**NEW JERSEY DEP ARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION**  **HIGH EMITTER VEHICLE DETECTION**

**RACM Analysis**

Michael Baker Jr., Inc. High Emitter Detection - 1 **Control Measure:** Repair or replace at least 50% of the high emitter vehicles in the region. **Description:** This control measure analyzes emission impacts of repairing or replacing high emitter vehicles older than 15 years in all the counties in New Jersey. **Methodology :**  Emission factors were calculated for each county for a Typical Summer Day as well as Annual. The emission rates were calculated using MOBILE6.2 and the setups for each county of the respective MPO. **Inputs/A ssumptions:**   2010 seasonal VMT was calculated for all counties in the three MPOs (NJTPA, SJTPO & DVRPC) based on their conformity setups.  It was assumed that number of vehicles > 15 years old is approximately 13% of light duty cars and trucks based on registration data.  It was assumed that 10% of these vehicles high emitter vehicles.  High emitter vehicles were assumed to travel approximately 35 miles/day.  Of these high emitter vehicles 50% can be repaired or replaced in each county. **Results:** Emission Reductions (Statewide):

**Pollutant Typ**  **e An**  **aly sis Year 2010** 

Tons/Day Tons/Year **VOC** 2.998 1,045.438 **NOx** 2.463 997.489 **PM2.5** 0.0023 7.745 **SO2** 0.013 4.579

*Note: Negative means increase in emissions Ozone Analysis – Daily Benefits in New Jersey

**Benefits (Reductions) Ozone Non**  **- At** **tainment A rea**  **New York -**  **N. New Jersey**  **- Long Island,**  **NY -**  **NJ -**  **CT Philadelphia**  **- Wilmington**  **** **Atlantic City PA** **- NJ**  **- MD**  **- DE**  **HEV VMT Reduced (VMT/Day)** 606,609 337,234

**VOC (Tons/Day)** 1.927 1.071 **NOx (Tons/Day)**  1.583 0.880 *Note: Negative means increase in emissions**NEW JERSEY DEP ARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION**  **HIGH EMITTER VEHICLE DETECTION**

**RACM Analysis**

Michael Baker Jr., Inc. High Emitter Detection - 2 PM2.5 Ana lysis – Annual Benefits in New Jersey **Benefits (Reductions) PM**  **2.5 Non**  **- At** **tainment A rea**  **New York -**  **N. New Jersey**   ** Long Island, NY** **- NJ**  **- CT**  **Philadelphia -**  **Wilmington PA** **- NJ**  **- DE**  **HEV VMT Reduced (VMT/Year)** 205,438,685 49,775,645

**NOx (Tons/Year)** 638.515 154.626 **PM2. 5 (Tons/Year)**  4.948 1.199 **SO 2**  **(Tons/Year)** 2.926 0.709 *Note: Negative means increase in emissions **COST/BENEFIT ANALYSIS** The cost of replacing/rebuilding or repairing the engine of a high emitter vehicle was assumed to be approximately $6,000 per vehicl e. It was assumed that this vehicle would have a life of 7 years. Total costs were estimated as follows: Capital Cost = $6,000/vehicle over 7 years Annual Operating/Maintenance Cost = N/A Total Annualized Cost = $857 /vehicle/year Total cost for the v arious non - attainment areas are as follows:

**County Estimated Cost For Each Non**  **- Attainment Area** 

**Ozone PM 2.5**  **NY -** **NJ -**  **CT PA**  **- NJ** **- DE**  **NY -** **NJ -**  **CT PA**  **- NJ** **- DE**  Atlantic - $1,212,000 - - Bergen $2,349,429 - $2,349,429 - Burlington - $1,418,571 - $1,418,571 Camden - $1,218,857 - $1,218,857 Cape May - $440,571 - - Cumberland - $492,857 - - Essex $1,468,286 - $1,468,286 - Gloucester - $852,000 - $852,000 Hudson $690,000 - $690,000 - Hunterdon $611,143 - - - Mercer - $1,046,571 $1,046,571 - Middlesex $2,305,714 - $2,305,714 - Monmouth $1,824,000 - $1,824,000 - Morris $1,639,714 - $1,639,714 - Ocean - $1,158,000 - - Passaic $861,429 - $861,429 -**NEW JERSEY DEP ARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION**  **HIGH EMITTER VEHICLE DETECTION**

**RACM Analysis**

Michael Baker Jr., Inc. High Emitter Detection - 3 Salem - $420,000 - - Somerset $944,571 - $944,571 - Sussex $432,000 - - - Union $1,233,429 - $1,233,429 - Warren $496,286 - - - **Total** $14,856,000 $8,259,429 $14,363,143 $3,489,429 Cost/Benefit Results **Pollutant Cost/Benefit for Each Pollutant**  **Ozone PM 2.5**  **NY -**  **NJ -**  **CT PA**  **- NJ**  **- DE**  ****

**MD NY**  **- NJ**  **- CT**  **PA -**  **NJ -**  **DE VOC ($/Ton/Day)**  $30,841 $30,843 - - **NOx ($/Ton/Day)** $37,542 $ 37,544 - - **NOx ($/Ton/Year)** - - $24,622 $24,635 **PM2.5 ($/Ton/Year)** - - $3,177,360 $3,177,307 **SO2 ($/Ton/Year)** - - $5,373,476 $5,373,386 * Daily Costs used in calculation of cost/benefit ratio are Annual costs divided by 250