5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




/%(576216 
1&



	






$7,21$/ $%25 (/$7,216

2$5'




	




1,7(' 22' $1'200(5&,$/ 25.(56
1,21 2&$/ 



!"#$%$%!&'#(%#)*!+

&'!&'.#/#!$&*!

*$%!*-*1'#-*

2 3

'56#+786!#

9#.%+#+*!+%-#+76
 

  




7KH +RQRUDEOH :LOOLDP - +D\QHV -U 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW -XGJH

IRU WKH 0LGGOH 'LVWULFW RI 7HQQHVVHH VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ

#&'#7:*!+;
<%'.6%$86+5# :	

9%$'%.$86+5#









	  "#$#' < !+#'! "	 ;	 =
	 	#*$$-# *0%!5$! &' "#$%$%!#'  80! '1*1

	9*0%!5$!9 &' #,!+#!$  ;%-#  ;%1! ;9;<
	
=;
	"'$-*!+'#5!&'
!$#'(#!'
"#$#'<!+#'!"*$'%.><%.0*#-<*++#!"	;	=
		#*$$-#*0%!5$!8*/#  6'># 


 *.0*#-  )# ?
;<

;=??<"%!.%!!*$%0%&'"#$%$%!#'80!'1*1%-##!'/$'!50*'-#"9!!#--@8'86-%#<*'.6

	9*0%!5$!9&'#,!+#!$;%-#;%1!;#!#<#.0*!%. ;9; <
 	
 =;
	 "'$-*!+ '#5! &' 
!$#'(#!'  *@!# #.>#'"=;;?*!*%$@<%6'%<%.0*#- ; 9-*! 99 
?	< =#):'>#):'>#-!9$>%!


<""'$-*!+'#5!&'/%.%6'%*#







:%'.6%$86+5#-1#'$!
!.AB-1#'$!CD*

'#$*%-5'.#'##>'#(%#)&*+#.%%!1@$0#*$%!*-*1'#-*$%! *'+ AB*'+CD %! )0%.0 $0# *'+ 0#-+ $0*$-1#'$!.//%$$#+*!6!&*%'-*1','*.$%.#*5*%!$$)6!%!)0#!-1#'$!*--)#+.0*'%$*1-#5'6,$-%.%$! %! *!+ *'6!+ %$ ,',#'$@ ! (*'%6 ..*%! 16$
  

+#!%#+!!#/,-@##6!%!'#,'#0#*'+0#-+$0*$$0%,'*.$%.#($0# *$%!*- *1' #-*$%! -1#'$! +%.'%/%!*$#+ *5*%!-1#'$!.!$#!+$0*$#/,-@#1@*--)%!5.0*'%$%#$-%.%$!$0$0#*/#'%50$$6!%!6!+#'$0#.0#*'+)0%.0.',#$%$%!&.!$#!+!*,,#*-$0*$$0#*6$0'%!-@ *,,-%# %! %$6*$%! )0#'#*.$%(%$@$0*$)6-+0*'/$0##/,*.$%(%$@*!+$0*$!#&$0#6!%!#!5*5#+%!6.0*.$%(%$@16$'*$0#''$0# '#*!$0*$&--))#*'+ '+#' *!+ 	 $0#-1#'$!

	




!(#/1#'49'%(#'	

+*!+-#'-#'%.*-*!+
!+6$*&&%-%*$#+)%$0
!$#'!*$%!*-'$0#
AB.*-ECD*6!%!-.*$#+&%-#+*!6!&*%'-*1','*.$%.#.0*'*#2*--#5%!5'#/(# '#,'##!$*$%(# & $0# 6!$'#.*-E'#,'##!$*$%(#-1#'$! $'# %! '+#' $ +.6$/#'!$$,6'.0*#,'+6./*!6&*.$6'#')%$0)0/$0#6!%

!9#.#/1#'2*+%&&#'#

//#'.%*- '>#' 
!%! 
!%$#++*!+//#'.%*-
AB.*-CD&%-#+*.0**#3440#.0*'50*+$0'#*$#!#+.*-'#,'##!$*.$%!&'*$$#/,$%!5$5*%!*..#-*'>6!$@*0%!5$!%!'+
2 

  

.*'+&'/#/,-@##0#6!%!*--#5#+$0*$*..#06-+0*(# 1##! *--)#+ ,6'6*!$ $ * --#.$%(# *'5*%!%!55'##/#!$ ABCD 1#$)##! .*-  *!+ -1#'$!.(#'%!5 *-- ,'##!$ *!+ &6$6'# $'# %! -*'> 6!$@*0%!5$!  ! ,'%-  2 $0# 6!%! */#!+#+ $0#.0*'5#$*--#5#$0*$.*-0*+1##!$'#*$#++%&&#'#!$-@$0*! $0#' '5*!%F*$%! )0%.0 )#'# *--)#+ *..# $-1#'$!$'#

!<*'.043.*-&%-#+*#.!+.0*'5#*5*%!$

-1#'$! A3443D *--#5%!5 $0*$ -1#'$! 0*+'#&6#+$*--)6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#*..#$-1#'$!$'#%!'#5!*-%!'+#'$1$*%!*6$0'%F*$%!.*'+&'/#/,-@##)0%.0$0#6!%!.-*%/#+)**--)#+6!+#'$0#.*-*/#!+#+$0%.0*'5#!,'%-3*--#5%!5$0*$-1#'$!0*+'#&6#+%$*..#$%$$'#,'#/%#)0%-#*--)%!56.0*..#$$0#''5*!%F*$%!

0##5%!*-9%'#.$'.!-%+*$#+*#344

*!+3443!<*@33	61#G6#!$-@*#2)*.!-%+*$#+)%$0$0#$0#'$).*#0#,*'$%# /(#+ $ $'*!&#' $0# /*$$#' $ $0# *'+ )*%(#*'56/#!$ 1#&'# *! *+/%!%$'*$%(#-*) H6+5# AB8CD *!+$%,6-*$#$$0#&*.$0#*'+.!%+#'#+$0#/*$$#'&'*-/$ &6' @#*' *!+ %! * 0*',-@ +%(%+#+ +#.%%! $0#*'+/*H'%$@&6!+$0*$-1#'$!.//%$$#+*!6!&*%'-*1' ,'*.$%.# *!+ (%-*$#+ $0#  1@ #I.-6+%!5'#,'##!$*$%(#&.*-E*!+&'/%$$'#

-1#'$! &%-#+ $0% $%/#-@ !$%.# & *,,#*- !

(#/1#'    -$0650 !!# & $0# *.$%!./,-*%!#+&..6''#+%!$0%.%'.6%$H6'%+%.$%!%,',#',6'6*!$$
	J3A&D)0%.0,'(%+#$0*$*,*'$@/*@##>'#(%#)&**'++#.%%!%!$0#.6'$&*,,#*-%! * H6+%.%*- .%'.6%$ )0#'# $0# ,*'$@ $'*!*.$ 16%!#-1#'$!.!$#!+$0*$%$0*)#--(#'#/,-@##%!#!!### *!+<%.0%5*! *!+$06 '#(%#)1@$0%6'$%,',#'  0# *'+ 0* .',#$%$%!#+ *!+ ##>#!&'.#/#!$&%$'+#'

  

:H DOVR UHMHFW WKH %RDUG¶V DUJXPHQ

6DQGXVN\ UHJDUGLQJ WKH WHUP 3GLVFULPLQDWDQ DUJXPHQW LV EHOLHG E\ WKH ODQJXDJH LQ W

 )G DW  3>:@H KROG WKDW WKH WH%DEFRFN PHDQV IDYRULQJ RQH XQLRQ RYHU UHODWHG LQIRUPDWLRQ ZKLOH EDUULQJ VLPLODHPSKDVLV DGGHG

1#&'#6%!$0#%!$*!$.*#)#0+%.'%/%!*$%!,'(%+#+%!	




'$0#&'#5%!5'#*!)#

*'+ '+#' *!+ 	 $0#-1#'$!
2 

  

#& .6'# *- *'#16!+1@$0%6'$0-+%!5%!

"#16$*)#0*(##I,-*%!#+$0*$.*#+#!$'#G6%'#

$0*$)#'#H#.$$0#+#&%!%$%!&+%.'%/%!*$%!*#$&'$0%!
 !*!+	0%6'$0*'#.5!%F#+$0*$$0#'#%

*!0%#'*'.0@&'%50$6!+#'	#.$%!4&$0#

$+34E3EEA3$0%'2D0%-#$0# .'# *.$%(%$@ ,'$#.$#+ 1@ 	#.$%! 4 % $0# '%50$ &#/,-@## $ #-&'5*!%F# * ,'#(%6-@ $*$#+ B!!#/,-@## 0*(# * K+#'%(*$%(# '%50$ $ #!5*5# %!'5*!%F*$%!*- *.$%(%$%#C    *'$0#$ '#/(#+ &'/,'$#.$%! 6!+#' 	#.$%! 4 & $0#  % $0# *.$%(%$@#!5*5#+%!1@$0#!!#/,-@##%!	*!+
 !,%.>#$%!5*.$%(%$@$+*$3EA#I,-*%!%!5$0*$!!#/,-@##,%.>#$%!5 )*''*!$ #(#!-#,'$#.$%!$0*! !!#/,-@## '5*!%F*$%!*- *.$%(%$@D  0%-# !!#/,-@##'5*!%F#'/*@)*''*!$5'#*$#','$#.$%!6!+#'$0#$0*!!!#/,-@##)0#!5*5#%!!!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@1$0%$6*$%!$%--%/,-%.*$#$'#,**.$%(%$@$0%6'$%!"#!$#+B$'#,*.*#.'#*$#*%$6*$%!

)0#'#$0#%!$#'#$&$0#$'#,*#'%& *!+

$0#'#&'# $0# ,',#'$@ )!#' 0* * ,'#6/,$%(# '%50$ $#I.-6+#!!#/,-@##&'/%$,',#'$@C+*$A#/,0*%*++#+D06)0%-#BK*!#/,-@#'/*@!$*-)*@1*'!!#/,-@##6!%!'5*!%F#'&'/0%,',#'$@C$0#16'+#!$0#6!%!1#*'%!0)%!5$0*$$0##/,-@#'/*@!$+ % * BK0#*(@!# #(%+#!.#+1@$0# &*.$$0*$$0#1*-*!.#$'6.>1@$0#*'+*!+$0#.6'$6!+#'$0# *..//+*$%!,'%!.%,-#0*'*'#-@1##!%!&*('&$'#,*'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@C%'
	*$AG6$%!5
 (		

23
	EA4EDD
!.!$'*$)0#'##/,-@##'%50$*'#*$%6#B!'#$'%.$%!!#/,-@##'%50$$#-&'5*!%F*$%!%,#'/%%1-#6!-#$0# #/,-@#' 0) $0*$ 6.0 '#$'%.$%! % !#.#*'@ $/*%!$*%!'+#'*!++%.%,-%!#C%'
	*$#.*6#*/!5$0#'$0%!5$0#6'$%!"#*++'##+.!.#'! '#5*'+%!5 #-&'5*!%F*$%!*- '%50$& #/,-@##$0#/#-(# *!+ $0# '%50$ $0*$ $0#@ *'# 5'*!$#+ 6!+#' $0#$0#6'$0#-+$0*$%$)*!$16!+1@	*!+
 !  #.*6# )# + !$ 0*(# 6.0 .!%+#'*$%!

  


! 

0#&*.$*'###!$%*--@6!+%,6

$%,6-*$#+$$0#/1#-)-1#'$,-%.@!*..#*!+-%.%$*$%!*!+)0%.01*!*!@*!+*---%.%$

#$

#$)##!(#/1#'*!

E#!5*5#+%!*!#.!/%.$'%>#-.*$#+%! 	,>*!#*0%!5$!+%$'%16$#0*!+1%--*$%I&-1#$'#%!$0#	,>*!#*'#*0#0*'#&'*%! &'/ 16@%!5 '*+(%#)-1#'$!-+%!*/6.0*'*1#!#&%$&*'1#-)$0#%!+6$'@$*!/*+#.-#*'$0*$$0#6!%!+%,6$#16$ !-@ )%$0 '*+(%#)  !#650$ $ +%#/%!*$# $0# 0*!+-1#'$!-1#'$!'#G6#$#+$ '#/(# 0*!+1%--#' &'/ %$ ,$'#

!(*'%6..*%!)0%-#$0#

,*6$$0#%'0*!+1%---1#'$!%$,',#'$@$-%.%$+!*$%!%'# ;%'- *!+ @ @ 	.6$.0-6'$0#'$0#	*-(*$%!1#--+6'%!50*!>5%(%!5*!+0@#*'

##

96'%!5 <*@  $ #1'6*'@

+#!%#+!!#/,-@##16%!#'#,$$0#%!$#'%' *!+%//#+%*$# #I$-.*$#+%!-*'>6!$@*0%!5#!+'#5!A$'#E4*!+EA$'#ED.*-'#,'##!$*$
3 

  

'XULQJ RUDO DUJXPHQW WKH %RDUG H[SUHVVO\ VWDWHG WKDW /RFDO 

GRHV QRW FODLP WKDW $OEHUWVRQ¶V VKRXOG KDYH DOORZHG WKH XQLRQ DFFHVV WRLWV VWRUHV XQGHU DQ\ ULJKWV JUDQWHG E\ WKH &%$ 5DWKHU RQ DSSHDO WKH

$'#%!'+#'$-%.%$$0#./,*!@#/,-@##$1#./#/#/1#'&*!+L'$'#G6#$'#,'##!$*$%!1@.*-


!#*'-@86-@*!+!.$1#'6,#'(%'*$

$'# E *!+L' E +#!%#+ *..# $ .*- '#,'##!$*$%(#*!+$-+$0#/$-#*(#$0#,'#/%#

.*-1#5*!%$'5*!%F%!5.*/,*%5!%!,'%-*!+

*,*'$&$0*$.*/,*%5!'#,'##!$*$%(##!$#'#+%!$$'#$$*-> $ #/,-@## *!+ +%$'%16$# -%$#'*$6'# *!+ ,-*.#+-%$#'*$6'#!.*')%!+0%#-+%!$0#,*'>%!5-$!<*@-1#'$!!$%&%#+.*-1@-#$$#'$0*$%$.!+6.$(%-*$#+ $0# $'# !-%.%$*$%! ,-%.@  .*- '#,'##!$*$%(#*5*%!*$$#/,$#+$+%$'%16$#/*$#'%*-%!86-@ *!+ )#'# $-+ $ -#*(#  
! * 86-@   -#$$#'-1#'$!*5*%!*+(%#+$0#6!%!$0*$%$.!+6.$(%-*$#+$0#$'#!-%.%$*$%!,-%.@	%/%-*'-#$$#')#'##!$$$0#6!%!%!(#/1#'*!+#1'6*'@3*&$#'.*- '#,'##!$*$%(# 0*+ *5*%! *$$#/,$#+ $ +%$'%16$# %$/*$#'%*- *!+ -%.%$ /#/1#' *$ /# & $0# ./,*!@$'#

.*-*-'#*+@0**)%$0*,,'I%/*$#-@24&$0#

./,*!@$'#%!'#5!*!+%!$)$'#%!*0%!5$!$(*'%6$%/#%!$0#,*$-1#'$!*,,*'#!$-@*--)#+.*-'#,'##!$*$%(#''#,'##!$*$%(#&,'#+#.#'6!%!*..#$$0#%!$#'%''#I$#'%'&%$!#)$'#%!'+#'$%!&'/#/,-@##*16$$0#6!%!..'+%!5$$0# .(#'%!5 $'# E4 EE *!+ E .*-  )**--)#+ $'# *..# $ %!(#$%5*$# $0# 6!%! $*!+%!5 &'#,'##!$#+/#*$+#,*'$/#!$#/,-@##..'+%!5$.*-$0#.-*6#%!$0#*-,'(%+#+$0*$-1#'$!*5'##+$'#.5!%F#.*-*$0#'#,'##!$*$%(#&%$!!#I#/,$5'.#'@#/,-@##%!$'#E4EE*!+E1*#+6,! * /*H'%$@ & $0# #/,-@## *6$0'%F%!5 6.0'#,'##!$*$%!)%$06$0*(%!5*!#-#.$%!

  %!$*!$.*#0%.*#%/,-%.*$#-1#'$!$#I.-6+#+%$'%16$%,',#'$@  6'$0#' $0% .*# %#/,-@####>%!5*..#$$0#.!'#-#(*!$-*1',-%.%#*'#*+(*-%.%$*$%!%!$0%.*#)0#'#$0#$0# $*'5#$ *6+%#!.# )* $0#')%&*.$'$0*$+%$%!56%0#$0%.*#&$0#&*.$$0*$$0#.*#%!(-(#+!0#*'+6'5#$0*$)#+%$%!56%!$0*$!#5'6!+)#(#'$0'#*!#+1*%$H6$%&@6'+%!5*$$0#/#*!%!5&$0#$#'/B+%	 )* %!$#','#$%!5 $0*$ $#'/)**!+ ()*) ()*
	*#/,-@#' 0*+ '#&6#+ $ *--'5*!%F#' ! ./,*!@ ,',#%!&'/*$%!$*'5#$#+*$./,*!@#1*% ! )0%.0 $ +%$%!56%0 $
 ! % $0*$ $0# .*# %!(*.$%(%$@ @#$%!'#*.0%!5$0#0-+%!5$0#@)#'#%!$#','#$%!5*!'5*!%F6!+#'$0##.%'.6/$*!.#$0#.1#+%$%!56%0#+&'/$0#%!$*!$16!+1@$0#%'0-+%!5++22A3$0%'D16!+$&--),'#.#+#!$%*-*6$0$0%.6'$6!-#6.0*6$0'%$@.*.6''#!$ ,*!#- % %!.-%!#+ $ +%*5
 !2+*$3A#I,-*%!%!$0%.%'.6%$%$0*$!#,*!#-.*!!0-+%!5D 
	&3EA3$0%'3DA0-+%!5$0*$*,'%' .*# &'/ +%&&#'#!$ ,*!#-%6#%!(-(#+)*0#*(%-@&*.$+'%($0#0-+%!5&$0#!#,'%'.*#)$0#%6#1#&'#$0#.6'$D
 

  

+%$%!56%0#+	*!+#I,-*%!#+$0*$$0#,*!#-%!$0*$.*#*+,$#+*!*'')+#&%!%$%!&B+%.'%/%!*$%!C**'#6-$&AD$0#5#!#'*-'6-#$0*$*!)!#'&,'%(*$#,',#'$@%6!+#'!1-%5*$%!$,#'/%$$0#+%$'%16$%!&6!%!-%$#'*$6'#!%$,',#'$@ AD$0#61$*!$%*-+%&&#'#!.#1#$)##!$0#'%50$& #/,-@## *!+ !!#/,-@## )%$0 '#,#.$ $ $0#+%$'%16$%!&6!%!-%$#'*$6'#!,'%(*$#-@)!#+,',#'$@ *!+ AD $0# &*.$ $0*$	 %!(-(#+ !!#/,-@## 6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(##!5*5%!5%!!!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@*$
!*++%$%!$0#6'$%!"#*-!$#+$0*$	
0-+%!5'#-%#+!*,-%.@.!%+#'*$%!!$,'##!$%!"#7

BMN0# 6'$ )*    %!&-6#!.#+ 1@ $0# &*.$ $0*$ K-.
!/0'
!

%%


%0%*'
!
1&%%0
%&
CA#/,0*%*++#+DAG6$%!5	+*$23D

0#6'$%!"#+%$%!56%0#+$0#.*#1#&'#%$&'*--

$0#'#*!!$#+*1(#*!+!$*$0#*'+.-*%/-#-@1#.*6#	%!(-(#+!!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@6'$0#'%$ % #(%+#!$$0*$$0#6'$ +%$%!56%0#+"# 
'!

1#.*6# $0*$ .*# %!(-(#+ "#
 #/,-@##   0"# + *$ AB0#/*H'%$@1#-%#(#$0*$$0#-	.+#&%!%$%!&+%.'%/%!*$%!06-+1#!$1#*,,-%#+%! $0# %!$*!$ .*# %!.# M$0# &'/#' .*#N %!(-(#+ !!#/,-@## -%.%$' *!+ $0% .*# %!(-(# #/,-@##CDA''%8+%#!$%!5D$0#/*H'%$@%!"#,%!$#+6$

$0%+%$%!.$%!%!#&61$*!.#*$A!$%!5$0*$BM#N/,-@##*'#*..'+#+5'#*$#','$#.$%!6!+#'$0#.$$0*!!!#/,-@##16$$0#@M#/,-@##N*'#*..'+#+#(#!5'#*$#','$#.$%!6!+#'$0#.$)0#!$0#@*'##!5*5#+%!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@CD 

 
	*$3E

A#I,-*%!%!5$0*$$0#+%$%!.$%!1#$)##!#/,-@##'%50$$+%.6 #-&'5*!%F%!5 *!+ $0# '%50$ & !!#/,-@##'5*!%F#' % !# & B61$*!.#CD 	  + *$ 23A*/#D

(#'@&*.$'#I.#,$!#$0*$$0#6'$%!"#,%!$#+$

%!'+#'$+%$%!56%0$0*$.*#&'/	%'#-#(*!$$$0#

  

%RDUG FRQWHQGV WKDW $OEHUWVRQ¶V VKRXOG KWR LWV VWRUHV GHVSLWH $OEHUWVRQ¶V QR$OEHUWVRQ¶V DOORZHG VXFK DFFHVV WR FKDUL

0# *'+ ,%!$ 6$ $0*$ 

.0*'%$*1-# *!+L' .%(%.L#+6.*$%!.6$/#'%!$0#*'#*%//#+%*$#-@$$0#$'#'%!$*!.#+6'%!5&%(# $'# *--) 	*-(*$%! '/@./,*!@.6$/#'	$'#E;%'- 	.6$ @ 	.6$ ')!5'6,$-%.%$%$.6$/#'	$0*(#*--)#+$0#;%'-	.6$*/&'#%5!*'9%*1-#+O#$#'**!+.0-5'6,$-%.%$

;#!#'*--@$0##5'6,*'#*--

*+H*.#!$ $ $0# $'# #!$'*!.#-1#'$! *+/%$ $0*$ +6'%!5 %,#'/%$$#+ $0# ;%'- 	.6$ *!+ 	**..# $ $0# %//#+%*$# %!$#'%' 6!$@*!+#!+L#+/!+	*-(*$%!$'#,',#'$@$0'6506$$0#/0# -*'> 6!$@ ;%'- 	.6$ *',',#'$@$)%.#*@#*'+6'%!5*$)#!+L#+/!+ *'#*;%'-	.6$ $0#%'.>%#!.#*@#*'&'%I$#-*'>6!$@@	.6$*'#5'*!$$#--,'+6.$$)%.#*@#*'+6'%!*!$0#'/!$0%!$0#,'%!50#*..#$,',#'$@!#$$0'##+*@@#*'  $ #*.0 & $0# &%(# $'#*--)#+*!$0#'-*1''5*!%F*$%!0*!+1%--'$-%.%$.6$/#'!$0#,'#/%#

-1#'$!0* '#H#.$#+ '#G6#

$0#' '5*!%F*$%! *%+# &'//#!$%!#+ *1(# 6.0 * ,-
E 

  

'5*!%F*$%! 6!&*/%-%*' $ $0# .//6!%$@ *!+ *-- !!.0*'%$%#




&

-1#'$! ##> '#(%#) & $0# *'+ +#.%%! *!+

.!$#!+ $0*$ -1#'$! 0* * '%50$ $ #I.-6+# &'/ %$,',#'$@!!#/,-@##6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#)0#!5*5#%!#%$0#'!!'5*!%F%!5''5*!%F%!5*.$%(%$%#..'+%!5$-1#'$! $0# *'+ #''#+ %! &%!+%!5 $0*$ -1#'$!+%.'%/%!*$#+*5*%!$$0#6!%!1@*--)%!5.#'$*%!.0*'%$*1-#5'6,$-%.%$!%$,',#'$@16$+#!@%!5$0#6!%!6.0'%50$-1#'$!&6'$0#'.!$#!+$0*$$0%&%!+%!51@$0#*'+.!&-%.$)%$0$),%!%!&'/$0%6'$
 !

" 	   2 + 3E A3$0 %' D *!+	

-2	3.+24A3$0%'3D

!*,,#*-$0#*'+*'56#$0*$-1#'$!+%.'%/%!*$#+

*5*%!$.*-*!+(%-*$#+	#.$%!EA*DAD&$0# 
	 J EA*DAD )0#! -1#'$! #I.-6+#+ 6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#&'/%$$'#0#*'+.!$#!+$0*$*!#/,-@#'(%-*$#$0#)0#!%$+#!%#*6!%!*..#$%$,'#/%#&''5*!%F*$%!*-,6',#16$*--).0*'%$%#$ -%.%$ +!*$%! ! %$ ,',#'$@  
$ .!$#!+ $0*$ *!#/,-@#'$-#'*!.#&!!#/,-@##.0*'%$*1-#-%.%$*$%!%,'1*$%(##(%+#!.#&+%.'%/%!*$%!*5*%!$!!#/,-@##'5*!%F%!5*.$%(%$@
$&6'$0#'*'56#$0*$$0#'#%!1*%&'$'#*$%!5.0*'%$%#*!@+%&&#'#!$-@$0*!6!%!.!$#!+%!5$0*$$'#*$%!5$0##$)5'6,%/%-*'-@*(%+$0#$#/,$*$%!&-*1#-%!5 B#/,-@##C '5*!%F*$%!*- *.$%(%$@ 0*'/&6- $ *!#/,-@#' 16%!# )0%-# -*1#-%!5 .0*'%$*1-# -%.%$*$%!0#-,&6-'*+(*!$*5#6$16%!#

0#*'+*-.!$#!+$0*$$0%6'$06-++#&#'$$0#

*'++#&%!%$%!&B+%.'%/%!*$%!C1#.*6#1@+#&%!%!5$0*$$#'/$0#*'+)**--#5#+-@%!$#','#$%!5$0#*'#,!%1%-%$@#!$'6$#+$%$1@!5'#0%-#$0#*'+'#.5!%F# $0*$ $0% 6'$ 0* !*'')-@ +#&%!#+ $0# $#'/

  
 !*$0#*'++#.%%!*!@6.0+%$%!.$%!%!'#*.0%!5%.6'$    /6$ H6+5# $0# ,','%*+/%!%$'*$%(#*5#!.@N-#-@!$0*5#!.@C+ A3$0%'E4D AG6$%!5
	 2 3 A24DD  B .*+/%!%$'*$%(# *.$%! 1@ 61$%$6,',#'1*%M*!+NM$N0%6'$)*.$%!1*#+!'#*!!$'#-%#+ A'#H#.$%!5 *'+ *'56/#!$ 1*'+ '#*+%!5 & $0# "$*- 6,,'$#+1@*$0#!'#.#!$	6,'#/!$-#!+6.06,,'$*!+*'+&*H6$%&@%$'#*+%!5&$0#.$%!%$4 !	'!	! AD AB#+!$ 61'*$%!*-# &' $0# '#*!%!5 6,,-AG6$%!5  5% +A24DD  
! *!@ #(#!$ #(#! %& *'+ *'56/#!$ ! *,,#*- +%$%!56%0*1-#&'/	*!+$0*$$0#*'56/#!$*+(*!.#+)%$0

0#*'+'#-%#!"#

A3$0 %' 4D $ 6,,'$ %$ .'#5*'+%!5$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!$#'/)*6#+%! ()%!$*!$.*#
!"#$0##/,-'+#' '#G6%'%!5 <#%H#' * &+ '#$*%-#'$*--)#/,-@##*$!#%!%5!%*)0%-#!$0#H1*$#!&'.#+*+'#.+#$0*$1*!!#+)%$0 $0#%' 6!%&'/ *!@$0%!5 ./,*!@ *,,'(#+ 16$$! 
!%$'#.5!%$%!,%!*$

<#%H#' *'56#+ $0*$ 	 )*

+#&%!%$%! & B+%.'%/%!*$%!C #+%,%$%(#   *$   0
 

  

WR FRPPXQLFDWH ZLWK $OEHUWVRQ¶V HPSOR\HHV 0%-# *.>!)-#+5%!5 $0*$ $0# +#&%!%$%! &$0#$#'/+%.'%/%!*$%!*#$&'$0%!	*!+
 !%*!*'')!#$0#*'+.!$#!+$0*$$0%6'$%!$16!+1@$0#.*# 1#.*6# $0% 6'$ 61#G6#!$-@ 0* -%/%$#+ $0#%'0-+%!5$%$6*$%!%!(-(%!5*6!%!#.!/%.*$$*.>*5*%!$ *! #/,-@#' *!+ !$ * 0#'# )0#'# $0# 6!%!%#!5*5%!5%!'5*!%F%!5*.$%(%$@6'$0#'$0#*'+.!$#!+$0*$$0#+%.6%!'#5*'+%!5$0#+#&%!%$%!&+%.'%/%!*$%!%!
 !*!+	)*/#'#-@+%.$*0%-#$0#*'+%.''#.$$0*$*,*!#-&$0%6'$+%$%!56%0#+	%!*.*#+#.%+#+ 61#G6#!$ $ 	 * #I,-*%!#+ 1#-) $0#+%$%!.$%!%!$*&*')##,%!5*$0#*'+.!$#!+

&'!!()(	


)##I,-*%!#+#*'-%#'$0#*'++#.%%!%!$0%.*#

&*%-$+%$%!56%01#$)##!$0#*.$%(%$@#!5*5#+%!1@.*-E*!+.*-
!+##+$0#*'+*!*-@F#+$0#.-*%/'#5*'+%!5.*-EA%!(-(%!5!!'5*!%F*$%!*-1@.$$%!5

*.$%(%$%#D*!+.*-A%!(-(%!5'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@D$5#$0#'0#*'++#.%%!5#!#'*--@0#-+$0*$*!@*!+*--#I.-6%! & $0# 6!%! &'/ *! #/,-@#' ,'#/%# %+%.'%/%!*$'@ )0#'# $0# #/,-@#' *--) $0#' 6.0 *.0*'%$%#$0#'%50$$-%.%$!%$,'#/%#06$0#*'++#$#'/%!#+ $0*$ %$ +%+ !$ /*$$#' )0#$0#' $0# *.$%(%$%##!5*5#+%!1#$)##!.*-E*!+.*-*!+$0#.0*'%$%#)#'#%/%-*'')0#$0#'.0*'%$%#*!+6!%!*'#./,*'*1-#5'6,

 !2+*$3A0-+%!5$0*$$0#*--#5#++%.'%/%!*$'@.!+6.$%!*--)%!5-%.%$*$%!1@!#5'6,)0%-#1*''%!56.0-%.%$*$%!1@*!$0#''#G6%'#$0*$$0#+%.'%/%!*$%!1#*/!5./,*'*1-#5'6,'*.$%(%$%#D
$%!-@!*,,#*-$0*$$0#*'+*'56#$0*$.0*'%$%#*!+6!%!*'#%!+%$%!56%0*1-#&',6',#&*+%.'%/%!*$%!*!*-@%*!+$0*$6!%!#!5*5%!5%!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@,#.%&%.*--@*!+.0*'%$@-%.%$*$%!*'#./,*'*1-#*.$%(%$%#0# *'56/#!$ $0# *'+ !) ##> $ '*%# *'# .-#*'-@.'*&$#+ &' *,,#*- 1#.*6# & 6' 0-+%!5 %! 	 *!+

  B+%.'%/%!*$%!C%!
 !*!+$0*$ $0#@ *'# +%$%!56%0*1-# %! $6!%!6'5%!5*.!6/#'1@.$$*
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
	  A3D %! )0%.0 $0# B+%.'%/%!*$%!#I.#,$%!C$$0#5*'#!$16!+$,#'/%$6!%!/#/1#' !#/#/1#'&$0#*'+,*!#-/#/1#'$*$#+$0*$$0#,'0%
 

  

,Q DGGLWLRQ WR WKH SDUWLHV VHYHUDO DPLFL DOVR KDYH VXEPLWWHG EULHIV

LQ WKLV DSSHDO 7KH DPLFL DUH WKH 6DOYDWLRQ $UP\ %L0DUW D ORFDO UHWDLOHUDQG WKH &DPSILUH %R\V DQG *LUOV :KLOH WKH %RDUG PDMRULW\ VWDWHG WKDWWKHUH LV QR HYLGHQFH WKDW HPSOR\HUV KDG FORVHG WKHLU GRRUV RQ FKDULWDEOHVROLFLWDWLRQV VHYHUDO RI WKH DPLFL FRQWHQG RQ DSSHDO WKDW WKLV VLWXDWLRQ KDVRFFXUUHG

6!%!-%.%$*$%!16$$0*$*!#/,-@#'/*@*--)!#$@,#&-%.%$*$%!!%$,',#'$@)0%-#!$,#'/%$$%!5$0#'$@,#&-%.%$*$%!'%!$*!.#$0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#'$*$#+$0*$*!#/,-@#'/*@,#'/%$-%.%$*$%!1@.0*'%$%#&'.*!.#')0%-#+#!@%!5$0#1@'5*!%F*$%!$0*$./1*$
9	0#+%#!$%!5 /#/1#' .0*'*.$#'%F#+ $0# ./,*!@ ,-%.@ *,#'/%$$%!5-%.%$*$%!1@.0*'%$*1-#5'6,)#-->!)!$$0# .//6!%$@ )0%-# 1*!!%!5 6.0 -%.%$*$%! &'/.0*'%$*1-# 5'6, $0*$ *'# !$ )#-- >!)! ' 1@ ,-%$%.*-5'6,'.//#'.%*-5'6,#--%!55+*!+#'(%.#0#+%#!$%!5 /#/1#' *) ! ,'1-#/ )%$0 6.0 * ,-%.@%!*/6.0 * $0# -%!# -1#'$! +'#) '#5*'+%!5 $0#'5*!%F*$%!$0*$.6-+*!+.6-+!$-%.%$)*!$*!*!$%6!%!-%!#0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#''#*!#+$0*$$0#6!%!%!$0%.*#)#'#!$-%.%$%!5.0*'%$*1-#.!$'%16$%!16$'*$0#')#'#*$$#/,$%!5*/!5$0#'$0%!5$,#'6*+#$0#./,*!@#/,-@##$B16@C%$'#,'##!$*$%!*-#'(%.#)0%.0 $0# $'# !-%.%$*$%! ,-%.@ ,'0%1%$#+  0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#',%!$#+6$$0*$%&!#&$0#.0*'%$%#$0*$)*,#'/%$$#+$ -%.%$!$0#./,*!@,',#'$@ 650$+!*$%!&'*,-%$%.*-.*/,*%5!6.0-%.%$*$%!)6-+1#,'0%1%$#+ 6!+#' $0# ./,*!@ !-%.%$*$%! ,-%.@)#(#'%&*6!%!650$$'*%#/!#@&'$0#/#'%.*!*!.#'6!+*$%!%$)6-+1#,#'/%$$#+$+6!+#'$0#,-%.@0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#'#I,-*%!#+$0*$6.0*,-%.@)*,#'/%$$#+6!+#'$0#1#.*6#%$)*!$1*#+!6!%! .!%+#'*$%!  0# +%#!$%!5 /#/1#' &6'$0#'1#-%#(#+'#G6%'%!5#/,-@#'$,#!$0#%'+'$6!%!)0#!#(#' $0#@ .0# $ +  &' .0*'%$%# )6-+ -#*+ $#/,-@#'.-%!5$0#%'+'!.0*'%$%#*-$5#$0#'*!+$0*$$0#*'+06-+#!.6'*5##/,-@#'$1#*5#!#'6*,%1-#%!*--)%!5*..#$$0#%','#/%#&'1#!#&%.#!$*.$

  

7KH SDUWLHV SUHVHQW QXPHURXV DUJ

XQLRQV DQG FKDULWLHV DUH FRPSDUDEOH IRU DQDO\VLV 7KH DPLFL DOVR KDYH VXEPLWWHG VDPH LVVXH %HFDXVH RI RXU GLVSRVLWLRQ LQ YDULRXV LVVXHV UDLVHG E\ WKH DPLFL RU WKH SDRU GLVVLPLODULW\ EHWZHHQ FKDULWLHV DQG XQLLQ &5(3 WKDW 3>Q@R UHOHYDQW ODERU SROLFHPSOR\HUV WR SURKLELW FKDULWDEOH VROLFLWDWLWR H[FOXGH QRQHPSOR\HH GLVWULEXWLRQ ZKHLV RWKHUZLVH DYDLODEOH ́  )G DW  WKDW GHVSLWH WKH KROGLQJV LQ &5(3 DQG 6

KROGLQJ LQ 1/5% Y 6WRZH 6SLQQLQJ &R WKH %RDUG¶V YLHZ WKDW GLVFULPLQDWLRQ RFZKHUH DQ HPSOR\HU DOORZV DFFHVV WR LWV SVLPLODU DFFHVV WR XQLRQV $V D SUHOLPLQDU\ 

LQWHUSUHWLQJ WKH 3GLVFULPLQDWLRQ H[FHSWL:LOFR[ DV 6WRZH 6SLQQLQJ ZDV GHFLGHG )XUWKHU 6WRZH 6SLQQLQJ LV GLVWLQJXLVKDE

%RDUG IRXQG WKDW IRXU HPSOR\HUV LQ D VPDODERU SUDFWLFH ZKHUH WKH HPSOR\HUV KDG ULQ WKH RQO\ PHHWLQJ KDOO LQ WKH WRZQ DOWKRRWKHU JURXSV LQFOXGLQJ VRPH RI D FKDU6SLQQLQJ  86 DW  VHH DOVR 1/5

)G   WK &LU  QRWLQJ WKDW VXFK SXUSRVHV DV FKXUFK EDQTXHWV /DGL&KULVWPDV SDUW\ IRU VFKRRO FKLOGUHQ +R%RDUG¶V ILQGLQJ WKDW WKH HPSOR\HUV¶ DFWLSUDFWLFH WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW H[SODLQHG WVROH UHDVRQ WKDW WKH HPSOR\HUV GLVDOORZUHVXOW RI DQWLXQLRQ ELDV 6HYHUDO HPSOR\IRU WKHLU XQLRQ DFWLYLW\ DQG WKH HPSOR\HUWKDW WKH\ UHIXVHG DFFHVV RI WKH KDOO WR WKH IRU XQLRQV  86 DW  	 Q ,Q DGGLW FRXOG QRW FRPSDUH WKH DFFHVV WR WKH PHHGRPLQDWHG ́ WRZQ ZLWK 3WKH YDVW PHWURSRKDOOV DUH DYDLODEOH ZLWKLQ HDV\ UHDFK RI SU

7KXV LQ DGGLWLRQ WR DQWLXQLRQ ELDV WKHUH RWKHU UHDVRQDEO\ DYDLODEOH IRUXP IRU WKH &5(3  )G DW  3:KHUH UHDVRQDEH[LVW  
V JXDUDQWHHV GR QRW DXWKRURUJDQL]HUV HYHQ    μXQGHU    UHDVRQDEOH %RDUG ́ TXRWLQJ /HFKPHUH  86 D

WKHUH LV QR FODLP WKDW /RFDO  ODFNHG RW

6'$%!	*!+'#*&&%'/#+%!..6''#+%!$0%.*#
E 

  

0# 6!%! &%-#+ *! 6!&*%' -*1' ,'*.$%.# .0*'5# *5*%!$	*!+6>@*!+$0#*'+&6!+$0*$	*!+6>@0*+(%-*$#+$0#

! *,,#*- $0# 6'$ *++'##+ $0# ,#.%&%. %6# &

)0#$0#'B	*!+6>@/*@1#./,#--#+$,#'/%$!!6!%!#/,-@##6!%!/#/1#'$$'#,*!$0#/*--,',#'$@&' $0# ,6',# & +%$'%16$%!5 0*!+1%-- 6'5%!5 /*--.6$/#' !$ $ ,*$'!%F# !!6!%! #/,-@#'C  

#-@%!5 ! 	 $0# 6'$ %! 
 ! *!)#'#+ $0#G6#$%!%!$0#*&&%'/*$%(# 6" 
4334322*$PA2$0 %' 86-@  3D A0-+%!5 $0*$ #/,-@#' +%+ !$+%.'%/%!*$#*5*%!$6!%!)0#!%$*--)#+.0*'%$%#!%$,',#'$@$-%.%$.!$'%16$%!16$)6-+!$*--)!!#/,-@##6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#$#!5*5#%!B+!$,*$'!%F#-%.%$*$%!C $*'5#$#+ *$ $0# #/,-@#'D   ! 70  %&   244  EA$0%'<*@DA0-+%!5$0*$/*--+%+!$+%.'%/%!*$#*5*%!$6!%!)0#!%$*--)#+;%'-	.6$*!+1-+/1%-#!/*--,',#'$@)0%-#!$*--)%!5,%.>#$%!5!!#/,-@##'#,'##!$*$%(#D

0#0-+%!5%!	*!+
 !$0*$*!#/,-@#'+#

!$+%.'%/%!*$#*5*%!$*6!%!)0#'#$0##/,-@#'*--).0*'%$%# $ +%#/%!*$# %!&'/*$%! ! $0# #/,-@#',',#'$@)0%-#%$1*'6!%!&'/+%!5$0#*/#)%$06$/'# *,,#*' $ &'#.-# $0# *'+ *'56/#!$ $0*$+%.'%/%!*$%!..6''#+%!$0%.*#
$%6!.!$#$#+$0*$-1#'$!!-@*--)#+.#'$*%!.0*'%$%#$-%.%$+!*$%!*'6!+ $0# #I$#'%' & %$ ,',#'$@ #I.#,$ %! %!.-#/#!$)#*$0#')0#!%$*--)#+$0#;%'-	.6$*!+	*-(*$%!'/@1#--'%!5#'*..#$$0#%!%+#&/#%$$'#0#'#%!#(%+#!.#%!$0%.*#$0*$+6'%!5$0#$%/#-1#'$!'#&6#+$ *--) .*-  !!#/,-@## '5*!%F#' $ +%$'%16$#-%$#'*$6'#!%$,',#'$@-1#'$!*--)#++%$'%16$%!1@*!$0#' 6!%! ' $0*$ -1#'$! %$#-& +%#/%!*$#+%!&'/*$%! %/%-*' $ $0*$ %$ 1*!!#+ .*-  &'/+%#/%!*$%!5	+*$230#'#&'#6!+#'$0#+#&%!%$%!&$0#$#'/ B+%.'%/%!*$%!C * #$ &'$01@$0%

  

#I,-*%!#+1#-))#1#-%#(#

.!$'-$0#+%,%$%!&$0%.*+#&%!#+$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C$0*$$#'/%! ()**!+%.'%/%!*$%! %! $0# %!$*!$ .*#-$0650*$0#*'+!$#1@.$$%!5 *.$%(%$@ )0#! B+%.'%/%!*$%!C$0%6'$->#

56%+*!.#)0%.0%$#-&)**.*#*.$%(%$@06$0#*'+0* &*%1*%$+%$%!56%0
 !*!+	

&

0#,*'$%#.!$#$$0#*,,-%.*1-

*'+ *'56# *$ -#!5$0 $0*$ $0%+#&%!%$%!&$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*'#*.0 $0*$ +#&%!%$%! $0# *'+$*$6$'@,'(%%!6!+#'$0#


4A0-+%!5$0*$)0#'#$*$6$#/#*!*'+ /6$ +#&#' $ !5'# )0#'# */1%56%$@ #I%$ .6'$ /'#*!*1-#%!$#','#$*$%!&$0# +71
E4 AE2DD..'+%!5$$0#5#!#'*- $#'/ $0*$ *! #/,-@#' ,'*.$%.#1@*/!5$0#'$0%!5'#.#'$*%!'%50$56*'*!$##+1@$0##/,-@##$#-&'5*!%F#'$HJJ 4 EA*DAD  0# *'+ 1#.*6#!5'#0*!$,>#!$*!#/,-@#'B+%.'%/%!*$#C*5*%*--) !!#/,-@## 6!%! '5*!-%$#'*$6'#!%$,',#'$@*-$0650%$0#!$0%6'$/6$*..#,$$0*$$'%16$#$$0#$#'/+%.'%/%!*$%

0%6'$0**++'##+*!+'#

1@$0#*'+%!
 !)0#'#)
 

  

&'#(%#)*,,-%.*1-#$*'++#.%%!*#*'-%#'#$&'$01@$0%6'$%!	#,%!$#+6$%!
 !$0*$B)#'#(%#) $0# *'+ &*.$6*- *,,-%.*$%! *!+ $*$6$'@.!$'6.$%! 6!+#' * 61$*!$%*- #(%+#!.# $*!+*'+ *+#&#'#!.#$0*$% )*''*!$#+%&$0# *'+ .!.-6%! *'#1*#+6,!*'#*!*1-@+#&#!%1-#.!$'6.$%!&$0#.$C2+*$3E4AG6$%!5	+*$23D	61$*!$%*-#(%+#!.#/#*!B6.0'#-#(*!$#(%+#!.#**'#*!*1-#/%!+/%50$*..#,$**+#G6*$#$6,,'$*.!.-6%!C7
7&
'
	+42E3*$P2A3$0%'86-@D

)#(#'$0%6'$5%(#!+#&#'#!.#$$0#*'+)0#'#

$0#*'++#.%%!B'#$MN!#''!#6-#5*-&6!+*$%!C%'
	4ADA0-+%!5$0*$*'+#''#+%!&%!+%!5$0*$#/,-@#'06-+0*(#*--)#+6!%!!%$,'#/%#1#.*6#%$0*+!$0#')*@$'#*.0%$$*'5#$ *6+%#!.# %!*/6.0 * %! '#*.0%!5 %$ +#.%%! $0#*'+/%.!$'6#+,'%'	6,'#/#6'$,'#.#+#!$D6'$0#')0#'#$0#*'+ .!.-6%!&-*)+!$%!$#','#$$0#)#'#(%#)$0#.!.-6%!"#+A3$0%'4D
!$0*$(#%!)#'#(%#)  $0# *'+ %!$#','#$*$%! & 	6,'#/# 6'$ *!+	%I$0 %'.6%$ +#.%%! *!+ 5%(# $0# *'+ ! +#&#'#!.#B)%$0 '#,#.$ $ $0# %!$#','#$*$%! & H6+%.%*- ,'#.#+#!$C
 ! 2 + *$ 3  
 
   ) 00  E +   !E A3$0%' 4DA+#&#''%!5$$0#*'++#&%!%$%!&B-*1''5*!%F*$%!C16$!$%!5+%&&#'#!.#%!+#&#'#!.#5%(#!$*'+'#*!*1-#%!$#','#$*$%!&$0#*,,#+$%$%!$#','#$*$%!&	6,'#/#6'$,'#.#+#!$.!$'6%!5$0#.$D


! $0# %!$*!$ .*# $0# *'+ +#.%%! $6'!#+ ! %$

&%!+%!5$0*$-1#'$!+%.'%/%!*$#+*5*%!$.*-*!+.*-E1@'#&6%!5$*--)$0##$)6!%!$+%$'%16$#$0#%' -%$#'*$6'# ' $0#')%# -%.%$ ! $0# ,'#/%# & $0#./,*!@$'#)0%-#*--)%!5.#'$*%!.0*'%$%#$+0#%6#&)0#$0#'*!#/,-@#'B+%.'%/%!*$#C*5*%!$*6!%!6!+#'6.0.%'.6/$*!.#%!$!#&&%'$%/,'#%!%!$0% .%'.6%$ *)# *++'##+$0%%6#%!
 ! *!+

  5#!#'*--@06-+1#'#,#.$&6-&$0$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C$0%*'+ +#.%%! % )#+ ! +#&#''!#6-#5*-&6!+*$%!C
$0*$BM!N'#-#(*!$-*1',-%.%##/,-@#' $ ,'0%1%$ .0*'%$*1-#,'##'(# $0# '%50$ $ #I.-6+# !!6!%! -%$#'*$6'# )0#! *..# $$0#')%#*(*%-*1-#C0#6	#.$%!EA*DAD&$0#%$%!$#'&#'%!5)%$0#/,-@##	#.$%6.0.!%+#'*$%!%!/%!+$0#

!)!#'&*,'%(*$#.//#'.%* .0*'%$*1-# '5*!%F*$%! $ +%.!+6.$ -%.%$*$%! ! %$ ,'%/,-%.*$#$0#,-%.%#&$0#/'# '#!+#' *! #/,-@#' 56,'*.$%.#)0#!-*$#'%$.0#$&B(*-%+-@,$M%!5%$N,',#'+%$'%16$%!&6!%!-%$#'*$6'#C

A.%$%!5 
	*$

	6.0 .!%+#'*$%!-#+$0%

+%.'%/%!*$%! * 6#+ %! 

B&*('%!5 !# 6!%! (#' *!$0#'#-*$#+ %!&'/*$%! )0%-# 1*''%%!&'/*$%!C


!
 !$0%6'$*5*%!*+

#I.#,$%! %!   ( )*1#5*!*,%.>#$%!5.*/,*%5!*&$#'*6!%! .!$'6.$%! .!$'*.$' *!*!$0#'/*--$#!*!$ &'$0#*/# 	*!+6>@)0%.0)!#+*!+,#'6!%!$0*$0*!+1%--#')6-+1#.$0*$ $0#@ )6-+ 1# *>#+ $ -#*+%$'%16$#+ 0*!+1%-- %! $0# /*-- )#'#*>#+$-#*(##*.0$%/#.*--#+$0#,-%.#*!+0*+$0#0*!+1
3 

  

7KH &RXUW LQ /HFKPHUH IRFXVHG RQO\ RQ WKH ILUVW H[FHSWLRQ WR WKH

3JHQHUDO UXOH ́ WKDW DQ HPSOR\HU 3FDQ EDU QRQHPSOR\HH XQLRQ RUJDQL]HUVIURP KLV SURSHUW\ ́ EHFDXVH LQ WKDW FDVH LW ZDV XQGLVSXWHG WKDW WKHHPSOR\HU KDG QRW SHUPLWWHG DQ\ RWKHU JURXS WR GLVWULEXWH OLWHUDWXUH RQ LWVSURSHUW\ /HFKPHUH  86 DW  Q

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
	*$4D


!	$0#*'+*'56#+$0*$%')*!$'#-#(*!$

%!*/6.0*%'&*%-#+$*!*-@F# ()*


+%.'%/%!*$%! #I.#,$%! 1#.*6# " B+%.'%/%!*$#+*5*%!$ $0# 6!%! 1@ ,#'/%$$%!5 $0#' -%.%$*$%! 1@.0*'%$%#C *$2320%6'$+%*5'##+$0*$%'

+%+!$*,,-@16$/'#%/,'$*!$-@&',6',#&$0#%!$*!$.*#%$0#-+$0*$6!+#' ()**!+%$,'5#!@6.0*%'B)0%.0)#%500#*(%-@%!&*('&,'%(*$#,',#'$@'%50$C$0#)'+B+%.'%/%!*$%!C+#!$.*''@$0#)#%50$ $0# *'+ *.'%1# $ %$   *$ 23  0# 6'$#I,-*%!#+$0*$BM$N+%.'%/%!*$#%!$0##!&'.#/#!$&M*!#/,-@#'N !-%.%$*$%! ,-%.@ .*!!$ /#*! $0*$ *!#/,-@#'.//%$*!6!&*%'-*1','*.$%.#%&%$*--)$0#;%'-	.6$$#--.>%#16$%0%#-+#+&'/$0##&&#.$&$0#.$ %& %$ ,'0%1%$ $0#/ &'/ +%!5 C    0# 6'$

'#.5!%F#+$0*$ %!.#  ()* )* +#.%+#+$0#

	6,'#/#6'$0*+!#(#'B.-*'%&%#+C$0#$#'/+%.'%/%!*$#6'$0#')0%-#$0%6'$%!	*.>!)-#+5#+$0*$)#

  	6'$0#'%!'#*.0%!5%$+)*%!$#','#$%!5B+%.'%/%!*$%!C*	6,'#/#6'$.*# ()$*!+*'+ & '#(%#) & $0# *'	6,'#/#6'$*6$0'%$@%3

&

	#.$%!EA*DAD&$0#,'

6!&*%' -*1' ,'*.$%.# &' *! #/'#$'*%! ' .#'.# #/,-@## %! 56*'*!$##+ %! #.$%! M4 & $0JEA*DAD	#.$%!4&$0#$0*$BM#N/,-@##0*--0*(#$0#'%&'/ H%! ' *%$ -*1' .--#.$%(#-@$0'650 '#,'##!$*$%(*!+$#!5*5#%!$0#'.!.#'$#+*.--#.$%(#1*'5*%!%!5'$0#'/6$ 
	 J 4  ! #/,-@#' *!+.//%$*!6!&*%'-*1''%!$#'&#'#)%$0$0#'%50$&#/,-$	#.$%!4%'
	

B@%$,-*%!$#'/$06$0#

#/,-@##!$!6!%!'$0#%'*$B'#$'%.$%!/*@1#'%50$$+%.6#-&'5*!%F*$%!$0##/,-@#'.*!+#/!$'*$#$0*$/*%!$*%!,'+6.$%!'+%.%,-%!#)#+$!!#/,-@##'5*!%F#'

$0#'%5%!*-DAG6$%!5&3A2DD	#.$%!4Q'5*,,-@!-@B+#'%(*$%(#-@C$!!#/ *$  
 
 
 

	!7
	1	
A4ED A#I,-*%!%!5 $0*$ BK!  !!#/,-@##'5*!%F#' *!@'%50!*!#/,-@#'Q,',#'$@%*+#'
2 

  

7KH %RDUG KDV KHOG WKDW WKH GLVFULPLQDWLRQ H[FHSWLRQ JHQHUDOO\ LV

VXEMHFW WR WZR H[FHSWLRQV RI LWV RZQ $Q HPSOR\HU GRHV QRW GLVFULPLQDWH LI WKH HPSOR\HU DOORZV D IHZ LVRODWHG LQVWDQFHV RI FKDULWDEOH

VROLFLWDWLRQ 3EHQHILFHQW DFWV H[FHSWLRQ ́ RU  LI WKH VROLFLWDWLRQVDSSURYHG E\ WKH HPSOR\HU UHODWH WR WKH HPSOR\HU¶V EXVLQHVV IXQFWLRQV DQGSXUSRVHV 6HH /XFLOH 6DOWHU 3DFNDUG &KLOGUHQ¶V +RVS DW 6WDQIRUG Y

1/5%  )G   '& &LU  FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG ,Q WKH

LQVWDQW FDVH WKH %RDUG KHOG WKDW WKH IUHTXHQF\ ZLWK ZKLFK $OEHUWVRQ¶V

DOORZHG FKDULWLHV WR VROLFLW GRQDWLRQV RQ LWV VWRUHV¶ SUHPLVHV H[FHHGHG WKDWSHUPLWWHG XQGHU WKH EHQHILFHQWDFWV H[FHSWLRQ $OEHUWVRQ¶V GRHV QRWFRQWHVW WKLV ILQGLQJ RQ DSSHDO +RZHYHU $OEHUWVRQ¶V GRHV FRQWHQG WKDWWKH %RDUG RIIHUV QR UHDVRQDEOH MXVWLILFDWLRQ IRU LWV EHQHILFHQWDFWVH[FHSWLRQ DQG DV WR ZK\ HPSOR\HUV¶ SURSHUW\ ULJKWV VKRXOG EH GLPLQLVKHG

#/,-@#'Q #/,-@##$ #I#'.%#$0#%' '5*!%F*$%! '%50$#&&#.$%(#-@CD

0#5#!#'*-'6-#%$0*$B*!#/,-@#'.*!!$1#./,#--#+

$ *--) +%$'%16$%! & 6!%! -%$#'*$6'# 1@ !!#/,-@##'5*!%F#' ! 0% ,',#'$@C %'  
	 *$ 

)#(#'$0#	6,'#/#6'$0*'#.5!%F#+$0*$B$0#'%50$&#-&'5*!%F*$%!+#,#!+%!/#/#*6'#!M*!#/,-@#'#/,-@##N *1%-%$@     $ -#*'! $0# *+(*!$*5# & #-&'5*!%F*$%!&'/$0#'C*$0#'#&'#	#.$%!4 /%50$ B%! .#'$*%! -%/%$#+ .%'.6/$*!.# '#$'%.$ *!#/,-@#''%50$$#I.-6+#!!#/,-@##6!%!'5*!%F#'&'/ 0% ,',#'$@C  *$   %' '#*&&%'/#+ $0#

	6,'#/#6'$#*'-%#'0-+%!5$0*$*!#/,-@#'/*@B,$0% ,',#'$@ *5*%!$ !!#/,-@## +%$'%16$%! & 6!%!-%$#'*$6'#%&MN'#*!*1-##&&'$1@$0#6!%!$0'650$0#'*(*%-*1-#.0*!!#-&.//6!%.*$%!)%--#!*1-#%$$'#*.0$0# #/,-@## )%$0 %$ /#*5# *!+ MN %& $0# #/,-@#'!$%.#''+#'+#!$+%.'%/%!*$# *5*%!$$0#6!%!1@*--)%!5$0#'+%$'%16$%!M$0#K+%.'%/%!*$%!#I.#,$%!NC ()*
	*$"*'$%.6-*'-@*$$0#+%.'%/%!*$%!#I.#,$%!B$0#*--#5#++%.'%/%!*$'@.!+6.$%! *--)%!5 -%.%$*$%! M'N0*!+1%--%!5 '#G6%'#MN$0*$$0#+%.'%/%!*$%!1#*/!5./,*'*1-#5'6,'*.$%(%$%#*!+$0*$ $0# *.$%(%$%#$0#/#-(# 6!+#' .!%+#'*$%! /6$ 1#./,*'*1-#C
 !2+*$3A.%$*$%!%!$#'!*-G6$*$%!/*'>*!+*-$#'*$%!/%$$#+D

  DV D UHVXOW RI WKHLU JHQHURVLW\ WR FKDULWLHV$OEHUWVRQ¶V GRHV QRW FRQWHQG WKDW WKH FKDULWV SUHPLVHV UHODWH WR LWV EXVLQHVV DV D UHW

	&  ( 	
 

 '(!(

0%6'$0*+%.6#+$0#

'#5*'+%!5+%.'%/%!*$%! %!

+24$0#6!%!1#5*!*0<*'.*'#$*%-$'#*!+!#&/*!*5#+1@"*$20<*'.0*+(%-*$#+.0%-+-*1'-&6!+%!1I#&'*%%!$0#$'#

$0#0*!+1%--)*$%!&'/$0#,616!%!$'#*!+$*>$0#,61-%.!

&$#'<*'../,-*%!#+$$0#,'$*>#!$0*(#$0#0*!+1%--#'.#*#(#!$6*--@$0#,',#'$@/*!*5#')0#!$0#0*!+1%--#'0*+'#&6#+$%!(%-*$%!&$0#.%$@'+%!*!.#*5

0# 6!%! &%-#+ *! 6!&*%'-*1

"*!+*!8&6!+$0*$%!$00*+1##!*--)#+$+%$'%16$#-#*&,*'>#+ *$ $0# /*--  0# 8 &6.*!+%+*$#0*+1##!*--)#+$-	.6$ 0*+ -+ .>%#  $0#' )%$06$ 1#%!5 *>#+ $ -#*(# -6/16 $0# @ 	.6$ (#$#'#--%!5.*!+@&'(*'%6.0-,'

$0*$$0#6!%!'5*!%F#')#'##!56!+#'$0#*!+&6!+%$%''#)#'# !$ #/,-@#+ 1@ <*'. #/,-@##&$0#'6!%!%F#+$'

0%6'$ &'*/#+$0#%6# *

)!#' & * ,'%(*$# '#$*%- 0,,%!'#,'##!$*$%(# &'/ +%$'%16$%!0,,#'$+%.6'*5#$0#/&'/