UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT

SO UTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

M ALVIN GARNETT,M INOR NCG

PLAINTIFF

V.

LesliePtlzo,DikshaM ehan Shanna,JudgeGeorgeSarduy,

PriscilleDuvalsaint,GeneralM agistrateCarlosFernandez,PriscilleDuvalsaint,

Yasm inM orshedian,

RESPONDENT.

CASE NO.:22-CV-23543-A1.FATWA

REOUEST FOR EXTEN SION AND PROPOSED ORDER

COM ESNOW ,thePlaintiff,M ALVIN GARNETT,bymeansofprose,and

hereby filesthisrequestforextension.

1. lntheexistencetofollow OnDecember11,2022,theplaintiffrequestedfrom the

Judgesolutionforsubstituteserviceandhasnotifiedthecotlrsewithevidenceof

attemptsofserviceforallpartiesthatwerenotservedatthetimePriscilleDuvalsaint,

M arieLiautaud,andLesliePtzzoEsq.

2. OnJanuary6,2023thepetitionersentanconferm entofconferralmskingifthey

objecttoemailormailforservice.OnJanuary24,2023LesliePuzowasservedshe

alsorespondedfrom thatem ailaddressbutnottothewaiveofservice.OnJanuary

24,2023PriscilleDuvalsaintrespondedfrom theemailaddressbutdidnotrespondto

thewaiveofservice.EXHIBIT 1

3. Thepersonsinquestiontobeservedisbreakingthelaw .JudgeW illinm Haury

orderedtofollow thelaw forPriscilleDuvalsaintto changeheraddressondrivers

licenseSeptember21,2021.TheprivateinvestigatorhasstatedtheM aritalhom e437

SW 3rdst. //4M iam i,FL 33130istheaddressonherlicensestillasofJanuary 14,

2023.Healso stated shehasanAudi2022registeredtothemaritalhom easwell.The

processserveronJanuary24,2023byaskingbuildingm anagementhasstatedthe

address2321LagunaCircleApartm ent709thatthepartiesinquestion liveatthe

home.Theplacethathasover10attemptsonthepartiesandthefollowingpersons

confinnedlivethere.Thepetitionerisrequestingfororderofextensiontoserve.

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 1 of 11
Therehastobeasteakoutbytheprocessserverduetothetwopartiesintentionally

evading service.

4. OnJanuary26,20235outof7defendantshavebeen servedthelasttwoliveinthe

housetogether.Todenyjusticethepartiesarenotansweringthedoorandaremade

awareofthe1aw suitandhaveseenitbycertifiedmail.

5. Tofurthersolidifythetargetslocation,em ailaddressonJanuary20,2022 were

confirmed byLesliePtlzoby slingamotiontowithdraw from thefam ilycaseandit

statesalltheinformationthatthepetitionerisstatingforservice.EXHIBIT 2

6. Itseem swhathasmatteredinpreviouscaselaw istheattemptswerelatedueto

negotiatingorinvestigatingthecmselaw.lnthiscasehasbeenatleast10attemptson

nam edpersonM arieLiautaudandPriscilleDuvalsaint.

7. Thepetitionerhassentcertitiedmailtothefollowingpartiesforservicerequestingto

waiveservicewiththesumm onsandlitigationdocum entsof52pages.Servicestates

Yotlritem wasdeliveredtothefrontdesk,receptionarea,orm ailroom at12:26pm

onJanuary9,2023inM IAM I,FL 3318I.EXHIBIT 3

8. Ascertificateofconferral,a11partieswereasked.

çtAskingfordefendantspositionsonmotionforextensiontoserve2more

parties.Pleaserespondin 24hoursorwillbelievenooppositiontotherequest.''

AttorneysLesliePtlzoandDikshaMehanSharmaareobjectingtothismotiontoextension.

LesliePuzohasstatedt1objecttotheextensionoftime.''

DikshaShannahasstated1tlobjectsopleasedonotcertifythatthereisnoobjectionfrom

ourend.Thanks.tt

çRespectfully,notsurethatwehavetoprovideareason,butitappearsthattherehasbeen

enoughtim eandextensionsgivenpreviouslyalreadysothatwouldbeourreason.''

TherehasnotbeenanextensionevergrantedinthiscaseregardingattorneySharma's

statem ent.

10.Thiscaseisofconstitutionalcivilrightsthatwereabusedofam inorchildandfather.

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 2 of 11
11.Rule4(9permitsserviceonanindividual,otherthanaminor,anincompetentperson,

orapersonwhosewaiverhasbeenfiled,ataplacenotwithinanyjudicialdistrictof

theUnitedSàtes,byoneofthreemeans.UnderRule4(943),courtscanorderservice

throughavarietyofm ethods,ttincludingpublication,ordinarymail,mailtothe

defendantslmstknownaddress,deliverytothedefendant'sattom ey,telex,andm ost

recently,email,''providedhereisnointernationalagreem entdirectlytothecontrary.

RioProps.,Inc.v.ltioIntern.lnterlink,284F.3d1007,1016(9thCir.2002).

M ultipleformsofalternativeserviceatoncearealsopermissible.1d. at1017.Finally,

to comportwithdueprocess,tthemethodofservicecraftedby thedistrictcourtm ust

beûreasonablycalculated,underallthecircum stances,to appriseinterestedpartiesof

thependencyoftheactionandaflbrdthem anopportunitytopresenttheir

objections.'''1d.at1016-17(quotingMulanev.Cent.HanoverBank& TrustCo.,

339U.S.306,314(1950)).OfthemethodsRule4(t)permits,ittldoesnotdenoteany

hierarchyorpreferenceofonem ethod ofserviceoveranother.''RioProperties, 284

F.3dat1015.Thepetitionerhasservedbyem ailaswellmsbymail.

12.TheelementofRule4(9(3),requiringthatservicebereasonablycalculatedtoapprise

Defendantofthelitigation,willalsobemet.lndeterminingwhetheraplaintiffhas

exercisedttreasonablediligence,''thecourtexam inestheaffidavittoseewhetherthe

Plaintiffttookthosestepsaremsonablepersonwhotrulydesiredtogivenoticewould

havetakenunderthecircumstances.''Donel,Inc.v.Badalian,87Cal. App.3d 327,

333(1978).Theçtreasonablediligence''requirementlçdenotesathorough,systematic

investigationandinquiryconducted ingoodfaithby thepartyorhisagentor

attorney.''Thepetitionerhasshownover10attem ptsforservicehascompleted 75

percentofthe5/7defendants.W ithgoodcausethepetitionerbelieveshehmsmethis

btlrdentoprovereasonforgoodcauseandrequestmotionforextensionbegranted.

Thereisnothingelsethatthepetitionercouldhavedonedifferently. Ifthisisdenied

thePetitionerwouldrequestforpublicationasthefmalsourceofservice.

W HEREFORE,thePetitioner,M ALVIN GARNETT,respedfullyrequeststhis

CourtGrantorderofextension for30 daysofthebasisofgood cause and the

effortputforthtoservea11parties.

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 3 of 11
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

IH EREBY CERTIFY thatatrueandcorrectcopy ofthisM otionwas

servedon

PriscilleDuvalsaint-M arieLiautaud

priscillenoeli@ amail.com

JudgeGeorjeSarduyandCarlosFernandez

Emomotiml.Brisibe@mWloridalegal.com

LesliePuzo

lesliee ouzolaw.com

Diksha Mehan

diksha@dmsharmalaw.com

Yasm in Morshedian

infoe vmleqalservices.com

January27,2023

M alvinGarnett

437SW 3rdST //4

M iam i,FL 33130

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 4 of 11
EXH IBIT 1

EM AILS W O RKS A N D SERV ICE W AS

G IV EN

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 5 of 11
1/26/23,12:10PM

From:priscilenoeli@gmail.com,

To:bkbridge7l8@aol.com,

Subject:PhysicalExam Updated

Date:Tue,Jan24,20239:26pm

M alvin,

AnnualPhysicalW ellnessExam hasbeencompleted 1/16/23 .M y healthinsurancecoveredthevisit.The

updatedSchoolHealthForm shavebeensubmittedtoKLA sinceIastweektoensurenoissueswithherattending

classes.

PhysicalExam Updated

Nubiadoesnothaveanypendinglabsnorvaccinestotakethisyear.HerPCPatDR ALVARO J.DANGOND

MD PA (SamePediatricianOfhceshehasattendedsincebirth)notesthathernextlabswillbetakennextyear.

Shehasno shotstotakesincesheisalreadyuptodatewithaIlofherschoolmandatedimm unizations.

Sheisnotonanyprescribedmedications.Shetakesm ultivitaminsandprobiotics.TheotherareOTC creamsfor

herskinasneeded whichtheIV!Phademailedyouandmyselfsince5/2022.Herallergylistfrom thelabstaken

werealsoprovidedtoyouviae-mailIastyear.Ifyouareinneedofanothercopyyoumaycontacttheirofhces

directlyforcopiesofherrecord.

Thankyou,

Priscille

htpsr//mail.aol.com/webmil-std/en-us/pHntMessage

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 6 of 11
EXH IBIT 2

AU O RN EY STATING EM A ILA DDRESS,

PHO N E N U M BER,A N D A D DRESS

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 7 of 11
Filing# 165162564E-Filed01/20/202304:09:18PM

IN TIIE CIRCIJIT COIJRT OFTHE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT

IN AND FOR M IAM I-DADE COIJNW ,FLORIDA

IN RE;TllEM ARIUAGE OF

PRISCV LE DW ALSAINTGARNETT,

Petitioner/ormerW ife,

and

M ALVIN LEOPOLD GARNETT,

Respondene ormerHusband.

M OH ON TO W ITHDRAW

COM ESNOW ,LesliePuzo,Esq.,andmovesthisCourttoW ithdraw asCounselfoTthe

PetitionerT ormer W ife,PRISCILLE DW ALSAINT GARNEW ,and as grounds therefore

sGtes:

1. Irreconcilable differences have arisen between undersigned Counsel and the

CASENO.:2019-013774-FC-04

PetitionerT ormerW ife.

2. Allfurtherpleadings,motions,discovery,anyanda11othercommunicationsconcerningthis

mattershouldbesenttothePetitionerTormerW ife,PRISCILLEDIJVALSAW Tataddress:

2321LagunaCircle,Apt.0709,Miami,FL33181andbyE-mail:priscillenoelli@gmail.com.

Petitioner'sCellphoneNumberis(516)298-6060.

Undersigned Counselrequeststo appearvirtually byZoom forhenringontheM otion to

W ithdmw.

W IIEREFORE,thetmdersignedcounsel,LesliePtlzo,Esq.,respectfullyrequeststhiscourt

gmnt this M otion to W ithA w as counsel for the PetitionerTormer W ife,PRISCILLE

DUVALSAW T.

ICERH H CATE OF SERW CE TO FOLLOW ON NEXT PAGEI

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 8 of 11
MotiontoeffAtfrtzw

CaseNo.:2019-013774-F6704

Page2of2

CERH FICATE OF SERVICE

IHEREBY CERTIFY thatatnzeandcorrectcopyhasbeenE-filedwith theClerkof

CourtsandE-servedtoRespondene ormerHusband,M alvinLeopoldGarnettthroughemailat

bkbridge7l8@aol.com andmgarnett3os@ pnail.com andtothePetitionerTormerW ife,Priscille

Duvalsaint,viaE-mailatpriscillenoelli@gmail.com andviamailto7980NW 155*Street,Suite

A,M iami,Florida33016,onthis20tbdayofJanuary2023.

PUZO LAW

1175N .E.125= STREET

StJITE618

N ORTH M IAMI,FL 33161

'1YL:(305)428-2220

B .Q .wB .../-y-.. y:* - W

LESLY Puzo,ESQ.

FLO Rm BARNUM BE 1419791

LESLG PUZOLAW.COM

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 9 of 11
EXH IBIT 3

CERTIFIED M AILRECEIPT FO R W AIVE

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 10 of 11
1/26/23,12:15PM

From:DoNotReply@ereceiptusps.govl

'ro;BKBRIDGE7I8@AOL.COM,

Subject:USPSeReceipt

Date:Sat,Jan7.202312:58pm

IT < <

ST L S l oa

FLAGLER MIAMI

500 NW 2ND AVE

MIAMI, FL 33101-9998

(800)275-8777

01/07/2023 12:57 PM

Product Qty Unit Price

Price

Priority Maill 1 $10.20

Legal FR Env

Glendorae CA 91741

Flat Rate

Expected Delivery Date

Tue 01/10/2023

Tracking #z

9505 5141 9973 3007 6978 26

Insurance $0.00

Up to.$. 100.00 included

Total $y;.z;

First-class Mail* $3.60

Large Envelope

Miami, FL 33161

Weiqht: 9 kb 10.92 oz

Estimated Delivery Date

Mon 01/09/2023

Certified Mail* $4.00

Tracking #:

70221670000166572961

Total $7.60

First-class Mail* $3.60

Large Envelope

Miami, FL 33181

Weight: 0 lb 10.90 oz

Estimated Delivery Date

Mon 01/09/2023

Cer 'fied Mail* $4.00

T ing #t

7 1670000166572978 ;'

To $7.6û

irst-class Mail@ $3.60

Large Envelope -.---.>,...N -

Miami, FL 33181 ï NN

Weight: 0 lb 10.90 oz

Estimated Delivery Date .

' Mon01/09/2023 j rtified Mail* ' $4.00 '

ng #t

7022 66572992

Total

Grand Total: $33.00

Debit Card Remit $43.00

Card Namo: VISA

Account #t XXXXXXXXXXXX2266

Approval #: 095612

Transaction #: 655

Receipt #: 056548

Debit Card Purchase: $43.00

AID: A0000000980840 Chip

AL: US DEBIT

PINZ Verified

Cash Back -$10.00

https://mail.aol.coe webmil-stien-us/phntMessage

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 33 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/27/2023 Page 11 of 11 USPSeReceipt