U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE

WASHINGTON : 

For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office,

http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center,

U.S. Government Printing Office. Phone 202–512–1800, or 866–512–1800 (toll-free). E-mail, gpo@custhelp.com.

57–952 PDF 2010

S. Hrg. 111–691 

IMPEACHMENT TRIAL COMMITTEE 

ON THE ARTICLES AGAINST 

JUDGE G. THOMAS PORTEOUS, JR. 

HEARINGS 

BEFORE THE

SENATE IMPEACHMENT TRIAL 

COMMITTEE 

UNITED STATES SENATE 

ONE HUNDRED ELEVENTH CONGRESS 

SECOND SESSION 

ON 

THE ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT AGAINST JUDGE G. THOMAS 

PORTEOUS, JR., A JUDGE IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA 

November 16, 2010 

Volume 1 of 3, Part A 

( 

Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.access.gpo.gov/congress/senate 

ii 

IMPEACHMENT TRIAL COMMITTEE ON THE ARTICLES 

AGAINST JUDGE G. THOMAS PORTEOUS, JR. 

CLAIRE MCCASKILL, Missouri, Chairman 

ORRIN G. HATCH, Utah, Vice Chairman 

AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota 

SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island 

TOM UDALL, New Mexico 

JEANNE SHAHEEN, New Hampshire 

EDWARD E. KAUFMAN, Delaware 

JIM DEMINT, South Carolina 

JOHN BARRASSO, Wyoming 

ROGER WICKER, Mississippi 

MIKE JOHANNS, Nebraska 

JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho 

COMMITTEE STAFF 

DERRON R. PARKS, Staff Director and Chief Counsel 

THOMAS L. JIPPING, Deputy Staff Director and Deputy Chief Counsel 

JUSTIN KIM, Counsel 

REBECCA S. SEIDEL, Counsel 

ERIN P. JOHNSON, Deputy Counsel and Chief Clerk 

LAKE DISHMAN, Professional Staff Member 

CONGRESSIONAL RESEARCH SERVICE STAFF 

SUSAN NAVARRO SMELCER, Analyst on the Federal Judiciary 

SENATE LEGAL COUNSEL STAFF 

MORGAN J. FRANKEL, Senate Legal Counsel 

PATRICIA MACK BRYAN, Deputy Senate Legal Counsel 

GRANT R. VINIK, Assistant Senate Legal Counsel 

THOMAS E. CABALLERO, Assistant Senate Legal Counsel 

iii 

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 

The Committee gratefully acknowledges the high standard of professionalism and 

long hours of dedicated service of its staff. The Committee also expresses its appreciation to Lynden C. Armstrong, Chief Clerk of the Committee on Rules and Administration, and to the following staff of Committee members: 

STAFF OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS 

Senator MCCASKILL, Chairman, Derron R. Parks 

Senator HATCH, Vice Chairman, Thomas L. Jipping 

Senator KLOBUCHAR, Paige Herwig 

Senator WHITEHOUSE, Stephen C. N. Lilley and Justin G. Florence 

Senator UDALL, Matthew T. Nelson 

Senator SHAHEEN, Thomas J. Maloney 

Senator KAUFMAN, Nhan Nguyen 

Senator DEMINT, Erica Suares 

Senator BARRASSO, Bryn Stewart 

Senator WICKER, Emily Ferris 

Senator JOHANNS, Sarah Novascone 

Senator RISCH, Jason Bohrer 

INTERNS 

Christian Dibblee 

Timothy Holman 

Hannah Lockhart 

Annie Moulton 

Michael Naclerio 

Patrick Sadler 

v 

C O N T E N T S 

VOLUME 1 

PART 1A 

I. Preliminary Matters ......................................................................................... 1 

a. Articles of Impeachment Against Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. (H. 

Res. 1031, 111th Cong., 2d Sess. (2010)) .................................................... 3 

b. Issuance of the Writ of Summons, S. Res. 457, 111th Cong., 2d Sess. 

(2010) ............................................................................................................. 12 

c. Authorization to Appoint Impeachment Trial Committee, S. Res. 458, 

111th Cong., 2d Sess. (2010) ........................................................................ 15 

d. Appointment of Impeachment Trial Committee (156 Cong. Rec. S1647- 

01, March 17, 2010) ...................................................................................... 18 

e. Writ of Summons (April 7, 2010) ................................................................ 19 

f. Answer of Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr., to the Articles of Impeachment (April 7, 2010) ...................................................................................... 21 

g. Replication of the House of Representatives to the Answer of Judge 

G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. (April 15, 2010) ................................................... 38 

h. Amended Replication of the House of Representatives to the Answer 

of Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. (April 22, 2010) .................................... 51 

i. Organizational Meeting of the Impeachment Trial Committee (April 

13, 2010) ........................................................................................................ 64 

j. House Managers’ Scheduling Letter (May 11, 2010) .................................. 76 

k. COMMITTEE ORDER: SITC Scheduling Order (May 26, 2010) ............. 79 

II. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Prior to the August 4, 

2010 Hearing on Pre-Trial Motions ................................................................ 81 

a. Discovery Matters 

i. General Issues 

1. House Managers’ Discovery Letter (April 13, 2010) .......................... 83 

2. House Managers’ Letter Requesting a Meeting (April 15, 2010) ...... 89 

3. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Discovery from House Managers (May 

28, 2010) ................................................................................................. 91 

4. House Managers’ Response to Judge Porteous Motion for Discovery 

from the House Managers (June 4, 2010) ............................................ 112 

5. House Managers’ Motion for Reciprocal Discovery from Judge 

Porteous (May 28, 2010) ........................................................................ 122 

6. Judge Porteous’s Response to the Motion of the House Managers 

for Discovery (June 4, 2010) ................................................................. 156 

7. COMMITTEE ORDER: SITC Disposition of Discovery Issues (June 

9, 2010) ................................................................................................... 159 

8. House Managers’ Exhibits Letter (June 15, 2010) ............................. 161 

ii. Depositions ................................................................................................ 163 

1. Judge Porteous’s Notice regarding Possible Future Deposition Requests (May 28, 2010) ............................................................................ 165 

2. House Managers’ Response to the Judge Porteous Notice regarding 

Possible Future Deposition Requests (June 4, 2010) .......................... 168 

3. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Authority to Issue, or Assistance 

in Issuing, Deposition Subpoenas (June 30, 2010) ............................. 170 

4. House Managers’ Opposition to Judge Porteous’s Motion for Authority to Issue, or Assistance in Issuing, Deposition Subpoenas 

(July 7, 2010) .......................................................................................... 180 

5. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (July 15, 2010) ..................... 204 

6. Adoption of Impeachment Trial Committee Rules (156 Cong. Rec. 

S5988-02, July 19, 2010) ....................................................................... 205 

7. Judge Porteous’s Request to Tape Depositions (July 27, 2010) ........ 207 

8. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (August 2, 2010) .................. 209 

iii. Motion to Compel .................................................................................... 211 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Compel Inspection of Non-Privileged 

Materials Collected and Maintained by the House of Representatives and Request for Expedited Consideration (June 27, 2010) ....... 213 

vi 

II. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Prior to the August 4, 

2010 Hearing on Pre-Trial Motions—Continued 

iii. Motion to Compel—Continued 

2. House Managers’ Consolidated Opposition to Judge Porteous Motion to Compel and Motions for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

(July 1, 2010) .......................................................................................... 255 

3. Correspondence related to Judge Porteous’s Motion to Compel ........ 282 

a. Judge Porteous’s Letter in Support of Motion to Compel (July 

1, 2010) ................................................................................................ 282 

b. House Managers’ Response Letter (July 2, 2010) ........................... 285 

c. Judge Porteous’s Reply Letter (July 2, 2010) .................................. 293 

4. COMMITTEE ORDER: SITC Order on Judge Porteous’s Motion 

to Compel and for Depositions (July 19, 2010) ................................... 296 

iv. Motions for Assistance in Securing Discovery from Third Parties ...... 299 

1. Metropolitan Crime Commission (MCC) and American Bar Association (ABA) 

a. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

from the Metropolitan Crime Commission (June 27, 2010) ........... 301 

b. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

from the American Bar Association (June 30, 2010) ....................... 310 

c. Judge Porteous’s Notice of ABA Refusal to Provide Documents 

Voluntarily (July 13, 2010) ................................................................ 329 

d. Correspondence with the Senate Judiciary Committee 

i. SITC Letter to Senate Judiciary Committee (July 9, 2010) ........ 340 

ii. Senate Judiciary Committee Response Letter (July 27, 2010) .. 341 

iii. SITC Letter providing Judiciary Committee files to the parties (July 30, 2010) ......................................................................... 343 

e. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Judge Porteous’s Motions 

for Assistance in Securing Discovery from the MCC and the 

ABA (August 4, 2010) ........................................................................ 344 

2. Department of Justice (DOJ) ...............................................................

a. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

from DOJ (June 27, 2010) ................................................................. 346 

b. Judge Porteous’s Request Letter to DOJ (June 30, 2010) .............. 360 

c. DOJ Response to Judge Porteous Declining Request for Documents (July 19, 2010) ........................................................................ 362 

b. Pre-Trial Filings regarding Witnesses and Subpoenas ............................. 395 

i. Judge Porteous’s Preliminary Designation of Witnesses, Requests 

for Subpoenas, Related Funding and Immunity Orders, and Response 

Addressing Stipulations regarding Art. I, III, IV (June 9, 2010) .......... 397 

ii. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding Article II filings (June 9, 2010) ..... 402 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Preliminary Designation of Witnesses as to Article 

II, Requests for Subpoenas as to Article II, Related Funding and 

Immunity Orders as to Article II, and Response Addressing Stipulations regarding Article II (June 10, 2010) ............................................... 405 

iv. House Managers’ Preliminary Designations of Witnesses and Requests for Subpoenas and Immunity Orders (June 8, 2010) ................. 413 

v. House Managers’ Supplemental Filing in Support of its Preliminary 

Requests (June 30, 2010) .......................................................................... 471 

vi. Judge Porteous’s Requests for Subpoenas and Immunity (August 

2, 2010) ....................................................................................................... 479 

vii. House Managers’ Supplemental Designation of Witnesses and Requests for Subpoenas (August 2, 2010) .................................................... 486 

viii. House Managers’ Memorandum in Support of calling Judge 

Porteous as a witness (August 2, 2010) ................................................... 489 

ix. Judge Porteous’s Motion Requesting Funding for his Defense (June 

30, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 547 

x. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Motion Requesting Funding 

for Defense (July 26, 2010) ....................................................................... 553 

c. Attorney Disqualification ............................................................................. 555 

i. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding Change in Representation (June 

9, 2010) ....................................................................................................... 557 

ii. House Managers’ Response Letter regarding Attorney Conflict of 

Interest (June 10, 2010) ............................................................................ 559 

iii. SITC Letter memorializing June 10, 2010 Meeting of all Counsel 

(June 10, 2010) .......................................................................................... 572 

vii 

iv. Judge Porteous’s Response Letter to Counsel’s proposed ethical firewall (June 13, 2010 ................................................................................... 574 

v. Judge Porteous’s Motion for a Continuance (June 11, 2010) ................ 587 

vi. House Managers’ Opposition to Motion for a Continuance (June 

14, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 596 

vii. Judge Porteous’s Letter Requesting Motions Due Date Clarification 

(June 14, 2010) .......................................................................................... 619 

viii. Judge Porteous’s Expedited Motion for a Hearing (June 14, 2010) .. 621 

ix. COMMITTEE ORDER: Vacating Motion Filing Deadlines (June 14, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 624 

x. COMMITTEE ORDER: Motion for a Continuance (and Committee 

disqualification of Richard Westling) (June 21, 2010) ........................... 625 

xi. Judge Porteous’s Letter confirming full formal Withdrawal of attorneys Sam Dalton and Re ́my Voisin Starns (June 14, 2010) .................. 633 

xii. Judge Porteous’s Joint Motion for Withdrawal of Sam Dalton and 

Re ́my Voisin Starns (June 24, 2010) ....................................................... 634 

xiii. Judge Porteous’s Letter confirming Withdrawal of Richard 

Westling (June 24, 2010) .......................................................................... 659 

PART 1B 

d. Pre-Trial Motions .........................................................................................

i. Motions regarding the dismissal of the Articles of Impeachment ......... 661 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article I (July 21, 2010) ........... 663 

2. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article II (July 21, 2010) ......... 810 

3. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article III (July 21, 2010) ........ 868 

4. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article IV (July 21, 2010) ........ 928 

5. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss the Articles as Unconstitutionally Aggregated (July 21, 2010) ............................................................ 1040 

6. House Managers’ Consolidated Opposition to Judge Porteous’s Motions to Dismiss the Articles of Impeachment (July 28, 2010) .......... 1070 

ii. Cross Motions regarding the Admission of Judge Porteous’s Immunized Testimony Before the Fifth Circuit Special Committee ............... 1289 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Exclude the Use of His Previously 

Immunized Testimony (July 21, 2010) ................................................. 1291 

2. House Managers’ Opposition to Exclude Immunized Testimony 

(July 28, 2010) ....................................................................................... 1492 

3. House Managers’ Notice of Intent to Introduce Judge Porteous’s 

Fifth Circuit Testimony (July 21, 2010) .............................................. 1542 

4. Judge Porteous’s Objection to House Managers’ Notice of Intent 

to Introduce his Immunized Testimony (July 28, 2010) ..................... 1690 

iii. Cross Motions regarding the Admission of Prior Testimony, Transcripts and Records from Prior Judicial and Congressional Proceedings ...................................................................................................... 1703 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Exclude Prior Testimony and Limit 

the Presentation of Testimonial Evidence to Live Witnesses (July 

21, 2010) ................................................................................................. 1705 

2. House Managers’ Opposition to Porteous’s Motion to Exclude Prior 

Testimony and Limit the Presentation of Testimonial Evidence 

to Live Witnesses (July 28, 2010) ......................................................... 1721 

3. House Managers’ Motion to Admit Transcripts and Records from 

Prior Judicial and Congressional Proceedings (July 21, 2010) .......... 1724 

4. Judge Porteous’s Opposition the House Managers’ Motion to Admit 

Transcripts and Records from Prior Judicial and Congressional 

Proceedings (July 28, 2010) .................................................................. 1779 

iv. Motion for an Extended Evidentiary Hearing ....................................... 1795 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion (July 21, 2010) ............................................. 1797 

2. House Managers’ Opposition Motion (July 28, 2010) ......................... 1826 

III. Pre-Trial Motions Hearing—August 4, 2010 ............................................... 1829 

a. COMMITTEE ORDER: Pretrial Hearing (August 2, 2010) ...................... 1831 

b. Pre-Trial Motions Hearing (August 4, 2010) .............................................. 1832 

c. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (August 4, 2010) .......................... 1966 

d. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Pre-Trial Motions (August 25, 

2010) ............................................................................................................... 1967 

viii 

PART 1C 

IV. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Leading up to the September Evidentiary Hearings 

a. Filings regarding Witnesses and Subpoenas ............................................. 1975 

i. Judge Porteous’s Witness List (August 5, 2010) ..................................... 1977 

ii. House Managers’ Witness List (August 5, 2010) ................................... 1981 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Provide Travel Funding for Expert Witnesses (August 12, 2010) .......................................................................... 1984 

iv. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Judge Porteous’s Motion to 

Provide Travel Funding for Expert Witnesses (August 27, 2010) ......... 1992 

v. Porteous Motion to Add One Witness to the Subpoena List (August 

13, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 1993 

b. Ongoing Discovery ........................................................................................ 1997 

i. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (Department of Justice) ........... 1999 

ii. Judge Porteous Investigation Grand Jury Subpoena Log (August 

11, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 2001 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Letter in Support of Motion for Assistance in 

Securing Discovery from DOJ (August 17, 2010) ................................... 2010 

iv. SITC Committee Staff Informal Email to DOJ (August 19, 2010) ...... 2059 

v. SITC Letter to DOJ Assistant Attorney General Ron Weich (August 

25, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 2080 

vi. DOJ Production Cover Letter—Bodenheimer (August 27, 2010) ........ 2091 

vii. Judge Porteous’s Discovery Letter (August 27, 2010) ......................... 2092 

viii. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Subpoenas to be Issued to DOJ Attorneys (August 28, 2010) .............................................................................. 2094 

ix. DOJ Opposition to Judge Porteous’s Motion for Subpoenas to be 

issued to DOJ Attorneys (September 3, 2010) ........................................ 2115 

x. House Managers’ Response to Judge Porteous’s Motion for Subpoenas to be Issued to DOJ Attorneys (September 8, 2010) .................. 2139 

xi. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Request # 4 (September 3, 2010) ............................................................. 2144 

xii. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Requests # 10-16, 18 (September 7, 2010) .............................................. 2145 

xiii. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Requests # 17 and 19 (September 8, 2010) ............................................. 2147 

xiv. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Request # 1 (September 10, 2010) ........................................................... 2149 

xv. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Request # 8 (September 10, 2010) ........................................................... 2150 

xvi. DOJ Cover Letter regarding Disclosure Orders (September 10, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 2152 

xvii. Letter from DOJ Assistant Attorney General Ron Weich (September 12, 2010) ........................................................................................ 2154 

xviii. DOJ Cover Letter Response to 9/20 In Camera Review (September 20, 2010) ........................................................................................ 2159 

xix. DOJ Cover Letter Response to 9/20 In Camera Review (October 

29, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 2161 

c. Filings regarding Stipulations ..................................................................... 2163 

i. Judge Porteous’s Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 5, 2010) ......... 2165 

ii. House Managers’ Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 5, 2010) ....... 2200 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Responses to the House Managers’ Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 12, 2010) ............................................................. 2284 

iv. House Managers’ Responses and Objectives to Judge Porteous’s 

Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 12, 2010) .................................... 2363 

v. Judge Porteous’s Reply to the House Managers’ Responses to Judge 

Porteous’s Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 19, 2010) ................. 2438 

vi. House Managers’ Reply to Judge Porteous’s Responses to the House 

Managers’ Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 19, 2010) ................. 2459 

vii. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding the Stipulations process (September 6, 2010) .......................................................................................... 2516 

viii. House Managers’ Response Letter (September 7, 2010) .................... 2521 

ix. Agreed Stipulations of Fact (September 8, 2010) ................................. 2526 

x. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding the Submission of Joint Stipulations (September 9, 2010) ......................................................................... 2553 

xi. House Managers’ Response to Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding 

the Submission of Joint Stipulations (September 10, 2010) .................. 2576 

d. Pre-Trial Statements .................................................................................... 2579 

ix 

IV. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Leading up to the September Evidentiary Hearings —Continued 

i. COMMITTEE ORDER: Designating Contents of Pre-Trial Statements 

including full list of subpoenaed witnesses of the SITC (August 26, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 2581 

ii. Judge Porteous’s Pre-Trial Statement (September 1, 2010) ................. 2584 

iii. House Managers’ Pre-Trial Statement (September 1, 2010) ............... 2659 

iv. Judge Porteous’s Pre-Trial Statement Supplement (September 8, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 2755 

v. House Managers’ Request to divide Opening Statements (September 

7, 2010) ....................................................................................................... 2760 

VOLUME 2 

PART 2A 

V. Evidentiary Hearings—September 13–16 & 21, 2010 .................................. 1 

a. Evidentiary Hearings ................................................................................... 1 

i. Opening Statements .................................................................................. 7 

ii. The Case of the House Managers ........................................................... 117 

1. September 13, 2010 ............................................................................... 118 

a. Jacob J. Amato, Jr. ............................................................................ 118 

b. Robert Creely ..................................................................................... 248 

c. Joseph Mole ........................................................................................ 381 

2. September 14, 2010 ............................................................................... 443 

a. Louis Marcotte ................................................................................... 452 

b. Lori Marcotte ..................................................................................... 560 

c. Jeffery Duhon ..................................................................................... 605 

d. Aubrey Wallace .................................................................................. 631 

e. Rafael Goyeneche ............................................................................... 667 

f. Charles Gardner Geyh ....................................................................... 713 

3. September 15, 2010 ............................................................................... 741 

a. Charles Gardner Geyh ...................................................................... 744 

b. Rhonda Danos .................................................................................... 778 

c. Bobby Philip Hamil, Jr. ..................................................................... 813 

d. DeWayne Horner ............................................................................... 870 

e. Claude Lightfoot, Jr. .......................................................................... 982 

f. Duncan Keir ........................................................................................ 1093 

PART 2B 

iii. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (September 15, 2010) ............. 1137 

iv. The Case of Judge Porteous .................................................................... 1139 

1. September 15, 2010 ............................................................................... 1140 

a. Timothy Porteous .............................................................................. 1140 

b. Ronald Bodenheimer ......................................................................... 1168 

2. September 16, 2010 ............................................................................... 1246 

a. Rafael Pardo ....................................................................................... 1258 

b. S.J. Beaulieu, Jr. ............................................................................... 1376 

c. Don Gardner ....................................................................................... 1404 

d. Dane Ciolino ...................................................................................... 1480 

3. September 21, 2010 ............................................................................... 1549 

a. John Mamoulides ............................................................................... 1552 

b. Darcy Griffin ...................................................................................... 1634 

c. Henry Hildebrand .............................................................................. 1653 

d. Ronald Barliant ................................................................................. 1700 

e. Robert B. Rees .................................................................................... 1744 

f. G. Calvin Mackenzie .......................................................................... 1802 

VOLUME 3 

PART 3A 

VI. Post Trial Filings ........................................................................................... 1 

a. House Managers’ Response to Senator Whitehouse’s Inquiry during 

the Evidentiary Hearings (Sept. 28, 2010) ................................................. 3 

b. Judge Porteous’s Proposed Findings of Fact (October 1, 2010) ................ 6 

c. House Managers’ Proposed Findings of Fact (October 1, 2010) ................ 162 

VII. Filings regarding Exhibits ........................................................................... 235 

a. House Managers’ statement concerning Authenticity of Judge 

Porteous’s Exhibits (September 8, 2010) ..................................................... 237 

b. House Managers’ List of Exhibits to be Admitted (September 21, 2010) 238 

x 

VII. Filings regarding Exhibits—Continued 

c. Judge Porteous’s Response to House List of Exhibits to be Admitted 

(September 23, 2010) .................................................................................... 274 

d. Agreed Exhibits to be Admitted (September 26, 2010) ............................. 281 

e. Disputed Exhibits to be Admitted (September 27, 2010) .......................... 300 

f. House Managers’ Letter regarding Exhibits (September 28, 2010) .......... 306 

g. Judge Porteous’s Response Letter (September 28, 2010) .......................... 336 

h. COMMITTEE ORDER: Order on Admitted Exhibits (November 4, 

2010) ............................................................................................................... 342 

PART 3B 

VIII. Exhibits Admitted (in numerical order) .................................................... 365 

NOTE: Exhibits with a notation (*) are not included in this report and 

are only available for viewing by the full Senate 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

1 ...................... House Resolution 15 .................................................................................................................. 367 

2 ...................... House Judiciary Committee Resolution (Jan. 22, 2009) ........................................................... 369 

3 ...................... House Judiciary Committee Resolution (May 12, 2009) ........................................................... 376 

4 ...................... DOJ Complaint Letter to 5th Circuit (5th Cir.) ......................................................................... 378 

5 ...................... 5th Cir. Special Investigatory Committee Report ..................................................................... 400 

6 (a) ................ 5th Cir. Judicial Council Order and Certification ..................................................................... 466 

6 (b) ................ 5th Cir. Judicial Council Dissent .............................................................................................. 472 

6 (c) ................ Judge Porteous’s Reply Memo ................................................................................................... 521 

7 (a) ................ Judicial Conference of the U.S. Letter to Speaker Pelosi ......................................................... 535 

7 (b) ................ Judicial Conference of the U.S. Certification to Speaker Pelosi ............................................... 536 

7 (c) ................ Judicial Conf. Report and Recommendations ........................................................................... 538 

8 ...................... 5th Cir. Order and Reprimand .................................................................................................. 594 

9 (a) ................ Pres. Clinton’s Nomination of Porteous .................................................................................... 602 

9 (b) ................ Senate Confirmation Hearings Excerpts .................................................................................... 605 

9 (c) ................ Cong. Rec. of Porteous Confirmation ........................................................................................ 655 

9 (d) ................ Judge Porteous’s Nomination Affidavit ..................................................................................... 657 

9 (e) ................ Judge Porteous’s Resignation Letter to State Court ................................................................. 658 

9 (f) ................. Judge Porteous’s Senate Questionnaire .................................................................................... 662 

10 .................... Judge Porteous’s 5th Cir. Testimony ......................................................................................... 698 

12 .................... Robert Creely 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ................................................................. 832 

17 .................... 5th Cir. Compulsion and Immunity Order for Judge Porteous ................................................. 870 

20 .................... Jacob Amato, Jr. 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................ 872 

21 (b) .............. Jacob Amato, Jr. Calendars 1999–2001 ................................................................................... 907 

21 (c) .............. Jacob Amato, Jr. Credit Card Records ...................................................................................... 958 

32 .................... Don Gardner 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 .................................................................. 1015 

35 (b) .............. Gardner Retainer Agreement ..................................................................................................... 1041 

43 .................... Rhonda Danos 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................... 1043 

48* .................. FBI Surveillance video (March 11, 2002) ................................................................................. 1075 

50 .................... PACER Docket Report of Liljeberg ............................................................................................. 1076 

51 (a) .............. Liljeberg: Motion to Substitute Counsel .................................................................................... 1128 

51 (b) .............. Liljeberg: Order Granting Motion to Substitute Counsel ........................................................... 1130 

52 .................... Liljeberg: Motion to Recuse ....................................................................................................... 1132 

53 .................... Liljeberg: Opposition to Motion to Recuse ................................................................................ 1145 

54 .................... Liljeberg: Motion to Leave to File Reply with Memo. ................................................................ 1154 

55 .................... Liljeberg: Response to Motion to Leave to File Reply w/ Memo ............................................... 1164 

56 .................... Lifemark Recusal Hearing Transcript ........................................................................................ 1174 

57 .................... Liljeberg: Judgment on Motion to Recuse (Denied) .................................................................. 1199 

58 .................... Liljeberg: Lifemark’s Recusal Motion Appeal to 5th Cir. .......................................................... 1201 

59 .................... Liljeberg: Order Denying Lifemark’s Recusal Motion Appeal to 5th Cir. .................................. 1329 

60 (a) .............. Liljeberg: Motion to Substitute Counsel .................................................................................... 1331 

60 (b) .............. Liljeberg: Order Granting Motion to Substitute Counsel ........................................................... 1333 

61 .................... Liljeberg: Transcript Trial Excerpts ........................................................................................... 1335 

62 .................... Liljeberg: Opinion ....................................................................................................................... 1350 

63 .................... Lifemark Appellate opinion ........................................................................................................ 1455 

65 .................... Joseph Mole 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ................................................................... 1515 

67 .................... Cover Emails and Pres. Records re: Porteous .......................................................................... 1547 

69 (a) .............. DOJ Production 6/18/09 ............................................................................................................. 1565 

69 (b)* ............ FBI Background Check of Judge Porteous June 25, 2009 ........................................................ 1789 

69 (b) .............. PORT297–301 Attachments to 69(i) ......................................................................................... 1790 

69 (b) .............. PORT491 2nd Hamil 302 ........................................................................................................... 1795 

xi 

VIII. Exhibits Admitted (in numerical order)—Continued 

NOTE—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

69 (b) .............. PORT492–494 3rd Hamil 302 ................................................................................................... 1796 

69 (d) .............. PORT594–597 MCC Report ........................................................................................................ 1799 

69 (d) .............. PORT610–629 Wallace Hearing Transcripts ............................................................................. 1803 

69 (d) .............. PORT672 Section 881 ................................................................................................................ 1823 

69 (d) .............. PORT673–677 Sections 881 (continued from PORT672) and 883 ........................................... 1824 

69 (i) ............... 1st Hamil 302 ........................................................................................................................... 1829 

69 (j) ............... FBI Interview of Judge Porteous (unredacted) .......................................................................... 1834 

69 (k) .............. FBI Interview of Judge Porteous (unredacted) .......................................................................... 1835 

70 .................... U.S. v. Marcottes: PACER Docket Report .................................................................................. 1838 

71 (a) .............. Louis Marcotte Plea ................................................................................................................... 1845 

PART 3C 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

71 (b) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Louis Marcotte Plea Agreement ................................................................... 1867 

71 (c) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Louis Marcotte Plea Agreement Addendum ................................................ 1874 

71 (d) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Louis Marcotte Plea Agreement Factual Basis ........................................... 1878 

71 (e) .............. Marcotte Imprisonment Document ............................................................................................ 1891 

71 (f) ............... U.S. v. Marcottes: Unsealed Pleadings ..................................................................................... 1897 

73 (a) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Plea Agreement ..................................................................... 1917 

73 (b) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Plea Agreement Addendum ................................................... 1923 

73 (c) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Plea Agreement Factual Basis .............................................. 1927 

73 (d) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Judgment ............................................................................... 1932 

77 (a) .............. Jeffery Duhon expungement records .......................................................................................... 1937 

77 (b) .............. Jeffery Duhon expungement records .......................................................................................... 1940 

77 (c) .............. Jeffery Duhon expungement records .......................................................................................... 1942 

81 .................... Aubrey Wallace Drug Possession File ........................................................................................ 1944 

82 .................... Aubrey Wallace Burglary File ..................................................................................................... 2005 

88 (d) .............. Bodenheimer Criminal Complaint ............................................................................................. 2112 

88 (e) .............. U.S. v. Bodenheimer: Plea Agreement ....................................................................................... 2116 

88 (f) ............... U.S. v. Bodenheimer: Plea Agreement Factual Basis ............................................................... 2122 

88 (g) .............. U.S. v. Bodenheimer: Plea Agreement Factual Basis Supplement ........................................... 2134

88 (h) .............. US v. Bodenheimer: Judgment and Probation .......................................................................... 2136 

90 (a) .............. Prof. Bail Agents Conf. 1996 .................................................................................................... 2137 

90 (b) .............. Prof. Bail Agents Conf. 1999 .................................................................................................... 2139 

102 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Report: 05/12/1997—Reporting Period: 01/01/1996– 

12/31/1996.

2141 

102 (b) ............ 1996 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2145 

103 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Report: 05/13/1998—Reporting Period: 01/01/1997– 

12/31/1997.

2237 

103 (b) ............ 1997 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2241 

104 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Report Date: 05/13/1999—Reporting Period: 01/01/ 

1998–12/31/1998.

2311 

104 (b) ............ 1998 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2315 

105 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Form: 05/05/2000—Reporting Period: 01/01/1999– 

12/31/1999.

2384 

105 (b) ............ 1999 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2388 

119 (a) ............ News Article ............................................................................................................................... 2458 

119 (z) ............ News Article ............................................................................................................................... 2459 

122 (b) ............ Claude Lightfoot crime Fraud Ruling ........................................................................................ 2460 

124 .................. Claude Lightfoot 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................ 2464 

125 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Petition ....................................................................................... 2492 

126 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Amended Petition ....................................................................... 2497 

127 .................. Judge Porteous’s Proposed Schedule Plan ................................................................................ 2499 

128 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Commencement Notice ............................................................... 2530 

129 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Memo to Record of Creditors Mtg ............................................ 2533 

130 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Creditors Meeting Transcript .................................................... 2534 

131 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Amended Schedule F and Modified Chapter 13 Plan .............. 2538 

132 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Amended Chapter 13 Plan ........................................................ 2540 

xii 

PART 3C—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

133 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Court Order Confirming Plan ..................................................... 2543 

134 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Trustee’s Notice of Intention to Pay Claims ............................. 2546 

135 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Trustee’s Ex Parte Motion to Amend the Plan ......................... 2547 

136 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Trustee’s Final Report ............................................................... 2548 

137 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Discharge of Debtor After Completion of Chapter 13 Plan ..... 2549 

138 (a) ............ Claude Lightfoot Handwritten Notes ......................................................................................... 2550 

138 (b) ............ Bankruptcy Worksheets .............................................................................................................. 2553 

139 .................. Cover Letter and Remainder of Lightfoot File .......................................................................... 2582 

140 .................. Fleet Credit Card Statements .................................................................................................... 2715 

141 .................. Judge Porteous Tax Return ........................................................................................................ 2723 

143 .................. Fidelity Money Market Statements of Transaction Items .......................................................... 2725 

144 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bank One Records ......................................................................................... 2732 

145 .................. Judge Porteous’s PO Box Application ........................................................................................ 2749 

146 .................. Claude Lightfoot Letter re: Proposal/Excluding Regions ........................................................... 2750 

148 .................. S.J. Beaulieu Pamphlet .............................................................................................................. 2754 

149 .................. Harrah’s Casino Credit Application ........................................................................................... 2759 

167 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statement for December 1996 .................................................. 2760 

168 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statement for December 1997 .................................................. 2761 

169 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statements for December 1998 ................................................ 2766 

170 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statements for December 1999 ................................................ 2769 

188 .................. Letter from Gegenheimer to Agent Horner ................................................................................ 2774 

189 (1) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2775 

189 (2) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2778 

189 (3) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2782 

189 (5) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2785 

189 (6) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2787 

189 (8) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2792 

189 (10–14) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2795 

189 (16–20) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2813 

189 (22–25) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2834 

189 (27) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2857 

189 (28) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2859 

189 (29) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2862 

189 (31–48) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2871 

189 (50–56) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2963 

189 (58–65) .... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3000 

189 (67) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3031 

189 (68) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3036 

189 (69) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3044 

189 (71–76) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3051 

189 (78) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3072 

189 (79) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3079 

189 (80) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3084 

189 (81) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3087 

189 (82) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3095 

189 (84) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3099 

189 (85) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3106 

189 (87) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3114 

189 (88) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3120 

189 (91–96) .... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3125 

189 (99) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3169 

189 (100) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3173 

189 (101) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3177 

189 (104) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3184 

189 (105) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3192 

189 (107) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3195 

189 (108) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3200 

189 (109) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3203 

189 (111) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3208 

189 (114) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3211 

189 (116) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3213 

189 (118–125) Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3217 

189 (127) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3249 

189 (130–48) .. Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3254 

xiii 

PART 3C—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

189 (150–156) Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3340 

PART 3D 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

189 (157–90) .. Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3379 

189 (192–226) Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3530 

241 .................. FBI Surveillance video ............................................................................................................... 3697 

245 .................. Bodenheimer Factual Basis of Plea .......................................................................................... 3698 

246 .................. Aubrey Wallace 9/21/94 Proceeding .......................................................................................... 3710 

280 .................. Louis Marcotte Affidavit ............................................................................................................ 3715 

283 .................. Task Force Deposition Exhibit 83 Jacob Amato, Jr. Calendar June 1999 ................................ 3717 

295 .................. William E. Heitkamp Fifth Circuit Testimony October 30, 2007 .............................................. 3719 

296 .................. Letter from S.J. Beaulieu, Jr. to Claude C. Lightfoot, enclosing correspondence from William 

E. Heitkamp.

3726 

298 .................. Letter from Michael F. Adoue, staff attorney for S.J. Beaulieu, Jr., to FBI Agent Wayne 

Horner.

3728 

299 .................. Letter from Noel Hillman, Chief, Public Integrity Section, Department of Justice, to S.J. 

Beaulieu, Jr.

3731 

301 (a) ............ Judge Porteous Grand Casino Gulfport Patron Transaction Report (02/27/2001 markers) ..... 3732 

301 (b) ............ Judge Porteous Bank One Statement (with copies of checks to Grand Casino) March 23, 

2001–April 23, 2001.

3733 

302 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry (03/02/2001 markers) ............ 3739 

303 .................. Judge Porteous Beau Rivage Credit History (one–time credit limit increase on 04/06/2001) 3741 

304 .................. Judge Porteous Beau Rivage Balance Activity (04/07/2001 markers) ..................................... 3742 

305 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry (04/10/2001 markers) ............ 3744 

306 .................. Judge Porteous Harrah’s Patron Credit Activity (04/30/2001 markers) ................................... 3746

307 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(05/07/2001 markers) ......... 3747 

308 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(05/16/2001 markers) ......... 3749 

309 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report (05/26/2001 markers) and corresponding Bank One records.3750 

310 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(06/20/2001 markers) ......... 3753 

311 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(07/19/2001 markers) ......... 3754 

312 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(07/23/2001 markers) ......... 3755 

313 (a) ............ Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(08/20/2001 markers) ......... 3756 

313 (b) ............ Judge Porteous Treasure Chest IOU’s and Hold Checks Ledger ............................................... 3758 

314 .................. Judge Porteous Harrah’s Patron Credit Activity (09/28/2001 markers) ................................... 3759

315 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry (10/13/2001 markers) ............ 3760 

316 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(10/17/2001 markers) ......... 3761 

317 .................. Judge Porteous Beau Rivage Balance Activity (10/31/2001 markers) ..................................... 3763 

318 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(11/27/2001 markers) ......... 3764 

319 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(12/11/2001 markers) ......... 3766 

320 .................. Judge Porteous Harrah’s Patron Credit Activity—(12/20/2001 markers) ................................ 3767 

321 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report—(2/12/2002 markers) .................. 3768 

322 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(04/01/2002 markers) ......... 3769 

323 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report—(05/26/2002 markers) ................ 3770 

324 .................. Judge Porteous Application for credit increase at Grand Casino Gulfport (from $2,000 to 

$2,500).

3771 

325 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report (07/04/2002 markers) and corresponding Fidelity Money Market Account records.3772 

326 .................. Central Credit, Inc. Gaming Report for Judge Porteous ........................................................... 3775 

329 .................. Fleet credit card statement with accompanying check written by Rhonda Danos, paying off 

balance in March 2001..

3777 

330 .................. Fleet payment stub and check written by Judge Porteous September 2, 2002 ...................... 3780 

332 .................. Gerald Dennis Fink 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ........................................................ 3781 

335 .................. Judge Greendyke 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................ 3817 

337 .................. Agent Horner’s summary of gambling losses ........................................................................... 3832 

338 .................. Dewayne Horner 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................. 3854 

339 .................. S.J. Beaulieu Letter to Claude Lightfoot #1 .............................................................................. 3915 

340 .................. S.J. Beaulieu Letter to Claude Lightfoot #2 .............................................................................. 3917 

xiv 

PART 3D—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

341 (a) ............ Capital One credit card application August 13, 2001 ............................................................. 3920 

341 (b) ............ Judge Porteous’s Capital One credit card statements ............................................................. 3921 

342 .................. Claude Lightfoot Affidavit in Support of Attorney’s Fees ......................................................... 3943 

343 .................. Judge Porteous Asset and Liability Documents ........................................................................ 3949 

344 .................. 2001 Instructions for Completing Bankruptcy Official: Form 1, Voluntary Petition ................ 4147 

345 .................. 2001 Instructions for Completing Bankruptcy Schedules ........................................................ 4159 

346 .................. 2001 Instructions for Completing Bankruptcy Statement of Financial Affairs ........................ 4221 

350 (1–56) ...... Bonds ......................................................................................................................................... 4241 

351 (1–26) ...... Bonds ......................................................................................................................................... 4359 

370 (a) ............ 1999 PBUS Beau Rivage Convention Records related to Judge Porteous ............................... 4385 

370 (b) ............ 1999 PBUS Beau Rivage Convention Records related to Rhonda Danos ................................ 4387 

371 .................. Records related to 1996 and 1998 Marcotte–Danos Las Vegas Trips .................................... 4391 

372 (a) ............ Beef Connection Bill and Lori Marcotte Credit Card Record .................................................... 4394 

372 (b) ............ Lunch Receipt ............................................................................................................................ 4396 

372 (c) ............ Beef Connection Bill and Lori Marcotte Credit Card Record .................................................... 4398 

372 (d) ............ Lunch Receipt ............................................................................................................................ 4400 

373 (a) ............ Lunch Receipt ............................................................................................................................ 4402 

373 (c) ............ BBU Calendar, Beef Connection Bill and Lori Marcotte Credit Card Record ........................... 4405 

373 (d) ............ BBU Calendar, Beef Connection Bill and Norman Bowley Credit Card Record ....................... 4408 

375 .................. Emeril’s Receipt ......................................................................................................................... 4411 

376 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statements May 1999 ............................................................... 4412 

377 .................. Caesar’s Palace Records (Creely’s credit card charges for Porteous’s Room) ........................ 4414 

378 .................. Robert Creely’s Credit Card Charges May 1999 ....................................................................... 4415 

381 .................. Judge Porteous Fidelity Records re: IRA .................................................................................... 4418 

382 .................. Judge Records related to $1,000 Beau Rivage Payment ......................................................... 4423 

383 .................. Additional Judge Porteous IRA Records .................................................................................... 4429 

439 (a)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from William E. Willis, Chair of the American Bar Association 

Standing Committee on Federal Judiciary, to Senator Biden re: Judge Porteous’s qualifications for appointment to the federal bench.

4451 

439 (b)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Biography .......................................... 4451 

439 (c)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Blue Slips from Senator Breaux and 

Senator Johnston.

4451 

439 (d)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Dates of Materials Received ............. 4451 

439 (e)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Nomination Hearing Transcript ......... 4451 

439 (f)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: White House Nomination of Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. to be a 

United States District Judge for the Eastern District of Louisiana.

4451 

439 (g)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Porteous Questionnaire .......................................................................... 4451 

439 (h)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Porteous Questionnaire and Financial Disclosure Form ........................ 4451 

439 (i)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—state court Cases .............................. 4451 

439 (j)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—state court opinions .......................... 4451 

439 (k)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—reversals of state court opinions ...... 4451 

439 (l)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—additional decisions requested ......... 4451 

439 (m)* ......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—news articles ..................................... 4451 

439 (n)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. to Senator Biden re: Senate 

Questionnaire supplemental materials.

4451 

439 (o)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. to Senator Biden re: Senate 

Questionnaire supplemental materials.

4451 

439 (p)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. Staff Memorandum (Committee 

Confidential).

4451 

439 (q)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: confidential notes taken from FBI file of G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. ...... 4451 

440 (a) ............ Pages 19–57: House Task Force Hearing (Part I)—November 17–18, 2009 .......................... 4452 

440 (b) ............ Pages 98–137: House Task Force Hearing (Part I)—November 17–18, 2009 ........................ 4491 

440 (c) ............ Pages 139–180: House Task Force Hearing (Part I)—November 17–18, 2009 ...................... 4531 

441 (a) ............ Pages 8–40 (omitting exhibits on pages 10, 11, 12, 39, and 40): House Task Force Hearing (Part II) December 8, 2009.4573 

441 (b) ............ Pages 41–66: House Task Force Hearing (Part II) December 8, 2009 .................................... 4606 

441 (c) ............ Pages 66–82: House Task Force Hearing (Part II) December 8, 2009 .................................... 4632 

442 .................. Pages 41–79: House Task Force Hearing (Part III) December 10, 2009 ................................. 4649 

445 .................. SITC Deposition of Robert Creely .............................................................................................. 4688 

xv 

PART 3E 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

446 .................. SITC Deposition of Jacob Amato ............................................................................................... 4827 

447 .................. SITC Deposition of Louis Marcotte ............................................................................................ 4926 

448 .................. SITC Deposition of Lori Marcotte ............................................................................................... 5071 

451 .................. Judge Porteous Bank One Records Aug.–Sept. 2001; Aug.–Sept. 2002; Aug.–Sept. 2003 ..... 5207 

452 (a) ............ Judge Porteous Bank One Records May–July 2002 .................................................................. 5220 

452 (b) ............ Judge Porteous Fidelity Records May–July 2002 ....................................................................... 5232 

453 .................. Judge Porteous Fidelity Records July–August 2002 ($1,300 check to Grand Casino Gulfport) 5235 

529 .................. Pre–Bankruptcy Fidelity Checks to Casinos .............................................................................. 5241 

530 .................. Post–Bankruptcy Fidelity Checks to Casinos ............................................................................ 5247 

1001 (a–y) ...... Legal Codes ............................................................................................................................... 5251 

1002 (j) ........... Rules of Prof. Conduct .............................................................................................................. 5481 

1002 (y) ........... Rules of Prof. Conduct .............................................................................................................. 5497 

1003 ................ Judge Porteous Tolling Agreement #1 ....................................................................................... 5538 

1004 ................ Judge Porteous Tolling Agreement #2 ....................................................................................... 5541 

1005 ................ Judge Porteous Tolling Agreement #3 ....................................................................................... 5544 

1007 ................ List of 24th JDC Judges ............................................................................................................ 5547 

1008 ................ Beef Connection Menu ............................................................................................................... 5553 

1061 ................ G. Calvin Mackenzie CV ............................................................................................................ 5557 

1064 ................ Newspaper Bankruptcy Announcements .................................................................................... 5565 

1067 ................ Rafael Pardo Law Review Article .............................................................................................. 5569 

1068 ................ Katherine Porter Law Review Article ......................................................................................... 5650 

1070 ................ The Honorable Steven W. Rhodes Law Review Article .............................................................. 5712 

1097 ................ Rafael Pardo CV ........................................................................................................................ 5767 

1098 ................ Ronald Barliant Bio ................................................................................................................... 5775 

1100 (b) .......... Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Petition ....................................................................................... 5778 

1100 (c) .......... Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Amended Petition ....................................................................... 5783 

1100 (d) .......... Judge Porteous’s Proposed Schedule Plan ................................................................................ 5785 

1100 (g) .......... Trustee’s Objection .................................................................................................................... 5814 

1100 (h) .......... Amended Schedule J .................................................................................................................. 5815 

1100 (i) ........... Amended Chapter 13 Plan ........................................................................................................ 5817 

1100 (o) .......... Chapter 13 Plan Summary ........................................................................................................ 5820 

1100 (z) ........... Trustee’s Final Report and Account .......................................................................................... 5823 

1104 ................ Good Faith: A Roundtable Discussion, 1 Am. Bankr. Inst. L. Rev. 11 (1993). ........................ 5824 

1108 ................ Letter from Beaulieu Staff Attorney .......................................................................................... 5857 

1109 ................ DOJ Letter to S.J. Beaulieu ........................................................................................................ 5860 

1111 (a–l) ....... Judicial Ethics Opinions ............................................................................................................ 5861 

1112 ................ Hamilton Jail Overcrowding Order ............................................................................................. 5955 

1113 ................ Jefferson Parish Criminal Justice System Report ..................................................................... 5959 

1115–1130 ...... Various Articles on Presidential Nominees ............................................................................... 5999 

1134 ................ Bail Law Review Article ............................................................................................................. 6046 

2001* .............. CD of 1986 Bail Bonds ............................................................................................................. 6076 

2002 ................ Bond subset (Sept. 1986) ......................................................................................................... 6077 

2003 ................ Bond subset (Feb. 1986) ........................................................................................................... 6128 

2004 ................ Bond subset (Dec. 1986) .......................................................................................................... 6169 

2005 ................ DOJ Letter to Chairman McCaskill (Sept. 12, 2010) ................................................................ 6198 

2006 ................ Jeffery Duhon record .................................................................................................................. 6203 

2007 ................ Greg Guidry 302 ........................................................................................................................ 6215 

IX. Demonstrative Exhibits utilized during the Committee’s Evidentiary 

Hearings (in numerical order) ......................................................................... 6217 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

190 .................. Chart of Curatorships given to Robert Creely from Judge Porteous ........................................ 6219 

500 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 1: Fleet’’ .................................................................................. 6220 

501 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 2: Treasure Chest’’ .................................................................. 6221 

502 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 3: Tax Return’’ ........................................................................ 6222 

503 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 4: Fidelity’’ .............................................................................. 6223 

504 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 5: Undisclosed $2,000 in Bank One’’ ..................................... 6224 

xvi 

IX. Demonstrative Exhibits utilized during the Committee’s Evidentiary 

Hearings (in numerical order)—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

505 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 6: Undisclosed Grand Casino Markers’’ ................................. 6225 

506 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 7: ‘‘Ortous’’ ............................................................................. 6226 

507 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 8: Gambling Losses/Statement Financial Affairs (Question 

8)’’.

6227 

508 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 9: Violations of Order (Capitol One)’’ ..................................... 6228 

510 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 11: Danos Payment to Beau Rivage’’ ..................................... 6229 

513 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 14: Payments to Fleet’’ ........................................................... 6230 

514 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 15: Bankruptcy Timeline’’ ....................................................... 6231 

515 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 16: Use of Fidelity pre-bankruptcy’’ ....................................... 6232 

517 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 18: Use of Undisclosed Fidelity (cash horde)’’ ...................... 6233 

518 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 19: Post-Bankruptcy Fidelity Checks to Casinos’’ .................. 6234 

519 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 20: Wallace (Intro)’’ ................................................................ 6235 

520 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 21: Wallace Slide 2’’ ............................................................... 6236 

521 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 22: Wallace Slide 3’’ ............................................................... 6237 

522 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 23: Wallace Slide 4’’ ............................................................... 6238 

523 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 24: Wallace Slide 5’’ ............................................................... 6239 

524 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 30: 1996 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6240 

525 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 31: 1997 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6241 

526 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 32: 1998 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6242 

527 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 33: 1999 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6243 

528 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 34: Instructions to Financial Disclosure Forms’’ .................... 6244 

532 .................. Summary Chart: Judge Porteous’s Gambling Markers—July 2001 through July 2002 ........... 6245 

(1) 

Volume 1 of 3, Part A 

I. PRELIMINARY MATTERS 

2 

3 


Insert offset folio 72 here 57952.072
4 


Insert offset folio 73 here 57952.073
5 


Insert offset folio 74 here 57952.074
6 


Insert offset folio 75 here 57952.075
7 


Insert offset folio 76 here 57952.076
8 


Insert offset folio 77 here 57952.077
9 


Insert offset folio 78 here 57952.078
10 


Insert offset folio 79 here 57952.079
11 


Insert offset folio 80 here 57952.080
12 


Insert offset folio 81 here 57952.081
13 


Insert offset folio 82 here 57952.082
14 


Insert offset folio 83 here 57952.083
15 


Insert offset folio 84 here 57952.084
16 


Insert offset folio 85 here 57952.085
17 


Insert offset folio 86 here 57952.086
18 


Insert offset folio 87 here 57952.087
19 


Insert offset folio 88 here 57952.088
20 


Insert offset folio 89 here 57952.089
21 


Insert offset folio 90 here 57952.090
22 


Insert offset folio 91 here 57952.091
23 


Insert offset folio 92 here 57952.092
24 


Insert offset folio 93 here 57952.093
25 


Insert offset folio 94 here 57952.094
26 


Insert offset folio 95 here 57952.095
27 


Insert offset folio 96 here 57952.096
28 


Insert offset folio 97 here 57952.097
29 


Insert offset folio 98 here 57952.098
30 


Insert offset folio 99 here 57952.099
31 


Insert offset folio 100 here 57952.100
32 


Insert offset folio 101 here 57952.101
33 


Insert offset folio 102 here 57952.102
34 


Insert offset folio 103 here 57952.103
35 


Insert offset folio 104 here 57952.104
36 


Insert offset folio 105 here 57952.105
37 


Insert offset folio 106 here 57952.106
38 


Insert offset folio 130 here 579523.130
39 


Insert offset folio 131 here 579523.131
40 


Insert offset folio 132 here 579523.132
41 


Insert offset folio 133 here 579523.133
42 


Insert offset folio 134 here 579523.134
43 


Insert offset folio 135 here 579523.135
44 


Insert offset folio 136 here 579523.136
45 


Insert offset folio 137 here 579523.137
46 


Insert offset folio 138 here 579523.138
47 


Insert offset folio 139 here 579523.139
48 


Insert offset folio 140 here 579523.140
49 


Insert offset folio 141 here 579523.141
50 


Insert offset folio 142 here 579523.142
51 


Insert offset folio 107 here 57952.107
52 


Insert offset folio 108 here 57952.108
53 


Insert offset folio 109 here 57952.109
54 


Insert offset folio 110 here 57952.110
55 


Insert offset folio 111 here 57952.111
56 


Insert offset folio 112 here 57952.112
57 


Insert offset folio 113 here 57952.113
58 


Insert offset folio 114 here 57952.114
59 


Insert offset folio 115 here 57952.115
60 


Insert offset folio 116 here 57952.116
61 


Insert offset folio 117 here 57952.117
62 


Insert offset folio 118 here 57952.118
63 


Insert offset folio 119 here 57952.119
64 


Insert offset folio 120 here 57952.120
65 


Insert offset folio 121 here 57952.121
66 


Insert offset folio 122 here 57952.122
67 


Insert offset folio 123 here 57952.123
68 


Insert offset folio 124 here 57952.124
69 


Insert offset folio 125 here 57952.125
70 


Insert offset folio 126 here 57952.126
71 


Insert offset folio 127 here 57952.127
72 


Insert offset folio 128 here 57952.128
73 


Insert offset folio 129 here 57952.129
74 


Insert offset folio 130 here 57952.130
75 


Insert offset folio 131 here 57952.131
76 


Insert offset folio 132 here 57952.132
77 


Insert offset folio 133 here 57952.133
78 


Insert offset folio 134 here 57952.134
79 


Insert offset folio 135 here 57952.135
80 


Insert offset folio 136 here 57952.136
(81) 

II. COMMITTEE ACTIONS AND FILINGS OF 

THE PARTIES PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 4, 

2010 HEARING ON PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS 

a. Discovery Matters 

i. General Issues 

82 

83 


Insert offset folio 137 here 57952.137
84 


Insert offset folio 138 here 57952.138
85 


Insert offset folio 139 here 57952.139
86 


Insert offset folio 140 here 57952.140
87 


Insert offset folio 141 here 57952.141
88 


Insert offset folio 142 here 57952.142
89 


Insert offset folio 143 here 57952.143
90 


Insert offset folio 144 here 57952.144
91 


Insert offset folio 145 here 57952.145
92 


Insert offset folio 146 here 57952.146
93 


Insert offset folio 147 here 57952.147
94 


Insert offset folio 148 here 57952.148
95 


Insert offset folio 149 here 57952.149
96 


Insert offset folio 150 here 57952.150
97 


Insert offset folio 151 here 57952.151
98 


Insert offset folio 152 here 57952.152
99 


Insert offset folio 153 here 57952.153
100 


Insert offset folio 154 here 57952.154
101 


Insert offset folio 155 here 57952.155
102 


Insert offset folio 156 here 57952.156
103 


Insert offset folio 157 here 57952.157
104 


Insert offset folio 158 here 57952.158
105 


Insert offset folio 159 here 57952.159
106 


Insert offset folio 160 here 57952.160
107 


Insert offset folio 161 here 57952.161
108 


Insert offset folio 162 here 57952.162
109 


Insert offset folio 163 here 57952.163
110 


Insert offset folio 164 here 57952.164
111 


Insert offset folio 165 here 57952.165
112 


Insert offset folio 378 here 57952.378
113 


Insert offset folio 379 here 57952.379
114 


Insert offset folio 380 here 57952.380
115 


Insert offset folio 381 here 57952.381
116 


Insert offset folio 382 here 57952.382
117 


Insert offset folio 383 here 57952.383
118 


Insert offset folio 384 here 57952.384
119 


Insert offset folio 385 here 57952.385
120 


Insert offset folio 386 here 57952.386
121 


Insert offset folio 387 here 57952.387
122 


Insert offset folio 176 here 57952.176
123 


Insert offset folio 177 here 57952.177
124 


Insert offset folio 178 here 57952.178
125 


Insert offset folio 388 here 57952.388
126 


Insert offset folio 180 here 57952.180
127 


Insert offset folio 181 here 57952.181
128 


Insert offset folio 182 here 57952.182
129 


Insert offset folio 183 here 57952.183
130 


Insert offset folio 184 here 57952.184
131 


Insert offset folio 185 here 57952.185
132 


Insert offset folio 186 here 57952.186
133 


Insert offset folio 187 here 57952.187
134 


Insert offset folio 188 here 57952.188
135 


Insert offset folio 189 here 57952.189
136 


Insert offset folio 190 here 57952.190
137 


Insert offset folio 191 here 57952.191
138 


Insert offset folio 192 here 57952.192
139 


Insert offset folio 193 here 57952.193
140 


Insert offset folio 194 here 57952.194
141 


Insert offset folio 195 here 57952.195
142 


Insert offset folio 196 here 57952.196
143 


Insert offset folio 197 here 57952.197
144 


Insert offset folio 198 here 57952.198
145 


Insert offset folio 199 here 57952.199
146 


Insert offset folio 200 here 57952.200
147 


Insert offset folio 201 here 57952.201
148 


Insert offset folio 202 here 57952.202
149 


Insert offset folio 203 here 57952.203
150 


Insert offset folio 204 here 57952.204
151 


Insert offset folio 205 here 57952.205
152 


Insert offset folio 206 here 57952.206
153 


Insert offset folio 207 here 57952.207
154 


Insert offset folio 208 here 57952.208
155 


Insert offset folio 209 here 57952.209
156 


Insert offset folio 210 here 57952.210
157 


Insert offset folio 211 here 57952.211
158 


Insert offset folio 212 here 57952.212
159 


Insert offset folio 213 here 57952.213
160 


Insert offset folio 214 here 57952.214
161 


Insert offset folio 220 here 57952.220
162 


Insert offset folio 221 here 57952.221
(163) 

II. COMMITTEE ACTIONS AND FILINGS OF 

THE PARTIES PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 4, 

2010 HEARING ON PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS 

a. Discovery Matters 

ii. Depositions 

164 

165 


Insert offset folio 215 here 57952.215
166 


Insert offset folio 216 here 57952.216
167 


Insert offset folio 217 here 57952.217
168 


Insert offset folio 218 here 57952.218
169 


Insert offset folio 219 here 57952.219
170 


Insert offset folio 222 here 57952.222
171 


Insert offset folio 223 here 57952.223
172 


Insert offset folio 224 here 57952.224
173 


Insert offset folio 225 here 57952.225
174 


Insert offset folio 226 here 57952.226
175 


Insert offset folio 227 here 57952.227
176 


Insert offset folio 228 here 57952.228
177 


Insert offset folio 229 here 57952.229
178 


Insert offset folio 230 here 57952.230
179 


Insert offset folio 231 here 57952.231
180 


Insert offset folio 232 here 57952.232
181 


Insert offset folio 233 here 57952.233
182 


Insert offset folio 234 here 57952.234
183 


Insert offset folio 235 here 57952.235
184 


Insert offset folio 236 here 57952.236
185 


Insert offset folio 237 here 57952.237
186 


Insert offset folio 238 here 57952.238
187 


Insert offset folio 239 here 57952.239
188 


Insert offset folio 240 here 57952.240
189 


Insert offset folio 241 here 57952.241
190 


Insert offset folio 242 here 57952.242
191 


Insert offset folio 243 here 57952.243
192 


Insert offset folio 244 here 57952.244
193 


Insert offset folio 245 here 57952.245
194 


Insert offset folio 246 here 57952.246
195 


Insert offset folio 247 here 57952.247
196 


Insert offset folio 248 here 57952.248
197 


Insert offset folio 249 here 57952.249
198 


Insert offset folio 250 here 57952.250
199 


Insert offset folio 251 here 57952.251
200 


Insert offset folio 252 here 57952.252
201 


Insert offset folio 253 here 57952.253
202 


Insert offset folio 254 here 57952.254
203 


Insert offset folio 255 here 57952.255
204 


Insert offset folio 771 here 579525.771
205 


Insert offset folio 143 here 579523.143
206 


Insert offset folio 144 here 579523.144
207 


Insert offset folio 376 here 57952.376
208 


Insert offset folio 377 here 57952.377
209 


Insert offset folio 772 here 579525.772
(211) 

II. COMMITTEE ACTIONS AND FILINGS OF 

THE PARTIES PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 4, 

2010 HEARING ON PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS 

a. Discovery Matters 

iii. Motion to Compel 

212 

213 


Insert offset folio 257 here 57952.257
214 


Insert offset folio 258 here 57952.258
215 


Insert offset folio 259 here 57952.259
216 


Insert offset folio 260 here 57952.260
217 


Insert offset folio 261 here 57952.261
218 


Insert offset folio 262 here 57952.262
219 


Insert offset folio 263 here 57952.263
220 


Insert offset folio 264 here 57952.264
221 


Insert offset folio 265 here 57952.265
222 


Insert offset folio 266 here 57952.266
223 


Insert offset folio 267 here 57952.267
224 


Insert offset folio 268 here 57952.268
225 


Insert offset folio 269 here 57952.269
226 


Insert offset folio 270 here 57952.270
227 


Insert offset folio 271 here 57952.271
228 


Insert offset folio 272 here 57952.272
229 


Insert offset folio 273 here 57952.273
230 


Insert offset folio 274 here 57952.274
231 


Insert offset folio 275 here 57952.275
232 


Insert offset folio 276 here 57952.276
233 


Insert offset folio 277 here 57952.277
234 


Insert offset folio 278 here 57952.278
235 


Insert offset folio 279 here 57952.279
236 


Insert offset folio 280 here 57952.280
237 


Insert offset folio 281 here 57952.281
238 


Insert offset folio 282 here 57952.282
239 


Insert offset folio 283 here 57952.283
240 


Insert offset folio 284 here 57952.284
241 


Insert offset folio 285 here 57952.285
242 


Insert offset folio 286 here 57952.286
243 


Insert offset folio 287 here 57952.287
244 


Insert offset folio 288 here 57952.288
245 


Insert offset folio 289 here 57952.289
246 


Insert offset folio 290 here 57952.290
247 


Insert offset folio 697 here 5795211.697
248 


Insert offset folio 698 here 5795211.698
249 


Insert offset folio 699 here 5795211.699
250 


Insert offset folio 700 here 5795211.700
251 


Insert offset folio 701 here 5795211.701
252 


Insert offset folio 702 here 5795211.702
253 


Insert offset folio 703 here 5795211.703
254 


Insert offset folio 704 here 5795211.704
255 


Insert offset folio 291 here 57952.291
256 


Insert offset folio 292 here 57952.292
257 


Insert offset folio 293 here 57952.293
258 


Insert offset folio 294 here 57952.294
259 


Insert offset folio 295 here 57952.295
260 


Insert offset folio 296 here 57952.296
261 


Insert offset folio 297 here 57952.297
262 


Insert offset folio 298 here 57952.298
263 


Insert offset folio 299 here 57952.299
264 


Insert offset folio 300 here 57952.300
265 


Insert offset folio 301 here 57952.301
266 


Insert offset folio 302 here 57952.302
267 


Insert offset folio 303 here 57952.303
268 


Insert offset folio 304 here 57952.304
269 


Insert offset folio 305 here 57952.305
270 


Insert offset folio 705 here 5795211.705
271 


Insert offset folio 706 here 5795211.706
272 


Insert offset folio 707 here 5795211.707
273 


Insert offset folio 708 here 5795211.708
274 


Insert offset folio 709 here 5795211.709
275 


Insert offset folio 710 here 5795211.710
276 


Insert offset folio 711 here 5795211.711
277 


Insert offset folio 712 here 5795211.712
278 


Insert offset folio 713 here 5795211.713
279 


Insert offset folio 714 here 5795211.714
280 


Insert offset folio 715 here 5795211.715
281 


Insert offset folio 716 here 5795211.716
282 


Insert offset folio 364 here 57952.364
283 


Insert offset folio 365 here 57952.365
284 


Insert offset folio 366 here 57952.366
285 


Insert offset folio 367 here 57952.367
286 


Insert offset folio 368 here 57952.368
287 


Insert offset folio 687 here 5795211.687
288 


Insert offset folio 369 here 57952.369
289 


Insert offset folio 370 here 57952.370
290 


Insert offset folio 688 here 5795211.688
291 


Insert offset folio 371 here 57952.371
292 


Insert offset folio 372 here 57952.372
293 


Insert offset folio 373 here 57952.373
294 


Insert offset folio 374 here 57952.374
295 


Insert offset folio 375 here 57952.375
296 


Insert offset folio 306 here 57952.306
297 


Insert offset folio 307 here 57952.307
298 


Insert offset folio 308 here 57952.308
(299) 

II. COMMITTEE ACTIONS AND FILINGS OF 

THE PARTIES PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 4, 

2010 HEARING ON PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS 

a. Discovery Matters 

iv. Motions for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

from Third Parties 

300 

301 


Insert offset folio 323 here 57952.323
302 


Insert offset folio 324 here 57952.324
303 


Insert offset folio 325 here 57952.325
304 


Insert offset folio 326 here 57952.326
305 


Insert offset folio 327 here 57952.327
306 


Insert offset folio 328 here 57952.328
307 


Insert offset folio 329 here 57952.329
308 


Insert offset folio 330 here 57952.330
309 


Insert offset folio 331 here 57952.331
310 


Insert offset folio 332 here 57952.332
311 


Insert offset folio 333 here 57952.333
312 


Insert offset folio 334 here 57952.334
313 


Insert offset folio 335 here 57952.335
314 


Insert offset folio 336 here 57952.336
315 


Insert offset folio 337 here 57952.337
316 


Insert offset folio 338 here 57952.338
317 


Insert offset folio 339 here 57952.339
318 


Insert offset folio 340 here 57952.340
319 


Insert offset folio 341 here 57952.341
320 


Insert offset folio 342 here 57952.342
321 


Insert offset folio 343 here 57952.343
322 


Insert offset folio 344 here 57952.344
323 


Insert offset folio 345 here 57952.345
324 


Insert offset folio 346 here 57952.346
325 


Insert offset folio 347 here 57952.347
326 


Insert offset folio 348 here 57952.348
327 


Insert offset folio 349 here 57952.349
328 


Insert offset folio 350 here 57952.350
329 


Insert offset folio 351 here 57952.351
330 


Insert offset folio 352 here 57952.352
331 


Insert offset folio 353 here 57952.353
332 


Insert offset folio 354 here 57952.354
333 


Insert offset folio 355 here 57952.355
334 


Insert offset folio 356 here 57952.356
335 


Insert offset folio 357 here 57952.357
336 


Insert offset folio 358 here 57952.358
337 


Insert offset folio 359 here 57952.359
338 


Insert offset folio 360 here 57952.360
339 


Insert offset folio 361 here 57952.361
340 


Insert offset folio 145 here 579523.145
341 


Insert offset folio 146 here 579523.146
342 


Insert offset folio 147 here 579523.147
343 


Insert offset folio 148 here 579523.148
344 


Insert offset folio 362 here 57952.362
345 


Insert offset folio 363 here 57952.363
346 


Insert offset folio 309 here 57952.309
347 


Insert offset folio 310 here 57952.310
348 


Insert offset folio 311 here 57952.311
349 


Insert offset folio 312 here 57952.312
350 


Insert offset folio 313 here 57952.313
351 


Insert offset folio 314 here 57952.314
352 


Insert offset folio 315 here 57952.315
353 


Insert offset folio 316 here 57952.316
354 


Insert offset folio 317 here 57952.317
355 


Insert offset folio 318 here 57952.318
356 


Insert offset folio 319 here 57952.319
357 


Insert offset folio 320 here 57952.320
358 


Insert offset folio 321 here 57952.321
359 


Insert offset folio 322 here 57952.322
360 


Insert offset folio 262 here 579522.262
361 


Insert offset folio 263 here 579522.263
362 


Insert offset folio 264 here 579522.264
363 


Insert offset folio 265 here 579522.265
364 


Insert offset folio 266 here 579522.266
365 


Insert offset folio 267 here 579522.267
366 


Insert offset folio 268 here 579522.268
367 


Insert offset folio 269 here 579522.269
368 


Insert offset folio 270 here 579522.270
369 


Insert offset folio 271 here 579522.271
370 


Insert offset folio 272 here 579522.272
371 


Insert offset folio 273 here 579522.273
372 


Insert offset folio 274 here 579522.274
373 


Insert offset folio 275 here 579522.275
374 


Insert offset folio 276 here 579522.276
375 


Insert offset folio 277 here 579522.277
376 


Insert offset folio 278 here 579522.278
377 


Insert offset folio 279 here 579522.279
378 


Insert offset folio 280 here 579522.280
379 


Insert offset folio 281 here 579522.281
380 


Insert offset folio 282 here 579522.282
381 


Insert offset folio 283 here 579522.283
382 


Insert offset folio 284 here 579522.284
383 


Insert offset folio 285 here 579522.285
384 


Insert offset folio 286 here 579522.286
385 


Insert offset folio 287 here 579522.287
386 


Insert offset folio 288 here 579522.288
387 


Insert offset folio 289 here 579522.289
388 


Insert offset folio 290 here 579522.290
389 


Insert offset folio 291 here 579522.291
390 


Insert offset folio 292 here 579522.292
391 


Insert offset folio 293 here 579522.293
392 


Insert offset folio 294 here 579522.294
393 


Insert offset folio 295 here 579522.295
(395) 

II. COMMITTEE ACTIONS AND FILINGS OF 

THE PARTIES PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 4, 

2010 HEARING ON PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS 

b. Pre-Trial Filings regarding Witnesses and 

Subpoenas 

396 

397 


Insert offset folio 389 here 57952.389
398 


Insert offset folio 390 here 57952.390
399 


Insert offset folio 391 here 57952.391
400 


Insert offset folio 392 here 57952.392
401 


Insert offset folio 393 here 57952.393
402 


Insert offset folio 689 here 5795211.689
403 


Insert offset folio 690 here 5795211.690
404 


Insert offset folio 691 here 5795211.691
405 


Insert offset folio 396 here 57952.396
406 


Insert offset folio 397 here 57952.397
407 


Insert offset folio 398 here 57952.398
408 


Insert offset folio 399 here 57952.399
409 


Insert offset folio 400 here 57952.400
410 


Insert offset folio 401 here 57952.401
411 


Insert offset folio 402 here 57952.402
412 


Insert offset folio 403 here 57952.403
413 


Insert offset folio 404 here 57952.404
414 


Insert offset folio 405 here 57952.405
415 


Insert offset folio 406 here 57952.406
416 


Insert offset folio 407 here 57952.407
417 


Insert offset folio 408 here 57952.408
418 


Insert offset folio 409 here 57952.409
419 


Insert offset folio 410 here 57952.410
420 


Insert offset folio 411 here 57952.411
421 


Insert offset folio 412 here 57952.412
422 


Insert offset folio 413 here 57952.413
423 


Insert offset folio 414 here 57952.414
424 


Insert offset folio 415 here 57952.415
425 


Insert offset folio 416 here 57952.416
426 


Insert offset folio 417 here 57952.417
427 


Insert offset folio 418 here 57952.418
428 


Insert offset folio 419 here 57952.419
429 


Insert offset folio 420 here 57952.420
430 


Insert offset folio 421 here 57952.421
431 


Insert offset folio 422 here 57952.422
432 


Insert offset folio 423 here 57952.423
433 


Insert offset folio 424 here 57952.424
434 


Insert offset folio 425 here 57952.425
435 


Insert offset folio 426 here 57952.426
436 


Insert offset folio 427 here 57952.427
437 


Insert offset folio 428 here 57952.428
438 


Insert offset folio 429 here 57952.429
439 


Insert offset folio 430 here 57952.430
440 


Insert offset folio 431 here 57952.431
441 


Insert offset folio 432 here 57952.432
442 


Insert offset folio 433 here 57952.433
443 


Insert offset folio 434 here 57952.434
444 


Insert offset folio 435 here 57952.435
445 


Insert offset folio 436 here 57952.436
446 


Insert offset folio 437 here 57952.437
447 


Insert offset folio 438 here 57952.438
448 


Insert offset folio 439 here 57952.439
449 


Insert offset folio 440 here 57952.440
450 


Insert offset folio 441 here 57952.441
451 


Insert offset folio 442 here 57952.442
452 


Insert offset folio 443 here 57952.443
453 


Insert offset folio 444 here 57952.444
454 


Insert offset folio 445 here 57952.445
455 


Insert offset folio 446 here 57952.446
456 


Insert offset folio 447 here 57952.447
457 


Insert offset folio 448 here 57952.448
458 


Insert offset folio 449 here 57952.449
459 


Insert offset folio 450 here 57952.450
460 


Insert offset folio 451 here 57952.451
461 


Insert offset folio 452 here 57952.452
462 


Insert offset folio 453 here 57952.453
463 


Insert offset folio 454 here 57952.454
464 


Insert offset folio 455 here 57952.455
465 


Insert offset folio 456 here 57952.456
466 


Insert offset folio 457 here 57952.457
467 


Insert offset folio 458 here 57952.458
468 


Insert offset folio 459 here 57952.459
469 


Insert offset folio 460 here 57952.460
470 


Insert offset folio 461 here 57952.461
471 


Insert offset folio 462 here 57952.462
472 


Insert offset folio 463 here 57952.463
473 


Insert offset folio 464 here 57952.464
474 


Insert offset folio 465 here 57952.465
475 


Insert offset folio 466 here 57952.466
476 


Insert offset folio 467 here 57952.467
477 


Insert offset folio 468 here 57952.468
478 


Insert offset folio 469 here 57952.469
479 


Insert offset folio 537 here 57952.537
480 


Insert offset folio 538 here 57952.538
481 


Insert offset folio 539 here 57952.539
482 


Insert offset folio 540 here 57952.540
483 


Insert offset folio 541 here 57952.541
484 


Insert offset folio 542 here 57952.542
485 


Insert offset folio 543 here 57952.543
486 


Insert offset folio 476 here 57952.476
487 


Insert offset folio 477 here 57952.477
488 


Insert offset folio 478 here 57952.478
489 


Insert offset folio 530 here 57952.530
490 


Insert offset folio 531 here 57952.531
491 


Insert offset folio 532 here 57952.532
492 


Insert offset folio 533 here 57952.533
493 


Insert offset folio 534 here 57952.534
494 


Insert offset folio 535 here 57952.535
495 


Insert offset folio 536 here 57952.536
496 


Insert offset folio 479 here 57952.479
497 


Insert offset folio 480 here 57952.480
498 


Insert offset folio 481 here 57952.481
499 


Insert offset folio 482 here 57952.482
500 


Insert offset folio 483 here 57952.483
501 


Insert offset folio 484 here 57952.484
502 


Insert offset folio 485 here 57952.485
503 


Insert offset folio 486 here 57952.486
504 


Insert offset folio 487 here 57952.487
505 


Insert offset folio 488 here 57952.488
506 


Insert offset folio 489 here 57952.489
507 


Insert offset folio 490 here 57952.490
508 


Insert offset folio 491 here 57952.491
509 


Insert offset folio 492 here 57952.492
510 


Insert offset folio 493 here 57952.493
511 


Insert offset folio 494 here 57952.494
512 


Insert offset folio 495 here 57952.495
513 


Insert offset folio 496 here 57952.496
514 


Insert offset folio 497 here 57952.497
515 


Insert offset folio 498 here 57952.498
516 


Insert offset folio 499 here 57952.499
517 


Insert offset folio 500 here 57952.500
518 


Insert offset folio 501 here 57952.501
519 


Insert offset folio 502 here 57952.502
520 


Insert offset folio 503 here 57952.503
521 


Insert offset folio 504 here 57952.504
522 


Insert offset folio 505 here 57952.505
523 


Insert offset folio 506 here 57952.506
524 


Insert offset folio 507 here 57952.507
525 


Insert offset folio 508 here 57952.508
526 


Insert offset folio 509 here 57952.509
527 


Insert offset folio 510 here 57952.510
528 


Insert offset folio 511 here 57952.511
529 


Insert offset folio 512 here 57952.512
530 


Insert offset folio 513 here 57952.513
531 


Insert offset folio 514 here 57952.514
532 


Insert offset folio 515 here 57952.515
533 


Insert offset folio 516 here 57952.516
534 


Insert offset folio 517 here 57952.517
535 


Insert offset folio 518 here 57952.518
536 


Insert offset folio 519 here 57952.519
537 


Insert offset folio 520 here 57952.520
538 


Insert offset folio 521 here 57952.521
539 


Insert offset folio 522 here 57952.522
540 


Insert offset folio 523 here 57952.523
541 


Insert offset folio 524 here 57952.524
542 


Insert offset folio 525 here 57952.525
543 


Insert offset folio 526 here 57952.526
544 


Insert offset folio 527 here 57952.527
545 


Insert offset folio 528 here 57952.528
546 


Insert offset folio 529 here 57952.529
547 


Insert offset folio 470 here 57952.470
548 


Insert offset folio 471 here 57952.471
549 


Insert offset folio 472 here 57952.472
550 


Insert offset folio 473 here 57952.473
551 


Insert offset folio 474 here 57952.474
552 


Insert offset folio 475 here 57952.475
553 


Insert offset folio 01 here 57953.001
(555) 

II. COMMITTEE ACTIONS AND FILINGS OF 

THE PARTIES PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 4, 

2010 HEARING ON PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS 

c. Attorney Disqualification 

556 

557 


Insert offset folio 544 here 57952.544
558 


Insert offset folio 545 here 57952.545
559 


Insert offset folio 546 here 57952.546
560 


Insert offset folio 547 here 57952.547
561 


Insert offset folio 548 here 57952.548
562 


Insert offset folio 692 here 5795211.692
563 


Insert offset folio 549 here 57952.549
564 


Insert offset folio 550 here 57952.550
565 


Insert offset folio 689 here 57952.412
566 


Insert offset folio 551 here 57952.551
567 


Insert offset folio 552 here 57952.552
568 


Insert offset folio 553 here 57952.553
569 


Insert offset folio 554 here 57952.554
570 


Insert offset folio 555 here 57952.555
571 


Insert offset folio 556 here 57952.556
572 


Insert offset folio 557 here 57952.557
573 


Insert offset folio 558 here 57952.558
574 


Insert offset folio 559 here 57952.559
575 


Insert offset folio 560 here 57952.560
576 


Insert offset folio 561 here 57952.561
577 


Insert offset folio 562 here 57952.562
578 


Insert offset folio 563 here 57952.563
579 


Insert offset folio 564 here 57952.564
580 


Insert offset folio 565 here 57952.565
581 


Insert offset folio 566 here 57952.566
582 


Insert offset folio 567 here 57952.567
583 


Insert offset folio 568 here 57952.568
584 


Insert offset folio 569 here 57952.569
585 


Insert offset folio 570 here 57952.570
586 


Insert offset folio 571 here 57952.571
587 


Insert offset folio 572 here 57952.572
588 


Insert offset folio 573 here 57952.573
589 


Insert offset folio 574 here 57952.574
590 


Insert offset folio 575 here 57952.575
591 


Insert offset folio 576 here 57952.576
592 


Insert offset folio 577 here 57952.577
593 


Insert offset folio 578 here 57952.578
594 


Insert offset folio 579 here 57952.579
595 


Insert offset folio 580 here 57952.580
596 


Insert offset folio 581 here 57952.581
597 


Insert offset folio 582 here 57952.582
598 


Insert offset folio 583 here 57952.583
599 


Insert offset folio 584 here 57952.584
600 


Insert offset folio 585 here 57952.585
601 


Insert offset folio 586 here 57952.586
602 


Insert offset folio 587 here 57952.587
603 


Insert offset folio 588 here 57952.588
604 


Insert offset folio 589 here 57952.589
605 


Insert offset folio 590 here 57952.590
606 


Insert offset folio 591 here 57952.591
607 


Insert offset folio 592 here 57952.592
608 


Insert offset folio 593 here 57952.593
609 


Insert offset folio 594 here 57952.594
610 


Insert offset folio 595 here 57952.595
611 


Insert offset folio 596 here 57952.596
612 


Insert offset folio 597 here 57952.597
613 


Insert offset folio 598 here 57952.598
614 


Insert offset folio 599 here 57952.599
615 


Insert offset folio 600 here 57952.600
616 


Insert offset folio 601 here 57952.601
617 


Insert offset folio 602 here 57952.602
618 


Insert offset folio 603 here 57952.603
619 


Insert offset folio 604 here 57952.604
620 


Insert offset folio 605 here 57952.605
621 


Insert offset folio 606 here 57952.606
622 


Insert offset folio 607 here 57952.607
623 


Insert offset folio 608 here 57952.608
624 


Insert offset folio 609 here 57952.609
625 


Insert offset folio 610 here 57952.610
626 


Insert offset folio 611 here 57952.611
627 


Insert offset folio 612 here 57952.612
628 


Insert offset folio 613 here 57952.613
629 


Insert offset folio 614 here 57952.614
630 


Insert offset folio 615 here 57952.615
631 


Insert offset folio 616 here 57952.616
632 


Insert offset folio 617 here 57952.617
633 


Insert offset folio 618 here 57952.618
634 


Insert offset folio 619 here 57952.619
635 


Insert offset folio 620 here 57952.620
636 


Insert offset folio 621 here 57952.621
637 


Insert offset folio 622 here 57952.622
638 


Insert offset folio 623 here 57952.623
639 


Insert offset folio 624 here 57952.624
640 


Insert offset folio 625 here 57952.625
641 


Insert offset folio 626 here 57952.626
642 


Insert offset folio 627 here 57952.627
643 


Insert offset folio 628 here 57952.628
644 


Insert offset folio 629 here 57952.629
645 


Insert offset folio 630 here 57952.630
646 


Insert offset folio 631 here 57952.631
647 


Insert offset folio 632 here 57952.632
648 


Insert offset folio 633 here 57952.633
649 


Insert offset folio 634 here 57952.634
650 


Insert offset folio 635 here 57952.635
651 


Insert offset folio 636 here 57952.636
652 


Insert offset folio 637 here 57952.637
653 


Insert offset folio 638 here 57952.638
654 


Insert offset folio 639 here 57952.639
655 


Insert offset folio 640 here 57952.640
656 


Insert offset folio 641 here 57952.641
657 


Insert offset folio 642 here 57952.642
658 


Insert offset folio 643 here 57952.643
659 


Insert offset folio 644 here 57952.644