8D -i 

## APPENDI X 8D: L IFE

! CYCLE COST SEN SITIVITY AN ALYSIS TABLE OF CONTENTS 8D.1 DESIGN LINE 1 RESULTS ........................................... 8D-1 8D.1.1 Design

Line 1; Candida

te Standa rd Le vel 1 ........................ 8D-2 8D.1.1.1 Baseline .......................................... 8D-3 8D.1.1.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................. 8D-4 8D.1.1.3 High A & B Distribution ............................. 8D-5 8D.1.1.4 Low Loading ...................................... 8D-6 8D.1.1.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-7 8D.1.1.6 Low Electricity Price ................................ 8D-8 8D.1.1.7 High Electricity Price ............................... 8D-9 8D.1.1.8 Low L

oad Grow th ................................. 8D-10 8D.1.1.9 High Load Grow th ................................ 8D-11 8D.1.1.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-12 8D.1.1.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-13 8D.1.2 Design

Line 1; Candida

te Standa rd Le vel 2 ....................... 8D-14 8D.1.2.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-15 8D.1.2.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................ 8D-16 8D.1.2.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-17 8D.1.2.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-18 8D.1.2.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-19 8D.1.2.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-20 8D.1.2.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-21 8D.1.2.8 Low L

oad Grow th ................................. 8D-22 8D.1.2.9 High Load Grow th ................................. 8D-23 8D.1.2.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-24 8D.1.2.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-25 8D.1.3 Design

Line 1; Candida

te Standa rd Le vel 3 ....................... 8D-26 8D.1.3.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-27 8D.1.3.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................ 8D-28 8D.1.3.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-29 8D.1.3.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-30 8D.1.3.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-31 8D.1.3.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-32 8D.1.3.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-33 8D.1.3.8 Low L

oad Grow th ................................. 8D-34 8D.1.3.9 High Load Grow th ................................. 8D-35 8D.1.3.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-36 8D.1.3.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-37 8D.1.4 Design

Line 1; Candida

te Standa rd Le vel 4 ....................... 8D-38 8D.1.4.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-39 8D.1.4.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................ 8D-408D -ii 

## 8D.1.4.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-41 8D.1.4.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-42 8D.1.4.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-43 8D.1.4.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-44 8D.1.4.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-45 8D.1.4.8 Low L

oad Grow th ................................. 8D-46 8D.1.4.9 High Load Grow th ................................. 8D-47 8D.1.4.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-48 8D.1.4.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-49 8D.1.5 Design

Line 1; Candida

te Standa rd Le vel 5 ....................... 8D-50 8D.1.5.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-51 8D.1.5.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................ 8D-52 8D.1.5.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-53 8D.1.5.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-54 8D.1.5.5 High Loading .................................... 8D-55 8D.1.5.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-56 8D.1.5.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-57 8D.1.5.8 Low L

oad Grow th ................................. 8D-58 8D.1.5.9 High Load Grow th ................................ 8D-59 8D.1.5.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-60 8D.1.5.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-61 8D.1.6 Design

Line 1; Candida

te Standa rd Le vel 6 ....................... 8D-62 8D.1.6.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-63 8D.1.6.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................ 8D-64 8D.1.6.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-65 8D.1.6.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-66 8D.1.6.5 High Loading .................................... 8D-67 8D.1.6.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-68 8D.1.6.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-69 8D.1.6.8 Low L

oad Grow th ................................. 8D-70 8D.1.6.9 High Load Grow th ................................ 8D-71 8D.1.6.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-72 8D.1.6.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-73 8D.2 DESIGN LINE 12 RESULTS ......................................... 8D-74 8D.2.1 Design

Line 12; Candid

ate Stand ard L evel 1 ...................... 8D-75 8D.2.1.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-76 8D.2.1.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................ 8D-77 8D.2.1.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-78 8D.2.1.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-79 8D.2.1.5 High Loading ..................................... 8D-80 8D.2.1.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-81 8D.2.1.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-82 8D.2.1.8 Medium Load Grow th .............................. 8D-83 8D.2.1.9 High Load Grow th ................................. 8D-848D -iii 

## 8D.2.1.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-85 8D.2.1.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-86 8D.2.2 Design

Line 12; Candid

ate Stand ard L evel 2 ...................... 8D-87 8D.2.2.1 Baseline ......................................... 8D-88 8D.2.2.2 Low A & B D istribution ............................ 8D-89 8D.2.2.3 High A & B Distribution ............................ 8D-90 8D.2.2.4 Low Loading ..................................... 8D-91 8D.2.2.5 High Loading .................................... 8D-92 8D.2.2.6 Low Electricity Price ............................... 8D-93 8D.2.2.7 High Electricity Price .............................. 8D-94 8D.2.2.8 Medium Load Grow th .............................. 8D-95 8D.2.2.9 High Load Grow th ................................ 8D-96 8D.2.2.10 Low Equipment Price .............................. 8D-97 8D.2.2.11 High Equipment Price .............................. 8D-98 8D.2.3 Design

Line 12; Candid

ate Stand ard L evel 3 ...................... 8D-99 8D.2.3.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-100 8D.2.3.2 Low A & B D istribution ........................... 8D-101 8D.2.3.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-102 8D.2.3.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-103 8D.2.3.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-104 8D.2.3.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-105 8D.2.3.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-106 8D.2.3.8 Medium Load Grow th ............................. 8D-107 8D.2.3.9 High Load Grow th ............................... 8D-108 8D.2.3.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-109 8D.2.3.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-110 8D.2.4 Design

Line 12; Candid

ate Stand ard L evel 4 ..................... 8D-111 8D.2.4.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-112 8D.2.4.2 Low A & B D istribution ........................... 8D-113 8D.2.4.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-114 8D.2.4.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-115 8D.2.4.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-116 8D.2.4.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-117 8D.2.4.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-118 8D.2.4.8 Medium Load Grow th ............................. 8D-119 8D.2.4.9 High Load Grow th ............................... 8D-120 8D.2.4.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-121 8D.2.4.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-122 8D.2.5 Design

Line 12; Candid

ate Stand ard L evel 5 ..................... 8D-123 8D.2.5.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-124 8D.2.5.2 Low A & B D istribution ........................... 8D-125 8D.2.5.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-126 8D.2.5.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-127 8D.2.5.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-1288D -iv 

## 8D.2.5.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-129 8D.2.5.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-130 8D.2.5.8 Medium Load Grow th ............................. 8D-131 8D.2.5.9 High Load Grow th ............................... 8D-132 8D.2.5.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-133 8D.2.5.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-134 8D.2.6 Design

Line 12; Candid

ate Stand ard L evel 6 ..................... 8D-135 8D.2.6.1 Baseline ........................................ 8D-136 8D.2.6.2 Low A & B D istribution ........................... 8D-137 8D.2.6.3 High A & B Distribution ........................... 8D-138 8D.2.6.4 Low Loading .................................... 8D-139 8D.2.6.5 High Loading ................................... 8D-140 8D.2.6.6 Low Electricity Price .............................. 8D-141 8D.2.6.7 High Electricity Price ............................. 8D-142 8D.2.6.8 Medium Load Grow th ............................. 8D-143 8D.2.6.9 High Load Grow th ............................... 8D-144 8D.2.6.10 Low Equipment Price ............................. 8D-145 8D.2.6.11 High Equipment Price ............................. 8D-146

LIST OF TABLE S Table 8D.1.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design L

ine 1 ............ 8D-1 Table 8D.1.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Summar

y Ta ble ....................... 8D-2 Table 8D.1.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-14 Table 8D.1.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-26 Table 8D.1.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-38 Table 8D.1.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-50 Table 8D.1.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-62 Table 8D.2.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design L

ine 12 .......... 8D-74 Table 8D.2.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-75 Table 8D.2.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-87 Table 8D.2.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Summar

y Ta ble ...................... 8D-99 Table 8D.2.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Summar

y Ta ble ..................... 8D-111 Table 8D.2.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Summar

y Ta ble ..................... 8D-123 Table 8D.2.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Summar

y Ta ble ..................... 8D-1358D -v 

## LI ST OF FIGURES Figure 8D.1.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), by Scenario for Design Line 1 ............. 8D-1 Figure 8D.1.2 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 1, Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................................... 8D-2 Figure 8D.1.3 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Base line Scenario ................................... 8D-3 Figure 8D.1.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Base line Scenario ................................... 8D-3 Figure 8D.1.5 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Base line Scenario ................................... 8D-3 Figure 8D.1.6 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ...................... 8D-4 Figure 8D.1.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ...................... 8D-4 Figure 8D.1.8 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ...................... 8D-4 Figure 8D.1.9 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ...................... 8D-5 Figure 8D.1.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ...................... 8D-5 Figure 8D.1.11 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ...................... 8D-5 Figure 8D.1.12 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ..................... 8D-6 Figure 8D.1.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ..................... 8D-6 Figure 8D.1.14 Pay

back Per iod Freq uency Chart; De sign Line: 1; Can didate Sta ndard Level: 1; Low Transformer Loading

Scenari o .......................... 8D-6 Figure 8D.1.15 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-7 Figure 8D.1.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-7 Figure 8D.1.17 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-7 Figure 8D.1.18 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ......................... 8D-8 Figure 8D.1.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ......................... 8D-8 Figure 8D.1.20 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ......................... 8D-8 Figure 8D.1.21 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ......................... 8D-9 Figure 8D.1.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard8D-vi 

## Level: 1; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ......................... 8D-9 Figure 8D.1.23 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ......................... 8D-9 Figure 8D.1.24 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-10 Figure 8D.1.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-10 Figure 8D.1.26 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-10 Figure 8D.1.27 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-11 Figure 8D.1.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-11 Figure 8D.1.29 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-11 Figure 8D.1.30 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-12 Figure 8D.1.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-12 Figure 8D.1.32 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-12 Figure 8D.1.33 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-13 Figure 8D.1.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-13 Figure 8D.1.35 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-13 Figure 8D.1.36 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 1, Candidate Standard Level 2 .......................................... 8D-14 Figure 8D.1.37 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-15 Figure 8D.1.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-15 Figure 8D.1.39 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-15 Figure 8D.1.40 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-16 Figure 8D.1.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-16 Figure 8D.1.42 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-168D -vii



## Figure 8D.1.43 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-17 Figure 8D.1.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-17 Figure 8D.1.45 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-17 Figure 8D.1.46 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-18 Figure 8D.1.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-18 Figure 8D.1.48 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-18 Figure 8D.1.49 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-19 Figure 8D.1.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-19 Figure 8D.1.51 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-19 Figure 8D.1.52 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-20 Figure 8D.1.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-20 Figure 8D.1.54 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-20 Figure 8D.1.55 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-21 Figure 8D.1.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-21 Figure 8D.1.57 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-21 Figure 8D.1.58 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-22 Figure 8D.1.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-22 Figure 8D.1.60 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-22 Figure 8D.1.61 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-23 Figure 8D.1.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-23 Figure 8D.1.63 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-238D -viii



## Figure 8D.1.64 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-24 Figure 8D.1.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-24 Figure 8D.1.66 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-24 Figure 8D.1.67 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-25 Figure 8D.1.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-25 Figure 8D.1.69 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-25 Figure 8D.1.70 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 1, Candidate Standard Level 3 .......................................... 8D-26 Figure 8D.1.71 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-27 Figure 8D.1.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-27 Figure 8D.1.73 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-27 Figure 8D.1.74 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-28 Figure 8D.1.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-28 Figure 8D.1.76 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-28 Figure 8D.1.77 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-29 Figure 8D.1.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-29 Figure 8D.1.79 Pay

back Per iod Freq uency Chart; De sign Line: 1; Can didate Sta ndard Level: 3; High A & B Dist ribution Sc enario ........................... 8D-29 Figure 8D.1.80 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-30 Figure 8D.1.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-30 Figure 8D.1.82 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-30 Figure 8D.1.83 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-31 Figure 8D.1.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-318D -ix



## Figure 8D.1.85 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ............ 8D-31 Figure 8D.1.86 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-32 Figure 8D.1.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-32 Figure 8D.1.88 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-32 Figure 8D.1.89 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-33 Figure 8D.1.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-33 Figure 8D.1.91 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-33 Figure 8D.1.92 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-34 Figure 8D.1.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-34 Figure 8D.1.94 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-34 Figure 8D.1.95 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-35 Figure 8D.1.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-35 Figure 8D.1.97 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-35 Figure 8D.1.98 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-36 Figure 8D.1.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-36 Figure 8D.1.100 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-36 Figure 8D.1.101 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-37 Figure 8D.1.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-37 Figure 8D.1.103 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-37 Figure 8D.1.104 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 1, Candidate Standard Level 4 .......................................... 8D-38 Figure 8D.1.105 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-398D -x



## Figure 8D.1.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-39 Figure 8D.1.107 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-39 Figure 8D.1.108 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-40 Figure 8D.1.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-40 Figure 8D.1.110 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-40 Figure 8D.1.111 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-41 Figure 8D.1.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-41 Figure 8D.1.113 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-41 Figure 8D.1.114 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-42 Figure 8D.1.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-42 Figure 8D.1.116 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-42 Figure 8D.1.117 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-43 Figure 8D.1.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High Tr ansformer L oading

Scenari o ........................... 8D-43 Figure 8D.1.119 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-43 Figure 8D.1.120 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-44 Figure 8D.1.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-44 Figure 8D.1.122 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-44 Figure 8D.1.123 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-45 Figure 8D.1.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-45 Figure 8D.1.125 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-45 Figure 8D.1.126 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-468D-xi



## Figure 8D.1.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-46 Figure 8D.1.128 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-46 Figure 8D.1.129 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-47 Figure 8D.1.130 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-47 Figure 8D.1.131 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-47 Figure 8D.1.132 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-48 Figure 8D.1.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-48 Figure 8D.1.134 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-48 Figure 8D.1.135 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-49 Figure 8D.1.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-49 Figure 8D.1.137 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-49 Figure 8D.1.138 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 1, Candidate Standard Level 5 .......................................... 8D-50 Figure 8D.1.139 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-51 Figure 8D.1.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-51 Figure 8D.1.141 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-51 Figure 8D.1.142 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-52 Figure 8D.1.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-52 Figure 8D.1.144 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-52 Figure 8D.1.145 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-53 Figure 8D.1.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-53 Figure 8D.1.147 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-538D -xii



## Figure 8D.1.148 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-54 Figure 8D.1.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-54 Figure 8D.1.150 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-54 Figure 8D.1.151 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-55 Figure 8D.1.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-55 Figure 8D.1.153 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-55 Figure 8D.1.154 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-56 Figure 8D.1.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-56 Figure 8D.1.156 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-56 Figure 8D.1.157 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-57 Figure 8D.1.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-57 Figure 8D.1.159 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-57 Figure 8D.1.160 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-58 Figure 8D.1.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-58 Figure 8D.1.162 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-58 Figure 8D.1.163 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-59 Figure 8D.1.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-59 Figure 8D.1.165 Pay

back Per iod Freq uency Chart; De sign Line: 1; Can didate Sta ndard Level: 5; High L oad Grow th Scenar io ............................... 8D-59 Figure 8D.1.166 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-60 Figure 8D.1.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-60 Figure 8D.1.168 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-608D -xiii



## Figure 8D.1.169 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-61 Figure 8D.1.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-61 Figure 8D.1.171 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-61 Figure 8D.1.172 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 1, Candidate Standard Level 6 .......................................... 8D-62 Figure 8D.1.173 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-63 Figure 8D.1.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-63 Figure 8D.1.175 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-63 Figure 8D.1.176 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-64 Figure 8D.1.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-64 Figure 8D.1.178 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-64 Figure 8D.1.179 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-65 Figure 8D.1.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-65 Figure 8D.1.181 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-65 Figure 8D.1.182 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-66 Figure 8D.1.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-66 Figure 8D.1.184 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-66 Figure 8D.1.185 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-67 Figure 8D.1.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-67 Figure 8D.1.187 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-67 Figure 8D.1.188 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-68 Figure 8D.1.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-688D -xiv



## Figure 8D.1.190 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-68 Figure 8D.1.191 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-69 Figure 8D.1.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-69 Figure 8D.1.193 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-69 Figure 8D.1.194 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-70 Figure 8D.1.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-70 Figure 8D.1.196 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low Loa

d Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-70 Figure 8D.1.197 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-71 Figure 8D.1.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-71 Figure 8D.1.199 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-71 Figure 8D.1.200 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-72 Figure 8D.1.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-72 Figure 8D.1.202 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-72 Figure 8D.1.203 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-73 Figure 8D.1.204 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 1; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-73 Figure 8D.1.205 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 1; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-73 Figure 8D.2.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), by Scenario for Design Line 12 ........... 8D-74 Figure 8D.2.2 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 12 , Candidate Standard Level 1 .......................................... 8D-75 Figure 8D.2.3 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-76 Figure 8D.2.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-76 Figure 8D.2.5 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-76 Figure 8D.2.6 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-77 Figure 8D.2.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard8D-xv 

## Level: 1; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-77 Figure 8D.2.8 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-77 Figure 8D.2.9 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-78 Figure 8D.2.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-78 Figure 8D.2.11 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-78 Figure 8D.2.12 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-79 Figure 8D.2.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-79 Figure 8D.2.14 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-79 Figure 8D.2.15 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-80 Figure 8D.2.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-80 Figure 8D.2.17 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-80 Figure 8D.2.18 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-81 Figure 8D.2.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-81 Figure 8D.2.20 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-81 Figure 8D.2.21 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-82 Figure 8D.2.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-82 Figure 8D.2.23 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-82 Figure 8D.2.24 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ....................... 8D-83 Figure 8D.2.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ....................... 8D-83 Figure 8D.2.26 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ....................... 8D-83 Figure 8D.2.27 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-848D-xvi



## Figure 8D.2.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-84 Figure 8D.2.29 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-84 Figure 8D.2.30 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-85 Figure 8D.2.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-85 Figure 8D.2.32 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-85 Figure 8D.2.33 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-86 Figure 8D.2.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 1; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-86 Figure 8D.2.35 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 1; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-86 Figure 8D.2.36 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 12 , Candidate Standard Level 2 .......................................... 8D-87 Figure 8D.2.37 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-88 Figure 8D.2.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-88 Figure 8D.2.39 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Base line Scenario .................................. 8D-88 Figure 8D.2.40 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-89 Figure 8D.2.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-89 Figure 8D.2.42 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io ..................... 8D-89 Figure 8D.2.43 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-90 Figure 8D.2.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-90 Figure 8D.2.45 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o ..................... 8D-90 Figure 8D.2.46 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-91 Figure 8D.2.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-91 Figure 8D.2.48 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o .................... 8D-918D -xvii



## Figure 8D.2.49 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-92 Figure 8D.2.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-92 Figure 8D.2.51 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-92 Figure 8D.2.52 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-93 Figure 8D.2.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-93 Figure 8D.2.54 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ........................ 8D-93 Figure 8D.2.55 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-94 Figure 8D.2.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-94 Figure 8D.2.57 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ........................ 8D-94 Figure 8D.2.58 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ....................... 8D-95 Figure 8D.2.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ....................... 8D-95 Figure 8D.2.60 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ....................... 8D-95 Figure 8D.2.61 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-96 Figure 8D.2.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Load Growth Sc enario .......................... 8D-96 Figure 8D.2.63 Pay

back Per iod Freq uency Chart; De sign Line: 12; Ca ndidate St

andard L evel: 2; High L oad Grow th Scenar io ............................... 8D-96 Figure 8D.2.64 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-97 Figure 8D.2.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-97 Figure 8D.2.66 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ....................... 8D-97 Figure 8D.2.67 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-98 Figure 8D.2.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 2; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-98 Figure 8D.2.69 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 2; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-988D -xviii



## Figure 8D.2.70 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 12 , Candidate Standard Level 3 .......................................... 8D-99 Figure 8D.2.71 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-100 Figure 8D.2.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-100 Figure 8D.2.73 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-100 Figure 8D.2.74 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-101 Figure 8D.2.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-101 Figure 8D.2.76 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-101 Figure 8D.2.77 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-102 Figure 8D.2.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-102 Figure 8D.2.79 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-102 Figure 8D.2.80 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-103 Figure 8D.2.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-103 Figure 8D.2.82 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-103 Figure 8D.2.83 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-104 Figure 8D.2.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-104 Figure 8D.2.85 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-104 Figure 8D.2.86 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-105 Figure 8D.2.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-105 Figure 8D.2.88 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-105 Figure 8D.2.89 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-106 Figure 8D.2.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-1068D -xix



## Figure 8D.2.91 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-106 Figure 8D.2.92 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-107 Figure 8D.2.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-107 Figure 8D.2.94 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-107 Figure 8D.2.95 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-108 Figure 8D.2.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-108 Figure 8D.2.97 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-108 Figure 8D.2.98 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-109 Figure 8D.2.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-109 Figure 8D.2.100 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-109 Figure 8D.2.101 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-110 Figure 8D.2.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 3; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-110 Figure 8D.2.103 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 3; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-110 Figure 8D.2.104 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 12 , Candidate Standard Level 4 ......................................... 8D-111 Figure 8D.2.105 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-112 Figure 8D.2.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-112 Figure 8D.2.107 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-112 Figure 8D.2.108 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-113 Figure 8D.2.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-113 Figure 8D.2.110 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-113 Figure 8D.2.111 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-1148D-xx



## Figure 8D.2.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-114 Figure 8D.2.113 Pay

back Per iod Freq uency Chart; De sign Line: 12; Ca ndidate St

andard L evel: 4; High A & B Dist ribution Sc enario .......................... 8D-114 Figure 8D.2.114 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-115 Figure 8D.2.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-115 Figure 8D.2.116 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-115 Figure 8D.2.117 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High Tr ansformer L oading

Scenari o .......................... 8D-116 Figure 8D.2.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-116 Figure 8D.2.119 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-116 Figure 8D.2.120 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-117 Figure 8D.2.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-117 Figure 8D.2.122 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-117 Figure 8D.2.123 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-118 Figure 8D.2.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-118 Figure 8D.2.125 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-118 Figure 8D.2.126 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-119 Figure 8D.2.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-119 Figure 8D.2.128 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-119 Figure 8D.2.129 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High Load Grow

th Scenar io ................................ 8D-120 Figure 8D.2.130 LCC Sav ings Cumu

lative Cha

rt; Desig n Line : 12; Candid

ate Stand ard L evel: 4; High L oad Grow th Scenar io .............................. 8D-120 Figure 8D.2.131 Pay

back Per iod Freq uency Chart; De sign Line: 12; Ca ndidate St

andard L evel: 4; High L oad Grow th Scenar io .............................. 8D-120 Figure 8D.2.132 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario .............................. 8D-1218D-xxi



## Figure 8D.2.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-121 Figure 8D.2.134 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-121 Figure 8D.2.135 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-122 Figure 8D.2.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 4; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-122 Figure 8D.2.137 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 4; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-122 Figure 8D.2.138 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 12 , Candidate Standard Level 5 ......................................... 8D-123 Figure 8D.2.139 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-124 Figure 8D.2.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-124 Figure 8D.2.141 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-124 Figure 8D.2.142 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-125 Figure 8D.2.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-125 Figure 8D.2.144 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-125 Figure 8D.2.145 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-126 Figure 8D.2.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-126 Figure 8D.2.147 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-126 Figure 8D.2.148 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-127 Figure 8D.2.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-127 Figure 8D.2.150 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-127 Figure 8D.2.151 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-128 Figure 8D.2.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-128 Figure 8D.2.153 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-1288D -xxii



## Figure 8D.2.154 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-129 Figure 8D.2.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-129 Figure 8D.2.156 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-129 Figure 8D.2.157 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-130 Figure 8D.2.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-130 Figure 8D.2.159 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-130 Figure 8D.2.160 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-131 Figure 8D.2.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-131 Figure 8D.2.162 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-131 Figure 8D.2.163 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-132 Figure 8D.2.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-132 Figure 8D.2.165 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-132 Figure 8D.2.166 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-133 Figure 8D.2.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-133 Figure 8D.2.168 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-133 Figure 8D.2.169 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-134 Figure 8D.2.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 5; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-134 Figure 8D.2.171 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 5; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-134 Figure 8D.2.172 Sensitivity of L CC to Input Changes for Desig n Line 12, Candidate Standard Level 6 ......................................... 8D-135 Figure 8D.2.173 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-136 Figure 8D.2.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-1368D -xxiii



## Figure 8D.2.175 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Base line Scenario ................................. 8D-136 Figure 8D.2.176 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-137 Figure 8D.2.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-137 Figure 8D.2.178 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low A & B D istribution Scenar io .................... 8D-137 Figure 8D.2.179 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-138 Figure 8D.2.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-138 Figure 8D.2.181 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

A & B Di stribution

Scenari o .................... 8D-138 Figure 8D.2.182 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-139 Figure 8D.2.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-139 Figure 8D.2.184 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low Transf

ormer Loading

Scenari o ................... 8D-139 Figure 8D.2.185 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-140 Figure 8D.2.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Transformer Loading

Scenari o .................. 8D-140 Figure 8D.2.187 Pay

back Per iod Freq uency Chart; De sign Line: 12; Ca ndidate St

andard L evel: 6; High T ransfor mer L oading

Scenari o ........................ 8D-140 Figure 8D.2.188 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-141 Figure 8D.2.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-141 Figure 8D.2.190 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low Electr

icity Price Sce nario ....................... 8D-141 Figure 8D.2.191 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-142 Figure 8D.2.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-142 Figure 8D.2.193 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

Electric ity Price Sce

nario ....................... 8D-142 Figure 8D.2.194 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-143 Figure 8D.2.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-1438D -xxiv



## Figure 8D.2.196 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Medium

Load Growth Sc enario ...................... 8D-143 Figure 8D.2.197 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-144 Figure 8D.2.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-144 Figure 8D.2.199 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

Load Growth Sc enario ......................... 8D-144 Figure 8D.2.200 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-145 Figure 8D.2.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-145 Figure 8D.2.202 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; Low Equipme

nt Price Sc enario ...................... 8D-145 Figure 8D.2.203 LCC Savings Frequenc y Chart; Desig

n Line: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-146 Figure 8D.2.204 Payback Period Frequency Chart; Design Line: 12; Candidate Standar d Level: 6; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-146 Figure 8D.2.205 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design L ine: 12; Candidate Standard Level: 6; High

Equipment

Price Sce nario ...................... 8D-1468D -1 Fig ure 8D .1.1 M ean LCC Savings ($), by Scenario for Design Line 1 

## APPENDI X 8D: L IFE

! CYCLE COST SEN SITIVITY AN ALYSIS 8D.1 DESIGN LINE 1 RESULTS

Table 8D.1.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design Line 1 Sce nar io Candidate Standard Level 1 2 3 4 5 6 Baseline 93 98 5 180 3 -688 Non Evalu ati ng A & B Dist ributi on 342 375 246 446 241 -457 High Eva luating A & B Distr ibution 10 7 -72 90 -66 -754 Low Load ing 84 76 -53 155 -62 -790 High Loading 101 130 73 213 87 -560 Low Electri city

Price 77 73 -39 120 -87 -798 High Electrici ty Pri ce 107 122 52 245 91 -575 Low Loa d G rowth 86 65 -63 151 -79 -809 High Loa d G rowth 100 112 32 192 36 -633 Low Eq uipm ent P rice Sc enario 96 109 65 278 164 -399 High Eq uipm ent P rice Sc enario 86 75 35 202 -56 -9248D -2 Fig ure 8D .1.2 Sensiti vity of LCC to Input Changes for Design Line 1, Candidate Standard Lev el 1 

## 8D.1.1 Design Line

1; Candidate Standard L evel 1 Table 8D.1.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Sum mary Ta ble Transformers hav in g LCC Sa vi ng s > $0 ( %) Mean LCC Savings ($) M ean Payback (Yea rs) Baseline 95.1 93 11.4 Non Evalu ati ng A & B Dist ributi on 95.8 342 7.2 High Eva luating A & B Distr ibution 95.2 10 21.9 Low Load ing 94.4 84 11.8 High Loading 95.6 101 10.7 Low Electri city

Price 94.5 77 12.2 High Electrici ty Pri ce 95.8 107 10.2 Low Loa d G rowth 94.5 86 11.0 High Loa d G rowth 95.4 100 10.9 Low Eq uipm ent P rice Sc enario 96.8 96 9.0 High Eq uipm ent P rice Sc enario 89.6 86 15.18D -3 Fig ure 8D .1.3 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Basel ine Sce nar io

Fig ure 8D .1.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Basel ine Sce nar io

Fig ure 8D .1.5 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.1.1.1 Baseline8D -4 Fig ure 8D .1.6 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Fig ure 8D .1.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Fig ure 8D .1.8 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Li ne : 1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.1.2 Low A & B Distribution8D -5 Fig ure 8D .1.9 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.11 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.1.3 High A & B Distribution8D -6 Figure 8D. 1.12 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.14 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.1.4 Low Loading8D -7 Figure 8D. 1.15 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.17 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.1.5 High Loading8D -8 Figure 8D. 1.18 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.20 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.1.6 Low Electricity Price8D -9 Figure 8D. 1.21 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.23 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.1.7 High Electricity Price8D-10 Figure 8D. 1.24 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.26 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.1.8 Low Load Growth8D-11 Figure 8D. 1.27 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.29 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.1.9 High Load Growth8D-12 Figure 8D. 1.30 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.32 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.1.10 Low Equipment Price8D-13 Figure 8D. 1.33 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.35 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.1.11 High Equipment Price8D-14 Figure 8D. 1.36 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Cha nges for Design L ine 1, Candida te

Sta nda rd L eve l 2 

## 8D.1.2 Design Line

1; Candidate Standard L evel 2 Table 8D.1.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Sum mary Ta ble Transformers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean Paybac k (Years ) Baseline 83.4 98 21.9 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 89.9 375 11.3 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 82.5 7 32.8 Low Loading 81.6 76 23.7 High Loading 86.5 130 19.4 Low Electricity

Price 81.4 73 24.0 High Electricity

Price 85.5 122 20.2 Low L oad Grow th 81.0 65 21.8 High Load Grow

th 85.0 112 21.5 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 89.6 109 17.9 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 73.1 75 25.88D-15 Figure 8D. 1.37 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.39 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.1.2.1 Baseline8D-16 Figure 8D. 1.40 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.42 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Li ne : 1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.2.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-17 Figure 8D. 1.43 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.45 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.2.3 High A & B Distribution8D-18 Figure 8D. 1.46 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.48 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.2.4 Low Loading8D-19 Figure 8D. 1.49 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.51 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.2.5 High Loading8D-20 Figure 8D. 1.52 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.54 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.2.6 Low Electricity Price8D-21 Figure 8D. 1.55 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.57 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.2.7 High Electricity Price8D-22 Figure 8D. 1.58 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.60 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.2.8 Low Load Growth8D-23 Figure 8D. 1.61 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.63 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.2.9 High Load Growth8D-24 Figure 8D. 1.64 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.66 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.2.10 Low Equipment Price8D-25 Figure 8D. 1.67 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.69 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.2.11 High Equipment Price8D-26 Figure 8D. 1.70 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Cha nges for Design L ine 1, Candida te

Sta nda rd L eve l 3 

## 8D.1.3 Design Line

1; Candidate Standard L evel 3 Table 8D.1.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Sum mary Ta ble Transformers having LCC Saving s > $0 ( %) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 47.2 5 36.0 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 62.3 246 19.1 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 42.9 -72 43.1 Low Loading 41.8 -53 38.8 High Loading 53.1 73 32.5 Low Electricity

Price 43.1 -39 38.4 High Electricity

Price 51.7 52 33.5 Low L oad Grow th 41.9 -63 35.5 High Load Grow

th 50.0 32 35.8 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 64.3 65 29.8 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 56.5 35 25.78D-27 Figure 8D. 1.71 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.73 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.1.3.1 Baseline8D-28 Figure 8D. 1.74 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.76 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Li ne : 1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.3.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-29 Figure 8D. 1.77 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.79 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.3.3 High A & B Distribution8D-30 Figure 8D. 1.80 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.82 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.3.4 Low Loading8D-31 Figure 8D. 1.83 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.85 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.3.5 High Loading8D-32 Figure 8D. 1.86 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.88 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.3.6 Low Electricity Price8D-33 Figure 8D. 1.89 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.91 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.3.7 High Electricity Price8D-34 Figure 8D. 1.92 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.94 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.3.8 Low Load Growth8D-35 Figure 8D. 1.95 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.97 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.3.9 High Load Growth8D-36 Figure 8D. 1.98 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.100 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.3.10 Low Equipment Price8D-37 Figure 8D. 1.101 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.103 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.3.11 High Equipment Price8D-38 Figure 8D. 1.104 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Cha nges for Design L ine 1, Candida te

Sta nda rd L eve l 4 

## 8D.1.4 Design Line

1; Candidate Standard L evel 4 Table 8D.1.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Sum mary Ta ble Transformers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean Paybac k (Years ) Baseline 72.3 180 15.5 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 85.7 446 13.4 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 68.4 90 16.1 Low Loading 71.1 155 15.7 High Loading 73.9 213 15.1 Low Electricity

Price 65.4 120 17.0 High Electricity

Price 78.5 245 14.1 Low L oad Grow th 71.2 151 15.4 High Load Grow

th 73.8 192 15.3 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 91.1 278 11.0 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 76.9 202 15.98D-39 Figure 8D. 1.105 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.107 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.1.4.1 Baseline8D-40 Figure 8D. 1.108 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.110 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Li ne : 1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.4.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-41 Figure 8D. 1.111 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.113 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.4.3 High A & B Distribution8D-42 Figure 8D. 1.114 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.116 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.4.4 Low Loading8D-43 Figure 8D. 1.117 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.119 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.4.5 High Loading8D-44 Figure 8D. 1.120 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.122 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.4.6 Low Electricity Price8D-45 Figure 8D. 1.123 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.125 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.4.7 High Electricity Price8D-46 Figure 8D. 1.126 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.128 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.4.8 Low Load Growth8D-47 Figure 8D. 1.129 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.130 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.131 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.4.9 High Load Growth8D-48 Figure 8D. 1.132 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.134 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.4.10 Low Equipment Price8D-49 Figure 8D. 1.135 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.137 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.4.11 High Equipment Price8D-50 Figure 8D. 1.138 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Cha nges for Design L ine 1, Candida te

Sta nda rd L eve l 5 

## 8D.1.5 Design Line

1; Candidate Standard L evel 5 Table 8D.1.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Sum mary Ta ble Transformers having LCC Saving s > $0 ( %) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 42.1 3 24.4 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 57.4 241 19.4 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 36.9 -66 25.9 Low Loading 36.8 -62 25.6 High Loading 47.4 87 23.0 Low Electricity

Price 32.4 -87 26.8 High Electricity

Price 50.1 91 22.3 Low L oad Grow th 35.4 -79 24.2 High Load Grow

th 44.7 36 24.5 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 63.4 164 23.6 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 37.9 -56 30.28D-51 Figure 8D. 1.139 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.141 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.1.5.1 Baseline8D-52 Figure 8D. 1.142 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.144 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Li ne : 1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.5.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-53 Figure 8D. 1.145 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.147 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.5.3 High A & B Distribution8D-54 Figure 8D. 1.148 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.150 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.5.4 Low Loading8D-55 Figure 8D. 1.151 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.153 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.5.5 High Loading8D-56 Figure 8D. 1.154 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.156 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.5.6 Low Electricity Price8D-57 Figure 8D. 1.157 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.159 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.5.7 High Electricity Price8D-58 Figure 8D. 1.160 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.162 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.5.8 Low Load Growth8D-59 Figure 8D. 1.163 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.165 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.5.9 High Load Growth8D-60 Figure 8D. 1.166 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.168 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.5.10 Low Equipment Price8D-61 Figure 8D. 1.169 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.171 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.5.11 High Equipment Price8D-62 Figure 8D. 1.172 Sensitivity of LCC to Input Cha nges for Design L ine 1, Candida te

Sta nda rd L eve l 6 

## 8D.1.6 Design Line

1; Candidate Standard L evel 6 Table 8D.1.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Sum mary Ta ble Transformers having LCC Saving s > $0 ( %) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 9.5 -688 45.0 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 22.0 -457 31.1 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 5.6 -754 49.2 Low Loading 6.2 -790 47.8 High Loading 14.0 -560 41.6 Low Electricity

Price 6.4 -798 49.4 High Electricity

Price 12.9 -575 41.3 Low L oad Grow th 5.4 -809 44.7 High Load Grow

th 11.1 -633 44.7 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 15.2 -399 43.7 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 7.3 -924 51.68D-63 Figure 8D. 1.173 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.175 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.1.6.1 Baseline8D-64 Figure 8D. 1.176 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.178 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Li ne : 1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.6.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-65 Figure 8D. 1.179 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.181 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.6.3 High A & B Distribution8D-66 Figure 8D. 1.182 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.184 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.6.4 Low Loading8D-67 Figure 8D. 1.185 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.187 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.6.5 High Loading8D-68 Figure 8D. 1.188 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.190 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.6.6 Low Electricity Price8D-69 Figure 8D. 1.191 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 1.193 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.1.6.7 High Electricity Price8D-70 Figure 8D. 1.194 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.196 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.6.8 Low Load Growth8D-71 Figure 8D. 1.197 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 1.199 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.1.6.9 High Load Growth8D-72 Figure 8D. 1.200 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.202 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.6.10 Low Equipment Price8D-73 Figure 8D. 1.203 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.204 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 1.205 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 1; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.1.6.11 High Equipment Price8D-74 Fig ure 8D .2.1 M ean LCC Savings ( $), b y Scenari o for Desi gn Line 12 

## 8D.2 DESIGN LINE 12 RESULTS

Table 8D.2.1 Mean LCC Savings ($), Summary Table for Design Line 12 Candidate Standard Level 1 2 3 4 5 6 Baseline 2,600 3,973 5,485 6,812 -650 -655 Non Evalu ati ng A & B Dist ributi on 11,033 15,868 19,944 22,607 15,289 15,436 High Eva luating A & B Distr ibution 424 877 1,646 2,732 -4, 641 -4, 699 Low Load ing 2,145 3,238 4,046 4,578 -5, 234 -5, 091 High Loading 2,713 4,481 6,051 8,125 1,947 1,790 Low Electri city

Price 2,063 3,254 4,186 5,153 -3, 705 -3, 500 High Electrici ty Pri ce 2,917 4,748 6,340 8,458 2,232 2,044 M edium Loa d G rowth 2,783 4,370 6,270 8,598 2,642 2,386 High Loa d G rowth 2,984 4,436 6,497 9,108 4,525 4,184 Low Eq uipm ent P rice Sc enario 2,496 3,725 4,993 6,410 1,319 1,596 High Eq uipm ent P rice Sc enario 2,534 4,279 5,906 7,091 -5, 842 -57978D-75 Fig ure 8D .2.2 Sensi tivity of LCC to Inp ut Changes f or Desi gn Line 12 , Ca ndid ate S tan dar d Le vel 1 

## 8D.2.1 Design Line

12; Candidate Standard L evel 1 Table 8D.2.2 Candidate Standard Level: 1; Sum mary Ta ble Candidate Standard Level Transform ers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 98.6 2,600 0.8 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 95.7 11,033 0.7 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 99.5 424 1.0 Low Loading 98.4 2,145 0.8 High Loading 98.6 2713 0.8 Low Electricity

Price 98.4 2063 0.9 High Electricity

Price 98.7 2917 0.7 Medium Load Grow

th 98.5 2783 0.8 High Load Grow

th 98.5 2984 0.8 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 99.2 2496 0.7 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 93.8 2,534 1.98D-76 Fig ure 8D .2.3 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Basel ine Sce nar io

Fig ure 8D .2.4 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Basel ine Sce nar io

Fig ure 8D .2.5 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.2.1.1 Baseline8D-77 Fig ure 8D .2.6 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Fig ure 8D .2.7 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Fig ure 8D .2.8 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.1.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-78 Fig ure 8D .2.9 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.10 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 1; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.11 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.1.3 High A & B Distribution8D-79 Figure 8D. 2.12 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.13 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.14 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.1.4 Low Loading8D-80 Figure 8D. 2.15 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.16 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.17 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.1.5 High Loading8D-81 Figure 8D. 2.18 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.19 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.20 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.1.6 Low Electricity Price8D-82 Figure 8D. 2.21 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.22 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.23 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.1.7 High Electricity Price8D-83 Figure 8D. 2.24 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.25 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.26 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; M ediu m L oad Gro w th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.1.8 Medium Load Growth8D-84 Figure 8D. 2.27 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.28 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.29 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.1.9 High Load Growth8D-85 Figure 8D. 2.30 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.31 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.32 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.1.10 Low Equipment Price8D-86 Figure 8D. 2.33 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.34 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.35 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 1; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.1.11 High Equipment Price8D-87 Figure 8D. 2.36 Sensi tivity of LCC to Inp ut Changes f or Desi gn Line 12 , C and idate Stan dar d Le vel 2 

## 8D.2.2 Design Line

12; Candidate Standard L evel 2 Table 8D.2.3 Candidate Standard Level: 2; Sum mary Ta ble Candidate Standard Level Transform ers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 98.5 3,973 1.6 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 95.4 15,868 1.4 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 99.0 877 6.5 Low Loading 98.3 3,238 1.5 High Loading 98.5 4,481 1.5 Low Electricity

Price 98.0 3,254 1.8 High Electricity

Price 98.2 4,748 1.3 Medium Load Grow

th 98.2 4,370 1.5 High Load Grow

th 98.4 4,436 1.6 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 98.9 3,725 1.3 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 95.7 4,279 2.88D-88 Figure 8D. 2.37 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.38 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.39 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.2.2.1 Baseline8D-89 Figure 8D. 2.40 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.41 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.42 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.2.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-90 Figure 8D. 2.43 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.44 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 2; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.45 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.2.3 High A & B Distribution8D-91 Figure 8D. 2.46 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.47 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.48 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.2.4 Low Loading8D-92 Figure 8D. 2.49 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.50 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.51 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.2.5 High Loading8D-93 Figure 8D. 2.52 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.53 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.54 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.2.6 Low Electricity Price8D-94 Figure 8D. 2.55 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.56 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.57 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.2.7 High Electricity Price8D-95 Figure 8D. 2.58 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.59 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.60 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; M ediu m L oad Gro w th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.2.8 Medium Load Growth8D-96 Figure 8D. 2.61 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.62 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.63 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.2.9 High Load Growth8D-97 Figure 8D. 2.64 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.65 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.66 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.2.10 Low Equipment Price8D-98 Figure 8D. 2.67 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.68 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.69 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 2; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.2.11 High Equipment Price8D-99 Figure 8D. 2.70 Sensi tivity of LCC to Inp ut Changes f or Desi gn Line 12 , Ca ndid ate S tan dar d Le vel 3 

## 8D.2.3 Design Line

12; Candidate Standard L evel 3 Table 8D.2.4 Candidate Standard Level: 3; Sum mary Ta ble Candidate Standard Level Transform ers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 94.2 5,485 2.3 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 94.4 19,944 2.2 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 94.4 1,646 6.2 Low Loading 93.3 4,046 2.2 High Loading 94.4 6,051 2.2 Low Electricity

Price 93.2 4,186 2.6 High Electricity

Price 95.6 6,340 2.0 Medium Load Grow

th 94.8 6,270 2.3 High Load Grow

th 94.8 6,497 2.3 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 96.3 4,993 1.8 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 90.6 5,906 4.48D-100 Figure 8D. 2.71 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.72 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.73 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.2.3.1 Baseline8D-101 Figure 8D. 2.74 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.75 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.76 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.3.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-102 Figure 8D. 2.77 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.78 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 3; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.79 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.3.3 High A & B Distribution8D-103 Figure 8D. 2.80 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.81 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.82 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.3.4 Low Loading8D-104 Figure 8D. 2.83 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.84 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.85 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.3.5 High Loading8D-105 Figure 8D. 2.86 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.87 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.88 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.3.6 Low Electricity Price8D-106 Figure 8D. 2.89 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.90 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.91 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.3.7 High Electricity Price8D-107 Figure 8D. 2.92 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.93 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.94 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; M ediu m L oad Gro w th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.3.8 Medium Load Growth8D-108 Figure 8D. 2.95 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.96 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.97 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.3.9 High Load Growth8D-109 Figure 8D. 2.98 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.99 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.100 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.3.10 Low Equipment Price8D-110 Figure 8D. 2.101 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.102 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.103 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 3; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.3.11 High Equipment Price8D-111 Figure 8D. 2.104 Sensi tivity of LCC to Inp ut Changes f or Desi gn Line 12 , C and idate Stan dar d Le vel 4 

## 8D.2.4 Design Line

12; Candidate Standard L evel 4 Table 8D.2.5 Candidate Standard Level: 4; Sum mary Ta ble Candidate Standard Level Transform ers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 81.8 6,812 3.9 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 91.2 22,607 3.1 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 78.8 2732 11.5 Low Loading 76.1 4578 4.2 High Loading 83.4 8125 3.6 Low Electricity

Price 77.2 5153 4.5 High Electricity

Price 84.4 8458 3.3 Medium Load Grow

th 83.8 8598 3.9 High Load Grow

th 85.0 9,108 4 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 82.3 6,410 3.3 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 76.1 7,091 5.38D-112 Figure 8D. 2.105 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.106 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.107 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.2.4.1 Baseline8D-113 Figure 8D. 2.108 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.109 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.110 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.4.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-114 Figure 8D. 2.111 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.112 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 4; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.113 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.4.3 High A & B Distribution8D-115 Figure 8D. 2.114 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.115 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.116 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.4.4 Low Loading8D-116 Figure 8D. 2.117 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.118 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.119 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.4.5 High Loading8D-117 Figure 8D. 2.120 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.121 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.122 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.4.6 Low Electricity Price8D-118 Figure 8D. 2.123 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.124 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.125 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.4.7 High Electricity Price8D-119 Figure 8D. 2.126 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.127 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.128 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; M ediu m L oad Gro w th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.4.8 Medium Load Growth8D-120 Figure 8D. 2.129 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.130 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.131 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.4.9 High Load Growth8D-121 Figure 8D. 2.132 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.133 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.134 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.4.10 Low Equipment Price8D-122 Figure 8D. 2.135 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.136 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.137 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 4; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.4.11 High Equipment Price8D-123 Figure 8D. 2.138 Sensi tivity of LCC to Inp ut Changes f or Desi gn Line 12 , C and idate Stan dar d Le vel 5 

## 8D.2.5 Design Line

12; Candidate Standard L evel 5 Table 8D.2.6 Candidate Standard Level: 5; Sum mary Ta ble Candidate Standard Level Transform ers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 29.4 -650 7.0 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 66.5 15,289 5.3 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 19.9 -4641 21.2 Low Loading 19.4 -5234 7.5 High Loading 34.3 1947 6.8 Low Electricity

Price 23.1 -3705 8.2 High Electricity

Price 35.6 2232 6.2 Medium Load Grow

th 34.9 2,642 6.9 High Load Grow

th 40.0 4,525 7 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 33.6 1,319 6.2 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 23.6 -5,842 8.98D-124 Figure 8D. 2.139 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.140 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.141 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.2.5.1 Baseline8D-125 Figure 8D. 2.142 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.143 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.144 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.5.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-126 Figure 8D. 2.145 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.146 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 5; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.147 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.5.3 High A & B Distribution8D-127 Figure 8D. 2.148 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.149 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.150 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.5.4 Low Loading8D-128 Figure 8D. 2.151 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.152 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.153 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.5.5 High Loading8D-129 Figure 8D. 2.154 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.155 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.156 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.5.6 Low Electricity Price8D-130 Figure 8D. 2.157 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.158 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.159 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.5.7 High Electricity Price8D-131 Figure 8D. 2.160 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.161 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.162 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; M ediu m L oad Gro w th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.5.8 Medium Load Growth8D-132 Figure 8D. 2.163 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.164 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.165 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.5.9 High Load Growth8D-133 Figure 8D. 2.166 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.167 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.168 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.5.10 Low Equipment Price8D-134 Figure 8D. 2.169 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.170 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.171 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 5; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.5.11 High Equipment Price8D-135 Figure 8D. 2.172 Sensi tivity of LCC to Inp ut Changes f or Desi gn Line 12, Ca ndid ate S tan dar d Le vel 6 

## 8D.2.6 Design Line

12; Candidate Standard L evel 6 Table 8D.2.7 Candidate Standard Level: 6; Sum mary Ta ble Candidate Standard Level Transform ers having LCC Savings > $0 (%) Mean LCC

Savings ($) Mean

Payback (Years) Baseline 29.9 -655 7.0 Non Evaluating A & B Distribution 66.4 15,436 5.4 High Evaluating A & B D istribution 20.5 -4,699 21.4 Low Loading 19.8 -5,091 7.4 High Loading 34.0 1,790 6.9 Low Electricity

Price 23.8 -3,500 8.1 High Electricity

Price 35.8 2,044 6.1 Medium Load Grow

th 35.9 2386 7.1 High Load Grow

th 38.5 4184 7.0 Low E quipment Pr

ice Scenario 34.1 1596 6.3 High Equ ipment Pric e Scena

rio 23.7 -5,797 8.98D-136 Figure 8D. 2.173 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.174 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Basel ine Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.175 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Ba seline S cen ario 

## 8D.2.6.1 Baseline8D-137 Figure 8D. 2.176 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.177 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Lo w A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.178 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.6.2 Low A & B Distribution8D-138 Figure 8D. 2.179 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.180 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12 ; Can di da te St an da rd Le ve l : 6; Hi gh A & B Distr ibutio n Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.181 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High A & B D istribu tion S cen ario 

## 8D.2.6.3 High A & B Distribution8D-139 Figure 8D. 2.182 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.183 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.184 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.6.4 Low Loading8D-140 Figure 8D. 2.185 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.186 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.187 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Tra nsfo rme r Lo adin g Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.6.5 High Loading8D-141 Figure 8D. 2.188 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.189 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.190 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.6.6 Low Electricity Price8D-142 Figure 8D. 2.191 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.192 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io

Figure 8D. 2.193 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Elec tricity Pric e Sce nar io 

## 8D.2.6.7 High Electricity Price8D-143 Figure 8D. 2.194 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.195 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Medium Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.196 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; M ediu m L oad Gro w th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.6.8 Medium Load Growth8D-144 Figure 8D. 2.197 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.198 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Load Gr ow th Sc ena rio

Figure 8D. 2.199 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Lo ad G row th Sc ena rio 

## 8D.2.6.9 High Load Growth8D-145 Figure 8D. 2.200 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.201 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.202 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; Low Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.6.10 Low Equipment Price8D-146 Figure 8D. 2.203 LCC Savings Frequency Chart; Design Line:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario

Figure 8D. 2.204 Payback Peri od Frequency Chart ; Desi gn

Line: 12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario Figure 8D. 2.205 LCC Savings Cumulative Chart; Design Li ne:

12; Candidat e Standard Level: 6; High Eq uipm ent P rice S cen ario 

## 8D.2.6.11 High Equipment Price