# OAR Box 1828 Prepped byOllie Stewart



## Document

Number: 

# 137 ) ll-K-(B)-13 6 Docket Number: 

# A-83-2 7

Printed 11/12/200811:12:53 AM Sheet 137 of 325 P. 1P. 2 

# B ^~I— I ENERG

YAN D ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS , INC . A

_ O O m 

# O 7

j II-K-(B)-13 6 Apri l 5 , 198 4 . '

Mr . Rober t Shor t Economi c Analysi s Branc h Environmenta l Protectio n Agenc y MD-1 2 Researc hTriangl e Park , N C 2771 1 Subject : Industria l Boile r NSPS ; (1 ) Majo r Stea mUser s Economi c Impacts , an d (2 ) Backgroun

d Dat a o n Mode l Boiler s an

d Valu e Adde d fo r Selecte d Industrie s EP AContrac t No . 68-02-3536 , Tas k #3 4 Dea r Robert : Attache d ar e the thre e table s providing the remianing dat a o n the revise d economi c impac t analysi s fo r the Industria l Boile r NSP S SO

- Alternativ e Standard :

• Tabl e 1 contain s produc t pric e impact s fo r the majo r stea m users . Th e value s fo r th e element s tha t ar e use d i n computing th e pric e impact s ar e als o shown . A s yo u can see , th e impact s ar e negligibl e withi n eachindustr ygroup .

• Tabl e 2 list s th e majo r assumption s fo r th e mode l boiler s fo r eac ho f th e si x selecte d industrie s whos e impact s wer e analyze d an d sen t t o yo u o n Marc h4 , 1984 .

• Tabl e 3 present s th e valu e adde d an d valu e o f shipment s dat a use d t o calculat e cos t impact s a s a percentag e o f valu e adde d fo r th e selecte d industries ' mode l plants . Cos t impact s a s a percentag e o f valu e adde d wer e no t don e fo r the majo r stea m users , sinc e thei r impact s ar e negligibl e a s a percentag e o f tota l produc t cost . I f yo u hav e an

yquestions , pleas e giv e m e a call .



## Sincerely , /

/ / 

# 7<6JL
Kar l F . Hel d Projec t Manage r KFH/c e Enclosur e
cc : A l Weh e

Economic s / Engineerin gTABL E 1 MAJORSTEA

M USER S ECONMI C IMPACT S 1 /

Industr y

Food Textile s Pape r Chemical s Petroleu

m Refining Stone , Clay

an dGlas s Stee l Aluminu m Othe r Tota l Steam/Produc t Pric e (MMBtu/ j o f Shipments )

.003 5 .004 7 .020 4 .015 2 .004 2 .001 4 .006 0 .014 7 .000 8 .003 3 % Stea m Affecte d

15 % 8 % 6 % 18% 0 0 0.3 % 0.4 % 11 % 12 % Ne wS t (Alterna t ear

nCos tImpac t i v eNSPS-Bas eCase ) ($/MMBtu ) Lo wGa s Pric e 0.01 6 0 0.01 7 0.01 5

0 0 0.02 0 0.01 7 Hig h Ga s Pric e

0.23 9 0.18 7 0.26 7 0.28 2

0.95 0 0.25 4 0.18 3 0.24 5 Chang e i nProduc tPric e (Percent )

. Low-Ga s Pric e <0.0 1 0 <0.0 1 <0.0 1

0 0 <0.0 1 <0.0 1 Hj l j h Ga s Pric e 0.0 1 0.0 1 0.0 3 0.0 8

<0.0 1 <0.0 1 <0.0 1 0.0 1

1 / Lo w ga s pric e cas e impact s ar e base donIFCA M round3 (12/20/83) , usin g Optio nCas e Ul

result s (i.e. , 90 % scrubbing requiremen t fo r coa l an dresidua l oil-fire dboiler s >10 0 MMBtu/hr) . Highga s pric e cas e impact s ar e base do nIFCA M roun d4 (2/29/84) , using Optio n # 5 result s (i.e. , 90 % scrubbing requiremen t fo r coa l an dresidua l oil-firedboilers , wit ha 0. 4 lbSO , ceiling fo r coal-fire dboilers) . The -base case s assum e tha t the PM/N

O recommende dstandar di s inforce .

T J C OTABL E 2 MODE L BOILE R ASSUMPTION S FOR SELECTE D INDUSTRIE S

Industr y Bee t Suga r Rubbe r Reclaiming Aut o Manufacturing Petroleu

mRefining

Iron an d Stee l Liquo r Distilling Boile r Siz e (MMBtu/hr ) 

### 17 5 10 0 10 0 32 5
13 7 10 0 Capacit y

Utilizatio n (Percent ) 

### 4 5 4 5 4 5 7 5
5 5 4 5 Fue l Type s

Coa l Coa l Coa l Residua l Oi l

Coa l Coa l EP

A Regio n 

### 8

, 5 

### 5 6
5 4 Pollutio n Contro l Equipmen t

Bas e Cas e Fabri c Filte r Fabir c Filte r Fabri c Filte r

Fabri c Filte r Fabri c Filte r S0

_Alternativ e Lime SprayDrye r Lime SprayDrye r Lime SprayDrye r Once-thr u Sodiu

m FGD Lime SprayDrye r Lime SprayDrye rP. 5

TABL E 3 RATIO S O F VALUE ADDE D T O VALU E OF SHIPMENT S 

### 1 /

Selecte d Idustr

y Bee t Suga r Fruit/Veg
. Canning Rubbe r Reclaining Automobile s Petro l Refining Iron + Stee l Distille d Liquo r 

### SI C 206 3 203 3 303 1 3711,13,1 4 291 1 331 2 208 5 U.S . Valu e

Adde d 

### (io 5 

### $ ) 34 5 2,54 2 

### 2 5 36,29 2 14,42 3 15,33 2 1,15 0 U.S . Valu e

o f Shipment s (10 ° $ ) 1,18 1 6,66 2 

### 4 2 114,27 0 91,68 9 41,99 8 2,29 6 Rati o

0.2 9 0.3 8 0.6 0 0.3 2 0.1 6 0.3 6 0.5 0 Two-digi t SI C 20-3 9 Foo d Textile s Pape r Chemica l Petroleu

m Stone , Clay , Glas s Stee l Aluminu m
Othe r Tota l 

### 2 0 2 2 2 6 2 8 2 9 3 2 331 2 3315-1 7 333 4 3353-5 5 56,06 2

16,10 4 22,17 0 56,72 0 16,37 7 19,12 9 18,04 1 4,22 0
376,50 0 585,16 5 192,91 1

40,55 0 52,08 5 118,15 3 97,45 2 35,47 7 49,35 0 13,66 8
758,10 0 1,358,00 0 0.2 9

0.4 0 0.4 3 0.4 8 0.1 7 0.5 4 0.3 7 0.3 1
0.5 0 0.4 3



### 1 / 197 7 Censu s o f Manufacturers , Apri l 1981 , repor t M C 7 7 - S P - 1 .