National Impact Summa

National Impact Summa
National Impact Summa

National Impact Summa

Equipment Class 3:

• 2 of 62 or 3 2% kVA Shipments 2 of 62 or

3.2% kVA Shipments

• Net Present Value Peak @ EL2 or EL1

• 0.10 of 7.10 or 1.4% (3% at EL1)• 0.12 of 7.63 or 1.6% (3% at EL2)

Suggest Equipment Class 3 is left at base case, the benefits do noIncrease in efficiency.By not changing Manufacturers will only have to focus on conversioMarket and Equipment Class 4
National Impact Summa

National Impact Summa

Equipment Class 4:

• 60 of 62 or 96 8% kVA Shipments 60 of 62 or 96.8% kVA Shipments• Net Present Value Peak EL4 with a smaller Peak at EL2

• 3% Differences 7.51 to 8.00 6.5% Increase for EL• 7% Differences 1.88 to 1.85 1.6% Decrease for E

Suggest Equipment Class 4 is set at the EL2 Level
Comments on Summary D

Comments on Summary D

• Computer Models Computer Models

– Assumes manufacturers will be at lowe

at year of implementation at year of implementation.

• Since product is purchased on First Cost n

adapters 5-10%

• Must support building Base Efficiency Lev

through conversion date

– L t C t d i bt i bl h Lowes

t

Cos

t

designs are obt

ainable, 

h

will take 3 to 5 years after law is implem

to achieve sell price from analysis to achieve sell price from analysis
Last Conversion on Manufact

Last Conversion on Manufact

• January 1, 2007 conversion January 1, 2007 conversion

– 25-30% of the market already mandated so p

already existed – lessen impact during last conversion

– After conversion the price jumped as manufa

finalized what the long term designs would be finalized what the long term designs would be

• Capacity• Materials• Tolerances due to operations

– Sell Price is just starting to be reduced to con

2011/2012 (4 to 5 years after implementation2011/2012 (4 to

5 years after implementation
Lessen Impact on Manufactu

Lessen Impact on Manufactu

• Equipment Class 3 will not receive a

Equipment Class

3 will not receive a

resources for conversion – will end uhow E

qp p ui

pment Class 4 are im

pleme

– Lowest cost from computer model will 

achieved if it matches material and pro

E i t Cl 4 Equipmen

t Class 

4

• R tM f t tb d Reques

t

Manu

fac

turers are no

t

bur

d

with converting 3% of the business f

1 5% of the total NPV 1.5% of the total NPV.
Equipment Class 4 Equipment Class

4

• DL7

– 75kVA

• DL8

– 300kVA

• 15, 30, 45, 75, 112.5, 

150kV

A

DL8 300kVA

• 225, 300, 500, 

1000kV

A

• Issues with scaling at 

the 15kV

A

• Issues with sca

the 750 and 10

– Request changed to 

0.60 instead of 0.75

– Request chan

0.69 and 0.68
Giving us the following Ta

Giving us the following Ta

kV

A EL0 EL1 EL2 EL3 EL4 EL5 EL

15 97.00% 96.68% 97.13% 97.37% 97.74% 97.98% 98

30 97.50% 97.78% 98.08% 98.24% 98.49% 98.66% 9845 97.70% 97.99% 98.26% 98.41% 98.64% 98.79% 9875 98.00% 98.23% 98.47% 98.60% 98.80% 98.93% 99

112.5 98.20% 98.40% 98.61% 98.73% 98.91% 99.03% 99

150 98 30% . 98 51% . 98 71% . 98 82% . 98 99% . 99 10% . 99 225 98.50% 98.71% 98.95% 99.08% 99.19% 99.27% 99300 98.60% 98.80% 99.02% 99.14% 99.25% 99.32% 99500 98.70% 98.94% 99.14% 99.24% 99.34% 99.40% 99750 98.80% 99.09% 99.26% 99.35% 99.43% 99.49% 99

1000 98.90% 99.18% 99.33% 99.41% 99.49% 99.54% 99

Suggest Levels to be EL2 with scaling the outer limits modified from the 0 75 the outer limits modified from the

0.75
Manufacturing Impact Manufacturing Impact

• EL2 com

p (p ) ared to EL4 

(two 

peaks

)

– Out of pocket expenses will be 100% more to 

to EL4 than EL2 ($16.4 to $8.3 M)

– Quads for from 1.09 to 1.24 only 14% increas

Quads for from 1.09 to 1.24 only 14% increas

• Small Manufacturers

– Butt Lap Designs can still be incorporated

• M t i l dC P M

a

terial an

d

Core 

Process

– M6 Butt Lap and Miter– M4 Miter– M3 Miter– Allows for other process and materials to be 

by manufactures as they obtain lowest cost sby manufactures as they obtain lowest cost s