8D-i

APPENDIX 8D: LIFE!CYCLE COST SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

8D.1 DESIGN LINE 1 RESULTS ........................................... 8D-1

8D.1.1 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 1 ........................ 8D-2

8D.1.1.1 Baseline .......................................... 8D-3

8D.1.1.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................. 8D-4

8D.1.1.3 High A & B Distribution ............................. 8D-5

8D.1.1.4 Low Loading ...................................... 8D-6

8D.1.1.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-7

8D.1.1.6 Low Electricity Price ................................ 8D-8

8D.1.1.7 High Electricity Price ............................... 8D-9

8D.1.1.8 Low Load Growth ................................. 8D-10

8D.1.1.9 High Load Growth ................................ 8D-11

8D.1.1.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-12

8D.1.1.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-13

8D.1.2 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 2 ....................... 8D-14

8D.1.2.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-15

8D.1.2.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-16

8D.1.2.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-17

8D.1.2.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-18

8D.1.2.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-19

8D.1.2.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-20

8D.1.2.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-21

8D.1.2.8 Low Load Growth ................................. 8D-22

8D.1.2.9 High Load Growth ................................. 8D-23

8D.1.2.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-24

8D.1.2.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-25

8D.1.3 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 3 ....................... 8D-26

8D.1.3.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-27

8D.1.3.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-28

8D.1.3.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-29

8D.1.3.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-30

8D.1.3.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-31

8D.1.3.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-32

8D.1.3.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-33

8D.1.3.8 Low Load Growth ................................. 8D-34

8D.1.3.9 High Load Growth ................................. 8D-35

8D.1.3.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-36

8D.1.3.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-37

8D.1.4 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 4 ....................... 8D-38

8D.1.4.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-39

8D.1.4.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-40
8D-ii

8D.1.4.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-41

8D.1.4.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-42

8D.1.4.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-43

8D.1.4.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-44

8D.1.4.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-45

8D.1.4.8 Low Load Growth ................................. 8D-46

8D.1.4.9 High Load Growth ................................. 8D-47

8D.1.4.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-48

8D.1.4.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-49

8D.1.5 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 5 ....................... 8D-50

8D.1.5.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-51

8D.1.5.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-52

8D.1.5.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-53

8D.1.5.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-54

8D.1.5.5 High Loading .................................... 8D-55

8D.1.5.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-56

8D.1.5.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-57

8D.1.5.8 Low Load Growth ................................. 8D-58

8D.1.5.9 High Load Growth ................................ 8D-59

8D.1.5.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-60

8D.1.5.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-61

8D.1.6 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 6 ....................... 8D-62

8D.1.6.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-63

8D.1.6.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-64

8D.1.6.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-65

8D.1.6.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-66

8D.1.6.5 High Loading .................................... 8D-67

8D.1.6.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-68

8D.1.6.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-69

8D.1.6.8 Low Load Growth ................................. 8D-70

8D.1.6.9 High Load Growth ................................ 8D-71

8D.1.6.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-72

8D.1.6.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-73

8D.2 DESIGN LINE 12 RESULTS ......................................... 8D-74

8D.2.1 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 1 ...................... 8D-75

8D.2.1.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-76

8D.2.1.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-77

8D.2.1.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-78

8D.2.1.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-79

8D.2.1.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-80

8D.2.1.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-81

8D.2.1.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-82

8D.2.1.8 Medium Load Growth .............................. 8D-83

8D.2.1.9 High Load Growth ................................. 8D-84
8D-iii

8D.2.1.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-85

8D.2.1.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-86

8D.2.2 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 2 ...................... 8D-87

8D.2.2.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-88

8D.2.2.2 Low A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-89

8D.2.2.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-90

8D.2.2.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-91

8D.2.2.5 High Loading .................................... 8D-92

8D.2.2.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-93

8D.2.2.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-94

8D.2.2.8 Medium Load Growth .............................. 8D-95

8D.2.2.9 High Load Growth ................................ 8D-96

8D.2.2.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-97

8D.2.2.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-98

8D.2.3 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 3 ...................... 8D-99

8D.2.3.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-100

8D.2.3.2 Low A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-101

8D.2.3.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-102

8D.2.3.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-103

8D.2.3.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-104

8D.2.3.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-105

8D.2.3.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-106

8D.2.3.8 Medium Load Growth ............................. 8D-107

8D.2.3.9 High Load Growth ............................... 8D-108

8D.2.3.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-109

8D.2.3.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-110

8D.2.4 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 4 ..................... 8D-111

8D.2.4.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-112

8D.2.4.2 Low A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-113

8D.2.4.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-114

8D.2.4.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-115

8D.2.4.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-116

8D.2.4.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-117

8D.2.4.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-118

8D.2.4.8 Medium Load Growth ............................. 8D-119

8D.2.4.9 High Load Growth ............................... 8D-120

8D.2.4.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-121

8D.2.4.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-122

8D.2.5 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 5 ..................... 8D-123

8D.2.5.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-124

8D.2.5.2 Low A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-125

8D.2.5.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-126

8D.2.5.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-127

8D.2.5.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-128
8D-iv

8D.2.5.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-129

8D.2.5.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-130

8D.2.5.8 Medium Load Growth ............................. 8D-131

8D.2.5.9 High Load Growth ............................... 8D-132

8D.2.5.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-133

8D.2.5.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-134

8D.2.6 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 6 ..................... 8D-135

8D.2.6.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-136

8D.2.6.2 Low A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-137

8D.2.6.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-138

8D.2.6.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-139

8D.2.6.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-140

8D.2.6.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-141

8D.2.6.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-142

8D.2.6.8 Medium Load Growth ............................. 8D-143

8D.2.6.9 High Load Growth ............................... 8D-144

8D.2.6.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-145

8D.2.6.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-146

LIST OF TABLES

Table 8D.1.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design Line 1 ............ 8D-1

Table 8D.1.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Summary Table ....................... 8D-2

Table 8D.1.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Summary Table ...................... 8D-14

Table 8D.1.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Summary Table ...................... 8D-26

Table 8D.1.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Summary Table ...................... 8D-38

Table 8D.1.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Summary Table ...................... 8D-50

Table 8D.1.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Summary Table ...................... 8D-62

Table 8D.2.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design Line 12 .......... 8D-74

Table 8D.2.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Summary Table ...................... 8D-75

Table 8D.2.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Summary Table ...................... 8D-87

Table 8D.2.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Summary Table ...................... 8D-99

Table 8D.2.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Summary Table ..................... 8D-111

Table 8D.2.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Summary Table ..................... 8D-123

Table 8D.2.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Summary Table ..................... 8D-135
8D-v

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 8D.1.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), by Scenario for Design Line 1 ............. 8D-1

Figure 8D.1.2 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate Standard

Level 1 ................................................... 8D-2

Figure 8D.1.3 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Baseline Scenario ................................... 8D-3

Figure 8D.1.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Baseline Scenario ................................... 8D-3

Figure 8D.1.5 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Baseline Scenario ................................... 8D-3

Figure 8D.1.6 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ...................... 8D-4

Figure 8D.1.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ...................... 8D-4

Figure 8D.1.8 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ...................... 8D-4

Figure 8D.1.9 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High A & B Distribution Scenario ...................... 8D-5

Figure 8D.1.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High A & B Distribution Scenario ...................... 8D-5

Figure 8D.1.11 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High A & B Distribution Scenario ...................... 8D-5

Figure 8D.1.12 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ..................... 8D-6

Figure 8D.1.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ..................... 8D-6

Figure 8D.1.14 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level:

1; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .......................... 8D-6

Figure 8D.1.15 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-7

Figure 8D.1.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-7

Figure 8D.1.17 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-7

Figure 8D.1.18 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Electricity Price Scenario ......................... 8D-8

Figure 8D.1.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Electricity Price Scenario ......................... 8D-8

Figure 8D.1.20 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Electricity Price Scenario ......................... 8D-8

Figure 8D.1.21 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Electricity Price Scenario ......................... 8D-9

Figure 8D.1.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 
8D-vi

Level: 1; High Electricity Price Scenario ......................... 8D-9

Figure 8D.1.23 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Electricity Price Scenario ......................... 8D-9

Figure 8D.1.24 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-10

Figure 8D.1.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-10

Figure 8D.1.26 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-10

Figure 8D.1.27 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-11

Figure 8D.1.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-11

Figure 8D.1.29 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-11

Figure 8D.1.30 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-12

Figure 8D.1.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-12

Figure 8D.1.32 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-12

Figure 8D.1.33 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-13

Figure 8D.1.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-13

Figure 8D.1.35 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-13

Figure 8D.1.36 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate 

Standard Level 2 .......................................... 8D-14

Figure 8D.1.37 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-15

Figure 8D.1.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-15

Figure 8D.1.39 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-15

Figure 8D.1.40 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-16

Figure 8D.1.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-16

Figure 8D.1.42 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-16
8D-vii

Figure 8D.1.43 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-17

Figure 8D.1.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-17

Figure 8D.1.45 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-17

Figure 8D.1.46 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-18

Figure 8D.1.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-18

Figure 8D.1.48 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-18

Figure 8D.1.49 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-19

Figure 8D.1.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-19

Figure 8D.1.51 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-19

Figure 8D.1.52 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-20

Figure 8D.1.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-20

Figure 8D.1.54 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-20

Figure 8D.1.55 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-21

Figure 8D.1.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-21

Figure 8D.1.57 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-21

Figure 8D.1.58 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-22

Figure 8D.1.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-22

Figure 8D.1.60 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-22

Figure 8D.1.61 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-23

Figure 8D.1.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-23

Figure 8D.1.63 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-23
8D-viii

Figure 8D.1.64 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-24

Figure 8D.1.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-24

Figure 8D.1.66 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-24

Figure 8D.1.67 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-25

Figure 8D.1.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-25

Figure 8D.1.69 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-25

Figure 8D.1.70 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate 

Standard Level 3 .......................................... 8D-26

Figure 8D.1.71 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-27

Figure 8D.1.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-27

Figure 8D.1.73 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-27

Figure 8D.1.74 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-28

Figure 8D.1.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-28

Figure 8D.1.76 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-28

Figure 8D.1.77 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-29

Figure 8D.1.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-29

Figure 8D.1.79 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level:

3; High A & B Distribution Scenario ........................... 8D-29

Figure 8D.1.80 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-30

Figure 8D.1.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-30

Figure 8D.1.82 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-30

Figure 8D.1.83 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-31

Figure 8D.1.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-31
8D-ix

Figure 8D.1.85 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate 

Standard Level: 3; High Transformer Loading Scenario ............ 8D-31

Figure 8D.1.86 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-32

Figure 8D.1.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-32

Figure 8D.1.88 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-32

Figure 8D.1.89 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-33

Figure 8D.1.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-33

Figure 8D.1.91 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-33

Figure 8D.1.92 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-34

Figure 8D.1.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-34

Figure 8D.1.94 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-34

Figure 8D.1.95 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-35

Figure 8D.1.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-35

Figure 8D.1.97 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-35

Figure 8D.1.98 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-36

Figure 8D.1.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-36

Figure 8D.1.100 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-36

Figure 8D.1.101 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-37

Figure 8D.1.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-37

Figure 8D.1.103 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-37

Figure 8D.1.104 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate 

Standard Level 4 .......................................... 8D-38

Figure 8D.1.105 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-39
8D-x

Figure 8D.1.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-39

Figure 8D.1.107 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-39

Figure 8D.1.108 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-40

Figure 8D.1.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-40

Figure 8D.1.110 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-40

Figure 8D.1.111 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-41

Figure 8D.1.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-41

Figure 8D.1.113 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-41

Figure 8D.1.114 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-42

Figure 8D.1.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-42

Figure 8D.1.116 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-42

Figure 8D.1.117 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-43

Figure 8D.1.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4;

High Transformer Loading Scenario ........................... 8D-43

Figure 8D.1.119 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-43

Figure 8D.1.120 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-44

Figure 8D.1.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-44

Figure 8D.1.122 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-44

Figure 8D.1.123 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-45

Figure 8D.1.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-45

Figure 8D.1.125 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-45

Figure 8D.1.126 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-46
8D-xi

Figure 8D.1.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-46

Figure 8D.1.128 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-46

Figure 8D.1.129 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-47

Figure 8D.1.130 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-47

Figure 8D.1.131 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-47

Figure 8D.1.132 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-48

Figure 8D.1.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-48

Figure 8D.1.134 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-48

Figure 8D.1.135 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-49

Figure 8D.1.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-49

Figure 8D.1.137 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-49

Figure 8D.1.138 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate 

Standard Level 5 .......................................... 8D-50

Figure 8D.1.139 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-51

Figure 8D.1.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-51

Figure 8D.1.141 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-51

Figure 8D.1.142 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-52

Figure 8D.1.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-52

Figure 8D.1.144 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-52

Figure 8D.1.145 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-53

Figure 8D.1.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-53

Figure 8D.1.147 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-53
8D-xii

Figure 8D.1.148 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-54

Figure 8D.1.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-54

Figure 8D.1.150 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-54

Figure 8D.1.151 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-55

Figure 8D.1.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-55

Figure 8D.1.153 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-55

Figure 8D.1.154 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-56

Figure 8D.1.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-56

Figure 8D.1.156 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-56

Figure 8D.1.157 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-57

Figure 8D.1.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-57

Figure 8D.1.159 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-57

Figure 8D.1.160 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-58

Figure 8D.1.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-58

Figure 8D.1.162 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-58

Figure 8D.1.163 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-59

Figure 8D.1.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-59

Figure 8D.1.165 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level:

5; High Load Growth Scenario ............................... 8D-59

Figure 8D.1.166 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-60

Figure 8D.1.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-60

Figure 8D.1.168 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-60
8D-xiii

Figure 8D.1.169 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-61

Figure 8D.1.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-61

Figure 8D.1.171 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-61

Figure 8D.1.172 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate 

Standard Level 6 .......................................... 8D-62

Figure 8D.1.173 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-63

Figure 8D.1.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-63

Figure 8D.1.175 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-63

Figure 8D.1.176 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-64

Figure 8D.1.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-64

Figure 8D.1.178 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-64

Figure 8D.1.179 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-65

Figure 8D.1.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-65

Figure 8D.1.181 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-65

Figure 8D.1.182 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-66

Figure 8D.1.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-66

Figure 8D.1.184 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-66

Figure 8D.1.185 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-67

Figure 8D.1.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-67

Figure 8D.1.187 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-67

Figure 8D.1.188 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-68

Figure 8D.1.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-68
8D-xiv

Figure 8D.1.190 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-68

Figure 8D.1.191 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-69

Figure 8D.1.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-69

Figure 8D.1.193 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-69

Figure 8D.1.194 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-70

Figure 8D.1.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-70

Figure 8D.1.196 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-70

Figure 8D.1.197 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-71

Figure 8D.1.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-71

Figure 8D.1.199 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-71

Figure 8D.1.200 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-72

Figure 8D.1.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-72

Figure 8D.1.202 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-72

Figure 8D.1.203 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-73

Figure 8D.1.204 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-73

Figure 8D.1.205 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-73

Figure 8D.2.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), by Scenario for Design Line 12 ........... 8D-74

Figure 8D.2.2 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12 , Candidate 

Standard Level 1 .......................................... 8D-75

Figure 8D.2.3 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-76

Figure 8D.2.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-76

Figure 8D.2.5 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-76

Figure 8D.2.6 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-77

Figure 8D.2.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 
8D-xv

Level: 1; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-77

Figure 8D.2.8 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-77

Figure 8D.2.9 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-78

Figure 8D.2.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-78

Figure 8D.2.11 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-78

Figure 8D.2.12 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-79

Figure 8D.2.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-79

Figure 8D.2.14 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-79

Figure 8D.2.15 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-80

Figure 8D.2.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-80

Figure 8D.2.17 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-80

Figure 8D.2.18 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-81

Figure 8D.2.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-81

Figure 8D.2.20 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-81

Figure 8D.2.21 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-82

Figure 8D.2.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-82

Figure 8D.2.23 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-82

Figure 8D.2.24 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Medium Load Growth Scenario ....................... 8D-83

Figure 8D.2.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Medium Load Growth Scenario ....................... 8D-83

Figure 8D.2.26 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Medium Load Growth Scenario ....................... 8D-83

Figure 8D.2.27 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-84
8D-xvi

Figure 8D.2.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-84

Figure 8D.2.29 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-84

Figure 8D.2.30 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-85

Figure 8D.2.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-85

Figure 8D.2.32 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-85

Figure 8D.2.33 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-86

Figure 8D.2.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-86

Figure 8D.2.35 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 1; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-86

Figure 8D.2.36 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12 , Candidate 

Standard Level 2 .......................................... 8D-87

Figure 8D.2.37 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-88

Figure 8D.2.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-88

Figure 8D.2.39 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Baseline Scenario .................................. 8D-88

Figure 8D.2.40 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-89

Figure 8D.2.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-89

Figure 8D.2.42 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-89

Figure 8D.2.43 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-90

Figure 8D.2.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-90

Figure 8D.2.45 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High A & B Distribution Scenario ..................... 8D-90

Figure 8D.2.46 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-91

Figure 8D.2.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-91

Figure 8D.2.48 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Transformer Loading Scenario .................... 8D-91
8D-xvii

Figure 8D.2.49 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-92

Figure 8D.2.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-92

Figure 8D.2.51 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-92

Figure 8D.2.52 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-93

Figure 8D.2.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-93

Figure 8D.2.54 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-93

Figure 8D.2.55 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-94

Figure 8D.2.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-94

Figure 8D.2.57 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Electricity Price Scenario ........................ 8D-94

Figure 8D.2.58 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Medium Load Growth Scenario ....................... 8D-95

Figure 8D.2.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Medium Load Growth Scenario ....................... 8D-95

Figure 8D.2.60 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Medium Load Growth Scenario ....................... 8D-95

Figure 8D.2.61 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-96

Figure 8D.2.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Load Growth Scenario .......................... 8D-96

Figure 8D.2.63 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level:

2; High Load Growth Scenario ............................... 8D-96

Figure 8D.2.64 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-97

Figure 8D.2.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-97

Figure 8D.2.66 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; Low Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-97

Figure 8D.2.67 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-98

Figure 8D.2.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-98

Figure 8D.2.69 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 2; High Equipment Price Scenario ....................... 8D-98
8D-xviii

Figure 8D.2.70 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12 , Candidate 

Standard Level 3 .......................................... 8D-99

Figure 8D.2.71 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-100

Figure 8D.2.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-100

Figure 8D.2.73 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-100

Figure 8D.2.74 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-101

Figure 8D.2.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-101

Figure 8D.2.76 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-101

Figure 8D.2.77 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-102

Figure 8D.2.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-102

Figure 8D.2.79 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-102

Figure 8D.2.80 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-103

Figure 8D.2.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-103

Figure 8D.2.82 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-103

Figure 8D.2.83 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-104

Figure 8D.2.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-104

Figure 8D.2.85 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-104

Figure 8D.2.86 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-105

Figure 8D.2.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-105

Figure 8D.2.88 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-105

Figure 8D.2.89 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-106

Figure 8D.2.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-106
8D-xix

Figure 8D.2.91 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-106

Figure 8D.2.92 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-107

Figure 8D.2.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-107

Figure 8D.2.94 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-107

Figure 8D.2.95 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-108

Figure 8D.2.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-108

Figure 8D.2.97 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-108

Figure 8D.2.98 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-109

Figure 8D.2.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-109

Figure 8D.2.100 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-109

Figure 8D.2.101 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-110

Figure 8D.2.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-110

Figure 8D.2.103 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 3; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-110

Figure 8D.2.104 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12 , Candidate 

Standard Level 4 ......................................... 8D-111

Figure 8D.2.105 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-112

Figure 8D.2.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-112

Figure 8D.2.107 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-112

Figure 8D.2.108 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-113

Figure 8D.2.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-113

Figure 8D.2.110 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-113

Figure 8D.2.111 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-114
8D-xx

Figure 8D.2.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-114

Figure 8D.2.113 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level:

4; High A & B Distribution Scenario .......................... 8D-114

Figure 8D.2.114 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-115

Figure 8D.2.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-115

Figure 8D.2.116 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-115

Figure 8D.2.117 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4;

High Transformer Loading Scenario .......................... 8D-116

Figure 8D.2.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-116

Figure 8D.2.119 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-116

Figure 8D.2.120 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-117

Figure 8D.2.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-117

Figure 8D.2.122 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-117

Figure 8D.2.123 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-118

Figure 8D.2.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-118

Figure 8D.2.125 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-118

Figure 8D.2.126 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-119

Figure 8D.2.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-119

Figure 8D.2.128 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-119

Figure 8D.2.129 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4;

High Load Growth Scenario ................................ 8D-120

Figure 8D.2.130 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level:

4; High Load Growth Scenario .............................. 8D-120

Figure 8D.2.131 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level:

4; High Load Growth Scenario .............................. 8D-120

Figure 8D.2.132 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4;

Low Equipment Price Scenario .............................. 8D-121
8D-xxi

Figure 8D.2.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-121

Figure 8D.2.134 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-121

Figure 8D.2.135 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-122

Figure 8D.2.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-122

Figure 8D.2.137 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 4; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-122

Figure 8D.2.138 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12 , Candidate 

Standard Level 5 ......................................... 8D-123

Figure 8D.2.139 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-124

Figure 8D.2.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-124

Figure 8D.2.141 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-124

Figure 8D.2.142 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-125

Figure 8D.2.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-125

Figure 8D.2.144 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-125

Figure 8D.2.145 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-126

Figure 8D.2.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-126

Figure 8D.2.147 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-126

Figure 8D.2.148 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-127

Figure 8D.2.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-127

Figure 8D.2.150 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-127

Figure 8D.2.151 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-128

Figure 8D.2.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-128

Figure 8D.2.153 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-128
8D-xxii

Figure 8D.2.154 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-129

Figure 8D.2.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-129

Figure 8D.2.156 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-129

Figure 8D.2.157 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-130

Figure 8D.2.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-130

Figure 8D.2.159 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-130

Figure 8D.2.160 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-131

Figure 8D.2.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-131

Figure 8D.2.162 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-131

Figure 8D.2.163 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-132

Figure 8D.2.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-132

Figure 8D.2.165 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-132

Figure 8D.2.166 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-133

Figure 8D.2.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-133

Figure 8D.2.168 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-133

Figure 8D.2.169 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-134

Figure 8D.2.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-134

Figure 8D.2.171 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 5; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-134

Figure 8D.2.172 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12, Candidate 

Standard Level 6 ......................................... 8D-135

Figure 8D.2.173 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-136

Figure 8D.2.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-136
8D-xxiii

Figure 8D.2.175 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Baseline Scenario ................................. 8D-136

Figure 8D.2.176 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-137

Figure 8D.2.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-137

Figure 8D.2.178 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-137

Figure 8D.2.179 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-138

Figure 8D.2.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-138

Figure 8D.2.181 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High A & B Distribution Scenario .................... 8D-138

Figure 8D.2.182 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-139

Figure 8D.2.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-139

Figure 8D.2.184 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Transformer Loading Scenario ................... 8D-139

Figure 8D.2.185 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-140

Figure 8D.2.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Transformer Loading Scenario .................. 8D-140

Figure 8D.2.187 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level:

6; High Transformer Loading Scenario ........................ 8D-140

Figure 8D.2.188 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-141

Figure 8D.2.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-141

Figure 8D.2.190 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-141

Figure 8D.2.191 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-142

Figure 8D.2.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-142

Figure 8D.2.193 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Electricity Price Scenario ....................... 8D-142

Figure 8D.2.194 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-143

Figure 8D.2.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-143
8D-xxiv

Figure 8D.2.196 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Medium Load Growth Scenario ...................... 8D-143

Figure 8D.2.197 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-144

Figure 8D.2.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-144

Figure 8D.2.199 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Load Growth Scenario ......................... 8D-144

Figure 8D.2.200 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-145

Figure 8D.2.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-145

Figure 8D.2.202 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; Low Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-145

Figure 8D.2.203 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-146

Figure 8D.2.204 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-146

Figure 8D.2.205 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standard 

Level: 6; High Equipment Price Scenario ...................... 8D-146
8D-1

Figure 8D.1.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), by Scenario for Design Line 1

APPENDIX 8D: LIFE!CYCLE COST SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS

8D.1 DESIGN LINE 1 RESULTS

Table 8D.1.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design Line 1

Scenario

Candidate Standard Level

1 2 3 4 5 6

Baseline 93 98 5 180 3 -688

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 342 375 246 446 241 -457

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 10 7 -72 90 -66 -754

Low Loading 84 76 -53 155 -62 -790

High Loading 101 130 73 213 87 -560

Low Electricity Price 77 73 -39 120 -87 -798

High Electricity Price 107 122 52 245 91 -575

Low Load Growth 86 65 -63 151 -79 -809

High Load Growth 100 112 32 192 36 -633

Low Equipment Price Scenario 96 109 65 278 164 -399

High Equipment Price Scenario 86 75 35 202 -56 -924
8D-2

Figure 8D.1.2 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate Standard

Level 1

8D.1.1 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 1

Table 8D.1.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Summary Table

Transformers

having LCC

Savings > $0 (%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean Payback

(Years)

Baseline 95.1 93 11.4

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 95.8 342 7.2

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 95.2 10 21.9

Low Loading 94.4 84 11.8

High Loading 95.6 101 10.7

Low Electricity Price 94.5 77 12.2

High Electricity Price 95.8 107 10.2

Low Load Growth 94.5 86 11.0

High Load Growth 95.4 100 10.9

Low Equipment Price Scenario 96.8 96 9.0

High Equipment Price Scenario 89.6 86 15.1
8D-3

Figure 8D.1.3 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.5 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1;

Baseline Scenario

8D.1.1.1 Baseline
8D-4

Figure 8D.1.6 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.8 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.1.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-5

Figure 8D.1.9 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.11 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.1.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-6

Figure 8D.1.12 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.14 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.1.4 Low Loading
8D-7

Figure 8D.1.15 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.17 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.1.5 High Loading
8D-8

Figure 8D.1.18 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.20 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.1.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-9

Figure 8D.1.21 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.23 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.1.7 High Electricity Price
8D-10

Figure 8D.1.24 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.26 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.1.8 Low Load Growth
8D-11

Figure 8D.1.27 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.29 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.1.9 High Load Growth
8D-12

Figure 8D.1.30 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.32 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.1.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-13

Figure 8D.1.33 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.35 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.1.11 High Equipment Price
8D-14

Figure 8D.1.36 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate

Standard Level 2

8D.1.2 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 2

Table 8D.1.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Summary Table

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean Payback

(Years)

Baseline 83.4 98 21.9

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 89.9 375 11.3

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 82.5 7 32.8

Low Loading 81.6 76 23.7

High Loading 86.5 130 19.4

Low Electricity Price 81.4 73 24.0

High Electricity Price 85.5 122 20.2

Low Load Growth 81.0 65 21.8

High Load Growth 85.0 112 21.5

Low Equipment Price Scenario 89.6 109 17.9

High Equipment Price Scenario 73.1 75 25.8
8D-15

Figure 8D.1.37 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.39 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2;

Baseline Scenario

8D.1.2.1 Baseline
8D-16

Figure 8D.1.40 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.42 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.2.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-17

Figure 8D.1.43 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.45 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.2.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-18

Figure 8D.1.46 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.48 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.2.4 Low Loading
8D-19

Figure 8D.1.49 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.51 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.2.5 High Loading
8D-20

Figure 8D.1.52 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.54 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.2.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-21

Figure 8D.1.55 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.57 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.2.7 High Electricity Price
8D-22

Figure 8D.1.58 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.60 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.2.8 Low Load Growth
8D-23

Figure 8D.1.61 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.63 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.2.9 High Load Growth
8D-24

Figure 8D.1.64 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.66 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.2.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-25

Figure 8D.1.67 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.69 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.2.11 High Equipment Price
8D-26

Figure 8D.1.70 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate

Standard Level 3

8D.1.3 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 3

Table 8D.1.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Summary Table

Transformers

having LCC

Savings > $0 (%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 47.2 5 36.0

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 62.3 246 19.1

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 42.9 -72 43.1

Low Loading 41.8 -53 38.8

High Loading 53.1 73 32.5

Low Electricity Price 43.1 -39 38.4

High Electricity Price 51.7 52 33.5

Low Load Growth 41.9 -63 35.5

High Load Growth 50.0 32 35.8

Low Equipment Price Scenario 64.3 65 29.8

High Equipment Price Scenario 56.5 35 25.7
8D-27

Figure 8D.1.71 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.73 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3;

Baseline Scenario

8D.1.3.1 Baseline
8D-28

Figure 8D.1.74 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.76 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.3.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-29

Figure 8D.1.77 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.79 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.3.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-30

Figure 8D.1.80 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.82 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.3.4 Low Loading
8D-31

Figure 8D.1.83 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.85 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.3.5 High Loading
8D-32

Figure 8D.1.86 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.88 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.3.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-33

Figure 8D.1.89 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.91 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.3.7 High Electricity Price
8D-34

Figure 8D.1.92 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.94 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.3.8 Low Load Growth
8D-35

Figure 8D.1.95 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.97 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.3.9 High Load Growth
8D-36

Figure 8D.1.98 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.100 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.3.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-37

Figure 8D.1.101 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.103 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.3.11 High Equipment Price
8D-38

Figure 8D.1.104 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate

Standard Level 4

8D.1.4 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 4

Table 8D.1.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Summary Table

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean Payback

(Years)

Baseline 72.3 180 15.5

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 85.7 446 13.4

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 68.4 90 16.1

Low Loading 71.1 155 15.7

High Loading 73.9 213 15.1

Low Electricity Price 65.4 120 17.0

High Electricity Price 78.5 245 14.1

Low Load Growth 71.2 151 15.4

High Load Growth 73.8 192 15.3

Low Equipment Price Scenario 91.1 278 11.0

High Equipment Price Scenario 76.9 202 15.9
8D-39

Figure 8D.1.105 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.107 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4;

Baseline Scenario

8D.1.4.1 Baseline
8D-40

Figure 8D.1.108 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.110 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.4.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-41

Figure 8D.1.111 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.113 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.4.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-42

Figure 8D.1.114 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.116 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.4.4 Low Loading
8D-43

Figure 8D.1.117 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.119 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.4.5 High Loading
8D-44

Figure 8D.1.120 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.122 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.4.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-45

Figure 8D.1.123 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.125 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.4.7 High Electricity Price
8D-46

Figure 8D.1.126 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.128 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.4.8 Low Load Growth
8D-47

Figure 8D.1.129 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.130 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.131 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.4.9 High Load Growth
8D-48

Figure 8D.1.132 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.134 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.4.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-49

Figure 8D.1.135 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.137 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.4.11 High Equipment Price
8D-50

Figure 8D.1.138 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate

Standard Level 5

8D.1.5 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 5

Table 8D.1.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Summary Table

Transformers

having LCC

Savings > $0 (%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 42.1 3 24.4

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 57.4 241 19.4

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 36.9 -66 25.9

Low Loading 36.8 -62 25.6

High Loading 47.4 87 23.0

Low Electricity Price 32.4 -87 26.8

High Electricity Price 50.1 91 22.3

Low Load Growth 35.4 -79 24.2

High Load Growth 44.7 36 24.5

Low Equipment Price Scenario 63.4 164 23.6

High Equipment Price Scenario 37.9 -56 30.2
8D-51

Figure 8D.1.139 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.141 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5;

Baseline Scenario

8D.1.5.1 Baseline
8D-52

Figure 8D.1.142 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.144 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.5.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-53

Figure 8D.1.145 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.147 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.5.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-54

Figure 8D.1.148 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.150 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.5.4 Low Loading
8D-55

Figure 8D.1.151 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.153 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.5.5 High Loading
8D-56

Figure 8D.1.154 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.156 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.5.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-57

Figure 8D.1.157 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.159 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.5.7 High Electricity Price
8D-58

Figure 8D.1.160 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.162 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.5.8 Low Load Growth
8D-59

Figure 8D.1.163 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.165 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.5.9 High Load Growth
8D-60

Figure 8D.1.166 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.168 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.5.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-61

Figure 8D.1.169 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.171 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.5.11 High Equipment Price
8D-62

Figure 8D.1.172 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate

Standard Level 6

8D.1.6 Design Line 1; Candidate Standard Level 6

Table 8D.1.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Summary Table

Transformers

having LCC

Savings > $0 (%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 9.5 -688 45.0

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 22.0 -457 31.1

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 5.6 -754 49.2

Low Loading 6.2 -790 47.8

High Loading 14.0 -560 41.6

Low Electricity Price 6.4 -798 49.4

High Electricity Price 12.9 -575 41.3

Low Load Growth 5.4 -809 44.7

High Load Growth 11.1 -633 44.7

Low Equipment Price Scenario 15.2 -399 43.7

High Equipment Price Scenario 7.3 -924 51.6
8D-63

Figure 8D.1.173 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.1.175 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6;

Baseline Scenario

8D.1.6.1 Baseline
8D-64

Figure 8D.1.176 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.178 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.6.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-65

Figure 8D.1.179 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.1.181 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High A

& B Distribution Scenario

8D.1.6.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-66

Figure 8D.1.182 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.184 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.6.4 Low Loading
8D-67

Figure 8D.1.185 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.1.187 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.1.6.5 High Loading
8D-68

Figure 8D.1.188 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.190 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.6.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-69

Figure 8D.1.191 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.193 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.1.6.7 High Electricity Price
8D-70

Figure 8D.1.194 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.196 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.6.8 Low Load Growth
8D-71

Figure 8D.1.197 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.1.199 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.1.6.9 High Load Growth
8D-72

Figure 8D.1.200 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.202 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.6.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-73

Figure 8D.1.203 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.204 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.1.205 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.1.6.11 High Equipment Price
8D-74

Figure 8D.2.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), by Scenario for Design Line 12

8D.2 DESIGN LINE 12 RESULTS

Table 8D.2.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design Line 12

Candidate Standard Level

1 2 3 4 5 6

Baseline 2,600 3,973 5,485 6,812 -650 -655

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 11,033 15,868 19,944 22,607 15,289 15,436

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 424 877 1,646 2,732 -4,641 -4,699

Low Loading 2,145 3,238 4,046 4,578 -5,234 -5,091

High Loading 2,713 4,481 6,051 8,125 1,947 1,790

Low Electricity Price 2,063 3,254 4,186 5,153 -3,705 -3,500

High Electricity Price 2,917 4,748 6,340 8,458 2,232 2,044

Medium Load Growth 2,783 4,370 6,270 8,598 2,642 2,386

High Load Growth 2,984 4,436 6,497 9,108 4,525 4,184

Low Equipment Price Scenario 2,496 3,725 4,993 6,410 1,319 1,596

High Equipment Price Scenario 2,534 4,279 5,906 7,091 -5,842 -5797
8D-75

Figure 8D.2.2 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12 ,

Candidate Standard Level 1

8D.2.1 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 1

Table 8D.2.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Summary Table

Candidate Standard Level

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 98.6 2,600 0.8

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 95.7 11,033 0.7

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 99.5 424 1.0

Low Loading 98.4 2,145 0.8

High Loading 98.6 2713 0.8

Low Electricity Price 98.4 2063 0.9

High Electricity Price 98.7 2917 0.7

Medium Load Growth 98.5 2783 0.8

High Load Growth 98.5 2984 0.8

Low Equipment Price Scenario 99.2 2496 0.7

High Equipment Price Scenario 93.8 2,534 1.9
8D-76

Figure 8D.2.3 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.5 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1;

Baseline Scenario

8D.2.1.1 Baseline
8D-77

Figure 8D.2.6 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.8 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.1.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-78

Figure 8D.2.9 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.11 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.1.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-79

Figure 8D.2.12 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.14 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.1.4 Low Loading
8D-80

Figure 8D.2.15 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.17 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.1.5 High Loading
8D-81

Figure 8D.2.18 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.20 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.1.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-82

Figure 8D.2.21 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.23 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.1.7 High Electricity Price
8D-83

Figure 8D.2.24 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.26 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1;

Medium Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.1.8 Medium Load Growth
8D-84

Figure 8D.2.27 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.29 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.1.9 High Load Growth
8D-85

Figure 8D.2.30 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.32 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.1.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-86

Figure 8D.2.33 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.35 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.1.11 High Equipment Price
8D-87

Figure 8D.2.36 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line

12 , Candidate Standard Level 2

8D.2.2 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 2

Table 8D.2.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Summary Table

Candidate Standard Level

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 98.5 3,973 1.6

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 95.4 15,868 1.4

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 99.0 877 6.5

Low Loading 98.3 3,238 1.5

High Loading 98.5 4,481 1.5

Low Electricity Price 98.0 3,254 1.8

High Electricity Price 98.2 4,748 1.3

Medium Load Growth 98.2 4,370 1.5

High Load Growth 98.4 4,436 1.6

Low Equipment Price Scenario 98.9 3,725 1.3

High Equipment Price Scenario 95.7 4,279 2.8
8D-88

Figure 8D.2.37 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.39 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2;

Baseline Scenario

8D.2.2.1 Baseline
8D-89

Figure 8D.2.40 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.42 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.2.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-90

Figure 8D.2.43 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.45 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.2.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-91

Figure 8D.2.46 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.48 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.2.4 Low Loading
8D-92

Figure 8D.2.49 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.51 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.2.5 High Loading
8D-93

Figure 8D.2.52 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.54 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.2.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-94

Figure 8D.2.55 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.57 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.2.7 High Electricity Price
8D-95

Figure 8D.2.58 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.60 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2;

Medium Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.2.8 Medium Load Growth
8D-96

Figure 8D.2.61 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.63 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.2.9 High Load Growth
8D-97

Figure 8D.2.64 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.66 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.2.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-98

Figure 8D.2.67 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.69 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.2.11 High Equipment Price
8D-99

Figure 8D.2.70 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12 ,

Candidate Standard Level 3

8D.2.3 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 3

Table 8D.2.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Summary Table

Candidate Standard Level

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 94.2 5,485 2.3

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 94.4 19,944 2.2

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 94.4 1,646 6.2

Low Loading 93.3 4,046 2.2

High Loading 94.4 6,051 2.2

Low Electricity Price 93.2 4,186 2.6

High Electricity Price 95.6 6,340 2.0

Medium Load Growth 94.8 6,270 2.3

High Load Growth 94.8 6,497 2.3

Low Equipment Price Scenario 96.3 4,993 1.8

High Equipment Price Scenario 90.6 5,906 4.4
8D-100

Figure 8D.2.71 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.73 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3;

Baseline Scenario

8D.2.3.1 Baseline
8D-101

Figure 8D.2.74 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.76 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.3.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-102

Figure 8D.2.77 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.79 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.3.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-103

Figure 8D.2.80 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.82 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.3.4 Low Loading
8D-104

Figure 8D.2.83 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.85 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.3.5 High Loading
8D-105

Figure 8D.2.86 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.88 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.3.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-106

Figure 8D.2.89 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.91 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.3.7 High Electricity Price
8D-107

Figure 8D.2.92 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.94 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3;

Medium Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.3.8 Medium Load Growth
8D-108

Figure 8D.2.95 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.97 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.3.9 High Load Growth
8D-109

Figure 8D.2.98 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.100 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.3.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-110

Figure 8D.2.101 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.103 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.3.11 High Equipment Price
8D-111

Figure 8D.2.104 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line

12 , Candidate Standard Level 4

8D.2.4 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 4

Table 8D.2.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Summary Table

Candidate Standard Level

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 81.8 6,812 3.9

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 91.2 22,607 3.1

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 78.8 2732 11.5

Low Loading 76.1 4578 4.2

High Loading 83.4 8125 3.6

Low Electricity Price 77.2 5153 4.5

High Electricity Price 84.4 8458 3.3

Medium Load Growth 83.8 8598 3.9

High Load Growth 85.0 9,108 4

Low Equipment Price Scenario 82.3 6,410 3.3

High Equipment Price Scenario 76.1 7,091 5.3
8D-112

Figure 8D.2.105 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.107 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4;

Baseline Scenario

8D.2.4.1 Baseline
8D-113

Figure 8D.2.108 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.110 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.4.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-114

Figure 8D.2.111 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.113 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.4.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-115

Figure 8D.2.114 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.116 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.4.4 Low Loading
8D-116

Figure 8D.2.117 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.119 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.4.5 High Loading
8D-117

Figure 8D.2.120 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.122 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.4.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-118

Figure 8D.2.123 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.125 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.4.7 High Electricity Price
8D-119

Figure 8D.2.126 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.128 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4;

Medium Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.4.8 Medium Load Growth
8D-120

Figure 8D.2.129 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.130 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.131 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.4.9 High Load Growth
8D-121

Figure 8D.2.132 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.134 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.4.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-122

Figure 8D.2.135 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.137 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.4.11 High Equipment Price
8D-123

Figure 8D.2.138 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line

12 , Candidate Standard Level 5

8D.2.5 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 5

Table 8D.2.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Summary Table

Candidate Standard Level

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 29.4 -650 7.0

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 66.5 15,289 5.3

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 19.9 -4641 21.2

Low Loading 19.4 -5234 7.5

High Loading 34.3 1947 6.8

Low Electricity Price 23.1 -3705 8.2

High Electricity Price 35.6 2232 6.2

Medium Load Growth 34.9 2,642 6.9

High Load Growth 40.0 4,525 7

Low Equipment Price Scenario 33.6 1,319 6.2

High Equipment Price Scenario 23.6 -5,842 8.9
8D-124

Figure 8D.2.139 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.141 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5;

Baseline Scenario

8D.2.5.1 Baseline
8D-125

Figure 8D.2.142 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.144 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.5.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-126

Figure 8D.2.145 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.147 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.5.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-127

Figure 8D.2.148 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.150 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.5.4 Low Loading
8D-128

Figure 8D.2.151 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.153 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.5.5 High Loading
8D-129

Figure 8D.2.154 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.156 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.5.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-130

Figure 8D.2.157 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.159 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.5.7 High Electricity Price
8D-131

Figure 8D.2.160 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.162 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5;

Medium Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.5.8 Medium Load Growth
8D-132

Figure 8D.2.163 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.165 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.5.9 High Load Growth
8D-133

Figure 8D.2.166 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.168 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.5.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-134

Figure 8D.2.169 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.171 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.5.11 High Equipment Price
8D-135

Figure 8D.2.172 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 12,

Candidate Standard Level 6

8D.2.6 Design Line 12; Candidate Standard Level 6

Table 8D.2.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Summary Table

Candidate Standard Level

Transformers having

LCC Savings > $0

(%)

Mean LCC

Savings ($)

Mean

Payback

(Years)

Baseline 29.9 -655 7.0

Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 66.4 15,436 5.4

High Evaluating A & B Distribution 20.5 -4,699 21.4

Low Loading 19.8 -5,091 7.4

High Loading 34.0 1,790 6.9

Low Electricity Price 23.8 -3,500 8.1

High Electricity Price 35.8 2,044 6.1

Medium Load Growth 35.9 2386 7.1

High Load Growth 38.5 4184 7.0

Low Equipment Price Scenario 34.1 1596 6.3

High Equipment Price Scenario 23.7 -5,797 8.9
8D-136

Figure 8D.2.173 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Baseline

Scenario

Figure 8D.2.175 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6;

Baseline Scenario

8D.2.6.1 Baseline
8D-137

Figure 8D.2.176 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.178 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.6.2 Low A & B Distribution
8D-138

Figure 8D.2.179 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High A & B

Distribution Scenario

Figure 8D.2.181 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

A & B Distribution Scenario

8D.2.6.3 High A & B Distribution
8D-139

Figure 8D.2.182 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.184 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.6.4 Low Loading
8D-140

Figure 8D.2.185 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

Figure 8D.2.187 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading Scenario

8D.2.6.5 High Loading
8D-141

Figure 8D.2.188 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.190 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.6.6 Low Electricity Price
8D-142

Figure 8D.2.191 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electricity Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.193 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electricity Price Scenario

8D.2.6.7 High Electricity Price
8D-143

Figure 8D.2.194 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Medium

Load Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.196 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6;

Medium Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.6.8 Medium Load Growth
8D-144

Figure 8D.2.197 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High Load

Growth Scenario

Figure 8D.2.199 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Load Growth Scenario

8D.2.6.9 High Load Growth
8D-145

Figure 8D.2.200 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.202 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.6.10 Low Equipment Price
8D-146

Figure 8D.2.203 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.204 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design

Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment Price Scenario

Figure 8D.2.205 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment Price Scenario

8D.2.6.11 High Equipment Price