l

l1

l

UNITED STATESbISTRICTCOURT

SOIJTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

CaseNo. -CV-

(Judge'sLastNameN agistrate'sLastName)

:

EstateofCherishPnnkey.by

theoersonalrepresentativefortheEstate.

RobbiealTerrv-Brown

FILED BY D 4 .C.

Plaintiffts) ggg gj 2g22

v s. . jtïypLuty.

Ellk?tEt

. CnrnivalCruiseLines -.DOFq .'MIAMI

*' @.

s .vxb %

k-vx .o'.é <N-x tt-oc)

Defendantts).

/

Com plaint

1, Robbieal Terrp Browm the personal representative for the Estate of Chedsh Pankey.

rplaintiffl.intheabovestyledCause.OnDecember9.2021.CherishPrmkevs25vearsofageat

thetim e.boardedacarnival%M îracleCruiseVessel''alongw1t11herboygiçndandlliscousin on

athree-day cruiseto Ensenadm M exico.Itisalleaed bv otherpmssengers on board the vessel.

including the boyfriend's cousim in addition'to an elevator video whem Cherish and her

boygiendèatlbeseenmxuina.Anelevatorvideocapturedbvtheboyfriend'scousinshowedthat

:

on December 10.2021.Cherish wasarguing w1111herboyfriendthroughoutvariousareasofthe

vesselandthecomedydub.W ithoutintervention9om Carnival.Tllisleadsintotherlight.where

sheSghtsand s% gglesin herstateroom with herboyG end before fallingâom hertm h-floor

Case 1:22-cv-24004-BB Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/09/2022 Page 1 of 6
stateroom balconv-the earlv m orninzofDecember11.2021.A fallthatCnrnivalCruiseLines

l

hadnotcaptmednorwasawareof.CoupledO tIithedelayonthebovfriend'sparttoseekhelp.

W henCarnivalbecameawarenfsuchfallhm andstartedtheirsearch andcheckedthecam ermsto

verifvthefal.CarnivalcontactedtheUrlitedStatesCoastGuardforsearchandrescueeforts.A

tht'rty-m inutewindow orm orehadpmssed.leadingtheUrlitedStatesCoastGuard on afrivolous

search and rescue effort.Iwas inform ed thatthe video didn'tshow how she wentoverthe

balcony or how she landeds olzlv the assumption after. Search and rescue attem pts were

exhausting.* 111noluckfindincher.

Respectfully subm itted,

Date: December8.2022.

EstateofCherishPankey,by

thepersonalrepresentativefortheEstate.

RobbiealTeny-Brown

Nam eofFiler

AttorneyBarNtlmber(fapplicable)

AttomeyE-mailAddress(fapplicable)

Firm Nnme(fapplicable)

Case 1:22-cv-24004-BB Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/09/2022 Page 2 of 6
I

I

r

(1''frim topofpage,andcentered,

begintitlechfCourt) l

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

CaseNo. -Civ(Judge'sLastNameN agistrate'sLastName)

'

(FulNameofPlaintif/s),%%uwx. wv e-wcvsx-kcxok.-q.

Plaintif(s) X xytuxv 'kGxxwkhavwzxaoxw . xv-'orix. u-xk.q. (.NOuvyye.

VS. 1

(Fu1NameofDefendant/s),

Defendantts).

Q-y qw-fkqèktl-kuxkstMkixvsj j

k-G t w'Jxcuk. t-orkuukv voo w)ovxo'.vo-k VYoNv''Nu

O PLAINT x .

..

-

- '--xxjk . xc

vo u xws kau... x . x e.ùX Mk p 'ntifr

. l , , intheabove ledcause,suedetkndants): .1 xç0-.$ V .

wxx t.. c. .sk t. .0 Nx x Ne- kN-w fxykkc.y

Q.% R .

Thisactionisfiledunder(indicateunderwhichfederallaw orsectionoftheU.S.C stitution

thisactionisbeingfledl:L- x *-N.Y Z% -';'V %% S6 hi'A 'Y-- Mk V X' *' . '

Dated:M onth,day,year

NhA%h8.&k* Rjs-pwecwtfuxlwysubmitedk

,u'.kLr'N%w '

wjk

..q ,.rouk4uu

NameofFile N Exosw

AttorneyBarNumber(ifaplicable)

AttorneyE-mailAddress(ifapplicable)

Firm Name(ifapplicable)

StreetAddress

City,State,ZipCode

Telephone:(xxxlxxx-xxxx

AtorneysforPlaintiff/Defendant(partyNametsll

(ifapplicable)

Case 1:22-cv-24004-BB Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/09/2022 Page 3 of 6
' Q

'?'

xuqxjvx OV. W '<SQ SERVICXiLIST

tk1 u Nb '%..wxv t.ksootx

PartyorA orneyNa e ' xPSiIbYVVIP' PartyOrAttorneyName

%-kY%V% .

. uvvk-wk

AtorneyE-mailAdress(IfaplicabF. ' =OAtorneyE-mailAdress(Ifaplicable)

R . vu3

Firm Name(fapplicable) Firm Namenfapplicable)

StreetAddress

t-A- 'okïA. . %(...I.

City,State,ZipCode

Telephone:<y-. ) ç-t-s-qlkj

Facsimile:

Attolmeysfor 1' ' efendant

I'par'ty'sNamelsl.l(i plicable)

Street?kddress

City,State,Zip Code

Telephone:

Facsimile:

AttorneysforPlaintiffr efendant

fparty'sNamelsll(fapplicable)

Case 1:22-cv-24004-BB Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/09/2022 Page 4 of 6
1

CertificateofService*

.

%.k

Iherebycertifythatatnleandcorectcopyoftheforegoingwasservedby(specl vxt-.ï

methodofserviceqongdateqonal1counsel rpa ' recordontheServiceListbelow.

ïkhyoïJ'.vpA.

Signatreo 1er

*:aCertificateofServiceisonlyrequirediffiledconventionally(notthroughCM/ECF).seeSection3K(4),CM/

ECFNextGenAdministrativeProcedures.

!

Case 1:22-cv-24004-BB Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/09/2022 Page 5 of 6
% h Yv&l

Dated:M o th,d y,year Relspec,txfu-.lyvsiubm/it)%ed.,% k. ks4x kbje.,r

P q % < . x .

Name f .je v'

.

N, <sje. oxaw.j .Qokhx w k

. %X -t< v- etyx.u wv-.

AttorneyBarNumber(Ifapplicable)

AttorneyE-mailAddress(fapplicable)

Firm Nam enfapplicable)

StreetAddress

City,State,ZipCode

Telephone'. -

Facsim ile:

AttorneysforPlaintiff/Defendantfpartynametsl.l

(fapplicable)

CertificateofService

Iherebycertifythatatrueandcorectcopyoftheforegoingwasselwedby

N KV- k gspecirymethodofservicelon ïù yate)

onal1counselorpartiesofrecordontheServiceListbelow.

Sinat eofFiler (/

Case 1:22-cv-24004-BB Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/09/2022 Page 6 of 6