12/29/201 1 17:4 8 FAX 202493514 2 FA A r OM S gjOOl/OO S

Timoih y li . Miller , OS B No . 8209 1 Limmillegf.'iniitlciandas.sociaie^avii.cotn Stuar t W . Smirh , OS B No . 0442 0 eiu:iTii'.miUiut'TniUeranda&^ocim.ci>avaxot n Mille r & Associate s 50(-> 5 $ WMe-idow s Rd. , Suit e 40f . Lak e Oswegn , O R9703 5 rckphonc : (503 ) .S'^R-196 6 Facsiiiiile i (503 ) 598-959. 1 Attorney s fo

i Medfyr dAi r

Service , LL C 

## '^^^i^l^PORTAl!0^ ; • vCKE IOPERAltGM S 

# HECEWfc£ > rtEARIMGDOCKE T mm. 0 A ^ 0 ,

UNITE D STATE S O FAMERIC A DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N OKKIC RO FHEARING S WASHINGTON . D.C .

Inth e Matte r

of: J . RANDOLP H BABBIT T Kedera l Aviatio nAdminisiralion ,

Complainant , FA A Cas e No . 201INM09005 4

MFDFOR D AI RSERVICE , LLC ,

Respcnden L 

# ^Mhl^S' J

ANSWE RAN D COUNTERCLAI M Fo r hi." ; answe r

t o th e Federa l Avialio nAdministration' s 0*FAA" ) Complaint , Medford Ai r Service , LL C ("Respondenl" ) admits , denies , an dallege s a s follows : I . Responden t

admit s th e allegation s inparagrap hI o f th e FAA' s Complaim . II 1 . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nII , paragrap h1 , o f th e FAA' s Pag e 1 o f

4-.ANSWE RsnoSSWM.adow ^ R«d , S,nU-40 5 1 ak rOf'^'Ceo . OrcBOr i O'O'.' i Telephone (50jif98-l?6 6 Fi»:.C.Sn.i'}59S-05<J. l12/29/201 1 17:4 8 FAX 202493514 2 FA A^ DMS [2|002/00 5

Complain L 2 . Responden t

admit s i l operate daflight o nApri l 1 5 , 2011 . Responden t denie s th e remainin g illlegaiion s containe dinSectio nFT . paragrap h2 , o f

th e FAA' s Complain L 3 . Responden i denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nIT , paragrap h3 . o f

th e FAA' s Complaint . 4 . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe dinSectio nII , paragrap h4 , o f th e FAA' s Complain L 5 . Responden t

admit s i t

use dapilo t

incommand . Responden t denie s th e remaining . allegation s containe dinSectio nII , paragrap h5 , o f th e FAA' s Complaint . a . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nII , subparagrap h5(a) , o f th e FAA' s Complain t

a s n o suc htes t

o r check s wer e required . b Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nIT , subparagrap h5(b) , o f th e FAA' s Complain t

a s n o competenc y chec k wa s required . c . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nn , subparagrap h5(c) , o f th e FAA' s Complain t

a s n o suc hflight

chec k wa s required . ili . 1 . Respoiiden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nTIT . paragrap h1 . o f

th e FAA' s Complain t a . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe dinSectio n111 , subparagrap h1(a) , o f th e FAA' s Complain L b . Responden i denie s th e allegation s containe di nSeetio nIII , subparagrap h1(b) , o f th e F.AA' s Complaint . c . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nITT , subparagrap hl(c') , o f Pac e ^ o f 4

- ANSWE RMit.i.FP . AASsocriATt

s Luk e Oi^cgu , Orcgui i flTOlS Telephon e (503 ) 59K-1''6f t raN:f.<ii).T).V))^-*>5v." i12/29/201 1 17:4 8 FA X 202493514 2 FA A - DM S [2j003/00 5

th e FAA' s ComplainL . d . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe dinSectio nTTT , subparagrap hi{d) , o f th e FAA' s Complain L e . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nTil , subparagrap h1(c) , o f th e FAA' s Complaim . f Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nm , subparagrap h1(0 , o f th e FAA' s Complaim . g . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe dinSectio nHI , subparagrap h1(g) , o f th e FAA' s Complaint . h . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe dinSectio nQI , subparagrap h1(h) , o f th e KAA' s Complain L i . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio nIII , subparagrap hl(i) , o f th e F/^A' s Complaint . J . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe dinSectio nIII . subparagrap hl(j) . o f th e FAA' s Coniplaint . 2 . Responden t

denie s th e allegation s containe di nSectio n(II , paragrap h2 , o f th e FAA' s Complaint . 3 . Re.sponden t

denie s tli c allegation s containe di nSectio nTI Lparagrap h3 , o f

th e FAA' s Complaint . / / / / / / / / / / / / Page3of4-ANS\^T R ^flLL^, Kj;. - ASiOL'lATll S fOO- ^ .S WMcadDw s P.03J , Siiili ; 40 ; 1 ik e Otwcf.i . Orego n ^10 } ^ Iclqjhoncf^O? ! 5!-'8-196 6 l••3K•^•50•^).^'>R-<)^Q 312/29/201 1 17-4 3 FA X 202493514 2 FA A ^ DM S (^004/00 5

FIRS T COUNTERCLAI M Responden t

i s entitle dt o hi s fee s an dothe r expense s incurre di ndefendin g th e FAA' s actio nagains T th e Respondent . WHEREFORE , Re.sponden t pray s for dismissa l o f

th e FAA' s Complain t

an da nawar do f al l fee s an dothe r

expense s incurre db y th e Respondent . DATE D thi s 23' " da y o f December , 2011 .

MILLE R& ASSOCIATE S 

## B y ^u^^^» ^ 'T^dtJI ^ Stuar t W . Smith , OS B No . 04420 9 stuarismiihui'mi l Icrandassociateisti vii.co m Timoth y E . Mille r

OS B No . 82091 0 li[nnii11ei(aimillerandas50ciaLesavn. c on i O f Attorney s for

Responden t

Paec4of4-ANSWE: R MILLliR A ASSOCIATI-. S ?On. S S WMcaJOA' i Road . Suic c 40 5 Lak e Oiwcgv , Oicpn nOyi'ij f Teltfphoii c (50.'! ) 5'JK-P,''ti 612/29/201 1 17:4 8 FA X 202493514 2 FA A DM S 005/00 5

4

7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 T l ^ ^ 2 3 2 4 2 5 CERTIFICAT EO FSERVIC E

I hereb y certif

y tha t I serve dth e foregoin g RESPONDENT' S ANSWE RAN D COUNTERCLAI M o nth e following: .

Federa l Aviatio nAdminisiralio n Hearin g Docke t

Clerk . AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Buildin g - Suit e 2W100 0 80 0 Independenc e Avenu e S W Washington , D C 2059 1 Fax : 1-202-493-514 2 (b y firs t clas s mail ) Davi dF . Shayn e Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counsel , ANM- 7 160 1 Lui dAvenu e S W Renton , W A 9805 7 Fax : 1-425-227-100 7 (b y firs t clas s mail ) FA A Attorne y (Origina l an d1 copy )

.r d o nthi s 2,^ ^ da y o f

December , 2011 . MILLE R& ASSOCIATE S



# C-^-^(UJ£ ^ B y i Stuart W . Smith , OS B No . 04420 9 stuaitsmith'^)millcrandas.sociatesavn.con i Tria l Attorney- . Timoih y E . Miller , OS B No . 82091 0 timniJllerirt'millefandassociatcsavn.co m O f Attorney s for

Responden t

Pag e I o M - CERTIFICAT EO FSERVIC E Mille r & Associaic i .'iOO S .SWMeadow s Road , Suit e 40 5 Lak e Oswct-o . O R9703 5 Telephon e (503)598-196 6 Fi x (503 ) S9S-959 3