RETURN OF SERVICE

UNITEDSTATESDISTRICT COURT

Miami-Dade Distrid ofFlorida

CaseNumber:22-C*23543-R%

Plaintqs:

MalvinGarnet,NCG,Minor

VS.

Defendants:

YasminMorshe ian;MarieLiakexud;due efb-rgeSardy;LesliePuzo;General

MagistrateCarlos Fernane z;Priscille Duvalsaint;DikshaMehanSharma

For:

MalvinGarnett

437SW 3Street,#4

Miami,FL33130

ReceivedbyMiamiPSPI,LLC onthehhdayofNovember,2022at1:35pm tobeservedonGeneralMagistrateCarlos

Fernandezv175NW 1Avenue,#1726,Miami,FL33128.

1,JosephOnega,doherebyaffirm thatonthe16thdayofIw -eme r,2022at12:e pm,1:

SERVEDanauthori- individualbydeliveringatruecopyoftheSUMMONSINACIVILACTION,ORDER INCASES

W ITHMULTIPLEDEFENDANTS,andAMENDEDCOMPIAINTFORVIOLATIONOFCIVILRIGHTSwiththedateandhour

ofserviceendorsedthereonbyme,to:CHERYLROBINSON,asadminilrativeassistanttoPatriciaGladlonGeneral

CounselasEmploy- Authori- ToAcceptServiceattheaddressof:175NW 1Avenue,Room 3nM ,Miami,FL33128,

whostatedtheyareauthorizedtoaceptserviceforCarlosFernane yandinformedsaidpersonofthecontentstherein, in

compliancewithstatestatutes.

Additionallnformatione rlainingtotbis% -iee:

11/22/2022 12:00pm Atemptedserviceat175NW 1Avenue,#1726,Miami,FL 33128.Theoffice isIocked.Nooneis

present.Thefloorhalwaysareempty.

11/28/2022 9:24am Attemptedserviceat175NW 1Avenue,#1726, Miami,FL 33128,.TheofficeisIocked.Noanswer

whenlknock.Noone ispresent.

12/2/2022 2:50pm Attempted serviceat175NW 1Avenue, #1726,Miami,FL 33128.Theolice isIocked.Noone is

Present.SecurityintheIobbyhasnoinformationaboutCarlosFemandez'sworkinghoursorwhenhiisintheoffice.

12/14/2022 9:45am Attemptedserviceat175 NW 1Avenue, #1925,Miami,FL 33128.ThedoorisIocked.Noanswer.

12714/2022 10:27am Attempte serviceat175NW 1stAve., Rœ m 3033,Miami,FL33128.Thisistheoffice ofPatricia

Gladson.Sheisnothere.1*m toldatlherecepb'ondeskthatshewillikelybeintomorrow midmoming.

12/16/2022 12:45pm ServedChefylRobinson,asadministrativeassistanttoPatriciaGladsonGeneralCounsel,at175NW

1stAve.,Room 3033,Miami,FL33128.Servedinthismannerpertheplaintiff'srequest.

DescriptionofPersonServed:Age:50, Sex:F,Race/skinColor:Black,Height:5'61Weight:135,Hair:Black,Glasses:Y

IacknowledgethatIam overtheageof18wars,ing* dstandinginthejudicialcircuitinwhichthisprocesswasserved

aSndthatIhave nointerestintheaboveaction. Undermnaltyofperjury,IdeclarethatIhavereadtheforegoingReturno,f

erviceandtheadsstated in itaretrue.F.S.92.525(2).

J phon

s1861. s 1253

Miamipsp1,LLC

1800coralway,Suite1511

Miami,FL33145

(30* 285-4321

OurJobSerialNumber:NA7-2022001902

CopyKght@ 1992-- D'*e*''maServk;es#x)-Pt----'S- sTcx:tm W lc

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 25 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/28/2022 Page 1 of 4
RETURN OFSERVICE

UNITED STATES DISTRICTCOURT

Miami-Dade Distrid ofFlorida

CaseNumber:22-CV-23543-R%

Plaintiff:

MalvinGarnet,NCG,Minor

VS.

Defendants:

YasminMorshe ian;MarieLiautaud;JudgeGe rgeSardy;LesliePuzo;General

Magistr---CarlosFernane z;Priscile Duvalsaint;Diksha MehanSharma

For:

MalvinGarliet

437SW 3Street,#4

Miami,FL33130

ReceivedbyMiamiPSPI,LLC ontheethdayofNovember,2022at1:35pm tobeservedonYasminMorshe ian,1East

Broward Boulevard,#700,FortLauderdak,FL3RM 1.

1,JosephOnega,doherebyaffirm thatonthe22nddayofY m- r,zozzat11:05am,1:

SUBSTITUTEservedbydeliveringatruecopyoftheSUMMONSINACIVILACTION,ORDERIN CASESWITHMULTIPLE

DEFENDANTS,andAMENDEDCOMPIAINTFORVIOLATIONOFCIVILRIGHTSto:AGxaSalnx r,r---lionistatthe

virtualoffioe,apersonincharge oftheprkatemaile x,virtualoffice,orexecutive officeorminisuiteattheaddressof:1

EastBrowardBoulevard,A 00,FortLauderdale,FL33301:afterdeterminingthattheD rsontobeservedmaintainsa

mailbox,avirtualoffice,oranexecutiveofficeorminisuiteatthatIœation,incompliancewithFLAYlte ï48.031(6).

DesoriptionofPersonServed:Age:30,Sex:F,Race/skinColor:White,Height:5'5'',Weight:140,Hair:Black,Glasses:N

lacknowledgethatIam overtheageof18w ars,ingoodstandinginthejudicialcircuitinwhichthisprocesswu served,

andthatlhavenointerestintheaboveaction.UnderD naltyofpetury,)declarethat1havereadtheforegoingReturnof

ServiceandtheactsstatedinRaretrue.F.S.92.525(2).

J phO

S 1861' S1253

Miamipsp1.Luc

18c0coralWay,suxelsll

Miami,FLaalls

(x s)iase al

OurJobSerialNum- r:NAY-2022œ 1897

Copydght@ 1992-N22D'AG''-Setvie se ..prtxv S- r'STfmltm e.lc

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 25 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/28/2022 Page 2 of 4
RETURN OF SERVICE

UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT

M iami-DadeDistrid ofFlorida

CaseNumber:22-CV-23543-8%

Psaintl:

MalvinGarnu,NCG,Minor

VS.

Defendants:

YasminMorshe ian;MarieLiautaud;Jue eGeorgeSardy;LesliePuzo;General

Magistr --CarlosFernanzœ *;Priscile Duvalsaint;DikshaMehanSharma

For:

MalvinGarnett

437SW 3Street,#4

Miami,FL33130

ReceivedbyMiamiPSPI,LLConthe8thdayofNovem*r,2022at1:35pmtobeservedonJuë eGe rgeSarduy,175

NW 1Avenue,* 925,Miam i,FL33128.

1,JosephOnega,doherebya#irm thatonthe16thdayofn- m- r,2022at12:45pm,1:

SERVED anauthori- individualbydeliveringatruecopyoftheSUMMONSINACIVILACTION,ORDERINCASES

WITHMULTIPLEDEFENDANTS,andAMENDEDCOMPLAINT FORVIOLATIONOFCIVILRIGHTSwiththedateandhour

ofserviceendorsedthereonbyme,to:CHERYLROBINSON,asadministrativeassistanttoPatrieiaGladsonGeneral

CounselasEmploye Authorl!e ToAcœ pt% rviceattheaddressof:175NW 1Avenue,Room 3n*q,Miami,FL33128,

whostatedtheyareauthorizedtoacceptserviceforGeorgeSarduy,and informedsaidpersonofthecontentstherein,in

compliancewithstatestatutes.

AdditionalInformationG rœiningtothis% rvice:

11/22/2022 11:50am A/emptedserviceat175NW 1Avenue,#1925,Miami,FL 33128.ThejudgechamberdoorisIocked.

Noanswer.IaskedseveralpeopleinthehalwayaboutwhereIcanfindthejudgebutnonehaveanyinformation.Thejudges

nameisGeorgeSarduy

11/28/2022 9:09am Attemptedserviceat175NW 1Avenue,#1925,Miami,FL 33128.TheofficeisIocked.Noonehas

information.Thehalwayisempty

12/2/2022 3:05pm A/emptedserviceat175NW 1Avenue,#1925,Miami,FL 33128.Theofficeislocked.Nooneis

present.Thesecun'tyinthelobbyhu no information.

12/6/2022 2:26pm PerthePlaintiftforthefinalatempt,servePatriciaGladson,œ iceOfGen.Counsel,11thJudCirCt.

LawsonEThomasCoue ouseCenter,Room M tkq,175NW ls'tAve.,Miami,FL33128.ThisisforJudgeSarduy

(2022001903)andMagistrageFernandez(2022* 1902).

12/14/2022 10:27am Attemptedserviceat175 NW 1stAve.,Room 3033,Miami,FL33128.ThisistheofficeofPatricia

Gladson.Sheisnothere.I'm toldatthereceptiondeskthatshewilIikelyte intomorrow midmoming.

12/16/2022 12:45pm ServedCherylRobinson,asadministrativeD sistanttoPatriciaGladsonGeneralCounsel,at175NW

1stAve.,Room 3033,Miami,FL33128.Servedinthismannerpertheplaintifrsrm uest.

IuecriptionofPersonServed:Age:50,Sex:F,Race/skinColor:Black,Height:516'1,W eight:135,Hair:Black,Glasses:Y

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 25 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/28/2022 Page 3 of 4
RETURN OF SERVICE For22-W -23543-RKA

lacknowledgethatIam overtheageof18years,ingoodstandinginthejudicialcircuitinwhichthisprocesswasserved,

andthatlhavenointerestintheaboveaction.Underpenaltyofperjury,IdeclarethatIhavereadtheforegoingReturnof

Serviceandtheactsstatedinitaretrue.F.S.92.525(2).

J phOn

S 1861. S 1253 '

MiamiPSPI,LLC

1800CoralW ay,SuRe1511

Miam i,FL33145

(305)285+ 21

OurJobSerialNumber:NAY-2022001903

Copydght@ 1992-** D'eGeM Selvicesk:c-Pr-----H sTcol*xV8lc

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 25 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/28/2022 Page 4 of 4