ANDREW M. CUOMO 

GOVERNOR 

Ms. Judith A. Enck 

Regional Administrator 

U.S. EPA Region 2 

290 Broadway 

New York, NY 10007-1866 

Dear Administrator Enck: 

STATE OF NEW YORK 

DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 

ALBANY, NEW YORK 12233-1010 

ocr w~ 5 2012 

JOE MARTENS 

COMMISSIONER 

This letter is in response to the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) July 26, 

2007 request for additional information pertaining to the New York State Department of 

Environmental Conservation's (DEC) carbon monoxide (CO) state implementation plan (SIP) 

revision submitted on April 5, 2007. The SIP revision clarifies the commitments identified in 

DEC's November 15, 1992 submittal entitled "Carbon Monoxide Attainment DemonstrationNew York Metropolitan Area". 

DEC wishes to move forward with the SIP revision at this time and hereby submits the July 17, 

2007 public hearing records and the DEC's response to comments received during the public 

comment period. DEC is also submitting monitoring data for 2007 through 2011 that 

demonstrates continued compliance with the national ambient air quality standard (NAAQS) for 

CO. The current design value for CO (2010-2011) is 1.8 parts per million (ppm), which is lower 

than the 2.5 ppm design value at the time of the 2007 submittal, and well below the NAAQS of9 

ppm (9.4 ppm monitored due to rounding). 

I've also enclosed the April 5, 2007 CO SIP revision clarifying the commitments identified in 

DEC's November 15, 1992 "Carbon Monoxide Attainment Demonstration- New York 

Metropolitan Area" and EPA's July 26, 2007 request for additional information. 

We look forward to EPA's expeditious approval ofthis SIP revision. 

Please call me at ( 518) 402-8540 if you have any questions. 

Enclosures 

cc: R. Ruvo, EPA 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

REGION 2 

290 PC)0ADWAY 

NEW YORK. NY 10007-H'66 

JUL 2 6 2007 

Ja:-ed Snyder 

Assistant Commissioner 

New York State Department of 

Environmental Conservation 

625 Broadway, 14!11 Floor 

Albany, NY l 2233 

Dear Mr. Snyder: 

RECEIVED 

AUG 0 2 2007 

DmC£ Of Ail. CtWA T£ CHANGE 

ANOf:NERGV 

This is in response to New York's April 5, 2007 State L'11plementation Plan (SW) revisio:t 

submittal to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The April ~ letter indicates it 

is clarifying the commitments identified in New 'York's November 15, 1992 Carbon 

Monoxide (CO) SIP submittal, "Carbon Monoxide Attainment Demonstration New 

York Metropolitan Area." Attached ro the Aprii 5th submittal is a document that is 

intended to demonstrate that the removal of a reference to a limited off-street parking 

program thai is imposed and enforced by the City ofNev,' York, will noljeopardize 

attai:m1C'll vvith the CO national ambient air quality standards. 

F0 A unrk:rstands that a public hearing was i11itially scheduled for May 23, 2007, b'Jt h~d 

w be rescheduled and was subsequently held on July I 7, 2007. Without the public 

hearing record documentation, the April 5th submittal cannot be detennined complete 

pursua::1t to the SIP revision completeness criteria found in Title 40, Part 51, Appendix V 

of the Code of Federal Regulations. Once New York submits the public heating record. 

wbch n:Jsl include a response to comments received, EPA will evaluate the submi;t<:.l kn 

completeness and approvability under the Clean Air Act. 

Should there be any questions associated wi:h this matter, please have your staff contact 

Mr. Rayn10nd Werner, Chief, Air Programs Branch. tv1r. Werner can be reached at (21J,) 

61,']_4". ) •-< ..) '( 

Walter 1\'lugdan, Director 

Dtvision of Environmental Planning & Protcct;on 

lntemet AddrE<ss {JRL) • http;liwww.E';'c gov 

p.,,:-ycl•di'R...,ycl.,blo • P>rlnled wfth Ve\)'ll8bll! OB Ba.""ct ~·~·;"" fl'>(]i~:l P~ (UIN'n~:m ?~% Pc-"'c'"'"'"""~" 
Assessment of Public Comments 

On the Proposed Amendment to the 

New York State Implementation Plan: 

Carbon Monoxide Attainment Demonstration: 

New York Metropolitan Area 

August 2012 

Comment #1: DEC's proposal to remove the Manhattan Central Business District (CBD) 

parking limitation strategy from the State Implementation Plan (SIP) for carbon monoxide is 

particularly ill advised in view of the fact that DEC is making this proposal solely in furtherance 

of its litigation strategy in Hell's Kitchen v. Bloomberg (05 Civ. 4806) to avoid having to enforce 

that very SIP provision. Rather than trying to change the rules, DEC should join in enforcing 

them. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #1: The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) 

can submit a state implementation plan (SIP) revision at any time and for any reason, as long as 

it is in compliance with the Clean Air Act (CAA). In this case, the DEC submitted the SIP 

revision to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on April 5, 2007 to clarify 

the commitments made in its November 15, 1992 Carbon Monoxide (CO) Attainment 

Demonstration for the New York Metropolitan Area (NYMA). 

Comment #2: DEC's April 5, 2007, SIP revision letter to EPA (Proposed Revision) mischaracterizes virtually every aspect of the parking limitation strategy in an attempt to minimize 

its importance, the better to eliminate it. The Proposed Revision incorrectly claims that the 

parking limitation strategy was merely "considered" in the 1979 SIP, that it was "compensated 

for" by other control measures, that it is not a pre-1990 SIP commitment, that it can be removed 

because no tonnage reductions were taken for the program, and that modeling data is sufficient to 

demonstrate that removal of the program will not jeopardize maintenance of the standard. None 

of these claims is even remotely correct. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #2: The DEC disagrees with all points of this comment. The only CO SIPs 

approved by EPA are dated September 21, 1990, November 13, 1992, March 21, 1994, August 

30, 1999 and March 22, 2000. These are the only SIPs that contain State enforceable measures, 

and any references to control measures in SIPs with other dates (i.e. 1973 and 1979) are not 

applicable for purposes of this proposed SIP revision. In this proposed revision, the DEC is 

demonstrating that no tonnage reductions were ever taken (i.e. approved by EPA) for the offstreet parking program, and therefore any reference to that program are allowed to be removed 

from the SIP without consequence. It needs to be noted that the NYMA, as well as the entire 

state, is attaining the CO national ambient air quality standard (NAAQS), the sole reason for 

preparing the CO SIP. 

APC Page 1 of 12 
Comment #3: For DEC to now pretend that the CBD parking limitation strategy is a 

small matter that can be "clarified" out of existence is disingenuous at best. [Daniel Gutman, 

July 24, 2007] 

Response #3: Again, no tonnage reductions were ever taken for the off-street parking 

program, therefore any reference to that program are allowed to be removed from the SIP 

without consequence. 

Comment #4: Both the 1992 CO SIP and the 2001 CO maintenance plan make clear that 

some SIP commitments were withdrawn pursuant to the proper Clean Air Act (CAA) procedure; 

but the CBD parking limitation strategy is not among them (1992 SIP, pp. 20-23; 2001 

maintenance plan, p. 6). Therefore the CBD parking limitation strategy is still a SIP 

commitment [CAA, §llO(n}(l)] and is integral to both the 1992 CO SIP and the 2001 CO 

maintenance plan, whether or not it is mentioned explicitly in those documents. [Daniel Gutman, 

July 24, 2007] 

Response #4: In this proposed SIP revision, the DEC is demonstrating that no tonnage 

reductions were ever taken for the off-street parking program and therefore any reference to that 

program are allowed to be removed from the SIP. Control measures and corresponding 

emissions reductions are in fact explicitly approved by EPA. Again, the NYMA is attaining the 

NAAQS. 

Comment #5: DEC disingenuously claims that removing the CBD parking limitation 

strategy from the 1992 CO SIP is acceptable because "the Department took no tonnage 

reductions" for the strategy (SIP Revision, p. 1). Actually DEC did take tonnage reductions for 

the program in the 1973 SIP when the .~trategy (Strategy B-3) called for a 40-50% reduction in 

CBD parking (see 1973 TCP, pp. 6-2, A-29). But as it was modified in the 1979 SIP, the 

purpose of the CBD parking management strategy was not to reduce emissions, but rather to 

"ensure that existing air quality is not fUrther degraded" by emissions from additional vehicle 

trips (1979 SIP, p. V-36). Since no emission reduction was intended, the fact that DEC took no 

CO tonnage reductions for the parking program in its 1992 attainment demonstration is 

irrelevant. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #5: The DEC disagrees with this comment. Again, the only CO SIP revisions 

approved by EPA are dated September 21, 1990, November 13, 1992, March 21, 1994, August 

30, 1999 and March 22, 2000. These are the only SIPs that contain state and federal enforceable 

measures. The DEC believes it is very relevant that no CO tonnage reductions were taken for the 

parking program referenced in its 1992 attainment demonstration that was approved by EPA. 

APC Page 2 of 12 
Comment #6: To remove the CBD parking limitation strategy from the SIP, DEC needs 

to demonstrate that any consequent degradation of air quality would not jeopardize attainment of 

standards. Monitoring data alone, the only numerical information submitted with the Proposed 

Revision, is insufficient to demonstrate what might happen if the parking strategy is removed 

from the SIP; rather such a demonstration requires a calculation of the impact on CO levels of 

increased driving to the CBD due to additional parking spaces. To be able to perform this 

calculation, DEC and the City decided to conduct a study to establish a relationship between 

parking supply and driving to the Manhattan CBD. That commitment -contained in a 1978 

court order in Friends of the Earth v. Carey and repeated in the 1979 SIP -required DEC and 

the City to complete a parking management study by October 31, 1979 (1979 SIP, p. V-35). 

However the study was never done. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #6: The New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP) 

Bureau of Science and Technology completed "The New York City Parking Management Study" 

in 1981. Please note that the 1978 order to which you refer was vacated on January 20, 1983, 

thereby relieving the City of any previously existing obligation to complete a parking 

management study (even though it had already been completed.) The 1981 study found that 

"The air quality impact of economically based parking management strategies is minimal. (For 

example, the greatest impact studied consisting of a $1 0 daily parking surcharge would yield a 

2.7% reduction in CO, or about 0.6 parts per million (ppm) at hot spots in the Midtown Core.)" 

Given the NYMA design values for CO are about 2.5 ppm and the NAAQS is 9 ppm, the DEC 

agrees with the NYCDEP's assessment that the air quality impacts are minimal and not 

significant. 

Comment #7: Because ofthe absence of a completed parking management study, DEC 

has never been able to calculate the emissions benefit of the CBD parking limitation strategy, or 

the impact of its removal from the SIP. DEC cannot use its inability to quantify benefits to 

justify removal of the program, since DEC's inability is due to its own failure to adhere to a SIP 

commitment. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #7: The DEC has evaluated the NYCDEP's 1981 parking management study 

and concluded that there are minimal emissions benefits from CBD parking limitations. This 

combined with the fact that no emissions reduction credits were ever taken in the SIP, justifies 

the removal of any language referring to the parking strategy. 

APC Page 3 of 12 
--------------------~-------- 

Comment #8: According to DEC's 2001 CO maintenance plan, "the potential for future 

exceedances of the CO standard cannot be ruled out at this time" (CO Maintenance Plan, p. 20). 

Given this assessment, the maintenance plan continued programs committed to by DEC in earlier 

SIPs. The 1979 SIP strategy to limit any increase in the number ofCBD parking spaces was not 

only intended to be an attainment strategy, but it was also intended to be a maintenance strategy. 

As described in the 1979 SIP, the purpose of the CBD parking limitation strategy was also to 

"ensure that ... once air quality standards are achieved, those standards will be maintained" 

( 1979 SIP, pp. V -34-38 at p. V -36). Thus the CBD parking limitation strategy must be 

considered part of the CO maintenance plan. That being the case, removing a sentence from the 

1992 SIP, as the Proposed Revision would do, does not remove the parking limitation program 

from the CO maintenance plan or change the status of the program under federal law. [Daniel 

Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #8: Again, the parking control strategy in the 1979 plan is not an EPA 

approved SIP measure. It is not in the 1992 SIP or 2001 maintenance plan. Please note that the 

NYMA currently attains the CO NAAQS, no exceedances of the CO standard occurred in the 

maintenance years and none are expected in the future. 

Comment #9: In its SEQRA negative declaration, DEC claims that removing the CBD 

parking limitation strategy from the SIP would have no significant adverse impact on the 

environment. But that is merely a conclusory statement, with no explanation and based on 

absolutely no analysis. Consequently the negative declaration does not "contain a reasoned 

elaboration and provid[e] reference to any supporting documentation" [6 NYCRR §617.7(b)(4)J. 

The SEQRA negative declaration is wholly inadequate and should be withdrawn. [Daniel 

Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #9: The DEC disagrees with this comment. The removal of the parking 

limitation strategy will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. For the recent 

Cross-State Air Pollution Rule promulgated by the EPA, technical support documents consider a 

significant impact as having the potential to cause a I% change in the NAAQS. Applying that 

methodology here, a significant impact would result in a design value change of0.9 ppm. The 

NYCDEP parking study stated that the most economically feasible control strategy (e.g. a $10 

parking fee) would result in a design value decrease of0.6 ppm. Therefore, the removal of the 

reference to the parking limitation strategy will not have a significant adverse impact on the 

environment. 

APC Page 4 of 12 
Comment #10: DEC claims that if its Proposed Revision is adopted, the 20,000 

additional parking spaces that New York City has already allowed in the Hudson Yards area 

would "not [be] a contravention of a SIP commitment," and thus would be legal (Proposed 

Revision, p. 2). As a consequence of DEC's action, thousands of additional CBD parking spaces 

would become available, attracting more drivers to the CBD. More driving to the CBD means 

slower traffic··- not only for cars, but for trucks and buses as well- and higher emissions of all 

traffic-related pollutants. Even if we accept DEC's contention that its action will have no 

significant environmental impact with respect to the national ambient air quality standard 

(NAAQS) for carbon monoxide, DEC's action would increase emissions of other traffic-related 

pollutants, including ozone precursors (hydrocarbons and nitrogen oxides), fine particulate 

matter, and carbon dioxide. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #10: This proposed SIP revision is limited to Carbon Monoxide as prescribed 

in the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990. Separate PM and ozone SIP issues have been/will be 

analyzed separately. To that matter, the parking restriction to which you refer is not included in 

either of the latest PM or ozone SIP attainment demonstrations as they were not needed to 

demonstrate attainment with the respective standards. Carbon Dioxide (C02) is not a criteria 

pollutant with a NAAQS. 

Comment# 11: Since the New York City region currently violates the NAAQS for 

ozone and fine particulate matter, higher traffic-related emissions of those pollutants may cause 

significant environmental impacts with respect to those standards. There is no standard for 

carbon dioxide, our newest Qfficial pollutant (see Massachusetts v. EPA, Supreme Court case 05-

1272), but emitting more carbon dioxide is inconsistent with State policy to reduce such 

emissions. Thus removing the CBD parking limitation strategy from the SIP may have a 

significant adverse impact on the environment. Consequently DEC should rescind its negative 

declaration and should prepare an environmental impact statement [6 NYCRR §617.7(f)]. 

[Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #11: This proposed SIP revision is limited to CO as prescribed in the CAA. 

The NYMA now attains the PM2.s NAAQS; has developed a plan to attain the 1997 ozone 

NAAQS and is in the process of developing a plan to meet the 2008 ozone NAAQS. The State is 

taking measures to reduce C02 emissions, including motor vehicle standards and the Regional 

Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI). 

APC Page 5 of 12 
Comment #12: How significant an impact on the environment would occur from 

removing the CBD parking limitation strategy from the SIP? The responsibility for figuring that 

out rests with the DEC staff. Again, the basic infonnation required is knowledge of the 

relationship between parking supply and driving to the Manhattan CBD. DEC cannot know the 

impact of its actions, without completing the parking management study it promised 25 years 

ago. Ignoring the environmental impacts of its action, as DEC has done, only sets a bad example 

and will cause the agency continuing embarrassment. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #12: See Response to Comments #6 and #7. 

Comment #13: The DEC staff will undoubtedly argue, as their co-defendants already 

have in federal court (see Oct. 16, 2005 Reply Brief of the City and the MT A, in Hell's Kitchen 

v. Bloomberg, 05 Civ 4806, pp. 6, 7, fn. 2, 3), that the CBD parking limitation strategy can be 

removed from the SIP because its environmental impacts were already examined in the Hudson 

Yards FGEIS, which found no contravention of the NAAQS for 'carbon monoxide. But the 

Hudson Yards FGEIS is no help here. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #13: The DEC did not consider the Hudson Yards FGEIS in this matter. 

Comment #14: The CBD parking limitation strategy is a reasonably available control 

measure (RACM). First, it was so designated in the 1979 CO SIP (1979 SIP, Table 1-1); second, 

it has been in effect for the past 25 years without causing any serious problem; and finally, it 

clearly remains reasonable available. Consequently the CBD parking limitation strategy must be 

included as a RACM in DEC's forthcoming PM2.s SIP. That being the case, it is 

counterproductive for DEC to continue its attempt to remove the strategy from the CO SIP, only 

to have to re-impose it in April. [Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #14: This proposed SIP revision is limited to CO as prescribed in the CAA. 

Furthennore, this limited parking control strategy was not incorporated into the PM25 SIP {or the 

Ozone SIP). 

Comment #15: DEC's current Proposed Revision has attracted wide-spread opposition 

among environmental, transportation, and civic groups similar to those that participated in the 

nine years of litigation and negotiations in the 1970's. DEC should carefully consider whether it 

wants to upset the hard· won consensus that the CBD parking limitation strategy represents. 

[Daniel Gutman, July 24, 2007] 

Response #15: The proposed revision has attracted both opposition and support. The 

DEC plans to move forward with this proposed revision as requested in its April 5, 2007letter to 

EPA. 

APC Page 6 of 12 
Comment #16: Environmental Defense requests that NYSDEC not revise the SIP. 

Environmental Defense requests an environmental review to demonstrate that its proposed action 

would not cause or contribute to violations ofthe revised 24-hour NAAQS in the NYMA for fine 

particulate matter (PM2.s) promulgated by US EPA on October 17, 2006; or cause harm to the 

health of sensitive populations in the Manhattan Central Business District (CBD) [Environmental 

Defense, July 24, 2007] 

Response #16: This proposed SIP revision is limited to CO as prescribed in the CAA. 

The "environmental review" that you request has been conducted in separate ozone and PM2.s 

SIP processes. The NYMA is currently attaining the PM2.5 NAAQS. 

Comment #17: The environmental assessment for the SIP revision only looked at 

carbon monoxide (CO) which can not be tracked to other criteria pollutants of concern such as 

ozone and PM2.5 which are directly ties to parking and the resulting traffic created. Hotspots of 

PM and ozone could exist in communities affe(.,ied by the SIP revision. The NYMA has long 

repeatedly missed deadlines for meeting federal air pollution standards. Although the region is 

now in attainment of the carbon monoxide (CO) National Ambient Air Quality Standard 

(NAAQS), it routinely experiences multiple annual violations of other NAAQS, such as ozone 

and PM2.5 New York City has been designated a non-attainment area for PM2.5[70 FR 944 

(January 5, 2005)]. [Environmental Defense, July 24, 2007] 

Response #17: Again, this proposed SIP revision is limited to CO as prescribed in the 

CAA. The NYMA is currently meeting the PM2.

5 NAAQS, and the DEC has submitted a plan to 

EPA for attaining the 1997 ozone NAAQS. 

Comment #18: NYSDEC's proposal to remove the limitation on off-street parking as an 

emission reduction measure in the SIP would allow for the addition of thousands of new parking 

spaces within the Manhattan Central Business District (CBD). At a time when plaNYC 2030 is 

poised to reduce traffic in the CBD, it makes little sense to lift the parking limitation in this way. 

Increased parking results in increased traffic resulting in poor air quality for New Yorkers. This 

additional parking capacity would likely make it more difficult for the NYMA to meet the 

stronger PM2.5 air pollution standards recently put into effect by EPA under the Clean Air Act, 

and would affect local public health. Pollutant impacts from traffic associated with additional 

parking capacity can result in increased ozone and PM2.5 emissions, which have been shown to 

increase asthma hospitalization rates, exacerbate lung function problems, and cause heart attacks 

(see Environmental Defense's report at www.AllChokedUp.org). Thus removing the CBD 

parking limitation strategy from the SIP may have a significant adverse impact on the 

environment. [Environmental Defense, July 24, 2007] 

Response #18: Again, this proposed SIP revision, and corresponding documents such as 

the negative declaration, is limited to CO as prescribed in the CAA. Separate PM2_5 and ozone 

SIP issues have been/will be analyzed separately. The parking restriction to which you refer is 

not included in either of the latest PM or ozone SIP attainment demonstrations as they were not 

needed to demonstrate attainment with the respective standards. 

APC Page 7 of 12 
Comment #19: The City ofNew York submits this letter in support of the revision of the 

state implementation plan (SIP) clarifying the commitments identified in the November 15, 1992 

"Carbon Monoxide Attainment Demonstration- New York Metropolitan Area." The New York 

City Department of Environmental Protection ("NYCDEP") has reviewed the air quality 

modeling data presented by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 

("NYSDEC") in support ofthe proposed revision, and agrees with NYSDEC that "removal of a 

reference to a limited off-street parking program imposed and enforced by the City ofNew York 

from the CO SIP will not jeopardize attainment" ofNAAQS. [City ofNew York Law 

Department, July 24, 2007] 

Response #19: Comment noted. 

Comment #20: The city does not believe the improved air quality in the city, including 

the reduction in ambient levels of carbon monoxide and attainment of CO NAAQS, is associated 

with the off-street parking program under the city's Zoning Resolution, which has not been 

shown to deter drivers from entering the subject areas. Rather, the improved carbon monoxide 

levels result from other factors, including the development of more efficient automobiles and 

pollution control technology that is now installed in motor vehicles. [City ofNew York Law 

Department, July 24, 2007] 

Response #20: The DEC agrees with this comment. 

Comment #21: NYSDEC states in its April 5, 2007letter that "the off-street program 

was not relied upon in the attainment demonstration." Similarly, the city does not rely on that 

program as a means to improve air quality or maintain attainment ofNAAQS. [City of New 

York Law Department, July 24, 2007] 

Response #20: Comment noted. 

Comment #21: The revision clarifies that the off-street parking provisions are not SIP 

requirements; however, the provisions remain in effect for much of Manhattan under the city's 

Zoning Resolution, and, together with other local programs, are a feature of the regulations the 

city uses with respect to development projects, including projects which require discretionary 

land use approvals and are subject to environmental review for assessment of any potential air 

quality impacts, among other issues. The recent rezoning of the Hudson Yards area to promote 

public transit oriented mixed-use residential and commercial development included different offstreet parking provisions to accommodate the increased parking demand and replace parking 

facilities displaced by the development of the area. The potential for significant adverse 

environmental impacts resulting from the development of Hudson Yards, including the potential 

for air quality impacts, was assessed through a comprehensive environmental impact statement. 

[City of New York Law Department, Ju)y 24, 2007] · 

Response #21: Comment noted. 

APC Page 8 of 12 
Comment #22: Do not permit this parking limitation provision to be removed. [Kathleen 

McGee Treat, Chair. Hell's Kitchen Neighborhood Association] 

Response #22: See Comment #21 from the City of New York. As it states, .. The revision 

clarifies that the ofT-street parking provisions are not SIP requirements; however, the provisions 

remain in effect for much of Manhattan under the city's Zoning Resolution, and, together with 

other local programs, are a feature of the regulations the city uses with respect to development 

projects. including projects which require discretionary land use approvals and are subject to 

environmental review for assessment of any potential air quality impacts, among other issues ... 

Comment #23: Chekpeds and Manhattan Community Board 4 oppose the New York 

State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC)'s proposal to remove the parking 

provision from the 1982 (sic) New York State Implementation Plan (SIP). pursuant to the Clean 

Air Act. This change is going backwards and threatens to erase 25 years of progress in the tight 

to make the air in New York City cleaner. Once the city may approve more parking, it will do so. 

The prime example is Hudson Yards: where over 20,000 new parking spaces are allowed to be 

constructed in the Manhattan Central Business District, a 15% increase over current levels. 

[Christine Berthet, Co-Founder, Clinton/Heirs Kitchen Pedestrian Safety Coalition: Manhattan 

Community Board 4] 

Response #23: The proposed clarification to the CO SIP will have minimal impact on 

air quality, and no emissions reduction credit was ever taken for the parking measure in the SIP. 

Comment #24: While the SIP does not include an explicit target for the parking 

provision, there is a significant correlation between the quantity of parking provided and 

employee transportation mode split (Moral & Bolger, 1996). Therefore. the parking provision in 

the SIP is instrumental as a means to reduce traffic congestion and improving air quality in the 

city. The parking provisions of the 1982 SIP have proven an etTective tool and should not be 

discarded when so much more needs to be done to improve air quality in many neighborhoods of 

the city. [Christine Berthet, Co-Founder, Clinton/Hell's Kitchen Pedestrian Safety Coalition: 

Manhattan Community Board 4] 

Response #24: The DEC disagrees with this comment. The revision clarifies that the 

off-street parking provisions are not SIP requirements. Similarly. the city has stated in writing 

that it does not rely on that program as a means to improve air quality or maintain attainment of 

NAAQS. Other programs implemented by both the city and state are improving air quality to the 

point that the CO and PM standards are being attained in the entire State of New York. 

APC Page 9 of 12 
Comment #25: T.A. i-s deeply troubled that the Spitzer Administration (Administration) 

proposes to alter the commitments identified in the November I 5, 1992 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 

Attainment Demonstration for the New York Metropolitan Area (NYMA). The Administration 

argues that its proposal will not jeopardize CO attainment because ambient levels are well below 

the NAAQS and trending downward. Yet by permitting nearly 23,000 new and publiclyaccessible parking spaces within the Manhattan Central Business District, the Administration's 

proposal will exacerbate traffic congestion and increase emissions of criteria air pollutants. 

[Transportation Alternatives. May 23. 2007] 

Response #25: The DEC disagrees with this comment. The removal of the parking 

limitation strategy will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment, and is not a 

part of this SIP revision. 

Comment #26: In its single-minded focus on CO, the Administration's SIP revision 

ignores other criteria pollutants such as PM 2.5 (tine particulates) and ozone, levels of which are 

above than the federally mandated attainment levels tor the region, to the severe detriment of the 

health. environment, and quality oflife ofNew Yorkers. [Transportation Alternatives, May 23, 

2007] 

Response #26: This proposed SIP revision, and corresponding documents such as the 

negative declaration, is limited to CO as required by and in accordance v.·ith the CAA. Separate 

PM and ozone SIP issues will be/have been addressed separately, again as required by and in 

accordance with the CAA. To that matter, the parking restriction to which you comment are not 

included in either of the latest PM or ozone SIP attainment demonstrations as they were not 

needed to demonstrate attainment. 

APC Page 10 of 12 
Comment #27: T.A. commissioned KEA to estimate the increase in carbon dioxide (C02) 

emissions that will result from the auto trips that will be generated by the additional 23,000 

parking spaces. With a very conservative estimate of just l vehicle round-trip per commercial 

space, and accounting for residential and mixed-use spaces, the additional parking would lead to 

the production of an additional 129,000 annual tons of C02. For reference, this increase in C02 

will effectively take away more than one-third of the gains promised by Mayor Bloomberg's 

i1movative plan unveiled yesterday (May 22) to more than double the mileage efficiency of every 

medallion taxicab in the city. [Transportation Alternatives, May 23, 2007j 

Response #27: There is no NAAQS for C02• The State is taking measures to reduce 

C02 emissions, including motor vehicle standards and the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative 

(RGGI). 

Comment #28: "For the economic, health, and environmental welfare of the City, I urge 

DEC not to remove the 1982 New York State Implementation Plan parking provision." This 

commenter also reiterated all of the comments submitted by Manhattan Community Board 4. the 

Clinton/Hell's Kitchen Pedestrian Safety Coalition and Hell's Kitchen Neighborhood 

Association. l Richard M. Gottfried, Assembly Member] 

Response #28: The only CO SIPs approved by EPA are dated September 21, 1990, 

November 13, 1992, March 21, 1994, August 30, 1999 and March 22, 2000. These are the only 

SIPs that contain State enforceable measures. and any references to control measures in SIPs 

with other dates (i.e. 1973 and 1979) are invalid for purposes of this proposed revision. In this 

proposed SIP revision, the DEC is demonstrating that no tonnage reductions were ever taken (i.e. 

approved by EPA) for off-street parking. Furthermore, the DEC has evaluated the NYCDEP's 

1981 parking management study and concluded that there are minimal emissions benefits from 

CBD parking limitations. This combined with the fact that no emissions reduction credits were 

ever taken in the SIP, justifies the removal of any language referring to the parking strategy. 

Comment #29: I am writing to you in regard to DEC's proposed State Implementation 

Plan revision that would remove the reference to a limited off-street parking program imposed 

and enforced by the City of New York. It is my understanding that the DEC began the process of 

removing the parking provision before you were appointed Commissioner~ I hope you \viii take 

steps to reverse the process no\v that you are in the position to do so. My concern is that if this 

change is made, the State will lose an important regulatory tool to protect our neighborhoods 

from dangerous gridlock and poor air quality. [Thomas K. Duane, New York State Senate, 29th 

District] 

Response #29: The revision clarifies that the off-street parking provisions are not SIP 

requirements; however, the provisions remain in effect for much of Manhattan under the city's 

Zoning Resolution. and, together with other local programs, are a feature of the regulations the 

city uses with respect to development projects, including projects which require discretionary 

land use approvals and are subject to environmental review for assessment of any potential air 

quality impacts, among other issues. 

APC Page 11 of 12 
Comment #30: The current process of removing the parking provision from the SIP 

follows a 2001 study on carbon monoxide in the New York Metropolitan Area, commissioned by 

a predecessor of yours, which determined that Federal carbon monoxide standards have been 

met. Even if this study was executed adequately-and I have serious concerns about the test 

samples used-the parking program is still needed to address hydrocarbon and fine particulate 

emissions going forward. Granted. the quantity of parking that is appropriate for any given area 

is variable. But it is undeniable that it has a real effect on the health and safety of our 

neighborhoods, and regulation ofthat quantity should remain within the purview of the DEC. 

[Thomas K. Duane, New York State Senate, 291

h District] 

Response #30: The current process of removing the parking provision from the SIP is a 

result of DEC certified monitoring data in the NYMA, not a 2001 study. This monitoring data, 

which has been approved by EPA, shows the CO design values to be far below the standard. 

Hydrocarbon and particulate emissions relate to criteria pollutants that have their own NAAQS, 

and any SIP process for those pollutants is prepared according to the CAA. Lastly, the DEC 

believes that local parking regulations should be implemented and enforced by the City ofNew 

York, not the State. 

APC Page 12 of 12 
ENB Statewide Notices - NYS Dept. of Environmental Conservation 

NEW YORK STATE 

DEPARTMENT OF 

._,ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 

ENB Statewide Notices 

NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING (CORRECTED} 

NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 

PROPOSED REVISION TO THE STATE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 

Page 1 of2 

Notice is hereby given that the NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL 

CONSERVATION (Department) will hold a legislative PUBLIC HEARING on the following revision to 

the State Implementation Plan (SIP). This PUBLIC HEARING is a re-scheduling of the canceled May 

23, 2007 PUBLIC HEARING. 

The Department is submitting a SIP revision to the United States Environmental Protection Agency 

clarifying the commitments identified in its November 15, 1992 Carbon Monoxide (CO) Attainment 

Demonstration for the New York Metropolitan Area (NYMA). In this SIP revision, the Department 

demonstrates noninterference with the CO National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) by 

submitting air quality data in lieu of modeling showing that the removal of any reference to a limited offstreet parking program imposed and enforced by the City of New York from the CO SIP will not 

jeopardize attainment because ambient levels are well below the NAAQS and trending downward. 

The PUBLIC HEARING on the proposed SIP revision will be conducted as follows: 

DATE: TUESDAY, JULY 17, 2007 

TIME: 6:00 P.M. 

PLACE: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 

Region 2 Annex· Hearing Room 106 

11-15 47th Avenue 

Long Island City, NY 11101 

The PUBLIC HEARING is scheduled in a place that is reasonably accessible to persons with impaired 

mobility. At the hearing, the Department will provide interpreter services for deaf persons at no charge. 

Written requests for such services are required and should be submitted by June 26, 2007, to Laura 

Becker, NYSDEC, 625 Broadway, Albany NY 12233-3250; (518) 402-8451; 

us. 

Pursuant to Part 617 of the implementing regulations for the State Environmental Quality Review Act, 

the Department has prepared a Negative Declaration stating that the proposed action will not have a 

significant effect on the environment. 

The Department invites all persons, organizations, corporations, and government agencies that may be 

affected by the proposed revision to the SIP to attend the hearing and/or to submit oral or written 

statements for the record. A cumulative record will be compiled of both oral and written statements 

received. It is not necessary for persons wishing to make an oral statement to request an appointment 

in advance. Written statements received prior to, during, or after the hearing and oral statements made 

at the hearing will be given equal weight. 

Written statements must be received by July 24, 2007, which is an extension of the original May 30, 

2007 deadline. Written statements should be sent to: Robert D. Bielawa, P.E., NYSDEC, Division of Air 

http://www .dec.ny .gov/enb/20070613 _ notO.html?showprintstyles 8/10/2012 
ENB Statewide Notices - NYS Dept. of Environmental Conservation Page 2 of2 .. 

Resources, 625 Broadway, Albany, NY 12233-3251, telephone (518) 402-8396; email 

lY liS. 

The proposed SIP revision may be obtained from Mr. Bielawa or from any of the following Department 

offices: 

REGION 1, Building #40, State University of New York, Stony Brook, NY 11790, Attention: Ajay Shah 

REGION 2, Hunters Point Plaza, 47-40 21st Street, Long Island City, NY 11101, Attention: Sam 

Lieblich 

REGION 3, 21 South Putt Corners Road, New Paltz, NY 12561, Attention: Ken Grzyb 

REGION 4, 1150 North Westcott Rd., Schenectady, NY 12306, Attention: Don Spencer 

REGION 5, Hudson Street Extension, Box 220, Warrensburg, NY 12885, Attention: Jim Coutant 

REGION 6, Watertown State Office Bldg., 317 Washington St., Watertown, NY 13601, Attention: 

Thomas Morgan 

REGION 7, 615 Erie Boulevard West, Syracuse, NY 13204-2400, Attention: Reginald Parker 

REGION 8, 6274 East Avon-Lima Road, Avon, NY 14414, Attention: Thomas Marriott 

REGION 9, 270 Michigan Ave., Buffalo, NY 14202, Attention: Larry Sitzman 

http://www .dec.ny.gov/ enb/20070613 _no tO .html?showprintstyles 8/10/2012 
ENB Statewide Notices Page 1 of 4 

ENB- STATEWIDE NOTICES 

Notice of Public Hearing 

New York State 

Department of Environmental Conservation 

Proposed Revision To The State Implementation Plan 

Notice is hereby given that the New York State Department of Environmental 

Conservation (Department) will hold a legislative Public Hearing on the following 

revision to the State Implementation Plan (SIP). 

The Department is submitting a SIP revision clarifying the commitments 

identified in its November 15, 1992 Carbon Monoxide (CO) Attainment 

Demonstration for the New York Metropolitan Area (NYMA). In this SIP revision, 

the Department demonstrates noninterference with the CO National Ambient Air 

Quality Standard (NAAQS) by submitting air quality data in lieu of modeling 

showing that the removal of a reference to a limited off-street parking program 

imposed and enforced by the City of New York from the CO SIP will not 

jeopardize attainment because ambient levels are well below the NAAQS and 

trending downward. 

The Public Hearing on the proposed SIP revision will be conducted as follows: 

loate IITime ]jPiace 

NYS Department of Environmental 

Wednesday, May 23, 1:00 p.m. - 4:00 Conservation 

Region 2 Annex - Hearing Room 106 2007 p.m. 11-15 47th Avenue 

Long Island City, NY 11101 

The Public Hearing is scheduled in a place that is reasonably accessible to 

persons with impaired mobility. At the hearing, the Department will provide 

interpreter services for deaf persons at no charge. Written requests for such 

services are required and should be submitted by May 1, 2007, to Laura Becker, 

NYSDEC, 625 Broadway, Albany NY 12233-3250; (518) 402-8451; email: 

Pursuant to Part 617 of the implementing regulations for the State 

Environmental Quality Review Act, the Department has prepared a Negative 

Declaration stating that the proposed action will not have a significant effect on 

the environment. 

I 

file://H:\NYMA CO SIP [Hell's Kitchen]\ENB Statewide Notices.htm 8/10/2012 
' ENB Statewide Notices Page 2of4 -

The Department invites all persons, organizations, corporations, and government 

agencies that may be affected by the proposed revision to the SIP to attend the 

hearing and/or to submit oral or written statements for the record. A cumulative 

record will be compiled of both oral and written statements received. It is not 

necessary for persons wishing to make an oral statement to request an 

appointment in advance. Written statements received prior to, during, or after 

the hearing and oral statements made at the hearing will be given equal weight. 

Written statements must be received by May 30, 2007, and should be sent to: 

Robert D. Bielawa, P.E., NYSDEC, Division of Air Resources, 625 Broadway, 

Albany, NY 12233-3251, telephone (518) 402-8396; email 

The proposed SIP revision may be obtained from Mr. Bielawa or from any of the 

following Department offices: 

Region 1, Building #40, State University of New York, Stony Brook, NY 11790, 

Attention: A jay Shah 

Region 2, Hunters Point Plaza, 47-40 21st Street, Long Island City, NY 11101, 

Attention: Sam Lieblich 

Region 3, 21 South Putt Corners Road, New Paltz, NY 12561, Attention: Ken 

Gryzb 

Region 4, 1150 North Westcott Rd., Schenectady, NY 12306, Attention: Don 

Spencer 

Region 5, Hudson Street Extension, Box 220, Warrensburg, NY 12885, 

Attention: Jim Coutant 

Region 6, Watertown State Office Bldg., 317 Washington St., Watertown, NY 

13601, Attention: Thomas Morgan 

Region 7, 615 Erie Boulevard West, Syracuse, NY 13204-2400, Attention: 

Reginald Parker 

Region 8, 6274 East Avon-Lima Road, Avon, NY 14414, Attention: Thomas 

Marriott 

Region 9, 270 Michigan Ave., Buffalo, NY 14202, Attention: Larry Sitzman 

Public Notice 

DEC Announces Fourth Annual Environmental Excellence Awards 

Applications Available 

Applications are now available for New York State's Fourth Annual Environmental 

Excellence Awards. This award program recognizes New York's environmental 

and conservation leaders who are solving environmental challenges through 

innovative and environmentally sustainable practices or creative partnerships. 

Eligible applicants include: businesses, not-for-profit organizations, government 

(local, state and federal), educational institutions and individuals. To be 

file:/IH:\NYMA CO SIP [Hell's Kitchen]\ENB Statewide Notices.htm 8/10/2012 
ENB Statewide Notices Page 3 of 4 

considered, a project application must result in an environmental benefit beyond 

what could have been achieved by using standard techniques or complying with 

regulatory requirements. 

The Department is interested in projects that are contributing to the sustainable 

use of New York's natural resources or are developing and delivering education 

programs that advance sustainability and innovation and positively contribute to 

a trained workforce. The program will also consider projects that address 

pollution prevention, manufacturing process improvements, energy efficiency, 

environmental justice, waste reduction and recycling, stormwater management, 

watershed planning, natural resource and habitat protection and restoration/ 

land conservation, and other environmental protection and restoration 

initiatives. Applicants should be able to demonstrate that they are a leader in 

their field. 

Review criteria will include an assessment of: the environmental benefits; the 

economic benefits; the innovative approach of the project; the advancement of 

sustainability; how creative partnerships were created or strengthened by the 

project; the demonstration of leadership and management commitment to the 

environment; the demonstration of transferability and the demonstration that 

practices go beyond standard techniques or compliance requirements. In order 

to be considered for an award, an applicant must be in compliance with New 

York Environmental Conservation Law, applicable permits and local laws. 

IMPORTANT: Applications must be postmarked by Friday June 1, 2007. The 

awards are scheduled to be presented in the fall of 2007. 

The 2007 application brochure is available through the DEC's website: 

, .. h I, by looking under the "Subject 

Index" button and selecting "E" or by doing a search for "Environmental 

Excellence Awards." 

Anyone interested in obtaining more information regarding the application and 

criteria for the awards 1 should contact Michelle Hinman at the Department of 

Environmental Conservation, Division of Environmental Permits, 625 Broadway, 

Albany, NY 12233-1750, telephone (518) 402-9469, fax (518) 402-9168, email 

t ) :' \' \' 

New York State Thruway Authority 

and New York State Canal Corporation 

Announce Public Review Period for Draft Annual Reports for GP02-02 

This notice announces the availability of the Draft Annual Reports prepared by 

the New York State Thruway Authority (NYSTA) and New York State Canal 

Corporation (NYSCC) pursuant to the New York State Department of 

file://H:\NYMA CO SIP [Hell's Kitchen]\ENB Statewide Notices.htm 8/10/2012 
' ENB Statewide Notices Page4'of4 ~ 

Environmental Conservation State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System 

General Permit for Stormwater Discharges from Municipal Separate Stormwater 

Sewer Systems (MS4s), GP-02-02. The Draft Annual Reports document activities 

related to the NYSTA's and NYSCC's Stormwater Management Program during 

the Reporting Period of March 10, 2006 to March 9, 2007. The NYSTA and 

NYSCC are making these draft documents available for public comment for a 

period of 30 days, ending May 17, 2007. Interested parties may provide their 

comments to the NYSTA and NYSCC via e-mail, phone, or mail to be considered 

in finalizing the documents. 

Background: SPDES General Permit for Stormwater Discharges from Municipal 

Separate Stormwater Sewer Systems (MS4s), GP-02-02, requires that agencies 

or municipalities identified as Regulated Small MS4s must develop a Stormwater 

Management Program to address six Minimum Control Measures. This public 

notice serves to comply with the NYSTA's and NYSCC's "Public 

Involvement/Participation" Minimum Control Measure. Information: The Draft 

Annual Reports are available online during the comment period at: 

'Y"·Y.\:Y.-111c.vway_,stJc1te. f}y_,_us/abQ1ttLms4/imtex. htrn!. Hard copies of the NYSTA and 

NYSCC Draft Annual Reports are also available for review at the following 

locations: 

New York Division Syracuse Division 

Contact: Michael Wetzel Contact: Kurt Weiskotten 

4 Executive Blvd. Suite 250, 2nd Floor 

Suffern, NY 10901 Liverpool, NY 13088-2104 

(845) 918-2526 (315) 438-2393 

Albany Division Buffalo Division 

Contact: Tom Moore Contact: Robert Romeo 455 Cayuga Road 270 Mount Hope Drive Suite 800 Albany, NY 12209 Cheektowaga, NY 14225-1309 (518) 436-3006 (716) 635-6291 

Email comments to: 

Thruway: OJ ?_4_.::l.It~Y .. @JbE~J~~flB1£tt§' -Jl':l ,t,L? 

Canal: n aJ~@ttl_ruw ay_.__sta!f::JI y_- 1-J:;; 

Mail comments to: 

New York State Thruway Authority 

Environmental Services Bureau 

Attention: Elizabeth K. Novak 

200 Southern Blvd. Albany, NY 12209 

Phone: 

Elizabeth K. Novak 

(518) 471-5926 

file://H:\NYMA CO SIP [Hell's Kitchen]\ENB Statewide Notices.htm 8/10/2012 
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING 

NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 

PROPOSED REVISION TO THE STATE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 

Notice is hereby given that the NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL 

CONSERVATION (Department) will hold a legislative PUBLIC HEARING on the following revision to the State 

Implementation Plan (SIP). This PUBLIC HEARING is a re-scheduling of the canceled May 23, 2007 PUBLIC 

HEARING. 

The Department is submitting a SIP revision to the United States Environmental Protection Agency 

clarifying the commitments identified in its November 15, 1992 Carbon Monoxide (CO) Attainment Demonstration 

for the New York Metropolitan Area (NYMA). In this SIP revision, the Department demonstrates noninterference 

with the CO National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) by submitting air quality data in lieu of modeling 

showing that the removal of any reference to a limited off-street parking program imposed and enforced by the City 

ofNew York from the CO SIP will not jeopardize attainment because ambient levels are well below the NAAQS 

and trending downward. 

The PUBLIC HEARING on the proposed SIP revision will be conducted as follows: 

DATE: 

TIME: 

PLACE: 

TUESDAY, JULY 17, 2007 

6:00P.M. 

New York State Department ofEnvironmental Conservation 

Region 2 Annex - Hearing Room 106 

11-15 471h Avenue 

Long Island City, NY Ill 0 J 

The PUBLIC HEARING is scheduled in a place that is reasonably accessible to persons with impaired 

mobility. At the hearing, the Department will provide interpreter services for deaf persons at no charge. Written 

requests for such services are required and should be submitted by June 26, 2007, to Laura Becker, NYSDEC, 625 

Broadway, Albany NY 12233-3250; (518) 402-8451; " . :• 

Pursuant to Part 617 of the implementing regulations for the State Environmental Quality Review Act, the 

Department has prepared a Negative Declaration stating that the proposed action will not have a significant effect on 

the environment. 

The Department invites all persons, organizations, corporations, and government agencies that may be 

affected by the proposed revision to the SIP to attend the hearing and' or to submit oral or written statements for the 

record. A cumulative record will be compiled of both oral and written statements received. It is not necessary for 

persons wishing to make an oral statement to request an appointment in advance. Written statements received prior 

to, during, or after the hearing and oral statements made at the hearing will be given equal weight. 

Written statements must be received by July 24, 2007, which is an extension of the original May 30, 2007 

deadline. Written statements should be sent to: Robert D. Bielawa, P.E., NYSDEC, Division of Air Resources, 625 

Broadway, Albany, NY 12233-3251, telephone (518) 402-8396; email " , 1., 

The proposed SIP revision may be obtained from Mr. Bie1awa or from any of the following Department 

offices: 

REGION 1, Building #40, State University ofNew York, Stony Brook, NY 11790, Attention: Ajay Shah 

REGION 2, Hunters Point Plaza, 47-40 21"1 Street, Long Island City, NY 11101, Attention: Sam Lieblich 

REGION 3, 21 South Putt Comers Road, New Paltz, NY 12561, Attention: Ken Grzyb 

REGION 4, 1150 North Westcott Rd., Schenectady, NY 12306, Attention: Don Spencer 

REGION 5, Hudson Street Extension, Box 220, Warrensburg, NY 12885, Attention: Jim Coutant 

REGION 6, Watertown State Office Bldg., 317 Washington St., Watertown, NY 13601, Attention: Thomas Morgan 
REGION 7, 615 Erie Boulevard West, Syracuse, NY 13204-2400, Attention: Reginald Parker 

REGION 8, 6274 East Avon-Lima Road, Avon, NY 14414, Attention: Thomas Marriott 

REGION 9, 270 Michigan Ave., Buffalo, NY 14202, Attention: Larry Sitzman 
State of New York 

COUNT'f OF NEW YORK 

601896 

d(" jl i /~ { () ,._ /' \' U::::L:._it{i_lj (·· K·L~ J { f.j'Jj_______ beir~9 cJuly S'Norn, 

says !'lilt he/she is ttlc principal Cicrk 1;l !lle Put>tishc- of the 

lVew York J>o.s·t 

<1 daily newspaper of general circulation printed ,md pu~lished ir the 

English language, tn the County of Now YorK, State o' NPw Yo;k; tt1at 

advertisement horeto annexed has been rHgularly puc'l!~;·y;cJ in the 

said "NEW YORK POST" once, 

on the i 3 day of June, 2007 
,._.EW YORf< ST!\TE DlPARTMb'lT Of 

ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 

f>ROf'OSF.D REVISION TO THf STATE 

IMPtEMr:NTATION f'LAN 

Noltce •~ M·cllYJI'''~n lhJ1 :he NEW YOHK s·>AI£ DfPA~TM~NT OF HNIROIIMfNTAL CONSfR\IM!Otl 

1ne~Jthw.mt) will ho'd ii \r.yr.;.JatrvL· ~urn IC HEARiNG on uu.:- f.;llo...,<nQ U!Vt:.,on toW£ .S!atE~ •mpli!'flleflt~thon 

?l~n tSII') It"'· i'UHUG HJ,\RING ·;a 'E Sf.lil'dallll'J ol t~ii C<lllcelr.d Ma~ 23. ?001 PL•SLIC Hf.ARING 

!le [Jepar:iiH'O~ ~~ .~ubrmttiny a SfP fNi'S40n to th+.:: Uru~ed States Envuomnent3\ ?rmtctlf.}H Aqe~l' 

rJa:d.'r'IHtJ the Lcw::.lm~:~ts ldr.ntifieo in :ts Nowr,!Jer 1~1. 1992 C;t!tJon Mono~ute {CO} .o.n::onm.:rn1 

Dt•rr-Jmlt;trJtiUL IPr the Nev .. Yor:.c Mdmp<1l~ta11 A,ted. ;N'rMA) :1l lt;is SiP' ~t:Vt~,!on. 1he Or.-~nrtrrw,nt Pjoemon 

ol!.,tr·-; noomt~• krwce. ""'" lfw CO Natiooili Amhrent Air o,_,hty S!a'"larct iNAAm>) by submm<!HJ ,.;, O<•JIit"J' G.1tl :l, h+>u ot n1u~!elinq $hrJ\V!l1Q !h.1t the 'rmoval c;l ar:y rB:t£nmt{' to J l!1ll!t~!d uH ';i~reer park\n~JflHI!Jf<l11trHpusr-a .Yl~ t:n:utct~d bv rhe C1~y ol N~w Yt.'!~ from :J;~ GO SIP' ~ill nn: je·:~;J~udi/U JUMfllliNd 

tit'\' o~uc~r 3rnbtrrn t1;v~is ·;n:: w,•n tlfi.nw HH: 1'-h'\.AOS and trerdtnu O:J'L~t~rtW:3rd 

!tt~. t'fdH If. d:AJW~:i: r.n the p; qlnsrd SIP :~\·.tun 1.1;1:! b~ ~ t•!'dl~ :f';1 ;,~ in·b~·;t>, 

OAH , U!:S:JAY .. !IJLY! f, i(IOi 

T!Mf. I! 00 PM 

PLACE; 1\a;~"~' 'lrHh ~~tu1-c IJt::v~nme·,, of tro·¥·no::"llf'il.!f Coo<;-en·di<~JII 

Pe!JH111;? Ann~:t- He:l!lrltJ ~{CIOHJ t% 

; :-1 ~ 4il~• A·;,:nuc 

I :·111~ l~l;.nd C1:y, NT' :I 1~1 

ih~ ;

1l;c.i I(~ LH:AHINt; t•. ~:hedufr-:.: m J pl.:tt..l! tlt.lf 1-r: rAJ'SOOJdbly fl:cr.es::;,bk to p~:"c-;Cn<~ W!HI on.p<H:ed 

~~~~~~·ht:.: ~'-' lh' ltt:iin;-o.; ;tu: lh:t~U'till1."'0f "'·,11 p~nv!O€ mt!lfJJ-fN~.r UtVIi;e~~ tnr de.Jr ~"en,ct~'i at no chat~ 

Wfftf~·ff :r.qt't'S!~ J.:.i ~-'J~~~ '-'P'OV:'~"eS dH! lff1urtt:'O Jl,IJ ~;hm~id be s.ub.mttt~d tJ~· J~mP ~G. 2007. 40 L~tUiH 

Ht:t.~n NY~Of-C fFJ :z~o3r.1·;~.:r Al'b!ny NY 1??31-:.2S1J (') lfn 40~·8-iS _ JHrey~4"~)w dt1t !;.;a1~.nvus 

PHr;;uant w P;ut i;, / t~~ !.hl'. r;lplf'Tn~rtrrng rnyulatfOf'l'$ hH ;~·e ~-f~He r.~r,·!f: lnmc.;tiJf Ouaht'l Uevre.'lf ,..\r.:f 

t--u! f);•p:trtmem r:~J'-' t-1r·)rJ::ed J Nt·9ahvP. L~~d.1r1tion ~,f,_f(triQ lh::t tt\113 ~u.,on~Pd JChm w11l nut l"Mvr a 

~·Jgnjf•(iJ~lt ptf~·r~ (til :lit e~~'.!'lfOflr.'!<P.r I 

H1e Dt:pJftrr:ont w;.·rk:, .1:1 pt. ~ ... ~;ns orgd:tlZiWor:~. cOJpG·1.1N•ns. ;~;::1fJO\'I..~trlf1Jt.·J·.J .:t(;I?U.Pr:~; th;,H ma~· be 

Jlftded LJ Hu.! J.lf~'"J~'!;JSf~'l H:'VeKJf' to ~he r~IP t:: atlt:mi 11-:e 1le~!tn{_j .md.'or W '-iUhmif oral Or ~vr,N~n st;,:c 

tntn'-r •.. cr the r?.r:ur':l A {.t.rr.t.•la:Ne ICtoni w t; b.e comp:f.ec. vt rt;JtiJ or;1l ilrlC' writl1;.u stater:~tPh t~C~fvee1 

It:~. rml nec-:!>: .• 1.<~, ~t)r pf::l~~r,:i~<- wt~hmg ~o 1n,:k::! ;H1 or.:tf o.;ta1t>l•'r:n: ·o r~~qw~sr :ill .lpt.:~lifl1menllll il11lJ'~"::-e 

W•,nca :,1;-:to:ot·J~nt'. H:rn~··~j rmi:i w. <jl,fiHQ. ')I ~ner mt: hur:ng ~nd 01al si:Jt~r1erts m:dA r:t Hle !J~~~·rr.;u 

Wlfl bE- ~·\-£'11 C'~\lil; o,\'t'?~·~~ 

WroH<"f) ~r;U\~n·.pnt':'~ rr :1~1 tJ-C 1lL,'111'(d b:t.~u\12-1, 20fl7. \"'lut .. P -~·::Ill t'J.lt:H:.:.•P'l vf ttt~ Ull\il!ld1 M.,y JO 200/ 

.j:QaJJhm~ Wnnt~ll !i!~i!l!menl.:: ~!otdd be !;enl aY Robet~ D i11eL·,...,,1 P t 1-JYSO'cG, Dr..·lslon ot Au Pr:\1"111'(€$, 

'i?~ 810J,jw,Jy ·~lh.JLI~ rlY 1U:J3·3?51.1elevhPur: (5 18) .:()2 8J'lii eiTidll.ilfS<~w""' siote •'Y IJ·; 

'11H PJOj;()Si!·J Slf-' '~''-"'" mJy be •ll~;"'wd from Mr Hli'lilvv1 D' ilom ~ill' ot IIH~ !oi<<Jwll1<J iJep;trtme111 ofl~;;"'; 

Bfl:!!ON 1, ~IIIIC.n:; •4-J, Statc. r.:n•nrsi~;ot IJ~w Yor>.. sror 1• Hwuk NY 11?90 l\t1tol•<>n ~-f.'Y SMh 

RF(il_QlL2, fiurws P:Jml Plaia. H 4~ lbt S1rcet Lonu :\iemJ CL!·, NY 111Ul At!Lr.f-vn Sa111: •ebl<th 

fi£Gilli(J, <I Sot:ll> r•ll Corne•> R.::>c Ne-> ?:t'ti, 1-i' 12~1il At!enlin11 f.;n Guvl> 

flt:GJQH~. IISn NMh W"··r'o~ lld. Srlle.nect:uty Nr ttl% M€nbon: Do:1 S.pc;,u, 

_REGIOf!_5. Hudson .S:11:e' r>1~os1on. R~~> 220. Warrp•tsb,;g NY 1?8U~, Mlfnt•on. J,m Co.Jinlll 

!IEGI()ti_6, W-llr·n"'"'' $\;li;·Otfoo: Bldq Jf t V/a:;hmqtcn Sf. VM::ri1Mn NY UMt.llnenllofr ThoP<?; Mtcrqr,n 

!!EGlON]. lil(, iri~ 8oule>Jr(. West Syrawre. NY 11?0~-2-1QO, A:tenti3n. rkgmo:d f',,,k,·r 

ij({iiOII ~- 62/l fw:t A>•On·l""" Read, Avec NY 1·1~1~ A~en\FJI Tho~"l' M:Jrnvt! 

IUGf-Qlf 9. ?/0 M:dnt}ti.- A'it'. lln~~lo NY l.!2U2, Ath:·!JIKJr. L.1uy Sill!T':Jfl 
62 

c 

:.; 

?:· 

-f 

t 

ss __ 

Notictt;; 

\\ \t)nK ('f 

L '\. \'!l{()'\;\.IF'-.T.-\1 CO\ SF"\.\--:-!(:". l :''{()f'OSED R:C:\'lS!C". T() THE ':'T'T[ L\lf'l F.\1J",T\TIO:"' ": -\ ', 

-

--.::.-::_ T -; 

J ·,,,,, d :. ' - ,. I . ., - '··-1-

I . · .. -/':·--··· . .<.,. -·-:J 

' I 

I 

.· .. : 

r·,;..:•:= 

·t 

_ _.,_,_ -!'.. . 

LAT-E '-., 

'lt.lE' 

) ... 

'-

.. . 

:l··-· 

---. '. ·.'' 

l•' 

·r·-

---l' 

j'-,·: 

·: 'I•· ':'1::•-:-·; 

"t '", c - -' 

··-

.. r;_,:,_ " .. ;! - 11 ! ...... - ·., r · 

...,. -"" 

: -.· .. l 

..J:· I 

· ! i,·- ·. · · . - ·,: 

• :"' !! , , :.- r :"' . . 

·1-·.•J: •:c· .r .: .:.' __ ,' · . :· !' 

"""; ,...,. "1' ·;•.o',! I .'•'• •·" 

;I• ···;'"'' .;, 'I,; ' ' 

··,•·r -·l: '.:.',' ,; !I• ··.•, 

. ",'·.' • r i- '• l : 

: ,-1'-,'. '? 

: '·-. - -. -

·.: ':r ,,, 1' ' ,. .... .. , 

:: c ,· :, ' '.:::!J3: .," ;1: .: , ;:- • J .:.,Tj. 1' 

·- t· 

__ lEGAL NOTICE 

I 

I - ? 

I 

I 

II 

.. \ll.l.t.:.:· 

... -<"',)!<1;', 

.-;. 

;itlt.'',·l/1:;-

!);tO•,•.·;...: 

........ f:J; .;:est. 

• , 

:·=· 

Cni ,· per 

,--. 

', :T:Jj!!I;J, 

li<Y- G 

. I ' 

r··.· 

II , .• ! ,J 

l. 

'· 

. ,) •, I .J ' '• • • 

.•;., · ·:,:; 

-.-+r-•;:- = C•:-.. -r-•.,1-:• I! .'\j 

1 

;._ 1-1 ' 

2 ·I I'' I' I ..... ' ·.::. 'J ..... ,,, 

,qEG1GN.3. I - ,'i' • -£"·- ••, _ _,_;_:: .. ·-. -, .. _,_,, 

_! 1--, !._ · 

'll\,clf, 

·-:'fl"'·-+;:::; ':- _:_ 

··' .. 

1' 

.. c·;:-

- '·lr._ 5 

' , • Jt, c'. 

f E t. J. 

0' '. :1 -· -1 ·, --, • -

- t fl--

-·. .; 

J.' 

,,. 

.,, -.,,--; 

r ACCIDENTs oNLY 

FREE coNsULTATION : i IB31f.• .:u• 

Dominick W. Laveile 1 

Ar.orney at law - ....;.;.. : 

• 

.... .!..... 

:.,. ·-'.r 

·'·,::: :.;!c·· 

• 

NOTICE OF PROPOS

CERTAIN RA

·c:·c:l-;_,- given:-,,:;, 

::cer"' " tn :he f'JC'.\:orliT'·SSIC<l f thG t(itiff ·,_ '

:e'""''ce--- -=·/ ·:=:or.YYliss :Jn. 

6. 2·:G7 

The tari'f rs 

Dial Wne access lr

- Res Serv·ice 

iexcll.ci'\l Ufc Lt1<::: 

Pes·der.ce Fla: t:?.:E3 

'11-:::' ,:·- [·y· ,· -4:2· 

R:::·e Ci 3 

F:.::e G:::; 1.'f:; ::• 

f-<;.,:c: G:::;·,q:.--:-

t-l,:1te 

Or-·e-Fart.\' .. >.:: 

{Rate 9) 

Lc:-: a

The rares cha

'Nh;ch a-e availab!e :or pc;bt .

Yc•d<. r<:- s CGCI1c oi-f ce at • 

r·· h t ·-:1 r 2::re .;:is 

r· t·Jrr:·-n;ss·c ·:

;,lbar''i rvla ,, ,,- 

... a: 

.. ?-'11:-;:"":r"- ,.-tf:.i 

IZ::: :' \J 

[ID_V):!H 
NEWSDAY 

-R~F~C::l:IVED !AFFIDAVIT f)F PUHLICATif>N 

\ ' ,....0 \ : ~IR-OU 1 

L .. --~~--· -------' 

CREi\ TIVF f\:IED!A ACiENCY/~1 !P 

:N3 JEf{JCHO TPKE /SUITE 3 

MI~EOLA t\Y 

STATE OF NEVv· '{ORK l 

Ss., : .. "··.: 

COL!\T'{ OF SlH:I·"f)LI< 1 

K:lthy Sctlliv;ill 

1)284\05 

of Ne\vsday. inc .. Surfnlk County. N.\'., bcmg duly sworn, says rlwt such person 

:s, ;md at the time ol pu:1!ica1i(lll of the :11mcxcd Nntice was a duly autlwrizcd 

t"U-..1tldi<Hl of rcnn·ds of \ic\vsd~ly, lnv, the publisher of NE\'v"SD;\ '{,a newspapL'l 

publish:d Ill thL' Ctlllllty l)f Sulfu!l-:. Cuun:y uf Nass<HL C'l!llnly or ()UCL'IlS, and 

l'lscv .. JJ:.::rl~ in the StalL' u! New Ynr!-.. ~md ()tiler places, amJ tllul the Nntict· nl 

which :he :mnc\cd is a lrLI(.' copy. w:1s published in thl': fnllnwing editions/ 

l'l>LII:lil~.-.. u! s:tid lll'\Vspapcr un !Ill' foi](l\\·illg dall's: 

\\ lllNi .SI >.\ Y Jl NJ 

"' 

I<' 

I 

'-' (; u) P. \\' asst•r 

I\ol<try Puhli1.·, Stale of Nt·w York 

:\o. 01 \\' i\(J045')24 

Commission Expires OS/07/2010 

Qualifit•d in Suffolk CountJ 

/ '-- L J L' /------ -----
:- '! 

::i· 

~:; "; ~- : . -. 

-7'. 

,., 

/ 

~ :.' 

,. 

. . 0 

?"'·'" 

' . 

-· C< 

' .. , 

~ 

-. 

~ 

•r :if 

.·; I s; 

> .-.,,I .. .., 

;ro 

·-'> 

-· 

;;: 

r 

~ """1 

L. 

---1 

..-' 

--\ 

r 

-----1; 

; ~·I 

'; n/ I ',? :...,.. 

.-. ' .,. 

" r· r· ~· 

::-::, /. ;>c< 

:::: ,.. ·'• ""1 ·.fl I I 

< 7. -1 I 

).- I I -J .o _,.,. T I"" - r· L. c ·r· 

..., K,;• 

,, ·"' ~ 

-- . .....; ·~ +_::- '.-"' _..,., ~-~ 

; ' 

:'1 

! ~ ....... 
~ . Jq!>u),(J!'-ti~d.- :::\....JL ___ _ --- .... ._,~·~t .. u.~ · 

. I ~' j 
,'\E\V YORK STATE Drt'ART\!L". T Ul 

F~VIRO~\lE:\ fAL CONSri\V-\'1 h ''" 

1'1\0POSEI> 1\EV!SIO!'\ TU Tfl" ST\11 

!M 1'1 f::\U'_'lTAfl0'' I' I A"\ 

• J·: lL·· s ,we-.~·· w.:·~., !··.t: ,.,.j "-:v~ ,'( '~"- ~-:. F..l t , :.1-;: ·{ 1 ~.1: ·.·1 'jl t\J ·ir:-.-1t; J' t·. 'd 

1 ~·+~.ff·.:",\l,f~N d•t;p.:.rtJIY·q::: ·Nill h·~L: l <i;•J!~.Hr·:-- ;:-111 J ·l ;r .-.~~ f·. ·.:.1 :IL· !:_tl' 

f~/:l:Jui· 10 lhe ~IJif'! lff;~·IC.1Tr{:r1 !tlOi1 f!J 1 ''!!'.• 'i_ t l ·t_.: •l!'\l• · 1· : .·.: ·' -, .h ····; 

•~' r1o: 1 a 11·f:~-e-J "-'<"' 1 ~- ?fifll f' r:r ;r: :,1 t\H f· 

! r~' ;fllVtl' ("I; ··~ Hf)lfd!ilt-:J J :~ ·1 1 1·.· :r·! II 1to I t· I ! •li:·•' ;: f .~, - 1 ',11 ~· ·.·, ,...;·1;~ 

~~r;,t,:ct•JI"I r.g-tnl:y e,t.t'lf_;w-g lh') C\!:rtfl':·::~~•--T~s d•.-..1Ttti~c ., i\.. ''Lt;.tlliiH '·' : :~:~.1 ._;.H::o1 

M~ 0•, '(•().:'" ~·co} At;;tl;,ltllt [lomor:,l'!t~ c f('l ~'IE' tko• . .tur~. r..ti.~]'IP' ~ 1": .• ~.' 'i tr·,, fl·l!f lr. 

t ~·s :_,II· f"'\'i}IOil ihe O!~p;v~rPt'!~ jl,' rwn·.:j..JI':!.::. 1:1, ~~q~~;l>:tl~V-rl ·,:[1~ 'J·~~ Gt! nJ,) .. f,',ii 

•·mtl:t:~tt . .:.·r ·]l'i;:.t:. Sl~;nd~;! ff'j;.,~,t:·:. t1·1 ::.Jt.~ ~!ilr,•; ;1 .. ·l~r.dt''/ ::.J,~ i!~·u. 1 !l111,)·:!Jf1.l 

;,rl.'\'<'lr<r; th]~ lilt! 'C'illlh',JI nf at•:,· rd(r~nc~ ~') J i1":'1Ht'1' :a·_:~ :·•I!IIJf-11 {} ll!d)l-~' t!ll['<~:.?,~i 

~ .. :~ ~··f,_.:.-~'~ b'/ thf \;J!'! t"•! t·.l.,:,.~; ·y,.~ lr:S.i1 'ht! (··-' :. ::.: 11-.1 ,~~h')I(11J~ :t1:u·1 ::~~rL 

t · ·H1~\' i1mt_.,, ... ; ;~·.:~1!:. .:to:: :t:r.H ld;,,•: :lh: N,:lJ::t:~ .. _. 1..~ ·~--·-II·:•J d ..,. ....... 

u;\1l: fU~ ',f_~: .. i, .~:t .·t 

ii\·H ;t.' t'.f.' 

fl~ J\ 1;l ,:·'o' '/II ·~\.l\t · ,·;;T: !I'd! ['11·-· !' •I .1 ; .. : ·, 

;, .• ,,!•1 ~A: •·' ·J,•,_, ·~;. i·:1: ;p 

: 1 -~- tl1 ; .• :•r;· 

" ( ' . " I II i~J l -II ' l : \· 

fir· -,,, i I l;. fl., I i i, ..: ; , :,. ._1 .. ,.fl.~t •II • ).•J. ::I r " 

. .-,.;'11 ··"1'·11!'. w .t .. li:. :'.·l·w r •!-!•··~:, '· 1.: '·:,'Ill~ 

ti:\1' :·· ··,· 1 d '!'• •.l·.'l:ft i{-,'1 ::1.'' rr 1 •:,: f.:r · .. l. · 

:tot"ll!l[l- ,' ·; .JI ·-: ··;· ;•i•)/ ~~.( ;--..,.·~· -:.,·~.: fd :;: ' 1 

~:·.··~- ·' ! :~·· .;q·;· ·: r: ; 11 q •.•. r.<·:;.·. ~:~.~·.,I,!:. 

~~.:r·tJ,rn 1 ;·~11 r.--~ ·!' H·~ .ur·· .. ,.-.. ·~t~.•J :·'~.Jil:tl'<, 1 

! t! 

·II r·· 

"ll .;L ;i·'i,: 

d!J'I!o'lli:l 

:JirJi~·v r"~~~v·r:: 1 id. l!:':.! L\i':-lJ'•n:·:! h., .. 1-<·f~t(·~ J . , , '11 '}'lt. "-: h• 

011 .. ' l'i!fJ~!tmf~lll":·k, ,!,I: ~~··t~:· .L 

:ha: rr.~·r ::1' a.~kdt• i tr1 Hu· ;~r 

.~~tr.ltY .. ,·· l• ·;It· ,, d ~~~. ;•ilp··:td -1•;~ , 

k. t·.w:l t· · ·!,:· ·:.' t: ·i'~';lt. 1' t ···J •I.=. ,[1[1 ~-·· 

~o ~Jtm r tP! ·'J: .•1i:>~rr \tJ!i,;1!;.~·~·:.; 'u :: f:. r~r r), -:-. /· .··~~--~~ 1-d'": t·~\ · ;1 ~·o; ,_..:: ··q·,,h,~ 

<1! >;rtl (-,·~j .Jn(J '.'<'!It/..';: ~l.~lld 11-'fi~·: H'l' •':A··J H ·. II; t II·_ ··~, -r ·: I . t . ! • f 1, ~~I'· t1lll[J t • 

!''<.1~ ~ :'lfl ·Jr;1i st;n;m.;;:r;. to fCQv~;t ilf• Jl'f.·•,:nln'c:·,; n J.'l\'v'1.•; \", ·tlk i.l!·' ,, :11 I·~·>··.·~·; 

O!'V t·) ':.1·1rt;, ·: ;~flC the i.f!~!-:10 1r · 01-1 ~:~1-1 ;'""It ;1;·· •t !": r1_ 11 r i . t ,. G.,.,, 

:1; l.l ;~ ' 1 : r:; ~ 1 t 

;flti! r/,··. :u ~Lt[-.' d:·•;~:···m. W·lfi:!tl ·;t11~·:·;rf; l:· ::··oL '.1 ".,t' ,!'! l · , .i,'id. ;.~ 

t~·.';.~-~~i. r~t-.-i:,:uJ: r•l /\!r flf;;,.'~nf·(:~~, •:/:· H"Oll":'f'.'l\· ll:;-t.·:· 1)\ ·.;,>:-r·<.lr:;'.~·~·)i'; 

1

_, ~ 1 4' ' .. r,~:( ~- ,'.~11! JL~'•·i>"~/~t,;-.'.',tV ~·.;ft! ···, l:;.. 

1'·,:: t-:k0u~c: SF1 revi~:r(JH .;r.:, 1., ~<V~ ·:cd t ::..-: 'J f • 1 1" 1 

: .. rl'r,:·,1.'.1•;: :;-,-.:;<trJrnt:rrl u~hl•!' 

RE:.G.Dh_ f, 8,JI:Ql~; r'·1f). ~·2-~i.~ .::rl··: ~r-_r,. :·r1 -~-~·.'·.' ':' .;~~ ·~t : f· 1 ,-,~ •: 11 J·~·~ .io:t-:'1:ii.lfi 

'\J,!'-r'·Jfl.!i 

n::oro~~J. dcli·"r:.tr~~nti"Jl:. ~~~·:(· ·t·.o ~,:-t.tl, t.·t·(_ll: l"C (tr 11·.·· .),_·~~-.-l:~:;-· 

:'!;11! L!t•';,fft, 

HlYlUJ{~. ~· r S ·1dl1 '· 111 r .. ·:rw.:r::.. F: .-!rl ~-f~ .: 1 'J~:..·. :.. · r.· . ~· 1 . :·. ·l.-r1l' · · ~ :_ t :1: ;·r. 

HdJIO!i4.. tE'JClt-.··ar;'t.··~slc~~:HIJ ~--:..:.:·.:~i:"'..:tLJ(h. iJr ::.i~.ti .... Jit,,:'tt<~ [I· 1~--:;·.=t·-r 

flti!J.Q~ -:,, l \.t1~ .. n ~h~;r: ~s!·~:.i-·rn. 'l'tPc 7.?~J 'l~'irr:.:n·,~,,:· .: l. •. :!(·.~ '\:!-; 1! - J,, c. ql,u ·: 

!il·_GfON 6, W>iH:l:-·,':;· ~)t:1lC· .. IJ'ft(L ::1:)·., ·;;/ ',.1./J~l·~'t..::v'l ~-' ;.'·i,tl! ·~~~;t,, f.{ 1j._l_'i 

-'.[1t;r~]i• .'· fh£:·~7fJ~ 1.1t'i•J•HI . 

Ht·CtOr4 .1, fi' ~1 ln11 ur.! .·.:vi!r(~ .;: .. ~~·t. ~)' at:tJ~..: f'll 1 • , 

FH;:t;m~, ·1. r.~., ~.: f·:·.;t t.:.;r .. l-li:T• F:n·. /.·..rtP. JV 1 1:~: , 

'nf: ~·~.U,·; ·~·-'I f-,. ijtll.!l J 1']·~·:r 

.\~t . !:'\( f1 !11 "oc, {.,~,'ji 'I• .f! 
In Print. Online. All the Time. 

CRF.:A TIVE MEDIA AGENCY 

393 JER!Cf 10 TPKE STE 3 

ATTN ARTHUR KRIEGER 

MINFOI/\, NY 1'150 1 

Albany Times Union 

News Plaza 

Box ; 5000 

Aibany, New York 12212 

Account Number 

Order Number: 

Order Identifier: 

0528310011 

0003083646 

kjlkjfkljadkJ sd ak 

r Dolla>d I D Hess I D LaCoppla of the city of Albany, being duly sworn, says tr1at he/she s 

principal Clerk of THE TIMES UNION, a daily newspaper printed in the county of Albany Town 

of Colonie. and Published i11 he County of Albe:my Town ot Colonie and tnc C<ty of 1\lba•ly. 

aforr~said <md that notice 'Jf which a printed copy IS annexed has been ;egulary published in tt1e 

said /\LB!\NY TIMES UNION on tile followmg dates 

06 13-?00/' 

Sworn to before me. tll1s Thursday, .June 14, 2007 ~ _) I 

--fv.. tl ,_./:1ti,'_i~_---_-_ .. --

Notary Public 

Albany County 
r----------··.--w. ±Ill r I & 

\H\ \ ORK '~T.'\1 E UEPARTMt\T CY 

i·\JVlRO'.JME\fTM CONSFRV.\TIOi', 

PROPOSED REVISION TO THE STAH 

IMPT.EMENTAT!Or-.' PlAN 

'l,,o,_·o ·~ 11nb·; Ql'itl• tr..ot :·:,• fllW '\Ofi•; .':·;-r OFr•;:n·'.l:'n Oi r:·h:tl!•:t;\1£~~1Al 

cor-:smv~JI\1~~ \D~p:::trner::; ... ,.,:1 ~,·,:~ ~ lcJr;lat.< FJ8:_rr; H.i.'ii!·JG :Jn trt tr.iw.·:•·CI 

l•:itSIOF t· l~e State I11Pi€iT·?'I.:Mn Plili rS.?i 11., F'IJJL ,,~ li ·'-";'II·~ 1\ :r '>·Sl•leJ·; rr; 

ol1rr. n:t\e ·lU ~h.y2}, ('.JD7 PU3L{ HEfl.P.:t·.' 

lh:· Q(;;<r~m~nt :i <•.Tr:W!IIIQ ::: SIP i'•!l',nn :n b. :_1:1r•:· s·>:c: _,, ronmcn 

Froli:d -: r Age~cy· •:lar:lylllg ::re r rr-lll'mrw; IGcntitie·J ltll~: ~1<:'-''r:~·-•r · :. trr;: Ccr::r:t 

MJnD•II1F. iCO! A~a·rnent O?mOIIS!raliOP •o: :·reNew YJit r:."·nrulu:: Are.; iN t\1.~ Iii 

tn:} Slf revisr•:r.. !hi' :lepafH1~!1\ .:>.rn~rstrat<s nor:r.!c '~''''';' \) tn :hr cc: '·J:rJ;~)r:JI 

An·bi~n. Air Qua;;ty Sranoard !NAAG'i) t;y subrc;:MrnQ a: r,;G.ri ~:,1;1 HI ~lf:J i!i I"G:clmt] 

£!JOI'Ilng thai i~e !emo•;a1 of aoy ~cie:on:e 13 a !,pled cil-nt-:: ;1ark:~g prngrJm •m[ .. :JS·:d 

a~d enic·rced by !';e C•t) 0' tl~w \'ork !rom :he CO S'P w: n:.; iorJ('.Jr:li!B .-!~:,mmen: 

brca~s' a'llbie:.t if'.'>: Is a··~ V'r:i t-elow the tiM:)S 11'd trni--] 1:-·,;;n .. v,;d 

fhe ;·UBL'C HE.~R:~'G on the pmuo>•d SIP :f.'::s:m ,,il :;, ·.:Jnnr::etl Jo 'GIIcwi 

OAT£ !UESOA'/.lii Y 17_ 2&Ji 

11Mf !iCC P ~· 

PtACE: New T'!r~ Sia!t Jt:j•a·H·:~-:1 •;'l:>·llllilll· :11 ., r: fX.-W 

Reqtc:12 Ann''' ~far,c: ~.:Y•:-- 10' 

ir_.J •'UBUC hfAi<.tflG 1$ SChEiiu'?·: c; ,1 pi3LC 11di t) '"·:b•'1<·! r1 J:<-.''Sici'' 11 ;:'\0'~ 

\·;th tmpa:n:d rnobdt"l .~ 1 th; h~.tinJ. :he Df:'"""n ~·,JI. JI~··;P_Ic in'~lr'·:er ,_,.,.,it·:s 'W 

:1~a1 ~rSOfiS at nc- Ci.·Jfij('. Wr nt:~ r~q:IC)!S ~.:· 'SUCI"l sert::.r-s --;r,-. ri>J~.rtlj J~ J ):r.;· ,j tt 

lurm'!led 0·1 ;c~€ 26, ?lli}7. L1 LMJ 8fr~~r. w:::GfC. 62~· Gr•:.JMTi A.l;v··,· fl." :z?:\3-

]{5(i, (518) ·!C2-8451; a:'ifl;~"7gw.decstm.:r, u: 

P~rsJan• b Part 6fi of ~.1e i~1ple11e1:nq rPgutltirw, 1 :-r :re :.tJI.• Fl!'oi'QIIfllc;1!J; 

:lualt~l He;ie,-1 At!. :ho llr~Jr.rnt::•tlm> r.rr~J-•:•1 a fbn':.t U"'llYr•rn ·\rnq :h:r rh': 

cropJ<;r.• ;y:l:cn will no• r~t( :i sqrf.Kanl ~11:: :t- r'li~ c::r• T"rrt 

T ·~ Qe~·-111':'~:1' nr-Jr'es a• Jc·•~c-:';, orur.·.'l'lr>~1'; v.•rp•J d':e;J:-.. •rj ~1·.• :1·1 uct Jf)fn· 

~'t" L1a' ffi1'i te dkl?d by l·1e ern·:~.o.:: ''''"''''':;II~ '·IF i'· .-.:1 r! :t,,) llccr'roq n.J'•. 

In ;ubl'l- c:1l '~' •:ri::en >l<t~n~n:s 'ir tr: r~:w :\ tj'Pii'I·P ''l·:'•i '-'·II itt:' ... ,, < 

Jl bOth Jral Jnd ~~CJ~·:n '.!JIFn;;~:~ :·~O:"i'~:J II 1:, c;\ ::::;.''<:-:r-· ; r~~·.: ~'- .,._,,,hilt~ I• · 

'T<J;.e an !Jr~! 5tl.!1e':le:-r t:· l;'~tl•: ~· "~' lP~IJIP~rfl~f; HI JJ'./~;n~,. V•/r ;t: .~1 :;~.!:·· "GFt'S J~~~!',r:·~ 

:riDr tJ .;v1r.g Or l!~frll,~ r•(,<;:c•: ._ :~ i/.11 .;:o:' ·:;;;t-. 1J'~: f ·1~; \Hl-1y 1', I t•~ :-r.-·:; 

e~:.:a: wr~·Jht 

Wrrt:~n slal~m·~r.t; musl re r~cei•:cd ty.t 1L ;.1 ?(liJ7 ;.hrctl i:; ·,n e.xiEl'"JII cl t:·e ;;T;-

imiiiJy -30, 2007 ileadlrc-J. tirin?n sloh:m~nt >l•oul1 te ;·JIIi ;c Hohm :J Be!JwJ. 0 : . 

tlvSDEC. Division of /!Jr R•·so t•ces 6~5 8r-:cJ1·,.r.:·1. Alt•on·; N'1 • ;'"13-.1:)~ i te:encne ~sm 

402-831fl; e::;a! airSIIJS'iii\·11 r;.: s!O:Q ny li> 

The proposed SIP r;;·.• sinr. rr.1-1 c;r· ol,toiiJF.d 1r~11 1.1- Rn;J.,._,:; :•r lr-:rm :.''i' :r t·,e 

!oi;owi!l(] O~pJrhne•11 o~ir•' 

[t~GION '. Bmh1tfi1J !4i] s:a!~ lln!':~iSii ::·1 fi~·!, ,_,., S'•)il', gIll~. N· 11:'9) i::!~·llll:f; 

Ai~Y Sha~ 

RtGIO.!!Z. ~tLrl::r·:. Po."! Pl;;::r ~~ r• 21st,:·.-, • i •He !~ -11 i •) · '. l 1 i: :•: '·t!;o;: ·:·· 

SalT ~~t~li' 

A£610~J. ?I S~utl· F:it C~w~rs Ho.li Ia·.; f.;;·, :r: ·:;~r; ->.~:- ! _: ~,·n ;~-?-:t! 

REGLQM ~,: ~~1D f'il·~r~h ~~/i'!':.t'.~·H H-J. ;;:-itCFfi~T/ '/! ~2J;;i· ,'1!1:·~ I~-· \.:·; Spr.--:r:•'l 

RE_~l011.~. Hu~~.on St~:::~l V~n' on b;) ??II '>l'>r•'~:-t•:rrn ~! '1:',';.';\ ;\!'n•t a' . 111 :._.~_ _,r.f 

HEGmN __ ~, WJ!f!nc.vm Sratf J:~1t:~~ Sl!JJ 31.: i'/~s1mGt:~~· :~)i 'l~\-;i~rl'},·:r \.1y· !Jbt;J 

l<ite"!•on ;ncm.1;, '·-1n;~:ln · · 

~tGI3N ~- ~ tilt' B-::u:e·;~·d Vi%1.-:)~JJ:'J~t 'JY 1:\\4 ~-iiJ ,\f,_•n:u;•t ~,~lflli<i Prh; I R~~!OH 8, e;;:,: r1) .Ann·' r:-a R.:,.":- A;J NY 11-1' .. \ i;Mcn·r•Jil Tr:•r6 '1::: [ 

~o..R ... fG .. !P ... '* .. s.· ... z:_v_'' .. -i~ .. hi.. Qo_A_v~--.. ~1.J' .. :·,,_,j_N .. ·-· ... I-·1i .. :· ... :- .. :...!:c •. I .. ' .. -- .. L .. •t .. r:· ... :... ·, ... ·n·.r.' ___ ....,~ ! l 
:)TATE ClF :'\JE\V Y01ZK; 

____ [\A \" f\ 1) ,. L lv-inc• +•'··· ··v·•rrr __:_ • ..!.e\('-ui..J,')S;u,.'i.L C · '..~·.:)!.."\_<;:_(~--~-·~ ~ .... , ·''' ' 

cT;;. r.i\Y 1 .;~-,-. :• :~n ;,u:l.•.•ri:•:d ·:· ... ·::~pte·· T••r L~" Fnr"'lTT•r'···: r: ll:lHH:r: .. ,' Tl-H; 1"-:_··~::T 3T:'\I, 

ZO_ 0:.7._ 

2il(J_l 

Cynthia J. 9101'/i'l 

· Nctary Public, State ol New York 

Quali!ieri in W a:;hington County 

Rea. #01BR6118957 f M~ Comr~'ssitn Elpires Oec. 13. 20_9 
'III::W YORK STAT[ DrPAl\T\VH~N"( OF 

Ii:'IIVIHONMENTAL CONSERVArlON 

PROPOSED REVISI0:\1 TO Til F. STATE 

IMPLFMENTAflON PLAN 

~;:;her. ,, ller<IJY q,ve:: 1'"1 li•< N!W ~fJ'll( .)lt:f Dc~.~'i1Mlf;T Of lN'II;\()NMft;if•l 

cmJS.iFN;e..; u:m tOt.~.lrll'ft:ttltj ',).';/;:·~:I;;;~ ~~·:;~<.{r !~ r:n~ 1c. Hf l\l-li.'1G 1w t.io•~: !r::~~1J·Nir'!1 r~yr".wn 

:n11~(' S!:1ltJ lmp}ement;thO!! Pl.\il \S1P 1. :hi~. PtfPl !(, hl ,,p N(i ·~· .\l!;.'·~·tl r.(11~: n:; r.o! 1ht~ ::.l~I(('IW 

~h·,· 2:1. :;;~c; P;:m ~r. HFAI1. ~-

th~ \!~,~.lartrru~nt •!i \i'.lbl1Jt'l•n~J ,\SIP ·~·.,.t',~r,;, :o ttli; .Ji· ~el: 'St;,~r:s t~•m(Jr::ql?'l!:.,ll'!Uir,:lwo 

1\Qt'l'~·~ ;,:i:..:11;;·1t; t.e t:U.mrnihntut•; R.}t;l!l.ilf:l(i ·:1 1:':. -~11\t'r.i.lc:t ~·, l :f.t2 CJrL"C~ ~fl{lr,)•.1e tCOj 

A.na·nmt::lil ~~Hl\.l.ftSIF~ll!.:r. tal tilt! ~ .. P."\1 Yi_~r~ ~/k.·!: .Jrnhun AH1CI n'l"M.AI l11 thts SlP ft\'IS10£t tlte 

~e~ ;;r.rtfl!~'lll)•"flti.!·"ltlr<.l~e~ f'JlJ1it;1Pr1.-:r o:or.r_~· of'l:i; lt.t· (,!j N:HiiJt,::: f~i'11btl~t·l A!: ~}1/dl'&)t Sqnclan~ 

(Nl! . .AQSl hy ~\jUt~tl\11~} dit r;u;.;· ~'<' u_..!.:. u~ 'H!t .·j ~T'i .. ~ ... !wo~,j ·~hn·.~ ·tG h-.,1~ lh !f-11\J..:vll ut a:w t":!frP!1'l:f: lc: ,1 itlmtr.d v/ 1 ~~r~'f.i l1r.•~.nr; tJH).~·JI'1 t."lj··:~tt! J'l) ~:lh:!..td b·r· r:-r; ~tf't t>l N~li't: t'l~ih 

1r{1:nlt1P ;;(1 ~;if' \\j,ln nof !~"Op.lf :h.·P. -ll: ,HnP<!fr1 i• :CJ,I'dl -~·1•.'•101 .~ lt-,ii·L; .tr•- •·-r~H tflo~t l~P. t~.e..An:~ 

Jrt;! fit!lk! l:j Jl,'i\11-"l;'\·)1'-; 

lji:~ I': 1;1Ut litAHdiC U:l t~n: ··,rov·:·c~ .. ,~ '·::f tP· ..• ;~,~ ·.'nl: , .. :· "t'.i·W11'1' -~·.- t0f\:1w": 

O~lT lJi:;[r.W ,,,,, l~.:·:r. 

TIML Hi) PM 

?LA:CE {l•:w v.,,i~ :)!~\:' ·~••r;rtt,rJ'•tl '~~~•·•H.Jfr"r'nl,l 1 ,,_'1:.t.'!J,J'; 1 

n ~ ~m · ; • Art•~·.~ - 1 !• .11 , 1:_, \1 '· :. ·• · n~, 

1 ' 1 r1 ', 7 ll J\•.'" ''.•'~ 

t'."l:.;r:.lflut:c·:-.- n·· .,.111 

1

-hf.' pqt)·, '( H; f.~'-1ihC t~. ~.•:!r!!ltf l If,-' lj,,J::~:.· rr·.~~ :. r~:.•~ .. 1.1!.'.:1 a,_~.::·,·-.'y;· :u wi~•JI·, ,:/··:1 

·w.:r:::J r:n~rlrl'.l At tv hfl"it!'-'~ thJ ,;.,.[.r:11'•1··n~ ·....-11 ~r.-·m:.·· wh•1p1c1n Sth'K.t:.:- fu dl!:Ji 

:1: I'CI fl',.-!ft).:. \;11titU! t.;,~!,, •.:.,_ ]IJ! '·!!;:!! ~.;:;'.!{'.(':(..JF r>-llW r-c: ~!tr\ -;(-JL .'.! ~~ '>t.ibt'PI:teJ 

0• .. ·t<'W 2'i :·~or :1 :.:u1J 1\r.r..r.r r~:· :.T· ::·cs =ltu.1.h-'l,j. ;.;,;,1n~ i:;r :>:'~J 

I J tG .. J;J2 <.'-L· •. Jll···~·.i.t~~\- :f·~ :t;,:p J·; I ;, 

Pt.i~t;.nt lt r'dr' ::.1 ;· :~11trr• l1!.i'lWf,!i[r~ 1:] '•.' ,l.lhli:J ·• t··1 111 .... ·;\:~'r: \, 'i,'C• '!I'~ ·,t,1' tJ.:Jll:y 

• ·''Jrh,'r f·.r'' ! fir f.i ~ n:~rt :r;- r ,; 1~.~ ; p ··::1J;.ro , j ,J ~.,_, ':1 ,,r\ ·; ' ,: ~~ :. ·,.I,~! ul Y.i ~t. 'lJ_J: J'L1 U 1:" :,r 'J pc,( ~ J·:;\~•~f. 

·,·,rill'! t !i,CY ~ ·J;_;t•.:h.f<·'' ~IJf., I-'· lfii~ ~ t·,•r ••:11:·r,•' 

1~~ L:.Jat~r.:t:ll 1 w.·.·i;r.:: .JtJ \'":·:·Y'' OJ•:- .1 .~,··r -; 1 p.:L?I(J!'>-: ,"!.."!; ~l~·V~-'fi1'il'r.;.~' ~\]i:nC.l~""· 

1;-;tt ;p,,1 {J:: ;)li;!Jot..h¥'! tr.' jf ,; f' ,~I••;·C..!!-1) ;-','1' ·i·l• 1(. n~,. ~.tr r .. rtll~'II'• 'f'P 1rf'jl[l-l::1 111J'~)j f~) -,..:_:t':n:-.i 

_·;;ir)t ·,•d,'!::ll '.l i1P.n~pj·, 1111 :t f 1•'1'111 i .'' 'I II.IJYt I•'''U11i 1\•JI ::r~ (f).j•tr•vJi [tl.b~:'ft 01~1 ~~·,j 

•

1- "tlit:rt •:{J:f;fn!."'r~~l fo-[,{ 'o~•}~l I' rl.. ~~.;·~~-~'Co! ',1/i' i(El j;-fl-·:-.·, ,,- ~.p,;'Hfr(i l't Ili-a.· ~1f1 l)(';j1 l,!fltf"t.'~l~ 

!:; r~tjl <,:t,! ciFl .lrO<,_Ilfl:nt:,~~ til .;·:i'-J;,;,._ ,. 'I~ i .\' 'I 1J:t·l~it;Jr'\ 'l~•'-''11;;~ rn-. • ',, r"tii'11.~j . .. :~ ,lUr•f t::. 

I ·;_t. ·,i·'l ,!·,,1 f)ni r,t,l'!: l'f'fit(. "lUfW .1! f ,.,, f. 1• :1 fr'•i \•·th !"·r 'I '•' ._,, •!ll'i'·i-i ·;.,~~;· 1~ 

,·~;~t;.r.-r; ·;t,d:1Tr~nt'3 1'rli'SII...e H"cl•t•Jt'd 'i'.' h.'?':'·~ :~ftl r ,•rt·.-r·t· v; .~r~ r~.1·-,;~~ n: ;:.t llit: (!ir~l!"\..1: M .:' 

:-!0 ?0\..'l t~1fme \\lr1:e-n :-.~;;~~.::n'.i'Jr.~", sr,,.1L1 ~le sc·11 t" Ft .. twn U f\W:f;;'t"<.:l, Pt rt..-',:llrC 

_n·~~:; st: 01 fl,or riP,'iliiW~r~~- tjz•. l/tJ; i~vt.1" :• !;~1 ·. N'J · ·,~~..;-~ ~2~. t li"f~u':l1!:-J!~ l118i -i0::'-3::·9'-· 

r·;l'l:l:l .t•i~ u.:;~(t<l!,' Je·: ~(Jt? n~ ··~ 

7~1l' p "P::o~·t.<: t>; ~ l;:.v:~;.-._n ".~·¥ r,~ ..... t •:!1~·1 

l,·:th'n. ··1-J th::fltit~flh.'f' U!1U\•:: 

fUG1QJ~ 1, Bntt{k;lfJ 1nf) :.:!;1:t -_!tt;,.~·t r,tl\' ill·~~:.·. • J.k :-.,(:;-:'<· ':'.!0.-J~~ NY i 1 '' 10.1\ltt~rlh·,, A!,t1

· .~;~1 i;: 

~fGJOH ~ HU11tP~ jJ J:PH~3Z.:'I •1[ -tJ t b1 ./;•.'(' ~ !.)l)Q)~,·;;:pt: ~~l:·i N'( 11 w:. A:i!-:01101'1 Soi111lfAt•l"-.t: 

BJGJQH lt ? ·, Sot. I~ Pun ·:;c.:wr:; Ru.•,; Nu' r 111!. M' ' 'f. 1, 1\cel,:i• .• r ~:·n Grr,:> 

6f£iiQ1t4. 1\50 N[rll We:.h.Jf. [~,;~. -~•:lrr"-'ff.l•:ty NY !:..,V.Jh AtVrlth~.L ~:In 1iU~:1C•'r 

fU:._GlO"i_5, rt•JI.1'!-0I'l8ie!lt'! f-';..Ftr·>h~\ s.~,.; ?<"J-. \~:{·!K-'t~lt· 1. r.; 1 17~N:- M'-:;nh~it; .Jt;!l ((it :,_,.\I 

RlGlON_lj. W;,H:rt.n~.-q StJh' ·.::rtr. · L\1q ·, r •.'J,;~).•f·.~!;o.· ·-;\ \,V,nt~r,,•,:J k{ ·:::un, ,U.!h'r•:t;·,;· 

lhUf\l~i ~~Jf~Cr: 

R~~~Q-~J, b' ~· t r . .,; lii.•1Ji!l:v,JP:1 \\!·,:·~~ ·Jv'.!l 1: ,p :·:Y t ·~: ·~l-; :-'.!110 :Oltr···:, )n 4c:on-,d~ Pat ~f'! 

fii:.G}f)M,J, t)?7J. [.t-;;,.' !'t:.:on ir;1;1 i\·:·;h\ ;;.·.,ur r~~ 1·1-i' .l, i'r.\1..:nt(-fi 1r!:·,"li-~<:. ~tlii"ii;,t 

RlG~(}N lj:, :).·IJ V::(ti,•Ja; A·i•' Hulal·· -:-.r~ t.~.,,}?. -~ .. nv"~·t:·;! 1 .m"J ~:-1t ··~~d'l 

, 

I 

I 

t! 
PROCF OF 

State New of ss. D1ane 3. City of 

County, duly do:t depose and says: the 

?.!:::..::cipal Clerk :.n the office o:'. ':'i-:E POST-S?PCJDARD, a pu:Cl1:::: J:ewspaper, 

' . ,, l ' c r •• ; . ·- ... ;... ., ("'- '. n >:: -- ("' ' , "' ·'"" ,..., ',-' - q - (' ,..._,. t" y '·, v ,. r y - n d .... :1- ,. E=:·_......_, l._..._l,_.C : .. 4. .... .-'.J.- o.....n .. j': •. -.t-:.' ........ ·. r.-...... 

no:1ce. c: 13 a copy cut saJd newspaper, 

was and reg:1lar ed1t::..on and issue of newspaper 

che days, viz.: 

CREAT:VE MES:A A 

Ad ;;:l 7215 

Pace:::.· FS Start: 

;:Des 1 

F; It 

6/13 

l8 2 .:-3 S FS 

Step 6/l3 

t tl:uPr:t..:-JC :.pal Cler-k 

. > ,... fore I: I- • :1 . / ··;c. ;; 

l L o :..J - \, / (J ,-/ { . \......._._ 

. ,j ,-y COlliTY. - ,.......-.r.tmJ. s s=.. G.l \._.. ..... ' i .L 

.... / .. -- :·: 

.,_1 P. :_.I.· I·- :·. <.· -. 1\. 

,,; .:: C '·JZ Gt· 

C),J:L;i,::(J l'" :;::..•." 

,\' 

'{ -' 

., ··:; .. 

.._ I 

r .. 

:-JEW YORK STATE DEPAl{

ENVJRONME::\TAL CONSE

PROPOSED REVlSlOX TO 

IMPLEMENTATION 

• .:: ta s r:1a! tt.e N::'.'J STAT! DE

-:, CO\StRVAT/Ofl w•l• hOle a ;ey;sla!i

!BVISI:n ;c lr>i &Ute kT,pJ&m&nJa;;on P·M !SIP

le·omed•J• ,,, ol!he tancaled May 23. 2007 PJBLIC f<EA

fhe is a Sl=' ra\•tsmn I(.l :he 

Frote-::tior. Agtncy :he :orrmr!meots CB-!1f flee

r ;:n:;on :C:'lt A:.:d1:1n1tH !:;·!, dli-Jr, !u, the 

.·n S!? iJcoann·.rmt :,.g;mcr.:str:;:te

Atr>h!tllt Air ·r_! S:anoa!:: by subn

r:9e. srl.:; .... o; reterenc.e 1:1 a 

... t r>ty bf .. fW York t'O!Ti 

Oeca-.se i!rrt-1e•· hH·t;: wen 

P: . .l3t C t:·n 1·.:: :-J··:.;.-::s.;.;; 51? re·/·3c<•: ·.

DAlE: .. JU z:rF 

!!ME· &'CG.0 V 

PLACE· t·.o?\'-' i:nr. S:rre £r.,'!1 :·1':

?.a;r:.:·r 2 hea·ing F.o:H'' 1G6 

1 1·15 .;lin >;·,tr ... 

3nd uv 

ft·g ;,,BUG rtEARth(j 15 &::t;N"!!Jl£1:: h .3 ;lac.e s 

S:•rs :,· :h !":'·pt;re; Al t!'t: :qe 

vl;f.'S 'D' !lt.tl per;on; il; ro Wr •ll<lutsrs IC4 

;t.·:·. <I :·t su:>m>ttld Dt J.ne 26,200: :0 '"aura Setlw llY

IJV 1?733..J25D (51!) 4C2·!i-l51 alr"e9s<;(IWQIC Sl!!< "

P1,;rs:..a"'i. !.C ::<a1 617 'J 1 the irn: 'll.,t.''t':t-.J 

3udlrrt Ai:t. :le:;ilrtner! .1 

a s:;r on l"e 

Tte 11l _:)1\J.l"l':al ::r:;, 

.J;;s·'-:les thl: rHy be itietied tt'l.e c;;roo-ose-d ·: 

..:.r . .:!JCt1!:- su:lm·t :ora; cr M:'i!tl:n '01 

Jf t:t-1 :;ra ·N•tthn ttltel·.oed :: 

iFl stn:,...t"'l 1c dr 

pr ::·r :o ::::1.1 'liJ l't;';f lf'W jn::" 

:. I :•:: BQU-1 

b'v' .1 I!", t".; ?OT 

·:or·4 tl&J' JO. 2J.:·i ;.;sd:;u !::. .:.t'c•;l;; 

r.r · ... .:,..,,....-. ·' "· r. .• _,.. ..... ..., ... .::-'"'!:::; 

....... 

.1.,j;;. 

L...r'.J '.L,i;tp 

t.n 

•C8 ": :: 

• 

0:1ne· "' 
!·;tdh:- L·i· l\le~.<v ':'uri.. 

C(1;; 'ty Cf 1\~(!r'~CC 

C1ly' cf Fn~ :·~:•:Jt-:' 

CRtcATIVE' MED;A !>.GCNC" 

:l!n JLRICHO fPKL l'L Ti''KE .·· 

MINEOLA. NY ·1'5C11?01'i 

fVli>.!\ 1.::, f')f'TUE'Ell--- ·-- bt-•'19 rhily sworn, ·1epuses and says 

~hr1! th c, r·tr:c:.)ll 15 the pnnopa! cleo k In !he offiCe of 

f'.. t!C!•'Y ''t;'N.~fnpcr p:.;hil5hP.c 1n 1)1e Cll)·' of Rochester, 

Cr.unty <Jnd :l!;_1l<-: aV ,.,•,aid <mJ \hat a 110hce of which 

"' :llllHo~Xed IS :l p•H1t~d LO~y, W.:JS r·ubl1;f1ed 10 the said 

rnper nn t!"!f: kAio'1' .. ng ri;Jh:·:-, 

PO 

A.[) fl 

;\(;(;UUN i' JJ 

."-LJLC 1 n:nwu 

101t.l-110C7:=. 

•:i1r-:::0122or:nEi~. 

fq~~(J ptJ'.It~-. ·:1-!0:~ r:n pn::;r, ~t 1 m·~c-r1rc .. n 1r c.f;JS$ CL u;oals 4900"-49 10 

P..nd .'J :'~-~ I":C':-

fl;r c'1c:nqc~~ (Jtv:- f;lr~j pny;-,t,,c· to 

Thl""' c~.-1r~:1et! f~~Jch•_:-:der Ne-Nsp::l~-er~ 

1r: ttl!::" .~~q"'OL ·1: of 2.221 SC 

./~;;-:7 

/f,:/,:_:z'_(;'~ ~ 

CYNTHIA M. WILSON 

Commissioner ot Deeds 

State of N11w York 

Monroe County., '~ /. 

Commissioo Explfes ~rJ>c·.r 

N[W YORK S1ATL lJU',\KT\:1:;\l ur 

f"<VJR0!';\1(NT;\L CO\f~·l]{V;\T!O'< 

l·'I~CWOSI'I1 KI:VlSIU'-' 'f( ~ THl ~'!:\!I 

IMPLE\-1FNT•\T!ON l'! ;\ "i 

r-,,_qtct ~::.: ··•er~:tN !;:•;!!1' trh_,i l;!t: fJtV•/ <JH.·: :; P rt _·f ~"!-\ : u~:rrH '•r -:-Jv!Rt ;Nh'! "J 

Tl\1 U>Nr:fi\",/1\TLlN \DP.p-rlnm;>t-1: ·Ntll !m:1 tl .rq.-:-.!;•1 ·,·f' ,._d'd( i-i•_l\t-1:~~:: nr. ll1r: 

t ·. -:··.•,';l'r~ re,•i·-:;.ct'1 to t!•:.: !:J!J~i.! in·dni!'I'1;;111Ji> :,L•tl ; \;1·~) "'ft ~·)17:J lr: ·f"/~o.;'T.:L 

r~. :.• 'Tduhn~ -~I ttlf' r:;n_:,~len M;r·; :' · ,'t::!.' F-· .tL · 1 \ :rlt_ 

<t·oe Ue;::i)r\tlj~l;\ IS :.;JIJnt\1.'-rJ ,j ::!···, IU·:' •"\ 'fl th· lllll••i .. ,~--:. r, ;fHif~Jr'lt.JI 

f·:,Jh'(.I'Wl fi,1_1!'f:t~)' I lar,:OjiPg tt ~! ~ 'T :-·1ilf' oJ, 1l • h. 'li 1.' I , 1 1·:, f·~t ·, 'II' .It I ' ~:·. 1 ~,~/:! 

Ci!~J.ll ~l't..:>m.un '.~·r_:;. A.t:.}itl'i:l'ni L~(···, ;;1'.1rJtt rr1 ', 1 !b J.h, ·,, 1.. u~~~liq"-dt1., 1 .. r..,.-.'f.t 

·:'·J'r'td:\' 1·: Hti~·. S-lf-1 tf.\·htl)n a·.; >=-"'.Jttw•t' ck<~! ·i·:-~; ·,1,_. 1• ,,,nt• .. , , ~ .'nl'l 'lo~. C!t 

\::1t 'Jtd .Alr'!t~Jr.J.i l\.J {h.,dit.,..- ):ntn!.;r.J 1":,1/~.j:~.~ !, : •,,,tq ,1 '· llJ 111 ". !ir. d'li • 1: .; 'l , 1 

lJtl: 1 Wl,ff(,~ t flH( [!I :(tJ:d t111 :It~~!_ ·fr' ' ~~, .. ·, \.d. /1"11 !l ,. l_! .1 ;:, : 

I, J'll.!r:J.if, 

.... ' I) '; ~~~ i 'I. •'' '~ . 't 

J:t.w\:'Jjnt ~tc=tu~e ;;·n~· >':'1t ]:~·~""'·',rill. 1/\'-·il :·d·J·:,· u ;· tJ:',_,· ,JU: 1 1:d ·) rjr•!'i'"1'J, 1··-;J 

· ~::~·.o.~,·~ rltt'· .. · .:'~:1; 

f.·JI.!FM 

'.',' 

llATI 

T:ME. 

Pi.~Cf r·~~t: '1'li1d ;:.t:lt·" '•'f.JI'h-11 '~IJ'h-:• ltl'l'' 

2 Ailti\·: H,• H 1) I~· "il• l· •I 

Ttl·' PI H IC !lf"tS.ilr·::; t~: \Cii,ll~~- ·~··11n ,1 pit.,: J;·, ,. l' ~·ll•l•:·r ;1· ,. I',. :;•"· t· 

: .. ~~~ , ~.-tit t.~truu~\t ·:v~~.d·i·: ~tlllt:·ltv ~· ~11:; H: · h til' ·:·A 1 ,: ''"I;>· 11 J!..- :~ .:_; •· ,. r 

•;ur.•: 1: · d•'•_d f-<"_11'31):1·, ;'l\ •IU rl.;··1:'! rtl 'tr·,· ·: 1·. i 11 .:. ·tt · ,.,. , ..1 .~··· lf·1111h':: 

-w;: :.t/,·!lfl :1~1 ;,abtl'.t;H;! ::·1 ,liJ,If-1 ··,-!) ~/)(·.~ 1, 1':; f·,··· ,,·'/, tt'j '·,fi~ I, f1:~- P,- · .·lw•: 

~:t•.l"\· t.·r ~~~·n·:j~:~:U. f;;-dB• 1·;·.·.'~-r fll·t'tJ' ·h·1 1.-1 .. ,~..,. 

Pr;J· .r.:·l: t:: f .ht t-1/ U th, Hr.fJI(•I-,l'•ltll • 

~.1..· L• E '>.·irs 1\: ~. th~ 01:p 1r1rn:·rtl 1"•'1'· ,;,_d 

;u·-:~.c:;rll ;n,h(w ·,'l'tl: It:•: /uv11 ;-: ~~~Jl.'l~ ~·~~~·; ·:! 

.• 1 "1 t,' - ... :-.;·i Cr1•:: 1'1'11111 

r-: I ~ j, :' l'c. L J ' I I ; : I ! ..1' 'I 1' I ,t I. Ito: 

; ~ l·~ ·.:f 1 . I • ' ,-, i"l :' I : ' 

~"i' fif:p;1fliU".J,I :·<•I:C\ ;JIJ ,:•.''\.h ', >1/l)'r')l ,·J .J .•1 ,·:!j I;' '.'l'fl' 'II''' . 

.il)l: .,( 11:: tid H lH! ,t:!~Cle.J j,,~ ~II•; !II' Jl' •· " ' ' i' '·I! '•. i • ' j ' Jt' -tlF 1•1 ;r r hr·--1 ~,·J 

. uJ: •r t·, · ~J·;·:m IN,-:: m wrl~~~~n·.t.t'•:ll'" 1:. i·. !':• 1r.1 .:. : :,.,,,_:,,1···•' \LL ·1 ; ,. bt' 

1,·; ··w,,~~ :t t:'~-''·'' \·•.tiJt·': -q~,·n~:' ~.t;-~,,--,,~q: 

·.~ :.l :"~ Ht n: .. ~~ .J!: .·1 <SI·~t.J\C'IIi:1ll1J h qu ",I 4·> ·, ·n rr 

~!e1T-, ~tl(~;i'f,'J f'ltlH t:_i lj[.J:•lQ ·q (_;:·., 1t1·· •••:\ I' I,· ,I 

'•t ,,!J">fJ \'.'~;I l··i~ qj•. 1!;1 C'· ~·.IJI V,'!Jil)\ I 

'h ,:-:-p,r ~t.w~ml?nt: nu~t nt! r"(•;i•"·~ I.Jl, !-~ 

;.''11 1 I]J\~ .. \1)'3~) 2t1(1i'll~•·l'.Jiill~ w·~~:l'l ·::tl l;·ll 

P ~. '";y·~~DfG Dl\':-..un ··/ A:r -:: .... -,,.. 1\' 

1t--uJJ~ ... II: ~:i18l ·~fl? -3:1i;f., ~·P.1tl ;. ,_-, .,·,..;•q·,·~ .>·• ·.! J• 

rhe L+lu,PI);.~.:J ~ •. r -l:i·:-.;r\·,, n~~t 

fn, ·~'.'! ;q flt!(ljlj~fH!):ll •/ft\~:. 

II oi • ~ 1 111!'' fi ;f 1J .,.•"jf[' 

; .. -_,1 :' ',-'; l'"::rr ~.1.+~-

d·.l' i'· o.•,·.r•·J'':r 

:;,:·· 

-~,·I" I. I) I' d~.•;l 

r.' . . {.I 

REGlOJrl 1 Hulidi1m .ll'-11 ~-~.~~t: !lw·.'-''~·~ !·,t ·~···· :,_.. r •·11 l'· ··~ :~·"~ 11 

At~~~lll(•n S.k~l.: 

REGION ?. "t:':er' Pr .. r: ·.•:" 

.tr.tn:ivH: ';...~~~~ l1~bh·.l·. 

R[GIOH ~- ?1 Sw.H· Pt~i.l :,,, 

H~GfQ.N 4_ :! s.lj '·L:: ,~ We-~!;::o;tf '--it I ' nv·r '''.! '( i ··-~ j : ~ '"j; ,',"'t! !L •I Dl•li •;'.,.t: It L ~ 

RJ'J:;:ION~. Hurl:'r.litStrc!t.[rl'!J:,Ln !:)·, (..c!l '/i:.ttt~. ·:_-.,:,J t.i ·~;lk': :,t···l"i'fti -,~.(-·:/;m 

f\E.G!ON 6, VJ:tie'1nw·1 :)t;m; ['ltir·~~ lh.l11 -.,, \\' l1i1. l· ~"..-.~-~ r .••• ,. . f

1.i ·,:)I))' 

Ai1t":;jr)IJ rhop].~· M:·;t,.H 

~tGION i, 615 rr,_. f;,.)•Jl-.r,~:,rd 'li"-,1. '··.rtJ 

f\~{;I_QlL~. t:::.'/·1 ta·;~ ~~':lw _m,., ;,._, .•1 r•.·· · 

~r~ ;, :o 1 

'··"· .. ,. I 

· · ~, r.:t.. ··\. 11 1·. :1~11 ••. d I· trlq:t 

f.~~~ ol ft1r•f ,"I' ' •• \:H ~ 'i 

'•"f\ ,._ '"':'] 

2il 
o/. .iw!<', _)/10/ 

tlrh,- (ill' nl li!if!;Ji.,, .\t·n l ()r4. f,cut~; 

rlu!r SH'!Jt''· d.posc.\ ,n;d scns rlt{/i 

lt.• 1/t,· 11 l'nnCIJ!!ll ( krk of /"I IF 

IN II· -1/ 0 \F II'S I >IJ ·_ ( J! 

n uu,s; Iff? r r 1.1 -rn. nr: 1 r 1.\'t · . 

Puhl1sha n/tlw If { '!fA I 0 :\' t:i r.':l. u 

JI('I\'Sf'dj!('l' j)/1/!(fl/tnf !If Y<liif C!il'. i/i<t/ 

tiu' nnf11 c ,,(Hinch r/11• 111111!'\<'d f!~'llif<'d 

sft{,> fl!f..:l'll/1'0111 SOli/ /lt'IUfltl/1<'1' IS t1 

Clll'-l'. 11 <1.\' ill.'-t'rtcd i//1(1 flllhlishc·d 

tlli'I'CIII I IU!It', tilt' 11!.\'< /"{/(!//"''ill.!; C_lli 

!hi' i/' d,n·r'f. .fttllt' _'(1()-

z'l tJ.:/. ~S_c?,f2-/a., :~6·.<!v/ 

/laic _·/d 8,u; -6 J 3 () · 

::J ~JFf :=;;-:-:lft=:~: 

·-f,\F. r·~;'t .. -:, ··;L}.T~ D·:···;::~·,,\' (0:\K 

f<_.: T:·,.:.·~, 
PtbC! 

!i 

'tt.J'-~-r 

frllg(1l 

-~.{I -\',lt'H I 

i IHI\·V •_1Vi' 

adj'e<tivp 

Tu ill' th•li'./ 

,., ill_j 

Ri G!vN f!. ·;•;:n i•.' ,,. ·;'.J'·' , ·:, •·:I. 

Kl•iWN 

!;-' ·~!111;! ~ I ',)t : ''; 

RttiPJ~~ 8 

Ri·c;IQ~ 9. :•;"•. ooo<oA--·-··-------.....--... ,.. ...... _..~,, 

~\ 

,,. 

I 

; 

I!! ;!I 

,, 

I I' 

I· ii' · . ;, li I 'I'~. .• ! J I 

lll·l···•.r.l I, 

,, flt, Ji•lil 

(116) 849-~~3:. 

fax (115)1!49·34 5!• 

'THlf'"rh;;rdoJ'f;~~!W''h'" CD-"" 

\. ., •IJ'~ : :' • '·, 't1 

{I.'.'- \~' j 'l-1 t" 

. r~~~::·~ ,''.~: \/1 .... ·J , 

·r;/ _. ~~ 1-.' 

,., \ t; j 

:,.1 !·• t•t •\.;, 

J·r ttly · ... 

Ty J I.JN 

''··· 

ft : !u'.l 

T.,j, 

'-" , · l ; ; I l - t ~ 

1-. l i !' N .\ 1''·1 

I• ', L r: I. 

\Vord (~a 

'[';)[), 

<I i'.I!FTI<, 111·:!\, 

t~dtwd··· l L~·;,rti.' 

i\VI'f;l}:1 1:• •l 

'j iltllll 

iFl 

1);1' 

I!' :;·,_\H 

.J' II J'"' 
STATE OF NEI'J YORK 

DEPARTMENT OF ElNIRONMENTl\L CONSERVATION 

625 Broacway 

Albany, New York 12233-1550 

In the Mat t·er 

of the -

PROPOSED REVIS=ON TO THE 

STATE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 

FOR CARBON MONOXIDE 

HEARING Rl:-IPORT 

- by 

----~-4:·~ Susan J_ DuBois 

Administrative Law Judge 

August l3, 2007 
PROCEEDINGS 

The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 

(Department or D8C) proposes to revise the State Imp] ementat ion 

Pldn (SIP) for carbon monoxide (CO) . The revision con<:er,ns 

removal from the CO SIP of any reference to a limited otf-street 

parking program imposed and enforced by the C:ity of New York, and 

the Department's demonstration of non--interference with the 

National Awbient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for CO. 

The Department scheduled a public heari~g on this proposed 

SIP revision. The notice of hearing was published in the ,June 6, 

2007 on-line Environmental Notice Bu)..letin (ENB). A corrected 

nctice, in which two typographical error·s were cor:-ected, was 

published in the ENH on June 13 and 20, 2007. 

The notice of hearing was also published on June 13, 2C07 in 

tl:~e following newspapers: New York Post, Newsday:, Albany _:rime§. 

U~ion, Glens Falls Post Star, Syracuse Post-Standarq, ~ochester 

Democr-at_ and Chrorticl~, and the Buffalo News. 

The hearing took place on July 17, 2007, at 6:00 P.~., at 

the Department's Region 2 Office annex, 11-1.5 47th Avenue, Long 

Island City, New York. In addition to the hearing, the notice 

provided that comments on the proposed SIP revision could be 

submitted in wr:iting on or before '--uly 24, 2007. 

In addition to Department Staff, four persons attended the 

hearing, three of whom presented comments. Following the 

statements, a recess was taken in case anyone arrived late. The 

hearing concluded at 6:57P.M., with no additional statements. 

The hearjng had originally been scheduled for May 23, 2007. 

Due to a problem with the arrangements for the hearing, Lhe May 

23 hearing was cancelled and the hearing was held, inste?d, on 

the July 17 date. Four written comments dated May 23, 2007 were 

included in the record. These comnents were from Manhattan 

Community Board 4; Matthew Roth, of Transportation Alternatives' 

NYC Streets Renaissance Campaign; Hell's Kitchen Neighborhood 

Association; and Clinton/Hell's Kitchen Pedestrian Safety 

Coalition. In addition, a Cune 19, 2007 letter from Senator 

T:10mas K. Duane was included in the record. The Cfflce of 

Il<-:!arings and Mediation Services :rece:_ved the hearing transcript 

on August 9, 2007. 

DEC Slaff was ::epresented at the hearing by Robe·rt C.. 

Bielawa, p. E. I Environmental E.:nginee::.- 2 r Rureau of Air Quu.l i r_y 
Planning, Division of Air Resource~;. M:r. Bielawa stated the 

Department is proposing to clarify commit.ment.s ide:1titi c,d in its 

November 15, 1992 state implementaticn plan for carbon mouoxide 

ire the New York City metropolitan area. He stated t:te propOS(:~d 

revision provides the Department's demonsLration of 

no!:"lintcrfcrence with the CO NAP.QS by submitting air quality ciata 

show1ng that removal of references tc a limited off-street 

perking program imposed and enfor·ced by the City o:t New York: will 

not jeopardize attainment of the CO standard. Mr. Bielawa stated 

t.hat ambi.ent CO levels a:r·e well below the NMOS and arc trendu!g 

downward. He added that the Department took no tonnage 

reductions in the 1992 CO attainment demonstration or the 1999 

re-designation and maintenance plan, both of which were approved 

by the United States Environmental Protection Agency in 2002. 

Kyle Wiswall, General Counsel of '::.he Tri-State 

T::_-ansportation Campaign (Carnpai~Jn) , described his orgar: i zat ::._o:1 dS 

an independent, non-profit policy and advocacy group promotinq 

sustainable transportation policies in the New York metropolitan 

a:i:ea. ~e stated the Campaign strongly opposes the proposed 

revision because it would result in increased air pollution and 

traffic congestion, noting that increased access to parking 

induces an increase in vehicle trips. He stated that adding 

nearly 23,000 new, publicly-accessible parking spaces in the 

Hell's Kitchen neighborhood would dramatically worsen traffic 

conditions, in an area that is already bad1y congested, as well 

a~> allowing more parking capacity in other areas of the cectrc:;l 

b-.Jsincss district. He identified extension of the #7 subway J i ne 

a'id corcstruction of Moynihan Station as alternative ways of 

n~>:>eLing development goals of the Hudson Yards area. Mr. WiswE> ll 

s~atcd the Spitzer administration's proposed SIP revision wou]d 

b:o cont:;.ary to efforts to reduce traffic congestion in ManhattdE 

a1d in the ci.ty as a whole, and that the state is putting 

o·~tmoded development concepts ahead of the well-beinq of Ne\·J 

Y:)rkcrs. 

Daniel Gutman, who did not identify himself as representing 

a~y organization, stated that the proposed SIP revision would 

under~ine a lawsuit that seeks to en~orce the SIP prov~sion. He 

discussed the history of the limttatjcn on off-street parkiny, 

statjng it was contained in the 1973 SIP as part of imp.lement1ng 

t.hc~ Clea_n All Act of 1970. Mr. Gutman stated that, fo~ lowj ng a 

l:twsuit concerning 17 air polJuticn control measures, settlement 

of the lawsuit in 1979 lefl the parking limilation as the only 

one or :hese measures thal \\lould te .implemented. He slated tha~, 

aftc:r· .:1dditional years, New York City had adopted a zonircg 

ordi -:1ancc related to the limitation but had t:t-ied to a.baEdon t.::Li~~ 

commitment a couple years ago. 
Mr. Gutman stated that env].ronmental impacts of th€' proposed 

revision need to be evaluated under the State Environmental 

QL:.ality Review Act (SEQRA) ,'in addiLLon to considering 

attainment of the NAAQS for •:::o. He described the DeparLment' s 

negative declaration under SEQRI\ as a conclusory statement based 

on no a~aly~is. He stated that even if the proposal has no 

impact on the metropolitan area's ability to meet the CO 

standard, more traffic will mean more air pollutants such as 

particulate matter, ozone precur;>ors and car.bon dioxide, which 

t.Le Department should evaluate in addition to CO. Mr. Gutman 

stated the Department should prepare an environmental impact 

statement concerning the proposed SIP revision. He also stated a 

p,;;rking management study that New York City and Department wer.e 

going to conduct was never completed, and that lack of this study 

wc-.s the reason why DEC took no CO reduction credits for the 

parking l.imitation. 

Matthew Roth, of Transportation Alternatives, added to his 

written statement by expressing co~sternation at the approach DEC 

is laking and astonishment that Commissioner Grannis, who he 

described as having an excellent environmental record, would wish 

to have this proposal as his legacy. Mr. Roth noted similar 

surprise concerning what he identified as Mayor Bloomberg's views 

on the proposal. Mr. Roth stated the proposed SIP revision 

contradicts PLANYC 2030's goal of reducing the City's carbon 

footprint. Mr. Roth criticized the Department for looking only 

at co in proposing this revision, and recommended that the 

Department and the City look at how other cities are revising 

their land use and transportation policies. 

8nvironmental Conservillion Law article 8. 
NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL 

CONSERVATION 

PROPOSED REVISION TO THE STATE IMPLEMENTATION 

PLAN 

BEfORE: 

New York State Department 

of Environmental 

Conservation 

Region 2 Annex 

Hearing Room 106 

t 1·15 47th Avenue 

Long Island City, New York 

July 17, 2007 

6:10 o'clock p.m. 

SUSAN DUBOIS, 

Administrative Law Judge 

1]Jiecording - ~ . ., - ~ -- -........ ,_,..., -· -· :_.-: . . >.,(.•~...._ - . '-' • .:. :; '~I 
JuLy 1/, lCC/ 

I i 

JU:K1S U!JBCl::: l1c :...cc:ur~l, 

Good c: v r; ~' i n '-J 

·1 ~; 1 " t , · D c p 0 r t rn c n t o i :c: :--. ·1 ~ r on :n e r: L a 1 c: o n ::.; e r v " t. i c :1 ' :-; 

r:. u ~ o p -~; .s c d r c v :_ s ion t: o t :·. e :; l. ':' t ':"! 1 :n p 1 em e r, t. d L i r' n 

(; Pl i·ll1 tel~ carbcn :nonox.i.de 

7 t·1 y n am e i s :; :.; .': ,-, r 1 f.• ·,: b o -j .::; • T d :11 d r1 

ti ."·dlmiriiS''·a• ivt-e T.a>oJ ,Judqc '...J;tl1 the UEC's Ot:tic:c cf 

'lr.c proceciu:-e t<·til':!hl Ls Lhi-!i I here 

1.~ r.-.::>p(;,:-:E·d r~_;vi sc en 

1 1 7\ r: d f o ' ·1 o · . .; i n q ·· t , :::: h c r c w i L ! b c 

I'· o < • o ruN: n t o n T. ;: • · 

l b I-' 1 n p · } ~-; <-o 1 

1') :c~:c.Ld, and don't need to be restated, alth<:;uoll, 

? ~l i i v :) L: :1 r c 1': ere an 1 l s ·,; b rn i I t e d a >-i r i t t c: 

:,> l .c; · ;-J t. c~ 'Tl ,, n t , a L d would 1 ~ k e t o c; d d I o t h :1 t , o l c! i-J :-; 

~;/: ic:el L:J do \~at. 

'l' he s L a t. em en t s t 1" a t h a v e b 0 e n 

writinq tttu.s fdr are : r·om Se•1 ii l_c: ~ 

J\R-TlJlecording 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEPOe376) 

Toll hee Fax:800.337.6769 

142 Willis Avenue 

Mineola, NY 1· 501 

305 Madiso:1 Avenuf.' 

New York, NY 10165 
1 3 c: :t r d ~ ; ~t; a L t. h t~ '-'• R o t. h , o :· T r :'1 Il s p o 2:· '~ a L l o n 

-- P..l t c r n ,~, t i 'l c .':3 ; f r ,_, i l ' ::; K 1 L ': h "' r: N e 1 g h b o r h o o d 

A::·;sCJcia_tion, and Lh<~ Clintc:; !Jell's KiLc:hen 

4 ' c· J c: :·J t r L a n S a f e L y C o cJ. l .i L .i o n 

The notice ot thi_s hearjnq was 

6 f.)-~l)lJshPci ir1 Lh.(·· Jcpu.rtmcnt's RnvirrJTlmr.:nta1 

'! Notice B:dleLtn, which i~i an on-line publication, 

~' a ;: ::J. i t. 1tJ a s p 11 b 1 i_ s h e d on ,; u n e 6 , 2 0 0 '/ , i n i : i <1 11 y 

A sor~erLed nolice was publ.ished in 

10 t'l:~ ,June "1:3t.h i-:lnci Jur:e 20, :.:001, editions ot the 

1? published to correct typqqraphical error-s 1:1 t.t1e 

"]!. p-:uail udd:-css that was 1r1 LhP. noLice 

• l This vJas :subsequt:,n-::ly corrected on 

T h c not ice ,:_; f t he h <--'!a r· i n g and Ut ,__ 

~B prcpc.scd rc;v~ s i tln wns d 1,-;o published in t:1e :Jc1.: 

l9 Yo·:k PosL, J..n Ne·wsd<J.y, :he l\lbany Times Union, 

i h <-; .:; ; P n :~ ~-all s ~ o s t - S t a r , t h c Syracuse 

?1 PcsL-Stundard, the Roch<::-;Lc-->r CemoccaL & 

23 publicatjons were on J~ne 13, 280J. 

24 W.r:itten stutcrr:cnt.s concerning t.h.e 

?': proposed revision rnust l::E~ :-:eceived by July 24, 

1\_R TI JteGording 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

142 Willis '\venue 

Mineola, NY 11501 

305 Madison Avenue 

New York, N'/ 10165 
_1-~Ll v - ' I ' ' ( -, 

----------------

/ :)UC7, c!eddl inc: 

T ~~ e 1-1 r 4 t t c n ;-; \ a t ,_, m c n L '' ;-; l1 o u ·1 ci b ~~-

hat, 1 Cdfl q:'..r:::· l:: 

;/i_'•U _[_c,l1 OHing t.hP: CO:Ume:.! S 

~: 

1 0 "' t t_ b e :''l' no. r :. me :1 L ' s R C' q i o L ::t 1 (l f t i c cc s , i n c 1 '·' d i n q 

1·.· ,• 'f be s }J e c~ 1 t 1 c d. d d r ~·~ s .s c s <:1 r e is r C' cl -in 

l .) 1 h ,_. ; : c t '- --~ e 

And -:- bc.licve ;-1l 

l !, J.s trc main rr~qion<1l off;ce. 

1 () t h ,.., ·~·-: d r 1 •:: n ;::; b u r: g s ll b 0 1 r i c P. 

l 7 With th2t, 1 '11 coil on Mr n i r. I ,1 -,., d 

ld MH. B T P.T.J\WA l.h.'JT '< VOU .t'-1:.::. Dubci ~~. 

I 'J c-;oocl eveni•:q. 

20 My n am o i ts L~ o b c :· t B i e law 2l • 

? .3 d L L h c N P '~"J· Y o r k S r_ a L e f) c t) ~ r t. r:t E": n 1-. c: f E: n v l r o n rr c: :~ t o l 

::: C L ,c-; f> I V 'l t i 0 I1 1 in Albany. l 

______ _ -----------------

J\RTI Jtecording 

516.741..5342 212.349.9692 888.242.0EP0{3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

ot 

142WillisAvenue 

Mineola. NY 11501 

305 Madison Avf'nue 

New York. NY 10 · 6~ 
~"}uli' ll, LCO i 

r. 

:<: r' v i r o rur:e n t z.t.l C c n s c rv '" t i •J n, her-e t. of or e r e l c:: r c: ::i 

i c:.>~mil.rnents idcr:t.:.ticd in ~l:s November l~;, l9'J2, 

4 c,_,rbuJt mo:!nxide attainment- dcrno:;sl.r<:Jt.i:Jn, Np·,.., 

6 

i r·ev.i::>ion, the Dcparl.rren:. derncnsLI·u::cs 

8 non i n t r:; r f c r e n c e w 1 t t1 :_ h e c .::t r bon m on o x i de ~• :cJ 1. ) o n d ·; 

10 qua I i l.y Clc1tc1 sho\•;j nq u,,,!l_ Uoe reiT.OVcll ot 

l : r (• r ~ r e n c e ~-, '.: o a l ;, tT: ; t v (I r! f C ~~ t r e R L p a r k i :1 q 

14 am b i c n t. l eve 1 s a r c w c l I b '-' ! ow :. he n d L l. on d 1 

1:} actbieLl. <1.::.r quality st.;-utdard ol nine parts pEc:r 

1;:; r:ti.llion, and ar' l.renci.inq cio'w'nward. 

17 F L r· l. her m or c , t h c D cpa r 1. n en l. \. o ~:- k n r:1 

Hi t t"Hl n t-H; f' r e d u c l ..:_ o n s 1 n r h '·: I q 9 / ca. r b o: 1 m on o ;..; i o. •: 

19 aLI..diunent. domonstTa7..in!, (lr 1999 redesiqnotion 

/ ·i d p p :: o v c ci r~ y t ·h t-: U n : l. e d ,'-3 L <1 : c .s r.; n v i r on m c~ n t a l 

22 i'Yotc;cl.i.on Agency on April I rt, ?002. 

.-, ·~ 

"j The New -~~urk :-;Litle Dcpat~t.ment of 

2 !J ::: n v i r o n m c r1 t a · C ~) n !-:: e r v <:< l. i c: :·. w i l l b c a c c e p t. .L n y 

''H i t.t. t~ n r:: o mr.t e r. t . .s o n t h c p r o ~' o s e ci r e v i s i o n s t o t. h c 

A_R'TI _Recording 142 W1ll1:. /\venue 

Mineola, NY 11!>01 

516.7415342 212349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

305 Madis.on .O.ven ueNewYork,NY 10165 
lJ~J:y / 1 r·;(JU"/ 

'it p 1om,_,:. 1. :-1 t. i on t' 1 an r 2 ·.; i ~,; i r) n u :-:. L ~ ~ ,J' t 1 1 y ) 11 , ;..: C C / • 

Jl] DG!:: DU BO r ~;: 

M H . \r.J 1 S vJ 7\ T, T. : 

My n~me is Kyle Wiswall. Tam t:--:c 

:;er:t':·,:t.l. ".lunse1 at the Tri-S:-dt(~ TransporLi-iLi".l'' 

Tho:::: C:ampaiC!'' .LS ,-::n i ndcpcn•jcnt., 

.5 :~):Jprc-.,1;- ·policy ar1~~ aciv•.-::cac·y 'JIC,IJP promotinc.1 

l '; y,,·~k r:1el. rrJpol i t.an reg i cllt. 

lL 

l.:.:i ~, ·1 a:-; ,. or .~ 1 y CJ u a l.l L y 2 t t d i n n· (: :; t_ , p e r F. P T\ 

2 U :-: \.a n d a r d s . 

).I. The rcvisi.CJ[) W01Jl d ::cmove ce rf·!rCnCt~ 

::: 3 e :.:: p a n c;. t:> ci E) ;.; : k i n q c a p a < • i r. v i n t: h e f a ,.. tv o s t s i d e , 

2 ·. '· rcsult.inq in increased .::.1r uc·!uti.on, <::n:d l.rdtt'c 

)') •:·z-o:rlyc•st i )n. 

l_, 

J\R TI Recording 

516.141.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

142 Wtlli~ !\II PrJ ue 

Mineola, NY 11501 

305 Mac'tsun Ave11UP 

New York. NY 10165 
,.; u L y 1 i , :2 .) :_. 1 

C OPinlO n k~·~o'.-.i l r.d<:;e l.hLit incrc..,.--:.lsc:.d 

3 trii-'"· 

!J ~ht-:: <Jdditicn of nearly ?3,0()0 new, 

r\..:. t c} 1 c: n n e i g h ~) u r hood ld o u l d d r d m a 1 1 c a i ·1 y w or s e :t 

t. r i1 .t : i c c cnld i t i :.:- :: s i n a n u. r c a a l r c a d y s a d d 1 e d 

8 ,..,~ i. L h s om c o f: t h <: ,.,; o r s t. c o n g e s t i o n i n t h e c i : _ y , L o 

(-.. sa.y notr'inq of t.he pctential qrowt.h in other 

!0 arco.s of t-he Ce:~tral Business Di~>tr!c:t. t.hat. •:;ouid 

l4 c:<:t.•·,.,me mcus"clrc of e~ n:Lrcal.lng state clean ni r 

·17 c(Jnstru;_:t ion o[ 1:>-~oyniha:-, Stat. ion. 

lH New !'ork C:i ly, a:-; d 1-:nolc, <Jnd 

? C S C 0 ll Y iJ l' 0 [ C C Wj eSt i C:; d 1"' d (:X p j 0 r i :19 l 110 0 V J t j V C 

21 mcr.hod:-; of curbinq the u:1t.ena.ble numbers oc 

2 2 v c: h i c: 1 e :~ L r, a t c u r n: n I 1 y c.: ..L o g t he .s t r c c t_ s . 

23 The Spitzer administration's STP 

2~ revisior:. would backtr·ack and tly directly ln Lt~c 

/ '; .!" a c c o f t. l1 e :-; e e f .f. o r t s . 

516.741.5 342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(33 76) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

142 Willi> Avenue 

Mineola, 1\Y 11501 

305 Madison Avenue 

1'\ew York, r~Y 10165 
'!•, 'y 

·-·--·-·---1 

f: I i\~; a rc:.~;ul 

~: l Cl ~ 

c:i:luo;: :1cl untcalLhy iv'nq 

.. . J d 1' . ccn:>l L 1-.>IlS <:lnCJ 'cc lrtJ..:>;;~ th<-" 

r· ~; i :J c L L :'> .t n r h 1) r e z o n e d d r- P ri . 

(; 1,-J i t. h L h c ::· l t y :) c .:.. s p d \ c t. a k (_0 q r (' D r 

'l ~:;: .. r ldt);.~ .1.r'"! lmprovlr'q c~n·1ironn~entr.tl condi:-.ior1s tcr 

i i 

u1. :J E: r cut t h i ::- p r· o q r r~ s s by ~) L. i rHJ :111tmoclcd 

lU ': P w c: ; ~ - b C i ;, Cl ,-, l N 2 >·i 

ll v ;,; r· k c r s . 

L.! 

' ., 

1 c c; ,, t :-:-1;} n . 

l' t.IJR. c;PTM,!\N: 

I .L 0:1 ::: v l s "" d . 

·; r, t h ,·, l d c t t h Zl t it is b P ' 'J q p-:: c· posed I. o .J n d C' r rr. :.. n •: ,, 

/ (j 1 a~"' s u .i. l. \. h a t. s c c k s L o e r: [' o r c c t he S l. P p r 1 v i ~; i 

·.:.·he p a r k: i n q l i rn i t. a ' .. : ~HI pro vis l o :·1 ·,; d ,.; 

24 t 1 " i q i n ,·~ l J y F l r· o p D ::; c d 

l the ;:; [ ~) f and t.he (c!lP (: i:.\ t 

1\R TI_Jl_ecording 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

This was 

142 W1!l~s Avenue 

Min€'<:11J. NY ll SOl 

305 Madiso" Avenue 

Ne1.v York. NY 10165 
I a:: 

i m ~; I em en 1: t h c C 1 c <1 ::1 i\ :_ r ?\c-r.. o f 1 9 7 D . 

1'>. L r. h a t. · __ :n e , N e V·l Yo r :{ City propos c d 

4 '~cnt rd 1 nu.sines:-; Di:~L::_icr_ 

t\ n d t h c S 1 P :,J o_ s a c c c p t c d by D S c f c~ c' 

;;-~der<d Covernmcct and approved by i·::)!\_ 

8 0 t c o u r s c , a s i L h a p ~H'! n e d , t_ h a r. ""a s 

one of t.)Je lust d.CtS of ~-''c ~ i nd:-;ey 

::_o ddrnini;:;Lration, <1nd he Jcfl i;__ to his successors 

· _.:.1 : __ u i m p I e :n en :_ t h c s c ::c c '' c n-:: (_' '-' n rr: P ii :-: 11 " e ;-; _ 

1:2 

13 I . . . :-1 c m 1 r 1 t ::-: I. r d ··- _ :.) n w CJ ::.; s ,_- r :: 

l:i Th.-:1t :cd ::c :-:1 lnwsu.i.l.. 

J (. 

l 1 d u r l n g t: h c ;3 c v c n L l e s , d : d i :. ~" a s £ i r: a 1 _:__ v s c t t 1 c d 

"ji~ i ! 1 2. c).! 9 by c> ~; C' r L l P rn P n ~ fi 9 ::: e e ffi C n t t h cJ. t t c- ~J k y c ,'J ;- .S 

;.> 0 arc n c r (_.! t o: lay , rr: <1 n y o :t t h c t r a n s p o r t a t_ i on 

~1 q'!"'<)~Jp~, env.L.coninc:1to I qrcups .. 

,...),-. 

. -·· ... ·· r\ n d ~) f ~- r l P- s e \/ c n c c- c n m c a t:; u r c: s , 

L J s i x t e f: :~ o [ \.hem, it 'll as ci q r e E: d , w o u 1 d not. have -:. o 

24 be implemenled. 

OnJ y one~ c( l.hose ~oevencccn ncusurcs 

1\_R TI Jtecording 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

142 Willis Avenue 

Mineola, 1\:Y 1!501 

305 Mad1s.on Avenue 

New York. NY 10165 
/ (' ~ .. : t 1: c :-n e . 

'l t:: c 1 '1 "i Transport,: Lien Cont.: ol Plan. 

T .. t-.ouk Zlr:othc't l.hc:ee yertrs bcfc'-c 

r: t h c r_: i t y :· i n a 1 1 y adopt r: c1 L he: ;con i r1 q o r d i n << n c: (_' 

'/ tha:. lhrs r.lCC~.suro requir·ed. 

9 U1i:; .";Tr provision has bePn ir; place, the C~l.y 

' i '/ ::· r k t:' r s d r e o c~ t: t c T o t t l '"J r 1. r. • 

i 8 c () ;n ;) J i ii n c e ,.., i r. h t l1 c c a r· b o n rr. t : n c x ; d c s t a n d a r d . 

~l .0c·t § 

·:::1 cn·ii.tonnenta l impact. 

1\R TI J:tecording 

516.741.5342 212.349.9691 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax: 800.337.6/69 

142 Wiilis 1\veflUl' 

Mineola, NY 11 ~01 

305 Mad:son .ll.ve:-tue 

Ne'<vYork.NY 10165 
t.• t_j i ~'i , I 1 ?0()7 

11 

l hu:_ ~~~l ncqativc declaration 

on\: pnge, ol a onc--naqc docurnt;nt_. 

4 

~) T ~. r: p r· o p o :o e u S __:_ P p r o v i s i c n c: 1 a i rn s t h a t i f ~ L J. ·-; 

C adoc:_ed, l:hc 20, OOCJ ac:d it. • o:Ji-d parki:'lg spac-es 

il b v c h a n q i n g ~: :r: e z on inc t w c y c a r s ago , \v o u 1 d r 1 u :. 

10 ',vcu 1 d bt" legal. 

;:; o i n c · ~- e r ~" u r: d 3 , L £·: e a_ c t i o n s t h .J t 

the Stutc i_ c• ·-' Luday wo;__:.:.a lc-qa:.i:o:c d!'d 

_s 2:Lcn.,r 20,COO addi .. iondl par.king space::;. 

We 1 1 Wl' ;-; L are :_he conscqt:cnce'S 

16 f::vcn it V.'(; acc(~pt l.hr. ~>:.dLe'~-; 

l f3 ., n v c r: o s .i g n l i l c <1 n l l m n a c -::-. w ' t h r e s p e c L t _ u t_ h e 

19 t . d - l ci'l r L:c:·: monoxl c stanoa rc, vJha l. abo LA i the impo.c:. 

2:) :_Hl u:--·.cHlt-e, particulate maL ~-;r· and carbon dioxide"? 

2' 

7? l L e: p r.1 r k i n q l i rn i L n t. lor. s L r :J. t c q y, t: ;--, c on c ·,; c ' : c; 

23 di:.~cussinq, t.hen lncreusin[j the number cf pnrki.ng 

211 i spaces in Lhe Central Business Di!-;LL.icL '-.rould 

~~ ) ~~~:::-~~ c a s c t r a r r i c b y :n i .. k l n q cl r i '·1 i n g t c t h l: c B D 

J\R TI Recording 142 Willis Avenue 

Mineola,NY 11501 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

305 Madison Avenue 

New York, f"Y 10165 
.l 

l 

•i 

c 

~} 

' 0 

'7 

8 

·~) 

.L () 

' .L -

..Li... 

l -) 

' tJ 

' I - J 

-~ (, 

.l / 

Fi 

l (~ 

:?U 

., 

L. -

/. ., 

. '--

,, 

<: :~ 

).-j 

') l) L. 

I) 

Cl \) r C -, t 1_ L' u C t i \f C" • 

h i q ~"'.: P 1.: ~ rn · ;; s i or ..s . 

pilrl.i.c·l:i'J::c ma\t:<-;r i-:!'lci <·.;;rb:;n dioxi<lc. 

: h u s , r en~'·' ,, n q t h c p c. r .". 1. r: g 

'•ni:.::~- ,,,._,strategy !:err· t·n.-- :3.1.1-' Iftd'J hdv,-: --1 

r.;r pare .:tn env1ro:,::nc':-tldl in;c;:1·~t s·.a~_ernenl. .. 

T. · .. ,-, c'l:.: (: .~ !. i-1 f t . 

The basic i nf•,rrr1 ation requ i r~:·l 

Sdj:}!;-~ly drld ciri\ll!lCJ tf!ro:.lqt:a l.11t: C:nD. 

U :1 ci e .r ., 9 7 9 ' .'." ~; l P , D F, C i:-l n d : i'1 c c: l L y 

A e r (; :" u p p o 1-; e d -:::. o c o n d :.1 (: t. ;-1 p a r k l11 y rn a n a q c m c n ~ 

l l n l 9 9.-1 , t h c 1...: i l. y he g -3 n :.:; u c :, d 

1\R TI Jiecordiug 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll free Fax:800.337.fi769 

142 'Nilli~ AV•2nu0 

Minen!<l, NY 11501 

30') Mad;son Av<>ntJe 

i'Je-w York, NY 1 0' 65 
. -

:. l I 

) t:'crrtple7:.inq it . 

. -:~ L I. he. ~:: a r.t c t i. m c U1 ;, :. t. h'"' C i L y w a ::: c on s i d c r i n q 

,1 ..:.-;t 1Jdy Via!.--~ suspendcci, anci :--tot comple.tt-:d .. 

So Lhc zoninq amendme~t wds 

·n .iH~pact it. wciJlci hdve on a:r ;-;oJluTion. 

An :i ~ :"l c com n i t rn en ~- to do t. he ,:; L u d. y 

-~ 

·' \• .: ,·, s ~~ c t.h d co:nmi :.men-::-. C· t' I. h P. c· .1. :.y and ;_he: St ate 

·1 r1 Th P. c i Ly ~ C• - t.) lhc cn.Ly one ::.har 

·t'; Cl·~t<:'mrtcd tCJ, Ute only party that at.::<~mpled ltl 

i\ n d l ~- h ::_ :·~ }: t h c ::; t 11 d y 1 :-; :; e c e s s ii r y 

ln crdcr o::o d(J ar; PnvironmenL,:l_;_ imn,_:ct 

·1 0 r P v i c:; 't>' or an c r~ v i r or~ rn en t. a 1 i :n p i1 c t s t rJ t c :-n en t . 

NexL, lJLC c.Laim.s thC:l:-: ·they cH.b 

L.l rc'rr:ove :.he parkinq 1imi 1.dLion :-;L.caLeqy ir:orr. the 

') ') 

/. '· (."1- ,.) 

... } 1 ' ~H' c :1 u s c t h e: y t D o >. -:: d 1:: bon mono x i d c r c: d u c t i o n 

;'3 cn•cLi.:.s tor it In the 2.99.:0: Sl.::'. 

.. , / 

L-'t Bu~. <l9a.in, the I ack of a pcttk.ing ~ 

.s _ ud y is -;:- ·--:c~ rE~d_s_'_:·-·l_l_._'l_<_t_t._'_~_o_r_c_c_i'_uct i '~~ 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

142 Willi; Avenue 

Mineola, 1\ Y 1 1501 

305 Madi5on Avenue 

New York. NY 10165 
cJU J \' 

------------------- ---~ 

14 ; 

j 

? 

,_ 

study 'w'dS not. complet.cd 1 th<ey ·,.;ere not able t.o de 

B t h c c rl l c u 1 <1 l i on s 1 r:l n d t h e r e I c) r ·=~ , l. h '' y t o o .< :· u 

1 0 'l'o s:-1y- nOv! : ~1at 'y'c.JU can re:n:>vc the 

11 .'~tr~::· egy, because r:o c:rcc.it. ·.,.;d:"; lc:t1.:.er:, seems 

i :' :-'. <. r:1•: ',·J hii :__ bac; kvJ a. rd s. 

·: '? 1 .) And, in cc•rt · \ :_;~~i_::Jn, i ~- seems to 'llc 

14 rha.t b~~f::re you remove somet.h~·'q oi thi:'3 

20 

:nP '-l :.; '1 ·.· c at. ::;ucJivod [rD'n the 197~ SlP, ;-;ncj t:l>-" 

And 1 n c r d co r t· o d-.:; L hat: 1 you n (' t' d ' _,-. 

Ms. ,:;"CDGJ:.: DU11CTS; 'f>,ank you. 

The \-J !1 o signed t: p I 

~- ' ~? ,._ L

! r) ',)- ,-, < ib::..y Lo i<. c t_ h, ·.-v h o had _________ j 

1\_B.-TI Recording 142Willis Aven.Je 

Mineol•'· NY IIS::Jl 

516.7 415342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0{33 76) 

To!l Free Fax:800.337.6769 

305 Madiso.~ Aven .H~ 

NC'w York. NY 101 (l5 
:;tate .:.rnplcmcn::a~' :y, FL'ln 

~· :.::at? 

MR. HOTH: 1 would .like to add, yes. 

:) Hy ndrne i:o Nat thew N.oth. 

6 wiLh ~ransportation Alternatives, a 

B New tor~ City. 

.S'.1bm~.ttc~d tcst.irnony d:. Lhe 

10 p r r:: v ' c u :-; I y :~ c: he d u 1 c d ~1 car~ n q d a t: c , T w o u ; d ~ .i !<. c 

ll t o i-.1 d J i n v e r y s i rr, p l c w o r d ~'· my r: o n s l. e r n <.ll. i o '' a. t 

L~ has beet1 alluded to hr_:rc. 

[lu t a :n i-l :~ L on i s he d :. h a ~-

15 Ccmmiss1oncr Grdnnis, who has such an exc~11cn~ 

16 C:'·vi rl)flf~tenLdl .recor::i throuqhcu-:-. his pol it.ic~dl 

·1 7 ~: ,_t r E· e .::: , w o u I d ;..,· .;1 :1 t t h i s r e v .i s i. o n L o be :1 l s 

!H l~C:qacy. 

19 TL' s ver.y clear outside of Nc\...r Yo:·J.:: 

20 City, :L's very clear ::o many transportr:~ticr: 

21 ('Tl(Jir;er.rs, experts, a:ivocat:cs, t~hat !.here i:-; rt 

.? ;~ d i. r e c: t 1 ink b c t "": c: on a v a ~ ~ ~ l) i 1 i. t. y of parkin q 

2 3 ;~; 1J p r l v, '·"'he t. h c: r on L he :-; L reel or off s t r c c t , and 

;.:'1 1-·1,.., ind~1cemenl t.c drive. 

l\nd :-;o, 1ike,N·.ise, l'm 

J\R TI R~cording 516.741.5342 2~ 2.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

asloc,;,shcci 

142Willi~ Avenue 

Mineola, NY 11501 

305 Madison Avenue 

New York, NY 10165 
,j !Jl'\/ 

.--------------------···"··--------------------

.L0 1' --~ 

. ::d I :_· l . j YorL 

' 

r i c:::-: 

J d t' tc n . 

4 I i p~; in the fncc ot 

l (\ , ) ) t f; I in'~. 

'I 

8 r qucss by makinq 

Y ~.hi:-; dctcrmt~1ation pl>rcly ')n r-o, •,.;c a.re, nt bc.st, 

hJ irr·l]·,; ::·')llLr·iid~ctin(d "vc:::v irr.[Jc·rtd.nc: po! ic·y; 

~:)O T 'WOU.lcl ;\fc~drti J.V P!J'.:oUTdQC both 

14 

·1:·J ~~ .. :ifc•r,cr-, Jouk at t.ltP l·i::crd' •.lrf·, l..:)ok iit. 

16 

.. ..., . I 

)0 

:22 

., I /. ' 

')1-. 

.::._,) 

j_ l ~ (; i r-. i c s J. j_ :C_ E: 

·:) ~n p l c: t c l y t~- ( -~ \l -= ~:; l r 1 c.: 

Tha~k yoJ very ~u~n for your ti~H. 

T ;··: .] n K yo 1.1 .. 

iJ i d you .," a rc t t e: rrLt '- "" .~ s t a t em e n t. ? 

1\ VOlC:<'.: I L----------------------------------

J\R TI fi_eco:rdiflg 

516.7 41.5342 212.349.9692 888.212.0EP0(33 76) 

Toll Free Fax:BOC.33/.6769 

142 Willis Avenue 

Mlneola,NY ilSO' 

305 Madison Avenue 

New York. NY 10165 
 

July~ 1/, ~cc / 

17 

l IL's about 6:3C ~aw. 

? t h i Tl k '•v (; 1 : l g 0 () f r I. h e ~- e c (; ~- d i:l n (~ 

4 ,.._,,r·(, li-i(.e, ~ldrl_.i<·ula:.· __ y in vl(:·w ot the~ ::imc• c-::: 

5 d d y r a n d t h c p 0 s ~' i b i 1 . t. v () f (j c t t i r: q c i-l l1 q h ' i •. , 

C I_ r '" f £. i , ... 

0~1 the record, ple~se. 

(Recess.; 

,HJUCt:: DUBo.:.::J; On the record, 

10 plPiC.;~P.. 

1 t ' s ~ b o u t. t h r c c m ~ n u t c _<; b C' f o -.: <> 

14 '7'h n n k yo l;. 

lJ {T.ime notcci: 6:30 o'clock p.m.) 

l6 

1 7 

If; 

1 0 -' 

)1 

2j 

24 

J\RTI Recording 

516.7 41.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.DEP0(3376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

1t12Wilfis Avenue 

Mine ala, NY 11501 

305 Madison Avenue 

New York, NY 10165 
i, )')()7 

l C r. I.Z T i. · 

.J S T 7\ 'l L U l:' N 1: \.>1 Y 0 H K 

6 

·I R c p ') r t e r n n d Not <1 r y P u b 1 i c w i t h i n d rt d r o r L h c 

'l' h a l. l~ h c· 'd i t t: .:.. ;! · :-; a t r u c a n cl 

lU d•"'"IJ~',·:tc trans(·ript :_~t th•, : t-':;i irnurt',' tak,;:n ~Hl Lr•'-' 

l.'J 'tJI.,,,.,_.,_"-t':·d in the outcume ni th~!; mctttc::. 

?0 

Ll 

24 I 

L_ 

1. my h ~.l r; d t h i '" d f\C \cj d y o 1: ~ i..A.~\ L~<L t ivJ 

S'T'F:VI:::N !<Lf;:TN 

J\R_'TI Recording 

516.741.5342 212.349.9692 888.242.D£.P0{?.376) 

Toll Free Fax:800.337.6769 

142 W:lis Avenue 

Mincoi;,,NY 11501 

30S Mddison Avenue 

New York. NY l o ](,~ 
7.9 

7.3 

NYMA Carbon Monoxide (CO) Monitored Design Value (DV) 

NAAQS = 9.0 ppm 

7.9 

6.3 6.1 

5.8 

5.0 

4.3 

3.5 3.4 

,...,_, ..__... 3.0 

2.5 2.5 

2.0 2.0 1.9 1.9 1.8 

........ 

94-93 95-94 96-95 97-96 98-97 99-98 00-99 01-00 02-01 03·02 04-03 05-04 06-05 07-06 08-07 09-08 10-09 11-10 

Year 
---------t2006 06-Q5 2007 

2nd Max 

---------

DV 2nd Max 

---· 

ppm ppm ppm 

n7'117o8j _______ 1 ___ 7 1.7 1.4 

(pt"IZerl __ - 1.7 2.2 1.9 

_2 __________ 1.6 1.6 2.0 ---------

€!<!_?/9/08) 

2.5 

SUMMARY 

2nd Max and Design Value 

2007-2011 

07-06 2008 08-07 

----·-

-------

DV 2nd Max DV 

ppm PPm_ ppm 

1.7 1.2 1.4 

1.9 1.6 1.9 

20 1.6 2.0 ----1:'3 1.3 

2.0 2.0 

09-Q8 --2o:w- 1()..09 11-10 

-2nd-Max 

-----------

DV DV 2nd Max DV 

ppm ppm ppm ppm 

X 1.4 X X X X 

- - -1-:-9- 1.9 1.5 1 9 --1.7 1.7 

----- --------

___ , _____ 

1.7 1.7 1.7 1.7 1.4 1.7 

1.8 1.8 1.8 1.7 1.8 

1.9 1.9 1.8 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

_egion 

ites 

Site No. 

7093-!0 

094-06/7094-10 

7095-06 

7096-08 

7096-15 

I 1997 I 

l.O 

0.6 

0.8 

---

---

Annual Averages 1997 through 2007 

Annual Arithmetic M - ' ---, 

1998 I 1999 I 2000 I 2001 I 2002 I 2003 

1.0 l.O 0.9 0.8 0.7 (0.8) 

0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.8 

0.8 0.8 XX XX XX XX 

0.7 0.7 0.6 0.5 XX XX 

-- --- --- -- 0.6 0.6 

Sampling at 7095-06 was terminated on 12/3111999 and at 7096-08 on 12/30/200 I. 

--- ----

-

----

I 2004 

0.7 

0.6 

XX 

XX 

0.5 

I 2005 I 2006 

0.6 0.6 

0.6 0.5 

XX XX XX XX 

0.5 0.4 

One-Hour An•rage Running 8-Hour 1hcrage (Non-Overlappmg) 

I 2007 

0.6 

0.6 

XX XX 

0.4 

Maxllnum not to exect:d 35 PPM nwre th<tfl one.: per calendar !\·fax unum not !n cxce<.:d '! PPM mon:: than once per calendar 

year* year* 

Observations Highest Values, PPM Obsenations Highest Values, PPM 

Total 0/o >35 >9 Days> 

e No. Obs. Avail PPM 1" 2nd 3nl Total PPM I" 2Ad J•d 9PPM 

2.5 2.3 2.3 1.5 1.4 1.4 

93-10 8.573 98 () [03/03, [03103. [11114. 8.466 0 [11!22, (01/15, [ 11/14. 0 

09) 08] 071 02] 24] 08J 

3.1 2,7 2.5 2.0 l.9 !9 

10 K.68J 99 n i l 1'!4. 111 14. 104/21. i\.729 0 [I 1!14. I O!il5. !lW22. 0 

09] Ol<'j 23! 09] 241 03] 

J...f \ i .l.O 2.?< 2.0 1.5 

96-l) :-<..\61 q:; 0 r 11 n. j! I 14. [ ll 13. 8.310 () lll 1 14. [ 02/22. [03110. 0 

1 -·' 07J --':j 05J 09J lJI 

I 

sed on less than 7 available data) 

 Quality Standard 

[Date of Occurrence. Hour] 

-Denotes a contravention ofNYS/Federal AAQS (Note: 9PPM standard is not exceeded unless 8-hour avg > 9.4 PPM) 
egwn 

CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Annual Averages 1997 through 2007 

------- --, 

Site 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 

8100-02 1.7 1.6 L5 lA 13 XX XX XX 

!ilOO-tn 1.7 !.6 !.5 14 l.l Ll l.l l.O 

8100-06 u 1.3 1.3 1.2 1.0 1.0 l.O 0.9 8100-07 (2.4) (2.2) !.7 L5 ( 1.3) XX XX XX 

2005 2006 

XX XX 

09 0.8 

XX XX 

XX XX 

100-07 was tenninated on 10/12/2001. at 8100-02 on 12/31/2001, at 8100-06 on 1 J/01/2004; and at 8100-03 on 01/02/2007. 

mparison Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 2007 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

2007 

XX 

(06) 

x.x XX 

not to exceed 35 PP\1 molT than once per calendar Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per ..:alendar 

year* 

Observations 

Total % 

 No. Obs. Avail 

0-03 . .) 99 

d on less than 75% available data) 

uality Standard 

>35 

PPM 

0 

year* 

Highest Values, PPM Observations Hig_hest Values, PPM 

>9 Days> 

l" 2ad 3'd Total PPM 1'' zod J'd 9PPM 

1.4 1.2 1.0 LO 

[01/0l. [01/0L [OiiOl. 30 0 l () l/0 l. XX XX () 

l5J If>] lOJ 17] 

[Date of Occurrence, Hour) 

-Denotes a contravention ofNYS/Federal AAQS (Note: 9PPM standard is not exceeded unless 8-hour avg > 9.4 PPM) 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

 Sites 

Annual Averages 1998 through 2008 

----------------------

.. 

---

Site No. 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 

7093-10 10 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 (0.8) 0. 7 0.6 06 0.6 (0.5) 

7093-25 --- --- --- --- --- -- -- -- -- --- 0.4 

94-0617094-10 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.8 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.6 0.5 

7096-0!\ 0.7 0.7 0.6 0.5 XX XX XX XX XX XX .XX 

--- -- --- --- Oh 0.6 0.5 05 I 04 0.4 0.4 

l 

hng was terminate{\ at 709o-Oll on l2/30t200 I at 7093-10 on 0710 I ill!>; samplmg commenced at 7093-25 on 07/09;0!:1. 

---·· .. · ....... -.............. ..., .. ..,_ .. --· x--.. ·· _.._ __ .................. __. .............. _.. ... _______ .... ·--· ---------- .. --- - .......... 

One-Hour A vcrage Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to cx.;:eed 35 PPM more than OrJ(;C per calendar Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per calendar 

Observations 

Total o;o 

e No. Obs. Avail 

3-10 4,245 96 

3-25 4,114 98 

4-10 8,700 99 

6--15 8,181 93 

 on less than 75% available data) 

uality Standard 

I 

>35 

PPM 

0 0 

0 

u 

--

vear * vear * 

Highest Values. PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

>9 Days> 

1st 2nd 3rd Total PPM 1st 2nd 3rd 9PPM 

1.6 1.5 1.5 1.2 1.2 1.1 

[02/06, [01/08, (01/08, 4,188 0 (Ol/08, (02/06, (01!06, 0 

10] 19] 201 23] 03] 23] 

1.8 1.7 1.7 1.4 1.3 1.2 

[12/24, [ll/04, [12/24, 4,126 0 . [12/24, [lli04, [12/25, 0 

17] 021 181 I 221 03] OJ] 

2.3 2.1 2.0 1.8 1.6 1.6 

[10/27. [11104, [01/01, 8,740 0 [ll/04, [01/07, [ ll/03, 0 

08] 01] 021 ) 031 21] 24] 

-, ' 2.2 2.1 

.\,,, 1 

I I-:' ...,.Jc !.6 1.5 

LWOlsJ (10110, [ 10/07. fJ . r I ()'OX 11024, ill! 11. 0 I , . '. 

'--_22L . 231 24] : __ gR_ _QI] 

[Date of Occurrence, Hour] 

.,. Denotes a contravention ofNYS/Federal AAQS (Note: 9PPM standard is not exceeded unless 8·hour avg > 9.4 PPM) 

I 

! 

_! 

' 
CARBON MONOXIDE. Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Annual Averages 1999 through 2009 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm 

Site No. 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 I 2008 2009 

7093-10 Ul 0.9 0.8 0.7 (0.8) 0.7 0.6 0.6 0.6 (0.5) XX 

7093-25 --- --- --- --- --- --- --- - --- 0.4 0.6 

4-06/7094- I 0 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.8 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.6 U.5 0.5 

7096-08 I 0.7 0.6 0.5 XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX 

7096-15 I --- --- --- 0.6 ()f, 0.5 0.5 ()_..! 0.4 0..+ 0.5 

I 

··- ----- _____________ 

ling was terminated at 7096-08 on 12/30/2001 at 7093-10 on 07/01/08; sampling commenced at 7093-25 on 07/09/08. 

--

.. 

----

-

. 

-----------

. 

---

----- ---- 4 ----------- ---

---- -- --

.. 

-- --- ------

..... 

---- -

__ , 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than llOCe per calendar Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per calendar 

Observations 

Total "/o 

e No. Obs. Avail 

3-25 8,582 9!) 

4-10 8,689 99 

%-1:; ...,_,.,(, I X.:l 

d on less than 75% available data) 

uality Standard 

>35 

PPM 

0 

0 0 

year* vear * 

Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest \' alues. PPM 

>9 Days> 

1st 2nd 3rd Total PPM 1st 2nd 3rd 9PPM 

28 2.3 2.2 2.0 1.8 1.6 

llli09. [ 11/09, [11/09, 8,581 0 [11/09. [02il L [ 11/09. 0 

091 10] II] 11] 02] Ol j 

3.4 2.8 2.5 1.9 1.9 

[U2'tl2. (02/07. [02 l L 8,738 0 [02/07, [02 1 L i 1 i (Ill I 0 

09) 09) 09] 08] lO] '·c;21 . I 

3.1 2.8 2.b 1.9 I 7 !.6 I 

(02'02. I [02 02. [02.02. 7 _)40 0 [02 02. ! l l '09. I 0 

09] l 08] !()] 1 11 09] 10] 

[Date of Occurrence. Hour] 

+Denotes a contravention ofNYSirederal AAQS (Note: 91'PM standard is not exceeded unless 8-hour avg > 9.4 PPM) 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Site No. 2000 2001 2002 

7093-10 0.9 0.8 0.7 7093-25 --- -- ---

94-06i7094-l 0 07 0.7 0.7 

7096-0R 0.6 0.5 XX 

--·- -· I (i (l 

Annual Averages 2000 through 2010 

Annual Aritluneiic Mean (ppm) 

2003 2004 2005 2006 

(0.8) 0.7 0.6 0.6 

--- -- -- ---

OS 0.6 0.6 0.5 

XX XX XX XX 

I 0.11 (lj 0.5 OA 

-

2007 2008 2009 2010 

0.6 (0.5) XX XX 

--- 0.4 0.6 0.5 

0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 

XX XX XX XX 

U.4 04 0.5 0.4 

pling was terminated at 7096-08 on 12/30/2001 at 7093-10 on 07/0l/08; sampling commenced at 7093-25 on 07/09/08. 

--.-----.----------------- ------ ---- ---·----- ---- ""IL------ -------------- --------- ----- ----

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once per calendar Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per calendar 

Observations 

Total 0/o 

e No. Obs. Avail 

93-25 8,353 95 

94-10 8,753 100 

96-15 !1.492 97 

d on less than 75% available data) 

uality Standard 

>35 

PPM 

0 0 

u 

year* year • 

Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

>9 Days> 

1st 2nd 3rd Total PPM 1st 2nd 3rd 9PPM 

3.5 2.3 1.9 1.8 1.8 1.7 

[01108, [Oli23, [01/21, 8,331 0 (01/ll, fOl/11, [01122, 0 

10] 20] 19] 01] 09] 00] 

2.1 2.0 2.0 1.6 L5 1.2 

[03/18, [03119, [03/25, 8,755 0 [03!19, [02/16, [01/01, 0 

23] 00] 06] 

-

04] 12] 131 

3.4 3.4 3.2 2.7 L7 1.4 

r 11 L\. I I fllll4, r 11 1\ .. "iO-:' 0 fll '14. [0319. [ 11/03 0 

''] I 00] 22J 02J 07] 09] ., I 

[Date of OccmTence, Hour J 

-Denotes a contravention ofNYS/Fedcral AAQS (Note: 9PI'M standard is not exceeded unless 8-hour avg > 9.4 PPM) 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Annual Average!! 2001 through 2011 

-

------------

_, _____ ---· 

Site No. 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 

7093-10 OJ.< 0.7 (0.8) 0.7 0.6 0.6 0.6 (0.5) XX XX XX 

7093-25 --· -- -- --- --- --- --- 0.4 0.6 0.5 0.4 

4-0617094-10 0.7 0.7 0.8 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.4 

7096-0l:\ 0.5 XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX 

7096-15 --- 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.5 0.4 0.3 

plmg was termmated at on 12/3012001 at 7093-10 on 07/01/0!:1; sampling commenced at 7093-25 on 07r09t08 . 

--···--...... ....... ._ ····-·--·· ........... - .... - .. - .......... - •• ... '"""'"' ""C __ ,.... ...... .. - ... --.. _.., ....... __ ,.. ______ ---- --.... 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average I !\ion-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once per calendar Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per calendar 

year* ,year* 

Observations Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

Total % >35 >9 Days> 

e No. Obs. Avail PPM 1st 2nd 3rd Total PPM 1st Zod 3rd 9PPM 

3.1 2.7 2.7 2.0 1.7 1.6 

93-25 8,751 100 0 (11109, [11/04, [ 11/09, 8,749 0 [11/09, [11/27, [02/18, 0 

101 Ill lll 111 071 001 

3.2 3.0 2.9 2.8 1.7 1.6 

94-10 8,750 100 0 (11/27, [11/27, [11/26, 8,746 0 [11/27, [11/09, [ 12/04, 0 

001 011 23] 051 ____!& 071 

2.1 1.9 ],9 1.8 14 I 

96-15 !US! 96 0 [ll/08, ro"'"'O 'll'O" l u [11106, (01/26, [ 11/27 0 l '- . ll -· .. 

- --------- ·······-·-- --· ----- - _ _QJ] - ____;ll___ ___Q§l __ c__j)ll __ __ 001 

d on less than 75% available data) [Date of Occurrence, Hour] 

uality Standard Denotes a contravention of NYS/Federal AAQS (Note: 9PPM standard is not exceeded unless 8-hour avg > 9.4 PPM) 

I 
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 

Deputy Commissioner 

Office of Air & Waste Management, 14t" Floor 

625 Broadway. Albany, New York 12233-1010 

Phone: (518) 402-8549 • FAX: (518) 402-9016 

Website: V..'Ww.dec.state.ny.us 

llonorahk i\ Ian J. Steinberg 

Regional Admmistrator 

l' S. FP:\ RctJlt1ll::: 1 90 Broadwav 

~.,;\\ '{twk, NY 10007-1866 

Dear Administrator Steinberg: 

April 5, 2007 

lhe '\ie\v Y~1rk State Department of Environmental Conservation (Department) is submitting 

a state implementation plan (SIP) revision danfying the commitments Jdcnuticd m th 

:..:on:mbcr 1.';. 1992. "Carbon Monoxide Attainment Demonstration- New Yorl\ 

r-.h:trnpnlJtan Area." In tlus SIP rc\'ision. the Dt:partmcnt demonstrates noninkrfcrcnc~: \l.ith 

the carb\l!l monoxide (CO) Natwnalt\rnlllt.:nl An Quality Standard (1\AAQS) by . .;ulmtlt\ing 

aJJ qualtty dola in lieu of modeling showmg that the removal of a reference to a !itmtcd nff .. 

street parking program imposed and enft.)rc.::d hy the City of New '{ork from the CO SIP \\ill 

not icopanli/c attai11ment because amb1cnt kv(+, arc well below the NAAQS and are 

trending downward. 

rhc CO NA,'\QS requires that not more th:.m one R-hour average per year can exceed 9 p:n1<; 

per milium (greater than or equal to 9.5 ppm IP adjust t(w rounding). Attainment is e\·aluatcd 

''\ cr a tW<.l year period. If an area has a design\ aluc gr-.:ater than 9 ppm. it means tht:n.: \\a;; a 

mnniwring site where the second highest S-huur average \vas greater than 9 ppm in a1 L.:a:;1 

cmc year Thcn.:fore. there \\·ere at least two va!\l('S alwvc the stambrd durmg \•nc v'.:<~I :it tint 

sik and thus the standard was 11t1t met. The actual New York Metropolitan Area (~Y\1'\) 

Design Values for CO have steadily dedmcd from 13.5 ppm in 1988-1981

) tn 2 S ppm in 

2 ons- 2 oo(>. 

The I ()l),:! CO SIP idt"l1tified thl' ti.}llowing mc:1sures that would he relied upon in the 

<llt:tinnh:nt dcnwnstration and commitmt~t1ts that wiH be continued: traflk ~.:nntmf nk':L··tir("" 

(rC\:b) within the \1anhattan Central Busincs:' District (CBD), traffic ent(wccmcnt 

Downtm\ n Brooklyn Master Plan. motor' chide inspe..:titm and maintcnmwc program ;wd 

\•l'f-slrccr parking program Tl11s proposed SIP revision WL)u\d rcmo\·e the nfl-..;lrcct p:11kmv. 

prPg.r:ml as an applkahk commitment since tht: Dcpurtmcnt t\1ok no tonnage rcdu;;_·tiPns in 

the I 'N2 CO attainment dcmonstrution or l 'N(J redesign::~tion request and maintcnarh.:~.: pLm 

Th-: D<.:'p:.utmcnt's 1992 CO attainment demonstration and 1099 rcdcsignation request and 

maintenance plnn were both approved hy the l 'nitcd State<> Environmental Protcttinn Agcncv 

iEPi\) on April 19.2002. 
... 

\~ ;)a(kground. th~ niT-:-;tn:et parking prnbrram was initially considered in the Dcparum.:nt·s 

! ·' "--::w lin· tlw u-.ntr.-·1 ofC! l :md hydrtlcarhons in th.: N..:w \'ork City .lrca. The nH:ao.;urc 

'-' \' <tidudctl umkr Nt:w York City hmd LIS(.: puitt:ics and t..l<:vcklpment controls as a potcn!tal 

'r~·c~th i'ur lmpro\ ing air quality. Subsequently, !he Department submitted SIP rev1siuns m 

i <JS_' .md i9S-l ltknttfying cl)ntrol measures ~..:ommittcd for implementation along wtlh 

ex pee ted cnw.s10n rL~duction benefits. Th;.; \lew York City land usc pol icics and dcvclopmen! 

cnnrrub. uutully advam:..:d for volatile mgamc t:1.H11pound {VOC) abatement. ,., .. ere not 

qu.mtlli•:d. II,!WC\·er. the !91'\2 SIP discussed vehicle restriction mcnsurcs in the Manhattall 

{ 'BIJ. includtng parking controls and zomng changes, that were evaluated by \'cw York City 

Dcp.trrnn:nt ofTransportation (NYCDOT) and the New York City Department of City 

Pl:mmng. (NYCDCP) wtth the conclusion tlwt vehicle access resttictions are compensated for 

hy tl\h;.;r tontrol measures, such as tranic tlow improvements and TCMs included in the SIP. 

SL·cuotl 4.1 of the 1992 CO SIP. "SIP Provision:-; to Remain in Effect", discussed the status of these 

mca..;urcs and commitments that would be relied upon for attaining the CO NAAQS. The 1992 CO 

~lP mcntwncd that the off ... strcct program will be continued stating, 'The City and State of Nt~w 

·vdrk arc committed to the continuation of a progr;un whereby off-street parking facilities m the 

Bowugh of Manhattan below 601

" Street arc prohibited without a special penn it, which rcqutn.!s an 

assessment of the potential air quality impacts of the proposal." Th1s proposed SIP rcvision removes 

the statement of t·ontinuation smcc the off-str~;ct program was not relied upon in the attainment 

dcmt•nstration and clarities that the otf-strcet program was not an existing pre- I 990 CAAA 

c\mlm itment. 

lu pmposing this SIP revision, the Department ts not supporting the discon!inuation of otT-stn:ct 

parking programs but is asscning that ofC-strc~:t parking is regulated by New York City Department 

(lft'Jty Planning Zoning Resolution: Article I: General Provisions Chapter 3- Comprchcnstvc 011· 

Sttn:t Park1ng Regulations in Community Distncts I, 2. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 & 8 in the Borough of 

ivlanhattan and a portion of Community Distncts I and 2 in the Borough of<,)uccns and not the CO 

SIP. ModltleatJOil of l\YCDCP zoning policies affecting off-street parking is not a contravention of 

a SiP commitment. 

Jfyoll have any question pkasc contact Mr. Robert D. Bicluwu, P.E. at (5l8) 402-X396. 

Sincerely, 

Carl 

L:~-- Johnson 

Deputy Commissioner 

Endosure 

cc R. Ruvu,EPA 

D. Shaw 

R. Slivnnski 

\·1. Re;s j' 

R B1duwa· 

c · M ... l ·:mhy 
NYMA Carbon Monoxide (CO) Monitored Design Value (OV) 

NAAQS = 9.0 ppm 

-----------------

------·--··---· ............. ····--·--·-··· 

-· 

-····------···-·· ···-·············--·· ··--·------------· 

-j 

·---------------···············-··· 

· ·-······--· 

. -

--

.. ---·-----1 

·······--·----· 

--·-· ··-·-··--···· ·-·-----····-··· -----· 

···-·······------··-·--·--·······----·---· ·------··--·-------

----------····--··-----··- •... 

89 91-90 92-91 93-92 94-93 95-94 96-95 97-96 98-97 99-98 00-99 01-00 02-01 03-02 04-03 05-04 06-05 

Year 
SUMMARY 

2nd Max and Design Value 

1998-2006 

Summary Page 2 of 3 
_____ _ 

--

SUMMARY 

2nd Max and Design Value 

1998-2006 

Sum111ary Page 3 of 3 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

ontrol Region 

Annual Averages 19% through 2006 

• ---· ··• l • ..... .._, ...... ... j 

Site- No. 19% 1997 JQ9)J 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 

8100-02N 19 1.7 1.6 1.5 14 1.3 XX XX XX XX XX 

8100-03 1.9 1.7 1.6 !.5 1.4 1.l 1.1 Ll 1.0 0.9 0.8 

8100-06 1.6 l.3 l.3 1.3 1.2 1.0 1.0 1.0 0.9 XX XX 

8100-07 2.5 (2.4) (2.2) 1.7 1.5 (1.3) XX XX XX XX XX 

Sampling at 8100-07 was tenmnated on 10/!2;2001, at 8100..02 on 12131/2001, and at8100-06 on I J/01/2004. 

arison Bt>tween NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 2006 

One-Hour A verag<' Running 8-llour A\·crage (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPJI.f more than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per calendar 

calendar year • year • 

Observations Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPJ\1 

Total % >3S >9 Days> 

Obs. Avail PPM I" lad Jrd Total PPM 1" l"d 3"1 9PPM 

5.9 5.4 4.9 2.5 2.5 2.3 

3 8,656 99 0 [12!15. [12/21, [12/18, 8,7111 0 [ 11/28, lJ2!l8, (02il 6, 0 

20] 081 081 l2J 151 10] 

n less th.1n iS% available data) 

ty St3rtdard 

(National Air :>!onitoring Station} [Date ofOccurrem:e, Hour) 

"'" 0..'1lNe5 a contra\ "ntinn uf SYS ·Federal AAQS ('\otc: 9PP\f standmu is not exceeded unless 8-Jwur aYg > 0 4 PP:\1) 
;\IO:"JOXIDE- Continuous ]'.;on-Dispersive lnfrared 

Contml Region 

und) Sites 

Anuual ]<J96 through .::!006 

\nJ'l:.:,·ll :\rithn1ct \1 ran { 1 

! I I r 

! Site 1\\o. 191itl jQtp 19QH 19 20H6 l 1)9 2\JOO 2001 2002 20fiJ 2004 I 1005 I 

i 'G9J-l Cl I ; l l Ill l il c t1 0 7 I " r. 

 ( ,'•(! Uf> 

I [l,{) 0,6 ()'I i): 1\-. \·, U.7 (l :).f\ Of. 0 I u.s I 

7095-06 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 XX XX XX -'IX X.l( XX XX 

7096-08 --- ·-- 0.7 0.7 0.6 0.5 XX XX XX XX XX 7096-15 --- --- ·-- ·-· -· --- 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 04 

Sampling at 7095-06 was terminated on 12/3111999 and at 7096·08 on I 2130/2001. 

....-..... ... , .... -.......................... ,., ....... .., . .....c:.--....... ... ........ ,. ......... _,_ __ ... _ ........ _._.. . ..._ .. ....... _ ... __ .................... -·"·,..£. ............. -...-..... vvv 

One-Hour .-\verage Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlappmg) 

Max unum lW' tc· 35 nwrc than .wee re; Maximum not tr c"<ceed 9 PP\·1 more than once per calendar 

cak-ndar year • year • 

Obsenations Highest Values, PPM ObserYations Higbest Va!ues, PPl\t 

Total o,,. >35 >9 Days> 

e Obs, A'·ail PPM 1" 2"" 3"' Total PPM 1" rd 9PPl\J 

2.3 2 . .3 2.0 1.9 1.7 L6 

93·10 8.451 97 () [11128, [11/27, [ll/::17. 8,.:?95 0 [ 11/27, [ 11 [ll/2/'l. 0 

10] llj 10] !J] ll] 02] 

2.6 22 2.2 1.9 l.7 1.6 

4-06 8,586 98 0 { 11128, [02/16. [11/27, 8,632 0 [02!16. [I 1/28, [01;29. 0 

09] 08] 08] 12] 10] 10] 

2.5 2.3 2.3 us j{, 1.5 

8.148 93 0 [ i l<:!R. [ ll/28. [I J/28. 8.10 i i) [ 1 1/28. [11/05, 0 

96-l" • OS l 07] O'lj 1">1 -- - 

_____ L -· -- -

l\.i )t:..,:, tll;u; 

Stunj,_lanj 

( \.atHlaJl ,\H \ ,,f Hourj 

-

.. -t Ci.'rtT.l'.-<::lV'.n 0f\:YS Fe .. h;ra: ;\/\OS ('Sot-c; qpp\f is r.ol X·h·Y..:r ::'.'j:: > o PP\1i 
Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

 Control Region 

Annual Averages 1995 through 2005 

I Arithmetic M ........ I , .... j 

Site No. 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 

8J00-02N 2.1 1.9 1.7 1.6 1.5 1.4 1.3 XX XX XX XX 

8!00-03 1.9 1.9 J.1 1.6 !.5 1.4 Ll l.l 1.1 l 0 0.9 

8100-06 1.? !.6 1.3 1.3 1.3 l.2 LO I 0 l.O 0.9 XX 

8!00-07 2.7 2.5 (2.4) (2.2) l.1 1.5 (I 3} XX XX XX )(.\ 

Sampling at 8 I 00-07 was terminated on 10/121200 I, at 81 00·02 on 12/31!200 I. and at R I 00-06 on 11 !0 l/2004. 

mparison Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards far Calendar Year 2005 

One-Hour Average Running S·J:lour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not lo exceed 35 PPM more than once pt::r calendar Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per cal_cndJr 

year • year • 

Observations Hi&hest Values, PP;\1 Observations Highest Values, PPM 

Total % >35 >9 Days> 

e No. Obs. A\·ail PPM I" 2"d 'nt Total PPM I" 2" 3'd 9PPM 

5.0 4.! 3.5 2.4 2.2 2.2 

0-03 8,583 98 0 [11119, [04/08, [02107, 8,668 0 [Oiil3, [02/02, [0410!, 0 

221 241 241 16] 031 141 ! 

d on li'.!!i.!i. than 75')-.J .;\\.itilat:-k tbtat 

uality Standard 

(Natinna!Air M<mitoring Station) [Date Hc>ur] 

·• n .:ontr,1\'cn!i(JO <1f NYS'l'c<kral AAQS (Note: 9l'PM "·'ndard i> not c«ccdcd 8-hour > 9 4 P!'\f) 
I\'101\'0XIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive 

y Control R·.::gion 

wundl Sites' 

Sitr :\o. 1995 

7093-10 l l 

7094-06 0"' ·' 

7095-06 0.8 

7096-08 ---

7096-!5 ---

Annual .\ 199" lhrough 200" 

· l...rithmetic \1 

19% 19')7 !998 1999 2000 

! ! J (I 1.(1 LO 09 

0.6 06 07 l) 7 0.7 

Oil 0.8 0.8 0.8 XX 

--- --- 0.7 0.7 0.6 

--- --- --- --· ---

lOOl 

o .. 

0.7 

Xl< 

0.5 

---

Samplmg at as tenninated on l2t31 '1999 and at 7096-08 on 12!30/::!001. 

I 20ll2 

0. 7 

07 

XX 

XX 

0.6 

., ---· • - " '·' ............ • -·· __ x.--·--. ........... r-··-. - -------· -- --- --·------ --'"' -...- ... -

2003 2004 

i0.8! {).'"' 

O.x 0.6 

XX XX 

XX XX 

0.6 0.5 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Avenge (Non-Overlapping) 

2005 

0.6 

(ill 

XX 

XX 

0) 

.\Lt\ll11Ui11 r::o! to 35 Pll\1 n;nrc once.: fh.:·r c1!cndar '.hxHmun nO! to cxccJJd 9 PP.\1 more than once per calc,ldar 

• year • 

Observations Highrst \'alm•s, PPM Observations Highest Value!>, PPM 

Total >35 >9 Dll)P I 

ite ;"'n. Obs. Anill I" 2"d .3'd Tu111l PP'V[ l" r• J'd 9PPM 

2.3 2.2 2.1 16 l.5 15 

0':l3-IO ii,587 0 [05.! J, [0.:\.07, [02/ll!\. X,4S5 0 [! ).06, [0201:1. ;o::.IJ2. (l 

24] 09] !OJ 05} 13) 02] 

3.9 3.5 3.3 2.5 2.2 !.7 

094-06 8.504 en 0 [02/08. [10!17. 8.529 0 [02/0R, [02/02, [12/25, 0 

09] 07] 10] !2] 02] 04] 

I 

) l 24 2.1 !.6 1 ,. I ,\1 

0CJ6-15 I •))'\ 0 '02.'01, [02!0!. [01:29, :::,:!Q.J u :()2;02. [Oi,2'1. 0 

l .;j ) '' !OJ 02j 121 09i ·'-"I 

,,,, <i' .l;J.,h.t l!.lUi K=f'.;A \.:r \ ... S:,!ti,Vll (lf(h . HonrJ 

1r tj'J3lHy Stand:.m.: - Dt:"t·'-'It·•. J .._-, "'r:.:YS· 1'- '\:\r:r-: \ !'\otr st;!n{knJ. i: exceeded unless. il\'g >· 9 . ...:. 

' 
CARBON 1\'IONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

y Control Region 

Annual 1990 through 2000 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

Site 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1991 1998 1999 2000 

2950-10 ! 1 l.(} 0.9 0.8 O.S 08 08 0.7 0.6 0.7 (0.7) 

Sampling at 2950-10 was terminated on 5/31/2000. 

ased on leu than 

rQuality StJnd:nd 

(SotiC>n.>l Air Statmn.l I Date flou( 

+ Drnnt_, o ccl\•u,enlh>n AAQS (Note· 91'1'M srandurd ts liO! exceeded unless S·hour avg > 9.4 PPM! 
CARBO:\ i\10NOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispcrsi"'e Infrared 

Control Regit<n 

Annual :\' l9!J4 through ZOO-l 

Aru;ual Arirhn;etk \1e.ln (n:1r1: J 

Site :\n. 1994 1995 1996 ]1.)91 1998 1999 2000 I 2001 1002 201l3 2004 

8l :: 3 2 I l 9 l ; 1.6 5 : l.J :u. :n XX 

i\ l 00-03 2.2 19 \.9 l.., 16 l 5 : 4 '1 ' ' 1' !,, l.i l 0 '-' 

&100-06 1.9 L7 1.6 13 1..3 u 1.2 1.0 10 LO 0.9 

8100-07 24 2.7 2.5 (24) (2.2) l 7 1.5 (1.3) XX XX XX 

Sampling at 8100-07 was terminated on l0il2!2001, at 8100-02 on 1:2131/2001, and at 8100-06 on 1 JiOI/2004. 

mparison Bctwt>cn l"YS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 2004 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour A\·crage (Non-Overlapping\ 

).·laxl!nu:n !Wt 10 c;;,ceed 35 PP\! more than D!l(c per ..:alend;1r Ma:omum not '"' exceed 'J i'P\1 rnme than c-nce per 

year • year • I ' 

Obsenatiom Highest Values, PP:\1 Obsen·atinns Highest \' alues, PPlVt I 

Total >.35 >9 

t No. Obs. Avail PPM 1" J'd Total PPM l" 2"d 3'' 9PPM 

):) 3.6 3.6 2.9 - 2.5 2.5 

00-0J 8,672 99 0 [02/03, [10/08, [12122. 8,748 0 [04/26, [02/03, (02/07, 0 

08] 081 08] 17] 13] 01] 

37 3.6 3.5 2.9 2.4 22 

00·06 7t235 9'l 0 [05/12, [05/!2, [05112. 7,279 0 [05/12, [04!26. [02/07, 0 

08] 09] 07! 121 18] 02) I 

d ,ln th.1.n 75''·t- l\a:l.thh: d;Wlj N ·:J\'/1,MS .. \tr ::.uPic:;, (Dale Ht)U:j 

.l ..,t ... ·1"S h:<.:c:-.t' t"St,!t". 911P\ri.'>Ltnd.tni IS <hi! c'\Cn:de ... ! t;lllt:.'i PPM) 

I 
CARBON l\fONOXIDE Infrared 

 Control Region 

ound) Sites 

Sile No. ]994 

7093- !0 u 

7094-06 ·-· 

7095-06 0.9 

7096-08 ---

7096-15 ---

Annual A Vl'ntgl's 1994 through 2004 

Annual Arithmetic M 

1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 

l.3 l l LO !.0 LO 

0.7 06 0.6 0.7 0.7 

0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 

--- ·-- ··- 0.7 0.7 --- --- --- --- ---

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 

0.9 0.8 0.7 (0.8) 0.7 

0.7 0.7 0.7 0.8 0.6 

XX XX XX X :I: XX 

0.6 0.5 XX XX XX 

--- --- 0.6 0.6 0.5 

Sampling at 7095-06 was temmmted on t 2i3l 11999 and !lt 7096-0R on 12!30/200 l. 

....... ---..--- .. --- ..... ....... ...... --..... _ ..... _ .-......... _ .. ___ ..... -- .. ,. __ , ___ •¥· - _ ..... ___ • ---. 

Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non.Overlappmg) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM mmc than once per calendar Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more tlmn once per calend:tr 

year • 

Obsl'rvatiuns 

Total ''lo 

e Obs. Avail 

93-IV 6,836 78 

94-06 8.664 99 

R.39 7 96 

on lcs.s tha.si 75'!.-l'. a-.·ailahlc 

Quahty S!and\-4rr.1 

>35 

PPM 

0 

0 

0 

year • 

HighcM \'alues, PP;<.t Observations Hif!hest Values, 

>9 Days> 

1" 2" J'd Total PPM t" 2"d 3'" 9PPM 

2.9 2.6 2.6 2.1 2.0 1.9 

[05/1 2. [05/12, [05/l".!. 6,734 0 [05,]2, [04/26, [10'0H, 0 

09] 08] IOJ 12] 18] 12] 

3.3 2.8 2.4 2.0 2.0 1.8 

[03/22, [12/22, !12122. 8,709 0 {!0/08, [12/22, [05/13, 0 

lO] 09) !OJ 091 12] 12] 

3.) 3.1 3.0 2.4 19 !.8 

[IJ.!l. r 1.2·2:2. 8.3:! i 0 [ 12;22, [ l J/17, [05/12, 0 

24] 09] !OJ !OJ 02] 13] 

!N.at!O:Iil"l A1r \1oni!urmg StJti<"n} lOtHe H\ll;r) 

• Denotes a AAQS (!'lore: 91'!':-.1 s!.:mdard is nut e)lcecdtd un<c•s a'g > '14 
CARBO.\' l\10NOXIDE. Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

y Contr,,; R<.:pon 

Annual Average> 1990 through 2000 

Anmwl Arithmetic l\ k<m q>pm) 

Site No. 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 

2950-10 l 1 LO 0.9 0.8 0.8 08 OR 0.7 0.6 0.7 {0 7) 

Sampling at 2950-l 0 was tcmmlatcd on 5/31/2000. 

t'tas.cd on .. 

-\H (.}u.Oll:ty 

... _..,_1, ·\ \t:, iNut!lina! ,\il J\,hmironng Stat:vn) : pf On·t:rn:nce. 

...... J ..::ontr.1·vc-rlth.Hl ofSYS.Tcduaj A.-\Q.S oppz-,.1 i;,. ll(lt ... G ·l 
CARBON !\10NOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Cont:t•l R-:gion 

Annual Averages 1990 through 2000 

Annui.ll Arnhmetic (ppm} 

 Silt> :\n. 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 I 2000 

 2950-10 l 1 1 0 09 08 O.R ()8 O.R 0.7 0.6 0.7 I (0,7) I 

Sampling at 2950-10 was tcnninated on 5/31/2000. 

Pn than <J.Va:.iablc <iJta) 

'" Qua1:1)· Standard 

Air Monitoring Station) [Date ll<>ur] 

1 Denotes a ror:tro' of !'JYS 'Federai Ai\QS {Note: \'IPP\1 stand•nl is not exccedod unle;.s 8-h,Klr avg :> 9..1 PP:'.I) 
Continuous Infrared 

Control Rc:g;on 

·\nnual A n>ntgn 199."1 tin ough 2!HJJ 

:\nrhr:v:tit.< •, ppn1) 

! . T 1 ,;;s l zouo ]_ 200 2003 

i Rllli.J-fl"" +-, "\f1 f I I I' 11.1 I I 1- 1 1 i - 1 i -.-- 1 . _,._, -<-- - - ! - ·- •• l I ; I ' I ·' ; :; : ! "3 '..\ f "·' 

,, ' ,.., 1 1 ! . 1 - I I I 

8!0G-0> I-- -·- !9 l LY )7 \.6 1' 14 11 Ill l 11 

l\1100-06 1.9 l l.'l 1.7 111 13 L3 1.3 1.2 UJ 10 I l.O 

8100-07 t2.9) I 24 1.7 2.5 (2.4} (2.2} 1.7 1.5 (IJ) '0: T "' 

Samplmg at 8100-07 term mated on 10'1212001 and at 8100·02 on !:;nJ<!OOl. 

Comparison Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 2003 

Ont>-Bour :\verage II Running 8-llour A\cragc \:--:cn-Ovcrlappmg) 

\.Ll"XinnHr: n\.,t 10 .\5 PP\I f;'\Oft!' than once rt:r li \1axinHnn noi h) 9 PP\1 mc;re than pe-r Ciilendar I c'Jiendur )'Clf. year • 

Obscrvations Highest Values, PP:\1 Obsuntions Highest Values. pp,\IJ 

I Total I >35 >9 Days> 

e No. Obs. Avail PPM I" 2"" Total PPM l'' 2"" v• 9PPM 

)(i-03 8,442 96 0 4.1 ' " J ... 3.4 8,479 0 3.0 2.ti 25 0 

[04102. [051()0, [0>/05, fll/05, i llil7, [04102. 

081 13] OSJ 22] 14) i 1 J 

0-06 8,61'" 98 0 4.0 3.7 3.6 I 0 3.3 3.0 2.8 0 

(ll/22, [03/05. [03"05, [08/16. [03/05, (ll/23, 

. -

20] 14] 131 I 02] !6' 031 

ased or; !c:::.s. dmn 7.5::-t. C::·:!' 

 Oci;;_;J!'"\" 

(\:<ttlonal Alf Stah(m) [Dated 0<:-:urrctKC. H,,ur' 

. .I ·JTPM qa.rn3.ud :s ·, '!.; PP.:V1; 

l 
CARBON J\IIONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Control Region 

u11d) Sites 

Annual Averages 1993 througll 2003 

1 Arithmetic M ' 

Slte 1993 1994 1995 !996 1997 I 1998 1999 2600 2001 2002 lOOJ I 

7093-10 12 lJ J.J l.l JO !.0 1.0 0.9 0.8 07 (0 H) 

7094..()6 -- --- 0.7 0.6 0.6 0.7 0.7 07 0.7 0.7 0.8 

7095-06 0.8 0.9 08 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 XX XX XX XX 

7096-{)8 -- --- --- - -- 07 0.7 0.6 0.5 XX XX 70%-15 -- -- -- - -- -- - --- -- 0.6 0.6 

Sampling at 7095-06 was tenninated on 12!3!' 1999 and ar 7096-08 on l2i30l200 l. 

Be NYS Ambient Alr Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards ror Calendar Ynr 2003 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PP!\·imore than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per ca!er.d3r 

calendar year • year • 

Observations llighest Values, PP:\1 ObseMtatlons Highest Values, PPM 

Total % I >35 >9 Days> 

teNo. Obs. Avail PPM I" 2"" 3'd Total PPM 1'' 3'd 9PP'1 

U93-JO 4.712 0 4.6 4.0 3.7 4,625 0 2.6 2.5 25 0 

[02!05, 101129, [02105, [02!05. [01/29. {03/05. 

16) 16] 21] 2!J 21] !6] 

94-06 8,661! 99 0 4.1 3.4 3.2 8.72! 0 2.2 2.2 2.1 0 

[Ol/30, [03fl6, [llll2, [031{)5. [l ll23. [03116, 

15) 02] 191 15] 03] 06] 

90-!5 7.689 &8 0 J.i 3.2 HJ 7.629 0 2.6 25 2.3 i 0 

poio7, p1 ·::3. [os12o. r, 1m. ro3!28. 1 

08] 01 J 07} 07) 04] 13) 1 

hnM•c on than .JV:<•l.lh'c d:Hal :\ ·'it\MS 1\lr ).lont!onng Stalion) [DMc of Occurrence, llcHlt] 

\,, QuaLr;.· Stnmian! ' 11 ."ontranntion ofNYS-'l'ederal A:\QS (Note: 9PP!If standard i> not exceeded unless 8-hour a\·g > 9,4 PP!\1) 
lV10l"OXIDE- Continuous :\on-Dispersive lnfi·ared 

Control R;:f:JOil 

Annual Averages 1990 through 2000 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

Site No. 1990 1991 I 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 1ooo I 

295t)-}{1 l.l !.0 I 0.9 0.8 OJ\ 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.6 07 ru 

Sampling ,1! (; \Va,; on 513 I, 2000. 

ba:.ied un JVilHahle dfttJ.i 

\(: 

\!S (Naticlnli !\H St;\!ion) fr.bt.; ot lhhH1 

t Demnr:s a c,1nH;nTntWJI df AAQS stJ.nd:1.td is t!(•t exc"l"cd..:J ' .. mk.-:.. : ... ... q 4 P?\1) 
CARBON ]\;JON OXIDE. Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Control Region 

:'llo. 1992 

8J00-02i'> 3.] 

8!00..{)3 2.1 8!00..()6 2.1 

s !()(}-{)7 -

Annual Averages 1992 through 2002 

Annual i\rithmetic Mean ( 

I 1993 1994 19'15 1 1996 1997 

2.6 23 2.1 ]9 1.7 

2.2 :!,2 !.9 ].9 1.7 

l.9 l.9 . .., 1.6 l.3 

(2.9) 2A 2.7 2.5 (2.4) 

Sampling at 8100-07 was terminated on 10.'12/2001 and at 810CJ-02 on 1213112001. 

1998 1999 2000 2001 1002 

!.6 1.5 1.4 !.3 JO( 

1.6 J.5 J 4 Ll I l 

lJ 13 l2 1.0 1.0 

(2.2) I 7 l.5 (l.J} )(,'( 

Comparison Between Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air QuaUt)• Standards for Calendar Year 2002 

e No. 

00-03 

One-Hour Average 

not to e:w.ceed 35 PPM more than once per 

calendar year • 

Observations Highest Values, PPM 

l Total •;G >35 

j Obs. Avail PPM P' 2"" 3'd 

I !1.612 9S 0 6.ll 4.9 4.9 

[09/0J. [03/07, [03!07. 

12] 22] 24) 

Running 8-Hour A wr11ge (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to .:xcccd 9 PPM more than once per calendar 

year • 

Jl Obsen·ations I Highest Values, PPM 

>9 l Davs> 

Total PPM I" l"" J•d 9PPM 

8.627 0 3.9 3.4 .:u I 0 

(03/08, [0Jil5, [02/01, 

02] 24} 16] 

O-Ofi I 8,639 99 0 5.0 45 4 3 I 8,691 0 . 3.4 I 3.0. 2.9 I 0 

I [09tJO, [03;07, [031 !5, I [03'0R, I [01/16, [04/10, 

I !6] 241 231 01] I- 021 191 I _jJ 

on than avai1ab!f! J.Ha) 

 Quality Standard 

(:O.:.lt>@a! Air Monitoring Station) !Date ofO.:currence.l!,,urj 

• '' contra,·cnnon ,,rNYSffederal AAQS (Note: 9PPM standard is nor ""'ee<fcd S-twur avg > 9,4 PP:C.1l 
:\10NOXIDE -Continu0u" Kon-DispcrsiYc Infrared 

Control Region 

Annual 2!l02 

.... !,l,ih•l .'-l;.dD 

I I ' -1 

r Sitt :"<> .i_J992 ___ j_)'i9:1 I i()i)..; l9'J:" l91Jo I 19•}-: __ - 1998 

·j- t ' _j -

, l -·i , i ! 1 l ,_.. I . -

t 

"tm-lu l.O ! (1 I 0 ! (I \1 l i)F; J l)- i 

7094-06 Oo OJ\ Ui (li Q"; (}" I \.'' 

7095-06 09 OR 0.8 0.8 0.8 );."1( \,'\ I XX 

0.7 0.6 I 05 1 XX --- I 06 

7096-08 0.7 7096-15 

Sampling ut 7095-06 was terminated on I 2/31.1!999 and at 7096-08 12!301200! 

n Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 2002 

! One--Hour Awrage II Running 8-Hour A nugc l \cn-Overlapptng) 

; :\-'1ax.HnU!11 fl\_'t ;n C\Z.:cl:d nh)rc (1r:r" .. !"Jt:f !!J \taxbnnn1 no'. to 0 rnore rhan (1nrc pe:-- I I . 

1 ..::ak"nd.:u \ear • -' VCLtr 11 I Obsen Highest PI'M Hlghe!t PI'M 

Total I .. 

- I I >35 I /(t 

ite I Obs. i A\ail PP'-1 + 

093-:il i l\.203 9.: I 0 I 

I" 2"" 

3.3 I {03!07, 

22] 23] 

0'N-06 8,.:'9.5 98 0 43 3.7 

[! 1.'25, 10410'-J, 

09) 13] l 

' ' .- ' t . , 

._,f, ,_, 8,000 ), I; "'0 3 

l ' --. ! ·- ··-' 

3'" 

(03-'15, 

23] 

36 

[I 1121, 

13] 

II ·-" I , '" 

! Total i PPM 

8.057 0 

8.637 I) 

1" 

2.4 

OJ] 

29 

[l lt21. 

06} 

T 

I 

Days> 

2"" 3'" 91'1':\I 

z:: L8 0 

roJ-J6, [05/03, 

04] OlJ 

2.1 2.1 f) 

[03/02, p l/25. 

07] 12} 

0 

1..:---;.:-; !h:-!'1 J J.t.n 

·\i' (h;,l:·ry Su:-1J::rd. 

:\n !\1orHtonng iDatt: H> 

1 J. (Ontravcntion Gf NYS·-Fed::-rJl 1 Sotc 9PP;-.,t r..ot c'':ecdcd fl\·g .• 9 4- Pl':'>.11 
CARBON IVIONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Control Region 

Annual AYeragcs 1990 through 2000 

- n 

Site No. 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 

2950-10 l.l 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.7 (0.7) 

Sampling at 2950-10 was tenninatcd on 5131/2000. 

arison lktween NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 2000 

One-Hour Average I Running 8·Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

not !0 c.-.;cccJ 35 PPM more than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per calendar year* 

calendar year • 

' Observations Highest VaJues, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

Total >35 >9 I Days> j 

e No. Obs. Avail PPM pt rd 3rd Total PP!\1 lit 2"d 3rd 9PP;\I i i 

50-10 3.494 96 0 3.7 3.6 3.6 3,57 0 3.0 2.5 2.2 

--0 

(01!06. [01107, [02110, 6 [01/07, [01/02, [02/23. 

24] 01] 08] 06] 10] 

·--

L............_ ___________ ------------·-- L_ _____ -- . - . 

on than i5""J{i av.i.il.thlc dauJ 

H (luaitty Standard 

"'"NAMS (\:altona! Air \lomtoring Statitm) [Date of(kcur:en.:e. l!owi 

DcnlH<'S" nntra\ention AAQS (Note: Handa!'J b nt>! e.<e·ccded lmlr" X·honr a>f eo Y 41'PMi 
Comw: Annual AH"rages 1991 through 2001 

· Anmnl .-\rithm(::tic Mean ( nm) 

( Site ;\o. I 1991 j 1992 l 

l\IONOXIDE- Contumous 1\on-Di::;persivc Infrared 

l ] 

1997 /_t998 i _!999 2000 I 2UIIl 

li'r\l' !'< I I 1] I''' ]., l JL. l" 

, l<..J·U_,, 1 ... i _._ __t• -·, 1 .. ' .t) .• • _ 

[ ' ' I ! !I 

Rl00-03 1 2cl 1 2 l I 2.2 1 1.9 l.9 !-:' 16 j . 

8100-06 I 2.3 \ 2.! 1.9 1 !.9 T L7 1.6 1.3 1.3 11 

! 5 i4 

l.O 

1.4 I l 1 

' L.) l 1 

8100-07 (2.9) l 2.4 I 2.7 I 2.5 I (2.4) I (2.2) 1.7 1.5 ( 1.3) 

--- ---· ----- ------------- ·-· -...---- --------------- ___ -...----- --------- ___________ Vear2001 

I One-Hour Average 8-Hour Anrage (Non-Overlapping) 

l Maxm1Um nut to exceed 35 PPM more than once per !Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per calendar year • alendar year • 

Observations I Highest Values. PP.\1 Observations Highest Values, PP:\1 

i I I I J i I 

i Total 01 '' ' I >9 I 1 !lap> i ' I . I 

e 'Jo. I Obs. 1 Avall PPM 1 1'1 • 2".1 I J'd Total PP:'II l" l"d Jrd j 

0-02\ ' 1<.659 99 0 I' ·Ul 4.4 

1 

4.4 8,734 0 .U 3.0 3.0 I 0 

l<l..,0° ·r·..,·[iO t'O'Cl'l (0'_.1.,. 1 !',.!'" 1 7 , .t.. • ...... ,;..J • ....,.. t .::..- "-'· j 

20] !BJ 19] 23] 21] "20} 

0-03 8.468 97 0 8.5 5 7 4.8 R,522 0 4.1 3.5 3.5 0 

[osn2. [osr21, ro11os. 1 tottos, lll/23, [ll/29, 

02J 18] 09J i 15) 07J 23 J 

0-06 8,661 99 0 7.7 6.5 .

1 

5.7 8,728 0 3.3 3.2 3.1 0 

[03!19, [CJ2110, [!2105, [12/05, [02/09, [01131, 

I I I 09] 07J I 19] 23] I 23] 12] 

Ofl-0 7 .. ,f;.·, ..•.. 601 "' ,, I 4" I 44 i 42 [!, .... , () 3.2 3.0 '2 .. 9. I .0 

I I [04 I [ilJ li, ; fOl 1'7 , il [0209. [OJ !3. I ro:: ;:c: l 

L- --- i 08] i IX] l 08J II 23] 22] i 

h1st'd i_\1} .... ih:H: "";'-::.<1,, avai:j1h:e dai<l) Au· S!atlo!i: o-f ( Hcu.:r) 

"·"Qua:''' Stand:ud + Dcnores a con!raven!ion AAV=' (."ictc· 'if'i'\1 standnrd '' IJ()f 1miess rc-hour ""$ > Y ·1 !'l'MJ 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

ontrol Region Annual Averages 1991 through 2001 

... lJU ... 4 / UIW..Ultl'WU ..... 

Site No. 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 200 I I 

7093-10 !.4 14 1.2 1.3 1.3 l.l l.O l.O 1.0 0.9 0.8 

7094-06 --- ... . .. ... 0.7 0.6 06 0.7 0 7 0.7 0.7 

7095-06 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 XX XX 

7096-08 ··- ... ·-· --· ... ... --· 0.7 0.7 0.6 0.5 

Sampling at 7095-06 \vas tenninated on 12/31/1999 and at 7096-08 on 12/30/2001. 

--- .. ---.. . - -- . ------ ·---· ""'---· ., --·- - --··-........... "'--- ",....,._..... ----..... --- -- --- --------· .. ----· - ... -...-

One-Hour Avenge Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per 

per calendar year • calendar year • 

Observations Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, 

Total % >35 >9 I Dayp i 

e No. Obs. Avail PPM 1'' 2"d Jnl Total PPM 1" 2nd 3"' 9PPM 

93-10 8,443 96 0 4.0 3.7 2.9 8.392 0 2.3 2.3 2.2 0 

[12/05, [12!05, [03113, l03!l3. ( 12J05, (04iO'J, 

20] !9) 19] 20] 23] 15] 

94-06 8,268 94 0 5.4 4.9 4.2 8,315 0 3.7 2.7 2.6 0 

[01/31. [l 1'22, [ll/22, [ll/23, [01/3 I, [10/21. 

09] 22] 23] 03] l3J 06} 

96-08 7,899 90 0 3.6 3.1 3.0 7.834 0 2.4 2.0 2.0 0 

[01/23, [12/04, [0!/Jl, {Ol/24, [ 10f02. (10/19. 

22) ()91 09] 02] 02] 09) 

ha<ed llfl less than 75% avatlabk dala) Alr Mon;tonng Station\ roate ('( H<•m] 

1t ()\Ja!if\• Srandani + n conrrnventicm ofN'YSifederal AAQS (Note: 9Pl'M $tandard is not exceeded unles• 8-hour avg ,> 9.4 rr:-..11 
CARBON Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

Contro' 

i\.nnual Averagt's 1990 through 2000 

-·. ----- . -- -. hmctic M ean! Pml 

I 

Site No. 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 i 

2950-10 I.l 1.0 0.9 0.& 0.8 0.8 O.R 0.7 0.6 0.7 (0.7) I 

Samphng at 2950-l 0 was ternHnated on 5.'3 1/2000. 

rison Bctwt>en NYS Ambient Air Qualit) and Ambient Air Qualit)· Standards for Cakndar Year 2000 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

per Lot ta e;..\-·ced per ct1ler.dar 

vear * • I 

Highest Values, PP!v1 H1ghcst Values, PP\1 

Total >9 

ite So. Obs. A rail PPl\I I" 2"d 3'd Total Pf>M 1" 2"4 3'4 91'1';\1 

950-10 3,494 96 0 3.7 3.6 3.6 3,576 0 3.0 2.5 2.2 0 

[Ol/06, [01/07, [02/10, [Ol/07, [0 1/02, [02/23, 

__________ 24] OJ} 08] 071_ , - __ _lOL 

ba;-.cd nn than datal 

\:· t)n.1.fJ; 

, .. (:-.;atH"rm! A1r St:1ii;Jl1) [Dnte p( • .'e-, l 

+ <:OtHH1\ enrien cf>-: .. {S. FcVCf;il A,·\QS 9PPM st•tmbrJ i.r. not l\'f ) 9.4 PP\1} 
CARBON 1\fONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

ontrol Region 

Annual Averages 1990 through 2000 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

Site No. 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 ! 

2950·10 1.1 l.O 0.9 0.8 0.8 . 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.7 (0.7) I 

Sampling at 2950-10 was tenninated on 5/3 1/2000. 

 on less than ava1lab!c data} 

uality St;mdan.l 

(NatJOna! Air Mnnitoring Stalion) [ Oilte of(kcurrenc<:, Htwtl 

• DenMes?. c!'mmvcmwn of NYS+ederal AAQS 9PPM stand.ud is not exceeded unless avg > 9.4 PP!>-1) 
CARBON 1\'lONOXIDE. Continuous ;\on-Dispersiv·e Infrared 

Annual A vcrages t 9QO through 2000 

Annual Anthmcuc Mean lppm) 

Control Regic>n 

Site '\o. 1990 1991 !9()2 1993 J9t)-t 1995 199(, l!J97 1998 191/{) zoon 

XJDO-lC'\ ::.x : :'! 

R l00-03 :u, 24 

8!00-06 (2.3) 2.3 

8100-07 

' ' ! 

., 1 

2.1 

2.6 

2.2 2.2 

1.9 1.9 

{2.9) 2.4 

2.1 : .... , l 7 Ui 

l 9 !.9 !7 !.6 

l.7 1.6 1.3 I l.3 

2.7 2.5 (2.4 > I (2.2) 

5 

f ' 

J .. 

L7 

1-+ 

14 

• '1 L._ 

1.5 

rison Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and .-\mbient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 2000 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour A\·erage (Non-Overlapping) 

Maxtmum not to 35 PPM more than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per 

calendar year • calendar year • 

Obsc.rvatiom Hi£ht:st Values, PPM Hi2hest \'aJues,..PP,\1 

Total I >9 

e No. J Obs. AHtil PPl\1 1 ,, r• 3'" Total I'P.\t I" ·2ftLi 3'" Pl''H 

0-02!'\ I 8,651 98 0 {),4 5.6 ::: 'EP2(; 0 4.6 4.2 3.8 f 0 

[02124. [02/24. [04/15, (02/24. [04/15, [0312-i, 

21] 19] 17j 23] 20] 02) 

00-03 I S.5l3 I 9-I I 0 I 6.5 6.2 5.9 F1,5ti7 0 4.5 4.3 4.0 I 0 

[OVOR, [02110, [03/08, [03/08, [02/04, [03/24, 

091 08) !OJ 13] 20] 02) 

00-06 I 8,666 I 99 I 0 I 5.5 4.9 4.7 8,720 0 ),7 3.3 3J I 0 

[03/09, [05/ 12. [02/24, (02/24. [02!04. [04/!5, 

201 12] 21] 24] 22] 18] 

00-07 S,2t>8 !J:j u 6.0 6.0 5.3 11,304 0 4.1 3.9 3.9 I 0 

f03- 123. ft'J3'09. f08i2), [01/0!-\, [02/24, 1Q:t09, 241 2fl] 08 1 12] 241 22] 

:VlONOXIDE .. Continuous Non-Dispersive lnfmred 

1\t·d ;,·rt ;t:...,, :h<U', data; ("\atu.mal -\:r St:HlfJn) [Datt: HourJ 

Qw..iltt") - Denut<:s o to:Jtravcnt:i'n oJ KYS hderai AA(.>S (J'tHc· Stl\n,hrd I' no! exceeded unl<>> :.vg ·• '14 PP\1) 
._ . .,_./ .._..,._ ..... 

Annual Averars. thnmgh 2000 

o ,.J .1-loJLlll'v\.il\.o. A-".1.'-"Utl .-pl&,t;/ 

Site No. 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 I 

7093-10 1.6 L4 1.4 L2 l.3 1.3 l.l !.0 1.0 10 () ') 

7094-06 --- ....... - ··- ·-· -·- 0.7 0.6 0.6 0.7 0.7 0.7 7095-06 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 \X 

7096-08 --- --- --- -·· -- -· --- --- 0.7 0.7 0.6 

Sampling at 7095-06 was t1.:rminated on 12/31/1999 

n tsetween l'\1 y::; Ambient Air Quantv and Amolent Air _!Zuality :Standards tor Calendar Year LOUO 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per 

calendar year • calendar year • 

Observations Highest Values, PPM Obllervations Hit:hest Values PPM 

Total o;., >35 >9 

e No. Obs. Avail PPM 1" 2"" J'd Total PPM 1" 2"d Jnl 9PP1\I 

93-10 8,272 94 0 4,7 4.1 4.0 R,l98 0 2.9 2.8 2.7 0 

[05!06, [03/09, [03/08, [11/09, [10/27, [03108, 

13] 20] 10] 09] llJ ll J 

94-06 8,613 98 0 6.0 6.0 5.3 8,663 0 4.9 3.5 2.8 0 

[I 1/03. [ll/04, [ ll/03, fl l/04. [12105, [ l 0127. 

22] 01] 24] 04) 02] 08] 

96-08 8,178 93 0 8.0 6.3 5.4 7,906 0 4.6 3J 3.2 0 

(12104. [12/04, [12/04, fJ 2104, [06/30, [06/30, 

17] I 5J 18] 22] 21] 01] 

sed un k.ss tha.n .i\3Hat-le I,LUal 

Quality Standard 

N"-l\A\IS {Nation>! Air Monitnnng Station) [Dat< M Occurrence. Hz•c;r] 

+ De!Klte,; • <:<mlra".'IHHI!l cfe'IIYS.Teder>l AAQS (Note: 9Pl'\1 stand:ud is no! cxcecde,t "'g ·· '·'.! pp>,tj 
CARBON :\'lONOXIDE- Continuous 1'\Cin-Dispcrsivc Infrared 

ontn'l Rt·gion 

Annual Averages 1989 through 1999 

· hmetic M -- \£_["_ 

Site No. 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 

2950-10 { 1.0) 1.1 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.7 

Between -"YS Ambknt Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 1999 

One-Hour Anragc Running 8-Hour Av('rage (:"Jon-Overlapping) 

Maxn:mm not rc) e:-.cccd 35 PP\! more thatl once per Ma.ximum not to e:>.c"ccd 9 PPM mere than once: per calendar 

calendar year " 

Observations 

Total 0' ,. >35 

 No. Obs. ;\\'ill! . PPM 

0-10 8,624 98 0 

on than 75no dau·· 

StilPdsrd 

year • 

Highest Values. PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

>9 Day>" 

1'1 2nd 3;-d Total PPM 1" znu 3rd 9l'P\1 

6.4 6.2 6.2 8,688 0 5.2 4.5 4.3 0 

[ 12/08, (02:01. (12/09, [ 12109. [02/04, (01127, 

22] 22] 23] 02] 03] 04] 

-·-

l Atr !\.1oni!orlr!r. Stntmnl [Date of"C);:L·urren...:c. HourJ 

-· D.:notes J 1:-.:u\c 9P!':-1 standard is not exccc.JeJ unb;s 8-huur a;e -' 4 PPM) 
CARBON 1\10NOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

ontrol Region Annual Averages 1989 through 1999 

............ 

-··-

S!le No. 1939 1990 1991 !992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 \9l)9 

8100-02N 2.9 2.8 2.8 3.! 2.6 2.3 "' ' ..:..I l.CJ 1.7 1.6 1.5 

8 !00-03 3.0 2.6 2.4 2.1 2.2 2.2 1.9 1.9 1.7 1.6 !.5 

8100-06 - (2.3) 2.3 2.1 1.9 1.9 1.7 1.6 1.3 1.3 1.3 

8100..07 -· - - - (2.9) 2.4 2.7 2.5 (2.4) (2.2) 1.7 

Between NYS Ambient Air Qualitv and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 1999 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average G'lon-Overlapping) 

Maximum no! to exceed 35 PPM more than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per 

calendar year • 

Observations 

Total Gi /f)-

Obs. Avrnl 

02N 8,530 97 

03 8.434 96 

06 8,455 97 

07 8.376 96 

d''" less availabk da!J) 

:'uaky 

>35 

PPM 

0 

0 

0 

0 

calendar year * i 

Highest V alucs. PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM I 

>9 Days> 

I •t 2"J :vc Total PPM t Sl 200 'I PPM 

9.3 7.1 6.2 8,582 0 5.0 4.1 3.9 0 

[08112, [08/12, [10/29, {1 0/30, [08112. [I 1123. 

21 J 20] 24) 03] 23) 19] 

7.8 73 6.6 8.51g 0 SA 5.0 4.7 0 

(10/29, [09127, [01121, (10/30, [05/22, [01121, 

23] I 4) 08] 05) 051 14] 

5.8 5.4 5.4 8,527 0 4.9 4.8 3.7 0 

[10/29, [01/25, [05/22, (10/30, (05/22, [ll/23, 

23] 15] 01] 03] 06J 18) 

6.8 6.2 5.9 8,434 0 5.5 4.7 4.4 0 

[ 10/29, [10'29, [10130, [10/30, ro2n6, I rot/21. 

23] -w 02] 04] 141 I 121 

N-S,\MS {;-..:nllonalt'ln Monitoring Station) [Date of Occurrence. Ht)ut] 

Dl.'notc"S a c<>mnnc•!Hl\Hl <>f NVS, Federal AAQS (Note•: tJPPM standard is not excci:Jc•d 8-lwur avg > 'i 4 PPM 1 
CARBON :VIONOXIDE ·Continuous )Jon-Dispersive Infrared 

ontrol Region Annual Averages 19S9 through 1999 

nd) Sites Annual Arithmetic M ean (ppm) 

i SHe \:o 1%9 i '-)9(1 i 1991 :99: I 199:• ]<)•:q i99.:=; ]')')(1 !9'1! !99'1 

l i t 

7093-l 0 1.6 ! ].4 1.4 L:! 1 ' 1.3 ' ' 1.0 10 1 0 

 .t. / I , i.l 

··--

7094-06 --- --- I --- --- ... --- c·"' ,I ; (](, 0.6 0. 7 7 

7095-06 1.0 iO I 0.9 0.9 08 (' ) .. l) CUI CUI OS 0.)'; OS 

7096-08 -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- 0.7 0.7 

Between NYS Ambient Air Qualitv and Ambient Air Qualitv Standards for Calendar Year 1999 

One-Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

not to exceed 35 PPM more than once Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once 

per calendar year * 

Observations 

Total % 

No. Obs. A vall 

0 8,5.'30 97 

-06 1 s.s8! 98 

I 

-06 8.567 98 

I 

0::) l 92 

nn k-ss than availabkdat;o 

a:Jty Standard 

·"1 - :>J) 

PPM 

0 

0 

0 

n 

I 

per calendar year* 

Highest Values. PPM Ohscrvations Highest Values, PPM 

l >9 Duv'' 

l'" 21'J )nJ Total 1 PPM !"! )f.d :;rd 9PP.\: 

84 50 411 8,506 0 3.7 3.6 2,9 0 

[02127. [02/27, [01117 .J..tM, I [02/27, [10/30, [02/16, 

24] 20) 23] 24] 01' 14] 

6.2 5.7 5,7 8,600 0 4.6 4.0 3.2 0 

[10/29. [02116, [ 12/08, ( 10/30, [ 12/08, [12!10, 

23] 10) 21] 03] 23] 09] 

4.5 3.9 3.9 8,601 0 3.6 3.3 2.R 0 

ro Ji21, [05/21. [05/21' ( l2/13, [05/22, [01/Zl, 

09] 24) 23] 16) 05) 11] 

?,.5 3 s.oos 0 2..8 2.() I 2.5 I () 

[05 '()(). [12 103. (05130, [i2l09, (05.<09. I [IIL'2!. I 

04] 09] OJl ' 02J 01\j .l.QL_j 

.. tl AH \·1orHtt'nng S1.:t1Pn) t:l ()"-:',;:ren(t-, Hour} 

+ Dr:notes a contravenlh>n of Te,_kr:li AA\)c; 9PP\<! stand:aJ i:i not .1 /t' > 9 -1 PP\1 1 

I 

I 
loul 

CARBON MONOXIDE· O:m.ti:nwtu Non-Dilpenlive blfhrred 

Air QllalityCcnlrol.lqim 

kSies AmluJ Urroqb JJJI Allmlal A.rithll.edc Nea (ppm) 

lila No. 1.9tl IJU 1990 Ufl 1992 l9tl 1.994 lffi U96 tm 1991 

llt ll0()..()2N 3J u 2.1 2.1 :u 2,6 l.J 1.1 J.9 l.i u 

dJ 1101-0) l.l lJ 11 2..4 l.l 2.7 1.9 Ut 1.7 u 

tet lUll .of - - (1.3) u u u lJ 1.7 1..6 1J u 

lllli-07 - - - - - (U) 2.4 2.7 2.S (2A) (2.2) 

a.,.._....,_ NYI Amtat .tb-oa.llrltud.IIWfor C ... YMF1J91 

lllllllilll.a.llftr A ..... (Nim-<>nrl&.pJillc) 

Maximum Mt1.1 er:mecd lS Pn& lillie d."'" per lo t JIPM men llwlnDeper 

....,..,..... 

Tatal " >9 

S*N'o. a.. A.ftl 1Titf I"' z- , .. Te6al Pltl .. IG ]1,. = 

:d 810o.o2N 11,661 9' 0 IJ 6.4 u 1,718 0 4.2 u J • .9 () 

(CJIIDI, (11/30, {0..51!)4, (01101, [12106. (OJIJO, 

12] 11] 1%] Jf) 23) IJl 

uil 11Q0-6] 8,502 9'1 a 7.1 6.4 6.1 .. ,$4 0 4A 4.1 J.9 0 

JOll&4. f1V08, (06113, [OlJB, {Ol/10, [OlflG, 

11) lOJ 22) 20] 12) 161 

eet 111004 8,6Sl 99 0 5.9 u Hi &,'727 0 u u u 0 

(0111.11, [04/17, (124!, (041'U, (0-4/19, {IXIJU, 

tY1J 12J U] l8} OS) U] 

1100-m' .5,1150 57 0 l.l.l 9.1 9.1 5,193 G u s.a S1i 0 

[C171'l2., (!)7Jn, [OJI29, {0.1'29, {Wl4, 

Of} 0571 211 13) lJ] . __ 

...,.._ ............. 

l A.11MBt 

.......... 0\llrbllll ... 

+n.-a• P I ..... .... ...._ .... ,llAI'Pio!) 

-
gion2 CARBON MONOXIDE- Cmltinucus Non-Dispenive ll'lfrued 

Ai:r=Co:rrtrol Amuul t:.!Sa UU tbroaab m1 

) oc..d) Si!ca ,\ritbrutic MMD tppm) 

Slt.t No. 1981 1919 19tl 1992 l99l 1994 199j ',996 1997 i 1998 

70'1J-10 1.6 1.4- 1.4 1.2 u lj l u Jl} !J} 

·---·--

cl.u 1f1J4..06 

- -- -· - -·· - -·-- 0.7 O.fi 0.6 07 

10J.5..Q6 . U l I.Q LO 0.9 IU 0.8 O.!J Ci.l 0.1 OJ 0.1 

.. CeD 10K.OI - ' C.'l .... -· -j- -- - - -

-

u)Miflcla B.t.tw.ll NY& A.taWc:af Ak o-»itJ IPid AJIW!at Afr QUI ..., IIDdtrdl ror ca•cnda.r Yar D9t 

ODe-Hour A.Yerip ltullDfaci-Bcnu Avencc (Noa-Owcdllpp.iDI') 

Mginown JlOt to ta.ca:d 35 PPM men fha DltCC Ulllmum not to cxoeal J .PPld mon: tiLm anoo 

p« call!lldar yqr. -perc ctlmdv )'C8l • 

---· 

HiJhat V.W:., PPM Ob llftl'llltic111 .Hisfwt VAlues, :PPM 

I TNI % >H! ! v )Y' l.JaJP 

; Sitc:No. Obi. A.nl1 PPM 1" 2- j111 TaW FI'U 1" I 2"" WPM 

7093-10 a.m 96 0 6..0 4.4 4.l l..f71 0 •U h9 .3.9 0 

[ll/'l7, (llfl6, r12116, p2/t6', [11115, [IVLC, 

I 22] 20} 21) 2.4] Z3) 16j 

dens 7()94...(}6 1)49 9S 0 4.7 u l,lS7 • S.3 l.l u o-1 [Ol/10, [lOllS, {Ollto, [01110, [OUJO, 

OJ] llJ 02f O?J 04} m 

7095..()6 !.5&9 91 0 u J..4 lJ 1.5n • 1.1 l6 1A i 0 [".i)/Oj, (l!WS, (05116, I f<!S/t 6, (OWS, (0!/U, I 

i !J) 12] 07] I M"j 21] 20} ! 

70%-(18 4,479 I 11-1 0 43 4.1 :u 4,4B D 2.7 1.1 1.0 t 0 

I fl.2J! 6, 

e fOWl, I 

i [OWlO. j [12116, !4) 21] 2.1) (12Jl7. I [11129. 01] 11] 

J.!J) I j t7Jj 

. . 

.--......... ...__ .,.......u..w....., 

.$lt.lllllllS 

!+-HAWS (lllll IUD! 

o-, ........... AQS (lftaest'fl( U l'JtoO 
CARBON MONOXIDE· Contitruous Non-Dispersive lnfrared 

1 

QualilyControf Rqjon 

AlunlaJ Anngea 1981 Chrou&fl J9t8 

AnnuaJ .Arifhalelic Mea (PJIID) 

Site No. 1918 191.9 1990 1991 tm 1991 199-4 1995 199'6 1997 1998 

2950..10 1.( (1.0) 1.1 1.0 0.9 o.a 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.6 

ariloll 'Bdwtlll NYI Air Quilty_. AmblelltA.lrQuliylb•danh forCalndlt" 1991 

o.o.Hou A venae Ru .. 

Mail _ _. IQ MQC'Od 35 pt'IJI lllartlba o.ece per ...._., a.at10 tttd 9 PPMIIICI'll 6ID 0tlallu 

Oblcr•6nl 

Total 

Site No. Obi. A..U " 

19.1>-JO 8,613 91 

QQ .... ?.,. mdWalo liM) 

...u Qa}tlr......., 

>JS 

l'PM 

0 

,.. 

Hip.tVthlai.1PM Oblervlltit:a 

>t JloJP 

t• 1!' ,.. ,... .. 14 1" ,. , .. '""' 

'·' S.6 5.5 8,665 0 4.7 4.0 3.9 0 (02110, [12116, {lZ/16, [12117, (ll!.29, (12/0S, 

OIJ 2.f} U] 02] 01] Ol] 

-

f'+oo)(IIM ............... ) {tllo8 Q(O.,. -. lbwJ 

+u.a..• ......... ANI' ..... .....w .u......_oa,.li.A f'PIIQ 

• Q 

c 

.. • 

.. 

2 

:;,: 

&1 

' 

.,, 

el 

19 

g 

"' 

' 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

ity Control Region 

Annual Averages 1987 through 1997 

Annual .1\rithmetic Mean (ppm) . 

Site No. 1987 !988 1989 1990 199! 1992 1993 1994 1995 !996 1997 

8100-0lN 3.2 3) 19 2.8 2.8 3. I 2.6 23 2.1 1.9 !.7 

-

8100-03 3.5 2.8 3.0 2.6 2.4 l 2.2 ... ",;. .. !.9 1.9 1.7 

----

8100-06 -- .. - (2.3) 2.3 2.1 L9 1.9 L7 1.6 1.3 

8100-07 -- -- - - - - (2..9) 2.4 2.7 2.5 (2.4) 

on Bttweeo NYS Ambieat Air Quality and Ambient Air QuaUty Staadards for CaJeodar Year 1997 

One-Hour Average Running 3-Bour Average {Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more !han once per 

calendar year • 

Observations 

Total % ! >35 

Site No. Obs. AVail j PPM 

! 

100-02N 8,405 96 f 0 

8100-03 8,398 96 0 

100-06 8,720 99 0 

1 00-07 6,241 

 

71 0 

based or. less tht.n 75% avail&ble data) 

A!f Quality SW>::Iatd 

calendar year • 

Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

>9 DaY$-'> 

1'1 2nd Total PPM l" .,...; 3'd 9PPM ... 

7.8 6.2 5.8 8.415 0 4.6 4.2 4.0 0 I 

[01/03, (12/17, (10/05, [ 10106, [OliOS, [03130, 

20] 091 . 20] on 211 01] 

7.5 7.1 6.8 8,436 0 5.0 4.3 4.3 0 

[10131, [02/14, [02114, [02/14, [10/07, [ 12/22, 

081 lOJ 09] 15] 23] 21] 

6.3 6.\ 5.6 8,754 0 4.1 3.8 3.6 0 

[01125, [Ol/09, (o7n5. [10106, [07/26, [1Oft 9, ' 

23] 12) 24) 03} 04] 20] 

18.0 13.6 13.2 6,267 0 6.2 6.1 n 0 

[02/26, [OJ/20, [05/0!, [10106, [02/26, [03127, 

07) 20] 19] 

-- --·-·-··---

Ol] 

-

' l4J ' 24] 

N•NAMS (Nanonal Air M0<1iklrinJ Station) ofOc:wm:ncc, HoUJj 

.. • <omuvenlK>o ofNYS/fedua: AAQS (Nou:: 9PPM ttJrnil.wj i' not c:xcecdcd 8-l>ourava > 9.4 PPM) 

+-

.... 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

lity Control Region 

kground) Sites 

Site No. 

7093-05 

7093-10 

7094-06 

7095-06 

1987 

--

-

--

l.l 

Annual Averages 1987 fhrougb 1997 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 

1.2 1.1 1.2 l.l 1.0 

1.7 1.6 1.4 14 

-- --- -- ---

0.9 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.9 

1993 1994 

(0.9) XXX 

1.2 1.3 

-- ---

0.8 0.9 

1995 1996 

XXX )(XX 

1.3 1.1 

0.7 0.6 

0.8 0.8 

on Betweea NYS Ambient Air Quality aad Ambfeot Air Quality Staodards for Caleadar Year 1997 

1997 

XXX I 

1.0 

0.6 0.8 

One-Hour Average Ruaniug S..Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once 

per calendar year • 

Observations 

Total % >35 

Site No. Obs. Avail PPM 

7093-10 8,465 97 0 

7094-06 8,177 93 0 

7095-06 8,251 94 0 

based on leu than dala) 

Air Qualtty S!indlrd 

per calendar year • 

Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values. PPM 

>9 Days> j 

111 2nd 3"' Total PPM 1" 21111 3"' 9PPM 

s. 1 4.5 4.2 8,459 0 3.2 3.2 2.8 0 

(01/28, {10/09, (10114, {10106, [01/03, {01/05, 

121 10] 23} 06) 18} 24] 

7.4 7.3 7.0 8,197 0 4.6 3.5 3.3 0 

[ 11/21, {07/26, [ 11/21, [11121, [ 11130, [07126, 

!OJ 01] 09} lO] 03] 04] 

4.0 3.7 3.4 8,274 0 2.8 2.7 2.6 0 

(01/03, (01/03, [09/19, [09/19, [Ol/03, [12117, 

19) 20] 01] 04] 24) 12] 

N•NAMS (N&Iional Air MorulorinJ Sllllion) (Dale of Occum:ncc. How J 

• Denotes a oonnve•uion of NYSIFedcnl AAQS {Notc:: IIPPM is not exceeded unless 1-botrr ""' > 9.4 l'l'M) 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

gion 1 

Air Quality Control Region 

Annual Averages 1987 through 1997 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

Site No 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 

Park 2950-10 l.O u ( 1.0) Ll t.O 0.9 0.8 

__ 

0.8 0.8 07 

---

omparison Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Sblndards for Calendar Year 1997 

---

One--Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Noo-Overlapr-ing) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once per Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more once pu calcn\h( 

calc ndar year • 

Observations 

Total % 

Site No. Obs. Avail 

Park 2950·10 8,676 99 

------ --

:nthese< an: bued on leu !han 75•,; awil•blc dat.t) 

al Ambient Alt Quality Sr:an!Dnl 

>35 

PPM 

0 

year • 

Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

>9 Otys> 

1" 2nd J!d Total PPM 1" 2"" Jnl 9Pl'M 

8.5 8.4 8.4 8,721 0 4.9 4.7 4.4 0 

{01/03, [08/05, [12/17, [12117, [11/30, [ ll/21, 

19) 18] 09] 03] 

....__ _____ 03) ----- 03] ..... 

N•NAMS (NationAl Air Moni!Gling Statiofl) !Date ofOctum:nce, Hour) 

• 11 connvrolion ofNYSI'Fedcol AAQS {Note: 9PI'M Slalldltd is not unless S-hOU! 1"1 :> PPM) 

I 
 

CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

uality Control Region 

 

Site No. 

8100-02N 

8100-03 

8100...06 

8100-07 

1986 

3.6 

3.7 

--

Annual Averages 1986 tllrougb 1996 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 

3.2 J.J 2.9 2.8 2.8 

3.5 2.8 3.0 2.6 2.4 

.. -- ·- (2.3) 2.3 

·- - -- .. -

1992 1993 1994 1995 

3.1 2.6 2.3 2 I 

2.1 2.2 2.2 19 2.! 1.9 1.9 1.7 

-- (2.9) . 2.4 2.7 

rison Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambteat Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 1996 

One-Hour Average Runalng 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

1996 

1.9 1.9 

1.6 

2.5 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than once per Mu.imum not to exceed 9 PPM mote than once per 

calendar year • calendar year • 

Observations Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values. PPM 

Total % >35 >9 Days> 

Site No. Obs. Avail PPM 1"' 2"" Jrd Tou} PPM J" 2nd Jnl 9PPM 

8100-02N 8,404 96 0 6.6 6.3 6.1 8,477 0 5.0 4.4 4.3 0 

{05/14, [O.S/08, [12/17, {1111 8, (04120, [12/17, 

!OJ 13J 16} 21] OIJ 16) 

8100-03 8,299 94 0 11.2 10.8 8.9 8,281 0 6.5 6.1 5.4 0 

[11127, [02121, [05108, f02/2l, [11118, [OS/08, 

10] 08] 08] 20] 21] 14] 

8100-06 8,.S6l 98 0 7.1 6.9 6.9 8,570 0 5.3 5.0 4.9 0 

[10/03, [01/18, [03/13. [02/22, [11118, {02121, 

13] IOJ 20] 16} 15] 18] 

8100-07 7,916 90 0 11.7 10.8 10.2 7,918 0 6.4 6.J 6.2 0 

[05105, [03/!5, [07116, f04/20, [05/04, [ 11/18, 

IJJ 

__ 03) 22} 01] 

' 

I 

i 

re based on leu than 7S% Available d•c.J 

nt Air Qual! I)' Srandard 

N•NAMS (National Air Monitorint Stali<>n) !Date: of Occurrence, lioutJ 

t D.-notes 1 contrnc:nlioo AAQ5 (Note: 9PPM slan<brd is nut uccedc:d 8-hcur av11 > 94 PPM) 
CARBON MONOXIDE- Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

lity Control Region Annual Averages 1986 through 1996 

kground) Sites Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

-

Site No. 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 199t 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 

l 

7093-05 --- --- 1.2 1.1 1.2 1.! 1.0 (0.9} XXX XXX XXX . 

----f-.-------- ---r-- ------- -·------

7093-10 -·- -- -· 1.7 1.6 1.4 1.4 L2 1.3 l.J 1.1 

7094-06 --- -- --- --- ·- ... ·-· --- --- 0.7 0.6 

7095-06 1.2 u 0.9 t.O l.O 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.9 0.8 0.8 

on Between NYS Ambient Air Quality and Ambient Air Quality Standards for Calendar Year 1996 

One--Hour Average Running 8-Hour Average (Non-Overlapping) 

Maximum not to exceed 35 PPM more than onee Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once 

per calendar year • per calendar year " 

-

Observations Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM j 

Total % >35 >9 Days> 

Site No. Obs. Avail PPM 1" 2lld J'd Total PPM tst 2nd 3'4 9PPM 

7093-10 8.562 98 0 5.1 5.1 4.9 8,571 0 4.3 3.9 3.8 0 

(04/23, [09/20, ( 11117. [11!!8, [0212!, [0 l /0 I, 

09} 02J 24] 15] 18J 08! 

7094-06 7,199 90 0 5.7 5.3 5.2 7,211 0 4.3 3.8 3.3 0 

{03/15, [01/01, [03/15, [01/0 I, [03115, {0 1118, 

09] 01] 10] 03) 13) OIJ 

-- '----

7095-06 7,524 86 0 5.2 5.1 4.8 7.534 0 3.6 3.4 2.9 0 

 

[01/18, [10/30. (0Jfl8, [OJ/18, [IIi I 8, [ 11 !18. 

_. 14) 20] 10) 14] 2 !] OIJ ... - ---, ---

based on tess than av.ail3ble dat.a} 

Air Quality Sttnda•d 

N•NAMS A•r Mon:tormg Stauon; {Date o(O\:curren<:c, Hourt 

+ D<:ttolcs. rontravcnlion ofNYS/hde ... ! AAQS (Nulc. 9PPM >tW<lJid I) 1101 e>ee<ded unlcll8·i>OUI l>g > 9 4 rPM) 

tO" 
CARBON MONOXIDE. Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

ity Control Region 

ADaual Averages 1986 tbrougb 1996 

Annual Arithmetic Mean (ppm) 

Site No. 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 !991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 ! 

2950..10 1.1 J.O u (1.0) 1.1 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 . 

oa Bdweea NYS Ambleat Air Quality and Ambltat Air Quality Staoduds for Calendar Year 1996 

One-Hour Average Runafag S.llGur Average (Non-Overbpping) 

Maximum JWt to exceed lS PPM more than Oftee per Maximum not 10 exceed 9 PPM more than per calendar 

c:alendar year • 

Observations 

Total % 

Site No. Obs. Avail 

2950-10 8,475 96 

a.ocd "" Ina tl!lll 1 IYailablt data} 

ir Qualil)' SI:Pidtnl 

>35 

PPM 

0 

year • 

Highest Values, PPM Observations Highest Values, PPM 

>9 Days> 

•• 2 .. Jnl Total PPM , ..2"" Jrd 9PPM 

6.9 6.6 6.6 8,499 0 5.8 4.9 4.4 0 

[11129, [11129, {02/06, I 11130, {02/07, (12/09, 

23) 24] 24} 021 03] 02] 

N•NAMS {NitSon.tf Air Monilorin& Station) [Dale flour) 

+Denotes • COIItniVMiion ofNYS/Fedel'ltl MQS (Nore: 9PPM suodard is not tmlcu 8-hour avg > ?.4 PPM) 

w 

N 
CARBON MONOXIDE - Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

2 

IR QUALITY CONTROL REGION 

ANNUAL AVBRAGBS 1985 THROUGH 1995 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC MEAN (ppm) 

SITE NO. 1985 1t8• 1917 1988 1989 1910 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 

 8100-02N 3.7 3.6 3.2 3.3 2.9 2.8 2.8 3.1 2.6 2.3 2.1 . 

 8100-0J 3.7 3.5 2.8 3.0 2.6 2.4 2.1 2.2 2.2 1.9 i 

8100-06 -- -- -- -- -- (2. 3) 2.3 2.1 1.9 1.9 1.7 

8100-07 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- (2 .9) 2.4 2.7 

f'B8lf na AllliiD'l UR QOALII'Y AJID AMBID'l' AIR QUALITY STABDARDB CALDDU YIU Uti 

OD•BOOR AYmitAG. RUiflfUfQ 1-BOt:nl AVDAQB (lfon-overlappinq) 

Maxiatwl not to exceed 35 PPM 1110re than once Maximwll not to exceed 9 PPM 1110re than once per 

per calendar year • calendar Y••r • 

OUDVA!UOWI •tedft' VALtJ'BI, PPM OBIJDVATIOIIS IIODft VALUIS, PPM 

tlqt 

Tota.l " >33 " > 9 >t 

O. Oba. Avail. ""' lat 2ad lrd TO!al ITM lat. lad 3111 !'nl 

N 8,543 98 0 10.1 10.0 9.3 8,565 98 o 7.1 7.0 6.5 0 I 

[03/1.1, (06/14, (01/14, [03/14, (03/21, j: 

20) 191 211 04J 01! 17) 

I 

 7,074 81 o 12.9 11.5 11.3 7,077 81 0 9.8 7.9 7.4 o 1 

(02/28, (05/111 [02/28, {02/28, (Olfll, [OljlJ, I' 

09) 09] 10) lSl 011 24} 

I 

 8,671 99 0 9.7 9.0 8.4 8,685 99 0 i.S 6.5 6.1 0 

1

1 

{01/30, {02/28, (01/13, (02/28. (01/13, (01/13, . 

03} 14) 22} 17} 24} 01} 

 8,656 99 0 14.6 10.7 9.7 8,685 99 0 8.3 7.9 7.3 0 I 

(07/18, !01/13, [01/12, (01/13, (01/13, (02/28, 1 

lJJ 011 241 02L ____ 23L ___ 

oaed .......... 7!11 ....no.t.le ... , 

AJr Ql>lo!illi1 ....... 

(NIIioooal Air !lllitlaol) [v.c d o..:un--, »-1 

+ r-. t emil"""*- cl I'IYllifecltnl MQ6 (loiQet; 9 ri'M lladanl It D<ll liOJeM ......... > 94 l'l"Wl 
ARBON MONOXIDE - Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

 

R QUALITY CONTROL REGION 

AKRVAL AV&RAQjS 1t85 THROUGH 1995 

-, ---·--- . 

SITE NO. 1t81 , .. , ltl7 1181 ltlt UtO Ut1 1192 1tt3 1194 uu 

7093-0!5 --- --- --- 1.2 1.1 1.2 1.1 1.0 (0.9) XXX XXX 

7093-10 --- --- --- --- 1.7 1.6 1.4 1.4 1.2 1.3 1.3 

en 7094-06 --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- 0.7 

709!5-06 1.2 1.2 1.1 0.9 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.9 0.8 

XXX - SaJIO .1na at Mabel Dean was terminated on 06/28/93 

.,. 

BD Jll'l AliBIJDft Ata QU&LI'fY AD AD!Sft .lilt QUU.rJ.'1' 8TAJIDUD8 1'01\ CU.BJm.U 'RU UU "' 

on-JIOUil a:nmaoz RU'lQJDIG 8-liOmt AVDAGB (Man-overlapping) 

HuiJJwa not to exceed 35 PPM 1110re than one• Ma.xi.mua not to exc .. d 9 PPM 110r• than onc::e per 

per calendar year • calendar year • 

OUDYA'l'l01r8 I .IGII.Bft 'OUJB8, PPII 08ARV&riOJrl atGDI'l' V&LUBI, PJIIII 

Dirt 

Total • >JJ • >9 >9 

Ob•. A nil ..... bt 2Dd lrd Ta A nil. f1'M ht 2DCI lnl PI'M 

8, 515 98 0 8.1 7.1 6.6 s,seo 98 0 5.6 5.4 4.9 0 

[01/12, (02/28, [02f28, [01/13, [02/28, [ 12/14, 

24] lSJ 14} 021 161 211 

8,271 94 0 6.7 6.6 6.0 8,243 ,. 0 3.7 3.6 3.6 0 

[Ol/27, (06/19, ( 10/27, [ 02/19, [12/31, [12/16, 

ll) 13J 09} 061" 24} Oil 

8,594 98 0 s.s 8.0 7.7 8,604 98 0 7.0 5.3 4.1 0 

{01/12, [01/12, (01/12, [Ql/12, [12/14, [01/13, 23] 24] 22) I 

-- -

09) 

... leu ... 7l• .....a-ble 4ab) 

Quality -....s I'I•MAMS l,NIIIilall Statioal Cll* d fkul + o-,... I_,.....,. d NYIIl'odcnl. MQS (N<Ik: t I"I'M ...... ..,.,.,..,......, J..K_. ........ > t.4 I"PU) 
CARBON MONOXIDE - Continuous Non-Dispersive Infrared 

 

IR QUALITY CONTROL REGION 

AHHUAL AVBRAG!S 1915 THROUGH ltt5 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC MEAN (ppm) 

SITE NO, 1985 1181 1987 1188 1189 lttO 1991 1992 1993 1994 1915 

rk 2950-10 1.3 1.1 1.0 l.l (1.0) 1.1 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.8 

f1rBD lfY8 .IDID'T Ail. Q'OA.Lift .ut'D AKBIDrl' AIR QOALI'l'Y S'l'MfDARDS l'OR CALDDAR YDR 1!95 

OBB-BOOR AVBRAOB 1U1DilrG I-BOOR AVDAGB {Non-overlapping) 

.Kaxilllwa not to exceed 35 PPM 1110ra than once Maximum not to exceed 9 PPM more than once per 

per calendar year • calendar year • 

OBIDVA%10111 BIGUH VALUBS, PPM BIODS'l' V.&LUBII, PPM 

Dm 

m Total • >U " >9 >t 

. Oba. A ... me lat. 21ld lrd Total A'111iL J'!'W lat. 21ld 3nt ""' 

8,674 99 0 8.5 6.9 6.5 8,705 99 0 5.3 s.o 4.3 0 

[01/30, [Ol/30, [02/18, (02/18, {11/18, (01/30, 

20) 211 01) 06} 02) 24] 

oal Air Qao.lily lltoDoia:rd 

N-NAM.S (N...;..,u Air W...tloril:c bboJ (Date d Hom) 

+ o..-a.-., "Ji<w <tl WYJ.IJ'edmol MQS IN'*': 9 PPM IIUaJdr.n! lo-•z.....st.4 ....S... t-II<Nr """""" > P .• I1'Ml 
CARBON MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-RED 

GION 2 

 AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGION 

. ANNUAL AVERAGES 1984 THROUGH 1994 

s 

Street 

ransit 

 

Street 

ales 

SITE NO. 

8100-02N 

8100-03 

8100-04 

8100·06 

8100-07 

1984 1988 

4.0 3.7 

(4.2} 3.2 

5.3 

... ... 

ANNUAL A.RITlilrWTIC MEAN £ppml 

111§ 00 1988 1989 19.90 

3.6 3.2 3.3 2.9 2.8 

3.7 3.S 2.8 3.0 2.6 

4.6 5.4 4.6 4.4 4.0 

. .. ... . .. "" (2.3) 

1991 1992 

2.8 3.1 

2.4 2.1 

4.3 (3.7) 

2.3 2.1 

1993 1994 

2.6 2.3 

2.2 2.2 

... ••• 

1.9 1.9 

(2.9} 2.4 

SON BETWEEN N.Y.S. AMBIEl'rf AIR QUALlTT AND AMBIEN'l' .AJll QUAlm' STANDAJU)S FOR CALENDAR n:AR 1994 

OHB-HOUR AVERAGE RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

MulmiUII not Ia ....t 31! PPM mon1 t1lan 

.... calladar,.. • 

NO. of OBSERVA'l'IONS HIGHEST VALUES. PPM 

Total • >38 

Sl'l'E NO. Ot.. Aft.ll. PPM .l!t 

8100-02N 8,101 92 0 10.4 

[02/20, 

21] 

8J(J().03 8,505 97 0 10.8 

[11/28, 

10] 

8100·06 8,619 98 0 12.0 

[lZ/04, 

21] 

8100-07 8,590 98 0 13.8 

[12/04, 

21] 

th-e. are bahd on leu than 78% a'l'allab!e data) 

derul A.mbl&nl Alr Quality Standard 

Monitoring Station) 

1M .A'd 

10.3 9.3 

[02118, [02/20, 

11) 20) 

10.3 9.6 

(12/05, [12/04, 

10] 21] 

9.1 8.5 

[12/04, [10/23, 

20) 17] 

12.0 11.7 

[ 12/04, [12/04, 

22] 20] 

Ma.l:lmurt! not Ia esc..s II PPM - than 

once per calend.u .,_.. • NON-OVEIU..J\PPIN'G 

OBS 

Total " >8 HJCHEST VALUES. PPM will I lor OJ.. Aftil. PPM _l!l 2nd 3rd > 9 PPM 

8,108 92 0 7.5 7.2 7.1 0 

(03125, [02/18, [02/19, 

01] 23] l7J 

8,523 97 0 8.1 6.4 6.3 0 

{12/04, [02/19, [lZ/22, 

22] 03J 24] 

8,646 99 0 6.8 6.1 6.2 0 

[12104, (10/23, [03/25, 

231 18) 02} 

8,587 98 0 8.7 7.3 7.2 0 

{12/04, [03/25, [ 12i23, 

241 03) Ol) 

[Date of Occurrence. Endino l!oml 

I)enot&11 a contravention of NYS/Federal AAOS 

N'()'J'f;o S!Andud of 9 PPM ie not e:r:c<>dded unlen 8-Hour average uo > 9 4 PPM 
CARBON MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-RED 

GION 2 

AIR QUALm CONTROL REGION 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1984 THROUGH 1994 

ANNUAL A.Rrl'HMETIC MEAN (PPm) 

Sl'J'E NO. 1984 198Q 1988 1987 1988 !990 1m 

ackground) Sites 

n 7093-05 ... ··- -·- -·· 1.2 Ll 1.2 1.1 1.0 (0.9) 

7093-10 ··- ... . .. ... 1.7 1.6 1.4 lA 1.2 1.3 

7095-06N 1.3 1.2 L2 1.1 0.9 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.9 o.s 0.9 

ON BE'tWEEN N.T.S. AMBIEN'l' AlR OUJllam AND AMBIEN'l' AIR QUALIT!' STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR TEAR 1994 

ONE-HOUR AV'EIAGE 

l>iukn111n na1 to ..-! 311 PPM mere than 

NO. of OBSERVA'l'IONS IDGHEST VALUES. PPM 

'fatal " >38 

Sl'I'E NO. Obe. PPM -1!! 2nd 3rd 

7093-10 8,304 95 0 9.7 7.7 1.6 

[12/04, [09/14, [12122, 

21] 01] 091 

1095-00N 8,483 97 0 6.6 6.3 5.6 

[12/04, [02/19, (02/19, 

21] lO] 09] 

 .. Sampling at Mabel Dean was terminated on 06/28/93. 

tho- <!Ill baeed on than 75% an.ilable data) 

eral Ambient Alr Quality Standard 

Mortltonno Station) 

RUNNING B HOUR AVERAGE 

Mul.mum not lo PPM men than 

ooce per calend&l J'llll • 

OBS 

Total " >8 Obe. Aftil. PPM 

8,362 95 0 

8,514 9'1 0 

:iON-OVERLAPPING 

""'0.,. 

HlOHEST VALUES. PPM rib. hr 

..l!! 2nd 3rrl > 9 PPM 

S.9 4.9 4,9 0 

{12/22, {12122. [12/04, 

141 24] 23] 

5.0 4.5 3.9 0 

[02/l9, [12/04, (lOll B. 

12] 23] 02] 

(Data of Occ.lrTonco, E;ndlnq Houri 

+ DenotM a conttaventiort of NTiiiTederal MCX. 

NO'l'E: Statld<Hrl or 9 PPM is not exc:ooded u.nleae 8-tlour average Is > 9.4 PPM 

<1 

·-
CARBON MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-RED 

N l 

R QUALITY CONTROL REGION 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1984 'l'HROUGH 1994 

ANNUAL AR.mlJ4ETlC MEAN <mnl 

SITE NO. 1984 !Jg lJ.tm 1m 

rk 2950-10 1.3 1.3 1.1 1.0 

1988 1989 

1.1 ( 1.0) 

1990 

1.1 

1991 1992 1993 1994 1.0 0.9 0.8 . 0.8 

 BETWEEN N';t'.S. AMBIENT AIR OUALl'l'T AND AMBIEN'l' AIR QUALm STANDABDS FOR CALENDAR TEAR 1994 

ONE-HOUJI AVEIAGE 

Mutmllm aat tllaa 

s- caleadax fW.l • 

NO. of OBSERVA'J'IONS mGBEST VALUES. PPM 

Total " >38 

E NO. 2ti!L Aftil. nM _1ft ..bd 3ld 

0-01 8,492 97 0 9.7 9.0 

[12/01, [12/22, 

IS] 09) 

- are hued on lea than 78'11. 1.'f11.1lahl11 data) 

l Ambient Air Quality Standard 

nltoring Statton} 

8.9 

[12/20, 

22} 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

Mufmum not to 8 PPM !T'IOnl !han 

ea!endar JeC • NON·OVERLAPPINQ 

Total " 

Obs. 

8,519 97 

OBS Nt;r.Dwrw 

> 8 HlO'HES'l' VJU.UI::s, PPM .,. a 11r 

UM .1m ..aM 3ni 

0 6.4 5.4 4.9 0 

[12/21, [12/22, [03/24, 

01) 11] OS] 

[Dal11 of O.:cummce, Ending Hour) 

+ Denotl!lll • contraY11ntlon of NYS/redenl MOO 

NOTE; Standard of 9 PPM Is not em-.Jed un!r>sa 9-llour average ill > 9.4 PPM 

t. 

c 
\ 4 1 '\ , , .... ,-....... i'a :, ....... • .. I '\ i -. t ._ \ .• , ' "' •. -r •. \o :• • • : t · l I • 4; ..,t. 

OlON 2 ALITY CONTROC REOlON AL AVEliAG&S 1083 '1'11110UGIII083 C MEAH (p!!!!!) 

AIR QU ANNU 

srre No. 1988 1988 Ler.l 1988 1989 1990 199l 1993 

ackground) Sites 

n 1093-0S ... ... --- 1 2 u !.2 1.1 l.O (0.9) 

7093-10 --· ... ... ... --· ... 1.7 1.6 1.4 14 1.2 

7095·06N (1.2) 1.3 l.Z 1.2 1.1 0.9 1.0 l.O 0.9 0.9 0.8 

SoN BETWEEN N.T.S. AMIIEN'l' AIR .OUALrrT AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STAHilARDS FOR CALENDAB TEAR 1993 

ONE·HOUR AVERAGE RtJNNIRO 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

Mu::1tnum not to GCMd 38 PPM mot'l tJ:o.al'l 

pet yeu • 

NO. of OBSERVATIONS lnGHES'I' VALUES, PPM 

!otal " >38 

srrE NO. Oba. Aftil. PPM J.!! 2nd 3rd 

7093-0S 3,816 sa· .. 0 s.s 5.2 4.S 

[00/22, [01/22. [03/27. 

16} 12} 01) 

7093-10 8,147 93 0 9.3 7.5 7.3 

[03105, [08/24, [10/20, 

lll 151 191 

7095-06N 8,473 91 0 5.5 5.0 4.9 

{03/0S, {11/11. [05/11, 

12) 09] 241 

• • • Sampling at Mabel Dean was terminated on 06128/93. 

ue bued on IAMtl than 75% anll.llble data) 

federal Ambient AU Quallty St1.nda:d 

ir Mot>ltorll>ij1 Station) 

MulmUl'll t101 to --.d I PPM mon1 !hall 

onoe per calantiar .,.u • NON·O!EftWPINO 

OBS N<>. o.y,. 

Total " >9 HlGHES'l' PPM wthlllt Ot.. AnJL PPM ..!!! ..and 3:d > 9 PPM 

3,829 88 0 3.5 2.5 2.3 0 

[03/21, (03103, [02/22, 

i 1 J 03] 21 J 

8,152 93 0 3.9 3.5 3.4 0 

[ 11{19, [03/21. {OB/27, 

Z3l 04] 13] 

8,470 91 0 3.8 3.6 3.1 0 

[10/16, [11/ll, [10/09, 

lOJ 09) 04} 

{Dilte ol Occunence, Ending Hour) 

+ O<onat• a contnr.yentlon of l't!'S/Fodertl AfC10 

NCYI'E: Stndacd of 9 PPM iJI not a:ceedod unlau 8-Hour avera'Je f.s > 9.4 PPM 

- · · -- P ' ·rses z· r ... tn3'T'FC·- , . ·- . r ": ·· mt s r · - -- -nrhl 
CARBON MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON-DJSPE'RSI'VE I p ... -¥ I 4 "'OSQC 

ION 2 

AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGIOINNUAL AVElt.AGES 1883 THROUGH 1993 

ANNUAL AlllTHMSTIC MEAN tppm> 

sriE NO. 00 ll§:f 1!1§ 1!!.§ 1m 1988 !!!!! 1990 00 1992 

8l00.02N 3.7 4.0 3.7 3.6 3.2 3.3 2.9 2.8 2.8 3.l 2.6 

ansit 8100-03 --- (4.2) 3.2 3.7 3.5 2.8 3.0 2.6 2.4 2.1 2.2 

8100-04 --- --- 5.3 4.6 5.4 46 4.4 4.0 4.3 (3.7) ... 

Streel 8100-06 ... ... ... --- --- --- --- (2.3) 2.3 2.1 1.9 

es 8100-07 ... --- ... ... . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. .. . (2.9) 

ON BETWEEN N.Y.S. A!OIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT Am QUALl'l'T S'I'ANDIB.DS FOR CALENDAR TEAR 1993 

ONE-HOUI AVERAOE RUNNlNG I HOtm AVEBAGE 

MuSmum not to tm:..:l 38 PPM more th111 Muhnum not b) IIICIMd ; PPM men 1tw1. 

pw calandLr ,.u • onca pe: oalondat YMr • NQlf..OVERI..tAPflNG 

NO. of OBSERVATIONS lnOHES'I' VALUES, PPM OBS No. o.,. 

'l'ot.al '16 >38 Total " >9 HlGHSS'l' VALUES. PPM wlll. 1lr 

ITE NO. Qa. PPM .1!! ..2nd .Jnl rutL Ani. lm JJt 3ni 

100-02N 8,275 94 0 9.8 9.5 8.9 8,290 95 0 6.7 6.3 6.2 0 

[01124. (03/20, [04/21, [03120, [01/24, [02/22, 

17] 19] 23] 20] 21] 211 

100-03 8,548 98 0 13.8 12.6 12.5 8,514 98 0 7.1 7.0 6.9 0 

[1W21, {09117, { 10/21, [10121, [10/20, [09/08, 

09] 09] . 10) 15} 141 21) 

100-06 8,688 99 0 9.8 9.5 8,8 8.722 99 0 6.4 5.9 5.9 0 

[09i27, [09127. [03/11, [09/27, {09/27, [09/21. 

12) 11} 14) 14) 01) 211 

100-07 4,231 91 .. 0 16.0 9.1 9.0 4,249 92 0 6.8 6.1 6.6 0 

[11/24, [10114, [07/22, [10/21, [09/27, [ 10/09, 

08] 21] 08] 11) 01] 03] 

xanders was terminated on OS!l!l/92; •• - SampUng commenced at on 06/22193. 

Ut- 11.n1 ba....t on 1-than 78% aYIII.l.able data) 

eral Ambient Ale Owal.ity St.andud 

Monltarln<J &tatlon) 

{DJ.t• ot Oecurrenc:e. Endlno Hour) 

+ • eontxuenlion of NTS.IFedenll !IN}S 

NOTE: Sta11dard ol9 PPM Is not exceeded unleu 8-Hour average Is > 9.t PPM 
CARBON MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON-DIBPBBSIV 

GION l 

n AIR CONTROL REGION 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1983 THROUGH 1993 

A.NN'Q&.ARJ'I'HME'MC MP.AN (ppm} 

SITE NO. 1984 1988 1987 1988 1989 1991. 1993 

er Park 2950-10 1.3 L3 13 l.l 1.0 Ll (1.0} Ll !.0 0.9 0.8 

ISON BE'l'WEEN N.T.S. AMBmNT Ala QUALm AND .AMBmNT ADt QUALJ"''T STANllARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1993 

ONE-HOUR AVERAGE 

Muim\lln 1101 to tllU!8«i 311 ?PM more than 

per calan4ar yeu • 

NO. of OBSERVATIONS HIGHEST VALUES, PPM 

Total " >36 

SITE NO. Obis. Aftll. PPM J!! and 

2950-01 8,535 97 () 9.'1 

[12/17, 

221 

renlhe«M are bu&d on leu lha.n "JS'!!, anliabla data} 

d f'eden.l Jl.mblent Air Quallr; Standard 

 Air Monltorl"lg Station) 

8.5 

[lZ/17, 

231 

8.5 

[12/11, 

Z4] 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

MuimUm not to oQCMd 8 PPM_., ll'w\ 

o=t pac ,..r • f!ON·O\'BRLAPPlNO 

Total 9fo 

2.2!:: Aftfl. 

8,55'1 96 

OBS N<>.·n.,.. 

> 9 HIGHEST VAI,ut':S, PPM wtlh • ht 

PPM ..!!! lnd > 9 PPM 

0 6.6 

{11/10, 

03] 

5.6 5.4 0 

[l0/16, (12117, 

OS) 241 

[Data of Occurrenee, EndlnQ Hour) 

+ Oenotea a contraTemtlon ol NYS/f'aderAI A1'J:)S 

NCY!'E: Stand&rd o! S PPM l• not o:xcooded unleP 8-Hour average > S.i PPM 

.............. .............. .............. .. 
CARBON MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-RED 

GION 2 

LI'I'Y CONTROL REGION 

ANNUAL AVE.I.AGBilMt !fBJIOUGH 1892 

NRn1AL AlllHME'J'1C MfWl (ppn} 

 

!l 

mE NO, .liR 1883 l!!!!M .ll!R 18 1987 l!!ll 18 00 JB 

 Street 

TWISit 

s 

h Street 

8100-02N 

8100-03 

8100.04 

8100-06 

4.0 3.7 -4.0 

(4.2} 

3.7 

3.2 6.3 

3.6 

3.7 

4.6 

3.2 

3.5 

5.4 

3.3 2.9 2.8 2.8 3.1 

2.8 3.0 2.6 2.4 2.1 

4.6 4.4 4.0 4.3 (3.'1) 

(2.3) 2.3 . 2.1 

lSOH BETWEEN N.T.S. AMBmN'l .AIR OUALl'JT .AND AMBIEN'J.' Alll QUALI'l'Y S'l'.lNDAllDS FOR CALENilAil TEAR 1992 

OIIE-BOUI AVEJWJE RUIOONG 8 BOUI AVElliGE 

...,.._, nat lD -..s as PPM mana t1w1 

HO. ot OISEIVA'I'IOHI HIOHEI't VALUES. PPK 

.,.. " >31 

SITE KO. QI!L A!!& rlM .lJt ...1!1!1 

8100-0ZN 8,265 &4 0 13.6 13.1 11.8 

[06/19, [06/19, [OS/08, 

16) 13] 11] 

8100-03 8,376 95 0 10.8 10.2 10.2 

[04/16, [01/23, [05122, 

19) 14} 18] 

8100-04 3,306 38 .... 0 13.0 11.7 11.3 

[05/13, [03108, [05113, 

22] 01] 231 

8100-06 8,689 99 0 11.1 lO.S 9.S 

(10/lf!, (10/07, [10/18, 

23] 09] 13) 

• • • Sampling at Alennders was terminated on 05/21/93. 

are on lea than 7'"' aftl.la.ble data) 

ederal Ambient Ak Quality Slandani 

k MonllotU'IO S!aliol'l) 

MutzmlniDOt to tlliDMd • PPM INIIW ... 

..- Plf ,_, • 1!0N..QV'PT·A.PPING 

'l'otal " 

OJ:.. Aft11. 

8,268 94 

8,429 96 

3,325 38 

8,745 100 

OIS Na.o.,. 

> I HrOHES'1' VM..UES, PPM -... 1 11r 

1!!!M ..lm .,lag 3rq > 8 PPM 

0 9.2 8.8 8.5 0 

[07/28, [04120, [01/0S, 

21] 21] 01] 

0 7.9 7.8 8.8 0 

(01/23, [01/28, (08/22, 

14] 24) 19] 

0 9.2 8.8 7.3 0 

[03108, [05/14. {02/23, 

08] OIJ 03] 

0 7.1 6.6 6.4 0 

[10{16, [10/ll, {01/23, 

01} 07] 16] 

[Date of Occumutce, Idldlnq Hour] 

+ Denote. a. or Nl'S/FoderaJ AAQS 

Sl&ndard of 9 PPM llt no! exceeded union 8-Hcu: n•roge llt > 9. 4 PPM 
CARBON MONOXIDE .. CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-RED 

NYSDEC REG10N 2 

Metropolitan AIR QUALI'TY CONTROL REGION 

A.NNUA.L AVERAGES 1SI82 IJ'HIOUGH 11192 

ANNUAL AJU'l'HMETlC MEAN lPllln} 

&mNo. 1882 1983 11M ag 1988 00 UJ88 1989 . ,lg 1991 00 

cksmmndl 

1093-05 (1.3) ... ·-- ... . .. . .. 1.2 1.1 1.2 l.l l.O 

7093-10 ... ... ... --- ... ·- ... 1.7 1.6 VI 1.4 

7095-0SN (1.2) (1.2) 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.1 0.9 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.9 

ON BE'tWEEN N.T.S. AMBJENT Am OUALlTT AND AMBIBN'I' Am OlWJ'!T S'I'ANDAlU>S FOil CALE'N'DAll 'TEAll 1892 

Otm-HOUit AVElUWE 

Mulmum liCit ta 18 PPM an Ulan 

.... 

NO. of OBSEIVATIONS HIGHEST VALUES, PPM 

'fotd " >88 

'm.H.O"' Ql!lt ADL UM _llrt 

093-05 7,965 91 0 6.1 

[10/11. 

04] 

093-10 8,495 9'1 0 9.0 

[09/ZS, 

01] 

095-06N 8,628 98 0 8.3 

[05/10, 

24] 

tm1 bu«1 em -. lh&n 7e'li nallab"' da.ta) 

ral knbie.nt JUr Quallty Sta.nda.rd 

Monltof'ino Station) 

3rd 

6.0 6.0 

(10/11. [10/11, 

OS] 06] 

8.8 '1.0 

[10/29, (03/08, 

12] 03) 

4.9 4.9 

[03108, [OS/10, 

021 10] 

lltmNIHO I HOmt AV'EIAGB 

Ml.lldamlm DOt ta tiiiCM4 II PPM 1DD11t ftlu 

one. ,. c:at.nd&r ,...... • lfQif.QYBlUall.fPINO 

OBS Na..O.,. 

Total " >t HIGH:Em' VlU.UES, PPio( wiio ... !!!& U.M ..1!1 lnd _am > 8PPM 

1,9'10 91 0 4.8 3.9 3.2 0 

[10/11, {10/16, [03/08, 

08] 02] OS] 

8,668 98 0 4.9 4.4 3.8 0 

[03108, [10!18, [05/23, 

06] OZ] 04] 

8,894 99 0 3.6 3.2 3.2 0 

[11/21, (05/11, [10/11, 

10} 02) 08J 

{Date of Ox:ru.mmooo, £ndlnq flour] 

+ Denot• a contrannt!ol'\ of N'tS/F'eder-.1 AAQS 

NOTE: Standard of 9 PPM Ia not un!Ma 8-Ham aTenge II > 9.4 PPM 
CARBON MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-RED 

GION l 

'l'Y CON'I'ROL REGION 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1182 TBROUOB 199'.1 

AHNtlAL ARI'1HMBTIC MEAN (ppm) 

SJTB HQ, 1111 .uu 1M 1988 lW.l 1981 Ill 1190 lf!Bl liU 

r Pazk 29$0-10 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.1 1.0 l.l (1.0) l.l 1.0 0.9 

SON BB'tWE!H H.T.S. AMBIBN'l' AIR Otw.m' .11m AMBlBlfr All OUALITf' STANDARDS POl CALBNDAR 1'EWt 1891 

ORE-BOOK AVERA.C::E 

.. aaMadar ,_r. 

NO. of OIIEIVATIONS HKJBES'f VALUES. PPM 

'fotlll " >31 

srm NQ., 21:at A'!lls rzM ..111 ..1!!1 

2950-01 8,563 98 0 8.7 8.2 8.1 

[01/30, [01/01, (01/01, 

09) 24} 23) 

an biNd on ..,_ !han 7!1'16 an.Dable d..ta) 

danl Ambktnt .IUr Quality Slu1darcl 

MonltoriAg Gtallcm) 

RUNHJRG I HOUR AVEIUlG£ 

Mulmaln BOtto -t I PPM aa llall 

.,. r- aaMadar ,.r • JfON.on:R.LAPPJNQ 

'l'olal " A!!L 

8,581 98 

OBS ..... .,.,.. 

> 8 HiaHEa'1' VALUES, PPM wtdl I w 

ElM .111 Jl!d 3M > 8 PPM 

0 6.4 8.6 4.6 0 

[01/02, (12/16, (10/ll, 

03) 03] 05] 

[01111 oC Ooournlnce, Endlnv Hour] 

+ 0enot1111 a eontruantlcn of Nm/Ftldfnal M06 

NOTE: Slaltdard of 9 PPM .. 1101 aceedfld 8-Hout e:nll:aqe Ia > 9. 4 PPM 
CARBON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INfRA- REO 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1962 THROUGH !991 

QUAliTY CONTROl REGION ANNUAL ARITHMETIC 

SITE NO. 1982 1983 !984 1985 1986 !987 1988 1989 1990 1991 

---

und} Sites 

7093-05 ( 1. J) --- --- --- --- 1.2 1.1 1.2 1.1 7093-10 --- --- --- --- --- --- --- 1.7 1.6 1.4 

709S-06N {]. 2) ( 1. 2) l.3 1.2 1.2 l.l 0.9 1.0 1.0 0.9 

7096-07 --- --- --- --- --- --- 1.1 1.3 ••• *** 

BETWEEN N.Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY ANO AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANOAROS fOR CALENDAR YEAR 1994 

U1 

ONE- HOUR AVERAGE RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 0 

MoxllTIUrn- Not ro e•ceed 35 PPM more !han once Mo•imum -Not ro exceed 9 PPM more !han once 

per calendar year • per calendar yeor • NON- OVERLAPPING 

NO. Of OOSERVATIONS HIGHEST VALUES PPM' oes NO.ofOAYS 

•t. >35 TOTAL .. 1 .. >9 Highest Values- ppm ._ith Slv 

SITE NO. Total Avail. PPM ht 2nd }rd OBS Avail. PPM tsr 2nd 3rd >9PPM 

-- -- - ----- ------ -- -- -- -

7093-05 8300 95 0 7.5 6.0 6.0 8291 95 0 4.5 4.3 4.0 0 

[2/19,[2/19,[11/21, [2119, [ll/30,(11/22, 21] l2] 22] 22] 2] 1] 

7093-10 8121 93 0 8.8 8.2 7.4 .8106 93 0 6.0 4.7 4.5 0 

[2/19,[2/19 [7/16, [2/19, (l/16, [10/22. 22] 21) 12] 23] 24] 23] 

7095-0614 8461 97 0 6.9 6.7 6.2 8482 97 0 5.5 4.4 4.4 . 0 

(10/23,[2/19,[5/31, [ 5!31. t 4/JU. l s; 1. 

9) 20] 7] 9] 24] I] 

ce, hour or hour] 

"',..,n,.n.a•• .,.. bo••d on •••• than ovoHobl• do to) 

.... ,. C•rbon monox1dl! monftQring at PS112 was tenninated on 2!27!90. 

'-G.;. .-n.w•n •• ·., ..-•e •• it ".2.1 
CARBON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INFRA- REO 

ANNUAL AVERAGES t982 THROUGHI99i 

CONTROL REGION 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC MEAN- PPM 

SITE NO. 1982. 1983 1984 1985 1986 !1!! 1988 1989 1990 1991 

810Q-01N 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.0 3.3 3.1 3.0 (2.8) ....... *** 

8100-02N 4.0 3.7 4.0 3.7 3.6 3.2' 3.3 2.9 2.8 2.8 

8100-03 --- --- (4.2) 3.2 3.7 3.5 2.8 3.0 2.6 2.4 8100-04 --- --- --- 5.3 4.6 5.4 4.6 4.4 4.0 4.3 

8100-06 --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- (2.3) 2.3 

BETWEEN N.Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 199t 

ONE- HOUR AVERAGE 

Not to eaceed 35 PPM more than once 

per calendar yeor • 

NO. OF OBSERVATIONS HIGHEST VALUES PPM' 

SITE NO. Total 

0/o 

Avail. 

>35 

PPM 

---

Itt 2nd 3rd 

8100-0ZN 8312 '95 0 15.3 12.7 10.7 

[2/19,(11/29,(2/19, 

21) 21] 20] 

8100-03 7804 89 0 15.3 14.3 13.3 

(11/29,(2/6.[9/13. 

Zl] 11] 9] 

8100-04 8225 94 0 17.8 13.8 13.6 

[3/8, [7/26,[9/8, 

14] 11] 11] 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

Mcuimum -Not to tllcted 9 PPM more than 

per c:otendQr year • NON- OVEHLAPPING 

TOTAL 

OBS 

6296 

7768 

, 

8273 

o;. 

.!!!!!: 

95 

89 

94 

OBS >9 

PPM 

0 

1 

2 

NO.ofDAV 

Hi91'1est Volues - ppm witi181Y AY> 

br 2nd 3rd >9 PPM 

. 9.3 8.2 7.4 

(2/19,[11/30,(11/21, 

22) 1] 24] 

10.9 8.4 7.7 

[ll/30,[9/13,[11/21. 

2] 14] 23] 

10.9 9.6+ 9.3 

[2/19,[10/3,[11/21, 

24) 22] 23] 

0 

2 

8100-06 8083 92 0 13.4 13. 1 10.6 8099 92 0 9. 0 7. 2 6. 3 0 

ur or ending hourJ [2/19,[2/19,(2/19, [2/19,(tl/22,(2/19, 

arenthnuorebosedoniUtlhonT5%oYailo01tltotol 21) 22) 18) 23] 2] 15] 

4 F.e•tol Ambient Atr Qvolity Standard tAAQSl •• ·t,on monoxide monitoring at 45th St. was terminated on 7/27/89. 

of N•w 'for• Stot•/f•ftrol Amllltat Alr Quolltf vd NOTE: STANOARO Of' 9pp"' IS NOT EXCEEOEO UNLESS 8·HOUR AVERAGE IS > 9 

ir Uonitorino Stotto-nl 
CARBON- MONOXIOE- CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-REO 

ANNUAL AVERAGES f98Z THROUGH 1994 

UTY CONTROL REGION 

ANNUAL ARITHME fiC MEAN- PPM 

SITE NO 1982 1983 1984 1985 f986 1981 1988 1989 1990 

-----

2950-10 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.1 1.0 1.1 ( 1.0) 1.1 1.0 

TWEE,_. N Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR t99f 

SITE NO. 

 2950-10 

ONE -HOOR AVERAGE 

Maximum- Not to 35 PPM more !han once 

per calendar year • 

NO. OF' OBSERVATIONS HIGHEST VALUES Pf'!!t 

% >'35 

Total Avoil. PPM 2nd '3rd 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

MoJ.Jmum- No! to e•ceed 9PPM more than once 

per calendar yea( • NON- OVERLAPPING 

TOTAL 

OBS 

% 

Avail. 

OBS >9 

PPM 

NO.ofOAYS 

Highest Values- ppm witM3hrAvq. .J.!.!.... 2nd >9 PPM 

6596 98 0 1L4 11.3 10.5 8644 99 

(1/15, 

0 8.7 6.6 6.4 

[11/14,(2/5, [l/29. 

24) 2] 4] 

0 

9] 22) 23] 

ur or endfng hour) 

••u- IS ,..<.H ()<C££0(0 UNLESS 8·1iOtJR AVfRAG[ IS> 9 4 
CARBON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- OtSPERSf'IE fNFR A- REO 

ANNUAL AVERAGES f98f THROUGH 1990 

ARITHMETIC MEAN- PPM 

SIT£ NO. t98t t982 1983 1984 1985 1996 1987 1988 !989 1990 

ality Regfon -Traffic Sites 

8100-0JN 4.6 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.0 3.3 J. 1 3.0 (2.8) ... 

8)00-0?N 4.0 4.0 3.7 4.0 3.7 3.6 3.2 3.3 2.9 2.8 

8100-03 - - - ( 4. 2) l.Z 3.7 3.5 2.8 3.0 2.6 

8100-04 - - - - 5.3 4.6. 5.4 4.6 4.4 f.O 

8100-06 - - - - - • - - - (2.3) 

WEEN N. Y S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR t990 

AVERAGE RUNNfHG 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

Moll.,_,- Not to 35 PPM thon once Moaimum ·Not to beeed 9 PPM more than once 

• IN" cotendar year per calendar yeor • 

NO. OF t-tG£ST VALUES PPM 

NON- OVERLAPPING 

085 NO off)AY! 

•t. >35 TOTAL "'!. >9 Hiqhtst VOiues- ppm ""ith8hrAv<; 

SITE NO. Total Avoil. PPM ht 2nd 3rd OBS A•oil. PPM tst Znd 3rd >9PPM 

-- ----

8100-02tf 8418 96 0 16.6 ll.l 12.9 6438 96 1 10.1 8.9 7.7 1 

[2/1B,t4][J/ll,[J/1l, [3/11, [2/16,(12/15, 

20] 18-19} Z4) lO] 17] 

8100-0.J 8477 97 0 15.5 ll.l 11.9 8512 97 1 9.6 9.4 9.0 

(4/30,11][2/15,[2/lS, [2/16, r uts . r ua . 

100-04 8549 9ll 0 17.0 18] 15.0 17] 14.9 8568 98 4 11l 1.3 20] 16] 10.8+ 10.8+ J 

[4/17,11](10/23,[12/22, [3/JJ. r 4121. £ •tv t. 

17] t9] 24] 15 J 14) 

100-06 2327 27 0 1J .J 9.2 R.S 7329 27 0 6.9 6.3 6.2 0 

[JI/1,21][9/ZS,[IlllZ, [11[1. [12ll5,(JI{27, 

t"- O'leii«J .. dolo) 12] J8J 24 J 17] 27] 

ret ,..., .. It! Air Out!lfy UAOSl [Date of occurrent::e 1 hour or ending hour) 

f .... Yotl Stete/F.._,ol Amb1t11t Air OuoHtr Sr.,.clclr4 l'tOf£.: STAfo!OARD Of 9ppm IS "Of ( l!C[{0£0 IJHl.£SS II·HOtJR AVERAGE IS :> 9 

ilot'inqStulioot) •**Carbon IIIIJr,oxfde monitoring at 45th St. was_ terminated on 7/27/89. 
CARSON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS ___ , __ NON -DISPERSIVE INFRA- RED 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1981 THROUGH 1990 

MEAN- PPM 

SITE NO 1961 t982 1983 1984 !9B5 1966 1987 

 Qua IHy tes 

7093-0S 1.3 (1.3} 

709S-06N 

7096-07 

(1. 2) (1. 2) J.] 1.2 1.2 1.1 

1988 1989 1990 

L2 1.1 1.2 

1.7 1.6 

0.9 1.0 1.0 

1.1 l.3 ••• 

BETWEEN H. Y S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY $TANOAROS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1990 

ONE - HOOR AVERAGE RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

Not lo 35 PPM more! ttton onrt Maximum · Not. to e•ceed g PPM more thon cnte 

pe!r colendor yeor • 

NO. Of VAU.J£5 PPM 

per cotenoor reor • NON - OVERLAPPING 

085 

"1. > 35 TOTAL •;. > 9 HiQhesl Votues- ppm 

SITE NO. Total Avoil PPM 2nd Jrd OBS Awoil. 

7093-05 8309 95 0 8.3 7.6 7.5 8357 95 0 6.6 3.9 3.7 

[2!16, [2/16,[2/Hi, [2/16, (1/17, (12!11. 

16] 14) 15] 20] 13) 17] 

7093-10 8352 95 0 A.1 7.2 7.2 8380 96 0 5.9 5.9 4.8 

[6/26, [Z/16,[4/16, [2/16, (3/13, [3/12, 

) 1] 16] 12] 21] 22] 1] 

7095-06N 8605 98 0 8.1 7.7 6.8 8671 99 0 5.6 4.1 4.1 

[1/17, [ll/15,[12/15. [12/15,[2/16,[9/27, 

R] 13] 14} 17] 17] 4J 

7096-07 1344 0 11.6 9.4 0.6 1343 15 0 6.0 S.7 4.1 

fl/17, [1/17. [1/16, (l/17, [2/16,[1/16, 

en I>Qud 0111c, u,.,.., 7!\ "!., o•o•I<Jblc dolo) I 0 J 9 J I I J 14 J 20] 131 

, F,.,., 0, Amb*-' Ar. o'""'*'' s'"""" 1 AAOS 1 [Date of occurrence, hour or end1 ng hour J 

NO of DAYS 

.Hth8hrAvg. 

>9PPM 

---

0 

0 

0 

0 

 nlloft of fi•• Yor• Sta It/ f..,_tOl A"'blenl Air QvalltJ StonNtd HOT E: S TAttOARO Of 9ppl!l !S NOT XCf £0(0 IJI'tU: SS I.Ht()UR AV(RAij( 15 > 9 4 PO"' 

Air Montto""9 Sh1tiool .,.,.,.Carbon monoxide monitoring at f'Stl2 was terminated on 2/27/90. 

I 

.... 

Y' 
CARBON- MONOllOE .- CONTINUOUS NON-DISPERSIVE INFRA-REO 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1981 THROUGHt990 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC 

SITE NO. t99f f982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 

lftx Contro1_Reg1on 

10 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.1 1.0 1.1 ( 1. 0) 1.1 

EEN N. Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY ANO AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANOAROS F'OR CALENDAR YEAR t990 

ONE -HOOR AVERAGE 

M<nimum- Not to eaceed 35 PPM more thon Ol'ltt 

ITE NO. 

10 

per cotendor reor • 

NO. OF OOSERVATIONS 

•t. >35 

Total Avoil. PPM 

--

8446 96 0 

HG£ST VALUES PPM 

tst 2nd 3rd 

-----

11.9 11.5 10.8 

[l/17,9](11/14,[12/7, 

hour or ending hour] 

ore band o" ltu thon 75°/0 ""''lloble dolo I 

ot Ami>"'"' Air Qvollty Sta,..Jtll'd ( AAQS) 

21] 9] 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

MOlimUIII- Nof 1o e•tetd 9 PPM more fhon onet 

per calendar reor • NON -OVERLAPPING 

085 NO of DAYS 

TOTAL .. ,. ).g values ppm wittiBtw Avg. 

085 Avoil. PPM bf 2nd )rd >9PPM 

-- ---- --

8503 97 0 7.8 7.2 6.6 0 

[1217. [11/15, [1/17. 

1] 1) 10] 

f Htw Yor\ Stole/fe ..... ot Mtbltnl Air Oucrllfy S .... rd NOTE: STANOARO Of" 9ppm IS NOT [XCE£0£0 UNLESS 8·HOIJR AV[RA(j[ IS > 9 4 QPII 

iOHJ>9 Slolionl 

I 

r 

( 
CARBON- MONOKIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INFRA- REO 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1980 THROUGH 1989 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC MEAN- PPM 

SITE NO t980 1961 1982 198:3 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 t989 -- -- --

-

8100-0lN 5.2 4.6 4.0 4. l 4. 2 4.0 3.3 3.1 3.0 (2.8) 

8100-0:2N 4.0 4.0 4.0 3. 7 4.0 3.7 3.6 3.2 3.3 2.9 

8100-03 - - - - ( 4. 2) 3.2 3.7 3.5 2.8 3.0 8100-04 - - - - .. 5.3 4.6 5.4 4.6 4.4 

WEEN N. Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBfENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR t989 

SITE NO. 

8100 OlN 

Bl00-02N 

8100-04 

8100-04 

ONE- HruR AVERAGE 

Morimum • Not to exceed 35 PPM more than once 

per calendar year • 

NO. OF OBSERVATIONS HiGHEST VALUES PPM 

Total 

4867 

8372 

91 41 

8172 

0/o 

Avoil. 

56 

96 

93 

93 

>35 

PPM 

0 0 

0 

0 

1st 2nd 3rd 

14.2 13.9 13.0 

[1/24, (3/15,11/24, 

101 20 l 9 J 

14.6 13.8 13.7 

[3/15, !3/18,[1/23, 

19} 151 18] 

15.3 15.2 14.3 

(10/26,(10/26,{3/15, 

22) 23) 21) 

17.5 17.0 16.6 

r a;u, r 8/29, r 1;23, 

hour or ending hour] 141 18) 11) 

RUNNING 9 HOUR AVERAGE 

Moximum- Not to exceed 9 PPM more thon once 

per catendor yeor • 

TOTAL 

OBS 

o/o 

4904 56 

8454 96 

8218 94 

8169 93 

OBS 

>9 

PPM 

2 

2 2 

16 

NON- OVERLAPPING 

I NO of DAYS 

Highesl Volues - ppm w,th 8tv Avg. 

tst 2nd 3rd >9 PPM 

9.5 9.5+ 9.2 

[1/24, [3/15,(1/30, 

14] 23} 151 

9.9 9.6+ 8.3 

[3/15, [l/23,[10/28, 

21) 23j 221 

12.3 10.4+ 9.0 

[10/27,(7/5, (3/15, 

2) 20] 23] 

11.9 ll.S+ll.l+ 

[l/15, [8/22,(3/28, 

221 21] 201 

2 

2 

2 

15 

hunarellO!Cedonlusthon75o/,avoilabltdoto) NOTE: Carbon monoxide monitoring at llO E. 45th St. was terminated 

deral Ambient Air Quality Standard !AAQS) on 7/27/89. 

n of Hew Yorlc Stofl/ FetlerCJI Ambient Air Ouolily Stondord NOTE; S lMmARO OF 9ppm IS NOT EXCEEDED UNLESS 6 HCUR AVE.f'AG[ ,5 > 9, 4 f 

onolorinq Sloi>On) 
CARBON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INFRA- RED 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1980 THROUGH 1989 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC 

SiTE NO. 1980 198i 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 

7093-05 1.3 1.3 ( 1.3) 

.7093-10 

7095-06N - - ( 1. 2) (1.2) 1.3 1.2 1.2 

7096-07 

1987 

1.1 

1988 ,989 

1.2 l.l 

0.9 

1.1 

1.7 

1.0 

1.3 

TWEEN N Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1989 

ONE- HOOR AVERAGE B,ill:!NING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

Not lo eaceed 35 PPM more than once 

per calendar year * Maximum-Not to exceed 9 PPM more thon once per calendar year • 

f'«J. OF OBSERVATIONS HIGHEST VALUES PPM OBS >9 

PPM 

ole. >'35 

SITE NO. 

---

Total Avail. PPM 

7093-05 8256 94 0 

7093-10 7672 88 0 

7095-0ESN 7907 89 0 

7096-07 8292 95 0 

 hour or ending hour] 

lhtsn are bosed Ofl tess thon 75°/o ovoiloble do1o I 

Ftdtrol Ambltnl Air OUGity Slandard (A AQ S l 

lSI 2nd 3rd 

TOTAL 

OBS 

"/o 

Avail. 

9.0 7.9 7.8 

(l/24,(3/15,[3/15, 

S) 201 191 

8326 95 

9.7 8.9 7.4 

20) 19] 221 

7703 88 

10.4 9.7 9.5 7822 89 

[10/26,(10/26,(10/25, 

23] 22] 9} 

12.0 10.3 10.2 8281 94 

(1/24, [10/25,110/27, 

9) 24) 2) 

0 

0 

0 

0 

NON- OVERLAPPING 

\ NO of 

Highest Values - ppm wittl Bhr Av'" 

lsr 2nd 3rd >9 PPM 

6.1 5.5 4.9 

ll/24,{10/27,{3/15, 

101 7) 22} 

6.5 6.1 5.8 

{3/15,(10/28,[10/24, 

231 31 131 

7.9 5.4 4.6 

[10/27,{10/26.[1/24, 

3l 3} 13) 

7.9 6.9 6.5 

[10/27,{1/24, {1')/26, 

4) 10] 2) 

0 

0 

0 0 

on of Nt• 't'orli. Stolt/fe411ro1 Ambient Air Quality Stonclorlf NOTE: STANDARD Of 9ppm IS NOr EXCE.EDEO UNLESS 8·HOVR All( RAGE IS > 9 

Mt>nilori119 Station) 
CARBON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INFRA- RED 

SITE NO 

2950-10 

1980 

1.3 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1980 THROUGH 1989 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC MEAN- PPM 

1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 !986 

1.3 1.3 1.3 1 '3 L3 1.1 

1987 1988 1989 

1.0 l .1 ( l '0) 

WEEN N.Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1989 

SITE NO. 

2950-10 

ONE - HOUR AVERAGE 

Mo•imum- Not to exceed 35 PPM more than once 

per col!f'ldar yeor • 

NO Of OBSERVATIONS HIGHEST VAlUES PPM 

o/o '>35 

Total Avail. PPM 1st 2nd 3rd 

----

6274 72 0 10.0 9.9 9.7 

110/24,(10/25,{11/6, 

9] 91 23) 

hour or ending hour} 

hns orr bou<l Ofi Its! I han 75%, ovollotllt! dora l 

derol Ambltmt A!r Quolily StandanS ( AAQSJ 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

Maximum-Nor to exceed 9PPM more than once 

per calendar year • 

TOTAL 

OBS 

6296 

o/o 

AVO! I. 

72 

085 

>9 

PPM 

0 

NON- OVERLAPPING 

1 NOofDMS 

Highest Values- ppm with8hrAvq. 

tf,r 2nd >9 PPM 

7.0 6.5 6.1 

(10/28,[11/7,[10/27, 

3 J 3) 2) 

0 

of N1w York Stall/ Ftdtro! Ambltnl Alt Qualify Standard NOT [; STANDARD Of 9ppm IS NOT E XCE EOEO UNL£ SS 8 ·HOUR AVERAGE IS > 9 4 p 

n1totm9 Slohon) 
CARBON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INFRA- RED 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1980 THROUGH t989 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC MEAN· PPM 

- -

SITE NO. _1_W t981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 t986 1989 - -

7093-05 1.3 }.3 ( 1. 3) -

-

-

-

- 1.2 1.1 

-

-

-

-

- 1.7 

7093-10 -

-

-

7095-06N -

- (1.2) (1.2) 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.1 0.9 1.0 

- 1.1 1.3 

7096-07 

WEEN N 1. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR !989 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVERAGE 

ONE- HOUR AVERAGE 

Moxtrnum· Not to exceed 35PPM more than once 

per calendar year • 

Maximum-Not to exceed 9PPM mote than onGt 

per calendar year • 

!:&.Qf OOSERVATIONS VALUES PPM 

TOTAL 

OBS 

0/o 

OBS >9 

PPM 

SITE NO. 

7093-05 

7093-10 

Total 

8256 

7672 

709S-06N 7907 

7096-07 8292 

% >35 

tst 2od 3rd Avail. PPM 

8326 95 

94 

88 

89 

95 

0 9.0 7.9 7.8 

ll/24,{3/15,(3/15, 

a 1 201 191 

0 9.7 8.9 7.4 

{3/15,[3/15,[3/lS, 

20] 19} 22} 

7703 sa 

0 10.4 9.7 9.5 7822 89 

{10/26,(10/26,{10/25, 

231 22] 9) 

12.0 10.2 8281 

[1/24, {10/25.110/27, 

9} 241 2) 

94 

0 

0 

0 

0 

0 

NON- OVERLAPPING 

·\ NO. of 

Highesl Values - ppm with Bhr Avg 

..J£_ 2nd >9 PPM 

6.1 5.5 4.9 0 

[1/24,(10/27,13/15, 

101 7l 221 

6.5 6.1 s.e o 

t 3/15' {l0/28, [ 10i24' 

23} 3! u: 

7.9 5.4 4.8 

(10/27,{10/26,(1/24, 

3) 3] 131 

7.9 6.B 6.5 

(10/27.11/24, {10/26. 

4] lO) 2] 

c 

0 

 hour or ending houri 

lltsfl Oft band 011 IUS than 75°/o O'II!Jiloblt dolo) 

AmOienl AlrQUOIIIJ IAAQSl 

on of New Yorlt Stott/Fede!ol Ambient Air QuoiiiJ Slonlk!ul 

NOTE: STANDARD OF 9pp!11 IS NOf EXCEEDED UNLESS 8·1't0UR AVERAGE IS > 9 

MnniforifiQ Stohonl 
CARBON- MONOXIOE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INFRA- RED 

-

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1979 THROUGH 1988 

ARITHMETIC MEAN· PPM 

SITE NO 1979 t980 19tH 1982 t983 1984 !985 i966 1987 1968 

J 8100-0lN 5.6 5.2 4.6 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.0 J. J ).1 3.0 

8l00-02N <1.5 4.0 4.0 <1.0 J. 7 4.0 3.7 3.6 3.2 3.3 8100-03 - -

-

-

- ( <1. 2) 3.7 3.7 ).5 <!.8 

-

- S.J 4.6 5.4 <1.6 

8100-04 

TWEEN N.Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY ANO AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR !988 

RUNNING B HOUR AVERAGE ONE- HOUR AVERAGE 

Mox•mum· Not to uceed 35 PPM more than once Mm1mum ·Not to exceed 9 PPM mort fhon once 

per calendar year • 

NO Of OBSlRVATIONS 

per calendar year • 

"'/o > 35 

SITE NO. Total Avo11 PPM 

 l 8100-0lN 8142 93 0 

81D0-02N 8136 93 0 

2l 8100-03 7588 t3b 0 

8100-04 7682 87 0 

HIGHEST 

TOTAL 

1st 2nd 3rd OBS 

----· 

14.0 11.6 11 . 5 8164 

[l/25,8}{1/18,(6/15, 

10] 1 i J 

16.6 15.3 8124 

(7/ll,15l[ll/26,(11/26, 

19] lGl 

14 '0 1 3 . 7 1 J . 2 7 4 79 

IS/18,17][1/25, [5/17, 

17) 171 

23.0 21.7 19.5 7672 

[6/2?,1GI!7/ll, 

.! 1! 

! b/2t. 

lil 

nee, hour· or endl nq hour l 

n1tltl''"e" \U« on IKon ova1loblt datn l 

 ft>detol A.mbioel"t Air Ouantt (AAOS) 

Hof\" of N•• Vo.rk Stat• / Fac:Mtol Amb••n't Aif QyaUty Stondcud 

CBS 

"fo >9 

PPM 

93 0 

93 4 

85 s 

87 26 

NON -OVERLAPPING 

NO ol DAYS 

Highest varues - ppm witl'lBhr Avg. 

Is! 2nd 3rd >9 PPM 

8.9 a.s 8.3 0 

[5/31, [4/4, (2/1,23] 

161 151 

12.0 ll.7+ 11.5+ 4 

[8/31, [2/15 .. [11/26, 

15] l9l 22) 

10.8 10. 7+ 10. H 5 

(5/6, [l/7S,[5/lB,l7l 

2.1.] 18j 

13.9 13.5> 11.6> 21 

{6/22. !7/11, [8/l), 

171 1 a 1 211 

w ' 

"' ' 
CARBON- INFRA- REO 

tes 

• 1988 

... ARITHMETIC MEAN- PPM 

) SITE NO. 1979 1980 1981 !2B 1983 1'*34 1985 1986 1987 1988 -- -

(2) 8100-01N 5.6 5.2 4.6 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.0 3.3 ].1 3.0 

2l 8100-02N 4.5 4.0 4.0 4.0 3.7 4.0 3.7 3.6 3.2 3. 3 

it(21 8100-03 - - - - - ( 4. 2 J 3.2 3.7 3.5 2.8 

 8100-04 - - - - - 5.3 4.6 5.4 4.6 

BETWEEN N Y. 5. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY. STANDARDS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1988 

ONE- HOUR AVERAGE 

Ma•1mum- Not to exceed 35 PPM more than once 

per calendar yeat • 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVE RAGE 

Moxtmum- Not to ewcted 9 PPM more once 

per coiendor year • 

NO OF OBSERVATIONS VA_LUES PPM 08S 

a/., >35 TOTAL % >9 

SITE NO. Tofal A ... a.t. PPM 1st 2nd 3rd OBS PPM 

(21 8100-0lN 8142 93 

) tH00-02N 8136 93 

t(2) 8100-03 7588 86 

0 

0 

0 

14.0 11.6 1:.s 

(l/2S,B}[l/l8,[6/l5, 

10] ll] 

8164 

t7.5 16.6 15.) 8124 

( 7/11, lSI ( ll/26, I 11/26, 

19 I l6l 

1].7 13.2 7479 

(5/18,17){1/25, (S/17, 

171 l7 J 

8100-04 7682 87 0 23.0 21.7 19.5 7672 

(6/22,16)i7/ll, iE./22, 

ence, hour or endinq 17 I ) 71 

ren!htses c•e bosed on ltn •non •::. y.., o•o•loC!tt dolo) 

nd F•d•rol Ambt.ant Au QJJalily Stondrwd ( AAOS) 

93 0 

93 4 

85 5 87 26 

NON- OVfRLAPPING 

NO. of DAYS 

Hig11es1 Values - ppm w•ttl Bhr Avg 

hi 2nd 3rd >9 PPM 

8,9 8.5 8.3 0 

{5/]1, (4/4, [2/1,231 

16! 15) 

12.0 11. 7+ II. 5+ 4 

(8/31, 

151 191 22] 

10.8 10.7+ 10.1+ 5 

(5/6, ll/25' [5/18. 17 J 

21] 18 I 

.:. 3. 9 13.5-+ 11.6+ 21 

[6/22, 

l7l lf!l 2 l I 
CARBON- MONOXIDE - CONTINUOUS NON- DISPERSIVE INFRA• RED 

ANNUAL AVERAGES 1979 THROUGH 1988 

ANNUAL ARITHMETIC MEAN- PPM 

STATION 

l SITE NO 1979 \980 1981 1982 1983 19B4 1965 !986 

-- --

Eisenhower Park(ll 29SO-l0 1.2 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 ].] l.l 

(tong Island) 

COMPARISON BETWEEN N.Y. S. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR CAL

STATION 

(£neon Reg•on) SITE NO. -·---

Eisent1owel Pat·i< ( l) 2950-10 

(Low; ; " 1 and l 

ONE· HOUR AVERAGE 

• Not to 35 PPM more tnon once 

per calendar year • 

NO. OF OBSERVATIONS HIGHEST VALUES PPM 

Ofo >35 

Total Avail. PPM 

7967 ')l 0 

1st 

11;12' 

10] 

2nd 3rd 

12.3 ll.9 

[1/ll,!ll/22, 

10 l 21] 

[Date of occurrence 1 or er1ding houri 

(Annual Mean:. 10 ·:lre bo,ed on ltss O\l'otloble ctnto) * N.,. tQrk S1ate on<! Amb...,l Air Q...,klw Slandwd {AAOSl 

"'t Opot•• o COf\tU•v•ft-Uott of New Yortt 

RUNNING 8 HOUR AVE

Maximum· Not !o exceed 9 PPM m

per calendar year • 

TOTAL 

oas 

7983 

o;., 

91 

OBS >9 

PPM 

1 

NON- 

Highest 

IST 

9.9 

111/26, 

3 I 
THIS PAGE LEFT INTEl\'TIOr\ALL Y BLANK 

THIS 

PACiE LEfT 

INTENTIONALLY 

BLANK 

THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK