1

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

Case No. 1:22-cv-24066-KMM

GRACE, INC., et al.,

Plaintiffs,

v.

CITY OF MIAMI,

Defendant.

/

JOINT EXHIBIT LIST AND PLAINTIFFS’ EXHIBIT LIST

FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION HEARING

At the preliminary injunction hearing on March 29, 2023, Plaintiffs introduced 93 exhibits 

into evidence, the first 18 of which the Parties introduced as joint exhibits. All 93 exhibits were 

previously filed in support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction at ECF No. 24.

Additionally, the City introduced 12 exhibits not previously filed in this case.

Se Court directed Plaintiffs to file a notice of the above, in lieu of re-filing the exhibits 

themselves. Se following lists the 18 Joint Exhibits and 75 Plaintiffs’ Exhibits:

J O I N T E X H I B I T S

ECF No. Description No. of 

Pages

2022 Redistricting Cycle Materials

Legislative Documents

24-1 Resolution 22-131 and Exhibit 1 Sereto 10

24-2 Master Report for Resolution 22-131 2

Consultant Reports and Presentations

24-3 Nov. 18, 2021 Slide Presentation 18

24-4 Feb. 7, 2022 Slide Presentation 40

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 49 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/30/2023 Page 1 of 7
2

24-5 Feb. 7, 2022 Presentation Outline 10

24-6 Feb. 7, 2022 Cody Memo on Areas Moved in Feb. 7 Draft 10

24-7 Feb. 25, 2022 Slide Presentation 32

24-8 Mar. 11, 2022 Slide Presentation 15

24-9 Mar. 11, 2022 Initial Russell Plan Presentation 6

24-10 Mar. 24, 2022 Slide Presentation 15

City Commission Meeting Transcripts

24-11 Tr. 1: Nov. 18, 2021 44

24-12 Tr. 2: Dec. 9, 2021 35

24-13 Tr. 3: Feb. 7, 2022 115

24-14 Tr. 4A: Feb. 25, 2022, Morning Session 66

24-15 Tr. 4B: Feb. 25, 2022, Afternoon Session 46

24-16 Tr. 5A: Mar. 11, 2022, Morning Session 92

24-17 Tr. 5B: Mar. 11, 2022, Afternoon Session 42

24-18 Tr. 6: Mar. 24, 2022 92

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 49 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/30/2023 Page 2 of 7
3

P L A I N T I F F S ’ E X H I B I T S

ECF No. Description No. of 

Pages

2022 Redistricting Cycle Materials (cont.)

News Coverage of the 2022 Cycle

24-19

Joey Flechas, Former Lawmaker Ends Contract to Redraw Miami 

Voting Districts After Questions Arose, MIA. HERALD (Jan. 25, 2021), 

https://www.miamiherald.com/article248745895.html

3

24-20

Joey Flechas, Miami Hires Redistricting Expert, City Hall Lobbyist to 

Redraw Voting Districts, MIA. HERALD (Feb. 26, 2021), 

https://www.miamiherald.com/article249516260.html

4

24-21

Jim Turner, Don’t Cubbyhole Ken Russell as the White Man in the 

Race, MIA. TIMES (June 22, 2021, updated Aug. 13, 2021),

https://www.miamitimesonline.com/article_67457ba2-d36f-11eb9e02-ff42b1ba1864.html

3

24-22

Joshua Ceballos, Joe Carollo: “So What?” If Redistricting Puts His 

Coconut Grove Home in District 3, MIA. NEW TIMES (Mar. 4, 2022), 

https://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/new-miami-redistrictingproposal-moves-joe-carollos-coconut-grove-house-into-his-district140182185

24-23

Joshua Ceballos, City of Miami Sued for ‘Racial Gerrymandering’ in 

Redistricting Map, WLRN (Dec. 15, 2022), 

https://www.wlrn.org/politics/2022-12-15/city-of-miami-sued-forracial-gerrymandering-in-redistricting-map

4

24-24

Joey Flechas, Miami Commissioner Resigns a Few Days Early, 

Leaving District 2 Seat Open in New Year, MIA. HERALD (Dec. 29, 

2022), https://www.miamiherald.com/article270560797.html

4

24-25

Joey Flechas, Voters in Miami’s District 2 Will Choose Zeir Next 

Commissioner in Special Election, MIA. HERALD (Jan. 8, 2023, 

updated Jan. 9, 2023), 

https://www.miamiherald.com/article270923747.html

3

Other Materials from the 2022 Cycle

24-26 First Russell Resignation Letter (June 3, 2022) 2

24-27 Second Russell Resignation Letter (Dec. 29, 2022) 3

24-28 First ACLU-FL Letter (Feb. 25, 2022) 4

24-29 Second ACLU-FL Letter (Mar. 31, 2022) 4

24-30 Email from Supervisor of Elections’ Office (Jan. 30, 2023) 3

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 49 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/30/2023 Page 3 of 7
4

Expert Reports

24-31 Expert Report of Dr. Carolyn Abott 34

24-32 Expert Report of Dr. Bryant Moy 63

Plaintiff Declarations

24-33 Declaration of Carolyn Donaldson (GRACE, Inc.) 2

24-34 Declaration of Rebecca Pelham (Engage Miami, Inc.) 2

24-35 Declaration of Harold Ford (South Dade NAACP) 3

24-36 Declaration of Daniella Pierre (Miami-Dade NAACP) 2

24-37 Declaration of Clarice Cooper 2

24-38 Declaration of Jared Johnson 2

24-39 Declaration of Steven Miro 2

24-40 Declaration of Alexandra Contreras 2

24-41 Declaration of Yanelis Valdes 2

News Coverage from Past Cycles

1997 Cycle News Coverage

24-42 Alfonso Chardy, Rights Group’s Suit Wants Miami to Change Election 

System, MIA. HERALD, Nov. 21, 1996, at 2B 2

24-43 Karen Branch, Miami Group Pushing Hard for Single-Member 

Districts, MIA. HERALD, Dec. 30, 1996, at 12A 2

24-44 Karen Branch, Single-Member Districts Touchy Issue at City Hall, 

MIA. HERALD, Jan. 20, 1997, at 2B 2

24-45 Manny Garcia, Giving Miami Blacks a Voice, MIA. HERALD, Mar. 13, 

1997, at 1A 3

24-46 Manny Garcia, Election Remap for Miami, MIA. HERALD, Mar. 14, 

1997, at 12A 2

24-47 Panel Named to Draw Miami Districts, MIA. HERALD, Mar. 15, 1997,

at 2B 2

24-48 Editorial, Where to Draw the Line, MIA. HERALD, Mar. 15, 1997, at 

10A 2

24-49 Karen Branch, Professors Get Election Homework, MIA. HERALD, 

May 5, 1997, at 2B 2

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 49 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/30/2023 Page 4 of 7
5

24-50 Alfonso Chardy, Blue-Ribbon Panel Picks 2 Plans for Redrawing 

Districts, Mia. Herald, June 19, 1997, at 1B 3

24-51 Plan to Expand Miami Commission Draws Public Support, MIA.

HERALD, June 24, 1997, at 2B 2

24-52 Karen Branch, Super-Strong Mayor for Miami?, MIA. HERALD, June 

25, 1997, at 1B 3

24-53 Karen Branch, Miami Leaders Divided Over Redistricting Plan, MIA.

HERALD, June 27, 1997, at 3B 2

24-54 Karen Branch, Districts: Back to Drawing Board, MIA. HERALD, June 

29, 1997, at 1B 3

24-55 Karen Branch, Miami Commission Leans Toward 5-Member Panel, 

MIA. HERALD, July 2, 1997, at 1B 3

24-56 Karen Branch, Voting Districts to be Chosen Today, MIA. HERALD, 

July 3, 1997, at 4B 2

24-57 Editorial, Go for Seven, MIA. HERALD, July 3, 1997, at 22A 2

24-58 Karen Branch, Commissioners Choose 5-Seat Plan, MIA. HERALD, 

July 4, 1997, at 1B 3

24-59 Karen Branch, Miami Commission OKs 5 Voting Districts, MIA.

HERALD, July 11, 1997, at 1B 3

24-60 Liz Balmaseda, Commission’s Districting Logic Is Hard to Digest, 

MIA. HERALD, July 12, 1997, at 1B 2

24-61 Enrique Patterson, Power Games Rob African Americans, MIA.

HERALD, July 14, 1997, at 13A 2

24-62 Jim Hampton, Schizoid Choices? No, It’s Just Miami, MIA. HERALD, 

July 20, 1997, at 2L 2

24-63 Andres Viglucci, Abolition Attempt Crushed, MIA. HERALD, Sep. 5, 

1997, at 1A 3

24-64 Karen Branch & Dan Keating, Vote Favors a Black Commissioner, 

MIA. HERALD, Sep. 5, 1997, at 1B 3

24-65 Andres Viglucci, Teele Wins Miami Seat, MIA. HERALD, Nov. 5, 1997, 

at 1B 3

2013 Cycle News Coverage

24-66 Kathleen McGrory, New District Shifts Spur Controversy, MIA.

HERALD, June 8, 2012, at 1B 3

24-67 Kathleen McGrory, Eastsiders Battle Redistricting, MIA. HERALD, Feb. 

14, 2013, at 5B 2

24-68 Kathleen McGrory, Redistricting Foes Get Another Chance, MIA.

HERALD, Feb. 15, 2013, at 5B 2

24-69 Charles Rabin, Commissioners Delay Vote on Redistricting, MIA.

HERALD, Apr. 26, 2013, at 5B 2

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 49 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/30/2023 Page 5 of 7
6

24-70 Charles Rabin, Commission Votes Allow ‘Double-Dipping’ by 4 

Employees, MIA. HERALD, May 24, 2013, at 1B 3

Other Materials from Past Cycles

Legislative Documents

24-71 Resolution 97-495 and Ex. 1 Sereto 21

24-72 Resolution 03-448 and Substitute Ex. A Sereto 17

24-73 Resolution 13-208 and Substitute Ex. 1 Sereto 15

24-74 Agenda Item Summary Form for Resolution 13-208 3

24-75 Feb. 14, 2013 Commission Meeting Minutes 158

Consultant Reports and Presentations

24-76 2013 Initial Report: Redistricting the City of Miami Commission After 

the 2010 Census 27

24-77 2013 Second Report: Report on the Status of Redistricting and 

Proposed Redistricting Plan, and Tabs 2 and 3 Attached Sereto 91

24-78 2013 Final Report Regarding the Proposed Redistricting Plan 6

24-79 2013 Presentation: Redistricting Alternatives Compared 20

Maps (with Google Maps links, if applicable)

Historical Plans

24-80 1997 Plan (https://bit.ly/3wC1K8j) 1

24-81 2003 Plan (https://bit.ly/3Dn6mTH) 1

24-82 2013 Plan (https://bit.ly/3wDsHsl) 1

2022 Cycle Plans

24-83 2022 Enacted Plan (https://bit.ly/40b7OCk) 1

24-84 Feb. 7 Draft (https://bit.ly/3wEowg4) 5

24-85 Feb. 22 Draft/Base Plan (https://bit.ly/406t64d) 7

24-86 Russell Sketch 1

24-87 Initial Russell Plan (https://bit.ly/3YaKzGR) 2

24-88 Revised Russell Plan (https://bit.ly/3XNuas4) 2

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 49 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/30/2023 Page 6 of 7
7

24-89 Reyes Plan (https://bit.ly/3kL3kSB) 2

24-90 2022 Precinct Map, with 2022 Enacted Plan overlaid

(https://bit.ly/3jjbRvQ) 1

24-91 2020 Census Voting Tabulation District (VTD) Map, with 2022 

Enacted Plan overlaid (https://bit.ly/40wASEv) 1

Miami-Dade County Elections Department

District Demographic Analysis Reports

24-92

Feb. 1, 2022 District Demographic Analysis, 

https://www.miamidade.gov/elections/STATS/2022/2022-01-voterregistration-statistics-districts.pdf224

24-93

Feb. 1, 2023 District Demographic Analysis, 

https://www.miamidade.gov/elections/library/reports/voterregistration-statistics-districts.pdf230

Respectfully submitted this 30th day of March, 2023,

/s/ Nicholas L.V. Warren

Nicholas L.V. Warren (FBN 1019018)

ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc.

336 East College Avenue, Suite 203

Tallahassee, FL 32301

(786) 363-1769

nwarren@aclufl.org

Daniel B. Tilley (FBN 102882)

Caroline A. McNamara (FBN 1038312)

ACLU Foundation of Florida, Inc.

4343 West Flagler Street, Suite 400

Miami, FL 33134

(786) 363-2714

dtilley@aclufl.org

cmcnamara@aclufl.org

Neil A. Steiner*

Dechert LLP

Sree Bryant Park

1095 Avenue of the Americas

New York, NY 10036

(212) 698-3822

neil.steiner@dechert.com

Christopher J. Merken*

Jocelyn Kirsch*

Dechert LLP

Cira Centre

2929 Arch Street

Philadelphia, PA 19104

(215) 994-2380

christopher.merken@dechert.com

jocelyn.kirsch@dechert.com

* Admitted pro hac vice

Counsel for Plaintiffs

Case 1:22-cv-24066-KMM Document 49 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/30/2023 Page 7 of 7