o 

U.S. Department 

Of Transportation 

Federal Aviation 

Administration 

Office of Regional Counsel 

March 6. 2012 

Northwest Mountain Region 

Colorado, (daho, Montana, 

Oregon, Utah. Washington, 

Wvominu 

1601 Lind Avenue S.W. 

Renton. Washington 98057 

Tel: (425)227-2758 

Fax:(425)227-1007 

JOA^JN.PUTNAMf«)FAA.GOV 

VIA FA X AND FIRST-CLASS MAI L TO JUDGE GOODWIN AND FAX COPY TO PATRICIA MATTHEWS, 

•LZi3-~ 

r •"! 

-The-Honorable-Richaid C. Goodwin - — - ....__-. _ _ 

Administrative Law Judue r^ \^'-'"4^ 

Office of Hearings. M-2n 

U.S. Dcpaiinient oFTransportation 

1200 New Jersey Avenue. S.E. ~" 

Washington. DC 20590 ^ 

Re: Withdrawal of Complaint - FlyingB Aviation. LLC - FDMS No. FAA-2011-0066 

Dear Judge Goodwin: 

This is to ihfomi you that the parties in'this case have reached a settlement. 

Pursuant to the Settlement Agreement executed on August 10. 2011. at Paragraph 4 {see 

ciiuichecl). Respondent Brandon J. Naccarato. Agent for Flying B Aviation, LLC. agreed to 

withdraw and waived his right to hearing, appeal or further administrative or judicial review in 

this matter. 

The V.W hereby withdraws its Complaint dated. March 15. 2011, in the referenced case and 

requests that a Termination Order be issued. We apologize for any inconvenience or confusion 

'causcd:--we wereunder the impression^that Respondent's'counseFexpresslvAvithdrew his'appeal 

and request for hearing at the Office of Hearintis after settlement was reached. 

h^UfJ 

<roann M. Putnam 

FAA .Attorney 

cc:: Richard A. Johnson. Esq.. Respondent's Counsel 

3815 Rickenbacker St.. Suite 208 

Boise.-ID 83705 

.Attachments - Settlement Agreement: Service List 
UNITED STATES OF AMERIC A 

DEPARTMEN T OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE O F HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D C 

.Flying B Aviation, LLC 

FAA Case No. 2009NM070092 

FDMS No: FAA.2011-0066 

Judge Richard, C. GoodwinSETTLEMENT ,^r,Pgir\fFKT 

Complainsnt, Federal Aviation AdmiiiismdoD (FAAX sod KespondcnV Flying B 

Aviation, LLC, through their respective undersigaed Rptcsentilives, hereby agree to settle the 

above rerereneed matter, with piqudioe, upon the &llowiiiK tarns and cooditioss. 

1. By eotaiog into this Settlenunt AenexDCDt, Flying B Aviation, IXC CPIying B") agrees 

thai m Order Assesabg Civil Penalty COnici") will be issued by the FAA setting forth Gndiogs 

of fact and of regnlatcny violatioas as alleged in the FAA's Mvch 16,2010 Notice of Proposed 

Civil Pcnal^ in this nutan. 

2. FDIflgB BclowwledgcsthattheOtdcrwlllcoDsUtutetheFAA'sfindinBsofvlolation 

vnth respect to this manar and thai the FAA findings will become final upon issuuce of the 

Order. 

3. The onginal civil penalty pnipooed by the FAA was $42>500. The FAA Order will 

aiacts a civil peoal^ of SS,O00. Paymem of the S5,000 will bo per the tenns and coDditlorts of a 

scporalely executed prooiissoiy note thai is specifically iacorporaicd into this agrcenem. 

4. Rrspondttii hereby expressly -withdnwt and waives bis right to hearing, appeal, or fiuther 

- atlniluluinUvc uf judlLlal Biview lu Uila umin. 

5. The pajtiei agree that this settleipept agreenent will be retained in the onforccment file. 

6. The poaons executliig this Sctttemcn] Agreemesl represeiit that they have the ability to 

bind the parties to the tcnns of the Settlcmenl Agreetnect 

7. The parties ame that each party shall bear its own costs and attomcyii* TCCB incurred in 

this nuLttET, and that Respondent il ^ not seek to recover said costs and fees fi^m the Federal 

AviadiOD'Adniiiiistrarion. " ' " ""' —>^-

6. This Agteement may benecuted in any numberofcoonteipaits, each of which shall be 

an original; but such counterparts shall togetfaei constitute one and the same isstrument 

bruZooT Kafearato, Ageotfioi • Jo ^ Putnam 

Flying B Aviation, IXC FAA Attorney 

Die : g//// / Date: ^//o//l 
CERTIFICAT E O F SERVICE 

I certify that the foregoing Withdrawal of Complaint in Flying B Aviation, LLC, has been 

served via U.S. First Class Mail to the following: 

Federal Aviation Administration 

800 [ndependence Ave SW 

Washington. D.C. 20591 

Attn: Hearing Docket Clerk. AGC-430 

Wilbur WrighT BIdg. - Suite 2WIOO0 

U.S. Depanment of Transportation 

1200 New Jersey Avenue. SE 

Washington, D.C. 20590 

Attn: Docket Management System 

Docket Operations. M-30. Room WI2-M0 

I also certify that the foregoing, Withdrawal of Complaint in Flying B Aviation, LLC, has been 

served via facsimile and U.S. First Class Mail this date, to the following: 

The Honorable Richard C. Goodwin 

Administrative Law Judge 

Office of Hearings. M-20 

U.S. Department ofTransportation 

1200 New Jersey Avenue, S.E. 

Washington. DC 20590 

FAX: (202) 366-7536 

TEL: (202)366-5121 (Staff Assistant/Paralegal) 

Richard A. Johnson. Esq.. Respondent's Counsel 

3815 Rickenbacker St., Suite 208 

Boise. ID 83705 

FAX: (208) 3-14-5121 

TEL: (208)344-1348 

! also certify that the foregoing has been served via U.S. First Class Mail and CertiHed Mail - Return Receipt 

Requested this date, to the following: 

riyinu B Aviation. LLC 

- — c/o-Brandon J. Naccarato ' "'" "•'•• "^ ~^ ^ 

501 W 90 S 

Salem. UT 84653-9156 

Dated this 6'^ dav of March. 2012. 

l^.iuhionj 

rANJN M. PUTNAM. Esq. 

Office of Regional Counsel (ANM-7) 

Federal Aviation Administration 

1601 Lind Ave. SW 

Renion. WA 98057 

TEL: 425.227.2758 

FAX: 425.227.1007