(©)

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 20 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

(2) If you did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why:

This issve ans prot Presentesl or PreServeck badeal on Ve Ack fevers carl
(welhective AS3rSHtante. OF CoOmSel ,

Post-Conviction Proceedings:

(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?
Yes | Nok

(2) If you answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Type of motion or petition:

Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes CL] No ‘|

(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?

‘Yes CJ No LC]

(5) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?

Yes CL] No CI

(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:

Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) If your answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

Page 7 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 41 of 68

i

photo of ber Pollisy her irk up, Exposing her supple. oust A ~ a

emticeaink of & Minor to exxgatie. in Sean Ackiviteg)e ” Ccesphasis collet)
| Tocte'S Uipulatect condack, while. Pepeqrant cle? rk anton
40 “Seawel Ackirity”, ie. the Proobuctions of Child poewogeaphu. There i$
No evidence, IHD thee Fackval bats te Sappoct a, cerruithion) thet Thrdler
erticedl a enor to Pcodkce. a Photograph. Asch chile. Here 19 angle
evtelessee. beSecl op the Bipvlatedl fetS thot Tracker attesptecl to
Proce, a rnule Pledegrnph, panel Bcees3 Fuiley click Gecite. Chile
Ponoegrfle pNedher ave Fails within He Federn( definition of

33
“Cosel Ackivi tag” iS Celation te Chiled peenege phy.

Firsnske , there iS wo eviclewce iv Discovery thet a. phetograph
OF AVE oh cer prechitel fac Trader. A forenBit. xan of Muss
electronic. cbsice. Gord tose. Speti Creal , the tite. asl date Hosp
CF the tun ietaged Mud Ses to Trncler, Gnd tsever aliaste Th S 18
eportawt becate od He. wight OF Avy 30; 201F, cherd the. Thewseavitle
police. Lepartrrent invibiotle feportedl to wua’s hevw- her tedber Siqred
a ConSent to Search for for her adaugider'’ tabled.

Dering the. initial Sorch of thet teblet, ne of He responding

OFF :cec8 “ Weteck thooogh, He MesSageS art the Seu Ai opp axel Foch Savnl
cle Conver snbions Ob bes thet lav} hnol era ber Phere. . Toelvcliny
(Seok tere wore Fue men aesqgitee ev Tl the ak Sue. Poitse
ackitteol to Kiwccding De ead Goong / cnakrage, eral Bill Revestisig photos
ot her or Seuelinag her Suck. pheteS of HlewSelve3."


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 37 of 68

Conrdbock arte WigdS of shea 1S 20% exsch rteug 90 20°F (she He Wrowtion
of 249als) eccurcecl) eomid Fre hovete Gall wIAkid Yee Cecberol abebisition)
Of Bxcnl activity @xk Serorol, be Cosacble. Comb, These. 00 pasts
equal ove. bhole. eerie util en iscarporetes the. ofor%e bob te
ele$enxeliast coutel bere been Sergecl with. D> Tacler'S Cn8e., he Grxbick
An3 § The. Ke Fa. cen Phere Cysteret) hy ao actotl, te entice a buivor
do take wl Serck ore ruck. Photo. Te, Fe 80S the he couiel bre
been heegeck eith a3 Mateo by the qarernecent are t Flori Kotute,
$2t.oti (3) 1 Prostebing a Social performance by a Chiled 5 aook
wetoul, PESEIBSindg a Sowal Performance. by & child, +

The gervernetense hecdeuer aliol sack Specify vith ch bese
Subsections of Florida. Hotute SZEOR HS Feliging per for HS bnSiS OF
Conuichiond for £6 23.6. 2402 Cb) arc 1 Stencl eles o> thers belt. Bt
ater herqig Seuceone evith 2422, (6) for an of Ferd Fetectinig to chile
Pereg ph Orley tre Prechschion oF hel Porsography fils thas the-
Feeleral ebfissi tia OF Surcunl ackitityy. EO He iSihost CnSe_, one. oF
te Muitifle. Stekuiory Uolations the Grernttenk Rls pew fer conwichien
ie mds Stool correckle j (3 the Succe83Eul eben’ of a. eunoc to
engage in Her Secon! activites of potges3ien of chill Poewography «

| SEN Prd Cates jon cheherdarst chargeal wills 2422 (b) wit a
ender la: nq Mere. instituting lel porsogcaplus y have. Pelgerd «por the
te Solera Yetute Probibibog te Precloctien of Chilel Porwogcaphs ,

it oSe 1 OF Felueed pars a. Bote Yntute Probibiting the
Prndction of Ciel forwogenphy whith fosck® Hee largquage. of the. Geiral a.


Case 2/22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 46 of 68

Thee pre\wlie Toclr 2ifecek a8 a. CSt OF COWSN'S AeFivien

(Pectorst indivrelvally aod Cebisieel (3 SbSavtial. Trades (3

Bs NG @ betel Setence. of ALFE. Comst LS He Onke Count OF ahich fee
i 3 comuicheel, WOM a. Mercier of LIFE, (thot Vek Conviction, Tacle—
| uted sok Farce Heck Sorkence, AS te Hortiawnr Sadutory penalty for each
i thee Har Sur Coke Mohs ConUickion 1S a tere Of years . There Sore. , Trasler’S
(Serlepce iS HSE frook of Wee Prejuolite., akith Car nor be iguorecl
lal Corel imkarecl Trader of Hee Forenanteel hoe IRS to Course a.) He
| resott 06 tHe. Proceecting woutel have bead different. Tasks tanstel Noe
roe. plecl quilly te Kis cent del istered wnvied hese. Preceralocl to tial,

Takes’ ea 84 URS ackrller jynocent

Cot 1.3 2. there and wso<Cieiewe eileen jaul 3

oct @. Conrinectiion) Uncles

for bee rectors explairecl $a Seectio TH acl LL , aches
‘appellate. attorney wnt meMective Sor Sailing to argue Whig afpee|
ye Clair. of ackod iwnacence..A deBerdlayt whe Fails to tert a Claim
3 entitled toa Pais ertac Ceriew) of Hed Clie wher taiteel for be. First
‘Hine od appent, Oude a. plais eccor Horelarel , be defirvolarr bears Be-
|boralers to Yes Here. iti. Error, 2. bet is plein, awl 3, Het abfecdS
[Substantial CgldS « Sea’ wilecl Yates U- Koghwavl, 84 £3 (387

363 (ui Cit, 202 i)’ “ethers He explic. it lagrquages KaAaHeatke, eo Cleo
7
- Met SpeciFeetle Solve a2 (Suen, Here Cao be Ne plain error, Zd,

H


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 14 of 68

The following list of discovery is being provided:

"(C) and/or (D)" RESPONSE and/or OTHER DISCOVERABLE MATERIAL:

pp 131 - 138
Stipulation of Facts that is signed by the defendant from federal case number 2:17-cr-14047-

Middlebrooks.

SAMO0002: Search Warrant Affidavit and Search Warrant; Photos from execution of search
‘watrant.

Agency Number: 2016-20329
Lab Number:
CAD Number:

Digital Media available as indicated below (see Electronic Discovery receipt for details):
FWC Bodycam Link Expiration Date:
Evidence.com Link Expiration Date:
Motorola Bodycam Link Expiration Date:

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true copy of the foregoing has been furnished to, Mary
Celidonio, by eservice/email at the designated email address of Mary.Celidonio@pd19.org,
Dawn.Johnson@pd19.org on May 31, 2022.

RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED
THOMAS R. BAKKEDAHL
State Attorney

By: /s/ Donald R. Richardson
Donald R. Richardson
Assistant State Attorney

FL Bar#: 779121

411 S. 2nd Street

Fort Pierce, FL 34950

(772) 465-3000

Designated eService address:
SA19eService@saol9.org


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 56 of 68

becavse. hig Serene i§ ELEE aod nat a. ter of years. He. cdill ree
awe le ogdortinilig to gekort of prison) axl this Wevtel hate. bees obikferest
ack te gavernaeost nok Lee atleweel to inttodice. tek report, which aco Ye
decicling Sartor Of Tadler’S StoXt«

Ab be-tery seisinteut ar objection to te port's itreckacion thet un
prertuled , LooAd fave Cepvitedl He Cort to ASF hows this aocsuset US
Chtaweet arrsk if He qevernatentt had the. Const’ Perieis3ion or te pastes
Coes ThiS toi here. freservecl tHe. ‘gue. fo Proper appellede. rteus.
Cex Sel a208 tell to ale His theoaghast te proceeding hack eueng eppoctrity
to de it, bt failecl to hb So.

Thete®ore. CoS Sernrclerech ineKeckive- AISi Stee. Ak Se HEIR
ether he Rilecl to chjeck to tle GoxrrHor® instroccction of He. “Pase-sica
Ald Eurlookion” ceferk , thick Be goer detent chtaireel Magali, ook
eitbet ConSest ; Freva Tracter'S Clectroric. dleurce. , Haed Cora Sel chyectee(

He the aclu ibility FAIS Corfidlerbials Protecttcl eport , there (3, AL He
Vers eat, a eekmable probabi lite thet He @8vtk of He proceechsq cartel
feu beer dlitterent, Trcler'S Sortecce, weuted hewr hoor ater cf wens,
ancl wot LEKE. but Er Canbe'sS Bbficlert PoFocumorrce..



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 54 of 68
{

Te be Sore., Agent click rick teguedt PerisSion Frees Trooler” ) NOM
idl Tader Give ages PerntiSSiond ab avrg tite ,t endl , OSe., hue j;O7 PSSESS
Anig bivol oF Medical or Hostal heal corel Such aS this report, LikesiSe.,
oll ek Cegeedt Pererissiond Saute court te Upseal His devant,

ken (S Still Seatecl a8 of ths coriting  Mereasr, te governutent
Aluittedd at Sotorcing they chtaired Ho leper fra Trader's laptep
covspan Po thes intradiceel the. plctegraphs of te. report, rook the report
HSE. There. (S RO ion) He. Gomrrntenste Biveus) te. rokdore KF His pork
lane highla ComFiclembial, LEIS Weel a8 Sec oP He frst bro Pages , axsol.
He Gorersutenk Clears Call the. report,

Dering Sentescing, Tracer Cepeatectly toll corre to chjerk te
Hen totracloction oF this repoct betseel om Hese griscls. Bak CoxSel, Se Soste-
jurexphinable, Mao, cbhjecticl only to te elevasce of tHe. fepork cal
poothing ets Pues Tadler tn8 able, te Retice. He. qavensiok and Ling “Hus
Ieper te Sad eid Sid) DH 4/8 Ko Sueperse, Het Particular cbyection Gilecl.
Theowdet He, estire Precerebrrag ) Teele toll Cor8el to object te he
introcdaction KAS report, ard he. Lil rx*.

{ CONSENS Failure to abject tHe ihedichion of, OF vive. Ec

he exclusion f, the. “Parenting Pld eualuation” brsed’ on axe of He
PreVWioBle MeMionedd Grows; Prejudice? Tader berate. the goenutok
Peck His vepork Quer andl cee agains Hamagheot He abot exo bax log Prem ting
ie eb Traders aargquatod teak BF yenrs wourel be, a appropriate, Soto
(The goveronek Sel this report dlocing Heim PreSetation OF exticllence— arith
JHS.2. Ogee Beier Cesge These cSBeal i+ docing C088 = exemrinntio OF



Case 2:2

‘le

2-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 60 of 68
|

for ap echickolest”

ZED He iSterst Coe. Thank 18 clameed util 6 SuceBOl ack, te
erticetlor fa. ator to a ri WS Grxcia( aekiite, £@, He Preedeokion
OF chilel Porregrephy Beeb ons bee Conieertedions Trcder hil ul MUL.
ore canscl believe these teteriel be. Pecbable.. Coute hee oo A6tet, Chesgia hin
ait Precbckion of chited Pocwngrophy. Aaderer, aS exploined willis ; there, (8
4 least Cxtiorrable- chet Tasker alied nat ploy a. Sole (2 te procdctos of He
cong Chile Pemegraply falieek for Be thes chesee. Tague Orrtesd® tus Gebsie
iB merBitutionnl a8 applied te hin, as i oledes AiS Doc. precess Cots
|\qearanteenl bg He. SY, 6" asced Ht aautereltot te, thee rsiteed YtabS Comb tution).

See: (Det 22:5~6)) (owt 53 + py ze/2r~2s-, pq 2i/i-2s")
10.5.6. J4Z4
[Sees (vet 22.2 o-0)) (oer 5-2 pqs zo - 22)

See? (OKT 2252); Cyt 92: pg ol [rt > 25, py fit)

[See i MewHan ov emiterl Gale, Zoly 0.9. dist lexis 2o¢3sF

1G.d. Kestuckey , Dex. tt, Bott) Ls Becounn), jose aS 19 He. Bint CoS,
We cefenabarse yong ocgeeh with a Viokdios of Z422.(b), WH ar nse laine
MER OF Practuchios & chilel Pommogenpha(eThe.. Court iS Nes Wass Fexrol
and CWidlersbiear, heer Ue Kepireck buente- Ye Gekial baSiS abel

WW Contels euichgce. Het the, clehoclask esticecl Yo. wiser Uhr

ite expage. IN Bacon active.” Godan the Alecsdinog of the. Yiokerte.«



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 64 of 68

ancl ccrmalel fave held t troletecl fis Ciakk to privacy guaranteed bg te
oorth amencloionrt hikes Se, , Teadec consol nok have Pleck quill Conrdlcticnrally
pad cor8el correctly pkeruech hive Hak tig ctbte asoutel pot be, Park of
be cecorel op appen', Tater's enstire. Strategy on appea( un8 baSiol aroun
this Baten. .It Seas mathe te boliewe he usrted hare. Sigreol te

| Plee. agrecseot Mert iSe,

i Therefore. Cow Sel 1208 weFfeckive for wok erparcting He rexerel

ii be abistrick Court with He necessary Mfiraation Meeclecl to Prevail
ew creck appeal, arhile- at He Same, tire. Banaieg He. Strategy, Aevelopeck

it bis Clie. Hal Cor8l woe providecl imcorceck ikormeation + Tracker before
(Sgrrg 48 flea. agree stent jhe. trated prot lave Pleacl pity aul Weal
(teratel have Preceecled) te trial.

a

96. es dapat Bepl briek, Bufo? - pgs 6-#

34. ater SubHtS + He Gort a8 Euiclence leter's be hk Swete Curb
ae eyes ; e-atireing his perils Hot Corel Kiseu) te. Strategy of
| Cadler's Ge all Mtoughok He Caiauval peecess. Exhibit €

By. le: Pro Se. terion, thy/del cbs pqs 6-% /o. ul, fo &/hs.lé
[See ate ‘pre S- pobor , (22 [colt CDS pgs F-Phs.ul , pg wo/s.16

Sees Santobelle is ews Bork, YO v.39. 25° , 2625 FZ s.ck. €955
ae (Cra)

i
|
Hl
i

i
|
ul


Case 212

ibe Hook; Free , Gril (6 Seo, fees Moth arch catheg

2-Cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 52 of 68

Ant sees igh ( w2ase oe ivshewalbchion oe a Pasenstivg

Mars EnleecbiogS Ceport iMlegalleg clei rec 4g the. eaxcnsics,
Qik dich tactoredl isto He chekecurjwation tdher)
no Te Ire.

The igh fo He ffeckive. assistance. of Counsel extensls to
Bete cing Ard Vowel be ealoatedt uuder Stricklanel. See %

Clowes Ue wvitedt YobeS, $3( 08. 12%, 121 3.c+. CFE (Zot).
Trader wx nck etoreled this Cekk, CORSE cea an ineffeckive. for

Gailey te objet jo axe Mearsiryfel Craig | te He Mntrodichion a.

Basexsk ing Plans Eualoations Report Conalicteol im 213 a3 part of

Tades'S or - Going Chilek caAetache “lapses pert i3 hgh

Comet ae Prestectenkl as Private. Reber Hu leurs F tHe Sete. oF

ocietstt Godl Hee writeck SteteS , Gnck wx ablaired 4g He. naa
3

| Megall Serr Tincle'S Clectrosic alee.

Dp £018 avel dheto an gory Chile Cock, disputes , He

Abemorable. Larbara. 00. Branis, Worelye- K He. Nineteen, Wolicie|

Circutt is axl Sr Sank Loci, Coty , Clovicla » orclerecl 0." Pareticg
Plas Valuation” Are appointest as inelepenrelent expert to Cordlick
QW Socie.( muestigetion ancl Studs ) of both He Pasents, ave te. Chilel.

the. Privary (SSue. te be. adkresseal a228 whedher the existing order,

Onder which each parke has egoal tise Sari ihag Cth the, Chi bol, Sheviel
a



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 24 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

12. For this motion, state every ground on which you claim that you are being held in violation of the Constitution,
laws, or treaties of the United States. Attach additional pages if you have more than four grounds. State the facts
supporting each ground. Any legal arguments must be submitted in a separate memorandum.

GROUND Five: Tradec's appellate. CouSel lens ireMechie. 6c failing to Cie. (2528
(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):

Cee! Herorapichor of Lew, Section) x)

(b) Direct Appeal of Ground One:
(1) I£you appealed from the judgment of conviction, did you raise this issue?
vel] we
(2) Ifyou did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why: ; ,
The. IS8U0 OF ineMeckive ASB/Stmxce. Of CorSel 18 appropriately GiSel 1 a
Motion te Uncake- PoSumot to Ze 08.0. 2855" ag MH cepulre3 ac evidertiaryg
heaving
(c) Post-Conviction Proceedings:

(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?
vel] wo
(2) Ifyou answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Type of motion or petition:

Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes[_] no[__]

Page 5 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 42 of 68

The. ives cortisvedl! “JewA\ also he8 oblar ae SSegirg apps On
_ her doblek al access to He. itermek which £ clicl Nek go Hhceugh Cabile a
Revats mothe | wrt is rag vehicle. Ye asteal to Check the pleto gauerg

_ Sent fo. ‘Seok’ along. eath Photo of ’Scekt'S chevgiters? hee Sok her Suvol

tober query: Se alse hel wate. pluie s of ber ten Fuirol to hur gallery

Bhat 20.0 Sent te her Hheougt thee Sieg Meeppr
MUL fied tattiple. Cormtec3okions with Her edhe au cegeetert tule.

_ Photos 0€ her ,dercl Sort he role. plekoS of Herbed. She. bael Hed pletor
Sauteal te ber photo gatleap iss her debltek , Shealse hact He photor Lk herrel€
which Ge Sek te Tock, Saueel to her gaitery: epockasstly, 590 ase, beaw8
fried lonsg the. phetoS oF ui. axe. Saveck te her gallerq, Or herd Hac tibted

they edere.. cbichcibuteul fos ber gallery Tocler 1S convithesl af Usbleing

“PAU. te peockoce. thet. tue Phetogeaphs , but She Cowie hee. Prochxael

_ these. dees _Phetogcaphs. Se expe K thee Mer De t008 heytiosg &. Conver B6kiow).

tot, WIiMcot EX AAIIG te tine cel date Hrup of the photos; there iS.

_ No weg te be Sure. Nek ably, He goternetent les Mevec Did ehits. “PrescloeeelTM
these Pike graphs foe Tack. The. only Verb the. government heS eve Sect iS -
Bek” Mud “Sere” theo to Teele aooel thet Sade geocl. Bu bewuiies Toabe
0228 convichecl Of a coupleseak ack ariel rok an atteupt, 2442 (b) are BMAF
Cequire Hore ter jE Sent", Meee then jbo Restavtal Step iv ar atenpt

to pcoclocl.. “the. GtetukeS ancl the Subsequent Cake. acd Repuice the "Seal

axel the Gesecneert heS aver offerech Ang.

Mehta to ackuallig hue taker plete. There. 18 10 extiedterte AS Aasgyshere,


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 5 of 68

foge. 2K 9

Sif towel Lo ce rnart bya) bo canrbec Ce tes Locket bells rate Anspinrs Mile Out piste.» Priel atheed
beers. So berel, NE Sguictecd ast AF tyut note aril Art me ,taich Mack yee bash

1 piel (Lose.
7
ole. _ _ _
Le QE Lee 2 lerufs Cassi Samseaiten hoot iden BiluiayS aril biertt staS tanbora, teste.
Stat with ster 1 Hee bctheoorr tater? Uh) ettast flea) (pep) Aurel et to tole gad baele ip oi
4 é

ight ie ups cane 1. Aoacb raha, ste treulel flay Arsel flirt tarth Yad etendreie pe tree. Hane

U Hae bres apes satel Slits Knnd He Chait ren crotel [eile Tatcinss fe State.._Mvel or Kina

Cravelfin Leos Lert Sraanble fe tSecl to Fok pie Laek Qosk Forks Birsgnt3 Hat Soup
LyJeo All Lose. se Hcl ase. call <2 lssagh tall. Bab ste, Sam. yo mate. Arg Sesh ge ol Wey

Wiles taropled Legiss anct Erclt tant tps £ ret, 60 ornnteel any of fais fo dsppe).

Dat “ a fe Kacud poe sc, f pews deck How Neo Mather ta tet Silpies€, Says N lela Htacf
aut. Lack bette of Seeddes, drt Li ater titer buck fait, OC fe Soster L020 tess Heeb UE jag bh
f a

Se Atuch, Lo fa weet eet i deck. fottats ok, Ms hong ES fed clade gs Fossembc Witte Cae to

z AlzalfS, tales

Ba este ty tet reine , Lose beeatte gah fo See. {efi fe op. To a8, Col

re baete pists nh E eovst. I ¢ dart cad bn Fewatibee Hen Suypes & foe <1setight abt Lea, __

. .
fexd_attnoe ty Sleep, Cexebrighh, Sleep dight fiesitnske hccwnt, Eo besiec ford» Be taDante fed to Bord
£ Sau Hat Leceryp wright tothe Leghtest Yew tr thee Sky So, ahmwever afese teins fe talk to pe.

ish laok up at tak Dt ts £1 bene dow. Till the, Sash bined £'ll alongs fen leokity Aoste.

oP Lai, Ed Alelaly fh cts, wueess. E Love. Vad _

Lette;
Ds. ~ Keep) Singing | Debi Asche E aterayps, aott bs sper

Lo Loves eeVen Cfed Suey

Loa Still hear x Sigs



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 35 of 68

Actoool anocence. Clam Mage Cer Cente Proceelora( dbfavit.
Hea SI WS, 183 Sct. 1924, 192, (on3), “Atin| tenocence”
Meco factual jutocence ,wok mere legal jBvFiCieney, Barselest
wikecl State , 52S 0-8. Gt, 623 Uitte)

§

i x. Teak 1 5S aetvalt miocente oC Uolekime IF (S.C. 222.)
IS dd “ange, un

fec cohich any Berson cenich be, Choraecd with. ce. Crinuse| Mee. Thee xnkr ei

Cowsple bed “Sexo Activity” Trodes's Wolecion 1 beSeo fon 1S bed

Shee F Clotide. OFFed3e8 tswolur Ne chilel Pach1ag 6 aphy. Hoeven,

accaceling ta te. Ceclerel hefinsiven 0 “Be xcal | Adit” fedatinag
to He tweloSion of chilel poase ; brleissn KGS ele,
nok. Gall ro) Hus tHe, seeps oe, of Sexo. Acciiritg” for a. Wolatios oF 2422 lw).

tn ablitiod Tadeo oI03 wok “Tenganeod” (9 He Prochuction K the

hitel pocscgen phe 14 esseptial element under te Phir Lessqe nge fF

Trader eoS Chorgent with a Wwolation OF LE U8. 2422 Ch),
thick 3 Relewenrt Part Prohibit ¢ The. enbceitek oa pero te egage iP
Sexcial ackivity for chick ancy perSom cr be. chesgeel ete a. COuainea.| esse.
There. are. fase Clewern& Ceguirecl for a Wolection oF MoS Stetute. ) ork taze
are Pehevient here the First elesut Ceguires the, deferclose to achieve
2 Henkel State ever a minor, Quel tes Bip thet Mestal Stele te have
Heke atinor engage. 02 Sercenl Achiuiite.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 21 of 68

AO 243 Rev. 09/17)

GROUND THREE: 77 dlar'S Deke Se aor ey @raleced) inetfeckive. ASS Stare

(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):

Tivetheahive ASS/Stance ans enddececl becacse ConSe| Qilecl to Have Sbigedte.

Soecifi'c. fucks o€ Traderc'¢ ca3e, te Charge Cages hiv Q0e tHe CoSe law) (9

ae -_ He time. Of Trader's plea, Spec. (Picall aol Sc Ha aSns ce foelt, “ ~
tOPS IO ad MT OF Ander’ Menoranckowr of leu), ther CoxnrSo{ Klee ;

te cbiseiss Com A of He inode ;
Guill ee Nek ctrtent, Ql wher’ be- OLUSecl Tales te A

(See! mMeotoransdiet of bre) Section mi aoel TE)

(b) Direct Appeal of Ground Three:
(1) If you appealed from the judgment of conviction, did you raise this issue?

Yes[_] No

(2) Ifyou did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why:

The issue ck imeMeckive- ALS Iter, OF ComBel 1S app opriatele aiseck js
he fee” to vacate pursuant to 2¥ 0.5.6. 2253 as Hk (equiteS an eviclernsbiaree

(c) Post-Conviction Proceedings:

(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?

Yes[_] No Ze

(2) If you answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Type of motion or petition:

Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:
Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes C] No CJ

(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?

Yes | No |

(5) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?

Yes[_] No

Page 8 of 13,


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 27 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

GROUND Sevens! Tia wec's: plea. Af Guilty tes A Cont of He. trcbicketate 4208 Macle.

Onknensdingly aral inolortactles , asst Cor Sel fercberect jwelbe chive a33/Stewce. ter?
(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):

he Faitecl to iSe. (S328 of Hert to He Dittniek Courk, arxl leel Tader to believe be Coviel apfen |
tier, Specifreathy atesTacks pled quit te bis Cerrdbrtiapal Plec. agree tert, he. Lelieuect
Part of his preSértecl (SSH IE, a5 a Challenge to te facts ino We abbiclauit bor the
Search warrant Trades ane Made to believe be cored thet WS CUS a> appec( earth Ircludle-
te abilitee to (AGREE OA FIKE hearivg chee ty tha, BWUETOonr8 FalScheeck acl AVS ONS witless the
86 (ha, Eto Search, Troe heel Cipendedtley (eguestect COS Fite a tlerios For @ Faysks eas
Pretrial, Claiming 20 thet these. inrtenCionn FalsebeodlS, th aC dai wotel lock Prebble. Cae
COWL heel ASE Tincler tek, hecarte Hee Savi, WAS AF ithe) 0203 Cletiengeck n> pehion
to S.fnress Gor otar Grarsets) aszal he heel Plecl Quilh Cord terrastee she. hed pregcacl He Giga os
Appel to Chatierge. te peiSleaclrxy Fol borels witless the abiclau/t, CAPE Clearly wu Sleaed Tadler

Gos bel he Eis) these Cbd oer Nek presemveck bee txaxel be
lect quia cooditintnine © pi et Fen teraxel hewe_ Clectecl to G6 te tie father

(b) Direct Appeal of Ground Three:
(1) If you appealed from the judgment of conviction, did you raise this issue?

Yes[_] No

(2) Ifyou did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why:
The (Sive_ OF (nekheckive ASS/ Stace OF Come (3 appropriately aisedl i a weiorS
te Vacate puSvart to 2¥ VS.C. 225357 aS It (eGU!R38 @> ewieloobiaceg feariry,

(c) Post-Conviction Proceedings:
(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?
Yes C] No ae
(2) If you answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Type of motion or petition:

Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes CL] No im

(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?

Yes | No im

(5) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?
Yes Cc] No

Page 8 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 23 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

Type of motion or petition:

Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes CI No[_]

(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?

Yes | NoL_|

(5) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?

Yes im No |
(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:

Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:
Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) If your answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

13. Is there any ground in this motion that you have not previously presented in some federal court? If so, which
ground or grounds have not been presented, and state your reasons for not presenting them:
The- Growl PreSertedl dd tis stcdion atere tok previo Bly Predenteck based
On Be. cleficiest ancl nekFeckive 298/3tante ck CowWSel, DoeFfeetise
BS 'g i . . °
j Si'Shance ck CornmBel Cling are Prapert, aiSeel i> a Motion to Uncabe_
UrSuat +o 18 U.S.C, ZZS7S,

Page 10 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 36 of 68

| i lelbess CeSeacebutog chad" ‘Sean Act den iS discentecedt tok

(Tits Stabutenerhich i's anal iss Chapter: IE o€ trble 18 of Me crsitend Soke

| - __ eehe. , dec. wok clefirse.Sesecol Ackicity Peder, OSeaaxel Atkility tS Nek
_AeEisseck tetun pote Gcherel criminal Code.” Vasxuaher te thee Orshe Kieior

leks ritioss 1S thet Congres Speciti@otty Airtel Srrxaol actiuity to éocluok,

i “4
tee Pradkction of Chilel porrogrephs GS abencliel BS IE 5.0, 24EE.

_ L UK Si. ZIBE js Fat 1§ He Hokute. foe He, “rieleSion OF
be ‘sag Fe chil spluy i19 LAAN OF ( aetit ‘e
ae OFS (eating 40 chilel Porseg oxpluy. 19 abhinsitions OF Semel actuity for cchieh

3s, Pers Gnd be Chesgecd with @ CCibsitie herb” asol + Stele $20 Ae
- thea OSL. Be A 8) AN ON OLDS _

poe gp OF MeLisscak 18 Seckiond Bab Ce).
. . TBI wtea:08. once ch the boos Gorm OF Comeback LE IS6.. DYER £2. pechi 46,
— “na explaineol by oS. 2dZE (3 the, Sante concback prebubiteck be ESO.
BBS ( (ed, thee Prockeckion of Chile Peesegeapla | to dver, He Hedutes broad -
Ctith be HS as ConSteuckion. Bee, rock extend ty He Crrvbck Prelubite

by iS. ZISZ te, possesion anscl) clsecabition OF Chilel paerograplats
| _ eee Clearly. ComBickesecd Hee “il Biond a & es te hiled

ch oaths a6 alehiv thin Te

Tht, Seacenrol elenterr Gedterst here. fegvices ask iscacporakes.
Lwritiir tt, a2 wraelerlairg oorbe- tek F Cooresithecl aay peceo orr be. Chosztel
Bat. critendal of As Rlakivg to Tiedes Ais Hears thet MS allepeck


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 18 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

12. For this motion, state every ground on which you claim that you are being held in violation of the Constitution,
laws, or treaties of the United States. Attach additional pages if you have more than four grounds. State the facts

supporting each ground. Any legal arguments must be submitted in a separate memorandum.

GROUND ONE: ~Téade.c (3 ackually immocent of Wrolating IF oS. 2422(6) (Cormld)

(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):

2492.(b) Prohibits augeve Frou engaging (8 “Anu Semval Activity for which any Parser Cecil
be chee jeol WH a criminal effeaseTM, The, unederlaiiog Completecl “Sescart Ackivity Thacter's
4 rolation iS ose nis ee State. A Clore. OF Fesx8e8 involving Chilel formegraphi.,
Klee, Giccoreks PG to eheral deities OC “ Seran( ekivity” (elaki to He pel
- rl esti 7 Sion
Of Chilelporscagaphe ; Hes. tur orderly 2g OFFO225 (Pos5eS3i'en eel Provetos) do mot fe
Cale the Mec. oF “Serunal Activity’ Sr a Uielediod o€ 2422 Cb) ; , ime

(See. HeHOrONAIA OF Law, Seckiod x)

(b) Direct Appeal of Ground One:
(1) Ifyou appealed from the judgment of conviction, did you raise this issue?

Yes im No
(2) If you did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why:

TRIS (80 UNE Nek PreSertecl oc Reserve sal baSeck ore AK c.jorr acl
tne Meck ive essiHtase_ € CorSel,

(c) Post-Conviction Proceedings:
(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?

Yes | Nok)

(2) Ifyou answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Type of motion or petition:
Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:
Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes | No Cc

Page 5 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 62 of 68

Zl, See? (0S.c, 2422 (b) 7 1g V8.6, Z42F ; CA Stok, FH OFL(3):
SLA Sick, PZ7.0tS) ,

22. Treter Aier's CawBed as tole elie, 129 0. Plone. Call Alter Be. isitio( brief toed
Ve
gore thrawh CorreSpondlrce, dal toll te iGWs Ie OD Leck

lack , abot Ce x8 feaas roll 34 Aig 2YILG) Coasurekions Coane er 1

@fpenl. Acktctionalty , COoMBAS write, Leclio. Prttecseug eke a3 fepresermrbhy Ne
(Tincler io hie Comme 68. against te Yoke of Coral jus also stale Audnre.
OF te (2303 Sucrescdbing hs 2422 (6) coruretion » See dubilS €,F

4
23. Sees (bet 20)
BY. See: Appeblant'S brief, Ue Ltn’

(Seat Fos. outions cbteck Heeler, toliliay, tolssfecie, the leo,
lee leet? tel et?

as,

i
Zé. | Speciticathy Traber'ss pro Se. rections clbcbeol he feote, col 1fe2. lech

BA. See? respose. of Corel cbtenl toftfaoe , 2b1ae9

tt

2%, See: Gevternves'3 beck, tholtei?

2¢. Pees Mekion Ker Axte Sion of dime etlion ~ 4 i/wt

30. See: Rese mations sls litt ~ £4 xls. i, CDS fq Ply 5

“os le - - p45 7/s.1%, CDS a thet
i


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 10 of 68

Page. & of ¢

hee bt Asses 12 my Coll, E pier be Aaver the. Wena we Erect

ead. £ Dywt paawt Hem te Grohe coer tyne. ce boast to Che. nits teu AG 'é Hthatp nuele. Cecant,

fact dupe. £ pepodl ext goth ote sesuees p Marr, Eabelie., Arial Mie Bll wsesb enast to Péactijd
o ri

Sti Kesh

D
‘en bey

cunt), Me palette Gado big lots to See LE thes da Oo be aw te Rete tes nated texth mek
u G

én

tye hacl Tost fright So wee trict ts tea loth acl thats) totsst fe Give. hele), Misaty Balip bel 2

wectish C36, peas fork? Sets asel frase 5laSses.

So anced Cort flee toe Sd,

tee, fash

.

te
i

Laeet wre tal ¢

pact

te took cove bo Cie. win Jaw te eA,

treet & Dal « Lo alas kal

wl oe gh

the. beest- plese. Cina ttl £ tar, SS! Se lees coms Giger tee here bach a both, itt dh ard Evert

ee. Aleosp fel Spasb Sarees 1) the VE plé Ke gve. Clb Ss bad tot rack fami Fabeko.

hoe derbi 4 Slee whe? pase got force Te 18 Ad ben ti4

neh 2, tar we, lah? evel) diel boot

one LBS Hex & Meg Eteel Jerk.

x” rh eS end Sacbdred of
3g

he last + filece: Poesia enite LO peitet ae Sexwesles Goa bh Lahelin pein

=<

Zo weeks. Tha toate ex. Eeeswiensen. Sol. ‘ By back. Sie. bevel vt, Go Fe Biel

nee Belles bike.
a Stil bueliens besthu®, bat Sab

J

Ble ks, Lo beck 2. és
bug tle. wecswtheas fee
J

vate. Seem ceutl ond Ties, Heep B25" Jere.

The. best Hite. £ Pau) “Pexer, besivles covik wong Sept BY Bett. She. unse,

see Owl Fes, So Dik Kiam .S

Le mit

f, #E fiber. fever petro! blot. abler “Hewe Gar

6 fvegal al Kessel fee equettlne., btiure. te Lett £2
oe a
Miser b

te tersl, Hen Lo _ td aazineg Gs,

farsel Plenit lewd Bite. Get. %

oy Foo. Af Hlebs.cietel | beet, BAPE ier all © cite g FF

ied, instil, bel Gevie Legesicte

ep e2rile. eurol Kiel. o¥at 4 jaye Pe



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 33 of 68

UNETED STAT STARZ
SeuTHERN DrsTarcT or FLOREDA

OCoe DOseEPH TRADE

Phsrstit€ [Motmsk §—NO. BR~Cv ~

| VS. No. 2i$ -CA- Moet ~KLDDLEBROOKS
Deforolort / Respondent

MOVANT SCOTT JosePH TRADER's MEMORANDUM OF LAW
IN SvPPORT OF AIS Motzzon To VACATE. SENTENCE.
PURSUANT TO 28 0.S.C. § 2985S

1 Movest, Scott To3ePH TRADER , espectfiule FeS ths
Mestorarsoler OF Law) 1:3 Spport OF hiS Suhon 2283 Motion to
Uneate. Seoterce- ave State? a8 Ffoliaod ¢

i x. Mewohrels Govern se Khecd

i saistace of ComSel Claies,

A Prigonex i8 entitlecd to aw eu clenstiany heerissg On & Sckion 22SS~
Mobion OntesS He wection, File8 aah. eevrols & te Ose ConcloSvedd Show
Mok Wee prisemrer 19 nok entitle to Click. ZF USC. 8 £258 The
Court an Criiew MABE accept a & te pbttionec's ateegeol fads

08 true, anol. dbbecurise whether He petitioner h& Sa forth a lick
Clais.” Agars U. Dugger, $35° Rd 1334, 183% Cc cic, 678%).


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 30 of 68

AO 243 Rev. 09/17)
14. Do you have any motion, petition, or appeal now pending (filed and not decided yet) in any court for the
you are challenging? Yes No

If “Yes,” state the name and location of the court, the docket or case number, the type of proceeding, and the

issues raised.

15. Give the name and address, if known, of each attorney who represented you in the following stages of the
judgment you are challenging:
(a) At the preliminary hearing:
wl
(b) At the arraignment and plea: FYeteher Peacock )AFPD, 109 yrorth. 2pol Hreet,

FL, Pierce, Flocidea 34950 Tel. (442) Yee - Z1Z3
(c) At the trial:
VIA
(d) Atsentencing: Fletcher Recock AEPD, 10% nwacth Buck Street, Et, Pierce ) ~
flerida 3ES0 TEL. (4-42) 189 - 2123
(e) On appeal: (Fletcher Peacock ,AEPD, 10F Kort, Arnel Breet, FE. Perce,
Florida. 34?S0 Tél, (4-42) €8F - 2103

(f) In any post-conviction proceeding: Becnarela Lope-% ,AFPD, ONC COF Browrerel bivel.,
fhe HOO , Fork Lave a of =
Suite , hecolale., Ft. 33301 - 184Z (on worth of ceckiorars)

(g) On appeal from any ruling against you in a post-conviction proceeding:

wl.

16. Were you sentenced on more than one court of an indictment, or on more than one indictment, in the same court
and at the same time? Yes No

17. Do you have any future sentence to serve after you complete the sentence for the judgment that you are
challenging? Yes im No
(a) If so, give name and location of court that imposed the other sentence you will serve in the future:

(b) Give the date the other sentence was imposed:

(c) Give the length of the other sentence:

(d) Have you filed, or do you plan to file, any motion, petition, or application that challenges the judgment or
sentence to be served in the future? Yes Cc] No |

Page 11 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 7 of 68

| Rage dof

. Labeke £ prot fra te (eomber tak toe trere. on Fawuily Epos mevec 4elprer 13 viet lifer Phen

thes £ Ast cfs anal fot Sister avel Mow met fo der urece a bof Sealy, Z Alxegs Suttcl_

jecrcver £ bvokul ak fon, Blat 22. tht hues pecaviec Yea) tural dies’ feu Sel€ th? Pecical Cloltes ancl

oStumes ancl awsull leek, a7] EL Lereck wren (yar tbat. flock root Chase, thes Le

ed Ely ouec supthias acl Loecy bite. fon ateree hy Siompurss Brcimp (ee were Such ey tw)

‘ Aope. Yad ace. claws ttell (wd Gypsies hes ped elect. an paaburel Gt ital E Adis fo cell See ter) plete:

Laake hope tsi tke. Sheol acl ac: ley Qosel 1) (ee. A Aycle re 20 pach bo Froud Lie Hot.

2 feck ch fost We ecrypute: MUL. Cote trntteck 0 be ws See. had Suceecl 1rd Sehook Yhsel 2 broad

(a2 gill, efor ace. Yee Strack. Lp learned pretrr they? So Saat! doo ase. ereg Very Quest, hike

tof New arul £
Lo hope. aus seca Lirdbecbrete (that feed gfe! Heal bs Sag hee wave.) Sine Aestlowtecs thy

trac 2 wae & be ec So back. Ell Alacays Cres taactehinis Ces efess Rohela., Mota. ptprent

se hp tha Leth byte abo foe tln, Sey fate tos sel teint Leb I tl bes beads “a her

|
| A Phe iee "daa, fat © ant a quad Batam dalam qu te Hh kt bs back
| ney wel ZL pooutel reverb b easttpone ever. [lease nnd tet abet bie, ob bcbg. Sow peg.

ae

lage £ Lee es awed € sol alenys he te frets le iE vig Kost i Spievk, Abcays keep
C heatl op, Hose @ Fadel, arch thers bave. &, ethihen Fanuyey arte lees by be. Brass Qe
tf lef.

back. £ Love: os Falak, $y Moped _

Lae, - 7
; DADDA, fod voit alulays de. opr tadely
Is ow alesays saope. ex ay ——
Yeaung’s Gucl bat Yoo tack —_ a ne
ny heest, F Low 2 € Nae

Take. Lave: 2 Harstad Lol fMés. a _ ee _ a

X nese Kissie-, /rexs your lose



|

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 6 of 68

lage 3 0€ 2

Weelve /Hetlet

“Au Mosel, Rake Ka.

rat L
SPV Ler ny.
ara

Gud Pb ob

fet petphe, = Stil!

tet woee. tes) arutttirin LOIS EE
2

he epgebee pitny Mok £ fog. fod

Mar then, Goad. Bho p, about He. (ery Belay Cecun cher 0s the hawpfest tlyitsy, Bin eseel be otek
¥ “S

rath x west cto te !

chil the. Cherder. Ce eadzteh spew qteinde i hagit. chad o!

wiry Hots tee caer puch, fot fos sil he Mises. ace. HL sacnld Eo prevet” Powe til L enrorolch

ate te fivde uattbout Lp. BAL ezdapste few be Eiinetad » etber\Eidel feed wel ty fall ty fe, Bast

sek gp at 4 ferghtest Stor 13 tee SK Haak tall, EU Gene vt. E cart aladaysS Pate hae kis

fowls go On, Sy LO tant Alwar’ See nw Lv Gileters Pade. Ha. Grivel, At Be. bth. bee 3E
a ¥ e
te weet to lo. Ge were. tHe. Biggest, lite. Asips” anujoie. evel ASE Fee (exw fone.

URS He, opetd 5, ft. Ledaratt al ty Alp Hcl fe ant fie o, Gia Leg Pos L Lekptec Basch

DSesever Bretort gine Sali Baty tines Had ates. always Tight fare.. to bel) fas
= 9
7

pm Gh, fee eee

bowl, fort 6 snwael eutety Seconwl of st. £ rsa fo lente b Le Lys Ce te thus

hable. avinaevtr of pene Sot OF Grech. w3a$ Sabine y Seve eyes eamtol frsuikle. Bosh {ike

Ware flaws. ~ —

abeta En wet 2 fact Med hk tel yerip devel te Gives thers, Baal ifewst Sst

ete the c/a LS pyr beck. L C200 feat. te CCastinber te tia tutes 6 angst Fedeke if
Sees pte bo Aa B0f Blektn « Ge Sect

eo hstcl, ee kiss, Gactl KeSS pu

by frex cxtectfllans bees, tHe greah, chews fire Piastee 1. Lo Bok wee Knrgubee Lo, Aianep

Shibeel eetemal? py) Sel shoal hog3 tackles cect tn £4 Baw AI? bet. Biel g neme art

foue Lek. FO pete ne te Cecstitthtl lay at, 11? BG wast the flog Elett yas hb, take Fela Sezust:

bas Cell ensieep. E wdast fad ba Comerker Cssthellr’ YP arith
é

o
te. aod giatehsse Fectt S, Var Sept Sage 20 cal coved Baie Dactfy, Bact , actly
ma

\edehy , Declohy. iss bla js the. fet. OC toabbery Sagecl lta i Jett, efit :

fal dat, Lo turaeghe pete fas iti eo lhl te. LoS Kiso Gaertn
g Z a gf

Wax, 28, cl, earch cleetst bi
age a

ay
BE

aw giteles acewws te. kitehess Eo sanst fend Lo Cetmenbiel

é .
o Phen 5» LA.

Cmuditse, Bi, cit these. bile People as bbe. walt tbat dns atetags petnd ah paths twten.
cs Kappiie Bv-3 : _



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 19 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)
(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?
Yes CL No | ,
(5) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?

Yes CJ No

(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:

Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:
Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) If your answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

GROUND TWO! rncler” (§ actually inmecent hk Violating I¥ 75.c.. 24226) Count 1)

(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):
ZXZZb) Prohibits anscpose- Frou estURG any inoliviefval the be wor attainecl He age fF IE
ears te “engage” in “arg Sexual actiuty S for tobueh aay Peon Corel be Chosgeel 02 it a
Comeral cflesse . “Sescun( Act ta 'S Ae €ivedk 3 1% 09.0. 24LE aS troelo b4 “Me,
Predboctio» ¢ oe chitet porwog raph arsek He outrte 9g CoPletecd "Sean Atkiite® Cade
(3 Con rei' OF Q0Ong Mar, is the Production o€ chill Poi ie
Consdock Set Korte i ne soe OF LeecdS for an tees ae Me Specific

OFS Urseler te Statute. Koeller, SoFicient Cnielence iS lacking to Sdishy, he
Clemots of a Cotpletecl Sachan 2422, (6) Uidation, Tracker an¥ wok “Ee, as me
He Prectuction nerd hitel Parserg imps these U0 Sook to bins sel Beenie. hte tat
ia ae fine tac iste Prodoesion C Ha. Porsegropleg , be ‘Ss Ackeolly tnanrccest CF He 2422 (b
(See: peroranatirs of Lau ) Sections I)
(b) Direct Appeal of Ground Two:

(1) Ifyou appealed from the judgment of conviction, did you raise this issue?

Yes[_ ] No eT

Page 6 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 9 of 68

fige. of

Heel [alee

& Esecuparsen — _

aa
As Ewb gece pyle fey cor dt. Soeeipon

:
neéel enh, tre FE

aldap theX
oz eh tae!

hat Bin new Gaus Ge Stes Qriupostes Asais/) fwth LE 4 ho, ZE well foes (Siche,. the toxallS 06 &
Sor, Lh fever Sen fe euctlead fovelinp fie ot OS Lickevideng Wop yey ker #he Fee ancl Ket.
Aeon seet Tire wie. b2evlel Gor Gr Qn ay Lis weber

fe (ever cfernre eonr Point Hoeerpitare.d Eo
%§ o #

ethwt Hat fyiste. £ alesss tempitesl Bie Mpa ME oret peip Casrs[th
ens Sea del bia utn bose

fas. eaditirury, fe Benet Coatrs Srd9 len ah tb th
oth
’

Bn mee gous fe fe. fix.

dad 2 trtwted bu

ve ZI Sity (G7), Mei) th, Some (3 | poo) Zé vel Dee Zeck, GL oth, Age!

Hone te veep becaby Lad Pein s beset Wien Pee ge, £ bere

lock Manny May Bier Dal
Sea het,

bhi Bo pawl ig ba Spel Eusecey Sinele. Chererenas ak se vr pbaeed peice v6, Cas

fe.
‘Bllowee—, oly Lb LE kenwt ce Deeg Aud Easy whee He asp ite) Git Sand tnd bank Bodgon st fiok
si

5 fave. acousiel pie. -
Mo € exit, ba Bt heres Oo ay puce£E Gieted etal, Lay Kiel gcd fl, My. fads Flan
EviaceyS , Mriol fity Jake (2% Clad « Ail eatiitee Bion. taht t bien ooalls Of cx. PeiSee +

An of. cantina fo bef US twel Te, Pass can fay Wee dr Beate #5, why. Lina sot opdihf erry,
wor bo f fae. fin. Stest, ox! Ma. Sheasigth to ae = ty Feet tate buck be ttewh,; Siherd,23
het Lame, wet tes» L Mavs thee Tass bak tite. frals All aoetrale, lash tere. 15 wot Cros tte
tad Ned we. to Gael Aire. Tar Gr) Lrnosstional Guutp Le eal OS Ewes BtS eashey 8 Cendel

ever hiertan tren ley ude Seppe gnit, Cte? Mes BE Alaays Manieoge be Bork ERA O00

2
So, here 3 ft isd dey ee,

A ob ptf bie. fs feiteet, a Shit haven BY fours Leet Coclihoe d bes able. fo Salt
tyslE. Law Batley Brick Chit €0 berxé Lee kwgtty) behore. Laer Coictel CF a coins, tag nx
b ken Aus. Sena ve Cont. (lbs. LEE be Fh flare. Bik of aati fakes Poop ou

pte nite, £ wit de. Che to alucays be site tre people E howe
Ee «. Gide to alucad n Wan fie

Py

et alf begS bh Ae. aud of tee. ee



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 25 of 68

AO 243 Rev. 09/17)
(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?
Yes | No LC]
(5) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?
Yes C4] No

(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:

Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) Ifyour answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

GROUND Six? Corfe 608 ineRertive or ulin to cbject isd arg Hearingfal tateug tor the

rheedockio “ in Jon + Serstenciitog,
(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):
. Pepork a8 Codocteck in) LolB 08 part of Tenler's an -Goixg Chilef Custeacteg ctspote-,
lool dhe weg Corfidential, Prckectodt 08 Private rater the. laa of he” Hale. Ceri
2 Wired Sete Qo’ wx oblainecl by be purr illegally eur Teag's
Clectimrie. alevice, Adlol-bieralla tis epork Specifically Factoredd iS He judges
AMekerwsirecber> hes Sokesciseg Fader ty LIFE. ins Posed, ComBelS Kajlore to abjeck

to Aax(thisse Sot He, Colearce_ of Herk fe ch Al spite. Tracer 11 5
x C ” nite, Wom Aint
Gro wdl, ComStertes eeective ASS Stince ote Sone. mend OE Sah

(b) Direct Appeal of Ground Two:

(1) If you appealed from the judgment of conviction, did you raise this issue?

Yes im Nok

Page 6 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 1 of 68

Exhibit td

Trader's Bex Kiel rote3

|
|



Case 2:

\22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 48 of 68

EE Cont ov olveck appeal aol Soviel be Celuatedl urcber te Serie klacel
Slevolrel of Prejudice , Suith v. Rebbirss , SAX v.38. 259, at BS Bb (2000), Te Dew)
prejebice woekr Hevektas, He. hefesrolast nts Dew) Hoek the Mek cient
[Perfocounsee.. prejvobicecl He Hfrse”, Sicickiondlat ESF. Ark prejvetiee
1s esteblishecl ceber “there 1$ aceoSrable- Probabilitg bt 0 CxnBel'S cagprofesgions (
error'S, He fedolt of He procezcling aaniel hive bead hilirert. Bicklaad, of CH,
4.

Trecter Sippel a Cordbitiona( plea. agreeblet, He. bik So after detehopine
eB Strategy COMA CoB  dohich Certerecl arounel brivsgny & Specific. acgUetoe ond
diveer apperl. Heewener, thers crse| Gilead He twitial brik; Taner heel no Kion:sleclge-
ct it, (t png poorly deotted cal barely included agi urtlind 4 bet Ceamse-|
edd discusseel with Tater Ptior to Signira He plea. Cgeeetlen THIS IS wok a Kew)
Couiplainst .Tader Fert wlwitiple. Piro Se wetter’ 40 = Cletorth Cirevit agter He bree
tens Filed expressing his alssiekisgnction wth Come, LiMn HeSe- wckionS Theta
aol OBkel He court for Pecuussion te Sgpleuterst He brief or allernakivelig Galore
COMBA Fon He Cede ancl ReBet He beietiig Schenllte. . The wekiens Listech
enoweratecl @aSons for tus aetien, explaisecl eoheg y aul iret a Propesect
wwitial bere to Spplemet or place. He ove aug kleck, “
Aer cote! eiperdect to Trasber's Cleio8, te gersronent Fleck Heir brie,
land te Court guste ass eacterBiend OF tie. to Fie a Cpl, w7Hbirs tbe Hotions 0 an
J@dexSion of tine, Cone tele? He Court he. “sa geang to incorporate. Testers
eiposecl haitial brick, wto He reply brick: Tanler Once again worcke. He Cour,

Cited correspondence, For Coopsel ancl Cleeth Circo Cade law Quel infoeres?
te. Cerree Hak Comel i BuegeUing to aise iSwves for te First tine Ao @ pig
beret, talidh hen i8 bork perwtittecl to ale, The court clesivel Tracks , ack cet.

i
{
i
|
i
i
i
|
|

Fleck ce Reply briek that tan Glutedt- txoret for wore ule Tecer heel prepebeot
2

, 3
Supplementing to He oitial , aclackig arpterts Nok lscel witli 4,


| Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 12 of 68

| : E xbibit Z

Supplesterrta| Discovery id Packer's Stake Crimurnl Cade.

2 Pages


|

|

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 11 of 68

fage. 2 of 9

ceviel beste. hvre hetteset besicles free aul fen

Iboe fe tet» There. 1S pocthey datfers
tel pe. Bese, Pees te pate thar £ petapre blue ctlel pes Dts Mike. 2. chyicl etrdy Gettack

wine fo Mont J = Shee atl £ awnt Hecugh

epiel sv spats q

S LfeesS.
¢

Sepecess of Lavs9 cestenl oi Sone tiin Leal tb Sn phids fo fecsairter tint © ies ee

nite. € Pike

Ltn Stet Ce Lunyot-, DF Cart telee 1b back Aescl h bert! ptt Gth flee Et
+ g

é up:
we. Sow age. alt

in a. byttle. Zou

EE reww Se. 220) f aS be. Bere. her
v

&e Bi Se ppt, Bat £ Litherathys and Mert Lrkkee

My Seimei ,

, aig fn Leeed fot mever Gowg fe Ste

Wig. af ts 2S ren ottl 72: wt Thee 1 Hn Penh th
= if

nye. aga. Lo arent yoo all to Keep) Hie. ind fou Forte, please. Yat tet tien Ricks Cages. Best t

Tore eal Ogibidg  £ fest Yor Pests, fled £ auf

C wnll See Un) Sen Fenliia , Goats , WD. sins ePnrcllen £& ly
¢ a) ,

LU always, fove- all of fad Basel Eig. Sere _ —



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 61 of 68

MH. united Hotes Ve Kushal, %4 63k 135%, 1364-65 (u" cir, 2021)
| 1st i Teadec's Chesge- & flea hees-1a a held ad Rpt, 29, 2008, Sees AKT S’2

|

6. See! Tugloc, 640 63d ass, 25% Ft! cir, tol); See also!

i Demiaguez , PE C3 NZI, WAM 25° (it gic, 4021)
| i
i

Wh. See. ! Dew wingueZ, FFE Bel at UZ3 - 2S" GC* cir, 2021)

1%, (See! Beckisch ,¥s% 6300 22,1133 0.13 (ut cic Zot) (erg 26, até)

19. See? Sectiosat ,N.4
0. TS kis Powrk, @ Cece depth Cirevik Cade IS a Gerel exccuple.. £0
coittel Sate3 Ue Leabella ) $e 3k BC Co cir, 20i@), the. eesrollvk cr
Chasgecl cote B4Z2(b) Se beth. attemplenl cock Coumplehecl ah® « Lob, b BLE WZ,
he. Gevrer intent elec! on @ orcberleiig Feeleral OMerSe_ of Prackchion’
OF Chilel pocopsaphy El.) ab BIC. Bevabe. the abfrrterk cLicl wack pl
|G Sole. a2 te Prockchied a3 He ony Chil Peerogerphy Chesgec® (x the Gant
| Prenclehocl te. leferrdet® CowersebiedS Gtk te. purer, he coviel ons
be Feunsel guilty of atteupteal production. Lal. ak Bttn.2 , FBE.
(wee alse! ttaiteet Sate S |e Leuba tite, »Z0L( 8, Dist Lexis 2QCER , at lo-il
—_ Noa. (E, 207i).
i The Eisbirgeibutet betutons Diabolo. asl Trodker (8 , ESebello
8 chergecl aah. both aHempledl ancl ceupbheel cS. Toole aS enhe
Chergenl with, axl Coniteck of a. Completed act.



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 44 of 68

be for Conrel'S rprofeBiove! errOrs ; He Cult F Hee Procezcling

out hue beed Afterent.” zeg., at CP,

\ tetwre a b&rrcberse ensterg aq (hy Pleo. por He Aolinte of
[Coursel, “He Yolombarivess of He plea alipercl? or arbediar Come’
adbice ag willis t erge. of Competence Arerctaol K earrexs
a9 Crimi Cases. Ail v. Leckhark, CH VS. 52,86 (98s). HocklonrdlS
Prejvelice Prong i's aledkiFrtclh 62 He Crh 6 a guilty Peer, ascl
| Prejuclice 18 Shown IF “ there 1S a RaSorable Probabilitye Hat, bt Ge
(CoonBul'S errors, The abhinelessEl tetrncl poor have. fleaclecl guity aasal
tool hor w8isteal a2 going te trial ” Hl, ak 5?. “A ee
Probability Sa Probability, Shhicienk te cnaclernuine. Corfiebesste in

te atcote Sricklasch , Wb 2.5. ak CFE

| AB Sek Er io Section IL , Court Chergeok Tencler torr Soece3shotly
jenticing @ auvor toi 2. “engage” DZ. Quy “Sexval ackiity * eich 3. hee
Covel be “hergeol witha crmival offense”, These Necessary Clenents of

i (22 (6) wore. of Critical mpoctance- to de Gere HentS Consuittied OF Ave
Zo ths Camt, THe gover lest hore Hee burden of preok thar Tacks wet ath
06 Mase ehewtentS for He $2008 Gremamedl 2 Section KW, Trade! Corte
oes inefkective beepise hee Cilech  nwestigate : A. Gee Sprsifie. Facts
of Trackers CoS} 2, Ye. Chesee. agaist hint j Qook 3. He. elebive. Cade
“lau in Cah at Hee bine of Tracler'8 quite plea

| The. Cures ater of ZU2Cb) u08 evoackal iyo 129K, with ZIZE.
(aolledl He. Fate goo Stet 208, Here 20S @2 oper gestior OF Law Bde
Clereath Circuit as to te abborsiliod of "Sexcnl ackivity” (9 ZAI2 6), ONS
He" San | ack involud Chile prororaee plug « 1 2.3.¢.. 242%, The, linaitS


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 32 of 68

AO 243 Rev. 09/17)

Therefore. movant asks that the Court grant the following relief: a) Diteck ar axSvwr be Fleck arook

Appoint Corel, b) Holel ar evrihertiary hearing orl the. after, Qu .
COPSUCKIMB Ax Se, heree arr Fosse bine avy otber (Alef 40 which fe reat ofS L-

or any other relief to which movant may be entitled.

(Deo Se.) _

Signature of Attorney (if any)

I declare (or certify, verify, or state) under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct and that this Motion

under 28 U.S.C. § 2255 was placed in the prison mailing system on Septouthe ZA F022,
’ (month, date, year)

Executed (signed) on CA 242002. (date)

Seatk Saalere-

Signature of Movant

If the person signing is not movant, state relationship to movant and explain why movant is not signing this motion.

Page 13 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 49 of 68

thes He Clerwoth Cireuit clecicleel the cote Hey only actlresieot a. limiteat
“auton Of Thacler'S arguatentS Quel insteowl eel CaSe. law which Said, uw~ Soonpriscnglg 5
tak thee Geet writl rok ConBioler argudersS ised for He Fissttine iP a cept brief.
Quiterl Boles vince, 91 Cet P61, 969 (at cir, Boze). Udexplavable
(Counsel, ad akkorniesy ath cbecocleS OF ER. nee. Clearly bik pot Exod or
det nok Carete Kec Hig wait extablishedl case law), Gite? after his chek
informal hier of ib, Then (828 Teles wWerteanl presersedl io Ge irsitial brik
pot oral heel stort, Gordd arere pres) partir OF laud aber te Siprente
court Aewicteol competes Ue irsitedd Steke8 (88 Sch 2206 (tor2), bot

hy asese. jrStronndel to Taster iv deciobirry to pleak qeriltee conclrbionraleg:

| et 2k alenyS te plas behuseed hive wel course. 40 be; 309 Hasse argeutokS fo
be Clever Cirewit eter carposter uns decictecl, Br utot 0208 broogick worthy
tre initial beet is beak closer Las a. lore, brenek io Scope. akterpl 4
ary 22. He Cighk to privacy, 9 a cleherdlarst 'S ap abthess awel &-tteil GlelreRS.,
| Trader's Narewly Chaklest ; Specific. arqertnnS beought pote Seplg were, hart,
ak Skill have. pet bed actetressid by the. Cleversth Circuit.
i Thee GuseStiow§ brenaght earth these ArgumerHS 6126. (ech. He. Main (s3ve- OF
Tm ler’ appeal! tthedber He. war antess Lizure aod Search of histories
(ecorele Ceeadecl bya cell phacen, Csealicg tee leerbion axed wosestenré of thet Crlplece.
sec Ones Ko degS 18 ferunittedl) bg th. fourth anlorctuese — ZF te cheda, Cvrelitig
the location Ql wtoveteo tS were Collecteak (13h for Of Lp aleleess iforuation.
: This (8: rook tee guestion te Court abecicled boone 418 toe Hee argos

(Pb Forth by Gensel gee He ipitiel Bie, Teck 00S the. Cighh te privace oF ar

ap acklre3§ irs ral, Not oneS thd are grvratedl by a Cl Plax Ie, SO

He cnt marr aadltrssecl Be igh to Private to te ceil plone, o8er'g cel
s igh to Privace, Bleroe-,c8-'s Pls:

plaseoeot8, “Tee Fepl Ug bre ait this cargrtiond te te Corts estio’ , basecl oD

| Compete aul nel BoteS VU. Spe , GES VS. 400 , 132 B.ct. PS Giz),


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 31 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

18. TIMELINESS OF MOTION: If your judgment of conviction became final over one year ago, you must explain
why the one-year statute of limitations as contained in 28 U.S.C. § 2255 does not bar your motion.*

The Sopra. Corrrt depiedl Wacks's pakittien for a wre o& Cectioraci 3
Cckeher Ol, Zot, Thes the jvdgner of Corviction becane Erral om cckebec
Ot, Zotl arnck He ateranttic eotien to Vacake a8 Bel to be, Elect
OC before @cteber 04, 20172. Notably uvder Fool, R civ, D ‘ °
oleug of He. Werk el te) Oe ee OM), “Me
ran ee ‘age s He fhirud PaciockTM is exclinle ky wil
Mee Presess te le Court op Hee anor dete oh a. de;

S cri ;
, im om oO one fear Pertoek OF feriteatioNS Set ost spo ZB vs ines ancl
). Therefore the. TH ‘ SS ”
HAC. Thacles'S Sections 2253" biotin 'g mel
Ak w24h'n) ee Orre_-~ Yeas” Ytrdute- OF lie tation? as Cocknncrne i, ted
‘ O3.6.. Zas-s-

Se a

* The Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996 (“AEDPA”) as contained in 28 U.S.C. § 2255,
paragraph 6, provides in part that:
A one-year period of limitation shall apply to a motion under this section. The limitation period shall run
from the latest of —
(1) the date on which the judgment of conviction became final;
(2) the date on which the impediment to making a motion created by governmental action in violation of
the Constitution or laws of the United States is removed, if the movant was prevented from making such a
motion by such governmental action;
(3) the date on which the right asserted was initially recognized by the Supreme Court, if that right has
been newly recognized by the Supreme Court and made retroactively applicable to cases on collateral
review; or
(4) the date on which the facts supporting the claim or claims presented could have been discovered
through the exercise of due diligence.

Page 12 of 13


a

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 68 of 68

Cectificate, K Sevice.

ax HEZEBY Cacti fy Het on thig ZL ola of

& prembe.— ,2022,, x Mai lea through He Prison
legal mail Syster, Lh Copys of He eregainsg focrment
for delivecy to all CourSel of fecorel.

Bl Leaet Sxnahe

Batt Toler



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 8 of 68

Ige. of 9

lad

Lan fObe. , da teion

e ; f bf 7 fen Rep yp Lim th fe nf
: i towitnie hina uss fedter eine. cto Tb, it Pavte the. Crght fo Tag Se for éfenal

a

i elemuS fast, hoicl EB aledengs snoitl . La have, tteple. bnee fayfy fed

* deren Yond Beate ince:

lent cota gant’?

np Ln Sead enegh fo por £ Let mp ALI) Bo wach, Hol L hare. ed
! iL : 4

wees Gor bat Lee cerere. Sippoial te fogetier Ceever, bi) tale. lend lel auto extaes iat

eh. others acms. Wares t's the tree to blame. bee, besides wie. D aver eeted te fastt sped, thats

ten base Hrs £ adrtel bit Hats tha happeredl. £ hope. a2 Cine Aappilsaeos gaits, efea! deseve. pb Sp

eth Ch ee. Seoebr o& eget fears ek be rial adits. Be ul palhel:
Y
LBs Afi cps ost Gorget abel tga. Lele, bade calect nd ciate Brack hoe tagedlee, S fa.
$

ces. Tels Ga bog bie AS 6 Md, £15, Speers enscl De wiasths bak © Linon) Tin te entyy cure, oho

dks tet Mot £ ale

¢ adill. Te tt., foo axe. Gnel CrlainyS bill be. ty oI



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 22 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:
Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:
Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) If your answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

GROUND FOUR: Affeilate. Con s8e 0x18, (20K ‘ ilinee to Bran. OD,

(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):

Thet Cader 1, 28 athuully ipocent A Comk 4} 2, There ad
INSAF Clepok Cvickece to Comet For Cot 45 3. The factun( a8i§
dloe8 rook Suppork a Gerurcdion Under Section) 2422 (6).

(See: Mestorarsdon OF Bd, Section az)

(b) Direct Appeal of Ground Four:
(1) Ifyou appealed from the judgment of conviction, did you raise this issue?

vel] No
(2) If you did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why:
Thee iSSue_ of mekfeckve 298/Stance of ComBe (s appropCrately faiseal im a
Mekie to Vacate PorSvact to 28 U.S.C. 2838743 tb QUE as evidbertian
Aeasing. ES
(c) Post-Conviction Proceedings:
(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?

Yes im No =a

(2) If you answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Page 9 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 59 of 68

Re. be. Clear, t | feet, 2020.60) Orsly Rgvices Heck ad onceler] a
Cristie effete. bee checperble. Thee Gakute. Leek wor Cegvire. a Cbhercetrse
__ackenlleg bite chase eel writh thee cnrelecke inh Criatioel Messe, wlike. Hee

200 Alok hich elec See AZ OSL NIV). LikesOSen , the. Sebrie,

_ look tsk Sopuire. a. Combesion, OC i ten Context of a> adtoniph Med @

Beckisch , PSF. Bol W212, UBY (ue wie, ttt) "Zaye 0b) aloe, sack Copusice.
- thd the cibhersclimk Creissile any [iCior Critten ak atl pacer tek: de cheek oshly

torcrrchers 26 Me sroolrlyity Crietisel AF eSe. Crier ie oe

engage. jn Coa aslaul Sexor.| ackiwibe” (ceileckivg C2308)" (aT

Mepiteatak Hora chioattor attenph te Vieteke. 2. Stekore- «Section ZB2 (6) @) a analy.
. Cepaites Hee @ atosclat-aBionpt heute. a nein’ te aagine. isan ack tat
tava be Mega.” ” Zeb At M28 19.8 “2492.0) does 29 Coguire thet a

— abeRemcllck ackuelly Uiolake Me lhel Gote, Hedtes "ad ak 9B

bedecl c€ He comrobich of He wack cheng Crinsisel Sebo ar Lesgorvel a.

Th essence, BEBO) lncers He. Storsclasol of quill foe a comickiod

Censaanble, dsb tea probable Cassa; Bard onde prebpble caches ig sxedeoh de

- allege. a. Urolakion of way Crinuixn ( Static. which. thed fori tee bnSiG OF

He. 2472.00) Wiobebiond. See enriteed HebeS VU. Marwan, SES” LAA HE,

ie. Cet cir, 2002). Feank Miteralleg , Beration 2422. DO looted Heke, ib
0 Scheca ORFinSe. te eorgaage. it2 Comeback Mek erees tecl only prebable. Case.
Ae sk, tek arebud conmled a crinainnl Mase. ,Sicee prebable. ake
A alt Hed i8 Coguived to Charge, Satwone. tail a> ARS. ” ¢ See, also!

_ unitead Bote? Us SulelaDa -Riverm, Ol 6.3L VAL, Feb (1 cic, Zor a.

a “Qu. wtign (cheraleg Real E netion). ata baxgunge. a8:  heaeliachissg SuSp'cies.

b 4 Reverthe leas Lawhel Coneluct Hk_aléght fi Ornish probable. Caer


Case 2422-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 66 of 68
|

Ther are wat Orclwary, Aco IS Sich & basking recerds, Morearr, Hi8
| US a Sealeel Hecrmest wlirs Ge cork f He Hote. of Cloride.. tack to
| Peri Suche a. chest ty be Seitecl prcsoank to His Search tonceenst,
| wotel beta Perit a. gorral Search, adhich th forte Anereliiod PeebibitS -

So, Ste. DKT SB, (9s 36-3

ST. |\Seet DET SE, ad 6 [43-25-

SL. |e. der 56, pq3t/S-1l

YS. ||[Sees DET SE, pos BC- 3%, prs 42-43, py TS", PFS F2-Fo, pgs 9-74
S4, |\See? DET SE, pps Ba-3¢

SS1 [Sees DET SE, PRS SS- SE

S@ See DET SC, pas FF-80

SF. ||\Set DKT SE, PGs G-FZ

4

See! DET Z/

S?. See DKT 14-1



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 39 of 68

ang performance which imclodes Sexual Comdick ha. chilel less thas
& ywoss oF age. a (caphasis aaklech)

: As ax isitial Matter, SbSech on 2) & Florida. Kakute. SELON
Prohibits rurbiple Forms o& Cristina Conabick Rlakiscg to chilel porogeaghess
avd cath form 0 Comloch has dhifeerent atherwative Means for @
cekesiobiook te theleke- le, Sedu. Tis obber tonecls, the teruS prothoce,
heck OC Provdetes” cack Probibh't diferent Garlick.” Prockeee” of
(hircctTM ase. rock AS ined bx Slade yard Shevlel be ger theie Plais
ark orchinacg public Heong, Pronete hacer 13 hfe? bg Hodobe-
agi’ ! “te procure, Marutacture , 1SSve— Sell, giver, Prawiek., lexreb pail,
ebelivec, trasther , traSpwre- , publiSh chstribute ,circviate abi ssteinoke ,
Present jexbubit, oc ackertise oc 10 fer oc agree. to cle the. Suite, a
Flocile. Yedter BEL CLLCMGLY,So “Procrede. Means anonrg other Hines ,

to elbisteibure?”

on Hei Ackrparteatiratrt AF Sheree eleser tS , the govern vein
uses the. whele. Zbsection 2), OF FZLOU . Then whiny SubGeckion (3),
evi phasi Beol ins boted leMerinsg are the booredS ” Dreckoced, hiv ch? ac prowess
ann, perforvunce- which ioclocles Sovval conoleste bg a-chilel ls then)

© gars of age.” This lerquoge. either ierplys thet Tncler'§ Condo
Sprsmeol the. ertive Rope of tle Yakrte , OF the. Gevernwtink chick bot
Speci€icadie icbuwbitig bf whek wean’ Taner Uolakeel He Stedvte . Bor
as flee Eleventh. Ciresit kB alrenoky tecomizecdl , beca Se Woakr 3
checgeol avol Coruictedd wih e coupleseal act He gevenvent Cad Kok Chavet.
Mottiple crimes Wik te poSSibilee Teacher's censedock Ceviel fekentiaily
Viotece. at katt aoe of Wen. “obviously, iC 0 eleheroleart fe Ssoveschorluy


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 40 of 68

PeSvaceel 14000 be oe ar cmltol Socal ack, tes coil
_thePicai
_ pelentiet tata abine gull eens azated ooh —
Picea state. , He. abferrhate will fae. Cherwestl seo rit atlespe, bot with

— Arkwally erbieig a. aise ta cosuit the, SPpecikic. Sx ack ek 0S.

; Cenifleteol ach Mok wIll be. lsteck i: te inclekoten” uwtteol Stoke

_Avel Cures if they Covted 2 then Polestiol Wiolabions tlotel hese te Fall emer —

This gerade st Cam wok list pokembial violakion’ for a cocspleteok aed,

de. beast clpable. conduck Criesinalittel by Sedse- $Zt.0FG) vs.

_ distesbution ; the alberwakive teas here, ale rset. -

oa _ Separateh Tears Stpulatecl cordock with Wt dLeeB rok
potent to. volation & Section 2422.(b), Thee Hiple$ion Of F$§ 22 Sefpork
oe Waders gui te Plea Sensacize3 bie. comelock tenobsag to He. Wolediiond
— AS KeulWS 2 HEL Sas Chel Frees Teale to thee toehios Mek naeleclenl casen
other Haisags, smecerS BpHS fraps hirer ten Uicdiog to Sarat Mier mle,
feeeges. Ab First, Hee Uirkion Ptovitleel Trobe Seur.cal prekoreS of her full
. clothech warhieh Clarke inalicatecl She, und _a_pcekee) Rupile..<Taces_

BMS0 aSkeed He Ueber , Gtlong otter thing’, hid oll She t208 arvod. Sen telel

Ait Shee 08 NINE , te coheeh he. Ceplied Aud, geu'ce. prektee Fo four Ogee.»

Be look Serie fod stheBee Pajere3 . Lio Ce8pr%e to TackecS Coqve8t8y a

: the Uickirn everbsally Seask at lade 6122. photo a hem Uaginta. arch opie

seco, 98% 6.300 22,33 9008 (then ged)

He Sealeca.l abGinsition OF Sexual Achinitre Felekiog to Chilel Porneg capi, « Bocas.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 55 of 68

i sx
| Trader's expect writvess ; Br. aichael P. Beason, PSK.D ; PS Cheney

“nel He geremued Seek this epert alocing Heir MeSing argustost
| The. Geverrsitent Cori S00Blg Beol tis report to See) te. Court
“Het nating BA LIFE. CO0vtel be, SAF cient ie Trade Feces Se. of hs
ericson, Arch pelye wicklle Brooks agceecl Speci€jealley Sele, Hidelle briekS
cite this sepork as a Sector oo clekesntiming Teele'S Sexstence.* “aL have
| Me Comficlensce. tak: he. asill Step this betewior because. he. Comincect chile
(oN Brel fren a State. Gort Preceedling axl exer cabule. he. ux heise eublucdedl
bs stedlical PrekeSSioNals ito he w2S, apparent ) able to fe isto belies
pe did't present a. threnk te hs chillers at He Saute titte he wr cousin
Cem arainsh Hebe chien.”

rdlpe. oidelle brooks GpeS o> to Sag Het be. “ConBiclerecl ark LA
(taker Brio Sly MO Peabeck'S araet§ Ghar Ha PBibilite tat agp Hey
Prowiete prokechien, 4t£ 1 gies We history > Hus GaSe) Eke seek

ou meecl of Hak.” xl.

i Hack ComSeh ebjectecl to He. istroatoctions of ths tepock beset

i th Lack tek 4 unS cbhtainecl Megalleg ars (.2HhleA Consent or, Perusiios
Seow the Gurt , Trader'S Setenta, tixrvtel bese. bees diferost. He. wie st ber
beer Sesterceal te a teem of iP SoNHest OF aramd Zo wars \a3 epxcHeck,
Gael Coole bewe. heel He dare te gekat & Prisoniat aronel the age of Go
ears ole. The. Fprene. ceoet beB Saicl “Crag anourst of Geko jevil tee has

| Sikth cumoluot Siqrifitancee.”« Glover ve ovitecl YoteS, $3 0.9, (96,
| B08, (Zz S.ch, C96 Geol) * See aise! Leflec Vv. Coopen, '32 S.chk, ISE

| Gea). The. Sid. anencloieste Siqni€icarte 02 Teedle'S O88. (8 Orme ,


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 28 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:

Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) If your answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

GROUND Eq? 52, e's flen of quills Un wet pacle. socestigertleg , Grral tate Kate [e208 placte.

Kiara cb HOU i wK- face Bick bok ESS. CeLé ( Shote. oF 20)
(a) Supporting facts (Do not argue or cite law. Just state the specific facts that support your claim.):
Ord Saplembes- 2%, Zorg te bake. Sul, a elecisior. ON Sepleaber 28, Zax, Mere. hour’ before
He Change OF Alec. hens4,Teder experienrcecl arouakit Crore 1a Hate court totes the Depart
OF Chitelre> ausel fayilieS termenatert his Parental cigltS over brS ter beior Chiletres . x49 adlel tier, (D>
He time between) He tive Court heosisQS ,Thecter 0208 betel (ote Special he Bing rit where be attesiplecl
Sutedeten 2 hiS Cell, Gow Bel eS hiaole hotly AIRF OF All CLEA leneliry to the. Chosge. of ler. hersing
be Tractor, arel Coptinvedt to eceorage. hire to plecel quilts bg /forrong hie tek A tacciel he 143 hiS hese
[otereSt, the. bearing ERS altencl Shee tect ,Qsicl He Court eUINS Los anstinng therm time . Bt it Consol
gaol bere peSchécllecl He of Ble beasisxe, toa ater tine eters Tircks- U9 Kok WUINL to rere thiscg
Aeppersiing acral hies he. warviel beive alitecl He T8828 reich Ase. New) berg Ci8eel 12 ak (eae four Otcrreke
OF Hus patition, MorecnS, Tacks arte hee Fath CarSiclerecl He tps a Guilty Ree. wrrtel have. obit,
As Galera arl State CBS. Beta Se_ ch US. eB excel MLSS, Thaclrs Pee of girthy US Not Keele (shesligen He
Gos (b) Direct Appeal of Ground Four: Pleat quilt, el reel fee roconda? fet RA Pe Nee

(1) Ifyou appealed from wo of conviction, did you raise this issue?

Yes LC] No

(2) Ifyou did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why:
The (3.x of ineShechive. AB8IStace Of Corel (Ss appraptictely farsect in a motion to
Vacate Ppersvant to 2 0S.C, Z2857as 14 pore as eutelerbrery bearivg

(c) Post-Conviction Proceedings:

(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?

Yes LC] No

(2) If you answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Page 9 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 58 of 68

i

4. CouctS hace helol Ctrssgh Mere. 4D jt aswel), Hosk the cmseler lages39
Crintina( oFfenSe- to atich He Antute fers Covel bea Yate
Or feckera| CCme) Qlthocagh th Statute. dot wot Say Ser See.
oiled States v. Bill, HO €.30b 130%, 1381-52 OO exe o)
He. Please Tevinival eel 1S wot bfisecl ins te federal Crier!
Loole® f Bok Se? woiteal Hobed Ut Seckisch FSFE 3aL 122 a4

Gis cic, 2008) (128.6. 24206) prohibAS “Sexvn( activity Mek + Corel
hace feBvitedt 60 CSiainal Heres creer Bate or Feuberel fou) »

| TFFotke'S @Sc~ ig 6. prime excesple. why iS '§ Cows itotionl.
“The Prockuckion of Chile poeogrsph Sekuter io ta Stoke OF Clie esdcereh eg
broad acl incledeS Cereloct rark coverecl withis We bebirsiticay CF
Bexenl activity Gor a iolickions of 2182 (b).” Cor a. Fesleral Hed te.

do Fix He Snsbersce for & bread Gibeqory 0€ Cordck Ceimislitedl by
Blate beod , Such af Coxe Tereal ackitity for which ry person) Ce be. hesgol
orth a. Criaivnl Mens (Sa guittiorablee prrctice, . Congess Cossiot

Kee is adlitavce wet Cornett te Stoke Olt clecile: te tebe: Chissinel
iailor, C40 Cb 2557 256 CAM csr tout) Lio twsitecl Hote U. Bogert

BOF 3. dDiSe Lecig FISH (D KanSaS Ke sl (2019); He Coork
ackreavleGek “1320 deka be8 ete hatiergeal thes (5e- before .
Moreciver, tte) Coots hex, ites pletedl Hig Ghatute, no te, @rtect
Of & tonBkiberional Chatlearsge. , they hue helol, asl SerahineS Sasple A8rsted,
thet Grete band olenSes are icorporekerl” wal. ZAP 0S. pst besa& CE

| As as alteconkive- argavaent, fox He Cen Si focth. eLIN, Thovcbic
Conmende tig Aotute-, 2122 (6), is Cnconsttotionn| ag apphe8 to Mink.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 67 of 68

COINS 10)

| for ail te foregoing RABONS , Ard for aSoar8

Nok gee Weludeal w2thiss tis Herorenlxr Tader pres
that this court Cordict as eviclersiary hearing or AS Seckiond
PLS potion ancl Hereatles grace au selie€ to ahicly

he. wasg, be eptitlect,

|

'

ZX declare. vvdesr pervalty or perjory » Porseant
to 29 0.8.c., (IU, ted te foregoing S tre avd Correct,

| Executect op tis 24 Lag of Sephembs 2022.

Respect folle Subsitted

+

[S| Ket Vitehae
Scott Wade
Keg p00. (CU&- 104
£.0.0,. Coleman
| US.P. Clemens TC
Po. Box 1034
Colevan, £4. 3352 (



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 4 of 68

Page. [of @

Melee ha see

}
Leet Sapna ntlr - ~~
—— +

; p 4 met 4
eife.g ttiite. Bil Face Hen Srahi bo Sep Bho. spose ealely.

TA. ede sbuis pber Edits
€
sate Law & Cet! frstse,

chad Siste ptere Po!

ho ctleewtS vttzote oe.
Dist fhe E alsninns tolol ead ts Je. Sica. Gab, Eb".

he Eine, bat, Sinste.. fy a yor fares Lelod CNG ped
oF i

Cat Ua te Burns thet Lo Legon Wyle) cae
ov

: _ficeewnk. as efor, Aurel EZ Gpees bows wsi'l

Od Mice Clits wet. 42 sdetebe Ls ¢

thoaus Le Hak beavtec ancl

0b, Hil bie. Cenvialotel prvuritl s

of eae , et beack. EE Aspens enh ealehoe fra) ill Cepiewboce tes Cor fie. Doody biel

eS, He fen bat Sax axl exgubtel by fe, Hat Eile, Madel ots

BM uel Gtalk Be

wetikles fe cate da pala. Tuto fo) coin Faxfif

Cewek cent to Lerremubue Hote hstsinrg, Sarre, Cather whe

Bale.

tie. Saute. bowl fo 2p hd
a
2 Crerber peice 36, Sa merstire'S Spasethvish Stéesd. Zo Lede L, het,

2 Soe pe, blase. Dot Cemember pie Exe t

Bare wi lee

foal Celis oT Vaaenler £ wel Be Py aworiol
sit cima ged a. thine, Got
; A vee ele nig Teese ter to:€..
Ls Lan fi gp Tesed
4 nal 7 .
. - wage bye we oe
Pte He. Same Devaar, er hy Lew, Je fb. Sar we. Tease HD ice Sy ee. “ose

¢

th Bese cherishes pietes3S » Ml fle gals. &

fo ferme toe to Cement,

wav Globes thew Ge ty tage Se, Oi nté ist ok.

YH weet swee.

2. A pf 9, i £
th Pi See ll Pie. ne ie a

vite Fe 4
ie Seme Cems School, eel the.

4. —beclety

ra
dookehe
—

back flip wt ag offs t0nith egal. Amarante L want sos bes Leva ec flee
oho Cevikl sever eet snc &! <i, Mok £6 a heck, Bole oldst (yell 2 Bh spon. L biish feu boy Concertos
j get. J

wh dacratins: L poet een, 10. emeirb

Wey tty Gore Abe. ace gas
Sakes gr Pee , ble tethrg Me £

Sse. #8fe. Sizes ti

Spuilel Corba. ca! oul tlle Got, XS



Case 2}22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 47 of 68

:
|
i
\
|
| Lip this oe. , the. lomguege- OF AU Srotte? Celiecl Uflod for Cone
Gare exeplicith, Clee for tee WEG St Forth. 12 Suction IL, Tacks 1% atkvally
immocerst of Ulett cg Sechion BAZ) 2k Hare 028 100 eiclence or €ackval
Lass to Sppert a anwiction. fdldtionralle appeitote. Cosel oes wlook
auuce. OF these Speci€vre. L238 wit Trader’ Sectiew 2422, 0b) Conaviedion) .
lanel for Som. Umexplaipable- GeSed, Conte lil Mot QiSe. these. (C3128

ibe aappea|, ever after Fader expressly totel hird to,

Th, bat Gr failure of appellee Coursel, He Elerrvth, Cires't carick
awe helel tok it aes Plain Ercar ta Conrnch Texler aool Sosterscce- hier

Ha LIFE fie Comba . Forte, Hey sol hae isstcgckest te discick
Couck te Ubeake. Teader'S Sechien 24220) Coovietion and LIFE Sosterce.,
laud veserl back Ge Lorber Proceedlogs.

\ EZ. i €. Bide ebec diy

te >

He witial boel, 08 cpocbeck to te. Cpl heee

Bere, a chhorilnt esters a gritty Plea por te alice K CorBel,
Wee volorkeri 358 of Ve leo ab pers or2 atether Ceam8e 18 adleiee. 28 ceoithir
te. onge, F Coopertenrce, Avarrleel of abordeys iv crisixal ease.” Aytl, 104
OS, 62,56 (ss) Seicklacds pre jbice Prony 18 etoel Feel jarsck Prejechce iS
Teun if “Here. Ra taxable. Peobabilite thak, br for Cavs error’S ,
be elebesselass earicl et hve Pleolel quithe acl cexnxel fare brGisteel od gong
i[to trial” Midi ak 5%. “A ranserrable Prebrbiliby (5.0. probability SKiciak to
jnderutive. cortideree, jie ootcoue-. Stcickavel, CL 08. ak 6F4,
Aelelitirco.leg 0 tkfodlot (3 entitlecl to the effectiie, A8S/Starce



Case 2}22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 45 of 68
in

i

OK LYN), Sot by 24, cre. clear, Bexaste. a2. of He Gade of Sloriede.
Boktee elieal efor be Ye. gormutot & te PABSESION K Chilel pornegeaph
Hader's Ceombel wn ineffective Foc failing te abSiis8 Cent 4, Qe

eetvising Fadler to plenal guilty bt. Adbbtimratt,  becerse the. other Bote.
lof Gloria, Sakute Pelieel exptem by He gevermuunt iicclod8 Ofer Se Grrchck

Buch as cbsteibution of Chiled Porsagraphy Ce Bet 003 agai inethective. for
failing te Asis Cost 2 aad for acter 'Sig Tarker to Pleaol quithe to it.
Moreover , becacbe Cleves Cicesit Precertsst ab te tine of Trastr'S
quilts Pleo nwebtoterl a deKyclsste Conk po be coruitted of Uortirg Scher
212263 Gngleterl ack epirner bsticg ktoltiple Patesbial Sxtotorg
Violations a8 He frecticate. MSE) COSA ux8 pxeFFechive foe failing 1

jlefsxiss cot a aul ach/Sing Treats to Plena’ quilhy w it.

fourth, becr8e.“Crinunel 82" (8 pot AG Ieck 4 Bette ZUL2.(4) to
rca. Heke ql Fabra! SEES, drool eco WS i95v2 Hill AS wor beed
actedresstol he Ye Claret Circwit, Trashr'S Cate Preserteed a. Noo Friveles,
Meritorin® Claes 08 te the Soke, AS eat rot Of Pla te Sexton 2022 ()
Mrolation’. His Cur8el cong ircefFeckivee ther fe filed te ASwuce Coat 4. brieol
low the groaxl, aul Further imefFectivn for addiSing Tote to Planch guilhg to t.

Finattg berm Be Tadks'S Core failecl  megtigate. ete pa Prockxend

Han tude Pets foe, wohich Bee beter “Sem” 4o Tracks, dock beceste ar B%rtial
lenient Da Cupleterl act o BEBO) (8 actually emticing be. minor to
engage in, thig Cee te. Prealvestion of He ante Chilel Porwography involved
ie thiS Coot, ack betate COrSel back Kewlecye. of ara. havioy hack
xin Comunicakiea® with at lease or other achotl ter, Corel eS whelleg

ieee. for alising Tineler to Pearl guilty whe? be heel a Viable alee Se

Ho cor the birewd Nosthiseg ahevt, Accl acer s.92g Ayins Sigh @ Facto baS/

ph lackech Lpport Sc te chien 2¢220b) Viekstion.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 15 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

MOTION UNDER 28 U.S.C. § 2255 TO VACATE, SET ASIDE, OR CORRECT
SENTENCE BY A PERSON IN FEDERAL CUSTODY

United States District Court

[District “Gausthers District of Cloriela.

[Name (under which you were convicted):

Docket or Case No.:

Seett Dose bh Mach Zi -CA- MOLE - pECODME Baers

Place of Confinement: S46 NE.S4Y* Tecrege., | Prisoner No.:
USP Colerar Tl, Covras, € 3352, ,|/E/IS- lod

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

Movant (include name under which convicted)

v Scott Wese Ph Teader

MOTION

1. (a) Name and location of court which entered the judgment of conviction you are challenging:

ONZTED STATES DISTRICT COURT, Suthers Bistrice of Foricda,

FL. Pierce. Nivsion
10( Sth OS, Highurur a

) 4 Piette, Ceridla, 34950

(b) Criminal docket or case number (if you know): Z 7 /7F -CR ~ LLOLE —- MADE BRAKS

2. (a) Date of the judgment of conviction (if you know): 09/29 /2ott
(b) Date of sentencing: /Z lot I Zott

3. Length of sentence: Té-tal tere of ADEE

4. Nature of crime (all counts): Enticettensr of a bt x0r do engage b> Saxon ( Ackiitey, tn)
Vielatior Of 1% US.¢.. 2422.(8) (cert 1) £ Distributing material A3VoIUNG He
Sexcnl Axploitaton of sinoes, in Violation OF IE OSC. 2ZS2 )(2) aol (6)()

(count 2) | RSSE3310N Of Material AOUaIUING He, Sexn( €xPlor
io Violation OF I© OS.C. 2252 (a)() anced 6
Makerial jovolving He Sexen( exploitation o
225| @) and (2) (comb)

; ‘tation of Aixors,
@) (Coons 3) 7 BL Prochoing
EMLINEES ; > Ujoiation Of IS S.C,

5. (a) What was your plea? (Check one)
(1) Not guilty

(2) Guilty a (3) Nolo contendere (no contest) |

6. (b) If you entered a guilty plea to one count or indictment, and a not guilty plea to another count or indictment,
what did you plead guilty to and what did you plead not guilty to?

6. If you went to trial, what kind of trial did you have? (Check one) JuryL_] Judge only LJ

7. Did you testify at a pretrial hearing, trial, or post-trial hearing? Yes | Nof-]"

Page 2 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 57 of 68

footnote

L. tinclic'S trocbichowmt (DRT 1:2) arcd hes Stiptolation) & Locd& carl
Ore eleven tS Caer 2a: 8-6), Chasge- hint evith @ Couspleded ack endhey —
Gna sgek ar abbewph

2. See Wroitecl Hates Ve Pusisen, S91 Feel. Appr. HO,U3 ch cx. 201s) 3
wed Hote8 Vv. Dorsinguez , BEF Fol 121, M24 Ge cir. 202t)

8. See. oitel Gales U. Taglor, CHO £.2eb 2585 25°76 ES car BOI")
A See! Drwinnquez., WE 3b, MAL, MES” G4 er: 2021)
united AnteS Y. Leabella, UCL Bet Gb, S50 -°BE CAs" RL
Cc ce. 201) (cotleching oases) jp See alse! Aaitvel States wv Lee. ,.
603 £3 Pot, WSC Gir, 2010)

Bee:

_ €..See! Regwolds ut insritest Hate’, 201F OS. Dist. Lexis fooF Ee __
6d. tiineis, dacch 2, B01e)." Congress dil sek define. thee tered

Bemval ackinite 28 418 v8eel 2 ZAI 6) other Has to Sug the

TbecledeS He Proclictions of hit peewegraphe” U6 25.6. 2424  Dobeak

oe PAE OS. diSt lexis fb., See. alse ¢ Bagloc, C0 F.30l. ak 2S @ (eh Git dot ) a

T The. qesrrotesk ackrocuteclges Hot Sexual ackiuridy €oc which ary Pers

bene hee chisel writh a Csiuival ekferxtes (8 explicitls aeficecl te_iilice

Proclenineg Chile Poc-sogruply « (B86, 2424." See also.) 0S. Ou,
2022. VS. Dit LexiS (30016 (5,000.0. Bolg 21,2022) at Lexis 3-6



Case 2:92-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 63 of 68

|

|
[
|
i

31.) Seet amke's clatenl 12, (9 |aenty , lt f2cn?

wo
»

. Appettats Repl hoet ) Bl l2o19
33, |See? Appellant's brier, Cholix - pas OF Ie
BY. |s02.! Appetasts Reple brief, 3M lol? - pgs t-6

BS) The court also reachecl thig Conclos’an brSecl in Part on te lack of
\Mforatation abot te location clita. providtect be KiK to Howelarel Security:
Becasse Gnel acl prot attach We corks of this decta to te. wickior te Soppress,
phere weve Loans. art of Ye Erorell Or SCs), Gal the, appellate. coort unr
Jrever able, to View Hem, Conse! 29 eholle mefective Sr rot Provicling
He Bistriek Court coh He informations ehich e298 saot jest te BSIS for He
wtchios to Sppress , but and te cleferteAS whele. arguree+ on appeal,
Comms later Hocorrecthy forse! Tracle ted He appellate Cosrt
trate bave ACLS te view Wes CeeonlS theese Ascsery. This, (Reorreck
imforwation mfloentecl Tadbr's decisio) to Pleacl quite Cond tienrallie,
Asc becarse te Gort at oral AQ UH ent Question tHere. CO irGrrertion)
Container? arithic the bik came Storr, Come Covlel wat Point to archer
edith Hoe, record to beck He- tracking ClainS stl be Tule, See t Oaibit
JCal argunent, U9 [todo ~ 4 9/s-28 , 9 ol ~ 24, 3 22 [ @-23
Hal Com provid) be. tracking Ake te Drie Gort
poe the totion te Sypress, He Appellate. eurk wrovtel hewe. farreseel ct,
lr te Sit of He preceeding Coil have. beers liFFerote. Tee Court
Cdercl have, beers able. te Ue) He tracking of Tiackr's physica! HakwtortS ,



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 17 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)
(4) Nature of the proceeding:
(5) Grounds raised:

(6) Did you receive a hearing where evidence was given on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes | No CI

(7) Result:

(8) Date of result (if you know):

(b) If you filed any second motion, petition, or application, give the same information:
(1) Name of court:

(2) Docket of case number (if you know):

(3) Date of filing (if you know):
(4) Nature of the proceeding:

(5) Grounds raised:

(6) Did you receive a hearing where evidence was given on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes C] No i

(7) Result:
(8) Date of result (if you know):

(c) Did you appeal to a federal appellate court having jurisdiction over the action taken on your motion, petition,
or application?

(1) First petition: Yes CL] No |

(2) Second petition: Yes | No LC]

(d) Ifyou did not appeal from the action on any motion, petition, or application, explain briefly why you did not:

Page 4 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 3 of 68

Exhibi £4%

Noke§ avd leHer'Z Showsiivg
Kotiees Wzelre - Waclre

? pages

“Tracles’S nertal Sole of mel


|

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 38 of 68

Nee. hive. felegeel Lypor He Posse SSion) of Chile A forse
_Cithar ob the Stose..00 Sobirol aed 68 a2 cnderheine offers y Mor Coteh
— thesp 3. theb wovtel leacl to absurd acl erroneous esvits.. Such (3
He. ope. here. , ether. Hen gortenraatk fe essenrtioliy Akirreel Me.

tere “Sexual activity’! to ivelicle: Hes possesion of a phetegroph.
—.. SubSeguentlig, when teubioing thee Gateratet& clekirritio Of
Seacuml active “beg, eat the 2 Stabtory CNB CAN ave doterpretohion
an 2482 Cb), wrhiel, agains PebibitS the evbredent of the wunior to engoges
feo Mes Senee, ackivity ahich He obfmrolrse Cotch bye. cheogedl 1940
_ccwunal offerte, rt creates te ebSucel @Butk tek He auvor /S

— Bovaherd. ensgegek. 63 Hee PoSse58ion of Hen hetooroph Het te elehernelerk

ch ba Cherwech aIiith PoTEssi2g

i The. Secevsch cnscbiche sty Cevnsiviel Ofer In thee gevrer nate: aleperls

uperrtoc AS ba8is of Conuiction cnchm 2422.0), (8. &. holekion of fer

Slekute. L2T.SUUG), Prooutiiay @ Sercvel perkoresesce by a cht id. l Hecdewe
there ace. switiple. Problens wll chargirag hig crsdecleisg inaissel OER y
: the. Heit Selevert beisse Hok “tHe beat calpable. conelck He Steduie
Ccimivalizes. is “< dest botion fa Pletogeaph of @ Chile le33. tha»
agus age. This lees Nok Fall ensch the. Sobral aehirition of
- Setonl ackivihy for a. Wolation of 2472 (0).

— _ Flecide Habe, SZE.OF3) States ir Clevert pork “A pecion
is fa gull of Provieting 0. Serta | pecfocutance by a. Chilel ake, Kieuoiag the.

chacackec Gucl Censtent therec€, he, oc be. products, hicorks 0c Promotes.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 26 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

(2) Ifyou did not raise this issue in your direct appeal, explain why:

The (SS Of WeFeckve BSiShw xe hk Come (3 apprapatel @iSeeh 1> a

Morios> to Uscake. Pursuant to ZF V5.0, 2ag55~ aS it CequireS @> andertiang
Aealivsg.

(c) Post-Conviction Proceedings:
(1) Did you raise this issue in any post-conviction motion, petition, or application?
| Yes | wo

(2) Ifyou answer to Question (c)(1) is “Yes,” state:

Type of motion or petition:

Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes L] No CL]

(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?

‘Yes LC] No |

(5) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?

Yes tC] No CL]
(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:

Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) Ifyour answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

Page 7 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 2 of 68

 Eihibit X
| Pratt Argustek far LrakQ hear OD arpa!

22 Pages


Case 2122-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 50 of 68

but He Geork altel prok CorSieter 4, Thacler, a+ 969, Ack tienaliy, Corel’
(er pusterst lec He Coork io Teaches to Conrsclucle, “sy tlerosk MeiKk0a8 ALER3E woivekeRs
Hobermek medunckS } Computers, tablets, gaming corsoles ,horscholel appliances , aac
tore. Aisel each K tase clesteeS hes @> interwek Pratoce | adedreS8, We. C2 rok
Conucte, Heb ictensek Prekoceal anbbesSes are. Ce Phere Rol? whe? they are a
Fecture of every elechtonsic, abepiice Hak CORLAS to Hen soterniet Locker, ak KP
Crtensal pretation’s quittect)

Corte. 0 He Hikial bk rortionedt a yk to Privacy i LP acklresse3;
Goel Hes Poisstedl Hr Courk tewarel Capester. Bot he Seemingly hl te Priwery
rguetost Toader wwstect made 7p te be Covet tes neke For hit. Aewrerier tether

Thncber Sigheat bis Cnrdbrtiantal Pler agreeseet , he expectecl his camel Wat
Ye Court; to Qe on Kis bohal€. Bee aan gueStion treet wratvdl preseorteal to
He Court, whith wos Ver elecidivca foctor 10 Bigasiag He condbtioa( Plea ux!
Wek breapict te the court wnotil Pe reply bot Hack not been for ConSel’S Error,
Trader ixstel have Prevaited or appeal. This Pefforitaccee by conse( Cad orig
be abseribecl a9 fatting below a9 aljective: Steroelarel of GenSonrable ness.

Zio avoller argrecomte rok CorBvolurecl by be Coort, badeck (p> pate ons
(avtteol Bteke8 U. Karo, WEF 0.8. Fos; tot S.ck 3296 C9e4) , Kigllo i. sited
States, $83 0.5. Zt, 141 8.ch 103% Ceol), ancl nriteed Yates Ue Tre,
Ses" 0.5, too, 182 $.ch Pes" (toi2), He gueshion Beocighh arithis 4 09 ¢
FES a Cul flee USer's expectation of Primacy wIAhie his hese , rick He PhySica|
WlereHtors to avel Frour big howe, Aigicterreak ter He Coopers alecsSion 1
We cbto. evealiiag Hen locator aol prema’ erere. caileckecl iss the foros OF
ap adklress i Koruotions, Oirce. apgaiss, beer Ae Crgesseess WIS braid a8 fart

od He Fafaleg brief, Ye Court diol nok CorSicher it. adler, ab 9? 36

Dd Sant , Cho Tack agrenel to Plee.quiths 5 (bax Grrebtvonial, He wns
Woncg te apfra! ater them Casputer decision aol baie tek appre atersel these
{



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 34 of 68

plu the, Cole. e-SBery to e8ure. Hat the tel (foie Steck bse
 UbdShisrgtns, Ue U3. 66%, Ges Card) 279 other wore, the. Sige
te ental i8 He Lighh & effeckive. aRiStance of ComBel. Like ak ELE.
: Sheiektnnl establisheck a. tex Prarageal Bat for alekereninsinig ebethe
0. leSensdlak bi Seesiveck (:2Sbeckive. ASSIGtae. OF COSA y
- velar Hee First Prong, te Courk Hit ceseroive,” thetber COREA S
_ Perbocuesrt. wns deficiest.” Seicklarsel C6 08. ak CFF. CorBAS
Pebhocwre i deficienk where. AGUS below) as cbjeckve Harselosel
A teaSowableness, Leb. at 68%
— Undler He Seconred Steckiosel prong, the Cont: Met atehecnse-
teleMer He hhicierk pectortue ck Corel prercliceck te. deberscli®'S
_08e.. TO Sekisty Han Prequokive. Prong. A the, tet, a cheherrclant nerok

ws acerSenk iS ectitlest to be asittentl by as aMornest eve ether

Wek Shouwd Hake, bok fF ConBel'$ 6700S He. OkCote. OF tee peacer hrs
— tedaistel stores libiekey Har ob habe beer hiferote, Sto clklassal, C66 (7.8..0& C23,
_ Fedler, 0. ab fosclosk suit erst Sheed tek “there 2 6. Ceatonrable. prabebility 4 —
_ Hhed, bob foe COINS inrprofesBienral croc , Hee C8utk of He. preceeding
AL bower beer deen. “A fetirrable. Prebebilitg 13.6 © Probability
ECiclemk te umcleretine Corficlence to the tate?) Socklorl ,
YEE 8. a C44
iL ER He Comferct of a quilty, flea, ahabeas pebititione an Fad
Prequelice bg aleelorStCakinig “a. CeSerdable. Probability thet, but for.
wea 8eN'S erro, he tirutet hae. wok pleakeel guilty ask tried bese.
nSigteed ad ping te teil. hee. th miter! Ynited, (TF Suck LBS,
quoting: Hilt Leckbact, Ht 0.3. 92, 5-9 (es)


Case 2)

22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 43 of 68

Actual Preporalice 13 Seon by establishing & MiSCare ‘age

Lk juthie.. Hence v. trritecl Heke, FI F. Bol 1668, 12%2 Ul cir. Zoo't)

(the conviichions OF One coho 'S Getuntley mmocent 15 ABE @ Mises Cicge

of justice, See! Susur Ve uivbley, Sos" us. 333, 33% (1992)
Acxoorelinaleg For au of the Fore gent PeaSens , 2b for te

Gr eondts (aidee? (3 Teeler’s ZE8'S~ Hekion , Tader ¢3 earheratlig

innocent of a 2¢220b) Violakion becacse 1-his Condick does

pork all cd\Msins Hoe Fi naibien) OF Socal achive | al Zhe ated,

Rok engare Ci, ;OF Cate. He etinor to engage. IN , Hee Proeiction

or Chile Porcreraph

FHL. Feole’S Deke Se. athornmep erdlocedl inefeekive AT: Stante
becase he. failecl to jax bstigate. He Peeikic. Ket? K Teerbs§$ De,
Te Geree.. age not hist ck Hee Cre Lew) 9 ofeach Ob thee hive of
Leader's Plea. . SpeciFitallre asich Soe Ye. CaSw§ Skt Soeth (ns Suction IL,

wher corel Frilec to besi98 Combt K Hee inickowrs, ariel shod

hee aclisech Thaler te plencl guilly to ot

A clefixclanst alleging ineKeckive aittasce f Corel Wt Box) tek:
fe Coir Bel’ Perforce Ail wot tenth ao objective Gervlarol ck RoSnvble hess 5
pod Z. Cortel’S dbficior Performasa Prequdbiecl te LOS, allpriving
Ye. olefrelnse F atrial oe, BSult 1S fellable . Hecklasel v. seks, rolen ,

ICE 0.3, 66&, CB% - 6 (asd). DeFiciemt pertocnanse 18 ted ostich is

“Nok with the Wiebe Fange. Of Compedensce cheval K adkorpegs (9

| Ceikinial C88.” Geb, ab Cee Crterm( gutetion arts omittect),

re ejecbice is eStablislecl hed “bare i a nSonable- probability )



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

13.

Type of motion or petition:

Page 29 of 68

Name and location of the court where the motion or petition was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(3) Did you receive a hearing on your motion, petition, or application?

Yes im No CL]

(4) Did you appeal from the denial of your motion, petition, or application?

Yes | No |

(5S) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” did you raise the issue in the appeal?

Yes LC No |

(6) If your answer to Question (c)(4) is “Yes,” state:

Name and location of the court where the appeal was filed:

Docket or case number (if you know):

Date of the court’s decision:

Result (attach a copy of the court’s opinion or order, if available):

(7) If your answer to Question (c)(4) or Question (c)(5) is “No,” explain why you did not appeal or raise this

issue:

Is there any ground in this motion that you have not previously presented in some federal court? If so, which
ground or grounds have not been presented, and state your reasons for not presenting them:

Thee Grout Presertect i His Motion were tot Previously Preserstecl LoSecl

On Hee AF (Cia ax0l ireFlective assistece. Of CourSel, TreHechive eSi Stace.
OF Corre ClaimS are. proper PalSecl iS a Mobod te acate Persea to

BE 0S8.c., BASS.

Page 10 of 13


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 P. 13 of 68
Filing # 150588234 E-Filed 05/31/2022 04:45:02 PM age i 0

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF
THE NINETEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN
AND FOR SAINT LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA

Case No. 56-2016-CF-003220-A
-VS-

Scott Joseph Trader
Defendant

Eleventh Supplemental Answer to Demand

COMES NOW the State of Florida, by and through its undersigned State Attorney and files
this Supplemental Discovery Exhibit pursuant to Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.220(j) and amends the
original State's Discovery Exhibit by either amending information concerning witnesses by
(adding a new witness/changing the category of a previously listed witness/changing the address
of a previously listed witness) and/or adding other material which has come into the State's
possession since the original Exhibit was filed:

STATE OF FLORIDA
|
|

STATE'S DISCOVERY EXHIBIT

(1) Pursuant to Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.220(b)(1)(B) through (L), the State discloses to the defendant,
and will permit the defendant to inspect, copy, test, and photograph the information and material
within the State’s possession or control as specifically identified below.

(A) Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.220 (b)(1)(A) The names and addresses of all persons known to the
prosecutor to have information which may be relevant to any offense charged, or to any defense
thereto, or to any similar fact evidence to be presented at trial under section 90.404(2), Florida
Statutes, are listed below.
|

(i) Category A Witnesses: Pursuant to Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.220
(b)(1)(A)@, the State identifies witnesses encompassed by this
section with an ‘A’ preceding their name. Separately identified
within this category are persons who were present when a recorded
or unrecorded statement was taken from or made by a defendant or
codefendant, and these witnesses names are preceded by an ‘S’.

(ii) Category B Witnesses: Pursuant to Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.220
(b)(1)(A)(ii), the State identifies witnesses encompassed by this
section with a ‘B’ preceding their name.

(iii) Category C Witnesses: Pursuant to Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.220
(b)(1)(A)(iii), the State identifies witnesses encompassed by this
section with a ‘C’ preceding their name.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 65 of 68

46,

al,

i See! Khibit O , Preorincg Plas Evalcokios Keport

love. Fla. Mot. 642 le. (2.3638 K Florich Kaul lars KileS fk

|

|Procectore., Sra alse? Cdibit o, Cover Sent ~ pq |

42.

dy.

"4,

i

|
|
| Seet DET 4-0, CDS fags H-1t

| Hale iofocanbion (8 cficesl rseler HIPAR aS intersershen Wak i8 Cresteot

beg health aothecity Hak lake to te pel, predink, or Ksture. aterta.|

health Cordition o€ ans indiviiclenl. YZ 03.6, (320 ()(4)

UNH Sersbercing  Taotem Sill heck Properits Cab Ark aawerShip Over
(Ais Seitedl eleckcmeS, See! DKT [oS 98-#¢4 5 See also! Kel R of
lerim P 32.2(4)4)(A)

See: EhibitO, pg!

| See 2 Exhibit 0, hier Seed

eet Qdb tT, Shete of Floriola civil docket Seek

|
|
{
i

ce. DET 14-(

De pleacling Quilkey ;Tracler tan rook CorbeSbicg anrmerSip of He. Seizeek
lelecteoaics . Adittionally  Mecbieal Vette health. pecord are. fretectecl by
in Celedecl acts exrctedl Prior 40, acl Gbler, He erathrtok of HEPAR,

€ 2 Clocicla i. 03. HHe, CUS 6 Bol (LBS, 133- 3s— (eis, zou)



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 51 of 68

(feo QreMions , Co8e.( on Colley aware of tek Strategy prior to Sipsing Hen ple,
i
tatuaceicedely FollesdiG He Lasposes cbecision , wr Georaklycrhaak (eel beiore. He
(poital brick 028 Fleck, TIS Case 1S 0 Prrive, CXeaiple. Of Gthere. Co wBl'S
leGieient Pertorutscce iS tock 198d thee wel. Tange. oF Comperessce. cbharcledl

OF AHononigs ito Criminal GaSe". Steicklasal at CFF, Gers Taster, with so
legal expecrence hal realized Counsel'S hocompetenct: hacl ahmaged his
(Chezce3 of Presailivg on appeal, asl trical te Hep ite His Oar Only aabl to He
Chins Heck Faker 08 tok provieled pith eMeckive. adsitterce dorig the appeal.

i] Tncler tons prejudiced bey this becouse hel he. Kaos his Specific. argvrek
art (S28 he emrteel te. court te aubles8 Ord cppen | t gored nook bee Cea rsichreot,
he wcnxed rook have. Signet fe Cearcbitional plea agrees Dub, He ceniel hewe» Proc0vabel

te trial, He. courcl hare. later negotiated a alileror pleo. agree ek One. pohere,

Certain Corks urre. drcporel ter aloe WS reoxiiwa tine ino Prison). Tee Crrolstiensa|

i Part oF He Plea agreenek 0228 abet Tacles aeivedl aS pact of Ye Give. auch tobe

| Process oF Negotiating wah te gaxmuest, Aucl hens trkood ung Hine CoxBel8

peste Sante. «

Bepacatele, LE coursel hect't Gilet to emteckively Epresent hs Clint, he
nud hae Biel be. u&b ngector (sSue3 of Teckr's appeal willis He svitial
beet a8 opposcl to te ceply beiek Av elective attorney wrested hae. Kuo bell
otal shee! Gtzlas ait te Crevit, ar at He. Long least Corvecteal fis aistake

! nce retigied, Hod He Eleweoth circuit beens preseatesl He argutont Tach
panel bekire He court, there 18 a, @asnable. Probability He ett cf te Preceecliny
pone have. bear hor. The Elewwith Circe Coutel heave. herel Teawler’s feacth.
(Warselotet Calls acere, Uroleteel, The. court cexsted bene, fesuerdleal le. cade, bak te
be Distriek Cour woth oroler’S te lacake. Tachr's Convictions, acl allewceel hina,

he wildland hig Plec of quilty« the Ceock wench hase heel csceg pourberr of

ati lable, Reourses , but €or Ceunsel'S inet Feckivness ,


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 53 of 68

A¢ter He evaluation ux Finithecl a Gpork detailing 8
(esule n8 torte on October 22,2013) arc a Af of He. port
and Proizlecl to tha attorneys presenting each of He facets arsal
a Cofth 4208 Proiiclecl te the port. The Pase#8 rere. wok fernittent
| to PeSSeS8 0. Ope OF He. Seport; arcl on Decentber- 12,228, akties
He carters alispute L228 CSoalecl , te report G3 exterecl ON
he Civil cleckek oF He Cie neler “Ordler OF ConFiclertiaitey
fod Court decwutost.
| fewer Toder, oitlet his atormsegs keeeledpe heel takes
“a.phetw Of Gach of te Spor'S BELGE fem hig personal Ccecls wok
Stored Hen on his laptop Compters Thee lapkp uns Saizeot be ereclereh
(Beccary agetS a Tene () 20°F, PorSuat to a. Search emrrant, Notably ,
| thet Search conrrat anlg Geur- agent permission to Search for eviclence
or Visual eépickionsS involving He Sucval exploitation of ainers ,
A ‘euler 1S pack aware. of Another Search werrank giving Aged pereuission
ite Search Be aoametS Clatecl to Trader's | fanilig aot ProceeclingS )
“pesstal or Mecbcal health.) or arsething ese. eset He ‘parenting flor
et lention” port Aeug be interpreted as. ee ‘aides (3 250 pick anave,
of whet eviclernce, of Cried He geen orn be Stardhing Sees te 8S
(Sach aS He.’ Parersiixg flor evaluation” Cepek for, ER otha Cots , tHe
_Pletogensphs Of te repork are. Nok UiSual alepections Of H— Sexe (
exploitation Of wixacs Th govern legelle Shesel wot Inve. beer atlosienl
| te Search far, aool pessess this Copert, Which MeorS, He. Garermnot Slocl
[NOK have. Beer Allereel 4s PrSent this report at Sater ing Gack to re perdeclly
Se. His report AgAINGE Treeler te Seed bis ecscliviser.


:

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 16 of 68

AO 243 (Rev. 09/17)

8.

9.

Did you appeal from the judgment of conviction? Yes A No CL]

If you did appeal, answer the following:

(a) Name of court: Gwitenk SHedeS Court of appeals for He Clever Cicrwit
(b) Docket or case number (if you know): /Y -/S7G I

(©) Result: A€€icuenl
(d) Date of result (if you know): Novestbec 257, 2020

(e) Citation to the case (if you know): (iteol Slates Ue Trader, 9x1 £.3d Gl (ute Cit, Botte)
(f) Grounds raised: 2 , helices Goose’ Proce tenet € He. deferrdastis “Krk”
Subse tiber Cecoras  intcleling lecadion iforwation, witheot a eure: 3
Volation of H0. Thackc's @aSerable Privacy OPEL ON Unvaler He raliven) ie 5 dot,

2, whether te aff iclavit (3 Suppock o€ the wncrark to Se, OT ‘ °

to Shows Probable- Case on (tS face, AC Track 's peru Bile

3, ohesthes- #0. Teele '€ Sertence OF (fe iA peiseprtert 6hI SbStavctivel¢

UN Cecsormble. ,

(g) Did you file a petition for certiorari in the United States Supreme Court? Yes ze No |
If “Yes,” answer the following:
(1) Docket or case number (if you know): Zl-3°3Z2
(2) Result: DNewienl

(3) Date of result (if you know): Ockebe C4 , 202
(4) Citation to the case (if you know): “Wadler Ve epritecl HoteS, (42 §.c4 2 *
(5) Grounds raised: BU LEL Lol 134 Cock, , 202 D)
1. whether He gormter ConolurtS a Seacth Unable te Loocth A betgs ok
thers ‘& accesses historical LP, adle3S PecoretS fr a. nchile.c
© Prowicle a. CoupteherSive htosile of He US'S pri Monee ?

Other than the direct appeals listed above, have you previously filed any other motions, petitions, or applications,
concerning this judgment.of conviction in any court?
Yes CL] No

If your answer to Question 10 was “Yes,” give the following information:
(a) (1) Name of court:

(2) Docket or case number (if you know):
(3) Date of filing (if you know):

Page 3 of 13