12/30/201 0 12:2 8 FAX202493514 2 FA A ^ DMS glOOI/OO B

Michae l Selig , MD , FACC , CFI- H 281 6 0refiel d Roa d Allentown , PA . 1810 4 

### CFRART^IEN TO F •^•-^'^^SPORTATIO N ' B OPERATION S OE C 2 ! a n



## 5 1 '^EARIN G D">CKE T riif i nr r~ r U.S . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C , Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Cynthi a DorTiinik . Laur a Pcnto , Laiony a Wiiliam s Complainant s M & R Helicopters , LLC . Responden t FA ACase : No : 20095095043 4 Federa l Docket . No : 2010-121 1

RESPONDENT' S MOTIO N FO R JUDGMEN TT O DISMIS S 4 FAILUR E T

O RESPON D O R MEE

TFILIN G DEADLINE S O N 8 PLEADING S AN D NOW , come s respondent , MICHAE LB . SELIG , MD , FACC , CFI-H , principl e fo rM & R Helicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operationa l sinc e 2009 ) who m aver s an d file s th e followin g MOTIO N FOR JUDGMEN Tsinc e th e co^-^^'.o'.-.cr.' i hav e faile d t o respon d o ranswe rfilin g deadline s i n accordanc e t o §13.218(d) . 1 . O n Jul y21 , 2009 , FA AOfficers , Latony a William s an d Kimm yPoo n appeare d fo ra n initia l inspectio n a tth e join toffic e o fLifelin e Cardiolog yan d M R Helicopters , LLC . 2 . Th e allege d violatio n to rM rBake raccordin g t o M s William s Inspecto r Statemen tlO P 9 record , wa s du e t o "inabilit yt o fin d FA Aapprove d dru g an d 1 o f412/30/201 0 12:2 3 FAX202493514 2 FA A- DMS 0002/00 6

alcoho l testin g progro m informatio n fo rFligh tMethods" . M rBake rwa s no t employe d b yFligh tMethods , bu tb yAi rMethod s Corporation , therefor e M s William s erre d i n thi s fundamenta l fac tdrivin g th e violation . 3 . M s William s faile d t o perfor m wit h du e diligenc e an d i n goo d fait h a n investigatio n confirmin g tha tM rBake rwa s no to n a dru g an d alcoho l program , th e sol e premis e fo rdrivin g th e violation . Counse l is boun d b yjudicia l estoppel s fo ran yotHe " c'cims . 4 . O n Octobe r21 , 2010 , MR H wa s serve d wit h a Fina l Notic e o fPropose d Civi l Penalty , citin g a potentia l fin e o f$540 0 (Fift yFou rHundre d Dollars) . Thi s occurre d ove r1 yea rlater , pas tth e statu e o flimitation s an d therefor e tim e barred . 5 . O n Octobe r27 , 201 0 a certifie d lette rwa s sen t t o M s Pont o requestin g discovery . To dat e n o objectio n o rproductio n ha s bee n receive d pas tth e 3 0 da ydeadlin e an d I n violatio n t o § Rul e 13.220(d) . 6 . O n Novembe r24 , 2010 , a lette rwa s faxe d an d sen tt o M s Ponto s deportmen tremindin g the m o foutstandin g issues , no t oddi-esse d '' •^^o ^ C dc y deadlin e perio d i n violatio n t o §13.218(d ) o ri n th e 3 0 da ydeadlin e period , i n violatio n t o § Rul e 13.220(d ) (Exhibi t1-faxconfirmatio n sheet) . 7 . O n Novembe r27 , 2010 , PreliminaryObjection s wa s faxe d an d submitte d t o M s Ponto s department , t o whic h n o objectio n o ranswe rwa s submitte d i n th e 1 0 da ydeadlin e perio d i n violatio n t o §13.2l8(d ) Exhibi t 1-fa x confirmatio n sheet) . 2 o f4r* * + nMS 01003/00 8

12/30/201 0 12:2 8 FA X202493514 2 FA AUH i

8 . O n Novembe r27 , 2010 , a lette rt o M s Ponto s departmen twa s faxe d an d sent , remindin g he ro fth e requeste d hearin g transcript s (Exhibi t 1-fa x confirmatio n sheet) . 9 . O n Novembe r29 , 2010 , a Motio n an d Brieft o Quash , Strike o rDismiss Complain twa s faxe d an d sen tt o M rPonto s department , t o whic h n o objectio n o ranswer s hav e bee n receive d withi n th e 1 0 da ydeadlin e unde r§ Rul e 13.220(d ) '^x^'b' ' •-TC XccnfirmiaTio n sheer) . 10 . No wi n additio n t o th e abov e 5 document s tha thav e no tbee n objecte d t o o ranswere d t o thi s dote , o n Novembe r30 , 2010 , a motio n t o Strike Allegatio n wa s faxe d an d sen tt o M s Ponto s departmen tt o vvhic h n o objectio n o ranswe rwa s receive d withi n th e 1 0 da ydeadlin e unde r§ Rul e 13.220(d ) (Exhibi t1-fa

xconfirmatio n sheet) . 11 . O n Decembe r1 , 2010 , a Motio n fo rDepositio n o fLatony a William s wa s faxe d an d sen tt o M rPonto s department , t o whic h n o objectio n o ranswer s hav e bee n receive d withi n th e 1 0 da ydeadlin e unde r§ Rul e 13.220( d 12 . O n Decembe r2 , 2010 , a Motio n t o Compe l Discoverywc s 'cxeo ' an d .sentt o MrPonto s department , T O whic h n o objectio n o ranswer s hav e bee n receive d withi n th e 1 0 da ydeadlin e unde r§ Rul e 13.220(d) . 11 . Ther e I

s n o reaso n fo rcounse l t o no tb e abl e t o respon d t o an y8 o f th e abov e deadlin e date s I n accordanc e t o th e FA ARule s o tCivi l Penalt y Proceeding s 1 4 C.F.R . §13.1 6 an d subpar tG , a s th e Offic e o fChie fCounse l employ s man yattorneys , handle s thousand s o fviolation s yearl yan d therefor e 3 o f4+ QM S @1004/00 G 12/30/201 0 12:2 8 FAX202493514 2 F^A

alternative s ar e readil yavailabl e t o cove ro rsubstitut e fo rvacation , illnes s o r othe rreasons . 12 . Thi s cas e doe s no thav e exclusiv e authorit yo fonl yM s Ponto , a s ther e hov e alread ybee n othe rIntervenin g attorney s tha thav e reviewe d o r bee n involve d i n th e case , includin g Pete rLynch , Esq. , (lette rOctobe r21 , 2010 , (exhibi t1) , Charie s Raley , Esq . (Octobe r1 , 201 0 telephon e hearing , transcript. s outstanding! , M s Cynif^i cZ;c~-;r;k , =sq . iTeiepnon e cal l Decembe r8 , 2010) , therefore , ther e is n o excus e o rreaso n fo rabsen to rlat e filin g o fobjection s o r answer s unde ran ypremis e fo ral l th e abov e 8 documents . 13 . Defendan tdoe s no t agre e t o an yfor m o fcontinuanc e as th e cas e basi s i s frivolou s a tbes tfro m th e onset , du e t o insufficiency , erre d claim s an d no wmultipl e procedura l mishaps . WHEREFORE , th e responden tpray s tha tthi s Honorabl e Cour t wil l gran t th e Motio n fo rjudgmen tt o dismis s th e cas e du e t o unresponsiv e on d absen tfiling s i n accordanc e l o Rule s § 13.220(d ) an d § 13.220(d) . Respectfull ySubmitted , Michae l B . Selig , MD , FACC , CFI- H 

### Dat e \\\ \ C^^A" ^ 

# ^X^ ^

4 o f412/30/201 0 12:2 8 FA X202483514 2 11/30/201 0 6:14P M KA X FA A si.an ; Time . Addres s + DM S gl005/00 G IgOOOiJ No . Mod e VH.Kf . Res u l. t 1.1/1.9
- 12:5 3 P M 11/2 1 05:4 4 P

M .1/2 4 06:0 5 P

M .1.1./2 7 07:2 6 A

M 1.1/2 7 10:0 4 AJ

l 11/2. 9 10:0 3 P

W 11/.3 0 06:1 3 PJl 61 0 77 0 983 4

610434052 0 120226-7,'5l0 6 1202267510 6 12022875.10 6 1202267i510 C 1202287510 6 500 3 007 1 007 2 007 3 007 4 007 5 Aut o R

X S«n d Sen d Sftn d Sen d Sen d 007 0 Sfeii d EC U RC M KCA f EC M rjc M liC M iCC M 4 O

K

4 3 7 O K O K 00'4 1 4 2 2 O K O K O K 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 2 2 7 2 5 1 9 IO K 02'4 4 06'S O 00'5 6



## c^lnh t [12/30/201 0 12:2 8 FA X202483514 2 FA A + DM S gl006/00 6

U.S . DEPARTMEN TO fTRANSPORTATIO N Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Cynthi a Dominik , Laur a Ponto , Latony a William s Complainant s M & R Helicopters . LLC . Respondon t FA ACas e 2009SO95043 4 V . CERTIFICAT E O F SER ' I HEREB YCERTIF

Ytha t I hav e thi s da yserv t foregoin g entriofs l RESPONDEN

TS MOTIO N FOR JUDGMEN TT O DISMIS S 4 FAILUR E T

O RESPON D O R MEE

Tf-ILIN G DFADLINI^ S O N 8 PLEADING S upo n al l partie s o frecor d i n thi s proceeding , i n accordanc e wit h th e requirement s o fRul e 2 9 pursuan tt o 2 8 U . .S

. C . § 1746 , Servic e b yfirsl-clos s mail , postqq e preooid , addresse d o s follows : Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Wilbu rWrightAvenue-Suit e 2W100 0 Washington , D.C . 2069 1 Aft : Hearin g Docke tClerk , AGC-43 0 Th e Honorabl e Ronni e A . Yode r U S Departmen to fTransportatio n Ofric e o tHearings , M-20 , Roo m El 2 32 0 1200 Ne wJerse yAvenue . S.E . Washington , D C 2059 0 Cynthi a Dominik , Esq , Enforcemen tDivision/AGC-30 0 Oiflc e J- " :;~. e C'le rCounse l FA A 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W yyaSMngton , D C 2059 1 ''V^'AX20 2 26 7 5I0 6 By: . Michae l B . Selig , MD , FAC C 281 6 Orefiel d Roo d Allentown . Po . 18104 61 0 36 0 395 3 Date : 

# O 

# l^K ^

_\^-V^ ^