5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS	

			



/%(5762161&


$7,21$/$%25(/$7,2162$5'


1,7('22' $1'200(5&,$/25.(561,212&$/!"#$%$%!&'#(%#)*!+',,-%.*$%!&'!&'.#/#!$&*!'+#'&$0#*$%!*-*1'#-*$%!*'+2 344 3443'56#+786!#9#.%+#+*!+%-#+7656$

 7KH +RQRUDEOH :LOOLDP - +D\QHV -U 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW -XGJHIRU WKH 0LGGOH 'LVWULFW RI 7HQQHVVHH VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ#&'#7:*!+;
<%'.6%$86+5# :	9%$'%.$86+5#  "#$#' < !+#'! "	 ;	 =
	 	#*$$-# *0%!5$! &' "#$%$%!#'  80! '1*1

	9*0%!5$!9 &' #,!+#!$  ;%-#  ;%1! ;9;<
	
=;
	"'$-*!+'#5!&'!$#'(#!'
"#$#'<!+#'!"*$'%.><%.0*#-<*++#!"	;	=
		#*$$-#*0%!5$!8*/#  6'># 


 *.0*#-  )# ?
;<

;=??<"%!.%!!*$%0%&'"#$%$%!#'80!'1*1%-##!'/$'!50*'-#"9!!#--@8'86-%#<*'.6

	9*0%!5$!9&'#,!+#!$;%-#;%1!;#!#<#.0*!%. ;9; <
 	
 =;
	 "'$-*!+ '#5! &' 
!$#'(#!'  *@!# #.>#'"=;;?*!*%$@<%6'%<%.0*#- ; 9-*! 99 
?	< =#):'>#):'>#-!9$>%!


<""'$-*!+'#5!&'/%.%6'%*#:%'.6%$86+5#-1#'$!
!.AB-1#'$!CD*'#$*%-5'.#'##>'#(%#)&*+#.%%!1@$0#*$%!*-*1'#-*$%! *'+ AB*'+CD %! )0%.0 $0# *'+ 0#-+ $0*$-1#'$!.//%$$#+*!6!&*%'-*1','*.$%.#*5*%!$$)6!%!)0#!-1#'$!*--)#+.0*'%$*1-#5'6,$-%.%$! %! *!+ *'6!+ %$ ,',#'$@ ! (*'%6 ..*%! 16$ 

+#!%#+!!#/,-@##6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#$0#*/#'%50$0#*'+0#-+$0*$$0%,'*.$%.#(%-*$#+	#.$%!EA*DAD&$0# *$%!*- *1' #-*$%! .$ ABCD %! $0*$-1#'$! +%.'%/%!*$#+ *5*%!$ $0# 6!%! -%.%$*$%!-1#'$!.!$#!+$0*$#/,-@#'+!$(%-*$#$0#1@*--)%!5.0*'%$%#$-%.%$!$0#%',',#'$@)0%-#+#!@%!5$0#*/#'%50$$6!%!6!+#'$0#.%'.6/$*!.#,'##!$0#'#0#*'+)0%.0.',#$%$%!&'#!&'.#/#!$&%$'+#'.!$#!+!*,,#*-$0*$$0#*6$0'%$@'#-%#+!1@-1#'$!!-@ *,,-%# %! %$6*$%! )0#'# $0# 6!%! % #!5*5#+ %!*.$%(%$@$0*$)6-+0*'/$0##/,-@#' 6.0*1@.$$%!5*.$%(%$@*!+$0*$!#&$0#6!%!%!$0#%!$*!$.*#)*!$#!5*5#+%!6.0*.$%(%$@16$'*$0#'%!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@'$0# '#*!$0*$&--))##!&'.#/#!$&$0#*'+ '+#' *!+	 $0# ,#$%$%! &' '#(%#) 1@-1#'$!	
 !"!(#/1#'49'%(#'	*-#/#!*'#06#/#!+*!+-#'-#'%.*-*!+
!+6$'%*-"'+6.$%!.*-E*&&%-%*$#+)%$0
!$#'!*$%!*-'$0#'0+&#*/$#'AB.*-ECD*6!%!-.*$#+%!	,>*!#*0%!5$!&%-#+*!6!&*%'-*1','*.$%.#.0*'5#*5*%!$-1#'$!%!*#2*--#5%!5$0*$-1#'$!650$$'#/(# '#,'##!$*$%(# & $0# 6!%! &'/ $0# &'!$ & %$$'#.*-E'#,'##!$*$%(#0*+.!(#!#+%!&'!$&-1#'$! $'# %! '+#' $ +%$'%16$# 0*!+1%-- *>%!5.6$/#'!$$,6'.0*#,'+6.$&'*+(%#)9*%'@*/*!6&*.$6'#')%$0)0/$0#6!%!)*!$'%>#!9#.#/1#'2*+%&&#'#!$6!%!
!%$#++*!+//#'.%*- '>#' 
!%! .*-  *&&%-%*$#+ )%$0!%$#++*!+//#'.%*-'>#'
!$#'!*$%!*-
!%!
AB.*-CD&%-#+*.0*'5#*5*%!$-1#'$!%!*#3440#.0*'5#*--#5#+$0*$-1#'$!0*+$0'#*$#!#+.*-'#,'##!$*$%(#)%$0*''#$*!+.%(%-*.$%!&'*$$#/,$%!5$5*%!*..#$$'#E*!+E%!-*'>6!$@*0%!5$!%!'+#'$1$*%!*6$0'%F*$%!2

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	61#G6#!$-@*#2)*.!-%+*$#+)%$0$0#$0#'$).*#0#,*'$%# /(#+ $ $'*!&#' $0# /*$$#' $ $0# *'+ )*%(#*'56/#!$ 1#&'# *! *+/%!%$'*$%(#-*) H6+5# AB8CD *!+$%,6-*$#$$0#&*.$0#*'+.!%+#'#+$0#/*$$#'&'*-/$ &6' @#*' *!+ %! * 0*',-@ +%(%+#+ +#.%%! $0#*'+/*H'%$@&6!+$0*$-1#'$!.//%$$#+*!6!&*%'-*1' ,'*.$%.# *!+ (%-*$#+ $0#  1@ #I.-6+%!5'#,'##!$*$%(#&.*-E*!+&'/%$$'#-1#'$! &%-#+ $0% $%/#-@ !$%.# & *,,#*- !(#/1#'    -$0650 !!# & $0# *.$%!./,-*%!#+&..6''#+%!$0%.%'.6%$H6'%+%.$%!%,',#',6'6*!$$
	J3A&D)0%.0,'(%+#$0*$*,*'$@/*@##>'#(%#)&**'++#.%%!%!$0#.6'$&*,,#*-%! * H6+%.%*- .%'.6%$ )0#'# $0# ,*'$@ $'*!*.$ 16%!#-1#'$!.!$#!+$0*$%$0*)#--(#'#/,-@##%!#!!### *!+<%.0%5*! *!+$06 '#(%#)1@$0%6'$%,',#'  0# *'+ 0* .',#$%$%!#+ *!+ ##>#!&'.#/#!$&%$'+#' 

:H DOVR UHMHFW WKH %RDUG¶V DUJXPHQW WKDW RXU KROGLQJV LQ&5(3DQG6DQGXVN\UHJDUGLQJ WKH WHUP 3GLVFULPLQDWLRQ ́ ZHUH PHUHO\ GLFWD DV VXFKDQ DUJXPHQW LV EHOLHG E\ WKH ODQJXDJH LQ WKRVH RSLQLRQV6HH HJ&5(3)G DW  3>:@HKROGWKDW WKH WHUP μGLVFULPLQDWLRQ¶ DV XVHG LQ%DEFRFNPHDQV IDYRULQJ RQH XQLRQ RYHU DQRWKHU RU DOORZLQJ HPSOR\HUUHODWHG LQIRUPDWLRQ ZKLOH EDUULQJ VLPLODU XQLRQUHODWHG LQIRUPDWLRQ ́HPSKDVLV DGGHG1#&'#6%!$0#%!$*!$.*#)#0-+$0*$$0#+#&%!%$%!&+%.'%/%!*$%!,'(%+#+%!*!+
 !.!$'-'$0#&'#5%!5'#*!)##!&'.#/#!$&$0#*'+ '+#' *!+	 $0# ,#$%$%! &' '#(%#) 1@-1#'$!2

 #& .6'# *- *'#16!+1@$0%6'$0-+%!5%!"#16$*)#0*(##I,-*%!#+$0*$.*#+#!$'#G6%'#$0*$)#'#H#.$$0#+#&%!%$%!&+%.'%/%!*$%!*#$&'$0%!
 !*!+0%6'$0*'#.5!%F#+$0*$$0#'#%*!0%#'*'.0@&'%50$6!+#'	#.$%!4&$0#$+34E3EEA3$0%'2D0%-#$0# .'# *.$%(%$@ ,'$#.$#+ 1@ 	#.$%! 4 % $0# '%50$ &#/,-@## $ #-&'5*!%F# * ,'#(%6-@ $*$#+ B!!#/,-@## 0*(# * K+#'%(*$%(# '%50$ $ #!5*5# %!'5*!%F*$%!*- *.$%(%$%#C   *'$0#$ '#/(#+ &'/,'$#.$%! 6!+#' 	#.$%! 4 & $0#  % $0# *.$%(%$@#!5*5#+%!1@$0#!!#/,-@##%!*!+
 !,%.>#$%!5*.$%(%$@$+*$3EA#I,-*%!%!5$0*$!!#/,-@##,%.>#$%!5 )*''*!$ #(#!-#,'$#.$%!$0*! !!#/,-@## '5*!%F*$%!*- *.$%(%$@D  0%-# !!#/,-@##'5*!%F#'/*@)*''*!$5'#*$#','$#.$%!6!+#'$0#$0*!!!#/,-@##)0#!5*5#%!!!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@1$0%$6*$%!$%--%/,-%.*$#$'#,**.$%(%$@$0%6'$%!"#!$#+B$'#,*.*#.'#*$#*%$6*$%!)0#'#$0#%!$#'#$&$0#$'#,*#'%& *!+$0#'#&'# $0# ,',#'$@ )!#' 0* * ,'#6/,$%(# '%50$ $#I.-6+#!!#/,-@##&'/%$,',#'$@C+*$A#/,0*%*++#+D06)0%-#BK*!#/,-@#'/*@!$*-)*@1*'!!#/,-@##6!%!'5*!%F#'&'/0%,',#'$@C$0#16'+#!$0#6!%!1#*'%!0)%!5$0*$$0##/,-@#'/*@!$+ % * BK0#*(@!# #(%+#!.#+1@$0# &*.$$0*$$0#1*-*!.#$'6.>1@$0#*'+*!+$0#.6'$6!+#'$0#*..//+*$%!,'%!.%,-#0*'*'#-@1##!%!&*('&$'#,*'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@C%'
	*$AG6$%!5
 (		
23
	EA4EDD!.!$'*$)0#'##/,-@##'%50$*'#*$%6#B!'#$'%.$%!!#/,-@##'%50$$#-&'5*!%F*$%!%,#'/%%1-#6!-#$0# #/,-@#' 0) $0*$ 6.0 '#$'%.$%! % !#.#*'@ $/*%!$*%!'+#'*!++%.%,-%!#C%'
	*$#.*6#*/!5$0#'$0%!5$0#6'$%!"#*++'##+.!.#'! '#5*'+%!5 #-&'5*!%F*$%!*- '%50$& #/,-@##$0#/#-(# *!+ $0# '%50$ $0*$ $0#@ *'# 5'*!$#+ 6!+#' $0#$0#6'$0#-+$0*$%$)*!$16!+1@*!+
 !  #.*6# )# + !$ 0*(# 6.0 .!%+#'*$%! 

!0#&*.$*'###!$%*--@6!+%,6$#+%!*/6.0*$0#,*'$%#$%,6-*$#+$$0#/1#-)-1#'$!0**&'/*-)'%$$#!,-%.@!*..#*!+-%.%$*$%!)0%.0*,,-%#$*--$'#*!+)0%.01*!*!@*!+*---%.%$*$%!#$%#$)##!(#/1#'*!+8*!6*'@33.*-E#!5*5#+%!*!#.!/%.$'%>#*5*%!$'*+(%#)9*%'@-.*$#+%! 	,>*!#*0%!5$!  .*- E *$$#/,$#+ $+%$'%16$#0*!+1%--*$%I&-1#'$!'#$*%-*!+5'.#'@$'#%!$0#	,>*!#*'#*0#0*!+1%--6'5#+.6$/#'$'#&'*%! &'/ 16@%!5 '*+(%#) 9*%'@ ,'+6.$ )0%.0-1#'$!-+%!*/6.0*'*+(%#)&&#'#+B)*5#*!+1#!#&%$&*'1#-)$0#%!+6$'@$*!+*'+C0#0*!+1%--*-/*+#.-#*'$0*$$0#6!%!+%,6$#)*!$)%$0-1#'$!16$ !-@ )%$0 '*+(%#)  !# & $0# %!+%(%+6*- )0650$ $ +%#/%!*$# $0# 0*!+1%-- )#'# #/,-@## &-1#'$!-1#'$!'#G6#$#+,-%.#*%$*!.#%!'+#'$ '#/(# 0*!+1%--#' &'/ %$ ,',#'$@ *$ #(#'*- & $0#$'#!(*'%6..*%!)0%-#$0#0*!+1%--#'*$$#/,$#+$,*6$$0#%'0*!+1%---1#'$!*--)#+$0#'5'6,!%$,',#'$@$-%.%$+!*$%!0##%!.-6+#+$0#*/,%'# ;%'- *!+ @ @ 	.6$ ;%'- 	.6$ *!+ *'#*.0-6'$0#'$0#	*-(*$%!'/@)**--)#+$ '%!51#--+6'%!50*!>5%(%!5*!+0'%$/**$$0#$'##*.0@#*'###96'%!5 <*@  $ #1'6*'@ 3 -1#'$! *-+#!%#+!!#/,-@##16%!#'#,'##!$*$%(#&.*-$$0#%!$#'%' *!+%//#+%*$# #I$#'%' & &%(# &%$ $'#-.*$#+%!-*'>6!$@*0%!5$!A$'#E*!+ED#!+'#5!A$'#E4*!+EED*!+#+/!+'#5!A$'#ED.*-'#,'##!$*$%(#650$*..#$$0##3

 'XULQJ RUDO DUJXPHQW WKH %RDUG H[SUHVVO\ VWDWHG WKDW /RFDO GRHV QRW FODLP WKDW $OEHUWVRQ¶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
! * 86-@   -#$$#'-1#'$!*5*%!*+(%#+$0#6!%!$0*$%$.!+6.$(%-*$#+$0#$'#!-%.%$*$%!,-%.@	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

%!$*!$.*#0%.*#%/,-%.*$#$0#,'#6/,$%(#'%50$&-1#'$!$#I.-6+#+%$'%16$%!&6!%!-%$#'*$6'#!%$,',#'$@  6'$0#' $0% .*# %!(-(# !!-1#'$!#/,-@####>%!5*..#$$0#./,*!@,',#'$@%!*--@!'#-#(*!$-*1',-%.%#*'#*+(*!.#+%!1*!!%!5.0*'%$*1-#-%.%$*$%!%!$0%.*#)0#'#$0#'#0*1##!!.-*%/$0*$$0# $*'5#$ *6+%#!.# )* $0#')%# %!*..#%1-#  0# !-@&*.$'$0*$+%$%!56%0#$0%.*#&'/'
 !%$0#&*.$$0*$$0#.*#%!(-(#+!!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@0#*'+6'5#$0*$)#+%$%!56%0$0#.*#&'/$0%!#!$0*$!#5'6!+)#(#'$0#*'+0*,'##!$#+!'#*!#+1*%$H6$%&@6'+%!5
!'#*.0%!5%$0-+%!5*$$0#/#*!%!5&$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C$0#6'$%! )* %!$#','#$%!5 $0*$ $#'/ * 6#+ %!  ()**!+ ()*)**!'5*!%F*$%!*-.*# ()*
	*$3EA#I,-*%!%!5$0*$$0##/,-@#' 0*+ '#&6#+ $ *--) !!#/,-@## 6!%!'5*!%F#' ! ./,*!@ ,',#'$@ $ +%$'%16$# 6!%!%!&'/*$%!$*'5#$#+*$./,*!@#/,-@##D06$0#!-@1*% ! )0%.0 $ +%$%!56%0 $0% .*# &'/ '
 ! % $0*$ $0# .*# %!(-(#+ !!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@ @#$%!'#*.0%!5$0#0-+%!5'#5*'+%!5+%.'%/%!*$%!$0#@)#'#%!$#','#$%!5*!'5*!%F*$%!*-.*##1#-%#(#6!+#'$0##.%'.6/$*!.#$0#.*#.*!!$/#*!%!5&6--@1#+%$%!56%0#+&'/$0#%!$*!$.*#*!+)#*'#$0#'#&'#16!+1@$0#%'0-+%!5+,'
%!E4+22A3$0%'DA#I,-*%!%!5$0*$*,*!#-%16!+$&--),'#.#+#!$%*-*6$0'%$@&'/*!$0#',*!#-&$0%.6'$6!-#6.0*6$0'%$@.*!1#+%$%!56%0#+#(#!%&.6''#!$ ,*!#- % %!.-%!#+ $ +%*5'## )%$0 ,'%' +#.%%!D
 !2+*$3A#I,-*%!%!5$0*$B&%'/&%I#+'6-#C%!$0%.%'.6%$%$0*$!#,*!#-.*!!$(#''6-#*,'%',*!#-0-+%!5D 
	&
	E3+33EA3$0%'3DA0-+%!5$0*$*-$0650!$0#%'&*.#$),'%' .*# &'/ +%&&#'#!$ ,*!#- *,,#*' $ .!$'*+%.$ $0#%6#%!(-(#+)*0#*(%-@&*.$+'%(#!*!+.6'$)6-+*,,-@$0#0-+%!5&$0#!#,'%'.*#)%$0&*.$/$*!*-56$$0#%6#1#&'#$0#.6'$D

 +%$%!56%0#+*!+#I,-*%!#+$0*$$0#,*!#-%!$0*$.*#*+,$#+*!*'')+#&%!%$%!&B+%.'%/%!*$%!C**'#6-$&AD$0#5#!#'*-'6-#$0*$*!)!#'&,'%(*$#,',#'$@%6!+#'!1-%5*$%!$,#'/%$$0#+%$'%16$%!&6!%!-%$#'*$6'#!%$,',#'$@ AD$0#61$*!$%*-+%&&#'#!.#1#$)##!$0#'%50$& #/,-@## *!+ !!#/,-@## )%$0 '#,#.$ $ $0#+%$'%16$%!&6!%!-%$#'*$6'#!,'%(*$#-@)!#+,',#'$@*!+ AD $0# &*.$ $0*$ %!(-(#+ !!#/,-@## 6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(##!5*5%!5%!!!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@*$
!*++%$%!$0#6'$%!"#*-!$#+$0*$0-+%!5'#-%#+!*,-%.@.!%+#'*$%!!$,'##!$%!"#7BMN0# 6'$ )*    %!&-6#!.#+ 1@ $0# &*.$ $0*$ K-.
!/0'
!
%%


%0%*'
!
1&%%0
%&
CA#/,0*%*++#+DAG6$%!5+*$23D0#6'$%!"#+%$%!56%0#+$0#.*#1#&'#%$&'*--$0#'#*!!$#+*1(#*!+!$*$0#*'+.-*%/-#-@1#.*6#%!(-(#+!!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@6'$0#'%$ % #(%+#!$$0*$$0#6'$ +%$%!56%0#+"#'!1#.*6# $0*$ .*# %!(-(#+"# #/,-@##  0"# + *$ AB0#/*H'%$@1#-%#(#$0*$$0#-	.+#&%!%$%!&+%.'%/%!*$%!06-+1#!$1#*,,-%#+%! $0# %!$*!$ .*# %!.# M$0# &'/#' .*#N %!(-(#+ !!#/,-@## -%.%$' *!+ $0% .*# %!(-(# #/,-@##CDA''%8+%#!$%!5D$0#/*H'%$@%!"#,%!$#+6$$0%+%$%!.$%!%!#&61$*!.#*$A!$%!5$0*$BM#N/,-@##*'#*..'+#+5'#*$#','$#.$%!6!+#'$0#.$$0*!!!#/,-@##16$$0#@M#/,-@##N*'#*..'+#+#(#!5'#*$#','$#.$%!6!+#'$0#.$)0#!$0#@*'##!5*5#+%!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@CD 

	*$3EA#I,-*%!%!5$0*$$0#+%$%!.$%!1#$)##!#/,-@##'%50$$+%.6 #-&'5*!%F%!5 *!+ $0# '%50$ & !!#/,-@##'5*!%F#' % !# & B61$*!.#CD   + *$ 23A*/#D(#'@&*.$'#I.#,$!#$0*$$0#6'$%!"#,%!$#+$%!'+#'$+%$%!56%0$0*$.*#&'/%'#-#(*!$$$0# 

4%RDUG FRQWHQGV WKDW $OEHUWVRQ¶V VKRXOG KDYH SHUPLWWHG /RFDO  DFFHVVWR LWV VWRUHV GHVSLWH $OEHUWVRQ¶V QRVROLFLWDWLRQ SROLF\ EHFDXVH$OEHUWVRQ¶V DOORZHG VXFK DFFHVV WR FKDULWLHV0# *'+ ,%!$ 6$ $0*$ -1#'$! 0* *--)#+.0*'%$*1-# *!+L' .%(%.L#+6.*$%!*- 5'6, $ -%.%$ %$.6$/#'%!$0#*'#*%//#+%*$#-@6''6!+%!5$0##!$'*!.#$$0#$'#'%!$*!.#+6'%!5$0#0'%$/*#*!*--&%(# $'# *--) 	*-(*$%! '/@ 1#--'%!5#'$ -%.%$$0#./,*!@.6$/#'	$'#E*!+E0*(#*--)#+$0#;%'- 	.6$ @ 	.6$ ')!%# *!+ @6$0 *!+ .0-5'6,$-%.%$%$.6$/#'	$'#E4EE*!+E*-0*(#*--)#+$0#;%'-	.6$*/,&%'#;'6,$0#O#$#'*!&'#%5!*'9%*1-#+O#$#'*!&/#'%.**!+@6$0*!+.0-5'6,$-%.%$;#!#'*--@$0##5'6,*'#*--)#+$#$6,%!$0#*'#**+H*.#!$ $ $0# $'# #!$'*!.# *!+ #I%$  )#(#'-1#'$! *+/%$ $0*$ +6'%!5 %!.-#/#!$ )#*$0#' %$ 0*,#'/%$$#+ $0# ;%'- 	.6$ *!+ 	*-(*$%! '/@ 1#--'%!5#'*..# $ $0# %//#+%*$# %!$#'%' & $0# $'#  0# -*'>6!$@*!+#!+L#+/!+	*-(*$%!'/@1#--'%!5#'-%.%$!$'#,',#'$@$0'6506$$0#/!$0,'%'$0'%$/*0# -*'> 6!$@ ;%'- 	.6$ *'# 5'*!$#+ *..# $ $'#,',#'$@$)%.#*@#*'+6'%!5*$))##>,#'%+#*.0$%/##!+L#+/!+ *'#*;%'-	.6$ *'#5'*!$#+ *..#$ #--$0#%'.>%#!.#*@#*'&'%I$##!.!$%!66+*@0#-*'>6!$@@	.6$*'#5'*!$#+*..#$$'#,',#'$@$#--,'+6.$$)%.#*@#*'+6'%!5!#/!$0%!$0#&*--*!+*!$0#'/!$0%!$0#,'%!50#$0#'5'6,*'#5'*!$#+*..#$,',#'$@!#$$0'##+*@+6'%!5$0#.6'#&$0#@#*'  $ #*.0 & $0# &%(# $'# -1#'$! 0* !#(#'*--)#+*!$0#'-*1''5*!%F*$%!$+%$'%16$#-%$#'*$6'#$0*!+1%--'$-%.%$.6$/#'!$0#%!$#'%''#I$#'%'&$0#,'#/%#-1#'$!0* '#H#.$#+ '#G6#$$ -%.%$+!*$%!1@$0#' '5*!%F*$%! *%+# &'/ $0# .0*'%$*1-# 5'6,/#!$%!#+ *1(# 6.0 * ,-%$%.*- 5'6, .0*'%$*1-#E

 '5*!%F*$%! 6!&*/%-%*' $ $0# .//6!%$@ *!+ *-- !!.0*'%$%#
&-1#'$! ##> '#(%#) & $0# *'+ +#.%%! *!+.!$#!+ $0*$ -1#'$! 0* * '%50$ $ #I.-6+# &'/ %$,',#'$@!!#/,-@##6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#)0#!5*5#%!#%$0#'!!'5*!%F%!5''5*!%F%!5*.$%(%$%#..'+%!5$-1#'$! $0# *'+ #''#+ %! &%!+%!5 $0*$ -1#'$!+%.'%/%!*$#+*5*%!$$0#6!%!1@*--)%!5.#'$*%!.0*'%$*1-#5'6,$-%.%$!%$,',#'$@16$+#!@%!5$0#6!%!6.0'%50$-1#'$!&6'$0#'.!$#!+$0*$$0%&%!+%!51@$0#*'+.!&-%.$)%$0$),%!%!&'/$0%6'$
 !" 	   2 + 3E A3$0 %' D *!+

-2	3.+24A3$0%'3D!*,,#*-$0#*'+*'56#$0*$-1#'$!+%.'%/%!*$#+*5*%!$.*-*!+(%-*$#+	#.$%!EA*DAD&$0# 
	 J EA*DAD )0#! -1#'$! #I.-6+#+ 6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#&'/%$$'#0#*'+.!$#!+$0*$*!#/,-@#'(%-*$#$0#)0#!%$+#!%#*6!%!*..#$%$,'#/%#&''5*!%F*$%!*-,6',#16$*--).0*'%$%#$ -%.%$ +!*$%! ! %$ ,',#'$@  
$ .!$#!+ $0*$ *!#/,-@#'$-#'*!.#&!!#/,-@##.0*'%$*1-#-%.%$*$%!%,'1*$%(##(%+#!.#&+%.'%/%!*$%!*5*%!$!!#/,-@##'5*!%F%!5*.$%(%$@
$&6'$0#'*'56#$0*$$0#'#%!1*%&'$'#*$%!5.0*'%$%#*!@+%&&#'#!$-@$0*!6!%!.!$#!+%!5$0*$$'#*$%!5$0##$)5'6,%/%-*'-@*(%+$0#$#/,$*$%!&-*1#-%!5 B#/,-@##C '5*!%F*$%!*- *.$%(%$@ 0*'/&6- $ *!#/,-@#' 16%!# )0%-# -*1#-%!5 .0*'%$*1-# -%.%$*$%!0#-,&6-'*+(*!$*5#6$16%!#0#*'+*-.!$#!+$0*$$0%6'$06-++#&#'$$0#*'++#&%!%$%!&B+%.'%/%!*$%!C1#.*6#1@+#&%!%!5$0*$$#'/$0#*'+)**--#5#+-@%!$#','#$%!5$0#*'#,!%1%-%$@#!$'6$#+$%$1@!5'#0%-#$0#*'+'#.5!%F# $0*$ $0% 6'$ 0* !*'')-@ +#&%!#+ $0# $#'/ 


 !*$0#*'++#.%%!+%+!$#I,'#-@'#-@!*!@6.0+%$%!.$%!%!'#*.0%!5%$+#.%%!B'#(%#)%!5.6'$    /6$ H6+5# $0# ,','%#$@ & M$0# *.$%! & *!*+/%!%$'*$%(#*5#!.@N-#-@!$0#5'6!+%!(>#+1@$0#*5#!.@C+
E+ A3$0%'E4D AG6$%!5		%!		 2 3 A24DD  B .6'$ )%-- !$ *&&%'/ $0#*+/%!%$'*$%(# *.$%! 1@ 61$%$6$%!5 * /'# *+#G6*$# ',',#'1*%M*!+NM$N0%6'$)%--!$*&&%'/$0#*'+*.$%!1*#+!'#*!!$'#-%#+6,!1@$0#*'+%$#-&C A'#H#.$%!5 *'+ *'56/#!$ 1#&'# $0% 6'$ $0*$ $0#*'+ '#*+%!5 & $0# "$*- #'5*!%F*$%! .$ )*6,,'$#+1@*$0#!'#.#!$	6,'#/#6'$.*#)0#!.*#+%+!$-#!+6.06,,'$*!+*'+&*%-#+$'#-@!$0*$.*#$H6$%&@%$'#*+%!5&$0#.$%!%$+#.%%!1#-)D 
4 !	'!		
	434! AD AB#+!$ 61$%$6$# .6!#-,$0.'*$%!*-# &' $0# '#*!%!5 6,,-%#+ 1@ $0# *'+ %$#-&CDAG6$%!5  5% + 222 
	 34 3E !A24DD  
! *!@ #(#!$ #(#! %& )# )#'# $ .!%+#' $0#*'+ *'56/#!$ ! *,,#*- * $ )0@ $0% .*# %+%$%!56%0*1-#&'/*!+
 !)#+!$1#-%#(#$0*$$0#*'56/#!$*+(*!.#+)%$0$*!+.'6$%!@0#*'+'#-%#!"#+A3$0 %' 4D $ 6,,'$ %$ .!$#!$%! $0*$ $0# 0-+%!5'#5*'+%!5$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C#$&'$0%!*$0*$$#'/)*6#+%! ()*%%!*,,-%.*1-#$$0#%!$*!$.*#
!"#$0##/,-@#'.0*--#!5#+**'+'+#' '#G6%'%!5 <#%H#' * &+ *!+ 5#!#'*- /#'.0*!+%#'#$*%-#'$*--)#/,-@##*$!#&%$$'#$)#*'6!%!%!%5!%*)0%-#!$0#H1*$0#$'#/*!*5#'0*+#!&'.#+*+'#.+#$0*$1*!!#+#/,-@##&'/)#*'%!5)%$0 $0#%' 6!%&'/ *!@$0%!5 $0#' $0*! !*/# 1*+5#./,*!@ *,,'(#+ 16$$! 
!%$#+ *@ ,%! *!+ #'(%.#'#.5!%$%!,%!*$<#%H#' *'56#+ $0*$ )* .!$'--%!5 *!+ $0*$ $0#+#&%!%$%! & B+%.'%/%!*$%!C #,6#+ %! $0*$ .*# )*+%,%$%(#  *$   0% 6'$ +%*5'##+  
$

 WR FRPPXQLFDWH ZLWK $OEHUWVRQ¶V HPSOR\HHV 0%-# *.>!)-#+5%!5 $0*$ $0# +#&%!%$%! &$0#$#'/+%.'%/%!*$%!*#$&'$0%!*!+
 !%*!*'')!#$0#*'+.!$#!+$0*$$0%6'$%!$16!+1@$0#.*# 1#.*6# $0% 6'$ 61#G6#!$-@ 0* -%/%$#+ $0#%'0-+%!5$%$6*$%!%!(-(%!5*6!%!#.!/%.*$$*.>*5*%!$ *! #/,-@#' *!+ !$ * 0#'# )0#'# $0# 6!%!%#!5*5%!5%!'5*!%F%!5*.$%(%$@6'$0#'$0#*'+.!$#!+$0*$$0#+%.6%!'#5*'+%!5$0#+#&%!%$%!&+%.'%/%!*$%!%!
 !*!+)*/#'#-@+%.$*0%-#$0#*'+%.''#.$$0*$*,*!#-&$0%6'$+%$%!56%0#+%!*.*#+#.%+#+ 61#G6#!$ $ * #I,-*%!#+ 1#-) $0#+%$%!.$%!%!$*&*')##,%!5*$0#*'+.!$#!+&'!!()()##I,-*%!#+#*'-%#'$0#*'++#.%%!%!$0%.*#&*%-$+%$%!56%01#$)##!$0#*.$%(%$@#!5*5#+%!1@.*-E*!+.*-
!+##+$0#*'+*!*-@F#+$0#.-*%/'#5*'+%!5.*-EA%!(-(%!5!!'5*!%F*$%!*-1@.$$%!5*.$%(%$%#D*!+.*-A%!(-(%!5'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@D$5#$0#'0#*'++#.%%!5#!#'*--@0#-+$0*$*!@*!+*--#I.-6%! & $0# 6!%! &'/ *! #/,-@#' ,'#/%# %+%.'%/%!*$'@ )0#'# $0# #/,-@#' *--) $0#' 6.0 *.0*'%$%#$0#'%50$$-%.%$!%$,'#/%#06$0#*'++#$#'/%!#+ $0*$ %$ +%+ !$ /*$$#' )0#$0#' $0# *.$%(%$%##!5*5#+%!1#$)##!.*-E*!+.*-*!+$0#.0*'%$%#)#'#%/%-*'')0#$0#'.0*'%$%#*!+6!%!*'#./,*'*1-#5'6,

 !2+*$3A0-+%!5$0*$$0#*--#5#++%.'%/%!*$'@.!+6.$%!*--)%!5-%.%$*$%!1@!#5'6,)0%-#1*''%!56.0-%.%$*$%!1@*!$0#''#G6%'#$0*$$0#+%.'%/%!*$%!1#*/!5./,*'*1-#5'6,'*.$%(%$%#D$%!-@!*,,#*-$0*$$0#*'+*'56#$0*$.0*'%$%#*!+6!%!*'#%!+%$%!56%0*1-#&',6',#&*+%.'%/%!*$%!*!*-@%*!+$0*$6!%!#!5*5%!5%!'5*!%F*$%!*-*.$%(%$@,#.%&%.*--@*!+.0*'%$@-%.%$*$%!*'#./,*'*1-#*.$%(%$%#0# *'56/#!$ $0# *'+ !) ##> $ '*%# *'# .-#*'-@.'*&$#+ &' *,,#*- 1#.*6# & 6' 0-+%!5 %! *!+ 

B+%.'%/%!*$%!C%!
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	6,'#/#6'$+#.%%!%! ()*		  A3D %! )0%.0 $0# 6'$ &%'$ +%.6#+ $0#B+%.'%/%!*$%!#I.#,$%!C$$0#5#!#'*-'6-#$0*$#/,-@#'*'#!$16!+$,#'/%$6!%!!$0#%',',#'$@$ -%.%$/#/1#' !#/#/1#'&$0#*'+,*!#-+%#!$#+0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#'$*$#+$0*$$0#,'0%1%$+%.'%/%!*$%!*5*%!$

 ,Q DGGLWLRQ WR WKH SDUWLHV VHYHUDO DPLFL DOVR KDYH VXEPLWWHG EULHIVLQ WKLV DSSHDO 7KH DPLFL DUH WKH 6DOYDWLRQ $UP\ %L0DUW D ORFDO UHWDLOHUDQG WKH &DPSILUH %R\V DQG *LUOV :KLOH WKH %RDUG PDMRULW\ VWDWHG WKDWWKHUH LV QR HYLGHQFH WKDW HPSOR\HUV KDG FORVHG WKHLU GRRUV RQ FKDULWDEOHVROLFLWDWLRQV VHYHUDO RI WKH DPLFL FRQWHQG RQ DSSHDO WKDW WKLV VLWXDWLRQ KDVRFFXUUHG6!%!-%.%$*$%!16$$0*$*!#/,-@#'/*@*--)!#$@,#&-%.%$*$%!!%$,',#'$@)0%-#!$,#'/%$$%!5$0#'$@,#&-%.%$*$%!'%!$*!.#$0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#'$*$#+$0*$*!#/,-@#'/*@,#'/%$-%.%$*$%!1@.0*'%$%#&'.*!.#')0%-#+#!@%!5$0#1@'5*!%F*$%!$0*$./1*$
9	0#+%#!$%!5 /#/1#' .0*'*.$#'%F#+ $0# ./,*!@ ,-%.@ *,#'/%$$%!5-%.%$*$%!1@.0*'%$*1-#5'6,)#-->!)!$$0# .//6!%$@ )0%-# 1*!!%!5 6.0 -%.%$*$%! &'/.0*'%$*1-# 5'6, $0*$ *'# !$ )#-- >!)! ' 1@ ,-%$%.*-5'6,'.//#'.%*-5'6,#--%!55+*!+#'(%.#0#+%#!$%!5 /#/1#' *) ! ,'1-#/ )%$0 6.0 * ,-%.@%!*/6.0 * $0# -%!# -1#'$! +'#) '#5*'+%!5 $0#'5*!%F*$%!$0*$.6-+*!+.6-+!$-%.%$)*!$*!*!$%6!%!-%!#0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#''#*!#+$0*$$0#6!%!%!$0%.*#)#'#!$-%.%$%!5.0*'%$*1-#.!$'%16$%!16$'*$0#')#'#*$$#/,$%!5*/!5$0#'$0%!5$,#'6*+#$0#./,*!@#/,-@##$B16@C%$'#,'##!$*$%!*-#'(%.#)0%.0 $0# $'# !-%.%$*$%! ,-%.@ ,'0%1%$#+  0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#',%!$#+6$$0*$%&!#&$0#.0*'%$%#$0*$)*,#'/%$$#+$ -%.%$!$0#./,*!@,',#'$@ 650$+!*$%!&'*,-%$%.*-.*/,*%5!6.0-%.%$*$%!)6-+1#,'0%1%$#+ 6!+#' $0# ./,*!@ !-%.%$*$%! ,-%.@)#(#'%&*6!%!650$$'*%#/!#@&'$0#/#'%.*!*!.#'6!+*$%!%$)6-+1#,#'/%$$#+$+6!+#'$0#,-%.@0#+%#!$%!5/#/1#'#I,-*%!#+$0*$6.0*,-%.@)*,#'/%$$#+6!+#'$0#1#.*6#%$)*!$1*#+!6!%! .!%+#'*$%!  0# +%#!$%!5 /#/1#' &6'$0#'1#-%#(#+'#G6%'%!5#/,-@#'$,#!$0#%'+'$6!%!)0#!#(#' $0#@ .0# $ +  &' .0*'%$%# )6-+ -#*+ $#/,-@#'.-%!5$0#%'+'!.0*'%$%#*-$5#$0#'*!+$0*$$0#*'+06-+#!.6'*5##/,-@#'$1#*5#!#'6*,%1-#%!*--)%!5*..#$$0#%','#/%#&'1#!#&%.#!$*.$ 

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́  )G DW  7KH %RDUG FRQWHQGV KRZHYHUWKDW GHVSLWH WKH KROGLQJV LQ&5(3DQG6DQGXVN\ WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW¶VKROGLQJ LQ1/5% Y 6WRZH 6SLQQLQJ &R  86  VXSSRUWVWKH %RDUG¶V YLHZ WKDW GLVFULPLQDWLRQ RFFXUV XQGHU%DEFRFN 	 :LOFR[ZKHUH DQ HPSOR\HU DOORZV DFFHVV WR LWV SURSHUW\ WR FKDULWLHV EXW GHQLHVVLPLODUDFFHVV WR XQLRQV $V D SUHOLPLQDU\ PDWWHU6WRZH 6SLQQLQJZDV QRWLQWHUSUHWLQJ WKH 3GLVFULPLQDWLRQ H[FHSWLRQ ́ DQQRXQFHG LQ%DEFRFN:LOFR[ DV6WRZH 6SLQQLQJZDV GHFLGHG VHYHUDO \HDUV SULRU WR WKDW FDVH)XUWKHU6WRZH 6SLQQLQJLV GLVWLQJXLVKDEOH RQ LWV IDFWV ,Q WKDW FDVH WKH%RDUG IRXQG WKDW IRXU HPSOR\HUV LQ D VPDOO WRZQ KDG FRPPLWWHG DQ XQIDLUODERU SUDFWLFH ZKHUH WKH HPSOR\HUV KDG UHIXVHG WR DOORZ D XQLRQ WR PHHWLQ WKH RQO\ PHHWLQJ KDOO LQ WKH WRZQ DOWKRXJK WKH HPSOR\HUV KDG DOORZHGRWKHU JURXSV LQFOXGLQJ VRPH RI D FKDULWDEOHQDWXUH WR GR VR6WRZH6SLQQLQJ  86 DW VHH DOVR 1/5% Y6WRZH 6SLQQLQJ &R )G   WK &LU  QRWLQJ WKDW PHHWLQJ KDOO KDG EHHQ XVHG IRUVXFK SXUSRVHV DV FKXUFK EDQTXHWV /DGLHV $LG 6RFLHW\ PHHWLQJV DQG D&KULVWPDV SDUW\ IRU VFKRRO FKLOGUHQ +RZHYHU LQ UHIXVLQJ WR XSVHW WKH%RDUG¶V ILQGLQJ WKDW WKH HPSOR\HUV¶ DFWLRQV FRQVWLWXWHG DQ XQIDLU ODERUSUDFWLFH WKH6XSUHPH&RXUW H[SODLQHG WKDW WKHUH ZDV HYLGHQFH WKDW WKHVROH UHDVRQ WKDW WKH HPSOR\HUV GLVDOORZHG WKH XQLRQ PHHWLQJ ZDV WKHUHVXOW RI DQWLXQLRQ ELDV 6HYHUDO HPSOR\HHV IRU H[DPSOH KDG EHHQ ILUHGIRU WKHLU XQLRQ DFWLYLW\ DQG WKH HPSOR\HUV WKHPVHOYHV IDLOHG WR GLVSXWHWKDW WKH\ UHIXVHG DFFHVV RI WKH KDOO WR WKH XQLRQ EHFDXVH RI WKHLU GLVGDLQIRU XQLRQV  86 DW  	 Q ,Q DGGLWLRQ WKH &RXUW HPSKDVL]HG WKDWLW FRXOG QRW FRPSDUH WKH DFFHVV WR WKH PHHWLQJ KDOO LQ WKH VPDOO 3FRPSDQ\GRPLQDWHG ́ WRZQ ZLWK 3WKH YDVW PHWURSROLWDQ FHQWHUV ZKHUH D QXPEHU RIKDOOV DUH DYDLODEOH ZLWKLQ HDV\ UHDFK RI SURVSHFWLYH XQLRQ PHPEHUV ́,G7KXV LQ DGGLWLRQ WR DQWLXQLRQ ELDV WKHUH ZDV HYLGHQFH WKDW WKHUH ZDV QRRWKHU UHDVRQDEO\ DYDLODEOH IRUXP IRU WKH XQLRQ PHHWLQJ LQ WKH WRZQ&I&5(3  )G DW  3:KHUH UHDVRQDEOH DOWHUQDWLYH PHDQV RI DFFHVVH[LVW 
V JXDUDQWHHV GR QRW DXWKRUL]H WUHVSDVV E\ QRQHPSOR\HHRUJDQL]HUV HYHQ   μXQGHU    UHDVRQDEOH UHJXODWLRQV¶ HVWDEOLVKHG E\ WKH%RDUG ́ TXRWLQJ/HFKPHUH  86 DW ,Q WKHLQVWDQW FDVHWKHUH LV QR FODLP WKDW /RFDO  ODFNHG RWKHU UHDVRQDEOH PHDQV E\ ZKLFK6'$%!*!+'#*&&%'/#+%!
 !!+%.'%/%!*$%!..6''#+%!$0%.*#E

 0# 6!%! &%-#+ *! 6!&*%' -*1' ,'*.$%.# .0*'5# *5*%!$*!+6>@*!+$0#*'+&6!+$0*$	*!+6>@0*+(%-*$#+$0#! *,,#*- $0# 6'$ *++'##+ $0# ,#.%&%. %6# &)0#$0#'B	*!+6>@/*@1#./,#--#+$,#'/%$!!6!%!#/,-@##6!%!/#/1#'$$'#,*!$0#/*--,',#'$@&' $0# ,6',# & +%$'%16$%!5 0*!+1%-- 6'5%!5 /*--.6$/#' !$ $ ,*$'!%F# !!6!%! #/,-@#'C #-@%!5 ! $0# 6'$ %!
 ! *!)#'#+ $0#G6#$%!%!$0#*&&%'/*$%(# 6" 
4334322*$PA2$0 %' 86-@  3D A0-+%!5 $0*$ #/,-@#' +%+ !$+%.'%/%!*$#*5*%!$6!%!)0#!%$*--)#+.0*'%$%#!%$,',#'$@$-%.%$.!$'%16$%!16$)6-+!$*--)!!#/,-@##6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(#$#!5*5#%!B+!$,*$'!%F#-%.%$*$%!C $*'5#$#+ *$ $0# #/,-@#'D   ! 70  %&   244  EA$0%'<*@DA0-+%!5$0*$/*--+%+!$+%.'%/%!*$#*5*%!$6!%!)0#!%$*--)#+;%'-	.6$*!+1-+/1%-#!/*--,',#'$@)0%-#!$*--)%!5,%.>#$%!5!!#/,-@##'#,'##!$*$%(#D0#0-+%!5%!*!+
 !$0*$*!#/,-@#'+#!$+%.'%/%!*$#*5*%!$*6!%!)0#'#$0##/,-@#'*--).0*'%$%# $ +%#/%!*$# %!&'/*$%! ! $0# #/,-@#',',#'$@)0%-#%$1*'6!%!&'/+%!5$0#*/#)%$06$/'# *,,#*' $ &'#.-# $0# *'+ *'56/#!$ $0*$+%.'%/%!*$%!..6''#+%!$0%.*#
$%6!.!$#$#+$0*$-1#'$!!-@*--)#+.#'$*%!.0*'%$%#$-%.%$+!*$%!*'6!+ $0# #I$#'%' & %$ ,',#'$@ #I.#,$ %! %!.-#/#!$)#*$0#')0#!%$*--)#+$0#;%'-	.6$*!+	*-(*$%!'/@1#--'%!5#'*..#$$0#%!%+#&/#%$$'#0#'#%!#(%+#!.#%!$0%.*#$0*$+6'%!5$0#$%/#-1#'$!'#&6#+$ *--) .*-  !!#/,-@## '5*!%F#' $ +%$'%16$#-%$#'*$6'#!%$,',#'$@-1#'$!*--)#++%$'%16$%!1@*!$0#' 6!%! ' $0*$ -1#'$! %$#-& +%#/%!*$#+%!&'/*$%! %/%-*' $ $0*$ %$ 1*!!#+ .*-  &'/+%#/%!*$%!5+*$230#'#&'#6!+#'$0#+#&%!%$%!&$0#$#'/ B+%.'%/%!*$%!C * #$ &'$01@$0% 

#I,-*%!#+1#-))#1#-%#(#$0*$
 !*!+.!$'-$0#+%,%$%!&$0%.*#0#.*#!*'')-@+#&%!#+$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C*$0#	6,'#/#6'$6#+$0*$$#'/%! ()**!+,'#.-6+#*&%!+%!5&*+%.'%/%!*$%! %! $0# %!$*!$ .*# ! $0# ./,*!@ ,*'$-$0650*$0#*'+!$#
 !*!++#*-$)%$01@.$$%!5 *.$%(%$@ )0#! %!$#','#$%!5 $0# $#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C$0%6'$->#+$ ()*&'56%+*!.#)0%.0%$#-&)**.*#$0*$+#*-$)%$0'5*!%F%!5*.$%(%$@06$0#*'+0* &*%-#+$,'##!$ * '#*!#+1*%$+%$%!56%0
 !*!+&'/$0#%!$*!$.*#&0#,*'$%#.!$#$$0#*,,-%.*1-#$*!+*'+&'#(%#)0#*'+ *'56# *$ -#!5$0 $0*$ $0% 6'$ /6$ +#&#' $ %$+#&%!%$%!&$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C1#.*6#%!'+#'$'#*.0 $0*$ +#&%!%$%! $0# *'+ 0*+ $ .!$'6# .#'$*%!$*$6$'@,'(%%!6!+#'$0#,!6'
	

4
	EA3DA0-+%!5$0*$)0#'#$*$6$#/#*!%!5%1(%6.6'$*!+*'+ /6$ +#&#' $ !5'# 6!*/1%566 %!$#!$ 16$)0#'# */1%56%$@ #I%$ .6'$ /6$ +#&#' $ *! *5#!.@'#*!*1-#%!$#','#$*$%!&$0# $*$6$#D A.%$%!5% +71
	234
	E4 AE2DD..'+%!5$$0#*'+$0#$*$#%!5#!#'*- $#'/ $0*$ *! #/,-@#' .//%$ *! 6!&*%' -*1','*.$%.#1@*/!5$0#'$0%!5'#$'*%!%!5'%!$#'&#'%!5)%$0.#'$*%!'%50$56*'*!$##+1@$0#6.0*$0#'%50$&#/,-@##$#-&'5*!%F#'$H%!*6!%!
	JJ 4 EA*DAD  0# *'+ ##!$%*--@ .!$#!+ $0*$1#.*6#!5'#0*!$,>#!$$0#,'#.%#%6#&)0#!*!#/,-@#'B+%.'%/%!*$#C*5*%!$*6!%!1@'#&6%!5$*--) !!#/,-@## 6!%! '5*!%F#' $ +%$'%16$# 6!%!-%$#'*$6'#!%$,',#'$@*-$0650%$*--)$0#'5'6,$+$0#!$0%6'$/6$*..#,$$0#/#*!%!5$0*$$0#*'+*$$'%16$#$$0#$#'/+%.'%/%!*$%!#+%*5'##0%6'$0**++'##+*!+'#H#.$#+*%/%-*'*'56/#!$1@$0#*'+%!
 !)0#'#)#'#*&&%'/#+$0#$*!+*'+

 &'#(%#)*,,-%.*1-#$*'++#.%%!*#*'-%#'#$&'$01@$0%6'$%!#,%!$#+6$%!
 !$0*$B)#'#(%#) $0# *'+ &*.$6*- *,,-%.*$%! *!+ $*$6$'@.!$'6.$%! 6!+#' * 61$*!$%*- #(%+#!.# $*!+*'+ *+#&#'#!.#$0*$% )*''*!$#+%&$0# *'+ .!.-6%! *'#1*#+6,!*'#*!*1-@+#&#!%1-#.!$'6.$%!&$0#.$C2+*$3E4AG6$%!5+*$23D	61$*!$%*-#(%+#!.#/#*!B6.0'#-#(*!$#(%+#!.#**'#*!*1-#/%!+/%50$*..#,$**+#G6*$#$6,,'$*.!.-6%!C7
7&
'
	+42E3*$P2A3$0%'86-@D)#(#'$0%6'$5%(#!+#&#'#!.#$$0#*'+)0#'#$0#*'++#.%%!B'#$MN!#''!#6-#5*-&6!+*$%!C%'
	4ADA0-+%!5$0*$*'+#''#+%!&%!+%!5$0*$#/,-@#'06-+0*(#*--)#+6!%!!%$,'#/%#1#.*6#%$0*+!$0#')*@$'#*.0%$$*'5#$ *6+%#!.# %!*/6.0 * %! '#*.0%!5 %$ +#.%%! $0#*'+/%.!$'6#+,'%'	6,'#/#6'$,'#.#+#!$D6'$0#')0#'#$0#*'+ .!.-6%!&-*)+!$%!$#','#$$0#)#'#(%#)$0#.!.-6%!"#+A3$0%'4D
!$0*$(#%!)#'#(%#)  $0# *'+ %!$#','#$*$%! & 	6,'#/# 6'$ *!+%I$0 %'.6%$ +#.%%! *!+ 5%(# $0# *'+ ! +#&#'#!.#B)%$0 '#,#.$ $ $0# %!$#','#$*$%! & H6+%.%*- ,'#.#+#!$C
 ! 2 + *$ 3  
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
 ! *!+ 

45#!#'*--@06-+1#'#,#.$&6-&$0#*'+%!$#','#$*$%!&$0#$#'/B+%.'%/%!*$%!C$0%6'$*-#I,-*%!#+$0*$$0#*'+ +#.%%! % )#+ ! +#&#'#!.# )0#'# %$ B'#$ !#''!#6-#5*-&6!+*$%!C
!$0*$(#%!$0%6'$0#-+$0*$BM!N'#-#(*!$-*1',-%.%#*'#*+(*!.#+1@'#G6%'%!5#/,-@#' $ ,'0%1%$ .0*'%$*1-# -%.%$*$%! %! '+#' $,'##'(# $0# '%50$ $ #I.-6+# !!#/,-@## +%$'%16$%! &6!%! -%$#'*$6'# )0#! *..# $ $0# $*'5#$ *6+%#!.# %$0#')%#*(*%-*1-#C0#6'$!$#+$0*$$0#,6',#&#.$%!EA*DAD&$0#%$,'#(#!$#/,-@#'&'/%!$#'&#'%!5)%$0#/,-@##	#.$%!4 '%50$#*'%!56.0.!%+#'*$%!%!/%!+$0#6'$'#*!#+$0*$7!)!#'&*,'%(*$#.//#'.%*-,',#'$@)0,#'/%$* .0*'%$*1-# '5*!%F*$%! $ +%$'%16$# %!&'/*$%! '.!+6.$ -%.%$*$%! ! %$ ,',#'$@ %/,-@ +# !$%/,-%.*$#$0#,-%.%#&$0#*!++#!$)%$06$/'# '#!+#' *! #/,-@#' 56%-$@ & *! 6!&*%' -*1','*.$%.#)0#!-*$#'%$.0#$&--)$0#5#!#'*-'6-#&B(*-%+-@,$M%!5%$N,',#'$@*5*%!$!!#/,-@##+%$'%16$%!&6!%!-%$#'*$6'#CA.%$%!5
	*$D6.0 .!%+#'*$%!-#+$0%6'$$0-+$0*$$0#$#'/+%.'%/%!*$%! * 6#+ %!  ( )* /#*!B&*('%!5 !# 6!%! (#' *!$0#' ' *--)%!5 #/,-@#''#-*$#+ %!&'/*$%! )0%-# 1*''%!5 %/%-*' 6!%!'#-*$#+%!&'/*$%!C!
 !$0%6'$*5*%!*++'##+$0#+%.'%/%!*$%!#I.#,$%! %!  ( )*  0# 6!%! %!
 !1#5*!*,%.>#$%!5.*/,*%5!*&$#'*$'#%!*/*--0%'#+*!!6!%! .!$'6.$%! .!$'*.$' *!+ $0'#*$#!#+ $ 0*!+1%--*!$0#'/*--$#!*!$ &'$0#*/# '#*!2+*$3E2*!+6>@)0%.0)!#+*!+,#'*$#+$0#/*--!$%&%#+$0#6!%!$0*$0*!+1%--#')6-+1#.!%+#'#+$'#,*#'*!+$0*$ $0#@ )6-+ 1# *>#+ $ -#*(#   0# 0*!+1%--#'+%$'%16$#+ 0*!+1%-- %! $0# /*-- ! #(#'*- ..*%! *!+)#'#*>#+$-#*(##*.0$%/#%!*--@$0#/*--/*!*5#'.*--#+$0#,-%.#*!+0*+$0#0*!+1%--#'*''#$#+*$3E3

 7KH &RXUW LQ/HFKPHUHIRFXVHG RQO\ RQ WKH ILUVW H[FHSWLRQ WR WKH3JHQHUDO UXOH ́ WKDW DQ HPSOR\HU 3FDQ EDU QRQHPSOR\HH XQLRQ RUJDQL]HUVIURP KLV SURSHUW\ ́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
	*$4D!$0#*'+*'56#+$0*$%')*!$'#-#(*!$%!*/6.0*%'&*%-#+$*!*-@F# ()*+%.'%/%!*$%! #I.#,$%! 1#.*6# " B+%.'%/%!*$#+*5*%!$ $0# 6!%! 1@ ,#'/%$$%!5 $0#' -%.%$*$%! 1@.0*'%$%#C*$2320%6'$+%*5'##+$0*$%'+%+!$*,,-@16$/'#%/,'$*!$-@&',6',#&$0#%!$*!$.*#%$0#-+$0*$6!+#' ()**!+%$,'5#!@6.0*%'B)0%.0)#%500#*(%-@%!&*('&,'%(*$#,',#'$@'%50$C$0#)'+B+%.'%/%!*$%!C+#!$.*''@$0#)#%50$ $0# *'+ *.'%1# $ %$  *$ 23  0# 6'$#I,-*%!#+$0*$BM$N+%.'%/%!*$#%!$0##!&'.#/#!$&M*!#/,-@#'N !-%.%$*$%! ,-%.@ .*!!$ /#*! $0*$ *!#/,-@#'.//%$*!6!&*%'-*1','*.$%.#%&%$*--)$0#;%'-.6$$#--.>%#16$%0%#-+#+&'/$0##&&#.$&$0#.$ %& %$ ,'0%1%$ $0#/ &'/ +%!5 C   0# 6'$'#.5!%F#+$0*$ %!.#  ()* )* +#.%+#+$0#6,'#/#6'$0*+!#(#'B.-*'%&%#+C$0#$#'/+%.'%/%!*$#6'$0#')0%-#$0%6'$%!*.>!)-#+5#+$0*$)# 

6'$0#'%!'#*.0%!5%$+#.%%!1#-)$0#*'+)*%!$#','#$%!5B+%.'%/%!*$%!C*$0*$$#'/)*6#+%!$0#6,'#/#6'$.*# ()*!#G6#!$-@6'$*!+*'+ & '#(%#) & $0# *'+ %!$#','#$*$%! & $0*$6,'#/#6'$*6$0'%$@%
 !2+*$3&#.$%!EA*DAD&$0#,'(%+#$0*$BM%N$0*--1#*!6!&*%' -*1' ,'*.$%.# &' *! #/,-@#'$ %!$#'&#'# )%$0'#$'*%! ' .#'.# #/,-@## %! $0# #I#'.%# & $0# '%50$56*'*!$##+ %! #.$%! M4 & $0# NC   
	JEA*DAD	#.$%!4&$0#,'(%+#%!,#'$%!#!$,*'$$0*$BM#N/,-@##0*--0*(#$0#'%50$$#-&'5*!%F*$%!$&'/ H%! ' *%$ -*1' '5*!%F*$%! $ 1*'5*%!.--#.$%(#-@$0'650 '#,'##!$*$%(#&$0#%')!.0%!5*!+$#!5*5#%!$0#'.!.#'$#+*.$%(%$%#&'$0#,6',#&.--#.$%(#1*'5*%!%!5'$0#'/6$6*-*%+','$#.$%!C 
	 J 4  ! #/,-@#' /*@$0#'#&'# (%-*$#$0#*!+.//%$*!6!&*%'-*1','*.$%.#)0#'#%$'#$'*%!'%!$#'&#'#)%$0$0#'%50$&#/,-@##$'5*!%F#,6'6*!$$	#.$%!4%'
	*$B@%$,-*%!$#'/$06$0#.!&#''%50$!-@!#/,-@##!$!6!%!'$0#%'!!#/,-@##'5*!%F#'C*$B'#$'%.$%!/*@1#,-*.#+!$0##/,-@##'%50$$+%.6#-&'5*!%F*$%!'0%'
6!-#$0##/,-@#'.*!+#/!$'*$#$0*$*'#$'%.$%!%!#.#*'@$/*%!$*%!,'+6.$%!'+%.%,-%!#16$!6.01-%5*$%!%)#+$!!#/,-@##'5*!%F#'C*$A#/,0*%%!$0#'%5%!*-DAG6$%!5&
03
	3A2DD	#.$%!4Q'5*!%F*$%!'%50$$0#'#&'#*,,-@!-@B+#'%(*$%(#-@C$!!#/,-@##6!%!'5*!%F#' *$   
 
   ( 	   70!7
	1	
23
	E4!2A4ED A#I,-*%!%!5 $0*$ BK!    1-%5*$%! % )#+!!#/,-@##'5*!%F#' *!@'%50$$0#@/*@0*(#$-%.%$!*!#/,-@#'Q,',#'$@%*+#'%(*$%(#&$0#'%50$&$0*$2

 7KH %RDUG KDVKHOG WKDW WKH GLVFULPLQDWLRQ H[FHSWLRQ JHQHUDOO\ LVVXEMHFW WR WZR H[FHSWLRQV RI LWV RZQ $Q HPSOR\HU GRHV QRW GLVFULPLQDWH LI WKH HPSOR\HU DOORZV D IHZ LVRODWHG LQVWDQFHV RI FKDULWDEOHVROLFLWDWLRQ 3EHQHILFHQW DFWV H[FHSWLRQ ́ RU  LI WKH VROLFLWDWLRQVDSSURYHG E\ WKH HPSOR\HU UHODWH WR WKH HPSOR\HU¶V EXVLQHVV IXQFWLRQV DQGSXUSRVHV6HH/XFLOH 6DOWHU 3DFNDUG &KLOGUHQ¶V +RVS DW 6WDQIRUG Y1/5%  )G   '& &LUFLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG ,Q WKHLQVWDQWFDVH WKH %RDUG KHOG WKDW WKH IUHTXHQF\ ZLWKZKLFK$OEHUWVRQ¶VDOORZHG FKDULWLHV WR VROLFLW GRQDWLRQV RQ LWV VWRUHV¶ SUHPLVHV H[FHHGHG WKDWSHUPLWWHG XQGHU WKH EHQHILFHQWDFWV H[FHSWLRQ $OEHUWVRQ¶V GRHV QRWFRQWHVW WKLV ILQGLQJ RQ DSSHDO +RZHYHU $OEHUWVRQ¶V GRHV FRQWHQG WKDWWKH %RDUG RIIHUV QR UHDVRQDEOH MXVWLILFDWLRQ IRU LWV EHQHILFHQWDFWVH[FHSWLRQ DQG DV WR ZK\ HPSOR\HUV¶ SURSHUW\ ULJKWV VKRXOG EH GLPLQLVKHG#/,-@#'Q #/,-@##$ #I#'.%#$0#%' '5*!%F*$%! '%50$#&&#.$%(#-@CD0#5#!#'*-'6-#%$0*$B*!#/,-@#'.*!!$1#./,#--#+$ *--) +%$'%16$%! & 6!%! -%$#'*$6'# 1@ !!#/,-@##'5*!%F#' ! 0% ,',#'$@C%'  
	 *$ )#(#'$0#	6,'#/#6'$0*'#.5!%F#+$0*$B$0#'%50$&#-&'5*!%F*$%!+#,#!+%!/#/#*6'#!M*!#/,-@#'#/,-@##N *1%-%$@     $ -#*'! $0# *+(*!$*5# & #-&'5*!%F*$%!&'/$0#'C*$0#'#&'#	#.$%!4 /%50$ B%! .#'$*%! -%/%$#+ .%'.6/$*!.# '#$'%.$ *!#/,-@#''%50$$#I.-6+#!!#/,-@##6!%!'5*!%F#'&'/ 0% ,',#'$@C  *$  %' '#*&&%'/#+ $0#6,'#/#6'$#*'-%#'0-+%!5$0*$*!#/,-@#'/*@B,$0% ,',#'$@ *5*%!$ !!#/,-@## +%$'%16$%! & 6!%!-%$#'*$6'#%&MN'#*!*1-##&&'$1@$0#6!%!$0'650$0#'*(*%-*1-#.0*!!#-&.//6!%.*$%!)%--#!*1-#%$$'#*.0$0# #/,-@## )%$0 %$ /#*5# *!+ MN %& $0# #/,-@#'!$%.#''+#'+#!$+%.'%/%!*$# *5*%!$$0#6!%!1@*--)%!5$0#'+%$'%16$%!M$0#K+%.'%/%!*$%!#I.#,$%!NC ()*
	*$"*'$%.6-*'-@*$$0#+%.'%/%!*$%!#I.#,$%!B$0#*--#5#++%.'%/%!*$'@.!+6.$%! *--)%!5 -%.%$*$%! M'N0*!+1%--%!5 '#G6%'#MN$0*$$0#+%.'%/%!*$%!1#*/!5./,*'*1-#5'6,'*.$%(%$%#*!+$0*$ $0# *.$%(%$%#$0#/#-(# 6!+#' .!%+#'*$%! /6$ 1#./,*'*1-#C
 !2+*$3A.%$*$%!%!$#'!*-G6$*$%!/*'>*!+*-$#'*$%!/%$$#+D 

DV D UHVXOW RI WKHLU JHQHURVLW\ WR FKDULWLHV $V IRU WKH VHFRQG H[FHSWLRQ$OEHUWVRQ¶V GRHV QRW FRQWHQG WKDW WKH FKDULWDEOH VROLFLWDWLRQV LW DOORZHG RQLWV SUHPLVHV UHODWH WR LWV EXVLQHVV DV D UHWDLO JURFHU& ( ( !* )(!( ) '(!(0%6'$0*+%.6#+$0# ()*0-+%!5'#5*'+%!5+%.'%/%!*$%!%!
 !*!+
!+24$0#6!%!1#5*!*0*!+1%--.*/,*%5!*5*%!$<*'.*'#$*%-$'#*!+!#&$0#$#!*!$%!*$'%,/*--/*!*5#+1@"*$20#0*!+1%--.!(#@#+$0*$<*'.0*+(%-*$#+.0%-+-*1'-*)*!+$0*$)'/)#'#&6!+%!1I#&'*%%!$0#$'#-+0#,6',#&$0#0*!+1%--)*$%!&'/$0#,61-%.$0*$<*'.)**!!6!%!$'#*!+$*>$0#,61-%.!$$0,$0#'#*$23&$#'<*'../,-*%!#+$$0#,',#'$@/*!*5#'$#,)#'#$*>#!$0*(#$0#0*!+1%--#'.#*#$0#%'1@.$$%!5*.$%(%$%#(#!$6*--@$0#,',#'$@/*!*5#'.*--#+$0#,-%.#!#+*@)0#!$0#0*!+1%--#'0*+'#&6#+$-#*(#1#.*6#$0#@)#'#%!(%-*$%!&$0#.%$@'+%!*!.#*5*%!$-%$#'%!5*$230# 6!%! &%-#+ *! 6!&*%'-*1' ,'*.$%.# .0*'5# *5*%!$"*!+*!8&6!+$0*$%!$0#,*$$0#	*-(*$%!'/@0*+1##!*--)#+$+%$'%16$#-#*&-#$!)%!+0%#-+&.*',*'>#+ *$ $0# /*--  0# 8 &6'$0#' &6!+ $0*$ ,-%$%.*-.*!+%+*$#0*+1##!*--)#+$-%.%$%5!*$6'#*!+$0#;%'-.6$ 0*+ -+ .>%#  $0#' 5'6, *--)#+ $ -%.%$)%$06$ 1#%!5 *>#+ $ -#*(# %!.-6+#+ $0# ?!%50$ &-6/16 $0# @ 	.6$ (#$#'*! *!+ .0- .0%-+'#!#--%!5.*!+@&'(*'%6.0-,'H#.$0#8&6!+$0*$$0#6!%!'5*!%F#')#'##!5*5#+%!*,'$#.$#+*.$%(%$@6!+#'$0#*!+&6!+%$%''#-#(*!$$0*$$0#0*!+1%--#')#'# !$ #/,-@#+ 1@ <*'. %!*/6.0 * $0#@ )#'##/,-@##&$0#'6!%!%F#+$'#*$$0#/*--0%6'$ &'*/#+$0#%6# * &--)7 BMN0#$0#'$0#)!#' & * ,'%(*$# '#$*%- 0,,%!5 /*-- /*@ &'1%+ 6!%!'#,'##!$*$%(# &'/ +%$'%16$%!5 0*!+1%-- +%'#.$#+ *$0,,#'$+%.6'*5#$0#/&'/,*$'!%F%!5*!!6!%!