CD e1:22-cv-24066-KM M Docum ent171 Entered on FLSD Docket02/02/2024 Page1 of3

IN TH E UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

CaseNo.1:22-cv-24660-11M M

GIRACE,1.nc.,etal.,

Plaintfg,

CITY OF M IAM I,

Defendant.

FILED BY D.C.

FE2 25 2224

ANGELAE.NOBLE

CLERKUS DIS'ECQ

s.D.olz/.l..k.-MIAMI

NOTW E OFFILU G DEFENDANT'SEXHIBITSADM ITTED AT TRIAL

PursuanttoLocalRule5.3(b)(2),DefendantherebyfilesthisNoticeofFilingDefendant's

ExhibitsAdmitled atTrialduring January 29-30,2024.The following isa listofa11Exhibits

admitted,witheachExhibitattachedhereto.l

D 's Dèscription

Exhibk

No. .

1 Ci ofM inm iResolutionR-21-0485

2 Ci ofM iam iResolutionR-22-0030

3 Ci ofM iamiResolutionR-22-0031

4 Ci ofM iamiResolutionR-22-0032

5 Ci ofM iamiResolutionR-22-0033

6 Ci ofM iamiResolutionR-22-0070

7 Ci ofM iam iResolutionR-22-0085

8 Ci ofM iamiResolutionR-22-0114

9 Ci ofM iam iResolutionR-22-0117

10 Ci ofM inmiResolutionR-23-0171

12 Ci ofM iamiResolutionR-22-131ado tin EnactedPlan,witllexhibit

13 Ci ofM iam iM asterRe ortonResolutionR-22-131

22 ConsultantPresentationsmadetothéM iamiCityCommissiononNovember18,

2021

1Defendant'sExhibit30containsgigabytesofvolmninousinfoln ationregardingcensusdata. ThisExhibitwill

insteadbephysicallyfiledwiththeCourtviaathumbdrive.

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 175 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2024 Page 1 of 3
C* e1:22-cv-24066-KM M Docum ent171 Entered On FLSD Docket02/02/2024 Page2 of3

A

23 ConsultantPresentationsmadetotheM inmiCityComm ission on February7,

2022

24 ConsultantPresentationsmadetotheM iam iCityComm ission on February25,

2022

29 P.L.94-171Redistrictin D ataforCi ofM iami

30 DatautilizedandreliedonbyCityofM iarniConsultr tsindrawingEnacted

Plan,includingcurentandhistoricdem ographicdata,andcurrentandhistoric

electionsdata

34 RediskictingM iami2022,RevisedDistrictingPlanReportbyM iguelA.De

Grand ,Es .andSte hen M .Cod ,J.D .datedFebnla 22,2022

55 Ex ertRe ort-JohnAlford,Ph.D.

58 DocumentsproducedbyPlaintiffsandtheirexperts,includingPlaintiffs'expez't

re orts,Plaintiffs'Plans1throu h4,andtheassociateddemo a hicdata

61 A11dem onstrativeexhibits

62 JohnAlford,Ph.D.U datedCurriculum Vitae

63 Sl'mm of2018Votin Data

Respectfully subm ittedonFebl'uary2,2024.

I By:/s/ChristopherN Johnson

:

GRAYROBINSON,P.A .

JasonL.Unger

FloridaBarNo.991562

Jason.lmcero cav-l'obinson.com

GeorgeT.Levesque

FloridaBarNo.55551

Georae.levesuue@grav-robinson.com

AndyBardos

FloridaBarNo.822671

Andv.bardos@aray-robinson.com

301S.BronoughStreet,Suite600

Tallahassee,Flodda32301

Telephone:(850)577-9090

Facsimile:(850)577-3311

ChristopherN.Johnson

FloridaBarNo.69329

Christophel'.lou son@arav-robinson.com

MarleneQuintana,B.C.S.

FloridaBarNo.88358

Mrlene.ouintana@ lay-robinson.com

FabianA.Ruiz

FloridaBarNo.117928

Fabiml.Oizo crav-robùzson.com

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 175 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2024 Page 2 of 3
Case1:22-cv-24066-KM M Docum ent171 Entered on FLSD Docket02/02/2024 Page3 of3

JessicaD .Santos

FloridaBarNo.1038776

Jessica.s> toso vav-robinson.com

SydneyM .Feldm an

FloridaBarNo.1017798

SyA ey.feldm=@gray-robinson.com

333 S.E.2ndAvenue,Suite3200

M iarni,Florida33131

Telephone:(305)416-6880

Facsimile:(305)416-6887

CITY OFM IAMI

VictoriaM éndez,CityAttorney

FloridaBarNo.194931

JohnA.Greco,ChiefDeputyCityAttorney

FloridaBarNo.991236

KevinR.Jones,DeputyCityAtlonaey

FloridaBarNo.119067

EricJ.Eves,AssistantCityAttorney

FloridaBarNo.91053

OfficeoftheCityAttom ey

444 SW 2ndAvenue

M iam i,Florida33130

Telephone:(305)416-1800

Facsimile:(305)416-1801

CERTI-FICATE OF SERW CE

1HEREBY CERTIFY thatonthe2ndofFebt'uary2024,1electronicallyfiledtheforegoing

docum entwith the Clerk ofthe Coul'tusing CM /ECF,which willservethis docum enton a11

cotm selofrecordviatransm issionofN oticesofElectronicFilinggeneratedby CM /ECF.

By:/s/ChristopherA2Johnson

i

3

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 175 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2024 Page 3 of 3