Rec Tables.xls

Author: Abt Associates Inc.

Created: 9/24/10

Updated 3/24/11

Worksheet Description

regional benefits

tables summarizing species-specific benefits by

regulatory option and region

regional benefits summaries

tables summarizing regional benefits by regulatory

option

Purpose: Summary tables supporting the recreational fishing benefits chapter, appendix, and

analysis

File Info 1 of 32
Baseline Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the California Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

California halibut 38,418.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 196.7 374.6 715.4

Flounders 246.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 1.3 2.4 4.6

Total (Flatfish) 38,664.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 198.0 377.0 720.0

Striped bass 1,209.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 5.0 9.0 15.0

Total (Small Game) 1,209.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 5.0 9.0 15.0

Cabezon 7,158.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 12.8 21.2 35.0

California scorpionfish 58.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.1 0.2 0.3

Croakers 32,132.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 57.5 95.0 157.1

Rockfish 285,002.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 509.8 842.9 1,393.2

Sculpin 111,780.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 200.0 330.6 546.4

Sea bass 512,501.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 916.8 1,515.8 2,505.3

Smelts 21.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.1 0.1

Sunfish 13.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.1

Surfperch 30,172.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 54.0 89.2 147.5

Total (Other Saltwater) 978,837.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 1,751.0 2,895.0 4,785.0

Total (Unidentified) 3,629.0 $1.86 $3.10 $5.18 7.0 11.0 19.0

Total (Undiscounted) 1,022,339.0 . . . 1,960.0 3,292.0 5,539.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,740.0 2,923.0 4,917.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 1,681.0 2,823.0 4,750.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 1 in the California Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

California halibut 71.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 0.0 0.8 1.5

Flounders 22.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 0.0 0.2 0.5

Total (Flatfish) 92.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 0.0 1.0 2.0

Striped bass 0.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Small Game) 0.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 0.0 0.0 0.0

Cabezon 10.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.0

California scorpionfish 50.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.1 0.1 0.2

Croakers 4,696.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 8.4 13.9 23.0

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

regional benefits 2 of 32
Rockfish 636.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 1.1 1.9 3.1

Sculpin 3,284.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 5.8 9.7 16.1

Sea bass 284.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.5 0.8 1.4

Smelts 17.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.1 0.1

Sunfish 1.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.0

Surfperch 26,391.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 47.0 78.3 129.1

Total (Other Saltwater) 35,369.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 63.0 105.0 173.0

Total (Unidentified) 976.0 $1.86 $3.10 $5.18 2.0 3.0 5.0

Total (Undiscounted) 36,438.0 . . . 66.0 109.0 180.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 51.0 85.0 141.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 46.0 75.0 125.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 2 in the California Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

California halibut 32,753.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 167.9 319.9 610.0

Flounders 213.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 1.1 2.1 4.0

Total (Flatfish) 32,967.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 169.0 322.0 614.0

Striped bass 1,031.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 4.0 7.0 13.0

Total (Small Game) 1,031.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 4.0 7.0 13.0

Cabezon 6,103.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 10.9 18.0 29.8

California scorpionfish 57.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.1 0.2 0.3

Croakers 28,097.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 50.3 83.1 137.3

Rockfish 242,999.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 434.7 718.6 1,187.8

Sculpin 95,765.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 171.3 283.2 468.1

Sea bass 436,840.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 781.5 1,291.9 2,135.3

Smelts 20.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.1 0.1

Sunfish 12.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.1

Surfperch 29,711.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 53.2 87.9 145.2

Total (Other Saltwater) 839,604.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 1,502.0 2,483.0 4,104.0

Total (Unidentified) 3,240.0 $1.86 $3.10 $5.18 6.0 10.0 17.0

Total (Undiscounted) 876,841.0 . . . 1,681.0 2,822.0 4,748.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,037.0 1,741.0 2,929.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 792.0 1,330.0 2,237.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 3 in the California Region (harvestable adult fish)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 3 of 32
5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

California halibut 34,260.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 174.9 333.8 637.9

Flounders 222.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 1.1 2.2 4.1

Total (Flatfish) 34,482.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 176.0 336.0 642.0

Striped bass 1,078.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 5.0 8.0 13.0

Total (Small Game) 1,078.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 5.0 8.0 13.0

Cabezon 6,383.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 11.4 18.9 31.2

California scorpionfish 57.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.1 0.2 0.3

Croakers 29,198.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 52.2 86.3 142.7

Rockfish 254,174.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 454.5 751.6 1,242.4

Sculpin 100,044.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 178.9 295.9 489.0

Sea bass 456,964.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 817.2 1,351.3 2,233.6

Smelts 21.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.1 0.1

Sunfish 12.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.1

Surfperch 29,987.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 53.6 88.7 146.6

Total (Other Saltwater) 876,840.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 1,568.0 2,593.0 4,286.0

Total (Unidentified) 3,349.0 $1.86 $3.10 $5.18 6.0 10.0 17.0

Total (Undiscounted) 915,750.0 . . . 1,755.0 2,948.0 4,959.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,096.0 1,840.0 3,095.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 832.0 1,396.0 2,349.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 4 in the California Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

California halibut 69.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 0.0 0.8 1.5

Flounders 21.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 0.0 0.2 0.5

Total (Flatfish) 90.0 $5.11 $9.76 $18.62 0.0 1.0 2.0

Striped bass 0.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Small Game) 0.0 $4.21 $7.26 $12.43 0.0 0.0 0.0

Cabezon 10.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.0

California scorpionfish 49.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.1 0.1 0.2

Croakers 4,565.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 8.1 13.5 22.3

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 4 of 32
Rockfish 618.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 1.1 1.8 3.0

Sculpin 3,192.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 5.7 9.5 15.6

Sea bass 276.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.5 0.8 1.3

Smelts 16.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.1

Sunfish 1.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 0.0 0.0 0.0

Surfperch 25,654.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 45.5 76.1 125.4

Total (Other Saltwater) 34,382.0 $1.79 $2.96 $4.89 61.0 102.0 168.0

Total (Unidentified) 949.0 $1.86 $3.10 $5.18 2.0 3.0 5.0

Total (Undiscounted) 35,421.0 . . . 64.0 106.0 175.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 50.0 83.0 137.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 44.0 73.0 121.0

Baseline Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the North Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Winter flounder 310,442.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 1,182.0 1,850.0 2,925.0

Total (flatfish) 310,442.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 1,182.0 1,850.0 2,925.0

Atlantic mackerel 903.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 1.9 5.8 15.4

Bluefish 1.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Striped bass 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Weakfish 33.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.1 0.2 0.6

Total (small game) 937.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 2.0 6.0 16.0

Atlantic Cod 1,281.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 2.3 3.8 6.4

Cunner 107,374.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 191.9 320.2 533.7

Pollock 4.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sculpin 323,088.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 577.5 963.4 1,606.0

Scup 128.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.2 0.4 0.6

Searobin 823.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 1.5 2.5 4.1

Tautog 14,323.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 25.6 42.7 71.2

White Perch 0.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (other saltwater) 447,021.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 799.0 1,333.0 2,222.0

Total (unidentified) 2,783.0 $1.80 $3.01 $5.03 5.0 8.0 14.0

Total (Undiscounted) 761,183.0 . . . 1,988.0 3,197.0 5,177.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,765.0 2,838.0 4,596.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 1,705.0 2,742.0 4,440.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 1 in the North Atlantic (harvestable adult fish)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 5 of 32
5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Winter flounder 836.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 3.0 5.0 8.0

Total (flatfish) 836.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 3.0 5.0 8.0

Atlantic mackerel 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluefish 1.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Striped bass 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Weakfish 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (small game) 1.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Atlantic Cod 40.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.1 0.1 0.2

Cunner 19.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.1

Pollock 1.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sculpin 345.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.7 0.7 1.4

Scup 8.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Searobin 45.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.1 0.1 0.2

Tautog 17.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.1

White Perch 0.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (other saltwater) 476.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (unidentified) 181.0 $1.80 $3.01 $5.03 0.0 1.0 1.0

Total (Undiscounted) 1,495.0 . . . 4.0 7.0 11.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 3.0 5.0 9.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 3.0 5.0 8.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 2 in the North Atlantic (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Winter flounder 253,297.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 964.0 1,510.0 2,387.0

Total (flatfish) 253,297.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 964.0 1,510.0 2,387.0

Atlantic mackerel 736.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 1.9 4.8 12.5

Bluefish 1.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Striped bass 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Weakfish 27.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.1 0.2 0.5

Total (small game) 764.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 2.0 5.0 13.0

Atlantic Cod 1,054.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 1.9 3.1 5.2

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 6 of 32
Cunner 87,542.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 156.6 261.0 435.1

Pollock 3.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sculpin 263,485.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 471.2 785.6 1,309.6

Scup 106.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.2 0.3 0.5

Searobin 682.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 1.2 2.0 3.4

Tautog 11,681.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 20.9 34.8 58.1

White Perch 0.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (other saltwater) 364,555.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 652.0 1,087.0 1,812.0

Total (unidentified) 2,313.0 $1.80 $3.01 $5.03 4.0 7.0 12.0

Total (Undiscounted) 620,929.0 . . . 1,622.0 2,608.0 4,223.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 939.0 1,510.0 2,446.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 698.0 1,122.0 1,817.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 3 in the North Atlantic (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Winter flounder 265,676.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 1,012.0 1,583.0 2,503.0

Total (flatfish) 265,676.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 1,012.0 1,583.0 2,503.0

Atlantic mackerel 772.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 1.9 4.8 12.5

Bluefish 1.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Striped bass 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Weakfish 29.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.1 0.2 0.5

Total (small game) 801.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 2.0 5.0 13.0

Atlantic Cod 1,104.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 2.0 3.3 5.5

Cunner 91,836.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 164.3 273.8 456.5

Pollock 3.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sculpin 276,392.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 494.4 823.9 1,374.0

Scup 111.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.2 0.3 0.6

Searobin 713.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 1.3 2.1 3.5

Tautog 12,253.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 21.9 36.5 60.9

White Perch 0.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (other saltwater) 382,413.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 684.0 1,140.0 1,901.0

Total (unidentified) 2,417.0 $1.80 $3.01 $5.03 4.0 7.0 12.0

Total (Undiscounted) 651,307.0 . . . 1,701.0 2,736.0 4,430.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,018.0 1,638.0 2,652.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 756.0 1,216.0 1,969.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 4 in the North Atlantic (harvestable adult fish)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 7 of 32
5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Winter flounder 836.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 3.0 5.0 8.0

Total (flatfish) 836.0 $3.81 $5.96 $9.42 3.0 5.0 8.0

Atlantic mackerel 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluefish 1.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Striped bass 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Weakfish 0.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (small game) 1.0 $2.13 $5.94 $16.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Atlantic Cod 40.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.1 0.1 0.2

Cunner 19.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.1

Pollock 1.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sculpin 345.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.7 0.7 1.4

Scup 8.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Searobin 45.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.1 0.1 0.2

Tautog 17.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.1

White Perch 0.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (other saltwater) 476.0 $1.79 $2.98 $4.97 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (unidentified) 181.0 $1.80 $3.01 $5.03 0.0 1.0 1.0

Total (Undiscounted) 1,495.0 . . . 4.0 7.0 11.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 3.0 5.0 9.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 3.0 5.0 8.0

Baseline Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Mid-Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Summer Flounder 5,310.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 19.7 30.0 45.0

Winter Flounder 4,946.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 18.3 28.0 42.0

Total (Flatfish) 10,256.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 38.0 58.0 87.0

Black Crappie 3.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 16.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Brown bullhead 3,847.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.9 3.9 8.2

Bullhead 11.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 8 of 32
Channel catfish 2,891.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.5 2.9 6.2

Crappie 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Menhaden 966.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.5 1.0 2.1

Sunfish 221.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.1 0.2 0.5

Total (Panfish) 7,956.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 4.0 8.0 17.0

Bluefish 126.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 0.3 0.7 2.0

Red drum 2,667.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 6.0 15.7 41.4

Spotted seatrout 1,768.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 4.0 10.4 27.4

Striped bass 166,917.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 377.4 985.1 2,589.8

Weakfish 459,710.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 1,039.3 2,713.0 7,132.5

Total (Small Game) 631,187.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 1,427.0 3,725.0 9,793.0

Northern pike 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Atlantic croaker 1,782,932.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 3,304.3 5,205.0 8,205.4

Atlantic herring 57.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.2 0.3

Black drum 255.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.5 0.7 1.2

Cunner 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Scup 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Searobin 8.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Smallmouth bass 57.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.2 0.3

Spot 5,388,053.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 9,985.6 15,729.6 24,796.9

Striped mullet 12.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.1

Tautog 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

White perch 33,237.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 61.6 97.0 153.0

Whitefish 426.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.8 1.2 2.0

Total (Other Saltwater) 7,205,039.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 13,353.0 21,034.0 33,159.0

Total (Unidentified) 1,226,622.0 $1.91 $3.24 $5.74 2,344.0 3,978.0 7,036.0

Total (Undiscounted) 9,081,061.0 . . . 17,166.0 28,803.0 50,092.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 15,239.0 25,569.0 44,467.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 14,721.0 24,701.0 42,958.0

Reductions in Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities for Option 1 in the Mid-Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Summer Flounder 4,051.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 15.1 23.1 34.7

Winter Flounder 499.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 1.9 2.9 4.3

Total (Flatfish) 4,550.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 17.0 26.0 39.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 9 of 32
Black Crappie 3.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 12.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Brown bullhead 787.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.5 0.7 1.7

Bullhead 8.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Channel catfish 2,205.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.4 2.1 4.8

Crappie 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Menhaden 0.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sunfish 169.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.1 0.2 0.4

Total (Panfish) 3,185.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.0 3.0 7.0

Bluefish 96.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 0.2 0.6 1.5

Red drum 2,035.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 4.6 12.0 31.6

Spotted seatrout 1,349.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 3.0 8.0 20.9

Striped bass 796.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 1.8 4.7 12.4

Weakfish 121,529.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 274.3 716.8 1,885.7

Total (Small Game) 125,805.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 284.0 742.0 1,952.0

Northern pike 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Atlantic croaker 19,396.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 35.9 56.6 89.3

Atlantic herring 43.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.1 0.2

Black drum 195.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.4 0.6 0.9

Cunner 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Scup 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Searobin 5.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Smallmouth bass 44.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.1 0.2

Spot 318,070.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 589.2 928.2 1,464.2

Striped mullet 9.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Tautog 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

White perch 2,541.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 4.7 7.4 11.7

Whitefish 325.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.6 0.9 1.5

Total (Other Saltwater) 340,629.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 631.0 994.0 1,568.0

Total (Unidentified) 74,846.0 $1.91 $3.24 $5.74 143.0 243.0 429.0

Total (Undiscounted) 549,015.0 . . . 1,077.0 2,009.0 3,994.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 846.0 1,577.0 3,136.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 749.0 1,396.0 2,776.0

Reductions in Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities for Option 2 in the Mid-Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

regional benefits 10 of 32
5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Summer Flounder 5,180.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 19.1 29.2 44.1

Winter Flounder 4,569.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 16.9 25.8 38.9

Total (Flatfish) 9,749.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 36.0 55.0 83.0

Black Crappie 3.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 16.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Brown bullhead 3,585.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.9 3.8 7.6

Bullhead 10.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Channel catfish 2,820.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.5 3.0 6.0

Crappie 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Menhaden 885.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.5 0.9 1.9

Sunfish 216.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.1 0.2 0.5

Total (Panfish) 7,536.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 4.0 8.0 16.0

Bluefish 123.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 0.3 0.7 1.9

Red drum 2,602.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 5.9 15.4 40.4

Spotted seatrout 1,724.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 3.9 10.2 26.7

Striped bass 152,927.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 345.7 902.6 2,372.8

Weakfish 430,538.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 973.2 2,541.1 6,680.2

Total (Small Game) 587,915.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 1,329.0 3,470.0 9,122.0

Northern pike 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Atlantic croaker 1,634,350.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 3,028.8 4,771.2 7,521.5

Atlantic herring 55.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.2 0.3

Black drum 249.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.5 0.7 1.1

Cunner 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Scup 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Searobin 8.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Smallmouth bass 56.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.2 0.3

Spot 4,959,382.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 9,190.9 14,478.0 22,823.8

Striped mullet 12.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.1

Tautog 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

White perch 30,638.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 56.8 89.4 141.0

Whitefish 415.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.8 1.2 1.9

Total (Other Saltwater) 6,625,167.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 12,278.0 19,341.0 30,490.0

Total (Unidentified) 1,129,224.0 $1.91 $3.24 $5.74 2,158.0 3,662.0 6,477.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 11 of 32
Total (Undiscounted) 8,359,591.0 . . . 15,805.0 26,536.0 46,188.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 8,381.0 14,073.0 24,501.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 5,831.0 9,792.0 17,049.0

Reductions in Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities for Option 3 in the Mid-Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Summer Flounder 5,198.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 19.6 29.1 44.5

Winter Flounder 4,622.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 17.4 25.9 39.5

Total (Flatfish) 9,820.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 37.0 55.0 84.0

Black Crappie 3.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 16.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Brown bullhead 3,622.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.9 3.8 7.6

Bullhead 10.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Channel catfish 2,830.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.5 3.0 6.0

Crappie 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Menhaden 896.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.5 0.9 1.9

Sunfish 216.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.1 0.2 0.5

Total (Panfish) 7,595.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 4.0 8.0 16.0

Bluefish 123.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 0.3 0.7 1.9

Red drum 2,611.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 5.9 15.4 40.5

Spotted seatrout 1,730.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 3.9 10.2 26.8

Striped bass 154,871.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 350.2 914.0 2,402.9

Weakfish 434,593.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 982.7 2,564.7 6,742.8

Total (Small Game) 593,930.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 1,343.0 3,505.0 9,215.0

Northern pike 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Atlantic croaker 1,655,004.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 3,067.0 4,831.4 7,616.6

Atlantic herring 55.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.2 0.3

Black drum 250.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.5 0.7 1.2

Cunner 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Scup 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Searobin 8.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Smallmouth bass 56.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.2 0.3

Spot 5,018,970.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 9,301.1 14,651.8 23,098.1

Striped mullet 12.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.1

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 12 of 32
Tautog 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

White perch 30,999.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 57.4 90.5 142.7

Whitefish 417.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.8 1.2 1.9

Total (Other Saltwater) 6,705,773.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 12,427.0 19,576.0 30,861.0

Total (Unidentified) 1,142,763.0 $1.91 $3.24 $5.74 2,183.0 3,706.0 6,555.0

Total (Undiscounted) 8,459,880.0 . . . 15,995.0 26,851.0 46,731.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 8,584.0 14,410.0 25,078.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 5,975.0 10,030.0 17,456.0

Reductions in Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities for Option 4 in the Mid-Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Summer Flounder 4,047.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 15.1 23.1 34.7

Winter Flounder 499.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 1.9 2.9 4.3

Total (Flatfish) 4,546.0 $3.74 $5.62 $8.52 17.0 26.0 39.0

Black Crappie 3.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 12.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Brown bullhead 786.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.5 0.7 1.7

Bullhead 8.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Channel catfish 2,203.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.4 2.1 4.8

Crappie 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Menhaden 0.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sunfish 169.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.1 0.2 0.4

Total (Panfish) 3,182.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.0 3.0 7.0

Bluefish 96.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 0.2 0.6 1.5

Red drum 2,033.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 4.6 12.0 31.5

Spotted seatrout 1,347.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 3.0 8.0 20.9

Striped bass 796.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 1.8 4.7 12.3

Weakfish 121,415.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 274.3 716.8 1,883.7

Total (Small Game) 125,687.0 $2.26 $5.90 $15.52 284.0 742.0 1,950.0

Northern pike 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 0.0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 0.0 0.0 0.0

Atlantic croaker 19,377.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 35.9 56.5 89.2

Atlantic herring 43.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.1 0.2

Black drum 195.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.4 0.6 0.9

Cunner 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Scup 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 13 of 32
Searobin 5.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 1.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Smallmouth bass 44.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.1 0.1 0.2

Spot 317,770.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 589.2 927.2 1,462.3

Striped mullet 9.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

Tautog 0.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.0 0.0 0.0

White perch 2,538.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 4.7 7.4 11.7

Whitefish 324.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 0.6 0.9 1.5

Total (Other Saltwater) 340,307.0 $1.85 $2.92 $4.60 631.0 993.0 1,566.0

Total (Unidentified) 74,775.0 $1.91 $3.24 $5.74 143.0 243.0 429.0

Total (Undiscounted) 548,496.0 . . . 1,076.0 2,007.0 3,991.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 845.0 1,576.0 3,133.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 748.0 1,395.0 2,773.0

Baseline Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the South Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Flounders 778.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 3.0 4.0 6.0

Total (Flatfish) 778.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 3.0 4.0 6.0

Spotted seatrout 1,898.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 4.8 10.5 22.6

Weakfish 455.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 1.2 2.5 5.4

Total (Small Game) 2,353.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 6.0 13.0 28.0

Croakers 96,913.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 207.6 276.1 365.6

Pinfish 1,518.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 3.3 4.3 5.7

Silver perch 76.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 0.2 0.2 0.3

Spot 30,313.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 64.9 86.4 114.4

Total (Other Saltwater) 128,820.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 276.0 367.0 486.0

Total (Unidentified) 1,945.0 $2.15 $2.86 $3.82 4.0 6.0 7.0

Total (Undiscounted) 133,897.0 . . . 290.0 390.0 529.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 257.0 346.0 469.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 249.0 335.0 453.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 1 in the South Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 14 of 32
5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Flounders 491.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 2.0 3.0 4.0

Total (Flatfish) 491.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 2.0 3.0 4.0

Spotted seatrout 0.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 0.0 0.0 0.0

Weakfish 224.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 1.0 1.0 3.0

Total (Small Game) 224.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 1.0 1.0 3.0

Croakers 1,762.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 3.8 5.0 6.7

Pinfish 0.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 48.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 0.1 0.1 0.2

Spot 12,733.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 27.1 35.9 48.2

Total (Other Saltwater) 14,543.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 31.0 41.0 55.0

Total (Unidentified) 624.0 $2.15 $2.86 $3.82 1.0 2.0 2.0

Total (Undiscounted) 15,882.0 . . . 35.0 47.0 64.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 28.0 37.0 50.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 24.0 33.0 45.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 2 in the South Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Flounders 663.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 3.0 4.0 5.0

Total (Flatfish) 663.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 3.0 4.0 5.0

Spotted seatrout 1,583.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 4.0 8.8 19.3

Weakfish 386.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 1.0 2.2 4.7

Total (Small Game) 1,969.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 5.0 11.0 24.0

Croakers 80,881.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 173.2 230.2 305.2

Pinfish 1,266.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 2.7 3.6 4.8

Silver perch 65.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 0.1 0.2 0.2

Spot 25,654.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 54.9 73.0 96.8

Total (Other Saltwater) 107,866.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 231.0 307.0 407.0

Total (Unidentified) 1,641.0 $2.15 $2.86 $3.82 4.0 5.0 6.0

Total (Undiscounted) 112,139.0 . . . 243.0 327.0 443.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 141.0 190.0 257.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 103.0 139.0 188.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 3 in the South Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

fish)

regional benefits 15 of 32
5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Flounders 663.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 3.0 4.0 5.0

Total (Flatfish) 663.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 3.0 4.0 5.0

Spotted seatrout 1,586.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 4.0 8.8 19.3

Weakfish 387.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 1.0 2.2 4.7

Total (Small Game) 1,972.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 5.0 11.0 24.0

Croakers 81,012.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 174.0 231.0 306.0

Pinfish 1,268.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 2.7 3.6 4.8

Silver perch 65.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 0.1 0.2 0.2

Spot 25,677.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 55.1 73.2 97.0

Total (Other Saltwater) 108,023.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 232.0 308.0 408.0

Total (Unidentified) 1,642.0 $2.15 $2.86 $3.82 4.0 5.0 6.0

Total (Undiscounted) 112,301.0 . . . 243.0 327.0 443.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 141.0 190.0 257.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 103.0 139.0 188.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 4 in the South Atlantic Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Flounders 491.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 2.0 3.0 4.0

Total (Flatfish) 491.0 $3.87 $5.61 $8.28 2.0 3.0 4.0

Spotted seatrout 0.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 0.0 0.0 0.0

Weakfish 224.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 1.0 1.0 3.0

Total (Small Game) 224.0 $2.72 $5.72 $12.04 1.0 1.0 3.0

Croakers 1,762.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 3.8 5.0 6.7

Pinfish 0.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 48.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 0.1 0.1 0.2

Spot 12,733.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 27.1 35.9 48.2

Total (Other Saltwater) 14,543.0 $2.14 $2.85 $3.78 31.0 41.0 55.0

Total (Unidentified) 624.0 $2.15 $2.86 $3.82 1.0 2.0 2.0

Total (Undiscounted) 15,882.0 . . . 35.0 47.0 64.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 28.0 37.0 50.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 16 of 32
Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 24.0 33.0 45.0

Baseline Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Gulf of Mexico Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Mackerels 1,156.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 3.3 6.5 12.8

Red drum 26,719.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 76.6 150.4 294.9

Spotted seatrout 512,503.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,470.0 2,885.1 5,656.4

Total (Small Game) 540,378.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,550.0 3,042.0 5,964.0

Atlantic croaker 179,036.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 382.3 497.3 646.6

Black drum 1,542,661.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 3,294.3 4,284.6 5,571.5

Pinfish 257,750.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 550.4 715.9 930.9

Sea bass 119.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.3 0.3 0.4

Searobin 118,160.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 252.3 328.2 426.7

Sheepshead 46.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.1 0.1 0.2

Silver perch 1,474.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 3.1 4.1 5.3

Spot 30,308.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 64.7 84.2 109.5

Striped mullet 49,804.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 106.4 138.3 179.9

Total (Other Saltwater) 2,179,358.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 4,654.0 6,053.0 7,871.0

Total (Unidentified) 131,612.0 $2.36 $3.66 $5.91 311.0 482.0 778.0

Total (Undiscounted) 2,851,347.0 . . . 6,515.0 9,576.0 14,612.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 6,022.0 8,852.0 13,506.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 5,999.0 8,818.0 13,456.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 1 in the Gulf of Mexico Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Mackerels 885.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 2.5 5.0 9.8

Red drum 17,368.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 49.8 97.8 191.7

Spotted seatrout 351,547.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,008.6 1,979.2 3,879.6

Total (Small Game) 369,800.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,061.0 2,082.0 4,081.0

Atlantic croaker 136,979.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 292.8 380.2 494.6

Black drum 2,576.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 5.5 7.1 9.3

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 17 of 32
Pinfish 5,161.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 11.0 14.3 18.6

Sea bass 91.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.2 0.3 0.3

Searobin 65,096.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 139.1 180.7 235.0

Sheepshead 0.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 59.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.1 0.2 0.2

Spot 18,785.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 40.1 52.1 67.8

Striped mullet 4,732.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 10.1 13.1 17.1

Total (Other Saltwater) 233,480.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 499.0 648.0 843.0

Total (Unidentified) 62,417.0 $2.36 $3.66 $5.91 147.0 228.0 369.0

Total (Undiscounted) 665,697.0 . . . 1,707.0 2,959.0 5,293.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,398.0 2,422.0 4,334.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 1,275.0 2,210.0 3,953.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 2 in the Gulf of Mexico Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Mackerels 1,148.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 3.3 6.5 12.7

Red drum 25,256.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 72.5 142.2 278.7

Spotted seatrout 492,047.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,412.2 2,770.3 5,430.6

Total (Small Game) 518,450.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,488.0 2,919.0 5,722.0

Atlantic croaker 177,750.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 379.5 493.6 642.0

Black drum 1,044,602.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 2,230.5 2,900.8 3,772.7

Pinfish 176,490.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 376.9 490.1 637.4

Sea bass 119.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.3 0.3 0.4

Searobin 106,846.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 228.1 296.7 385.9

Sheepshead 31.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.1 0.1 0.1

Silver perch 1,021.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 2.2 2.8 3.7

Spot 28,270.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 60.4 78.5 102.1

Striped mullet 35,647.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 76.1 99.0 128.7

Total (Other Saltwater) 1,570,775.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 3,354.0 4,362.0 5,673.0

Total (Unidentified) 114,838.0 $2.36 $3.66 $5.91 271.0 420.0 679.0

Total (Undiscounted) 2,204,063.0 . . . 5,113.0 7,701.0 12,073.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 3,225.0 4,866.0 7,642.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 2,491.0 3,760.0 5,908.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 3 in the Gulf of Mexico Region (harvestable adult fish)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 18 of 32
5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Mackerels 1,149.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 3.3 6.5 12.7

Red drum 25,279.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 72.5 142.3 279.0

Spotted seatrout 492,479.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,413.2 2,772.2 5,435.3

Total (Small Game) 518,907.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,489.0 2,921.0 5,727.0

Atlantic croaker 177,884.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 379.8 494.1 642.4

Black drum 1,047,164.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 2,235.9 2,908.4 3,781.9

Pinfish 176,912.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 377.7 491.4 638.9

Sea bass 119.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.3 0.3 0.4

Searobin 106,965.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 228.4 297.1 386.3

Sheepshead 31.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.1 0.1 0.1

Silver perch 1,024.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 2.2 2.8 3.7

Spot 28,298.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 60.4 78.6 102.2

Striped mullet 35,724.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 76.3 99.2 129.0

Total (Other Saltwater) 1,574,119.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 3,361.0 4,372.0 5,685.0

Total (Unidentified) 114,982.0 $2.36 $3.66 $5.91 272.0 421.0 680.0

Total (Undiscounted) 2,208,009.0 . . . 5,122.0 7,714.0 12,091.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 3,258.0 4,906.0 7,690.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 2,510.0 3,781.0 5,926.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 4 in the Gulf of Mexico Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Mackerels 878.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 2.5 4.9 9.7

Red drum 17,237.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 49.5 97.0 190.2

Spotted seatrout 348,894.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,001.0 1,964.0 3,850.1

Total (Small Game) 367,009.0 $2.87 $5.63 $11.04 1,053.0 2,066.0 4,050.0

Atlantic croaker 135,945.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 290.4 377.8 491.1

Black drum 2,556.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 5.5 7.1 9.2

Pinfish 5,122.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 10.9 14.2 18.5

Sea bass 91.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.2 0.3 0.3

Searobin 64,604.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 138.0 179.6 233.4

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 19 of 32
Sheepshead 0.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

Silver perch 58.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 0.1 0.2 0.2

Spot 18,644.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 39.8 51.8 67.3

Striped mullet 4,696.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 10.0 13.1 17.0

Total (Other Saltwater) 231,717.0 $2.14 $2.78 $3.61 495.0 644.0 837.0

Total (Unidentified) 61,946.0 $2.36 $3.66 $5.91 146.0 227.0 366.0

Total (Undiscounted) 660,672.0 . . . 1,694.0 2,936.0 5,253.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,387.0 2,404.0 4,301.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 1,265.0 2,193.0 3,923.0

Baseline Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Great Lakes Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 23.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 0.1 203.0 394.0

White bass 23,688.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 104.9 203.0 394.0

Total (Bass) 23,710.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 105.0 203.0 394.0

Whitefish 69,428.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 424.0 655.0 1,018.0

Total (Other Trout) 69,428.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 424.0 655.0 1,018.0

Black crappie 11.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 27.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.1

Channel catfish 571.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.4 0.8 1.4

Crappie 4,785.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 3.3 6.3 12.0

Rainbow smelt 5,802.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 4.1 7.7 14.5

Sculpin 6,516.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 4.6 8.6 16.3

Smelts 14,657.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 10.2 19.3 36.6

Sunfish 13,996.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 9.8 18.5 35.0

Yellow perch 18,055.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 12.6 23.8 45.1

Total (Panfish) 64,420.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 45.0 85.0 161.0

Salmon 1,253.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 10.0 17.0 27.0

Total (Salmon) 1,253.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 10.0 17.0 27.0

Northern Pike 0.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 0.0 0.0

Walleye 250.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 250.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Unidentified) 190,587.0 $3.33 $6.22 $11.71 635.0 1,185.0 2,232.0

Total (Undiscounted) 349,648.0 . . . 1,219.0 2,146.0 3,834.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 1,127.0 1,984.0 3,544.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 1,123.0 1,977.0 3,530.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 20 of 32
Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 1 in the Great Lakes Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 19.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 0.1 60.0 116.0

White bass 6,939.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 30.9 60.0 116.0

Total (Bass) 6,958.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 31.0 60.0 116.0

Whitefish 60,141.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 367.0 567.0 882.0

Total (Other Trout) 60,141.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 367.0 567.0 882.0

Black crappie 9.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 23.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.1

Channel catfish 460.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.3 0.6 1.1

Crappie 112.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.1 0.1 0.3

Rainbow smelt 4,248.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 2.9 5.6 10.6

Sculpin 290.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.2 0.4 0.7

Smelts 12,641.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 8.7 16.6 31.6

Sunfish 192.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.1 0.3 0.5

Yellow perch 12,437.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 8.6 16.4 31.1

Total (Panfish) 30,413.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 21.0 40.0 76.0

Salmon 845.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 7.0 11.0 18.0

Total (Salmon) 845.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 7.0 11.0 18.0

Northern Pike 0.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 0.0 0.0

Walleye 217.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 217.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Unidentified) 77,515.0 $3.33 $6.22 $11.71 258.0 482.0 908.0

Total (Undiscounted) 176,089.0 . . . 685.0 1,162.0 2,001.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 561.0 951.0 1,638.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 511.0 867.0 1,495.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 2 in the Great Lakes Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 21 of 32
Smallmouth bass 22.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 0.1 175.0 340.0

White bass 20,444.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 90.9 175.0 340.0

Total (Bass) 20,466.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 91.0 175.0 340.0

Whitefish 68,676.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 419.0 648.0 1,007.0

Total (Other Trout) 68,676.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 419.0 648.0 1,007.0

Black crappie 10.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 27.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.1

Channel catfish 557.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.4 0.7 1.4

Crappie 3,846.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 2.7 5.1 9.6

Rainbow smelt 5,568.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 3.9 7.4 13.9

Sculpin 5,267.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 3.7 7.0 13.1

Smelts 14,487.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 10.2 19.2 36.1

Sunfish 11,220.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 7.9 14.9 28.0

Yellow perch 17,155.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 12.1 22.7 42.8

Total (Panfish) 58,137.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 41.0 77.0 145.0

Salmon 1,187.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 10.0 16.0 26.0

Total (Salmon) 1,187.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 10.0 16.0 26.0

Northern Pike 0.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 0.0 0.0

Walleye 247.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 248.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Unidentified) 169,259.0 $3.33 $6.22 $11.71 564.0 1,053.0 1,982.0

Total (Undiscounted) 317,974.0 . . . 1,124.0 1,970.0 3,502.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 720.0 1,261.0 2,241.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 559.0 979.0 1,739.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 3 in the Great Lakes Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 23.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 0.1 177.0 343.0

White bass 20,651.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 90.9 177.0 343.0

Total (Bass) 20,674.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 91.0 177.0 343.0

Whitefish 68,832.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 420.0 649.0 1,009.0

Total (Other Trout) 68,832.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 420.0 649.0 1,009.0

Black crappie 10.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 27.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.1

Channel catfish 559.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.4 0.7 1.4

Crappie 3,902.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 2.7 5.2 9.7

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 22 of 32
Rainbow smelt 5,590.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 3.9 7.4 13.9

Sculpin 5,343.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 3.7 7.1 13.3

Smelts 14,520.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 10.2 19.3 36.2

Sunfish 11,386.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 8.0 15.2 28.4

Yellow perch 17,232.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 12.1 22.9 43.0

Total (Panfish) 58,570.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 41.0 78.0 146.0

Salmon 1,192.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 10.0 16.0 26.0

Total (Salmon) 1,192.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 10.0 16.0 26.0

Northern Pike 0.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 0.0 0.0

Walleye 248.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 248.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 1.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Unidentified) 170,680.0 $3.33 $6.22 $11.71 569.0 1,062.0 1,999.0

Total (Undiscounted) 320,196.0 . . . 1,131.0 1,982.0 3,526.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 725.0 1,271.0 2,261.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 561.0 984.0 1,750.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 4 in the Great Lakes Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 19.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 0.1 59.0 115.0

White bass 6,880.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 30.9 59.0 115.0

Total (Bass) 6,900.0 $4.42 $8.56 $16.61 31.0 59.0 115.0

Whitefish 59,632.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 364.0 563.0 874.0

Total (Other Trout) 59,632.0 $6.10 $9.43 $14.66 364.0 563.0 874.0

Black crappie 9.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.0

Bluegill 23.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.0 0.0 0.1

Channel catfish 456.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.3 0.6 1.1

Crappie 111.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.1 0.1 0.3

Rainbow smelt 4,212.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 2.9 5.6 10.5

Sculpin 287.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.2 0.4 0.7

Smelts 12,534.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 8.7 16.6 31.2

Sunfish 190.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 0.1 0.3 0.5

Yellow perch 12,332.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 8.6 16.4 30.7

Total (Panfish) 30,156.0 $0.70 $1.33 $2.50 21.0 40.0 75.0

Salmon 838.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 7.0 11.0 18.0

Total (Salmon) 838.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 7.0 11.0 18.0

Northern Pike 0.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 0.0 0.0

Walleye 215.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 1.0 2.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 23 of 32
Total (Walleye/Pike) 215.0 $2.18 $4.11 $7.80 0.0 1.0 2.0

Total (Unidentified) 76,860.0 $3.33 $6.22 $11.71 256.0 478.0 900.0

Total (Undiscounted) 174,601.0 . . . 679.0 1,152.0 1,984.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 556.0 943.0 1,624.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 507.0 860.0 1,482.0

Baseline Recreational Fishing Losses from IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Inland Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 190,994.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 818.3 1,721.3 3,643.5

White bass 1,656,537.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 7,097.7 14,929.7 31,600.6

Total (Bass) 1,847,530.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 7,916.0 16,651.0 35,244.0

Whitefish 2,061.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 3.0 6.0 11.0

Total (Other Trout) 2,061.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 3.0 6.0 11.0

Black bullhead 31,025.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 16.4 32.8 65.3

Black crappie 145,478.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 76.9 153.7 306.0

Bluegill 433,471.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 229.0 458.0 911.7

Brown bullhead 14,807.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 7.8 15.6 31.1

Bullhead 5,390.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.8 5.7 11.3

Channel catfish 441,689.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 233.4 466.7 929.0

Crappie 386,810.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 204.4 408.7 813.6

Menhaden 308.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.2 0.3 0.6

Rainbow smelt 9,240.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 4.9 9.8 19.4

Smelts 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sunfish 1,511,686.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 798.7 1,597.3 3,179.6

White Perch 5,479.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.9 5.8 11.5

Yellow perch 625,983.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 330.7 661.5 1,316.7

Total (Panfish) 3,611,368.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1,908.0 3,816.0 7,596.0

Salmon 5.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Salmon) 5.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

American shad 3,070.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 5.0 16.5 55.4

Striped bass 19,797.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 32.2 106.2 357.3

Sturgeon 1,735.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 2.8 9.3 31.3

Total (Small Game) 24,603.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 40.0 132.0 444.0

Northern pike 36.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 0.1 0.1 0.3

Sauger 180,270.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 357.2 739.7 1,537.2

Walleye 209,854.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 415.8 861.1 1,789.5

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 24 of 32
Total (Walleye/Pike) 390,160.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 773.0 1,601.0 3,327.0

Total (Unidentified) 6,716,737.0 $1.08 $2.23 $4.60 7,283.0 14,985.0 30,898.0

Total (Undiscounted) 12,592,464.0 . . . 17,923.0 37,191.0 77,520.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 16,566.0 34,376.0 71,653.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 16,504.0 34,247.0 71,384.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 1 in the Inland Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 9,573.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 41.0 86.3 182.6

White bass 649,610.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 2,783.0 5,854.7 12,392.4

Total (Bass) 659,182.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 2,824.0 5,941.0 12,575.0

Whitefish 1,642.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 2.0 5.0 9.0

Total (Other Trout) 1,642.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 2.0 5.0 9.0

Black bullhead 25,176.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 13.3 26.6 53.0

Black crappie 14,071.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 7.4 14.9 29.6

Bluegill 334,160.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 176.6 353.1 703.0

Brown bullhead 4,771.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.5 5.0 10.0

Bullhead 3,245.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.7 3.4 6.8

Channel catfish 228,275.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 120.6 241.2 480.2

Crappie 24,144.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 12.8 25.5 50.8

Menhaden 258.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.1 0.3 0.5

Rainbow smelt 3,097.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.6 3.3 6.5

Smelts 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sunfish 193,777.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 102.4 204.8 407.6

White Perch 4,067.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.1 4.3 8.6

Yellow perch 298,679.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 157.8 315.6 628.3

Total (Panfish) 1,133,719.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 599.0 1,198.0 2,385.0

Salmon 4.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Salmon) 4.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

American shad 2,569.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 4.1 13.7 46.4

Striped bass 16,562.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 26.6 88.3 299.3

Sturgeon 184.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 0.3 1.0 3.3

Total (Small Game) 19,315.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 31.0 103.0 349.0

Northern pike 30.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 0.1 0.1 0.3

Sauger 7,809.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 15.6 32.0 66.6

Walleye 13,152.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 26.3 53.9 112.2

Total (Walleye/Pike) 20,991.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 42.0 86.0 179.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 25 of 32
Total (Unidentified) 2,486,184.0 $1.08 $2.23 $4.60 2,696.0 5,547.0 11,437.0

Total (Undiscounted) 4,321,037.0 . . . 6,194.0 12,880.0 26,933.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 5,071.0 10,545.0 22,049.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 4,626.0 9,619.0 20,115.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 2 in the Inland Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 157,772.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 676.0 1,421.9 3,009.7

White bass 1,469,625.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 6,297.0 13,245.1 28,035.3

Total (Bass) 1,627,397.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 6,973.0 14,667.0 31,045.0

Whitefish 1,977.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 3.0 6.0 10.0

Total (Other Trout) 1,977.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 3.0 6.0 10.0

Black bullhead 29,849.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 15.8 31.5 62.8

Black crappie 121,385.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 64.1 128.3 255.3

Bluegill 413,894.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 218.7 437.3 870.6

Brown bullhead 12,951.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 6.8 13.7 27.2

Bullhead 4,984.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.6 5.3 10.5

Channel catfish 401,691.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 212.2 424.4 844.9

Crappie 320,377.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 169.3 338.5 673.9

Menhaden 298.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.2 0.3 0.6

Rainbow smelt 8,104.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 4.3 8.6 17.0

Smelts 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sunfish 1,269,826.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 670.9 1,341.7 2,671.0

White Perch 5,204.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.7 5.5 10.9

Yellow perch 564,857.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 298.4 596.8 1,188.1

Total (Panfish) 3,153,418.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1,666.0 3,332.0 6,633.0

Salmon 5.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Salmon) 5.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

American shad 2,968.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 4.8 15.9 53.7

Striped bass 19,136.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 30.9 102.4 346.1

Sturgeon 1,450.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 2.3 7.8 26.2

Total (Small Game) 23,554.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 38.0 126.0 426.0

Northern pike 35.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 0.1 0.1 0.3

Sauger 148,695.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 294.6 609.9 1,267.7

Walleye 173,822.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 344.4 713.0 1,482.0

Total (Walleye/Pike) 322,552.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 639.0 1,323.0 2,750.0

Total (Unidentified) 5,932,467.0 $1.08 $2.23 $4.60 6,433.0 13,236.0 27,290.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 26 of 32
Total (Undiscounted) 11,061,370.0 . . . 15,751.0 32,690.0 68,154.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 9,578.0 19,879.0 41,449.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 7,361.0 15,277.0 31,856.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 3 in the Inland Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 164,627.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 705.4 1,483.6 3,140.5

White bass 1,509,996.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 6,469.6 13,609.0 28,805.5

Total (Bass) 1,674,624.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 7,175.0 15,092.0 31,946.0

Whitefish 1,999.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 3.0 6.0 11.0

Total (Other Trout) 1,999.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 3.0 6.0 11.0

Black bullhead 30,167.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 15.9 31.9 63.5

Black crappie 126,378.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 66.8 133.6 265.8

Bluegill 418,926.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 221.4 442.8 881.2

Brown bullhead 13,347.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 7.1 14.1 28.1

Bullhead 5,077.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.7 5.4 10.7

Channel catfish 410,600.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 217.0 434.0 863.7

Crappie 334,101.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 176.6 353.1 702.7

Menhaden 300.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.2 0.3 0.6

Rainbow smelt 8,347.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 4.4 8.8 17.6

Smelts 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sunfish 1,320,111.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 697.6 1,395.3 2,776.7

White Perch 5,273.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.8 5.6 11.1

Yellow perch 578,320.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 305.6 611.2 1,216.4

Total (Panfish) 3,250,948.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1,718.0 3,436.0 6,838.0

Salmon 5.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Salmon) 5.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

American shad 2,997.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 4.8 16.1 54.1

Striped bass 19,322.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 30.8 103.8 348.7

Sturgeon 1,509.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 2.4 8.1 27.2

Total (Small Game) 23,828.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 38.0 128.0 430.0

Northern pike 35.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 0.1 0.1 0.3

Sauger 155,207.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 307.2 637.0 1,323.3

Walleye 181,266.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 358.8 743.9 1,545.4

Total (Walleye/Pike) 336,508.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 666.0 1,381.0 2,869.0

Total (Unidentified) 6,101,138.0 $1.08 $2.23 $4.60 6,616.0 13,612.0 28,066.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 27 of 32
Total (Undiscounted) 11,389,049.0 . . . 16,216.0 33,654.0 70,160.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 9,966.0 20,684.0 43,122.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 7,592.0 15,755.0 32,847.0

Increased Recreational Harvest from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities under Option 4 in the Inland Region (harvestable adult fish)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Smallmouth bass 9,339.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 40.0 84.2 178.2

White bass 633,751.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 2,715.0 5,711.7 12,089.8

Total (Bass) 643,090.0 $4.28 $9.01 $19.08 2,755.0 5,796.0 12,268.0

Whitefish 1,602.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 2.0 5.0 8.0

Total (Other Trout) 1,602.0 $1.52 $2.83 $5.29 2.0 5.0 8.0

Black bullhead 24,562.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 13.0 26.0 51.7

Black crappie 13,727.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 7.2 14.5 28.9

Bluegill 326,002.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 172.1 344.6 685.6

Brown bullhead 4,655.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.5 4.9 9.8

Bullhead 3,165.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.7 3.3 6.7

Channel catfish 222,702.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 117.6 235.4 468.3

Crappie 23,555.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 12.4 24.9 49.5

Menhaden 251.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.1 0.3 0.5

Rainbow smelt 3,021.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 1.6 3.2 6.4

Smelts 1.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 0.0 0.0 0.0

Sunfish 189,046.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 99.8 199.8 397.6

White Perch 3,967.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 2.1 4.2 8.3

Yellow perch 291,387.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 153.9 308.0 612.8

Total (Panfish) 1,106,041.0 $0.53 $1.06 $2.10 584.0 1,169.0 2,326.0

Salmon 4.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total (Salmon) 4.0 $8.16 $13.27 $21.61 0.0 0.0 0.0

American shad 2,506.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 4.0 13.4 45.2

Striped bass 16,158.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 25.7 86.6 291.6

Sturgeon 179.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 0.3 1.0 3.2

Total (Small Game) 18,843.0 $1.61 $5.36 $18.07 30.0 101.0 340.0

Northern pike 29.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 0.1 0.1 0.2

Sauger 7,619.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 15.3 31.3 65.1

Walleye 12,831.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 25.7 52.6 109.6

Total (Walleye/Pike) 20,479.0 $1.98 $4.10 $8.53 41.0 84.0 175.0

Total (Unidentified) 2,425,487.0 $1.08 $2.23 $4.60 2,630.0 5,411.0 11,157.0

Species

Annual Increase in

Recreational

Harvest

(harvestable adult

fish)

Value per Fish

Annual Benefits from Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

regional benefits 28 of 32
Total (Undiscounted) 4,215,546.0 . . . 6,043.0 12,566.0 26,275.0

Total (3% discount rate) . . . . 4,947.0 10,287.0 21,511.0

Total (7% discount rate) . . . . 4,513.0 9,384.0 19,623.0

regional benefits 29 of 32
Recreational Fishing Benefits from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the California Region, by Option (2009$)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Baseline 1,022,339 $1,740 $2,923 $4,917 $1,681 $2,823 $4,750

Option 1 36,438 $51 $85 $141 $46 $75 $125

Option 2 876,841 $1,037 $1,741 $2,929 $792 $1,330 $2,237

Option 3 915,750 $1,096 $1,840 $3,095 $832 $1,396 $2,349

Recreational Fishing Benefits from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the North Atlantic Region, by Option (2009$)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Baseline 761,183 $1,765 $2,838 $4,596 $1,705 $2,742 $4,440

Option 1 1,495 $3 $5 $9 $3 $5 $8

Option 2 620,929 $939 $1,510 $2,446 $698 $1,122 $1,817

Option 3 651,307 $1,018 $1,638 $2,652 $756 $1,216 $1,969

Recreational Fishing Benefits from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Mid-Atlantic Region, by Option (2008$)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Baseline 9,081,061 $15,239 $25,569 $44,467 $14,721 $24,701 $42,958

Option 1 549,015 $846 $1,577 $3,136 $749 $1,396 $2,776

Option 2 8,359,591 $8,381 $14,073 $24,501 $5,831 $9,792 $17,049

Option 3 8,459,880 $8,584 $14,410 $25,078 $5,975 $10,030 $17,456

Annual Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(harvestable adult fish)

Annual Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(harvestable adult fish)

Annual Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(harvestable adult fish)

Scenarios: Baseline = Eliminating Baseline I&E Mortality Losses; Option 1 = I Everywhere; Option 2 = I Everywhere and E for

Facilities >125 MGD; Option 3 = I&E Mortality Everywhere; Option 4 = I for Facilities > 50 MGD

Scenarios: Baseline = Eliminating Baseline I&E Mortality Losses; Option 1 = I Everywhere; Option 2 = I Everywhere and E for

Facilities >125 MGD; Option 3 = I&E Mortality Everywhere; Option 4 = I for Facilities > 50 MGD

Scenarios: Baseline = Eliminating Baseline I&E Mortality Losses; Option 1 = I Everywhere; Option 2 = I Everywhere and E for

Facilities >125 MGD; Option 3 = I&E Mortality Everywhere; Option 4 = I for Facilities > 50 MGD

Annualized Benefits from Increase in Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

3 % Discount Rate 7 % Discount Rate

Regulatory

Option

Regulatory

Option

Regulatory

Option

3 % Discount Rate 7 % Discount Rate

Annualized Benefits from Increase in Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

Annualized Benefits from Increase in Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

3 % Discount Rate 7 % Discount Rate

regional benefits summaries 30 of 32
Recreational Fishing Benefits from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the South Atlantic Region, by Option (2009$)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Baseline 133,897 $257 $346 $469 $249 $335 $453

Option 1 15,882 $28 $37 $50 $24 $33 $45

Option 2 112,139 $141 $190 $257 $103 $139 $188

Option 3 112,301 $141 $190 $257 $103 $139 $188

Recreational Fishing Benefits from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Gulf of Mexico Region, by Option (2009$)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Baseline 2,851,347 $6,022 $8,852 $13,506 $5,999 $8,818 $13,456

Option 1 665,697 $1,398 $2,422 $4,334 $1,275 $2,210 $3,953

Option 2 2,204,063 $3,225 $4,866 $7,642 $2,491 $3,760 $5,908

Option 3 2,208,009 $3,258 $4,906 $7,690 $2,510 $3,781 $5,926

Recreational Fishing Benefits from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Great Lakes Region, by Option (2009$)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Baseline 349,648 $1,127 $1,984 $3,544 $1,123 $1,977 $3,530

Option 1 176,089 $561 $951 $1,638 $511 $867 $1,495

Option 2 317,974 $720 $1,261 $2,241 $559 $979 $1,739

Option 3 320,196 $725 $1,271 $2,261 $561 $984 $1,750

Annual Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(harvestable adult fish)

Annual Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(harvestable adult fish)

Annual Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(harvestable adult fish)

Regulatory

Option

Regulatory

Option

Scenarios: Baseline = Eliminating Baseline I&E Mortality Losses; Option 1 = I Everywhere; Option 2 = I Everywhere and E for

Facilities >125 MGD; Option 3 = I&E Mortality Everywhere; Option 4 = I for Facilities > 50 MGD

Scenarios: Baseline = Eliminating Baseline I&E Mortality Losses; Option 1 = I Everywhere; Option 2 = I Everywhere and E for

Facilities >125 MGD; Option 3 = I&E Mortality Everywhere; Option 4 = I for Facilities > 50 MGD

3 % Discount Rate

Regulatory

Option

Annualized Benefits from Increase in Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

3 % Discount Rate 7 % Discount Rate

Annualized Benefits from Increase in Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

7 % Discount Rate

Annualized Benefits from Increase in Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

3 % Discount Rate 7 % Discount Rate

regional benefits summaries 31 of 32
Recreational Fishing Benefits from Reducing IM&E at In-Scope Facilities in the Inland Region, by Option (2009$)

5

th Mean 95th 5th Mean 95th

Baseline 12,592,464 $16,566 $34,376 $71,653 $16,504 $34,247 $71,384

Option 1 4,321,037 $5,071 $10,545 $22,049 $4,626 $9,619 $20,115

Option 2 11,061,370 $9,578 $19,879 $41,449 $7,361 $15,277 $31,856

Option 3 11,389,049 $9,966 $20,684 $43,122 $7,592 $15,755 $32,847

Scenarios: Baseline = Eliminating Baseline I&E Mortality Losses; Option 1 = I Everywhere; Option 2 = I Everywhere and E for

Facilities >125 MGD; Option 3 = I&E Mortality Everywhere; Option 4 = I for Facilities > 50 MGD

Annual Increase in

Recreational Harvest

(harvestable adult fish)

Regulatory

Option

Scenarios: Baseline = Eliminating Baseline I&E Mortality Losses; Option 1 = I Everywhere; Option 2 = I Everywhere and E for

Facilities >125 MGD; Option 3 = I&E Mortality Everywhere; Option 4 = I for Facilities > 50 MGD

Annualized Benefits from Increase in Recreational Harvest

(2009$, thousands)

3 % Discount Rate 7 % Discount Rate

regional benefits summaries 32 of 32