M ALVIN GARNETT,M INOR NCG

PLAINTIFF

V.

LesliePuzo,DikshaM ehan Sharm a,JudgeGeorgeSarduy,

PriscilleDuvalsaint,GeneralM agistrateCarlosFem andez, PriscilleDuvalsaint,

Yasm inM orshedian,

RESPON DENT.

FILED BY D.C.

IJNITED STATESDISTRICTCOURT wj. ('Ar.!gj yjyy

SO UTHERN DISTRICT O F FLORIDA ,

' ,ï .ï r',

juL(1..:. )jyi:..k.t.!..,

'-

.zb(;.'..;,i.>-rk!p;'.év1I .Vmœ .a<u>a..;.>œ '

CASE NO.:22-C V-23543-11.FM WX

RESPONSEFOR RULETO SHOW CAUSEAND REOUESTFOR EXTENSION.

COM ESNOW ,thePlaintiff,M ALVIN GARNETT,bymeansofprose, andherebyfilesthis

requestforextension..

OnDecem ber11,2022,theplaintiffrequestedfrom theJudgesolution forsubstituteservice

andhasnotisedthecoursewithevidenceofattemptsofservicefora11partiesthatwerenot

served.

Thepurposeoftheproseplaintiffshowingattem ptsto show thatthisisnotani11attem pt.

Therehasbeenattemptsofallpartiesfrom 1weekofthislawsuitbeingfiled. Thiscaseisthe

oppositeoftheFloridaSupremeCourtissuingtheM oralesv.Sperry Rand, 601So.2d538

(F1a.1992)decisioninthiscasetheattorneywaited110daysbeforestartingservice.laskthat

thecourthavebroaddiscretioninreviewingthefactsand determinethatgoodcausebe

establishedforfailingtoservethecomplaintwithin 120days.

OnDecember28,2022n eHonorableRoyAltm anhasstatedthatonly 1outof7plaintiffs

wasservedonDecem ber28,at11:23AM aruletoshow causewasissued. Ironicallythepro

sedoesnotreceiveitemselectronicallybecauseprose.At1:09pm coincidentallythepro se

plaintiffbroughtin3returnofservicemakingitnow 4outof7defendantshavebeenserved.

2.

3.

4. ltseem swhathmsmatteredinpreviouscaselaw istheattemptswerelateduetonegotiatingor

investigatingthecase.Therehasbeen numerousattempts. Ontheremainingthreeparties.

W hentheproseaskfortheJudgetoreview thefactsofthecase, thisisafatherthatwent

throughafalsedom esticviolencecasefor8m onthsandhedidnotseehisexwife. W iththat

being saidtheprocessserverisgoingtothehouse. OnDecem ber14,2022thenon service

affidavitwasuploadedforPriscilleDuvalsaintandM arieLiautaud. Therehasbeenover7

attem ptsatresidentialhomeanddefendantslawyersoffice. TheattemptsmadeEXHIBIT 1

AsfarasLesliePuzothe7attemptshavebeenuploadedonDecember14, 2022aswellm ore

importantlysheisonvacationfrom Decem ber5, 2022toJanuary 5,2023thenoticeof

unavailabilityisattachedEXHIBIT 2.

5.

6.

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 1 of 9
7. lfPriscilleDuvalsaintandM arieLiautauddoesnotanswerthedoor,theplaintiffwould

requestforthatthesllmm onsbeissuedbyregularm ailfrom theclerkoranyothersolution

deemedbytheJudge.

8. Thisisasensitiveissuebecausetheonlyotheroptiontosew eiswhenPriscilleDuvalsaintis

droppingminorchildofftoschoolbutthefatherwmstryingtoavoidthatingontoftheminor

child.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

1HEREBY CERTIFY thatatrueandcorrectcopyofthisMotionwasservedonPetitioner,

PriscilleDuvalsaint,viaherattorney,atthefollowingem ailaddress:

LesliePuzo,Esq.

leslie@puzohemandez.com

Attorneyfor

Petitioner

On DateJanuary4,2023

t e

M alvinGam ett

437SW 3raST #4

M iami,FL 33130

1

.

2

i

.-

' . t

it

tq

7

t

Jq

l

.i

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 2 of 9
EX H IB IT 1

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 3 of 9
RETURN OF NON-SERVICE

UNITED STATES DISTRICTCOURT

Miami-DadeDistrictofFlorida

CaseNumber:22-C*23543-RKA

Plainti#:

MalvinGarnet,NCG,Minor

VS.

Defendants:

YasmlnMorshe lan;Ma* Llautaud;Juë eGe meSardy;LeslePuzo;General

Maglstrateœ rlosFernandc ;PriscileDuvalu lnt;DlkshaMehanShanna

For:

MalvinGarnett

437SW 3Street,#4

O ami,FL33130

Re eivedbyMiamiPSPI,LLC onthe8thdayofNovember,2022at1:35pm tobeservedonMarleLk.zeAud,ByA rvlng

LeslePunn,Esq.,1175 NE 125St----#* 18,NodhMiami,FL33161.

1,JosephOnœ a,doherebyaffirm thatonthe1+ dayofn- m - r,ZOZZat1:30pm,1:

NON-SERVEDtheSUMMONSIN A CIVILACTION ORDER IN CASES WITH MULTIPLE DEFENDANTS,andAMENDED

COMPLAINTF0RVIOLATIONOFCIVILRIGHTSJuetonoresponseonatemptesIiste bebw.

M dltle alInfe #lqnG lalningtothls% rvIœ :

11/1ù/2022 10:16am Atemptedserviceat1175NE125Street,#618,NorthMiami,FL 33161.ThedoorisIœ ke . No

answer.Therlpk.lhWprsareIx ked.

11/14/2022 11:47am Attemptedserviceat1175NE125Street,R 18,NorthMiami,FL 33161.The(soorisIx ke .No

answer.Theneighborloldmesheseesthem onFridap .

11/18/2022 10:53am Attemptedserviceat1175NE125Street#618, NorthMiami.FL 33161.Leglie':assistr SaZ Leslie

i.notin.Sh:cqnx ygivemeanyinformationbesidesLeslieworksmostlyremote.

11&7* 22 7:32pm Aqempte serviceat2321LagunaCircle,#709,Miami,FL 33181. Thisisanapartment Noanswer

andnomovement.Theneighborhasnoinformation.

11/:6/D 22 7:58am Attempte serviceat2321LagunaCircle,#709,Miami, FL 33181.Noanswerandnomovement

11/:9/2022 8:35pm Atempte serviceat2321LagunaCircle,#70%MiamiuFt 33181.Noanswerandnomovement.

12/1/2022 1:30pm Attempte serviceat2321LagunaCircle, #709,Miami,FL 33181.Noanswerandrlomovement. Al1

wasdarkari quiet.

Iacknowle gethatIam overtheageof18mars,ingtx)dstandinginthejudtialcircuitinwhichthisprx esswasserved

andthatIhavenointerestintheAhnveaction. , S Ue erpenaltyofperjury,IdK larethatIhavereadtheforegoiœ Returnof

erviceandtheactsstate initaretrue.F.S.92.52542).

phOn a

S 1861' S 1253

MlamlPSpI,LLc

1M ncœ alWay,Suite1511

Mlami,FL33145

(305)2- 21

Our2obSerialNumber:NAY-2022œ 1K 0

Copyhght@ 1* 2.2022D-e poSœ'vie.esKc..Prc.erpsSœveslœltm * .1c

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 4 of 9
RETURN OF NON-SERVICE

UNITEDSTATESDISTRICTCOURT

Miami-Dade DistrictofFlorida

CaseNumber:22-CV-23543-RKA

Plaintiff:

MalvlnGarnet,NCG,Mlnor

VS.

Defendants:

YasmlnMorshe lan;Ma* Llautaud;Jue eGK œeSaYy;LeslePum ;General

MaglstrMeœ rlosFem ardc ;PriscilleDuvalu int;DlkshaMee nShac a

For:

MalvinGarnet

437SW 3Street,#4

H ami,FL33130

Re eive byMiamiPSPI,LLConthe8thdayofNovember,2022at1:35pm tobeserve onPHe lleDuvalu lnt,By

A rvlngLeslleP1z- ,E< .,1175NE 125St---#* 18,North Mlam l,FL33161.

1,JosephOnœ a,doherebyaffirm thatonthe1< dayofn- m- r,ZOZZat1:30pm,1:

NON/ERVE;theSQMMONSINACIVILACTION ORDERINCASESWITHMULTIPLEDEO NDANTS,andAMENDED

COMPLAINTFORVIOLATIONOFCIVILRIGHTSJuetonoresponseonatempteslistedbebw.

M dltlonalInformatione rtalningtothis% rviee:

11/10* 22 10:16am Attempte serviceat1175NE 125Street,#618,NorthMiami,FL 33161.Thedx rise ke .No

answer.TheneMe rsareIxked.

11/142022 11:47am Attemptedserviceat1175NE125Street,#618,NorthMiami,FL 33161.ThedoorisIx ke .No

answer.Theneighbortoldmesheseesthem onFridao .

11/18/2022 10:53am Attempte serviceat1175NE 125Street,e 18,NorthMiami,FL 33161.Leslie'sassistant= '18Leslie

isnotin.ShecannotgivemeanyinformationbesidesLeslieworksmostlyremote.

11/22* 22 7:32pm Attempte serviceat2321LagunaCircle,#709,Miami,FL 33181.Thisisanapartment.Noanswer

andnomovement.Theneighborhasnoinformation.

11/26* 22 7:58am Attempte serviceat2321LagunaCircle,#709,Miami.FL 33181.Noanswerandnomovement.

11/29* 22 8:35pm Anemptedserviceat2321LagunaCircle,#709!. .

MiamiuFL 33181.NoanswerandnomovemM t

12/1/2022 1:30pm Attemptedserviceat2321LagunaCircle,#709,Miami,FL 33181.Noanswerand nornovement.AI

wasdarkandquiet.

Iacknowle gethatIam overtheageof18wars,ingG)dstandiY inthejtzkialcircuitinwhthtNsprxmesswasserved,

andthatlhavenointerestinthenimveaction.Underpenaltyofperjury,Ide arethatIhavereadthefore oiœ Retum of

Serviceandtheactsstate initaretrue.F.S.92.525(2).

J hon

S 1861' S 1253

MlamlPSPI,LLc

18* coralw ay,SuRe 1511

Miam i,FL33145

(305)2- 21

OurJobSerialNumber:NAY-209*m1899

Copydght@ 1992-2022Dnfnlmm Fevice ,Mc.-Prtm.- SœvesTxltm W .1c

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 5 of 9
EX H IB IT 2

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 6 of 9
Filing# 144232584E-Filed02/18/202204:14:50PM

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF TIIE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL Cm CUIT

IN AND FOR M IAM LDADE COUNTY,FLORIDA

IN RE:'ITIE M ARRIAGE OF

PRISCILLE DW ALSAINT GARNEW ,

Petitioner/FormerW ife,

and

M ALW N LEOPOLD GARNETT,

Respondene ormc Husband.

/

NOH CE OF IJNAVAHA HJW

CASE NO.:2019-013774-FC-04

PLEASE TAK E NOTICE,thattheundersigned attomey hereby slesthisNotice of

Unavailability,forthefolloe gdates:

Februarv7.2022tllrove:Februarv;5.:1422

M arch3.2022throuehM arch8.2022

Afarch25.2022throuehsfarch31.2022

Anril6.2:22throuellApril12.2* 2

Julv/4.2022tlrouellAugust5.2942

November21.2022throu@ Norepbsr- 45.;N2

Decem ber6.2022throlœllJanaarv5.2023

Inordertoavoidanypotentialconllids,theundeoignedisrespectfullyrequestingthatno

hearingsordepositionsbe scheduled during theabove dates;any moéons, noticeto produce

interrogatoriesorotherpleadingsbeGledwllichrequireatimelyresponseduringsaidtime;and

thata11pendingmattersremaininstatusquo.

n e fling and service ofthisNotice shallconstitute an application and requestfor

continlnnce,extension oftime,motion for protective orderas the undersigned may deem

approptiateum nreviewingtheple ' fledduringtheabovestatedtimeperiod-

- CERM CATE OFSERW CE TO FOLLOW ON NEXT PAGE -

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 7 of 9
Noticeo/t/azpcf/eflf/.p

Page2of2

CERTHICATE OF SERNICE

IHEREBY CERTIFY thatatnzeandcorrectcopyoftheforegoingwasprovidedto

JenniferFordaEsq.,AttomeyfortheRespondenW ormerHusbandthroughemailat

Jennifer@jennifedbrd.lawyeronthe18*dayofFebruary2022.

PUZOLAW

1175N.E.125= STREET

SUITE618

Nok'rllM IAMI,FL33161

TEL:(305)428-2220

By:/sl eslie'l/zo

LESLIEPUZO,EsQ.

FLORDABARNU- E1419791

LESLG D LAW.COM

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 8 of 9
RETURN OFNON-SERVICE

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

Miami-DadeDistrlctofFlorlda

CaseNumber:22-CV-23543-R%

Plaintiff:

MalvinGarnet,NCG,Mlnor

VS.

Defendants:

YasmlnMorshe lan;MarleLlautaud;Jue eGe r:eSaYy;LeslePuzo;General

MaglstrdeCarlosFernandez;Prlsolle DuvalR int;DlkshaMee nShanna

For:

MalvinGarnet

437SW 3Street,#4

Miami,FL33130

ReceivedbyMiamiPSPI,LLConthe8thdayofNovember, 2022at1235pm tobeserve onLeslh PI'>n,1175NE125

Stre t,R 18,North Miami,Fk331q1.

1,JosephOnega,doherebyaffirm thatonthegthdayofA cember,2Q22at11:11am,1:

NON-SERVEDtheSUMMONS IN A CIVILACTION,ORDER IN CASES W ITH MULTIPLE DEFQNDANTS,andAMENDED

COMPLAINTFORVIOLATIONOFCI#IkRIGHTSforthereasonsdetaile inthecommentsbelow.

M ditionalInform ationG rtalningtothlsServ-m :

11/102022 10:16am Attemptedserviceat1175NE 125Street,R 18,NorthMiami,FL 33161. Thedoorislx ked.No

answer.TheneighborsareIocked.

11/14/2022 11:47am Attemptedserviceat1175NE 125Street,e 18, NorthMiami,FL 33161.Thedoorislœ ked.No

Answer.Theneighbortoldmesheseesthem onFridap .

11/18/2022 10:53am Atemptedserviceat1175 NE 125Street

!

#f18,NorthMiami,FL 33161.Leslie'sassistantsaidLeslie

isnotin.ShecannotgivemeanyinformationbesidesLeslieworksmostlyremote.

11/23/2022 10:51am Attemptedserviceat1175 NE 125Street. R 18,NorthMiami,FL 33161.ThedoorisIx ke andthere

isnoanswer.

11/28/2022 11:52am Attemptedserviceat1175NE 125Street,e 18, NorthMiami,FL 33161.ThedoorisIœ ked.No

answ er.

12/1/2022.2:25pm Attempte H rviœ at1175NE 125Stçeet,R 1:,G rtl:W ami, FL 33161.Tt* * is< e .Y answeç.

Theneighborhasnoinformation.

12/9/2022 11:11am Attemptedserviceat1175NE125Street,#618, NodhMiami,FL 33161.Thed* risIocke . No

ansWer.

lacknowlegethatIam overtheageof18mars,ing*dstandingintheje tialcircuitinwhththisprœesswasserved,

andthatIhavenointereM intheaboveaction.Underpenaltyofperjury,ldK larethatIhavereadthefore oiœ Returnof

Serviceandtheactsstate initaretrue. F.S.92.52542).

J hO a

S 1861, S 1253

MlamlPspl,LLc

lM ncoralw ay,suRe1511

Mlam1,FL33145

(305)2- 21

OurJobSerialNumber:NAY-2022001898

Copydght@1992.2022Datem- Se ces,Kc.-PrtressS- e sTtmlMxV .1c

Case 1:22-cv-23543-RKA Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/04/2023 Page 9 of 9