Non-Tier 2 Vehicles for V4 / E-87-2Brian West and John OrbanNovember 5, 20092CRC-DOE confidential–Do not Cite49 Vehicles Currently Under Test at 3 Sites16 models, 2006-2009, Tier 2Year Vehicle number2006 Chevrolet Silverado 4E0E10E15E202007 Honda Accord 4E0E10E15E202008 Nissan Altima 4E0E10E15E202008 Ford Taurus 4E0E10E15E202007 Chrysler Caravan 4E0E10E15E202006 Chevrolet Cobalt 3E0E15E20Year Vehicle number2009 Jeep Liberty 3E0E15E202009 Ford Explorer 3E0E15E202009 Honda Civic 3E0E15E202009 Toyota Corolla 3E0E15E202006 Chevrolet Impala 3E0E15E202005 Toyota Tundra 3E0E15E20Environmental Testing Corp (Colorado), mileage accumulation dynamometersYear Vehicle number2009 Saturn Outlook 2E0E152009 Toyota Camry 2E0E152009 Ford Focus 2E0E152009 Honda Odyssey 2E0E15FuelsSouthwest Research Institute (Texas), mileage accumulation dynamometers (E-87-2)FuelsTransportation Research Center (Ohio), test track agingFuels23Vehicles18Vehicles8vehicles3CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteProposed path forward: 19 Tier 2, 8 “pre-2004”Non-Tier 2 picks from same mfrs is most defensible mixRegistration database,E-87-1 “Top Ten,” and V1 screening considered in selectionsYear Make Model Engine site Year Make Model Engine Cert2006 Chevrolet Silverado 5.3L V8 SwRI2000 Chevrolet Silverado 5.3L V8 T1 or LEV2006 Chevrolet Impala 3.9L V6 TRC2009 Saturn Outlook 3.6L V6 ETC2006 Chevrolet Cobalt 2.2L I4 SwRI2003 Chevrolet Cavalier 2.2L I4 LEV? (Ion)2008 Ford Taurus 3.5L V6 SwRI2003 Ford Taurus 3.0L V6 LEV or T2B8?2009 Ford Explorer 4.0L V6 TRC2009 Ford Focus 2.0L I4 ETC2000 Ford Focus 2.0L I4 LEV2005 Ford F150 5.4L V8 TRC2007 Dodge Caravan 3.3L V6 SwRI2007 Dodge Caliber 2.4L I4 SwRI2009 Jeep Liberty 3.7L V6 TRC2002 Dodge Durango 4.7L V8 T1, LEV, or ULEV2005 Toyota Tundra 4.0L V6 TRC2009 Toyota Corolla 1.8L I4 TRC2009 Toyota Camry 2.4L I4 ETC2003 Toyota Camry 2.4L I4 ULEV2007 Honda Accord 2.4L I4 SwRI2000 Honda Accord 2.3L I4 LEV, ULEV, SLEV2009 Honda Civic 1.8L I4 TRC2009 Honda Odyssey 3.5L V6 ETC2008 Nissan Altima 2.5L I4 SwRI2002 Nissan Frontier 2.4L I4LEV2006 Nissan Quest 3.5L V6 SwRIHondaNissannon-Tier 2Tier 2GMFordChryslerToyotaBlack Text: Under TestRed Text: Planned / in acquisitionGreen Text: This Proposal2.0L I44CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteSummary•8 - 2009•2 - 2008•3 - 2007•4 - 2006•2 - 2005•4 GM•4 Ford•3 Chrysler•3 Toyota•3 Honda•2 Nissan•3 - 2003•2 - 2002•3 - 2000•2 GM•2 Ford•1 Chrysler•1 Toyota•1 Honda•1 Nissan19 Tier 28 Non-Tier 25CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteSix of Top Ten Vehicles From E-87-1included in this proposal•2002 Nissan Frontier (4cyl)•2000 Ford Focus•1999 Ford Crown Victoria•2001 Hyundai Accent•2001 Mazda 626 (4cyl)•2000 Honda Accord LX (4 cyl)•2006 Chevrolet Cobalt•2002 Dodge Durango 4WD•2003 Nissan Altima (4cyl)•2006 Nissan QuestE-87-1 Top Ten•2009 Ford Focus•2007 Honda Accord•2008 Nissan Altima (4cyl)Similar Models6CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteSummaryV2 models LFT nonLFTE-87 topTenTotalsTier 218 10 9 2 19nonT2- 264 8Total18 12 15 6 27•V2 / EPAct study – 19 models−18/19 match model, but various T2 model years−2006 Nissan Quest replaced Toyota Sienna7CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteScheduleFacility # vehNew/Used Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Se4 2007 Accord Used 35k 85k120k- - - -10b*4 2006 Silverado Used27k77k120k4 2008 Altima Used20k70k120k4 2008 Taurus Used17k67k120k4 2007 Caravan Used45k95k120k3 2006 Cobalt Used50k95k120k3 2006 Quest Used50k95k 120k3 2007 CaliberUsed50k95k 120k3 2009 Civic New4k60k120k3 2009 Explorer New4k60k120k3 2009 Corolla New4k60k120k3 2009 Liberty New4k60k120k3 2005 Tundra Used50k95k120k3 2006 Impala Used35k95k120k3 2005 F150Used50k95k120k2 2009 Outlook New4k60k90k120k2 2009 Camry New4k60k90k120k2 2009 Focus New4k60k90k120k2 2009 OdysseyNew4k60k90k120k20102009ETC(5000 ftEl.)TRCYear and ModelSWRI•Non-Tier 2 vehicles to start in Spring 2010 at SwRI and TRC•Priority on finishing Tier 2 vehicles per EPA/DOE•Non-Tier 2 vehicles could finish late 2010, early 20118CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteBackup Slides9CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteV4 Project Status•Vehicle emissions testing and agingunderway at SwRI (E-87-2 with CRC)−Aging on mileage accumulation dynamometers−23 vehicles purchased and under test•Parallel V4 contracts underway−TRC (Ohio)•Aging on track•12 new 2009 vehicles (4 matched sets of 3– 3 fuels per model)•6 used vehicles (2 matched sets of 3)−ETC (Colorado)•Mileage accumulation dynamometers•8 new 2009 vehicles (4 matched pairs – 2fuels per model)Ford TaurusNissan AltimaChevy SilveradoTRC TrackMAD ConsolesHonda Accord10CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteE-87-2 Program Status•SwRI has purchased 25 vehicles (23 under test)−5 models, 4 matched vehicles per model, 1 vehicle per fuel for aging−3 Cobalts – first veh model to use 3 fuels (no E10)•2007 Accordcomplete•2006 Chevrolet Silverado120k tests complete•2008 Nissan Altimacompleted 0k, 50k, on MADs•2008 Ford Tauruscompleted 0k, on MADs•2007 Dodge Caravancompleted 0k (3/4)•2006 Chev Cobaltin test•NEXT:−2006 Nissan Questshopping−2007 Dodge Calibershopping−2002 Nissan Frontiershopping−Other non-Tier 2 vehicles subject of this proposal....11CRC-DOE confidential–Do not Cite•Several relevant criteria impact vehicle selection−Model year, emissions standard (e.g., Tier 2, non-Tier 2)−Manufacturer, sales/registration volumes−LFT or non-LFT at WOT•Guidance and screening studies impact selection−EPA V2 vehicle list (19 popular models –test all)−CRC E-87-1 (e.g., “CRC Top Ten” non-LFT vehicles)−DOE V1 (additional info on LFT/non-LFT)•DOE/EPA guidance−Test all V2 vehicle models, multiple model years okay•1 exception – 2006 Nissan Quest replaces 2007 ToyotaSienna−Non-Tier 2 vehicles to follow Tier 2 vehiclesVehicle Selection Challenge12CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteV1- Test VehiclesOEM (make)ModelYearEngineInitialodometerreading(miles)EmissionstandardTest siteLFT atWOT?ChryslerTown & Country20073.3 L V635,000Tier 2, Bin 5NREL/CDPHENFordF15020075.4 L V828,600Tier 2, Bin 8TRCYFordF15020035.4 L V857,000Tier 1 LEVTRCYFordTaurus20033.0 L V689,600Tier 2, Bin 8TRCNGM (Buick)Lucerne20073.8 L V610,000Tier 2, Bin 5 (CALEV II)NREL/CDPHE andORNL*YGM (Buick)LeSabre20033.8 L V678,000Tier 2, Bin 8NREL/CDPHEYGMSilverado20074.8 L V812,800Tier 2, Bin 8TRCYHondaAccord20072.4 L I411,400Tier 2, Bin 5 (CALEV II)TRCNNissanAltima20033.5 L V653,300LEVTRCNToyotaCamry20072.4 L I426,440Tier 2, Bin 5ORNL andNREL/CDPHE*YToyotaCamry20032.4 L I472,800ULEVORNLNChryslerPT Cruiser20012.4 L I493,400NLEVNREL/CDPHEYFordCrown Victoria19994.6 L V850,900ULEVNREL/CDPHEYHondaCivic19991.6 L I479,680Tier 1ORNLNToyotaCorolla19991.8 L I496,400Tier 1NREL/CDPHEYVWGolf GTI20041.8 L I4 Turbo32,900Tier 2, Bin 8ORNLY*Round-robin vehicle tested at two sites13CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteV2 - EPAct Program VehiclesMake Year Brand ModelEngine Family BinGM 2008 Chevrolet Cobalt 2.2L I4 8GMXV02.4025 5GM 2008 Chevrolet Impala 3.5L V6-FFV 8GMXV03.9052 5GM 2008 Saturn Outlook 3.6L V6 8GMXT03.6151 5GM 2008 Chevrolet Silverado 5.3L V8-FFV 8GMXT05.3373 5Toyota 2008 Toyota Corolla1.8L I4 8TYXV01.8BEA 5Toyota 2008 Toyota Camry2.4L I4 8TYXV02.4BEA 5Toyota 2008 Toyota Sienna3.5L V6 8TYXT03.5BEM 5Toyota 2008 Toyota Tundra4.0L V6 8TYXT04.0AES 5Ford 2008 Ford Focus2.0L I4 8FMXV02.0VD4 4Ford 2008 Ford Taurus3.5L V6 8FMXV03.5VEP 5Ford 2008 Ford/Mercury Explorer/Mountaineer 4.0L V6 8FMXT04.03DB 4Ford 2008 Ford F1505.4L V8-FFV 8FMXT05.44HF 8Chrysler 2008 DodgeCaliber2.4L I4 8CRXB02.4ME0 5Chrysler 2008 DodgeCaravan3.3L V6-FFV 8CRXT03.3NEP 5Chrysler 2008 JeepLiberty3.7L V6 8CRXT03.7NE0 5Honda 2008 Honda Civic1.8L I4 8HNXV01.8LKR 5Honda 2008 Honda Accord2.4L I4 8HNXV02.4TKC 5Honda 2008 Honda Odyssey3.5L V6 8HNXT03.54KR 5Nissan 2008 Nissan Altima2.5L I4 8NSXV02.5G5A 514CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteAutomaker Vehicle SelectionsVINManufactuModel YearMileage2CNBJ13C916959807 Chevrolet Tracker 2001 CRC #1 2.0L 4 AT4 115,2232C1MR522016703462 Chevrolet Metro 2001 CRC #2 1.3L 4 AT3 81,7902FAFP73W9XX171619 Ford Crown Vic1999 CRC #3 4.6L V8 AT4 73,0573C8FY4BB51T270479 Chrysler PT Cruiser2001 CRC #4 2.4L 4 AT4 76,6371N4AL11D53C307269 Nissan Altima 2003 CRC #5 2.5L 4 AT 85,3961N6DD26S12C327998 Nissan Frontier 2003 CRC #6 2.4L 4 AT4 70,210KMHCG45CX14256655 Hyundai Accent 2001 CRC #7 1.5L 4 AT4 79,382WBAEV534X4KM35540 BMW 330i 2004 CRC #8 3.0 L AT 38,722JA3AY26A8XU029420 Mitsubishi Mirage 1999 CRC #9 1.5L 4 AT4 113,204JA4MT31R01P052786 Mitsubishi Montero 2001 CRC #10 3.5L V6 4WD85,8711HGEG8642SL063002 Honda Civic 1995 CRC #11 1.5L 4 AT4 165,4551J4GA64167L108305 Jeep Rubicon 2007 CRC #12 3.8L V6 4WD5,3123VWSE69M33M138195 VolkswageJetta 2003 CRC #13 1.8L 4 AT 88,02515CRC-DOE confidential–Do not CiteDOE Vehicle SelectionsVINManufactuModel YearMileage1G1AK55F367824348 Chevrolet Cobalt 2006 CRC #14 2.2L 4 AT4 12,4231GCEK19B36Z173669 Chevrolet Silverado 2006 CRC #15 5.3L V8 AT4 41,6133GNFK16T32G166739 Chevrolet Suburban 2002 CRC #16 5.3L V8 4WD83,0361FAFP34N67W297270 Ford Focus 2007 CRC #17 2.0L 4 AT 19,9881FAFP34PXTW235826 Ford Focus 2000 CRC #18 2.0L 4 AT 93,7551FAFP52U33G119410 Ford Taurus 2003 CRC #19 3.0L 2v V6A51,3661B4HS38N32F174754 Chrysler Durango 2002 CRC #20 4.7L V8 AT 75,1914T32F19C5YU248096 Toyota Sienna 2000 CRC #21 3.0L V6 AT 81,8801HGCG5641YA05648 Honda Accord 2000 CRC #22 2.3L 4 AT 97,2915N1BV28U66N122172 Nissan Quest 2006 CRC #23 3.5L V6 AT 35,6443VWSB69M41M209670 VolkswageJetta #24 2001 CRC #24 2.0L 4 AT 71,9271YVGF22C615206499 Mazda 626 2001 CRC #25 2.0L 4 AT 75,253