Plfs.' Tr. 

Ex.

Bates Number ECF Doc Date Description File Name Category Obj. Codes

1 24-11 11/18/2021 Nov 18 2021 Transcript 2021-22 Transcripts

2 24-12 12/9/2021 Dec 9 2021 Transcript 2021-22 Transcripts

3 24-13 2/7/2022 Feb 7 2022 Transcript 2021-22 Transcripts

4 24-14 2/25/2022 Feb 25 2022 Transcript AM 2021-22 Transcripts

5 24-15 2/25/2022 Feb 25 2022 Transcript PM 2021-22 Transcripts

6 24-16 3/11/2022 Mar 11 2022 Transcript AM 2021-22 Transcripts

7 24-17 3/11/2022 Mar 11 2022 Transcript PM 2021-22 Transcripts

8 24-18 3/24/2022 Mar 24 2022 Transcript 2021-22 Transcripts

9 COM24066-

027841

7/8/2021 2022 cycle De Grandy contract -clean copy Holland Knight PSA - 

Redistricting Services (Matter 21-354).pdf

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

10 COM24066-

028531

2/10/2021 Bid waiver for De Grandy contract Resolution R-21-0084 - Bid Waiver – 

Miguel De Grandy.pdf

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

11 COM24066-

052672

10/21/2021 2021 De Grandy VRA instructions 00000494_RE_ City of Miami 

Redistricting Update.msg

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

12 COM24066-

000772

11/12/2021 Nov 2022 De Grandy Initial Report 

cover email

PRR Responsive Records 10-31-22 

single_Redacted.pdf

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

13 COM24066-

000812

11/12/2021 Nov 2022 De Grandy Initial Report Redistrictng Initial Report and Legal

Primer_49399045v1.PDF

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

14 COM24066-

000066

24-3 11/18/2021 Nov 18 2021 De Grandy slides 11-18-21 CC Mtg - Miguel DeGrandy - 

PowerPoint 

Presentation_49399056v1.PDF

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

15 COM24066-

000001

24-4 2/7/2022 Feb 7 2022 De Grandy slides 02-07-22 SCC Mtg - Miguel DeGrandy - 

Redistricting 

Presentation_49399049v1.PDF

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

16 COM24066-

000040

24-5 2/7/2022 Feb 7 2022 De Grandy talking points 02-07-22 SCC Mtg - Miguel DeGrandy - 

Talking Points for Presentation.pdf

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

17 COM24066-

000643

24-6 2/7/2022 Feb. 7, 2022 Cody Memo on Areas 

Moved in Feb. 7 Draft

Memo - Miguel A. DeGrandy - 

Characteristics of Areas of Movement in 

the City of Miami (2.7.2022).pdf

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

18 COM24066-

009601

2/22/2022 De Grandy Redistricting Miami 2022 

report

Redistricting Miami 2022.pdf 2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

GRACE, Inc. v. City of Miami, S.D. Fla. 22-cv-24066-KMM

Plaintiffs' Rule 26(a)(3) Pre-Trial Disclosures Exhibit 1

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 1 of 7
19 COM24066-

000122

24-7 2/25/2022 Feb 25 2022 De Grandy slides 11493 Submittal - Miguel DeGrandy - 

Presentation to City Commission - 

Revised Plan 2-2522_49399055v1.PDF

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

20 COM24066-

000153

24-8 3/11/2022 Mar 11 2022 De Grandy slides 11582 Submittal - Miguel DeGrandy - 

Presentation to City Commission 03-11-

2022_49399046v1.PDF

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

21 COM24066-

045285

3/11/2022 Alternative: Keep Areas South of US 

1 in D2 and Adjust D3 City of Miami

Submittal - Miguel DeGrandy - Keep Area 

South of US1 in D2 with ADJUSTMENT 

Presentation – 03-112022.pdf

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

22 COM24066-

000167

24-10 3/24/2022 Mar 24 2022 De Grandy slides 11673 Submittal - Miguel DeGrandy - 

Presentation to City Commission _ 03-24-

2022.pdf

2021-22 Consultant 

Materials

23 24-28 2/25/2022 First ACLU letter to City Other 2022 Process 

Materials

H, I (improper 

expert/legal 

opinion)

24 COM24066-

049157

24-29 3/31/2022 Mar 31 2022 ACLU to Mayor Suarez ACLU-FL Letter on City of Miami 

Redistricting 3-3122.pdf

Other 2022 Process 

Materials

H, I (improper 

expert/legal 

opinion)

25 COM24066-

000409

4/1/2022 Mayor Suarez letter to De Grandy Jurisdictional Boundaries of the City of 

Miami Commission Districts.pdf

Other 2022 Process 

Materials

26 COM24066-

000827

4/2/2022 De Grandy response to Mayor Suarez Response to Mayor's Correspondence.pdf Other 2022 Process 

Materials

27 82-1 5/11/2023 May 11 2023 Transcript 2023 Transcripts

28 82-2 6/14/2023 Jun 14 2023 Transcript 2023 Transcripts

29 COM24066-

045805

77 6/14/2023 Jun 14 2023 De Grandy slides 14148 - Submittal-MDG - PowerPoint 

Pres 1.pdf

2023 Consultant Materials

30 COM24066-

045824

6/14/2023 Jun 14 2023 De Grandy draft maps 14148 - Submittal-MDG - PowerPoint 

Pres 2 - Final.pdf

2023 Consultant Materials

31 COM24066-

003401

82-5 6/14/2023 Jun 14 2023 redistricting mtg agenda Final Agenda - June 14, 2023 Special.pdf Other 2023 Process 

Materials

32 COM24066-

000209

77 6/14/2023 Resolution 23-271 Certified Copy - Resolution R-23-0271 -

Redistricting.pdf

Other 2023 Process 

Materials

33 COM24066-

048094

77 5/23/2023 May 23 2023 Plaintiffs letter with 

P1/P2

Miami Plaintiffs’ Letter re Proposed 

Remedial City Commission Maps.pdf

Other 2023 Process 

Materials

H, I (improper 

expert/legal 

opinion)

34 82-8 6/9/2023 Ability to elect in D5 P1/P2 Other 2023 Process 

Materials

H 

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 2 of 7
35 82-9 6/12/2023 Moy analysis re P1/P2 Other 2023 Process 

Materials

H 

36 82-7 6/13/2023 ACLU email to City counsel sharing 

maps

Other 2023 Process 

Materials

37 82-10 6/17/2023 Plaintiffs letter to Mayor Suarez 

urging veto

Other 2023 Process 

Materials

38 82-14 5/26/2023 Commissioner King instagram post Other 2023 Process 

Materials

A, H, R

39 82-15 6/14/2023 Commissioner King facebook post Other 2023 Process 

Materials

A, H, R

40 82-16 6/13/2023 Samantha Morrell, Supreme Court 

Decision Impact on Miami’s Black 

Voters as Redistricting Heats Up, 

MIA. TIMES

Other 2023 Process 

Materials

H, R

41 COM24066-

003822

6/30/2023 Mendez email re passage of new map 00001552_Fw_ Redistricting UpdateAdopted Maps fs119exempt.msgOther 2023 Process 

Materials

42 COM24066-

003283

8/1/2023 City to County email re City Map 

pending appeal

00000910_RE_ City of Miami - 

Redistricting Map (June 2023).msg

Other 2023 Process 

Materials

43 GRACEPLFS000

0002

10/24/2019 GRACE Bylaws GRACE BYLAWS_10-24-19.pdf Plaintiff Materials - 

GRACE

44 GRACEPLFS000

1299

5/26/2022 GRACE member orgs G.R.A.C.E., Inc. Partners.xlsx Plaintiff Materials - 

GRACE

H

45 COM24066-

063033

2/6/2022 Feb 6 2022 HOTA letter to City - 

GRACE org

City of Miami Commissioners 2-6-

2022.pdf

Plaintiff Materials - 

GRACE

A,H

46 COM24066-

063034

2/6/2022 Feb 6 2022 Coconut Grove 

Community Advisory Committee 

letter to City - GRACE org

CAC-Commissioners Letter 2-6-2022.pdf Plaintiff Materials - 

GRACE

A,H

47 GRACEPLFS000

0919

3/1/2019 NAACP unit bylaws Bylaws for Units _ NAACP.pdf Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

48 GRACEPLFS000

1012

3/1/2019 NAACP constitution NAACP Constitution _ NAACP.pdf Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

49 GRACEPLFS000

1056

2/1/2022 NAACP redistricting letter redistricting city of miami best.jpeg Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

50 COM24066-

059114

3/11/2022 Mar 11 2022 NAACP letter to City 00000544_Dilution of the Black residents 

of the Grove votes.msg

Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

H, I (improper 

expert/legal 

opinion)

51 COM24066-

060646

3/24/2022 Mar 23 2022 NAACP statement 00001451_Miami Redistricting.msg Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

H, I (improper 

expert/legal 

opinion)

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 3 of 7
52 COM24066-

060875

3/28/2022 Mar 28 2022 Pierre letter to Mayor 

Suarez

00001691_Use your veto power.msg Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

H

53 COM24066-

060969

3/30/2022 Mar 30 2022 Pierre follow up to 

Mayor Suarez

00001910_Re_ Use your veto power.msg Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

H

54 COM24066-

045212

2/25/2022 Feb 25 2022 NAACP joint letter to 

City

Submittal-Carol Jackson-NAACP.pdf Plaintiff Materials - 

NAACP

H, I (improper 

expert/legal 

opinion)

55 GRACEPLFS000

0054

7/13/2017 Engage bylaws Engage Miami Bylaws - As of Nov 

2019.docx.pdf

Plaintiff Materials - Engage

56 GRACEPLFS000

1296

10/7/2023 Engage members by district Engage Miami Members as of 

10_3_23_Miami (1)[99].xlsx

Plaintiff Materials - Engage H

57 GRACEPLFS000

0024

6/11/2023 Overtown community meeting flyer Forum 2023-06-11 at 12.16.09 AM.pdf Plaintiff Materials

58 GRACEPLFS000

0025

6/2/2023 Coconut Grove community meeting 

flyer

Forum 2023-06-02 at 9.53.15 PM.pdf Plaintiff Materials

59 GRACEPLFS000

1278

10/19/2023 Clarice Cooper state ID and voter 

card

License and Voter Card.jpg Plaintiff Materials - Cooper

60 GRACEPLFS000

1294

10/13/2023 Yany state ID Valdes License.jpg Plaintiff Materials - Valdes

61 GRACEPLFS000

1282

10/12/2023 Jared Johnson state ID Jared Johnson License.pdf Plaintiff Materials - 

Johnson

62 GRACEPLFS000

1263

12/8/2022 Lexi Contreras voter card voter id card.HEIC Plaintiff Materials - 

Contreras

63 GRACEPLFS000

1285

9/28/2023 Steven Miro voter card IMG_20230928_154043065.jpg Plaintiff Materials - Miro

64 24-80 1/1/1997 1997 plan Maps

65 24-81 1/1/2003 2003 Plan Maps

66 82-22 6/14/2023 2013 Plan (PI remedy version) Maps

67 82-23 6/14/2023 2022 Plan (PI remedy version) Maps

68 24-84 2/7/2022 Feb. 7, 2022 Draft Maps

69 24-85 2/22/2022 Feb. 22, 2022 Draft/Base Plan Maps

70 24-86 2022 Russell Sketch Maps

71 24-87 2022 Initial Russell Plan Maps

72 24-88 2022 Revised Russell Plan Maps

73 24-89 2022 Reyes Plan Maps

74 24-90 2/10/2023 2022 Precincts with 2022 Plan 

overlay

Maps A, H 

75 24-91 2/10/2023 Census VTDs with 2022 Plan overlay Maps A, H 

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 4 of 7
76 82-24 6/14/2023 2023 Plan Maps

77 82-25 6/14/2023 Version 12 Maps

78 82-26 6/14/2023 D1 alt map (version 14) Maps

79 82-27 6/14/2023 D2 alt map Maps

80 82-28 6/14/2023 D3 alt map v1 Maps

81 82-29 6/14/2023 D3 alt map v2 Maps

82 82-30 6/14/2023 D5 alt map Maps

83 82-31 6/14/2023 Areas moved from 2022 Plan to 2023 

Plan

Maps A, H 

84 82-32 6/14/2023 Map comparing V12 to 23 plan Maps A, H 

85 82-33 7/6/2023 Overtown definition maps Maps A, H 

86 82-38 7/6/2023 2022 Precincts with 2023 Plan 

overlay

Maps A, H 

87 82-39 7/6/2023 Census VTDs with 2023 Plan overlay Maps A, H 

88 COM24066-

045585

2/8/2012 2012 City VRA memo Submittal-City Attorney Email.pdf 2013 Process Materials R

89 COM24066-

045594

3/12/2012 2012 City redistricting memo Memo - Redistricting.pdf 2013 Process Materials R

90 COM24066-

045777

2013 2013 Slideshow video Submittal-Stephen Cody-Presentation 

(2).mov

2013 Process Materials R

91 24-75 2/14/2013 Feb. 14, 2013 Meeting Minutes 2013 Process Materials R

92 24-77 Report on the Status of Redistricting 

and Proposed Redistricting Plan

2013 Process Materials R

93 24-78 Final Report Regarding the Proposed 

Redistricting Plan

2013 Process Materials R

94 24-79 Redistricting Alternatives Compared 

slide presentation

2013 Process Materials R

95 24-42 11/21/1996 Alfonso Chardy, Rights Group’s Suit 

Wants Miami to Change Election 

System , Mia. Herald, Nov. 21, 1996, 

at 2B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

96 24-43 12/30/1996 Karen Branch, Miami Group Pushing 

Hard for Single-Member Districts, 

Mia. Herald, Dec. 30, 1996, at 12A

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 5 of 7
97 24-44 1/20/1997 Karen Branch, Single-Member 

Districts Touchy Issue at City Hall , 

Mia. Herald, Jan. 20, 1997, at 2B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

98 24-45 3/13/1997 Manny Garcia, Giving Miami Blacks 

a Voice , Mia. Herald, Mar. 13, 1997, 

at 1A

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

99 24-46 3/14/1997 Manny Garcia, Election Remap for 

Miami , Mia. Herald, Mar. 14, 1997, 

at 12A

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

100 24-47 3/15/1997 Panel Named to Draw Miami 

Districts , Mia. Herald, Mar. 15, 

1997, at 2B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

101 24-48 3/15/1997 Editorial, Where to Draw the Line , 

Mia. Herald, Mar. 15, 1997, at 10A

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

102 24-49 5/5/1997 Karen Branch, Professors Get 

Election Homework , Mia. Herald, 

May 5, 1997, at 2B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

103 24-50 6/19/1997 Alfonso Chardy, Blue-Ribbon Panel 

Picks 2 Plans for Redrawing 

Districts, Mia. Herald, June 19, 1997, 

at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

104 24-51 6/24/1997 Plan to Expand Miami Commission 

Draws Public Support , Mia. Herald, 

June 24, 1997, at 2B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

105 24-52 6/25/1997 Karen Branch, Super-Strong Mayor 

for Miami? , Mia. Herald, June 25, 

1997, at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

106 24-53 6/27/1997 Karen Branch, Miami Leaders 

Divided Over Redistricting Plan , 

Mia. Herald, June 27, 1997, at 3B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

107 24-54 6/29/1997 Karen Branch, Districts: Back to 

Drawing Board , Mia. Herald, June 

29, 1997, at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

108 24-55 7/2/1997 Karen Branch, Miami Commission 

Leans Toward 5-Member Panel , Mia. 

Herald, July 2, 1997, at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 6 of 7
109 24-56 7/3/1997 Karen Branch, Voting Districts to be 

Chosen Today , Mia. Herald, July 3, 

1997, at 4B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

110 24-57 7/3/1997 Editorial, Go for Seven , Mia. Herald, 

July 3, 1997, at 22A

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

111 24-58 7/4/1997 Karen Branch, Commissioners 

Choose 5-Seat Plan , Mia. Herald, 

July 4, 1997, at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

112 24-59 7/11/1997 Karen Branch, Miami Commission 

OKs 5 Voting Districts, Mia. Herald, 

July 11, 1997, at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

113 24-60 7/12/1997 Liz Balmaseda, Commission’s 

Districting Logic Is Hard to Digest , 

Mia. Herald, July 12, 1997, at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

114 24-61 7/14/1997 Enrique Patterson, Power Games Rob 

African Americans , Mia. Herald, 

July 14, 1997, at 13A

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

115 24-62 7/20/1997 Jim Hampton, Schizoid Choices? No, 

It’s Just Miami , Mia. Herald, July 

20, 1997, at 2L

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

116 24-63 9/5/1997 Andres Viglucci, Abolition Attempt 

Crushed , Mia. Herald, Sep. 5, 1997, 

at 1A

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

117 24-64 9/5/1997 Karen Branch & Dan Keating, Vote 

Favors a Black Commissioner, Mia. 

Herald, Sep. 5, 1997, at 1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

118 24-65 11/5/1997 Andres Viglucci, Teele Wins Miami 

Seat , Mia. Herald, Nov. 5, 1997, at 

1B

1997 Cycle News Coverage H, R

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 148-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/11/2024 Page 7 of 7