# D i! **OFFICE OF**  **THE AlTORNEY**  **GENERAL OF**  **TEXAS**
**AUSTIN 1** 



### Hoaonblo i?amqA. mlth

**Diathiat** 

### Attorney

DUP Sirs



### Ha Lra ln reooipt lng 

### our opinion88 to 

### Yheth ofYhioh

18 ltt.8chml

hento


### of freeport, 

### Illin Tuar provides **for** 

### TanMB8ee to the 

### of Iby 24, Paquutnt eoatraot, oopy l-tPu8t Law or mPotandThoma8 

### lp.loeat~in **am.gporr** 

### rPm **ltamphlr, tranqmPtatfon,**  

### rtor**gnu ’** **r Oxpsnrr**  **and** 

### to **hlr** ou8towPa **Pieu** theP8os. l e**u to**  **the**



### rmtll art*rho,tha oom- #grrgh 6 alro prS+Mer
ror return or lm801& mmeuadl8e to 

### aon8igtoP8 l t 

### th8 tiFmlna**t$on OS**  **the** 

### aantractr

**u0 baf0~0,**  

## thrt **a. it8**  

## r&w, **thlr on6**  **of 8ele**  

### or **good8** by tt3a party 

### do8lg~tod a8 the 

### psrtJ 6ulgMted **aa aonrlgn8@,**  bat **to** be, l o ontnot of **oonel@maxbt.** Th4

### Honokblo PamarA. hith, ?uo P

similar ln neul~ l 

### ll of **it8** 

### term8 to the **on8** 

### bofora the oourt 

### in Stein DoubleCudion tin Co. v. UB. 5. Pultoa Co., 159 II. w. 1013, 

### Vh8mII th0 miia8 cOIWt Of olri1 ~~ti#, in hO1Img that **the eontr8ot**  **before it**  **d.ld** 

### not vlolata the Turr AntitAl8t **bV8, #d&S** 

.a l +* **!fhO OOntl** **’ Wt**  **und8r** 

### aOSl#id@~tiOn #hod& tJh

OUF O#IliOSI, # OOilSt~ti l**8 OM**  Of **~O~Sl@WUlt, Sd**  **not OS&@** Of **SdO. 8UOh**  **it** 

### pUl'&JOZ'tS

**to b**  

### by **it8 1mrJ**  **ten,.** l l 

## l **.***

**iVtOP SUUF~S~**  **th8 plroTl8iCJIbS**  

### Of **th8 SCQtP8Ot,**  **th0 O#lSbll**  C~tiXlUSSS

**%hdS~ &WOVi81Ol%8**  Of the 

### QOlItZWt, it 

### OOOUl’S**t0 US,**  

### 6188r1r indtUt0 **tbt it**  **V88** th8 **pUl3BOS@ apd**  int~lktiOll

### Of **th8** 

### DUti.8 **th@POtO** 

### t0 WXiStltUtl,

th8 **?kktOll cv**  

### Of **teu8** ***p** 

### jX3llMt'8 fPOtOl'

Of USnt t0 8811 th8 gOOd8 d8llrered **to** 

### it **on oo1nl8rioa~**  

### the **general.** 

### property in the **Si@lOP.** l l 

## l

*II **gOOd8 l** **’ OUiSin~**  **in** 

### the **COXb**

**&Other CO88**  inYOlTing l 

### eOntmOt w&in ~Otilbrl~ almllar to the one hrro Intol~rd la 

### La Pea 1. ?&Us Rubber Co., **242** s. Y. 346. tenkizsa, J. in the 

### opinion of the Court of C;TIJ **hZQOa18 Of**  **Austin SW?iS8d**  **th.** 

### OOIltlrd **thW0** 

### lnrolted 88 fOl1OV8, at p. 3181

***ti th.**  **illStU&t -80,**  **- ~~~~~0,**  **a** 

## rolagn oorporation, 

## Bhfppod its gooda to **k ?On**  **t0 b8**  **w hir**  **#tOrti i.ll**  **hi8 V8lWhOU80,**  **l.u Wade,**  **lb.,** 

### ud by bin to 

### bo #Old 8nd d.llrOr#d in 28X-, in tb **WUSlti.8** 

### SDOOifled 

### in the OontFa~t. 

### Tha egant vu **author** 

### iSed t0 ~OXlS~tO SUOh W1*8 **YithOUt** 

### ?@fSl'- 

### rhq them **to** 

### hi8 DriPol **Each #ilO**  would be l P

### ii 

## for l mrOV& #al by 

## l

pp.llee in 

### th18 **#tit., thFOU@**  

### it8 **WUit rh0**  **-iAtLinUd** l pboe of **bUSiM88** ir WAbO, TOXU., Md 

### 8016 th. @BOdS Of apll" StOFSd ia 8 V-- hOUs in **that** 

### QltJ.



### In hold- that 

### thtr **oentrrut 614**  **sot** 

### viol&to 

### the **t-8 hlltl-tFU8t**  **hV8, w**  **OOliFt** aOnthu&t**‘ &St**  **th.8 4p@w,**  **08 OVMP**  

### Of **th0** goodr, had the rl&t to **detomlno** to vlma 

### it 

### llould

ml1 the 8amo and at VhAt 

### Prlo8* **8~6 had**  the **w** Pl&t Vhrn **8011in(l thmU@t**  ;;;bYUt **U** 

### if it had bout @big **Such S&S** 

**8Wh F08ttiStiOB**  **lDpon it8**  **WSlt TOUld**  **Wt d&t.**  **OllF St0tUt.S**  1~ ?OSt?iOtitNS Of tnd@.' **forbiddimq** OOSt?8OtS

**m OOUPt**  **Of citil~D.tiS**  **r0i\r80d ?SliOf**  **t0 th.**  

### p4l18 RUb bO?

M ilt

it8 l it **OB this**  **OWtnOt 0&S0t**  **ti Foa**  **on th0**  **tluo~ that**  **the &DDS=OO,**  **t&0 Pall0**  **ltubbor Compaq,**  **108** 

### a fO?dgSi OO?DOMtiOB dOi4 **bWinO88 in**  **%XU through**  **it8** agmBt rlthout **a** puwlt.



### ?h0 cai881Oa 0f &ppub ?0v0?88& this Ophb~~ Of tb **AU8tI.B** 

### COUPt Of ml1 &DU~# ia -8 mbBP CO. 1, u Yolk,256 

### 8. u. 577, on tha gPow6 **that** tha eoBtnot 

### ln quutiOB -8 ia faOt u iBtS?SutO tSOntP8Ot VhS?SfOm 

### th0 ml8 **IhbbU COlpIIy**  **V&S OBtitiSd**  **t0** 

### ?OiiOf **in ~OXU**  **cOU?tS OVSII**  

### though 

### It dldnot **b8r0 0**  panit 

### to **trMUOt** 

### bUSlne88 in turrs. It il 8ignifit3fUit, hOWTOP, th8t th0 c~881011 Of App8tiS 1ikSV188 ~OMtl'U8d m OOntr8Ot l

### S l OOSltnOt 

### Of aOll8~8Ilt 

### anb not l OOntMOt Of 

### #a10 

### dralaringbt 

### pa 5791

I+ l 

### l * 

### IotTlthrtMdlngthe oontrut 

### l'dSl'8**t0 md**  

### 688i~t88 **k fOlr**  l**@ ‘** **Q8Ikt, ’**  

### this would not **be oontroll%n&**  **The aaot**  

### relationbotvroa them **WSt bo**  &trml.wd **by** 

### th0 legal l rreot 0r the pr0~s810~8 **0r** th8 

### oontnat ltSOif, uul **it** 

### la gen8r8lly bald **th8t** 

### th0 niati08 **0r tb**  puti 

### ~89 th8 0l'db8~00?A81@l88Bt~~llt18B0FO **mot 1~**  **that Of**  **f8OtOP U&**  pPfmOig~&it **~6, ai0**  

### it IS tPU0 a **f*OtOP** 

### 18 in th0 ti8t 8dYSlS snageat, 

### theyuiayir~lmtedcum* **a..

In &M3OrSOS 

### TlPa h Rubber Go., v'. llobortr, 

### 12 9.w. (2d) 

### 154, J-0 CPltS, 

### th8B On th8 CoriSSiOB Of 

### &U?S~S, Olted the above tV0 

### m.ntioMd OI8.8 **Vith appl** **’ ~Tal**  **Utd r8tifmd**  **th. dOct?iM**  

### vhl0h th8J UUXWIOOd in th0 fOuOVhg &~gU~38l

??o 4@.. wlthtM 

### eontentloa or p&la

### tiff t&t, SO f&P a8 iBtO?StatS auSBSnt8 US conoemed, @it 

### is ran 88ttlSd th4t 

### obllg+ **t;w uimg**  **0a** 

### 0r **48naf 0Oea0t8**  **b0t7i.m**

### Honoxuhl* lta8q A. With, ?ago 4

oonrlgAor8 and aoA81&A.~*, gIrlA& the WA- **#i&A44 SXOh8iv4**  ?i@St Of ~10 VtthiB l 

### d@#igrutOd territory, 

### and the 00~81@~48 a@~l~ to 

### or- Do #took, 4nd Mt to odv.PtiS~, **and** Slot t0 **#elii th8**  

### go068 **Of** any **other** 

### aaaufaoturar, are entoroebble 

### under the 

### lava **0r** th18 **Stats. ’**  l l 

### l . w

**MtrP pOfl&tily**  **OUt th8**  

### &iStin~tiOA **b@tr8Ul 8OntXSOtS**  **Of 8410**  **~36 CO&IWOtS**  **Of Ctt3XSSigMULt**  **OP &@ACY** **’ ,**  **the QOti**  **h@id** 

### the contra& 

### thsro la quortlon to be 

### rot& **48** 

### b~iag IB tlole tiOB Of the Anti-tFI#t kV8, AOt kC~U8a Of 

### tb 8XpI%8~ t8m **Of the**  **OOat?SOt, but**  **be04U84 Of**  **th# SUl** **’ I** **’ O~**  **f8OtS M.6**  **Oi?- WIhWXWS**  **ShOWiog the**  **t?ULSUtiOR t0**  **b8 in**  fBOt **& 8610**  ?&ih@P than **a conslgnwnt.**  **The ceort**  

### adds

'mm 

### coatraot 0r date Iorember 7, 1921, might **b0 h3&**  **48 8**  **DOn** 

### WAq **0OAtF40t** 

### if 

### oarrhd **Out a8**  **Wpch,** 

### beOSU88, **in SU&**  **Went,** 

### it WOU~ **80181~** 

### haye arwt06 **int0r8tw OOI**  

### nwrce, but If 

### tha btaAt, and **pW9O84 Of**  **th.** 

### OoAtUOt, **48 SVidMCSd**  

### b7 th. **MOO?&** 

### md te8- tilKUly,

rhCV8 thlttit W88 to **Ofi&** 

### a dlmct outright sale to dSfWLdEUXt8, Whsrii.~

the **prop** 

### erty sold, and now **sued** 

### UPOA, became 

### a part 

### of the **common A488**  

### Of 9roperty IIS this stat., and **Subject** 

### to it8 lam, the fact that the COAtraat might havo bun la@ on its fbae, 

### as a~ agslley

contract, does AOt r8llSV4 it 0r it8 lllegality **as** 

### sotually **oparsted** 

### under and aarw. T. Ravlelgh co. v, Land (Tu. c"t:: g;:) 261 b. **V.** 

### l&; IQ., 

### 115 Tax. 

### 319, 279 S. U. 810. 

### &I other **YOrdS, if**  **th# til** **’ 88**  **in qU08t:OA**  **V8rS Sold**  **OUt?igbt t0**  

### d~fOAdm#, au& aftar thej arrived in Texus, belng th# 

### propww **Y 64teAd4At8,**  **If.?4 SUbj8Ot**  

### t0 th. **inrgrl protirioru**  0r 

### raid **contract, 88**  **8 coadf**  tion 

### pnoedant t0 SUCh BElO, than th8 tl'8AMO**tioXs t&ken**  **48** 

### b whole vaa rendered i~egal U&d 

### unenforceable. ’

liebelieve that 

### the attached oontP8ot **do88 aot**  

### an **its f8Ob**  **ViOhta th8**  **&hi-t?USt r&Y8**  **in that**  **it appSa?S**  **t0 US**  **t0 b8**  **OieS?i~ 4**  **COnt?Mt Of**  **COZSSi@I88At rrnd**  **48 SU0h**  **6-S AOtI;iO$t4**  the 

### htlti-tFll#t

I&W8 **under th8**  

### fOregOi **4UthOtiti48.** rrttten oontrbot **4008** AOt **in r40t**  

### MfiSot the trUe MbtiOMhlD

### Hononblo Rwr A. ddth, ?r(le5

betveen tha **pUti08** 

### UXd it eu~ ba 8hOlTQthat th0 **t?MMOtiOM** 

### botvoon tho SO-till86 WLSl@lO?S md SO-tilti OOXl8i@k8~ W **In** rm Sal88 

### 0r gOOd8 (88 -8 dOA* in **EhAdar8on** 

### Slr8 a Rubber Co. 

### v. BObSrtS, rapn) 

### thus rush oontnot would ba 8 rlohtion Of th8 hti-t?USt **hV8** Of 

### fSXa8 88 t0 h?4g?4jh 4 thWOf Vbe?Gin 

### th0 COI%SigW bgr*OS t0 1iaZt h.bSOli **f&I the**  **UiO Of**  the goods 

### to 8 'terrltox7 

### to be 

## l aaigzwd 

### to hid hnd vhwr4.a 

### th. rSSi.&B@Oyll'808"to UVO 'M **Oth8P** bU8ior88 **OP** -10-t hadto SO= OdJgOodS OOM4pudtO 

### hir by th@ 8&k& 00A81&AOF8: Vhdh.? JOA vould bo 

### l bl8 to SStbbli#h iWit A8OeSur]l to ShOV **8 ~18**  

### Of gOOd8 **t0 the**  **80-8~106 i488igM8,**  **in th8**  **f8Oa** 

### Of **tb** 

### sXpn** provlrlon8 to tba 

### oontrary la tha VritteIl mAtnot, 

### i8 & qtu#tiOISOf plVOf VhOl'8b VS, Of OOUP88, WOt BdViSS foU. Ve hope th8 ButhOriti~S

### hOrm%I& oltadmy b. hrlp~ t0 YOU la 

### this 

### oonn~otlon.
mar8 rery truly