1 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA 

CASE NO. 1:22-cv-24066-KMM 

GRACE, INC.; ENGAGE MIAMI, INC.; 

SOUTH DADE BRANCH OF THE NAACP; 

MIAMI-DADE BRACH OF THE NAACP; 

CLARICE COOPER; YANELIS VALDES; 

JARED JOHNSON; and ALEXANDER 

CONTRERAS, and STEVEN MIRO, 

Plaintiffs, 

v. 

CITY OF MIAMI, 

Defendant. 

/ 

DEFENDANTS’ TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST 

EXHIBIT 

NO. 

DESCRIPTION PLAINTIFFS’

OBJECTIONS

1. City of Miami Resolution R-21-0485 

2. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0030 

3. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0031 

4. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0032 

5. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0033 

6. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0070 

7. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0851 

8. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0114 

9. City of Miami Resolution R-22-0117 

10. City of Miami Resolution R-23-171 

11. City of Miami Resolution R-23-271 

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 1 of 4
EXHIBIT 

NO. 

DESCRIPTION PLAINTIFFS’

OBJECTIONS

12. City of Miami Resolution R-22-131 adopting Enacted 

Plan, with exhibit 

13. City of Miami Master Report on Resolution R-22-131 

14. Recording and transcript of Commission Meeting 

addressing redistricting held on November 18, 2021 

15. Recording and transcript of Commission Meeting 

addressing redistricting held on December 9, 2021 

16. Recording and transcript of Commission Meeting 

addressing redistricting held on February 7, 2022 

17. Recording and transcript of Commission Meeting 

addressing redistricting held on February 25, 2022 

18. Recording and transcript of Commission Meeting 

addressing redistricting held on March 11, 2022 

19. Recording and transcript of Commission Meeting 

addressing redistricting held on March 24, 2022 

20. Recording and transcript of Commission Meeting 

addressing redistricting held on June 14, 2023 

21. Records maintained by the City of Miami regarding 

public submissions related to proposed redistricting 

plans 

22. Consultant Presentations made to the Miami City 

Commission on November 18, 2021 

23. Consultant Presentations made to the Miami City 

Commission on February 7, 2022 

24. Consultant Presentations made to the Miami City 

Commission on February 25, 2022 

25. Consultant Presentations made to the Miami City 

Commission on March 11, 2022 

26. Consultant Presentations made to the Miami City 

Commission on March 24, 2022 

R

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 2 of 4
EXHIBIT 

NO. 

DESCRIPTION PLAINTIFFS’

OBJECTIONS

27. 2013 Benchmark plan and supporting materials 

28. 2023 Enacted plan and supporting materials 

29. P.L. 94-171 Redistricting Data for City of Miami 

30. Data utilized and relied on by City of Miami Consultants 

in drawing Enacted Plan, including current and historic 

demographic data, and current and historic elections data 

31. Organizational plaintiffs information regarding 

membership, composition, and organizational mission 

and historic operations 

32. 1997 Redistricting Plan and supporting materials 

33. 2003 Redistricting Plan and supporting materials 

34. Redistricting Miami 2022, Revised Districting Plan 

Report by Miguel A. DeGrandy, Esq. and Stephen M. 

Cody, J.D. dated February 22, 2022 

35. Deposition Transcript – Miguel A. DeGrandy, Esq. 

36. Deposition Transcript – Stephen M. Cody, J.D. 

37. Deposition Transcript – Alexandra Contreras 

38. Deposition Transcript – Clarice Cooper 

39. Deposition Transcript – Harold Ford 

40. Deposition Transcript – Jared Johnson 

41. Deposition Transcript – Steven Miro 

42. Deposition Transcript – Yanelis Valdes 

43. Deposition Transcript – GRACE, Inc. 

44. Deposition Transcript – Engage Miami, Inc. 

45. Deposition Transcript – Miami-Dade NAACP 

H

H

R, H

R, H

R, UP

R, UP

R, H, UP

R, UP

R, UP

R, UP

R, UP

R, UP

R, UP

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 3 of 4
EXHIBIT 

NO. 

DESCRIPTION PLAINTIFFS’

OBJECTIONS

46. Deposition Transcript – South Dade NAACP 

47. Deposition Transcript – City of Miami, Todd Hannon 

48. Deposition Transcript – City of Miami, Larry Spring 

49. Deposition Transcript –Miami-Dade County Elections 

Department, Christina White 

50. Deposition Transcript – Carolyn Abbot, Ph.D. 

51. Deposition Transcript – John Alford, Ph.D. 

52. Deposition Transcript – Cory McCartan, Ph.D. 

53. Deposition Transcript – Bryant Moy, Ph.D. 

54. Expert Report – Carolyn Abbot, Ph.D. 

55. Expert Report – John Alford, Ph.D. 

56. Expert Report – Cory McCartan, Ph.D. 

57. Expert Report – Bryant Moy, Ph.D. 

58. Documents produced by Plaintiffs and their experts, 

including Plaintiffs’ expert reports, Plaintiffs’ Plans 1 

through 4, and the associated demographic data 

59. All documents necessary for rebuttal or impeachment 

60. All documents identified as exhibits by Plaintiffs 

61. All demonstrative exhibits 

R, UP

H

H

H

H

R, H

R, H

R, H

R, H

R, H

R, H

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 4 of 4