LAWRENCE BERKELEY LABORATORY

Bldg: 90 Room: 4000 510 486-6493

Septembee 29.1993

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

RE:

Barry Berlin, DOE

Isaac Turiel, LBL

Enclosed please find LCC analyses for central air conditionerslheat pumps (modified

as requested by Ed Pollack) and furnaces. Please replace any previous versions of LCC

analyses for these products with the enclosed. If you have any questions please call me

at your convenience.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

LAWRENCE BERKELEY LABORATORY 

Bldg: 90 Room: 4000 510 486-6493 

Septembet 29,1993 

MEMORANDUM 

TO: Barry Berlin, DOE 

FROM: Isaac Turiel, LBL 

RE: 

Enclosed please find LCC analyses for central air conditionerslheat pumps (modified 

as requested by Ed Pollack) and furnaces. Please replace any previous versions of Lee 

analyses for these products with the enclosed. If you have any questions please call me 

at your convenience. 
Lite Cycle C-.llDCI Pay*1t Periocla "'3"00, SpUt System Centnl Air Coaditloner

8/17/83

IDa. I.IlIlalled Annual Annual CumuJ. L1fecycle Coots Cumuillive

SEER Manut'r Manut'r l.IlItaIlalioo MaiDlawl<:<Consume E1..,. EoCFJY Pa)iboclt COOl of COllKrved EoeraY

Lev. DotIp 0pIi0D Coot Coot COlI COlI Coot use COlt Pmod (1992$) (c:entsJl<Wh)

BIllbIW (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) tWhlyr (1992$) (ye...) 4~ 6~ 10~ 4~ 6~ 10~

0 Bue1lDo 10.00 $474.00 . S972.71 $46.69 52185.44 3427 5290 NA $5,415 $5,007 $4,395 NA NA NA

I 0+ BICtwonl1DdlDod 1Ddoor Blow... 10.28 $474.04 SO.04 $972.71 $46.69 52185.54 3337 5283 0.01 S5,330 $4,933 $4,337 0.01 0.01 0.01

2 I +Evapontor SUt Fiot 10.40 $474.13 SO.09 S972.7 I $46.69 52185.76 3297 $279 O.oJ $5,292 $4,900 $4,311 0.02 O.oJ 0.03

3 2+ ReciprocaliD. CoalpreI.or: 10.91 1!I!R .11.34 $481..:51 $7.38 $972.71 $46.69 $2203.91 3025 5256 0.54 $5,054 $4,694 $4,154 0.41 0.47 0,60

4 3+More ElrlCl.... CoDdalI... PSC FAD Motor (65.~) 11.47 $486.46 $4,95 S972.7 I $39,08 $2208.48 2990 5253 0.62 $5,026 $4,670 $4,136 0.47 0.54 0.69

5 4+ More BlrlCl.... BvapontorPSC FAD Motor (68.5~ 11.73 $493.68 $7.22 S972.71 $31.47 52218.63 2922 5248 0.78 $4,972 $4,624 $4,103 0.59 0.68 0.86

6 5 + Tw. Oolay Rday 12.18 $500.18 $6.SO S972.71 $31,47 $2234.62 2815 $239 0.95 $4,888 $4,552 $4,050 0.72 0.83 1.06

7 6 + COIldtDaer Grooved 'I\lbea 12.62 SS06.13 SS.95 $972.71 $31,47 52249.26 2716 $230 1.06 $4,809 $4,485 $4,000 0.81 0.92 1.18

8 7 + IDc:reue BVlponlOr FID Doatlly 10 14 (pI 12.68 SS06.88 SO.75 $972.71 $31.47 52251.10 2704 SZ29 1.07 $4,800 $4,477 $3.995 0.82 0.94 1.19

9 8+ Scroll Compreaor: 1I.so!!Elli NOD-Blood TXV 13.51 SS43.29 $36.41 S972.71 $31.47 $2340.67 2538 521S 2.06 $4,732 $4,430 S3,977 1.S7 1.80 2.29

10 9 + IDc:reue BVlponlOr F_ AroIIo 6.60 oq.n. 14.40 S565.51 $22.22 S989.69 $31.47 $2412.31 2381 5202 2.. $4,656 $4,373 $3,948 1.95 2.23 2.85

11 10 + IDaeuo eaa-F_AroIIO 18.03 oq.n. 15.19 SS86.24 520.73 SI024.25 $31.47 52497.87 2257 SI91 3.1S $4,625 $4,356 S3,953 2.40 2.75 3.51

12 II + Inaeuo BVlponlOrF_ AroIIo 7.so oq.n. 15.37 $594.35 S8.11 S1030.42 $31.47 52523.99 2230 $189 3.34 $4,626 $4,360 S3,962 2.54 2.91 3.72

13 12+ IDaeuo Condenser F_ AroIIO 28.33 oq.n. 15.82 $635.95 $41.60 $1099.53 $31.47 $2695.44 2167 $184 4.78 $4,738 $4,480 $4,093 3.64 4.17 5.32

14 13 + Evapontor HeM FAD Motor 16.40 S777.26 SI41.31 S1099.53 $47.09 $3058.68 2091 S177 7.71 $5,029 $4,780 $4,407 5.88 6.73 8.59

15 14 + Electronic EJtJllDlIoa V.Iv. 16.60 $853.43 $76.17 $1099.~3 SS6.07 $3255.04 2066 SI75 9.27 S5,202 $4,955 $4,587 7.06 8.09 10.33

16 15 + Condens... HeM PAD Motor 16.75 $919.98 S66.55 S1099.53 $63.68 $3426.36 2047 SI73 10.61 S5,355 S5,II1 $4,746 8.09 9.26 11.82

17 16 + Two-Speed Reclp-Compraoor Syo_ 18.20 SI,100.67 S180.69 S1099.53 $76.66 $3883.84 1884 $160 12.98 $5,659 SS.435 $5.098 9.90 11.33 14.47

18 16 + Vuilbl",Spood RocIfK:ompns.orSy._ 18.58 SI.511.92 SS91.94 S1099.53 S120.59 $4939.44 1846 SI56 20.54 $6,679 $6,459 $6.129 15.66 17.93 22.89

19 16 + Two-Speed Scroll-Comp,....or Sy...m 18.91 SI,41 1.92 $491.94 S1099.53 SII6.22 $4689.07 1814 SI54 18.30 $6.398 $6,182 S5.858 13.95 15.97 20.40

20 16 + VIriIbI",SPOed ScroIl·Com""""" SY....... 21.18 SI,56I.92 $641.94 S1099.53 S122.78 SS064.63 1619 SIJ7 18.78 S6,590 $6.397 $6,108 14.32 16.39 20.93

AlIllQlpsloaa.

1 Eledricity COIl_ 0.085 SltWb (Ivena. COIl In 1999 oblaiDod from AD Inwpolalioo of lbo 1995 IDd 2000 prices of eb:tricily f.,..,..1in DOE. AMuaJ EoeraY Ou~ook Im.innated

10 1992 doll...). Tho intapolllod vollle for 1999 i. 0.082 S/l<Wh (199IS) or 0.085 aile••djustin8 for innllioo from 1991 10 1992. The electricity price enduse foclOr forCAC Is 1.0 (no adjustment).

2 Lifetime. IS y..... Mortup fl""". 2.46.

3 O..ellne unit Includes:

EViporotor: 4.13 oq.n..13 lIN/IIlcll. Wlvy Fltu. 3 lube rows. Groove 'I\lbea

Condenocr: 12.88 .q.n., 20 rwflllCh, Slil Fins, I tube row, Smoolh Tubel

Compns.or: Reciprocotina. 10.20 HER (nomlnll)

Eyapontor Fan Molar: PSC, S8.5'llo emclent

Coodms... Fan MOlOr. PSC, 55.0'll0 errlClent

EnhoocemeoIOovic<l: Nooe

4 Non-Blood 1bermoIlI1Ic: EJtpllllioo Volv. repl..... lbo need for. Time DeilY Reily

5 Muimum S....lbl. HCI' Rallo. 76.5'llo

e Evapontor ECM FAD Motor 10 moduIIled. CoIl of fAD motor includes electronic moduJllina controls.

7 CondCIller HeM FAD MOl« II nID ItI 'iDslo .peed.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

Life Cycle Coea IIDd Pay'-" Pcriodl al3-toe, SpUl System Cml,.., Air Coaclilioner 

hx:r. WIaUed Annual Annual Cumul. Llfecycle C<>su Cumulative 

SEER Manut'r Manut'r lDstaIIadoa MaInlawIa Consume Eec. Energy Payboclt Coo, of ColllUVed Energy 

~. Doll ... 0pII0a Coo, Coo, COlI COlI C<>s, - cool Ptriod (1992$) (c:enuJltWh) 

BIUbIW (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) tWh/yr (1992$) (ye ... ) 4~ 6~ 10~ 4~ 6~ 10~ 

0 BuellDe 10.00 $474.00 - S972.71 $46.69 $2185.44 3427 $290 NA S5,415 S5,OO7 $4,395 NA NA NA 

I 0+ BlCtword IDcIIDocI iDcIoor Blow ... 10.28 $474.04 SO.04 $972.71 $46.69 $2185.54 3337 $283 0.01 $5,330 $4,933 $4,337 0.01 0.01 0.01 

2 I + EvaporllOr SUI """ 10.40 $474.13 SO.09 $972.71 $46.69 $2185.76 3297 $279 0.03 S5,292 $4,900 $4.311 0.02 0,03 0.03 

3 2+ RociprocaliD, CompreIlor: 10.911!1!R .11 .34 $481.51 $7.38 S972.7 I $46.69 $2203.91 3025 $256 0.54 S5,054 $4,694 $4,154 0041 0.47 0.60 

4 3 + M .... Emcttlll CoadeoIer PSC Faa MolOr (65.~) 11.47 $486.46 $4.95 S972.7 I $39.08 S2208.48 2990 $253 0.62 S5,026 $4,670 $4,136 0.47 0.54 0.69 

S 4 + M .... l!lrocltllll!vaporllOr PSC Faa Motor {68.S" 11 .73 $493.68 $7.22 $972.71 $31.47 $2218.63 2922 SlA8 0.78 $4,972 $4,624 $4,103 0.59 0.68 0.86 

6 S + TlIDo Delay Relay 12.11 SSOO.18 $6.S0 $972.71 $31.47 $2234.62 281S $239 0.9S $4.888 $4.S52 $4.0S0 0.72 0.83 1.06 

7 6 + CODCI«IIer Grooved 'Illba 12.62 $506.13 S5.95 S972.7 I $31 .47 $2249.26 2716 S230 1.06 $4.809 $4,485 $4.000 0.81 0.92 1.18 

8 7 + IIIcre&Je I!vlpcnlllr Fill Oooolly 10 14 (PI 12.68 SS06.88 SO.7S S972.7 I $31.47 $2251.10 2704 n29 1.07 $4.800 $4.477 $3,995 0.82 0.94 1.19 

9 8 + StroU Compruoor: 1I..so I!ER I NOD-Blood TXV 13.51 SS43.29 $36.41 S972.7I $31.47 $234Q.67 2538 $21S 2.06 $4.732 $4,430 $3.977 1.57 1.80 229 

10 9 + IIIcre&Je I!VlpcnIIlr F_ Aroo 10 6.60 oq.n. 14.40 SS65.51 $22.22 S989.69 $31.47 S2412.31 2381 $202 2.56 $4.656 $4,373 $3.948 1.95 2.23 2.85 

II 10 + IIIcre&Je ~ F_ Aroo 10 18.03 oq.n. IS.19 $586.24 $20.73 SI024.25 $31.41 SlA97.87 22S1 $191 3.15 $4.625 $4.356 $3.953 240 275 3.51 

12 II + IDaeuo I!vlpcnIIlr F_ Aroo 10 7..so oq.n. 15.37 $594.35 S8.l1 $1030.42 $31.47 $2523.99 2230 SI89 3.34 $4,626 $4.360 S3.962 234 291 3.72 

13 12+ InauleCondemerF_Aroo 10 28.33 oq.n. 1S.82 $635.95 $41.60 $1099.S3 $31.47 $269S.44 2167 SI84 4.78 $4.738 $4,480 $4.093 3.64 4.17 5.32 

14 13 + EvaporllDl' ECM Faa Motor 16.40 $777.26 $141.31 $1099.53 $47.09 $3058.68 2091 $177 7.71 SS.029 $4.780 $4.407 S.88 6.73 8.59 

IS 14 + Ele.clrOlIlc I!Jpa"lI"" Valvo 16.60 $853.43 $76.11 $1099::;3 $56.07 $3255.04 2066 $175 9.27 $5,202 $4.95S $4,587 7.06 8.09 10.33 

16 15 + Coademer ECM Paa Motor 16.75 S919.98 S66.S5 S1099.53 $63.68 $3426.36 2047 S173 10.61 $5,355 SS.III $4.746 8.09 9.26 11.82 

17 16 + Tw()oSpoed Rocip-Compn:uor Sya_ 18.20 SI.100.67 $180.69 $1099.S3 $76.66 $3883.84 \884 $160 1298 S5.659 $5.43S $5.098 9.90 11.33 14.47 

18 16 + Variable-Speed Rocip-Com"""lor Sy._ 18.58 SI,SI1.92 SS91.94 S1099.S3 S120.59 $4939.44 1846 SI56 20.54 $6.679 $6.459 $6,129 1S.66 17.93 2289 

19 16 + Two-Speed Scroll-Com"",,_ SY'1ml 18.91 SI ,41 1.92 $491.94 S1099.53 $116.22 $4689.07 1814 SI54 18.30 $6.398 $6,182 S5.8S8 13.95 15.97 20.40 

20 16 + Variable-Speed StroIl·Compf<SSOf Symm 21 .18 SI,56I.92 $641.94 $1099.53 $12278 $5064.63 1619 $137 18.78 S6.59O $6.397 $6.108 14.32 16.39 20.93 

AlIllQlpsIooa . 

1 Eledricity toil_ O.085"WI! (avenae COOlin 1999oblllDod £rom 10 1nlClpOIIIlioa of Iho 1995 ",d 2000 prices of eJec:trleily foroclSlln DOE. AMuai Energy Ou~ook 1993. !nnlled 

LO 1992 doUIR). Tho InltlpOlal<>d value (or 1999 i. 0.082 $JItWl! {I 99IS) or 0.085 ~r adjusting for innldoD Iiom 1991 LO 1992. The electrlei,y price enduse flC"" for CAC Is 1.0 (no adjuslmenl). 

3 BIS.Une unIllDcludeo: 

Evaporator: U3 oq.n., 13 1lnI,1nch, Wavy FilII, 3 lube rows, Groove Tuba 

Condenser. 12.88 'q.n., 20 rwflJlCll, Sill F .... I lube row. SmOOlb 'Illba 

Com""".or: Roc lprocatina. 10.20 EER (nomlnll) 

EvaporalOr FID Molar: PSC. 58.5" emelenl 

Co_ .. F", MOlar: PSC. 5S 0~ etroclenl 

Enhaoccmeol Devices: None 

4 Non-Blood 1bcrmoo1l1ic I!Jpanaio. Valve replacu!he need for a Time Deily Relay 

5 M .. imum S .... ibl. Heal Rallo. 76.5" 

8 EvaporllOr ECM PID MOlar \a moduIalod. C<>sl of flD motor Includes eloclrODic modullll., conlrOIs. 

7 Condem ... ECM FlO MOIOr \a nil! lila 'ina" .peed. 
$6,600

$6,200

$5,800

--.

(AM

r:J\

r:J\

e $5,400

u

u

...:l

$5,000

$4,600

9/17/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Split System

Central Air Conditioner

1--0-- 6% discount rate I

20

$4,200

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0 22.0

SEER

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

...... 

~ 

N 

a-. 

a-. 

$6,600 

$6,200 

$5,800 

e $5,400 

u 

U 

..:l 

$5,000 

$4,600 

$4,200 

9/17/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3·ton Split System 

Central Air Conditioner 

1--0----- 6% discount rate I 

20 

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0 22.0 

SEER 
9/17/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-too Split System

Central Air Conditioner

.

$7,000

$6,600

$6,200

$5,800

......

M

:=. $5,400

u

$5,000

$4,600

$4,200

--0- 4% discount rate

- - t'l - - 6% discount rate

- - -.•- - - - 10% discount rate

I::i..~

" 'I::it.....t,..

.,

•...'

.......... -_.-.... .. ... -.. --... -. -.-

••

,

.

.,

.

,.

,I::i

,

'" , "

,.

",'

'" . '" , '"

$3,800

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0

SEER

17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0 22.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$7,000 

$6,600 

$6,200 

$5,800 

$5,000 

$4,600 

$4,200 

$3,800 

9.0 

., •... ' 

9/17/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3·ton Split System 

Central Air Conditioner 

--0- 4% discount rate 

- - £1 - - 6% discount rate 

- - --. - - - - 10% discount rate 

...... . .fi .•.. , 

.. -. ---.. ----.- -- --.... 

10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 

SEER 

,. 

19.0 20.0 21.0 22.0 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of S.lon, Spilt System Central Air Conditioner

9/30/93

Incr. ImlaIled Annual Annual Clunv!. Lifecycle CoslS Clunullllive

SEER Manufr Manufr Installation Main~ Consumer Hlec. I!nergy Payblock Coli of Consaved Enagy

Leve Deoian Oplion COIl COil Cost Cost Cost use oost Period (1992$) (cenUlkWh)

BruhIW (1992$) 0991$) (1992$) (\992$) (1992$) kWh/yr (\991$) (years) 4~ 6% 1()'lI, 4% 6% IO'T.

0 Bueline 10.ol $666.00 - SI494.33 S46.69 S341248 5783 S490 NA S8,862 S8,173 S7,14 I NA NA NA

1 o+ Bactwonl1Dc1ined IndoorBlower 10.29 $666.02 $0.02 SI494.33 S46.69 S3412.54 5625 $477 0.00 S8,714 S8,043 S7,039 0.00 0.00 0.00

2 1+ Bvaponl« Slit Fins 10.38 $666.23 SO.21 SI494.33 S46.69 S3413.13 5576 S473 0.04 S8,668 S8,003 S7,008 0.Q3 0.03 0.04

3 2 + Scroll Co..." ..or: 11.30 BBR 11.88 $690.87 S24.64 SI494.33 S46.69 S348236 4871 S413 0.90 S8,073 S7,492 $6,623 0.69 0.79 1.01

4 3 +rUDe Delay Relay 1234 $697.37 $6.SO SI494.33 $46.69 S3SOO.63 4689 S397 0.95 $7,919 S7,361 S6,523 0.72 0.83 U16

5 4 + More Blf'teiaIl Bv.......... PSC Fin M.-(68.5'" 1265 S707.14 S9.77 SI494.33 S39.08 S352O.47 4573 S388 1.05 S7,83O S7,285 $6,469 0.80 0.92 1.17

6 5 + Non-Bleed ThermotIolic I!llpmsion Valve 1297 $714.72 S1.58 SI494.33 S39.08 S3541.77 4462 S378 1.15 S7,746 S7,215 $6,418 0.88 1.01 1.29

7 6 + More Blf'teiaIl PSC Fin Mocor (65.0'lI'o) 13.09 S72I.02 S6.3O SI494.33 S31.47 S3551.87 4420 S375 1.21 S7,718 S'7,191 $6,402 0.92 1.05 1.35

a 7 + IncreaoeBvaporllOr JTm Deruity 10 141'pi 13.14 S72248 SI.46 S1494.33 S31.47 S3555.97 4405 S373 1.23 S7,708 S7,182 $6,396 0.94 1.07 1.37

9 8 + IncreaoeBvaporllOr Face Ana 10 7.SO Iq.f\. 13.53 $739.70 SI7.22 S1504.62 S31.47 S3614.65 4276 S362 1.58 S7,644 S7,134 $6,371 1.21 1.38 1.76

10 9 + CondmI<r Grooved Tubes 13.69 $756.52 S16.82 S1504.62 S31.47 S3661.91 4226 S358 1.89 S7,644 $7,141 $6,386 1.44 1.65 2.11

11 10 + Increa., Condemer Face Area 10 27.«J Iq.f\. 13.95 S788.74 S3222 S1535.49 S31.47 S3783.32 4148 S352 268 S7,693 $7,198 $6,458 2.04 234 298

12 11 + Increue Condemer PICe Area to 36.SO Iq./l. 14.22 S8SO.4O $61.66 S1595.21 S31.47 S4016.3O 4069 S345 4.\6 $7,851 $7,366 $6,640 3.17 3.63 4.63

13 12 + B.aporllOr BCM Pin MOIOr 14.84 SI,03O.66 SI80.26 S1595.2I S47.09 $4538.45 3899 $330 7.05 S8,213 S7,748 S7,052 5,38 6.15 7.86

14 13 + Hlec1rOllic BJ<PlDlion Valve 15.04 SI,106.83 S76.17 S1595.21 S56.07 $4761.47 3847 S326 8.22 S8,387 S7,928 S7,242 6.27 7.17 9.16

IS 14 + Condemer BCM Fin MOIOr 15.11 SI,179.53 S7270 S1595.21 $63.68 $4973.37 3830 S325 9.43 S8,583 S8,126 $7,442 7.19 8.23 10.51

16 15 +Two-Speed Rccip-~lIor Syllem 16.76 SI,368.28 S188.75 S1595.21 S80.54 S5520.62 3452 S293 10.67 S8,m S8,362 S7,746 8.13 9.31 11.89

17 IS + Varilbl~ Recip-Compre..or Sylltm 17.67 SI,779.53 S600.00 S1595.21 S13224 S6727.93 3275 S278 15.60 S9,815 S9,424 S8,840 11.89 13.62 17.39

18 15 + Two-Speed Scroll-Compre..or System 17.02 SI,679.53 S5OO.00 S1595.21 S127.87 $644256 3400 S288 15.00 S9,646 S9,241 S8,634 11.44 13.09 16.72

19 15 + Varilbio-sPeed Scroll- rSyslerJl 19.62 SI,829.53 S650.00 $1595.21 SI34.43 $6870.62 2949 S250 14.40 S9,649 S9,298 S8,772 10.97 12.56 16.04

AapUJlIIioo,'

1 I!Iectricity COlt z 0.085 SItWh (average COlt in 1999 obtained from In inIerpolation ofthe 1995 ond 2000 prices of eleclricity foreea.n in OOE'. Annual Fnergy Oullook 1993, inflated

10 1992 dollan). The inIapoIaIed valve for 1999 is 0.082 SItWh (199IS) or 0.085 Iftt;r odjusting for inflation from 199110 1992 The electricity price enduse faclor for CAC il 1.0 (no odjuslment).

2 Ufetime a 15,..... Markup factor = 281.

3 Baseline lIRit iDcludea:

Bvaporator: 6.00 Iq.f\., 13 finsIinch. WaY)' Pins, 41l1be roWI, Groove Tubes

Condenler: 23.00 Iq.f\., 20 liDs{mch. Slit Pins, 2 blbe rows, SmoolhTubes

Compressor: Recip......q, 10.49EER (nominal); Accumvlalor

BvaporalOr P., Mocor: PSC, 58.5~ ellici...

CondmI<r PIlII Molar: PSC, 55.0'lI'o o1f'lCiaJt

l!llbIDcemed Devices: None

4 Non-Bleed TbermoIIIIic &ponsion Valve replaces the need for aTime Delay Rela,..

5 Maximum Sensible Hal Ralio • 76.5'"

6 BvaporllOr I!CM Pin MOIU il modulaled. COIl offin moIOr inclUdel elec1rOllic modulllling controls.

7 Condenser BCM Pin MOIOr is fWI at a lingle speed.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

9/30/ 93 

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Puiods or 5.lon, Split System Central Air Conditioner 

Incr. Ins1aIled Annual Annual CUmul. Lifecycle Cotu CUmulative 

SEER M.NI', Manul'r Installation MainIcnInot Consumer Elec. F.ne'l)' Payblck Coli of COItJ<rVed Energy 

Leve Desian Option Cost COil Cott Cost Coil uSe COlt Period (1992$) (ccnUiltWb) 

BruhIW (1992$) (19915) (19915) (19915) (1992$) kWll/yr (1992$) (year.) 4~ 6% 10% 4% 6% 1O'r. 

0 Buelint 10.01 $666.00 . 51494.33 S46.69 53412.48 5783 S490 NA 58.862 58.173 57.141 NA NA NA 

1 o + Bectwonl !nclinod lndocr Blower 10.29 $666.02 $0.02 51494.33 S46.69 S3412..54 562.5 $477 0.00 $8.714 $8.043 57.039 0.00 0.00 0.00 

2 1 + Bvapont« Slit Pins 10.38 $666.23 $0.21 51494.33 $46.69 53413.13 5576 $473 0.04 $8.668 $8.003 57.008 0.03 0.03 0.04 

3 2 + Saou CoqJl'eIlOr. 11.30 EER 11.88 $690.87 $24.64 51494.33 546.69 53482.36 4871 $413 0.90 S8.073 $7.492 $6.623 0.69 0.79 \.01 

4 3 + T'unt Delll)l Relay 12.34 $697.37 $6.50 51494.33 546.69 $3500.63 4689 S397 0.95 57.919 $7.361 56.523 0.72 0.83 \.06 

5 4 + More BlI"tciall BYJIiOnIOr PSC Pm MOl« (68.5"', 12.65 5707.14 59.77 51494.33 539.08 53520.47 4573 5388 \.05 57.830 $7,285 $6.469 0.80 0.92 1.17 

6 5 + Non-Bleed Thermotalie Bxpomion Valve 12.97 $714.72 57.58 $1494.33 $39.08 5354\'77 4462 $378 1.15 $7.746 $7.215 $6.418 0.88 1.01 1.29 

7 6 + More BlI"tciall ~ PSC Pm Moe« (6S ~) 13.09 $72\.02 56.30 $1494.33 53\,47 $3551.87 4420 $375 1.21 57.718 $1.191 $6.402 0.92 \.05 1.35 

a 7 + lnc!aae BvoporllOr F'm Deruity to 14 (pi 13.14 5722.48 5\.46 S1494.33 53\,47 53555.97 4405 $373 \.23 57.708 $7.182 $6.396 0.94 \.07 \.37 

9 8 + lncreue BvoporllOr Pace Area to 7.50 sq.!\. 13.53 S739.70 517.22 51504.62 S31.47 S3614.65 4276 S362 \.58 57.644 57.134 $6.371 \,21 1.38 1.76 

10 9 + Condauer Grooved Tubea 13.69 5756.52 S16.82 S1504.62 S31.47 S366\.91 4226 $358 \.89 S7.644 $7.141 $6.386 1.44 \.65 2.11 

11 10 + lncreaae CondcnJer Pace Area to 27.60 sq.!\. 13.95 S788.74 S32.22 51535.49 S31.47 53783.32 4148 $352 2.68 57.693 $7.198 $6.458 2.04 2.34 2.98 

12 11 + Increue Condemer Pace Are& to 36.50 sq.JI. 14.22 5850.40 $61.66 51595.21 S31.47 S4016.3O 4069 S345 4.16 $7.851 $7.366 $6.640 3.17 3.63 4.63 

i3 12 + e.aporllOr BCM Pili MOl« 14.84 SI.03O.66 SI80.26 S1595.21 S47.09 $4538.45 3899 $330 7.05 S8,213 S7.748 57.052 5.38 6.15 7.86 

14 13 + Electronic Bxponsion Valve 1S.04 SI.106.83 S76.17 S1595.21 S56.07 $476\.47 3847 5326 8.22 58.387 S7.928 $7,242 6.27 7.17 9.16 

15 14 + CondcnIer BCM Pili MOl« 15.11 SI.179.53 S72.70 51595.21 $63.68 $4973.37 3830 S32.5 9.43 S8.583 S8.126 S7.442 7.19 8.23 10.51 

16 15 + Twc>-Speed R~lIor Syaem 16.76 SI.368.28 S188.75 51595.21 S80.54 S5520.62 3452 5293 10.67 58.773 58.362 57.746 8.13 9.31 1 \.89 

17 15 + Varilbl~ Recip-Comprellor Syaan 17.67 $1.779.53 S6OO.00 $1595.21 SI32.24 S6727.93 3275 5278 15.60 59.815 59.424 S8.84O 1\.89 13.62 17.39 

18 15 + Twc>-Speed Saoll~sor Syl1an 17.02 SI.679.53 5500.00 51595.21 S127.87 $6442.56 3400 S288 15.00 $9.646 S9,241 S8.634 11.44 13.09 16.72 

19 15 + Varilb~ SaoU· r Sy.tem 19.62 SI.829.53 5650.00 $1595.21 SI34.43 $6870.62 2949 $2.50 14·.40 S9.649 $9.298 S8.772 10.97 12.56 16.04 

Ale"DllhE'· Electricity COlt - 0.085 5lkWb (averase COlt in 1999 obIained from III inI<rpolation of the 1995 and 2000 prices of electricity forecast in OOB'. Annual F.neraY Outlook 1993. inflaled 

to 1992 dol .... ). The inIapoIII.ed value for 1999 is 0.082 5lkWb (1991$) or 0.085 a&r odjusting for inflation from 1991 to 1992. The electricity price cnduse factor fOJ CAC il \.0 (no odjustment). 

3 B_line unit includes: 

Bvopora1Dr. 6.00 sq.!\.. 13 finIIincb. Wavy Pins, 4 wbe 'OW •• Groove Tubea 

Condenler: 23.00 sq.f\., 20 rmsflllCh. Slit Pins. 2 wbe ro .... Smooth Tubes 

Cornpuoor: Recip......q, 10.49 EER (nominal); Accumulator 

Bvoporaaor p., Mocor: psc. 58 5~ efficient 

Condauer Pm Mour. PSC, 55.0% c:1f'lCieol 

l!DblI1lc:emed Devices: None 

~ Non-Bleed 'IbermoItIIic Bxpoouion Valve rcplacet the need fOJ a Time Dell1)1 Relay. 

5 Muimlm Sensible Heal Raio - 76.5~ 

6 BvoporllOr ECM Pili MOl« il modulated. Cost of fill mocor include. electronic modullling control •. 

7 Condenser BCM Pm MOl« i. run at a lingle speed. 
9/29/93

Life Cycle Cost for 5-ton Split System

Central Air Conditioner

$9,500

$9,000 + 1--0- 6% discount rate I

,.... $8,500

N

0\

0\

>-4

-

..J $8,000

$7,500

19

$7,000

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0

SEER

16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$9,500 

9/29/93 

Life Cycle Cost for S-ton Split System 

Central Air Conditioner 

$9,000 1--0- 6% discount rate I 

__ $8,500 ~ 

N 

'" '" .... 

'-' 

u 

U 

..J $8,000 

$7,500 

$7,000 

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 

SEER 

19 

17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 
9/29/93

Life Cycle Cost for 5-ton Split System

Central Air Conditioner

20.0

••

17.0 18.0 19.0

."

16.0

1t

,

,

14.0 15.0

SEER

13.0

,

,

,.

12.0

,

,+ .. .... , .

"

..... -....

- - {:, - - 6% discount rate

. _..•- - - - 10% discount rate

11.0

'..,

-0-- 4% discount rate

o",L;

o"o"

".////

,.//

",'" ,..

~o'", ,.., ,

A "'. / .... ...... // o",,' b /o" '/:S "'" ..- __, v,

.... /f"-::'--:"-- ,','

.... T ,','

.... f :,' .... ' , , ,

.... ' , .... .... I- ,,':: .... '. / ,:',. .... / ,.. <.'

/ }:.'

.... (:;.

/

., - -tsts /j.

10.0

$9,800

$9,400

$9,000

$8,600

,-.

$8,200

.-4

'-'

U

u $7,800

..J

$7,400

$7,000

$6,600

$6,200

9.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$9,800 

$9,400 

$9,000 

$8,600 

,-.. 

~ $8,200 

'""" '-' 

u 

u $7,800 

..J 

$7,400 

$7,000 

$6,600 

$6,200 

9.0 

.+ + , 

10.0 

9/29/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 5-ton Split System 

Central Air Conditioner 

-0-- 4% discount rate 

- - tJ - - 6% discount rate 

- - - - +- - - - 10% discount rate 

. + 

, 

,+ 

• +. ,+ 

... .. ... . ....... .+ " ~ ... . . + ... 

11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 

SEER 

,+ 

17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 
Lire Cyde Costs and Payback Periods o(J-ton, Splll System Cenlral Heal Pump

g/17/V3

IDa. InoI&1Iod Anralal Eloc U.. Annu.II C\II11W. lifccydeC.... CIII11u1ali...

SEI!R HSPf Manufr M.nul'r lnll.&1l.tian M.aintaaancc corwumc:r CooIina HCltinl Enc"u P.yboc:k Cool 01ConacNod EnctaY

LAve Deoian Option Cool Ce»t C... Cool ..... coot Period (1992$) (=uiltWh)

BIUlvW BwIt/W (1992$l (1992$) (1992$) (1992$l (1992$) 1tWh/yr 1tWh/yr (1992$) (yean) 4CJb 10CJb 4CJb 6CJb 10CJb

0 Baseline 10.00 6.19 S677.OO S902.S3 $46.69 82743.27 3651 8,132 $999 NA S13,848 SI2,444 S10,34O NA NA NA

I 0+ Bac:ltwanllnclinod IndoorBlo_ 10.30 7.00 S677.OO SO.OO S902.S3 $46.69 82743.27 3S44 8.011 S979 0.00 SI3,633 SI2,256 SIO,I93 0.00 0.00 0.00

2 I + Indoor Coil SUt Fina 10.43 7.11 S677.03 SO.03 S902.S3 $46.69 82743.3S 3500 7,889 S965 0.00 SI3,476 SI2,119 S10.083 0.00 0.01 0.01

3 2 + Inaooaclndoor CoiIl"UI DonoilylO 14/pi 10.47 7.13 S677.69 SO.66 S902.S3 $46.69 82743.10 3486 7,838 S962 O.OS S13.433 SI2,on SIO.03~ 0.10 0.11 O.IS

4 3 + "'O~ l!lficia\t Indoor PSC Pan Moe« (68~CJb) 10.72 7.22 S684.89 S7.20 S902.33 $39.08 $2736.37 3406 7.76tl 3946 0.25 313.279 311.948 $9.933 0.49 0.36 0.71

3 4 + "'0"' Elficia\t o..tdoor PSC Fan Mo<or (65.0CJb 10.83 7.32 S691.19 S6.30 S902.S3 $31.47 $276S.66 3372 7,658 S93S 0.33 SI3.160 SII.84S S9.876 0.72 0.82 I.OS

6 3 +Time Del.y Relay 11.17 7.47 S697.69 S6.30 S902.S3 $31.47 $2782.88 3268 7,.506 S913 0.46 S12.937 SI1,6S2 $9,729 0.93 1.06 1.36

7 6 + Rcaprocatinl Campreaaor. 11.26 EI!R 11.69 7.68 S708.68 SIO.99 S902.33 $31.47 $2812.00 312.3 7.29S S883 0.s9 S12.632 SII ,390 S9~30 1.17 1.34 1.72

8 7 +lnaooaclndoor Coil F.ce: Aroa 0.04.97 "111. 12.41 7.97 S722.0S S13.37 S912.27 $31.47 821S7.17 2941 7.037 S846 0.74 S12.261 SII.071 39.290 1.44 1.65 2.11

9 8 +Demand Ddn>ot 12.41 8.20 S733.sS S\l50 S912.27 $31.47 82887.65 2941 6.831 5828 0.8S SI2,098 S10.933 S9,188 1.83 2.09 2.61

10 9 + o..tdoor Coil Oroc>¥ocI Tu.... 12.73 8.24 5740.S2 $6.97 S912.27 $31.47 82906.12 2869 6,803 S820 0.91 SI2,021 SI0.868 59.142 1.87 2.14 2.74

\I 10 + Inc:taae Indoor Coil F.... Area 10 6.39 Ill.!\. 13.12 8.40 S13S.6tl SIS.08 S922.01 $31.47 S29SS.82 2782 6,614 S802 1.08 SII.868 SI 0,74 I S9,032 2.20 2.32 3.22

12 II + Scroll CamplUaOr. \I ~O I!I!R 13.70 8.S0 Sn4.s8 S18.98 S922.01 $31.47 $3006.12 266S 6,.591 $71S 1.23 SII,729 SIO,626 S8.974 2.40 2.74 3~

i3 12 + Nan·Blood Thamt...Olio Baponaian Valv. 14.04 8.73 $717.03 S12.4S S922.01 $31.47 $3039.11 2600 6,421 $765 1.26 SII,.541 SI0.466 S8,8S3 2.S3 2.90 3.70

14 13 + lnc:taaoOwd_CoiIFI... AN to 11.00 IIl./\ 14.7. 9.06 S811.89 S14.86 S962.17 $31.47 $314S.25 1411 6,184 $734 U2 SII,302 S10,270 $8,725 3.06 3~1 4.48

IS 14 + Inc:tal.lndoor Coil FI..AN 10 7.50 Ill.!\. 1S.00 9.13 S822.19 510.30 S969.88 $31.47 $3180.16 1434 6.139 $727 1.61 SII,239 S10,238 S8,707 3.23 3.70 4.72

16 IS + In.,..•• Indoor Coil lUbe Dr>laity to 4 ro'" lS.ll 9.20 S844OS8 S21.39 S969.88 $31.47 $3239.49 1416 6,092 $721 1.79 SII,237 S10,243 S8.714 3.61 4.13 S.28

17 16 + Inc:ta•• OIlIlIoor Coil FI... Area 1030.00 IIl./\ IS,48 9.32 $890.19 S4S.61 SI030.27 $31.47 $3420.7S 23S9 6.018 $710 l.3S SII,314 S10,316 S8,821 4.71 S.4O 6.89

18 17 + o..u1oor ECM Fan Molar IS~9 9.4S S962.89 $72.70 S1030.27 $39.08 $3621.01 1343 S.93S $702 1.9S SII,421 S10,43S S8,9S8 6.03 6.91 8.82

19 18 + Elcaronic E'paNian Volvo IS.79 9,.50 $1.0\1.23 $48.34 S1030.27 $48.06 $37S8.09 2313 S.904 8696 3.36 SII,.502 SI0,.521 S9.03S 6.81 7.81 9.97

10 19 + Indoor ECM Fan Moe« 16.36 9,.56 SI,1S2.S3 SI41.3O S1030.27 863.68 $4148.16 2231 3.865 8686 4.S0 SII,779 S10.814 S9,368 8.91 10.19 13.02

21 20 +Twc>-Speod RccipoCam_ Syalan 17.90 9.6tl SI,332.79 SI80.26 S1030.27 $77.62 $4639.19 2040 3.837 S668 S.73 SI2,062 S\I,I14 S9.7I8 10.S9 12.12 IS.47

22 20 + Varllblo-Speod Rccip-Comp......"Syllan 18.24 10.01 SI,744.04 SS9UI S1030.27 SI23.47 SSnS.4S 1002 S.6tl1 $644 8,.56 SI2,941 SI2.034 SI0.677 16.S4 18.93 24.17

23 10 + Twc>-Speod ScroU,C""'l"""'or SyaUIn 18.48 10.19 $1,644.04 $49l.S1 SI030.17 S\l9.10 SSS06.08 1976 S,.5OO 8634 7.37 SI2,SS2 Sl1,661 SIO,326 14.84 16.99 21.69

14 20 +V.rl.blo-Soecd ScroU.cam-Or Sl'Item 1O.S3 11.01 SI,794.04 8641,.51 S1030.27 SI2S.66 SS910.14 17S3 3,089 S380 7.36 S12,338 S11,.543 S10,321 IS.oo 17.18 21.93

AMumotiOQl'

1 E1ectrici,y _t _ 0.08S S"'Wb (.....'" OOCI in 1999 obWnod fram an intO%poll1ian ohhe I99S and 2000 pri_ 01 electrici,y larecu, in DOE'. Annuli En.'IY o..uooll: 1993. infl.ted

to 1m dollan). The inlapo..ted value lor 1999 ia 0.082 Sl<Wh (I99IS) orO.OIS Iftor .djustina lor inllation fran 1991 to 1992. Th. electricity price a\duse raClOl' r",CAC is 1.0 (no adjustment).

2 lifetim. - IS y..... Mukup f.CIor -1.65.

3 Baseline unit Inclulla:

Indoor Coil: 30SS Ill.!\., 13linoMc11, WIVY Fina, 311lbe roW', Groov. Tuba

o..tdoor Coil: 1S.OO Ill.!\., 20 linaIInch, SUI FUll, 1tube row. SmOOlh Tuba

ComPl<llOr. Rec:iprocItina, 10.80 EER (nornin&1): ACX'\II11wllor

Indoor FlO Motor. PSt, S8.S" efficienl .

Ou,door Fan Motor: psc. SS.OCJb efficient

EnhIllCCrrlQ1I0..0-: Ncno

4 AU Twc>-Speod and Vuiablo-Speod CompniIaorS)'IlI:rOI includ. an ACCWllIl"IOI'.

5 Muim\ll11 SaWbie Heel Itotio - 760S..

6 Nan·Blced Thcml....tic I!lp....... Vol...rq>iI<c the nood lor. Time Delay Rol.y and an Acx:wnw.tor.

7 EVlpontor ECM FlO Mol.or ill modulated. Ccold Ian mocor inoludca clecIronic moduIotina _troll.

8 Condcnaor ECM Fill Motor ia NIl II • ainal.'pocd.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

Lire Cyde Costs and Payback Periods or 3-toa, Spill System Central Hut Pump 

iDa. InoWIod Annual Elec UIC Annual Cumul. llfccyd. C .. II 

SEER HSPI' Manuf'r Mmuf'r lnJt&ll.tian Ma1nunancc ClOnI"umc:r Coolina Hulin, En."y Payback 

U:.o DeoiIJI Opdon COIl c..1 Coo C- -. COOl """od (1992$) 

BIUh/W BtuhfN (1992S) (1992.S) (1992.S) (1992S) (l992$) kWh/yr kWh/yr (1992.S) (yun) 4% ~ 

0 n"eIine 10.00 6.19 S677.00 S902.53 $46.69 $1743.27 3651 8,132 $999 NA SI3,848 SI2,444 

1 0+ B.c:itwanl Incllncd InclocxBlower 10.30 7.00 $677.00 $0.00 $902.53 S46.69 $1743.27 3544 8.011 $979 0.00 SI3,633 SI2,2S6 

1 I + Indo..- Coil SUI Fino 10.43 7.11 S677.03 SO.03 S902.53 $46.69 $1743.35 3500 7,889 $965 0.00 11).476 SI2,119 

3 2. Inauaclndoot Coil fin Ocnoi'y 10 14 fpi 10,47 7.1l $677.69 SO.66 1902.53 $46.69 $1745.10 3486 7.858 S962 O.OS 11 3.435 SI2,On 

4 3 + 1010 ... I!fficicn,lnd_ PSC Fan 101""" (68.5%) 10.72 7.21 S684.19 17.20 $902.53 $39.01 $1756.57 3406 7.76tJ S946 0.25 $13.279 SII.941 

5 4 + 101 .... Efficien' o..tdoor PSC F." Motor (65.0'T0 10.13 7.32 S691.19 S6.30 S902.53 $31.47 $1765.66 3372 7,658 S935 0.35 113.160 SII.845 

6 5 + Tim. Delay Relay 11.17 7.47 S697.69 $6.S0 S902.S3 $31 .47 $1782.88 3268 7,506 1913 0.46 SI2,937 SII,6S2 

7 6 + Reciproeatina Carnpreuor. 11.26 EER 11.69 7.68 $708.61 $10.99 $902.S3 $31.47 $1112.00 312.5 7.295 S883 0.S9 S12.632 SII ,390 

8 7 + Increaaclndoot Coil F.ee Area 10 4.97 aq.fl. 12.41 7.97 Sn2.0S S13.37 $912.27 $31.47 S21S1.17 2941 7,037 $846 0.74 S12.261 SII,071 

9 8 + Demand Defroct 12.41 8.20 S733.5S $II.SO S912.27 $31.47 $1117.65 2941 6,832 S828 0.85 SI2,098 S10.933 

10 9 + Outdoor Coil Grooved Tuboo 12.13 1.24 S740.52 S6.97 S912.27 $31 .47 $1906.12 2869 6,803 S120 0.91 S12.021 $10,168 

II 10 + Inc:rea •• Inclocx Coil Fa ... Aru 10 6.39 aq.l\. 13.12 8.40 S755.6tJ 115.01 1922.01 $31.47 S2955.82 2182 6,674 1802 1.08 SII.868 SIO,741 

12 11 • scroU Compreuor. 11.50 EER 13.70 8.50 1n4.51 SII.91 S922.01 $31.41 $3006.12 2665 6,591 $785 1.23 SII,129 110,626 

i3 11 + Non·Bleed Thorm ... llio Bapllllion Val •• 14.04 1.73 $717.03 S12.45 S922.01 $31.47 $3039.11 2600 6.422 $765 1.26 111,541 110.466 

14 13 + Inmuo Outd_CoiI F ... Area 1021.00 "1./\ 14.71 9.06 $11\.19 S24.16 $962.27 $31.47 $3145.2.S 2411 6.184 1734 1.52 111,302 110,270 

15 14 + lncroaa.lnclocx Coil F ... Aru \0 7.SO aq.l\. 15.00 9.13 1122.19 110.30 S969.8I $31.47 $3110.16 2434 6.139 $721 1.61 SII,259 SIO.2)1 

16 IS + In .... ,. indO« CoiI1Ube Dona'y to 4 roWl 15.12 9.20 1844.58 $22.39 $969.88 $31.47 $3239.49 2416 6,092 $721 1.79 $11,257 S10,243 

17 16 • lncroa,. Outdoor Coil F ... Ala 1030.00 aq./\ 15.41 9.32 $890.19 $45.61 S1030.27 $31.47 $3420.75 2359 6.018 $710 2.35 SII,314 110,316 

\8 17 • Outdoor ECM Fan Molar 15.59 9.45 1962.19 $72.70 $1030.27 $39.01 $3621.01 2343 5,935 $702 2.9S SII,422 110.435 

19 II. El<ClTOnic Eapa.naiCll Val .. IS.79 9.50 $1.011.23 $48.34 S1030.27 $41.06 $3158.09 2313 5.904 1696 3.36 $11,502 $10,522 

20 19 + Indoor ECM Fan Molar 16.36 9.S6 $I,152.S3 SI41.30 S1030.27 $63.61 $4148.16 2232 5.865 1686 4.SO SII,779 S10.814 

21 20. Two-Spood Rcci~Carnprmaor Systan 17.90 9.6tJ $1,332.79 $\80.26 S1030.27 $77.62 $4639.79 2040 5.837 S668 5.73 SI 2.062 111 ,1 24 

22 20. Vaa.bl~Spood bci~ ... aorSyAan 11.24 10.01 SI.744.04 SS91.51 S1030.27 SI23.47 SSnS.45 2002 5,601 S644 1.56 $12,941 SI2.034 

23 20 + Two-Spood SaoU·Compraaor Sysum 11.41 10.19 $1,644.04 $491.51 SI030.27 SII9.10 SSS06.01 1976 S,500 S634 7.57 SI2.SS2 SII,661 

24 20 + V.d,bINpood SaoU-CCIl1pruoOr S)'I1an 20.13 11.01 $1,794.04 S641.S1 S1030.27 SI2.5.66 SS910.14 17S3 5,019 S580 7.56 $12,358 SII,543 

AuumptiOQl' 

I EI"";ci,y call. 0.085 S/I<Wb ( ...... '6 .... 10 1999 obWned fram an im<:rpolatiCll of~ 1995 and 2000 pri_ of oloctricilY fon:c:u, in DOE', Annual EnclJY Ou~ook 1993. inflated 

to 1992 dollan). Tho inIapol.alOd .alue for 1999 is 0.012 S/&Wb (1991 $) or 0.085 . ftcudjllltina for inOation frmt 199110 1992. The cJ"";ci'yprice enduse f.ctor ('" CAC is 1.0 (no .djllllmen'). 

2 Llfetim •• 15 yean. Mukup factor. 2.65. 

3 Buclln. unl,lncluda: 

Indoor COO: 3.55 aq.l\., 13 finoMcIt. W.vy Fino, 3 rube roW" Groov. Tuba 

Outdoor Coil: 15.00 aq.l\., 20 IirlIMcIt. SU, run. I ,ube "'w, Smooth Tuba 

ComPl<lIOr. Reciprocatin" 10.10 EER (naminal): Ac:cumulator 

Indoor Fan Motor. psc, 51.S!\. efficient . 

Ou,cIocx Fan Motor: PSC, SS.O'To elficien' 

Enh""""""" DcvU:ca: N .... 

4 AU Two-Spood and Variablo-Spood Comprooaor S)'IlaIU includ • ." Accwnul.ata. 

5 MuimlDll Senlibl. ROI' Ratio • 76.5!\. 

6 Nm·Blecd Theun,,"ti< Eaplllliat Val •• rq>Iaoe the nocd fer a Time Delay Relay and an Accumulator. 

7 EYlp<ntar ECM FlO Motor iI modulalOd. COIl d. fan motor includ .. dcctronic rnoduIatina c:cntroIt. 

CondCNQ' ECM Fill Motor is NIl ., • ainale 'pocd. 

10'To 

S10,34O 

SIO,I93 

110.085 

S10.05K 

19.955 

S9.876 

S9,729 

$9,530 

19.290 

19,181 

S9.142 

S9,OS2 

SI.974 

SI,855 

SI,725 

S8,701 

S8.724 

S8,121 

S8 ,9S8 

$9.0S5 

S9,368 

$9.718 

SIO,6n 

110,326 

$1 0,321 

Cllrnulati ... 

C-.fConlctvcd Enetu 

(c:mUlkWh) 

4% 6'To 10'To 

NA NA NA 

0.00 0.00 0.00 

0.00 0,01 0.01 

0.10 0.1t 0.15 

0.49 0.56 0.71 

0.12 0.12 I.OS 

0.93 1.06 1.36 

1.17 1.34 1.12 

1.44 1.65 2.11 

1.13 2.09 2.61 

1.11 2.14 2.14 

2.20 2.S2 3.22 

2.40 2.14 3.50 

2.53 2.90 3.70 

3.06 3.51 4.41 

3.23 3.70 4.12 

3.61 4.13 5.28 

4.71 5.40 6.89 

6.03 6.91 8.82 

6.12 7.11 9.97 

8.91 10.19 13.02 

10.59 12.12 15.47 

16.54 11.93 24.17 

14.84 16.99 21.69 

1S.00 17.18 21.93 
$12,500...... 0

$12,000

-.. $11,500

N

0'1

0'1

...

'-'

...:l $11,000

$10,500

9/17/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Split System

Central Heat Pump

1--0- 6% discount rate I

15

$10,000

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0

SEER

17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$12,500 0 

$12,000 

~ $11,500 

N 

0\ 

0\ 

~ 

'-' 

u 

U 

....J $11,000 

$10,500 

$10,000 

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 

9/17/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3·ton Split System 

Central Heat Pump 

I ~ 6% discount rate I 

13.0 14.0 

15 

15.0 

SEER 

16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0 
9/17/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Split System

Central Heat Pump

21.0

••

_-6

20.0

--

19.0

••

18.0

..

.

17.0

. .. .

.,l:.;.:.----

N "

.. - .. '- .....

14.0 15.0 16.0

SEER

- -- -.- - -- 10% discount rate

---D-- 4% discount rate

- - i:! - - 6% discount rate

13.0

••

..... ,-. ---.,

12.0

.... '.,

11.0

'. '.

•

•

"

/ /

"

/ /

/ /

"

"- / / / / -- '.u.'~ / // / __-..1'--

u.... /. / __-- " .• / tx~ /

't,...-n AI:!>

't::.._ -A ..... -c:,-t::IY

10.0

$14,000

$13,500

$13,000

$12,500

$12,000

,-,

(,h

$11,500

...... '"

t$ $11,000

..J

$10,500

$10,000

$9,500

$9,000

$8,500

9.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$14,000 

$13,500 

$13,000 

$12,500 

$12,000 

.-. 

~ 

~ $11,500 

0\ 

.-4 

'-' 

U $11,000 U 

...J 

$10,500 

• 

$10,000 

'. ~ ' . 

• 

'. , $9,500 

$9,000 

$8,500 

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 

9/17/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3·too Split System 

Central Heat Pump 

---D-- 4% discount rate 

' . 

. ,. 

, '. ' 

13.0 

- - -6 - - 6% discount rate 

----. ---- 10% discount rate 

, , ., ' ,* .. , . " ..... -. 

14.0 15.0 16.0 

SEER 

, -

17.0 

-- --

,. 

,+ -. .'. 

18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0 
Ure Cycle COIb and Payback Periodl of Solon, Spill System CtlltraJ Heal Pump

1//29/1/3

Ina. lnoullod Amual EI<c Uoe Amual c.m.u1. UlCC)<leC_ Cumulati..

SEER IlSPF M&nuf'r Mll1ufr IN..n.ti<l1 Mainterwlce CoaIuma CooIinI Heatina Encqy p,yb.clt CM atCoaIClVcd Encqy

Level Decian Cpti<l1 COI\ COlt CM CM COI\ COlt Paiod (1991$) (=UIltWh)

BIWv'I1I BtuhIW (1992$) (1991$) (1991$) (1991$) (1992$) kWhlvr ItWhlYr (1991$) (vears) 4'11> 6'11> 10'11> 4'11> 6'11> 10'11>

0 Bueline 10.00 1JIJ S934.OO . SI161.S4 $46.69 S3954.19 5798 13,556 SI,640 NA $12.193 SI9.886 S16.431 NA NA NA

I o• B.cItwanllnc1Jned Indoor Blower 10.30 7.21 S934.03 SO.03 S1161.54 $46.69 S3954.28 5629 \3,328 SI.607 0.00 $21.120 S19,56O S16.176 0.00 0.01 O.ot

2 1• Indoor Coil Slit Fin, 10.38 7.27 S934.25 SO.22 S1161.54 $46.69 $3954.93 5514 13,211 SI,593 0.02 $21,667 S19.427 SI6.072 0.03 0.04 0.05

3 2. Tune Delay Relay 10.68 7.40 S94O.75 S6.50 S1161.54 $46.69 S3974.04 5429 12.981 SI.560 0.25 $21.323 S19,I29 S15.142 O.~ 0.55 0.71

4 3 • Sc:n>ll Comprcuor. 11.30 EER 12.30 7.80 S96S.13 S24.38 S1161.54 $46.69 S404S.71 4715 12,320 SI.444 0.47 $20,100 SI8,069 S15,028 0.76 0.87 1.11

5 4 • M<m Effieicnl Outdoor PSC Fan Mooor (65.0'11> 12.42 7.89 S971.43 S6.30 S1161.54 $39.01 $4056.62 4666 12.176 SI.428 0.48 SI9,929 S17,922 S14,915 0.8\ 0.93 1.19

6 5 • Inoreue Indoor Coil Fin DonIity 10 14 (pI 12.46 7.93 S973.16 SI.73 S1161.54 $39.01 S4061.71 4653 12.117 S1,421 0.49 S19,865 SI7.866 SI4,873 0.14 0.97 1.23

7 6. Mo~ Elfieicnllndoor PSC Fan MOIllr (68.5'11» 12.81 8.04 $912.92 S9.76 SI161.S4 $3\.47 $4012.10 4525 11,946 SI.396 0.53 SI9.60S SI7.642 S14,702 0.91 1.04 1.33

1 7 • Demand DehooI \2.8\ 8.29 S994.42 Sl1.50 S1161.S4 $3\.47 $4116.61 4525 11,598 SI,367 0.59 SI9,311 S17,389 S14,511 1.15 1.31 1.68

9 8. Non·Bleed 'I'henDoNlic ElpIIlIi<l1 VaI_ 13.13 8.53 SI.016.0I S21.66 S1161.54 $31.47 84110.29 4415 11,266 SI.329 0.73 SII,958 S17.089 S14,290 1.47 1.68 2.IS

10 9 +InauoeIndoor CoilF_AIa 107.50 "l.ft. 13.5\ 8.63 SI.033.92 S17.14 SII71.83 $31.47 84243.03 4292 11,137 SI,308 0.87 SII,783 SI6.944 S14.190 1.73 1.97 2..52

11 10. Outdoor Coil Oroovod Tubat 13.71 8.66 SI,048.28 S14.36 SII71.83 $3\.47 8428S.2$ 4229 11,102 SI,299 0.97 SII.733 S16.906 SI4.169 1.90 2.17 2.71

12 11 .1nc:reaJe Outdoor Coil F....Ala 10 27.30 "In 14.17 8.89 SI,I06.4O S58.12 S1224.17 $31.47 84501.46 4093 10,807 SI,263 1.47 SII.5SO SI6.774 $14.114 2.92 3.35 4.27

13 12. Eloctronic Illpanoim Valve 14.37 8.94 SI.154.74 S~.34 SI224.17 $40.45 $4659.56 4036 10.747 SI.2$3 1.82 SII.591 S16.829 SI4.190 3.60 4.12 5.26

14 13 + 0Jul00r t!CM Fan Mooor 14.44 9.OS SI,227.44 S72.70 SI224.17 $48.06 84830.91 4014 10.616 SI,240 2.31 SII.668 SI6.925 S14,313 4.67 5.3S 6.83

15 14 .1nc:reaJ. OuId_Coil F.... Ala 1036.$0 "l.l\ 14,63 9.13 SI,29S.30 S67.86 S1215.90 841.06 S5142.IS 3963 10.527 SI,221 2.88 SII,797 S17.070 S14,484 S.82 6.67 8.51

16 15 +Indoor ECM Fan MOlOr IS.35 9.22 SI.47S.S5 SIIO.25 SI28S.90 $63.68 S5687.71 3778 10.419 SI,203 3.97 SI9,066 SI7,374 S14,840 7.72 8.84 11.28

17 16 + Tw~Speed Rceip-Compnuor SytlCm 16.98 9.23 SI.664.30 S188.7S S128S.90 S80.83 S62$9.78 3415 10,409 Sl,172 4.92 S19,287 S17.639 SI5,I71 1.70 9.96 12.72

18 16 + Vciablo-Speed Roeip-CompN_ S)WIn 17.\6 9.78 $2.075.5S S6OO.oo S1285.90 SI33.11 S7521.14 3378 9.831 SI,I20 6.8S S19,969 SI8.394 S16,037 13.26 IS.II 19.38

19 16. Tw~SpeedScrolI·CompN_ SfIICm 17.30 10.02 SI.975.55 SSOO.OO S1285.90 S128.74 S7222.77 3352 9,586 SI,097 6.01 S19.41$ SI7.873 SI5.564 12.02 13.76 17.57

20 16 • Vci.blo-Soood Scroll·Corn_or SVOlOnl 19.16 10.3\ $2.125.5S $6$0.00 S1285.90 S135.29 S7670.32 3026 9.322 SI.047 6.26 S19,306 SI7.835 S15,631 12.06 13.10 17.62

Awmptiquo

1 E\oclricity COlt. 0.015 SAtWb (a....... COlt in imol>Wncd from an interpolati<l1 oC the 1995 and 2000 pri.... of e1oct:icity Corocall in DOll.. Annual Encqy OulIooit 1993. inIl.<cd

10 1992 dol1an). Th. inlcrpol.olOd vaIuo Cor 1999 it 0.082 SAtWh (199\$) or 0.085 oCtcr .djuatina C... inllotion from 199110 1992. The e1octriei.y pri... aMIuoe Cacto< Cor CAC ",1.0 (no .djumnent).

2 Lifetime. IS y..... Mad:up Cactor· 2.94.

3 Buelinouni.includa:

Indoor Coil: 6.00 aq.fl. 13 fino/inch, Wavy Fino. 4 tube ro Groove Tuboa

OuldoorCoil: 19.5 "l.ft., 2OfinaMdI. SU,FinJ, 2 tube ro Smooth l\oboa

Ccmprcaaor: Rceiprocatina, 10.49 EER (nominal): AccumulalOr

Indoor Fan MOIOr: PSC, 58.5~ eftiei..,.

Ouldoor Fan Mocor: PSC. 55.0'11> effici"'t

EnhlJlCl:lT1onl Devicoo: None

4 Ma.unum Sauiblo Heal Ratio • 76.5~

Non-Bleed Tham.....tic EIjlO!l"i<l1 VaI_ repl.... the need C... aTime Delay Relay; Ac:cumullt... otill ""Iuircd due 10 ...... rdri.cnnc

6 E••pen... ECM Fm Mooor 11 moclutllod. COI\ oC Can mo<or inclod.. e10ctr0nic moduJatina controllo.

7 C<I1dema ECM Fan MOl« it Nr1 at a oinaJe .pood.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

Ufe Cycle CO!b and PaybKk Periodl 01 S-tOll. Spill System C ... traJ Heal Pump 

Ina. lmWkd AmU&! EI<c U .. AmU&! Cumul. lliecyclc C_ 

SEER HSPF ManW'r Mlllufr InaWiatian M&intenance CoNuma Coolin, Heatina £nalY Payb.dt 

Leyel DeCIJI Option COlI Coot COCI COCI COlI COl' Pericd (1992.$) 

BtuhII1I BtuhIW (l992S) (1992.$) (1992.$) (1992.$) (I992$) kWh/Y1' kWh/yr (1992.$) (years) 4~ 6~ 

0 Bueline 10.00 1.09 S934.00 . S1161.54 $46.69 S39S4.19 5198 13,556 SI,640 NA S22.1 93 SI9.886 

I 0+ B.dtwud Inclined Indoor Blower 10.30 7.21 S934.03 SO.03 S1161.54 $46.69 S39S4.28 5629 13,328 SI,607 0.00 $21 ,820 S19,56O 

2 I + Ind_ Coil Slit PUu 10.31 7.21 $934.25 SO.22 S1161.54 $46.69 $39S4.93 SSI4 13,211 SI,593 0.02 $21 ,667 S19,421 

3 2 + Tun. Delay Relay 10.61 7.40 S94O.7S S6.50 SI161.54 $46.69 53914.04 S429 12,981 51,560 0.25 $21 ,323 S19,129 

4 3 + Scroll Camprcuor. 11.30 EER 12.30 7.80 S965.13 S24.38 S1161.54 $46.69 $404S.71 4715 12,320 SI,_ 0.47 $20,100 SI8,069 

5 4 + M<m Efficienl Outdoor PSC Fan Mooor (65.()<jI, 12.42 7.89 5971.43 S6.30 SI161.54 $39.01 $4OS6.62 4666 12,176 SI,428 0.48 SI9,929 S1 7,922 

6 S + InClUje Indoor Coil Fin DoNity \0 14 tpi 12.46 7.93 5973.16 SI.13 SI161.54 $39.01 S4061.11 4653 12,117 51,421 0.49 S19,865 SI1,I66 

7 6 + More Elficienllndoor PSC Fan Motor (6I.5~) 12.11 1.04 S912.92 S9.76 SI161.S4 $31.47 $4082.10 4525 11,946 SI,396 0.53 S19,605 S17,642 

8 7 + Demand DehoII 12.81 3.29 S994.42 S11050 SI161.S4 $31.41 $4116,61 4525 11,598 SI,361 0.59 SI9,311 S17,389 

9 8 + Non·Bleed n.ar-..tie l!IJ>IIIIIon VaI_ 13.13 1.53 SI ,01 6.01 $21.66 S1I61.54 $31.47 $4180.29 44IS 11.266 SI,329 0.73 SII,958 S17,089 

10 9 + Inau .. lndoor Coil Faco A:oo \0 7.50 oq.1l 13.s1 8.63 SI,033.92 SI1.14 SII7I.83 $31.47 $4243.03 4292 11 ,137 SI,308 0.87 SU,783 S16,944 

11 10+ Outdoor Coil Clroovod Tuba 13.71 8.66 SI ,048.28 S14.36 S1I71.83 $31.47 $428S,25 4229 11,102 SI.299 0.97 SII,733 SI6,906 

12 II + lncruJ. 0u1d00r Coil Fa .. A:oo \0 27.30 "11\ 14.17 8.89 SI,I06.4O S58.12 51224.1 7 $31.47 $4501.46 4093 10,807 SI,263 1.47 SII,55O S16,774 

13 12 + EIO<IJonio I!lpanoion Val •• 14.37 8.94 SI ,I54.74 S48.34 SI224.17 $4O.4S $46S9.56 4036 10,747 SI,253 1.82 SII,591 S16,829 

14 13 + Outdoor I!CM Fill Motor 14.44 9.05 SI,227.44 S72.70 SI224.17 $48.06 $4"0.91 4014 10,616 SI.240 2.31 SII,66I S16,925 

15 14+ 1ncruI. Outd_CoilF ... A:oo \036.50"1.1\ 14.63 9.13 SI.29BO S67.86 S12IS.90 $41.06 S5142.15 3963 10,527 SI,228 2.88 SI8,797 S17,070 

16 15 + Indoor I!CM Pili Motor IS.3S 9.22 SI,475.5S SIIO.25 51285.90 $63.61 SS687.71 3778 10,419 SI,203 3.97 S19,066 S17,374 

17 16 + T_Specd Rodp-Compreooor SyslCm 16.91 9.23 51,664.30 5188.75 S128S.90 S80.83 S6259,78 34IS 10,409 51,172 4.92 S19.287 SI7,639 

II 16 + Vari.blo-Specd Roc:ip-Comp ....... SytlCm 17.16 9,78 $2,07S.5S $600.00 S1285.90 S133.1I S7521.14 3378 9,831 S1,I20 6.85 S19,969 SI8,394 

19 16 + Twc>Specd ScroIl·Camp ....... Syolan 17.30 10.02 SI,975.5S 5500.00 51285.90 S128.74 S7222.77 3352 9,586 SI,097 6.01 SI9,41S 517,873 

20 16 + Variablo-Spccd Scroll·Cam..-or Sy...." 19.16 10.31 $2,I25.5S $650.00 SI285.90 5135.29 S7670.32 3026 9,322 SI ,047 6.26 S19,306 S11,83S 

A$SUmpliW" 

t E1ccuidty -.. O.OIS SAtWb ( ........ -.In 1999 obIaincd from an interpol.tion of the I99S ond 2000 pricoo of elcct:icity f"",,,1ft in DOE'. Annual En ... y OWooit 1993, influed 

to 1992dollo.n). Theimcrpolatcd ...... far 1999 io 0.082 SikWl! (1991$) orO.08S UIU . djuotin& Cor inflation from 1991 \0 1992. The: elcclricilypric:c cnduoe f. etor CarCAC io 1.0 (no . djumncnt). 

2 Lifetime. IS yun. Mo!!t:up raotor · 2.94. 

3 Buelincunit Includa: 

Indoor Coil: 6.00 .q.fl., 13 finoMch, W.vy Fino, 4ll1be rewa, Groove Tubea 

Outdoor Coil: 19.5 oq.Il, 20 fiMMdt, SUt PUu, 2 wb. rewo, Smooth l'ubea 

Ccmprcuor. Roc:iprocatlna,l0.49 EER (nominal); Accumulator 

Indoor Fan Mour. PSC, Slo5~ efficient 

Outdoor Fon Mocor. PSC, SS.O'lI. offici"" 

EManccmatl Do:vics: None 

C Maximum Sauible Heat Rono • 76.5 .. 

Non· Bleed Thcrm .... tic Expanoion Val_ "",1000 the Deed for. Time Delay Relay; Accumulotor otiIl ""Iuircd due \0 ...... tdo8crutL 

6 I!Y.pontor ECM Fill MOlOr II modulatcd. COlI of ran.-or includea electronic modulotinl control.. 

I~ 

S16,431 

S16. 176 

SI6,072 

S15,842 

S15,028 

514,915 

SI4,873 

S14,702 

S14,511 

S14,290 

SI4,I90 

S14,169 

514,114 

SI4,I9O 

SI4,313 

SI4,414 

SI4,140 

SI5,I7I 

S16,037 

S15,S64 

S15,631 

CumWan .. 

COCI m CoNcrvcd En"'lY 

(ccnulkWl!) 

4~ 6~ 10'It 

NA NA NA 

0.00 0.01 O.ot 

0.03 0.04 0.05 

0.48 0.55 0.71 

0.76 0.87 1.11 

0.81 0.93 1.19 

0.14 0.97 1.23 

0.91 1.04 1.33 

1.15 1.31 1.68 

1.47 1.61 2. IS 

1.73 1.97 2.52 

1.90 2.17 2.78 

2.92 3.35 4.27 

3.60 4.12 5.26 

4.67 5.35 6.83 

S.82 6.67 I.SI 

7.72 8.14 11.21 

8.70 9.96 12.72 

13 .26 IS.II 19.31 

12.02 13.76 17.57 

12.06 13.10 11.62 
9/29193

Life Cycle Cost for 5-ton Split System

Central Heat Pump

20

I • 6% discount rate I

o

$17,500

$17,000

$19.000

$19,500

$20,000

u

$18,000

$18,500

....

'-'

12

$16,500

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0

SEER

16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$20,000 0 

$19,500 

$19,000 

~ $18,500 

0'1 

~ '-' 

u 

~ $18,000 

$17,500 

$17,000 

$16,500 

9.0 10.0 11.0 

9/29/93 

Life Cycle Cost for S-ton Split System 

Central Heat Pump 

- ... - 6% discount rate I 

8 

12 

12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 

SEER 

20 

18.0 19.0 20.0 
9/29/93

Life Cycle Cost for S·ton Split System

Central Heat Pump

19.0 20.0

-_.- ..-...•

18.0

- - &. - - 6% discount rate

17.0

.. - -.- ... 10% discount rate

-a-- 4% discount rate

14.0 15.0 16'.0

SEER

•

.•. ~;~~:;~:::~~~~~.

13.0

'., * .............. '.,

11.0 12.0

'.

.,

'.,

A.

~,6 ...... ...... ......

............ - /6 ...... /

...... /

'n.. // __ 6 _----I::.

/ -- --- l / -::.~~--...;- -- 1"w' .- .-

'b.-~~_n?

.,

10.0

$22,500

$21,500

$20,500

$19,500

- $18,500

c:I'I

""" '-"

U

U $17,500 ~.

$16,500

$-15,500

$14,500

$13,500

9.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$22,500 

$21,500 

$20,500 

$19,500 

~ $18,500 

c::I'I 

.-c 

'-' 

U U $-17,500 ~ -

$16,500 + , 

'+ +, 

'., $-15,500 

$14,500 

$13,500 

9.0 10.0 11.0 

9/29/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 5·too Split System 

Central Heat Pump 

'. 

, 

12.0 

'. 

., ~ 

'.* 

--.,. -- ... + 

13,0 14.0 15.0 

SEER 

-a- 4% discount rate 

- - 6. - - 6% discount rate 

- - - -+- - - - 10% discount rate 

• 

- + - - - -+ --- ---

17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 
Llfc Cyclc Costs llI>d Payback Pcrlodl 013·100, S1D1lc Pack,,&c Sy$icm CCDtral Air Cooditloocr

a/ze/D3

Ina. InslAlIed Ann.ul Annual Cumul ur""ycl. Coou Cumullllve

SEER MooIII'r Moour, 1ft&IaIlIlloo MliaIeowlc:cCOIlIUIIle Eloc. E.oqy Payback Coot oC Consavcd EDergy

Leve Deo1pOpdoa Coo. Coo. Cool Coot Coot use COCI Poriod (1992$) (ecnlSJltWb)

BbJIJ/W (\992$) (1992$) (1992$) (\ 992$) (\992$) kWblYl' (\992$) (y..,.) 4~ 6~ 10~ 4~ 6~ 10~

0 BueliDo 9.10 $414.00 . $1968.31 $46.69 $2953.58 3533 $299 NA $6,283 SS.862 $5,231 NA NA NA

1 0+ Bact...ord 1Dc:1Inod 1Ddoor BIo..... 9.91 $414.04 $0.04 $1968.31 $46.69 $2953.66 3440 $292 0.01 $6.196 $5.186 S5,112 0.01 0.01 0.01

2 1+ Evopon... Sill ADo 10.09 $414.13 $0.09 $1968.31 $46.69 $2953.84 3399 $288 0.02 $6.151 SS,152 SS,14S 0.02 0.02 0.03

3 2 + Reciprocl1llla Compnaor: 10.91 HER 11.00 $48l.S1 $1.38 $1968.31 $46.69 $2968.45 3118 $264 0.42 SS.901 S5,S35 $4,919 0.32 0.31 0.41

4 3 + Men Ell"lCllllt eoo-er PSC Pill Mocor (6S.~) 11.12 $486.46 $4.95 $1968.31 $39.08 $2910.64 3083 $261 0.45 S5,816 S5,S08 54.958 0.34 0.39 0.50

5 4 + Men ElIlcllllt EvoponlOr PSC Pill Mocor (68.S~ 11.38 5493.68 $1.22 $1968.31 $31.41 $2911.33 3013 S2S5 0.54 SS,816 S5,451 54.919 0.41 0.41 0.60

6 5+T'lDle Delay Relay 11.81 $SOO.18 $6.50 SI968.31 S31.41 S299O.20 2902 $246 0.68 S5,125 SS.380 54.861 0.52 0.60 0.16

1 6 + Cond<mc:r Oroovod tIIboo 12.25 S506.13 SS.95 SI968.31 $31.41 $3001.98 2800 $231 0.18 S5,641 SS,307 54.807 0.59 0.68 0.81

8 1 + lDacue EyaponlDt PlD 0-11110 14 (pI 12.30 S506.88 $0.15 SI968.31 $31.41 $3003.46 2188 $236 0.19 $5,631 SS,298 54,801 0.60 0.69 0.88

9 8+Scroll Compaaor. 11.50 EER I Noo·Blood TXV 13.11 $543.29 $36.41 SI968.31 $31.41 $3075.55 2616 $222 1.51 SS,541 SS,229 $4,162 1.20 1.31 1.1S

10 9 + 1DauIe EyaponlDt Ftco Ateo 10 6.60 ....n. 13.91 $565.51 $22.22 S1985.35 $31.41 S3136.53 2455 $208 2.00 SS,450 S5,151 54,119 1.53 1.15 2.23

11 10 + InacueC_Pial Area 10 18.03 .... n. 14.14 SS86.24 $20.13 $2019.91 $31.41 $3212.14 2321 SI91 2.53 S5,40S $5.128 54,112 1.93 2.21 2.82

12 11 + 1DauIe EYlponl« Pial Area 10 1.50 ....n. 14.91 S594.35 $8.11 $2026.08 $31.41 $3234.36 2299 S195 2.68 SS,401 $S,I21 $4,111 2.05 2.34 2.99

13 12 + 1DauIe CoodeDI.. Flal Area 10 28.33 .... n. 15.35 $635.95 $41.60 S2095.19 $31.41 $3385.84 2234 S189 3.93 S5.492 S5,22S $4,826 2.99 3.43 4.38

14 13 + Evopon... ECM Fill Mo... 15.91 S111.26 S141.31 $2095.19 $41.09 S3681.25 2155 S183 6.23 SS,112 S5.4S6 SS.071 4.15 5.44 6.94

15 14 + E1CCl101llc Eoponsloo Vllve 16.10 S853.43 $16.11 S2095.19 SS6.07 S3841.05 2129 S180 1.46 S5,848 SS,S94 $5,214 5.69 6.51 8.31

16 IS + Condmler ECM Fill MOIOr 16.25 S919.98 $66.55 $2095.19 $63.68 S3980.43 2109 S119 8.51 $5,968 S5,111 S5,340 6.49 7.43 9.48

11 16 + T...o-Speed Reclp-CCJIDlI"O&IO< SJ1IaD 11.66 SI.100.61 $180.69 $2095.19 $16.66 $4351.18 1942 SI65 10.36 $6.181 S5.9SO S5,603 1.90 9.04 1l.S4

18 16 + VIriabI",S~ Roclp-Compnaor SYI_ 18.03 SI.511.92 $591.94 $2095.19 SI20.59 SS209.38 1902 S161 16.31 $1.002 $6,115 $6,436 12.44 14.24 18.18

19 16 + Two-Speed Scroo.QlmproolOr Syolml 18.35 $1,411.92 $491.94 $2095.19 $116.22 S5007.ol 1869 S158 14.56 $6.768 $6,546 $6,212 11.10 12.10 16.22

20 16 + Voriobl",SDeod ScroD-Com_1OrS_ 20.55 $1.561.92 $641.94 $2095.19 SI22.18 S5310.51 1668 Sl41 14.91 $6,883 $6.684 $6,386 11.31 13.01 16.62

Auumpdoot·

1 ElecIrici.y COIl- O.085"Wh (lV....e _lID 1999 oblaiDod from III inlap01.Il1oo oC lbe 1995 and 2000 prica oC electricity COftlCu.ln DOE'I Annual EDergy OuOook 1993, lnlla~

10 1992 doolll). The IDIlIpOIo~ vl1ue Cor 1999 iJ 0.082 SJltWb (l99IS) or 0.085 &Iler IdJustiD8 Cor InIlation &om 1991 10 1992. The el""aicily priecenduse CICIOI' Cor CAC is 1.0 (no IdJUSlm<nI).

2 uretime. 15 y.... Mortup C&CIOr - 1.98.

3 Buellne unillncludel:

Eyopar : 4.13 Iq.n., 13 CinJI\Dcll. W.vy rial, 3 Nbe rows, Groove TubeJ

Condens : 12.88 Iq.n.. 20 Cino~. SUI FiDJ, 1 lUbe ro.... Smooth TubeJ

Compralor. Reclprocadoa. 10.20 EER (oomlnll)

EVoporilor Fill Mocor: psc. 58.5~ .mclal.

Condens... Fan MOlor. PSC. 55.~ eIl"lClall

Enhancemenl Devkel: Noae

4 NOD·Blood ThermoIlIIic Eo~1oo Volve rqJllCCllbe aced Cor I Time DeilY Relay

5 Milimum S-Ibl.Hell RIlio -16.5-.

5 Evoporl'" ECM Pill MOIOr 1l1DOdU101ed. COIl oC CIIl molor iacludeJ e1eclroltic moduIIIln8 conlrols.

7 Condense< ECM Pan Mocor >; ,011I11. liDsle lpeed.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

Lire Cyde Costs aod Paylw:k Perlocb or 3-100, Sloa1e P..:kaae System Ceolral Air Cooditiooer 

Ina. "" ... lIed AnnUAl AnnUAl CUmuL lli~ycl. Coo .. CUmul.uve 

SEER Manlll'r Manu/'r lDSI&II.uoa MolaIawIc:<Coosume Eloc. Eo<ogy Payblcll: COOl of Conserved EDeraY 

Lev. DertpOpdoo Cool Cool Cool COOl COOl use cocl Pmod (1992$) (c:en .. !1tWb) 

BlUhIW (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) kWblyr (1992$) (y .... ) 4~ 6~ 10% 4% 6% 10% 

0 B .. _ 9.70 $474.00 - $1968.37 $46.69 $2953.58 3533 $299 NA $6,283 SS.862 55,231 NA NA NA 

1 0+ BactwonllDc:lIDod IDdoor Blo ...... 9.97 $474.04 SO.04 SI968.37 $46.69 $2953.66 3440 $292 0.01 $6,196 $5,786 SS,I72 0.01 0.01 0.01 

2 1 + I!vlpORlDr Sill FIDo 10.09 $474.13 SO.09 SI968.37 $46.69 $2953.84 3399 $288 0.02 $6,1$1 SS,752 S5,I45 0,02 0.02 O.oJ 

3 2+ ReclprocatiDa Compnuor: 10.91 I!ER 11 .00 $481.51 $7.38 SI968.37 $46.69 $2968.45 3118 $264 0.42 55,907 SS,S35 $4,979 0.32 0.37 0.47 

4 3 + Mort EfflCl .... C..,-... PSC Fill MOlOr (65.~) 11.12 $486.46 $4.95 SI968.37 $39.08 $2970.64 3083 $261 0.45 S5,876 S5.so8 $4,958 0.34 0.39 0.50 

5 4 + Mort I!fflCl .... l!vlpORlDr PSC Fill Mocor (68 5~ 11.38 $493.68 $7.22 51968.37 $31.47 $2977.33 3013 S2S5 0.54 S$,816 55,457 $4,919 0.41 0.47 0.60 

6 5 + 1"un. Oolay Rolay 11.8\ S5OO.18 $6.50 51968.37 531.47 $2990.20 2902 5246 0.68 55,725 55.380 $4,861 0.52 0.60 0.76 

7 6 + Cond<mor Oroovod 'I\>boI 12.25 S506.13 55.95 SI968.37 S31.47 $3001.98 2800 $237 0.78 55,641 55,307 $4,807 0.59 0.68 0.87 

8 7 + IfIcreue l!yoponlDr Fla o-l1y 10 14 1\>1 12.30 S506.88 SO.75 SI968.37 $31.47 $3003.46 2788 $236 0.79 S5,631 SS,298 $4,801 0.60 0.69 0.88 

9 8 + Scrou Compuoor: 11.50 EER I Noa·Bleod TXV 13.11 $543.29 $36.41 SI968.37 $31.47 $3075.55 2616 S222 1.$1 55,341 55.229 $4,762 1.20 1.37 1.75 

10 9+ IfIaoue l!YoponlDrPICeAleo 10 6.6Osq.n. 13.97 S565.51 $22.22 S1985.35 $31.47 53136.53 2455 $208 2.00 55,450 55,1$1 $4,7 19 1.53 1.75 2.23 

11 10 + Incroue c..,-... Pial Azu 10 18.03 "I.n. 14.74 5586.24 $20.73 $2019.91 $31.47 $3212.14 2327 SI97 2.53 S5,405 55,128 $4,712 1.93 2.21 2.82 

12 II + lDcreue Ey.ponI« PICe Azu 10 7.50 "I.n. 14.91 SS94.35 $1.11 S2026.08 $31.47 $3234.36 2299 SI95 2.68 S5,401 S5,127 $4,717 2.0S 2.34 2.99 

13 12 + Increue CoodenI ... FICe Azu to 28.33 "I. n. 15.35 $635.95 $41.60 52095.19 $31.47 $3385.84 2234 5189 3.93 S5,492 S5,225 $4,826 2.99 3.43 4.38 

14 13 + EVlpORlOr OCM Fill MOlDr 15.91 $177.26 SI41.31 S209S.19 547.09 $3681.25 21SS S183 6.23 SS,712 S5,456 $5.071 4.75 5.44 6.94 

IS 14 + ElOClrODlc i!lponsloD Vllve 16.10 5853,43 $76.17 S2095.19 556.07 $3841.05 2129 S\80 7.46 $5,848 55,S94 SS,214 5.69 6.51 8.31 

16 IS + Condenser OCM FAD Mocor 16.25 $919.98 $66.SS $209S.19 $63.68 $3980.43 2109 SI79 8.51 S5,968 $5,717 55,340 6.49 7.43 9.48 

17 16 + Two-Speod Recip-Compraoor S,- 17.66 SI,100.67 $180.69 S2095.19 $76.66 54351.18 1942 $165 10.36 $6.181 S5.950 55,603 7.90 9.04 11.54 

18 16 + Variab1o-Speod Reclf>'Comprou« Sy._ 18.03 $1,511.92 SS91 .94 S2095.19 SI20.59 SS209.38 1m S161 16.31 $7.002 $6,775 $6,436 12.44 14.24 18.18 

19 16 + 'i'wo-Speod ScroU-Compr" .. or Sya_ 18.35 $1,411.92 $491.94 S2095.19 S\l6.22 SSOO7.ot 1869 S158 14.56 $6,768 $6,346 $6,212 11.10 12.70 16.22 

20 16 + Varlablo-Speod Scroll-Com __ S)'Illm 2O.5S SI,56I.92 $641.94 S2095.19 SI22.78 SS310.S7 1668 $141 14.91 $6,883 $6.684 $6,386 11.37 13.01 16.62 

Auympdogo' 

1 Ele<:Iricily COIl- O.085 "Wh (IY ..... CDt lD 1999 obla.iDod from an iDleIpOlolIoo of !be 1995 and 2000 prIca of eJeclricily foroc .. 1 in DOE'. Annual EDeraY Ou~ook 1993, in/lauod 

to 1992 doU.,.). The lDUIpOlauod yalue for 1999 is 0.082 $ltWb (199IS) or 0.085 &flu Idj ... ling for InrlolIoo from 1991 to 1992. The elOClricily pric:eonduse factor for CAC is 1.0 (no adjuslmml). 

2 llielim . .. IS y .... MIItIIp facl"" 1.98. 

3 Budine wUllocludoa: 

Evapar''''': 4.13 'q.n., 13 Im.JtD<:II. Wlyy FIDI, 3 lUbe roWl, Groove Tubes 

Condenser: 12.88 'q.n., 20 riDlAAcb, SUI Filla, I lUbe row, Smootl! Thbu 

Compra.or: Roelprocada&, 10.20 EER (oomlnal) 

Evaporl"" FAD Mo&or. PSC, S8.S~ "ffICi .. " 

Condenser Fan MOO': PSC, SS.09Io effoci .. " 

Fnbancemenl Devica: NoDe 

4 No.·Bleod Thermoolllic i!l~1oD Valve replacea!be aoed for I Time Del.y Relay 

5 Muimum Sa»lble Heal Robo - 76.5~ 

6 EVaporilOr OCM Fan MOIor illDOdUlau.!. Cool of fan mo"" iDcludel .lecll'OlIic modulatin8 conll'Ola. 

7 Co.denser OCM Fan Mocor 0; ..... 11. -inale.peed. 
9/28/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Single Package System

Central Air Conditioner

$7,000

$6,600 + 1--0- 6% discount rate1

...... $6,200

0\

0\

.-4

"-'

u

U

....J $5,800

$5,400

12

$5,000

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0' 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0

SEER

17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$7,000 

9/28/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Single Package System 

Central Air Conditioner 

$6,600 1--0- 6% discount rate I 

u 

U 

...:l $5,800 

$5,400 

$5,000 

9.0 10.0 11.0 

12 

12.0 ' 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 

SEER 

19.0 20.0 21.0 
9/28/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Single Package System

Central Air Conditioner

..A

/ /

/

/ /

/ // .. /

,,,/

,

•,

,

,

•

.•. II ,

....... - .... -. --....... -....

'.

....

..

- - -6 - - 6% discount rate

-----a------ 4% discount rate

/' / ' /,'

A. //:/:

Y\. / / ;/A: / / /,./ '

" / / r ' " I/~/: ' " I~ ,,' , , ' ' , ' ' '" ' , UA~A 6. :.' ' • ,,- .. U I ,,-' " " ,,-

....

U f • ",-- " "'" - , - ,;'.:-- '0-- / }."

--....u___ A' / .. tr - - -t.i1/

. . . . •. . .. 10% discount rate

.,

$5,000

$5,400

$6,200

$6.600

$7.000

e $5,800

u

u

..J

$4,600

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0

SEER

17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

~ 

s: 

$7,000 

$6,600 

$6,200 

e $5,800 

u 

u 

..J 

$5,400 

$5,000 

$4,600 

9.0 10.0 11.0 

9/28/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Single Package System 

Central Air Conditioner 

----0--- 4% discount rate 

- - tl - - 6% discount rate 

- - - -.- - - - 10% discount rate 

, -.. 

. -.. -. -- - II · 

12.0 

... ... , . - ... .. ..... . 

13.0 14.0 15.0 

SEER 

, 

, • 

.: , 

16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0 
Life Cycle COlits and Payback Periocls or 5-toD, Single Pack8llf System CeDtraJ Air CondltloDer

9/30/93

Incr. Inltalled Annual Annual CwI'I1I. Llfecycle Cos.. CIlmulllive

SEER Manufr Manufr InstallOlion Mainlmlncc Consumer E1ec. Energy Paybock Coil of Conserved Energy

Leve DeoilJl Option Cost Cost COS! Cost Coil ule cost Period (1992.$) (<:enIS/J(Wb)

BlIIhIW (1992.$) (1992$) (1992.$) (1992.$) (1992.$) kWhlvr (1992.$) (vean) 4~ 6~ 10% 4~ 6~ 10%

0 Budine 9.71 $666.00 - S222I.22 S46.69 S3773.07 5962 SS05 NA S9,391 S8,6&1 S7,616 NA NA NA

1 o+ Baclcwwd Inclined Indoor Blowa' 9.98 $666.02 $0.02 S222I.22 S46.69 S3773.12 5799 $492 0.00 S9,238 S8,S47 $7,512 0.00 0.00 0.00

2 1 + Evaponl« Slit Pins 10.07 $666.23 $0.21 S222I.22 S46.69 S3m.S9 5148 $487 0.03 S9,I91 $8,506 S7,480 0.02 0.03 0.03

3 2+ Sa'oll CCJr'I¥C'IOr. 11.30 EER lU2 $690.87 S24.64 S222I.22 S46.69 S3829.28 son S426 0.71 S8,S62 $7,963 $7,067 0.54 0.62 0.79

4 3 + Time Delay Relay 11.97 $697.37 $6.SO S222I.22 S46.69 $3843.97 4834 S410 0.74 S8,399 S7,823 $6,960 0.57 0.65 0.83

S 4 + More E!.lIiciSlt B'tlIporaor PSC Pal MOl« (68.S'llo 12.27 S707.14 S9.77 S222I.22 S39.08 S3858.44 4714 S400 0.81 S8,301 $7,739 S6,898 0.62 0.70 0.90

6 S + Non-Bleed 'Ibonno.-ic fupomion Valve 12.58 S714.72 $7.58 S222I.22 S39.08 $3875.57 4599 S390 0.89 S8,210 $7,662 S6,841 0.68 0.77 0.99

7 6 + More I!lflcient ConcIenaer PSC Pm MOl« (6S.0'll0) 12.70 S72I.02 $6.30 S222I.22 S31.47 S3882.20 4551 S386 0.92 S8,I77 S7,634 S6,820 0.70 0.80 1.02

8 7 + Inctuae EvlpnlOl' J7m Density 10 14 (pi 12.74 $72248 SI.46 S222I.22 S31.47 S3885.49 4542 S385 0.93 S8,I65 $7,624 $6,813 0.71 0.82 1.04

9 8 + Inctuae BvlpnlOl' Pate Area 10 7.SO sq.ft. 13.13 S739.70 $17.22 S223UI S31.47 S3934.70 4408 S374 1.23 S8,089 $7,S63 $6,776 0.94 1.07 1.37

10 9 + Condenl« Grooved 1'llbea 13.28 S7S6.S2 S16.82 S223UI S31.47 S3972.72 43S6 $369 1.41 S8,078 S7,559 S6,78I 1.12 1.28 1.64

11 10 + Increue ConcIenaer Pace A!u 10 27.60 aq.ft. 13.53 S188.74 S32.22 S2262.38 S31.47 S4076.4O 4277 S362 2.12 S8.107 S7,597 S6,833 1.62 1.85 2.37

12 11 + Increase Condc:rlRr Pac.. A!u 10 36.50 aq./\. 13.79 S850.4O S61.66 S232210 S31.47 S4275.47 4195 S3S6 3.36 $8.229 $7,729 S6.980 2.S6 2.93 3.74

13 12 + Bvaponl« HCM Pin MOl« 14.40 SI,030.66 SI80.26 S232210 S41.09 S4698.48 4019 S341 S.62 S8.486 $8,007 $7,290 4.29 4.91 6.26

14 13 + E1CClronic Exponsion Valve 14.59 SI,106.83 S16.17 S2322.IO SS6.07 S4879.61 3966 S336 6.S4 S8,617 S8,144 S1,436 4.99 S.71 7.29

IS 14 +Condensa ECM Pin MOIOr 14.66 $1,179.53 $12.70 $2322.10 $63.68 $S051.S2 3947 S33S 7.49 sa,771 $8,301 $7,596 5.71 6.53 8.34

16 IS +'lWc>-Speed Rccip-Compreslor Syl1ml 16.27 SI,368.28 S188.1S S2322.10 $80.S4 S5494-95 3551 S302 8.45 S8,847 S8,423 $7,788 6.44 7.37 9.42

17 IS + Variable-Speed Recip-CCJr'I¥C'IOI' System 17.14 SI.779.53 S6OO.OO S2322.10 SI32.24 $6476.08 3376 S286 12.33 S9.651 S9,2S5 S8.652 9.40 10.16 13.14

18 IS +'lWc>-Speed Sa'oll-C~aor System 16.52 SI.679.53 S5OO.OO S2322.IO S121.81 $6245.71 3504 S297 11.81 S9.S48 S9.13O S8,504 9.0S 10.36 13.23

19 IS + Variable-SDeed ScroD-ComDreaIOf SvSlClll 19.04 SI.829.53 S650.OO S232210 S134.43 $6591.27 3039 S2S8 11.38 S9,4SS S9,093 S8,SSO 8.67 9.93 12.68

Ayyrnprigoa'

1 Electricity COIl- O.08S $i\:Wb (avenae COIl in 1999 obcained from In interpolation ofthe I99S and 2000 prices of electricity forecast in OOE'I Annual F.nergy Outlook 1993, inflated

10 1992 dolIan). The inttrpolated value for 1999 il 0.082 S/kWb (199IS) or 0.08S after adjustin8 for inflOlion from 199110 1992..The electricity price enduse factor for CAC il 1.0 (no adjustment).

2 Ufetime - 15 yean. Markup faclOr. 2.26.

3 Baseline llllit includes:

Evapor1llOt: 6.00 aq./t, 13 fina/incll, Wavy Pins, 4111be rowl. Groove Tubes

Condensa: 23.00 aq./t, 20 finIAnch, Slit Pins, 2111be roWI, Smooth Tubes

CoqJreuor. ReciptOClliuc. 10.49 EER (DOIIIinaI); Acannu.laaor

Hvapor1llOt Pm Md<r. psc. S8.S~ etficiClll

Condensa P.. Md<r. PSC, SS.O% dficicft

I!nhancanCIlI Devices: None

4 Non-Bleed 1bermoI1aIic fupomion Valve replacathe need for a Tune Delay Relay.

5 ~imum Saulible HealRatio .. 76.5~

6 Bvapor1llOt ECM Pin MOIOr is mo~l1ated. Coat of fin ItlOIOr includel electronic modulatin8 controll.

7 Condenser ECM Pin MOIOr il run .alin81e speed.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

9130193 

Life Cycle COIiU and Payback Periods or S.lOn, Single Package System Central Air Conditioner 

!ncr. Inl\alled Annual Annual Cumul. Lifecycle Costs Cumulative 

SEER M .... uf, Manufr Inl\allllion MainlmlnCC Consumer !!Iec. Energy Paybock Coli of Conserved Energy 

Level Deaisn Option Con Con COlI Cost Coli use con Period (1992$) (cenII/ltWh) 

BIIIh/W (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) kWhJyr (1992$) (yean) 4% 6% 10% 4% 6% 10% 

0 Baseline 9.71 $666.00 - S222I.22 S46.69 53773.07 S962 5S05 NA S9,391 58,681 $7,616 NA NA NA 

1 o + Baclcw.d Inclined Indoor BIo ..... 9.98 S666.02 $Om S222.I.22 S46.69 $3773.12 5799 $492 0.00 $9,238 S8,547 $7,512 0.00 0.00 0.00 

2 1 + Evapor1ll« Slit Pins 10.07 $666.23 $0.21 S222I.22 S46.69 $3773.59 5148 $487 0.D3 S9,191 S8,506 S7,480 0.02 0.D3 0.03 

3 2+ Saoll Co, ......... or: 11.30 EllR 11.52 $690.87 S24.64 S222I.22 S46.69 S3829.28 S022 S426 0.71 S8,562 57,963 $7,067 0.S4 0.62 0.79 

4 3 + rune Oolay Relay 11.97 $697.37 $6.SO S222I.22 S46.69 $3843.97 4834 S410 0.74 S8,399 57,823 $6,960 0.57 0.65 0.83 

5 4 + More Bllicielll Ev..,orllOr PSC Pal Motor (68.S'I(, 12.27 S707.14 S9.77 S222I.22 S39.08 $3858.44 4714 $400 0.81 58,301 57,739 $6,898 0.62 0.70 0.90 

6 5 + Non-Bleed 'Tbermo.-ic &pllllioo Valve 12.58 5714.72 $7.58 S222I.22 S39.08 $3875.57 4599 S390 0.89 $8,210 57,662 S6,841 0.68 0.77 0.99 

7 6 + More B1ftcienl Coodenoer PSC P., Mocor (6'-0"') 12.70 $721.02 $6.30 S222I.22 S31.47 53882.20 45S7 S386 0.92 S8,177 57,634 $6,820 0.70 0.80 1.02 

8 7 + m.:re- EvsponlOf F'm Density 10 14 (pi 12.74 $722.48 SI.46 S222I.22 531.47 53885.49 4542 5385 0.93 58,165 $7,624 $6,813 0.71 0.82 1.04 

9 8 + Jncreax BvsponlOf Pace Area 10 7.SO sqA 13.13 5739.70 517.22 S2231.S1 S31.47 S3934.70 4408 S374 1.23 $8,089 $7,563 $6,776 0.94 1.07 1.37 

10 9 + Condenser Grooved Tubes 13.28 $756.52 $16.82 S2231.51 $31.47 $3972.72 4356 5369 1.47 $8,078 57,559 $6,181 1.12 1.28 1.64 

11 10 + Increue ConcIaueT Pace Are. 10 21.60 sq./\. 13.53 S188.74 532.22 S2262.38 S31.47 S4076.40 4277 S362 2.12 S8,107 S7,597 S6,833 1.62 1.85 2.37 

12 11 + Incruse ConcIaueT p.,., Are. 10 36.50 sq./l 13.79 S850.40 S61.66 52322.10 $31.47 $4215.47 4195 $356 3.36 $8,229 57,729 56,980 2.56 2.93 3,74 

13 12 + Bvlponll« ECM P .... Motor 14.40 SI,03O.66 5180.26 S2322.10 S47.09 S4698.48 4019 S341 5.62 S8,486 S8,007 $7,290 4.29 4.91 6.26 

14 13 + Electronic: &pmtion Valve 14.59 SI,106.83 $76,17 S2322.10 S56.07 54879.61 3966 S336 6.54 S8,617 S8,144 S7,436 4.99 5.71 7.29 

15 14 + Condenser ECM Pan Motor 14.66 51,179.53 S72.70 S2322.10 $63.68 SS051.52 3947 S335 7.49 S8,771 S8,301 $7,596 5.71 6.53 8.34 

16 15 + 'J'wo-Speed Rccip-Compreoaor Syllem 16.27 SI,368.28 S188.75 S2322.10 S80.54 55494.95 3551 $302 8.45 S8,847 S8,423 $7,788 6.44 7.37 9.42 

17 15 + Vlrioble-Speed Recip-Con.,.aoor Syllan 17.14 SI,779.53 S6OO.00 S2322.10 S13224 $6476.08 3376 $286 12.33 $9,657 59,255 S8,652 9.40 10.76 13.74 

18 15 + 'J'wo-Speed Saoll-Compresoor Syllan 16.52 SI,679.53 S5OO.OO S2322.IO S127.87 $6245.71 3504 5297 11.87 $9,548 59,130 S8,504 9.05 10.36 13.23 

19 IS + V lrioble-Speed SaoU-ComIrctoor SyI1elll 19.04 $1,829.53 $650.00 $2322.10 $134.43 $6591.27 3039 $2,S8 11.38 59,455 $9,093 S8,5SO 8.67 9.93 1268 

A'8!DJZIigna' 

1 Electricity COIt- 0.085 $'\:Wb (avenae COlt in 1999 obtained from .... inlel'pOlation of tile 1995 and 2000 prices of dCClricity forecast in OOE's Annual Energy Outlook 1993, infIaIed 

10 1992 dol Ian). The ina.rpolaLed value for 1999 i. 0.082 S/ltWh (1991$) or 0.085 a/l.er adju5ling for inflation from 1991 \0 1992..The electricity price enduse faclDr for CAC is 1.0 (no adjuslrrlmt). 

3 Bueline unit includes: 

Evaponaor: 6.00 sqA, 13 finI/incb, Wavy PiN, 4 lUbe row" Groove Tubes 

CondenIcr. 23.00 sqA, 20 finl.linch. Slit Pins, 2 lUbe row" SIIlOOIh Tubes 

Coqnaaor: RecipOCllinc. 10.49 EER (DOCIIinaI); Acannulaaor 

Evaponaor Pm Moler: PSC, 58.5'" etrlcicnl 

Condenser P .. Moler: PSC, SS.O% effici<ra 

I'!nhanc:anom Devioel: None 

• Non-Bleed 'JbermoNIic &pInIion Valve ""'I .... tile need for a rune Oolay Relay. 

6 Bvaponaor ECM P .. Motor i. mo&I1ated. Cost of fan motor include. electronic modullling COIIII'ols. 

7 Condmter ECM Pan Motor i. run at a .insle speed. 
$9,400

$8,900

.-.

EII'7

N

Cl'I

e- $8,400

u

U

,...J

$7,900

9/30/93

Life Cycle Cost for"S-ton Single Package System

Central Air Conditioner

1--0-- 6% discount rate I 19

$7,400

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0

SEER

16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$9,400 

$8,900 

~ N 

~ 

~ 

~ $8,400 

U 

U 

...J 

$7,900 

$7,400 

9.0 

9/30/93 

Life Cycle Cost for' 5-ton Single Package System 

Central Air Conditioner 

1--0-- 6% discount rate I 

10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 

SEER 

19 

18.0 19.0 20.0 
9/30/93

Life Cycle Cost for 5-ton Single Package System

Central Air Conditioner

..

••

. . .' , . .. , ' , . " . " ." . t':"':-" -'

.

.

•

- - {:x - - 6% discount rate

-- --.- --- 10% discount rate'

'..,

, / / ' / //

/ / //

/ / //

, 'i/ /// , 'l ///.

, 'l //

,"/// ." " ~-,/ _----6.' ,

, -- " "

'n., J ,'/

" ? ~, /

6. /

;f

-c:r-- 4% discount rate

.,

$7,700

$8.700

$9.200

$9,700

v;

N

0'\

0'\

$8,200

U

U

...:l

$7.200

$6.700

••

.•.

.

.,

,

,. ... -

......- .

" -~- . ....

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0

SEER

16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

v; 

N 

0'\ 

0'\ 

$9,700 

$9,200 

$8,700 

~ $8,200 

U 

U 

...J 

$7,700 

$7,200 

$6,700 

' ... 

9.0 10.0 

9/30/93 

Life Cycle Cost for Seton Single Package System 

Central Air Conditioner 

--0- 4% discount rate 

- - 6 - - 6% discount rate 

. - - -. --- - 10% discount rate ' 

, 

, • 

: 

•• , . ,. .. .. " ..... -... -. 

" " " 

, ' , , , ' , ' , ' 

" ' 

." "," . 

t':-'--'- ' ' - , 

, • 

-. 

11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 

SEER 

17.0 

.+ 

18.0 19.0 20.0 
Life Cyde Costs and Payback PeriodJ of3-lon, Single Package System Central Heat Pump

g/28/g3

!Aer. Annuall!loc: Uoe Annu.ol ClmuL Ufoc~leCeoli Q.mu1ati..

SEER HSPF Manut'r Manul'r InllollallCll M.IinI........ OOIlIllDlcr CoaIin& H..tin. EncrlY P.yboclt COlI ofConocrvod EncraY

Leve Deol." Opliall Coot COlI C... Coot coot .... Period (1992S) ("",II/lWb)

BlUh/W BtullIW (I992S) (1992$) (1992$) (1992S) (1992S) kWhlyr kWb/yr (1992$) (}'CUI) 4~ 6~ 10~ 410 610 1010

0 n..cIlno 9.70 6.69 $677.00 $1202.35 546.69 $261J1.OS 3764 8,379 SI,029 NA S14,134 SI2,687 S10,519 NA NA NA

1 0+ B.c:I<wud lnolinod Indoor Blower 9.99 6.79 S677.00 SO.OO S1202.35 $46.69 $26IJI.OS 36S4 8,254 SI,009 0.00 SI3,913 SI2,494 SIO,368 0.00 0.00 0.00

2 I + Indoor CoU SU, FiN 10.\2 6.90 S677.03 SO.03 S120235 $46.69 $261J1.I2 3608 8,128 S995 0.00 S13,751 S12,352 S10,257 0.00 0.00 0.01

3 2 +Ioaeooe Indoor CoU Pin DaIIily 10 14 (pi 10.16 6.92 S677.69 SO.66 S120235 $46.69 $261J2,S2 3594 8.096 S991 0.04 S13,709 SI2.316 S10,229 0.08 0.09 0.11

4 3 + Morc I!fIici.."Ind_ PSC Pon MoCor (680510) 10.40 7.01 S684.89 S7.20 S120235 $39.08 $2700.25 3512 7.995 S975 0.17 S13,544 SI2,I72 S10.118 0.33 0.37 0.48

5 4 + Morcl!flici.." Ouldoo< PSC Fon Mocor (65.010 10.51 7.10 S6IJ1.I9 S6.30 S1202.35 $31.47 $2706.06 3476 7.890 $963 0.23 S13,417 SI2,063 SI0,034 0.47 0.54 0.68

6 5 +Tlllle DcIoy Relay 10.84 7.25 S6IJ7.69 S6.50 S1202.35 $3l.47 $2719.90 3369 7.734 $941 0.33 SI3.183 SII.860 S9,878 0.66 0.75 0.96

7 6 +Rcciprocatin. ComJll"lUOf' 11.26 EER 11.34 7.46 S708.68 SI0.99 S1202.35 $31.47 $2743.31 3221 7,516 S910 0.44 SI2,862 SII,583 S9,666 0.87 0.99 1.27

8 7 +IncruIClndoor CoU Paoc Ana 10 4.97 "I./\. 12.04 7.73 S722.05 SI337 S1212.09 $31.47 ~781.53 3032 7,250 S872 0.57 SI2,472 S11,246 S9,41 I 1.11 1.27 1.63

9 8 +Danond 0._ 12.04 7.96 S733.55 SIUO S1212.09 $31.47 $2806.02 3032 7.039 S854 0.6S SI2,297 SI1.097 S9,299 1.41 1.62 2.07

10 9 +Ouldoo< Coil Oroovod TubOl 12.34 '.00 S74O.52 S6.97 S1212.09 $31.47 $2820.87 2958 7.009 S845 0.70 SI2,214 SI1.026 $9,247 1.45 1.66 2.12

II 10+ lncrcue Indoor Coil F.oc Ana 10 6.39 oq./\. 12.73 8.15 S755.60 SI5.08 SI221.83 $31.47 $2862.73 2868 6,877 S826 0.84 SI2,046 S10,885 $9.145 1.72 1.97 252

12 II + ScroiI Compreuor: 11.50I!EJl 13.29 •.25 S77458 SIM8 S1221.83 S31,47 $2903.\6 2748 6,791 S808 0.96 SII,892 S10,755 $9,053 1.88 2.15 2.7.

13 12 + NCIl·Blood Th..",OI\4li. l!aponoioa Volv.. 13.62 8.47 S787.03 SI2.45 SI221.83 S31.47 $2929.68 2681 6,616 $788 0.99 S11,691 SI0583 S8,923 1.98 2.27 2.90

14 13 + 1ncrcoIC QuldoorCall P.ocArea 1021.00 "1./\ IU4 '.80 S811.89 S24.86 S1262.09 S31.47 $3022.89 2347 6,372 $7S6 1.21 SII,428 S1036S S8.773 2.45 2.81 3.58

15 14 + lnauoelndoorCoiI P.oc Area 10 7.SOaq./\. 14.55 U6 S822.19 S10.30 S1261J.70 S31.47 $3OS2.44 2509 6.325 $749 1.29 S11,378 SIO.325 S8.748 2.59 2.97 3.79

16 IS + In<:rco.e Indoor Cci11\1bc Density 10 4 roWi 14.66 8.93 S844058 S22.39 S126IJ.70 S31.47 $3100.13 2490 6.276 $743 1,43 S11.362 S10,317 S8,752 2.89 3.31 4.22

17 16 + Incrcooe Outdoor Call F.oc Area '030.00 "1./\. 1S.G2 9.04 S89O.19 545.61 S1330.09 • S31.47 $3157.67 2432 6,200 $732 1.90 SII,392 SIO,363 S8,822 3.82 4.38 5.S9

18 17 + Outdoor ECM Fen Mocor 1S.\2 9.\7 S962.89 S72.70 S133O.09 " S39.08 $3420.\3 2415 6.115 $723 2.38 SI1,459 SI0.442 S8.919 4.86 5.57 7.11

19 18+ Elca:onicElponliCll Val.. 1S.31 9.22 SI.OIl.23 $48.34 SI33O.09 548.06 $3532.07 2385 6,083 $718 2.70 SII,512 SIO,502 S8,991 5.48 6.28 8.02

20 19 + IndoorECM Fon Motor 1S.87 9.28 SI.152.S3 S141.30 S133O.09 $63.68 $3848.66 2300 6.042 $707 3.59 SII,710 S10.716 $9,227 7.11 8.\4 1Q.il0

21 20 +Two-Speod Recip-Compreuor SywlaD 17.37 9.32 SI,332.79 S180.26 S1330.09 $77.62 54246.55 2102 6.012 $688 456 S11,894 SI0.927 S9.478 8.42 9.64 12.31

22 20 + Vuiobl",Spood Rocip-Cornpla_ SywlaD 17.70 9.72 SI,744.04 S59UI S1330.09 SI23.47 ssI68.37 2063 5.770 S664 6.78 SI2,SSO $\1.617 S10,218 13.10 15.00 19.IS

23 20 +Two-Speod scroU·Comp....... SywlaD 17.93 9.89 SI,644.04 549J.s1 SI33O.09· SII 9.\ 0 S49S1.00 2037 S.666 S6S3 6.00 SI2,210 SI1,292 S9.917 11.77 13.47 17.20

24 20 + Vuioblt>S.-d ScroU.comoraoorSwtem 20.21 10.6IJ SI,794.04 $64J.s1 S1330.09 SI25.66 SS277.06 1806 S,243 S597 5.99 S11,920 SII.080 $9.822 11.88 13.60 17.37

AwlmfiS!'1"

I E1t:ctlicity ceot. O.GIS Sfl:Wh (a..... 00II in 1999 oblain... fran on inIarpololiOll oflbo 1995 end 2OlIO priOCI or elOClticity fcrocu' in OOE'. Annuol En...y Outlook 1993, inflilod

10 1992 dollan). Tbc lnlorpololed vol..for 199911 0.082 SIo:Wb (l991S) or 0.085 aII....djuou". ror inflolion fran 199110 1994The elocaici,y prioc ..,duoe r.""" ror CAC is 1.0 (no .dj"""'ent).

2 Lifcllme. IS YWI. MaJkup f....... 2.13.

3 B..cIlne uni' includc:a:

Indoor Call: 355 aq./\., 13 1iNMch, WIVY fino, 3l11bc toWl, O_eTubOl

Outdoor COU: IS.OO "1./\.. 20 finIMc:h. Slil Pin•• Ilubc to". Smooth 1\IbOI

Comp","or. Rcciprocatin., 10.80I!EJl (nomillal); Accumulator

Indoor Fen Mo<or. PSC, S8.SI. emma.

Outdoor Fall Motor. PSC, 5S.0I0 cfticialt

EnhIllCOnall DcviOCI: None

• AD Tw~Speod end Variabl",Spood c..opraoorS_include en Accumulator.

5 M.aim"", Sensible Hat Rolio • 76.5"

6 Non·Blood ThCll1looll11. l!oponliCXI Volvoo "'I'looo the.-d for a Time DcIoy ReI.y ond en A=rnulacor.

7 Ev.porotor ECM Fen MllIOr Umodulaled. Ceot mfon motor inc1udoo c1caroni. modu1au". .CIltroU.

8 Condcnsa ECM Fall MOlOr UNIl " • oinlle.peod.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

Life Cyde Costs and Payback Periods of J.lon, Single Package System Cenlral Heal Pump 

ID ... IMoIIod Annu&ll!1ec: Uoe Annu&l Clmul. Ufcc~I.C .. u 

SEER HSPF Manurr Manul'r InIlolllliCll M.oin&......,. CIOIlIumcr CooIin& H .. tin, Enoray P.yboclt 

un Dcoiao> Opllaa Coot Coot COOl Coot COlt """ Period (1992S) 

Bwh/W BIIlb,IW (1992S) (1992l) (1992l) (1992S) (1992S) kWhlyr kWblyr (1992l) (yeuo) 4~ 6~ 

0 n .. dlne> 9.70 6.69 $677.00 '1202.35 846.69 $2(IJI.~ 3764 8,379 $1,029 NA SI4,134 $12,687 

I 0+ B.ci<wud lnclinod "'door Blower 9.99 6.79 S677.00 SO.OO $1202.35 $46.69 $2691 ~ 36S4 1.254 SI,009 0.00 S13.913 SI2,494 

2 1 + Indoor CoU Slit fino 10.12 6.90 $677.03 S0.03 S120235 $46.69 $2691 .12 3608 8.121 $995 0.00 $13.751 S12,352 

3 2 + ia"",oelndoor Coil Pin Doaoily 10 14 fpi 10.16 6.92 $677.69 SO.66 $1202.35 $46.69 $2692.52 3594 1.096 S991 0.04 S13.709 $12.316 

4 3 + MOJO I!fIiCQI' Indoor PSC Paa Mocor (68.5'l1o) 10.40 7.01 $684.19 $7.20 S120235 $39.01 $2700.25 3512 7.995 S975 0.17 S13,544 SI2,I72 

5 4 + Morcl!flicall OIIldoor PSC Fan Mocor (65 ~ 10.51 7.10 S691.19 S6.30 S1202.35 $31.47 $2706.06 3476 7.890 $963 0.23 $13.417 SI2,063 

6 5 + Tim. Dcloy Relay 10.14 7,2.5 $697.69 S6.50 SI202.35 $31.47 $2719.90 3369 7,734 $941 033 S13,183 SII.860 

7 6 + Rcciprocatin, Cern"""",,, 11.26 EER 1134 7.46 S708.68 SI0.99 S120235 $31.47 $274331 3221 7.516 $910 0.44 SI2,862 SII.583 

8 7 + inorcooelndoor CoU PIOC Ano 104.97 oqA 12.04 7.73 Sm05 S1337 S1212.09 $31.47 ~7&!.53 3032 7,250 S872 0.57 SI2,472 SII,246 

9 8 + Canlnd Ocr.- 12.04 7.96 S733.55 Sl1.SO S1212.09 $31 .47 $2806.02 3032 7.039 $854 0.6S SI2,297 S11,091 

10 9 + OIIldoar Coil OtooYod Tuboo 12.34 ' .00 S74O.52 S6.97 S1212.09 $31 ,47 $2820.87 2958 7,009 S845 0.70 SI2,214 SII,026 

11 10 • Incrcuc Indoor Coil PI"" Ana 10 6.39 oqA 12.73 I.U $755.60 SI5.OJ S1221.83 $31.47 $2862.73 2868 6,877 S826 0.84 SI2,046 S10,885 

12 11 + Scroll Canpnuor: 11.50 EER 13.29 U5 '714.51 SI8-.91 $1221.83 $31 .47 $2903.16 2748 6,791 S80J 0.96 $11,892 $10.755 

13 12 + Non·Blced ThamClNlio l!aponlica Valv .. 13.62 1.47 $781.03 SI2.45 $1221.83 $31.47 $2929.68 2681 6.616 $788 0.99 S11,691 $10,513 

14 13 + 1ncrea .. Outdoor Coil P.ooArea ",21.00 "1./\ IU4 '.10 $811.89 S24.86 S1262.09 $31.47 $3022.19 1547 6,372 S7S6 1.21 $11.428 $10.36S 

IS 14 + Incrcu.lndoorCoiI PIOO Ana 10 7.SO "1./1. 14.55 1.16 S822.19 S10.30 $1269.70 $31.47 $3~2.44 2509 6,325 $749 1.29 $11,378 '10.325 

16 IS + inc:reo •• Indoor Cci11Ubo Drruity '" 4 roWi 14.66 8.93 '844.58 $22.39 SI269.70 $31.47 $3100.13 2490 6,276 $743 1.43 S11.362 $10,317 

11 16 + InC1'elJ. Outdoor Coil P."" Area '030.00 "1./\ 1S.02 9.04 S89O.19 845.61 $1330.09 $31.47 $3257.67 2432 6,200 $732 1.90 $11,392 SIO,363 

18 11 + Outdoor ECM Fan MolOr 15.12 9.17 $962.89 '72.70 $1330.09 \ $39.01 $3420.13 2415 6,115 $723 2.31 SI1,459 $10.442 

19 11+ E1ecuonicl!apiNian Valve 15.31 9.22 $1,011.23 $41.34 $1330.09 841.06 $3532.07 2385 6,OJ3 $718 2.10 $11,512 $10,502 

20 19 + Indoor ECM Fan MOlOr 1S.17 9.21 $1 .152.53 $14130 $1330.09 $63.61 $3848.66 2300 6,042 $707 3.59 511.710 $10,716 

21 20. Two-Speed Reoip-Compnuor SywIaD 11.37 932 $1.332.19 $180.26 S1330.09 $77.62 84246.55 2102 6,012 $688 4.56 511 ,894 $10,927 

22 20 + Vuioblc"Speed Recip-Comp,., .. .., SywIaD 17.70 9.72 $1 ,144.04 $591.51 $1330.09 $123.47 $5168.37 2063 5,710 $664 6.18 SI2,SSO $11 ,617 

23 20+ Two-Speed scroU·Comp...- SywIaD 17.93 9.19 51 ,644.04 $491.51 51330.09 · 5119.10 $49SI.00 2037 5,666 $653 6.00 512,210 511,292 

24 20+ Vodob1t-Spcood ScroU.cernpr<aOr_S_ 20.21 10.69 $1,794.04 $641.51 $1330.09 SI25.66 $5277.06 1806 5,243 $597 5.99 $11,920 $11,080 

Apurmsi"'" . 

1 E1CC1Dcily _I- 0.015 Sfl:Wh (1 __ in 1999 oIJuinod frcm an intcrpoillion ohho 1995 IIId 2000 pric:a ofdaaricilY ( ....... ,in DOE'o Annul! Enoray Ou11ock 1993, infl.tDd 

to 1992 dollln). Tho inIcrpolItDd v ...... for 1999 It 0.012 $.o\Wb (1991S) or 0.085 allot Idjl>ltina f.., inflation &an 199110 1992. Tho decaici'y pcoc ..,duod.ClDr for CAC II 1.0 (no .djUllmcnt). 

2 lifcoim •• 1S yWl. Marltup f.dOt-2.13. 

3 B .. dine uni, includeo: 

Indoor Coil: 3.55 "lA, 13 1iNMch, W.vy Pine, 3 tube toWS, O""",.1Uboa 

CMdoorCoU; 15.00 "lA, 20 finIJinc:h. Slit Fino, l,ubc to ... Smooth Tuboo 

Comp",uor. Rcciproc:atin •• 10.10 EER (nomiDa1); Accumwtor 

Indoor Fan Motcr. PSC, S8.5'l1o c:fticien& 

Outdoor Fan Motor. PSC, S5.0'lI0 c:fticia11 

Enhanc:cmm,DeW:a : N_ 

• All Two-Speed and Vodoblo-Spcod c.""pra_ S)'IICIN includ. an Aoournu1ator. 

5 M .. imum Scmible Ha, Rltio - 76.5'l1o 

6 Non·Blced ThcrmOlulic Exp..wCll1 Valv .. ...,ltoe tho.-l for. Timo Dcloy RollY and III AC<UI1lwtor. 

7 EvopenlOr ECM Fan Motor u modwtDd. C .. I rL fon motor includ .. dcc:uonic modulotina eontrolo. 

I Cond""a ECM Fill Motor U NIl at I .mlle.peed. 

10~ 

SIO,S I9 

SI0,368 

S10,2.57 

S10.229 

$10,111 

SI0,034 

S9.87' 

$9.666 

S9.411 

S9,299 

$9,241 

S9,145 

$9.053 

$8,923 

$8.773 

$8,748 

S8,752 

SU21 

$8,919 

$8.991 

$9,221 

S9.478 

$10,218 

59,917 

$9,122 

g1281g3 

Oanuloli"" 

Coot of Conocrvod Enoru 

(o,,"I/\Wb) 

4~ 6~ 1~ 

NA NA NA 

0.00 0.00 0.00 

0.00 0.00 0.01 

O.OJ 0.09 0.11 

0.33 037 0.41 

0.47 0.54 0.68 

0.66 0.75 0.96 

0.87 0.99 1.27 

1.11 1.27 1.63 

1.41 1.62 2.07 

1.45 1.66 2.12 

1.72 1.97 2.52 

1.88 2.15 2.74 

1.98 2.27 2.90 

2.45 2.81 3.51 

2.59 2.97 3.79 

2.89 3.31 4.22 

3.82 4.38 5.59 

4.86 5.51 1.11 

5.41 6.2J 1.02 

1.11 1.14 10.40 

8.42 9.64 12.31 

13.10 15.00 19.1S 

11.71 13.41 17.20 

11.88 13.60 17.31 
9/28/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Single Package System

Central Heat Pump

16

o

1--0- 6% discount rate I

24

$10,900

$10,500

$12,100

$12,900

$12,500

$11,700 N

g:

...

'-'

u

:s $11,300

$10,100

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0

SEER

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$12,900 

$12,500 

$12,100 

~ $11 ,700 

... 

~ 

-

u :s $11,300 

$10,900 

$10,500 

$10,100 

o 

9/28/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3-too Single Package System 

Central Heat Pump 

1--0- 6% discount rate I 

16 

24 

9.0 10.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 20.0 21.0 

SEER 
9/28/93

Life Cycle Cost for 3-ton Single Package System

Central Heat Pump

20.0 21.0

..- ...

19.0

. ..

•

18.0

•

17.0

.• ~'~':'::<' <:::~ .' _.'

14.0 15.0 16.0

SEER

----.- -.. 10% discount rate

- - -6. - - 6% discount rate

13.0

..

......'.-.. .~

.............

12.0

...

--0-- 4% discount rate

11.0

'., ..~'..,

10.0

•

A.

'\

"

e:..

" "~ /6

~, // t._ // ---6.

"'-A / ------ '"" / ------ "" ? ---6.

u, ~-~---------------~ _ cs---

~-tF

$14,500

$14,100

$13,700

$13,300

$12,900

$12,500

...... $12,100

M

$11,700 .-4

'-'

U $11,300

U

...:l $10,900

$10,500

$10,100

$9,700

$9,300

$8,900

$8,500

9.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$14,500 

$14,100 

$13,700 

$13,300 

$12,900 

$12,500 

,-. $12,100 

fh 

~ $11,700 .-4 

'-' 

U $11,300 

U 

....J $10,900 

$10,500 + 

$10,100 

'+, $9,700 

$9,300 

$8,900 

$8,500 

9.0 10.0 11.0 

9/28/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 3·ton Single Package System 

Central Heat Pump 

--0- 4% discount rate 

- - -6 - - 6% discount rate 

-- --+---- 10% discount rate 

.. . . . ... ; .... .... ':; :::~ ..... -- + . +. ~~: ~ ~ . -... '. . +.+ '. -....... 

12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 

SEER 

- - + .. - .. -

19.0 20.0 21.0 
Life Cyde COlItI MIl Paybadl Perto<h 0I5·tOll, Single PKkage 5ynem Central Heat Pump

;/30/;3

Inc:. InoWied Annual Eloo Ute Annual Cumul. lifooyeJeCoou c::.wnw..tivc

SEI!R HS.PI' ManuI'r Mltluf'r inlWlaocn MaJnICNn" CoNume: CooIin, H..tin& En""y Payback COlt"Conserved En....y

level Docoi&n Cpocn COlt COli COlt COlt COlt .Ol' Poriod (1992$) (C<lllllkWh)

Bwh/W Bwh/W (I 992S) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (1992S) kWh/yr kWhlyr (1992$) I (Y..n) 4~ 6~ 1~ 4~ I~

0 Buclinc 9.70 6.81 $934.00 S1342.86 S46.fH $3593.79 59n 13,966 Sl,fHO NA $22,388 no,011 S16,451 NA NA NA

1 0+ B,oI<w,,1I Inclined IndoorBI_ 9.99 7.00 $934.03 SO.03 S1342.16 S46.fH S3593.86 5803 13.732 SI,656 0.00 $22,004 S19,676 SI6,I88 0.00 0.00 0.01

2 I + Indoor Coil Slit Fino 10.07 7,06 $934.25 SO.22 I S1342.86 S46.fH S3594.38 5757 13,611 SI,642 0.01 $21,847 S19,538 S16,081 0.Q2 0.03 0.04

3 2 + Tun. Delay Relay 10.36 7.19 $940.75 S6.50 S1342.86 S46.fH S3609.72 5597 13,374 SI,608 0.19 $21,488 SI9,227 S15,840 0.31 0.43 0.55

4 3 + S....UCcmpraaar: 11.30 I!ER 11.93 7.57 $965.13 S24.38 S1342.86 S46.fH S3667.26 4861 12,693 SI,481 0.36 $20,210 S18.118 S14,984 0.59 0.68 0.17

5 4 + M<= E.lfici..... Outdoor PSC Pan McIor (65.~ 12.al 7.66 $971.43 S6.30 S1342.86 $39.08 S3674.51 4811 12,545 SI,471 0.37 $20,031 SI7.962 SI4.864 0.62 0.71 0.91

6 5 + Inc:reaao Indoor Coil Fin Doaoily 10 14 fpi 12.09 7.70 $973.16 SI.73 S1342.86 $39.08 S3671.6O 4797 12,484 SI,465 0.38 S19,964 S17.904 S14,819 0.65 0.74 0.94

7 6 + MoM Effici..... lndoor PSC Fan Molar (68.5~) 12.43 7.81 $982.92 S9.76 S1342.86 $31.47 S3694.03 466S 12,308 SI,439 0.40 SI9,689 SI7.666 S14,636 O.fH 0.79 1.00

8 7+o.mand~ 12.43 1.04 $994.42 SII.50 S1342.86 $31.47 S3721.17 466S 11,950 S1,408 0.45 S19,379 SI7,399 SI4,432 0.87 1.00 1.28

9 8 + Non·Bloed Thcm>ooulic&ponalllll VaI_ 12.74 1.28 SI,OI6.08 S21.66 S1342.86 $31.47 S3772.29 4551 11,608 SI,370 0.56 S19,OOO S17.074 SI4,190 1.13 1.29 1.65

10 9 + Inerouo Indoor Coil PI" Ana 10 7.50 aq.ft. 13.10 1.37 SI,033.92 $17.84 S1353.1S $31.47 S3824.68 4424 11.475 SI,348 0.67 SI8,808 S16.913 $14,075 1.34 1.S3 1.96

II 10 + Outdoor Coil GroovedT_ 13.30 8.40 SI,04I.28 S14.36 S1353.1S $31.47 S3158.57 4360 11,438 SI,339 0.75 S18,747 SI6,864' $14,044 1.47 I.fH 2.15

12 II + Increue Ou:.door Coil F...Ana 10 27.30 aq.J\ 13.74 1.63 SI,I06.4O S58.12 SI4al.49 $31.47 S404&.07 4220 11,135 SI,301 1.17 SI8,511 S16,618 SI3.947 2.32 2.66 3.40

13 12 + 1!10C1n>C1ic &ponCcn Valve 13.93 1.68 SI,154.74 $48.34 SI4al.49 $40.45 $4171.13 4161 11,072 SI;291 1.45 SI8.527 S16,711 SI3,992 2.86 3.27 4.11

14 13 + Outdoor ECM Pan MCIC« 14.02 1.79 $1,2.27.44 S72.70 SI4al.49 $48.06 $4350.32 4137 10.936 SI,278 1.13 SI8.555 S16.758 S14,067 3.70 4.23 5.41

15 14 + lncreueOu:.doorCoilF_Ana 1036.50 aq./l 14.20 8.86 SI,295.3O S67.86 S1467.22 $48.06 $4572.20 4084 10.844 SI.26S 2.30 S18,64O SI6,861 $14.196 4.65 5.32 6.79

16 15 + Indoor ECM Fan Melar 14.89 8.95 SI,475.55 $180.25 S1467.22 $63.68 S5013.21 3893 10.733 SI,240 3.15 SI8.796 S17,053 S14,442 6.13 7.01 8.95

17 16 +Two-Sp«d Recip-Compr-..r SyalOm 16.48 8.96 $1.664.30 S181.75 S1467.22 S80.83 S5475.81 3519 10,722 SI,207 3.89 S18,897 SJ7,199 SI4.657 6.89 7.88 10.07

II 16 + VarilbJe-Sp«d Recip-eomp...._ S,....." 16.65 9.49 $2,075.55 $600.00 SI467.22 S133.11 S6498.64 3481 10.127 S1,153 5.41 SI9,323 S17,701 SI5,272 10.47 11.98 15.30

19 16 + Two-Sp«d Sa-oII,C""'P""_ SYIlan 16.78 9.73 SI,975.55 $500.00 SI467.22 S128.74 S6258.27 3454 9,875 SI.I30 4.75 S18,82O SI7,231 S14,852 9.50 10.88 13.89

20 16 + Vari,bl.,.Soeed Sm>U·CanD_... SYIlan 18.59 10.01 $2,125.55 $650.00 SI467.22 S135.29 S66I1.82 3118 9,603 SI.078 4.94 SI8,607 SI7.091 S14,820 9.52 10.89 13.91

Asmmptim.'

I I;lCClricilyeDlt - 0.085 $JkWb (lYonle COlt in 1999 ollIained fran an inlclJlOlatilll ofIh< 1995 Ind 2000 pric:a of dec:llicity forcellt in DOE', AnnUli Ener,y OuUooi 1993, innlltd

10 1992 dollll1). Th. inlIIIpololed yaI". far 1999l.a 0.082 SlkWh (1991 S) or 0.08S after Idjuolinl r...in1IatiOl1 fran 1991 10 1992. The dectricity price end,,"'"tt<rfor CAC l.a 1.0 (no IdjUllmCl1I).

2 lifcdmo _15 y..... Mad<up r""",,-2.36.

3 Budine uni, includoa:

Indoor Coil: 6.00 oqA, 13 finaAncb. WIVY Fino. 4wbe """, Groov. T\lbeo

Outdoor Coil: 19.5 aq.ft., 20 finallndl, Slit Fino, 2 wbe I'OWI, Smooth Tube<

ComPJOOlOr. Rce:iprocatin&, 10.49 EI!R 6lominal): AC<:IlImI1aIOr

Indoor Fan Motor: PSC. 51.510 dIici.....

OIltdoor Pan MClor: psc. 5S.~ oIlidonl

Enltanc:ancn. DovicCII: N....

Maxim\llll S<nIibIe Hat Ratio - 76.510

5 Non·Bloed Th....,....lic 1!>pItIIiaa VaI_ npI_ the noed f.... Tune Delay Rel,y: Accumu1.alor atill roquiJed clue '" ""COlI refrl,ennL'

6 flY'ponl« I!CM Pm Mooor iI IIlo&llllcll. Coat of fan mooor inelud.. electronic moduJatin& conlrDlJ.

7 Ccndenaa I!CM Fan Melar l.a ND II llin&1e opced.

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

Life Cyde Costa IIICI Paybadl Period! 0( 5·tOft, Single Package System CentBi Hut Pump 

Ina. InoWlecl Annual Eloc; U ... Annual Oonul. Lifoc;ycieCoou 

SEI!R H51'!' Manuf'r Manuf'r w\allaticn Main ....... "" Ccnaume: Coolin, Heatina Ene:&Y Payback 

Leyel DeqnOption Coot COlt COOl COOl COOl eoat Puied (1992$) 

Bwh/W BwhiW (l992S) (1992$) (1992$) (1992$) (I992S) kWhlyr kWh/yr (1992$) I (yean) 4~ 6~ I~ 

0 Bueline 9.70 6.81 S'J34.00 - S1342.86 $46.69 S3593.79 S977 13,966 SI,690 NA $22.311 $20,011 SI6,4S1 

I o • B.oIcw.rd Inclined Indoor Blower 9.99 7.00 S'J34.03 SO.03 S1342.86 $46.69 S3593.86 S803 13,732 SI,656 0.00 $22,004 SI9,676 SI6,III 

2 I • Indoor Coil Slit Fino 10.07 7.06 S934.25 SO.22 I S1342.86 $46.69 S3594.31 S757 13,611 SI,642 0.01 $21 ,847 SI9,s38 S16,081 

3 2. Tun. Oeloy Relay 10.36 7.19 S'J4O.75 S6.50 S1342.86 $46.69 S3609.72 5597 13,374 SI,608 0.1 9 S2!,411 SI9,227 SIS,840 

4 3 • Scroll Comprcuor: 11.30 I!ER 11.93 7.57 S965.13 S24.38 SI342.86 $46.69 S3667.26 4861 12,693 SI,488 0.36 $20,210 S1I,I18 S14,984 

5 4 + M"", EIfici ..... Outdoor PSC Fan MoIOr (65 ~ 12.ClS 7.66 S971.43 S6.30 $1342.86 $39.08 53674.51 4811 120545 SI,471 0.37 $20.031 S17,962 S14,864 

6 5 • Inc:reue Indoor Coil Fin DoaIily to 14 (Pi 12.09 7.70 S'J73.16 SI.73 S1342.86 $39.08 $3671.60 4797 12,484 SI,465 0.38 SI9.964 S17,904 S14.819 

7 6 + MoM Effici ..... lndoor PSC Fan _ (68.5") 12.43 7.81 S'J12.92 S9,76 S1342.86 $31,47 S3694.03 466S 12,308 SI,439 0.40 SI9,689 S17,666 S14,636 

8 7.Domand~ 12.43 1.04 $994.42 SI UO S1342.86 $31.47 S3721.1 7 466S ll,95O SI,408 0.45 S19,379 SI7,399 S14,432 

9 8 + Non·Bleed ThcrmoIIatie &ponriCII Val_ 12.74 8.28 SI ,016.08 $21 .66 S1342.86 $31.47 S3772.29 41S1 ll,608 SI,370 0.56 SI9,ooo SI7,074 SI4,I90 

10 9 + Inc::euo Indoor Coil Fa .. Area to 7.50 oq.1I. 13.10 1.37 SI ,033.92 SI7.84 SI353.15 $31.47 S3124.68 4424 11,475 SI,348 0.67 SIB,I08 SI6,913 S14,075 

II 10 + Outdoor Coil Oroovod 'I'Ilboo 13.30 lAO SI ,04I.2I S14.36 S1353.15 $31.47 S38S8.57 4360 ll,438 SI,339 0.75 SIB,747 SI6,864 ' SI4,044 

12 II + 1ncreaae Outdoor Coil F .... Area to 27.30 oql\ 13.74 1.63 SI,I06.4O S58.12 SI4ClS.49 $31.47 S4048.00 4220 11,135 SI,301 1.17 SIB,sII SI6,688 S13,947 

13 12 +l!lot1I'OItic &panaiCll! Valvo 13.93 1.61 SI,154.74 848.34 SI4ClS.49 $40.45 84171.13 4161 11,072 SI;291 1.45 SI8,s27 SI6,711 SI3.992 

14 13 + Outdoor I!CM Fan M .... 14.02 1.79 SI,227.44 $12.70 SI4ClS.49 848.06 84350.32 4137 10,936 SI,278 1.83 SIB,SSS SI6,758 S14.067 

IS 14. 1ncreaao Outdoor Coil F_ Area to 36.50 oq./\ 14.20 U6 SI,295.3O S67.86 S1467.22 848.06 84572.20 4084 10.844 SI,265 2.30 SI8.64O SI6,861 S14.196 

16 15. Indoor ECM Fan MOlar 14.19 8.9S SI,47S.5S SI80.25 SI467.22 $63.68 S5013.21 3893 10,733 SI,240 3.15 SIB.796 S17,053 S14,442 

17 16 + Two-Spocd Rcc:ip.com~ S1I- 16.48 8.96 SI,664.30 S188.75 S1467.22 S80.13 S5475.81 3519 10,722 SI,207 3.89 5IB,897 S17,199 S14,657 

18 16 + Vui.bl .. Spocd Recip-eomp ........ SyNm 16.65 9.49 $2.005.55 $600.00 SI467,22 SI33.11 S6498.64 3481 10,127 SI,IS3 5.41 SI9,323 SI7,701 SI5,271 

19 16 + Two-Spocd Scroll·Camp ....... Sy""" 16.78 9.73 SI,975.55 $500.00 SI467.22 S128.74 S6251.27 3454 9,I7S SI.130 4.75 SII,820 SI7,2JI SI4,152 

2D 16 + Vui,bl ... Spocd Scroll·Ccmp_ar Sy...." 11.59 10m $2,125.55 $650.00 SI467.22 S13S.29 S6618 .82 3118 9,603 SI.oo8 4.94 SII.600 S17,09I SI4,B20 

ASlUlDQtim.' 

I l!ICClricity COlt • 0.085 $",Wh ( ...... e COlI in 1999 obtained from an interpol.uon oC \he 1995 and 2000 prica oC decu:icity Cortellt in DOB', Annu.1 Bntrgy OuUook 1993, inII.ted 

to 1992 dollon). Tholnlerpollted value far 1999 it 0.012 S/ltWh (1991 $) or 0.08S after .djultin. far inJIaUOll from 1991 to 1992. The dCClricity price end .... factor Cor CAC it 1.0 (no .djwuncnt ~ 

2 Lifetimo. IS yom. Mamup C ....... 2.36. 

3 B"dino unit includoo: 

Indoor Coil: 6.00 "I.1\., 13 6naAncb, Wavy Fino, 4 wbe """, Groov. T1Jba 

OuIdoorCoil: 19.5 oq.1I., 20~dl, Slit Fino, 2 WberoWl, Smooth Tubea 

ComprcllOr: RcciprocatiDc, 10.49 EI!R C/lcminal): Ac:c:umulltor 

Indoor Fill Motor: PSC, S8.5 .. eIIId ..... 

Ouldoor Pan Maoor: PSC, 55.0lI0 dIidont 

Enhanoemmt Dovicoo: None 

• Maximum SaWb\e Rat Ratio .76.5 .. 

S Non· Bleed Th=oatie I!opanoi<m VoI_ RpI_ the need Car. Tune Oeloy Rear: Accumulalor ati\I .... uired due to acta rt!ti.<nnL · 

6 I!Y.pontor I!CM Fm M .... 11lI1odu1aa1. c- of fan.,.,..,. intlud .. dCClrorlit moduJatins eontrolJ. 

7 Candc:mcrI!CM Fan MOlar II run •• oin~1pocd. 

CumWltive 

COOl" eon.crved & .... Y 

(centlikWh) 

4~ ~ I~ 

NA NA NA 

0.00 0.00 0.01 

0.Q2 0.03 0.04 

0.38 0.43 0.55 

0.59 0.68 0.87 

0.62 0.71 0.91 

0.65 0.74 0.94 

0.69 0.79 1.00 

0.17 1.00 1.21 

1.13 1.29 1.6S 

1.34 1.53 1.96 

1.47 1.69 2.15 

2.32 2.66 3.40 

2.86 3.27 4.11 

3.70 4.23 5.41 

4.65 S.32 6.79 

6.13 7.01 8.95 

6.89 7.88 10.07 

10.47 11 .98 15.30 

9.50 10.81 13.89 

9.52 10.89 13.91 
9/30/93

Life Cycle Cost for 5-too Single Package System

Central Heat Pump

15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0

-20

14.0

SEER

I - 6% discount rate I

11.0 12.0 13.0

$20,200

I 0

"

$19,800

$19,400

$19,000

--- $18,600

'-'

U

U $18,200

.J

$17,800

$17,400

$17,000

$16,600

9.0 10.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$20,200 0 

$19,800 

$19,400 

$19,000 

,-. 

~ $18,600 

.-4 

'-' 

U U $18,200 

..J 

$17,800 

$17,400 

$17,000 

$16,600 

9.0 10.0 11.0 

9/30/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 5·ton Single Package System 

Central Heat Pump 

• 6% discount rate I 

~~---------------- 20 

12.0 13.0 14.0 

SEER 

15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0 
9/30/93

Life Cycle Cost for 5-ton Single Package System

Central Heat Pump .

---0-- 4% discount rate

17.0 18',0 19.0

- - '6 - - 6% discount rate

....•... - 10% discount rate

15.0 16.0

.' .. .-... .;..;.~~~~~~~~-:.-:.:.. •. ~.- -.... , . -' --- --'..

14.0

SEER

13.0

... . ......... _-.....

12.0

.... " .

••

11.0

••

to.O

~..... .

~, , , , , , ,

'A~,~, __ 6

-- -~~ -~~~---~~- ---~~---------~

+. '.••

$23,000

$22,000

$21,000

$20,000

--. $19,000

N

...., $18,000

U

U

.J $17,000

$16,000

$15,000

$14,000

$13,000

9.0

 CE-RM-93-801 COMMENT 0CC

$23,000 

$22,000 

$21,000 

$20,000 

.-, $19,000 

IA 

M 

~ __ $18,000 

U 

U 

...:l $17,000 

$16,000 

$15,000 

$14,000 

$13,000 

•• 

9.0 

'. 

•• 

to.O 

•• 

11.0 

9/30/93 

Life Cycle Cost for 5-too Single Package System 

. - .... ~ . 

12.0 

•• 

•• 

Central Heat Pump . 

.. ... - - -... ---..... 

13.0 14.0 

SEER 

15.0 

-0--- 4% discount rate 

- - il - - 6% discount rate 

-- --. - - -- 10% discount rate 

• • 

16.0 17.0 18.0 19.0