flow Rate 

(Steam)

Carbon 

Adsorber CPMS QAQC Plan Annual $10,358.94 No

Lime Flow Rate 

(Liquid)

Lime-injected 

Fabric Filter CPMS QAQC Plan Annual

$10,358.94

No

Lime Flow Rate 

and BLD (1 

sensor)

Lime-injected 

Fabric Filter CPMS QAQC Plan Annual

$10,358.94

No

SCR/Wet 

Scrubber

Air-to-fuel data costs were said 

to be half of CEMS VOC 

inlet/outlet costs per 6/127/09 

CPMS Purchased Equipment Annual No notes (mtg?)

Air-to-fuel Data $66,885.00

Flare

Regenerative 

Thermal 

Yes

$19,021.00

Annual

Recordkeeping and 

CPMS Reporting

Low Sulfur 

Fuel/Feed

Fuel Analysis and 

Records

Lime Flow Rate 

and BLD (1 

sensor)

Pressure Drop 

and Liquid Flow 

Rate

Venturi 

Scrubber for 

PM Control CPMS

Yes

$7,956.00

Annual

Recordkeeping and 

CPMS Reporting

Lime-injected 

Fabric Filter

Recordkeeping and 

Reporting Annual

$6,822.00

Yes

Yes

$19,021.00

Annual

Recordkeeping and 

CPMS Reporting

Use Low/No 

HAP Material

Product Analysis 

(Coatings and 

Solvents)

Page 2 of 5
2/24/2010 Cost Data Verification of the MCBAT Tool

Item

Control 

Measure

Type of 

Monitoring Type of Cost

Capital/

Annual

Original 

Cost in Tool

Able to 

Reconfigure 

Cost?

Modified Cost 

($2008) References Notes

Water 

Injection for 

Gas 

Temperature 

Reduction

Wet Scrubber

Wet ScrubberFGD/acid gas

NH3 Injection 

Rate

SCR/NSCR/S

NCR CPMS Support Facilities Annual $5,200.00 No

O2/CO2 (Excess 

Air) Monitor

Process 

Equipment 

and Operation 

for CO CPMS Support Facilities Annual

$5,200.00

No

Dry ESP

CPMS

Dry FGD with 

Fabric 

Filter/ESP CPMS

Dry ESP CPMS

Dry FGD with 

Fabric 

Filter/ESP CPMS

Pressure Drop Capture 

Devices CPMS

Performance Test 

Audits Capital $16,140.00 No

Pressure Drop 

(Vacuum)

Carbon 

Adsorber CPMS

Performance Test 

Audits Capital $16,140.00 No

Pressure Drop 

and Liquid Flow 

Rate

Venturi 

Scrubber for 

PM Control CPMS

Performance Test 

Audits Capital

$16,647.55

No

Pressure Drop 

and Liquid Flow 

Rate

Venturi 

Scrubber for 

PM Control CPMS QAQC Plan Capital

$10,358.94

No

Support facilities for Current is 

400 according to RTI Electrical 

Current CPMS spreadsheet 

($2007); 600 for voltage 

($2007); opacity is 1000 

($2008); assume V/C/P is $1500

annual accuracy audits for 

Current is 157 according to RTI 

Electrical Current CPMS 

spreadsheet and for voltage; 50 

CPMS QAQC Plan Annual No

$10,358.94

Support Facilities

Performance Test 

Audits Capital

Capital

Liquid Flow Rate

Opacity and 

Voltage/Current/P

ower

Opacity and 

Voltage/Current/P

ower

Yes

$5,200.00

$16,299.15

 $ 2,561.30 

 $ 540.25 

Condenser

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Current, Voltage

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Yes Current, Voltage

Page 3 of 5
2/24/2010 Cost Data Verification of the MCBAT Tool

Item

Control 

Measure

Type of 

Monitoring Type of Cost

Capital/

Annual

Original 

Cost in Tool

Able to 

Reconfigure 

Cost?

Modified Cost 

($2008) References Notes

Process 

Equipment 

and Operation 

for NOX 

(EGR)

Process 

Equipment 

and Operation 

for NOX 

(LNB/OFA)

Temperature 

(inlet) and 

Monthly 

Inspections

SCR/NSCR/S

NCR

CPMS

Performance Test 

Audits Capital

$16,140.00

Yes $ 163.42 

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Temperature

Annual accuracy audits for 

Current is 157 according to RTI 

Temperature CPMS spreadsheet

Dry ESP 

followed by 

Ambient 

Temp. Fabric 

Filter

Dry FGD with 

Fabric 

Filter/ESP

Dry ESP 

followed by 

Ambient 

Temp. Fabric 

Filter

Dry FGD with 

Fabric 

Filter/ESP

Voltage/Current/P

ower

Electrified 

Filter Bed

CPMS Support Facilities Capital

$5,200.00

Yes $ 1,561.30 

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Current, Voltage

Support facilities for Current is 

400 according to RTI Electrical 

Current CPMS spreadsheet; 600 

for voltage; assume V/C/P is 

$1500

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Temperature

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Temperature, Current, 

Voltage

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Temperature, Current, 

Voltage

Annual accuracy audits is 157 

according to RTI Temperature 

CPMS spreadsheet

Annual accuracy audits for 

Current is 157 according to RTI 

Temperature CPMS spreadsheet 

and for voltage/current

Support facilities for Current is 

400 according to RTI Electrical 

Current CPMS spreadsheet and 

for temperature; assume V/C/P 

is $1500

Performance Test 

CPMS Audits Capital Yes

Performance Test 

Audits Capital

CPMS Support Facilities Capital

CPMS

Yes

Yes $ 163.42 

 $ 1,977.64 

 $ 653.66 

Temperature $16,140.00

Thermal 

Oxidizer

$16,140.00

$5,200.00

Temperature and 

Voltage/Current/P

ower

Temperature and 

Voltage/Current/P

ower

Page 4 of 5
2/24/2010 Cost Data Verification of the MCBAT Tool

Item

Control 

Measure

Type of 

Monitoring Type of Cost

Capital/

Annual

Original 

Cost in Tool

Able to 

Reconfigure 

Cost?

Modified Cost 

($2008) References Notes

Voltage/Current/P

ower and Liquid 

Flow Rate

Wet ESP

CPMS Support Facilities Capital

$5,200.00

Yes $ 2,561.30 

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Current, Voltage

Support facilities for Current is 

400 according to RTI Electrical 

Current CPMS spreadsheet; 600 

for voltage

Voltage/Current/P

ower

Electrified 

Filter Bed CPMS Purchased Equipment Capital

$270.00

Yes

RTI CPMS 

Spreadsheets for 

Current, Voltage

690 for current according to RTI 

Current CPMS spreadsheet; 

8170 for voltage

Voltage/Current/P

ower and Liquid 

Flow Rate

Wet ESP

CPMS Purchased Equipment Capital

$20,958.54

Yes: $4,270 

add up costs for 

Voltage/Current/Power and 

Liquid Flow Rate

Voltage/Current/P

ower and Liquid 

Flow Rate

Wet ESP

CPMS QAQC Plan Capital

$10,358.94

$3,742.43 Control Cost Manual

$946.28 

Labor sheet handed 

down from Kathy

Product Analysis 

(Coatings and 

Solvents)

Use Low/No 

HAP Material

Periodic

Annual Accuracy 

Audits Annual

$25,073.00

No

Yes

Fuel Analysis and 

Records

Low 

Sulfur/Fuel 

Feed Periodic

Recordkeeping and 

Reporting Annual

$25,073.00

Page 5 of 5