U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE

WASHINGTON :

For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office,

http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center,

U.S. Government Printing Office. Phone 202–512–1800, or 866–512–1800 (toll-free). E-mail, gpo@custhelp.com.

61–913 PDF 2010

S. Hrg. 111–691 

IMPEACHMENT TRIAL COMMITTEE 

ON THE ARTICLES AGAINST 

JUDGE G. THOMAS PORTEOUS, JR. 

HEARINGS

BEFORE THE

SENATE IMPEACHMENT TRIAL 

COMMITTEE 

UNITED STATES SENATE 

ONE HUNDRED ELEVENTH CONGRESS 

SECOND SESSION 

ON

THE ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT AGAINST JUDGE G. THOMAS 

PORTEOUS, JR., A JUDGE IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA 

November 16, 2010 

Volume 3 of 3, Part B 

( 

Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.access.gpo.gov/congress/senate 
ii

IMPEACHMENT TRIAL COMMITTEE ON THE ARTICLES 

AGAINST JUDGE G. THOMAS PORTEOUS, JR. 

CLAIRE MCCASKILL, Missouri, Chairman

ORRIN G. HATCH, Utah, Vice Chairman 

AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota 

SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island 

TOM UDALL, New Mexico 

JEANNE SHAHEEN, New Hampshire 

EDWARD E. KAUFMAN, Delaware 

JIM DEMINT, South Carolina 

JOHN BARRASSO, Wyoming 

ROGER WICKER, Mississippi 

MIKE JOHANNS, Nebraska 

JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho 

COMMITTEE STAFF 

DERRON R. PARKS, Staff Director and Chief Counsel 

THOMAS L. JIPPING, Deputy Staff Director and Deputy Chief Counsel 

JUSTIN KIM, Counsel

REBECCA S. SEIDEL, Counsel

ERIN P. JOHNSON, Deputy Counsel and Chief Clerk 

LAKE DISHMAN, Professional Staff Member 

CONGRESSIONAL RESEARCH SERVICE STAFF 

SUSAN NAVARRO SMELCER, Analyst on the Federal Judiciary 

SENATE LEGAL COUNSEL STAFF 

MORGAN J. FRANKEL, Senate Legal Counsel 

PATRICIA MACK BRYAN, Deputy Senate Legal Counsel 

GRANT R. VINIK, Assistant Senate Legal Counsel 

THOMAS E. CABALLERO, Assistant Senate Legal Counsel 
iii

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The Committee gratefully acknowledges the high standard of professionalism and 

long hours of dedicated service of its staff. The Committee also expresses its appreciation to Lynden C. Armstrong, Chief Clerk of the Committee on Rules and Administration, and to the following staff of Committee members: 

STAFF OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS 

Senator MCCASKILL, Chairman, Derron R. Parks 

Senator HATCH, Vice Chairman, Thomas L. Jipping 

Senator KLOBUCHAR, Paige Herwig 

Senator WHITEHOUSE, Stephen C. N. Lilley and Justin G. Florence 

Senator UDALL, Matthew T. Nelson 

Senator SHAHEEN, Thomas J. Maloney 

Senator KAUFMAN, Nhan Nguyen 

Senator DEMINT, Erica Suares 

Senator BARRASSO, Bryn Stewart 

Senator WICKER, Emily Ferris 

Senator JOHANNS, Sarah Novascone 

Senator RISCH, Jason Bohrer 

INTERNS

Christian Dibblee 

Timothy Holman 

Hannah Lockhart 

Annie Moulton 

Michael Naclerio 

Patrick Sadler 

v

C O N T E N T S 

VOLUME 1 

PART 1A 

I. Preliminary Matters ......................................................................................... 1 

a. Articles of Impeachment Against Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. (H. 

Res. 1031, 111th Cong., 2d Sess. (2010)) .................................................... 3 

b. Issuance of the Writ of Summons, S. Res. 457, 111th Cong., 2d Sess. 

(2010) ............................................................................................................. 12 

c. Authorization to Appoint Impeachment Trial Committee, S. Res. 458, 

111th Cong., 2d Sess. (2010) ........................................................................ 15 

d. Appointment of Impeachment Trial Committee (156 Cong. Rec. S1647- 

01, March 17, 2010) ...................................................................................... 18 

e. Writ of Summons (April 7, 2010) ................................................................ 19 

f. Answer of Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr., to the Articles of Impeachment (April 7, 2010) ...................................................................................... 21 

g. Replication of the House of Representatives to the Answer of Judge 

G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. (April 15, 2010) ................................................... 38 

h. Amended Replication of the House of Representatives to the Answer 

of Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. (April 22, 2010) .................................... 51 

i. Organizational Meeting of the Impeachment Trial Committee (April 

13, 2010) ........................................................................................................ 64 

j. House Managers’ Scheduling Letter (May 11, 2010) .................................. 76 

k. COMMITTEE ORDER: SITC Scheduling Order (May 26, 2010) ............. 79 

II. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Prior to the August 4, 

2010 Hearing on Pre-Trial Motions ................................................................ 81 

a. Discovery Matters 

i. General Issues 

1. House Managers’ Discovery Letter (April 13, 2010) .......................... 83 

2. House Managers’ Letter Requesting a Meeting (April 15, 2010) ...... 89 

3. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Discovery from House Managers (May 

28, 2010) ................................................................................................. 91 

4. House Managers’ Response to Judge Porteous Motion for Discovery 

from the House Managers (June 4, 2010) ............................................ 112 

5. House Managers’ Motion for Reciprocal Discovery from Judge 

Porteous (May 28, 2010) ........................................................................ 122 

6. Judge Porteous’s Response to the Motion of the House Managers 

for Discovery (June 4, 2010) ................................................................. 156 

7. COMMITTEE ORDER: SITC Disposition of Discovery Issues (June 

9, 2010) ................................................................................................... 159 

8. House Managers’ Exhibits Letter (June 15, 2010) ............................. 161 

ii. Depositions ................................................................................................ 163 

1. Judge Porteous’s Notice regarding Possible Future Deposition Requests (May 28, 2010) ............................................................................ 165 

2. House Managers’ Response to the Judge Porteous Notice regarding 

Possible Future Deposition Requests (June 4, 2010) .......................... 168 

3. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Authority to Issue, or Assistance 

in Issuing, Deposition Subpoenas (June 30, 2010) ............................. 170 

4. House Managers’ Opposition to Judge Porteous’s Motion for Authority to Issue, or Assistance in Issuing, Deposition Subpoenas 

(July 7, 2010) .......................................................................................... 180 

5. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (July 15, 2010) ..................... 204 

6. Adoption of Impeachment Trial Committee Rules (156 Cong. Rec. 

S5988-02, July 19, 2010) ....................................................................... 205 

7. Judge Porteous’s Request to Tape Depositions (July 27, 2010) ........ 207 

8. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (August 2, 2010) .................. 209 

iii. Motion to Compel .................................................................................... 211 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Compel Inspection of Non-Privileged 

Materials Collected and Maintained by the House of Representatives and Request for Expedited Consideration (June 27, 2010) ....... 213 
vi

II. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Prior to the August 4, 

2010 Hearing on Pre-Trial Motions—Continued 

iii. Motion to Compel—Continued 

2. House Managers’ Consolidated Opposition to Judge Porteous Motion to Compel and Motions for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

(July 1, 2010) .......................................................................................... 255 

3. Correspondence related to Judge Porteous’s Motion to Compel ........ 282 

a. Judge Porteous’s Letter in Support of Motion to Compel (July 

1, 2010) ................................................................................................ 282 

b. House Managers’ Response Letter (July 2, 2010) ........................... 285 

c. Judge Porteous’s Reply Letter (July 2, 2010) .................................. 293 

4. COMMITTEE ORDER: SITC Order on Judge Porteous’s Motion 

to Compel and for Depositions (July 19, 2010) ................................... 296 

iv. Motions for Assistance in Securing Discovery from Third Parties ...... 299 

1. Metropolitan Crime Commission (MCC) and American Bar Association (ABA) 

a. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

from the Metropolitan Crime Commission (June 27, 2010) ........... 301 

b. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

from the American Bar Association (June 30, 2010) ....................... 310 

c. Judge Porteous’s Notice of ABA Refusal to Provide Documents 

Voluntarily (July 13, 2010) ................................................................ 329 

d. Correspondence with the Senate Judiciary Committee 

i. SITC Letter to Senate Judiciary Committee (July 9, 2010) ........ 340 

ii. Senate Judiciary Committee Response Letter (July 27, 2010) .. 341 

iii. SITC Letter providing Judiciary Committee files to the parties (July 30, 2010) ......................................................................... 343 

e. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Judge Porteous’s Motions 

for Assistance in Securing Discovery from the MCC and the 

ABA (August 4, 2010) ........................................................................ 344 

2. Department of Justice (DOJ) ...............................................................

a. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Assistance in Securing Discovery 

from DOJ (June 27, 2010) ................................................................. 346 

b. Judge Porteous’s Request Letter to DOJ (June 30, 2010) .............. 360 

c. DOJ Response to Judge Porteous Declining Request for Documents (July 19, 2010) ........................................................................ 362 

b. Pre-Trial Filings regarding Witnesses and Subpoenas ............................. 395 

i. Judge Porteous’s Preliminary Designation of Witnesses, Requests 

for Subpoenas, Related Funding and Immunity Orders, and Response 

Addressing Stipulations regarding Art. I, III, IV (June 9, 2010) .......... 397 

ii. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding Article II filings (June 9, 2010) ..... 402 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Preliminary Designation of Witnesses as to Article 

II, Requests for Subpoenas as to Article II, Related Funding and 

Immunity Orders as to Article II, and Response Addressing Stipulations regarding Article II (June 10, 2010) ............................................... 405 

iv. House Managers’ Preliminary Designations of Witnesses and Requests for Subpoenas and Immunity Orders (June 8, 2010) ................. 413 

v. House Managers’ Supplemental Filing in Support of its Preliminary 

Requests (June 30, 2010) .......................................................................... 471 

vi. Judge Porteous’s Requests for Subpoenas and Immunity (August 

2, 2010) ....................................................................................................... 479 

vii. House Managers’ Supplemental Designation of Witnesses and Requests for Subpoenas (August 2, 2010) .................................................... 486 

viii. House Managers’ Memorandum in Support of calling Judge 

Porteous as a witness (August 2, 2010) ................................................... 489 

ix. Judge Porteous’s Motion Requesting Funding for his Defense (June 

30, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 547 

x. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Motion Requesting Funding 

for Defense (July 26, 2010) ....................................................................... 553 

c. Attorney Disqualification ............................................................................. 555 

i. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding Change in Representation (June 

9, 2010) ....................................................................................................... 557 

ii. House Managers’ Response Letter regarding Attorney Conflict of 

Interest (June 10, 2010) ............................................................................ 559 

iii. SITC Letter memorializing June 10, 2010 Meeting of all Counsel 

(June 10, 2010) .......................................................................................... 572 
vii

iv. Judge Porteous’s Response Letter to Counsel’s proposed ethical firewall (June 13, 2010 ................................................................................... 574 

v. Judge Porteous’s Motion for a Continuance (June 11, 2010) ................ 587 

vi. House Managers’ Opposition to Motion for a Continuance (June 

14, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 596 

vii. Judge Porteous’s Letter Requesting Motions Due Date Clarification 

(June 14, 2010) .......................................................................................... 619 

viii. Judge Porteous’s Expedited Motion for a Hearing (June 14, 2010) .. 621 

ix. COMMITTEE ORDER: Vacating Motion Filing Deadlines (June 14, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 624 

x. COMMITTEE ORDER: Motion for a Continuance (and Committee 

disqualification of Richard Westling) (June 21, 2010) ........................... 625 

xi. Judge Porteous’s Letter confirming full formal Withdrawal of attorneys Sam Dalton and Re ́my Voisin Starns (June 14, 2010) .................. 633 

xii. Judge Porteous’s Joint Motion for Withdrawal of Sam Dalton and 

Re ́my Voisin Starns (June 24, 2010) ....................................................... 634 

xiii. Judge Porteous’s Letter confirming Withdrawal of Richard 

Westling (June 24, 2010) .......................................................................... 659 

PART 1B 

d. Pre-Trial Motions .........................................................................................

i. Motions regarding the dismissal of the Articles of Impeachment ......... 661 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article I (July 21, 2010) ........... 663 

2. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article II (July 21, 2010) ......... 810 

3. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article III (July 21, 2010) ........ 868 

4. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss Article IV (July 21, 2010) ........ 928 

5. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Dismiss the Articles as Unconstitutionally Aggregated (July 21, 2010) ............................................................ 1040 

6. House Managers’ Consolidated Opposition to Judge Porteous’s Motions to Dismiss the Articles of Impeachment (July 28, 2010) .......... 1070 

ii. Cross Motions regarding the Admission of Judge Porteous’s Immunized Testimony Before the Fifth Circuit Special Committee ............... 1289 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Exclude the Use of His Previously 

Immunized Testimony (July 21, 2010) ................................................. 1291 

2. House Managers’ Opposition to Exclude Immunized Testimony 

(July 28, 2010) ....................................................................................... 1492 

3. House Managers’ Notice of Intent to Introduce Judge Porteous’s 

Fifth Circuit Testimony (July 21, 2010) .............................................. 1542 

4. Judge Porteous’s Objection to House Managers’ Notice of Intent 

to Introduce his Immunized Testimony (July 28, 2010) ..................... 1690 

iii. Cross Motions regarding the Admission of Prior Testimony, Transcripts and Records from Prior Judicial and Congressional Proceedings ...................................................................................................... 1703 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Exclude Prior Testimony and Limit 

the Presentation of Testimonial Evidence to Live Witnesses (July 

21, 2010) ................................................................................................. 1705 

2. House Managers’ Opposition to Porteous’s Motion to Exclude Prior 

Testimony and Limit the Presentation of Testimonial Evidence 

to Live Witnesses (July 28, 2010) ......................................................... 1721 

3. House Managers’ Motion to Admit Transcripts and Records from 

Prior Judicial and Congressional Proceedings (July 21, 2010) .......... 1724 

4. Judge Porteous’s Opposition the House Managers’ Motion to Admit 

Transcripts and Records from Prior Judicial and Congressional 

Proceedings (July 28, 2010) .................................................................. 1779 

iv. Motion for an Extended Evidentiary Hearing ....................................... 1795 

1. Judge Porteous’s Motion (July 21, 2010) ............................................. 1797 

2. House Managers’ Opposition Motion (July 28, 2010) ......................... 1826 

III. Pre-Trial Motions Hearing—August 4, 2010 ............................................... 1829 

a. COMMITTEE ORDER: Pretrial Hearing (August 2, 2010) ...................... 1831 

b. Pre-Trial Motions Hearing (August 4, 2010) .............................................. 1832 

c. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (August 4, 2010) .......................... 1966 

d. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Pre-Trial Motions (August 25, 

2010) ............................................................................................................... 1967 
viii

PART 1C 

IV. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Leading up to the September Evidentiary Hearings 

a. Filings regarding Witnesses and Subpoenas ............................................. 1975 

i. Judge Porteous’s Witness List (August 5, 2010) ..................................... 1977 

ii. House Managers’ Witness List (August 5, 2010) ................................... 1981 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Motion to Provide Travel Funding for Expert Witnesses (August 12, 2010) .......................................................................... 1984 

iv. COMMITTEE ORDER: Disposition of Judge Porteous’s Motion to 

Provide Travel Funding for Expert Witnesses (August 27, 2010) ......... 1992 

v. Porteous Motion to Add One Witness to the Subpoena List (August 

13, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 1993 

b. Ongoing Discovery ........................................................................................ 1997 

i. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (Department of Justice) ........... 1999 

ii. Judge Porteous Investigation Grand Jury Subpoena Log (August 

11, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 2001 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Letter in Support of Motion for Assistance in 

Securing Discovery from DOJ (August 17, 2010) ................................... 2010 

iv. SITC Committee Staff Informal Email to DOJ (August 19, 2010) ...... 2059 

v. SITC Letter to DOJ Assistant Attorney General Ron Weich (August 

25, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 2080 

vi. DOJ Production Cover Letter—Bodenheimer (August 27, 2010) ........ 2091 

vii. Judge Porteous’s Discovery Letter (August 27, 2010) ......................... 2092 

viii. Judge Porteous’s Motion for Subpoenas to be Issued to DOJ Attorneys (August 28, 2010) .............................................................................. 2094 

ix. DOJ Opposition to Judge Porteous’s Motion for Subpoenas to be 

issued to DOJ Attorneys (September 3, 2010) ........................................ 2115 

x. House Managers’ Response to Judge Porteous’s Motion for Subpoenas to be Issued to DOJ Attorneys (September 8, 2010) .................. 2139 

xi. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Request # 4 (September 3, 2010) ............................................................. 2144 

xii. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Requests # 10-16, 18 (September 7, 2010) .............................................. 2145 

xiii. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Requests # 17 and 19 (September 8, 2010) ............................................. 2147 

xiv. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Request # 1 (September 10, 2010) ........................................................... 2149 

xv. DOJ Production Cover Letter Responses to McCaskill 8/25 Letter 

Request # 8 (September 10, 2010) ........................................................... 2150 

xvi. DOJ Cover Letter regarding Disclosure Orders (September 10, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 2152 

xvii. Letter from DOJ Assistant Attorney General Ron Weich (September 12, 2010) ........................................................................................ 2154 

xviii. DOJ Cover Letter Response to 9/20 In Camera Review (September 20, 2010) ........................................................................................ 2159 

xix. DOJ Cover Letter Response to 9/20 In Camera Review (October 

29, 2010) ..................................................................................................... 2161 

c. Filings regarding Stipulations ..................................................................... 2163 

i. Judge Porteous’s Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 5, 2010) ......... 2165 

ii. House Managers’ Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 5, 2010) ....... 2200 

iii. Judge Porteous’s Responses to the House Managers’ Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 12, 2010) ............................................................. 2284 

iv. House Managers’ Responses and Objectives to Judge Porteous’s 

Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 12, 2010) .................................... 2363 

v. Judge Porteous’s Reply to the House Managers’ Responses to Judge 

Porteous’s Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 19, 2010) ................. 2438 

vi. House Managers’ Reply to Judge Porteous’s Responses to the House 

Managers’ Proposed Stipulations of Fact (August 19, 2010) ................. 2459 

vii. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding the Stipulations process (September 6, 2010) .......................................................................................... 2516 

viii. House Managers’ Response Letter (September 7, 2010) .................... 2521 

ix. Agreed Stipulations of Fact (September 8, 2010) ................................. 2526 

x. Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding the Submission of Joint Stipulations (September 9, 2010) ......................................................................... 2553 

xi. House Managers’ Response to Judge Porteous’s Letter regarding 

the Submission of Joint Stipulations (September 10, 2010) .................. 2576 

d. Pre-Trial Statements .................................................................................... 2579 
ix

IV. Committee Actions and Filings of the Parties Leading up to the September Evidentiary Hearings —Continued 

i. COMMITTEE ORDER: Designating Contents of Pre-Trial Statements 

including full list of subpoenaed witnesses of the SITC (August 26, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 2581 

ii. Judge Porteous’s Pre-Trial Statement (September 1, 2010) ................. 2584 

iii. House Managers’ Pre-Trial Statement (September 1, 2010) ............... 2659 

iv. Judge Porteous’s Pre-Trial Statement Supplement (September 8, 

2010) ........................................................................................................... 2755 

v. House Managers’ Request to divide Opening Statements (September 

7, 2010) ....................................................................................................... 2760 

VOLUME 2 

PART 2A 

V. Evidentiary Hearings—September 13–16 & 21, 2010 .................................. 1 

a. Evidentiary Hearings ................................................................................... 1 

i. Opening Statements .................................................................................. 7 

ii. The Case of the House Managers ........................................................... 117 

1. September 13, 2010 ............................................................................... 118 

a. Jacob J. Amato, Jr. ............................................................................ 118 

b. Robert Creely ..................................................................................... 248 

c. Joseph Mole ........................................................................................ 381 

2. September 14, 2010 ............................................................................... 443 

a. Louis Marcotte ................................................................................... 452 

b. Lori Marcotte ..................................................................................... 560 

c. Jeffery Duhon ..................................................................................... 605 

d. Aubrey Wallace .................................................................................. 631 

e. Rafael Goyeneche ............................................................................... 667 

f. Charles Gardner Geyh ....................................................................... 713 

3. September 15, 2010 ............................................................................... 741 

a. Charles Gardner Geyh ...................................................................... 744 

b. Rhonda Danos .................................................................................... 778 

c. Bobby Philip Hamil, Jr. ..................................................................... 813 

d. DeWayne Horner ............................................................................... 870 

e. Claude Lightfoot, Jr. .......................................................................... 982 

f. Duncan Keir ........................................................................................ 1093 

PART 2B 

iii. MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD (September 15, 2010) ............. 1137 

iv. The Case of Judge Porteous .................................................................... 1139 

1. September 15, 2010 ............................................................................... 1140 

a. Timothy Porteous .............................................................................. 1140 

b. Ronald Bodenheimer ......................................................................... 1168 

2. September 16, 2010 ............................................................................... 1246 

a. Rafael Pardo ....................................................................................... 1258 

b. S.J. Beaulieu, Jr. ............................................................................... 1376 

c. Don Gardner ....................................................................................... 1404 

d. Dane Ciolino ...................................................................................... 1480 

3. September 21, 2010 ............................................................................... 1549 

a. John Mamoulides ............................................................................... 1552 

b. Darcy Griffin ...................................................................................... 1634 

c. Henry Hildebrand .............................................................................. 1653 

d. Ronald Barliant ................................................................................. 1700 

e. Robert B. Rees .................................................................................... 1744 

f. G. Calvin Mackenzie .......................................................................... 1802 

VOLUME 3 

PART 3A 

VI. Post Trial Filings ........................................................................................... 1 

a. House Managers’ Response to Senator Whitehouse’s Inquiry during 

the Evidentiary Hearings (Sept. 28, 2010) ................................................. 3 

b. Judge Porteous’s Proposed Findings of Fact (October 1, 2010) ................ 6 

c. House Managers’ Proposed Findings of Fact (October 1, 2010) ................ 162 

VII. Filings regarding Exhibits ........................................................................... 235 

a. House Managers’ statement concerning Authenticity of Judge 

Porteous’s Exhibits (September 8, 2010) ..................................................... 237 

b. House Managers’ List of Exhibits to be Admitted (September 21, 2010) 238 
x

VII. Filings regarding Exhibits—Continued 

c. Judge Porteous’s Response to House List of Exhibits to be Admitted 

(September 23, 2010) .................................................................................... 274 

d. Agreed Exhibits to be Admitted (September 26, 2010) ............................. 281 

e. Disputed Exhibits to be Admitted (September 27, 2010) .......................... 300 

f. House Managers’ Letter regarding Exhibits (September 28, 2010) .......... 306 

g. Judge Porteous’s Response Letter (September 28, 2010) .......................... 336 

h. COMMITTEE ORDER: Order on Admitted Exhibits (November 4, 

2010) ............................................................................................................... 342 

PART 3B 

VIII. Exhibits Admitted (in numerical order) .................................................... 365 

NOTE: Exhibits with a notation (*) are not included in this report and 

are only available for viewing by the full Senate 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

1 ...................... House Resolution 15 .................................................................................................................. 367 

2 ...................... House Judiciary Committee Resolution (Jan. 22, 2009) ........................................................... 369 

3 ...................... House Judiciary Committee Resolution (May 12, 2009) ........................................................... 376 

4 ...................... DOJ Complaint Letter to 5th Circuit (5th Cir.) ......................................................................... 378 

5 ...................... 5th Cir. Special Investigatory Committee Report ..................................................................... 400 

6 (a) ................ 5th Cir. Judicial Council Order and Certification ..................................................................... 466 

6 (b) ................ 5th Cir. Judicial Council Dissent .............................................................................................. 472 

6 (c) ................ Judge Porteous’s Reply Memo ................................................................................................... 521 

7 (a) ................ Judicial Conference of the U.S. Letter to Speaker Pelosi ......................................................... 535 

7 (b) ................ Judicial Conference of the U.S. Certification to Speaker Pelosi ............................................... 536 

7 (c) ................ Judicial Conf. Report and Recommendations ........................................................................... 538 

8 ...................... 5th Cir. Order and Reprimand .................................................................................................. 594 

9 (a) ................ Pres. Clinton’s Nomination of Porteous .................................................................................... 602 

9 (b) ................ Senate Confirmation Hearings Excerpts .................................................................................... 605 

9 (c) ................ Cong. Rec. of Porteous Confirmation ........................................................................................ 655 

9 (d) ................ Judge Porteous’s Nomination Affidavit ..................................................................................... 657 

9 (e) ................ Judge Porteous’s Resignation Letter to State Court ................................................................. 658 

9 (f) ................. Judge Porteous’s Senate Questionnaire .................................................................................... 662 

10 .................... Judge Porteous’s 5th Cir. Testimony ......................................................................................... 698 

12 .................... Robert Creely 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ................................................................. 832 

17 .................... 5th Cir. Compulsion and Immunity Order for Judge Porteous ................................................. 870 

20 .................... Jacob Amato, Jr. 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................ 872 

21 (b) .............. Jacob Amato, Jr. Calendars 1999–2001 ................................................................................... 907 

21 (c) .............. Jacob Amato, Jr. Credit Card Records ...................................................................................... 958 

32 .................... Don Gardner 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 .................................................................. 1015 

35 (b) .............. Gardner Retainer Agreement ..................................................................................................... 1041 

43 .................... Rhonda Danos 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................... 1043 

48* .................. FBI Surveillance video (March 11, 2002) ................................................................................. 1075 

50 .................... PACER Docket Report of Liljeberg ............................................................................................. 1076 

51 (a) .............. Liljeberg: Motion to Substitute Counsel .................................................................................... 1128 

51 (b) .............. Liljeberg: Order Granting Motion to Substitute Counsel ........................................................... 1130 

52 .................... Liljeberg: Motion to Recuse ....................................................................................................... 1132 

53 .................... Liljeberg: Opposition to Motion to Recuse ................................................................................ 1145 

54 .................... Liljeberg: Motion to Leave to File Reply with Memo. ................................................................ 1154 

55 .................... Liljeberg: Response to Motion to Leave to File Reply w/ Memo ............................................... 1164 

56 .................... Lifemark Recusal Hearing Transcript ........................................................................................ 1174 

57 .................... Liljeberg: Judgment on Motion to Recuse (Denied) .................................................................. 1199 

58 .................... Liljeberg: Lifemark’s Recusal Motion Appeal to 5th Cir. .......................................................... 1201 

59 .................... Liljeberg: Order Denying Lifemark’s Recusal Motion Appeal to 5th Cir. .................................. 1329

60 (a) .............. Liljeberg: Motion to Substitute Counsel .................................................................................... 1331 

60 (b) .............. Liljeberg: Order Granting Motion to Substitute Counsel ........................................................... 1333 

61 .................... Liljeberg: Transcript Trial Excerpts ........................................................................................... 1335 

62 .................... Liljeberg: Opinion ....................................................................................................................... 1350 

63 .................... Lifemark Appellate opinion ........................................................................................................ 1455 

65 .................... Joseph Mole 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ................................................................... 1515 

67 .................... Cover Emails and Pres. Records re: Porteous .......................................................................... 1547 

69 (a) .............. DOJ Production 6/18/09 ............................................................................................................. 1565 

69 (b)* ............ FBI Background Check of Judge Porteous June 25, 2009 ........................................................ 1789

69 (b) .............. PORT297–301 Attachments to 69(i) ......................................................................................... 1790 

69 (b) .............. PORT491 2nd Hamil 302 ........................................................................................................... 1795 
xi

VIII. Exhibits Admitted (in numerical order)—Continued 

NOTE—Continued

Exhibit No. Description Page 

69 (b) .............. PORT492–494 3rd Hamil 302 ................................................................................................... 1796 

69 (d) .............. PORT594–597 MCC Report ........................................................................................................ 1799 

69 (d) .............. PORT610–629 Wallace Hearing Transcripts ............................................................................. 1803 

69 (d) .............. PORT672 Section 881 ................................................................................................................ 1823 

69 (d) .............. PORT673–677 Sections 881 (continued from PORT672) and 883 ........................................... 1824 

69 (i) ............... 1st Hamil 302 ........................................................................................................................... 1829 

69 (j) ............... FBI Interview of Judge Porteous (unredacted) .......................................................................... 1834 

69 (k) .............. FBI Interview of Judge Porteous (unredacted) .......................................................................... 1835 

70 .................... U.S. v. Marcottes: PACER Docket Report .................................................................................. 1838 

71 (a) .............. Louis Marcotte Plea ................................................................................................................... 1845 

PART 3C 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

71 (b) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Louis Marcotte Plea Agreement ................................................................... 1867 

71 (c) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Louis Marcotte Plea Agreement Addendum ................................................ 1874

71 (d) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Louis Marcotte Plea Agreement Factual Basis ........................................... 1878

71 (e) .............. Marcotte Imprisonment Document ............................................................................................ 1891 

71 (f) ............... U.S. v. Marcottes: Unsealed Pleadings ..................................................................................... 1897 

73 (a) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Plea Agreement ..................................................................... 1917 

73 (b) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Plea Agreement Addendum ................................................... 1923

73 (c) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Plea Agreement Factual Basis .............................................. 1927

73 (d) .............. U.S. v. Marcottes: Lori Marcotte Judgment ............................................................................... 1932 

77 (a) .............. Jeffery Duhon expungement records .......................................................................................... 1937 

77 (b) .............. Jeffery Duhon expungement records .......................................................................................... 1940 

77 (c) .............. Jeffery Duhon expungement records .......................................................................................... 1942 

81 .................... Aubrey Wallace Drug Possession File ........................................................................................ 1944 

82 .................... Aubrey Wallace Burglary File ..................................................................................................... 2005 

88 (d) .............. Bodenheimer Criminal Complaint ............................................................................................. 2112 

88 (e) .............. U.S. v. Bodenheimer: Plea Agreement ....................................................................................... 2116 

88 (f) ............... U.S. v. Bodenheimer: Plea Agreement Factual Basis ............................................................... 2122 

88 (g) .............. U.S. v. Bodenheimer: Plea Agreement Factual Basis Supplement ........................................... 2134

88 (h) .............. US v. Bodenheimer: Judgment and Probation .......................................................................... 2136 

90 (a) .............. Prof. Bail Agents Conf. 1996 .................................................................................................... 2137 

90 (b) .............. Prof. Bail Agents Conf. 1999 .................................................................................................... 2139 

102 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Report: 05/12/1997—Reporting Period: 01/01/1996– 

12/31/1996.

2141

102 (b) ............ 1996 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2145 

103 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Report: 05/13/1998—Reporting Period: 01/01/1997– 

12/31/1997.

2237

103 (b) ............ 1997 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2241 

104 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Report Date: 05/13/1999—Reporting Period: 01/01/ 

1998–12/31/1998.

2311

104 (b) ............ 1998 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2315 

105 (a) ............ Judge Porteous’s Financial Disclosure Form: 05/05/2000—Reporting Period: 01/01/1999– 

12/31/1999.

2384

105 (b) ............ 1999 Financial Disclosure Instructions ..................................................................................... 2388 

119 (a) ............ News Article ............................................................................................................................... 2458 

119 (z) ............ News Article ............................................................................................................................... 2459 

122 (b) ............ Claude Lightfoot crime Fraud Ruling ........................................................................................ 2460 

124 .................. Claude Lightfoot 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................ 2464 

125 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Petition ....................................................................................... 2492 

126 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Amended Petition ....................................................................... 2497 

127 .................. Judge Porteous’s Proposed Schedule Plan ................................................................................ 2499 

128 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Commencement Notice ............................................................... 2530 

129 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Memo to Record of Creditors Mtg ............................................ 2533

130 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Creditors Meeting Transcript .................................................... 2534 

131 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Amended Schedule F and Modified Chapter 13 Plan .............. 2538 

132 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Amended Chapter 13 Plan ........................................................ 2540 
xii

PART 3C—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

133 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Court Order Confirming Plan ..................................................... 2543 

134 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Trustee’s Notice of Intention to Pay Claims ............................. 2546 

135 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Trustee’s Ex Parte Motion to Amend the Plan ......................... 2547 

136 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Trustee’s Final Report ............................................................... 2548 

137 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy: Discharge of Debtor After Completion of Chapter 13 Plan ..... 2549 

138 (a) ............ Claude Lightfoot Handwritten Notes ......................................................................................... 2550 

138 (b) ............ Bankruptcy Worksheets .............................................................................................................. 2553 

139 .................. Cover Letter and Remainder of Lightfoot File .......................................................................... 2582 

140 .................. Fleet Credit Card Statements .................................................................................................... 2715 

141 .................. Judge Porteous Tax Return ........................................................................................................ 2723 

143 .................. Fidelity Money Market Statements of Transaction Items .......................................................... 2725 

144 .................. Judge Porteous’s Bank One Records ......................................................................................... 2732 

145 .................. Judge Porteous’s PO Box Application ........................................................................................ 2749 

146 .................. Claude Lightfoot Letter re: Proposal/Excluding Regions ........................................................... 2750 

148 .................. S.J. Beaulieu Pamphlet .............................................................................................................. 2754 

149 .................. Harrah’s Casino Credit Application ........................................................................................... 2759 

167 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statement for December 1996 .................................................. 2760

168 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statement for December 1997 .................................................. 2761

169 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statements for December 1998 ................................................ 2766

170 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statements for December 1999 ................................................ 2769

188 .................. Letter from Gegenheimer to Agent Horner ................................................................................ 2774 

189 (1) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2775 

189 (2) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2778 

189 (3) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2782 

189 (5) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2785 

189 (6) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2787 

189 (8) ............ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2792 

189 (10–14) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2795 

189 (16–20) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2813 

189 (22–25) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2834 

189 (27) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2857 

189 (28) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2859 

189 (29) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 2862 

189 (31–48) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2871 

189 (50–56) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 2963 

189 (58–65) .... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3000 

189 (67) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3031 

189 (68) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3036 

189 (69) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3044 

189 (71–76) .... Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3051 

189 (78) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3072 

189 (79) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3079 

189 (80) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3084 

189 (81) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3087 

189 (82) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3095 

189 (84) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3099 

189 (85) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3106 

189 (87) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3114 

189 (88) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3120 

189 (91–96) .... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3125 

189 (99) .......... Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3169 

189 (100) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3173 

189 (101) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3177 

189 (104) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3184 

189 (105) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3192 

189 (107) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3195 

189 (108) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3200 

189 (109) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3203 

189 (111) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3208 

189 (114) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3211 

189 (116) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3213 

189 (118–125) Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3217 

189 (127) ........ Curatorship ................................................................................................................................ 3249 

189 (130–48) .. Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3254 
xiii

PART 3C—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

189 (150–156) Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3340 

PART 3D 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

189 (157–90) .. Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3379 

189 (192–226) Curatorships .............................................................................................................................. 3530 

241 .................. FBI Surveillance video ............................................................................................................... 3697 

245 .................. Bodenheimer Factual Basis of Plea .......................................................................................... 3698 

246 .................. Aubrey Wallace 9/21/94 Proceeding .......................................................................................... 3710 

280 .................. Louis Marcotte Affidavit ............................................................................................................ 3715 

283 .................. Task Force Deposition Exhibit 83 Jacob Amato, Jr. Calendar June 1999 ................................ 3717 

295 .................. William E. Heitkamp Fifth Circuit Testimony October 30, 2007 .............................................. 3719

296 .................. Letter from S.J. Beaulieu, Jr. to Claude C. Lightfoot, enclosing correspondence from William 

E. Heitkamp.

3726

298 .................. Letter from Michael F. Adoue, staff attorney for S.J. Beaulieu, Jr., to FBI Agent Wayne 

Horner.

3728

299 .................. Letter from Noel Hillman, Chief, Public Integrity Section, Department of Justice, to S.J. 

Beaulieu, Jr.

3731

301 (a) ............ Judge Porteous Grand Casino Gulfport Patron Transaction Report (02/27/2001 markers) ..... 3732 

301 (b) ............ Judge Porteous Bank One Statement (with copies of checks to Grand Casino) March 23, 

2001–April 23, 2001.

3733

302 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry (03/02/2001 markers) ............ 3739 

303 .................. Judge Porteous Beau Rivage Credit History (one–time credit limit increase on 04/06/2001) 3741 

304 .................. Judge Porteous Beau Rivage Balance Activity (04/07/2001 markers) ..................................... 3742 

305 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry (04/10/2001 markers) ............ 3744 

306 .................. Judge Porteous Harrah’s Patron Credit Activity (04/30/2001 markers) ................................... 3746

307 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(05/07/2001 markers) ......... 3747 

308 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(05/16/2001 markers) ......... 3749 

309 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report (05/26/2001 markers) and corresponding Bank One records.3750

310 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(06/20/2001 markers) ......... 3753 

311 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(07/19/2001 markers) ......... 3754 

312 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(07/23/2001 markers) ......... 3755 

313 (a) ............ Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(08/20/2001 markers) ......... 3756 

313 (b) ............ Judge Porteous Treasure Chest IOU’s and Hold Checks Ledger ............................................... 3758

314 .................. Judge Porteous Harrah’s Patron Credit Activity (09/28/2001 markers) ................................... 3759

315 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry (10/13/2001 markers) ............ 3760 

316 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(10/17/2001 markers) ......... 3761 

317 .................. Judge Porteous Beau Rivage Balance Activity (10/31/2001 markers) ..................................... 3763 

318 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(11/27/2001 markers) ......... 3764 

319 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(12/11/2001 markers) ......... 3766 

320 .................. Judge Porteous Harrah’s Patron Credit Activity—(12/20/2001 markers) ................................ 3767 

321 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report—(2/12/2002 markers) .................. 3768 

322 .................. Judge Porteous Treasure Chest Customer Transaction Inquiry—(04/01/2002 markers) ......... 3769 

323 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report—(05/26/2002 markers) ................ 3770 

324 .................. Judge Porteous Application for credit increase at Grand Casino Gulfport (from $2,000 to 

$2,500).

3771

325 .................. Judge Porteous Grand Casino Patron Transaction Report (07/04/2002 markers) and corresponding Fidelity Money Market Account records.3772

326 .................. Central Credit, Inc. Gaming Report for Judge Porteous ........................................................... 3775 

329 .................. Fleet credit card statement with accompanying check written by Rhonda Danos, paying off 

balance in March 2001..

3777

330 .................. Fleet payment stub and check written by Judge Porteous September 2, 2002 ...................... 3780 

332 .................. Gerald Dennis Fink 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ........................................................ 3781 

335 .................. Judge Greendyke 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................ 3817 

337 .................. Agent Horner’s summary of gambling losses ........................................................................... 3832 

338 .................. Dewayne Horner 5th Cir. Testimony October 29, 2007 ............................................................. 3854 

339 .................. S.J. Beaulieu Letter to Claude Lightfoot #1 .............................................................................. 3915 

340 .................. S.J. Beaulieu Letter to Claude Lightfoot #2 .............................................................................. 3917 
xiv

PART 3D—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

341 (a) ............ Capital One credit card application August 13, 2001 ............................................................. 3920 

341 (b) ............ Judge Porteous’s Capital One credit card statements ............................................................. 3921 

342 .................. Claude Lightfoot Affidavit in Support of Attorney’s Fees ......................................................... 3943 

343 .................. Judge Porteous Asset and Liability Documents ........................................................................ 3949 

344 .................. 2001 Instructions for Completing Bankruptcy Official: Form 1, Voluntary Petition ................ 4147 

345 .................. 2001 Instructions for Completing Bankruptcy Schedules ........................................................ 4159 

346 .................. 2001 Instructions for Completing Bankruptcy Statement of Financial Affairs ........................ 4221 

350 (1–56) ...... Bonds ......................................................................................................................................... 4241 

351 (1–26) ...... Bonds ......................................................................................................................................... 4359 

370 (a) ............ 1999 PBUS Beau Rivage Convention Records related to Judge Porteous ............................... 4385 

370 (b) ............ 1999 PBUS Beau Rivage Convention Records related to Rhonda Danos ................................ 4387 

371 .................. Records related to 1996 and 1998 Marcotte–Danos Las Vegas Trips .................................... 4391 

372 (a) ............ Beef Connection Bill and Lori Marcotte Credit Card Record .................................................... 4394 

372 (b) ............ Lunch Receipt ............................................................................................................................ 4396 

372 (c) ............ Beef Connection Bill and Lori Marcotte Credit Card Record .................................................... 4398 

372 (d) ............ Lunch Receipt ............................................................................................................................ 4400 

373 (a) ............ Lunch Receipt ............................................................................................................................ 4402 

373 (c) ............ BBU Calendar, Beef Connection Bill and Lori Marcotte Credit Card Record ........................... 4405 

373 (d) ............ BBU Calendar, Beef Connection Bill and Norman Bowley Credit Card Record ....................... 4408 

375 .................. Emeril’s Receipt ......................................................................................................................... 4411 

376 .................. Judge Porteous’s Credit Card Statements May 1999 ............................................................... 4412 

377 .................. Caesar’s Palace Records (Creely’s credit card charges for Porteous’s Room) ........................ 4414 

378 .................. Robert Creely’s Credit Card Charges May 1999 ....................................................................... 4415 

381 .................. Judge Porteous Fidelity Records re: IRA .................................................................................... 4418 

382 .................. Judge Records related to $1,000 Beau Rivage Payment ......................................................... 4423 

383 .................. Additional Judge Porteous IRA Records .................................................................................... 4429 

439 (a)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from William E. Willis, Chair of the American Bar Association 

Standing Committee on Federal Judiciary, to Senator Biden re: Judge Porteous’s qualifications for appointment to the federal bench.

4451

439 (b)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Biography .......................................... 4451 

439 (c)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Blue Slips from Senator Breaux and 

Senator Johnston.

4451

439 (d)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Dates of Materials Received ............. 4451 

439 (e)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—Nomination Hearing Transcript ......... 4451 

439 (f)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: White House Nomination of Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. to be a 

United States District Judge for the Eastern District of Louisiana.

4451

439 (g)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Porteous Questionnaire .......................................................................... 4451 

439 (h)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Porteous Questionnaire and Financial Disclosure Form ........................ 4451 

439 (i)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—state court Cases .............................. 4451 

439 (j)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—state court opinions .......................... 4451 

439 (k)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—reversals of state court opinions ...... 4451 

439 (l)* ........... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—additional decisions requested ......... 4451 

439 (m)* ......... Senate Judiciary File: Judge G. Thomas Porteous, Jr.—news articles ..................................... 4451 

439 (n)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. to Senator Biden re: Senate 

Questionnaire supplemental materials.

4451

439 (o)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. to Senator Biden re: Senate 

Questionnaire supplemental materials.

4451

439 (p)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: Letter from G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. Staff Memorandum (Committee 

Confidential).

4451

439 (q)* .......... Senate Judiciary File: confidential notes taken from FBI file of G. Thomas Porteous, Jr. ...... 4451 

440 (a) ............ Pages 19–57: House Task Force Hearing (Part I)—November 17–18, 2009 .......................... 4452 

440 (b) ............ Pages 98–137: House Task Force Hearing (Part I)—November 17–18, 2009 ........................ 4491 

440 (c) ............ Pages 139–180: House Task Force Hearing (Part I)—November 17–18, 2009 ...................... 4531 

441 (a) ............ Pages 8–40 (omitting exhibits on pages 10, 11, 12, 39, and 40): House Task Force Hearing (Part II) December 8, 2009.4573

441 (b) ............ Pages 41–66: House Task Force Hearing (Part II) December 8, 2009 .................................... 4606 

441 (c) ............ Pages 66–82: House Task Force Hearing (Part II) December 8, 2009 .................................... 4632 

442 .................. Pages 41–79: House Task Force Hearing (Part III) December 10, 2009 ................................. 4649 

445 .................. SITC Deposition of Robert Creely .............................................................................................. 4688 
xv

PART 3E 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

446 .................. SITC Deposition of Jacob Amato ............................................................................................... 4827 

447 .................. SITC Deposition of Louis Marcotte ............................................................................................ 4926 

448 .................. SITC Deposition of Lori Marcotte ............................................................................................... 5071 

451 .................. Judge Porteous Bank One Records Aug.–Sept. 2001; Aug.–Sept. 2002; Aug.–Sept. 2003 ..... 5207 

452 (a) ............ Judge Porteous Bank One Records May–July 2002 .................................................................. 5220 

452 (b) ............ Judge Porteous Fidelity Records May–July 2002 ....................................................................... 5232 

453 .................. Judge Porteous Fidelity Records July–August 2002 ($1,300 check to Grand Casino Gulfport) 5235 

529 .................. Pre–Bankruptcy Fidelity Checks to Casinos .............................................................................. 5241 

530 .................. Post–Bankruptcy Fidelity Checks to Casinos ............................................................................ 5247 

1001 (a–y) ...... Legal Codes ............................................................................................................................... 5251 

1002 (j) ........... Rules of Prof. Conduct .............................................................................................................. 5481 

1002 (y) ........... Rules of Prof. Conduct .............................................................................................................. 5497 

1003 ................ Judge Porteous Tolling Agreement #1 ....................................................................................... 5538 

1004 ................ Judge Porteous Tolling Agreement #2 ....................................................................................... 5541 

1005 ................ Judge Porteous Tolling Agreement #3 ....................................................................................... 5544 

1007 ................ List of 24th JDC Judges ............................................................................................................ 5547 

1008 ................ Beef Connection Menu ............................................................................................................... 5553 

1061 ................ G. Calvin Mackenzie CV ............................................................................................................ 5557 

1064 ................ Newspaper Bankruptcy Announcements .................................................................................... 5565 

1067 ................ Rafael Pardo Law Review Article .............................................................................................. 5569 

1068 ................ Katherine Porter Law Review Article ......................................................................................... 5650 

1070 ................ The Honorable Steven W. Rhodes Law Review Article .............................................................. 5712 

1097 ................ Rafael Pardo CV ........................................................................................................................ 5767 

1098 ................ Ronald Barliant Bio ................................................................................................................... 5775 

1100 (b) .......... Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Petition ....................................................................................... 5778 

1100 (c) .......... Judge Porteous’s Bankruptcy Amended Petition ....................................................................... 5783 

1100 (d) .......... Judge Porteous’s Proposed Schedule Plan ................................................................................ 5785 

1100 (g) .......... Trustee’s Objection .................................................................................................................... 5814 

1100 (h) .......... Amended Schedule J .................................................................................................................. 5815 

1100 (i) ........... Amended Chapter 13 Plan ........................................................................................................ 5817 

1100 (o) .......... Chapter 13 Plan Summary ........................................................................................................ 5820 

1100 (z) ........... Trustee’s Final Report and Account .......................................................................................... 5823 

1104 ................ Good Faith: A Roundtable Discussion, 1 Am. Bankr. Inst. L. Rev. 11 (1993). ........................ 5824 

1108 ................ Letter from Beaulieu Staff Attorney .......................................................................................... 5857 

1109 ................ DOJ Letter to S.J. Beaulieu ........................................................................................................ 5860 

1111 (a–l) ....... Judicial Ethics Opinions ............................................................................................................ 5861 

1112 ................ Hamilton Jail Overcrowding Order ............................................................................................. 5955 

1113 ................ Jefferson Parish Criminal Justice System Report ..................................................................... 5959 

1115–1130 ...... Various Articles on Presidential Nominees ............................................................................... 5999 

1134 ................ Bail Law Review Article ............................................................................................................. 6046 

2001* .............. CD of 1986 Bail Bonds ............................................................................................................. 6076 

2002 ................ Bond subset (Sept. 1986) ......................................................................................................... 6077 

2003 ................ Bond subset (Feb. 1986) ........................................................................................................... 6128 

2004 ................ Bond subset (Dec. 1986) .......................................................................................................... 6169 

2005 ................ DOJ Letter to Chairman McCaskill (Sept. 12, 2010) ................................................................ 6198 

2006 ................ Jeffery Duhon record .................................................................................................................. 6203 

2007 ................ Greg Guidry 302 ........................................................................................................................ 6215 

IX. Demonstrative Exhibits utilized during the Committee’s Evidentiary 

Hearings (in numerical order) ......................................................................... 6217 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

190 .................. Chart of Curatorships given to Robert Creely from Judge Porteous ........................................ 6219

500 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 1: Fleet’’ .................................................................................. 6220 

501 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 2: Treasure Chest’’ .................................................................. 6221 

502 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 3: Tax Return’’ ........................................................................ 6222 

503 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 4: Fidelity’’ .............................................................................. 6223 

504 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 5: Undisclosed $2,000 in Bank One’’ ..................................... 6224 
xvi

IX. Demonstrative Exhibits utilized during the Committee’s Evidentiary 

Hearings (in numerical order)—Continued 

Exhibit No. Description Page 

505 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 6: Undisclosed Grand Casino Markers’’ ................................. 6225 

506 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 7: ‘‘Ortous’’ ............................................................................. 6226 

507 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 8: Gambling Losses/Statement Financial Affairs (Question 

8)’’.

6227

508 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 9: Violations of Order (Capitol One)’’ ..................................... 6228

510 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 11: Danos Payment to Beau Rivage’’ ..................................... 6229 

513 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 14: Payments to Fleet’’ ........................................................... 6230 

514 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 15: Bankruptcy Timeline’’ ....................................................... 6231 

515 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 16: Use of Fidelity pre-bankruptcy’’ ....................................... 6232

517 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 18: Use of Undisclosed Fidelity (cash horde)’’ ...................... 6233 

518 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 19: Post-Bankruptcy Fidelity Checks to Casinos’’ .................. 6234 

519 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 20: Wallace (Intro)’’ ................................................................ 6235 

520 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 21: Wallace Slide 2’’ ............................................................... 6236 

521 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 22: Wallace Slide 3’’ ............................................................... 6237 

522 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 23: Wallace Slide 4’’ ............................................................... 6238 

523 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 24: Wallace Slide 5’’ ............................................................... 6239 

524 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 30: 1996 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6240 

525 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 31: 1997 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6241 

526 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 32: 1998 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6242 

527 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 33: 1999 Porteous Financial Disclosure Form’’ ...................... 6243 

528 .................. ‘‘House Demonstrative—Chart 34: Instructions to Financial Disclosure Forms’’ .................... 6244 

532 .................. Summary Chart: Judge Porteous’s Gambling Markers—July 2001 through July 2002 ........... 6245 
(365) 

Volume 3 of 3, Part B 

VIII. EXHIBITS ADMITTED 

(IN NUMERICAL ORDER) 
366 
367 
368 
369 
370 
371 
372 
373 
374 
375 
376 
377 
378 
379 
380 
381 
382 
383 
384 
385 
386 
387 
388 
389 
390 
391 
392 
393 
394 
395 
396 
397 
398 
399 
400 
401 
402 
403 
404 
405 
406 
407 
408 
409 
410 
411 
412 
413 
414 
415 
416 
417 
418 
419 
420 
421 
422 
423 
424 
425 
426 
427 
428 
429 
430 
431 
432 
433 
434 
435 
436 
437 
438 
439 
440 
441 
442 
443 
444 
445 
446 
447 
448 
449 
450 
451 
452 
453 
454 
455 
456 
457 
458 
459 
460 
461 
462 
463 
464 
465 
466 
467 
468 
469 
470 
471 
472 
473 
474 
475 
476 
477 
478 
479 
480 
481 
482 
483 
484 
485 
486 
487 
488 
489 
490 
491 
492 
493 
494 
495 
496 
497 
498 
499 
500 
501 
502 
503 
504 
505 
506 
507 
508 
509 
510 
511 
512 
513 
514 
515 
516 
517 
518 
519 
520 
521 
522 
523 
524 
525 
526 
527 
528 
529 
530 
531 
532 
533 
534 
535 
536 
537 
538 
539 
540 
541 
542 
543 
544 
545 
546 
547 
548 
549 
550 
551 
552 
553 
554 
555 
556 
557 
558 
559 
560 
561 
562 
563 
564 
565 
566 
567 
568 
569 
570 
571 
572 
573 
574 
575 
576 
577 
578 
579 
580 
581 
582 
583 
584 
585 
586 
587 
588 
589 
590 
591 
592 
593 
594 
595 
596 
597 
598 
599 
600 
601 
602 
603 
604 
605 
606 
607 
608 
609 
610 
611 
612 
613 
614 
615 
616 
617 
618 
619 
620 
621 
622 
623 
624 
625 
626 
627 
628 
629 
630 
631 
632 
633 
634 
635 
636 
637 
638 
639 
640 
641 
642 
643 
644 
645 
646 
647 
648 
649 
650 
651 
652 
653 
654 
655 
656 
657 
658 
659 
660 
661 
662 
663 
664 
665 
666 
667 
668 
669 
670 
671 
672 
673 
674 
675 
676 
677 
678 
679 
680 
681 
682 
683 
684 
685 
686 
687 
688 
689 
690 
691 
692 
693 
694 
695 
696 
697 
698 
699 
700 
701 
702 
703 
704 
705 
706 
707 
708 
709 
710 
711 
712 
713 
714 
715 
716 
717 
718 
719 
720 
721 
722 
723 
724 
725 
726 
727 
728 
729 
730 
731 
732 
733 
734 
735 
736 
737 
738 
739 
740 
741 
742 
743 
744 
745 
746 
747 
748 
749 
750 
751 
752 
753 
754 
755 
756 
757 
758 
759 
760 
761 
762 
763 
764 
765 
766 
767 
768 
769 
770 
771 
772 
773 
774 
775 
776 
777 
778 
779 
780 
781 
782 
783 
784 
785 
786 
787 
788 
789 
790 
791 
792 
793 
794 
795 
796 
797 
798 
799 
800 
801 
802 
803 
804 
805 
806 
807 
808 
809 
810 
811 
812 
813 
814 
815 
816 
817 
818 
819 
820 
821 
822 
823 
824 
825 
826 
827 
828 
829 
830 
831 
832 
833 
834 
835 
836 
837 
838 
839 
840 
841 
842 
843 
844 
845 
846 
847 
848 
849 
850 
851 
852 
853 
854 
855 
856 
857 
858 
859 
860 
861 
862 
863 
864 
865 
866 
867 
868 
869 
870 
871 
872 
873 
874 
875 
876 
877 
878 
879 
880 
881 
882 
883 
884 
885 
886 
887 
888 
889 
890 
891 
892 
893 
894 
895 
896 
897 
898 
899 
900 
901 
902 
903 
904 
905 
906 
907 
908 
909 
910 
911 
912 
913 
914 
915 
916 
917 
918 
919 
920 
921 
922 
923 
924 
925 
926 
927 
928 
929 
930 
931 
932 
933 
934 
935 
936 
937 
938 
939 
940 
941 
942 
943 
944 
945 
946 
947 
948 
949 
950 
951 
952 
953 
954 
955 
956 
957 
958 
959 
960 
961 
962 
963 
964 
965 
966 
967 
968 
969 
970 
971 
972 
973 
974 
975 
976 
977 
978 
979 
980 
981 
982 
983 
984 
985 
986 
987 
988 
989 
990 
991 
992 
993 
994 
995 
996 
997 
998 
999 
1000 
1001 
1002 
1003 
1004 
1005 
1006 
1007 
1008 
1009 
1010 
1011 
1012 
1013 
1014 
1015 
1016 
1017 
1018 
1019 
1020 
1021 
1022 
1023 
1024 
1025 
1026 
1027 
1028 
1029 
1030 
1031 
1032 
1033 
1034 
1035 
1036 
1037 
1038 
1039 
1040 
1041 
1042 
1043 
1044 
1045 
1046 
1047 
1048 
1049 
1050 
1051 
1052 
1053 
1054 
1055 
1056 
1057 
1058 
1059 
1060 
1061 
1062 
1063 
1064 
1065 
1066 
1067 
1068 
1069 
1070 
1071 
1072 
1073 
1074 
1075 
1076 
1077 
1078 
1079 
1080 
1081 
1082 
1083 
1084 
1085 
1086 
1087 
1088 
1089 
1090 
1091 
1092 
1093 
1094 
1095 
1096 
1097 
1098 
1099 
1100 
1101 
1102 
1103 
1104 
1105 
1106 
1107 
1108 
1109 
1110 
1111 
1112 
1113 
1114 
1115 
1116 
1117 
1118 
1119 
1120 
1121 
1122 
1123 
1124 
1125 
1126 
1127 
1128 
1129 
1130 
1131 
1132 
1133 
1134 
1135 
1136 
1137 
1138 
1139 
1140 
1141 
1142 
1143 
1144 
1145 
1146 
1147 
1148 
1149 
1150 
1151 
1152 
1153 
1154 
1155 
1156 
1157 
1158 
1159 
1160 
1161 
1162 
1163 
1164 
1165 
1166 
1167 
1168 
1169 
1170 
1171 
1172 
1173 
1174 
1175 
1176 
1177 
1178 
1179 
1180 
1181 
1182 
1183 
1184 
1185 
1186 
1187 
1188 
1189 
1190 
1191 
1192 
1193 
1194 
1195 
1196 
1197 
1198 
1199 
1200 
1201 
1202 
1203 
1204 
1205 
1206 
1207 
1208 
1209 
1210 
1211 
1212 
1213 
1214 
1215 
1216 
1217 
1218 
1219 
1220 
1221 
1222 
1223 
1224 
1225 
1226 
1227 
1228 
1229 
1230 
1231 
1232 
1233 
1234 
1235 
1236 
1237 
1238 
1239 
1240 
1241 
1242 
1243 
1244 
1245 
1246 
1247 
1248 
1249 
1250 
1251 
1252 
1253 
1254 
1255 
1256 
1257 
1258 
1259 
1260 
1261 
1262 
1263 
1264 
1265 
1266 
1267 
1268 
1269 
1270 
1271 
1272 
1273 
1274 
1275 
1276 
1277 
1278 
1279 
1280 
1281 
1282 
1283 
1284 
1285 
1286 
1287 
1288 
1289 
1290 
1291 
1292 
1293 
1294 
1295 
1296 
1297 
1298 
1299 
1300 
1301 
1302 
1303 
1304 
1305 
1306 
1307 
1308 
1309 
1310 
1311 
1312 
1313 
1314 
1315 
1316 
1317 
1318 
1319 
1320 
1321 
1322 
1323 
1324 
1325 
1326 
1327 
1328 
1329 
1330 
1331 
1332 
1333 
1334 
1335 
1336 
1337 
1338 
1339 
1340 
1341 
1342 
1343 
1344 
1345 
1346 
1347 
1348 
1349 
1350 
1351 
1352 
1353 
1354 
1355 
1356 
1357 
1358 
1359 
1360 
1361 
1362 
1363 
1364 
1365 
1366 
1367 
1368 
1369 
1370 
1371 
1372 
1373 
1374 
1375 
1376 
1377 
1378 
1379 
1380 
1381 
1382 
1383 
1384 
1385 
1386 
1387 
1388 
1389 
1390 
1391 
1392 
1393 
1394 
1395 
1396 
1397 
1398 
1399 
1400 
1401 
1402 
1403 
1404 
1405 
1406 
1407 
1408 
1409 
1410 
1411 
1412 
1413 
1414 
1415 
1416 
1417 
1418 
1419 
1420 
1421 
1422 
1423 
1424 
1425 
1426 
1427 
1428 
1429 
1430 
1431 
1432 
1433 
1434 
1435 
1436 
1437 
1438 
1439 
1440 
1441 
1442 
1443 
1444 
1445 
1446 
1447 
1448 
1449 
1450 
1451 
1452 
1453 
1454 
1455 
1456 
1457 
1458 
1459 
1460 
1461 
1462 
1463 
1464 
1465 
1466 
1467 
1468 
1469 
1470 
1471 
1472 
1473 
1474 
1475 
1476 
1477 
1478 
1479 
1480 
1481 
1482 
1483 
1484 
1485 
1486 
1487 
1488 
1489 
1490 
1491 
1492 
1493 
1494 
1495 
1496 
1497 
1498 
1499 
1500 
1501 
1502 
1503 
1504 
1505 
1506 
1507 
1508 
1509 
1510 
1511 
1512 
1513 
1514 
1515 
1516 
1517 
1518 
1519 
1520 
1521 
1522 
1523 
1524 
1525 
1526 
1527 
1528 
1529 
1530 
1531 
1532 
1533 
1534 
1535 
1536 
1537 
1538 
1539 
1540 
1541 
1542 
1543 
1544 
1545 
1546 
1547 
1548 
1549 
1550 
1551 
1552 
1553 
1554 
1555 
1556 
1557 
1558 
1559 
1560 
1561 
1562 
1563 
1564 
1565 
1566 
1567 
1568 
1569 
1570 
1571 
1572 
1573 
1574 
1575 
1576 
1577 
1578 
1579 
1580 
1581 
1582 
1583 
1584 
1585 
1586 
1587 
1588 
1589 
1590 
1591 
1592 
1593 
1594 
1595 
1596 
1597 
1598 
1599 
1600 
1601 
1602 
1603 
1604 
1605 
1606 
1607 
1608 
1609 
1610 
1611 
1612 
1613 
1614 
1615 
1616 
1617 
1618 
1619 
1620 
1621 
1622 
1623 
1624 
1625 
1626 
1627 
1628 
1629 
1630 
1631 
1632 
1633 
1634 
1635 
1636 
1637 
1638 
1639 
1640 
1641 
1642 
1643 
1644 
1645 
1646 
1647 
1648 
1649 
1650 
1651 
1652 
1653 
1654 
1655 
1656 
1657 
1658 
1659 
1660 
1661 
1662 
1663 
1664 
1665 
1666 
1667 
1668 
1669 
1670 
1671 
1672 
1673 
1674 
1675 
1676 
1677 
1678 
1679 
1680 
1681 
1682 
1683 
1684 
1685 
1686 
1687 
1688 
1689 
1690 
1691 
1692 
1693 
1694 
1695 
1696 
1697 
1698 
1699 
1700 
1701 
1702 
1703 
1704 
1705 
1706 
1707 
1708 
1709 
1710 
1711 
1712 
1713 
1714 
1715 
1716 
1717 
1718 
1719 
1720 
1721 
1722 
1723 
1724 
1725 
1726 
1727 
1728 
1729 
1730 
1731 
1732 
1733 
1734 
1735 
1736 
1737 
1738 
1739 
1740 
1741 
1742 
1743 
1744 
1745 
1746 
1747 
1748 
1749 
1750 
1751 
1752 
1753 
1754 
1755 
1756 
1757 
1758 
1759 
1760 
1761 
1762 
1763 
1764 
1765 
1766 
1767 
1768 
1769 
1770 
1771 
1772 
1773 
1774 
1775 
1776 
1777 
1778 
1779 
1780 
1781 
1782 
1783 
1784 
1785 
1786 
1787 
1788 
1789 
1790 
1791 
1792 
1793 
1794 
1795 
1796 
1797 
1798 
1799 
1800 
1801 
1802 
1803 
1804 
1805 
1806 
1807 
1808 
1809 
1810 
1811 
1812 
1813 
1814 
1815 
1816 
1817 
1818 
1819 
1820 
1821 
1822 
1823 
1824 
1825 
1826 
1827 
1828 
1829 
1830 
1831 
1832 
1833 
1834 
1835 
1836 
1837 
1838 
1839 
1840 
1841 
1842 
1843 
1844 
1845 
1846 
1847 
1848 
1849 
1850 
1851 
1852 
1853 
1854 
1855 
1856 
1857 
1858 
1859 
1860 
1861 
1862 
1863