# l}«?t.W

5 ^£.n,cAcr>,lpe^'\<^^ / in1'5a$/a^i(-oG-i ^ m k •.-PARTMEN TO F '<Hy ? -.-•iSPCRTATlO N

:.E TOPERATION S

IIRECTOR S i ATE O F MICHIGA N RICKSNYDE R DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N ^ , , .KlRX^X.-SJEjJDL E GOVERNO

R , 1 : n [•q yil l A! ; Q OIR—" " Novembe r

5 , 2O H

Mr . Denni s DeVan

y Chief , Essentia l Ai r Servic e Divisio n Offic e o f Aviatio nAnalysi s U S Departmen t o f Tisanspgrtation 1200_^N.ev

j Jerse yAve , S E Washington , D C 2 05 9 0 RE : DOT-OST-2009CJOO , DOT-OST-2003-15128 , DOT-OST-1999-5175 , DOT-OST-2011

- 0133 , DOT-OST-2009-030 3 Dea r Mr . DeVany : Th e Michiga nDepartmen t o f Transportation , Offic e o f Aeronautic s i s th e agenc yresponsibl e fo r th e preservatio nan d promotio no f ai r servic e throughou t th e Stat e o f Michigan . A s such , w e offe r th e followin g comment s i. nrespons e t o th e proposal s receive d unde r th e respectiv e USDO T dockets : DOT-OST-2009-030 0 (Alpena Comit yRegiona l Airport ) Vi econcu r wit hth e positio nexpresse d byth e Alpen a Count yBoar d o f Commissioner s tha t extensioi L o f th e du e dat e fo r respons e t o the RF P woul d b e i n th e community' s bes t interest . Th e proposal s received , t o dcite , woul d no t adequatel yaddres s th e vita l transportatio nneed s o f th e community . Pleas e conside r extendin g th e du e dat e fo r th e RFP , o r reopenin g th e selectio nprocess . Thi s wil l allo wadditiona l time fo r th e cominunit yt o see k ou t alternative s providers/proposals . 

## ti ( B S C 6i^^^ ] DOT-OST-2003-1512 8 (Delt a Count yAirpo r W e believ e th e proposa l offere d byDelt a Airline s provide s th e greates t economi c benefi t and jo bcreatio nopportunitie s fo r th e greate r Delt a Count yServic e .'^rea . W e suppor t selectio no f "Optio n1 " a s outline d i nDelta' s proposal . Th e associate d schedul e offer s 1 4 round tri p flight s pe r wee k - a leve l o f necessar yt o provid e th e greates t economi c benefi t t o th e community . DOT-OST-1999-517 5 (Ford Airport ) ( )^^'*- ^V^I XiX-w'^<2-«-

W W e suppor t selectio no f th e proposa l offere d b yGrea t Lake s Airlines . Th e servic e outline d i n thei r proposa l woul d provid e a superio r schedul e a s wel l a s th e stabilit yo f an established , certifie d ai r carrier . Grea t Lakes ' proposal , als o offer s appropriate-size d aircraf t whic hwoul d bette r serv e th e cornm.unitie s serve d b yFord Airport .

MURRA YD VA N WAGONE R BUILDIN G •PC

. BO X3005 0 •LANSING , MICHIGA N 4890 9 swvvw.michigan.go

v•(517 ) .373-2090 LH-LAN- 0 (01/11 )Mr . Denni s DeVany

Pag e 2 Novembe r 5 , 2 J.; . 1

DOT-OST-2011-013 3 (Pellsto nRegiona l Airport ) Whil e th e singl e responden t t o th e RFP , Delt a Airline s offere d thre e servic e option s wit hvaryin g subsidyrequirements . W e believ e "Optio n 1, " whic hprovide s 1 4 weekl yflight s throughou t th e year , offer s th e greates t benefi t t o th e community . T]i e schedul e unde r Optio n1 offer s consistenc yand , likely , mor e reliabl e service . Thi s i s particularl ytru e give nth e unpredictabl e v;eather experience d i nNorther nMichigan . Th e uniformit yo f th e schedul e wil l als o enhanc e year-round jo bcreatio nand economi c development . ent . _ \ DQT-OST-2009-030 3 (Chippewa Count yInternationa l Airport ) W e suppor t "Optio n1 " o f Delt a Airline' s proposa l t o serv e Chippew a Count yInternationa l Airport . A s explaine d i nth e previou s docket , Optio n1 provide s a consisten t leve l o f servic e whic hwil l allo wbot hth e maximizatio no f economi c developmen t opportunitie s and th e schedul e reliabilit ynecessar yt o servic e th e travelin g public . Optio n2 doe s no t provid e th e sam e leve l o f servic e and woul d likel yresul t i nsignifican t delay s fo r weekend traveler s i n th e even t o f cancelle d flight . Ou r offic e v/oul

d lik e t o expres s ou r appreciatio nfo r you r continue d thoroughnes s and professionalis mdurin g wha t mus t b e anunusuall ychallengin g period . Yo u and you r staf f ar e t o b e commende d fo r handing th e additiona l workloa d i na seamles s fashion . Than k yo u fo r th e opportunit yt o commen t o nth e Essentia l Ai r Servic e carrie r selectio nprocess . I f yo u hav e an yquestions , pleas e contac t m e a t 517-335

- 991 8 o r brinkerm3mi.gov . Sinc^ely , ^...--

- -. , / / { / Matthe wV . Brinke r Ai r Servic e Specialis t Michiga nDepartmen t o f Transportatio n Offic e o f Aeronautic s