* QMS iOOI/00 7 02/03/201 1 17;3 G FAX

_202493514 2 FA A@)000G/001 2 u •I u I I' t\

~ n n

••HSPORT/VlK) H Michae l Selig.MaFACC . :•:' : OPERA!lUN o 281 6 0refieldRoa d Allentown . PA . 181G 4 ^H ! FES- U A*^ : 0 0 U.S . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHJNGTON , D.C . Federa l Aviatio n Administraflo n Cynthi a Dominik , Laur a Ponto , ''^Compla^iantT ^

Honorabl e Judg e Ronni e Yode r

V , Federa l Docket . No : 2010-121 1 M & R Helicopters , LLC . Responden t MOTIO N FOR DEPOSITIO N O F CYNTHI ADOMlNlK A TGALLAGHE R REPORTING . ALLENTOWN , PA , AN D NOW , come s respondent , MICHAE LB . SELIG , MD , FACC , principl e fo rM R Helicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operationa l sinc e 2007 ) who m aver s an d file s th e followin g MOTIO N t o Depos e Cynthi a Dominik . Esq . unde rRul e §13.22 5 fo ra pr e tria l examinatio n a tGallaghe rReporting , Allentown . P A18101 , 1 . Throughou tthi s litigation , complainant s hav e faile d t o plea d t o specifi cnumbe rallegation s an d thereb ymakin g admission s o ftruth , 6 yfailur e t o addres s th e specifi cpleading s an d thereb yevadin g an d circumventin g respondent' s specifi callegations , complainant s hav e indubitabl yan d injuriousl y propagate d redundan tan d iterat e pleading s fo ra cas e tha tappeore d voi d a b 1 o f5+ QM S gl002/00 7 02/03/201 1 17;3 G FA X202493514 2 FA A00007/001 2



### initio . 2 . Throughou tthi s litigation , th e complainant s hav e refuse d t o addres s specifi cenumerate d paragraph s i n breac h o fFedera l Rul e 10(b) . B yfailur e t o addres s a pleadin g tha tthe n deem s tha tallegatio n a n admissio n o fth e trut h l o tha tpleadin g unde r§ 13.20a(f) . 3 . Throughou tthi s litigation , complainant s hav e no tpleate d fact s wit h sufficien tspecificit yan d i n accordanc e t o standar d practices . Th e purpos e o f thes e practice s is t o confin e th e pleadin g part yproo ft o onl ythos e act s olleged , thu s enablin g a respondin g part yt o prepar e thei rdefense' , 4 . Throughou tthi s litigation , complainant s file d lat e response s t o motion s pas tIh e 1 0 da ydeadlin e motio n perio d unde r§ Rul e 13,2ie(d) , an d hav e no tuse d objectiv e octua tdate s o fsigne d servic e whe n availabl e i n attempt s t o impai rth e dignit yo fthi s court , 5 . Th e Respondent s Motio n t o Quash , Strike o rDismiss Complaint , wit h associate d brie fwa s foxe d t o M rPonto s departmen to n Novembe r29 , 2010 , sen tb ymai l o n Novembe r30 , 2010 . Th e du e dat e wa s Decembe r9 , 2010 . A n objectio n o rrespons e wa s no treceive d o rserve d unti l Decembe r13 , 2010 , pas t th e du e dat e unde r§ Rul e 13.218(d ] (Exhibit s olread ypresente d I n th e Respondent s Repl yt o Complainant s Respons e t o Judgmen tt o Dismiss Faxe d 1 - 18-11) . 6 . O n Novembe r30 , 2010 , respondent s Motio n t o Strik e Allegatio n wa s 'Bake r V Kangos , 32 4 A.2<1498 , 50 5 (P aSupe r Cl . 197 d 2 O f5r.i . + QM S 121003/00 7 02/03/201 1 17:3 6 FA X202493514 2 FA A^0008/001 2

faxe d an d sen tt o M s Ponto s departmen tt o whic h n o objectio n o ranswe rv^as receive d v^ithi n th e 1 0 da ydeadlin e unde r§ Rul e 13.218(d ) , Alat e answe rwa s als o provide d i n th e collaborativ e correspondenc e receive d o n Decembe r13 , 2010 . 7 . M s Pont o faile d t o presen tan yrequeste d evidenc e as t o whe n th e respons e wo s actuall yreceive d i n he rrespons e t o thi s matter . Asubjectiv e dat e wa s indicate d o n th e documen tItsel fa s t o whe n i twa s drafted , doe s no t represen ta n actua l dat e o fservic e o rsigne d authorizatio n o freceipt . 8 . M s Domini k

o fth e FA

Aenforcemen t divisio n o fth e chie fcounse l calle d responden tdirectl yt o hi s persono l cel l phon e admittin g tha tth e complainant s coul d no tfil e response s withi n th e 1 0 da ydeadlin e period , woul d b e i n breac h o fthi s regulatio n an d thereb yreaueste d a continuanc e directj yt o respondent . Exhibi t1 show s cal l lo g o frespondent' s telephon e showin g M s Domlnik s numbe r202-267-7560 . 9 . Responden trefuse d a continuanc e an d requeste d th e cas e b e dismisse d o n thes e grounds . 10 . M s Ponto s defens e is tha tsh e neve rfile d a forma l continuance , knowin g tha tresponden talread ydenie d he rverba l reques t i n th e teleption e inquir yb yM s Dominik . 11 . A tn o tim e di d M s Pont o address , respon d o radmi t t o thi s statemen t o ffac twit h submitte d proof , a s ha s bee n he rpractic e t o evad e an d circumven i item s no tconvenien tt o address . 3 o f5m * nMS 01004/00 7 02/03/201 1 17:3 7 FA X202493514 2 FA A^0003/001 2

12 . Furthe rpre-tria l examinatio n i s no wrequired . 13 . Responden t i s a solo , privat e practic e cardiologis tan d require s tha t th e pre-tria l depositio n o fM s Domini k t o b e hel d at : Gallaghe rReportin g an d video , LLC , 160 0 Lehig h Parkwa yEast , Sui t 1 H Allentown , P A1810 3 a s t o no taffec thi s clinica l responsibilities , pos e inconvenienc e o rdelay s t o hi s neutra l part ypatients , i n servin g th e communit yo rpu thi m a tundu e ris k fo r liabilit yo rmalpractice .

14 . Complainant s prio rsubmitte d date s ca n b e utilize d fo rthi s deposition ,

) 5 . Alternatively , M s Dooiini k ca n submi t o writte n statemen t o r stipulatio n that :

a . sh e indee d calle d th e respondent . b . sh e di d not e tha tth e complainant s woul d b e unabl e t o submi twithi n th e timeframe .

c . a continuanc e wa s requeste d o n th e respondent . WHEREFORE , th e responden tpray s tha tthi s Honorabl e Cour twil l gron tth e pre tria l depositio n o fM s Domini k a t th e Allentown , P Alocatio n i fsh e choose s t o no t submi ta writte n statemen to ffac t t o th e abov e cal l an d discussion . Respectfull ySubmitted , 4 o f502/03/201 1 17:3 7 FA X202493514 2 FA A^ DM S @|005/00 7 vw^!/^U M J ' isrif l ^tt x1^0010/001 2

Michae l B , Selig , MD , FACC . Dat e

5 o f502/03/201 1 17:3 7 FA X 202493514 2 01/21/201 1 3:19P

M FA X FA A * DM S 0006/00 7

ISOOII/001 202/03/201 1 17:3 7 FA X 202493514 2 01/21/201 1 3:19P M FA X FA A + DM S @j007/00 7 ]0012/001 2

U.5 . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N Federa l Aviatio n Admlnlslratlo n Cynthi a Dominik , Laur a Ponto , Latony a William s Complainant s M & R Helicopters , LLC . Respondgn j Honorabl e Judg e Ronni e Yode r Docket : 2010-121 1 CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E HEREB YCERTIF Ytha tI hav e Thi

s da yserve d Ih e foregoin g entrie(s) : Dismissa l o rProceduro l schedul e Lette r MOTIO N FO R DEPOSITIO N Q F CYNTHI ADOMINIK . A TGALLAGHE R REPORTING , ALLENTOWN . PA . upo n al l partie s o frecor d i n thi s proceeding , i n accordanc e wif h th © requirement s o fRul e 2 9 pursuan tt o 2 8 U . S . C . § 174 6 . Servic e b vfirst-clas s mail , DOstOQg prepaid , addresse d as , follows : Fedora ! Aviatio n AdminislraHo n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue . S W Wilbu rWrigh tAvenue-Suit e 2WI0O O Washington , D.C , 2059 1 Att : Hearin g Docke tClerk , AGC-43 0 1/FA X20 2 49 3 514 2 Laur a Ponto , Esq . Enforcemen tDivision/AGC-30 0 Offic e o fth e Chie fCounse l FA A 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 ^/TA X20 2 26 7 510 6 Th e Honorabl e Ronni e A . Yode r U S Departmen to fTransportatio n Offic e o fHearings , M-20 . Roo m £12-32 0 1200 Ne wJerse yAvenue . S.E . Washington , D C 2059 0 t/FA X20 2 36 6 753 6 By: _ Michoe l B , Solig . MD , FAC C 281 6 Orefiel d Roa d Allentown , Pa . 1810 4 61 0 36 0 395 3 Date : 

# ,A^ '

w ^ y-^v-\ \