Case 2{22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 20 of 49

Ze of UG

Bn easing Dat dh. votreck ction’ oa. “Pasenshivg
Alar> Eisletion Ceport iMegallg chhaireck hoy the. se gusset ;

The ciglck fo He. effeckive. assistance of Counsel extents ta
Sekercing Axel Movie be ealvated under Stricklanel. Seat

Clover U, Lwibedl AokeS, 5303. 19%, 12 S.C. 6%6 (eo!).
Trader ws pot atarcled this ahd, CORS2( 208 ivefheckive. For

ailing te object i> arng Heardigfeol orang te He tetrocdachiond ofa

“Parenting Plass Euialantion” Report  Corcbictes! i Zot3 23 fart of
Toder's or- Going Chilel cartes step This Cefort iS hele

[Contatenstin, ) Prestectenl as Prise neler Hou laws fF He Stee of
Kloricke jad the nitecl SrteS, arb ax oblairecd he the Geasernetent
iMegelly Sar Tadles'S Clectrosic alee

De £018 ancl dhoete on “gory Child Cth, Asputes , He

|Aomorable. Labora tJ. Branis, Teolge F the Niveteeth, Tolicie|

Circuit is axl Sor Sainh Lovie, Coty; Floricla. » orclereall 0." Parenting

‘plan eValuation” Ard appoirtecl ay irelepenclent expert to Condlick

OW Seeies ( investigation ancl Studer of both He Paset$, art te Chilel,

The pricary issue t be adhfresseol wx8 whether the existing order,
| OWalem sohich each Parte hes epoal tise, Sharivsg rth the chile, Shovtel

he Hols Free , Gril (F Se, Foxe Hoth, arol catheg 7



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 41 of 49
Ul ef 49

46. Pe Exhibit © , Reerting Hed Etaleakion Report

dl, See: Fla. Sot, 61.2 Zo % Bole. (2.363 of Flaricla. Sauily Loss BleS a
|Procectore. » See alse 2 Orhibit 0, Cov1r Beet ~ PA |

A
i

42. |Health pforedion (8 hefiscecl welder HLPAK a intorutccton Hot (3 Creckeol
hea health, authority Heb elakeS to te posh, press, or <oture sterta.|
health, Conrebi'bion) of an indivicleal. Y2Z038.¢, 1320 (at)

43.)

‘|
i
|
i
i
'

LUN ( Sersbencing, Tole Still hack Proper! Wey COS arxek aatnership Cem
(AS Sized eleckrmseS, See! DKT pyS 98-94 5 See also! Kel R of
cin P 32.2 (6)H)(A)

> DET 14-(

dy. | [See! DET M- ( ODS pgs 14-1#
|
4, (fe Pleaolinag Rg quilhy Tracker wn rook CnrteSbidg avmerShip oF te. Seivecl
[eetenoes « Alettinally wecleal Veto tel health, gecords ere pretecteck bg
Au Bletecl acts encted Prior to, aacl cheer, He. erechutok o€ HTPAR,

(ee: Flocicla. U. 0-3. HHS, CHS CBel (29S, 193-357 Co ee, zou)


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 37 of 49
Bt of U7

MH. \umsitedl States UV. Ht; M4 6.3L 1359, 1364-65" Ci cir, 2021)

1

13% | Teacke's  hesge. of flee. hear; co held a Sept.29, 201%, Tee! MKT $2

6. See! Tayloe, ClO CSL 2ss-, 25% CH pi, so)? See. alse!
i Dorusoqguez , HF € Bel ZI, M24 - 25° Ct cic, Zo21)

V4, See} DeningueZ, FFE 6. Bel at was -2s- (1 cir. 2021)
4

(8. See! Bockisch ,$S-# 6.3cl W22 ,1133 0.13 Git cir Zot) (recy 26, att)

19. See! Section at , 0%

20, ‘ Teo His fut, a Cece tersth Cirwit Code (8 a. Geral excomple. £0
Writeal nde3 J. Labelle, 90 £300 Bil (io cir, 2008), te cbefyralint ws
cheegecl arith 24Z2(b) for both ebtemptecl aoc Commplehecl cet® » Leb, Ob BH pL,
ihe, Geevernndenst etiecl on eo umber leing Relea! oeSe of Prackectioss
oF Chitel porwog raphy . Eel. +) 6 B90. Becartie. the. defisrulerk cticl roe Plaix
1. fale. ao the Ptockchiesd a8 He onty Chitsl Porwegeaplig Cheegen€ ir the Cronk
pre ~cdekecl th. efordeowt§ CossveBebti0S with the piso he eovtel arty
Ot Feursel quilly Of attesaptecl production. Lab. , ak Sttw.2 , FBC.

(See also! Lavitel StnteS |, TBabe lien 4021 OS. DiS Lexi¥ BQICER , at to-il
Os. Golo, Poa, LE, 2070.1).

: Thee hgtivca neuihuer betwee Diabeile asl Tackle i$ , LSabedle

4268 chorgeal arth bath aHouplecl avol ccvsplhel acts .Tacke US enskg
1 Chergeol wit, axl Coniittecd of a. Completed ack.


(or :22-cv- 7
ase 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 46 of 49
YE of LG

42. See Cxdsbit Ry PQh 5 EbsbibS, PQ Z
43. Que! Gdibit &, pgs #-?

44. Dorirag He arek Of Tracker! Pleo hearing , Moleple events eccorcesl
inven WING ocler's Forberal Criminal Gn8e-, Stade Criminal Se) ak
Slate Civil action arith DEE'S fetitlor to Teateve- Tracks'S Cgit8
guer his Chiletoer. Henclat , September 2S, Dod , Tater feel a Cort
appearence b> hiss Dek action A triecl 223 prepaseel to hep op tat

te termine. hie poserrel gids His atone , Cherstopher A. AickS;

Haat bhorueel be ies the en, axl beSbory te Arsxble. his, action’

ateg
C39)
toniel be. do Uoltartlea Sige ever his igits to Mig chiletre?. He. bForewel
“Thats te bikelyghek oF heanveg his Chiletres> pracveel ur aluest Certain,
Heck He Yorclesd being appliecl wrote be clear aacl Cemuircing Cuidlerxk-,
which 6 lode the @aSrroble. cet Qed anegthing Said or dre_ 0 HS
Civil actiod Couted he. eel against hie. i eller of NE Crinixal CoS,
“Recler atteripteel to Sign his guts gars but Corel nok Poe te por

to He paper, The there Of it became So overtdiebainy to Teder Ke Got
Pheeeall, Sick aad cooaplaivedl do fe_ juolge- (2 O extobiercal outburst

Hed hig che, PreceS CigdS were. being Usoteteel by hearsay hes prota

Cig its reseed cottoe Firs being Censvichecl of 6. Crie.. Tneler b20
eScortect or of the daocbroon tun Teel 8 feschertleel for ThorSleg,
Septeaber 28, BF , whos Taelr get beck: te He ces joi ar altercation
appeceed bekeste hin aucl a. alprreg Serith ont “Goede aot tetie Sv.


Case 2: 2 -Cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 14 of 49
14 of CO

Tee Pre\ubice Techr Btfecek a8 a R8It £ COB’ alficiok
1 Performa Weliyelvally aod€ coubieck i$ Subsiavtial, Fader (3
Seoving Ga bhal Sembence. oF LEFE. Comte 11S tee only Gout Of eich be
Vs conuichecl, Lot a toxins of LIFE. lOMert Vek Conwichion, Track
Coviel bot face deck Srkewe, AS Pe Abxiewwr Yatutory peralby for each
(Of the. Har Kor Come WhS CAUIcsION 1S a dese OF yeurS There Sore, Tracber’$
[Sorte iS ASelE prof OF Hee Prejuolce. , CIvch Cod nave be iguocecl,
Macl Corel iocweol Taster p6 then Foreraruel clefts te corm a. the
res ult of the. Procsecbirrg wWeatel hee beers heros. Taghr wostel Noe
owe pleel quilty te His Coot, asel WStenel wouiel have Preceedeol to tial,

HT DW Trades" ¢. t fees 2 Uke ackeinlly noes

i Cont 1.3 2. tere eS wsoGCieient evidtersejaxcl 3

ct a. Conrinectiiand) neler

4 Sections 2422 (0).

for be Secone explaipeot io SectiorS Havel IL , Tracks's
peli attorney ind ineMective for failing to argue iw hig, Cfpeel
la Claws of achat inpocence .A deenrdlast whe fail to Sark a Chain
113 entilledl toa Pais errac Cried) of Hoek Clalit ther taitecl for te Feat
‘tow on appent, (neck a plais ecror Harelarel , He dekirolons bears te
‘burcless to Yow there. 16 1. Error, £. Het i plain, aol 3, Het arfecds
Bubstartial Cg ds « Sea’ werk Sates VU. Koshmal, 984 K8dl 1357,
|/36 3 Ci* cic Zo2 ') “tess He explicit lasquages MaKe ke, OF Flee
ees ek Spee iFcete Sole a2 (Sie, Here Cao be Ne Plain error”, Leb.



| Case 2:f2-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 24 of 49
| | Ze of 49

iH

becarse, hig Sorence. i§ LIFE) odd neat a tera of yeas. Hen coil preter
rave the ofPoctinrihe to geb ok of Prison) axel this Uouiel have. bees aber st
jack te gaversuiost nok bead owed to inttoclte. thak report, which an Ye
deciliry Sartor OF Tineler'$ Sartore»

: At He vere, ntiminect , a cbjetkion to te port's iistreckction thet un
| Qertoledk Lod fee Cepvired be Cort to USS hens this Cfocsutens 42S
Chhaisel; arsok (€ Ye goverieit hal Han Cour’ PerneisSier OF te partes
Corset This wrid hae freservecl Ye. ‘que. fC Proper appellee. rien.
Cea Sel e208 telel to alo his tho shat ve proceeding hack euene epporhoity
te ae it, bt failecl to ce So.

TheteSire., Corel Crolereck ineFeckive. A38i Stance. ak Sestercs sq
lashes he Frileel to cbject to He GaxrrHor® instroclockion’ oF the “Parone

| Alex Etaloaceion” Cefork , which be geurmovtet cbtaisect Megalig, axl
ithar ConSet ; fron Tacler'8 Electric. dence. . Hred Corre chyecter(

| [tothe acharissibilitey AMS Corfiderbials Prodecktel port , there 3, Gb he
Vers leat a. reeSable probabilitey the He. @Sutk of He. procevelisa oat

| haw. been itterent, THaclr's Sextesce, (ented hewe beer ated cf wens,
| bed not 266. bt Kor CarSe'S Aeficlerst peToruarte..



Case 2:

sa.

v2.

xs.

s¢.

22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 42 of 49
Z of £F

Ther, are toot Orelimary decsnodS Sich & basking recercl, Korean, HuS
(Sa Sealedl deamet Willers be wort of He Sete. € Cloride.. heck to
Pettit Suh a clecvewst te be Seitecl PorSeant to Kis Search toncrast,
Wrortel bode Permit a. gorerel Suorth, aabiel te Corth Areubliok peebibilS-

See: DET SB, Pps 36-3F

Seat DET S6, py %['23-25-
See DET SC, pa3t/s-u

See’ DET SE, Pas 36 -3Y, PAS {2-43, pe TS, pqs ¥2-Fo , pgs G1 -EZ

See! DET SE, pes Ba~3

See? DET se, pxS S8-Sé

“See: DET SC, pps F#-80

» |\Seet DKT Se, pas W-F2

Sce!’ DET ZI

Seet DKT 14-1



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 5, pf ti)

Condock os He WIPAS OF terag 1S BAF aad pheug Fo LF Cher He proution
of 200.66) cecurrecl) corre Frit hose te Kal obi tee Ceoleral abebicibion
AF xual actiity, ok Secorel, be Chosenble. Corobk, These. 400 Posts
equal one. bhole. eiementtscedich Hen (corforates thee olor thot tHe
ekeferreliast Coutel, base beer cheryeed cith, <> Theale 'S Cade., te anvdock
1208 5 Te. Fe of 0. cel far Grsterert) hy ad acbott, to entice a bine
do ake wl Sercl ore nuke Phebe. The, K62808 thd he courel he
ben hargek with, 2S Heteol by the gasernoent are: Foti. Hokute,
$ZLorl (3), Preeteting a Sexual performance by a chile § aool
R2L¢ se)(a. ) PESSEISi14g eH Stval Pecfoceance- by a hild, 4
i The gerrernaenrk fodeuer plick nik Speciée which of tese
Subsections of Florida. Yotute T2p0% is Felging por fac HE ba BiS OF
CONV CIOS For [6 03.6: 2422 Cb) ard 1 Hencl eles od Herr balls. Bt
wher Cher qirg Seusone cit 2y22, 0b) for an of Fer Releckinig to chilel
Porssegraph Orles thee Prechedion of chalet Porsegraphy Als HGD the
feleral abfisitiod OF Snail achivite TD He bStawt CaSe. , ove oF

He. wmsitiple. Sakviory Volatiles the germ Henk Peles por for Convichion,
Hf cmd Heck cocreckle 5 13 He Succ 285€ el entreentent of a sunec to

engage, in Hee Seaconl ackivity of PeBS0S3ior of Child Pervagcaphy «

ZEN Pn3t cas on eleferdank chargeal wit 2422 (b) db ad
onde leog AMerSe intotuing dle porsogrsplus hae Pedigen€ cppor the
He. Golira| Statute. Prokibilig He Preoloction of Chilel Porsogreply,,
os. 1 OF Felegond opord a Yate. Kntote Prohibibing tee
Prodactis OF Chited forwography, which tock? te larquage. of He. Gelers | o..


oo . — Crvetise.l beste bee chacpeable. . Thee FinkAc. ees. koe Reguire..a. albehescetenk _

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 35 of 49

BS” of 49

_- RicTe be Clear, (F OS.6. 242206) oraty Cgvices tek ad onekrteiag

— . —tacketally bee chesgect w2ith thee mdlerleivg Crime herSe-  Onlibe. then.
RECO Sebutes which elles. Sae (COSC N99 a). LikesoiSen , tHe. Botote.
a aloe8s bark Coguire, a. Comcrion, OF 62 feu Context of a attectph, Yet

On tancken Of Me crcolerlyivie CCieited PfenSe O12 be ek fO8Sibi tides Seen

BK isch PSHE. Bal 122, UB Ct cor. tort) 22 (oy dle sok Cope.
Heh tee cehersebost Consile dosy fie Crit. et all. er Hak te. cbeBoiell artenlly.
- Hinge fo cosy? Orla 6l Sexaial activites” (catlecivg C0868) "Here i810.
a Repuiteeteak Hota chsesbok atienspt to Violeke. a. Hecastee. Sredio® ZAI CG) avdly

a pete that 0. cliScaclao abteupk te ettce. a ativin’ te engage, isa tk Wek

8 AR terdak achiolly Wolake Me lthel Yebe, Hodte” Eel, ak MBB

— pecee tel be illegal.” Zab. QL MER INF “ZIIDA) cle8 roe regeiice tek a.

__. in esbence.., BAZ) Soares He. Stender ob guilt. for Corickios 0
a _ beSecl cf He tevrobich te nccderheern Crivaive| SeBe_ 4 FFar eyporl a.

oo _ asonble, eb te probable. Caste; lel orty Probphle. Cache. iG weedeok de 0.

ve allege @. Wolabion of wap Crinaixa| Sabtee athich the forui tHe. baSi& of a
a He 24220) Violation. See! tpoitedl YeteS Vv. Mas ave. SEE" (3b HE,
ME Ce Cir too?) feank fiteralhe Fation 222) tedatdl Hake, it

—— 0 Secbecal, ORR Sen te. esrpnage. ir2 Coseb.rk Heck creado chy Pretzable., Cas. oo

te fink tek ore herd comaritbesd ACE inine| hers8en ,Siteoe, probable. Be

; AB al At i8 Ceguiced te tharye. Sawin will ad offerte.” { Se. also! oe
teed Boke Us PillaBa Rivera. WE €3cb Fl, Fee AF cir, ZoiQ)

Aor ign Utherntl Ral Biction 2120TR) kexgeage. as: irclocding S.spieiou&
co. Bi Mererthe dens lentil Comddescé thet plight focniSh Probable Cote. oe



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 21 of 49
Zl 6€ 44

Aé4er He eValuetion ux Firithect a pork cletailing 48
(E80KS nd tories on October 22, 2013 ) arcl a Ape of He. port
(ARS Proviclecl to the attornens Epresenting ach of He facets, arsol
1@ Cofth 0202 Proviclel te the Cort The- Paet§ were wok pernuthecl
[to possess a cpu of He. reports crcl ons December 12,2213, aver
Hen Certadle clispte- ms @Solvecl, te report a3 erterecl om
he Civil ceckel OF He cate nxler “Oraler OF ConFiclertia (beg
(Of Court docstoc”.

\ Mouser Tenor, wishert his attorneys Kecilecdge. hack take)

| pete Of Cath of He Cpok'S BE eges for hig Personal Ccols ash.
Soredk Her or his laptep Copter: Thel laplep ans Seizeot bg Hepgeleeh
(Becor'hy agetS ar Tne |, Ze, porsuant te a. Search eancrant, Notable ,
| thet Search ederrank ante gaux- agents perussion te Search far evislesce.
OF ViSunl alepickienS involving He Sexval exploitation of aiiser3,

[Treder (Sct aware. of Another Search wmrrack qiuing Age4S Perexission\
ite Search Be cecwment§ BClatecl to Trader'S Senile curt ProceeclingS ,
Metal or mecbier| healt or assething ese; Ha He “parenstiiag plod
(eUtluntion” port Mnsg be istecpretedd 03. Teader 13 also Wok aware,

of ahect violence, K Crivte.8 He governor Garr be, Staring Sees vte 8S
(Sch a8 He. “Parenti Plas evaluation Ceport Sr, DD ettur wtornls , the

| Pletogesphs te report are. Nok ViSual epeckior® of He Sern (
exploitation OF Minas The Gevernatet legally Setel root hare. bee Aleoxrerl
[he Sear or, aonl possess this repert, Which Mee8, He Gorerntod Shoniel
[Net have Bees Allcsceell es PreSent this port ab Sastoxcing Gosek to Gperdtectly
Se. Huis report ageing Teele te Hews his @aiclivisus.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 27 of 49
2F of €?

5
ns Grwicked for Felony Chill neglect, Al of HeSe. 0US-represetionS ,

CULISBopS , Gael More , takes egether”, fontel Cerrter- Hee AF dla
wbat Prebable, Go8e as it excel lock & Pex Cletod .

CarSel b2cws here) Heonplg Faster felt aber HS (Sue
(bot ehisecl to Bequest a Flasks hearivig, Teele alse talel CoorSel
Hat es earctel isc Sigs ay een aprecnioot WKil course ab least 44s
to addltess ths Issue. Ak He Plee freesis3g ithe Govern (rtecedce 0
for He Fiegh tine, ,e. Stipvietion af facts” pohicle iocluelecl Manag oF
We “Gacts” fone the abicbawil 1 Sipport 6 then Serle whieh agai
Waele (198 awe pee troe, Beca&e fC tis, Sort Recess tock
Plece id hich. wertrades expressecl his LISSCAISEALION boil,
He Came “Karts” ferme ISteol ertlis th Btipoletion Gack Seugkb to
hewe- it Cocpectecl, Aho a wtpexe Cherie, beg te GovernMiteck ME,
Tatles'S Comsl essvrecl hive Hat Ye ttl 028 “N'Stecl wotus
the, eotion to Seppress 9 We. “Clete ntet OF FackS” roel
“becacse (1S atl iss there He (See is preservect for appeal”.

Onfortonatelig He. (SSve a8 rate Bisel (Predeie( QS Thiele
| wns keel to believe pasel poor PreServecl for appea( 6& 48 Cours|
| hcl tolel his, toretrer becacse- tle exclarne. Leto rele
| Gab hs eettoticeng tow plce edoring a pervecd OF Fe028S tHe GorverSetion
iS nko the Cecorel.. Trader & ecore, Of He bid Kew, bt Ob Ye
~ Aste be ut Sineply Westertig te Camel. Trade Fuel Cen who


Case 2: fe. -cV-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 23 of 49

ZB 06 UF

ss
Trades expat writes ; Br. seichael P. Branporn, PS&.d, Pssecholeg’st }

|, Qnool Hen Gevernutet Seal this port docine Heir UeSing argestost eS

i —The- Geversitost Ceri TOABLY Bent this report to Sas) the. Court

“Het noting bt LIFE null be SF icient oc Trades bece8e. of bis

“ eeiclivioer. vores wichlle Brer€S agceect, Spec ifreatt » Se. Hidelle Brer6S

cHteel thS pork aS a Keto bo clekernursing Tackr'S Sersterce “a have

Wo Corficlence Hak he earill Step this behavior becase. he. Combirceck i chile

(On Brel fra a Sate. eur Proceeding arf ere white: he ax being Qurlucdect
bg wedlicel ProkeSSionals tho he uxS, Apparerrtl able. 40 fea issto heliewiny

fe. aids Presenst a. trek to his chilelrers at Ho Same tite he. on Gomunidts) ect
SA
cries against Hebe chielien. ”
Woclge. thidtllebreoks GoeS or to Sug Hat he. “CovBiclerect arel LA

| taker Be/oSly oe. Peateck’s Brqitte tS Abert te PSibilitey Hat Cafe. Hed
Proviete. froteckion, Bt £ 1 Gis We historeg to Has Se) Ke sock

Cruintecl of bak,” rel.

Hack ComSel objectect to He istroctockion o€ 4his port bec

On te feck Mek Hun chtanecl Megallet acd ito CorSor% oc; Percussion
frown He Gort , Trader'S Sectence. wotel bese. bees ifort. He. exes her.
bow Seotemccel f a tere of MP SONHet € Arend? Bo OSS 543 Pepresticcl
scl tooule hee. heel Ho cerca to gekod priser arerniel te age. 60
egass ole. The Sepreme. Groot eS Sniol “Gray aout of Gekel jeuil tide, hes

| Sith crunsoleat Significance”. Glover ve writer? Bate, SBI 9.19%,

203, (2 8.c&, C96 (deol) Son. alse ! Leklec V. Cooper (32 S.ch, ISH

Gow), The. Sir. anenclocase Signi€i care. id Tprcle's G8. (3 OOHLB

il
‘


Case 2:28-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 36 of 49

IO, |

‘le

|
i BE of €¢

for as teobichoterst,”

EN He itarst C82; Thache 18 Cheageed with, a Sars2B6| act, he
erticetlor Ka minor ty erage. bo Soenl athirty, ie, te prleeLion
HOW chileh Porrcgrephy « BaSeol evs te Cnrertakion uke het ual. MUL. ;
ONe tensed believe there tdoricl be. Probable. Guke Sg 3 afc, Chea beg bret
Lok Precbction of chited Porrsearephe. Ahdever, OS expitised wolbis, tere, 's
4 leas @aterable- ceht Trader allel net ploy a Sole tote prod.ction of He
pri Chilel Permogrephy elieel pias Br hs Serge. .Tenater Anrkeadl tS Febte
1S muBtitetional as applied to hin, a it Hrolates AiS Doc Process Colds

cearanteecl bg He 6 essed OC aueralteAS te, tee citer? SoteS Cotton,

See: (DET 22 £5~6); (DT 92: pq ze/21~25", py 21/128")
|

18 2.3.6. JUZF

See! (DET B22 9-6) 5 (ev 52 “pq 20-22)

See? (DRT 2222)3 Coe 52: pg M [ce -25", PY sft)

oe: Newwan v. sited Yates, Zole 0.9. dist Lexig 2o93sF

(o.d, Kerth , Dec. u / dott} ZN Leconte ; jose aS 19 He Bist GaSe ;
foe abtenclastt wes egeed wath a Violetion of Z422(b), with as rset lang
paerte of protien of Chile PorsogenphiteThe. Corrrt 03 pleas dias’ Ferro
jer Cvidlerbiars hearing we Cepuived bene Ye. Crkval beS.5 abel

INH Contain euicbonce. Hek He abherniclas ecbcel He. pticor Uthent,
tte engage. IN Bacon act! vik Goitkis tee Mersdisg of the. Siokirte. «



'T UG

Case Pee Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 18 of 49

i
|

bot Ye Qaort abicl prot ConSieler 4. Tixcterr, at 969, Adkettiewallg, Corsets

(equator keel Hee Court 0 Teaches to Condsclucle. “pv Atleror Aces access wrireless

tithernek pakuockS | CouputerS , tnbledS, Gasaing consoles  horsehalel appliances , asl
tore. Arrcl each of these detieeS hes @> imteroek Peatoce| achdeSS, WE Ca? rok
Conclude, ecb isotenset Pretocet actress are. Ceil phox Recor athe Mey are a
Gecdure- of every elechtorric, abiuice Hak GreHS te Ye. worrnet.” Teacher, at 169
Custensal protatins's cuittect)

Cone Id te imiial bk Mnbionedt a okt to privacy i LP aablressed,
Qual Hes Poisten thee Courk tewarel? Campostes. But he Seesivgle leit thee Prissasy
argues Tncler wassteet mast. CP te te Court te nsake Sor hiv. Acero wterd
Teacler Siguect his Crrdbitional ple agrees, he. expectedl his carmel Mot
He court; to Cgc On Kis bohal€. Tee aan question Tred wratval presertent to
Hee Court, wahith (ons Ve abecidncy factor ie Bigesicg He cond tienzal Plea , ua
Wek bolt to He cork until Pe reply beef. Hook + Net been for Gensel’ Error,
Trader well hve Prevailedl om appeal. This Pehoremxce bg comse( Cad ake
be akesecibeol a3 fatting beled a objective Stewalarcl of Casnable ness.

Zier another argieeor not ConBclerech by He. Cort, badeck is> pratt ars
Cn iteal StedeS VU, Karo, LEX 0.3, Fos, (Of Sch 3296 Ge¢4) » Keagllo tt ited
State, 333 0.5. 24, 141 S.ch 203% Ceol), aucl naitee’ Stokes Us Tere,
SCS" o.3, Yoo, 132 8.ck ts (toi2) , Ye. gueBhion Beocipht crthass ard ¢
ZS @ Cesl Plepe Ser’ expectation Priviacey wthin hig heue. , arcl He Physica.|
PHOS to ancl Frour his, howe highterreot her be Carper. abeciSion  (F
He cite. fevealirg He locator aod peresie08 were. Goltectecl rs te form OF
EP aclelreSS horulotion, Orsce. agaiys, brent Aig argsasib wan8 broil 28 fart

oF Hee seple brieé, te Court hel kok ConSieler it. alee, ob U7 cao

Ao Sant, eles Packer agreed to Plea quilkye Heard Grob tional. He. uns
Govog fo Offre! after te Caper decision acl biSe thet appeal atorucl Hese-


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 10 of i
0 of ¢

Tien eR Comtivvend: “Tet alse beS ablax we8Qcaiig OfPS.OR.
a tes table ard access te Hee internred which E clued ete go theoogh.tedbile. a

— _. Beats wethee| wed ins rag vehicle. Ye asteol to Check the. pleto gailery ——

on Tews tablet and ae observed He. naked phates o€ hi BA€ She
_ Berk te Seo? along. arith Photos of ‘Stekt'S daughters” he. Sok her Furol

— te her gellec4» Shee also heel ake. fluie's of olber sen Fuel to her gallery ce

thot a2ece. Bert te her thea thee Sieg Be 6 fp

— AL Peek euthiple. Cormtecenkions. writ Hes the: all regeeterl tvele.

—PhekeS at her ere Sart her reel. plekoS of Hesbeiues She bel Heda. pldod
~~ Saeed te ler plete gallery iss her tablek  She-alse hact He. photos & hersel€ _.

which Se. Sok to Tock, Stel to ber Gailey: Baportarstle NO are Enans _—
a ) foe3g He. phetoS OF MUL, ater. Sareck te her gallery Or hed Hrvoy tied

ce they ware. cb heiborveol Koes her galled. Toler if conuichesl af esb'cing

PAU. te prrckece. thete tee photographs , bet te Cowiel have. Prockcenl

these. tose, phetegcaphs Few avsyde Cf the. Men De. 68 hesti39 & Comer Bekion..
~ «ith, GUithook exarsing He. tinal date Hamp of the Phobos there i.

Ne wag te be Sure. Nokeabl¢, He. gatemetust LoS Meauee Sail wv's..“Precbocecd”TM
Meaee Pickegrophs for Tooke. The..orte Veth the. qosercierk heS eer USeel iS _

“Berk” Mu “Gende” tent te Teele ase Hot Semele geod. Bur bewwikee Tete

8 Ae condicterl O€ a coupleteolack.avel rrok an atteupt, 2042 (b) arrl BHBF

Cegvire More tos iI Sout", Meee Hen jika Lastantal Step jv ar ateapl

to prorluct.» The. BetiteS ancl He Subsequent Cake. law) Rapviresthe."Geranl

nn Aetintctey” te ackitlly hee token plete, Thece 18 se cuticles, LARS axghetee

- axl Hee determines bes neuer ef feceh AB. oo i ee


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 33 of 49

33 of 4¢

8 he tRnalbec'S invebichewnot (DKT 7:1) ard his Stiptolation & facts asl.
a elberss elemie tS (niet 22:1 5-6), Chacge. hint ill Oleded ack cnrhes -

Gxt soak ar oktempe. 0 a

Be See! initecl Hates Ve Rusisen, S91 Kel. Appt, 10,03 Cu cic. 201s) 3

titer? Hate 8. Dessingvez , HE £50k 121 U2 Ct cir, 2020)

_ 8. See.t witwol Boles Ui Tiler, CUO 6B 285 257 FE cirs 201 Qo

Me Seat Downinquez. , 9 €. 3b, U2, U2es” GW er won)

5 Beet Woiteal Yates v. LSa bella, UCL BA Eb, C50 “BEL, AS" -BUY.

Ci exe. 201?) (Cottechinrg e305) 5 See. alse: (noiteel Hated vi Lee,
603 £.3eb Fot, WS CU" Cir. 200.)

6. See! Regwolds Up uniest HatsS, 2018 0S. Dist. lexik oot.

Bd. ziiweis, Macc 12, Boe) Congress. hick. wat aekinze. Hee dere
‘Sexual activites’ a8 18 eck de 2492.06) other thar to Sag Hak
Thetis He. proclockion) of Chill pomsogeaphe? LE 28.6. 2422" Lob ak

oe "then gocrsrorteick ackitocunteadges thee Sexual ckiwity Foe which cory ferSns
cn eo be Cherpeol wrth a Crinsisal offerte. (8 explicitts obelisseal te irehide.

on iPiceclestaing Chile Parcargraphy LE 0S. Cs 2424.” See also. U3. CwensS,

GAB, 2.5. DISt Lexi (26018 (8.0. 4).t/, Moly 21, Zorzyat lexi8 3-6


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 30 of 49
XS of |

WH. Taetec's. Plea. oh Guiles Ua toot blacle she cgersl
Brock phevekore. Un rele. Grkivedivgly Mc ivalimtarstes «

He abel tack possess He correct Utprtal State euinel ond

Se, £29, Ltt ; ecjS;,

On Seplenbes 2&, 2ott, Here hows before. Yo charge. a
Plea hear ice Track experience aderometic event id Heke
Couct ates He DePartuert € childre axl fresrilies tecainateck
hs Pasertal SigdS aver Ais tose misao Chi lebron i D acteltior, ix He
iste bekuxre) te tus Court heer nS , Tades con8 hell i the. Special
fowsing owit utere he ctemplel Licide im his ceils Counsel ang
Mask. Fully audare. OF aU be AS leacting tote badge of ples hearing
be Tach, ab conrbiweel fe oxtourage hick te pleacl ai Gs bq
i forsaing hie thee 1 eansel be iv bis beak joberest te Pleacl exarley ,
He heevire 0208 alrencts, Schedbleal , asset He court Gowns pn
Castise their time: ,
Bet if Counsel waotd hare seschestlecl Ye. chenge of
jplee hearin toa lates tine, wher Cocker wie wok muh to ererecthing
Pappesig around hist Hasler tooviel hive. fealizeol We 1388
Nad beity GiSeal in ak lee&e Foor Grerml® thie Meaorastomn a=
Moreover, he. total hove Koll, ConSictereal He. impacks a qe ty
Plea carl hue on bath his Kecteral acl Hote. Censinal cases
Becac%. of Hese eadons aul othes’S , Trader's plea OF Guilty
CE ot Meets suted(iqetly ack therefore. (208 On Kaading



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 7 7 tig

And performace tohich itludes Seal Condit he a Chilel less thas
“« wears Of axe 2 Ceaplesi¢ caldect)
AS a fritial Maker, LbSection @) of Florida. Hedvte- BLLOF.

Prohibits muckiple- Corus of Crieuinal Concdick Placing to chiled Porsogrnpls,

eral each fore OF Conchock has olifterent alteswative Mew for
chferolinr te trelchee He Yokute-. 28 oll toreoll the terns prodoce8,
Aiecd& , a Prevdotes” each Prob diferent Cardeck.” Prockce” or
BhirectTM are. tock obfinedd bg Habe stood Shevlol be guar theic Plaird
av oseli, arg Public. Mering. Ronete. hexver 113 hE vied be Stodute_
as: ‘te Procure. , Horkackure. ,1Sve- Sell; give Preiieh,, leoed pail,
sblivec, taster, trarQute- , PrbliSh.elstribute ji en ;
Preset jexchibit, ec actertise or 40 Offer ar ages. to de the Shee,
(eit Matter 82% tL (NGL).So “Promede Means aemirg other things ;

to elistribute.”
: in tleic Aekrncote desert F KhenSre ClemertS, Ce garmin
WHS the. ahele- Lbsection 3), OF EZEOLl hen ,urthird SabSeckion (3),
exiples Zeck in boted leMering are the wxorets " Precloced, birehS, or Prowokes
ass Pertonuasce- which icleeles Serva comobxt bg a.chilel 83 ther)
I ears oF age” ThE lerquoge. either ieaplys tak Tadlec’$ Concdlsct
Sparel the entire Kope of Yee Hebrie or the gerne chick Kok
Specieicalle iolewbitig b¢ whet wtean8 Teak Uoladeek the Sadute , Bot
AS Hee Eleventh. Circsit MS altenchy Recomizecd , becarSe Tacks 03
checgeol asol Cenwicted wh o- cousplekeol ack, He geval Gao bok Carpe
Metkiple comes wih fen poSSibililue Wacker's conrcdock Ceriel foterbially
Violoke. a ead one. ch theo, “obutiouSlg , 1€ a cbefereleast be Scves6fouly


wa supfec AS ba8iS of Coruickion tnsckm ZE2ZE), (5.4. ttolekion, ar Etocicla Lo

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Pagg Sof4e

Nei. hve Fedigeel Yor He. PoSECSSio OF chilel Porwegr phy
. Cither ab thee Yoke OC Sedired beak @8 ar creer hgisg oflenSe. Bor Corel
_ they 63th wnviel leak to absurd aud erroneous (eS8uits. Such (3.
He. ore here , urhere Hes gotenruet he e8senartiolly hekirel He

tee Sesvel ackivieg * fo jsclicte- tHe possesion of a phetogrop.
. SubSepuenthe, toed Consbiidisag He Geatenrtern§ AL AIO
_ Sexceel activdty, arith He Stafutory Canitcuctlen aud datecpretokion
OF 2492.(b), wrhich again Ptobibits the. erticesenoe of thee wuicC te engoges

(9 fee Seren ackiitey Chic He ob Fercleyrte Corto woth aw ee

Lo. rsa offerse y(t cceatesS He ebSuccl Bvt Holt He aumor iS _

Sauchaw erogagec’ in the. PoBes8ien of the phetogceph thal te eleFerdat.
Cortcl be. Bezgeck a2ith posseSSit24

ve on The. Secev a. ncbche ng Crinenie| offense. ten garernedesst abeperds

Shekvte LZLCUG), Prometing a. Sexvel pectoral by a. chiled Header
_ there. ace nenitiplee Probleas arth charging Haig crccleclging (Cusine FER.
Me. Mek Selee rst eirig Heck “He lease Coipable. comreloch te Stedute
Cibivalizes is i est botion fh a. Phetogea ph of @ Chilel le33 than
W. Koberal dekivrition of. .
. Sexcurl ackivhy for a. Uelakion of ZYB2 CO). 0
.Flotide tekst LEE. OF (3) States ie Elewewt pack 5A person
dS quilts of prometing a. Sater pec Focatance. bg a Lhitel shen, Keecirg the.
_. harachec ack tment thereo€ he. ox Se. pendece® chcectS oc fuatles a

Fears age. thes KS 190k Fall cnsch


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 19 of 49

1% cf 4E

two gestions . Comse.( a2 Folly aanre. of thek ‘Streckegu prioc te Signe te ple,
j inurecbircely FeollesiG hy gescPences! cbecs3tor orl Caratbredsol wre before. te

Livitel beet 0208 Fleck. xis StS 0 Prive CXeuple OF ethere Corw8l'S
ee Prerlorutrcte. 18" beck usta the wale Conse. of competersce. cbsarcledl
LO atoncaue in Criminal Gases”. Steicklaoal at 66%, Lars Tacbr, With so
legal expecrence hul fealized Cownsel'S docempetence: hacl afuuagedl his
ihesced of Prevailing on appeal ase teed te Hep it. This Cex One aethl to He
Chaim, Hck Tacler W208 bake prosicbedl pith eMective. aSsistesce aoricg thee appeal,
Peeler tena prejubicecd bey this becaute heed he. Kaew hie Speciic. argrdek
eel $328 hee amrteol tHe court te aekdess Or appeesl sorted not bee Crdiclereol,
pe verte wok hee Signecl fe denrbibional flea agrees Dub, He. ceric’ hewe, Procevcted
‘to trial, He. cacl fave later regeticterl a aliferer ple agreened nse. eghere.
Certain Coats ure dreppecl to @ebece WS caxioa tine. 3 Prison. Tee Garoltiena |
pot of tee Pleo agreener eae atok Tattle apiveel aS part of He gue aul eke
process Of Megas ving wel de garment, uct burs trkoo aug Abe te CAB18
| wikensarce ‘
i Sepacatele, LE corse Aeetss't failect to eofkecrhively eopreserst hig Client he
ponte hue iteel te ut inportok (Su03 of Traekr'e appee| within te svitia|
iP 26 a opposcol to He. ceply brick. Ar eftechix. atterray asovtel fave. Kicous oot.ll
Lestablisieel Ailend ails te Crevit, ac at He resp lendt Correcteal is, Higteke
jones. rckified, todd te. Elerth cirevit bees Presentesl He. argos Tach
posted before Ge court, thee 13 a MaSenable Probability He @autt of the. Preceding
pomesel have. bees hikeros. Tee Elerath Cirte+ Coviel have. heel Teadler’s earth
(rscletat Cigfds ware Violedonl, Thee door Cexrtel beve. rowunmrdial Ye cade. back to
oe District courk with oreler'S te cake, Trrcler’s CorictionS, az alleccel hin
ite woitkelrrw hig Plea of guilty. The Gert ariel have hie ay probir of
jedilable ecourses , bit for CerSel'? inet feck/i23s,


Case 2: 22- -cV-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page® a
o€

Bote OF bee Puulity her irk up, Expos ing her nacpple. Counts ~ an

Entice ebek of @ binor to engage in Stal Ackivieg)e * Cextphasss abet)

Wodke's Htipulatedl condck, while. fepugnanst aloes rock antortt

te “Stal Actin”, ie. Hee Proobuckions ck Child poewegesplus. There ig

No ewvclence GD He. Gockel beas'é te Sppock a, ceewvetion tok Taoer

porkicecl a munor te Produce, a Photograph. Ariel while Here i¢ anple-
eviclerce. besecl o> the Biplodeal Fact’ thet Taster altesptect to

feecores a newlee Pletegroph yaaa Socce33 folleg click tewites Chitel

Porwogceplax Nether ave. FAUlS arthin Hee Fecbern( dGrition of

“Sexcvrel Ackiviteg” is Celation to Child Pecwegre phy.

Firoethe there iS wo eviclemee ba Discovery tat a. Photograph
OF AVE W3 eer precbctch fac Teader. A Forentbit. exacr  MvaS
electronic. cheice, , Gesdl ptose. Speci Ficalle the tinte. asl dlode. Yon
OF the tuo (HageS AUD Sent to Trreltc, (08 rane alesse This 1%

| sePortanst becate od Ye. wight oF Mig 30; 200, wher the Thong ville
Police Departrrenst initiallg Peported to muss here her stolber Sins
a ConSent to Search for for her elavetker'¢ toblek ,

Dering the. witial Serch of the tebled, ope of He FeSpondding
OF ices “teeweck Heevah Ua Message’ am He Sag HK app avel Fused Sue
cher Conver Sakions Hb egos Hak Bava heel ops ber phere. . ivelvebioy

{Scott tere corre Five. Men MeSSraitas Ev Zl whe ak Sue. Poitse

tebuittecd to Kiscadinag De end oung / cnnlerege. ariel Sill Repvestiss, pletos

| 06 her or Serelinag her muck. PlikeS of HewSelves.”


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 25 of 49
2s o¢ Yq

ixlichktast URS Hach cna) 3G lop axl hyo. nbearile )
Br Le: cect ‘ ‘Ss
ilecl tes AiSee 1 of serrl t istiek
L. Tn ewe. bo. Corstel ( Best

Spe sificalig ote ache Pleo guilty mack Srgrecl A's
Cordltiopial Plece agree wi Ae. belieweel park of lis preSesvech
(Sreat , QRS A al eage tothe SackS wits tHe. SF ibarit
foc He Stauth: tanstast Taaler 028 ptrole.te belive by Corl
thet hee GigntS or apfes.| cerutel ixcloobe te abilitig to epeest
A Fark? has, xy hoe te Ye WHE IS hee ark Crysis
wither We abbidbuil te Searth.. Taster bacl eperedley Cegeestert
Geartel File a betias for a FtantS heating pre trict Chaining
wWitbed these. resign falsclece®3, Ye abbicleuit worl lock
Probelle Ce. Corl hecl asserecdl Tale, the, Lecase-
be Sasds wasrast obbiclevit 2908 Challerzecl (2 @ Motions C SZ poress
Co otler greanels), cael be fleck gaily Coneliblensalle jhe: feel

vel tle Col om ape: ( to Calo the biskadirg F(sheodl?
ee te vk .& . css clay a, Trach,
axel feel Toute Kescun) theS_ Sigt8 were, woe Preservel,
fe weil have electecl to Gots tial fetbar thes pleacl Guilty
Corrvb tionally . .


Case 2!22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page } IAA

i
UNITED STATES DxSTAICT COURT

SouTHERN DrSTATCT or FLORIDA

|

o DosEPH TRADE
Plesk i€6 [Mota No. 22-cv-
vs. No. 2204 -CA- MOWk ~HLDDLEBAOOKS
_ te
Deferolart / Respondent

MOVANT ScoTT JosePH TRADER's MEMORANDUM OF LAW
ZN SvPPORT Of HIS Moon To VACATE. SENTENCE
PURSUANT TO 2% 0.5.0. § 205°"

, — Movesst, Scott To3ePH TRADER , spectfiuty FleS this
Mestorarselenr OF baw i Sepport Of biS Suchen ZASS~ Motion to
Vacate. Shree avel State? a3 follavd é

| xz. te, hs Govern see

A Prisoner i¢ entitle to av euiedasbiany feeriog on a. Kckion 22ST
Molion cntes$ te diction, FileS arch. Revels K te CSE Conmelusivedy Brew
Mok Hee prisoner 19 wot enkitlel te @uel. 2 usc, § goss” The
Courk an Ruliew) “mat accept al & He pebionec's ategent fads

08 teva. anol. becuse whether He petiliorer hS Sed-forth a Ualick
Chin.” Agar i. Dugger, $35" § Bd 138F , 1833 Ce Cie, (ert).


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 48 of 49
UF of YP

se OND ThexSeliug , Sopheruber” 28, 20% , aE: oporly aoeeping ss
He courk tern j the urge cleSeel Ha-Ceork feork to Ceenpmt bd the. atloneys,
Thaler, asicl Tots vlotler, Thed Racer Bigs accry te CiGid® ths Chilled.
weiter be. get Bock do te jail hee forced te herig hive agai , ancl ages be Frilecl,
he saver Goes to Seep . Getoyy Septeviber 22, 2t$, Ltr Beciving ak
Fecleral coortrhese toxcl eatery te Goort (Corr Haake ote. agans
xtecl bis attomsey He hearing Cao ke tescrectlert becas. of te euots
tak heel takes Ploce- fe previo8 ay, Takr exphivedl to hg Bence Hak
Avs Kiel ase_ gun, he- beet Slept, aucl be- teed nivitipie. tired te tok. Ws life,
Bot Coors explalreel to Tocler thet A 7 iss iS bsSk intereSt to plea. qvilty
Carly to Receive He 3 por Rebction » X fave Alrecds beer tesportedt
do the Court hee, ta hearing 18 alceocle Sbectlecl, acl te Court Frew
Per eoating their time. Me, tell Tradle~ to Stef) acting like a baby cued
take reSpwsibility for MS actions. Axl Soros abil.

TS) cecler wereld brve fac ve vtotal capacitey to nate Starck tok on
Aappensing 6b’ Crucial Ce8e, wDted fevx, Petorecl, axscl Corceckeeh
both grovel PaiSed p> Sephior IL oF His steorarolsr j Mote, 357
OF Secbiows IL FAS Memorwcdarccol He georsel riXeck irs Sckion

nf
I. of 445 eemotnrdax,

YE. Ker Edubit Z, Spplemotal Diseuery tos Ynte Crimuval G8,


a

‘ Then Corres Sto of 2422.06) 128 toacteal isa 1898, wrth ZUE.
‘aoldedl te Sime. goat Dhl ( 20k! , Here as a oper gprition Of Law pte
Eleveth Cireut 08 to the abebrsitiond of “Sexecal aesivity” 19 B422. (6), OAS
Hea ahve involved Childe feropgeaphy LE 3.6. 242%, The. listihS

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 12 of 49

12 of 4G

but for Cancsel'S Umprofessional errors, He e8utt & He. Preceeabing
Wotel have. beer lfverest” zel., at CP,
7 there a Bbircberse EHerS a quill, Plea upod te dolvive of
(Corel, “tHe Volomtarivess of Ye plea alepercl? a arhekur Ces Bel'
Babee wh willis 1 Cnge. of Competence thnenctecl K attorneys
109 Crithanl Ca%e3.TM Mill U. Leckhare, CH ws. 52,30 (ses). York's
(Prejudice Prong 18 Alecbifiecl im He Crtexk Fa quilhy Pker, acl
Prejuclite 18 Shown) i Here 18 a RaSnatl frobabilitg Hed, BA Er
(CONES errors , Fhe obfinelssEl etrtel pot have fleaclecl quite assol
oot hive essed oo going te trial ” Hl. ak SP. “A eoepable
Probability (3 & Probability ShFicient te casera. Corfielerme in
tle ater” Stricklarel , U6 0.5. at EF,
AB Sek Gerth bo Sechion IL , Coomst A Chergeol Tact with Srcce8S6olly
jevhiing @ tise toi, “engage” i 2. Qoy “Sexval ackivitie” eahich 3, he
Cou be “Ghergeol corto crural offer3e, These. rec6esSarc, neg Clement of
pace (6) gore. of Critical mpoctarsce to He GOONS Consurekien OF Aime
ee tus Camb, The gee tot bore, tee boreler of prreok that Canker tek eat
OF Hse elewtertS «So Ya See50°8 Frerrantel 2 Beko I, Trrrele'§ Cernihe.(
ans inefective- becwte he Fileck bo iuestigate | A. He Specific. Kets
lok Trecke's cose} 2, He. Charge agaist hive 5 avct al te lative Case
eu 19 Check at He tise, of Tales'S quilt plea =



Case “prorseow Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 11 of 49

|
|
|
|

l o€ €9

Ackunl pre epic’ is Seen by establishing a Mistarc cage

NA Justice. Hecnrel v, otteol Hehe, 344 F. 300 166%, 18%2 Ci cir. Zoot)
[ee coriiichions OF One tobe iS Geter mmocent 1 Asif a Miser Cage

06 juBtice, See Sarre aditlegg, Sos” US. 333, 33% ((9¢2)

Accorclinelee for al of He Fore neg PeaSin , 20k for te
rend’ aiSec? (ps Feeler's 2283'S" Hekion , Tader tS ahirallig

Tpontoce nt OF A BEBO) Violation becase 1A Condick dhes
Host fal coitin He finition oF Sacvra( athiekey j Axl Zhe abe,

et engage, With ,OC Case tHe anor to engage. IN , tHe» Prodickion
of Chueh. fonsearaphy:

DIL TeadecS Det Se Mornep Crdlececl iefiekive. aT3iStance
because he, Gilecl to babStigate. He Pucibin Bets Wehr se,
Te. deme eget SE fink | Geick the. Ce Lewd 1) efeack ot He tine. of
lacks’ Plea. SpeciFitally aricl foc te. GaSw§ Set forth im Section TL,
when) Cour Sel Flee ty he%0i98 Cortd K Hen incbikewrst, ariel ator

hee adtssech Téade- +0 plench guilly te it,
v —

A alegre allepisag ineSective awictasce fk CornSel MS Bend Hed!
1. Cur Bel'S PerSorHaxe Ail wei feth a objective Garelerol K RS ble res3 |

aol 2. Cir8el'S Aficiesk Perfor parce Prejucbiceck the LES, abpriving

Ye. cbfrrlrst atrial ote, Bit 13 (lable. Hreklasl y. wksb nator ,
MEE U3, CCX, 68% -8E (asd), Deficient pertorreurce 18 ted athich iS
“Nek wrlhiss thee Wide Fane of Coupeherrce, cbumrbd of alkornegs io
COpMiNeL CoS.” Tol, at Cet Gutern( qtation aarks onitteel),

Prejudice is establisbeal ahes “tere is a eesnable- probability



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 44 of 49
l oF 4G

CF. viterl Stote8 UV. Pecce, (20 F Kk USB (er, 2) ;
erie te cevemitesk Cite l ak th Phe hearing, te Core adlelressecl
He gestion FE etencitional flee IS trae Consebibenal  esitbok

Heck Comrdirbes? fwne, beer iemitters hte the agreement, of hess tee
gqremneds corsout, Th. Gort heel thot “ArenBe pierre. ersterect --
laut He ebisprick ark acceplel -- His, qitty plea only on the Cassable
| (hot weishakens) belief tae pierre haul preservect He- LA Ses for eppeel,
Wis flew @r8 jas a wedter of ties so Koous'y Gack Wolortarg.

Pierre, ok USE SE.

Wee bestrick Coork alors Times's Chane OF ler yetile

ackroosledy ig are OF Tater's Corel biemeal (Tre 0008 “erhethe
ble Scart, werecark i HS CeSse. wns Tepporteal’ bey prorhle. ews,
dil woe expiry wha, A21RS'S | wrersel be RH to F291 probable
| Oaetien. Aperrs Teeter a wrsclar te ingpression je. aul Oallone Gets
| (Within te 6 elowit, The Georrwiot Acldtel te Tortks's Cor FoSion)
tarhers there Lice Gescord forthe (2 explerissiria, tet He Gad (S300

| 3 ahether Here 1 Prebahle. Cate jy> the Serch exncot,” DKT SZ,
| pes BS - BE, Hitt Gal ausSiors Go Mus tle. iclevt howe

 chirect bearing on “tAuther tore iS Prbclde Cre8ee 2 tee Search arsest

te. eet oiteed Yokes Ue Traber, PEL cl V6, 16E-Fto (eit. 2000)

Fl. “Tyee, Core Cor r8 Unselect. Cole EO) He guilty plea. Ht
~ he Free. Seo Coorcilors: @) Pe alefaelk noe wile Btevted He Kater


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 32 of 49

32 of 49

Trace Stteredl actinl Preyuolice where.,a% a feutt
CoMKNE failures jhe. Reve Accurately orate Stone! He ComBegresceS
06 his plea. Nawely ;Trackr tans ot aurse at Ye tine, ke pleel quilts
oF He SAX Preio Bly Heshodedl (> qrevndls O20 AL , at of
He potied te Uncate Sekere.. Bg Pleaclireg Mig (he  Traale
forfeiecl his Fight to trial aitheut a prope UaeleStoxebiig oF Hae
Check CorSegvere8 oF Accepting Crieured (eSporSibilite , ocak
Tack Lol nut have the geortal Copacites te casclerStaxel Hlicbe
OnrSegemrces, Therehore. , Packs asserts -thek ke hoS Bewnd Cote
Qosel Proguelice, te excuse. procedora| defatt.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 49 of 49
Ul 0€ YG

Contlos/on

for ail te fore gainR RABONS , Aad for CaSoar8

Wot cede ieclucleal willis Wis HHorandirr Trader preH8
hat this court Condick ad eviolerstiary hear ing op AZ Section
22S potion ancl Hereates Grant all felie€ to which,

fie mag be ertitlectl,

<x declare vd Pervalty Or perjury ) Porseant
to DX 1-$.c., (IE , Hed He foregoing 8 troe ave Correct,

Executest 0 tis 24 Lae of Sehtembor 2022.

Respect folly Subaittect

Is ree Vex,
Stott Wadler
Reg 120. 16 - 104
£0.06, Coleman
US-P.. leva I
Po. Box 1034
Coleen, FL 3352 (



| Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 31 of 49
Blo¢ €F

Qvsdl iovolortorilg Meche. ComSel 1nd iebbeckwe Ge Cooskineize
to encourage Nis Clitrst to Pleaol quite, afb being iorttedd Of his
CliokS Sorte. oF ativcol keadig up to te plea Carrel ani Fortlar
Weheckive for failing to CSchecdule. He hearin, which hat thee heed
deve pTadles wretel have hael te Correct Yede. of reine, worsted
nok have. pale qrittes xl Word have proteedsecl to trict.

Dei ciend Perfocnunsce- by car%l 13 cause tor
Preceatural efaolt, Aricklasd, GE 3. Ak ERE. Course
| Perfoctasce i$ atehitienst @here it QllS below ar chjechve Yascbsol
of CaS Abler288. Lol, at C8¢. The. hb cient PerForunat
corsel Seb alse have Prequeliced th Ahferlat'S on3e., To Satista
Prejelice, a deferrlesst MH — Yow) thet, bt for Oa 72l's estore ,
tere i3 a reas able. Probabilte tle resvit ot. the. Pracevclsg use? hee,
bod Bferesk. Usicklrscl , 466 U.3. ab C43, LE a. aleSorbert Pleats: guilty
Presented 18 See) 6 Hare 19 0 feasorable. Probability thed, bt $or-
CoroSel’$ ecroc's , He debecdbok woted rook hove Pleadlecl guilty asel
wrectel have isisteel ow quing to tial.” Hill, 44 0.8, $2, ¢ ese).
"A reeawable, Pebability ig. probability Sutticiok ty reels itive
Corder ire atave. Srickluel, GE v-3. at 0,
Additionally , He prejuclicin| Keck K CrwSel'® errors Hit
be wSickerecl Cemeatactively Cobher Had bhi icholl « Willian U,
Taelor, 52% V3. BZ, do S.ck, MEST Is1s- (deca)


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page Soi ae

- PesSvacdesl a erisor te. enmagtc. 2 ar carla fol Socal ack, Hus 020i
- heePicalle econ Hd He ach W228 Coospleteed ariel the. likelibeol o€ Mecttiplee

_ Pokerbiel Gtabstory Wolotions 1S gremtiy tedececl, tirdeecl, 9 Sha

wo i Ceeasshansce. tee abhorrence w2itl bea Cheryel sok with attesspl, base writ oo

_Arkually ebicing a eticor to coowsit the. peci€it. Sex ack Mek eS
_ Centplerecl acck thed will be. Wreck i te. inchehowen.” witeol Yobed
. HE Reckiile, SHC IL 28.189. 19.3 Ct cir, 2008) cee
TT ite Gaiteroerst Coss seek tisk pekembial Uiolakions foc.a.cospletenk arc.

Aved ever if tay Contel, al the. Polestial Violations tlt? feus to fall ere

He. Serdbre| ab Siwition OF Sexval activite febivie 40 chileé Porwogcaphy «Because.

the. least c-\pable. Cordock Cersisialiatel by Hobse. 2Zt0UG) 5

_ Aistrsbution j the. alkerwakive sens here, dee

i “Sepaccabele,ack adecs. shpulatecl conch with Mut heeB wok
; putas to a Wiolakion of Sersiond 2422.6), The. Seipwletion of FA$S ir2 Bopper k —
. a Toders & quilt, lean. Sumeasizes hit. cordlsck leoclscg te He, UWolediond ___
ps fete ¢ HSL Saud hedS Sten Treals to He. Vithine Hak irrclecbent, ae
other Hing muetecouS Byes. fear hier for tee Uiching to Sraral hier pale
_deteges. Ab First, Hee Uehiod. Provilecl Tivolem Sevrcel predureS of hes Full
_clethect wrhieh clarky inclicatecl She 3 a. preted ule. Fader
lS ASkiel the. Victor , Geong otter things, Aad alel The 208 drvol hee tall.

Mick Shee 008 NING y to cohich he. Peplieck Ad sgoutiee. fitedleg Cac. (fOr OG

- ee look Sexteg ir2 tite Pajorsad «Lia CeSprnr3e. te Toke % Cospre 884000.
Hhe. ics Airs Crkewivally Seas at teaSe 120. photo aCher vagina. arch eps


Case 2:

cee et

2-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 22 of 49
ZZ wok 49

Te be Soe. Agent olick sok tapeest Pernuission Frac Tracker’ Wor

idl Tadeo give Aq038 PerntisSiord ak aay tite ,t0 eal , OSe., fee ;OC SSE
Gnug Birel of Medlital or texte healdh tcorh Sich a8 His ceport, LikesoSe.,
AgertS Biel ok Cepeedk PewUssiod Forte cork te OSeal is abcouent,
GOKCh IS SEU Sealecl a8 of Hig corit Ng -Merecier, He. goversmot
peletittedd at Sosenscing they ebtairedl He feport frou Traders laptep
covspani Po thes intracterel the. Photographs hte. report, sack to. Cepot
ASCE. There. iS NO gueition te. Geerrwtenst Bice) He. Nodvre, KF this Gport
Un highle ComFiclerbial, Lt (8 Ute aS Sach od te firs oe Pegs , arsol
He Govern Clenrley Cal te. pert,

Dering Setterxcing, Tracer Cepeatectly toll Corel to ebjerk to
the. irtractaction of ths report hesecl on Hese. grovel. Bot Courier See
UNexphinable, a3, chiectedl only te te elevance of He. fepork carl

Nothing ese. .Ever Trader ans able to ratice. Ye. Gavernitok anS Sin ths

Cefort te Shas fecicliBir G ct 1/8 No Svepeise, Wet Partivulas abjyertiod Faileck.

: Throschest tHe, entire Preceecbiisg ) Treder tolel Go.r8el to object te he
Ugptrecboction hs Fefort , Ob fhe Mel vt.

CoWSel'S failure to check tothe tstrrdichlon of, OF vive GC

[he exclusions of the “Parenting Pls eualuction” brSedl om aa of the

Previa Bly Memionect grows , Prajuaticecd? Foder beaa&e, the qoerutok
Freel this repork Over dock Cuer agais Han agkost te aheSt tex0 hax log Protexclicg y
x

(He rebut Tader’s aarquetod Cheat BS years wouel be, ad appropriate, Soko
[Be Qeversrtenk Sel this Feport Aocing Heir freSetation of eticlence eth

H-S.2. Oger Beier Kaze These Bel ik doring C038 = OXeenrnmtiod OF



Case 2:42-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 39 of 49

wo
yp

w
Ww

w
a

w
w

3? of YF

|
|
}
'

(See anbe's cltend 12/9/20" , CH [2019
| Appests? Reply beef ) 8/4 [2019
[See Appellat's briee, Uolzeix - pas cf -18

S22 ApgedatS Feeflue bevef, BM 2019 - pgs f-E

The. court alse Ceachecl this Corelusian brSecl in Part op te lack of
JiMorutation abet te. locations dlcta. proictecl be KiK te Howelarel Sewriby.
Becase Corel ciel rack attach th cords of this data to te. nection ty Sopp,
[hey never Lecame. part of Ye corel or Revie), acl the appellate. cost uns
reaver able, to View thet, CONS “Re atotle mesfeckive Sor pak Providlng
je Districk Court cote He ioreekions adich, eos soot es te ESBIS Laer Hee
totio te Seporess , bt excS He Aeferrlot§ wtole argue OD appen!,
Comst| aber Hocorrectiy iforiedl Track theb He appellate Cart
betel have aLceS§ to Qview Wes econ Hasoragh Biscerery. THIS Reorreck
infortation ofloertecl Tadler's decision to Pleacl quilhy Condhitionalli.
Ancol becense te aurt at oral ASQ UE PMOL tHare. Ce ifGrretion)
Containea exithin the bickS came Kom, ComSe| Coulel rob Point to axpthere
earths Hee, etord to back He trockive ClainS steve bg Troster, See: Cxdibit
Ora( argument , fie [toz0 ~ pg P/s 25°, pz wl) -24 , pz 22 [2-23
Heol ComS| Proviclec? be tracking Beda ts He DiGheiee Gort
ih the sotion to Sypress, He Appellate. Curt wrovtel here. ferrexseal ct,
nul Ba Suit of He proceeding Grovicl hee beers cli fers. THe Coord
crate tax beer able te Uiew) We. teackitig of Tockr's physica} Marvin ,

|
|
!
i
|
|
|
|
|
|
|



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 40 of 49
Yo 0€ €?

acl crorlel fee held + Vrolatecb hig Crghk to Privacy quaranteccl bg te.
fourl arenclucest, Liber JiSe, Trader woriol wot hare plea guilty Conrelbicnrally
fad CoorBeet correctly jhorrech hie Had ig alata. exertel pro be, Park of
te cork op appea, Tracker's enstire. Strategy on appen| un8 Laseol arent
Mes clade. .Tt Yvaws Ceenbolity te believe he wotel have Sigecl to

| Pleo. agrenbink Herwise

Therehore. Cowl 129 nefheckive. for Mok erparrcting te tecoref
ji dhe alistrick Court with He pecesSary imfrnation Meccleel to frewunil

len beck capper |, erhile- at tee Same tire. Boong Ye Strategy, kevelopeck
“cithhis clock, Hel Gexr 8h ob Providecl imcorreck jsforration +, Taster bebire.
Siquing W's flee. agrees) jhe. waetel ot late Pleacl guilty act Stead
betel bare Proceeclked te trial,

Hi

BC. See: Appella+’s Geply brief, Blulet - pgs 6-¢

St, \Paolec Subs + te aort a8 Cuiclence. letes'S be kB Sette Cords
A
| on the yess; -a€Firing his PBL Hot Corel Krew) te Srateng of

| Tawler's Se atl trouthak He Crieinal Preness , Bydibst £
BY. See! Po Se muerions, thhy/tol? - CDS pgs 6-% |. UG EISAE
i ‘pro %- pechion , tfez [20%- CDS pqs F-? ho.ul 109 01 %.Mf

3%.)

i

See! Samtobelle vs seus bork, YO4 v.53. ZS, OZ 5 V2 s.ck. €¥55
hadaa Ci)

4
i
a
rt
a


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 28 of 49
28 of 49

he belececl w02 i$errtecl 2b tle be. belyevecl he. cevtel Peleg OD

tihe> Tadkr entered jisto his enrlticnal plea, he. fea Sonvabley

Delievecl he. tomsel he able. to erise. the, Partietar iste os appeal,
there, a ckefassla sk: eres a guilty Plea pd th atic of

xr, “He. Volustarinses8 OF the plea depots Os Cthethe— nelle

Adite r8 Wilks He. foue of Carpetare Lbaynuled’ of Attar Ney

de Crutiseel arse8 Hill, 42108. ab St, Prejvolice. 1S Sours if “Here

$0 teecoonble. Probability Hat bt For coure.'S exror, he desuselesk

loavtl worfue Plea.lect GUE Quel wrretel hee b8iSlecl om Gourg

to trial.” tel, of $9, rectoneble. Prosobiliter 15 6 probability SAG riot

tb ordirine GorCdlaxe ind He ortcane.,” Bock? GES. of CF,

| Take plecl Geil Grbtionalles, PeeSeruiiag bs Calc to

Blfeal the iSivee of ““ybethe- Hh Stand, wercart 3 th’ Case an Syport
bg proteble. Che. $78, t_ average. Pessod ibe eas Who Keowe) Crintiizal
laced, Hak Cordtiens Cass fe HiSleaslg te Srteore. ute Lelieves
Phere tere iOclorned’S arcel eunissenS cots He, RH Lark, wshuclr

| lel bo a Soaking of Prrtrble Be. Tt OAS Gm SelS SA te take

| Sure Waeths- onatsSteonl chet he. cng Peseta or appeal, aoe?

| leteck fe e03'b. DISkeael, Coorse| attic. eo rGe_. Kf Pear inag

| hecl fo Tel Exc A Seki ih, ayy Only Ber A852 eel getting

the ae. Rteieel prickly Ha ComBA isKorueel Toco oF te.

C1GltS he. bond GUD OP, Speeds ecatley He £, ‘gis t@ Challesse. th “Sacks

cditlid th Ki dlevit, Hort the (Sxe_ wrS Nog PeServed) for apes, (

OC Ces Prieta Caiseel proteet, Tacber t20120 sock howe


oe Cth be AS ca CoSteackion abe8 wok exter te tle. Corcbck Prohibited
we bes $ 2S... 2082 He. possesicrd asd) ahsecabition 6 Chill parregraphas. a

ee _ AG eb teten, arth Gebere Coimivel Coden’ xrohere. Thee Orde Keai2. 7

a hee Probuckion of ¢ chill porrocgeaply 63. anercbid bo IE oslo. nice

ee “wil carta CFG SIE | EAs a. lakive to Trooks, Mis Means Hot MS. allegeck __

Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 PaggA of q

_ tales cedneching eahok “Sercinl Aes’ Heed, (tS Ascouececdt tok —
Shes. Hedestes, whicheS forsol is) Cheptes fee. of ttle 1 of Hee nsitert Sake.

liebe, chee, took cleKisie.Sesevot Aekivdg?TM, Moreover 1 Secerrel Atk trig tS. beet O-
4 mitt 3 —t

a eehreritions 18 that Congress Speci€italle B&irxel Serxvel actuity to. eoclunk

oe A OS ZIP is Ctl 1§ He. Hndote. foe tle. “GiluSowor
- OES, Redeckissg to chilel Porsveggorpluy 12 Abhiaitions OF Seed achuity far edsel.
B28 Per snd Coed be chorgeck with a CCibitol Mere" avol i+ Sede TO Hig.

hep 2 08.6. 208 ek Sag), the fered Soanl achivicey. for which arg pore

wee bar bee Chergead. OH 0. Criwnssal Offer%e. (cloaks the Preabochion of Chile€
Pomogrephy : 23 MeFirseak (i Sections 2256)

oe TIS ele one cf te Moi; Meosg Frias A coir Stu. 2142. phe 46,
_ - aS explaineek by (oS.0. ZAZE, 13 the, Caste condlck prebubitea bg LES.
ez

BALM), Hen Peoebcekion of chile pocwegropha: Heder, te Gebites broaol

woe Congees. Cleewrleg ConBickerenh He "iclBiond K KeLeg. Celeckiay to Chilel _

ae _ Pocre graphs” ahed LEI 00. Semen actittes At one Jrlocke Rel He Pewrdiction
on EEE cilaird AS ale iia oe

ne a

ie [28 » Secrel renter £¢ Gest egvites ark, iscacporoke -
ee Cadel it,@2. tallying Anse rm thede (F Comnsitteel, Qe pessend abe Chesyeek



Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 47 of 49
CE of ¢4

HM,

Or? Teekay  Sepheuber 26, Dek , Toeler'S Feleral Prblic. Defoxler;
K. Cletche- Pentock , axl Teader'S Private Abtorreg Cepresertiny Wis
Blake criminal ante, Lubin PAhavite, Cave o See. Troi ok te Srna ine;
fe Pe tthle. (aor8. Firsk, his eatral pblc desxche Hc, peacek wartecl
to d0farm adler thet te coriter Aoxgicg his Ketion to Sppre8 eviblosce. «208
Gilecl the dace before ov> les. He. alee bul a plea agteentot for Tasker
» Sige, aS Pasay terested to jsoforen. hia thet (6 be. Chee 40 Sigh He
featral Pees agreewtex, these. 09 A Verbel agree sek Feacboek woith te Becbe.
Of Florida. for a tere of OS year$ to Mod derseorter® toi ve. Fekral
Sestort) 6 fe were te Cheote to aocepe it.
They both fae alse. Spoke. boith vic. dick aboot Toatr's evtctiona |
lvtbrSt He. Previous class ip Cork aoe wJantect te Make. Sure “tek woiel rk
Aepfer agains io ensy OF Ye. legal Proceecdug® Gosia Firtler, bt esperiaity i)
He Bote DF Peocezoliny an therSidoy ; url the Felrel Charge of plea
hescivog On Frv'elag Then Taster asoll his tem Criminal aktorrey? Proceeatel
do Practice He. flea Colloguy avel tr tolel mob fo AK Ye Crork ge%tienS,

a ee bel PeBierS, AK ME abtonseyS Teacter aBkecl (€ te Chae. PF Plecx
coulbe eschecllecl becabe. Sta Sate civil action te. clay bebore ,
Quel 03 biel Ke. Tracer ars Signsced He Plece aagrcemas,

OP Werbresclery  Sepheriber 24, BAF , Cheistopler A. HickS Came
to See Tracker te Prepare for He Court heacing on HurSitay. He aagaur
(dense Over Pa een wohey H ocrtel be- better for Coes yre if be. Voloobarlly
Sige! away hs ogds. Tower cgrescl to ale it, Later thee right, Thacker
cborce akteuplecl te free hustle. Rope. broke assed be Crital hint
do Seep.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-D
-DMM Document 1-
1 Entered on FLSD Docke
t 10/07/2022 Page 45 of
49

i

\ US wf 9

ag te Charge8 j ced (3) tle cbfadinsh wtb Feed ant vrh-sinsl
le. CenBeguernce? of ha guilty ples ae ae f Yer Core. COALEWS IS
Wot qiofieel, Heo He pla ’s ovale ” Pierre, ak USE:
| . “hoo arolembary plea. A esulk where the accusgecl Alex Not
v bassol ee wrrbure CF tle conetitotiona| protections Ae ¢'S coniving

% iG epoalliq Clear Her the cebesclaise U20d We asvale- that We guilty Plea
yerninel bis Sige te asserk a conmstibvhlnsal Challenge © appeal «++ AS
(corSegunce, Fic atferclosi) quill, Plea. aoes 1% Sak 36 ove OF
We core. COncerWS OF ote. ue fake He tive 0f his quill plea he
Ceaed jock hue vvvelerSeeoel 148 cossegoesces” Pierre, ust,
| LE a. eleberelenkS qui tig plea is tat Cpa Voluntary axel

(Kiang ths beer chtaidect 1 yolokiond OF dle Press ax 13
therefore. Void. Y Ae Cordes . urritect States, B74 V-S- ase es- CF

(1964)

outer 10 toll, Goal believeed ,h’s Preserve! appellate. foew
AG ntotio’ 40 Seppress iclootecl a Qclehitixel ened CF ad (Sue
Hott, 08 it -focwecl ost, 08 Keer calseel eoittars tock section. CevrSed 'g
nahectivesresS cavtecl tok. Bot beitter He garrbrak, wor He abstr
Court, ecplairect to Trecler assay thisg else which ware letck hier to
believe cthereate-- THiS Gourd ote, bee ote hseel 08 wok Feving te

pore oF hs plea.

| - ; oe
17, | Seat Exhibit Fs pq Fs Emhibit: S , PGF.


Case 2:2

|

2-Cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 15 of 49
is of 49

Zp Hus CoS. D the famgunge- OF All Batte? feliecl ufed for Course
fire. excpliciths Clear. for the PASO Sek Forth id Section I, Tarcler 1 actoally
immocenrt of Ureiotineg Section 2422.0) Cork there. 22S 100 eiclence- Or Fackval
basis to Sport a conviction), Aaldtionratte cafypeitate COUNSEL te look
aware OF Huse Seci€re LIG23 woith Trades'S Sector 2422 Cb) Commicdion i
jane for Seu. explainable eS), Conte ail nok ise. ese (S328
pr apppea |, ever after Tacko expressly doled hit to.

Th, bt Gr .ilore of appellate. Corel, Ye Elerrvtr Ciressit corricl
have beled thet (tas Plaid Error te Connick Teacler aot Sestessce. hina
Ha LIFE Gre Gants. Forter, ey tomidl hue invsrtucte te disicice
Courk te Uncette. Teadler'S Seti 2422(6) Cooviedion and LEFE Seastence.,
aul emasl back oe forthe Proceeclings.

ck fp ies
bere, a abfiniluk enters a quilt Plea. pow te acta  CorSel
“bee volortori288 oF Ye Pleo abpere®? arr atedber Comes advice. 023 ceilhird

He ange, OF Coperterce, abwancleal of attorneys in ceimuxel Gases.” Arlt, 14
5, 2,56 (6s) Seicklasds peejrlice Pron 18 roel Feel auek prrjeobice (3

Wow if “Here. i$ a. easoable Peobabilite Yok, 62 fC Caw Erroc's ,

Fie eletselersE\ waortel ct hese. Pleacleel quilt arch wirel he irSisteel OP going
ito trial” Ail, ak 5. “A rensensable Probability 1a. pecbabilibe TKGciet te
ences cortiderce, inte outceue- Steicklel, (66 08. at 624,

Ackeki tiorcolleg 10 eked ig antitleel to te effective, 2SiStance



Case 2: a2- -cV-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 17 of 49

TE o¢ “o

Bho He Cleroth Cires't cleciclecl the one Hu only ackdresteel a. limiteel
Botoont Of Thal 'S arguments Quel inttecel Oteel Ca8e law) which Srid, we -SerPrisngl
irthak the Ceaork wsitl tock ComBioler arguments (iSeed for He Fiest-tine 1D a ceplg Brief.
Qnoiteed Bakes ve ache, $51 Cae Be, 769 (it cic, 2020). oexplairablg,
(Coens, AD abhor, ath clecacleS of exprrcience Clearly abil wot Ecos) oF
‘deh wor Casete Koad tig weit establishedd Case lau); Quer after his clits
ioforuecl hin of tb, Thee 508 Treader wersacl preserte.l i He ioitial bref
sot orl Feel Her it, Gul arere peed geskiomss OF laud after Ue Rpreme
court Aevichel cosperrer_v. (witeed BoskeS , 13S S.ct 2206 (Gore); bot
hey caere_ jnstruwtntel te Tales iv cecicliing te pleack quilts comel tional.
Et ces alenys He plas beduseer hint ose course.| to brisag Hede arguisiod® to
‘ile. Eleventh Cireiik after Garporter wns decicecl, Bt whet was brargick within
the iritiel bok iS bent describe kos a. leay, break ie Scope atteuipt to
| pargoe ve Cipgkee to privacy 2 Anat’ S DP abbess awdl Keil hbeRS,
i Trader's Narrowly Craktest ; Specific, areponten nS meee mee replg were, rat,
ane Still have pet heed Actetresied by the Eletoxh Circuit
r Thee gueStions brought eaith hese Argus 75 iirclinl. He Main Hssve of
(eotir' appeal eheder He waranstless Bizvre wold Search historian
Records Creadeol bya cell phoisen, Rsealiog te location corel Moves of thot Celiphere,
128er ates Bo dag 1 fermittedl be te fourth anette ~ IF the dda, Aweeling
ie location arch nest? were coiterkead (12 We Forur of ap adelress eruedtion,

4 This iS nok Hee peti te Court cbecieled becnsee i415 koe Pe. argos
EPoe Forde bp Gend8el ay. He initial BveF, Tek ans Khe Cigik te frivaceg of ax
‘ap ARLES irs geveral « a Nob oneS Uk are prurateadl by a Cll Plax er, &

te Cork weve adil d the. igh to Privaceg Ob He Celt Pleide Ber pe cal
peaeccos, “Tee Sept brexrglt this arpztek to te Coots atesition , base gO
‘Carpenter al witeo? BoteS Ue Sope3 , SES VS. 400, 132 3.ck. P4S~ Gera),


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Pagew’ pb49e

Actool Bomocence. Clams Mig ORE CDH Procestral defavtt,
Meawiggis it iS, (33 Sct, 1924, 1932 Ce), “Adin terocence”
peo Factor pmocence , Wok Mere. legal BoE Clenew, Bor8ele. ley

wi bel Stated , 52S 0-8. Git, 623 (1968)

I. Teadbe i Qthoally Li oct of Ucoleckinog 1% 125.c. 2422, ©)
Geant 1), cohich Prohibits auyeme. oer engage ind “anne Seounl Aekivityy

Bec echich Guy PerSe> Convick ba. Sergeek grith. a Criauscel Kerge”. The roberts
Aewsple keel Sexeriol Activity " Teeder's Woleckion 1% beSecl Upon ,1$ tea

Stecke AK Flotilla. OFfer3e8 bavolue m9 chilol pecs} ia Hoxever,

De adbihind , Trader w203 wok “emgagee 9 0 He Procbetion KF the

Chilel porscaraphas 1 Qo essevtial element unclr te Duis lerquage of
the, (, ig therefoce. i be ho lecbicy
Tralee ¢o08 Corgenk with a. viatbon OF 18 (18.0. 2422 (ab),

tedhich. 3 eleverst Part Prohibits ¢ The evticemact of a peuror to engage. 1p
Sextial ackivcty fer tach arg person can be chesgeed 02 4b a. CGiaine | Messe. =
There ave. foor elena Pegvireck for a. woletion oF HeS Stodute. , arty ture

are Televent here. the First elesurk Ceguices the, Bferlank to achieve

i cherrtel Gate. cer a minor, ol bless wing thet eertal Sete te have

thet atinor engage 62 Sexual Ackiviite.


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 38 of 49
Be of CF

Zl. Seen! (€08.c, 2422 (b) 7 18 v8.6. 242T; A Set F2E.0%1 (3):
ELA Sted, F2F.OFUS),

BR. ncber Aser's Cawted aes toled clr ng a. Plex Cll After be. initial brief wad
lect , abot Ye. Sees feqarelng Fig 24226) Gomriction, Com8el a Further
Lingereol theowh Corresponrdbnce. auc! toll to aise S22. on abmck
appeal. Abéctionally y ComPi'S wite. Lectin. Pttanseug eke ad epresetng
Finder to his Coutival OSe. agaist te Bake of Floral jus alo rtnulee dscnte.

Lor He (2308 Sucresnaliice As 2422 (6) antiction » See: ExtibilS 0, 6

23. Sve: (bet 21)

2d. Sees Appellast’S bef, eft

25, Seat Roe wctions obtecl Ate lee, tcluleay, tolesfecie, ire lee,
ea. leet?, ¢llzee?
t

i
26. Specifically Tater's iro se. peetions atten thtfeelt, add s[22.laeth
‘|

ZA. See? response. of CawSeul cbdeol wo fdfaoe , 21219

4
BY, Sees Geter’ brick, theoleet9

1

29. (Beet Mekiod Fer AxteS8ion OF tine tealeos ~ pg iw
Be. See! Rose section’ le [tott 9g vhs. 1%, CDS £3 P/ly §
_ 22 [e019 - P93 els. (*, CDS ai West


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 26 of 49
LE 06 UG

SprciGeally ) Trade- Comstesds thot He iSSUing Magistrate,
Sochye. NS seusled ‘beg Material act thin te a€icheuit which,
Were. nok true. or accurate. , Sachas tHe Seccherl eSiderce e229
tee CeSiclorce. OF Scott Pach} Hak Zett Packer bistecl hig Mailire
@dlelenss, with DUSHMY a& He Searchecl @Sijdlence, ono Aug xt |, Zé} et
hat te Searthecl @Sidesce. uns purdchasecl bg Scott Taelr'S Hobher
axl Step Gtber On Rime, lb, Zo Accecclicg to He. YH. Lecie- é
froperke appraiser's woebs tor ase tet sete Trt Ak tipi
Ais reSidertial Giles? te te Searducl eSiclwrce Ges URL Sr
SH, Port Mi lcie, CL WiSZ,

ee HagiStrate Sudlge- wn bee 0 te wtet illege( cachinateg
Cecurect axil wat applicetion +h ackurty cecsrecl on j Goel weber ese
ware key O'SIion§ 43 to te UVolwajvous tr, “Srartflere Application
#2 resporateel 22K, This pclaede® cles Bory “legos Freud (2. oli erent
LP elles. The- able Eaileal to Hetion He. rejnor "Seere On
Contonsieeting Hh abis-reprsedtedl her Age. co hee PeoKile- For
Srartplese applications 0 Het Searles applerbior #1 aS Gr aclLUs
WE acl ars. Motemve, the kilaat GilS te Mortis Her He filicesTM
messrogel “Scott” First , acl 4 ales, sib boston) hese) tpt chederuiswel
He Uitheer “Seat” St to tle wire AXE Chill Poncogrely « Ths (3
Mfortat bnSe- the, Search, exert und israel te Sard L4-
idexe K Lktchkion of dill, Penegrepla. I$ VS&. 2252 @)G),

We Kb ibawik alse wis-Cepreserte? Tinder's Couinn (

oH

Arstery bolus Crimes agrmSk Childten), Specifically thc Taets-


| Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Pageg aga

Benepe “Ap. aceuSeol iS erskitlesl to be as2ithecd by ass abhorcesje 2 tothe.
- _plags He. Cole, reesSery to Bute. that He tial stoic.” Sheckler
— Uteshirrgtens, ee U8. 66%, 68S (eed) 25s Mer words, the Get
oe _ te Cartel 18 te Cob bo eeckive C8iStae of Come Dk at 686.
- . Shcicklnnl establishect a. tox Prorigeal €8t for aleheronivsissg wheter
Cae Seradlanst be Secs ivedk ireKeckites QSSttHatKe COWL go
neler Hee First Prong, Hee Courk Hust aleterenie,” bthetler CORBA S
Proce uns deficiest,” Sevcklarcel LEG 08. ak CFE. CARNE
_pelhocuisrce i3 Aficienk where se FolS. below) an chyeckiue. Harsclered

Ok teaSonrablene8S, Leb. ak CRE Co
1 Under te Secorreh Stecklasal prema, tee Cotte EH ehe rove.

tebedber He. obfilciek pefocuntt. of CorBel preelicedl be, defers

Te Sekisty Hee Prejuolive, Prong 06 He tet, 2 chehersdlant eeck

ne Bok Slow tek, bok for CanBel'$ errors tHe arkcor. K Hee peecee hig Me
bdatel Hore. Uilceley thao Nob hte beer berets. Strcklasal, €06 028. ob 683,
Keller a aefrrclank sate ory Shed tek” ‘Here 18 a. Ceatenrable. Prebebility be

Se hed, but fac COWES carpcn¥esBienal ararS, tee B&utt of le. prececching
f0SL Iewsee bce) doctecerk. "A teascrable. Prebchilitg i3.6.“ pechabititey
SvCicdemk. to cmdlereuine Comfichence tio the. etewte..” Stockland,
YEE 28, ak C24 _

oe a Hee Consterct oF a quilty plea, habeas petihibione cad Shea

- LOB C2.

 Preediet. by abelorStrakinig “a. CeaSorable. Probability tet, bt fr
bora %eN'S_errocS he. teatel have rok pleadeck poilley casl wsotel bavi
_iessteel_ en ging te teint”, Lees ol wrsileel Hake, FF Suck. LI,
quoting: Hilt heckbact, M4 0.3. 82,59 (M65)


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 34 of 49

Bd of 9

i

4. Cocks have helol Chorah Mere Fed jBe aitctoat), Heck He consoles laais24

Cristina Ooi to ahich the Sotube refers Cote bea. Sate.
Or feckera.l Coste) Borah te Hatvie. Low tite Soy Sen. See!

Usited States U Bill, WO €.30l 134%, 1351-52 (4 exc, zout)

he. Phrase. Frisina OFA, IS toot: doSreok ins te ecberal Crietin|
oete. | Bt Sea? writen! Hotes i bekiseh ISS 3cE #22 24
(ih cic, 208) (03.0. 2422) probihdS “Sexvral ackinrhy heh << Cored

hae Regullech 2 Chiatinal Heres inset Yate or Feakeol fad »)
iH

Taeks'S O8e- 18 a. prime. exorsaple. why His 1g meowStitotional.
The Proebsckios of Chile porsog gape Stekte i te Sinke, F Cori Senrnety
broad asl ixtledkS Codduct rick coverecl withio He. bf irsitiony
Beacnl mckulity for ce Welabieons oF £482 (6). foe a Faloral Hede-

te Cx the Stree. for a broad Gheqory 0€ Conredock Crisisalitecl be
‘Blade. teed, Scha8s Gong Rircen ectivitey For echich emory porSer> Ce be hereof
OI a. Crinixn oMfenSed 6S a gen rable- PRELICE « COGCESS Cressiere
Krew is edhtascce, whek Goribuck We Strde. o2:ll hci to poke. CorsinalTM
Butler, 6¥0 C3 2537 286 Ft cir, gout) Zin (nritecd Kote? wv. Bogers ,
BE 3. Digt Lexif F4S¥1 (b Kana Sie sl ait); He, dork

Ack navlecGeek “ "130 cbfinclanst beS ear heklergeak the issue before.
Moreover, (hes) Corts bi, ter predic this atte iv He, det

OF & Cor Pbitoelere | Chatlesge , they have betel, asl SvahiaeS Suagfley Outed,

thot Starke lowed fe SSes are icorporatwol,” acl. LIP OS. Disk lee CE
Ae ay alternative. argurens, Soe lee PLD ek Goeth OMS, Trader

Conbenaele His Hetote-, 2172.08), is entensttotionnl ag apie to hin.

i

i


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 43 of 49
; 43 of 49

Lead bickeS

Co. See? Cbubit E ; letters lated Mf22/ re, pat; shshe, p42
Bl. Beet Oxhibit O, Tracke'S Seiver8 bicen%e-

GZ. See3 Exdibit P.M, Locie Camby plaperty apptaiSer tcbrxtLieetler
Cos,

63. Ade. ora( Acqua tS TRaserS appeal ) te court. Peirteol ak Cot
AS XErvedtiod 'S bin whee ony Ye tecercl, which wrried AlSe barchele.
a Bclturt to Garth. See: Gdsbit S, pe ClO, 13-14
CY, See? DET /1~1, CDS pgs LFA
CS, See’ Exhibit V, Tater's Bap Sheek) pq IZ
C6, Ke Edibit 0, Mocks frre Thal ete , pgs

GL, See: DET 72, CDS MS 4-3

Cf. Ke! DET $2, p93 24-27


Case 2:22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 29 of 49
24 of 44

Sqred he Pleo, greenest coal Sten! Aexbf have precerclect
to trial.

Rejvdice aw alse be estabied becrok. the. Givit o€
He Proceecl) Ny 020d bave, bees ARerek. Tracker Corrtesels thee ©
@ Sparks h ine Cerred Meare beer helel He abl: wreotel lock
Prebble. Coc8e_. However, bbe terey least, ta Cotcect i2Fbruebiors
teroucl be_ or Caorel for ta afpellate, Gaurk te Bice ostiens
Hey were. acing Tocks's afpellbe. (Suet % wheter te
Piast wArast Gilet  etehlsha UK betwreed He €Sinfermee
to be Seotebecl txt He Centred activity Perceivert. SpeeuE catty ,
the. Kidbyt eal Vek Cooter libel hs reail np Geletress woth
DeSiw aS the. Searches! eSrebersce_ . THE 1S Yupley Not tree.
Te Upeltete court CnSidirec? this: wher baring tHe cresidecce. te
Teater, Haw’ HIS beer Mfprever, te areve Totes acton(
PeeSesvecl (Sve, cool bev bees Offeres, he. Cooce tcenial bee
| force? He Eiidlaut locke 0 ectrble- CrcSe. cork ariel hove

averse? TraclesS Comruichion,

Tracks ther Siqrniag MS flee. agree mio, belienedl WS oS
te oot UiKeleg ateorie., LEI, Corn Se lel hint to boliere, tk el
| Cechiall, Aeppor. Hacd Frater Kann His avteevte. 2 Mot POoBible,
| fee wrwid wok frse. Sigal te flee Caneeed; Cox ecacute fone (ySeucl
| Preceecleel to trinl. Wese Ere, Wokr biel tree Fiwonaly Oa Colsrasiliy
| Bute his ple. o€ qoitk Bete Be whos haclicl,, fe. lal rte Yosrel
He PRBible. CorSeguerces of his flee.


Case 2:2

Cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 13 of 49

D.
13 € 4G
i

OF BYR), Set by 2087, are. clea, Receste. aX. o& te Fate. of orice
Btatte? elienl for be He. gevernolet 1S Ye PERSERSion oF Chilol Porsseeeeihe
Trades'§ CxmSel wnS ineective Coc Failing to ASri88 Kerk 2 Quel
[OtiSing Tralee to plenel quiltyy tit. Additionally , becasSe Ye other Yocke.
OF Clocide. Statute Police cpus by He gevermmwt icles Fe Se Gurlck
Buch as abstribotion of Chilel Porrsogeaphy Cen Se( 429 Agni befective. for
[Rilinag te alisuies Cool 2) aoel for A819 Taster to pleacl giith, to it.
Morecuer , becatbe Clever Ciresitk precertnst ab th tue of Teroker's
Gritty Plea incbeaterl a dessert cool rot be corvicted of U tating Seton
21226) $ Gngpletecl ack Repeirenect Utne Aettiple- Poterkial Gabutory
Volek’ a8 He Preclinte. MoSe ; Sel ux pxeechive. for filing to
jichseiss comh a aval ab Si129 Traaler te Pleeal guilhy te it,

i fourth, beces8e. “Crinurel 8" 18 Not AEirel bg Btatite. 2422 (2) to
wcll, Sete aol Featral KFS, asl here se WS 1$6ve. Bill $8 were been
actetresseol be te Cleensth Circuit, Tacke's Co8e Presertee€ a Mond Fridotens,
per ctoring Chaies 08 tf taht Sete, FESS ho poe apple te Sretion ZZ2(b)
Molection$. His Counsel cans inserFeckive cher fe Sailecl ty Scie team A. brteol
pw thie greet, aul Farther insefFectivn for adkusiSing Treks to Pleicl guilty to it.
Finelig, bea Be, Tadks’s tore Crilecl nestigate ete pa. Prockeeol
jfHe tae flotels He, which Bee bdo “Serst” to Trach, ack bec tube. a> BE
elewent IS a Conpletel act of 2220) actully enticing te unio te
Jengage in, this cose Hen Prealocson of He ore Chilal Porograpy moive
[2 tS Crm, Cascl beceuhe CaS hao Keewleche of sua. Prstiscg hack

Sex Commanicarbior® with ck leit Cur other alle Meer, ComBel ar§ terheileg
dseHfectin. for alising Trreler to peal quilkg hes he hrel a. Viable. alegre ae
fio Comte bared beating Abat, Ql delerising hint te Sigh 2. Fackva| baSig
jolich lackeck Lppork Ge te Schon 24220) Uiekdion,



Case 2:

i
|
i
i
H
|
i
il
'
Hl

|

‘
1

22-cv-14348-DMM Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/07/2022 Page 16 of 49

16 oF UG

OF Com. on cliveck appeal , aol Soviel be velurtect under te. Strickles:l
Blesolarel of Prejudice, Suth U. Rebbirss , SZK v8. 269, at Les 86 (L000), Te Deu)
Prejedice. vvsekr Strreklask, Ye deferrlast “net Sow tek He Aes, ciont
[Perfocumoce._ prejuolicecl te, dlefirSe”, FecieKimal,at 8%. Arak Prejudice

is esteblishect ate “there's a teoSoroble. probabilite be Ge CoM BeN'S capprofessions |
error’, He. Ceault of te proceedhing anuiel hue bees bitferet. Yeicklead ot 694,

23.
Tracer Sigrcl a Cordlitiona( Plea. apreemast, He, bil So after eerelopine

2 Breategy LOMA CowSel which Comereel arourel bringa9 GE Spreibie argueta ond
| direct appeal, Heewener; athes Cornel Fileel He ivitial Berek; Taaler heel mo Kioaslectge.

cf it, i wend peocly drabled, axl barely included Ax Hung cerdind Ht het CrSe.|

ial diseusseel with Thacler Ptior to Sigsice He plea Ggreebles® This (Steet a Kew)

ComPlairst adler Sek sutbiple pro Be medion’ to te Clerenth Circwit ater He bre
, a=
eras Silecl expressing his dssekisgaction with Come, BiKbi0 Hee Mackin , Three

Pack ated te court for Pecuussion to Syplemest He brief or allernativele Cattose
[ONS fee He Cade ancl feSek te bciekincg Scheele. . The tckions Listech

sfonoertateal ReSens For tes tetien, explaireel ahg Axl inaclucledl a Prepeseed
2E
joitial bevel to Spplemet of Replece. He ome ceerSel Filec£, “

Afr Counsel eiprdecl ter Teacter'S Cloio§, the qeseoiost Fleck Heir brick,
ck he Court GreusteeL ass eacterBiod of tite to Fle, a Cpl, Min tak Motion fe ad

[estes oS tive, Coy Bel tlh He Court he ra gery $2 smcwr porate. Thacler's

Ip vposecl initial brick, isto He sephe brick Tater once agains aorcte. Ye Coort,
cited correspoudence, for. Cosel ancl Clewth Cirevit Cate law orel inhornesl
ue Gourk Hak dor8el (8 Bagge Mting &y false Shes for He First fie a replg
bev, tohih hee 1% Bok Perueittecl to alo, The- court clevieel Trohr, acd ccs
ifilewt a Peply brik tok tend Glued wort for wore whatTackr heel propcdeot
|[S.pplentestarg te He. dcihlal  talvedaag ares pret (iseel writs 4, a