03/24/2010 10:18 FAX 2024835142 FAA 0021008 A.N!IJ.-'1 

### 141 002

SCOT 

### r R. MORKt!) I:I\A OFrIC[; OF RRC!O'NAL COUNSEL 1601 LiND 1\**Yl~"** SW RGN'r<)N, W 1\:)1 I1'NGTON 98057**TF.LI.~PHONE:** 425,22,7,1417 FACSJMILW 425,217.1007 

### UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DEPARTMENT OF 

### TRANSPORTATION 

## OFFICE 

## OF HEARINGS**WASHJNGTON~** 

### D.C.

In th<: Muttet of; fAA DOCKET CP 09NM0008 FAA Case N(), 2008NM210025 DMS No. FAA-2009-0103 Judge Goodwin 

### -----,-,--­ ,----'---_.,_.­



### COM'PLAINANT'S RI<:SPONSI;:' 

### TO**lU~SPONOENT'S** S\JPPLEMENTA.L f)ISCOVF,RY' lU:QUJi:ST COlllplainl responds 

### to Respondent's supplemental 

### discovery request as 

### follows: 8UI)PLEMENTAL BEQUEST FOR PRODUCTION NO.1: Provide a 

### copy ofthc leIters 

## \.lr closure issued 

### by the FAA to each of the Great Lakes Aviation flighl crewmembers who wcr.e inve-stigated 

### by the FAA regarding the allegedly reversed squat switc,h wires at**issu~~** in this dispuTe.**hN~WER:** Objection, as this material is totally irrelevant lo these proceedil\g::> as 

### the tk:cision on 

### wh(;thcr or**n~)l** lo pllrsue celtitlcate 

### action is orle ofproseculorial 

### discretion left solely 

### to d1C Administratol'. Withl)u1 waiving said objection, attached are redacte<J unsigned copies of fOlll" letters**rc~ponsive** to Lhis**r~quest.** The signed copies ofthese documems 

### would have been destroyed six momhs after there;: issuance consistent with the Agency's expungcmcnl policy. :Howevcr, eleclronic copies ofthese letters**w~rc stilllivail~lblc**  and are 

### therefore being**product~d.** COMPI.lAINANT1S 3 rd SUP1)LEMENTALRES"f'ONSE TO RESfl'ONI)ENT"S IHSCOVERY REQUlLST
REQUEST l='OR PRODUCTION NO.1 (sic): Provide a copy of all Exhibits that yotl**v~jll** prCSCn! during the hearhlg in this matter_**h..NS.W.lll~:** Complainant still hM nOt decided what Exhibits it will actually U&I,;, I**T(.)w~v(!r,** I can l'ltate that we inlend to u::;c the following additional documents referenced below, <.:opics ofwhicb have**b~en** pn:viously provided in earlier discovelY rcsponse$,03/24/2010 10:18 FAX 2024935142 FAA + OMS 

### I4J 003/008

.,,- -..:.-.
... -,..::...:.
...**~** .. -- ..**"V~** .... .., 11.""'4 'T.t-V**"~I ~VV,**  111'1111-'( @003



### a. Faxed cop)' of Greal 

### Lakes GMM ferry permir I,;olicerning maintel\anCC performed 

### on 2**3/4/08~ .~**  b. N2190L Aircraft Maint. log pages 206341-206350 (varimls vcr!>ions t>/"thcsc '1 dOC\lfficnrs) !> c. AIM, volume IX, ChapLer 4,4.3.8 Rigging ofLanding Gear tlplllck. downluck 01'

. 

### 6 Stlfcry 

### switch sys1em 

### document, daT.cd 2-28-08 7 d, Extract ofthe Beech Model 1900D Airliner Maintenance Manual, entitkd Main Gear s Safety Switch··· Mainrenancc Practices '" c. OMM, vol VI, Chapter 9, page 9-2 and 9-42 lO 

### f. GMM vol VI, LEP J.l g, Extract ofthe Beech 1900D Airliner Electrical Wirillg diagrc:ll11 malltlal l;l 

### h.· Extract of King Air 

### and Airlil1cr 

### Series Primed CirC'llit 

### Board m.cmual (v·,·ith 

### AS! l3 

### Hulen's notes) 1 'I i. Extract ofBeech 19000 Airliner**Main\cn<ll1c~** Manual 15 a. Propeller Controlling- Description and Operations 15 

### b. Landing. gear Position and Warning .-**D~scriplion** 

### and Operation , 7 J. Model 1900D

### Airliner Electrical 

### Wirillg Di$lgr<l1l1 Manual J.e k. Email wi attachmem from Scott Lewis to Mike HuleU dated 

### 6/3/08 1**~** L Extr!:lcl oflhe Beech 19000 Airlil'ler Electrical Wiring diagrmn manual with AS I 20 lIulelt'$ notes and comments (in color) ;n m. Lcucr onnvestigation by ASJ Hulen

. . 22 n. Letter of 

### Response from Great Lakes (with attachmems) :1.:l o. Exrra-.:l from Lhe Beech 190(1) Flight St:indards 

### m<'lmml 24 

### p, A\ least three 

### Photographs of the aircraft whee] w\;!1 25 q. Rccurd ofconversation 

### by Mike Davey dated 8/14/08 21j r. Wrilten :;lal.Cmenls 

### by Mike 

### Smith. datod ) llll/08 :n $. Memorandum dated 

### 5/18/09 by ASI Hulett wi attachments conceming training 20 records 29 t. 

### Recoru ofconversation by 

### Bob Hofer, dated 1123/09 30 u. I)epo!:lilions or extracts thel'cofofChristopher Samuelson. Mike Smith, John Spragl.lt:. 31. 

### and 

### Benjamin Campbell, all occurring 

### in J

..

### muary 2009 32 c'

# ;~**Datc~/!'3~:~~~~,~fMarCh'** 2010

.

.

## ~S ...._,.

## ~/ \**~ /'''''/J'..,I~;;''**  __**._~-.'** 3 Q

..**~~~** ...**~-** ••• 1.'// .,;'1

### ",.,-;Scott 

### R. 'Mon-is 

# 6·,·''''' FAA 

### Attorney 39 '10 III
43**II~** 15 46 47 4!l 4.9 SO Sl !::l:! C'Implnimmfs**RC5p(ms~ ()fRc$p()l\lh::rn'~**  Supp[em1.!nlli.l ;\3 rHSl:o\,ery R(:'l..juc:slllnd Complahlallt'S**3"~** Supplemen1al**Rcsp~H1';O;:** to**Rc~rwfJacllt** " Di:=cO"l::ry Request GrdL\\**Lak..:~** Aviutiol1 CP(l9NM0008 TEL: 42.5.227.1-117

.. r/\X

. .j.2':'.2:!7.1l1117**Pa~t:** 2 of)03/24/2010 10:19 FAX 2024935142 + 

### OMS 

### IaI 004/008

:2

1:\ 11 I!,> Hi 17 :La 1:1 2() 21

.,., _/. 23 H 7.5 2., :n 2B 29 30 31 3'2 3J 34 3$ 36 H 38 :Hi 40 4] 42 43 11 iJ

... 46 4,7 48 49 50 51 !:>:? !:i3 @004



### CERTIFICATE OF SERVlCE j hereby certify that 

### rhefol'egoil'lg Com.plainant's Response to 

### Respondenf::> S\.lpplc.mental Disc()vcry and C,)mplainant's Third Supplemenlal Response to Rcspomknt 's**Discov~r:v** Request 

### has been served via Hlcsirnilc 

### <-Ind 

### certified 

### mail· ReTurn Rcceipl 

### Requeswd this dalt::, lO**th~~** 

### following:

The llonorable Richard C. Goodwin 

### Office**(lfhearing~,** 

### M·20 1200 New Jersey Avenue, S.E. 

### East 

### Building (I'round 

### Floor, 

### Rm El2·320 

### Wo\shinglol'l, D.C. 20590 

### TRL: 202.366.2139 FAX: 102.366.7536


### FtldcraJ Aviation Administralion 800 Ind¢pendence 

### Avenue SW Washington, 

### D.C. 20591 

### AHn: 

### Hearing,**DOCk.~1** 

### Clerk, AGC-430 Wilbur 

### Wright Building

- Suite 2W1 000 

### FAX: 202.493.5020 Timothy 

### J. Thornton, Esq. 

### Briggs and Morgan 2200 IDS Center &0 South 8th Street 

### Minl1eapoli:;, 

### MN 55402-2157 TEL: 612.997.8400 

### PAX: 612.997.8650

Dated this 2Jrd 

### day ofMarch, 2010.

I , • ('"1-'"

l

# 't "tfl I 

# ,;**~~** I"/; '-': .'

..**~** 

### _,.. ..::::=.:.. ,iI.."\,'\,..., v..,) '-vY ""'

.. , 

### SHERI BROWN Office ofRegional COUllSel 

### (ANM-7) F

### cdel'ai Aviation Administration 1601 Lind /\ve. SW

. 

### Renton, WA 98057 425.227.2925**CWr!plu.m~lIrs** l{cspollsl.: ofR;,:sPOlldtll)!'$ Supplementa!**Dlsc:o\'~r:' R~qul:sl**  and**C01Tlpl~i(lam\s** 3" Supplc:m(;nlal**R~;;rwll~e** !()**Rasp,)lldcm'~** Ois.,;ov.tr·y RequesL**Grt~al** Laki!:s .I\viallon

- (,P09NMOOO8 Tl;;L: 425,227.1417: fAX. '12.5.227.1007 Page) or 3

### ---------------------._- --._--­ 03/24/2010 10:18 FAX 2024835142 FAA -t OMS 

### III 005/008**vv,~~,~V&V v~**  •• o rA&**q~~** ZZI lUU7 ANM-7**~005** 

# o U.S. Department Northwest Mountain 

### Region 

### 1601 

### Linu !\'V <.:rn.lE) 

### S, W, OfTl'l:lnsportation**Colorl'Jd~.J,** Idaho, Montn.nn 

### Renton, Washington 

### 98051 Ft.ldcra) AvhltiQn Oregon, Ulllh, Washjngton Tel: (425)**227~2007** Administnltion Wyoming I;'ax: (425) 227··1007 Office of Regional COdnsel 

### February 24, 2009 FAA Case No. 2008N1'v12100%



### WITHDRAWAI

.. OF NOTICE OF' PROPOSED CERTn'ICATE 

### A<;;TION

Dear Mr. Holzinger: On August 22, 2008. 

### YOll were 

### advised through a 

### Notice ofPt"oposed CertiJicateActloli 

### thalthis oHice proposed to Sllspend YOlll 

### Airline Transport Pilot Certificate No. • 

### l**~ubsequent1y,** we have considered all available information relating to your case, including 111(; 

### information presented at the 

### itltormaJ conference 

### on November 1S, 2008, and h.IVC wndudcd that the PlJblic.; interest does not require the 

### S1.1SpenSlon ofyour AirHne Transport Pilot Ci;rlilicate. 

### This 

### i::; to 

### inform YOtl 

### that [he 

### Notice ofProposed 

### Certific(lte Action is hereby withdTiiwn. DWI(Tt)T 

### S. W1LLIAMS Regional Clmnsel



### By: 

### SC()tt R. 

### Monis FAA Attorney



### cc: Cory TiptOll, 

### Esq.+ OMS !gJ 00B/008 03/24/2010 10:19 FAX 2024935142 FAA
'

...... _ ..- .. -.., __ r .L,VVI Amn-I 

### tlJ 006 

# o
U.S. Department 

### Northwest Mountain Region 1601 Lind Avenue S.W. OfTransportation Colorado, Idaho, Montana 

### Remon, Washington 98057 

### Fedentl AvhlCioQ Oregon, Utah, Washington· 

### TeL (425) 

### 227·200i AdministraCion Wy()ming Fax: (425) 127·100'7 

### Oflicc of**Re~ional** 

### Counsel Febl'.\l-.Ir,Y 24, 2009 FAA Case No, 2008NM2I0094



### WITHDRAWAL OF N01]CE**O~'** 

### PROPOSED**~ERTIFI(:'t\** 

### TE ACTION,



### Dear Mr. Johal1n: 

### On August 22, 2008, you were advised through a Notice ofProposed Certificate Action 

### that this office proposed to 

### :suspen.d your Airline 

### Transport Pilot 

### Cerli1icate**No.~** Subsequently, Wt have considere(J all available intonnaliol1 relating to your c·ase, including the information presented at the informal conference on November 18, 2008 , and have conduded 

### that the public interest**do~s** not require 

### the suspensioll ofyour Airline Transport Pilot Ceniiicme. This is to l11i'onn you 

### That the Notice ofProposed Certiticate 

### Action 

### is bereby withdrawn. DWIGHT S. WILLIAMS. 

### Regional Cotmsel

By: 

### Scott R.**Morri~** FAA Attorney
cc; Cory E. 

### TiptOt1, Esq.03/24/2010 10:19 FAX 2024935142 FAA 

### " OMS**~007** /008

........**~** ..... _f ·... v ..... v V(!I

.. '\J' r-/\.A
.. ",v**~.t.1** .1VU( AN.Ill-7**~007** 

# «.)
U.S. Department 

### NQrthwest Mountain Region 1601 LindAvenueS.W. 

### OfTra..'1SpOrLation Colorado, ldilho, 

### t-
..lontana Renton, Washington 98057 Federal Aviation Oregon, l..hah, Washington Tel: (425) 227-2007 

### Admillist.'ation Wyoming Fax: (425) 227-] 007 Office of Regional Countlcl 

### February 24, 2009 FAi\Case No. 2008NM210097
Cody 

### James Christensen

WITHI)RAWAL OF 

### NOTICE OF I>ROPOSED 

### CERTIFICATE ACTION



### Dear Mr.Chri"tcnsen: 

### On August 

### 22, 2008, Y()'Ll 

### were advised 

### tlu-ough a Nolice 

### of Proposod

.

### on thallhis o1ticc proposed 

### to 

### suspend your 

### Airline Tral1spOrl 

### Pilot Certifica.te 

### S.ubsequently, we have considered all available information relating to your case, udlng the infonnatlon 

### presellled a.t the 

### informal conference on November 18,2008, and have concluded that the public 

### interesl does 

### nOT 

### l'Gquire the suspension ofyour Airline Tr<ln!lpol"1 Pilot**Ce:r\Hh:~ltC. ~nlis**  is to inform 

### you that 

### the Notice 

### of Proposed 

### CertifIcate Action is hereby 

### withdra\VIl. 

### DWIGHT S. WILLIAMS Regional Counsel

By: Scott R. MOlTis FAA AttOrney



### cc: Joseph H. Thibodeau, 

### Esq.----------------------- 03/24/2010 10:20 FAX 2024935142 FAA

.. OMS 008/008

V

... I",.U"V.LV**V~;"I** rJU.. 4Zb 1:':'1 lOu', ANlII-7**~006** 

# " U.S. Department**N~rthwest** 

### Mountnin Region 1601 Lind AVE'mtt:)S.W. OfTransportation Colt)rado, Ida.ho,**M~)ljlana** 

### Remon, Washington 98057 

### Fedeul A""intion Oregoll, Utah, WashlllgwlI TeL (425) 227-2007 

### Administratioll Wy()ming Fax: (425) 227·1007 Office of Regioual Counsel February 24,2009 

### FAA Case No. 200RNM21 0095

WITHnRAWAL OF 

### NOTICE OF PROPOSED 

### CERTIFICATE ACTION.



### Dear Mr. Chay: OIl A11gUSt 21.2009, 

### you Were 

### advlscJthrough a Notice off>roposed Certificale 

### Aclionlhat thi::. (lj'fice 

### proposed to 

### suspend your Aidinc Transport Pilot Cenificate 1\0. 

## Fit Subsequently, 

### we have 

### considered all 

### available inlbrmation rdaring (0 your case, including the 

### in1.orma.1ion presented at the 

### iuiormal 

### coniereucc on Noyember 18, 2008> and**h::tVt~** cQnc.1udcd 

### that the public interest does not require th<:l suspension 

### ofyour 

### Airline Transport 

### Pilot CtJrtitic<HC. This is to 

### inform you that the Notice ofPropo:-;ed 

### Certificate Action is 

### hereby withdrawn. DWIGHT S. WILLIAMS Regional 

### Counsel

By: Scott R. Mon-is FAI\. Attorney



### cc: Joseph 11. Thibodea:Ll, Esq.