NATIONAL BUREAU OF STANDARDS REPORT

NBS PROJECT NBS REPORT

311.05-1 1-31 10560 December 31, 1969 10 189

31 1.05-1 1-31 10561

REPORT ON DENTAL RESEARCH

AT THE

NATIONAL BUREAU OF STANDARDS

Progress Report

July 1 to December 31, 1969

The dental research program at the National Bureau of Standards is carried on in cooperation with the Council on Dental Research of the American Dental Association; the National Institute for Dental Research;

the Dental Research Division of the U. S. Army Medical Research and

Development Command; the Dental Sciences Division of the School of Aerospace Medicine, USAF; and the Veterans Administration.

IMPORTANT NOTICE NATIONAL BUREAU OF S'

for use within the Government, and review. For this reason, tl whole or in part, is not authc Bureau of Standards, Washing

the Report has been speciticall;

Approved for public release by the

Director of the National Institute of

Standards and Technology (NIST)

on October 9, 2015.

ess accounting documents intended

s subjected to additional evaluation

e listing of this Report, either in he Office of the Director, National

by the Government agency for which

copies for its own use. <NBS>

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

NATIONAL BUREAU OF STANDARDS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

1. Introduction 1

2. Reports Issued 1

3. Papers Published 2

4. Work in Progress 2 4.1 Determination of Crystal Structures 2 4.2 Physicochemical Studies of Apatite and Related

Inorganic Substances 5

4.3 Study of Dentinal and Enamel Surfaces from

Sorption Isotherms 10

4.4 Mechanical Properties of Oral Structures and

Restorative Materials 11

4.4.1 Dimensional Changes in Teeth Components 11

4.4.2 Physical Properties of Hard Tissues 12

4.4.3 Physical Properties of Soft Tissues 13

4.5 Dental Metallurgical Studies 15

4.6 Petrography of Dental Investments 16

4.7 Reinforced EBA Cements 18

4.8 Eonding of Monomers to Tooth Structure 18-

4.9 Grafting of Monomers to Hard and Soft Tissues 20

4.10 Adhesive Composite Direct Filling Materials 22

4.11 Three-Dimensional Panoramic X-Ray 24

4.12 Bonding of Materials to Poly (methylmethacrylate) 24

4.13 Clinical Research 26

4.14 Specifications and Advisory 28

4.14.1 Laboratory Testing for Subcommittee on Orthodontic Wire 29

4.14.2 Specification Committee Activities 29

4.15 Symposium on Dental Materials Research 32

Appendix

NBS Report 10061 Effects of Compositional Variations on the

Atomic Ordering in A-15 Phases.

NBS Report 10127 Amine Accelerators for Methacrylate Resin

Systems

NBS Report 10128 A Refinement of the Crystal Structure of

Na

2 C0

3

*H

2 0.

NBS Report 10155 Preparation of Hydroxyapatite by Hydrolysis

of a-Tricalcium Phosphate.

NBS Report 10177 Ultrasonic Methods for Determination of

Mechanical Properties of Dental Materials.

NBS Report 10178 EBA Cements.
g

t—h

E

r

g

E

r

E

E

E

[

E

E

t

E

1
REPORT ON DENTAL RESEARCH

at the

NATIONAL BUREAU OF STANDARDS

1. INTRODUCTION

Dental research at the National Bureau of Standards during the

half year ending December 31, 1969 included investigations of a wide range of materials used in restorative dentistry as well as studies of mineralized tissues and related compounds. The research

program is supported by the Council on Dental Research of the American

Dental Association, the Collaborative Research Office of the National

Institute of Dental Research, the Dental Research Division of the

U. S. Army Medical Research and Development Command, the Dental

Sciences Division of the U. S. Air Force School of Aerospace Medicine,

and the Veterans Administration. Support from the National Institutes

of Dental Research is also provided in the form of grants to Research

Associates sponsored by the American Dental Association. This support

is designated NIDR (Grant) where reference to it is made. In the

summaries of work in progress, sponsors of various projects are identified. However, since most of the projects are closely related

both technically and administratively, reports on all projects are presented for the information of all sponsors. Detailed reports

issued during the period on some phases of the research are listed

and are appended to this report.

2. REPORTS ISSUED

NBS Report 10061

NBS Report 10127

NBS Report 10128

NBS Report 10155

NBS Report 10177

NBS Report 10178

Effects of Compositional Variations on the Atomic

Ordering in A-15 Phases.

Amine Accelerators for Methacrylate Resin Systems.

A Refinement of the Crystal Structure of Na^CO^'H^O.

Preparation of Hydroxyapatite hy Hydrolysis of

a-Tricalcium Phosphate.

Ultrasonic Methods for Determination of Mechanical

Properties of Dental Materials.

EBA Cements.

1
3. PAPERS PUBLISHED

Huget, E. F. ; Brauer, G. M. ; Kumpula, J. W. and Civjan, S. A Filled

Cold-Curing Acrylic Resin As a Splinting Material. JADA 79:645-648,

September 1969.

Ohashi, M. and Paf f enbarger , G. C. Some Flow Characteristics at

37°C of Ternary Wax Mixtures That May Have Possible Dental Uses. J.

Nihon University School of Dentistry Vol. 11, #3, September 1969.

Sweeney, W. T. Dental Research at the National Bureau of Standards,

1919-1969. British Dental Journal 127:289-290, #6, Sept. 16, 1969.

Dickens, B. and Brown, W. E. The Crystal Structures of CaNa ? (C0

5H 9 0, Synthetic Gaylussite, and CaNa„(C0„) ‘ 2H 0, Synthetic

Pirssonite. Inorganic Chem. 8:2093-2103, PlO

October 1969.

Eick, J. D.; Caul, H. J. ; Hegdahl, T. and Dickson, G. Chemical

Composition of Dental Gold Casting Alloy and Dental Wrought Gold Wire

Alloys. J. Dent. Res. 48:1284-1289, #6, November-December 1969.

4. WORK IN PROGRESS

4.1. Determination of Crystal Structures

Sponsor: NIDR, NIDR (Grant), ADA

Calcium carbonates and calcium phosphates account for much of the

inorganic materials formed in_ vivo . Our objectives are to determine

and examine germane crystal structures to increase the understanding

of ionic arrangements in the solid state and to provide structural

experience for postulating models for

(1) groups of ions and water molecules in aqueous solution

which may be involved in reaction mechanisms.

(2) incorporation of 'defects’, impurities, vacancies and/or

non-stoichiometry in bone mineral in particular, and

crystal structures in general. This includes investigating possible epitactical (interlayering) and syntactical (substituted domains) relationships between

crystal structures and estimating the optimum molecular

parameters of adherents.

(3) nucleation and crystal growth phenomena.

Automatic Diffractometer

The Picker automatic single-crystal x-ray diffractometer equipped

2

-j-
with a highly oriented graphite crystal monochromator, was delivered

in May 1969 and has been aligned and used to collect several sets

of x-ray intensity data for use in the determinations of the crystal

structures. Intermittent malfunctions in the equipment have caused

delay; unclear, incomplete or omitted operating instructions have

caused a need for some repetition. In general, the equipment is

routinely producing high quality data.

Ca

2 Na 0 (CO^)^ (Shortite)

The structure of shortite was redetermined to provide more structural information on the coordination of Ca, Na, and CO^ ions,

and has been refined satisfactorily to R = 0.023. The Ca ion in

Ca

9 Na ? (C0^)^ is coordinated to 9 neighboring oxygens, including three

CO^ edges, with distances that indicate strong ionic bonding. Strong

coordination to 9 oxygens is unusual for Ca and is possible because

of the small 0...0 separation (^2.2A) in the edge of the CO^ group.

One Na ion is coordinated to 8 oxygens, including 2 CO^ edges, in a geometry like that of Ca in CaNa^ (CO^) ^ ' 51^0 ; the other is coordinated

strongly to 6 oxygens, including one CO^ edge, and weakly to a seventh.

BaCaCCO^)^ (Bary tocalcite phase)

The structure of barytocalcite was determined and refined to

2 + 2 +

R = 0.03 to learn how large cations such as Ba and Sr may be ac- commodated in structures such as calcite and aragonite, which are different forms of CaCO^ and important biological minerals.

The cations in barytocalcite form a pseudohexagonal layer parallel to (101) if Ca and Ba are considered equivalent. There are similar layers of Ca ions in calcite and aragonite. The CO^ groups

lie in a buckled layer between the cation layers. The structure re- peats with every fourth cation layer and is thus related more to

calcite than to aragonite which repeats everty third cation layer.

The Ca ion in barytocalcite is coordinated to seven oxygens,

including one CO^ edge; this coordination is different from the Ca

coordination of 6 oxygen atoms pn calcite and 9 oxygen atoms in

aragonite. The structure contains linear Ca-CO^ chains along c_. The

Ba ion is coordinated to 11 oxygens, including 5 CO^ edges. There

3
are non-linear Ba-CO^ chains along £. BaCa(C0^) 9 (Alstonite phase)

We have collected 25,000 x-ray reflections from an apparently

single crystal of alstonite. Alstonite is monoclinic, has a large

cell a = 30.164(9), b = 17.413(5), c_ = 6.110(1) and 6 = 89.91°(1)

crystallizes in space-group C2/m, Cm or C2. Work on the crystal

structure is beginning. From the relationship of its cell dimensions

to those of bary tocalcite , alstonite may have pseudohexagonal layers

of cations parallel to (001) which repeat every third layer and thus

be related to aragonite.

CaCO^ (Aragonite)

To our knowledge, the structure of aragonite had not been refined

from the positions given by Bragg in 1924. In view of the importance

of aragonite as a biological mineral and as a common phase of CaCO^,

we have collected new x-ray data and have refined the structure to

R = 0.03. At the present stage of refinement, the CO^ group in

aragonite appears to be essentially trigonal, with C-0 = 1.286(2) A.

The Ca ion is coordinated to 9 oxygens, including 3 CO^ edges. Because

of the twinning common in aragonite, the single crystal we used to

collect the x-ray data was necessarily small. If we are unsuccessful

in our search for a larger crystal of aragonite to improve the counting statistics and thus the precision of the x-ray data, we plan to

recollect the data with the present crystal. The diffractometer has now been modified to keep the least significant digit in all counts,

which it had not previously done. This will improve the precision

of our results in general since we are often forced to use small

crystals which do not have intense x-ray reflections.

Computer Programs

So that various experimental errors such as misalignment of the

crystal, and absorption or multiple reflection of the x-ray beam by

the crystal, may be checked, we routinely measure equivalent reflections with the diffractometer in gathering our sets of x-ray data for

crystal structure determinations. A program to merge any equivalent

reflections in a list of up to 30,000 reflections and to sort the

4
reflections has been written for the UNIVAC 1108 computer. The

program performs some value judgments on the data and is working

successfully.

4.2. Physicochemical Studies of Apatite

and Related Inorganic Substances

Sponsor: NIDR (Grant), ADA

Solubilities of Hydroxyapatite

The solubility of hydroxyapatite is a basic factor in tooth,

bone and calculus formation, bone remodeling, and the caries process.

Discordant results in the literature have created various interpretations of how hydroxyapatite crystals can equilibrate with aqueous

systems. However, three sets of solubility measurements, described

in previous reports, have established that the solubility principles

that apply to hydroxyapatite are the same as for other calcium

phosphates. Two types of anomalous behavior were observed:

1. The solubility constant appeared to be affected by

sample history, particularly heating at high temperature.

2. It was difficult to attain equilibrium from supersaturation (i.e., from conditions which would prevail

during crystal growth)

We have continued studies of these two effects.

Portions of a sample of hydroxyapatite (prepared as described

in earlier reports by titration of a Ca(0H) ? slurry with H^PO^ solution, followed by prolonged boiling, were heated at 1000°C in air or

in water vapor. The samples heated in air became slightly colored

(pink) for reasons not known, but probably related to the presence of

impurities. When heated samples were placed in water, the solutions

became alkaline to phenol-phthalein . The impurity responsible for

the alkalinity has not been established. The only calcium phosphate

that behaves in a similar manner was found to be tetracalcium phosphate,

Ca^O(PO^)

?

. The conditions of heating in air were such that hydroxyapatite could disproportionate into Ca^CKPO^^ and 8-Ca^(P0^) o , which

then could produce the alkalinity. Since Ca.O(PO.)„ cannot form in

4 4 2 the steam-heated samples, another impurity must account for the

alkalinity of these samples.

5
The heated samples yielded solubility products that were variable and larger than that obtained with unheated samples.

Thorough washing of the heated samples with 0.02 M^HPO^ , however,

reduced their solubilities so that they gave essentially the same results as the unheated samples. The major effect of the washing

was to remove the more soluble impurities so that the final measurements were made on bona fide hydroxyapatite. These results further

verify the reliability of the solubility data we have obtained

previously with both precipitated and steam-heated hydroxyapatite.

They leave in question, however, the cause of the higher values

obtained previously with the unwashed air-heated materials.

The most convincing proof that equilibrium has been achieved

in a solubility measurement is to reach the same value from supersaturation and undersaturation. An earlier set of equilibrations

from supersaturation gave what appeared to be a metastable’ isotherm

that was later found to correspond to that of g-Ca^(P0^) o

. Our most

recent experiments of this type gave variable results and the solutions were always supersaturated with respect to the values obtained

when equilibrium was approached from undersaturation. The finely

divided form of the hydroxyapatite used this time prevented us from

using the leaching technique that had been so successful in the earlier

experiments, thus accounting for part of the difference in the results.

We attach considerable significance to the fact that in neither

set of supersaturation experiments did we achieve equilibrium with

hydroxyapatite. The most reasonable interpretation is that other

calcium phosphates (probably 6-Ca (PO ) or Ca 0 H (PO ) *5H 0, and

j 4 z o z 4 b z possibly also materials that are vaguely characterized as the amorphous

"phase") formed more rapidly than hydroxyapatite even though there was present a very large surface area which should promote precipitation

of hydroxyapatite. This is consistent with numerous qualitative observations that have been made in the past. The formation of metastable

precursor phases has been amply demonstrated Tn vitro ; their occurrence

in vivo (in dental calculus, carious tooth, and pathological precipitates)

is being encountered in an increasing number of instances, and they

6
have been postulated as precursors in the formation of tooth and

bone mineral. All these observations are consistent with the view

that metastable precursors are likely to form with the result that

equilibrium will be difficult to reach from supersaturation.

Solubility of Calcium Phosphates

Our previous studies on solubilities of calcium phosphates were confined to the ternary system Ca (OH) ^-h^PO^-H^O . These studies are beiag extended to include other physiologically important ions. In

the current work, the effects of sodium chloride on the solubilities

of CaHPO^^H^O and the validity of approximations used to calculate

activity coefficients at physiological concentrations are being investigated. CaHPO^^H^O was selected for this work because it can

be prepared in a well crystallized form easily and its solubility

behavior and thermodynamic properties have been thoroughly investigated

previously in the ternary system. Equilibration of CaHPO^^H^O with

phosphoric acid solutions containing NaCl (zero to 0.5M) is carried

out at 25°C in the usual fashion. The preliminary results indicate that

the amount of dissolved CaHPO^‘2H9 0 is not significantly affected by

the presence of NaCl, but the pH of the equilibrating solution in- creases with NaCl concentration (ApH = 0.3 between solutions in which

NaCl varied from zero to 0.5M and the initial H„P0. concentration was

-2 3 4

1.48 x 10 M) . Between the zero and 0.15M NaCl solutions, the

calculated solubility products do not vary greatly (3% Davies; 6%

Debye-Hllckel) , but at higher NaCl concentrations the K values bv

sp

the two conventions for calculating activity products diverged rapidly.

More experimental work is being done using different initial phosphoric acid concentrations; this should allow us to cover a pH range

from 4.5 to 7.0.

Diffusion in the Ternary System, Ca (OH) ^-H^PO^-H^O

Theory of diffusion in this sytem based on the considerations

of electroneutral components, CaHPO , , H PO, , and HO and of ionic

2+ 2- - £

3 4 l

species, Ca , HPO^ , H^PO^ anc* ^ were described in earlier reports.

The ionic model is used in the present report period to calculate

7
practical (D..) and fundamental (L . . ) diffusion coefficients for

ij il

thirteen experimental systems saturated with respect to hydroxyapatite; the compositions of these systems, pH, total calcium and

phosphorous concentrations, are taken from the work previously re- ported by these laboratories on the solubility of hydroxyapatite.

A calculation of this nature was undertaken because of the possible

importance of the results in interpreting and understanding the

mechanism of mineralization and demineralization of the hard tissues.

The major findings of this study are:

1. The interference of H_PO, in the diffusion of CaHPO.

j) l\ q. component is significant in the pH range A. 5-7. 5; the

converse is true only for pH values below 6.

2. At the vanishing concentrations of CaHPO^ in 4.89 x 10 M

H^PO^ , the practical diffusion coefficient of phosphoric

acid, D

9? , approaches a value very close to the Nernst

limiting diffusion coefficient in the binary system,

H^PO^-H^O (1.575 x lO-

^ cm^/s); this suggests that the

presence of small amounts of CaHPO in dilute phosphoric

acid solution does not affect the diffusion of H PO,

3 4

3. Dilute solutions of CaHPO^ in the presence of very small

amounts of H PO^ do not behave as a binary system,

CaHPO. -H

? 0, Because the practical diffusion coefficient

of CaHPO^, D^.. , does not approach the Nernst limiting

diffusion coefficient; this indicates that the interference of H^PO^ persists in the diffusion of CaHPO^ even

at very low concentrations of both components.

4. Since large interferences can be more accurately determined

than the small ones, systems shown to have high interferences (at pH about 4.5) should be selected to test

experimentally the Onsager Reciprocal Relations .

A Generalized Least Squares Treatment of Solubility Data

In the last report it was noted that the generalized least squares

procedure, devised to treat the temperature-dependent solubility data

obtained for CaHPO^ ' 2H

? 0 , was being extended to effect the simultaneous

adjustment of the solubility data on all the calcium phosphates studied

in this laboratory. The program written for this purpose has been

completed, tested with selected portions of the data on B-Ca^PO^)..,,

Ca^OH(PO^)^, and CaHPO^’PH^O, and placed on FASTRAND. The available

data on CaHPO^*2H20, B-Ca^PO^^, Ca,- (PO^) ^OH , and CaHPO^ are being

consolidated into one master file in preparation for production runs.

8
To illustrate the general utility and applicability of the

multivariate least squares procedure, a program is being developed

to re-evaluate the data collected by Bates and others in estimating

the second dissociation constant of phosphoric acid.

The adjustment procedure as applied here is affected by a multivariate Taylor expansion; when applied to a given set of functions

dependent on several error-prone variables, it may fail to reach an absolute minimum in the sum of squares. While the effect on the adjusted values of the parameters is believed to be negligible, modified

procedures are being developed to insure that the true minimum is approached very closely and to afford more satisfactory insight into

the geometry of the adjustment.

Electrode-Chemistry and Calorimetry

Interest in supplementing the pH data used in characterizing

equilibrium conditions in various phosphate-containing solutions has

led to studies of the applicability of the mercury-based "phosphate

electrode", Hg^HPO^/HgCl) to these systems. Preliminary results,

from cells with liquid junctions, have indicated that the electrode

is responsive to changes in the activity of HPO^ ions in neutral

buffer solutions. Potentiometric solubility measurements of the dimercurous hydrogen phosphate and the use of the electrode in junctionfree cells are in progress. Results from these measurements should

provide independent values of the standard electrode potential, E°

Extension of the potentiometric method to classical junction-free

cells incorporating hydrogen gas and silver-silver chloride electrodes

is planned for studies of the quaternary system: H^PO^ , Ca(0H) 9

,

CC> 2 (g) and H

2 0.

In addition to the use of galvanic cells, the acquisition and

assembly of apparatus for the construction of a sensitive solution

calorimeter is continuing.

Topical Fluoridation

The reaction of hydroxyapatite with a fluoride solution to form

fluorapatite is known to proceed extremely slowly with poor yields.

One possible reason for this is that this reaction takes place with

9
virtually no change in volume of a hydroxyapatite. As a result, the

crystal can become covered with a thin fluorapatite coating which is

then impervious to ingress of the fluoride ions and to egress of the

hydroxyl ions.

It has been shown that in both in vitro and in vivo conditions,

the tooth enamel acquires larger amounts of fluoride in greater depth

when pretreated with dilute phosphoric or hydrochloric acid before

being exposed to the fluoride solution. This is probably because

hydroxyapatite, when treated with acid is partially converted to

CaHPO *2fL0 (or other less basic calcium phosphates). The reaction

4 l of CaHPO^ * 2H^0 with a fluoride-containing solution to form fluorapatite proceeds quite rapidly because the loss of water molecules and

phosphate ions inherent to the reaction results in a considerable

shrinkage in the volume of the crystal. Therefore, the penetration

of ions into the crystal occurs rapidly through the openings produced

by the shrinkage. The reactions of hydroxyapatite with various acids

to form CaHPO^*2H9 0 and other calcium phosphates are being studied.

The optimum conditions for the reaction of CaHPO^^H^O with calcium

fluoride to form fluorapatite are being investigated; the possible

reaction mechanisms are sought. The results obtained from these investigations may reduce the limitations of the methods presently in

clinical use and allow a more effective topical fluoridation of tooth

enamel to be developed.

4.3. Study of Dentinal and Enamel

Surfaces from Sorption Isotherms

Sponsor : NIDR

The adsorption study of basic and acidic groups (characterized

by NH^ and C0 o

) on components of tooth structure has progressed on schedule. The measurements have been made on dentin as well as on anorganic whole teeth at various temperatures. Isosteric heats of

adsorption have been determined in each case by application of the

Clausius-Clapeyron relationship. These have been compared with

average heats of adsorption obtained from the C-constant of the B.E.T.

equation and found to be in reasonably good agreement. For both

10
dentin and anorganic whole teeth, the heats of adsorption were appreciably greater for NH^ than for CO^. Surface area available to

the molecules of each gas was also computed and compared. Comparisons were also made with nitrogen adsorption results from 77°K B.E.T.

data. The concentration of adsorption sites as indicated by the apparent surface areas, i.e., areas available to each adsorbate, respectively, was especially interesting. Comparable values were found for

anorganic whole teeth regardless whether NH^, C0

? or N? was used.

Where collagen was present, as in the case of dentin, the area avail2 able to N was very small (7.5 m /g) as expected. The area of dentin

^ 2 available to NH^ at its b.p. was virtually the same (160 m /g) as the area of anorganic dentin when measured by N

? gas at the temperature of

liquid N . The area of dentin accessible to CO at its sublimation

2 2

^ point was 50 m /g - considerably less than for NH^; but more than six

times as great as . There is a good possibility that gas adsorption methods can be

used to suggest chemically reactive groups for possible incorporation

in a dental adhesive. If amino groups behaved like NH^ and if car- boxylic groups performed like CO^ , an adhesive incorporating the

amino groups in its reactive linkages would not only have stronger bonds

but more of them for the same overall area of contact than would the

carboxylic- containing material.

It is appreciated that this method has limitation. Probably foremost among them is the fact that many reactive chemical groups have no gaseous counterparts. The method could be expanded to include liquids

with reasonable vapor pressures at room temperature, but different apparatus would have to be built.

4.4. Mechanical Properties of Oral Structures

and Restorative Materials

4.4.1. Dimensional Changes in Teeth Components

Sponsor: USAF, VA, NIDR

Studies of the dimensional changes of enamel and dentin resulting

from changes in temperature and water content were continued. The

11
difference in the thermal expansion behavior of dentin below and

above 40°C has been of particular interest. Between room temperature and about 40°C dentin exhibits an approximately uniform linear

_6

thermal expansion of about 7.5 x 10 /°C. However, when dentin is

heated slowly above 40°C, the coefficient of thermal expansion de- creases to near zero or may become negative. Rapid heating results

in an expansion followed by a shrinkage. Although there appears to

be some permanent dimensional change, the major portion of the change

is reversible when the dentin is cycled a number of times over a temperature range of 20 to 60°C.

Limited data on specimens of anorganic dentin indicate that this

material has a thermal expansion similar to whole dentin below 40°C,

but does not exhibit the reduced coefficient above 40°C. This suggests that the reduced expansion of whole dentin is a result of a restraining effect by the organic portion of the material. Such an effect might be explained by a linear shrinkage of the collagen if

it can be assumed that (1) the transition which produces a large

linear shrinkage in soft tissue collagen near 60°C occurs at a lower

temperature in dentinal collagen, and (2) as a result of porosity or other effects, the linear shrinkage rather than the accompanying volume

expansion of the collagen is the effective force in the bulk dimensional

change of whole dentin.

As an alternative explanation, the possible effect of changes in

water content on the "thermal expansion" of dentin cannot be neglected.

The large dimensional changes observed when the moisture content of

the atmosphere surrounding whole dentin is varied are observed to only

a slight extent in anorganic dentin. Attempts so far to determine

whether or not "thermal" dimensional changes of whole dentin when immersed in water are related to changes in water content have been

inconclusive

4.4.2. Physical Properties of Hard Tissues

Sponsor: NIDR, AF

An improvement has been made in the proto-tvpe torsion pendulum

for the determination of the shear modulus of dental materials. The

12
pendulum and recording system have been refined and combined. This

allows for better alignment and adaptation of the test to more materials. Measurements at varying humidity and temperature are planned

4.4.3. Physical Properties of Soft Tissues

Sponsor: NIDR

Dynamic mechanical methods and apparatus that utilize various

vibrational principles and specimen geometries have been investigated

for application to soft tissue or skin. Wave propagation, free vibration and forced vibration methods have been tried. Sonic methods involving a longitudinal wave propagation seem to show some promise in

the determination of the dynamic mechanical behavior of skin.

Sonic velocity measurements were made with a commercial instrument, the Morgan Dynamic Modulus Tester. This instrument is designed

to measure sonic wave transit times in either fibers or thin films.

Velocities were determined with little difficulty on dry calf skin in

2 sheet form giving a Young's modulus value of 180 MN/irT. However,

after the same specimen had been soaked in water or when fresh ratskin

in sheet form was used, a measurable signal was not transmitted.

2 Using rat tail tendon in fiber form, a modulus of around 2,600 MN/m

was determined. Measurements on a fib er or filament of the soaked

2 calf skin gave values of about 30 MN/m . Attempts were also made to

measure the modulus of fresh rat skin in filament form, but unrealistical2 ly high values (around 50 MN/m ) were obtained. These are believed

to result from excessive straining of the skin during preparation of

the small cross-section specimen and to excessive drying-out while

the measurement was being made.

The Morgan sonic apparatus in its standard form has only limited

application to normally wet skin because of transducer design and

lack of means for environmental control so that the water content of

the skin, as well as the temperature, may be held constant during

measurement. But, the results obtained indicate that the longitudinal

wave propagation method could be successfully utilized to measure

the dynamic properties of skin when an appropriate apparatus is custom

13
built to meet the geometric and environment control requirements

strictly prescribed by normally moist soft tissues. The method

has the advantage that it can be applied to strips of soft tissue

of relatively irregular cross-section and no accurate measurement

of cross-section is required.

Since the wave propagation method has some limitations in

complete dynamic mechanical characterization of soft tissues and to assure that the mechanical parameter values are correct and that the

tissue is properly characterized, it is advisable to measure the

dynamic mechanical properties of the tissue by an additional method;

preferably utilizing a different vibrational principle. The second

method we have applied to normally moist skin appears to be more

readily adaptable to the measurement of the tissue dynamic properties.

This method utilizes a rocking-beam oscillator which is driven electromagnetically at various frequencies. The apparatus can be used at

resonance of the tissue sample or at off-resonance with appropriate

transducers which measure the dynamic stress and strain and their

phase relationship. A primitive model of the rocking-beam oscillator

has been built and preliminary measurements have been made on skin;

this proto-type model appears to indicate that the method can be used

successfully to measure the dynamic mechanical behavior of soft tissue

when the instrument is properly refined in design and equipped with

appropriate force and deformation transducers. This apparatus seems

to be particularly applicable in measuring internal friction in soft

tissue under various conditions due to the fact that the phase relation

between the stress and strain can be directly recorded. The internal

friction change in a material is a sensitive indicator of phenomena

such as a glass transition; thus, secondary transition phenomena, if

occurring in soft tissue under various conditions, may be delineated

by this method. A refinement of the prototype design is in progress

in anticipation of its use in the measurement of the mechanical properties of skin.

In the past six-month period, the dynamic calorimeter was applied to rat skin samples in an attempt to detect changes in heat

14
capacity of skin over the temperature range 15°C to 50°C. These

measurements were made in an attempt to verify the second order

transition reported by Mason and Rigby (Biochim. Biophys . Acta 66:448

(1963)), and by Rigby (Biochim. Biophys. Acta 79:634 (1964)). The

heat capacity of the water in the skin sample is so great, however,

that it appears to mask any second order change in the skin collagen,

if present. Second order transitions in a temperature range not too

far removed from body temperature would be expected to have a very

significant effect on the mechanical properties of fibrous tissues.

Efforts to detect the transition by measurement of dynamic mechanical

methods will be made when the technique of such methods is satisfactorily

developed

4.5. Dental Metallurgical Studies

Sponsor: ADA, NIDR (Grant)

Our work on phase diagrams of the noble metals is continuing.

One of our recent discoveries is the existence of a syntectic reaction

in the Cr-Pt alloy system. A syntectic reaction is rarely encountered

in the compilations of known binary phase diagrams. It may be described as a type of reaction which occurs as a liquid solution is

cooled. The liquid initially separates into two immiscible liquids

of differing composition as the temperature enters the region of a "miscibility gap." However, at a lower temperature (the syntectic

temperature) these two liquid solutions react to form a single phase

solid which, in the Cr-Pt system, is an ordered intermetallic compound

having the cubic A15 (8W) crystal structure.

The paradoxical nature of this newly discovered transformation

is evident when one considers that the formation of a highly ordered

intermetallic compound implies a strong attractive force between unlike

atoms (A-B combinations) as compared with the alternative like atom

(A-A or B-B) combinations. In a region of liquid immiscibility

however, one usually assumes that the attractive forces are strongest

between like atoms (A-A and B-B combinations). It is, therefore, quite

intriguing as to how such widely different phenomena could occur at a given alloy composition as a result of only a small temperature change.

15
Thermodynamic measurements would be of great interest in providing

more details of the energies involved and the source of such phenomena.

It is also interesting that the syntectic reaction occurs in connection with a sharp reduction in the melting point of the Cr solid

solution and may, therefore, reveal some useful information on factors

responsible for improvements in the casting properties of alloys con- taining chromium.

We have also recently discovered that the solubility of Cr in

solid platinum is extensive when the alloys are heated above their

order-disorder transformation temperatures, but the solid solubility

of Cr in Pt is sharply reduced below this temperature. In other words,

the ordered alloys dissolve less Cr than the disordered alloys. This

information was rather unexpected and may be helpful in controlling

these important reactions.

In the V-Pt system, we have discovered several order-disorder

transformations. In each case the crystal structures of the ordered

phases can be changed by introducing cold deformation. This can be

of great interest in controlling the ductility of ordered phases. In

the V-Pt system, one of these phases (VPt) forms ribbons extending

along certain crystallographic directions in the V-base body-centered

cubic solid solution alloys. It appears possible that single crystals

of such alloys can be grown having a built-in fiber reinforcement. This

should certainly receive further study.

4.6. Petrography of Dental Investments

Sponsor: ADA, NIDR (Grant)

Work on investments for high-fusing chromium-cobalt base alloys

has been nearly completed. A first report concerning the petrography

of phosphate investments has been written. A second report on the

petrograhy of silica-bonded investments is in preparation. Work is

also near completion on Ticonium's gypsum-bonded investment for lowfusing chromium-cobalt alloys and on the spalling action in zirconia

dental crucibles.

Major conclusions to be drawn from the work completed on dental

investments are as follows:

16
1. The degree of liquefaction in the high-fire prior to casting is very important in determining the configuration of fine sandsized quartz and cristobalite investment filler. On investment surfaces bounding the wax pattern, this configuration is generally coarser the higher the fire and the greater the degree of liquefaction in

sinter-bond formation. Where no protective coats are used, distinct

network patterns of hills and valleys are formed on the alloy cast

surface which key in with those formed on the free investment surface.

2. The cold strength of investments of similar composition in- creases with the degree of fusion involved in the bonding.

3. Fusion is promoted by various agents in investments. Silica

filler is not greatly mobilized at the low firing temperatures, 800°C,

of Ticonium's gypsum-bonded investment. Sintering in this material

appears to involve recrystallization bonds between calcium sulfate

grains promoted by some fusion induced by both sodium and chloride

ions and probably by slight disassociation of the sulfate.

4. In all investments investigated, thermal baking action of

the hot cast alloy commonly results in silica mobilization to depths

of 1/2 to 1 mm and sometimes up to 2 mm from the cast. These thermal

effects are likely to affect particle configuration and are expected

to influence the partial denture fit. It is obvious that different

parts of the cast will give off differing amounts of heat and that

this might affect in an anisotropic fashion particle configuration

and, therefore, mold deformation.

5. The corrosive effect of the cast alloy is usually very shallow.

However, at almost all investment cast interfaces, it appears that

induced silica fusion is enough to fill a very high percentage of the

interface pores with a viscous silica melt and melt-reaction products.

The resulting texture is such that this might have a pronounced effect on gas permeability. The zircon used in protective coats along

with fine-grained silica does not appear to react quickly and effectively enough to restrict this liquefaction. Certainly the incorporation

of sodium, probably largely in the form of metasilicate, in these protective coats promotes fusion.

6. Investments fired from 5 to 20 minutes under Durallium-alloy

17
beads in dynamic atmospheres of argon and air show corrosion.

Corrosion induced liquefaction appears to be more severe in the

argon atmosphere than in the air. However, the air atmosphere causes

the alloy to develop a highly porous structure. Chromium tends to

go into the more refractory components. In these investments, a very

thin blue zone is commonly developed deeper in the investment than

the green chromium-rich zone. The blue color of this zone indicates

that it is cobalt rich. It thus appears that cobalt oxide initially

diffuses more rapidly into the investment than the chromium. Cobalt

probably initiates and greatly extends silica fusion.

4.7. Reinforced EBA Cements

Sponsor: U.S.A.

Based on previous investigations in these laboratories, a number

of commercial EBA luting materials have appeared on the market. Resin

modified EBA restoratives show good stress-bearing characteristics

and should find applications as long-term temporary or intermediate

restorative materials. Recent studies by Bhaskar, Cutright, Beasley

and Boyers (Oral Surg., Oral Med. and Oral Path. 28:126 [1969]) have

shown that EBA cements will promote remineralization of decalcified

dentins. These properties should make EBA cements the materials of

choice in indirect pulp capping procedures since calcium hydroxide

does not possess the excellent sealing characteristics, whereas ZOE

or modified ZOE cements do not stimulate the formation of reparative

dentin to any appreciable extent. A detailed review of EBA cements

has been written and is appended to this report.

Pyrolysis-Gas Chromatography Techniques for Polymer Identification

The review of this subject has been brought up-to-date and is

scheduled for publication at an early date in Volume II of Advances

in Thermal Analysis.

4.8. Bonding of Monomers to Tooth Structure

Sponsor: U.S.A.

Improved Adhesion of Tooth Surfaces to Dental Restorative Resins

The objective of this investigation is to study various simple.

18
clinically feasible surface treatments for enamel or dentin to obtain efficient bonding between tooth surface and commercially available acrylic restorative materials. Bovine enamel or dentin were

treated with various acids or chelating agents and the bond strength

was determined, generally after 24-hour water exposure, by a tensile

adhesion test (J. Dent. Res. 48:211 (1969)). Round-robbin testing

indicated that results of this test fairly accurately determined the

magnitude of adhesion. Precision of the results between the different laboratories showed a coefficient of variation of 14%. Significant

adhesion of bovine enamel to acrylic resins was obtained by application of many dilute aqueous solutions of acids and of chelating agents

containing carboxylic acid groups to the tooth surface. Bond strength

to polished bovine teeth increased greatly on repeated pretreatment. Increasing concentration of the acid also increases the bond strength.

Thus, applying solutions of typical reagents such as 20% lactic acid,

5% 1,3,5-pentane tricarboxylic acid or 5% tetrahydrofuran-2 , 3 ,4 , 5-

tetracarboxylic dianhydride (TTAD) for 10 seconds, rinsing with water,

drying and then repeating the treatment after various time periods (3

min. to 24 hours) yielded enamel-acrylic restorative (Kadon) bond

2 strengths of up to 73 kg/cm (1040 psi)

No bonding was obtained without the pretreatment, whereas one

2 pretreatment with TTAD gave a tensile adhesion of 21 kg/cm (295 psi).

For TTAD bond strength increased if the second pretreatment was delayed.

Thus, repetition of the TTAD treatment after 3 min. yielded a bond

2 strength of 28 kg/cm (394 psi), whereas a second application after

2 one hour gave a value of 54 kg/cm (850 psi). Further delay in the

second application does not increase tensile adhesion. Exposure of

the interface to an aqueous environment for up to three months did

not reduce the bond strength.

Treatment of the enamel surface with 20% lactic or 5% 1,3,5-

pentanetricarboxylic acids repeated after 3 minutes gave tensile ad2 2 hesion values of 61 kg/cm (870 psi) and 51 kg/cm (720 psi), respectively. Such pretreatments should be clinically feasible. Somewhat lower

bond strength was obtained on treatment with many acids such as 50%

19
phosphoric-, 20% citric-, 5% quinic-, 5% 2- (hydroxyethyl ) ethylenediaminetetraacetic or 5% cis , cis , cis , cis-1 , 2 , 3 ,4-cyclopentane tetracarboxylic

acids. Adhesion was greatly lowered by pretreatment with a surfactant

to improve wetting. Treatment of the tooth surface with the tetrasodium

salt of ethylene-diaminetetraacetic acid in 0.001 M NaOH, a highly effective chelating agent for calcium, produced no bonding. Thus, the

increased adhesion is the result of the preferential dissolution of

enamel portions produced by the etching effect of the acid. This ex- planation was confirmed by scanning electron microscope pictures which

clearly indicate that 10 or 30-second exposure to dilute acid dissolves

portions of the surface enamel leading to the exposure of the enamel rods.

Improved adhesion probably results from the increased surface area produced by the pretreatment . However, no bonding was obtained with freshly cut dentinal surfaces.

Future efforts will be directed to find the most effective acid

treatment to be useful clinically. This study will involve the use of

a wide spectra of organic acids so as to correlate chemical structure

of the acid with efficiency of the enamel-restorative resin adhesive.

The scanning electron microscope will be utilized to determine in more detail the etching process. Equipment more suitable for the determination of the adhesion of resin restoratives to human dentin is being

constructed to evaluate the effectiveness of the various treatments

in bonding human enamel to acrylic restorative resins. It is hoped

that some clinical evaluation of this etching technique in combination

with placement of a restorative resin can be conducted in the near

future to assess its value in the treatment of precarious lesions.

4.9. Grafting of Monomers to Hard and Soft Tissues

Sponsor: U.S.A.

The initial objective of this study is to determine optimum con- ditions of grafting monomers to collagenous surfaces such as steer hide

powder and to characterize the presence of graft polymer on the surface.

A further aim is to graft by a simple experimental technique monomers

to hard tissues, especially dentin and bone. Another objective is to

determine what types of monomers can be grafted to a collagenous tissue

20
to yield a product with modified surface properties.

Grafting of over 20 monomers of varying polarity was investigated with ceric ammonium nitrate as initiator. Maximum weight in- creases were obtained after a 3-hour reaction time. A marked increase

in graft polymer yield was obtained employing 2% concentrations of

a wetting agent. Use of dioctyl sodium sulf osuccinate proved most

successful and resulted in grafted products having an increase in

weight of up to 114%.

A standardized grafting procedure was developed to determine the

amount of side chain polymer grafted onto the collagen backbone. This

procedure included removal of any soluble homopolymer by extraction

with a suitable solvent. Lower molecular weight acrylate and methacrylate esters can be grafted onto collagen in excellent yield. With

the higher homologous acrylate or methacrylates, the weight increase

due to graft polymer formed is decreased with increasing molecular

weight of the monomer. This effect may be caused by steric hindrance

as well as (1) the decreased solubility of the monomer in the reaction

mixture, and (2) lower rate of diffusion by the monomer into collagen.

Usually, smaller increases in weight were also obtained with acrylic

monomers containing functional groups such as chloro-, hydroxy-, dimethylamino- or jt-butylamino groups. With the polar methacrylic acid

monomer, only a 2% increase in weight was obtained. However, a collagenglycidyl methacrylate graft polymer with properties differing con- siderably from the steer hide collagen was obtained in good yield.

Such a product is likely to contain a hydroxyl group which could be

reacted to further modify the material.

Grafting of collagen to monomers such as vinyl acetate styrene,

acrylonitrile and vinylpyrrolidone was also demonstrated. Grafting

yields in aqueous solution vary widely, but probably can be improved

in mixed solvents. Studies of grafting to dentin and bone were also

initiated. Grafting to dentin was accomplished by presoaking dentin

powder in water in the presence of a wetting agent. After extraction

for 24 hours with acetone to remove homopolymer, an 8% increase in

weight was obtained as compared to a 21% weight loss for dentin powder

treated in the absence of methyl methacrylate monomer. Presence of

21
grafted poly(methyl methacrylate) was clearly established by the appearance of the COOCH^ absorption band around 1720 cm ^ in the infrared spectrum. Sections of dentin were also treated by this method.

Possible bonding of these surfaces to a commercial acrylic restorative was determined by a simple tensile adhesion test after storage

of the dentin-restorative resin interphase in water for 24 hours. A

slight adhesion was obtained as compared to no adhesion observed for

untreated dentin surfaces. However, further work is necessary to

prove if these values are significant.

A simple procedure was worked out to pulverize bone. Bone marrow

was cleaned and crushed in a Wiley mill in the presence of dry ice.

The powder was then sieved. Use of bone marrow eliminated the tedious

task of cleaning the bone of soft tissue. The powdered bone was subjected to the standard grafting procedure. A considerable amount

of the material remained in solution. The presence of possible grafts

is under active investigation. Thin collagen films have been procured

and grafting to such films will be studied. If these efforts are successful, physical and mechanical properties of the resulting products

will be determined. Possible surface changes after grafting will be

viewed by scanning electron microscope techniques.

4.10. Adhesive Composite Direct Filling Materials

Sponsor: ADA, NIDR (Grant)

The development of an adhesive restorative material for anterior

teeth continues. Since esthetics require that these materials have

translucency comparable to that of natural teeth, the fine particulate

reinforcing fillers must have refractive indexes that match, reasonably

well, the refractive index of the polymeric binder material. Consequently, of the 16 glasses prepared in the previous report, one was

found most suitable, and 20 pounds of it were prepared to our order

in powdered form by a commercial source. Previous investigations have

shown that the reinforcing filler particles should be spherical in shape,

rather than irregular. Consequently, a water-cooled cyclone separator

was designed and constructed. This device was equipped with a high

22
temperature filter bag attached to the exhaust of the cyclone

separator. This equipment will be used to investigate the feasibility

of preparing spherical particles from the irregular particles utilizing an oxygen-acetylene ceramic powder gun in conjunction with the

water-cooled cyclone separator. The glass powder to be used has a batch composition as follows:

Si0

2

, 70; BaF

2

, 8; B^, 4; A1 0 , 4; and ZnO

14 in mole percent.

In addition to having suitable x-ray opacity, it is anticipated that

its melting characteristics will be suitable for transformation into

spherical particles by the aforementioned equipment.

Further investigation of the ternary eutectic dimethacrylate

monomers, described in the previous report, was facilitated by co- operative efforts with a commercial organization whereby the monomer

in liquid form is now commercially available. Formerly it could be

obtained in crystalline form only. Utilizing this liquid, containing

a minimal amount of a known phenolic stabilizer, the relationship between the concentration of the stabilizer and the hardening time of

composite materials formulated with it was studied. Within the range

of interest with respect to the purpose of this project, the logarithm

of the hardening time had a linear relationship to the concentration

of the stabilizer.

The reaction products of glycidyl methacrylate with tertiary butyl

hydroquinone and with 2 , 5-di-_t-butyl hydroquinone , respectively, were synthesized and are being investigated. This is an attempt to provide

a hindered phenol-type stabilizer containing a copolymerizable methacrylate moiety, so that unreacted stabilizer or the reaction products

of the stabilizer (after the induction period) will be irreversibly

bound into the chains of the polymeric network.

The study of tertiary aromatic amines needed as polymerization

accelerators in these composite direct filling materials was continued.

The compound N ,N-bis- (3-p-tolyloxy-2-hydroxypropyl)- sym-m-xylidine was synthesized and purified by fractional recrystallization. This com- pound's high molecular weight, purity, and effectiveness in accelerating

23
polymerization in composite materials clearly demonstrated it to be

worthy of further investigation.

A surface-active coupling agent was synthesized (the reaction

product of N-phenyl glycine and p-chlorophenyl glycidyl ether) . This

will be compared with the previously reported coupling agents such as NPG-GMA (the reaction producty of N-phenyl glycine and glycidyl

methacrylate) and the reaction producty of N-phenyl glycine and

phenyl glycidyl ether, each of which significantly improved the adhesive bonding between composite materials and dentin surfaces. The

purpose of this comparison will be to evaluate the relative importance

of copolymerization and dispersion-force interactions between such

primers and polymeric materials. Such chelating coupling agents or primers might well have extensive applications in industry where protective coatings of metal or metal-containing surfaces are of economic

importance

A presentation entitled, "Composite Restorative Material" was given at the 50th Anniversary Symposium on Dental Materials Research

held at the National Bureau of Standards October 6-8, 1969, and the

first draft of the manuscript, which will form a chapter of the proceedings, has been prepared.

4.11. Three-Dimensional Panoramic X-Ray

Sponsor: A.F., ADA

The inoperative "original" panoramic dental x-ray machine has

been received from the Air Force (Brooks Air Base, Texas). This equipment is being renovated. A prototype 3-D camera (film carrier) is to

be designed and constructed. It is anticipated that this equipment

will allow two films to be exposed at the same panoramic exposure.

Adaptation of the process to non-dental related portions of the body

is also contemplated.

4.12. Bonding of Materials to Poly (methylmethacrylate)

Sponsor: ADA

Bonding cold-curing acrylic denture bases to acrylic teeth is

24
needed to replace the current dependence on mechanical retention.

Three methods of treating the teeth are under investigation:

1. Silica coating of the teeth followed by a silane

coupling agent.

2. Swelling and softening the teeth with solvent,

without or with heating.

3. Treating with a soluble polymer (PMMA) in various

solvents with or without heat.

Specimens were prepared by methods similar to ADA Specification No.

15, Sec. 3.7 and 4. 3. A. Controls of cold-curing base material and

acrylic teeth bonded to heat-curing denture base yielded average

2 strengths of about 500 kg/cm . Specimens subjected to various treat

2 ments with their respective average strengths in kg/cm are:

1. No treatment, 70.

2. Silica with silane, 0.0.

3. Painting liberally with cold-curing monomer (MMA) , 200.

4. CH

9 C1

2 and MMA, 260.

5. CH

2 C1 and MMA for

a. 2 min, 190

b. 5 min, 130

c. 7 min, 330

d. 10 min, 100

6. Heat with a solution of CH Cl ? and MMA monomer, 310.

2 2 2 7. PMMA dissolved in a CH Cl -MMA mixture, 380 kg/cm . These preliminary results present bonding strengths exceeding the

2 315 kg/cm required by ADA Spec. 15 in treatments 5c and 7. The de- crease in strength from 5c to 5d is attributed to excessive swelling

of the tooth by the solvent.

Future rests will determine the effects of successful technics

on the teeth. No crazing or softening has been observed. Neither

of these technics require additional equipment or time by the labora

tory technician. However, a production laboratory will be asked to

evaluate the technics to determine the practical merits.

25
4.13. Clinical Research

Sponsor: ADA, NIDR (Grant)

Clinical Evaluation of a Newly Developed Composite Restorative

Material

Fifty pairs of restorations were placed clinically in October

to December 1968 to evaluate a newly developed radiopaque anterior

filling material. Patients were recalled in December 1969 for the

first annual evaluation of these restorations. It is still too early

to draw any conclusions.

Development of a Radiopaque Denture Base Material

A literature search was made to determine the extent of the

need for an esthetically acceptable radiopaque denture base material.

It was found in a review of 123 cases of denture foreign bodies that

the greatest need was for resin based maxillary partial dentures to

which are attached one or more anterior teeth.

A radiopaque glass was previously developed for use as a reinforcing filler in dental restorative materials. It was thought that

this glass might be also useful as the filler in a radiopaque denture

base, thus fulfilling the above need.

The radiopaque glass was used with several monomers and polymers

to determine which combination appeared to exhibit the best characteristics for future development. The characteristics studied were optical

translucency , radiopacity, and general handling and finishing properties. Although several of these composite materials appeared to offer

possibilities for development, the one selected was based on poly (methyl

methacrylate) as the resin matrix. This material was selected because

of its long history of success as a denture base resin and because the

composite could be handled and molded with presently used techniques

and equipment.

Physical properties were determined on materials containing 30,

40, and 50% of the reinforcing glass as the filler and poly(methyl

methacrylate) as the resin matrix. The results indicated that these

materials would be acceptable as denture bases from a physical properties

viewpoint, but several disadvantages were evident. For example, the

26
densities and the ability to be finished to a smooth surface are less

than ideal

The materials were used in the construction of twenty technic

dentures to determine certain properties under actual fabrication conditions. Although dentures could be made without difficulty, it was

found that tooth breakage occurred in thick dentures containing 40

and 50% glass. The cause of the breakage appears to be the result of

a silane bond produced between the porcelain teeth and the composite

base material. If this is the case, then acrylic resin teeth could

be used as an alternative.

The glass filler used in this study contains barium and the

soluble salts of this element are extremely toxic. Therefore, before

clinical studies are instituted, studies may ha \e to be carried out

to find out what, if any, hazzard exists.

Clinical Evaluation of Two Resilient Denture Liners

Twenty-three dentures, 14 lined with Silastic 616 (Dow Corning)

and 9 with Coe Super Soft (Coe Dental Manufacturer) were evaluated

after being in service for 21 months. The majority of both types had

either deteriorated or lost their resilience to the extent that they

required replacement. Consequently, the following recommendations

are made for clinical use:

1. Use liners only in those cases requiring resilience

to replace lost normal tissue resiliency.

2. Observe at least every 3 months.

3. Limit or confine the material to a box shaped area having 90° angle finish line.

A manuscript has been prepared describing the results of this study.

Cavity Margin Sealing by Amalgam Restorations

Dimensional changes on hardening, as prescribed in the national

and international specifications, are being investigated to learn (a)

how the setting change relates quantitatively to the volume of the

spaces between amalgam and tooth, and (b) to establish clinically if

these spaces have pertinence to recurrent caries.

27
The procedure in this study is to determine quantitatively, by means of air under pressure, the degree of marginal seal obtained

when shrinking or expanding amalgams are placed in porcelain teeth.

Additional studies will be made of delayed expansion and corrosion

which may be caused by moisture condensation on the increments of

zinc-containing amalgam as they are placed in the mouth. Just as moisture condenses on a mouth mirror when in the mouth, it may also

condense on these increments of amalgam.

Progress to date includes:

1. Formulation and selection of 5 alloys with the following

dimensional changes on hardening, +60, +20, 0, -15, and -55 pm/cm in

24 hours.

2. Preparation of amalgam and alloy samples for characterization

by metallography.

3. Firing of porcelain teeth with Class I, Class V and MOD

cavity preparations (these teeth have holes drilled through the root

portion to the pulpal and axial walls to deliver air under pressure

to the base of amalgam restorations which will be placed in the

preparations)

4. Verification that the air-under-pressure test for quantitatively measuring the degree of adaptation is effective.

Future work includes:

1. Determination by using air under pressure of the effect of

the various dimensional changes on hardening on the degree of marginal

seal

2. Characterizing the alloy and resultant amalgams metallographically

3. Determining the effects on corrosion or delayed expansion

caused by moisture condensation on zinc-containing amalgam during

placement of the restoration.

4. Employing these variables in a clinical study.

4.14. Specifications and Advisory

Sponsor : ADA

28
4.14.1. Laboratory Testing for Subcommittee

on Orthodontic Wire

As part of the studies to develop a specification for orthodontic wires, the modulus of elasticity of 16 austenitic stainless

steel orthodontic wires was determined by a sonic method using the

Dynamic Modulus Tester PPM-5. Values varied from 26.4 to 30.1 x 10^

psi

The 6 inch-pound Tinius Olsen stiffness tester has been calibrated, and the results indicate that it is reproducible to 0.01

in. -lb. Preliminary work with Elgiloy Resilient wire shows that the

wire has a modulus of stiffness of about 17 x 10 psi. (The values

obtained by this procedure contain both elastic and plastic components according to the Tinius Olsen Company). With the 0.016 diameter

wire, a maximum moment of 0.16 in-lb was obtained for Elgiloy Resilient

while a maximum of 0.12 was obtained for Elgiloy Soft. For the purpose

of writing a specification, the maximum moment may be used as the measure

of resilience since the modulus values are approximately the same for

all wires tested.

4.14.2. Specification Committee Activities

Listed below are the Committee and Sub-committee assignments most

active in this current reporting period:

Chairman, American Standards Committee PH6 dealing with nomenclature, standards and specifications for dental x-ray film and dental

x-ray machines and accessories. .At the present time the committee is

voting on:

Draft USA Standard Exposure Time Designations for Timers

of X-ray Machines, PH6.4 - 1969.

Draft of Revision of USA Standard Size Designations and

Dimensions for Intraoral Dental Radiographic Film, PH6 . 2 - 1969.

Draft of Revision of USA Standard Speed Classifications for

Intraoral Dental Radiographic Film, PH6 . 1 - 1969.

Proposed changes in ADA Specification No. 22 for Intraoral

Dental Radiographic Film suggested by PH6 at its June 9, 1969

meeting.

All apparently are to be approved.

Leader: USA Delegation to the Plenary Session of ISO/TC 106 - Dentistry.

29
Vice chairman: WG 3 - Terminology and Miscellaneous.

Secretary: Subcommittee on Specification for Zinc Phosphate

Cements

Chairman: General arrangements committee for 1969 ISO/TC 106 - Dentistry meeting in Washington, D. C.

Chairman: FDI Commission on Dental Materials, Instruments,

Equipment and Therapeutics.

Chairman: Joint FDI/ISO Working Groups. These and the present

status of their work follow:

Joint Committee of FDI Commission on Dental Materials,

Instruments, Equipment and Therapeutics; ISO/TC 106-

Dentistry and ISO/TC 42-Photography on Specification

for Dental Radiographic Film

The Secretariat is preparing a third memorandum establishing the rules for mail balloting, sending copies of extant or proposed specifications and a draft proposal for discussion.

Joint FDI and ISO/TC 106-Dentistry Committee on Specification

For Root Canal Instruments

Rules for mail balloting have been agreed upon, a worldwide

list of manufacturers was prepared, extant specifications

(Japanese, Germand and USA) were collected, and several suggestions have been received. All of these have been transmitted

to the joint committee along with a list of proposed definitions

for root canal instruments and several motions.

An informal meeting was held by those attending the meeting

of ISO/TC 106 interested in the specifications for root canal

instruments. The Secretariat discussed methods of conducting

the work by correspondence and mail balloting, and received

comments which the Chairman will formalize as motions in the

next Circular Letter.

Joint FDI and ISO/TC 106-Dentistry Committee on Specification

for Zinc Silico-phosphate Cements

The Secretariat will initiate work on this project as the

current work on the ISO-FDI specification on zinc oxide-eugenol

cements is nearing completion.

30
Joint Committee of FDI , ISO/TC 106-Dentistry and IEC/TC 62-

Medical X-ray Equipment for Specifications for Dental X-ray

Machines

Resolutions were passed by ISO/TC 106 and this Commission at

its 1968 meetings establishing such a committee. The International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) has agreed to collaborate, but the exact mechanism of conducting the committee's

work has not been established. Correspondence with IEC is

proceeding to reach some agreement on the establishment of a joint committee of 24 members.

Procedure for Formulating and Revising International Specifications and Recommendations

By mail ballot the Commission voted for the establishment of

a joint FDI-ISO committee of six members to draft such a procedure. The ISO/TC 106 Secretariat agreed to such joint committee. The members are:

FDI - Dr. G. C. Paffenbarger USA

Mr. A. R. Docking Australia

Dr. F. E. Pinto Argentina

ISO - Prof. B. Hedegard Sweden

Mr. L. C. Smith UK

Dr. Vieillefosse France

ISO wishes to add another member to be nominated by Germany

and suggests an additional member from FDI.

Recommendations for Acceptance Programs for Dental Materials,

Equipment and Instruments

By mail ballot the FDI Commission on Dental Materials, Instruments, Equipment and Therapeutics (CDMIET) voted to propose a joint FDI-ISO committee of six members to draft a procedure as was recommended at the 1968 Varna meeting. ISO/TC 106-Dentistry

was invited to participate and circulated its member countries

after the FDI presented a more detailed scope of the work of

such a committee. The FDI suggestyd that such a committee would

explore all aspects of testing and accreditation programs for

dental materials, instruments and equipment, would consider who

has the primary responsibility, how the responsibility should be

divided, quality control, referee testing, resurveys, establishment

31