EXHIBIT 1

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 1 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

1

Case No.

Caption

File Date

Nature of Claim Answer and Defenses by 

PRHTA and other filings by 

the parties

Discovery

(Both Parties)

(Date)

Status Hearings 

and/or

Conferences

Proposed PreTrial Order 

and Pre-Trial 

Conference

Full Hearing Resolution Other relevant 

Information

2016-ACT-012

Santana Vázquez, 

Carlos

October 21, 2016

Appeal

Appointment/Announcement 

of Position Challenge

December 8, 2016 – PRHTA

submits that an indispensable 

party must be joined. Appellant 

requested an Order requiring 

PRHTA to disclose the identity 

of employee whose appointment 

is being challenged and who is 

currently occupying the position 

in controversy.

None None None None None The Board ruled

there is a lack of 

indispensable 

party and ordered

Appellant to 

provide notice and 

join the employee 

whose 

appointment is 

being challenged 

and is currently 

holding the 

position in 

controversy.

2016-ACT-010

Ortiz Olmo, Pamela

October 31, 2016

Appeal

Challenge of 

Announcement/Appointment to 

Position to which the Appellant 

applied 2017-05

Motion to Request Relief from 

Order

November 29, 2016

None None None None None None

2016-ACT-009

Velázquez Vázquez, 

Janet

October 26, 2016

Appeal

Appointment/Announcement 

of Position Challenge

(Announcement 2017-015)

November 29, 2016

Motion to Request Relief from 

Order

None None None None None None

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 2 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

2

2016-ACT-008

Cintrón Cintrón, 

William

October 25, 2016

Appeal

Appointment/Announcement 

of Position Challenge

PRHTA has not notified its 

Answer to the Appeal

None None None None None None

2016-ACT-005

Villegas Estrada, 

Aleria M.

April 15, 2016

Appeal

Reclassification of Position 

(Denial Challenge)

None None None Final Resolution 

April 26, 2016

dismissing 

(dismissing 

appeal later 

reconsidered)

May 18, 2016-

Resolution on 

Reconsideration

(vacating 

dismissal)

None After the 

Resolution of 

dismissal; on May 

11, 2016 

Appellant filed a 

Motion to Request 

Reconsideration of 

the Resolution 

ordering the 

dismissal of the 

appeal.

The Board 

reconsidered and 

the case was 

reopened and was 

active before the 

Title III 

PROMESA stay 

took effect

2016-ACT-003

Molina Pérez, Nurys 

A.

Reclassification of Position 

(Challenge of Denial or nonconsideration of petition to 

reclassify the same)

April 27, 2016-

Appellant filed

None None None April 7, 2016 

Board issued 

Final Resolution

None The Final 

Resolution 

dismissing the 

case was reversed 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 3 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

3

April 1, 2016

Appeal

Motion to Request 

Reconsideration of the 

Resolution ordering the dismissal 

of the appeal and request for a 

conference to argue the request. 

No ruling was issued in regards 

with this motion and the 

Appellant filed a review before 

the PR Court of Appeals.

dismissing the 

Appeal

by the PR Court of 

Appeals pursuant 

to its Judgment of 

June 13, 2017 

(Case No. KLRA

2016-00575.

2015-ACT-012

Sostre Serrano, 

Samuel

June 20, 2015

Appeal

Challenge decision by the 

PRHTA Executive Director 

reducing Appellant’s salary

September 4, 2015- PRHTA filed 

its Answer to the Appeal

None October 19, 2016 

(vacated)

None None None None

2015-ACT-009

Pérez Carrión, 

Lourdes

April 14, 2015

Appeal

Request for Reclassification of 

Position

May 18, 2015 – PRTH’s Answer 

and Motion to Dismiss

None None None None None May 30, 2017 –

Appellant 

requested full 

hearing

2015-ACT-008

Santiago López, 

María

April 9, 2015

Appeal

Wages Claim August 10, 2015 – PRHTA’s 

Answer to Appeal and dismissal 

motion request.

None None None None None On October 15, 

2015 –

Petitioner’s filed 

an Opposition to 

Dismissal Request 

Motion

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 4 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

4

Board has yet to 

rule on the 

jurisdictional

issue.

2015-ACT-003

Arocho Nieves, José

M.

March 24, 2015

Appeal

Request for Reclassification of 

Position

April 28, 2015 –PRTH submitted 

Answer to Appeal and Request 

for Dismissal for lack of 

Jurisdiction.

None None None None June 30, 2015 –

The Board

denied the 

request for 

dismissal, and 

order the 

continue of the 

procedures.

February 10, 2016 

– The Appellant 

filed Motion 

requesting the 

Board to schedule 

a Status 

Conference 

Hearing.

May 30, 2017 –

The Appellant 

filed a Motion 

requesting the 

Board to schedule 

a Status 

Conference 

Hearing.

May 13, 2015 –

Since the 

Resolution of June 

30, 2015 the 

Board has taken 

no action in this 

case.

2015-ACT-002

Morales Olmos, 

Sonia

March 18, 2015

Request for Reclassification of 

Position

April 15, 2015 - PRHTA’s 

answer to Appeal and motion 

requesting dismissal filed

None None None None Pending February 10, 2016 

– Appellant filed 

Motion requesting 

the Board to 

schedule a Status 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 5 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

5

Appeal April 23, 2015 – Resolution of 

the Board denying Motion for 

Dismissal

June 17, 2015 – Motion for 

Reconsideration filed by PRHTA

June 30, 2015 – Resolution of the 

Board denying motion for 

reconsideration

Conference 

Hearing.

May 30, 2017 –

Appellant filed 

Motion requesting 

the Board to 

schedule a Status 

Conference 

Hearing.

No further 

proceedings have 

been 

held/scheduled by 

the Board.

2014-ACT-016

Márquez Ruiz, José

October 22, 2012

Appeal

Disciplinary Measure Dispute Yes.

September 7, 2015 PRTH’s filed 

its answer to the Appeal

First Set of 

Interrogatories by 

Appellants

November 30, 2015

None None None None The case is 

awaiting the 

setting of a full 

hearing.

2014-ACT-009

Santiago Gelabert, 

Micky

May 8, 2014

Appeal

Wages Claim April 14, 2016 – PRHTA’s filed 

its answer to the Appeal

None May 19, 2016 –

Hearing was 

cancelled due to 

calendar issue.

None None None May 30, 2017 –

Appellant filed

Motion requesting 

the Board to 

schedule a Status 

Conference 

Hearing.

2014-ACT-001

Vázquez Velázquez, 

Janet

Wages Claim June 1, 2015 – PRHTA’s Answer 

and Motion to Dismiss

None None None None June 5, 2017 –

Resolution: 

Dismissed for 

November 10, 

2015- Appellant 

filed Opposition to 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 6 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

6

January 10, 2014

Appeal

alleged lack of 

prosecution.

June 21, 2017 –

Appellant filed a 

Motion for 

Reconsideration 

of Dismissal of 

Appeal

Dismissal 

Request.

After determining 

to consider and 

take under 

advisement the 

request for 

reconsideration 

filed by Appellant, 

the Board

2013-ACT-005

Negrón Vélez, 

Richard

July2, 2013

Appeal

Wage and Retirement Pension 

Claims

Motion to Request 

Reconsideration of Resolution by 

Which the Rejection of the 

Appeal is Ordered

November 26, 2013

None None None A full hearing 

was scheduled 

for December 7 

2016. It was 

vacated.

October 29,2013

Final Resolution

Dismissing 

Appeal

The Resolution of 

Dismissal was 

appealed first to 

the PR Court of 

Appeals which 

confirmed the 

same. (Case No. 

KLRA 2014-000-

13) Appellant 

filed a Certiorari 

Petition before the 

Supreme Court of 

PR. The writ was 

issued and the 

dismissal 

resolution of the 

Board was 

reversed by 

Judgment of 

October 3, 2016. 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 7 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

7

Case No. CC2014-0887.

2013-ACT-003

Andino Vega, 

Mildred

April 29, 2013

Appeal

Challenge of Transfer December 19, 2013 – PRTH filed 

its Answer to the Appeal

Sept 27, 2016 –

PRTH notified written

discovery.

December 6, 2016 –

The Appellant notified 

its response to 

discovery of evidence

None Proposed Pretrial Order –

January 28, 2014

January 28, 2014 

– The Appellant 

submitted its 

Pre-trial Report.

None None None

2013-ACT-002

Villegas Levis, 

Noelis

February 26, 2013

Appeal

Challenge of Transfer May 13, 2013 – PRHTA’s 

answer to the Appeal.

May 28, 2013-

Appellant notified 

written discovery to 

PRHTA, The same has 

not been answered.

None None None None September 18, 

2013 –Appellant 

filed Motion 

Requesting a 

Hearing, and order 

regarding failure 

of PRHTA to 

answer he written 

discovery

May 30, 2017 –

Appellant filed 

Request for a 

hearing, and Order 

regarding 

PRHTA’s failure 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 8 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

8

to answer 

discovery.

2012-ACT-068

Santana, Carlos M.

October 30, 2012

Appeal

Wages Claim – Including a 

claim for a salary differential

December 18, 2013

PRTH filed its Answer to the 

Appeal.

None None None None None None

2012-ACT-063

Rivera Miranda, 

Alba Iris

October 3, 2012

Appeal

Wage Claim (Claim of salary 

differential based on additional 

and extraordinary tasks.

October 18, 2012.

PRTH filed its Answer to the 

Appeal.

November 16, 2012.

Discovery notified

Status Conference 

held on

June 6, 2013

None None None The case is 

awaiting the 

setting of a full 

hearing.

2012-ACT-051

Cruz Martínez, 

Josué

September 10, 2012

Appeal

Reclassification October 11, 2012- PRTH filed its 

Answer to the Appeal.

Parties exchanged 

Written DiscoveryOctober 10, 2012 and 

December 14, 2012, 

respectively.

Conference on the 

status of 

procedures

May 19, 2016

None None None None

2012-ACT-050

Torres Carrero, 

Brenda

September 7, 2012

Appeal

Request for Reclassification of 

Position

September 24, 2012

Answer to the Appeal

None None None None None The case is 

awaiting the 

setting of a full 

hearing.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 9 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

9

2012-ACT-041

Seda Rivera, Ivonne

August 7, 2012

Appeal

Wages Claim August 31, 2012 – PRHTA’s 

answer to the Appeal.

September 7, 2012 – PRHTA’s 

Motion to Dismiss

November 26, 2012 - Appellant 

filed its opposition to Dismissal

September 27, 2012 –

Appellant notifies 

written discovery

October 17, 2012 –

PRHTA’s notifies 

written discovery

October 19, 2012 –

Appellant’s Answer to 

written discovery

PRHTA has not 

notified its answer to 

the written discovery.

November 11, 

2012 – status 

conference

May 14, 2014 –

full hearing

scheduled, then 

vacated.

None None May 14, 2013 –

Resolution, 

Board its going 

to address the 

request for 

dismissal during 

the Full Hearing.

The case is 

awaiting the 

setting of a full 

hearing.

2012-ACT-034

Adorno Esquilin, 

Milisa

July 11, 2012

Appeal

Reclassification of Position August 15, 2012- PRHTA filed

its Answer to the Appeal.

January 12, 2016- PRHTA files a 

Motion to Dismiss

March 28, 2016- Appellant files 

Opposition to Motion to Dismiss

August 17, 2012-

PRHTA notifies written 

discovery.

November 16, 2012-

Appellant notifies 

answer to written 

discovery

November 27, 

2012- Status 

Conference

January 26, 2016-

Status conference

None None None Pending resolution 

of jurisdictional 

controversy 

created by the 

filing of 

Appellee’s motion 

to dismiss.

Stay Order entered 

on June 20, 2017.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 10 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

10

2012-ACT-028

Lilliam Miranda 

Cristobal

June 24, 2012

Appeal

Reclassification of Position August 17, 2012- PRHTA filed 

its Answer to Appeal

None November 13, 

2012- Status 

Conference

January 25, 2016-

Status Conference

February 9,

2016- Status 

Conference

March 5, 2013-

Proposed PreTrial Order 

(Report) filed

None None None

2012-ACT-019

Marrero Figueroa, 

Evelyn

May 8, 2012

Appeal

Wages Claim May 31, 2012 - PRTH filed its

Answer to Appeal

June 14, 2012 –PRTH 

notified written 

discovery.

June 28, 2012 – The 

Appellant notified its 

answer to written 

discovery

October 23, 2012

October 29, 

2015– status 

conference

Joint Proposed 

Pre-Trial 

(Report) filed on 

August 29, 2013

September 3, 

2013- Pre-Trial 

Conference

December 4, 

2013

Continuation of 

Pre-Trial

Conference

December 4, 

2013

February 2, 2016 

– canceled

May 30, 2017 –

The Appellant 

filed Motion 

requesting the 

Board to 

schedule a Full 

Hearing.

New date 

pending

2012-ACT-012

Marrero Colón, 

Edgardo

April 18, 2012

Appeal

Reclassification Yes

May 24, 2012- PRTH Appeal 

‘answer

May 24, 2012

Discovery –

June 4, 2012

July 11, 2012

Status Conference

June 25, 2013.

Pre-Trial 

HearingSeptember 12, 

2013

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 11 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

11

Pre-Trial 

HearingJanuary 9, 2014

2012-ACT-011

Colón Cruz, José

April 13, 2012

Appeal

Wage Claim Yes

December 3, 2012

Answer to the Appeal PRTH’s

Yes. 

First Interrogatories by 

PRTHA’s

December 3, 2012

Answer to 

Interrogatories by 

Appellants

July, 17, 2013

Status Conference

January 25, 2016

Pre-Trial 

Hearing

January 15, 2013

None None None

2012-ACT-010

Ortiz Sanchez, 

Coraly M.

April 10, 2010

Appeal

Wages Claim October 17, 2012 –

Answer to de Appeal PRTH’s 

May 2, 2012 –

Petitioner’s

December 9, 

2015

None None None None

2012-ACT-005

Domínguez Pérez 

Javier E.

March 27, 2012

Appeal

Reclassification of Position Yes

Answer to Appeal

May 29, 2012

First Interrogatories for 

Appellant

May 31, 2012

Answer to 

Interrogatories for the 

Appellant

March 7, 2012

Interrogatories, 

Document Production 

Requirements and 

Conference on the 

Status of 

procedures

October 2, 2012

Status of 

Procedures

January 25, 2016

Pre-Trial date

January 9, 2014

Pre-Trial date

April 8, 2014

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 12 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

12

Admissions by the 

Appellant for ACT

Octoober 31, 2012

2012-ACT-004

Cosme Rivera, 

Heriberto

March 19, 2012

Appeal

Request for Reclassification of 

Position

Yes

Answer to Appeal

May 25, 2012

First Interrogatories, 

Admissions 

Requirement and 

Document Production

May 31, 2012

Answer to 

Interrogatories for 

Appellant

September 12, 2012

October 2, 2012-

Status Conference

January 25, 2016-

Status

Conference

Proposed PreTrial filed

January 15, 2013

September 19, 

2017 (postponed)

None The case is 

awaiting the 

setting of a full 

hearing.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 13 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

13

2011-ACT-040

Ramos Quiles, 

Edwin

December 19, 2011

Appeal

September 21, 2012

Amended Appeal 

Reclassification of Position Motion requesting dismissal

July 30, 2012

October 22,2012

PRHTA filed its Answer to 

Appeal

PRHTA has not filed an answer 

to the Amended Appeal

October 22, 2012-

Appellant notified 

written Discovery 

(including 

Interrogatories, Request 

for Admissions and 

Production of 

documents)

August 7, 2013-

Status Conference 

held

None None None None

2011-ACT-028

Carmen E. Serrano 

Robles

October 31, 2011

Appeal

November 28, 2011

Amended Appeal

Claim for the Reinstatement of 

Vacation Leave Balances 

discounted by PRHTA and 

overtime

PRHTA has not filed its answer 

to the appeal

Motion to Dismiss by 

Duplication of Appeals

February 2, 2012

June 1, 2017- PRHTA filed 

Motion of Reconsideration of 

Final Partial Resolution

June 15, 2017-

Appellants filed an Opposition to 

the Motion for Reconsideration 

PRHTA

None None None None None Consolidated case 

with

2011-ACT-023

Malavé Durant, 

José

THIS 

EMPLOYEE IS 

ALSO AN 

APPELLANT IN 

CASE NO. 2011-

ACT-23 IN 

WHICH 

APPELANTS 

ARE 

PROSECUTNG 

THE SAME 

CLAIM. CASE 

NO. 2011-023 

HAS BEEN 

SETTLED BUT 

IS STILL 

ACTIVE TO A 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 14 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

14

DISPUTE 

REGARDING 

THE EXTENT 

OF THE 

SETTLEMENT

2011-ACT-027

Maria J. Haddock 

López

October 31, 2011

Appeal

Amended Appeal

November 28, 2011

Claim for the Reinstatement of 

Vacation Leave Balances 

discounted by PRHTA and 

overtime

PRHTA has not filed its answer 

to the appeal

Motion to Dismiss by 

Duplication of Appeals

February 2, 2012

June 1, 2017- PRHTA filed 

Motion of Reconsideration of 

Final Partial Resolution

June 15, 2017-

Appellants filed an Opposition to 

the Motion for Reconsideration 

PRHTA

None None None None None Consolidated case 

with

2011-ACT-023

Malavé Durant, 

José

THIS 

EMPLOYEE IS 

ALSO AN 

APPELLANT IN 

CASE NO. 2011-

ACT-23 IN 

WHICH 

APPELANTS 

ARE 

PROSEUTING 

THE SAME 

CLAIM. CASE 

NO. 2011-23 HAS 

BEEN SETTLED 

BUT IS STILL 

ACTIVE TO A 

DISPUTE 

REGARDING 

THE EXTENT 

OF THE 

SETTLEMENT

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 15 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

15

2011-ACT-023

Malavé Durant, José

October 17, 2011

Appeal

November 28, 2011

Amended Appeal

Claim for the Reinstatement of 

Vacation Leave Balances

discounted by PRHTA and 

overtime

PRHTA has not filed its answer 

to the appeal

June 1, 2017- PRHTA filed 

Motion of Reconsideration of 

Final Partial Resolution

June 15, 2017-

Appellants filed an Opposition to 

the Motion for Reconsideration 

PRHTA

None None None None May 11, 2017 

Final Partial 

Resolution and 

Order. PRHTA

filed a Motion 

for 

Reconsideration 

that was opposed 

by Appellants.

On December 16, 

2016 the parties 

filed an 

Informative 

Motion Regarding 

Settlement of the 

claim reached 

with three 

Appellants. Under 

the terms of the 

settlement the 

same conditions 

and resolution 

should be 

extended to the 

other Appellants.

2009-ACT-015

Griselle Meléndez 

Maldonado, 

Golberto Robles 

Álvarez y Arnaldo 

Ruiz Ruiz (formerly 

Myrna Santiago 

Rodríguez and 

others)

June 2, 2009

Appeal

Wages Claim

(Claim of Merit Salary 

Increases)

October 2, 2013-

PRHTA filed its Answer to the 

Appeal

June 5, 2017

Motion in Compliance with 

Order to Show Cause and in 

opposition to dismissal of appeal

None June 12, 2013-

Status Conference

None None Partial 

Resolution

May 1, 2012

(dismissing 

Appeal as to 

some of the 

original 

Appellants)

May 13, 2013 

Final Partial 

Resolution-

(dismissing 

Appeal as to 

some of the 

original 

Appellants)

The Board has not 

rule on the Motion 

to Show Cause 

filed by 

Appellants on 

June 5, 2017.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 16 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

16

May 17, 2017-

Order to Show 

Cause Why the 

Appeals should 

not be dismissed 

for Lack of 

Prosecution

2009-ACT-006

Juan A. Sánchez 

Álamo

January 15, 2009

Appeal

Wages Claim

(Claim of Merit Salary 

Increases)

March 5, 2010-PRHTA filed its 

Answer to the Appeal

March 7, 2010.

PRHTA filed Motion of 

Dismissal for lack of jurisdictionJuly 15, 2010- Motion in 

Opposition to Request for 

DismissalPRHTA notified 

written discovery

November 7, 2014-

November 7, 2014-

Appellant notified its 

Answer to 

Interrogatories

June 6, 2013, 

November 7, 

2014-

Status 

Conferences held

None None None None

2008-ACT-062

Quirindongo Díaz 

Orlando

December 18, 2008

Appeal

Classification and Retribution 

Plan

May 30, 2013- PRHTA filed its 

Answer to the Appeal

None August 4, 2013 

Status Conference

Joint Proposed 

Pre-Trial filed

December 16, 

2013

None None None

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 17 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

17

2008-ACT-061

Colón Cruz, José A.

December 12, 2008

Appeal

Wages Claim

(Claim of Merit Salary 

Increase)

January 8, 2009

PRHTA filed its Answer to 

Appeal

October 27, 2012-Appellee filed 

Motion Requesting Dismissal 

and/or Summary Judgment

May 8, 2013—Appellants filed 

their Opposition to Motion 

Requesting for Dismissal

None None Pre-Trial 

Conference 

scheduled for 

January 9, 2013) 

(vacated)

None None The Board has not 

ruled on the 

motion to dismiss 

filed by the 

PRHTA nor the 

opposition filed by 

Appellants

2008-ACT-023

Miranda Pérez, 

Lizbeth

September 15, 2008

Appeal

Wages Claim

(Claim of Merit Salary 

Increase)

October 6, 2008 – PRHTA’s 

Answer to the Appeal

March 21, 2012 – Petitioner ‘s 

filed a Summary Judgment 

Motion.

September 26, 2012 – PRTH 

filed a Summary Judgment 

Motion.

January 29, 2009 –

PRHTA

March 16, 2010 –

Appellant

June 15, 2011 -

Status conference

August 10, 2011-

Joint Proposed 

Pre-Trial Report 

filed

Pre–Trial 

Conference held

August 12, 2011-

Continuation of 

PT Conference

held and 

concluded

None October 26, 2011 

– The Parties 

stipulated the 

documentary 

evidence and 

were required to

present a 

Summary 

Judgment 

Motion.

May 15, 2013 –

argumentative 

hearing. 

Settlement 

agreement 

possibility.

None None

2008-ACT- 058

Hernández Correa, 

Felix

November 14, 2008

Wages Claim

(Claim of Merit Salary 

Increases)

June 11, 2013- PRHTA filed its 

Answer to Appeal

Motion to Dismissal

September 15, 2015

None December 3, 

2013-

Argumentative 

hearing

May 18, 2016 

Joint Proposed 

Pre-Trial Order 

filed

The Pre-Trial 

Conference was 

set for 

September 7, 

2017 (vacated 

None December 9, 2015 

The Board issued 

resolution denying 

the motion to 

dismiss

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 18 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

18

Appeal

Amended Appeal

December 18, 2008

Opposition Motion to Dismissal

October 27, 2015

September 23, 

2015- Status 

Conference held

due to stay order 

issued on June 

12, 2017.

2008-ACT-008

Martínez Matos, 

Aramis

March 28, 2012

Appeal

Claim of Payment of 

Employer’s Contribution to the 

Retirement Account 

Yes

Answer to the Appeal

October 9, 2012

Argumentative Memorandum

Appellant- February 5, 2016

Appellees’ PRTH 

April 18, 2016. 

Stipulations of Fact 

December 12, 2015.

Solicitud de Reconsideración

PRHT’s

February 21, 2017

First Interrogatories 

PRHT’s 

October 5, 2012

None None September 17, 

2015

September 25, 

2015

December 10, 

2015

January 30, 2015

Final Resolution

January 30, 2017

This an appeal 

based on 

Appellant’s claim 

that PRTH did not 

make the 

payments to the 

Public Employees 

Retirement 

System

Administration 

corresponding to 

the full salary that 

Appellant was 

earning including 

a wage differential 

he was being paid 

for interim 

functions. Because 

the Appellant was 

retired by the time 

the claim was 

filed, the same 

was filed at the 

Court of First 

Instance San Juan, 

Part. Case No.

KAC 2009-1117

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 19 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

19

The Court entered 

a summary 

Judgment 

dismissing the 

claim. The 

Appellant then 

filed an appeal 

before the Puerto 

Rico Court of 

Appeals which 

reversed the ruling 

for lack of 

jurisdiction of the 

Court of First 

Instance and 

forwarded the case 

to the PRTH’s 

Appeal Board. 

KLRA 2011-1581

2005-ACT-011

Borges Martínez, 

Nancy;

Alvarado Iglesias, 

Pedro A.;

De la Peña Saleta, 

Alejandro;

Carreras González, 

Santiago J.;

Alvarado Cartagena

Héctor;

Torres Díaz, Sonia 

N.

Wages Claim (Salary increases 

based on Merit)

November 17, 2005 – PRHTA

filed its Answer to Appeal

May 16, 2007 – The Appellant 

filed Motion requesting the Board 

to schedule a Status Conference 

Hearing.

August 16, 2007 – Amended 

Appeal was filed.

October 8, 2007 –

Appellants notified 

written discovery.

November 27, 2007 –

PRTH files objections 

to the discovery.

Discovery was 

concluded in 

consideration of the 

settlement agreement.

August 8, 2007–

Status Conference

held

October 10, 2007 

– Continuation of 

Status held

November 29, 

2007 – Pre-Trial

Conference held

November 29, 

2007 – Pre-Trial

Conference held

November 29, 

2007 – Joint PreTrial Report 

Filed.

June 18, 2008 –

During the Full 

Hearing, the 

parties informed 

they had reached 

a settlement 

agreement with 

the following 

appellants:

Nancy Borges 

Martínez, Sonia 

N. Torres Díaz, 

Pedro A. 

October 7, 2008–

Board 

acknowledged

that there is a 

settlement 

agreement with 

almost all the 

appellants.

May 23, 2012 –

Resolution and 

Order by which 

the Appellant 

June 18, 2008-The 

parties informed 

hey had reached a 

settlement 

agreement with 

the following 

appellants:

Nancy Borges 

Martínez, Sonia 

N. Torres Díaz, 

Pedro A. Alvarado 

Iglesias, Alejandro 

de la Peña Saleta y 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 20 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

20

August 8, 2005

Appeal

September 19, 2007 - PRTH 

submitted Answer to Amended 

Appeal.

May 8, 2013 -

Status Conference 

in which the 

PRTH expressed 

that the 

agreement was 

not perfected 

because the 

signature of the 

Executive 

Director was 

missing. The 

Board granted 

PRHTA 30 days 

to obtain the 

signature of the 

Executive 

Director or in its 

defect, to state the 

specific reasons

for not honoring 

the settlement 

agreement.

Alvarado 

Iglesias, 

Alejandro de la 

Peña Saleta y 

Santiago J. 

Carreras 

Santiago.

was ordered to 

show cause why 

its appeal should 

not be dismissed 

due to lack of 

prosecution.

June 6, 2012 –

Appellant files 

motion to show 

cause.

March 18, 2013 -

Resolution and 

Order for the 

PRTH to comply 

within a period 

of 30 days as 

ordered on April 

21, 2010 and 

report whether 

the payment was 

made to 

Appellants.

June 5, 2013 -

PRTH filed 

Motion on 

Request for 

Reconsideration 

stating that the 

Board lacked 

jurisdiction to 

Santiago J. 

Carreras Santiago.

Only the claim of 

Héctor Alvarado 

Cartagena remains

active.

In May 16, 2007, 

the Appellant filed 

Motion requesting 

the Board to 

schedule a Status 

Conference 

Hearing.

The Appellants

have not filed the 

Motion for 

Voluntary 

Dismissal because 

PRHTA has not 

certified the 

payment to 

Appellants 

corresponding as 

per the agreement.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 21 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

21

enter into the 

merits of any 

dispute regarding 

a draft settlement 

agreement, its 

signature and its 

compliance.

May 30, 2017 –

Resolution and

Order requiring 

the PRHTA to 

indicate whether 

or not settlement 

agreement exists.

2005-ACT-002

Aponte Rivera, 

Gonzalo

February 10, 2005

Appeal

Wage Claim Yes.

Answer to the Appeal

June 2005

None None None None None Equal treatment 

claim in the bonus 

grant.

2004-ACT-122

Aponte Rivera, 

Gonzalo

September 21, 2004

Appeal

Wage Claim Yes.

Answer to the Appeal

November 8, 2004

First Interrogatories 

notified PRHTA May 

18, 2010

February 14, 

2005

Status Conference

Status Conference

June 13, 2007

Status Conference

Abril 28, 2010

Joint Pre-Trial 

Conferences 

September 7, 

2011

None None Claim for equal 

treatment in the 

granting of wage 

increases.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 22 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

22

Status Conference

October 20, 2010

Status Conference

November 17, 

2010

Status Conference 

June 29, 2011

2004-ACT-095

Tamaris Vargas, 

Celia et al.

Original Appeal 

August 2004

October 6, 2004

Amended Appeal 

Other Appellants or 

Cases consolidated:

Alvarado Cartagena, 

Héctor

Arroyo Rosario, 

Javier

Claims arising from the 

implementation of the 2003 

Classification and Retribution 

Plan

November 18, 2004 – PRHTA’s 

Answer to Amended Appeal

February 18, 2005 – PRHTA 

filed motion requesting the 

consolidation of various appeals 

that are interrelated.

September 11, 2009 – PRHTA 

notifies a second set of 

interrogatories

August 25, 2009 –

PRHTA notifies 

discovery

October 6, 2004 –

Status conference

February 4, 2005 

– hearing

February 25, 

2009 – Pre-Trial 

Conference

June 17, 2009 -

status conference

June 6, 2012 –

status conference

None None May 2005 –

consolidated

December 21, 

2011 - Order to 

show cause

May 30, 2017 –

Order to Show 

Cause

June, 2017 –

PROMESA

June 6, 2013

Important Note:

During the course 

of the 

proceedings, the 

Board has used 

different captions 

belonging to 

several of the 

cases that were 

consolidated. The 

cases have been 

consolidated under 

case number 

2004-ACT-095.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 23 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

23

Román Tejera, 

Gustavo

Colón Correa, Isaac

Céspedes Gómez, 

Carlos

Nazario Fabre, 

Andrés

Velázquez Muñoz, 

Héctor

Cordero Quiñones, 

Ángel

Maldonado Soto, 

Iván

Travieso Figueroa, 

Ariel

Morales Martínez, 

Rafael

2004-ACT-088

Irizarry Torres, 

Nemesio & others

Hernández Morales, 

Carmelo

Valentín Torres, 

Ricardo C.

December 22, 2004

Appeal

(consolidated 2005)

Claims arising from the 

implementation of the 2003 

Classification and Retribution 

Plan

None August 25, 2009 -

PRTH notified written 

discovery

September 6, 

2017 – status 

conference 

vacated.

None None None None

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 24 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

24

2004-ACT-078

Vélez Vélez, Sonia

October 19, 2004 

Amended Appeal

Claims arising from the 

implementation of the 2003 

Classification and Retribution 

Plan

None July 7, 2005 –

Appellant notified 

written discovery

August 23, 2004–

Status conference

October 20, 2004 

– Hearing

March 2, 2005 –

hearing

December 6, 

2004 – PT 

Conference

April 18, 2007 –

status conference

August 27, 2008 

– argumentative 

hearing

April 14, 2010 –

status conference

December 3, 

2004 – Proposed 

Pre-Trial Report 

Filed

May 23, 2007 –

Amended PPTO

Filed

March 25, 2009 

– canceled 

(PRHTA without 

legal 

representation)

None May 25, 2010 –

Petitioner in a 

termination 

process

2004-ACT-049

Consolidated Cases

Colón Correa, Isaac

2004-ACT-053

Da Silva Oliveros, 

Eduardo

2004-ACT-057

Céspedes, Gómez, 

Carlos

2004-ACT-058

Claim arising from 2003 

Classification and Retribution 

Plan

Claim for loss of tenured 

position’s relative hierarchy, 

erroneous classification and 

erroneous assignment of 

compensation on the salary 

scales

Yes. None None None None None None

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 25 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

25

Nazario Fabré, 

Andrés

2004-ACT-059

Velázquez Muñoz, 

Héctor

2004-ACT-061

Cordero Quiñones, 

Luis A.

2004-ACT-062

Maldonado Soto, 

Iván

2003-ACT-023

Ruiz Alvarez, Jorge 

A.

Rivera Álvarez, 

Cruz

Negrón Vélez, 

Richard

Rossy San Miguel, 

Enrique

June 30, 2003

Appeal

September 17, 2003

Amended Appeal

Claim arising form 2003 

Classification and Retribution 

Plan

None None Status Conference

August 27, 2003

Status Conference

October 2, 2003

None None None The case is 

awaiting the 

setting of a full

hearing.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 26 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

26

2003-ACT-113 -

2005-ACT-015 –

Vega López, 

William

2003-113

December 29, 2003-

Appeal 

2005-015

November 29, 2005

Appeal

Claim arising from 2003 

Classification an Retribution 

Plan

March 9, 2004 – PRHTA’s answer

August 24, 2004 - PRHTA’s amended 

answer

2005-0014

November 29, 2005 Petition Filed

April 18, 2006

PRHTA’s amended answer

June 14, 2003 

Appellant notified 

written initiated 

discovery

November 29, 

2007 – PT 

conference

June 25, 2008 –

PT conference

September 22, 

2003 – Filed

November 12, 

2004- Pre-Trial 

Motion 

amended

September 22, 

2010-Pre ́Trial 

Motion 

amended.

Full Hearing was 

scheduled for 

September 14, 

2017, but 

cancelled due to 

lack of legal 

representation of 

the PRHTA.

None Appellant’s 

different claims 

were consolidated

in November 29, 

2007

2003-ACT-106

Ramos Camacho, 

Ramón

December 16, 2003

Appeal

May 23, 2005

Amended Appeal 

Claim arising from the 

implementation of the 2003 

Classification and 

Retribution Plan

No answer to the Appeal nor the 

Amended Appeal was found in the 

file.

May 23, 2005

PRHTA notifies 

written discovery (First 

Interrogatories and 

Request for Production 

of Documents)

Status 

Conferences held 

on November 11, 

2002, January 21, 

2005

March 14, 2005, 

June 16, 2004

September 8, 

2005 and June 6, 

2012.

June 6, 2005

Joint Proposed 

Pre-Trial Order 

filed

Pre-Trial 

Conference held 

on

June 20, 2005

The full 

evidentiary 

hearing has been 

scheduled on the 

following dates: 

January 14, 

2014,

February 27, 

2014, October 6, 

2015

None None

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 27 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

27

The case is 

pending resolution 

of the Board after 

the full hearing 

was held.

2003-ACT-068

Stella Diaz, Irma A.

October 23, 2003

Appeal

Claims arising from the 

implementation of the 2003

Classification and 

Retribution Plan

August 17, 2012- PRTHA filed its 

Answer to Appeal

December 19, 2012. 

Appellant notifies her 

Answer to 

Interrogatories notified 

by PRHTA

October16, 2013-

Status 

Conference

Pre-Trial 

Conference 

scheduled for

February 2, 

2005

(postponed)

None None None

2003-ACT-097

Pérez Guillermety, 

Irma

Appeal 

December 5, 2003

Claims arising from the 

implementation of the 2003 

Classification and 

Retribution Plan

(Error in Classification of

Position held by Appellant)

April 12, 2004

Answer to Appeal

None Status 

Conferences held

September 6, 

2017, 

June 21, 2004, 

August 18 2004

None None None None

2003-ACT-100

Hernández

Martínez, Aarón

Appeal

December 8, 2003

Amended Appeal

May 23, 2000

Claims arising from the 

implementation of the 2003 

Classification and 

Retribution Plan

None First Interrogatories 

and Request for

Production of 

Documents

March 16, 2005

First Interrogatories 

notified by PRHTA

Answer to 

Interrogatories notified 

by PRHTA

Status 

Conferences held 

on

June 16, 2004,

December 8, 

2004, November 

17, 2004, January 

21, 2005, March 

14, 2005, April 

25, 2005

December 19, 

2013

Joint Proposed 

Pre-Trial Order 

filed

Pre-Trial 

Conference 

scheduled for 

August 20, 2013

June 5, 2014

October 31, 

2014

September 29, 

2015

December 17, 

2015

None Last year the 

Appellant died. 

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 28 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

28

Answer to 

Interrogatories by 

Appellant

June 6, 2013

May 30, 2012, 

September 19, 

2012, 

November 25, 

2013

2002-ACT-018

2002-ACT-019

William Rosado 

Santiago et al

August 28, 2002

Claim for equal treatment in 

the grant of productivity 

bonuses by all management 

employees who were 

members of the Association 

of Managerial Employees as 

of filing date (522 

appellants). 

August 18, 2011

Motion for Partial Dismissal of the 

Claims filed by some of the appellants

who resigned to their positions at the 

PRTH to obtain the benefits of an 

early retirement program pursuant to 

Law 70 of 2011.

None None None None Final Partial 

Resolution

September 

27,2011

dismissing the 

appeal of the 

following 

Appellants:

José Raimundí 

Rivera

Oscar Olmeda 

Mercado

Joaquín Class 

Rodríguez

José R. Trinidad 

Cañuelas

Eduardo 

Santiago 

Miranda

Luis M. Sánchez 

Casanova

Ramón Adrián 

Suárez

None

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 29 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

29

Edgardo San 

Miguel

Carlos J. Cruz 

Carrasco

Noel López 

Torres

Blanca l. Alicea 

Medina

Daisy l. Juarbe 

Toledo

Meralys Ramos 

Delgado

Marta A. López 

Padilla

Ramonita Álamo 

Aguayo

Deliris Ramos

Edna Benítez 

Delgado

Beverly 

González 

Galloza

Karen Lee 

Gumbe Santana

Félix D. 

Hernández 

Santiago

José J. Latalladi 

Disdier

Mayda E Avilés 

Traverso

Isaura Rivera 

Galloza

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 30 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

30

Milagros 

Miranda Lloréns

Celeste Quesada 

Rodríguez

Benjamín Soto 

Peña

José R. Dávila 

Soto

Sandra Rivera 

Marrero

Reginald Ledain 

Gentillon

Santiago L.

Burgos Rolón

José L. Bayala 

Rodríguez

José E. Borges 

Núñez

Vanessa M. 

Bosques Colón

Iraida Ortíz León

Evelyn S. Colón 

Berlingeri

Maritza Giol 

Torres

Nilsa Muñoz 

Muñoz

Marilú De la 

Cruz Montañez

Carmen Rivera 

Santana

Primitiva 

Santaella Díaz

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 31 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

31

Nancy l. 

Martínez Suárez

Briseida Merced 

Acevedo

Orlando 

Almodóvar 

López

Nancy Borges 

Martínez

Rosa Rivera 

Acevedo

Fabián Delgado 

Aponte

Rafael Luna 

Díaz

Iris N. Quiñones 

Vicente

William 

Hernández 

Vázquez

Marisol Esteves 

Pérez

1997-ACT-005

Negrón Padilla, 

José A.

April 29, 1997

Wages Claim based on PR

Law 96-1956 (repealed and

replaced by Law 180-1998)

providing double penalty 

payment on unexhausted

excess of vacation leave

balances (filed in behalf of

more than 300 managerial

employees who belonged to

the Association of

Managerial Employees as of

July 24, 1997 PRTHA filed its 

Answer to Appeal

None Status 

Conferences held

on:

February 29, 

2000, Abril 16, 

2003, November 

1, 2003,

November 25, 

2013

None None None The PR Court of

Appeals reversed

an interlocutory

decision

dismissing the

claim of case of

most Appellants.

See, José Negrón

Padilla et al. vs.

Autoridad de

Carreteras y

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 32 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

32

the date of the filing of the

Appeal

Transportación, 

2002TCA2468;

Judgment entered,

October 9, 2002

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 33 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

33

1994-ACT-056

Morales, Ángel, Et

Al.

Classification and 

Retribution 2003 Plan Wage 

Claim 

None Concluded None None None November 3, 

2014

The PRHTA has 

not certified thepayment to the 

appellants.

1994-ACT013

Osvaldo Acevedo 

Acevedo, Et Al.

March 4, 1994

Appeal

Wages Claim (Case of 138 

appellants, some already 

deceased, related to the 

claim of payment of 1⁄2 extra 

hour worked daily by 

employees of construction

projects who worked 8 hours 

unlike office employees who 

worked 71/2 hours a day.)

None Concluded None None January 31, 

2016,

Final Resolution 

of the Board 

January 31, 2016 

ordering PRHTA

to perform

computation of 

the time worked 

by Appellants in 

excess of 71⁄2 

hours daily and 

pay the overtime 

compensation 

owed to 

Appellants 

within thirty (30) 

days of the 

notice of the 

Resolution.

PRHTA has never 

complied with

orders to provide 

information about 

time worked by 

the Appellants.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 34 of 35
TABLE I

Puerto Rico Highway and Transportation Authority Appeals Board

(Active Cases that have been stayed pursuant to PROMESA Title III proceedings,

No. 17 BK 3283-LTS US District Court for the District of Puerto Rico)

34

2008-ACT-042

Virella Reyes, Deliz

No information available 

insofar she is no longer 

represented by the attorneys 

for the Managerial 

Employees Association who 

represent Movants in case

Reinstatement of 

Balances of Sick 

Leave

2009- ACT-016

Virella Reyes, Deliz

No information available 

insofar she is no longer 

represented by the attorneys 

for the Managerial 

Employees Association

Reclassification

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:2844-2 Filed:04/04/18 Entered:04/04/18 20:53:05 Desc:

Exhibit 1 Page 35 of 35